“AI Made Cheating Too EASY” - Universities Bring Back Real Learning
Episode Stats
Harmful content
Misogyny
1
sentences flagged
Toxicity
3
sentences flagged
Summary
University of Chicago bans devices in class to reduce AI reliance, and a Brown University professor says, "Let me read both of them, and then, I'll come to you mainly and then we'll go from there."
Transcript
00:00:00.000
This article that came out talking about University of Chicago Law School bans devices to reduce
00:00:04.760
AI reliance, and then it kind of coincides with the other story that shows a wake-up
00:00:12.180
Brown University professor says, let me read both of them, and then, Tom, I'll come to
00:00:18.700
So the first story I want to get to is University of Chicago decides they will ban first-year
00:00:25.940
law students from using iPhones, tablets, and laptops in class beginning this fall,
00:00:31.560
seeking to ensure students learn to think critically, strategically, and independently
00:00:39.300
Our commitment to rigorous legal education also must mean openness to even rapid adaptation.
00:00:48.500
Administrators say a willingness to rethink our practices is consistent with our law school's
00:00:54.180
after a year of consultation with students, faculty and law firm leaders, legal technology
00:01:01.920
executives and the broader university community administrators concluded that students must
00:01:05.600
develop independent reasoning while preparing to use AI in legal practice.
00:01:13.020
Brown University professor Roberto Serrano saw scores collapse between a take-home midterm
00:01:18.560
and an in-person final, which I'm glad they did that,
00:01:21.500
leading him to suspect widespread AI-assisted cheating.
00:01:29.920
Serrano teaches welfare economics and social choice theory.
00:01:34.780
after a school shooter killed two students in December.
00:01:40.200
is that the cost of cheating has basically gone down to zero.
00:01:43.900
It's very easy for students to succumb to the temptation
00:01:46.320
after Serrano announced that the final would be held in person.
00:01:49.840
Many previously high-score students dropped the course.
00:01:56.500
All of a sudden, they're like, no, no, we're doing it in school.
0.99
00:02:01.580
Others who earned grades in high 90s on the midterm scored in the 50s.
00:02:10.260
Are you surprised Serrano shared the details with Brown's standing committee
00:03:01.620
How many of them are sitting on laptop or an email?
00:03:11.920
how long would it take you to figure that out pat not long 15 minutes and be like you graduated
00:03:16.580
from from harvard with a harvard mba and you can't come in here to this room and just speak
00:03:21.840
intelligently form sentences and have your thoughts across and do that this you have to go back to your
00:03:26.080
desk let ai do for it so brown is is excuse me university of chicago they're they're concerned
00:03:32.380
about number one the reputation of the school and number two the ability to school to attract
00:03:37.220
Students, I love what they're doing. They're saying, time out. Put all those devices away. Let's talk about legal theory. Let's hear you reason. Let's hear you debate a fellow student the way you would in a courtroom. The second is, I love what happened at Brown. And there are people that have stepped out on this and have jumped on it to discuss it.
00:03:57.340
I love the fact that there is a student that got a 95.5 on the midterm and a 95 in-person
00:04:06.740
The teacher stepped back and said, the professor stepped back and said, you know what?
00:04:09.960
I regarded that individual through observation throughout the semester as an excellent student
00:04:21.160
So he's observing him in class and then he gives him the in-person final.
00:04:27.340
95 and 95, which means he didn't cheat on the midterm.
00:04:32.600
He said, I like equally well, but the guy was somewhat less initiated and he had a 55
00:04:42.980
Maybe it was, it was, maybe he's struggling with the class, but the two scores proved
00:04:47.680
I love these two stories because it's a shining a light on it that AI may be able to do assimilated
00:04:56.540
We use it for prepping for podcasts here, but when AI does the job for you, it's not
00:05:01.700
you and you're not getting smarter and you've got Brown and you versus Chicago, both blue
00:05:13.140
Well, the funniest thing that stuck out to me with this whole AI thing is, did you see
00:05:16.600
the line where they said professors will designate classroom scribes to take notes for first
00:05:23.840
and scribes they haven't used scribes since medieval times like what's i know people there's
00:05:29.780
a lot of people out there that want to bring back the crusades i'm not advocating for that
00:05:33.260
just yet but when we're using scribes in classrooms right now it's like maybe we've
00:05:38.740
jumped the shark on this ai thing and pbd i know you're a big basketball fan for i'll tell you this
00:05:43.700
i remember you know there's unfair advantages right so i remember when i was in ninth grade
00:05:48.540
they put me with the middle school team to play i was scoring 30 points a game
00:05:53.000
30 points a game, they're like, dude, you're crushing it.
00:05:54.740
They go, okay, now you're going to play with the high school kids.
00:05:58.520
Okay, maybe I had an unfair advantage with the kids that are in middle school.
00:06:01.700
But when you actually start competing and not using technology and unfair advantages,
00:06:05.640
basically cheating, you're basically going to be a reversion of the mean.
00:06:11.080
Whether it's medieval times, crusades, or taking away unfair advantages,
00:06:16.140
kids are going to have to put down the phone and actually learn in order to do their job moving forward.
00:06:21.860
Look, I like that they're doing this, and I don't – set aside politics.
00:06:25.420
If I'm taking a test home and I'm getting 95 and I'm doing it in school,
00:06:29.380
I'm doing it at 50, what the hell are you teaching the kids to go to school?
00:06:31.900
If I'm a parent, I'm like, why am I sending my kids to college?
00:06:36.760
Parents get upset if they hear something like this.
00:06:39.020
In less than eight weeks, Deval Conference, and this is the new manual, by the way.
00:06:43.100
This is the new manual that came in, and it's sick, and there's going to be a couple.
00:06:49.280
And it's going to be a couple of interesting stories and announcements at Vault being made.
00:06:52.660
But with that being said, for those of you guys that have been watching the Vault ads
00:06:56.220
left and right, and you keep saying, I'm going to go, I'm going to go, I'm going to go.
00:07:00.360
Prices are going up today for the Vault Conference.
00:07:02.760
With that being said, I want you to watch this video.
00:07:06.880
That there will always be something happening in your life at that moment to be able to
00:07:13.860
You've seen plenty of the Vault Conference videos.
00:07:17.640
you know there could be some people do business with or get some new strategies at an era like
00:07:21.960
this for you to win in a marketplace and have your dreams become a reality do not be the person that
00:07:27.060
says next year i'll go to the ball conference if you want to commit click on a link below or above
00:07:32.000
get registered for the ball conference i'll spend four days together from august 31st
00:07:36.200
to september 3rd at mgm grand arena in las vegas cannot wait to see you there but by the way and
00:07:41.820
here's what i will tell you there's going to be a couple people there that i haven't announced on
00:07:45.300
this list because it's potentially last minute type of, I can't tell you who it is till it
00:07:50.440
If you want to be in a place where you're around others who have conservative values,
00:07:55.060
fiscally, personal life, fathers, parenting, family, business, finance, economy, politics,
00:08:02.420
everything that we talk about comfortably and nobody walks on eggshells, go to vault2026.com.
00:08:14.220
Looking forward to seeing you there at MGM Grand Arena, Las Vegas.
00:08:18.420
If you enjoyed this video, you want to watch more videos like this, click here.
00:08:21.160
And if you want to watch the entire podcast, click here.
00:08:36.080
Feel the fun with PlayOjo, the online casino with all the latest slot and live casino games.
00:08:41.180
What you win is yours to keep with no wagering requirements, instant payouts, and no minimum withdrawals.
00:08:54.880
Concerned about your gambling or that of someone close to you?