Valuetainment - December 24, 2025


"Aisha Was Not Married At A Young Age" - Muslim Cleric SLAMS Prophet Muhammad Myths & Quran Lies

Hosted by
Mentioned
10 Hiring Rules Every CEO Must Follow in the AI Era “All Dogs Go To Heaven” - Patrick Bet-David Breaks Down Over Losing His Lifelong Dogs

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

160.2

Word count

1,662

Sentence count

184

Harmful content

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

17

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we discuss the life and legacy of Mufti Muhammad and how he changed the course of Islamic thought in the modern era. We talk about his impact on the culture of his time and the impact of his teachings on the world at large.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 What do you admire about him the most?
00:00:02 Everything.
00:00:03 Please unpack that.
00:00:05 Okay.
00:00:06 The Muhammad that the West has been introduced to is not our Muhammad, the Muhammad of the Quran. 0.99
00:00:16 Very important.
00:00:17 And please, Patrick, ask me any question.
00:00:21 And if you feel I haven't answered you, please go back and make sure that you're satisfied with my answer.
00:00:27 I'm not here to evade anything, so please.
00:00:32 Just so you know, you don't give me that vibe at all.
00:00:34 Okay.
00:00:34 You don't even have to explain yourself.
00:00:36 Thank you.
00:00:36 Thank you.
00:00:38 Arabia needed monotheism. 0.86
00:00:42 This was a society that was worshipping dates and stones and burying their daughters alive, worshipping idols.
00:00:50 The tradition of Abraham was corrupted in Arabia. 0.59
00:00:54 We call this the time of ignorance, Zaman al-Jahiliyyah. 1.00
00:00:59 God sent a man, we believe, in the same way he sent Moses and Jesus.
00:01:04 His name is Muhammad.
00:01:06 He sent him to Arabia, not to start a new religion, but to continue the religion of previous prophets. 0.51
00:01:14 Moses being, you know, the final Jewish prophet and Jesus being the messenger for the Christians. 0.84
00:01:26 Now, you may believe him to be the son of God.
00:01:29 I see him as a prophet of God.
00:01:32 But what we agree upon is that he was a messenger of God.
00:01:36 What he came with came from God, came from the, you call him the father, I call him Allah.
00:01:43 The prophet Muhammad, you may read the Quran that he came down with. 0.79
00:01:49 And we say he came with, but it was revealed to him.
00:01:53 So it did not come down as a tablet.
00:01:55 It came down as verse by verse or certain verses together.
00:01:59 His focus in Arabia was monotheism.
00:02:03 Who is God?
00:02:05 Who is our creator and our responsibility towards him?
00:02:08 That's it.
00:02:09 That is the main fundamental pillar of the message of the prophet.
00:02:13 Do not worship idols.
00:02:15 Do not worship idols that you create with your own hands.
00:02:18 And when you get hungry, you eat them out of dates and so on. 0.93
00:02:22 Do not have sexual relations with your parents. 0.99
00:02:26 Do not kill your parents. 0.97
00:02:28 Do not murder the innocent, for example.
00:02:31 Respect the basic Noahide laws.
00:02:35 This is exactly what our prophet advocated for.
00:02:38 Then there is a development of a religion.
00:02:41 That is where it gets more interesting.
00:02:44 Because it all goes back to those people following the prophet Muhammad. 0.94
00:02:50 The prophet Muhammad was born in 570.
00:02:54 He passed away in 632.
00:02:58 He was a prophet for 23 years.
00:03:01 In 23 years, all of his battles were defensive.
00:03:06 And you can look this up as I'm speaking.
00:03:08 They were all defensive.
00:03:10 And we can speak about treatment of Christians, of Jews, of any group.
00:03:15 Ask me any question.
00:03:16 I'll tell you this.
00:03:17 But before we do so, I want to just point to a book that I think is valuable just for context.
00:03:23 By John Tolan.
00:03:25 The Faces of Muhammad. 0.86
00:03:30 Right.
00:03:31 So, this book shows you that the West itself.
00:03:37 In this book, the author, Mr. Tolan, speaks about the faces of Muhammad in the West.
00:03:45 Muhammad during the medieval era.
00:03:47 How did the Western world view him?
00:03:49 Muhammad during the Reformation era.
00:03:51 Muhammad during the Enlightenment era.
00:03:53 So, when you ask me about my prophet, this question is coming from the developments and events happening in our time.
00:04:06 Muhammad was never looked at in a single way by the West.
00:04:09 He was looked at as Muhammad the businessman.
00:04:12 Muhammad the poet.
00:04:14 Muhammad the warrior.
00:04:15 Muhammad the father.
00:04:17 The father of orphans.
00:04:18 Muhammad the statesman.
00:04:20 Right.
00:04:20 So, when I speak about the prophet Muhammad, I'll tell you this.
00:04:25 He was a man sent by God to Arabia to guide them towards monotheism and ethics.
00:04:33 That's it.
00:04:34 That is who he was.
00:04:36 That's what his mission was.
00:04:37 And that is exactly what the Quran focuses on.
00:04:41 But, yes, it's a book that speaks to a developing community.
00:04:46 There's going to be conflict.
00:04:47 There's going to be war.
00:04:48 And there's going to be peace.
00:04:50 There's going to be a lot of difficult conversations to be had.
00:04:53 And we should not shy away from them.
00:04:56 What's the most difficult part of the Quran that you had to accept?
00:05:00 No, I accepted all with no difficulty.
00:05:02 None of it?
00:05:03 No, because there's no question you can ask me that I do not have a rational answer for.
00:05:06 The most basic one I'll go to that you've probably been asked a million times that you know of.
00:05:11 So, Aisha, how do you process that?
00:05:13 Aisha was not married to the prophet at a young age.
00:05:16 She was an adult.
00:05:18 And I've heard you say this before.
00:05:20 She was an adult.
00:05:20 Do you know how many people who are Islam, Muslim scholars, who do the complete opposite, who don't even debate it? 1.00
00:05:31 Right.
00:05:31 But you debate it.
00:05:31 They're preachers.
00:05:32 They're not imams. 0.80
00:05:34 They are preachers.
00:05:35 The son of an imam is not an imam. 0.99
00:05:37 Just because your dad has a mosque and leads prayers and gives you the microphone to speak, it does not make you a theologian.
00:05:44 If the average person goes and checks to see, by the way, let's do this.
00:05:48 Let me ask the question in a different way.
00:05:50 Right.
00:05:50 If he did marry Aisha at six, if he did consummate at nine, would you still be a Muslim? 0.87
00:05:56 The thing is, he would never do that.
00:05:58 No, but here's a different question I'm asking.
00:05:59 Right.
00:06:00 He would never do that.
00:06:00 I'm not asking that question. 0.75
00:06:02 If your prophet, if, this is an if, it's a key word, if he did marry a six-year-old, if he did consummate, which means, you know, have sex with somebody at nine, that some people would, you know, define that as rape. 0.82
00:06:17 They wouldn't even consider that as sex. 0.97
00:06:19 If he did, would you still be a Muslim? 0.96
00:06:21 Would you still see yourself as a Muslim yourself?
00:06:24 Patrick, I'm not running away from the question.
00:06:27 I swear on my life and on my mother's life.
00:06:30 I'm telling you, when you say prophet, to me, it means an infallible being that does not make a mistake or make error.
00:06:38 It doesn't make sense.
00:06:39 Then let me ask the question in a different way, okay?
00:06:45 You're born into a family that is non-religious at all.
00:06:52 You have to find your own way.
00:06:54 It's not third-generation imam.
00:06:57 They're not Muslim, but it's not atheists. 0.93
00:06:59 Maybe it's agnostic.
00:07:01 You go pick and choose and find your own.
00:07:03 Not Christian, not Presbyterian, not Jehovah, not nothing, right? 0.98
00:07:07 I would eventually end up as Muslim.
00:07:10 You say that.
00:07:11 You say that.
00:07:11 You say that now.
00:07:12 And, you know, I understand saying that.
00:07:16 You know, I would also say I would end up being a Christian myself.
00:07:20 And I would say that.
00:07:22 But neither one of us know that for a fact.
00:07:24 We can play that and say yes, but I get the positioning of you having faith in what you're saying.
00:07:29 If we put something on a board, facts of each religion out there, let's name one of them the religion of whatever.
00:07:40 But the founder of that religion, who was admired by a couple billion people.
00:07:46 If it was factually proven that he married someone at six and they had sex at nine, would you ever consider that religion?
00:07:55 If, I didn't say Muslim.
00:07:57 I said, if it was proven that the founder had done that, would you ever accept that religion?
00:08:01 No, of course not.
00:08:02 You wouldn't?
00:08:03 No.
00:08:03 Okay, beautiful.
00:08:04 But, again, the prophet for us, when you say Muhammad, you know what I process?
00:08:10 An infallible human being that does not make mistakes at all or any error.
00:08:15 So, it's impossible that he would make such a decision.
00:08:19 And, plus, the issue of Aisha, you have to weigh it against the society and the dates around her.
00:08:28 She was born after her sister Asma and she died before Asma.
00:08:33 And, I have it in a study which I can definitely send you.
00:08:36 She was either 18, from 18 to 21 years old.
00:08:41 There is no Muslim consensus that Aisha was three or six or nine or 15.
00:08:47 There are more popular opinions because there is a state behind the publications promoting them.
00:08:55 Yes, that I accept.
00:08:57 But, again, with all due respect, if you put a book in front of me, a history book,
00:09:02 and you tell me this book was authored by a very respected man, you know what I'll tell you?
00:09:08 I'll tell you with all due respect, Brother Patrick, I know you gave me a book.
00:09:12 You put a book in front of me.
00:09:14 But, God gave me a brain, and I can do mathematics, and I can understand exactly when she was born, where she was.
00:09:21 It's not hard to work it out.
00:09:24 Well...
00:09:24 18 to 21.
00:09:25 Okay.
00:09:26 Final verdict.
00:09:27 According to your opinion, it's 18 to 21, right?
00:09:30 According to your opinion.
00:09:31 But, I have Islamic sources for it.
00:09:33 But, those are also sources.
00:09:35 But, they are...
00:09:36 So, the two sources are debating each other.
00:09:37 Again, a source is measured and is judged based on the author, and based on the credibility of the source.
00:09:48 So, when you're telling me that she was...
00:09:50 It's narrated that she's 6 or 9, I understand where that comes from.
00:09:54 And, I can also tell you that book is banned in certain countries.
00:09:57 So, that's the same book for...
00:09:58 And, I don't want to mention...
00:10:00 I don't want to offend X percent of Muslims by saying this.
00:10:06 But, I'll tell you this. 0.68
00:10:07 If a book is rejected because it was relied upon by ISIS, it should also be rejected if it tells you that Aisha was 6 and that my prophet was a rapist. 0.54
00:10:16 If you enjoyed this video, you want to watch more videos like this, click here.
00:10:19 And, if you want to watch the entire podcast, click here.