Valuetainment - January 14, 2019


Episode 246: Should College Athletes Get Paid?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Episode 245: How To Break the Curse of Your Limiting Beliefs Episode 247: Self-Made Millionaires: Three Qualities They Have in Common

Episode Stats


Length

6 minutes

Words per minute

186.71

Word count

1,155

Sentence count

101

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Should college athletes get paid? Should the NCAA pay for college athletes to play college football, basketball, or softball? Is this a good idea or a bad idea? What are the best ways to pay college athletes?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 30 seconds, one time for the underdog, ignition sequence start.
00:00:06 Let me see you put them up, reach the sky, turn the stars up above, cause it's one time
00:00:13 for the underdog, one time for the underdog.
00:00:17 I'm Patrick Bedevi, host of Valuetainment, and today we're going to talk a little bit
00:00:20 about sports, and that is, should these college athletes who work their tails off and make
00:00:25 billions of dollars for the NCAA actually get paid?
00:00:29 There's two different sides to the argument.
00:00:31 One side, they shouldn't, because the scholarship is already a way of them getting paid, right?
00:00:36 And so if we do pay them, they're going to be spoiled, they won't put as much effort
00:00:39 to play.
00:00:39 Then on the other side, it's a business.
00:00:41 If the NCAA is making money, they should as well.
00:00:45 I got four points to cover with you, then an idea at the end.
00:00:47 Point number one, the NCAA last year generated $11 billion in revenues.
00:00:53 According to Mark Edelman, $11 billion, only two sports made more money than the NCAA.
00:00:58 That's the Major League Baseball and the NFL.
00:01:01 NCAA made more money than NBA and NHL.
00:01:05 The president of NCAA made $1.7 million last year, which he should, because he generated
00:01:09 revenues.
00:01:11 Point number two is a law passed back in 1972.
00:01:15 It's called Title IX.
00:01:17 The purpose of Title IX is to not discriminate against different sports.
00:01:22 So if I'm playing college football or basketball or tennis or gymnastics or track, I should,
00:01:26 one, get more scholarship because football is more important than tennis.
00:01:30 And it's also a discrimination against men and women.
00:01:34 So the scholarship should be treated equally.
00:01:35 But here's the thing, that in 1972, when that law passed, a lot of things have changed
00:01:40 from 1972 till today.
00:01:41 A company came out in 1979 that completely revolutionized everything.
00:01:45 That company's name is ESPN.
00:01:47 It turned a college football coach making $65,000 a year into a celebrity now getting paid $5 million
00:01:55 here getting endorsements.
00:01:57 A whole different story.
00:01:58 It turned viewers into college football fans, college basketball fans.
00:02:03 It turned them into these fans of these sports.
00:02:06 And it became a very big business.
00:02:08 And on the other side is back in 1972 when Title IX came out.
00:02:11 When you think about NBA, Major League Baseball, NHL, NFL, you got to know that most professional
00:02:16 athletes back then had a full-time job on the side.
00:02:18 You don't hear athletes today that play professional sports that have part-time jobs on the side.
00:02:23 They did back then.
00:02:24 Point number two is the fact that Title IX maybe needs to be re-looked at.
00:02:28 Number three, there's a big contradiction between Title IX and point number three because
00:02:34 Title IX is about discrimination.
00:02:36 We shouldn't discriminate yet. 0.92
00:02:37 You know, point number three, when you think about academic scholarship and athletic scholarship
00:02:42 is totally there's a discrimination there.
00:02:44 Because I could have gotten an academic scholarship.
00:02:47 I got a 4.3 GPA.
00:02:49 I'm out of Toledo.
00:02:50 And Arizona State picks me up.
00:02:52 I'm a very attractive, beautiful model.
00:02:55 I go to Arizona State University.
00:02:56 Maxim contacts me and says, we want to do a photo shoot with you because you submitted your
00:03:01 pictures.
00:03:02 You're beautiful.
00:03:02 We want to pay you $40,000.
00:03:03 Great.
00:03:04 That person can get paid, yet an athletic scholarship, they can't.
00:03:09 But how does that make any sense?
00:03:11 So what's academic is more important than athletic?
00:03:14 So there's somewhat of a discrimination there.
00:03:16 So why should not a collegiate athlete get paid on an endorsement they're getting with
00:03:22 Nike, Reebok, Adidas, Under Armour?
00:03:24 Why should they not get paid?
00:03:25 Why can't an athlete that plays for a university go make $500 in a day doing autographs?
00:03:30 That doesn't make any sense.
00:03:31 They should as well because that's their brand to help generate some kind of revenue to them.
00:03:35 Point number four, if the NCAA doesn't figure out a way to pay them, they're going to pay
00:03:39 them anyways.
00:03:39 I've spoken to some people in the business that said this is not a big deal to college
00:03:43 coaches or universities because they find ways to get the athletes money.
00:03:47 And here's typically how it works.
00:03:49 They'll tell the kid to go do a security job or go do a waiting, you know, whatever it
00:03:54 is.
00:03:54 They'll do something on the side here and they'll send somebody to go work that valet and that
00:03:58 person driving by will give a $100,000 tip.
00:04:00 You know what you can do?
00:04:01 You can't discriminate against giving somebody a tip.
00:04:03 What's your law against it?
00:04:04 You can't really control it.
00:04:05 So the kid got a tip.
00:04:07 It is what it is.
00:04:08 So that kind of stuff happens.
00:04:10 We've heard it many times, long list of athletes that that's happened to.
00:04:14 So unless if they figure out a way to stop that, this law is going to constantly be broken
00:04:18 because these kids are going to find ways to get monies and other people are going to
00:04:22 find ways to pay them to stick around with that university.
00:04:25 So my idea at the end is this.
00:04:26 Here's my idea.
00:04:27 One, let's figure out a way where these athletic scholarships can get money on the side with
00:04:32 their endorsements or autograph signing and different kind of things that they do.
00:04:36 And on top of that is if you're at a university, you get a student that decides to come to your
00:04:40 school, maybe give them a bonus structure.
00:04:43 I'm an athlete decides to go to Texas A&M.
00:04:45 Tell me in three years after being with you, if I hit XYZ numbers, you're going to give me
00:04:49 $800,000 at the end or million eight because of the company made this much money and you're
00:04:54 going to give me a million eight on that or $300,000 or $100,000 or some kind of money
00:04:59 that maybe I'm not getting that money early on at 18, 19 years old when I'm playing for
00:05:03 the college team.
00:05:05 Maybe it's going to be a little bit longer.
00:05:06 So if I'm college basketball, I'm willing to stay four years and get my four-year degree
00:05:10 rather than going to NBA right off the bat.
00:05:13 But there are ways to still incentivize the players of wanting to stick around.
00:05:16 Thanks everybody for listening.
00:05:18 And by the way, if you haven't already subscribed to Valuetainment on iTunes, please do so.
00:05:22 Give us a five-star, write a review if you haven't already.
00:05:25 And if you have any questions for me that you may have, you can always find me on Snapchat,
00:05:29 Instagram, Facebook, or YouTube.
00:05:31 Just search my name, PatrickVidDavid.
00:05:33 And I actually do respond back when you snap me or send me a message on Instagram.
00:05:38 With that being said, have a great day today.
00:05:40 Take care, everybody.
00:05:41 Bye-bye.
00:05:41 Bye-bye.
00:05:46 Bye-bye.
00:05:48 Bye-bye.
00:05:48 Bye-bye.
00:05:50 Bye-bye.
00:05:53 Bye-bye.
00:06:00 Bye-bye.
00:06:00 Bye-bye.
00:06:01 Bye-bye.
00:06:01 Bye-bye.
00:06:05 Bye-bye.
00:06:09 Bye-bye.
00:06:10 Bye-bye.
00:06:10 Bye-bye.