Former FBI Agent Sues The FBI & Bill Clinton For $1.4 Million and Wins
Episode Stats
Harmful content
Misogyny
7
sentences flagged
Hate speech
11
sentences flagged
Summary
Frederick Whitehurst is America s first successful FBI whistleblower. He changed the U.S. criminal justice system forever. And it doesn t stop there. In this episode, Fred talks about how he became a whistle blower, why he decided to speak out, and what it takes to be a true hero.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
The FBI is insidiously powerful. I don't care if it means I die. What's going on in the FBI lab
00:00:07.440
has got to be stopped. Is it intentional that you don't want to have a lot of limelight and you don't
00:00:12.420
want people to see your story? Is that a kind of a intentional thing on your end? Patrick, the issue
00:00:16.260
is not me. The issue is human rights violations. The issue is civil rights violations. The issue
00:00:21.720
is truth in our justice system. What involvement did you have in the World Trade Center bombing
00:00:26.460
case? That was a big bomb. The Pan Am 103. I was in the O.J. Simpson trial. I saw a lot of things that
00:00:33.500
were happening that were bad. Wait, let me let me get this straight. Has it always been where FBI has
00:00:38.360
been more powerful than the president? Until they met Mr. Trump. Then they met themselves. Joe Biden
00:00:43.780
did not want to get mixed up with upsetting the FBI. Why do you think that is? J. Edgar Hoover was a very
00:00:49.420
powerful man and his legacy is one of blackmail. They are absolutely terrified of the boogeyman and
00:00:56.300
the boogeyman is you. It's the media. Is there still a inspiration? Is there still a fire or a chip on
00:01:01.920
your shoulder to say what's wrong is wrong? I want to be able to go expose it today. Are you kind of
00:01:06.080
over it? I'm moving on. This is my country and I'm not giving it away to thugs, period. Define
00:01:24.760
My guest today is someone that if you Google his name, you're going to find articles. You're not
00:01:30.420
going to find a lot of stuff on him. Let's just say he's not the most liked guy for some of the stuff
00:01:35.760
that he did the right thing, but he's not the most liked guy for some of the stuff he did. But let me
00:01:39.640
kind of share with you his resume. PhD from Duke University with postdoc from Texas A&M. Three
00:01:47.180
tour veteran of Vietnam War. Youngest recipient of the Navy Medal of Heroism. And it doesn't stop
00:01:55.340
there. America's first successful FBI whistleblower. And he changed the U.S. criminal justice system
00:02:03.700
forever. My guest today is Frederick Whitehurst. Fred, how are you? I'm here. Nobody shot me yet.
00:02:12.600
How are you hiding? Like how, you know, you go through the story. Some of the stuff you've done
00:02:17.780
is, which we'll get into here in a minute, but is it intentional that you don't want to have a lot
00:02:22.740
of limelight and you don't want people to see your story? Is that a kind of a intentional thing on your
00:02:26.560
footprint? Patrick, the issue is not me. You know, I have asked not to be, I'm not the highlight,
00:02:34.700
you know, and I shouldn't be. The issue is human rights violations. The issue is civil rights
00:02:40.380
violations. The issue is truth in our justice system. The issue is the strength of this nation.
00:02:47.080
I'm just a brick in a wall and I choose to be a brick in a wall. Those folks who want to be the wall,
00:02:53.420
they make things unsafe for all of us because when they fall, the whole wall falls. Do you understand
00:03:02.480
the analogy? No question about it. Sure. No question about it. Have you always had this,
00:03:08.100
because you have this, you have this aura about yourself where there are certain values and
00:03:14.000
principles no one can break you up, meaning you're not going to be breaking a certain set of values and
00:03:21.620
principles that you live by? Have you always been this kind of a true believer or did some event
00:03:26.740
take place in your life where you became a true believer? No, I think I was raised by two very
00:03:34.000
strong parents, a father who was a naval officer, a mother who was a very outspoken social activist.
00:03:41.960
And they instilled in me, my father instilled in me, you call a spade a spade. My mother instilled in me
00:03:47.760
the concern for civil rights, for truth, that sort of thing. But I gradually, if you will, hardened the
00:03:58.220
metal in combat in Vietnam. I saw a lot of things in Vietnam that were wrong. And then, you know, of course,
00:04:04.880
in the FBI, that story is, you know, you can look it up. I saw things that were wrong. I tried to understand
00:04:11.860
them. It didn't, it, I never could, you know, I did a lot of things to understand. What am I seeing?
00:04:20.620
What am I, what am I seeing wrong? How am I, how am I wrong? But you say, have I always been that way?
00:04:27.260
I don't, I don't know how to put that. I've been me. And I've, I've matured in, in,
00:04:35.560
into hardened steel, if you will. Hey, it's, it's wrong. Tell me why I'm wrong, because I think it's
00:04:45.220
wrong. Yeah, it's very obvious to feel that energy from you. But by the way, politically,
00:04:50.200
were your mom and dad both on the same side politically?
00:04:57.500
You know, I don't know that politics was, was not an issue, not the thing that in my family,
00:05:04.320
I have three brothers, and we're divided, um, right down the center, you know, some of us like
00:05:12.180
me are conservative, uh, Republicans, and some of them, like a couple of my brothers are, are very
00:05:18.520
liberal, um, uh, Democrats, if you will. So your, so your parents kind of empowered you to, to be free
00:05:26.040
thinkers and think for yourself. They never imposed their political beliefs onto you guys, but they did
00:05:32.180
impose their values and principles onto you. Yes, that's correct. Okay. Okay. So, so right after
00:05:38.460
school, by the way, if I'm in high school with you, who was Fred in high school? I'm curious.
00:05:42.460
Fred was the kid that worked in the lunchroom. You know, um, I got there at five 30 in the morning.
00:05:48.920
Um, I went to work. I wasn't, uh, I wasn't one of the popular kids. Um, I didn't go to dances. I
00:05:57.740
didn't really go to football games. There were things that interested me that those things would
00:06:02.540
get in the way of such as I wanted to sail on boats. I wanted to build, rebuild machines. I
00:06:10.500
wanted to landscape. I wanted to work my, the work ethic in my family was something that left us
00:06:16.320
work is finer than, than fine spaghetti, if you will. I mean, it's, you know, uh, you wake up in
00:06:22.400
the morning and say, what am I going to do today? And the last thing my wife and I say at night is
00:06:26.380
what did we accomplish today? Even though I'm 73 years old, I got to do, I got to accomplish
00:06:31.520
something in my day. You're 73 years old. Yes. Good for you. What kind of skin products do you use?
00:06:38.800
I mean, that's the first thing my wife would ask you, like, what do you, are you like a Estee
0.99
00:06:43.300
Lauder or a Mac guy? Because you, you, some kind of skin products. You, you, you got the right side.
00:06:48.640
I mean, if you look at the backside, the hair is falling out. I've turned gray in the last five
00:06:52.100
years. So no skin products. Yeah. Listen, you, you, you, you look like a Tom selects a brother.
00:06:58.180
I mean, we talked about it earlier. You got the voice, you got the mustache, you got the look,
00:07:01.220
you, you look like you were one decision away from being in Hollywood. If you wanted to go
00:07:05.200
that direction. Well, Tom wants to be like me, but he can't quite get there.
00:07:12.480
So, so let's go back. So you're 18, you're like sailing, you're like building machines. That's
00:07:17.080
what you're doing. Did you go in the military simply because Pops was a Navy SEAL Navy officer?
00:07:22.960
I think you said he was a Navy officer. Did you go in because you just wanted to serve
00:07:25.840
your country? You know, um, I went into the U S army on a whim. Um, I know people that went
00:07:34.800
into the people's liberation army in Vietnam. Uh, the good friends that belong to the people
00:07:40.160
liberation army. That means the army of North Vietnam at the time. Um, they went as a result
0.80
00:07:45.880
of patriotism. Me, I woke up one morning, I was trying to accomplish a major in math,
00:07:52.000
chemistry and physics in college. I burned out. I said, I'm leaving. I left. I went to
00:07:56.980
New York city. The next morning I woke up, I joined the U S army. When they asked me, what
00:08:01.880
do you want to do? I said, I want to go to Vietnam and kill communists. And that's what
0.66
00:08:05.180
I told them every time, you know, I'm 73. I grew up in the McCarthy age, you know? And,
0.98
00:08:12.060
um, at the time I believed what, um, mad men told me, I believed in the domino theory. And
00:08:19.340
I believe that, you know, I needed to protect my nation from whatever that meant. Um, so when
00:08:26.640
you say a matter of patriotism, um, for me, um, I wish I were that kind of a patriot. I,
00:08:34.160
I went, um, one morning I was a student of science and math. The next morning I was the
00:08:40.140
United States army recruit. And, and how old were you when you got your Navy a medal of
00:08:45.740
heroism? Oh, well, I was at the time, the youngest man in Naval history received the Navy Marine
00:08:51.340
Coral medal. I was 17. Um, my first day in the United States Naval Reserve, I jumped in
00:08:57.160
a lake and save one guy from drowning and try to save another and lost him and, uh, broke
00:09:02.180
through ice to get into where the car had gone over this ledge and sunk in the water. But,
00:09:07.660
um, yeah, it was, um, it was a bad day. It was the 15th of January, 1965. So I was in the
00:09:13.980
Naval Reserve. Um, and I stayed in the Naval Reserve for about 18 months, but I had a tendency
00:09:20.320
back then to walk in my sleep and you can't walk in your sleep and being on a United States
00:09:24.880
Navy, you walk overboard. They don't know you're overboard until you're lost. So they gave me
00:09:30.240
an honorable, um, discharge and, um, Oh, three years later, I went to New York city to join
00:09:38.360
the, the U S army. And they said, have you been in the military before? And I said, Nope,
00:09:43.560
haven't been in the military before. I was 20 at that time. They didn't find out I'd been in
00:09:48.460
the military till I was in Vietnam for six months and, um, and went out of the infantry
00:09:53.760
into military intelligence. You're kidding me. So, so let me, so you get your honorable
00:09:58.520
discharge after getting your medal of, uh, uh, Navy medal of heroism at 17 for jumping
00:10:04.140
out of a, uh, uh, helicopter to go save somebody. And then jump out of a helicopter. I swam off
00:10:10.080
ashore. You swam off ashore and you saved one and you lost one. Yes. And, and, and you said
00:10:16.420
January 15 is, uh, I think it's a January 15, 19, January 15, 1965. Yeah. 1965. And then you go to
00:10:24.460
the army, you go from infantry to military intelligence. How did that happen to go from
00:10:30.540
infantry to MI? I saw things happening in the field that I disagreed with such as, such as war crimes,
00:10:38.900
you know, people being harmed that shouldn't. And, um, I, uh, found myself in an incident after
00:10:47.060
about six months where I, I, a young boy was being, um, brutally bridges, brutalized by six soldiers.
00:10:55.880
And I just said, you know, I quit. I'm, I don't belong to this military. I'm not going to be part of
00:11:00.720
this. And the helicopter came in and I got on it and I went to the rear and, and, uh, a couple of MPs
00:11:07.460
met me and put handcuffs on me and carried me over to the major who tried to talk me out of reporting
00:11:12.180
the, uh, the issues. And then they took me to the colonel who he tried to talk me out of it.
00:11:18.880
And, um, I wasn't going to be talked out of it. You're not going to do that. We're, you know,
00:11:23.300
we're the United States army. We're not, uh, Bashi Bazook of the Ottoman empire. We're the United
00:11:30.620
States army. Well, he said, these things happen. And by the way, you can't go back to the field in my
00:11:35.540
battalion because you're going to get shot in the back of the head by your own troops.
00:11:38.800
What do you want to do? So he offered me a couple of alternatives and, and, um, the, uh,
00:11:45.680
military intelligence detachment down at, um, Duc Faux in Quang Nha province, um, needed me down
00:11:52.260
there. So I went down, not speaking Vietnamese. I learned a little Vietnamese when I was in the field,
00:11:57.320
but, um, but, uh, went down there and, and stayed with them for two and a half years.
00:12:02.900
So you never ended up reporting it or he, the, the, so no, I, I reported it.
00:12:08.140
What happened to the soldiers that, uh, you reported? Um, what I understand was there were
00:12:12.660
six Marines and they were, um, they got what's called an article 15. That's, um, a slap on the
00:12:19.560
hand. Yeah. It's nothing. Um, you know, they permanently destroyed that 14, 13 year old kid,
00:12:24.860
but, um, you know, it's not an excuse that it was wartime when that visually stay with you
00:12:32.760
for the rest of your life or no. So what is, is that visual of what they did to that 13,
00:12:37.720
14 year old kid? I have a, I have a, a horrible trait of remembering things vividly. And, um,
00:12:46.040
you know, I mean, from, from all of my life and yes, I, I know what they did to that kid.
00:12:51.680
And I remember getting on the helicopter. I remember the warrant officer telling me to get
00:12:55.880
off of his helicopter with, um, words, we won't speak on this interview and me just saying,
00:13:01.840
no, and reaching for my 45 and okay. Okay. Just settle down. We'll take you to the rear time. I
00:13:07.180
got off the helicopter. I put my 45 on the ground and, um, and a couple of MPs came over and, um,
00:13:15.180
and they put handcuffs on me and took me to major's office. Well, office tent, whatever. But, um,
00:13:21.180
what was happening was wrong. And I don't know, Patrick, I don't know how not to do something.
00:13:29.620
You know, I'm, I'm, it's going on. It can't go on. I'm going to try and figure out why I'm wrong.
00:13:37.020
I'm not going to denigrate people or, or look down on them, but what you're doing is wrong.
00:13:42.480
In the United States military, in the Ameri-Cal division in Vietnam, um, you know, the My Lai
00:13:48.060
massacre. Well, I got there a year after the My Lai massacre in the same unit, in the same area.
00:13:53.840
And I saw a lot of things that were happening that were bad. They were, they were illegal or
00:14:00.460
they were just bad. And so my concept of becoming an interrogator of prisoners of war was, okay,
00:14:07.560
somebody is going to come in and they're going to tell me about this stuff. And I'm going to raise
00:14:10.620
cane. I'm not going to tell the U S media about it, but I'm going to raise cane so that people will say,
00:14:15.540
okay, don't, don't send it back there. We got a problem back there. And, um,
00:14:21.040
So would you interrogating people at the time? Was that part of your job?
00:14:25.700
And what was it? What was your approach? Because back then there was not a lot of regulations,
00:14:29.100
you know, it was a, it was a different time than it is today. What was your approach to interrogating?
00:14:35.200
Well, what you had was starving soldiers brought down from the North who didn't want to be there.
00:14:43.400
They had no idea. They didn't speak the language that we spoke. Uh, they were terrified. Um,
00:14:51.060
you could feed them, you could clap them on the shoulder. You could treat them nicely.
00:14:57.120
They weren't being treated nicely by their own political officers. They were, they were
00:15:02.060
starving to death. They were up in the, in the Hills. We cut off the rice lines. We put napalm all over
00:15:09.680
the mountains to get rid of the foliage. Um, they were, they were very easily convinced to say
00:15:16.580
there were some hardcore soldiers that were never going to talk, but you know, in two and a half
00:15:22.620
years, I think, uh, I probably saw two or three of those. What was the difference between your first
00:15:29.080
tour, your second tour and your third tour? Not a thing. Really? Not a thing. Um, I got there into
00:15:37.120
the AmeriCal division in March of 1969 and left out of the AmeriCal division in, um, April of 19,
00:15:49.160
six, seven, 1872. Three years. Three years. Yes. I went home. I went home every six months.
00:15:56.900
Okay. When you extended time in country, they give you a one month leave to think it over.
00:16:02.360
And I'd come back from the one month leave and I'd go right into the headquarters and I'd say,
00:16:07.560
okay, I want another six months, which would give me another full year. And they knew when I got off
00:16:12.220
the plane, I was going to come up and sign up for another six months. So I had another full year.
00:16:17.000
Got it. I, I, I saw, I wasn't an officer. I was an enlisted man. I was a specialist five. And I saw,
00:16:25.780
I'm going to go home and pick up cigarette butts for some young ROTC, you know, officer who's going
00:16:33.580
to harass me and whatever I need to be. If I'm a combat soldier, I need to be in combat
00:16:38.220
and I need to be with combat units. And so I just stayed out there for three years.
00:16:44.900
And what kind of reputation did you end up building after what you did when you reported
00:16:50.700
those guys, those Marines, the six Marines, what reputation did you have during those three years?
00:16:54.660
You know, there was a guy that came one time and I picked him up off the helicopter pad and
00:17:01.340
I brought him to the unit and I helped him with his baggage. And, um, we got to his, his tent,
00:17:09.020
you know, he did a, uh, whatever bag and I carried it and we got to go in the tent. He said, well,
00:17:15.840
you're a nice guy. They told me back at headquarters, you're a real son of a bitch.
00:17:21.800
That's your reputation. You had, well, I'm a nice guy. I'm a nice guy, but don't, don't pull that
00:17:30.360
stuff. Don't, you know, this is the United States army and, and that's real. That's not a concept.
00:17:38.300
That's not a idealistic thing. This is the United States army and we're going to act like the United
00:17:46.700
States army. And you know, that sounds maybe unrealistic of me. I think armies win when they
00:17:53.500
fight ethically, but you know, war messes people up because you have to establish too often your own
00:18:05.400
morality. You have to decide them or them. And it's pretty much an everyday thing.
00:18:12.940
Um, Fred, you could, you get out of the army. You said you do three years there. Do you fully
00:18:17.260
get out or do you still stay in the military afterwards? No, I got out. You're out. Okay.
00:18:21.620
So when you got out, so your opinion of Vietnam war, when you first went in, when you first got out
00:18:28.100
and now in 2020, when I went in, I went to Vietnam to kill communists. When I got there,
00:18:35.360
I found four peasants. I found as a prisoner warrantator, interrogated the people I was
00:18:41.020
interviewing were just people just like me. They had been conscripted, brought down South.
00:18:48.600
Well, they, they had a reason for fighting. Most American soldiers didn't want to be there.
00:18:54.960
But I got to the point while I was in Vietnam of saying, I need to do this fight. It was a foolish
00:19:01.680
concept, but I need to fight this just as hard as I can. I need to win this war. So this will stop.
00:19:08.260
Of course you couldn't win the war. The United States would never have won the Vietnam war.
00:19:12.500
And okay. So when I came home, I ran away, Patrick, and I hid, I hid in academia for 10 years.
00:19:22.800
I finished my undergraduate degree in chemistry. I went to Duke. I worked in a, in an area of
00:19:29.900
chemistry called quantum chemistry. It's all theoretical, mathematical, um, sort of when you
00:19:37.320
hear people talk about quantum physics, well, okay, quantum chemistry. And then, um, uh, I came out of
00:19:44.440
that and I came out of a postdoctoral fellowship, realizing that I could not be an academic. I had
00:19:51.680
to go back to war. It's almost like being an addict. I have to do something that means something every
00:19:59.220
day, rather than a long-term. I'm a simple man. I want to see results every day. I want to,
00:20:06.660
I want to make a difference every day. And so I joined the FBI, took me 18 months to get in,
00:20:13.460
but I joined the FBI. You know, there's something very inspirational about your mindset. I got to tell
00:20:19.180
you, there's something very, very inspirational about my, about your mindset. And you're not trying
00:20:23.760
to be motivational. You're just explaining who you are. You know, for you to say, I want to be able
00:20:28.200
to get results on a daily basis. I had to go back out to be, I'm a simple man. I had to figure out a
00:20:32.560
way to get results. That's a, that's a very, you know, uh, uh, uh, common sense way of explaining
00:20:39.540
how you want to bring value to a nation where you want to be someone that's given back. It's, uh,
00:20:45.380
it's, it's, it may be simple, but this is coming from a quantum chemist. So it's not like you're,
00:20:50.560
you got to, you don't have a simple brain. You don't have a simple mind. You don't have a simple
00:20:53.880
way of processing things, but your expectation is pretty simple. So you go into the FBI,
00:20:58.040
when you go into the FBI, 18 months later, what, what's now your goal? The first one was,
00:21:03.760
I want to kill commies. What do you want to do now? Oh, well, darn. I applied to work for the CIA
00:21:11.340
before I applied to work for the FBI. And, um, and I love those guys. They try to find out if I was,
00:21:19.020
if I still had a chip on my shoulder from Vietnam and I got an interview with a guy hooked up to a
00:21:23.900
polygraph and he started insulting my Vietnam service. And so I reached across the desk at him.
00:21:30.340
That was the fourth interview. They thanked me for the interview and I got back down to Texas and I
00:21:37.520
never heard from him again, but during the interview process, um, I don't worry. I didn't
00:21:42.980
assault the guy at Langley. Okay. But, um, during the interview process, a friend of mine who worked
00:21:49.380
on his doctorate at Duke, um, was working for the FBI crime lab. And he said, you ought to come over
00:21:54.000
here. You can have all the toys you want and you can do good things with all the toys you want.
00:21:58.620
So I went over and I went through the lab and oh my gosh. And, and Dennis told me, he said,
00:22:04.120
you can take on the, the biggest, most expensive problems that's, that satisfy the objectives of this
00:22:14.460
organization and have unlimited funding and unlimited, um, whatever. I mean, it's at the
00:22:21.020
peak of the pyramid of the tax structure of this country. And that was beautiful. And so I went back
00:22:28.680
down to Texas and I applied to the FBI and I just wanted to be a scientist. I wasn't interested in
00:22:35.120
being an FBI agent. I want to be a scientist, but a guy came out of the Houston office and he came over
00:22:42.880
and to recruit me. And he explained to me that at that time, this way it was, if you weren't a
00:22:48.120
scientist at the FBI, you're a second-class citizen. You could move forward up the ladder better if you
00:22:55.540
were, you know, and get things done if you were a, uh, if you were a badged agent. So shucks, I didn't
00:23:03.440
want to carry a gun again. You know, I carried a gun. I took lives with guns. I am not a gun person,
00:23:09.260
but I, um, I applied to go to the academy and, um, it took 18 months to, to get into my class,
00:23:22.920
uh, 1982 classroom class, excuse me, three, 82, three was my class at the academy. And, uh, boy, I,
00:23:32.460
I walked in there and I was on cloud nine, you know, when, when you're, when you're in that
00:23:38.920
environment, you get full of hot air. You are someone, you ain't nobody, you know, you're just
00:23:46.120
another joke on the road with a doggone gun on your hip and a piece of, of gold-plated metal in
00:23:52.740
your pocket, but you are someone, do you know? And, um, I spent the time at the academy,
00:23:59.620
very much dedicated to the academy. And, um, then they sent me down to the Houston field office as a
00:24:07.620
new agent. And will you, is that 86? No, that's 1982. That's 1982. I came in to go into the academy
00:24:18.160
on the 22nd of February. I got out of the academy on the 6th of June. Um, and I got out of the field,
00:24:27.440
the 6th of June of 82. I got out of the field. I went to the Sacramento field. I mean, the Houston
00:24:33.540
field office, the Sacramento field office had been the Los Angeles field office in four years.
00:24:38.700
And then I transferred to the, or they transferred me to the lab on the 6th of June, 86.
00:24:45.880
Is that when you became the supervisory special agent, uh, from 86 to 98 at the lab?
00:24:52.480
Well, actually what I was doing there, I spent the first year in training.
00:24:58.620
And, um, after the first, after 13 months, then I, uh, I, I spent, I think about a year before I was
00:25:12.440
What, what, what are some of the assignments you had at that time that we would know about,
00:25:16.360
or there were some big assignments you worked on? Because if I'm looking at that time, 82, you're,
00:25:21.960
you're Reagan, uh, senior, and you got a little bit of Clinton. That's when you were in.
00:25:30.380
You sued Clinton at one for like one and a half million or some number like that.
00:25:34.100
Well, I didn't sue him for the money. I sued him because, uh, I wanted to implement the
00:25:39.440
Whistleblower Protection Act, which was, which was federal law. I wanted to implement it into the
00:25:46.760
Department of Justice and forcing, we wanted to force him with a writ of mandamus to, to say,
00:25:52.680
Department of Justice, you got to obey federal law, which is bizarre, but that's where we were.
00:25:56.560
But, um, the kinds of cases I worked on initially were, it's low level fugitive cases, extortion cases,
00:26:05.080
um, bank robberies, that kind of thing. That was in the field. I was in the field in Houston for six
00:26:12.280
months, went to the Chico, California, where I did, um, mostly narcotics investigations, but, um,
00:26:20.600
also bank robberies and fugitives. Then I went down to Los Angeles for two years. I did, um,
00:26:27.560
oh, in 84, I got there. And for two years I did, um, narcotics investigations. And then I went to
00:26:34.960
the lab and in the lab. Oh, I mean, the cases you would have heard about were, um, the first World
00:26:43.040
Trade Center bombing case, the Pan Am 103 case. Oh, let me see. There were just a bunch of, I was in
00:26:52.220
the OJ Simpson trial, but I, I was there kicking and screaming. I didn't work the case, but I reported
00:26:59.300
issues in the case and the defense picked up on it. Um, oh, goodness. What, what happened with the
00:27:08.760
world? What, what, what involvement did you have in the World Trade Center bombing case?
00:27:13.100
That was the 93 bombing. What happened was, um, I went to New York city and set up a, an explosive
0.73
00:27:22.840
residue analysis testing laboratory in the NYPD, New York police department, um, academy. And we were
00:27:31.260
having to look through 40,000 tons of rubble. That was a big bomb, 40,000 tons of rubble, trying to
00:27:37.880
figure out what kind of the explosive it was. And that went on for 12 days. And we were sleeping
00:27:45.020
two hours a night for 12 days. And you can't do that and continue to function. And, um, then the lab
00:27:52.700
became contaminated. And so we had to move evidence down to FBI headquarters. And so I, I worked
00:28:00.700
on that. I worked on the, the Avianca 203 bombing case where the, um, a fellow named Dandani Munoz
00:28:10.340
Mosquero was accused of blowing up Avianca 203. And I worked on the residue from that case and
00:28:18.380
I'm still working on that case. Um, let me see the Pan Am 103. I was over in, in England
00:28:30.380
The, the 1993 case, is that the one where you were, uh, you were responsible for securing
00:28:36.380
a crime scene and then which led to, uh, later on, uh, you saw the forensic misconduct, which
00:28:42.960
later on you ended up, uh, exposing. Is that kind of how the whole thing got started?
00:28:50.440
No. Um, my training agent at the laboratory, um, was, I was there 90 days when he was telling
00:29:01.360
me how to commit perjury in court. And I was very upset with that. And his work product was sloppy
00:29:06.040
and I was very upset with that. And so I started going through my chain of command. The guys around
00:29:12.320
me said they'd try to do something about it for years and the command didn't do anything about it
00:29:16.580
because he'd become a big liability for the lab. And, um, I, I, I didn't go outside initially.
00:29:25.860
Um, I was upset that, you know, if you've done it there, maybe if you've committed perjury in one
00:29:33.300
case, maybe you've done it in another. And by the way, he never did commit the perjury. He just,
00:29:37.540
that was part of his training. You know, that was part of what he told me. And we were required to
00:29:43.280
report any, any indication of misconduct by FBI management, FBI management, but they didn't want
00:29:49.600
it reported. They just wanted to say, you need a report. And executive order required to report
00:29:55.980
fraud, waste, abuse, and corruption to the appropriate authority. And so I, uh, I said, okay,
00:30:03.120
well, here it is. And the appropriate authority initially was a unit chief. Then it was an
00:30:09.560
assistant section chief. Then it was a section chief. Then it was a deputy, uh, director of the
00:30:14.720
lab. Then it was the lab director. Then it was, um, let me see who was it then? Um, oh yes. I,
00:30:26.260
after I got nobody doing anything then, then I wrote a letter to Joe Biden. Okay. When he was,
00:30:32.260
he was, uh, head of the Senate judiciary committee and Patrick, this is a neat, a neat kind of a,
00:30:38.880
of an anecdote story. I got a letter back. I wrote it clearly as an FBI agent. I got a letter back
00:30:45.340
and I'm sure it was a staffer. He didn't come from Biden. He wouldn't, you know, he didn't have time
00:30:49.140
for that, but I got a letter back that said as a, as a federal prisoner, I should refer such issues to
00:30:56.340
my prison legals, uh, counsel. You know, what that said to me very clearly was Joe Biden did not want
00:31:05.740
to get mixed up with, with, um, upsetting the FBI. He, he just, he just wasn't.
00:31:12.880
Why do you think that is? Why do you think that is?
00:31:18.320
The FBI is insidiously powerful. It's insidiously dangerous. Louis Free, the director of the FBI,
00:31:25.520
actually said it could be the most dangerous agency in the United States.
00:31:29.580
Insidiously. Yes, it could be. Yes. Louis Free was the director and he made that comment publicly.
00:31:35.680
He didn't say it was. I'm saying, um, we want to have a good guy. You know, people want to look up to
00:31:45.920
something. And so they look up to the FBI is going to save them. But the FBI is made of humans and they're
00:31:54.000
inner, inner involved. They're involved in a human enterprise and all human enterprises fail.
00:31:59.520
The biggest failure the FBI's got is it won't admit its failures. It just, it won't so that we as a
00:32:07.760
nation can, can help them fix them. But, um, when the FBI is doing background investigations on anybody
00:32:16.000
that takes a seat up at the, at the hill, well, you know, there's the Washington two-step Patrick.
00:32:24.400
If you find out a staffer has been involved in something he shouldn't have, maybe illegal,
00:32:30.320
you can do one of two things. You can either report that or else you can put it in your pocket.
00:32:35.120
And when you want access, you can then say to the staffer, you know,
00:32:40.960
you know, you know, you don't even have to, you know, just, you know, um, we like some assistance.
00:32:48.400
And, um, you know, you remember back there in, in Podunk, uh, you know, Kentucky or whatever,
00:32:56.000
you know, boom, um, J. Edgar Hoover was a very powerful man. And his legacy is one of blackmail.
00:33:04.880
His legacy is one of, well, you know, like people are talking about Mr. Epstein. Now it was
00:33:12.080
controlled by information and until, until literally that's what my case involves. And I
00:33:23.440
didn't even know it. I went into a lawyer's office and they're the finest whistleblower
00:33:29.120
attorneys in the world, but I didn't know it at the time. I just by happenstance ended up there.
00:33:35.280
And I said, I don't care if it means I die. What's going on in the FBI lab has got to be stopped.
00:33:43.680
And my wife and I decided we will put our lives on the line if necessary, but these are human rights
00:33:50.400
violations. Well, that gave somebody, um, uh, somebody's to kind of go ahead. This guy doesn't
00:33:59.520
care if they shoot him. Well, I cared, but you know, he's going to go where, where he thinks
00:34:05.920
this ought to go. So I'm sitting around talking about mass spectrometers might not work and protocols
00:34:12.080
are not valid and things like that. And other people are talking about, let's get oversight.
00:34:18.320
Let's get oversight of the FBI here. And so years later, um, as we're sitting around talking about
00:34:26.800
the old days, somebody says what that really was about is getting oversight of the FBI.
00:34:33.360
There needs to be oversight. It says guys in the bureau used to say, don't worry about it. We're
00:34:39.680
the investigators and nobody investigates the investigators. Somebody needs to investigate
00:34:46.240
the investigators. Who would that be though? Us. Who's us, the people, you and me and all of us.
00:34:54.400
And all of us. Yes. Who has more power. We, the people, the FBI or the government. When I say
00:34:59.120
government, I'm talking about, you know, uh, exec, you know, executive level highest level.
00:35:05.520
I think when you get to Washington DC, the FBI trumps everybody, they trump the department of
00:35:11.120
justice. They trump the white house. They just trump them. Okay. That's too bad, but they trump.
00:35:16.560
And I think that's the way it operates as a system, but the FBI, I've been in there. They are
00:35:24.080
absolutely terrified of the boogeyman and the boogeyman is you. Is you more, tell me more.
00:35:30.160
Is you. It's the media. It's the media. They're terrified of public exposure. They are absolutely,
00:35:38.480
Patrick, terrified of public exposure. Nobody wants you pointing their camera or your camera
00:35:45.120
at the FBI agent will walk away from it. FBI managers. Oh my gosh. They're terrified.
00:35:53.440
And it's a, it's a culture of, we got to hide. We got to hide. We got to hide. We have to hide
00:36:00.640
everything. If that's the case, why is, why does Comey love the camera so much?
00:36:07.760
You know, he's using the camera. He's using it. What do you mean? Sure. Um,
00:36:14.560
there are, let's say there's chicken eaters and there's egg eaters. Boy, does that sound strange?
00:36:26.960
Doesn't it? There's guys who are journalists who will feed you up as their source.
00:36:32.400
They've eaten the chicken. They're not going to get any more information. Then there's egg eaters.
00:36:36.720
There's guys in the media who will continue to work with you, work with you, protect you as a source.
00:36:43.360
Okay. And they get a long stream of information till the phone taps and everything catch up.
00:36:52.720
Hundreds of people in the FBI wanted to come forward after I came forward.
00:36:58.080
They said, well, the settlement the FBI made with me became known as the white first deal. Okay. You're
0.87
00:37:04.640
going to pay me my paycheck until I would normally retire because you owe me that. I uphold my side of
00:37:10.480
the contract, but you didn't. Then you're going to pay me my retirement. And that wasn't a payoff to
00:37:16.400
quiet me down or I wouldn't be talking to you right now. But I think when you go to DC,
00:37:21.920
when you go to the media right now, media is afraid. A number of us in the FBI who blew the whistle
00:37:32.560
have put together a book called Our FBI. Louis Free put together a book called My FBI.
00:37:40.800
Our FBI was written by former agent Rosemary Dew, and she's a very good author.
00:37:47.200
And there's 15 or 16 folks that stories were told. And it's our FBI, something to the effect of the way
00:37:53.680
the FBI suppresses whistleblowers or retaliates against whistleblowers, whatever. We cannot get
00:37:59.760
a publisher to publish it. We can not get a, nobody wants to touch it. In fact, one of them actually
00:38:06.240
said, I don't want to go to war with the FBI again. We can't get anybody to put it out. And it's a
00:38:12.560
textbook of this is what will happen to you. And wait, wait, wait. So, so let me get this straight.
00:38:20.640
So there is a book called My FBI. Okay. I just looked it up right now. My FBI by Louis Fred,
00:38:27.680
Fred, right? Director of FBI, Louis Fred. Yes. Director of FBI. And this book was written.
00:38:33.280
This is not a newer book, right? By, uh, uh, this was a book written and to give the exact time.
00:38:41.920
Uh, it's not like the last couple of years, this came out 2006. Okay. First edition. Oh, six. So we're
00:38:47.440
talking 14 years ago when you guys wrote our FBI. When did you guys write that book? Or when did she
00:38:53.760
write the book? About the last, we've been working on it for about the last three years. No one wants
00:38:58.160
to publish the book. Nobody wants to publish the book. She's about to self publish it. And that's,
00:39:05.840
and that's craziness. That's craziness. It's not about politics, Patrick. It's not about politics.
00:39:13.200
You know, people, every time an FBI person blows the whistle, they say, are you a Democrat or
00:39:17.920
Republican or a liberal or whatever? That's not what it's about. It's about, this is what we said
00:39:24.800
happened. It's clear that this has happened. And we're not here to get paid off. We're not here
00:39:39.200
to help somebody overcome Trump or overcome Hillary over whatever. We're just saying, this is the way
00:39:44.720
the FBI stops whistleblowers. Imagine this, federal law, federal law, the Whistleblower Protection Act,
00:39:52.800
was passed in 1989. The FBI refused to implement it until 1996, 1997. They refused to implement
00:40:03.520
federal law at the FBI. And they got away with it. And why we sued William Clinton was to get a
00:40:12.240
writ of mandamus. That means get a court to order him to implement federal law. You know how bizarre that
00:40:18.480
it is? That's just bizarre, Patrick. The senior law enforcement agency, and they want to clearly
00:40:25.040
declare it the world, but you know, in the US, will not obey the law. It will not obey the law.
00:40:31.760
Let me read what happened. So maybe you can unpack a little bit what happened here. 1998,
00:40:36.000
the FBI, the FBI, and the DOJ agreed to settle with Dr. Whitehurst, yourself. Dr. Whitehurst's
00:40:41.840
whistleblower retaliation claims cleared his record, restored all of his rights, and paid him a record
00:40:47.440
breaking settlement of $1.42 million, an amount unheard of for any federal employee, least of all
00:40:55.600
an FBI agent. What happened there for them to pay the $1.42 million?
00:41:09.440
I think the man that is the strongest whistleblower advocate in the United States
00:41:15.040
in our Senate is Charles Grassley. You cannot bend that man. You cannot break that man.
00:41:22.720
He is exactly what you want to know a US Senator should be. He never quit. He never quit. He has
00:41:35.200
never quit. Just saying, you're going to adhere to the law, and by the way, I want to know this
00:41:42.160
information, and we give you the money to enforce the law. Now we want to know what you're using it for.
00:41:48.480
So there's no way to break Charles Grassley. He's a remarkable person.
00:41:57.840
But the FBI was facing that. They were facing the media. You know, when the O.J. Simpson trial came
00:42:05.600
along, I got dragged in as the mystery witness. That all of a sudden put it on the, uh-oh, there's this
00:42:11.760
FBI agent on the national news. Patrick, I live in a town of 1,600 people. My 1997 pickup truck has
00:42:19.360
crank-up windows in it, and that's who I am. I eat food out of the garden, okay? I had to ask Sam today,
00:42:26.560
the fellow that set this up with us, should I wear my suspenders and my, um, what do you see all the
00:42:34.240
lumberjack shirt, or should I put a suit on? He told me, well, it's up to you. Patrick doesn't
00:42:39.600
care, okay? It's so you see a suit. But we needed, I needed to stop what was happening there
00:42:46.880
in the lab, slanting, rewriting reports, altering evidence, um, people testifying about things they
00:42:56.480
had no idea about. But Washington, D.C. needed to get a handle on the FBI, which is out of control,
00:43:06.480
was out of control. And that, that's what they told me that my case really was about.
00:43:14.080
Um, I'm just a quantum chemist who wants to run a mass spectrometer the right way.
00:43:20.080
Yeah, but why did it pay to 1.42 million when you're saying the media? So you're saying they
00:43:25.040
wanted, they wanted to slant a story or they wanted to write a report? So are you saying that they
00:43:31.200
didn't want to tell the real truth of what happened and you did? And were they trying to kind of undermine
00:43:36.160
your reputation? No, I don't care about that. What they did, I don't have a reputation anyhow, okay?
00:43:41.440
What they did, Patrick, was to, um, we put forward to them, this is the settlement, okay?
00:43:52.000
Um, they had me under criminal investigation. They thought I had talked to the media,
00:43:56.240
okay? But this is what, this is what needs to happen. They agreed to admit to 40 sins, 40 things that
00:44:05.600
they'd done wrong, okay? And they did. And the, um, President Clinton agreed to order the FBI and the
00:44:21.280
U.S. Department of Justice to implement the Whistleblower Protection Act. He agreed to that.
00:44:26.560
And the U.S. Department of Justice agreed, finally, they were the holdouts to,
00:44:33.920
I wanted the contents of every file that the 11 guys that I reported misconduct,
00:44:40.000
their misconduct or malfeasance or misfeasance, I wanted the contents of every file they'd ever worked
00:44:46.320
on. And that was the largest Freedom of Information Act request of his kind in the FBI's history.
00:44:53.520
And I spent years acquiring it and then documenting it and cataloging it. And, um,
00:45:03.760
I've got it all. It's all digitized. Anybody that wants that information, I give it to them.
00:45:08.880
There was a fellow in the Harrison Fibers Unit who was found to have lied in the hearing involving a
00:45:17.200
federal judge. And I thought if he lied in that hearing, and I didn't find it out, another agent
00:45:25.520
sent a memo forward that said this guy had given false and misleading testimony there 27 times in a
00:45:32.080
hearing involving a federal judge. I mean, a federal judge was being, was being investigated for crime.
00:45:37.680
Okay. I figured if that guy did it with a federal judge, who else could he have harmed? So, so far,
00:45:45.120
I've collected the contents of about 1856 cases that he worked on. And men have gone free,
00:45:54.480
who have been in prison 20, 30 and 40 years because of that man's malfeasance,
00:46:00.800
have gone free. You can find their names. One of them is Donald Eugene Gates. Another one is Sante
00:46:07.440
Tribble and Sante died recently because of what happened to him in prison and the horrible conditions
00:46:13.680
he suffered under. Another was Kirk Odom and there's John Huffington. And the, and the names keep coming
00:46:20.240
out. They're like ghosts coming out of a fog because of one man, one man. And then it turned out that
00:46:29.360
his colleagues had also been doing the same thing. So in 2015, the FBI admitted that 26 of 28 FBI
00:46:41.200
hair examiners had given false and misleading testimony in their reports and or trial 90% of the
00:46:51.040
time over a 30 year period of time. And that's FBI admission, Patrick. And I can give you that.
00:46:57.440
And that's horrible. That, that brings tears to your eyes. It's so horrible because we need,
00:47:06.000
if I'm getting a little too loud, let me know Patrick, but we need to depend on somebody.
00:47:12.080
We need to know that our taxpayers dollars are going into protecting us into you real national
00:47:20.720
security. Not a bunch of people trying to make a career of their careers instead of do their jobs.
00:47:29.920
You know, it's amazing. I watch now Black Lives Matter and I'm cheering them. I'm a conservative,
00:47:36.080
old white Republican, and I'm cheering them because they've had enough. If you look at the record of the
00:47:42.480
people harmed by those hairs and fibers analyses, you'll find most of them are people of color.
00:47:49.680
Most of them are African American and nobody seems to pick up on that.
1.00
00:47:55.920
On that, that, well, he must be guilty. Therefore, the evidence is, this is what it means.
00:48:01.680
That's wrong. I, you know, I went to law school. I don't know if you noted that, but I went to
00:48:10.320
Georgetown and I got my JD. I went because the deputy general counsel at the FBI told me
00:48:18.080
when I went to her with these issues, if you just knew the law, Fred, you'd understand why these are
00:48:22.240
not really such big issues. So I applied to law school and Georgetown accepted me. Nobody else would.
00:48:29.520
But Georgetown accepted me. I went to law school for four years at night while I was
00:48:36.400
suing the FBI and the US Department of Justice and the President of the United States and
00:48:42.240
all those people and things. And I got out of law school and the deputy general counsel is still there.
00:48:51.920
And she said to me, Fred, that's just theory. You need to practice law. So I've practiced law for 16 years.
00:48:59.520
I've been a criminal defense attorney for 16 years. I got to tell you, Patrick, I've hated every
00:49:03.920
microsecond of it. I hate the courtroom. It's a place of misery. It's a place of crime. It's a place
00:49:09.680
of injustice. But at the end of it, I still think it's wrong for us to lie in court, to present half the
00:49:19.840
truth. And by the way, the FBI lab is doing it, still doing it. They moved and they recovered from
00:49:28.240
that. But now they've moved back into it. I watch FBI cases today and I look at, you know, I'm hired as
00:49:36.240
a forensic consultant. And I see, oh my goodness, they're rewriting reports. And oh my goodness,
00:49:43.280
they're talking about stuff they don't know anything about. And they're misinterpreting data.
00:49:47.680
You know, I asked you a question. I said, who's going to hold them accountable? So you said you,
00:49:53.600
who's me, media. Okay. Is me media or is me, we, the people? Which one is you?
00:49:59.280
You know what? We, the people read what you, the media published. Okay. Media, media has lost some of
00:50:06.880
its credibility too. You know, we've seen, we've seen that it's been politicized, but
00:50:11.120
one thing that's encouraging to me, literally, and I've said it already about Black Lives Matter
00:50:18.800
is that they've had enough. Those folks were right or wrong. They have had enough and they've had
00:50:27.580
enough and it's not going to, it's not going to stop. I pray it's not going to stop just because
00:50:33.000
it got cold. You know, it's not going to stop because we had our celebration this summer and now
00:50:38.940
we're going to go home and things are going to be right. I think it's going to carry forward.
00:50:43.520
And I think that demonstrates to this nation, we have had enough. This, this thing that you represent
00:50:51.060
is supposed to be our thing and you've made it into your thing.
00:50:55.120
Okay. Fred, question at the time when you were coming up. So one case, John F. Kennedy. So at
00:51:01.580
that time you said Hoover earlier, who was more powerful at that time? The mob, Hoover or JFK?
00:51:07.920
JFK. JFK was more powerful at that time. Yes, that's right. Then it's Hoover. Then it's the mob.
00:51:13.440
Did I say JFK? You said JFK at the top. I'm very sorry. No, I'm sorry. I misspoke. No,
00:51:19.900
the FBI. So Hoover was the most powerful in America. Yes. Who was after him?
00:51:29.220
I don't know that. I don't know that. Wait, let me, let me get this straight. So you're saying from
00:51:35.100
that time till today, the FBI, has it always been where FBI has been more powerful than the president?
00:51:42.700
Yes. And I would say it this way. I would say it this way until they met Mr. Trump. Okay. Then
00:51:52.700
they met themselves. You know, that's my opinion. He just wasn't going to be bullied around by that
00:51:57.920
stuff. And, you know, I was laughing about it. I wasn't in love with Mr. Trump, but I was laughing
00:52:03.040
about the fact that he, he just, wait a minute, you're not doing that. You're not coming over here
00:52:08.240
and doing that to me. I'm your boss, you know, and that famous saying of his, you're fired. Okay.
00:52:16.400
But we had an FBI director, the only FBI director in the FBI's history, William Sessions, who was a
00:52:23.460
true good American FBI agent, a true good man, an ethical good man that the FBI upper management
00:52:32.420
conspired against and got fired. William Sessions was a, I'll tell you, he sent a memo out to all
00:52:40.640
personnel at one time. He said, if you have an issue that you, you have not, do not feel has been
00:52:46.260
addressed, I want to know about it. Come to my office. When I got that memo, I picked the phone
00:52:52.260
up immediately. The memo was in my hand. His secretary said, come up right now. That doesn't happen at the
00:52:59.660
FBI. A mid-level manager like me goes up to the, yes. And he listened to me for 45 minutes.
00:53:06.900
That was a national leader. And then two weeks later, he brought me back with his general counsel
00:53:12.580
and they talked to me for two hours. Get out of here. Yes. And I was talking to him about the
00:53:19.280
problems in the lab. This is the director of FBI at the time. This is the director of
00:53:23.660
William Sessions. Yes. And then shortly after that, he got fired. He got set up by his upper
00:53:34.260
management because he was bringing some sense of, of good to us.
00:53:41.000
Let me ask you, since, since you've been out, since you've been out. Okay. So you, you're done. You
00:53:49.980
know, you get your obviously lawsuit settled 1.42 in 1998. That's 22 years ago. What have you been
00:53:56.800
doing the last 22 years? Well, um, for five years after I got out, I was offering my services as a
00:54:08.180
consultant, um, in forensic science. I was, um, going through FBI documents and watching how they
00:54:18.560
were handling cases and looking at what they were, how they were progressing. And they progressed, Patrick.
00:54:25.240
They're light years from where they were when I got out. Okay. But the rot is sneaking back in.
00:54:30.820
But, um, after five years, um, I live in a small county in the middle of nowhere in North Carolina.
00:54:39.340
Okay. After five years, I, um, said, well, I got a law degree and I don't understand these guys around
00:54:47.500
here. I'm offering my services free and nobody's calling me. So I said, well, I need to go over to
00:54:52.180
the courthouse, start practicing law and find out what's going on. And so I went over and, uh, by the way,
00:55:00.120
nobody would hire me. Nobody wants to hire somebody that sued the president, you know,
00:55:04.380
that's trouble around the office. I mean, nobody anywhere would hire me. Um, but that was okay.
00:55:09.380
I needed to work for myself. And, uh, I took the bar exam and failed it and took the bar exam and
00:55:16.800
failed it. And then I took the bar exam and passed it. And then I went over to the courthouse and for
00:55:21.200
about 90 days, I sat in the courtroom trying to figure out what in the Dickens is going on.
00:55:25.060
And then I, uh, went over the public defender's office and put my name on the, uh, indigent defense
00:55:33.400
list and started, uh, going to court with folks. And I got to tell you what goes on in the courtroom
00:55:40.400
has nothing to do with what goes on in law school. It's like, you know, if you don't go in as an
00:55:46.880
apprentice for somebody, you are lost. So I started defending folks to, to understand why
00:55:56.140
court, the courtrooms allow garbage in the name of science, name science, it's garbage
00:56:04.380
to be entered as evidence. And then I started consulting heavily. And then it was a point
00:56:13.200
at which I had about 250 cases I was representing, which is crazy impossible. And I learned the
00:56:20.880
culture of the courtroom is a big reason why the forensic science gets away with what it
00:56:26.280
gets away with. Um, when you go into a courtroom and there's 12 to 2,500 people coming through
00:56:32.760
that courtroom in one day, one day, and they have 360 minutes to parse among all of them.
00:56:40.560
You can't say Fourier transform infrared spectrophotometry. You can't say gas chromatography,
00:56:45.940
mass spectrometry. You've got a lineup behind the rest of the attorneys waiting for two or three
00:56:50.740
prosecutors, possibly only one. Hand them your, your, your bid for freedom. They give you back
00:56:57.660
their bid. You go to your client, you come back, you, I mean, it's going, it's a, it is a production
00:57:03.120
line and concepts of validation of scientific protocols are way, way, way outside the sphere
00:57:14.780
of people that practice law every day that literally go into court. So, so let me ask you,
00:57:21.120
did, did, did what you do the last 22 years distract you from going back and holding the FBI
00:57:29.280
accountable where you were kind of like, well, I did my part. I'm moving on to becoming an attorney
00:57:33.400
or is there still the fire right now where the last 22 years have taught you on how to go out there and
00:57:40.420
expose more today? Meaning, is there still a inspiration? Is there still a fire or a chip on
00:57:46.720
your shoulder to say what's wrong is wrong. I want to be able to go expose it today. Are
00:57:51.040
you kind of over it? I'm moving on. I will die exposing. I will die raising questions. I mean,
00:57:59.700
I'm saying it's 73. I got until I'm blind, until I can't get out of bed until I will do this till
00:58:07.340
the day I die. This is my country and I'm not giving it away to thugs period. Define thugs.
00:58:15.320
Thugs. What I saw at the FBI. Alter scientists reports. Alter evidence. Lie in court. Intimidate
00:58:28.260
people on the street. All of that. You know, I'm not giving it up to them. I'm going to fight smart.
00:58:36.760
You know, the Viet Cong taught me fight to fight again. You know, they didn't stand up and shoot at
00:58:43.520
you. They came out of a hole, shot at you and came back in the hole. Fight to fight again. Fight smart.
00:58:49.900
But I'm not giving my country away. I'm not going to. It's mine. And if everybody else wants to give
00:58:57.820
it away, that's just fine. So I look at their protocols. I look at whether they validated things
00:59:06.840
or not. I raise issues. Validate means that, and I'll tell you, the folks who may hear this may not
00:59:14.020
understand what I'm saying. Okay. When I ask you a question, you give me an answer, but did you give
00:59:20.280
me the right answer? You had a method which you used to give me an answer. Is it a method that gave the
00:59:26.920
right answer? If you validated it? Forensic science didn't even understand that. They didn't
00:59:34.440
understand that until about Supreme Court law, Daubert versus Merrill-Galph Pharmaceuticals came out and
00:59:41.800
said, if you're going to come into a court of law with evidence, you've got to tell us if you use the
00:59:47.460
right process to get to it. It's sort of, if we harken back to Matt versus Ohio, it used to be that
00:59:55.240
officers beat confessions out of people. Well, then you get the suppression of evidence.
01:00:02.800
Okay. We're not going to accept that evidence because it's more important that we do this job
01:00:07.960
right. Well, what happened was the nightsticks got traded for people in crime laboratories.
01:00:15.560
You're either going to do it right and give us the answer and prove how you got that answer
01:00:21.480
or else you're not going to do it. Well, it's taken over 20, 1993. What is that? 20 years or whatever.
01:00:34.680
And courts are still not accepting that. You walk in with a badge and a gun and you're an FBI agent and
01:00:41.960
by golly, we better believe those boys in blue. No, there are boys in blue who cross the blue line.
01:00:50.080
You know that expression. I didn't cross the blue line. They crossed. They go outside
01:00:57.080
the honorable profession of being law enforcement officer. And we have a difficulty pointing our
01:01:04.720
fingers at them because very often they are false heroes. So Fred, who fears them the most? Who fears the FBI
01:01:13.540
the most? I think the nation is afraid of the FBI. You think so? You think the nation as people
01:01:23.140
is afraid of the FBI? I think so, sir. Tell me, tell me why you think the nation is afraid of the FBI.
01:01:29.300
You know, the FBI in many ways represents a national security threat.
01:01:42.260
If I know what you're going to say, I can make you say anything I want you to. If I know that your
01:01:51.540
primary purpose in life is to become promoted so that you're making more salary, I can get you
01:01:58.820
promoted if you say what I want you to. I can do that. Then when we have national security threat,
01:02:06.740
like let's say weapons of mass destruction. I watched that silliness in where was Iraq,
1.00
01:02:15.940
you know? And I heard military officers say to me, we saw from our satellites what was coming out of
01:02:22.340
those tractor trailer trucks. Okay? You can't see from 30,000 feet in the air, much less 30,000 or
01:02:32.740
whatever. You can. It's not possible. But you get people to say it. And then what have we got?
01:02:40.260
We're running off on boondoggles, following faults. The American people need to demand more than that.
01:02:48.180
And I think when the media says we won't publish our FBI,
01:02:53.140
you know, they don't feel solidly on footing to put out information that's valid information
01:03:03.620
that can be tested and checked and documented. They're okay. They're not sure that the people
01:03:09.700
will back them. And the people, people are afraid of the FBI. And that's too bad.
01:03:17.140
Yeah. Who dislikes you? Who is afraid of you? Or people like you?
01:03:22.980
I think the people that, that dislike people like me are those that are guilty.
01:03:28.900
I think so. There are guys there, you know, I don't know what you're going to do with this footage,
01:03:34.020
but there are FBI agents that will be infuriated by what I'm saying. They will think that I crossed
01:03:40.820
the blue line. I have friends, very good and close friends who are still, well,
01:03:45.780
they're out of the FBI now, but it will tell me about conversations they go into where people say,
01:03:51.300
that guy's a nut. He's a traitor. Okay. Well, so I'm a nut. Oh, okay. But I present to you
01:04:02.020
US government documentation to say what I'm saying. Don't trust me. Don't trust the FBI. Ask for
01:04:11.540
the data. Ask for the process. And you know what? We're not going into court and asking for,
01:04:16.820
I want your data and I want your protocol. And I don't care if it's the data from an investigation
01:04:22.260
in the field or if it's in the laboratory or what I want to see it. And we're not doing that. And I
01:04:28.660
don't think we're, we're not doing that out of, of laziness. I think we're not doing that out of fear,
01:04:34.900
out of fear. What's going to happen? Is he going to start looking at my, um, computer, um, searches,
01:04:45.620
or, uh, is he going to look at my taxes or is he going to harass me or is what, is he going to show
01:04:51.940
up at my job and ask my boss if I'm there knowing my boss is afraid of him. So I'll lose my, all of that
01:04:58.580
stuff. You need to get a handle on that, Patrick. So then that means the business model of the,
01:05:04.900
if, because if you're saying that to me, first place I go to is the business model of, of an FBI
01:05:10.260
agent doesn't work. Meaning if I have to worry about kissing your ass to get a promotion, that
0.50
01:05:15.820
model doesn't work in the FBI. If that makes any sense. I don't know if I'm making any sense on what
01:05:19.480
I'm saying. The business model has to be based on markers. I hit whether you like it or not.
01:05:25.220
Uh, uh, and how you do that. I don't know how you do that. I'm not in that world. Uh, uh, I know
01:05:31.560
every business has a certain form of a compensation structure on how they pay people. And sometimes a
01:05:36.920
certain comp plan can create bad habits. So if you're saying I need to kiss someone's ass to get
01:05:44.080
a promotion, that is definitely not a good comp structure set up for FBI agents. I wouldn't want
01:05:48.960
that kind of account for FBI agents. Well, you give the right answer to the right guy,
01:05:56.700
to the right question at the right time to get the right job. And that's the model. And that's the
01:06:02.140
model. It's not effective. I mean, I, I just, I think there's no accountability. Yeah. If you make
01:06:10.140
a mistake, there's no account. You know what? I don't know what business you're in Patrick,
01:06:13.240
but if you're selling a product, okay. And you sell a product that doesn't work, but you know
01:06:19.180
what? You've got a business. There's no, there's no accountability there. So if you've got no
01:06:25.080
accountability, you've got to have maximum oversight. Every time you take a step, you take
01:06:30.600
a step, someone has to look over your shoulder. Now there's a public policy reason to have no
01:06:35.400
accountability for law enforcement because law enforcement would be sued continually and be
01:06:39.700
put out of work. That's been carried too far. And there's movement in this country right now
01:06:44.900
to start naming names and giving citizens the right to sue law enforcement officers who, you know,
01:06:52.660
who pull this stuff of shooting folks in the back who are running from them and things like that.
01:06:59.440
The man who put Donald Eugene Gates in prison for 28 years of his life lives in a
01:07:09.580
nice corner lot in a nice suburb, making a bunch of money. And for three years after he got out of
01:07:16.460
the bureau, there was the things I raised about him. Then the FBI hired him again as a contract
01:07:21.060
employee. They let him go. When I, when during a new revelations coming out, I called a newspaper,
01:07:30.440
a well-known newspaper, and I said, would you ask the question publicly, why is he still working for
01:07:34.520
the FBI when you know these things have happened? Okay. And they did. And the FBI let him go that day.
01:07:42.400
There is no accountability. They should go and seize his retirement check, seize his home,
01:07:48.580
seize all his property. I don't care where he goes. I'm sorry. He can live in an apartment someplace if he
01:07:53.880
can afford it. Take it all away and use it to try to make hold, though you will never make hold,
01:08:00.700
those people that he put down for decades with false and misleading testimony. And the government
01:08:07.940
has admitted this man did this. There's a case out there, U.S. versus Derry Nelson. Derry spent 33 years
01:08:16.840
in prison. He got out about two years ago after we fought for about four years. He got out. Now he's
01:08:23.680
waiting to be tried again for murder. And the government admits, and the court admits, that the
01:08:29.980
evidence presented by that particular FBI agent was lies and fabrications. And the court of appeals says
01:08:35.940
it was perjury. There's no accountability for that agent. He's beyond accountability. Patrick,
01:08:42.840
you know, if there is no accountability, there has to be absolute total oversight. Every day,
01:08:53.700
people are monitoring what's going. There are cameras. Everything you do, everything you do,
01:08:59.220
there's a camera pointed in. Otherwise, you don't fear anything. But you do want to get ahead and get
01:09:07.100
to be the section chief or the deputy director or go to the Rose Garden and have somebody put a medal
01:09:13.960
on you. You know? Yeah. So yes, kissing ass doesn't give a good product with promotion that way. But
1.00
01:09:21.880
it's the format for the FBI. You know, I'm looking at a number right now from Gallup, say FBI positive
01:09:31.540
job rating steady among Americans. This is from a year ago, May of 2019. It says, to give you the
01:09:39.640
specific numbers, 57% of Americans say the FBI is doing an excellent or a good job. Okay. 57%. This
01:09:48.220
is from Gallup. There's another one that says 76%, which is from courthouse news, saying 76% of Americans
01:09:54.940
think that the FBI is doing a good job. Do you think America looks at FBI in a trusting way and
01:10:04.620
they say, you know, I don't know what Fred is talking about. I just think he's a former disgruntled
01:10:09.560
FBI agent. He just, you know, somebody probably pissed him off and I get it, you know, good for him,
01:10:13.420
you know, something probably happened and more power to him, you know, but most FBI agents are good guys
01:10:19.900
and they're doing the right things. And I don't think they have the power. It's like cops, you know,
01:10:23.700
one, one cop doesn't ruin all cops. Of course there's bad cops, but not all cops are bad cops.
01:10:29.240
You know, I think it's just over-exaggerating. What would you say to that?
01:10:33.540
I would say, first of all, most FBI agents are good folks. And I testified to that on the Senate,
01:10:40.320
you know, don't paint this with too narrow a brush and don't paint it with too broad a brush.
01:10:45.240
Most FBI employees are good people. They do have a, a moral dilemma they have to face.
01:10:51.140
Um, do I uphold my oath or do I keep my family safe? Okay. But they're good people.
01:10:58.380
What happens is the management of the FBI is, is phenomenally, in my opinion, corrupt.
01:11:03.840
And I think when you go to the field and you ask field agents about what they refer to as
01:11:08.480
BU humps, BU as in boy uniform, Bravo uniform, BU humps. Nobody has a good opinion of BU humps.
01:11:16.880
They are people that gave the right answer to the right guy to get the right job, the right time,
01:11:21.460
that sort of. Okay. Um, I think that it's sort of like what you said about most think you're doing
01:11:29.000
a good job. There are people on the street that think I'm a good attorney. How do they know whether
01:11:34.920
I'm a good attorney or not? They're not attorneys. They can't judge me. How did anybody know that agent
01:11:41.300
that put, that put that man in prison for 28 years based on false and misleading testimony?
01:11:47.660
How did anyone know that that agent was not a good guy? When you looked at him, he was an agent's
01:11:53.920
agent. He was a very handsome man. He was tall. He was built. He was, you know, he was soft-spoken
01:12:02.300
and he was an out and out liar. He was a psychopath in my opinion. Okay. How would anybody know that?
01:12:11.460
He got three attorneys general's awards. I mean, the United States Department of Justice gave him
01:12:17.480
three awards. And then one day I'm in this other agent's office and the agent pulls out a memo he
01:12:25.920
wrote on the third day of August 1989. And he says that psychopath gave false and misleading testimony
01:12:33.660
27 times in a hearing involving a federal judge by the name of Alcee Hastings, who is now a senior
01:12:42.300
U.S. congressman. And he gave me that memo. And I copied that memo and the world would have never seen
01:12:52.200
that memo. And that memo was to that agent's boss to telling this is going on. And we need to fix this
01:13:00.600
or do something about it or the FBI's reputation is going to suffer. Okay. How would you, how would
01:13:05.760
the American people know whether FBI agents are doing the job right? By looking at the work product
01:13:11.800
of the Office of Congressional and Public Affairs. They got more agents worried about the media
01:13:18.740
representation and what the public perceives of them than they do about some major crime areas.
01:13:24.740
There's a hundreds of people in the Office of Congressional and Public Affairs.
01:13:28.820
Okay. And those guys are continually feeding misinformation. And so you see today's FBI,
01:13:36.580
you see, you know, there's an FBI show on right now where there's a woman agent and a Middle Eastern guy
01:13:42.900
who is an agent. And you say, boy, and those of us that have been in the FBI, there's a glass ceiling.
01:13:49.860
That's, that's silliness. That's silliness. You know, that's not what happens in the FBI.
01:13:55.780
The FBI is an old white man's organization. And it stays that way by brute force.
0.87
01:14:02.020
Is it really? Yes. If you call, say, call on Rosemary Dew or whatever, you know, and look at,
01:14:10.180
and look at some of the underlying, a friend of mine, a friend of mine just got out of prison on
01:14:14.900
the 18th of this month. He was an FBI agent. He got four years. He can't talk about it, but he got four
01:14:23.220
years because he did not want to go into Muslim communities of immigrants and force people in
0.99
01:14:35.140
the religious community to stitch on their people in the community. He don't want to do it.
1.00
01:14:42.100
And he went about revealing it in a way that the FBI was able to get him convicted to four years,
01:14:49.780
four years in sentence. He's just got out after two.
01:14:55.460
The American people do not know the problems in the FBI, and they can't know.
01:15:02.180
J. Edgar Hoover building is a bunker. And you're not allowed in.
01:15:08.580
Who's working hard right now to expose them? And who do you think can be successful at doing that?
01:15:18.500
That's the one you were talking about earlier. Senator Charles Grasley is an American hero.
01:15:23.860
Who's the biggest name that has his back even bigger than him, more powerful than him?
01:15:38.420
He is holding up the building. What's supporting Senator Charles Grasley is the fact that he is
01:15:50.900
He's above reproach. He's above the FBI tricks. Completely above it. He is an American hero. He is
01:16:19.140
Well, in today's times, you know, 73, we have a 78-year-old president-elect and a 74-year-old
01:16:27.220
So today, actually, that would be considered old a long time ago. Not today. Today, we're
01:16:36.820
You know, you eventually joined the board of directors at the National
01:16:40.900
Whistleblower Center, and you helped fight cases where misconduct has been involved,
01:16:45.540
helping innocent people get out of jail. And you've been doing that, you know, several of the
01:16:49.060
things you've worked on. What do you think about what Tulsi Gabbard said recently,
01:16:53.060
when she said she believes Trump should pardon Julian Assange and Edward Snowden? I don't
01:16:58.580
know if you caught that or not, but she just said that a few days ago.
01:17:14.580
You know, what Mr. Snowden pointed out was that there was not a place he could go to
01:17:20.900
in our national security agencies. That would work. That's what he pointed out.
01:17:29.060
The secrets that he let go, that I understand, I don't have first-hand knowledge that are damaging
01:17:37.140
to national security makes me say, you know, there's got to be another way.
01:17:48.020
There's got to be another way. NSA, CIA, intelligence community, whatever. There's got to be another
01:17:54.820
way to do this. Besides, when whistleblowers are not allowed to report internally.
01:18:02.580
Then they're like me. They finally just go out. And it creates a distrust.
01:18:12.020
But if Snowden was a righteous, he had righteous concerns. So did my friend that just got out of
01:18:19.940
prison after two, four years of sentence, but two years in. Okay. Righteous concern.
01:18:25.220
And the bullies in those organizations will not seriously consider the concerns and try to address
01:18:33.700
them. And, you know, as a nation, we're concerned about that stuff. Should they give him a pardon?
01:18:44.100
I am personally afraid of anything that Donald Trump does. I'm a Republican. I'm an old conservative
01:18:55.780
white man, Republican. Okay. But I am concerned about anything he does. He frightens me in his
01:19:03.060
amateur way of going about what he's going about.
01:19:04.820
Can you unpack that? You're saying he's going through things in an amateur way. Can you unpack
01:19:10.900
it? What do you mean by that? He's an amateur. He's not out of DC. He doesn't understand the
01:19:17.300
nuances of what he's doing. And he's, some of the, some of his ideas are good ideas, but
01:19:24.660
to continually get caught in lies in inappropriate activity and behavior and, you know, misogynistic,
01:19:36.420
whatever, and all of that stuff to encourage white supremacists or whatever. That's, that's,
01:19:42.820
that's a, that's an amateur. That's an amateur. Leading this country takes a professional and
01:19:49.700
um, it's too bad because we need that, uh, whatever it is that sort of, I'm going to stand
01:19:58.820
in your face, but we also need some substance behind it. And I'm, I'm afraid Donald doesn't
01:20:04.580
have that substance. That's my personal opinion. No, it's, it's your perspective is, is, is hurt.
01:20:10.660
You know, it's who would you say was a good combination of having a backbone and still
01:20:16.100
knowing how to play the political game. Who was a good combination of both?
01:20:20.660
Well, I'll, I'll announce in your show, I voted for Kamala Harris.
0.75
01:20:25.860
You voted for Kamala Harris. I did. I voted for, I voted for Joe Biden because
01:20:31.140
he's tagging along with Kamala, but she's been a public servant her whole life.
0.73
01:20:36.500
I want to see equality in this nation. I want to see someone who's an attorney, who's been in court,
01:20:44.260
who understands our legal system. I want to, I I've been up against her at a, at a distance
01:20:50.660
in a court case. I went through in San Francisco where she was actually providing cover for somebody
0.80
01:20:55.940
that was providing bad information. She didn't know it. But, um, uh, when I went down there,
01:21:02.500
that's, that's who I, that's my finger went, my pen went on that. Um, who, who are your all time, uh,
01:21:09.700
favorite presidents? I'm curious, like, who else have you voted for? Who do you look at as a
01:21:13.620
great president? I love Ronald Reagan. You know, um, I know Ronald had his faults,
01:21:19.940
but I love Ronald Reagan. I'm just sorry that he was a Hollywood cowboy, you know? Um, uh,
01:21:27.220
uh, and the first time, the first time I voted for Barack Obama, I was pleased that Barack's personal
01:21:37.380
life didn't get crowded into the media all the time exposure. I'm so tired of that, you know? Um,
01:21:45.940
but I didn't vote for anybody the next time I'm a, I was afraid that he went way too far in the other
01:21:51.380
direction and, and created Donald Trump is what I think he did. Did you vote for Trump or no? No. Um,
01:22:01.380
I did not vote for Trump. I couldn't vote for anybody in that election. Got it. Got it. Uh, uh,
01:22:10.180
uh, interesting, uh, interesting perspective for you to not, uh, support a Trump
01:22:16.420
pardoning Assange and Edward Snowden because they would be whistleblowers and why not pardon them so
01:22:27.140
they can be free. It's very interesting because you're very, um, you're, you're, you're tough to
01:22:34.580
put in a place because you're all, you're, you're in different places politically, but who you vote
01:22:40.500
for what you like, what you dislike, you like Trump's personality to go up against the FBI
01:22:46.180
because you thought he was the right guy that could go up against FBI, but you didn't vote for
01:22:50.180
him. You voted for Kamala Harris because you like her approach works. You know, you're very interesting
01:22:55.060
where you are and how you process issues. Very, very interesting. I have to say this to you. Um,
01:23:00.660
you know, I'd like to do a quick, uh, a speed round. I'll give you a name and tell me the first
01:23:05.460
thing that comes to mind. I'll give you one name and tell me the first thing that comes to mind. Uh, Putin.
01:23:25.940
I don't have a name for him unless you want me to say something. Oh, it's not a name, any word,
01:23:30.740
any word that comes to mind. You can tell me. Comey, what word comes to mind?
01:23:35.460
The word? Problem. Uh, so what word would come to mind for Putin?
01:24:54.660
I got to tell you, I've enjoyed this, uh, uh, conversation with you.
01:25:08.820
obviously, you know, the one thing is very, very clear with you.
01:25:20.340
You're calling out, you know, who you consider being one of the most powerful institutions that have not, are not held accountable by anybody.
01:25:31.300
Um, and I'm really curious to know what you're going to do at the young age of 73.
01:25:35.860
Like, I'm really curious to know what you're going to do next.
01:25:38.020
Because if you're talking about Senator Grassley at 87, being the one that's going around, you know, driving his initiative.
01:25:48.340
And he's the leader to be able to hold the FBI accountable.
01:25:52.340
That means, uh, you, you got some fresh, you know, legs to be able to make a run at some things you can expose.
01:26:01.220
And I'm very curious and looking forward to seeing what you're going to be doing.
01:26:06.580
Well, are you asking me a question or telling me good night?
01:26:11.940
I'm going to leave it open-ended for you to have closing thoughts.
01:26:15.540
What do you want to say before we wrap this up?
01:26:25.060
And I'm going to keep watching the people that I think are failing.
01:26:42.420
I've learned what I need to learn in a court of law.
01:26:45.060
And so I'm not going to represent defendants in courts of law anymore.
01:26:49.780
But, um, my, my strong point is science and just saying, you know, this is the way I see it.
01:27:03.940
And I, I think finishing up, I'm going to continue to collect data.
01:27:08.740
And it's, you know, it's U.S. government documents, or if it's data from crime laboratories, or if it's testimonies from courts or whatever, I'm going to continue to collect data and give it away to anybody that wants it.
01:27:24.980
Well, let us know if you got anything new you want to share with us, we're here to, uh, if you got anything you want to share with, uh, the world, because they're curious as well.
01:27:40.020
Uh, I know we're not going to be speaking probably in a month of December.
01:27:44.180
If we don't happy holidays, Merry Christmas and a happy new year to you.
01:27:50.740
How can that story be so secretive where not many people have heard his stories?
01:27:57.460
Like if you go online right now, you type in his name, you're not going to find out.
01:28:00.900
You'll see Wikipedia, but you're not going to find anything.
01:28:03.860
I mean, you're not going to find videos, interviews, nothing of him.
01:28:07.860
And to have that fascinating of an interview, to be that stubbornly curious that you want to know.
01:28:18.420
And, uh, if you enjoyed this, I mean, he's still got me thinking.
01:28:22.500
If you enjoyed this interview, you would also enjoy an interview I did with Michael McGowan,
01:28:25.940
former FBI agent who went up against the Sinaloa cartel and La Cosa Nostra.
01:28:30.820
If you've never watched this, click over here to watch that interview.
01:28:33.780
Nobody knew him until we did the interview, and then he ended up getting a million views
01:28:39.460
And if you've not subscribed to the channel, please do so.