Verdict with Ted Cruz - May 10, 2024


Big Tech Still Silencing Conservatives on Social Media plus NPR New CEO Questions 1st Amendment


Episode Stats

Length

44 minutes

Words per Minute

154.71536

Word Count

6,846

Sentence Count

209

Misogynist Sentences

18

Hate Speech Sentences

9


Summary


Transcript

00:00:00.000 This is an iHeart Podcast.
00:00:02.540 Guaranteed human.
00:00:05.340 Welcome.
00:00:06.160 It is Verdict with Senator Ted Cruz.
00:00:08.420 Ben Ferguson with you.
00:00:10.460 And you guys know if you listen to the show regularly
00:00:12.860 that the senator and I do this show around his Senate schedule,
00:00:17.060 especially when it comes to his official duties.
00:00:19.840 Well, if you are looking at my clock right now,
00:00:23.520 it's about two in the morning.
00:00:25.580 And the senator's flight, which was obviously extremely late,
00:00:29.120 meant that at this point, we still couldn't do the show.
00:00:33.540 Now, here's the good news.
00:00:35.200 We have two conversations that Senator Cruz and I had
00:00:38.140 that deal with big tech and also silencing of conservatives
00:00:41.940 that I'm going to play for you.
00:00:44.580 But this is the part I love about doing this show.
00:00:47.620 We do this show all times, day and night.
00:00:50.880 And then sometimes the flights just don't cooperate,
00:00:55.140 even in the early a.m. hours.
00:00:57.420 So, now you understand what's going on.
00:01:00.440 Don't worry.
00:01:00.980 We'll have your weekend review for you tomorrow as well.
00:01:05.180 But these are two important topics that I want you to hear about.
00:01:08.640 And there are a lot going on in D.C.,
00:01:11.220 specifically around the issue of big tech
00:01:13.860 and what they're doing to silence conservatives.
00:01:17.960 But first, there are so many verdict listeners
00:01:20.840 that have been asking how can you get involved
00:01:22.600 and how can you help the people in Israel.
00:01:24.880 Well, I want you to know about IFCJ.
00:01:28.280 IFCJ is helping on the ground in Israel right now.
00:01:32.440 Since October the 7th, the attacks on Israel have increased
00:01:35.780 with Iran and its proxies that launched an attack
00:01:38.320 of hundreds of drones and missiles.
00:01:40.660 And Israelis are living with the harsh reality of terror
00:01:43.120 every single day.
00:01:44.320 The International Fellowship of Christians and Jews
00:01:46.840 is on the ground addressing all of the urgent needs.
00:01:50.580 And that's why I want you to work with them.
00:01:53.380 They are doing incredible work
00:01:55.200 because they're helping the people there
00:01:57.040 with literal bomb shelters.
00:01:59.240 Emergency bomb shelter kits
00:02:00.860 that are being delivered immediately
00:02:02.500 to those in desperate need.
00:02:05.000 Your life-saving donation today
00:02:06.540 will help assemble and place these kits
00:02:09.240 with enough food and life-saving emergency supplies
00:02:12.140 for 20 people huddled in a bomb shelter.
00:02:14.720 Now, the cost to put together and distribute these kits
00:02:17.640 is $290 each.
00:02:20.620 And your gift will help save lives.
00:02:23.260 And thanks to a matching challenge gift
00:02:25.340 from a generous IFCJ supporter,
00:02:28.620 your gift will double in impact
00:02:30.720 to help provide twice the support needed on the ground.
00:02:34.080 So if you want to help the people of Israel,
00:02:36.940 all you have to do is call this number to make your gift.
00:02:40.440 888-488-IFCJ.
00:02:44.080 That's 888-488-IFCJ.
00:02:49.600 Or you can go online to supportifcj.org to give.
00:02:54.680 That's one word.
00:02:56.180 Support ifcj.org to give now.
00:03:00.860 Senator, big tech is obviously had a massive influence
00:03:04.800 over public opinion in this country.
00:03:07.120 We saw a recent report that came out
00:03:09.700 just on TikTok, for example,
00:03:11.900 where they were 45 to 1 stories
00:03:14.920 that were pro-Palestinian, pro-Hamas over Israel.
00:03:18.600 That's one example of how they've really been able
00:03:21.000 to shape public opinion,
00:03:22.200 especially with young people
00:03:23.280 and the riots and the chaos
00:03:25.240 we're witnessing on college campuses right now.
00:03:27.820 But there's also something else
00:03:29.180 that's happened with big tech.
00:03:30.480 I've been a victim of it.
00:03:31.660 I spoke out against big tech a few years ago
00:03:34.660 at a CPAC convention,
00:03:36.380 and before I landed home,
00:03:39.000 after I spoke out about big tech,
00:03:41.000 specifically Facebook,
00:03:42.540 my accounts were shut down.
00:03:44.880 They have never worked the same way
00:03:47.560 as they did before.
00:03:49.180 The reach has disappeared.
00:03:51.180 I've witnessed it.
00:03:52.640 And many other conservative leaders out there
00:03:55.280 are going through the same things.
00:03:56.980 And it always seems to happen, Senator,
00:03:59.080 right during a big election cycle
00:04:02.400 where the Democrats get a free flow of information out
00:04:05.700 and conservatives get hammered and silenced.
00:04:09.220 Well, that's exactly right.
00:04:10.340 So I started last year as the ranking member
00:04:12.900 on the Senate Committee of Commerce,
00:04:14.360 Science, and Transportation.
00:04:15.960 And from that position as the ranking member,
00:04:18.200 which means the senior Republican on that committee,
00:04:20.340 I launched an investigation
00:04:21.480 into the abuse of power from big tech.
00:04:24.080 And this past week, we put out a major report.
00:04:26.380 The report is entitled
00:04:27.340 Weaponizing Terms of Service,
00:04:29.660 How Online Service Providers Use Broad Policies
00:04:32.560 to Silence Conservatives.
00:04:34.180 Now, there are a lot of instances
00:04:35.720 that we know about that get a lot of publicity.
00:04:38.660 We know, for example, that Twitter,
00:04:40.960 before Elon Musk purchased them,
00:04:43.580 suspended the account of the Babylon Bee
00:04:45.980 for making a joke about a Biden administration official.
00:04:49.460 We know that both Facebook and Twitter
00:04:51.640 suppressed stories about Hunter Biden's laptop
00:04:54.380 before the 2020 election.
00:04:56.480 We know that Facebook removed posts
00:04:59.460 suggesting that COVID-19 originated in a Wuhan lab,
00:05:04.120 something we talked about at length on this podcast,
00:05:07.320 and a theory that has now been confirmed
00:05:09.480 both by the Federal Department of Energy
00:05:11.120 and the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
00:05:12.860 We know that YouTube took down
00:05:16.900 a March 2021 video of a panel discussion
00:05:19.680 with Florida Governor Ron DeSantis,
00:05:21.820 during which he disputed claims
00:05:24.180 that children needed to wear face masks.
00:05:26.720 We know that YouTube also,
00:05:28.920 which is owned by Google,
00:05:30.600 blocked access to a November 2023 episode
00:05:33.720 of this podcast verdict
00:05:35.380 because we were criticizing
00:05:37.580 the corporate media's favorable coverage of Hamas,
00:05:40.540 and YouTube deemed,
00:05:42.500 okay, you must be an adult
00:05:44.080 to see what is on the network news.
00:05:47.380 We also know in 2022,
00:05:49.140 DirecTV dropped One America News Network
00:05:51.680 less than a year after Democrat leaders in Congress
00:05:55.140 sent a letter to the CEO
00:05:56.440 calling on them to stop carrying the network.
00:05:59.180 We also know they did the same thing to Newsmax.
00:06:01.500 Now, I lit DirecTV up,
00:06:03.480 and they ended up bringing Newsmax back.
00:06:05.780 We also know that Intuit,
00:06:08.300 at the direction of its banking partners,
00:06:10.200 refused to provide payment processing
00:06:13.220 and payroll services
00:06:14.360 to gun manufacturers and sellers.
00:06:18.800 And we know that JPMorgan Chase
00:06:20.880 closed the account of the National Committee
00:06:23.860 of Religious Freedom,
00:06:24.980 which was created by former State Department
00:06:27.860 Ambassador-at-Large
00:06:29.000 for International Religious Freedom
00:06:30.520 and former U.S. Senator Sam Brownback.
00:06:32.760 We know that GoFundMe
00:06:34.500 blocked the release of $10 million
00:06:37.260 of donations to the Canadian Truckers Freedom Convoy.
00:06:41.420 We've seen that happen over and over and over again.
00:06:45.480 Well, what this report does
00:06:47.540 is it lays out an entirely new area
00:06:50.240 of discrimination,
00:06:51.740 and it is using web-based products and services,
00:06:55.660 online service providers,
00:06:57.420 to ban conservative organizations
00:06:59.640 from using their technology.
00:07:01.280 And it's going after the infrastructure
00:07:04.060 that is needed to communicate.
00:07:07.000 And in fact,
00:07:07.880 this investigation reveals
00:07:09.580 that online service providers
00:07:11.060 are following a playbook
00:07:13.380 for silencing conservatives
00:07:15.580 that leftist organizations,
00:07:17.380 including the Southern Poverty Law Center,
00:07:20.160 which is wildly left-wing
00:07:21.560 and hates conservatives,
00:07:22.820 and the Anti-Defamation League,
00:07:24.860 the ADL,
00:07:25.520 they together put together
00:07:27.500 this strategy,
00:07:28.360 this playbook,
00:07:29.140 to, quote,
00:07:29.680 remove infrastructure services
00:07:31.760 that conservative organizations
00:07:33.820 need to operate.
00:07:35.040 And so I'm going to describe
00:07:36.340 that playbook
00:07:37.060 and what they're doing in particular.
00:07:39.580 When you look at their playbook
00:07:41.460 and this amount of influence,
00:07:43.840 I mean,
00:07:44.080 this can change and alter
00:07:45.940 certainly an election cycle.
00:07:48.060 It can certainly,
00:07:48.820 I would argue,
00:07:49.600 change a presidential election as well.
00:07:53.220 And that's the reason
00:07:54.800 why they're doing this.
00:07:57.120 When you think about,
00:07:58.440 you know,
00:07:58.760 you've got millions of people
00:07:59.900 that follow you.
00:08:01.180 Facebook,
00:08:01.860 I've got,
00:08:02.340 you know,
00:08:02.700 over a million.
00:08:04.140 But if you turn off
00:08:05.420 and throttle
00:08:06.180 either one of us,
00:08:08.140 then the reach that we have
00:08:09.540 compared to the left,
00:08:11.080 it just disappears.
00:08:12.680 It's the old saying, right?
00:08:14.080 If a big tree falls in the forest
00:08:15.620 and no one's around it,
00:08:16.660 it makes a sound.
00:08:17.920 And that's exactly what they did.
00:08:19.600 But it wasn't just
00:08:20.440 to one or two people.
00:08:21.780 They were doing this
00:08:23.320 to hundreds of top
00:08:25.040 conservative voices
00:08:26.600 that people look to
00:08:29.120 for their opinions,
00:08:31.040 specifically when it comes
00:08:33.000 to election year issues.
00:08:34.740 So that's exactly right.
00:08:36.520 And what this report focuses on
00:08:38.080 is it uses a couple of key examples.
00:08:39.740 It uses,
00:08:40.420 number one,
00:08:40.940 Slack's removal of
00:08:42.620 libs of TikTok's workspace.
00:08:44.660 It focuses on Eventbrite's
00:08:47.080 removal of event pages
00:08:48.680 for events related to Matt Walsh's
00:08:50.620 What is a Woman documentary,
00:08:52.160 as well as an event
00:08:53.640 where Riley Gaines
00:08:54.540 was scheduled to speak.
00:08:55.980 And it focuses on
00:08:57.300 Bonterra's termination
00:08:58.620 of its relationship
00:08:59.560 with Independent Women's Forum,
00:09:01.440 which deprived that organization
00:09:03.460 of major nonprofit
00:09:04.960 technology service provider services.
00:09:07.780 And all of this follows.
00:09:09.480 There was a report
00:09:10.340 that was put out
00:09:11.260 by the Anti-Defamation League,
00:09:13.460 and it is called
00:09:14.820 Bad Gateway,
00:09:16.480 How De-Platforming
00:09:17.720 Affects Extremist Websites.
00:09:20.020 And here's what the ADL recommended.
00:09:23.180 It says,
00:09:23.920 quote,
00:09:24.940 De-Platforming websites,
00:09:26.460 removing infrastructure services
00:09:27.840 they need to operate,
00:09:29.120 such as website hosting,
00:09:30.480 can reduce the spread
00:09:32.240 and reach of extremism
00:09:33.440 and hate online.
00:09:34.820 But when does
00:09:35.740 de-platforming succeed?
00:09:37.140 And here's what ADL explained.
00:09:38.880 Quote,
00:09:39.100 This report shows
00:09:40.500 that de-platforming
00:09:41.300 can decrease the popularity
00:09:42.560 of extremist websites,
00:09:43.800 especially when done
00:09:44.900 without warning.
00:09:47.380 And they go through,
00:09:49.140 we learned four important lessons
00:09:51.140 about how de-platforming
00:09:52.720 affects extremist websites,
00:09:54.320 by which they mean
00:09:55.020 anything right of center.
00:09:56.760 Number one,
00:09:58.020 it can cause popularity rankings
00:10:00.040 to decrease immediately.
00:10:02.980 Number two,
00:10:04.380 it may take users a long time
00:10:06.600 to return to the website.
00:10:07.800 Sometimes the website
00:10:09.880 never regains
00:10:11.620 its previous popularity.
00:10:13.680 Bingo.
00:10:14.440 Number three,
00:10:15.920 unexpected,
00:10:16.860 and unexpected is key,
00:10:17.980 unexpected de-platforming
00:10:19.180 makes it take longer
00:10:20.720 for the website
00:10:22.200 to regain
00:10:23.020 its previous popularity levels.
00:10:25.540 And number four,
00:10:26.620 replicating de-platform services
00:10:28.520 such as discussion forums
00:10:30.700 or live streaming video products
00:10:33.400 on a standalone website
00:10:34.940 presents significant challenges
00:10:37.300 including higher costs
00:10:39.260 and smaller audiences.
00:10:42.060 Now,
00:10:42.620 I want to go into
00:10:43.960 a little bit more.
00:10:44.760 This is what the ADL report,
00:10:46.100 it has an entire section
00:10:47.200 that says,
00:10:47.740 what is de-platforming?
00:10:49.480 And by the way,
00:10:50.480 the corporate media insists
00:10:51.720 when we talk about de-platforming
00:10:53.260 that we're making it up.
00:10:54.380 Well,
00:10:55.260 if you actually read
00:10:56.400 the blueprint,
00:10:57.960 they are very explicit.
00:10:59.340 The left is explicit.
00:11:00.660 They want to silence you.
00:11:01.960 So let me read
00:11:02.480 from this ADL report.
00:11:03.740 Quote,
00:11:03.980 there are three main categories
00:11:06.500 of infrastructure
00:11:07.480 that keep websites running.
00:11:11.020 Domain registrars,
00:11:12.920 web hosting companies,
00:11:14.820 and security protection companies.
00:11:17.200 Number one,
00:11:18.460 the website must be able
00:11:19.580 to register
00:11:20.160 and keep a domain name.
00:11:21.620 A domain name,
00:11:22.560 such as google.com
00:11:23.820 or adl.org,
00:11:25.060 is how visitors find a site.
00:11:27.420 If a website is removed
00:11:29.160 from domain name services,
00:11:30.980 it becomes much more difficult,
00:11:33.340 if not impossible to find.
00:11:35.500 Number two,
00:11:36.940 web hosting companies
00:11:38.220 and content distribution networks
00:11:40.000 provide digital storage space
00:11:42.620 for all the files,
00:11:44.140 pictures,
00:11:44.720 videos,
00:11:45.120 and software
00:11:45.680 that make up
00:11:46.740 the content of a website.
00:11:48.420 When a website
00:11:49.200 loses its hosting provider,
00:11:51.160 the site's content
00:11:52.220 disappears.
00:11:54.660 Losing a CDN,
00:11:56.140 a content distribution network,
00:11:57.820 can cause slow service
00:11:59.460 for high traffic sites.
00:12:00.900 And number three,
00:12:02.380 a third category
00:12:03.400 of infrastructure provider
00:12:04.760 includes companies
00:12:05.660 that protect websites
00:12:07.120 from external security risks,
00:12:09.920 such as distributed denial
00:12:11.420 of service,
00:12:12.120 DDoS attacks.
00:12:13.740 DDoS attacks flood a website
00:12:15.760 with fake traffic
00:12:17.640 to overwhelm it,
00:12:19.480 rendering it unable
00:12:20.920 to answer normal user requests.
00:12:23.100 If an infrastructure company,
00:12:24.340 such as a network security firm,
00:12:26.700 Cloudfair,
00:12:27.340 refuses to provide
00:12:29.520 DDoS protection
00:12:30.580 to a vulnerable website,
00:12:32.740 it is vulnerable
00:12:33.640 to being flooded
00:12:34.540 with traffic,
00:12:36.100 rendering it inaccessible.
00:12:37.800 So,
00:12:38.900 you look at what this,
00:12:40.960 what we found out
00:12:42.340 and what you just went through.
00:12:43.900 The question is,
00:12:45.880 how is it that these companies,
00:12:48.520 and I'm specifically referring
00:12:49.860 to big tech,
00:12:51.040 are allowed to get away
00:12:52.300 with this
00:12:52.940 and do this
00:12:53.960 to many people
00:12:54.920 that they're in business with?
00:12:58.060 I use myself
00:12:59.300 as the example again
00:13:00.280 because I've experienced this.
00:13:02.540 When you went into business
00:13:04.040 and I felt like
00:13:04.720 I was in business
00:13:05.300 with Facebook,
00:13:06.160 they said advertise with us,
00:13:07.740 right?
00:13:08.720 Advertise your show,
00:13:10.340 advertise your content,
00:13:11.880 boost your content,
00:13:12.980 spend money with us,
00:13:13.920 and we're going to help you
00:13:14.960 grow an audience
00:13:15.720 and it'll be good for everyone.
00:13:17.560 And then all of a sudden
00:13:18.280 they just shut you down
00:13:19.620 and they were able
00:13:21.300 to walk away
00:13:21.960 and just say,
00:13:22.480 oh, well,
00:13:22.860 you violated our terms of service
00:13:24.900 or you did this
00:13:25.840 or you posted too many things
00:13:27.720 that liberals posted
00:13:29.060 as saying they were
00:13:30.620 factually incorrect.
00:13:31.640 The fact checkers came out,
00:13:33.000 right?
00:13:33.220 The liberals on the left,
00:13:34.560 they were fact checking
00:13:35.620 and putting dings
00:13:36.460 against conservatives
00:13:37.260 so they lose their reach,
00:13:38.500 lose their ability
00:13:39.020 to boost posts,
00:13:39.880 lose their ability
00:13:40.420 to advertise,
00:13:41.820 and it was all being done
00:13:43.280 to clearly influence
00:13:44.940 public opinion
00:13:46.160 and yet they've gotten
00:13:47.440 away with it.
00:13:48.120 So what's next?
00:13:49.620 Well, what this report
00:13:51.540 focuses on,
00:13:52.560 many of the de-platforming
00:13:54.100 steps by Facebook
00:13:55.780 or Twitter
00:13:56.420 or YouTube,
00:13:57.660 they're very public.
00:13:58.840 What this report focuses on
00:14:00.560 is the ones that are not public,
00:14:01.980 which is the back office infrastructure.
00:14:04.260 So let's take,
00:14:04.880 for example,
00:14:05.520 Slack,
00:14:05.960 which is used for communication
00:14:07.880 for many online organizations
00:14:10.640 and companies.
00:14:12.240 Slack canceled
00:14:13.320 libs of TikTok's workspace
00:14:15.000 for violating its terms of service
00:14:17.440 and the terms of service
00:14:18.780 prohibit users
00:14:19.820 from,
00:14:20.200 quote,
00:14:20.960 engaging in activity
00:14:22.060 that incites
00:14:22.700 or encourages violence
00:14:23.840 or hatred
00:14:25.060 against individuals
00:14:26.800 or groups.
00:14:28.600 Slack determined
00:14:29.380 that libs of TikTok
00:14:31.300 violated this policy
00:14:32.700 based on three social media posts
00:14:34.580 concerning,
00:14:35.320 quote,
00:14:35.700 gender-affirming hysterectomies
00:14:37.520 and all-age drag shows.
00:14:40.480 Now,
00:14:40.860 here's the interesting thing.
00:14:41.920 Slack shut down
00:14:42.940 libs of TikTok's workplace
00:14:44.220 without any warning,
00:14:45.700 without any explanation
00:14:47.120 as to how it has violated
00:14:48.580 Slack's policy.
00:14:50.340 And Slack's action
00:14:51.480 caused libs of TikTok
00:14:52.640 to effectively lose
00:14:54.060 its use of Slack's communications
00:14:56.700 and forced it to rely
00:14:57.900 entirely on cell phones
00:14:59.420 to run its business.
00:15:00.900 Now,
00:15:01.260 listen to this quote,
00:15:02.620 which is fascinating.
00:15:04.500 Slack told,
00:15:05.340 the Commerce Committee
00:15:06.060 told my investigation,
00:15:07.460 quote,
00:15:07.680 what makes
00:15:09.440 libs of TikTok's posts
00:15:11.200 problematic
00:15:11.820 is that libs of TikTok
00:15:14.140 has a specific audience
00:15:15.700 and they are taking
00:15:17.200 this information
00:15:18.040 and posting it
00:15:18.960 to that specific audience
00:15:20.220 so that everyone
00:15:21.540 in that audience
00:15:22.260 sees it at the same time.
00:15:23.500 In other words,
00:15:24.080 they didn't even find
00:15:25.300 objections with what
00:15:26.400 libs of TikTok
00:15:27.200 was posting.
00:15:28.040 What they were mad at
00:15:29.040 is conservatives
00:15:30.340 were reading it
00:15:31.700 and that was enough reason
00:15:33.420 to deplatform
00:15:34.380 libs of TikTok.
00:15:35.560 So,
00:15:35.940 when you shut down
00:15:36.740 a business
00:15:37.380 in essence
00:15:38.100 the way they did,
00:15:39.080 is there any real
00:15:40.700 and instant relief
00:15:42.640 for libs of TikTok
00:15:44.820 or others
00:15:45.540 or is this one of those
00:15:46.800 they're too big to fail,
00:15:48.240 right?
00:15:48.540 These companies are too big,
00:15:49.800 they're protected
00:15:50.520 and you're the minion
00:15:52.400 and just deal with it
00:15:54.000 and if you're,
00:15:54.840 and who cares
00:15:55.560 if your life work
00:15:56.340 is destroyed in 30 seconds
00:15:57.740 because they shut it off?
00:15:59.460 So,
00:15:59.800 right now
00:16:00.280 there is not
00:16:01.360 immediate relief.
00:16:02.260 You could presumably
00:16:02.900 file a breach
00:16:03.720 of contract case.
00:16:05.160 The biggest relief
00:16:06.160 and the reason
00:16:06.600 I did this report
00:16:07.420 is just sunshine.
00:16:08.420 They're doing this
00:16:09.120 in the dark.
00:16:09.800 They're doing this
00:16:10.420 without scrutiny.
00:16:11.820 There is right now
00:16:12.880 no federal law
00:16:14.320 that this is prohibited.
00:16:15.280 I'll give you another example,
00:16:16.200 Eventbrite,
00:16:16.680 which we focus on.
00:16:18.520 Eventbrite
00:16:19.000 canceled pages
00:16:20.140 for events
00:16:20.900 hosted by college
00:16:21.940 Republican clubs
00:16:22.860 concerning Matt Walsh's
00:16:24.920 What is a Woman film
00:16:26.000 and it also canceled
00:16:27.720 pages for an event
00:16:29.160 featuring swimmer
00:16:31.040 Riley Gaines
00:16:31.800 for violating
00:16:33.120 its terms of service.
00:16:34.880 Now,
00:16:35.400 critically,
00:16:36.600 no one involved
00:16:37.660 in the decision,
00:16:38.680 this is what they told
00:16:39.540 the committee,
00:16:40.700 watched the movie
00:16:42.020 What is a Woman?
00:16:43.280 So,
00:16:43.440 they never saw it
00:16:44.220 and they couldn't identify
00:16:46.920 anything objectionable
00:16:48.200 in the trailer.
00:16:48.900 So,
00:16:49.060 they just didn't like
00:16:49.840 the topic
00:16:50.340 so they decided
00:16:51.600 to take it down.
00:16:53.180 They relied instead
00:16:54.340 on Matt Walsh's statements
00:16:55.620 about,
00:16:56.420 gender-affirming surgeries,
00:16:57.880 pronouns,
00:16:59.120 and his
00:16:59.480 Johnny the Walrus
00:17:00.360 children's book
00:17:01.100 to reach the conclusion.
00:17:02.200 Likewise,
00:17:03.460 Eventbrite determined
00:17:04.520 that Riley Gaines' event
00:17:05.800 violated its policy
00:17:07.020 based on her
00:17:08.720 social media post
00:17:09.840 about biological men
00:17:11.120 competing in women's sports.
00:17:12.880 They shut down
00:17:13.680 the event page
00:17:14.540 without any warning,
00:17:16.280 without any explanation
00:17:17.160 as to how they violated
00:17:18.240 this policy,
00:17:19.280 without any way
00:17:19.820 to fix it.
00:17:21.260 And,
00:17:21.560 their actions
00:17:23.000 ruined advertisements
00:17:24.380 that included
00:17:25.500 QR codes
00:17:26.340 for the event pages.
00:17:27.220 So,
00:17:27.720 you know,
00:17:27.940 a lot had been done
00:17:28.640 to put out the codes
00:17:29.480 to say,
00:17:29.900 hey,
00:17:30.000 come to this event
00:17:30.760 and they forced
00:17:32.160 the event organizers
00:17:33.140 to quickly pivot
00:17:34.080 to a new method
00:17:34.940 of providing tickets.
00:17:36.860 And,
00:17:36.980 and the committee asked
00:17:38.080 Eventbrite
00:17:39.100 whether
00:17:40.820 Gaines' statement,
00:17:42.640 on October 10th,
00:17:43.680 2023,
00:17:44.460 she posted on,
00:17:45.480 on Twitter,
00:17:46.080 quote,
00:17:47.060 real women
00:17:47.800 lack a Y chromosome
00:17:50.180 and we asked
00:17:52.200 whether that violates
00:17:53.400 Eventbrite's policy.
00:17:55.840 Eventbrite responded
00:17:56.840 that,
00:17:57.340 quote,
00:17:57.660 the post
00:17:58.300 speaks for itself.
00:18:00.240 So,
00:18:00.620 they,
00:18:00.820 they needn't answer that.
00:18:02.620 How dare you say
00:18:04.020 that someone
00:18:04.860 with a Y chromosome
00:18:05.800 is not a woman?
00:18:06.700 We don't even need
00:18:07.820 to dispute it.
00:18:09.220 We have the power
00:18:10.180 to shut it down.
00:18:10.920 If you've got a cell phone,
00:18:12.880 99% of Americans
00:18:13.880 have a cell phone.
00:18:15.340 And when you use
00:18:16.060 that phone,
00:18:16.620 you may not realize
00:18:17.420 what you're supporting
00:18:18.320 with Big Mobile.
00:18:19.600 Did you know
00:18:20.120 that Big Mobile
00:18:20.720 gives massive donations
00:18:22.200 to democratic causes,
00:18:23.960 democratic candidates,
00:18:25.520 and organizations?
00:18:26.840 Did you know
00:18:27.200 that Big Mobile
00:18:27.700 gives big money
00:18:29.060 to Planned Parenthood?
00:18:30.900 Well,
00:18:31.240 that is why
00:18:31.860 I took my cell phone
00:18:33.400 and I switched
00:18:34.580 to Patriot Mobile.
00:18:36.300 Patriot Mobile
00:18:36.920 is the only
00:18:37.800 conservative Christian
00:18:39.360 cell phone provider
00:18:40.320 in the U.S.
00:18:41.180 with the same
00:18:42.340 exact coverage
00:18:43.480 that you get right now.
00:18:45.120 So,
00:18:45.540 you compromise
00:18:46.220 nothing
00:18:47.100 when it comes
00:18:47.760 to quality
00:18:48.500 when you switch
00:18:49.460 to Patriot Mobile.
00:18:50.660 Now,
00:18:50.860 the number one reason
00:18:51.640 why people don't switch
00:18:52.560 cell phone providers
00:18:53.420 is because they think
00:18:54.280 it's going to take forever.
00:18:55.540 That's true.
00:18:56.100 It used to take
00:18:56.840 a lot of time.
00:18:57.960 And so,
00:18:58.340 people would stay
00:18:59.260 because they didn't
00:18:59.640 want to go into a store
00:19:00.540 and waste two and a half
00:19:01.580 hours switching.
00:19:02.880 Not anymore.
00:19:04.020 With technology
00:19:04.620 in 2024,
00:19:05.640 you can literally
00:19:06.280 use your same phone
00:19:07.260 you have right now
00:19:08.240 and your same number
00:19:09.760 and switching
00:19:10.580 is easy
00:19:11.340 and it can be done
00:19:12.300 over the phone.
00:19:14.040 All you got to do
00:19:15.080 is go to
00:19:15.560 patriotmobile.com
00:19:17.000 slash verdict.
00:19:18.780 That's
00:19:19.080 patriotmobile.com
00:19:20.420 slash verdict.
00:19:21.200 Or you can call them
00:19:22.260 972-PATRIOT.
00:19:24.640 That's 972-PATRIOT.
00:19:26.560 Plus,
00:19:26.960 you can get free
00:19:27.480 activation
00:19:28.060 when you use
00:19:28.520 the offer code
00:19:29.540 VERDICT.
00:19:30.300 That's right.
00:19:30.840 Free activation.
00:19:32.140 Use the offer code
00:19:33.080 VERDICT.
00:19:33.500 Now,
00:19:33.700 when you switch,
00:19:34.720 here's what happens.
00:19:35.600 About 5%
00:19:36.720 of your bill
00:19:37.360 every month
00:19:37.900 is given back
00:19:39.300 to causes
00:19:40.200 and organizations
00:19:41.220 that support
00:19:41.900 free speech,
00:19:43.280 religious freedom,
00:19:44.520 the sanctity of life,
00:19:46.100 our Second Amendment,
00:19:47.180 as well as supporting
00:19:48.180 our military,
00:19:49.140 our veterans,
00:19:50.100 and our wounded warriors.
00:19:52.040 That is why
00:19:53.060 I love
00:19:53.940 Patriot Mobile.
00:19:55.120 So make a difference
00:19:56.140 with every phone call
00:19:57.020 you make.
00:19:57.560 Make a difference
00:19:58.020 with every text you make.
00:19:59.340 Make a difference
00:20:00.400 by switching your phone
00:20:01.940 right now
00:20:02.680 to Patriot Mobile.
00:20:03.820 I'm using it.
00:20:04.640 I travel all the time.
00:20:06.220 The coverage
00:20:06.900 is phenomenal.
00:20:08.480 972-PATRIOT
00:20:09.700 or PatriotMobile.com
00:20:11.100 slash VERDICT.
00:20:12.200 Use promo code VERDICT.
00:20:13.340 You'll get free
00:20:13.980 activation.
00:20:15.700 So now,
00:20:17.100 moving forward,
00:20:18.180 you shine light
00:20:19.380 on this
00:20:20.040 and you talk about
00:20:21.840 this is really
00:20:22.780 being done
00:20:23.580 in darkness
00:20:24.440 and we need to
00:20:25.260 shine light on it.
00:20:27.140 Was there any
00:20:28.420 nervousness
00:20:29.760 from those
00:20:30.840 that you're questioning?
00:20:32.300 I want to use
00:20:34.000 the word remorse
00:20:34.740 but I can't imagine
00:20:35.940 they're remorseful
00:20:36.740 but is it going
00:20:37.920 to at least
00:20:38.940 make them pause
00:20:39.940 before they do it again
00:20:41.440 or no?
00:20:41.960 So let me ask you,
00:20:42.660 Ben,
00:20:42.780 have you seen this
00:20:43.360 on CNN?
00:20:44.220 No.
00:20:44.980 Have you seen it
00:20:45.440 on ABC, NBC, CBS,
00:20:46.960 MSNBC?
00:20:48.020 Nowhere.
00:20:48.820 Have you read it
00:20:49.220 in the Washington Post?
00:20:50.000 You read it
00:20:50.740 in the New York Times?
00:20:51.880 No, no.
00:20:52.260 The corporate media
00:20:53.160 will not cover it.
00:20:53.880 I'll give you another example.
00:20:55.420 So Bontera,
00:20:56.460 which provides
00:20:57.360 non-profit
00:20:58.140 management services,
00:20:59.140 so it's back office
00:21:00.080 but it's incredibly important
00:21:01.840 and there are very few
00:21:03.380 providers of this.
00:21:05.080 They denied
00:21:06.440 those services
00:21:07.140 to Independent Women's Forum
00:21:08.420 which is a conservative
00:21:09.380 organization
00:21:09.920 that is focused
00:21:11.200 on advancing
00:21:11.800 women's rights
00:21:12.520 and Bontera
00:21:14.340 concluded
00:21:15.000 that it violated
00:21:15.800 its policies
00:21:16.720 which require
00:21:17.620 customers to agree
00:21:18.740 to refrain
00:21:19.320 from advocacy
00:21:20.100 denying
00:21:21.440 quote
00:21:22.020 LGBTQ rights
00:21:23.580 or denying
00:21:24.840 a woman's right
00:21:25.700 to reproductive choice
00:21:26.800 or denying
00:21:27.560 racial justice
00:21:28.500 or denying
00:21:29.480 climate change
00:21:30.580 and their policies
00:21:32.160 also prohibit
00:21:32.860 customers from
00:21:33.580 quote
00:21:33.880 promoting
00:21:34.400 encouraging
00:21:35.160 or facilitating
00:21:36.060 hate speech
00:21:37.000 violence
00:21:37.380 discrimination
00:21:37.880 based on race
00:21:38.820 color
00:21:39.120 sexual orientation
00:21:40.060 marital status
00:21:41.160 gender
00:21:41.560 or identity
00:21:42.280 expression
00:21:42.940 Bontera notified
00:21:44.920 Independent Women's Forum
00:21:45.900 of its decision
00:21:46.620 not to renew
00:21:47.200 their contract
00:21:47.920 without any explanation
00:21:49.600 of how the organization
00:21:51.020 violated this policy
00:21:52.240 as a result
00:21:53.600 Independent Women's Forum
00:21:54.680 had to quickly move
00:21:55.580 off Bontera's platform
00:21:56.740 and obtain a
00:21:57.380 replacement services
00:21:58.300 provider
00:21:58.820 Bontera told
00:22:00.900 the committee
00:22:01.380 that Independent
00:22:02.860 Women's Forum
00:22:03.520 violated its
00:22:04.260 terms of service
00:22:05.000 because the organization
00:22:06.140 quote
00:22:06.620 works to restrict
00:22:08.220 the rights
00:22:08.760 of the LGBTQ
00:22:09.560 community
00:22:10.520 Bontera could not
00:22:12.180 explain exactly
00:22:13.000 how
00:22:13.580 the group
00:22:14.840 was working
00:22:15.380 to restrict
00:22:15.980 LGBTQ rights
00:22:17.300 but generally
00:22:18.340 pointed
00:22:19.420 to Independent
00:22:20.500 Women's Forum's
00:22:21.440 advocacy
00:22:21.900 on issues
00:22:22.780 like protecting
00:22:23.660 women's sports
00:22:25.260 and women's
00:22:26.600 spaces
00:22:26.980 so if you
00:22:27.540 actually think
00:22:28.300 that girls
00:22:28.860 should compete
00:22:29.420 in girls
00:22:29.840 sports
00:22:30.320 that is a view
00:22:32.360 that is not
00:22:33.560 acceptable
00:22:34.140 and you will
00:22:34.680 be denied
00:22:35.440 online basic
00:22:37.180 infrastructure
00:22:38.020 from monopoly
00:22:38.940 and near monopoly
00:22:39.680 providers
00:22:40.320 the amount
00:22:42.040 of arrogance
00:22:42.800 that we see
00:22:43.700 now from these
00:22:44.440 companies
00:22:44.900 you've witnessed
00:22:45.860 it now firsthand
00:22:46.680 tells you
00:22:48.100 they feel like
00:22:48.800 they are protected
00:22:49.500 by the current
00:22:50.240 regime
00:22:50.660 am I wrong
00:22:51.240 you are exactly
00:22:53.000 right
00:22:53.520 and if you
00:22:56.000 look at
00:22:56.680 Eventbrite
00:22:57.960 for example
00:22:58.920 let's go back
00:22:59.480 to Riley Gaines
00:23:00.220 so Riley Gaines
00:23:02.500 they shut her
00:23:03.140 down because
00:23:03.640 they disagreed
00:23:04.700 about
00:23:05.920 not her event
00:23:07.520 but about
00:23:07.980 some posts
00:23:08.760 that she had
00:23:09.280 put out
00:23:09.800 what they
00:23:12.460 did not
00:23:13.380 object to
00:23:14.500 was an event
00:23:16.020 that we
00:23:16.360 identified
00:23:17.000 entitled
00:23:17.860 Gaza
00:23:18.640 and the
00:23:19.640 struggle
00:23:19.980 for
00:23:20.240 Palestine
00:23:20.700 now
00:23:21.960 that event
00:23:22.840 was flagged
00:23:23.960 by Eventbrite's
00:23:24.740 algorithm
00:23:25.160 and it was
00:23:26.320 reviewed by
00:23:27.000 its trust and
00:23:27.580 safety team
00:23:28.240 but it
00:23:28.920 determined
00:23:29.380 that that
00:23:30.120 event
00:23:30.440 did not
00:23:31.100 violate
00:23:31.660 its
00:23:31.900 hateful
00:23:32.480 events
00:23:32.780 policy
00:23:33.360 in an
00:23:35.200 October 9th
00:23:36.520 2023
00:23:36.980 statement
00:23:37.640 so two
00:23:38.060 days off
00:23:38.480 after
00:23:38.840 October 7th
00:23:40.120 here's what
00:23:40.700 the event
00:23:41.220 sponsor
00:23:41.760 the
00:23:41.960 Palestinian
00:23:42.440 American
00:23:42.900 Organization
00:23:43.500 Network
00:23:43.960 said
00:23:44.560 it called
00:23:45.060 the October
00:23:45.600 7th
00:23:46.040 attack
00:23:46.380 quote
00:23:46.860 self-defense
00:23:48.500 measures
00:23:49.000 and said
00:23:50.400 that
00:23:50.600 quote
00:23:50.920 Israel
00:23:51.460 bears
00:23:51.860 the full
00:23:52.280 responsibility
00:23:52.940 for those
00:23:53.500 attacks
00:23:53.980 and declared
00:23:55.360 that
00:23:55.640 quote
00:23:55.960 the Palestinian
00:23:56.600 people have
00:23:57.120 the right
00:23:57.440 to defend
00:23:57.860 themselves
00:23:58.260 and to
00:23:58.560 fight
00:23:58.760 the occupation
00:23:59.480 with all
00:23:59.980 means
00:24:00.280 available
00:24:00.700 we salute
00:24:02.140 the steadfastness
00:24:03.840 of the
00:24:04.140 Palestinian
00:24:04.680 people
00:24:05.180 and its
00:24:05.540 resistance
00:24:06.040 so
00:24:06.700 understand
00:24:07.500 saluting
00:24:09.080 the mass
00:24:09.860 murder
00:24:10.200 of 1200
00:24:10.820 people
00:24:11.300 the raping
00:24:11.940 of women
00:24:12.380 and girls
00:24:13.060 that
00:24:14.580 does not
00:24:15.240 violate
00:24:15.740 their
00:24:16.080 hateful
00:24:16.620 speech
00:24:16.980 policy
00:24:17.560 but
00:24:18.660 saying
00:24:19.420 that
00:24:20.280 girls
00:24:20.840 exist
00:24:21.640 that
00:24:23.000 does
00:24:23.560 saying
00:24:24.760 that
00:24:25.040 men
00:24:25.420 should
00:24:25.720 not
00:24:26.000 compete
00:24:26.400 against
00:24:26.740 women
00:24:27.040 in
00:24:27.220 women's
00:24:27.620 sports
00:24:28.000 that
00:24:28.760 does
00:24:29.360 that
00:24:29.880 is
00:24:30.240 the
00:24:30.520 utter
00:24:31.060 hypocrisy
00:24:32.180 and double
00:24:32.720 standards
00:24:33.380 that
00:24:34.200 that
00:24:34.400 allows
00:24:34.760 by the
00:24:35.120 way
00:24:35.480 event
00:24:36.800 bright
00:24:37.060 has
00:24:37.280 also
00:24:37.640 allowed
00:24:38.040 numerous
00:24:38.640 quote
00:24:39.080 stop
00:24:39.780 cop
00:24:40.300 city
00:24:40.760 events
00:24:41.340 which
00:24:42.160 support
00:24:42.700 violent
00:24:43.420 protesters
00:24:44.120 who
00:24:45.140 oppose
00:24:45.660 the
00:24:45.860 building
00:24:46.280 of a
00:24:47.000 police
00:24:47.540 and
00:24:47.780 firefighter
00:24:48.500 training
00:24:48.920 facility
00:24:49.580 likewise
00:24:51.560 event
00:24:52.680 bright
00:24:53.000 created
00:24:53.460 a map
00:24:54.100 of
00:24:55.120 black
00:24:55.540 lives
00:24:55.960 matter
00:24:56.280 protests
00:24:56.960 many of
00:24:57.420 which
00:24:57.600 turn
00:24:57.860 violent
00:24:58.260 to help
00:24:59.340 users
00:24:59.840 find
00:25:00.320 them
00:25:00.520 so in
00:25:00.860 other
00:25:01.040 words
00:25:01.260 actual
00:25:02.320 events
00:25:02.780 that
00:25:02.980 produce
00:25:03.360 violence
00:25:03.840 that
00:25:04.020 end
00:25:04.160 up
00:25:04.360 killing
00:25:04.740 people
00:25:05.140 that
00:25:05.360 burn
00:25:05.900 shops
00:25:06.960 that
00:25:07.220 firebomb
00:25:08.420 cars
00:25:08.920 those
00:25:09.840 are
00:25:10.220 not
00:25:10.540 deemed
00:25:10.840 hateful
00:25:11.260 and
00:25:11.440 violent
00:25:11.800 but
00:25:12.120 if
00:25:12.300 you
00:25:12.460 say
00:25:12.840 that
00:25:13.080 women
00:25:13.320 exist
00:25:13.920 you
00:25:15.140 must
00:25:15.380 be
00:25:15.580 deplatformed
00:25:16.260 Canadian
00:25:17.500 women
00:25:17.820 are looking
00:25:18.280 for more
00:25:18.900 more
00:25:19.340 to themselves
00:25:19.960 their
00:25:20.340 businesses
00:25:20.800 their
00:25:21.280 elected
00:25:21.580 leaders
00:25:21.940 and
00:25:22.380 the
00:25:22.520 world
00:25:22.680 around
00:25:22.960 them
00:25:23.140 and
00:25:23.460 that's
00:25:23.680 why
00:25:23.780 we're
00:25:23.980 thrilled
00:25:24.300 to
00:25:24.480 introduce
00:25:24.940 the
00:25:25.320 honest
00:25:25.660 talk
00:25:26.000 podcast
00:25:26.680 I'm
00:25:27.300 Jennifer
00:25:27.580 Stewart
00:25:27.980 and
00:25:28.360 I'm
00:25:28.560 Catherine
00:25:28.880 Clark
00:25:29.200 and
00:25:29.640 in
00:25:29.760 this
00:25:29.940 podcast
00:25:30.440 we
00:25:30.760 interview
00:25:31.080 Canada's
00:25:31.600 most
00:25:31.880 inspiring
00:25:32.460 women
00:25:32.880 entrepreneurs
00:25:33.560 artists
00:25:34.320 athletes
00:25:35.020 politicians
00:25:35.640 and
00:25:36.020 newsmakers
00:25:36.540 all at
00:25:37.200 different
00:25:37.460 stages
00:25:37.820 of
00:25:38.120 their
00:25:38.340 journey
00:25:38.680 so
00:25:39.200 if
00:25:39.460 you're
00:25:39.740 looking
00:25:40.000 to
00:25:40.180 connect
00:25:40.540 then
00:25:40.900 we
00:25:41.020 hope
00:25:41.220 you'll
00:25:41.400 join
00:25:41.620 us
00:25:41.980 listen
00:25:42.340 to
00:25:42.500 the
00:25:42.620 honest
00:25:42.860 talk
00:25:43.060 podcast
00:25:43.580 on
00:25:43.780 iHeart
00:25:44.180 radio
00:25:44.540 or
00:25:44.800 wherever
00:25:45.120 you
00:25:45.340 listen
00:25:45.560 to
00:25:45.660 your
00:25:45.760 podcasts
00:25:46.280 we
00:25:48.540 talked
00:25:48.820 about
00:25:49.040 the
00:25:49.260 media
00:25:49.640 giving
00:25:49.920 them
00:25:50.100 cover
00:25:50.440 I
00:25:51.080 expect
00:25:51.460 some
00:25:51.840 in
00:25:51.940 the
00:25:52.040 media
00:25:52.280 to
00:25:52.600 be
00:25:52.860 liberal
00:25:53.360 hacks
00:25:53.940 right
00:25:54.260 but
00:25:54.980 this
00:25:55.480 brings
00:25:55.820 up
00:25:56.060 a
00:25:56.240 big
00:25:56.420 issue
00:25:56.800 that
00:25:57.140 we
00:25:57.240 need
00:25:57.360 to
00:25:57.480 talk
00:25:57.740 about
00:25:58.020 with
00:25:58.220 NPR
00:25:58.660 the
00:25:59.660 new
00:25:59.960 CEO
00:26:00.420 of
00:26:01.140 NPR
00:26:07.200 described
00:26:07.420 the
00:26:07.620 first
00:26:07.900 amendment
00:26:08.220 as
00:26:08.740 the
00:26:09.020 number
00:26:09.740 one
00:26:10.440 challenge
00:26:11.760 she
00:26:12.500 faces
00:26:13.160 our
00:26:14.180 tax
00:26:14.560 dollars
00:26:14.920 are
00:26:15.100 going
00:26:15.300 to
00:26:15.440 a
00:26:15.600 CEO
00:26:15.920 who's
00:26:16.520 running
00:26:16.940 NPR
00:26:17.620 national
00:26:18.120 public
00:26:18.540 radio
00:26:18.980 saying
00:26:20.000 the
00:26:20.360 first
00:26:20.660 amendment
00:26:20.960 really
00:26:21.340 seems
00:26:21.680 to
00:26:21.880 get
00:26:22.040 in
00:26:22.180 her
00:26:22.420 way
00:26:22.820 really
00:26:23.540 that's
00:26:24.060 where
00:26:24.220 money
00:26:24.460 is
00:26:24.660 going
00:26:24.980 well
00:26:25.860 unfortunately
00:26:26.620 NPR
00:26:27.260 has been
00:26:27.700 profoundly
00:26:28.220 corrupted
00:26:28.720 and it's
00:26:29.060 been
00:26:29.220 made
00:26:29.480 worse
00:26:29.960 by hiring
00:26:31.000 a
00:26:31.260 CEO
00:26:31.620 who
00:26:32.140 is
00:26:32.360 a
00:26:32.600 brazen
00:26:33.180 blatant
00:26:34.220 unapologetic
00:26:35.580 radical
00:26:36.120 leftist
00:26:36.760 and she
00:26:37.060 doesn't
00:26:37.420 pretend
00:26:37.840 to be
00:26:39.040 unbiased
00:26:39.600 at all
00:26:40.000 now
00:26:40.300 we discussed
00:26:41.460 in a
00:26:41.720 previous
00:26:42.000 podcast
00:26:42.580 a couple
00:26:42.880 of weeks
00:26:43.180 ago
00:26:43.480 the
00:26:44.740 bombshell
00:26:45.740 report
00:26:46.280 from
00:26:46.700 Uri Berliner
00:26:47.480 Uri Berliner
00:26:48.300 was a
00:26:48.760 25 year
00:26:49.900 NPR
00:26:50.760 employee
00:26:51.320 and was
00:26:52.320 the former
00:26:52.680 business
00:26:53.100 editor
00:26:53.460 of
00:26:54.360 NPR
00:26:54.820 and he
00:26:55.240 wrote
00:26:55.600 an April
00:26:56.000 9th
00:26:56.400 essay
00:26:56.640 in the
00:26:56.860 free
00:26:57.060 press
00:26:57.480 which
00:26:58.300 resulted
00:26:58.980 in
00:26:59.280 NPR
00:26:59.700 suspending
00:27:00.520 him
00:27:00.820 for
00:27:01.020 publishing
00:27:01.440 how's
00:27:01.700 that
00:27:01.840 for
00:27:01.980 free
00:27:02.240 speech
00:27:02.580 if
00:27:03.020 you
00:27:03.140 criticize
00:27:03.480 us
00:27:03.980 you're
00:27:04.520 out of
00:27:04.760 here
00:27:04.980 yeah
00:27:05.520 you're
00:27:05.840 gone
00:27:06.160 and
00:27:06.840 ultimately
00:27:07.360 led to
00:27:07.780 his
00:27:07.920 resignation
00:27:08.280 so
00:27:08.660 he's
00:27:08.920 gone
00:27:09.280 this
00:27:09.560 essay
00:27:10.080 cost
00:27:10.560 him
00:27:10.700 his
00:27:10.820 job
00:27:11.240 but
00:27:12.080 he
00:27:12.500 laid
00:27:12.880 out
00:27:13.220 the
00:27:13.580 incredible
00:27:14.320 bias
00:27:15.500 in NPR
00:27:16.060 and the
00:27:16.600 shift
00:27:16.880 in NPR
00:27:17.360 so for
00:27:17.800 example
00:27:18.260 he laid
00:27:18.740 out
00:27:19.000 in
00:27:19.540 2011
00:27:20.020 which was
00:27:20.580 not
00:27:20.780 that long
00:27:21.200 ago
00:27:21.520 NPR's
00:27:22.880 audience
00:27:23.180 was
00:27:23.560 26%
00:27:24.980 conservative
00:27:25.700 23%
00:27:27.460 middle of
00:27:27.800 the road
00:27:28.140 and 37%
00:27:29.240 liberal
00:27:29.520 so it
00:27:29.900 leaned
00:27:30.160 left
00:27:30.480 but not
00:27:30.860 dramatically
00:27:31.400 so
00:27:31.840 by
00:27:32.820 2023
00:27:33.620 those
00:27:34.140 numbers
00:27:34.520 had
00:27:34.740 shifted
00:27:35.020 dramatically
00:27:35.640 it
00:27:36.840 was
00:27:37.060 now
00:27:37.380 instead
00:27:37.660 of
00:27:37.820 37%
00:27:38.580 liberal
00:27:39.020 it
00:27:39.720 was
00:27:39.940 67%
00:27:41.420 liberal
00:27:41.740 and
00:27:41.940 instead
00:27:42.320 of
00:27:42.860 26%
00:27:44.400 conservative
00:27:44.920 it
00:27:45.160 was
00:27:45.260 only
00:27:45.580 11%
00:27:46.700 conservative
00:27:47.220 and
00:27:48.220 Mr. Berliner
00:27:49.460 laid out
00:27:50.120 details of
00:27:51.020 how they
00:27:51.420 would
00:27:51.680 stifle
00:27:52.900 stories
00:27:53.440 that were
00:27:53.780 inconvenient
00:27:54.280 to liberals
00:27:54.900 they would
00:27:55.300 amplify
00:27:55.700 stories
00:27:56.320 like the
00:27:56.660 Russia
00:27:56.860 collusion
00:27:57.360 story
00:27:57.880 even if
00:27:59.060 they were
00:27:59.700 not supported
00:28:00.380 by the
00:28:00.760 facts
00:28:01.180 he
00:28:02.160 outlined
00:28:02.760 at
00:28:02.980 great
00:28:03.260 length
00:28:03.700 how
00:28:04.320 NPR
00:28:06.060 had
00:28:06.420 no
00:28:07.080 interest
00:28:07.860 in
00:28:08.280 being
00:28:09.040 impartial
00:28:09.980 being
00:28:10.260 unbiased
00:28:11.060 and then
00:28:12.280 you take
00:28:13.420 in the
00:28:13.800 wake
00:28:14.080 of this
00:28:14.540 in the
00:28:14.840 wake
00:28:15.160 of what
00:28:15.560 should
00:28:15.860 be
00:28:16.040 real
00:28:16.340 concern
00:28:16.820 of
00:28:17.100 hey
00:28:17.360 we're
00:28:18.140 national
00:28:18.480 public
00:28:18.820 radio
00:28:19.160 we're
00:28:19.440 supposed
00:28:19.840 to be
00:28:20.500 nonpartisan
00:28:22.160 we're
00:28:22.400 supposed
00:28:22.640 to be
00:28:22.920 down
00:28:23.120 the
00:28:23.280 middle
00:28:23.440 now
00:28:23.640 look
00:28:23.840 I
00:28:24.620 for
00:28:24.860 one
00:28:25.180 have
00:28:25.520 serious
00:28:26.200 doubts
00:28:26.760 why
00:28:27.180 the
00:28:27.380 taxpayers
00:28:27.800 should
00:28:28.160 fund
00:28:28.480 any
00:28:29.060 radio
00:28:29.420 station
00:28:29.800 I think
00:28:30.120 there are
00:28:30.320 plenty
00:28:30.560 of
00:28:30.700 for-profit
00:28:31.160 radio
00:28:31.520 stations
00:28:31.980 I don't
00:28:32.680 know why
00:28:33.040 the government
00:28:33.520 should
00:28:33.860 coercively
00:28:34.560 tax you
00:28:35.360 to pay
00:28:36.100 for yet
00:28:36.480 another
00:28:36.760 radio
00:28:37.100 station
00:28:37.540 but I'll
00:28:37.880 tell you
00:28:38.180 what
00:28:38.440 even if
00:28:39.300 there's
00:28:39.540 an argument
00:28:39.980 they should
00:28:40.480 do so
00:28:41.020 for generic
00:28:41.800 news
00:28:42.280 that somehow
00:28:43.060 there's not
00:28:43.560 a market
00:28:43.880 demand for
00:28:44.560 there is
00:28:45.600 no argument
00:28:46.340 I know
00:28:46.740 of that
00:28:47.060 they should
00:28:47.460 do so
00:28:48.000 only for
00:28:48.640 left-wing
00:28:49.060 propaganda
00:28:49.680 and the
00:28:50.880 newly
00:28:51.140 appointed
00:28:51.520 CEO
00:28:52.020 Catherine
00:28:52.520 Marr
00:28:53.260 has been
00:28:54.940 a hard
00:28:55.600 partisan
00:28:56.040 her whole
00:28:56.460 life
00:28:56.660 so for
00:28:57.060 example
00:28:57.520 in 2020
00:28:59.040 Marr
00:29:00.320 referred
00:29:00.800 to
00:29:01.860 President
00:29:02.280 Donald
00:29:02.660 Trump
00:29:03.060 as a
00:29:03.440 quote
00:29:03.800 deranged
00:29:05.380 racist
00:29:06.800 sociopath
00:29:08.100 well
00:29:09.380 then I'm
00:29:10.240 confident her
00:29:10.800 coverage of
00:29:11.460 Donald Trump
00:29:12.220 will be fair
00:29:12.840 as long as she
00:29:13.800 introduces him as a
00:29:14.720 deranged racist
00:29:15.560 sociopath every time
00:29:16.820 he's covered
00:29:17.280 how do you even get
00:29:18.540 that job
00:29:18.980 and I'm being
00:29:19.520 serious
00:29:20.080 if you're
00:29:20.820 National Public
00:29:21.500 Radio
00:29:21.840 how does that
00:29:23.600 automatically
00:29:24.560 disqualify you
00:29:26.120 from that position
00:29:27.100 as soon as they
00:29:28.120 see that quote
00:29:29.000 yeah and by the way
00:29:30.400 that's not an
00:29:31.160 outlier
00:29:31.580 in 2021
00:29:32.840 she celebrated
00:29:34.340 Trump's banishment
00:29:35.940 from social media
00:29:37.000 referring to him
00:29:37.820 as a fascist
00:29:38.560 so she loves
00:29:39.400 censorship
00:29:39.900 okay
00:29:40.420 the former
00:29:41.780 president of the
00:29:42.420 United States
00:29:43.020 elected by the
00:29:43.840 American people
00:29:44.600 I'm thrilled
00:29:45.900 that he's being
00:29:46.820 silenced
00:29:47.440 because I
00:29:47.940 dislike his
00:29:48.460 politics
00:29:48.920 and I think
00:29:49.320 he's a
00:29:49.580 fascist
00:29:50.060 in May of
00:29:51.100 2020
00:29:51.560 right in the
00:29:52.820 middle of the
00:29:53.220 George Floyd
00:29:53.740 riots
00:29:54.240 Marr suggested
00:29:55.980 that looting
00:29:57.880 represented a
00:29:59.760 form of
00:30:00.620 reparative
00:30:01.400 justice
00:30:01.980 for historic
00:30:03.800 wrongs
00:30:04.460 and she
00:30:04.760 remarked
00:30:05.920 how white
00:30:06.760 silence
00:30:07.660 is tantamount
00:30:09.440 to complicity
00:30:10.380 and violence
00:30:11.060 she's also
00:30:12.460 posted repeatedly
00:30:13.600 in support of
00:30:15.140 Democrat
00:30:15.540 politicians
00:30:16.200 including
00:30:17.520 Hillary Clinton
00:30:18.240 Elizabeth Warren
00:30:19.920 Kamala Harris
00:30:21.560 and Joe
00:30:22.700 Biden
00:30:23.060 now listen
00:30:24.680 as a private
00:30:25.700 citizen
00:30:26.120 she has a
00:30:27.180 right to be
00:30:27.700 an angry
00:30:28.120 left-wing
00:30:28.620 radical
00:30:29.060 and a
00:30:30.380 hard
00:30:30.920 Democrat
00:30:31.420 partisan
00:30:31.920 but
00:30:33.080 explain to
00:30:34.140 me why
00:30:34.760 on earth
00:30:35.300 the American
00:30:35.840 taxpayers
00:30:36.460 should fund
00:30:37.880 her partisan
00:30:38.600 propaganda
00:30:39.180 yeah and
00:30:40.300 yet that's
00:30:40.760 exactly why
00:30:41.360 she probably
00:30:41.860 got the job
00:30:42.480 because they're
00:30:42.780 like oh
00:30:43.080 perfect
00:30:43.500 you're gonna
00:30:43.980 keep pushing
00:30:44.640 this propaganda
00:30:45.360 out there
00:30:46.040 full speed
00:30:46.620 ahead
00:30:47.000 when I ask
00:30:47.920 all of you
00:30:48.440 listening right
00:30:48.960 now to do me
00:30:49.420 a favor real
00:30:49.980 quick I want
00:30:50.840 you to place
00:30:51.400 your hand
00:30:52.420 over your
00:30:53.260 heart if you
00:30:53.800 can can you
00:30:54.960 feel that
00:30:55.500 it's your
00:30:56.040 heartbeat
00:30:56.460 telling you
00:30:57.720 that you
00:30:58.080 are alive
00:30:58.720 it's the same
00:31:00.100 for a pre-born
00:31:00.960 baby their
00:31:02.140 heart begins
00:31:02.800 to form at
00:31:03.820 conception and
00:31:05.320 in just three
00:31:05.920 weeks it is
00:31:06.940 already beating
00:31:07.760 at five weeks
00:31:09.000 a baby's heartbeat
00:31:09.800 can be heard
00:31:10.620 on an ultrasound
00:31:11.600 and that is
00:31:13.120 why I am
00:31:13.820 proud to say
00:31:14.460 that I'm
00:31:14.820 partnering with
00:31:15.540 pre-born
00:31:16.160 because we
00:31:17.160 need to help
00:31:18.140 those precious
00:31:19.140 babies
00:31:19.620 every day
00:31:20.960 pre-born's
00:31:21.940 network of
00:31:22.740 clinic rescues
00:31:24.440 200 babies
00:31:26.460 from abortion
00:31:27.460 why because
00:31:29.280 when a mother
00:31:29.960 with an unplanned
00:31:31.160 pregnancy meets
00:31:32.200 her baby on
00:31:33.040 ultrasound and
00:31:34.600 hears their
00:31:35.320 baby's heartbeat
00:31:36.580 it is a divine
00:31:38.080 encounter that
00:31:39.280 doubles a
00:31:40.340 baby's chance
00:31:41.200 at life
00:31:41.980 by six weeks
00:31:43.360 eyes are
00:31:44.100 forming
00:31:44.440 by ten weeks
00:31:45.580 a baby is able
00:31:46.420 to suck his
00:31:47.080 or her own
00:31:47.900 thumb
00:31:48.320 and for just
00:31:49.600 twenty eight
00:31:50.560 dollars you
00:31:51.880 can be the
00:31:52.500 difference between
00:31:53.280 life or death
00:31:54.180 of that child
00:31:55.260 it is incredible
00:31:56.660 because what
00:31:57.740 pre-born does
00:31:58.660 is they give
00:32:00.160 the chance
00:32:01.500 for a mother
00:32:02.520 to hear
00:32:03.660 the baby's
00:32:05.100 heartbeat
00:32:05.920 now all gifts
00:32:07.160 are tax deductible
00:32:08.180 you can donate
00:32:09.400 and you can
00:32:10.260 donate easily
00:32:11.100 just dial
00:32:11.960 pound 250
00:32:13.460 and say the
00:32:15.020 keyword baby
00:32:16.200 that's pound
00:32:17.440 250
00:32:18.480 and say the
00:32:19.960 keyword baby
00:32:20.880 you can donate
00:32:22.160 securely at
00:32:22.960 preborn.com
00:32:24.140 slash verdict
00:32:25.400 as well
00:32:26.080 that's
00:32:26.940 preborn.com
00:32:28.920 slash
00:32:30.060 verdict
00:32:31.000 senator if
00:32:32.200 you are at
00:32:32.760 NPR
00:32:33.160 can you imagine
00:32:34.340 if you are
00:32:34.920 a lefty
00:32:35.980 how much
00:32:36.520 freedom
00:32:37.160 I think
00:32:37.740 it would
00:32:38.060 make you
00:32:38.540 feel like
00:32:38.940 you had
00:32:39.560 to then
00:32:40.540 go out
00:32:40.960 there and
00:32:41.360 continue to
00:32:41.880 push propaganda
00:32:42.660 on the
00:32:43.120 American people
00:32:43.880 if this is
00:32:44.440 your CEO
00:32:44.960 I mean
00:32:45.260 it's a
00:32:45.620 license to
00:32:46.240 to basically
00:32:47.320 go all
00:32:48.660 in on
00:32:49.680 liberal
00:32:50.040 propaganda
00:32:50.580 at the
00:32:51.560 taxpayers
00:32:52.260 expense
00:32:53.480 no that
00:32:55.180 that is
00:32:55.680 exactly
00:32:56.240 right
00:32:56.720 and and
00:32:57.280 and I've
00:32:57.740 got to
00:32:58.000 say listen
00:32:58.460 as you know
00:32:59.640 I'm the
00:32:59.900 ranking member
00:33:00.460 on the
00:33:00.720 senate committee
00:33:01.560 of commerce
00:33:02.120 science and
00:33:02.660 transportation
00:33:03.120 and part
00:33:04.940 of my
00:33:05.240 responsibility
00:33:05.900 in that
00:33:06.440 role
00:33:06.720 we've got
00:33:07.380 jurisdiction
00:33:07.900 over about
00:33:08.360 40% of
00:33:09.220 the US
00:33:09.580 economy
00:33:10.060 and and
00:33:11.120 part of my
00:33:11.640 responsibility
00:33:12.320 is oversight
00:33:13.180 and I can
00:33:13.700 tell you
00:33:14.200 that that
00:33:14.640 I am
00:33:15.200 actively
00:33:15.680 engaging
00:33:16.240 in oversight
00:33:16.740 right now
00:33:17.540 calling on
00:33:18.760 NPR
00:33:19.080 to explain
00:33:19.760 to explain
00:33:20.580 why they're
00:33:21.840 willing to
00:33:22.300 put in
00:33:22.620 place a
00:33:23.200 hard
00:33:23.780 left-wing
00:33:24.500 activist
00:33:25.380 not a
00:33:25.980 neutral
00:33:26.280 journalist
00:33:26.740 but someone
00:33:27.500 who is
00:33:28.180 biased
00:33:29.920 who is
00:33:31.460 who is
00:33:33.200 an active
00:33:34.060 supporter
00:33:34.700 of censorship
00:33:35.640 to violence
00:33:36.480 to silence
00:33:38.000 the views
00:33:38.600 she disagrees
00:33:39.380 with
00:33:39.760 why NPR
00:33:41.120 believes
00:33:41.700 that that
00:33:42.280 is an
00:33:43.740 appropriate
00:33:44.140 leader for
00:33:44.960 their institution
00:33:45.700 yeah that's
00:33:46.840 a really great
00:33:47.340 point
00:33:47.700 and listen
00:33:49.280 don't necessarily
00:33:50.300 take our
00:33:50.820 word for it
00:33:51.520 I want you
00:33:52.580 to listen
00:33:52.960 to Catherine
00:33:53.480 Maher
00:33:53.760 in her
00:33:54.000 own words
00:33:54.560 because it's
00:33:55.060 going to
00:33:55.280 show just
00:33:55.700 how radical
00:33:56.240 she is
00:33:56.760 and I want
00:33:57.260 to play
00:33:57.480 a couple
00:33:57.760 clips
00:33:58.140 let's start
00:33:59.160 with her
00:33:59.560 explaining
00:34:00.040 that in
00:34:00.380 her view
00:34:00.820 the number
00:34:01.180 one challenge
00:34:02.020 that she
00:34:02.780 faces is the
00:34:03.580 first amendment
00:34:04.100 of the
00:34:04.340 constitution
00:34:04.840 let's play
00:34:05.800 that clip
00:34:06.240 the number
00:34:07.180 one challenge
00:34:07.920 here that
00:34:08.340 we see
00:34:09.160 is of course
00:34:10.260 the first
00:34:10.700 amendment
00:34:10.960 in the
00:34:11.260 United States
00:34:12.040 is a
00:34:12.860 fairly
00:34:13.260 robust
00:34:13.960 protection
00:34:16.440 of rights
00:34:16.940 and that
00:34:17.980 is a
00:34:18.500 protection
00:34:18.740 of rights
00:34:19.040 both for
00:34:19.340 platforms
00:34:19.740 which I
00:34:20.000 actually think
00:34:20.380 is very
00:34:20.700 important
00:34:21.080 that platforms
00:34:21.640 have those
00:34:22.080 rights
00:34:22.340 to be able
00:34:22.880 to regulate
00:34:23.320 what kind
00:34:23.860 of content
00:34:24.300 they want
00:34:24.720 on their
00:34:25.080 sites
00:34:25.520 but it
00:34:26.260 also means
00:34:26.860 that it
00:34:27.240 is a little
00:34:27.620 bit tricky
00:34:28.240 to really
00:34:29.560 address
00:34:29.920 some of
00:34:30.440 the real
00:34:31.260 challenges
00:34:31.780 of where
00:34:32.700 does bad
00:34:33.420 information
00:34:33.980 come from
00:34:34.580 and sort
00:34:35.100 of the
00:34:35.260 influence
00:34:35.620 peddlers
00:34:35.960 who have
00:34:36.280 made a
00:34:36.600 real market
00:34:36.980 economy
00:34:37.400 around it
00:34:37.980 I mean
00:34:38.920 it's amazing
00:34:39.640 Senator
00:34:39.920 this is the
00:34:40.480 woman running
00:34:40.960 NPR
00:34:41.380 and I guess
00:34:41.940 this is almost
00:34:42.520 like the best
00:34:43.100 thing you can
00:34:43.400 put on your
00:34:43.780 resume
00:34:44.100 right
00:34:44.380 you're like
00:34:44.660 hey I
00:34:45.000 think the
00:34:45.320 first amendment
00:34:45.760 is a real
00:34:46.120 problem
00:34:46.460 it's like
00:34:46.780 perfect
00:34:47.180 we'd love
00:34:47.740 to hire
00:34:48.120 you at
00:34:48.440 NPR
00:34:48.840 yeah and
00:34:49.580 she actually
00:34:50.260 says well
00:34:50.860 the first
00:34:51.840 amendment
00:34:52.100 is really
00:34:52.620 important
00:34:53.100 for
00:34:53.340 platforms
00:34:54.040 but then
00:34:54.420 what she
00:34:54.700 describes
00:34:55.160 as their
00:34:55.460 first amendment
00:34:55.960 right
00:34:56.280 is for
00:34:57.260 their ability
00:34:57.840 to censor
00:34:58.420 and silence
00:34:58.920 things they
00:34:59.340 disagree with
00:34:59.960 so to her
00:35:00.920 mind
00:35:01.240 what she
00:35:01.740 cares about
00:35:02.360 is the
00:35:02.700 ability
00:35:03.100 if there's
00:35:04.220 a view
00:35:04.560 that is
00:35:05.280 right of
00:35:05.640 center
00:35:05.880 as far
00:35:06.800 as she's
00:35:07.180 concerned
00:35:07.480 the first
00:35:07.880 amendment
00:35:08.160 is all
00:35:08.520 about
00:35:08.780 silencing
00:35:09.380 those
00:35:09.760 views
00:35:10.040 there can
00:35:10.500 be no
00:35:10.880 dissent
00:35:11.340 I want
00:35:12.500 you to
00:35:12.700 listen to
00:35:13.060 another
00:35:13.280 clip
00:35:13.560 this is
00:35:13.880 a TED
00:35:14.280 talk
00:35:14.660 where
00:35:15.340 she's
00:35:15.680 discussing
00:35:16.140 truth
00:35:16.780 when she
00:35:17.080 was at
00:35:17.360 Wikipedia
00:35:17.760 and
00:35:18.820 somehow
00:35:19.820 she has
00:35:20.240 a different
00:35:20.520 view of
00:35:20.900 truth
00:35:21.140 than I
00:35:21.380 think
00:35:21.560 you and
00:35:21.800 I
00:35:21.920 might
00:35:22.140 have
00:35:22.580 give a
00:35:22.860 listen
00:35:23.100 the hard
00:35:24.360 things
00:35:24.880 the places
00:35:25.460 where we
00:35:25.860 are prone
00:35:26.340 to
00:35:26.560 disagreement
00:35:26.980 say
00:35:27.500 politics
00:35:28.360 and
00:35:28.680 religion
00:35:29.160 well
00:35:30.000 as it
00:35:30.620 turns out
00:35:31.240 not only
00:35:32.060 does
00:35:32.220 Wikipedia's
00:35:32.780 model
00:35:33.040 work
00:35:33.380 there
00:35:33.700 it
00:35:34.320 actually
00:35:34.740 works
00:35:35.120 really
00:35:35.460 well
00:35:35.800 because
00:35:36.640 in our
00:35:37.240 normal
00:35:37.680 lives
00:35:38.260 these
00:35:38.560 contentious
00:35:39.180 conversations
00:35:39.920 tend to
00:35:40.720 erupt
00:35:41.360 over
00:35:41.600 disagreement
00:35:42.340 about
00:35:42.860 what
00:35:43.220 the
00:35:43.540 truth
00:35:43.900 actually
00:35:44.640 is
00:35:45.120 but
00:35:46.020 the
00:35:46.140 people
00:35:46.340 who
00:35:46.520 write
00:35:46.780 these
00:35:47.040 articles
00:35:47.480 they're
00:35:48.120 not
00:35:48.360 focused
00:35:49.220 on
00:35:49.940 the
00:35:50.100 truth
00:35:50.440 they're
00:35:51.180 focused
00:35:51.420 on
00:35:51.600 something
00:35:51.900 else
00:35:52.300 which
00:35:53.160 is
00:35:53.280 the
00:35:53.440 best
00:35:53.740 of
00:35:53.920 what
00:35:54.080 we
00:35:54.340 can
00:35:54.580 know
00:35:54.980 right
00:35:55.720 now
00:35:56.180 and
00:35:57.300 after
00:35:57.540 seven
00:35:58.060 years
00:35:58.600 of
00:35:59.000 working
00:35:59.360 with
00:35:59.660 these
00:35:59.900 brilliant
00:36:00.280 folks
00:36:00.840 I've
00:36:01.720 come
00:36:01.880 to
00:36:02.060 believe
00:36:02.380 that
00:36:02.620 they
00:36:02.760 are
00:36:02.920 on
00:36:03.180 to
00:36:03.320 something
00:36:03.740 that
00:36:04.440 perhaps
00:36:05.140 for
00:36:05.680 our
00:36:05.900 most
00:36:06.360 tricky
00:36:06.800 disagreements
00:36:07.660 seeking
00:36:08.720 the
00:36:08.980 truth
00:36:09.340 and
00:36:10.440 seeking
00:36:10.760 to
00:36:11.020 convince
00:36:11.380 others
00:36:11.900 of
00:36:12.160 the
00:36:12.300 truth
00:36:12.640 might
00:36:13.720 not
00:36:13.980 be
00:36:14.360 the
00:36:14.800 right
00:36:14.980 place
00:36:15.280 to
00:36:15.480 start
00:36:15.800 in
00:36:17.000 fact
00:36:17.480 our
00:36:18.400 reference
00:36:18.940 for
00:36:19.180 the
00:36:19.340 truth
00:36:19.720 might
00:36:20.840 be
00:36:21.060 a
00:36:21.200 distraction
00:36:21.680 that's
00:36:22.680 getting
00:36:23.040 in
00:36:23.320 the
00:36:23.440 way
00:36:23.800 of
00:36:24.400 finding
00:36:24.860 common
00:36:25.360 ground
00:36:25.780 and
00:36:26.280 getting
00:36:26.540 things
00:36:26.920 done
00:36:27.180 now
00:36:28.540 that is
00:36:30.340 not to
00:36:30.780 say
00:36:31.100 that the
00:36:31.620 truth
00:36:32.000 doesn't
00:36:32.480 exist
00:36:32.940 nor is
00:36:34.180 it to
00:36:34.400 say that
00:36:34.720 the truth
00:36:35.120 isn't
00:36:35.460 important
00:36:35.940 clearly the
00:36:37.440 search for
00:36:37.980 the truth
00:36:38.440 has led
00:36:39.140 us to
00:36:39.660 do
00:36:40.000 great
00:36:41.040 things
00:36:41.780 to learn
00:36:42.600 great
00:36:43.080 things
00:36:43.640 but
00:36:45.000 I think
00:36:46.720 if I were
00:36:47.120 to really
00:36:47.540 ask you
00:36:48.200 to think
00:36:48.720 about this
00:36:49.360 one of
00:36:51.060 the things
00:36:51.380 that we
00:36:51.600 could all
00:36:51.940 acknowledge
00:36:52.420 is that
00:36:53.220 part of
00:36:53.780 the reason
00:36:54.220 we have
00:36:54.540 such
00:36:54.760 glorious
00:36:55.640 chronicles
00:36:56.380 to the
00:36:57.120 human
00:36:57.400 experience
00:36:58.040 and all
00:36:58.580 forms of
00:36:59.100 culture
00:36:59.460 is because
00:37:00.340 we acknowledge
00:37:01.080 there are
00:37:01.520 many
00:37:01.840 different
00:37:02.280 truths
00:37:02.760 and so
00:37:04.200 in the
00:37:04.720 spirit
00:37:05.100 of that
00:37:05.600 I'm
00:37:06.360 certain
00:37:06.760 that the
00:37:07.240 truth
00:37:07.480 exists
00:37:07.840 for you
00:37:08.360 and
00:37:09.120 probably
00:37:09.700 for the
00:37:10.100 person
00:37:10.380 sitting
00:37:10.700 next
00:37:10.960 to you
00:37:11.320 but
00:37:12.380 this
00:37:12.640 may
00:37:12.920 not
00:37:13.140 be
00:37:13.320 the
00:37:13.520 same
00:37:13.760 truth
00:37:14.140 this
00:37:15.480 is
00:37:15.760 because
00:37:16.060 the
00:37:16.500 truth
00:37:17.000 of
00:37:17.200 the
00:37:17.320 matter
00:37:17.620 is
00:37:18.280 very
00:37:18.620 often
00:37:19.180 for
00:37:19.500 many
00:37:19.820 people
00:37:20.280 what
00:37:21.180 happens
00:37:21.620 when we
00:37:22.040 merge
00:37:22.420 facts
00:37:22.880 about
00:37:23.140 the
00:37:23.340 world
00:37:23.660 with
00:37:24.160 our
00:37:24.360 beliefs
00:37:24.780 about
00:37:25.100 the
00:37:25.280 world
00:37:25.600 so
00:37:26.420 we
00:37:26.580 all
00:37:26.760 have
00:37:26.980 different
00:37:27.300 truths
00:37:27.800 they're
00:37:28.540 based
00:37:28.780 on
00:37:28.960 things
00:37:29.180 like
00:37:29.320 where
00:37:29.460 we
00:37:29.620 come
00:37:29.940 from
00:37:30.360 how
00:37:31.000 we
00:37:31.180 were
00:37:31.360 raised
00:37:31.960 and
00:37:32.520 how
00:37:32.680 other
00:37:32.980 people
00:37:33.420 perceive
00:37:33.860 us
00:37:34.320 what
00:37:35.440 utter
00:37:36.500 garbage
00:37:37.420 like
00:37:37.960 every
00:37:38.480 word
00:37:39.000 of that
00:37:39.280 you
00:37:39.420 want
00:37:39.600 an
00:37:39.740 indictment
00:37:40.360 of
00:37:40.500 the
00:37:40.620 modern
00:37:40.900 left
00:37:41.180 you
00:37:41.340 want
00:37:41.480 an
00:37:41.600 indictment
00:37:42.000 of
00:37:42.100 the
00:37:42.260 idiocy
00:37:42.800 of
00:37:43.080 media
00:37:43.320 you
00:37:43.480 want
00:37:43.620 an
00:37:43.740 indictment
00:37:44.260 of
00:37:44.620 the
00:37:44.740 academic
00:37:45.160 world
00:37:45.560 you
00:37:45.700 want
00:37:45.820 an
00:37:45.960 indictment
00:37:46.460 of
00:37:46.600 big
00:37:46.840 tech
00:37:47.160 good
00:37:47.500 god
00:37:47.920 what
00:37:48.140 utter
00:37:48.400 garbage
00:37:48.900 truth
00:37:49.500 doesn't
00:37:49.880 exist
00:37:50.200 george
00:37:50.600 orwell
00:37:51.160 is
00:37:52.260 spinning
00:37:52.680 in his
00:37:53.040 grave
00:37:53.320 and laughing
00:37:53.820 at the
00:37:54.140 same
00:37:54.360 time
00:37:54.680 two
00:37:54.880 plus
00:37:55.100 two
00:37:55.260 doesn't
00:37:55.540 equal
00:37:55.740 four
00:37:56.040 it
00:37:56.160 equals
00:37:56.420 five
00:37:56.780 because
00:37:57.020 we
00:37:57.220 say
00:37:57.460 it
00:37:57.600 is
00:37:57.740 there
00:37:58.180 is
00:37:58.520 no
00:37:58.720 truth
00:37:59.000 listen
00:37:59.240 to
00:37:59.360 that
00:37:59.520 quote
00:37:59.860 our
00:38:00.600 reverence
00:38:01.080 for
00:38:01.240 the
00:38:01.360 truth
00:38:01.680 might
00:38:01.940 be
00:38:02.100 a
00:38:02.220 distraction
00:38:11.600 politics
00:38:11.880 and
00:38:12.080 religion
00:38:12.440 when
00:38:12.660 it
00:38:12.780 comes
00:38:13.000 to
00:38:13.160 politics
00:38:13.540 and
00:38:13.820 religion
00:38:14.200 look
00:38:15.080 Jesus
00:38:15.560 Christ
00:38:15.900 said
00:38:16.120 I
00:38:16.240 am
00:38:16.360 the
00:38:16.440 way
00:38:16.560 the
00:38:16.700 truth
00:38:16.920 and
00:38:17.040 the
00:38:17.120 life
00:38:17.320 but
00:38:17.480 no
00:38:17.660 no
00:38:17.840 no
00:38:17.960 no
00:38:18.420 no
00:38:18.760 don't
00:38:19.100 have
00:38:19.300 reverence
00:38:19.680 for
00:38:19.840 truth
00:38:20.100 we're
00:38:20.300 not
00:38:20.460 interested
00:38:20.820 in
00:38:21.060 that
00:38:21.300 we
00:38:21.900 are
00:38:22.120 interested
00:38:22.660 in
00:38:23.140 set
00:38:23.660 aside
00:38:24.000 a
00:38:24.140 truth
00:38:24.420 that
00:38:24.600 can
00:38:24.740 be
00:38:24.880 your
00:38:25.120 truth
00:38:25.440 my
00:38:25.680 truth
00:38:25.980 everyone
00:38:26.280 has
00:38:26.580 a
00:38:26.720 truth
00:38:26.980 maybe
00:38:27.500 for
00:38:27.740 you
00:38:27.940 two
00:38:28.120 plus
00:38:28.360 two
00:38:28.660 is
00:38:29.100 five
00:38:29.620 what
00:38:30.620 utter
00:38:31.480 garbage
00:38:32.400 you
00:38:32.520 know
00:38:32.600 what
00:38:32.700 a
00:38:41.600 the
00:38:41.820 truth
00:38:42.120 remember
00:38:42.700 what
00:38:42.900 journalists
00:38:43.260 used
00:38:43.520 to
00:38:43.680 learn
00:38:43.920 who
00:38:44.100 what
00:38:44.300 when
00:38:44.500 where
00:38:44.720 how
00:38:44.960 why
00:38:45.260 like
00:38:45.720 what
00:38:45.980 happened
00:38:46.420 what
00:38:46.640 are
00:38:46.740 the
00:38:46.880 facts
00:38:47.240 well
00:38:47.460 no
00:38:47.620 no
00:38:47.720 no
00:38:47.840 not
00:38:48.100 according
00:38:48.420 to her
00:38:48.840 according
00:38:49.580 to her
00:38:50.360 there are
00:38:50.740 no
00:38:50.900 facts
00:38:51.200 there
00:38:51.380 is
00:38:51.560 no
00:38:51.740 truth
00:38:52.080 it's
00:38:52.320 your
00:38:52.500 truth
00:38:52.780 it's
00:38:52.960 my
00:38:53.160 truth
00:38:53.440 and
00:38:53.580 my
00:38:53.820 truth
00:38:54.140 from
00:38:54.680 Catherine
00:38:55.040 Mars
00:38:55.300 perspective
00:38:55.860 is
00:38:56.500 is a
00:38:56.780 left-wing
00:38:57.240 partisan
00:38:57.740 whatever
00:38:58.220 the
00:38:58.740 orthodoxy
00:38:59.480 is
00:38:59.720 and we
00:39:00.060 will
00:39:00.400 silence
00:39:01.480 views
00:39:01.840 that
00:39:02.020 disagree
00:39:02.480 and
00:39:03.820 the
00:39:04.000 first
00:39:04.300 amendment
00:39:04.700 is a
00:39:05.240 pesky
00:39:05.800 pesky
00:39:06.380 barrier
00:39:06.800 all right
00:39:07.320 I want
00:39:07.520 to play
00:39:07.720 one more
00:39:08.040 clip
00:39:08.300 yeah
00:39:09.060 one more
00:39:10.180 clip
00:39:10.600 where she's
00:39:11.840 describing
00:39:12.460 what she
00:39:13.220 did at
00:39:13.760 wikipedia
00:39:14.300 listen to
00:39:14.780 this third
00:39:15.200 clip
00:39:15.520 I started
00:39:16.520 by talking
00:39:16.920 about the
00:39:17.440 idea of
00:39:17.940 free and
00:39:18.420 open
00:39:18.720 as some
00:39:19.580 of our
00:39:19.800 founding
00:39:20.300 principles
00:39:20.860 sort of
00:39:21.200 free and
00:39:21.480 open source
00:39:22.060 coming from
00:39:22.640 the idea of
00:39:23.340 the open
00:39:24.040 source
00:39:24.280 community
00:39:24.760 well I
00:39:26.060 have come
00:39:26.420 to the
00:39:26.840 opinion
00:39:27.120 and the
00:39:27.740 perspective
00:39:28.120 that free
00:39:28.680 and open
00:39:29.120 was a
00:39:30.180 way of
00:39:30.820 looking at
00:39:31.220 the world
00:39:31.680 that was
00:39:32.140 inherently
00:39:32.780 limited
00:39:33.320 relative to
00:39:33.960 what we
00:39:34.200 were trying
00:39:34.600 to achieve
00:39:35.140 free and
00:39:35.660 open
00:39:35.800 has the
00:39:36.280 best of
00:39:36.760 intentionality
00:39:37.560 but in
00:39:38.480 the end
00:39:38.920 what free
00:39:39.300 and open
00:39:39.580 often ended
00:39:40.300 up doing
00:39:40.760 particularly
00:39:41.260 in the
00:39:41.560 case of
00:39:41.900 wikipedia
00:39:42.320 was really
00:39:43.180 recapitulating
00:39:44.560 many of the
00:39:45.140 same power
00:39:45.680 structures
00:39:46.160 and dynamics
00:39:46.820 that exist
00:39:47.440 offline
00:39:48.320 prior to
00:39:48.920 the advent
00:39:49.560 of the
00:39:50.000 internet
00:39:50.280 and so
00:39:50.740 what we
00:39:51.020 ended up
00:39:51.480 seeing
00:39:51.800 was wikipedia
00:39:52.720 really rebuilt
00:39:53.900 this idea
00:39:54.660 of knowledge
00:39:55.320 as a whole
00:39:56.020 around
00:39:56.760 what the
00:39:57.420 western
00:39:57.800 canon
00:39:58.240 you see
00:39:58.860 the exclusion
00:39:59.680 of communities
00:40:00.960 of languages
00:40:01.880 because of
00:40:02.740 the ways
00:40:03.280 in which
00:40:03.700 wikipedia
00:40:04.080 is based
00:40:05.020 on reliable
00:40:05.600 sources
00:40:06.020 the idea
00:40:06.520 of a
00:40:06.800 written
00:40:07.000 tradition
00:40:07.540 and something
00:40:08.720 that is
00:40:09.080 particular
00:40:09.420 to many
00:40:11.740 I mean
00:40:12.180 no sorry
00:40:12.720 the idea
00:40:13.220 of a
00:40:13.420 written
00:40:13.600 tradition
00:40:14.040 which is
00:40:14.400 particular
00:40:14.660 to some
00:40:15.120 cultures
00:40:15.520 and not
00:40:15.920 to others
00:40:16.460 the ways
00:40:17.080 in which
00:40:17.380 we
00:40:17.640 ascribe
00:40:18.700 notability
00:40:19.340 often
00:40:19.860 really comes
00:40:20.880 from sort
00:40:21.160 of this
00:40:21.400 white
00:40:21.900 male
00:40:22.520 westernized
00:40:24.400 construct
00:40:24.940 around
00:40:25.360 who matters
00:40:26.280 in societies
00:40:27.020 and who
00:40:27.540 is elevated
00:40:28.080 and whose
00:40:28.500 voices
00:40:28.840 and so
00:40:29.540 some
00:40:29.760 of these
00:40:30.080 ideas
00:40:30.540 of
00:40:31.020 sort
00:40:31.420 of
00:40:31.480 this
00:40:31.600 radical
00:40:32.080 openness
00:40:32.620 really
00:40:33.300 did not
00:40:33.800 end up
00:40:34.320 with the
00:40:34.640 intention
00:40:35.060 really did
00:40:36.160 not end up
00:40:36.580 living into
00:40:37.160 the intentionality
00:40:38.080 of what
00:40:38.380 openness
00:40:38.740 can be
00:40:39.620 I mean
00:40:41.200 that that
00:40:41.720 just is
00:40:42.220 brilliant
00:40:42.600 right there
00:40:43.300 god bless
00:40:44.800 so look
00:40:45.680 she's
00:40:46.040 explaining
00:40:46.560 at wikipedia
00:40:47.460 they deliberately
00:40:49.120 abandoned a
00:40:50.100 quote free
00:40:50.960 and open
00:40:51.420 approach
00:40:51.780 by the way
00:40:52.220 she's telling
00:40:52.680 you what
00:40:52.900 she's going
00:40:53.180 to do
00:40:53.380 at npr
00:40:53.940 npr
00:40:54.740 is not
00:40:55.240 going to
00:40:55.600 be free
00:40:56.120 and open
00:40:56.460 according
00:40:56.760 to her
00:40:57.080 because
00:40:57.360 she doesn't
00:40:57.900 believe in
00:40:58.480 free and
00:40:58.780 open
00:40:59.000 why
00:40:59.580 because
00:41:00.760 free and
00:41:01.220 open
00:41:01.480 number
00:41:01.700 one
00:41:01.980 she says
00:41:02.480 well
00:41:02.820 that
00:41:03.940 advantages
00:41:04.900 cultures
00:41:05.660 that believe
00:41:06.540 in the
00:41:07.060 written word
00:41:07.760 because you
00:41:08.340 know
00:41:08.580 what good
00:41:09.800 has book
00:41:10.200 learning
00:41:10.480 ever done
00:41:11.000 anyone
00:41:11.340 well heck
00:41:12.180 you're
00:41:13.480 forgetting
00:41:13.940 those cultures
00:41:14.640 that don't
00:41:15.120 believe in
00:41:15.640 that fancy
00:41:16.260 learning
00:41:16.680 stuff
00:41:17.120 like
00:41:17.380 what
00:41:17.900 utter
00:41:18.320 garbage
00:41:18.940 I'm
00:41:19.340 sorry
00:41:19.740 I thought
00:41:20.260 actually
00:41:20.960 a journalistic
00:41:22.840 outfit
00:41:23.340 should actually
00:41:24.320 reflect
00:41:25.700 celebrate
00:41:26.420 the best
00:41:27.920 of
00:41:28.480 education
00:41:29.460 of learning
00:41:30.280 of what
00:41:30.660 we know
00:41:31.120 but she
00:41:31.460 says
00:41:31.640 no no no
00:41:32.040 if it's
00:41:33.880 actually
00:41:34.240 free and
00:41:34.700 open
00:41:34.960 it will
00:41:35.480 recapitulate
00:41:37.440 a white
00:41:38.940 male
00:41:39.360 westernized
00:41:40.080 construct
00:41:41.340 let me ask
00:41:41.940 you something
00:41:42.340 Ben
00:41:42.580 what the hell
00:41:43.040 does that
00:41:43.400 mean
00:41:43.700 seriously
00:41:44.540 those are
00:41:45.260 the words
00:41:45.640 Marxists
00:41:46.140 use
00:41:46.500 and typically
00:41:47.900 the more
00:41:49.280 syllables
00:41:49.800 they use
00:41:50.620 when they
00:41:50.940 get
00:41:51.140 polysyllabic
00:41:52.100 the less
00:41:53.280 they're making
00:41:53.820 any sense
00:41:54.460 so explain
00:41:55.680 to me
00:41:56.040 the phrase
00:41:56.700 recapitulate
00:41:58.580 a white
00:41:59.340 male
00:41:59.780 westernized
00:42:00.600 construct
00:42:01.180 that does
00:42:02.420 not end
00:42:02.900 up living
00:42:03.380 into the
00:42:03.980 intentionality
00:42:04.900 of what
00:42:05.280 openness
00:42:05.680 can mean
00:42:06.360 those words
00:42:07.940 have no
00:42:08.460 content
00:42:09.160 other than
00:42:10.380 I want
00:42:10.900 the power
00:42:11.380 to silence
00:42:11.860 things I
00:42:12.420 don't like
00:42:12.820 am I
00:42:13.040 wrong
00:42:13.300 no you're
00:42:14.120 right
00:42:14.320 and my
00:42:15.000 question
00:42:15.460 goes back
00:42:15.900 to this
00:42:16.280 for you
00:42:16.760 it used
00:42:17.940 to be
00:42:18.620 at NPR
00:42:19.240 and others
00:42:19.580 they would
00:42:19.920 at least
00:42:20.500 fake it
00:42:21.060 like their
00:42:21.660 bias
00:42:22.140 now it's
00:42:23.260 just flat
00:42:23.780 out open
00:42:24.360 and they're
00:42:25.160 doing it
00:42:25.480 with our
00:42:25.680 tax dollars
00:42:26.300 is there
00:42:27.060 ever going
00:42:27.840 to be a
00:42:28.320 day of
00:42:28.820 reckoning
00:42:29.220 where NPR
00:42:29.840 finds out
00:42:30.640 hey good
00:42:31.800 luck do
00:42:32.380 your own
00:42:32.800 thing because
00:42:33.480 we're not
00:42:34.080 going to pay
00:42:34.560 for this
00:42:34.920 propaganda
00:42:35.380 anymore
00:42:36.100 look if
00:42:36.940 NPR cares
00:42:37.780 at all about
00:42:38.280 journalistic
00:42:38.840 integrity if
00:42:39.520 they care
00:42:39.940 at all about
00:42:40.960 continuing to
00:42:41.680 receive taxpayer
00:42:42.460 funds they
00:42:43.040 should terminate
00:42:43.740 Catherine
00:42:44.160 Marr
00:42:44.540 immediately
00:42:45.060 her job
00:42:46.020 should be
00:42:46.380 done they
00:42:46.800 should not
00:42:47.280 have a
00:42:47.760 rabid left
00:42:48.340 wing partisan
00:42:48.940 who hates
00:42:49.820 the first
00:42:50.240 amendment who
00:42:50.740 views it as
00:42:51.320 an inconvenience
00:42:52.040 who wants to
00:42:52.600 censor conservatives
00:42:53.460 who is actively
00:42:54.820 explicitly and
00:42:56.000 unabashedly opposed
00:42:57.280 to free and open
00:42:58.300 communication who
00:42:59.120 doesn't believe in
00:42:59.820 truth who believes
00:43:00.520 truth is an
00:43:01.480 impediment to what
00:43:02.380 she's doing that
00:43:03.180 is not a journalist
00:43:04.040 in any way she
00:43:05.160 ought to go and
00:43:05.860 join Emily's List
00:43:06.640 she ought to go and
00:43:07.380 join the DNC she
00:43:08.380 ought to go run for
00:43:09.100 Congress and become a
00:43:10.560 henchman to Nancy
00:43:11.440 Pelosi she should not
00:43:13.300 actually be running a
00:43:14.640 news organization
00:43:15.540 especially not a
00:43:16.480 news organization
00:43:17.280 funded by the
00:43:18.480 taxpayers and and if
00:43:19.740 we have to be
00:43:21.000 honest
00:43:21.480 if you had a
00:43:22.980 Democrat who had a
00:43:24.000 shred of integrity
00:43:24.820 they would say of
00:43:26.360 course this is not
00:43:27.160 appropriate for her to
00:43:28.000 run NPR the chances
00:43:29.460 of that happening are
00:43:30.340 zero but I can tell
00:43:31.820 you I'm going to be
00:43:32.480 pushing for
00:43:32.960 accountability and I'm
00:43:33.940 going to be pushing
00:43:34.420 for oversight of
00:43:35.220 NPR because it is
00:43:36.740 brazenly shameless
00:43:38.180 for them to put
00:43:39.920 someone so wildly
00:43:41.320 unqualified in that
00:43:42.960 position
00:43:43.360 don't forget we do the
00:43:44.860 show Monday Wednesday
00:43:45.640 Friday and a week in
00:43:47.300 review on Saturdays hit
00:43:48.860 that subscribe follow or
00:43:51.280 auto download button
00:43:52.080 wherever you're listening
00:43:52.780 this podcast so you do
00:43:53.960 not miss a episode also
00:43:56.160 on those in between
00:43:56.920 days download my
00:43:58.120 podcast the Ben
00:43:59.040 Ferguson podcast and I
00:44:00.240 will keep you updated on
00:44:01.240 the latest breaking news
00:44:03.120 that is happening on those
00:44:04.720 in between days and the
00:44:05.740 senator and I will see
00:44:06.460 you back here on Saturday
00:44:08.460 for a week in review
00:44:09.560 this is an iHeart podcast
00:44:12.860 guaranteed human