Ted Cruz is joined by Sen. Cory Booker (D-D.C.) and Amy Klobuchar (D, D-N.J.) as they join Sen. Marco Rubio (R-R.I.P.S.A.) to discuss the possibility of a Supreme Court overruling Roe v. Wade.
00:00:04.140We are potentially days away from the Supreme Court of the United States potentially overruling Roe v. Wade.
00:00:13.120This would be the biggest bombshell from the Supreme Court in 50 years, I guess since the ruling of Roe v. Wade.
00:00:21.080And this is going to fuel the already pretty loud demands from Democrats to pack the Supreme Court.
00:00:29.300I am very privileged to be joined by not just one, but two United States senators, both of whom have a whole lot of experience inside the court.
00:06:30.660You know, we disagreed on almost everything politically.
00:06:33.800But until the moment he left the Senate, he would bring me into his office periodically just to ask how my family was doing and check in on me.
00:06:42.760He was a he was a wonderful person in many respects.
00:06:46.460Michael, this is reflective of the relationships that exist within the Senate and also within the Supreme Court.
00:06:52.440Relationships that transcend party affiliation and political ideology of every kind.
00:06:59.680It it actually is a place where the relationships are much better than they appear on TV.
00:07:05.900That is good to hear, though, Senator Lee, I don't want to just skip over.
00:07:10.220Reid left you in the garage for hours.
00:07:12.360This wasn't a 15 minute practical joke.
00:07:20.520My wife used to joke that maybe Harry had accidentally sparked the creation of the Tea Party movement by doing so.
00:07:27.560I may have been overstating it, but it's a good observation.
00:07:31.000Senator Cruz, I guess I'll have you lead it off because I know basically nothing about the Supreme Court beyond what I learned from the bill up on Capitol Hill and in Schoolhouse Rock.
00:07:41.700But I do know from reading the news that the Supreme Court appears to be in greater peril than at any time in my life.
00:07:51.580Support for the court, trust in the court seems to be dropping.
00:07:55.480You have this major decision that could be coming out after the leaked opinion, which itself seemed unprecedented.
00:08:02.060And now you've got major calls to upend the whole institution.
00:09:06.540I wrote Saving Nine because a little over a year ago, I started seeing all the warning signs that the left was getting ready to pack the Supreme Court, something they haven't tried since 1937.
00:09:17.340As soon as I realized that they might actually be serious, I started thinking about it and I realized, oh, my gosh, nobody's comprehensively written, at least in modern times, a book explaining how you defeat this and why it needs to be defeated.
00:09:31.520But I had long been of the belief that one of the worst things that happened in American constitutional history was in 1937.
00:09:39.680But it's my belief, and that belief is born out in Saving Nine, where I tell the story of Associate Justice Owen Roberts flipping his vote in a seminal case called NLRB versus Jones and Laughlin Steele.
00:09:52.400That case was decided on April 12, 1937, two years from the date that the Supreme Court had moved into its new Marvel Palace, the first time in history it had had its own courthouse.
00:10:03.680Associate Justice Owen Roberts flipped his vote in that case and effectively redefined the Commerce Clause.
00:10:10.400He amended the Constitution, as it were.
00:10:12.220Had it been a constitutional amendment, this would have been among the most impactful constitutional amendments ever adopted into the Constitution because it changed the nature of the federal government.
00:10:24.180It turned it from a limited-purpose federal government into a general-purpose national government.
00:10:29.260All of this because Owen Roberts was afraid of FDR's threats.
00:10:34.640Even though FDR's court-packing plan failed legislatively, it succeeded and left an ugly, indelible mark, one that's costing the American people dearly to this day.
00:10:43.880So you're pointing out that even though by the numbers FDR's plan did not work, the political pressure that came about because of that really did transform the court.
00:10:55.420So is there something about the number nine?
00:10:59.300I don't want to diminish your book sales by having you give away the answer to the main question of the book, but what is it about this number nine that is so important?
00:11:08.560The number has changed over the course of the court, though it hasn't changed in recent memory, not just for Republicans or Democrats or conservatives or liberals, but for the functioning of our republic.
00:11:58.800It's just that Joe Biden, well, number one, he views himself as the modern reincarnation of Franklin D. Roosevelt, something that's very scary in and of itself.
00:12:06.700But number two, he wants to pack the court so he can change the court so he can remake it in its own image so that the court can be brought to heel to do his will and make sure that whatever he wants goes on the court.
00:12:20.620Well, you know, if Joe Biden were here, Mike, I think he'd say, Mike, I knew FDR.
00:12:29.900And I think he probably thinks he's talking to Eleanor Roosevelt now.
00:12:33.760Well, this was one of my favorite observations in the book, actually, is I didn't realize, Senator Lee, I knew that both of you gentlemen have a long history with the court.
00:12:43.080Senator Cruz, you clerked for Chief Justice Rehnquist, you've argued cases before the court.
00:12:48.640Senator Lee, you clerked for Justice Alito.
00:12:52.340And and also your father was the Solicitor General of the United States under Ronald Reagan.
00:12:57.580So you've got this chapter in the book where you talk about going to the Supreme Court as a kid.
00:13:02.920And I loved your description of walking up the steps of the Supreme Court.
00:13:08.140And and even though obviously the courts right there in Washington, D.C., you describe it as feeling as though you're leaving the petty swamp of Washington and going into a place with a little more dignity.
00:13:19.800That might be a little bit above the usual fray of politics.
00:13:24.840That's right. It was it was different than any proceeding I had ever been a part of.
00:13:28.920It was different than other government offices that I had ever seen.
00:13:33.520There was a reverence for the court and there was a careful deliberation that I saw in there.
00:13:37.740You know, at the age of 10, when I started watching Supreme Court arguments for fun, I didn't understand everything that was going on.
00:13:44.140I didn't understand most of it. It felt like church in a foreign language.
00:13:47.320You had to hold still. You had to be really quiet and pay close attention.
00:13:51.860But over time, I started figuring out the rhythm of the place and I developed a great respect for it.
00:13:58.140My my late father taught me that, you know, even when you disagree with the court's ruling, you've got to respect the court because our entire system depends on the integrity and the independence of the court.
00:14:09.780And that this is this is not a tribunal.
00:14:12.720This is not a court that sometimes does good things and is mostly bad.
00:14:16.920It's quite the opposite. It's a good court. It's the best of its kind, I believe, anywhere in the world, warts and all.
00:14:23.720It is it is a court that is basically good that sometimes makes mistakes because it's run by mortals.
00:14:29.940But what Joe Biden and the Democrats are trying to do, they're trying to demonize and delegitimize the court.
00:14:35.500They're trying to isolate those justices who dare to actually interpret the Constitution based on what it says.
00:14:41.600And they want to remake it in their own image in order to achieve a different policy outcome.
00:14:46.600The minute you do that, you rip off that Band-Aid, bad things will happen and it's not limited to abortion.
00:14:53.340This will extend into all sorts of other things and will end up reflecting the political will of power incumbents, principally presidents of the United States.
00:15:02.820So let me take a digression here. You know, Michael, you and I have talked about how Mike is my closest friend in the Senate by far.
00:15:11.160I love this man. He is both his staff and my staff get frightened when we get together.
00:15:18.760It is not over booze because Mike is a teetotaler, although being Cuban, Irish and Italian, I am not.
00:15:24.160As Mr. Knowles can attest, since since between scotch and cigars, we have killed a few liver cells together.
00:15:32.960But but when when Mike and I get together, we geek out as law geeks in a way that really scares our staff.
00:15:40.680And they're actually like, OK, enough of this.
00:15:43.180Like, like, like. But but I got to say, I want to take a digression for something you two were talking about a second ago, which is Mike's dad.
00:15:49.160So so I never had the privilege of knowing Mike's dad, but he is legendary.
00:15:54.340So listen, the position of Solicitor General of the United States.
00:16:00.040Is a unique position in our nation's history, it is the only position in all of government that is required by statute.
00:16:08.580It is written into statute that the Solicitor General must be learned in the law.
00:16:13.580That is a requirement of the job. And and there have been legendary Solicitor General.
00:16:21.420There have been legendary Solicitor General who were among the finest advocates ever to to be in in those marbled halls.
00:16:30.220And and I say with no exaggeration that that universally Mike's dad is considered one of the finest Solicitor General to have ever served.
00:16:40.380He is considered to be simply an extraordinary Supreme Court advocate.
00:16:44.740And Mike, as a kid, one of the reasons I love hanging out with Mike is he literally grew up watching arguments and around the dinner table debating bills of attainder and debating obscure, obscure aspects of the Constitution.
00:17:01.940On one occasion, he was arguing a case on behalf of the corporation of the presiding bishop of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
00:17:09.140And there was a question in there about a janitor who had not obeyed the teachings of the Church.
00:17:16.900Justice Scalia asked him a question. OK, so this janitor, if he were a good member of the Church, he would neither drink nor smoke.
00:17:22.820My dad said something to the effect of, yes, Justice Scalia.
00:17:25.580And that's a lot more than I can say for some of the Catholics I know.
00:17:29.260Apparently, the courtroom went entirely quiet.
00:17:33.840You could hear a pin drop because everybody was nervous about what was going to happen.
00:17:38.300Fortunately for my dad, Justice Scalia belted out laughing and the rest of the court joined him.
00:17:43.700But he developed this kind of fluidity, this kind of comfort with the court.