Verdict with Ted Cruz - April 11, 2020


Running On Empty ft. Wil VanLoh

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
How Do We Start The Economy Again? Easter In Isolation

Episode Stats


Length

36 minutes

Words per minute

184.25

Word count

6,813

Sentence count

546

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

16

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Ted Cruz speaks on the global pandemic, the collapse in oil prices, and why we should not be celebrating the temporary dip in gas prices. He also talks about his recent trip to the White House and his recent meeting with the Saudi Ambassador.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 This is an iHeart Podcast.
00:00:02 Guaranteed human.
00:00:04 A global pandemic.
00:00:06 Over 16,000 Americans dead.
00:00:09 And over 17 million Americans have lost their job.
00:00:13 And global energy markets crushed by collapsing oil prices.
00:00:18 These are extraordinary times in which we live.
00:00:21 This is Verdict with Ted Cruz.
00:00:30 Welcome back to Verdict with Ted Cruz.
00:00:33 I'm Michael Knowles, Senator.
00:00:34 You're starting us off on a little bit of a downer there.
00:00:37 But I guess we're living in fairly down times.
00:00:40 I want to focus in on something you said there about the energy markets.
00:00:44 Because last I checked, oil was trading at something like $22 a barrel.
00:00:48 It was very, very low.
00:00:50 And I think for most people, the interaction we have with the oil industry is when we fill up our gas tanks.
00:00:55 So low oil prices are not necessarily a bad thing when we look at it.
00:01:00 What are we missing here?
00:01:01 Well, I think right now we're facing three different crises all at the same time.
00:01:05 We've got a global pandemic, the coronavirus crisis.
00:01:08 We're all familiar with the cases, the deaths.
00:01:10 And we're taking extraordinary steps to try to stop the spread of that virus.
00:01:15 There's an economic crisis.
00:01:17 A disaster, 17 million people in the last three weeks have filed for unemployment.
00:01:21 We've seen entire industries decimated, and that's producing enormous damage.
00:01:26 But at the same time, you've got energy markets.
00:01:29 And in particular, the global price of oil has dropped more than in half.
00:01:34 And the consequence of that is it potentially risks bankrupting most, if not every, American energy producer.
00:01:42 And particularly in my home state of Texas, that's devastating.
00:01:45 But if you end up seeing American energy producers driven out of business, that also has massive implications in terms of you and me paying higher prices at the pump in years to come.
00:01:57 And also geopolitically, making us dependent on foreign countries in a way that we just now managed to get free and independent from.
00:02:05 So what you're saying is we shouldn't be celebrating maybe a little dip in the gas prices right now because in the long term financially, that could really hurt us.
00:02:13 And also it has these national security implications that look pretty bad down the road.
00:02:18 I just want to point out something you said, Senator.
00:02:20 You said you flew out and met with the president.
00:02:22 You met with the president specifically because of this energy crisis.
00:02:26 That's how bad it's gotten.
00:02:27 No, that's exactly right.
00:02:29 On Friday, I got on a plane on a United commercial flight that was practically empty.
00:02:34 There were only maybe 10, 15 of us on it.
00:02:36 Flew up to D.C., went to the White House, had a two-hour meeting.
00:02:40 And we're all from states that are big energy producers.
00:02:43 And we started by writing a letter to the Saudi ambassador.
00:02:47 Then a couple of weeks ago, we did a conference call with the Saudi ambassador, nine of us.
00:02:51 I got to tell you, it was the most bare-knuckled, candid conversation.
00:02:55 Really?
00:02:55 I've ever had with a foreign leader in eight years in the Senate.
00:02:59 Can you give us a little behind the curtains here?
00:03:01 I can.
00:03:02 And so we're on a conference call with the ambassador.
00:03:04 Here's what I said.
00:03:05 I said, listen, no state in the union does more business with Saudi Arabia than Texas.
00:03:10 And right now, you're taking advantage of a global health pandemic to try to screw and
00:03:16 bankrupt people across Texas.
00:03:19 And it is devastating.
00:03:21 And the 13 of us who signed on to the letter, as a matter of national security, have consistently
00:03:27 been allies of the Saudis.
00:03:29 Saudi is an important counterpart to Iran.
00:03:32 Iran and the Ayatollah are really dangerous for national security. 1.00
00:03:35 But I said, listen, you know, we've been with you, but you're now trying to bankrupt people
00:03:41 in my state.
00:03:42 And that is not going to stand.
00:03:43 Now, here's the Saudi ambassador's defense.
00:03:47 But Russia, but Russia. 0.74
00:03:49 They sound like the mainstream media for the last three years.
00:03:52 Well, they do.
00:03:54 And I said, listen, Russia's our enemy. 0.99
00:03:57 We know that.
00:03:59 They behave like our enemy.
00:04:00 We treat them as our enemy.
00:04:02 You're supposed to be our friend.
00:04:04 You want us to treat you like Russia? 0.98
00:04:05 Fine.
00:04:06 You want to be our enemy?
00:04:07 How about we pull up all our soldiers out of Saudi Arabia?
00:04:10 We pull our Patriot missiles out there because every time someone screws with you in the Middle 0.99
00:04:14 East, you pick up the phone to call the American military and say, save our asses. 0.77
00:04:20 Well, then don't bankrupt people in my state. 0.99
00:04:22 And I was pissed.
00:04:23 Yeah.
00:04:23 And I got to tell you, it was interesting that call.
00:04:28 I think it got there.
00:04:29 In fact, I know it got their attention.
00:04:31 So you and I, we've invited a guest.
00:04:32 It's a longtime friend of mine, Will Van Lowe.
00:04:35 Will is the CEO of Quantum Energy Partners.
00:04:38 Now, that is an $18 billion private equity energy fund.
00:04:43 Quantum is the third largest driller in North America.
00:04:47 And I got to tell you, Will is someone who knows the energy markets as well, if not better
00:04:53 than anyone I know.
00:04:54 And so in the last couple of weeks, as I went up to meet with the president and major energy
00:04:58 CEOs last week, Will was someone we literally spent probably six, seven hours on the phone
00:05:03 trying to understand what's happening here and the real threat to jobs and to energy security
00:05:10 in our country.
00:05:10 And so, Will, welcome to Burning.
00:05:11 Will, for so many years, we complained about how we're dependent on the Middle East for energy.
00:05:16 We are totally trapped for energy.
00:05:19 And yet this technology helped to lead us away from that and get us to what I guess we'd call
00:05:24 energy independence until maybe five minutes ago.
00:05:26 And that's right.
00:05:28 And I think that is a huge, when you think about, the United States has had more wells
00:05:33 drilled in it than the rest of the world combined.
00:05:35 That's a pretty amazing statistic to think about.
00:05:38 And when it comes to shale, do we have a lot of it here?
00:05:40 Yeah.
00:05:40 Oh, for sure.
00:05:42 Probably 95% of all shale production in the world is in the United States.
00:05:47 Part of that's due to our geology, right?
00:05:50 So they've tried it, for example, in Europe.
00:05:52 They don't have the same rocks over there.
00:05:54 Now, there's other parts of the world where there's a lot of shale, but those are parts
00:05:58 of the world that typically have a lot of conventional oil and gas as well.
00:06:02 And if you don't need to drill, it costs more money to drill wells unconventionally, horizontally,
00:06:07 and put the big fracks on them.
00:06:08 So places like in the Middle East, where they have a lot of conventional production, they
00:06:12 don't need to drill horizontal wells.
00:06:15 So the last 10 years, we have this technological innovation.
00:06:19 We discover how to access massive reserves that were there, but we didn't know how to get
00:06:25 to it.
00:06:26 And suddenly, America passes everybody.
00:06:29 We pass Saudi Arabia.
00:06:30 We pass Russia. 0.91
00:06:30 We become the top producer in the world.
00:06:34 Who is it that drove that?
00:06:36 And is the energy industry...
00:06:38 Look, I think a lot of people think of energy, and they think of big oil.
00:06:41 They think of a couple of giant companies, Exxon and Shell, and these giant companies.
00:06:46 Is that who did this innovation?
00:06:48 No, and that's the interesting thing, because so much of the dialogue right now in Washington
00:06:52 is involving the Exxons and the Chevrons of the world. 0.94
00:06:56 And there are certainly big players in Shell today, but they didn't drive the innovation.
00:07:00 It was actually the independents that drove that innovation in the United States.
00:07:03 So what's an independent?
00:07:05 Well, an independent is basically an oil and gas company that's not a major.
00:07:09 So the majors are typically integrated companies.
00:07:12 They're the largest companies in the world in terms of publicly or privately owned, outside
00:07:18 of government-owned oil companies.
00:07:20 And these majors, I mean, they're massive.
00:07:23 I mean, some of them, they have GDPs that rival companies.
00:07:25 Well, they do.
00:07:26 Like Exxon, for example, they produce over 4 million barrels a day, right?
00:07:30 There's only a handful of countries in the world that produce over 4 million barrels a
00:07:34 day.
00:07:35 But the shale revolution was started and driven by independents.
00:07:40 And independents, you're talking, you and I both spent a lot of time out in Midland, Texas.
00:07:44 You're talking sometimes 5, 10, 20 guys in a little office who were raising some money
00:07:52 and going out and drilling holes and innovating.
00:07:56 That's what drove this entire revolution and changed the entire geopolitics?
00:08:01 It did.
00:08:01 And to be fair, the technology was probably driven more by the larger public independents.
00:08:07 Companies like Chesapeake, companies like Pioneer, those types, they drove the technology.
00:08:13 But the smaller independents were very quick to get in and really take that.
00:08:19 And they're much more nimble than the public companies.
00:08:22 So they take the big technology revolutions and then they do a lot of evolutionary changes
00:08:29 in that technology.
00:08:31 And they get it out there very quick and they're able to access large amounts of land.
00:08:36 And so the independents, both the public, the larger public independents, as well as
00:08:39 the thousands of smaller kind of mom and pop independents, they're really the ones that
00:08:44 have made this independence of energy possible in this country.
00:08:49 Bill, I don't want to rain on your parade here, but this sounds too good.
00:08:53 This sounds too good to be true right now because you've got this great energy revolution
00:08:58 here.
00:08:59 You're empowering so many people, American ingenuity, and then the prices all plummet.
00:09:05 So I understand how it worked out so well.
00:09:09 What went wrong?
00:09:10 Well, let's back up a little bit.
00:09:13 And you think about prices plummeting.
00:09:15 Prices plummeted from about $60 a barrel at the beginning of the year down to about $20
00:09:19 a barrel a few weeks ago.
00:09:21 Now they're up in the mid to high 20s now.
00:09:23 But let's not forget before the shale revolution started in 2008, oil was $147 a barrel.
00:09:31 Okay.
00:09:31 Wow.
00:09:31 Hold on a second.
00:09:33 $147 a barrel.
00:09:35 And then it came down to $50, $60 a barrel.
00:09:38 And now it's plummeted to the 20s.
00:09:40 Right.
00:09:40 And through American innovation and ingenuity, we were able to get the cost.
00:09:46 Initially, these shale wells were very expensive, and you didn't recover a lot of hydrocarbon.
00:09:50 And through a lot of science, through a lot of just innovation and trial and error, we were
00:09:55 able to meaningfully perfect, if you will, the way we drilled and completed these wells.
00:09:59 And we got the cost down to a level where at $50 to $60, the U.S. oil and gas companies
00:10:06 can make a respectable profit.
00:10:09 And the industry for the last four or five years has been chugging along.
00:10:13 And $50 to $60.
00:10:15 Look, most of us don't buy a barrel of oil.
00:10:16 So that number doesn't mean anything to us.
00:10:19 What does that mean, $50, $60 oil?
00:10:22 What does that mean in terms of a gallon of gas, a gas pump?
00:10:25 And understanding a lot of the cost of gas is actually taxes, right?
00:10:29 And those don't change.
00:10:31 So $3 to $4, depending on the state and city you live in, is what $50 to $60 oil transit is.
00:10:37 So Michael will pay a lot more in California than we will in Texas.
00:10:40 He will absolutely pay more.
00:10:43 Although I don't know that you need to fill your electric scooter, Michael, so that may help.
00:10:46 That's the thing.
00:10:47 We actually just run on moonbeams out here, so we don't need any sort of energy.
00:10:51 So what I'm hearing, though, is you don't want the price of oil to be so expensive that
00:10:55 it's going to kill us all at the pump.
00:10:57 But you also don't want the price of oil to be so low that you put all of these companies
00:11:01 out of business.
00:11:02 You want there to be some medium in there.
00:11:05 What are the odds that we're going to be able to get back to that before the American 0.99
00:11:08 energy industry is just destroyed?
00:11:11 Yeah.
00:11:12 You know, right now, it's not looking good.
00:11:14 It's not looking good for two reasons.
00:11:16 One was Saudi and Russia have decided they were going to basically launch a market share
00:11:21 war on the U.S.
00:11:23 And as Senator Cruz said a minute ago, you know, the U.S. went from being a huge energy
00:11:27 importer.
00:11:28 You know, we imported more than 12 million barrels a day less than a decade ago to literally
00:11:34 over the last six months or so, we given on any given week, we will export or import
00:11:40 a few hundred thousand.
00:11:41 So we'll be a net exporter or a net importer of maybe 100 or 200,000 barrels, right?
00:11:45 And so that, if you think about that and you think about the impact on our economy, that's
00:11:50 depending on the price of oil, but say at $50 oil, that's about $250 billion a year that
00:11:56 stays here in the U.S.
00:11:58 That U.S. 0.96
00:11:59 oil and gas industry has created additional revenue, the taxes that come off of that,
00:12:03 the millions of jobs that were created out of that.
00:12:05 What does that mean for jobs?
00:12:06 How does that, whose jobs are we talking about here?
00:12:09 Well, we're talking about very high paying middle and upper middle class jobs.
00:12:15 We're talking about engineers, geologists, geophysicists, production engineers.
00:12:20 We're talking about a lot of jobs out in the field.
00:12:23 So for both lots of blue collar jobs, but also a lot of white collar jobs.
00:12:29 So if we lose American energy production, if these companies go bankrupt, we're still
00:12:38 going to need energy.
00:12:39 When the economy comes back, we're still going to drive our cars, we're going to fly airplanes.
00:12:43 And so if the American companies are bankrupt, where are we going to get our energy?
00:12:49 We're going to get it where we used to get it.
00:12:50 And that's from foreign sources like the Middle East, like Russia.
00:12:54 And that's really, to me, Senator, that the key question the U.S. has to ask itself is,
00:13:00 do we want to be energy independent or not?
00:13:03 And the answer to that question, all policy will flow from whether the answer is yes or no.
00:13:09 Sorry to interrupt, Will, because most people, I think, want that energy independence.
00:13:13 That's what we always hear our politicians talking about.
00:13:15 Certainly what I want for us.
00:13:17 But what you're describing is the problem here.
00:13:19 I just assumed it was all the coronavirus that's upsetting all the global markets.
00:13:23 You're saying there's something else in play, which is this price war between Russia and
00:13:28 Saudi Arabia going after the United States.
00:13:31 What does that mean?
00:13:32 I mean, is that related to the virus or is that a totally separate issue?
00:13:35 Totally separate.
00:13:36 And to be fair, the demand destruction that's associated with coronavirus is a much bigger
00:13:42 issue today in the near term.
00:13:44 If I understand it globally, the demand for oil in normal times four months ago was between
00:13:51 95 and 100 million barrels a day.
00:13:53 About 100 million barrels a day.
00:13:55 As a result of the economy slowing down and grinding to a halt in the U.S. and globally,
00:14:02 it's dropped to about, what, about 70 million barrels a day?
00:14:06 There's a lot of different estimates out there, but I'd say they range anywhere from a 20 to as
00:14:10 much as probably 35 million barrel a day demand destruction.
00:14:13 So that would say somewhere between 65 and 80 million barrels a day is currently what
00:14:18 the globe is using today.
00:14:20 So that had a big negative impact on price.
00:14:22 When a third or more of the demand disappears.
00:14:26 Right.
00:14:27 It's never happened.
00:14:29 It's beyond without precedent.
00:14:32 Well, that's everybody's car sitting in their driveways and everyone's airplanes staying parked
00:14:36 at the hangar and nobody flying and very few people driving.
00:14:39 And to put that into context, during the great financial crisis, total global demand dropped
00:14:44 by only about two and a half to three million barrels a day.
00:14:47 Wow.
00:14:47 So we're looking at 10 times as much reduction in demand now as during the financial meltdown.
00:14:55 That's exactly right.
00:14:56 But then you've got a second component, which is you have the Saudis and the Russians, right
00:15:01 as coronavirus is breaking.
00:15:03 Yes.
00:15:03 It's deciding this is a great opportunity to screw the Americans, to bankrupt the American 0.80
00:15:11 energy business.
00:15:12 And listen, what you're doing, drilling in West Texas shale, the Saudis and Russians have 0.99
00:15:17 hated it because you pass them up with America as the top producer.
00:15:22 And so they're sitting there, if I understand this right, they're taking this as an opportunity.
00:15:26 All right, we've got a crisis.
00:15:28 Let's put these guys out of business.
00:15:29 Let's bankrupt them so that when all is said and done, we're the only players left in the
00:15:34 game.
00:15:35 Senator, if you think back to when the oil shell revolution started and you look at total
00:15:40 global supply growth since then, so about eight or nine years ago, 80% of total global
00:15:46 supply growth has come from the United States of America.
00:15:49 Okay.
00:15:50 That's a country that today produces about 13, 14%, maybe 15 if you add in all the NGLs and
00:15:56 other liquids.
00:15:57 What's an NGL?
00:15:58 I'm sorry, natural gas liquids.
00:16:00 But let's see, the U.S. today produces about 15% of global liquid supply, yet we've accounted
00:16:06 for 80% of total global liquids growth over the last decade.
00:16:11 That's extraordinary.
00:16:13 And that challenged OPEC supremacy and it challenged Russia supremacy.
00:16:18 And it also helped, if I understand right, drive the price down quite a bit.
00:16:23 By two thirds.
00:16:24 It drove prices.
00:16:25 If, had the U.S. share revolution not happened, think about we were at $147 a barrel and that
00:16:31 was pre-oil shales.
00:16:33 Prices probably would have gone a lot higher from there.
00:16:35 And so that huge drop in what Russia and Saudi, I actually think that they may not have chosen 0.77
00:16:43 to launch this price war had it not been for coronavirus.
00:16:45 Because both countries, if you look at their ability to, how long can they go with low oil
00:16:52 prices?
00:16:53 You know, Saudi today is much worse equipped for a long price war than they were back in 1.00
00:16:59 2014 during the last big collapse in prices, right?
00:17:03 Because they've depleted a lot of their sovereign wealth funds.
00:17:05 And their break-even cost today is probably $80 a barrel.
00:17:11 And what I mean by that is they fund their entire government out of their oil revenues.
00:17:15 Whereas Russia's is only about $40 to $45 a barrel.
00:17:19 So Russia... 0.78
00:17:19 What they're doing used to be what we would call an antitrust law, predatory pricing.
00:17:24 Right.
00:17:24 In that they're, when they flooded the market with oil and they announced they were going
00:17:29 to do that and drove the prices way down, they were taking a big hit themselves, but
00:17:34 they were doing it to bankrupt their competitors and then sweep in and dominate the market.
00:17:39 That's right.
00:17:41 Let me pause for a second and kind of play devil's advocate.
00:17:44 You mentioned two technological innovations that helped us access all these massive shale
00:17:50 reserves.
00:17:50 One was horizontal drilling, but it was combining that with hydraulic fracturing, fracking.
00:17:56 Look, fracking, I've heard a lot of scary things on the internet about that.
00:17:59 I've heard it messes with the water table.
00:18:02 You can light the water on fire, that's what they say.
00:18:05 So is that for real?
00:18:07 Should I be worried that fracking makes it dangerous to drink the water?
00:18:12 No.
00:18:12 You know, there's probably not a bigger set of environmentalists in terms of people that
00:18:17 like the outdoors, that like the water, that are, you know, really love the earth than
00:18:21 people, the good people you'll find in the oil and gas business, right?
00:18:24 And I think there is, you got to remember when we frack a well, these wells are anywhere
00:18:30 between eight and 15,000 feet below the earth's surface.
00:18:34 The surface water that people drink is anywhere from 50 feet to maybe three or 400 feet below
00:18:39 the surface.
00:18:40 So let me make sure I understand that.
00:18:41 You got the surface 50 to 300 feet down.
00:18:44 Now that's not that far down, that's the water table.
00:18:47 That's where the water is that we get our drinking water.
00:18:49 That's correct.
00:18:49 So that's not where you're fracking.
00:18:51 No.
00:18:52 You're fracking.
00:18:53 10,000 feet below that.
00:18:54 And 10,000 feet, if my math is right, that's two miles.
00:18:57 About two miles.
00:18:58 Two miles of rock down low.
00:18:59 So where you're doing this is two miles away from the water.
00:19:03 Right.
00:19:05 All right, let me ask a different question.
00:19:06 So my daughter, Caroline, you know, Caroline, she's 11.
00:19:08 And she actually said to me last night, she said, you know, everything that's happened
00:19:13 in this crisis has been really good for the environment.
00:19:15 The environment is cleaning up.
00:19:17 That's right.
00:19:17 And listen, it is true.
00:19:19 If we have no production, if all human activity stops, that would be good for the environment.
00:19:26 It's just not very good for people.
00:19:27 That's right.
00:19:28 Let me ask you something.
00:19:29 What happens if all these independent energy producers go out of business, the economy
00:19:39 gets going again after the crisis, and we're dependent once again on the Middle East for 0.94
00:19:45 oil?
00:19:46 Is that good or bad for the environment?
00:19:48 You know, it's a great question because I think so many people think, you know, hey,
00:19:52 let's put the U.S. oil and gas producer out of business because oil and gas is bad for
00:19:57 the environment.
00:19:57 But that doesn't mean people are going to stop driving their cars.
00:20:00 It doesn't mean people are going to stop flying in airplanes.
00:20:03 It doesn't mean people are going to stop buying iPhones, which, by the way, take hydrocarbon
00:20:07 energy and the plastics, a lot of the parts.
00:20:10 Everything we have in our modern life, Senator, revolves around hydrocarbons in some form or
00:20:15 fashion.
00:20:16 So the need for them is not going to go away.
00:20:19 We will just shift the source of where we secure those from, and we'll go back to where we were
00:20:23 a decade ago, which is sending hundreds of billions of dollars overseas to people that,
00:20:29 quite frankly, don't like us very much.
00:20:31 We will lose significant geopolitical influence.
00:20:33 And if I remember right, an awful lot of the 9-11 terrorists who attacked us were from
00:20:38 Saudi Arabia.
00:20:39 They were.
00:20:39 They had their funding stores from there.
00:20:41 And so fueling the Middle East with billions of American dollars is not good for keeping
00:20:47 America safe.
00:20:47 It's not.
00:20:48 And it'll also cause the loss.
00:20:49 If you think about the biggest growth engine in U.S. jobs coming out of the great financial
00:20:54 crisis was the energy industry.
00:20:56 And the tens, if not hundreds of billions of dollars in taxes that the energy industry
00:21:01 pays every year to school districts, to other municipalities, hospitals, building roads,
00:21:09 bridges, infrastructure.
00:21:11 Right.
00:21:11 But this is just Texas, right?
00:21:13 I mean, we're only talking Texas jobs.
00:21:14 There's none anywhere else in the country.
00:21:16 No, there's a number of other places throughout the United States, both.
00:21:20 Like where?
00:21:21 Well, you've got the Bakken.
00:21:22 It's in North Dakota.
00:21:24 You've got the DJ that's in Colorado, the powder that's in Wyoming.
00:21:28 You've got the Permian, which is New Mexico.
00:21:31 You've got several plays in the scoop stack in Oklahoma.
00:21:35 That's just on the oil side.
00:21:36 Pennsylvania.
00:21:37 Well, as I say, on the gas side, the largest gas field in the United States, really one
00:21:41 of the largest, maybe the largest in the world, sits under Pennsylvania, West Virginia,
00:21:46 Ohio, and New York.
00:21:47 You've also got California.
00:21:48 California is a huge producer, right?
00:21:50 They are a huge producer.
00:21:51 In many ways, I can speak to California.
00:21:53 It's a completely lost cause.
00:21:55 But of course, we don't want the industry to go out here.
00:21:58 I just, I see, Will, your point that this is all over the United States, that we're talking
00:22:03 about a lot of jobs and a lot of industry all over the place.
00:22:05 So what do we do now?
00:22:07 I mean, looking down at this crisis, you've got the markets collapsing, rather.
00:22:12 How do we fix it?
00:22:13 What are our options before it's too late?
00:22:15 Well, you know, I think we have, again, we have to start with, we got to decide we want
00:22:20 to fix it, because that is, part of the issue is obviously the Saudi and Russian, what they've
00:22:25 done in trying to flood the market with additional barrels to drive down prices.
00:22:30 But the other, but the much bigger issue in the short term is obviously demand destruction
00:22:34 associated with coronavirus.
00:22:36 And so, you know, at these prices, the U.S.
00:22:40 independent cannot make money.
00:22:41 Okay, they just flat can't make money.
00:22:43 So there's, there is, there is that fact.
00:22:45 They're just revenues will not exceed their, their expenses.
00:22:49 But the other thing we have to also look at as an industry is.
00:22:52 And that's just simple math that, that, that, that it costs a U.S.
00:22:56 producer, what, about $40 a barrel to produce.
00:22:59 And so $20 a barrel, it doesn't work if it costs twice as much as the price to produce,
00:23:03 you're out of business.
00:23:04 At these prices, there's not probably, you know, less than 5% of all locations in the United
00:23:10 States are economic at these prices.
00:23:13 Okay.
00:23:14 That's, well, Michael, you know, one of the things, I mean, you asked, what do we do about
00:23:18 it?
00:23:19 Yeah.
00:23:19 There's, there's both a component of it.
00:23:23 We get our economy going again, but there's also a component of it, the foreign policy component.
00:23:28 I'll tell you, and you and I have talked about this.
00:23:30 That's something I've been really active in is taking on the Saudis. 1.00
00:23:33 In my office, I brought my national security team in.
00:23:36 I said, all right, I want a list of steps we can take to ratchet up heat on the Saudis 1.00
00:23:41 to make it more and more painful.
00:23:43 We looked at things like sanctions on individual, uh, officials in, in the Saudi government that
00:23:49 had directly targeted American businesses and said, if you're going to wage economic
00:23:53 warfare on us, well, well, welcome to the game.
00:23:56 And, and you better be prepared for the consequences.
00:23:58 Rewind to last week, Friday in the Oval Office meeting with the president, the president had
00:24:04 spoken in the, in the preceding week, both to Putin and MBS, the head of Saudis.
00:24:09 He had leaned in hard.
00:24:11 And it's interesting.
00:24:12 The president didn't start out that way.
00:24:14 I talked to the president a couple of weeks ago and his instinct is actually where you
00:24:17 started this show, Michael.
00:24:19 He was like, well, you know, aren't low, low oil prices good.
00:24:22 Isn't that a good thing?
00:24:22 He was thinking of it.
00:24:23 He's a real estate guy from a consumer's perspective until I and others started exploring.
00:24:28 Listen, we're looking at millions of jobs that go away.
00:24:32 And if we destroy America's producing capability, it makes the bad guys who hate us more powerful
00:24:38 and it makes America weaker.
00:24:40 That's a bad outcome.
00:24:41 Well, what the president said is, is that MBS and Putin had agreed to, to, to stop flooding
00:24:48 the market, to reduce their production.
00:24:51 He tweeted out two weeks ago, they were reducing their production 10 million barrels a day.
00:24:56 That resulted in oil, just that announcement going from 20 bucks a barrel to 27.
00:25:03 In the white house meeting, what he told us is he said, it's actually going to be more
00:25:07 than more than 10.
00:25:08 It's going to be more like 15 million.
00:25:10 And just today, the news broke that they're talking about 20 million.
00:25:15 Now the proof is in the pudding and we'll see if they actually do it.
00:25:18 Yeah.
00:25:19 But if they stop flooding the market, if they pull back, that will help.
00:25:23 It won't solve the problem.
00:25:24 Problem won't get solved until the economy comes back and people are able to drive their
00:25:29 cars and fly airplanes.
00:25:30 But, but, but if Russia and, and the Saudis follow through and, and, and stop flooding
00:25:35 the market, stop taking advantage.
00:25:37 In the meantime, before the economy comes back, if they're talking about cutting daily production
00:25:42 by, by 20 million barrels, okay, that's great.
00:25:45 How much do we need to actually see an impact on the American energy sector?
00:25:51 Right.
00:25:51 So, you know, going back again, I think there's somewhere between 25 and 40 million barrels
00:25:56 of demand destruction right now.
00:25:58 And, and so look, is 10 or 15 or 20 million barrels a lot?
00:26:03 It is.
00:26:04 It's nowhere close to what we need to really balance supply and demand.
00:26:08 And the fact is, is prices were cratering long before this, you know, it became apparent
00:26:15 of how bad, because most of the price drop happened when people were thinking demand destruction
00:26:20 was three to five million barrels a day.
00:26:22 Historically, if a producer, like if OPEC were to flood the market, even with a couple
00:26:27 million barrels a day of excess supply, meaning only a million or two million barrels difference
00:26:31 in supply and demand, prices would drop in half.
00:26:34 Okay.
00:26:34 So what we're talking about here is it's, it's a number that's really irrelevant.
00:26:39 Number one, number two, there's a conditionality on everything Saudi and Russia, Saudi and Russia
00:26:45 both have said in order to enact these cuts.
00:26:48 So for the econ wonks out there, there's, there's high price elasticity.
00:26:52 There's very high price elasticity.
00:26:54 And, and if you, and Saudi and Russia both said, if, if we're going to do these cuts, we
00:27:00 want contributions from all the major exporting countries in the world.
00:27:04 Including the U S including Norway, including Mexico.
00:27:08 So there's all these other countries that they want to participate in this.
00:27:11 And I think the president's been very clear.
00:27:13 The U S is not going to deliver a production cut.
00:27:16 Now he has talked about, there's going to be natural shut-ins and declines, and that is
00:27:21 going to be the case.
00:27:21 The question is, is that going to be good enough for the Saudis and for the Russians?
00:27:25 The other thing though, to keep in mind is every time OPEC or OPEC plus has said, we're
00:27:30 going to make a cut.
00:27:32 There's generally speaking, not great adherence to those cuts.
00:27:35 So they may say they're going to make a cut, but the actual cuts usually are much less.
00:27:40 So trust, but verify, and maybe even don't trust.
00:27:42 Let me bring out one other issue.
00:27:44 Because it's an important issue to, to, to understand.
00:27:47 And, and this is something you and I have talked a lot about, and it was the one deliverable
00:27:51 that came out of the white house meeting last week.
00:27:53 So we spent two hours talking about energy.
00:27:55 We talked about pressuring the Saudis and Russians. 0.99
00:27:57 That seems to have produced some results, but we also talked about access to capital.
00:28:01 And, and, and this is a piece where, where I think a lot of people don't understand
00:28:05 what's going on, but it's really important.
00:28:07 Wall street, the last couple of years has been cutting off more and more capital to
00:28:12 energy.
00:28:13 There, there, there's, there's a movement called the ESG movement, which is putting pressure
00:28:16 on wall street to say, we're not going to fund American energy producers.
00:28:21 And the consequence of that has, has, has been really significant.
00:28:26 So, so, well, I, I want us to understand it.
00:28:29 Let's say you're a small independent producer.
00:28:32 You're in West Texas, you're in New Mexico, you're in Colorado and you're in Pennsylvania
00:28:38 and the banks decide to cut off your capital.
00:28:43 How does that happen?
00:28:44 How does that work?
00:28:45 Why, why does capital matter?
00:28:46 And what would that, how would that impact you?
00:28:49 So in any oil and gas business, uh, companies obtain capital from banks and what's called RBLs
00:28:55 reserve, reserve based loans.
00:28:57 And those RBLs are redetermined every six months.
00:29:00 Okay.
00:29:00 So think about public companies.
00:29:03 They go issue debt and it's seven, 10, 15, 20 year debt.
00:29:06 They don't have to think about refinancing or having that debt called for a very long
00:29:10 time.
00:29:11 The independent producers in this country, the vast majority of them can't access that
00:29:15 kind of public capital to term out their debt.
00:29:17 And so they go to banks and the bank loans, if they get redetermined every six months.
00:29:22 So historically it's been a very symbiotic system and the banks understand the importance
00:29:26 of the business and they understand, you know, they, they loan companies money and they're
00:29:29 not going to change it a lot quickly in terms of the amount they're loaning them.
00:29:32 Well, what's happening now because prices have dropped so much and the banks have, have
00:29:38 actually had some significant losses on those RBLs.
00:29:41 They've made a decision that are going to significantly tighten the amount of credit to the sector,
00:29:46 but they had made that decision really before this price drop.
00:29:49 They'd made that to your point.
00:29:50 They've been getting a lot of pressure from, you know, ESG centric groups.
00:29:54 So the pressure is energy's bad.
00:29:57 It's, you know, killing the, killing the climate.
00:30:00 And so don't invest in energy companies.
00:30:03 Here's the fallacy of that Senator is, as we said earlier, unless people are going to
00:30:07 quit driving cars and flying in airplanes and buying products, they're going to keep
00:30:12 consuming the energy.
00:30:13 You were talking about reserve based lending.
00:30:16 And I want to make an analogy to, to, to say a home mortgage, uh, let's say you've got
00:30:21 a home that that's valued at $400,000.
00:30:24 So, so you get a mortgage, let's say for $350,000, you're paying your mortgage and it's based
00:30:31 on the value of the home.
00:30:32 Now, now drawing that analogy to, if you've got an energy producer, they get a loan based
00:30:37 on the value of their reserves, the reserves that they're, they're producing and going to
00:30:41 produce.
00:30:42 But you said in the energy business, every six months they come redeterminate.
00:30:47 So what that would mean, if you think about your home mortgage, you got a $350,000 mortgage
00:30:52 on what you think is a $400,000 house.
00:30:55 Suddenly the bank comes to you six months later and says, Michael, your $400,000 house, we
00:31:00 now think is a $200,000 house.
00:31:03 You borrowed $350,000.
00:31:05 So write me a check for $150,000 now.
00:31:08 And that's what's happening, Senator.
00:31:09 That is literally, we're hearing stories every single day about banks going to companies
00:31:16 and saying, you need to put equity in and pay down this loan, or we're going to throw your
00:31:21 loan over to the workout group.
00:31:22 And, and so in terms of deliverables from the white house meeting, what, what I suggested
00:31:26 to the president on Friday, I said, Mr. President, there is a real problem with the banks cutting
00:31:31 off capital to these American energy producers and ending American energy production.
00:31:36 And, and we need to make sure that, that energy is not discriminated against.
00:31:41 And, and so I suggested to him, Mr. President, you should ask the energy secretary, Dan Bruyette,
00:31:47 who is a Texan and a good friend, ask him to work with Steven Mnuchin, the treasury secretary,
00:31:52 to work with the bank regulators, to make sure that the banks are not discriminating and
00:31:59 bankrupting these energy companies in America and causing millions of people to lose their
00:32:03 jobs.
00:32:03 And the president said, I'll do it.
00:32:05 He directed Dan, Dan was sitting in the meeting, make it happen.
00:32:09 I can tell you, I've spoken with Dan almost every single day since then, uh, in order to
00:32:16 make sure that we just have the capital so these guys can survive. 0.92
00:32:19 Well, that's great news because it does seem from what I'm hearing, like it's one damn thing 0.65
00:32:24 after another that the American energy industry has to face.
00:32:28 And this leads to my last question.
00:32:30 We're running out of time here, but I suspect we're running out of time to solve this problem.
00:32:35 Will, do you have any sense of the timeline here before we reach a point at which we can't
00:32:39 turn this around anymore?
00:32:41 Well, if you think about the amount of capital that it took to, to basically get the shell
00:32:46 revolution to where it is today, it's about a trillion and a half dollars.
00:32:49 Okay.
00:32:51 And that capital, a lot of it was not spent very efficiently and public investors lost
00:32:58 a lot of money over the last decade on their investments in the energy space.
00:33:01 The problem is today is that magnitude of capital will never come back to our sector again.
00:33:07 And so if we lose the momentum, the problem with shell wells is they come on at prolific rates,
00:33:14 but they decline very rapidly.
00:33:16 And so what's going to happen over the next 12 to 18 months is U.S. production will decline
00:33:22 probably two to two and a half million barrels a day.
00:33:26 Okay.
00:33:26 That's off a base of 13 million barrels.
00:33:28 That's very significant.
00:33:30 And we'll never be able to recover that.
00:33:31 And if you shut in those wells, we don't know if you could open up again.
00:33:34 Well, you'll open them up, but there's a big chance you've damaged the reservoirs.
00:33:38 Okay.
00:33:39 So they'll come back on less productive.
00:33:41 But the bigger problem is that shale is very expensive to develop.
00:33:46 It's like a treadmill.
00:33:49 And the more you produce, the faster the treadmill goes.
00:33:52 And you've got to keep reinvesting and reinvesting and reinvesting.
00:33:55 And as soon as you break that cycle of reinvestment, you can never get back up unless you put
00:34:00 a lot of outside capital back into the system again.
00:34:03 So for every dollar that came in the door, the energy industry was spending about $1.50.
00:34:08 Okay.
00:34:09 That's how we grew production from 5 million barrels a day in 2010 to 13 million barrels
00:34:15 a day this month.
00:34:18 And, but, but now that that cycle has been broken.
00:34:20 5 million to 13 million in 10 years.
00:34:23 10 years.
00:34:23 But now that cycle has been broken.
00:34:25 So you ask the question, how much time do we have?
00:34:27 Not much.
00:34:27 And that's, that really is the critical, critical question.
00:34:30 In terms of this crisis that's hitting the energy sector and the American energy producers,
00:34:35 I got to tell you, for me, this is very personal and real.
00:34:41 As you know, I grew up in Houston.
00:34:42 Houston's my hometown.
00:34:44 When I was a kid, my parents owned a small business and it was in the oil services world.
00:34:50 It was a seismic data processing company.
00:34:52 So my parents are both mathematicians, computer programmers.
00:34:55 And in 1986, oil collapsed.
00:34:59 It dropped to $7 a barrel.
00:35:01 Texas went into a full on depression.
00:35:04 I was in high school at the time.
00:35:05 And, and I still remember my dad.
00:35:07 It was one Monday.
00:35:08 Now this was, his was a small, small business.
00:35:10 He had 25 employees.
00:35:12 I still remember the Monday where he had to lay off 19 of the 25 employees.
00:35:17 He came home, I, it, it, he, I've never seen my father look as unhappy.
00:35:23 He looked like he'd been beaten with a stick and he had employees arguing with him going,
00:35:27 Raphael, I'm not going to leave.
00:35:28 No, I'm going to stay.
00:35:29 This, this, this company is my home.
00:35:32 And he said, look, I don't have the money to pay you.
00:35:35 You have a family.
00:35:36 And so my parents went bankrupt.
00:35:40 We lost the company.
00:35:42 We lost our home, the home I grew up in.
00:35:44 And it's, uh, look, I, I've lived through that firsthand.
00:35:47 Well, you know, it, it really shows you that in the price of oil, there is a whole lot
00:35:52 more going on.
00:35:54 There are a lot of jobs.
00:35:55 There are a lot of families.
00:35:56 There's an entire sector of the American economy that's being destroyed.
00:35:59 It has implications for national security.
00:36:01 There's so much more to talk about.
00:36:03 Unfortunately, we are out of time, but thank you, Will.
00:36:05 Thank you so much for giving your insight.
00:36:07 And Senator, I had never heard that story.
00:36:09 I mean, it really brings it home on a personal level and we'll see.
00:36:13 Thank you, by the way, for your leadership and going to the president, trying to turn
00:36:16 this around.
00:36:17 We will just have to wait and see in the coming days.
00:36:19 Hopefully we turn it around before it's too late.
00:36:21 In the meantime, I'm Michael Knowles.
00:36:23 This is Verdict with Ted Cruz.
00:36:43 This is an iHeart Podcast.
00:36:56 Guaranteed Human.