Verdict with Ted Cruz - January 28, 2020


The Bolton Bombshell

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Democrats Throw Biden Under The Bus The Deal of the Century

Episode Stats


Length

28 minutes

Words per minute

181.77

Word count

5,159

Sentence count

419

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Ted Cruz reacts to a leak from John Bolton's new memoir, which alleges there was a quid pro quo between President Trump and his then-assistant, Michael Bolton, and the New York Times, and why it matters to the impeachment trial.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 This is an iHeart Podcast.
00:00:02 Guaranteed human.
00:00:04 What a day.
00:00:06 John Bolton throws impeachment into chaos.
00:00:09 President Trump's legal team comes out swinging on their first full day of arguments.
00:00:13 And the senator of this very podcast drives at least one journalist completely up a wall.
00:00:20 This is Verdict with Ted Cruz.
00:00:21 Welcome back to Verdict with Ted Cruz.
00:00:30 I'm Michael Knowles.
00:00:32 Thank you so much to all of the listeners who have kept this show at the top of the charts.
00:00:37 Again now into our second week.
00:00:39 What a big day.
00:00:40 It started as a crazy day before the impeachment trial even began because of a leak from the new memoir of John Bolton,
00:00:49 the former national security advisor, leaked to the New York Times and it alleges that President Trump tied Ukraine aid to an investigation of the Bidens.
00:01:00 Quid pro quo.
00:01:01 He's guilty as charged.
00:01:02 Isn't that right?
00:01:03 Well, today was a big and consequential day.
00:01:06 And you're right.
00:01:06 It started off crazy.
00:01:07 We all had off yesterday.
00:01:09 So I flew home, was home with my family, then came back to D.C. at the crack of dawn, walked into the Capitol.
00:01:15 The press was going nuts.
00:01:16 They were in a total tizzy.
00:01:18 The New York Times had broken this story that Bolton says there was a quid pro quo.
00:01:23 And I got to say, when I sat down at lunch today before we started the trial, there were a lot of Republican senators who were feeling a little rattled by it.
00:01:31 I mean, it was designed to shake people up and it had a little bit of that effect.
00:01:36 I'm actually somewhat surprised that this shook up Republican senators because the story itself made all of these headlines a big splash.
00:01:44 And yet it seems to me, just reading about it, and especially given our previous conversations on how the quid pro quo is not really a big deal, that it's a lot of sizzle and no steak.
00:01:54 Well, that's exactly right.
00:01:55 And one of the most important things for people to understand, it does not matter if there was a quid pro quo or not.
00:02:04 It does not matter.
00:02:05 It doesn't make a difference for the issues before the Senate.
00:02:09 It's something we talked about last week in our first couple of podcasts.
00:02:12 Look, quid pro quo sounds scary.
00:02:14 It's a Latin phrase.
00:02:16 I don't know what it means, but it sounds really bad.
00:02:18 All quid pro quo means is you exchange one thing for another, and this is not an exaggeration.
00:02:23 Every president from George Washington to today has done quid pro quos by the hundreds, and foreign policy does it every single day.
00:02:33 So whether or not it's a quid pro quo doesn't matter.
00:02:37 The question is, did the president commit high crimes and misdemeanors?
00:02:40 And a quid pro quo is not, whether it is or not, is not the constitutional standard.
00:02:45 So then why is this such a big headline?
00:02:47 Because that was my reaction, too.
00:02:48 I said, hold on.
00:02:49 I got to talk to the senator about this last week.
00:02:51 I can see through the headline.
00:02:53 Why is everybody making such a big deal about the John Bolton leak?
00:02:57 Well, look, part of it was that the defense team on Saturday had some fun pointing out that the evidence was contradictory, whether it was a quid pro quo or not.
00:03:06 So they leaned in a little bit, saying there wasn't clear evidence there was a quid pro quo.
00:03:11 And so that let the New York Times say, goodness, now we have someone saying there was.
00:03:17 It doesn't matter because, look, quid pro quos, Obama's Iran deal is a quid pro quo.
00:03:27 Right.
00:03:29 Russia sanctions.
00:03:30 I just passed last month sanctions on the Nord Stream 2 Russian gas pipeline.
00:03:35 If a company builds the pipeline, they get sanctions.
00:03:37 That's a quid pro quo.
00:03:38 You build the pipeline, you get sanctions.
00:03:40 You're admitting to a quid pro quo right now?
00:03:41 I and Venezuela sanctions.
00:03:44 We're telling Venezuela today that if Nicolas Maduro steps down from Venezuela, we'll lift sanctions.
00:03:49 And we do, by the way, carrots and sticks all the time where we'll give you aid, we'll impose sanctions.
00:03:55 That's how we conduct foreign policy.
00:03:58 So the Bolton leak, the quid pro quo news, that doesn't matter to the argument for impeachment itself.
00:04:03 And yet, surely it matters to the impeachment trial because now we're hearing more reports that we could drag this thing out weeks and weeks and finally hear from the witnesses, which the Democrats have been asking for now for weeks.
00:04:17 So I think the chances of the Senate hearing witnesses and of the trial being dragged on, those chances have increased.
00:04:24 We will vote probably on Friday whether or not additional witnesses will be brought in.
00:04:30 All 47 Democrats will vote yes.
00:04:32 If four Republicans join them, if 51 Republican, if 51 senators vote yes, then we're going to have additional witnesses.
00:04:39 Do you think that those four Republican senators will go over and now vote for the witnesses?
00:04:44 You know, I'm not certain about that.
00:04:46 I think there are a couple who have been pretty clear they will.
00:04:48 I don't know if we get to four.
00:04:50 OK.
00:04:50 And, you know, one of the striking things, I don't know that I have seen two Senate meals more different than lunch today and dinner today.
00:05:01 How so? What's the difference?
00:05:02 All right. So lunch today, everyone had just gotten back.
00:05:05 They were there.
00:05:05 The press was all in a frenzy about John Bolton.
00:05:08 We're talking about, oh, got to have witnesses, quid pro quo.
00:05:11 Not sure what quid pro quo is.
00:05:12 And then we had this afternoon where the Trump defense team finally got to put on their arguments and their evidence.
00:05:21 And listen, as you know, I have been begging them, put on systematically, clearly the evidence of Burisma and Hunter Biden and Joe Biden, all of the evidence of corruption.
00:05:33 That's what matters. The central question in this trial is whether a president can investigate corruption.
00:05:40 And the answer to that is obviously yes, if there are real and credible allegations of corruption.
00:05:45 And with Hunter and Joe Biden and Burisma, there was enormous evidence of corruption.
00:05:50 We finally heard that today.
00:05:51 And by dinnertime, the Republican senators were happy, relaxed, serene.
00:05:57 It was totally different because we'd just gone through several hours of the actual defense in the case, which finally got to be able to put on.
00:06:07 OK, well, I want to get into those arguments then, because this was a pivotal day.
00:06:10 We got a little preview of the Trump team's arguments on Saturday.
00:06:14 But today was the first full day.
00:06:16 Last week, the Democrats make their arguments.
00:06:18 And then this week, the Trump team gets to do it.
00:06:20 It opened up with Ken Starr, who was the star of the Clinton impeachment trial back in the 90s.
00:06:26 Then it went on to some of President Trump's other lawyers.
00:06:30 Toward the end, you get Alan Dershowitz, very famous lawyer, a professor of yours, I believe.
00:06:35 You know him well.
00:06:36 Taught me criminal law 101, my first week in law school.
00:06:39 And I've known him 25, 30 years.
00:06:42 So I hate to put you on the spot because you know one of the lawyers, you know, multiple lawyers who are arguing today.
00:06:47 How did they do?
00:06:49 They did very well.
00:06:49 This was a very good day for President Trump.
00:06:52 This was a very bad day for the Democrats.
00:06:54 And I got to say, watching the Democrats at council table, when Pam Bondi got up.
00:07:02 So Pam Bondi is one of President Trump's lawyers.
00:07:04 Right.
00:07:04 And Eric Hirschman, who are two of the lawyers for President Trump.
00:07:08 They both got up and they laid out the evidence of Burisma, the Ukrainian natural gas company that was built in corruption, that was paying Hunter Biden a million bucks a year.
00:07:19 And they finally showed the tape of Joe Biden bragging about how you want to talk about quid pro quo.
00:07:27 So on Donald Trump, the evidence is conflicting on whether there's a quid pro quo.
00:07:32 There's some evidence that some testimony said there was some testimony said there wasn't doesn't matter.
00:07:36 Do you know the one undisputed quid pro quo in this in this entire proceeding?
00:07:41 Joe Biden.
00:07:42 We saw on video.
00:07:43 Joe Biden on video said he told the president of Ukraine he would block a billion dollars in aid unless he fired the Ukrainian prosecutor who was investigating Burisma, which was paying his son, Hunter Biden, a million bucks a year. 0.99
00:07:58 And as you know, Biden ends it with going, well, son of a bitch, they fired him. 0.99
00:08:03 That's a quid pro quo. 0.99
00:08:04 And Biden not only admits to it, he brags about it.
00:08:07 He's proud.
00:08:08 And I got to say, playing that, I think the Trump team did a good job laying it out.
00:08:12 I think they walked through the evidence.
00:08:14 But but I spent a good chunk of it just watching the House managers faces.
00:08:19 I got to say, Adam Schiff was ashen.
00:08:22 I mean, really?
00:08:22 Their faces were horrified.
00:08:24 Because we couldn't see that.
00:08:25 I certainly didn't see that on the C-SPAN camera.
00:08:27 So you would see him kind of try to smile and like puff up his chest and then it sort of slumped down.
00:08:33 But the interesting thing is they knew this was coming.
00:08:38 It's why several days ago I said the House managers threw Joe Biden under the bus.
00:08:42 Because when they spent several hours of their presentation making the case that there is zero evidence to investigate Burisma or the Bidens for corruption, which is a laughable proposition.
00:08:53 They knew to a metaphysical certainty that today would happen. 0.99
00:08:58 In other words, they knew they knew about the son of a bitch video. 0.99
00:09:01 I mean, it's not like they're living in a cave. 0.99
00:09:03 Right.
00:09:03 And they set it up.
00:09:04 They knew about the video we played last week on the podcast where ABC asked Hunter Biden, would you have gotten this job?
00:09:10 You know, been paid a million bucks a year if your name wasn't Biden?
00:09:15 He's like, no.
00:09:16 I mean, they knew that was coming, but it was still painful.
00:09:19 But did you know that the Trump team would be so aggressive?
00:09:22 Because I, going into it, I had this fear, and we talked about it on the show, that the Trump team would play it cautious, play it safe,
00:09:29 simply answer the Democrat accusations from last week.
00:09:32 And instead, they got pretty aggressive.
00:09:35 Well, I think they heard from a lot of voices that they needed to affirmatively present the president's defense, that the president is innocent.
00:09:43 And there's a reason he's innocent.
00:09:45 It is perfectly OK.
00:09:47 And in fact, the president's got a responsibility.
00:09:50 If there's credible evidence of corruption, to investigate that evidence.
00:09:54 Yeah.
00:09:54 And, you know, it was striking.
00:09:57 You remember the first couple of days, Jerry Nadler, one of the house managers, he said, out of hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian companies,
00:10:05 why would Trump be interested in this one?
00:10:08 And the screaming answer is, well, as far as I know, it's the only Ukrainian company that was paying the son of the vice president a million bucks a year.
00:10:18 And the point is, it's not about some abstract interest in Ukrainian corruption.
00:10:24 It's not like the president's worried about someone knocking off 7-Elevens in Ukraine.
00:10:28 Right.
00:10:29 This is about American corruption.
00:10:30 This is about a prospect of a corrupt foreign company effectively bribing the vice president of the United States.
00:10:38 Now, that may not be the case.
00:10:39 I'm not saying that happened.
00:10:40 But there's more than enough evidence to investigate it and find out whether it did.
00:10:45 So you think that the Trump team did a good argument, Ken Starr, Alan Dershowitz, everybody in the middle.
00:10:51 I actually think that the biggest fireworks of the day were not presented by the Trump legal team.
00:10:56 I think they were presented by you when you were talking to the press.
00:11:00 Because during one of these breaks, you had a press gaggle.
00:11:03 You were answering their questions and speaking to them.
00:11:05 You, more than anybody that I've seen, have been very aggressive on this, saying that this impeachment is about burisma.
00:11:12 It's about corruption in Joe Biden, potential corruption by Joe Biden in the Obama administration.
00:11:18 Go after that.
00:11:18 I think you got under the press's skin so much that at one point, one of these reporters suggested throwing your nine-year-old daughter in jail.
00:11:30 Do we have the clip?
00:11:30 Basically, what they said was Hunter Biden got a job.
00:11:35 That was vice president.
00:11:37 If that's a crime, I mean, shouldn't half of your children be in prison?
00:11:41 My children are nine and 11.
00:11:42 I'm sorry that you want to throw a nine-year-old in prison.
00:11:45 But at this point, my third grader plays basketball and softball at her school.
00:11:51 So stop playing the nasty, no, no, stop playing the nasty Washington game.
00:11:56 I'm sorry, that's not nasty Washington game.
00:11:58 Attacking a nine-year-old?
00:12:00 Senator, I have no idea.
00:12:01 All right.
00:12:03 You know, I love that you kept your cool there and you kind of laughed it off.
00:12:08 But that is pretty deranged for a reporter to say they want to throw your kid in jail.
00:12:13 Well, you know, it shows the desperation of the press corps.
00:12:16 So Trump has had a lot of consequences for America, many of which have been fantastically
00:12:23 good in terms of policy, in terms of substance.
00:12:26 One of which that has been also really, really good is exposing the rampant bias of the media.
00:12:32 Exactly.
00:12:32 And Donald Trump has broken the media.
00:12:35 Their role right now is they're desperate to be the defenders of the Democrats.
00:12:39 And so I had just finished standing up and saying today was devastating for the House
00:12:44 managers and walking through a little bit of the evidence of corruption that was laid
00:12:49 out.
00:12:49 The media doesn't want to cover any of this.
00:12:52 So what that guy was doing, I mean, he was trying to say, well, everybody does it.
00:12:55 Come on, your kids do it.
00:12:57 And they're desperately, OK, so I got news for the media.
00:13:00 No, everybody doesn't do this.
00:13:02 I promise you.
00:13:03 If there's anybody else in Washington that has a kid making a million bucks a year from
00:13:09 a corrupt company that is getting favors from the vice president of the United States, that
00:13:15 ain't something everybody does.
00:13:16 Like, look, I mean, it's they're trying to cover it up as, oh, it's Uncle Joe.
00:13:23 It's no big deal.
00:13:25 This is bad stuff. 0.96
00:13:27 This stinks.
00:13:29 It's, you know, one of the things the Trump's defense team did today is they played from
00:13:37 the ABC clip with Hunter Biden, a component.
00:13:39 We still don't know, by the way, how much money Hunter Biden made.
00:13:42 Well, we know he was driving around Hollywood in a very expensive Porsche.
00:13:45 So I think he did pretty well.
00:13:46 Well, and ABC asked him, so how much did this corrupt Ukrainian natural gas company pay 0.99
00:13:51 you while your dad was vice president and why while he was leading Ukraine policy for
00:13:56 the Obama administration?
00:13:57 And he said, well, I'm not going to tell you.
00:13:58 I don't have to be open kimono.
00:14:01 Well, do you know that nobody knows how much he was paid?
00:14:04 We know it was at least $83,000 a month, but he's never answered that.
00:14:08 And the House managers have no desire to know the answer to that.
00:14:12 Well, what's so shocking to me about many of these interviews and that clip in particular
00:14:16 is the media have been going after not just you, but a lot of Republican senators.
00:14:20 And they've been assailing you all for not being objective and completely without an interest
00:14:27 in this impeachment trial because, you know, you're Republicans.
00:14:31 Of course, an impeachment trial is different than other trials, right?
00:14:34 You're going to have interests on both sides.
00:14:36 The one group that is supposed to remain disinterested, objective is the media.
00:14:41 And then the moment you get over the target of what this impeachment is all about, they
00:14:47 clearly lose their minds.
00:14:49 Well, you know, Judge Ken Starr started the argument today and he did a very good job of
00:14:53 pointing out.
00:14:54 So a lot of folks in the media like to say, oh, the senators are jurors.
00:14:58 That's not, in fact, right.
00:15:00 And in the Clinton impeachment trial, a Democratic senator objected to senators being called jurors
00:15:07 and Chief Justice Rehnquist sustained the objection.
00:15:10 Starr actually put it very well.
00:15:11 The Senate is a court, which means the Senate where the judges, where the jurors were deciding 0.58
00:15:17 questions of law and fact, and we're not supposed to be disconnected from the process.
00:15:22 The framers knew what they were doing when they handed it to the upper chamber of Congress.
00:15:26 But, you know, what we do need to do is keep the focus on the actual legal question, which
00:15:33 is whether high crimes or misdemeanors were committed.
00:15:37 And it's why, look, the fundamental answer, the reason the House manager's case fails and
00:15:45 the president will be acquitted is because, presidents, it's not an impeachable offense
00:15:50 to investigate credible evidence of corruption.
00:15:53 By the way, it would have been very different if Trump had said to Ukraine, hey, would you
00:15:59 concoct some fake and bogus material on Joe Biden and fraudulently accuse him of something?
00:16:06 Look, we'd have a totally different case there.
00:16:08 Right.
00:16:08 But that's not what he said.
00:16:10 All of the evidence, 100 percent of it said, investigate what happened.
00:16:13 This is bad.
00:16:15 Biden bragged about getting the prosecutor fired.
00:16:18 It is not an impeachable offense to investigate credible evidence of corruption.
00:16:24 That's the issue that matters.
00:16:26 And the press is going to try to change the subject.
00:16:29 You know what?
00:16:29 This Bolton bombshell today, it won't be the last bombshell.
00:16:34 We'll see another one coming up later this week.
00:16:36 And actually, a bunch of us on the Judiciary Committee who went through Kavanaugh, we were
00:16:40 saying we're kind of steel to this because we saw, I remember, day after day, there was
00:16:45 another revelation.
00:16:46 By the end of it, they had him in high school, like, drugging people and, like, participating
00:16:51 in, you know, all sorts.
00:16:52 I mean, it got, remember Michael Avenatti?
00:16:55 Briefly, the media wanted him to be the Democratic nominee for president.
00:16:58 He was this lawyer who would go on CNN.
00:17:00 This was during, now, Justice Kavanaugh's confirmation hearings to the Supreme Court.
00:17:06 It was the timing of every big scandal bombshell.
00:17:09 It seemed so perfectly coordinated.
00:17:11 And that's what it, I mean, that is the big news of the day, is this Bolton bombshell.
00:17:16 I'm sure you're right, it won't be the last.
00:17:18 But for those of us who don't know the inner machinations, how this was leaked, who leaked
00:17:23 it, who's going to leak the next one, I guess the question all of us have is, what happens
00:17:28 next?
00:17:29 Let's say that because of this bombshell from John Bolton, we now get witnesses, and this
00:17:35 trial drags on well past Saturday, maybe for weeks and weeks.
00:17:40 What are we going to look forward to next?
00:17:41 So we don't know for sure.
00:17:43 Tomorrow will be the last day of arguments, opening arguments, for the Trump legal defense
00:17:47 team.
00:17:48 Okay.
00:17:48 So they'll start tomorrow at 1 o'clock, go as long as they go.
00:17:52 Then the next two days, we're going to have questions from senators.
00:17:55 Eight hours a day for two days.
00:17:57 We ask questions, but we don't get to ask them ourselves.
00:18:00 We write them down, and the chief justice asks them for us.
00:18:04 So I will say to the folks listening to this podcast, if you have questions that you want
00:18:09 me to ask, either the house managers or Trump's legal defense team, suggest them.
00:18:16 You can tweet them.
00:18:17 I'm at Ted Cruz, and just put hashtag verdict.
00:18:20 And we are looking at what's online on Twitter and looking for questions that will help focus
00:18:27 on the issues that matter.
00:18:29 After the questions are over, then at the end of the week, we're going to vote up or down
00:18:34 are additional witnesses necessary?
00:18:36 If we get 51 senators who say yes, then frankly, it's Katie barred the door. 1.00
00:18:42 Right.
00:18:42 If it ends up that there are four Republicans who join the Democrats and say, okay, we need
00:18:47 to hear from John Bolton, I think that's possible.
00:18:49 I will give you some good news.
00:18:50 If that happens, I'm extremely confident we will also hear from Hunter Biden.
00:18:55 So you don't think there's a world in which they vote for witnesses, but the only witness
00:18:59 who is called is John Bolton?
00:19:01 Zero chance.
00:19:02 Okay.
00:19:02 Zero.
00:19:03 And the Democrats are terrified about that.
00:19:05 You know, Chuck Schumer's like, no, no, no, we can't call Hunter Biden.
00:19:08 You're seeing Democratic senators going, no, no, no, don't call Hunter Biden.
00:19:11 Look, today's testimony revealed if there's one witness that was called, it should be Hunter
00:19:16 Biden because he's right at the center.
00:19:17 And remember, the issue is not Hunter Biden.
00:19:21 I don't know the guy.
00:19:22 It looks like he's led a pretty troubled life.
00:19:25 The question is not even about whether he's involved in corruption.
00:19:29 It's about whether his father, the vice president who was making the Obama administration's policy
00:19:36 and leading it, whether he was involved in corruption.
00:19:39 And that's a question that goes right to the heart of Trump's asking it to be investigated.
00:19:44 And I want to underscore a point we said last week because people may not have focused on
00:19:51 its importance.
00:19:52 And it's about to become very, very important if we have witnesses, which is if Hunter Biden
00:19:57 is called as a witness, if we subpoena Hunter Biden, he will almost certainly plead the fifth.
00:20:02 He'll almost certainly come in and say, I refuse to answer questions on the grounds that it might
00:20:06 incriminate me.
00:20:07 And he has the constitutional right.
00:20:07 And he has a right under the Bill of Rights.
00:20:09 He doesn't want to testify and admit to committing a crime.
00:20:12 Here's a piece almost nobody knows.
00:20:16 If he does that, there is a statute that explicitly gives the Senate the power to give him testimonial
00:20:23 immunity, which means he would be immune from being prosecuted for what he says in his testimony.
00:20:30 Why does that matter?
00:20:31 You may think, gosh, immunity sounds like a good thing for him.
00:20:34 It's actually not because immunity means we can force him to testify because we want to
00:20:39 get the evidence of what did your dad know?
00:20:42 You know, one of the interesting things that we heard today.
00:20:45 So Hunter Biden had two business partners.
00:20:48 This guy, Devin Archer, was also on the board of Burisma.
00:20:50 Yeah.
00:20:51 And then John Kerry's son-in-law.
00:20:53 What a coincidence.
00:20:54 Or not son-in-law, stepson rather.
00:20:56 OK.
00:20:56 And his stepson, when his two business partners joined the board, he sent an email to the State
00:21:05 Department, to his stepfather's chief of staff, saying, Devin and Hunter have joined the board
00:21:11 of Burisma.
00:21:12 I don't know why they did this, but I got nothing to do with it.
00:21:15 And he broke off doing business with them because of their poor judgment in getting paid millions
00:21:22 from this corrupt company.
00:21:23 You know, we actually got a mailbag question specifically about the ability of the Senate
00:21:29 to force Hunter Biden to testify.
00:21:32 And the question comes from Susan.
00:21:37 If the Senate forces Hunter Biden to testify by granting him immunity, would he also receive
00:21:43 immunity if he perjured himself during the testimony?
00:21:46 So if he lies, he wouldn't.
00:21:47 So immunity does not immunize you from perjury.
00:21:51 And it doesn't immunize you from the underlying crimes, but it does prevent any prosecutor from
00:21:58 using your testimony as evidence against you.
00:22:01 Well, then there's a similar follow-up question.
00:22:02 And by the way, the way the statute works is the Senate, 51 senators vote to grant immunity.
00:22:07 We then have to go to a federal district court and file that, but the district court has to
00:22:11 grant it.
00:22:12 Right.
00:22:12 It's mandatory under the statute.
00:22:14 That, I've seen that nowhere in the press.
00:22:17 Obviously, I think Hunter Biden's probably sweating about that, and the Democrats in the
00:22:20 House are probably sweating more.
00:22:21 And Joe Biden is sweating more.
00:22:22 And by the way, I'll tell you, some of the happiest faces in that Senate were Bernie, Elizabeth
00:22:29 Warren, and Klobuchar.
00:22:31 All running for president.
00:22:32 Now, I mean, they, this was a bad, bad day for the House Democrats case, but also for
00:22:40 Joe Biden.
00:22:41 This was, this was not pretty.
00:22:42 So let's say President Trump gets off the hook.
00:22:45 He is not removed from office.
00:22:46 Matthew asks, does the Fifth Amendment regarding double jeopardy attach?
00:22:51 Should the Senate exonerate the president?
00:22:54 Can the president be tried again for the same articles?
00:22:58 I don't think we've ever seen that situation in history.
00:23:01 So impeachment and prosecution for a criminal offense are two different matters.
00:23:06 So yes, you can be tried separate.
00:23:09 Now, you've got to prove a crime.
00:23:10 You've got to prove beyond a reasonable doubt.
00:23:12 And amazingly enough, the House managers haven't alleged a crime.
00:23:15 It's one of the things, actually, Alan Dershowitz, Professor Dershowitz at the end, did a really
00:23:19 good job of walking through the constitutional history, that you can't, high crimes or misdemeanors
00:23:25 requires that you prove that the president has committed a crime on the order of treason
00:23:33 or bribery, because that's what the Constitution said.
00:23:35 And it was very interesting.
00:23:37 Professor Dershowitz walked through a couple of other provisions of the Constitution, which
00:23:41 almost no one knows who's looked at this.
00:23:43 So you know the impeachment clause.
00:23:45 But there are two other places where impeachment is referenced in the Constitution beyond
00:23:49 beyond the power of impeachment and the trial.
00:23:52 Because the impeachment clause is just saying that the Congress has the power to impeach
00:23:55 the president, and the Senate will conduct the trial.
00:23:57 And actually, the Constitution uses the word soul twice.
00:24:01 It says the House has the sole power of impeachment, and the Senate has the sole power to try impeachment.
00:24:06 So the only times the word S-O-L-E is used in the Constitution concerns impeachment.
00:24:11 But there are two other references.
00:24:12 Number one, in Article 2, which concerns the presidency, it gives the president the power
00:24:20 to grant pardons and reprieves for offenses against the United States, except in cases
00:24:25 of impeachment.
00:24:27 So the president can't pardon impeachment.
00:24:30 But it also says offenses against the United States, which are crimes.
00:24:34 In Article 3 of the Constitution, which concerns the judiciary, the Constitution says trial of
00:24:41 all crimes, except in cases of impeachment, shall be by jury.
00:24:47 Now, what does that imply?
00:24:49 Impeachment are crimes.
00:24:51 And so the House Democrats have admitted that they aren't alleging a crime.
00:24:55 So this is a unique historical situation in as much as we have the impeachment going on.
00:25:01 But when the Congress impeached the president, they did not accuse him of a crime.
00:25:06 So are you saying we're just in uncharted territory?
00:25:09 We are.
00:25:09 It has never happened in history that a president has been impeached without the articles alleging
00:25:15 he's committed a crime.
00:25:16 And actually, something Ken Starr said that was really powerful.
00:25:19 We have never before in history seen a president impeached on a pure partisan vote.
00:25:23 Only Democrats voted for it.
00:25:26 And Ken Starr made a great point.
00:25:27 You know, the Constitution requires for conviction to remove a president two-thirds of the Senate.
00:25:32 Impeachment was supposed to be a consensus, a national consensus that this crosses a high
00:25:39 threshold.
00:25:40 There ain't that consensus.
00:25:42 And so fighting this is just a partisan battle the way the Democrats are doing is wrong.
00:25:47 You know, the conclusion I draw from all of this is one of anxiety because we are in uncharted
00:25:53 territory here.
00:25:54 I think it's going to make the question time on Thursday so important.
00:25:58 So please, to all of our listeners, get your questions in.
00:26:01 Tweet them at Ted Cruz.
00:26:03 Use the hashtag verdict.
00:26:05 And we will try to get those questions asked during the impeachment trial.
00:26:08 Then you can come back here afterwards.
00:26:10 You know, this is an early night.
00:26:11 It's not even midnight yet.
00:26:12 You've made it over from the Capitol.
00:26:14 And we will go through all of it then.
00:26:17 Thank you.
00:26:17 There are two things I want to follow up on quickly because I have been given an assignment.
00:26:20 Okay.
00:26:21 So last week, you'll recall, I mentioned that I brought up with Caroline, my 11-year-old
00:26:25 daughter.
00:26:25 Yeah.
00:26:25 When we had risen to the number three podcast in the country, I called her and told her
00:26:29 and she said, Dad, I really don't care.
00:26:32 So I got home Saturday night, Sunday, yesterday, I was home.
00:26:36 And I told Caroline, you know, we rose from number three all the way to number one.
00:26:39 And look, I thought that was kind of cool.
00:26:40 Are you impressed now?
00:26:41 You know, trying to like, you know, get my daughter to think that's cool.
00:26:44 And she said, I know.
00:26:47 And you passed Joe Rogan.
00:26:49 And she said, and Joe Rogan interviewed Robert Downey Jr.
00:26:53 And that's the coolest thing in the world.
00:26:54 Caroline is like obsessed with Iron Man. 0.70
00:26:57 And she's like, if he interviewed Robert Downey Jr., I don't know how you passed him, Dad.
00:27:00 I don't know how that happened.
00:27:02 But that's really cool.
00:27:03 That's six degrees of Kevin Bacon.
00:27:05 And I got to say, for any dad of an 11-year-old, it is really hard to like impress an 11-year-old
00:27:12 with anything.
00:27:12 So, I thought it was very cool that passing Joe Rogan did it with Caroline Cruz.
00:27:17 And that made me pretty happy.
00:27:19 And there's a coincidence.
00:27:20 We passed Joe Rogan's show with this show, Verdict with Ted Cruz, just about a day or
00:27:25 two after Joe endorsed Bernie Sanders.
00:27:27 Is that a coincidence?
00:27:28 Look, I think it's cause and effect.
00:27:30 But let me say to everyone listening, if you haven't subscribed and signed up for this
00:27:36 podcast going forward, please do, because we're having fun.
00:27:40 We really appreciate it.
00:27:42 And it looks like with everything and uncertainty, I'll probably be stuck in D.C. for quite a
00:27:45 while now.
00:27:46 So be sure to tune back.
00:27:47 I'm Michael Knowles.
00:27:48 This is Verdict with Ted Cruz.
00:27:50 This episode of Verdict with Ted Cruz is being brought to you by Jobs Freedom and Security
00:28:02 Pack, a political action committee dedicated to supporting conservative causes, organizations
00:28:07 and candidates across the country.
00:28:09 In 2022, Jobs Freedom and Security Pack plans to donate to conservative candidates running
00:28:15 for Congress and help the Republican Party across the nation.
00:28:19 This is an iHeart Podcast.
00:28:21 Guaranteed human.