Verdict with Ted Cruz - July 01, 2026


Understanding the Historic Supreme Court Victories & Losses this Week

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
BONUS POD—FREEDOM VS. MANDATES: The Fight Over Faith, Jobs and Vaccines BONUS POD: Democrats Double Down on Trans Athletes Ahead of Midterms

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

159.89

Word count

7,474

Sentence count

357

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

15

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Ted Cruz and Ben Fergus Ferguson join host Jack Armstrong and Getty to discuss some of the most important Supreme Court rulings of the week, including the ruling allowing abortion access to the mail and the decision allowing the president to fire a trade commissioner.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 This is an iHeart Podcast.
00:00:02 Guaranteed human.
00:00:04 Take a spin, hit the tables, or join the action live.
00:00:08 With BetVictor, tons of casino games await.
00:00:10 Plus the excitement of the live casino.
00:00:12 All-in-one convenient app for when you choose to play.
00:00:15 For timeless classics, the newest releases, and instant withdrawals,
00:00:19 download the BetVictor app.
00:00:21 BetVictor, since 1946.
00:00:23 19 plus Ontario only, please play responsibly.
00:00:25 BetVictor operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGaming Ontario.
00:00:29 If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or the gambling of someone close to you, visit ConnexOntario.ca.
00:00:36 On Newt World Podcast, we're celebrating America's 250th birthday.
00:00:40 And I ask my guests how they're spending their 4th of July.
00:00:44 Brett Baer.
00:00:45 I will be working. I'll be in Washington because it's a big, big day.
00:00:50 Jared Isaacman.
00:00:51 I plan to be flying in an F-5 fighter jet painted in Freedom 250 colors along with four other fighter jets flying over the nation's capital.
00:00:59 Listen to Newt's World on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:01:06 Why should you listen to Armstrong and Getty on demand?
00:01:10 We're not boring.
00:01:11 A lot of news is boring.
00:01:12 And tedious.
00:01:12 And depressing.
00:01:13 And makes you angry.
00:01:14 You don't want to live your life like that.
00:01:17 Hey, I'm Jack Armstrong.
00:01:18 He's Joe Getty.
00:01:18 We're Armstrong and Getty.
00:01:19 We try to bring you the truth.
00:01:21 And help you figure out this crazy modern world.
00:01:23 How about something about a comedic tone?
00:01:28 We have a winner.
00:01:29 Yes. Listen to Armstrong and Getty on demand on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:01:37 Welcome. It is Verdict with Senator Ted Cruz, Ben Ferguson with you as well. It's nice to have you with us.
00:01:42 And Senator, we are going to have a really interesting show today because we have so many extremely important rulings that have come down from the Supreme Court.
00:01:50 We're going to break them into the wins and into the losses category here and let people know exactly what many of these rulings mean going forward.
00:01:58 Well, this was a landmark week in front of the U.S. Supreme Court.
00:02:02 Huge decisions came down this week.
00:02:04 We're going to break them down for you, try to explain them, make them understandable.
00:02:08 We had major, major victories that are enormously consequential.
00:02:12 We also had a couple of big, big losses.
00:02:15 We're going to break all of them down for you today.
00:02:17 Yeah, it's a lot of them, and we're going to talk about that in a moment.
00:02:20 But first, I want to talk to you about Americans United for Life.
00:02:24 The Supreme Court ruled that abortion drugs can keep being sent through the mail.
00:02:29 No doctor visit, no in-person exam, no one checking whether a woman is being pressured,
00:02:36 whether she's too far along, whether she's safe.
00:02:40 These are powerful drugs.
00:02:42 And right now, there is almost nothing standing between these drugs and your mailbox.
00:02:47 And that's why I want you to know about Americans United for Life, AUL.
00:02:52 For more than 50 years, they've been the legal backbone of pro-life movement.
00:02:58 They fight in the courts.
00:02:59 They hold the abortion industry accountable.
00:03:02 And right now, they are leading the efforts to restore basic safety protections for these drugs.
00:03:09 If anyone can fix this, it's AUL.
00:03:12 Now, here is how you can help and why it matters now.
00:03:16 A donor has put up $250,000 to match every gift to Americans United for Life, dollar
00:03:24 for dollar, but only through June 13th, $25 becomes 50, 50 becomes 100, but that window
00:03:34 closes in days. 1.00
00:03:36 There are women right now who need someone in their corner, and AUL is that someone. 1.00
00:03:43 And be a part of it. 0.99
00:03:44 Go right now to aul.org forward slash verdict.
00:03:51 That's aul.org forward slash verdict.
00:03:57 Give before June 13th and your gift will be doubled.
00:04:01 Again, that's aul.org forward slash verdict.
00:04:07 All right, so Senator, let's talk about some of the victories.
00:04:10 And one of them was a very interesting case.
00:04:12 It's about the president having the ability to fire people, and this was one of those that maybe wasn't on a lot of people's radar screen, but it's a really important case.
00:04:24 Well, let's start with two decisions, and this is a big victory, Trump versus Slaughter and Trump versus Cook.
00:04:30 And it dealt with the ability of the president to fire people in his administration.
00:04:37 So almost 100 years ago, the court decided a case called Humphrey's Executor.
00:04:42 Humphrey's executor, actually 91 years ago, the court concluded that the president cannot fire a commissioner of the Federal Trade Commission.
00:04:54 And the Federal Trade Commission was set up as a so-called independent agency.
00:04:59 It was an agency with three commissioners appointed by the president, confirmed by the Senate from the majority party, and two commissioners appointed by the president, confirmed by the Senate from the minority party.
00:05:12 And the so-called independent agencies arose coming out of the Woodrow Wilson era, coming out of the progressive era as a way to limit presidential power.
00:05:25 And Humphrey's executor said the president doesn't have the ability to fire an FTC commissioner without cause.
00:05:34 Well, in my view, Humphrey's executor was wrong the day it was decided 91 years ago.
00:05:40 and it has been wrong every day for nine decades since then why because under the constitution the
00:05:48 constitution the first three articles of the constitution article one vests all legislative
00:05:54 power in the congress of the united states article two vests all executive power in the
00:06:01 president of the united states and article three vests all judicial power in the judiciary
00:06:06 What Humphrey's executor did is severely limit the president's Article II authority over the executive branch.
00:06:16 Anyone in government, you are either in one of those three buckets.
00:06:20 You're either a legislative official.
00:06:23 I'm a legislative official.
00:06:24 I'm elected by the people of Texas to represent them in the Senate.
00:06:27 I'm in the legislature.
00:06:28 I'm in Article I.
00:06:30 You could be a judicial official.
00:06:31 That is appointed by the president, confirmed by the Senate.
00:06:34 you're a judge with life tenure adjudicating cases that's an article three everyone else
00:06:40 is an article two article two is the executive and under the constitution the president has
00:06:46 authority over the executive humphrey's executor said no no you don't there could be someone that
00:06:52 works for the executive and yet somehow congress has taken over the ability of the president to
00:06:58 control that person well when president trump came in in the second term he fired two fdc directors
00:07:07 commissioners rather one of which was rebecca slaughter rebecca slaughter is a democrat
00:07:12 she was one of the five fdc commissioners and he fired her he said you know what i just want
00:07:19 republican commissioners i'm not appointing democrat commissions now he did that knowing
00:07:24 it would prompt a legal challenge and anticipating that that it would be a legal challenge he would
00:07:30 prevail in i will tell you i've said publicly multiple times for for a long time trump was
00:07:36 going to prevail and you know as i talked to reporters they said well what do you think about
00:07:41 this case i said trump's going to win and he's going to win because humphrey's executor was wrong
00:07:46 the president has the authority over the executive branch and i believe the court is going to overrule
00:07:53 humphreys executive well this week that prediction came true by the way we talk on on this podcast a
00:08:00 lot about the predictions we make and the vast majority of the predictions we make come true
00:08:05 and and we hold ourselves accountable when they come true we lay them out when they don't come
00:08:09 true we lay them out in this instance chief justice roberts wrote the majority opinion
00:08:15 He was joined by Justice Alito, Justice Gorsuch, Justice Kavanaugh, Justice Barrett, and Justice Thomas in part.
00:08:25 So it was a 6-3 decision.
00:08:27 And the court overturned Humphrey's executor, said the president can fire an FTC commission.
00:08:34 That's a big victory.
00:08:36 That's a big victory for presidential authority.
00:08:39 That's a big victory for the text of the Constitution.
00:08:41 That's a big victory for the original understanding of the Constitution.
00:08:45 Now, here's kind of a weird wrinkle.
00:08:49 There was another case that was Cook versus Trump.
00:08:54 So Lisa Cook was a Federal Reserve governor.
00:09:01 Yeah. 1.00
00:09:01 And Trump also fired Lisa Cook.
00:09:05 Now, interestingly enough, look, you would think the same principle should apply,
00:09:10 that if Trump can fire an FTC commissioner,
00:09:15 he ought to be able to fire a Federal Reserve governor.
00:09:20 Well, you'd be wrong on that.
00:09:22 The court, by a vote of five to four,
00:09:25 held that Trump could not fire Lisa Cook,
00:09:27 that the Federal Reserve was different.
00:09:29 And it was a different majority.
00:09:31 Chief Justice Roberts wrote both opinions,
00:09:33 which did not surprise me.
00:09:35 Trump versus Cook was joined.
00:09:38 roberts joined by justice sotomayor justice kagan justice kavanaugh and justice ketanji brown jackson
00:09:46 so it was five four now clarence thomas dissented he called the ruling incorrect uh he he pointed
00:09:53 out that that it was inconsistent with the slaughter decision i gotta say this did not
00:09:58 surprise me at all and and and indeed i i had predicted humphrey's executors would be overturned
00:10:05 But at the same time, the court would be reluctant to accord the president carte blanche over the Federal Reserve.
00:10:15 And in my view, look, Chief Justice Roberts had different distinctions about the statute of the Federal Reserve.
00:10:21 I actually think those distinctions did not matter.
00:10:25 This was, I believe, in significant respects, a results-driven outcome.
00:10:32 I think at the end of the day, you did not have five justices.
00:10:35 that were willing to accede the power to the president to fire a Federal Reserve governor
00:10:43 because the role of the Federal Reserve with our currency, with our economy,
00:10:47 was significant enough that they were reluctant to do it.
00:10:50 That doesn't surprise me.
00:10:51 The consequence of these two decisions, is Trump versus Cook pure and true to the Constitution?
00:11:02 Probably not.
00:11:02 But it is a fairly narrow exception to the much broader precedent, which is Trump versus Slaughter, which overrules Humphrey's executor and upholds the president's authority to fire executive branch employees at his discretion.
00:11:23 That's going to obviously have big impact moving forward, right, over the next couple of years for the president as well.
00:11:27 Would you agree?
00:11:29 Yeah, no, no, it's a big deal, and it's going to mean as a practical matter going forward,
00:11:33 I think there's a real possibility, in fact, a likelihood that these so-called independent commissions will not have bipartisan commissions.
00:11:42 I think going forward, you're going to see commissions like the FTC, the FCC, potentially the FEC, the various commissions that are bipartisan.
00:11:54 Anderson, what we've seen with Trump is that he says, I'm not going to appoint Democrats to it.
00:11:59 And he leaves those seats vacant. My guess is if and when we have another Democrat president,
00:12:06 and unfortunately, we will likely have another Democrat president. I'd rather not. I think the 0.67
00:12:11 Democrats' policies are really damaging. But if history is any guide, we will see the Democrats
00:12:16 in charge of the White House at some point. And I think it is quite likely that when the Democrats
00:12:20 are in charge they will appoint to the independent commissions three commissioners from the democrat
00:12:26 party and zero republican commissioners and and look i'll say what 25 years ago when when george
00:12:35 w bush was elected president uh i came in i was a young campaign staffer i'd been down in in austin
00:12:41 texas on the campaign team with within governor bush i met heidi on the bush campaign she and i
00:12:48 came to join the bush administration i spent about six months in the department of justice
00:12:51 and then i went over to the federal trade commission and and the fdc is is what was
00:12:57 the subject of this litigation my boss at the time was the chairman tim muris tim is a brilliant
00:13:03 conservative lawyer economist uh and i was the head of policy at the fdc when i was 30 years old
00:13:10 i was a young kid it was a fascinating job i did that for a little over two years uh very much
00:13:15 enjoyed the job. At the time, we had three Republican commissioners, two Democrat commissioners,
00:13:20 and to be honest, to be a minority commissioner in the Pettit Commission, it's kind of a weird
00:13:24 job because you don't have the votes, but you can nonetheless express your views, you can dissent,
00:13:30 you write opinions, you press back within the executive branch. I think the consequence of
00:13:37 this decision is you're not going to see minority commissioners from the party out of power. You
00:13:42 will see the independent agencies operate much like the rest of the executives so just like
00:13:48 in the department of labor you don't have a republican secretary of labor and then a democrat
00:13:55 secretary of labor who argues against it instead you just have appointees of the president i think
00:14:00 you will see in the independent agencies the same sort of thing they will just be appointees of the
00:14:06 majority party it's going to be very very interesting to see like you said how this moves
00:14:09 forward, but certainly that is a victory for President Donald Trump. All right, I want to
00:14:14 move on to another one of the victories, and this was a big case. It's one that I was actually
00:14:18 involved with more than any other case that's ever been before the Supreme Court. My old roommate
00:14:22 is the West Virginia Attorney General J.B. McCuskey, and they were a part of bringing this
00:14:28 case. They knew that when they made their decision in West Virginia, it was probably going to reach
00:14:33 the Supreme Court. Sure enough, it did. I actually went into the Supreme Court for those oral
00:14:37 arguments that were being made that day with uh getting men uh out of women's sports uh this was
00:14:44 a massive victory it's a fight the president wanted it's a fight center that you've been
00:14:48 heavily involved with protecting uh women's sports and it was a huge victory that is going
00:14:54 to have real repercussions across sports at every level in this country well this is a big big deal
00:15:01 The Supreme Court has now made absolutely clear that we can protect women from men competing against them in sports.
00:15:09 We can protect girls from boys competing against them in sports.
00:15:13 This has been one of the things.
00:15:15 Look, you look at how the world has gone crazy.
00:15:18 Ten years ago, even five years ago, I don't think people really could have imagined this would be a thing.
00:15:23 And we're seeing it be more and more often a thing where boys are competing against girls, men are competing against women.
00:15:31 it is grotesquely unfair and and the good news is 27 states have now passed laws saying this
00:15:38 is not acceptable we are going to protect girls we're going to protect women in our states uh
00:15:45 this case west virginia versus bpj concerned the laws in west virginia and idaho two states that
00:15:54 have passed common sense state laws saying we're going to protect girls and women
00:15:58 plaintiffs brought lawsuits challenging that and saying the constitution and federal law
00:16:04 prohibits states protecting women's sports and protecting girls sports and the supreme court
00:16:11 unequivocally rejected that argument and so the majority opinion justice brett kavanaugh wrote
00:16:16 the majority opinion uh kavanaugh was joined by chief justice roberts justice thomas justice
00:16:22 alito justice gorsuch and justice barrett so it was a six three decision and and the court
00:16:28 concluded that that the laws in west virginia and idaho are constitutional that the equal
00:16:36 protection clause of the constitution so so the equal protection clause of the constitution is
00:16:41 part of the 14th amendment if you look at in the wake of the civil war we fought the civil war
00:16:46 bloody bloody war and then we adopted three amendments to the constitutions the 13th 14th
00:16:54 and 15th Amendment. The 13th Amendment prohibited slavery. The 14th Amendment, I'm going to come
00:17:00 back to in a second, the 15th Amendment protected the right to vote and prohibited discrimination
00:17:08 and the right to vote based on race. What did the 14th Amendment do? The 14th Amendment
00:17:12 protected the rights of citizens from discrimination by government, and there are
00:17:20 three key clauses of the 14th amendment there's the privileges or immunities clause which prohibits
00:17:26 the states from violating the privileges or immunities of citizens of the united states
00:17:31 there is equal protection clause that prohibits the states and also the local governments
00:17:36 from from denying americans the equal protections of the law and there's the due process clause that
00:17:43 prohibits the states and the local governments from denying Americans life, liberty, or property
00:17:51 without due process of law. The Equal Protection Clause is essentially a provision of the 14th
00:17:58 Amendment that says government cannot treat similarly situated people differently, cannot
00:18:04 unfairly discriminate against you. And so it was initially interpreted to protect against racial
00:18:11 discrimination by the way the equal protection clause is the basis on which the supreme court
00:18:16 has struck down racial discrimination in college admissions and it's made clear you can't
00:18:22 discriminate based on race in college admission that was the right decision well in this instance
00:18:28 the plaintiffs were arguing that stopping a biological male from competing in in women's
00:18:34 sports violated the equal protection clause the supreme court 6-3 rejected that argument said 0.96
00:18:41 that is wrong secondly there are federal civil rights laws that that protect civil rights these
00:18:49 are passed by congress uh and signed by the president and in particular there's a decision
00:18:55 called bostock that is an employment discrimination case uh where justice gorsuch had written the
00:19:01 majority opinion and had bizarrely i think bostock was wrongly decided but but the court
00:19:08 in bostock had concluded that the prohibition on discrimination based on sex also covered people
00:19:17 who are transgendered which which i don't think is remotely within the statutory language i think
00:19:23 bostock was wrongly decided the court here concluded nothing in bostock requires biological
00:19:32 males to compete in girls sports. That is a big, big victory. Now, I want to be clear what this
00:19:40 means. There are 27 states that have protected girls sports and women's sports. Those laws are
00:19:47 now constitutionally sound, and they are extremely unlikely to be struck down in litigation.
00:19:53 Now, doing the math, if 27 states have protected that, that means 23 states have not. The Californias,
00:20:01 the new yorks the illinois the blue states in this case now look the court was not deciding
00:20:07 uh whether there is a problem with california and new york allowing boys to compete in girls
00:20:13 sports i think there is a massive fairness problem there's a massive public policy problem
00:20:19 i would like to see congress i voted repeatedly in favor of congress passing legislation
00:20:24 prohibiting boys from competing in girls sports prohibiting men from competing in women's sports 1.00
00:20:29 I think that's the right policy. The outcome of this this case is those 23 states can continue to let boys compete in girls sports. 0.95
00:20:39 But thankfully, that means the voters can say enough is enough and get their states to pass laws protecting girls sports, protecting women's sports.
00:20:48 Yeah, it is going to be huge. And like you said, there's still going to be battles going forward, but they're going to be fought in a very different way than what we've witnessed so far.
00:20:58 And this is, again, this is about protecting women's sports, and now you're going to see a lot of people that have been pushed around who are going to say, hey, I don't have to be anymore.
00:21:07 I don't have to play in these two worlds.
00:21:09 I can do what now the Supreme Court says I can do, and that is huge.
00:21:14 I want to also move on to another—
00:21:15 And by the way, hold on a second.
00:21:16 I want to say something also.
00:21:18 It's worth noting that in this case, it was 6-3.
00:21:22 That means three justices dissented.
00:21:25 Sotomayor, Kagan, and Jackson.
00:21:28 dissented um and and in particular uh they argue that the case should have been remanded to the 0.96
00:21:36 lower court to figure out if the transgender athlete who wanted to compete uh whether
00:21:41 that transgender athlete had specific medical treatments that eliminated any athletic advantage
00:21:50 so they wanted to be able to say okay if you're a biological man but you're taking so much estrogen
00:21:55 that all of the advantages of being male in terms of physically competing in sports
00:22:01 have been eliminated, then you have a legal claim and you can strike down the law.
00:22:07 Justice Ketanji Brown-Jackson wrote separately, and mind you,
00:22:11 Ketanji Brown-Jackson, you'll recall, during her confirmation hearing,
00:22:15 famously was asked, what is a woman?
00:22:18 And she couldn't answer the question. 0.90
00:22:20 Do you remember what she said?
00:22:22 Yeah, she didn't know how to answer it.
00:22:25 She said, I'm not a biologist.
00:22:27 Yeah.
00:22:28 Well, it turns out she's still not a biologist because she dissented here.
00:22:32 And she said the court did not need to define sex as biological for the purposes of Title IX. 0.99
00:22:41 Title IX is the law that protects girls' sports.
00:22:44 She would have left the question open for future cases and refused to deny it.
00:22:49 Look, you've got three liberal judges who, and to be clear, 0.82
00:22:55 If the Democrats win, if they take the Senate, they want three to become five, to become more, who would strike down every law in the country protecting girls' sports and protecting women's sports.
00:23:07 So we ought to celebrate, celebrate this victory, a 6-3 victory that's important, but it also ought to scare us.
00:23:13 Not a single one of the liberals, they didn't admit even a moment's hesitation.
00:23:19 That's how extreme things have got.
00:23:21 Yeah, it's a great point. And it's exactly why presidential elections are so important, because whoever's elected, they get to appoint people.
00:23:31 And when they do, they stay for a very long time. And it has major consequences on America.
00:23:33 And by the way, Ben, it's not just presidential elections. The midterms in November, if the Democrats take the Senate, my prediction is they will block every single judicial nomination for the next two years.
00:23:46 it used to be the case
00:23:48 had a president of one party
00:23:50 a senator of the other
00:23:51 that you'd move forward
00:23:52 with judicial nominations
00:23:53 there'd be some moderation
00:23:54 but judicial nominations
00:23:56 would proceed
00:23:57 I think the Democrats
00:23:58 have gotten so radicalized
00:23:59 judges shut down
00:24:01 if they take the Senate
00:24:02 take a spin
00:24:04 hit the tables
00:24:04 or join the action live
00:24:06 with BetVictor
00:24:07 tons of casino games await
00:24:09 plus the excitement
00:24:10 of the live casino
00:24:11 all in one convenient app
00:24:12 for when you choose to play
00:24:14 for timeless classics
00:24:15 the newest releases, and instant withdrawals.
00:24:18 Download the BetVictor app.
00:24:19 BetVictor, since 1946.
00:24:22 19 plus Ontario only, please play responsibly.
00:24:24 BetVictor operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGaming Ontario.
00:24:28 If you have questions or concerns about your gambling
00:24:29 or the gambling of someone close to you, visit connexontario.ca.
00:24:34 This is Newt Ginglish, former Speaker of the House
00:24:37 and a proud American citizen.
00:24:40 I'm celebrating America's 250th birthday on my podcast,
00:24:43 new twirl with 15 special episodes and i've got some great guests walter isaacson jonathan turley
00:24:52 brett bear i will be working because it's a big big day i'll be in washington and have all kinds
00:24:59 of coverage through the day of america 250 rachel compass duffy there's nothing like american music
00:25:05 we're the home of rock and roll we're the home of rap we're the home of pop music eric metaxas
00:25:09 Jared Isaacman. I plan to be flying in an F-5 fighter jet painted in Freedom 250 colors along
00:25:15 with four other fighter jets flying over the nation's capital. The story of the national
00:25:21 anthem and the President of the United States, Donald J. Trump. Join me and let's celebrate
00:25:26 America's 250. Listen to Newt's World on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you
00:25:33 Did your podcast
00:25:34 Why should you listen to Armstrong and Getty
00:25:37 On Demand
00:25:38 We're not boring, a lot of news is boring
00:25:40 And tedious, and depressing, and makes you angry
00:25:43 You don't want to live your life like that
00:25:45 Hey I'm Jack Armstrong, he's Joe Getty
00:25:47 We're Armstrong and Getty
00:25:48 We try to bring you the truth
00:25:49 And help you figure out this crazy modern world
00:25:52 How about something about a comedic tone
00:25:53 We have a winner
00:25:57 Yes
00:25:58 Listen to Armstrong and Getty On Demand
00:26:00 On the iHeartRadio app
00:26:02 apple podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts i want to move to another big case it was a victory
00:26:08 uh it's a little inside baseball but it's a very important one it deals the fcc and
00:26:12 coordination expenditures explain this ruling as well this is a case called nrsc versus fec and
00:26:18 it's about free speech and it's a 6-3 decision that that there were strict rules on how much
00:26:25 a political party can spend in coordination with its own candidates. And the court struck down
00:26:32 those limits and said, the RNC can spend as much money as it wants to support Republicans in
00:26:38 elections. The DNC can spend as much money as it wants to support Democrats in elections.
00:26:44 And they can coordinate, they can talk with the candidate. The existing rules were really stupid, 1.00
00:26:49 where the parties could spend money, but they couldn't actually talk to the candidate they 0.99
00:26:54 were spending money to support and and that i believe is contrary to the first amendment to
00:27:01 the constitution you know one of the strange things about how democrats think about free speech
00:27:06 uh the first amendment says congress will make no law abridging the freedom of speech
00:27:12 for many democrats they are robust they are aggressive on the free speech when it concerns
00:27:21 pornography obscenity kiddie porn they're like oh yeah first amendment covers all of that you
00:27:27 you should be able to have uh any sort of grotesque obscenity in any context whatsoever
00:27:32 you should have explicit pornography in the library or kindergartens that's what the first
00:27:37 amendment is all about i understand the argument that the first amendment is so robust it even
00:27:43 includes things that that we would find distasteful but the bizarre thing about democrats is they say
00:27:50 somehow skips over political speech look if the first amendment is designed to protect anything
00:27:58 it is political speech it is speech about our democratic process it is speech saying 0.64
00:28:04 vote for my candidate throw this bum out of office here's the rules we should adopt here's 0.88
00:28:10 the laws we should adopt uh i'm for gay marriage i'm against gay marriage i'm for abortion i'm 0.96
00:28:17 against abortion i'm for protecting gun rights i'm against protecting gun rights i mean that's
00:28:21 the essence of our democracy and for many on the left they believe government can regulate the
00:28:28 living daylights out of political speech make it incredibly difficult to urge your fellow citizens
00:28:34 here's who you should elect here you here's who you should not elect and yet at the same time
00:28:40 they want it to protect uh speech at the outer edges of the first amendment i don't get that
00:28:46 the supreme court here this decision is really important in terms of ensuring robust democracy
00:28:56 and robust free speech and by the way do you know what one of the key precedents was that this
00:29:03 decision built on what was that the case decided in 2022 that was entitled fec versus ted cruz for
00:29:13 senate so it's kind of cool i i have over the course of of my life i i had been a a law clerk
00:29:22 at the supreme court so i have briefed and advised the chief justice on how to decide cases i had
00:29:28 prepared the first drafts of supreme court opinions as a law clerk i had been an advocate
00:29:34 and argued nine cases in front of the court and so stood in front of the court answered their
00:29:38 questions written briefs and won multiple big landmark cases but i've also been a litigant i've
00:29:44 been a party uh and so i filed a lawsuit that that culminated in fec versus ted cruz for senate
00:29:51 that was challenging a portion of mccain feingold mccain feingold was the big campaign finance law
00:29:57 uh that john mccain and russ feingold champion that put major constraints on political spending
00:30:03 in political speech.
00:30:05 I think McCain-Feingold was an absolute abomination.
00:30:08 One element of McCain-Feingold
00:30:10 is it limited the ability of a candidate
00:30:13 to loan money to his or her own campaign
00:30:17 and then pay yourself back.
00:30:19 And so when I first ran for Senate in 2012,
00:30:24 Heidi and I, in fact, right before the primary,
00:30:29 I went to Heidi and I had a pretty surreal conversation.
00:30:32 I went to my wife and I said, okay, we need to liquidate 100% of our liquid net worth and put it in the campaign.
00:30:43 Because if we don't, we can't win.
00:30:46 And listen, neither Heidi nor I come from money.
00:30:49 My parents, when I was in high school, went bankrupt. 0.97
00:30:51 My dad was an immigrant. 1.00
00:30:52 He came from Cuba with nothing. 1.00
00:30:54 It's a curious thing, Ben.
00:30:55 People assume if you're in the Senate, you were born with a silver spoon in your mouth.
00:30:59 Yes.
00:31:00 Some people in the Senate, that's true for.
00:31:02 it wasn't for me. I mean, I've been financially on my own since I was 17. My parents went bankrupt.
00:31:08 We lost our home. We lost our business. When I went to college, I got two jobs. I took student
00:31:15 loans. I've been supporting myself ever since then. But I will say over the years, I mean,
00:31:20 I got a good education. I got a good job. And Heidi and I made some money. And so we had
00:31:25 done well by working. And so by the time I ran for Senate, our liquid net worth,
00:31:30 what we had that we could liquidate was 1.2 million dollars which is a lot of money look
00:31:34 i've had spent a whole life trying to earn that i was really grateful to have that i gotta tell
00:31:39 you ben you've been married a long time not as long as i have but a long time i'm getting stressed
00:31:45 at the idea of having that conversation much else actually doing it it's an interesting conversation
00:31:50 and i will say when i went to heidi i felt very confident she would say yes but i sort of thought
00:31:57 we would have a long extended conversation we might talk an hour or two about well that was
00:32:02 campaign look can you win what are the prospects and it was one of the moments i was most incredibly
00:32:08 proud to be married to my best friend in the world because 20 seconds into the conversation
00:32:14 heidi said yes do it and and and we we put 1.2 million in and by the way the last week of the
00:32:20 campaign that was all the ads we ran like if i hadn't written that check we would have been dark
00:32:27 on tv that last week because we were broke we'd spent everything we'd raised and so that was the
00:32:32 only money we had and we ended up winning the race but mccain feingold limited the ability to pay
00:32:39 yourself back so when the whole campaign was over i could pay myself back some of it
00:32:43 but 550 000 of that i couldn't pay myself back so for more than a decade i had written a 550
00:32:50 000 check as a loan to my campaign and mccain feingold said i had to give that as a gift
00:32:56 uh i guess to the voters and just just sacrifice that money and it wasn't fair it wasn't right
00:33:02 and so this lawsuit challenged that and said listen you ought to be able to uh invest in
00:33:08 and invest your resources in political speech and six three i won in fec versus ted cruz for senate
00:33:16 uh big victory and it meant now and by the way those rules they didn't hurt candidates who were
00:33:25 really poor. If you had no money, then it didn't matter if you could loan money to your campaign
00:33:29 and pay it back. And they didn't really hurt candidates who were super rich, the gazillionaires
00:33:35 of the world. If you're so rich, it doesn't matter. You can write a check and you don't
00:33:40 miss it. What it really hurt was kind of folks in the middle, folks who say were professionals like
00:33:46 me. I was a practicing lawyer who had some resources. But, you know, most people aren't
00:33:51 willing to put 100% of their net worth in a campaign.
00:33:54 I mean, that's a big investment.
00:33:57 That's literally putting your money where your mouth is.
00:33:59 When you go sit down with a donor and you're like, hey, I'm all in,
00:34:02 they're like, well, really, how much are you?
00:34:03 You're like, no, like literally everything.
00:34:05 That's a testimony to how much you believe in your campaign and what you're doing.
00:34:10 Well, it is, and it's a question of being all in.
00:34:14 And that decision protected basic First Amendment rights.
00:34:20 Look, McCain-Feingold was passed by a bunch of incumbent politicians.
00:34:25 If you're an incumbent, you've got massive advantages.
00:34:28 You can drive media like crazy.
00:34:30 You have a fundraising apparatus.
00:34:32 There are huge benefits to being an incumbent.
00:34:35 Part of why Congress passed McCain-Feingold is that incumbents didn't want to be challenged.
00:34:42 They didn't want some upstart candidate to be able to run against them and beat them.
00:34:47 And so by cutting off the money for an upstart candidate, if a candidate has no name ID and a candidate can't raise money and a candidate can't invest their own money, you know what it means?
00:34:57 You can't beat an incumbent politician.
00:34:59 And so the decision in in FEC versus Ted Cruz for Senate, we won that 6-3.
00:35:07 That was a major precedent that in turn underlay NRSC versus FEC, and what that means now is that the parties will be able to spend and use – look, there are some people who say money isn't speech.
00:35:26 That view is objectively wrong.
00:35:30 Virtually all speech requires the expenditure of money.
00:35:33 You go back to the founding era.
00:35:35 um look the the federalist papers the federalist papers were op-eds printed in the newspaper in
00:35:43 in new york and they were advocating for ratification of the constitution that took
00:35:47 money printing newspapers take money uh you look at thomas payne's common sense that that that was
00:35:53 printed that took money you you look at benjamin franklin who spent a lot of money putting out
00:35:58 political pamphlets you you go forward to today if a little old lady goes to home depot and buys 1.00
00:36:06 a a stake of wood and a poster board a marker and writes throw the bums out that takes money 1.00
00:36:14 and and virtually all communication by the way the new york times every week spends millions of 0.96
00:36:22 dollars running printing printing presses uh printing newspapers distributing newspapers
00:36:27 NBC spends millions of dollars communicating about politics.
00:36:31 CNN spends millions of dollars communicating about politics.
00:36:35 Money is how you communicate to a nation of 330 million people.
00:36:40 And so this victory says, look, all of us have a right to participate in the political process and express our views.
00:36:46 That's a big victory for free speech.
00:36:48 All right, Senator, let's get to the bad cases.
00:36:52 There's two of them that I think we need to highlight. 0.95
00:36:54 One of them, and it's one that there's been a lot of discussion over, and that's birthright citizenship case.
00:37:00 My take on this was, look, the president wanted there to be a grand debate nationwide on birthright citizenship.
00:37:07 I think a lot of people around him knew that if this went to the Supreme Court and this was a fight they were willing to have,
00:37:13 that there was a good chance it was not going to be a victory, but it did open up a big conversation nationwide on immigration,
00:37:21 immigration status, and birthright citizenship, people coming in.
00:37:24 Birthright tourism is a simple way of putting it.
00:37:27 And it certainly did, I think, educate people on what's happening in this country.
00:37:32 That, for me, is a victory.
00:37:35 But the reality is, in the Supreme Court, this was a loss.
00:37:39 So it was.
00:37:41 The question is, what does birthright citizenship protect?
00:37:45 and in particular are children of illegal aliens entitled to become U.S. citizens because they
00:37:51 were born on U.S. soil. Now, as a policy matter, birthright citizenship, I think, is a very
00:37:57 foolish policy. It is a policy that encourages illegal immigration. It rewards people for 0.86
00:38:04 breaking our laws. Most other countries on earth don't have that policy. If you break in illegally
00:38:10 to another country, most other countries, if you have a kid there, that kid is not a citizen of
00:38:14 that country. It also encourages things, as you noted, like birth tourism, where pregnant women
00:38:22 will get on a plane and fly to America on tourist visa simply to have a baby in America so that
00:38:28 baby can become a U.S. citizen. That's a foolish policy. Now, there's a legal question of how can 0.86
00:38:37 you change birthright citizenship? And I talked a minute ago about the 14th Amendment.
00:38:44 And the 14th Amendment says all persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside.
00:39:02 This case turned on the phrase and subject to the jurisdiction thereof.
00:39:06 what happened there have long been understood as really two potential ways to change current law
00:39:16 and birthright citizenship the one way that is unquestionably permissible and valid would be a
00:39:22 constitutional amendment that changes the constitution and makes clear that the child
00:39:27 of an illegal immigrant born in america is not a u.s citizen i strongly support that i would vote 0.58
00:39:32 for that, that's good policy. The second way, and there's dispute among legal scholars,
00:39:38 is could Congress pass a law saying the children of illegal immigrants born in America are not U.S.
00:39:45 citizens? That is still a somewhat murky question. Donald Trump explored a third avenue, which is he
00:39:53 signed an executive order that said, I am ordering the children of illegal immigrants are not U.S.
00:40:00 citizens if they're born in the United States. Now, to be honest, prior to Trump coming into
00:40:05 office, I'd never heard anyone articulate a legal theory that that could be done by executive order.
00:40:11 The Trump administration knew it was pushing the bounds of what's permissible. You are right
00:40:17 that we've now had a robust debate on birthright citizenship and what a bad policy it is.
00:40:23 Now, the court, unfortunately, ruled 5-4 that the executive order is invalid and that the children of illegal immigrants born in the U.S. are U.S. citizens.
00:40:40 That is unfortunate.
00:40:41 Chief Justice Roberts wrote the opinion.
00:40:45 I will say that that did not surprise me.
00:40:50 It was clear from the oral argument this was the likely outcome.
00:40:55 This was where the votes were headed.
00:40:58 I wrote an amicus brief, actually two different amicus briefs in the court joined by multiple members of Congress, in which I asked the Supreme Court to restore the original meaning of the birthright citizenship clause.
00:41:13 And I would encourage anyone interested in this issue, go read the brief that I wrote that laid out the original understanding of what the phrase subject to the jurisdiction thereof meant and that someone who was unlawfully present in the country, it did not fall within those parameters.
00:41:28 I think that's the right conclusion.
00:41:31 I wish the court – I think the dissenters have the better argument.
00:41:34 I wish the dissenters, instead of having four votes that had five, I wish we had one more.
00:41:39 that being said i i was not surprised just now i will say this justice thomas wrote a spectacular
00:41:48 dissent 91 pages uh it is incredibly effective and i will say justice thomas's dissent cited my brief
00:41:56 twice in that dissent uh i'm glad that that that the dissent commanded four votes i wish it had
00:42:03 commanded five where does that leave us well there's still some ambiguity on whether congress
00:42:10 could pass legislation defining subject to the jurisdiction thereof to exclude the children born
00:42:18 by parents here illegally the court did not resolve that question because it wasn't presented
00:42:22 with that question uh but let me be clear from my perspective this is a terrible policy outcome
00:42:31 and it's also the wrong legal outcome and i would support number one a constitutional amendment
00:42:39 to end birthright citizenship i would support number two legislation just to end birthright
00:42:45 citizenship i hope we go down the road of both of those yeah yeah i agree with you there and
00:42:50 finally we got to deal with a case that deals with mail-in ballots that's right this is another case
00:42:55 that is Watson versus RNC, and Watson versus RNC deals with the laws in Mississippi
00:43:06 concerning governing absentee ballots.
00:43:09 So the laws in Mississippi say that absentee ballots have to be postmarked by Election Day,
00:43:15 and they can be received up to five days after Election Day.
00:43:20 And in this case, the RNC filed a lawsuit challenging that and saying that under the terms of federal election law, election day is understood to be the actual day of the election.
00:43:38 And so the argument the RNC made is that you could not count ballots received up to five days after the election.
00:43:44 unfortunately by a vote of five to four the supreme court rejected that argument and and
00:43:51 justice amy coney barrett joined by chief justice roberts and the three liberals
00:43:55 concluded that election day is understood to mean the day when quote voting is complete
00:44:02 not when ballots are received in other words they upheld mississippi's law allowing ballots to
00:44:09 received be received up to five days after election day uh there were vigorous dissents it was five
00:44:16 four uh but at the end of the day what it means is is that the court has concluded federal law
00:44:25 does not limit late received mail-in ballots the consequence of this is it's going to remain
00:44:32 state by state red states can put real and meaningful limits can limit uh balloting can
00:44:38 limit late received ballots. Mississippi can change their law. But it also means that blue
00:44:44 states, states like California, can have the atrocity they had in their most recent election,
00:44:50 their mayor's election in L.A., where they have votes coming in days, weeks, as much as a month
00:44:56 later. Look, this decision is unfortunate, but I'll tell you what it really underscores.
00:45:02 it underscores the need to pass the Save America Act.
00:45:05 The Save America Act would protect against illegal voting.
00:45:11 I'm an original sponsor of the Save America Act.
00:45:13 I'm fighting for it in the Senate.
00:45:15 This decision, unfortunately, was a real loss of the Supreme Court.
00:45:19 Yeah, it really was.
00:45:21 Well, it certainly is a lot, as you mentioned, coming down from the Supreme Court.
00:45:24 I'm glad we got to cover a lot of it.
00:45:26 You know the wins, you know the losses, and what it means moving forward.
00:45:29 This is why we do this show.
00:45:30 So don't forget, we do this show Monday, Wednesday, and Friday.
00:45:33 Hit that subscribe or auto-download button wherever you get your podcasts
00:45:37 so that you don't miss a single episode of Vertical with Ted Cruz.
00:45:40 And we'll see you back here on Friday morning.
00:45:44 On Newt World Podcast, we're celebrating America's 250th birthday.
00:45:49 And I ask my guests how they're spending their 4th of July.
00:45:52 Brett Baer.
00:45:53 I will be working. I'll be in Washington because it's a big, big day.
00:45:58 Jared Isaacman.
00:45:59 I plan to be flying in an F-5 fighter jet painted in Freedom 250 colors along with four other fighter jets flying over the nation's capital.
00:46:07 Listen to Newt's World on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:46:14 Why should you listen to Armstrong and Getty On Demand?
00:46:18 We're not boring.
00:46:19 A lot of news is boring.
00:46:20 And tedious.
00:46:21 And depressing.
00:46:21 And makes you angry.
00:46:23 You don't want to live your life like that.
00:46:25 Hey, I'm Jack Armstrong.
00:46:26 He's Joe Getty.
00:46:27 We're Armstrong and Getty.
00:46:28 We try to bring you the truth.
00:46:29 and help you figure out this crazy modern world.
00:46:31 How about something about a comedic tone?
00:46:36 We have a winner.
00:46:37 Yes.
00:46:38 Listen to Armstrong and Getty On Demand on the iHeartRadio app,
00:46:41 Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.