Western Standard - May 30, 2023


2023 Alberta Election Poll Analysis & Results | LIVE

Topics
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update May 29, 2023 Cory Morgan Show. Hey Premier Smith! Don’t blink!

Episode Stats


Length

4 hours and 42 minutes

Words per minute

163.7

Word count

46,308

Sentence count

2,158

Harmful content

Misogyny

70

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

15

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A special edition of the Western Standard and Alberta Report, brought to you live from The Western Standard studio in downtown Calgary, Alberta. Host Derek Fildebrandt is joined by co-hosts Nigel Hannaford and Corey Morgan to discuss the results of the latest advanced polling.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, welcome to a special edition of the Western Standard and Alberta Report.
00:00:20 I am Western Standard publisher Derek Fildebrandt, coming to you tonight live from the Western
00:00:26 standards uh studio in downtown calgary we're gonna have uh full and extensive coverage of
00:00:34 alberta's election uh this year it's uh everybody knows it's gonna be right down to the wire at least
00:00:42 we're expecting if all of the pollsters are correct and uh 10 pollsters they can't all be
00:00:47 wrong uh so we are expecting a very exciting night uh we've got a great lineup of co-hosts
00:00:54 and special guests coming to you uh political scientists uh political operatives journalists
00:01:02 uh really great team here uh before we get going though i want to thank uh my two favorite sponsors
00:01:08 the canadian shooting sports association i've been a member of the cssa for over a decade
00:01:13 because i trust them as canada's leading firearm owner rights group in canada if you're not yet a
00:01:18 member of the cssa go to cssa-cila.org or do what i do just google them and become a member today
00:01:24 This broadcast is also brought to you by Market Commodities. Market Commodities is a
00:01:32 Lethbridge, Alberta-based grain, barley, and wheat marketing company. If you are a farmer in
00:01:40 Western Canada and you need to get your products to market, check out Market Commodities. They
00:01:45 want to buy your grain. Okay, so I want to introduce our core panel tonight, my co-hosts.
00:01:51 I'm joined, as you would expect, by Western Standard opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford.
00:01:56 How are you, Nigel?
00:01:57 I'm great. It was a great night to be here.
00:01:59 I think so. Also joined by Western Standard senior Alberta columnist, Corey Morgan.
00:02:04 How are you, Corey?
00:02:05 Very good. I've been waiting a long time for this.
00:02:08 Indeed. Yeah, thank God it'll all be over soon.
00:02:12 But we've got a great lineup of guests coming who are going to come to us throughout the evening.
00:02:16 We've got our reporters on the ground at both the NDP headquarters in Edmonton and the UCP headquarters here in Calgary.
00:02:24 We're going to be going to them.
00:02:26 We've got our newsroom staffed up here.
00:02:29 We're going to be going to them for results as they come in.
00:02:33 But I guess what we'll do here, well, we're not going to go to them quite yet.
00:02:36 We'll go to them soon.
00:02:37 But I guess we'll start with you, Nigel.
00:02:42 Predictions for tonight.
00:02:44 Slim UCP victory.
00:02:46 but very slim. Very slim. I think that's that'll be the consensus of the polls at this point.
00:02:53 You're gonna put a number on it, how many seats? Yeah, I'll put a, I'll go 49 to 38, but
00:03:02 which it doesn't sound so slim, but some of those, some of those victories will be very thin,
00:03:08 small majorities. We're gonna have a pretty good idea fairly soon on, because of course
00:03:14 this advanced poll with 750,000. There are 2.8 million eligible voters in Alberta,
00:03:22 70% of them will vote if we do better than last time. So something like 2 million people voting
00:03:30 and 750,000, the results will be in very soon. So nobody had a better sample than that.
00:03:39 Yeah, so the polls close at eight o'clock. And normally we'd have to wait 45 minutes to an hour
00:03:44 for the first little tiny polls to trickle in,
00:03:46 but it's going to be very different today, Corey,
00:03:48 because there's automatic vote tabulating machines
00:03:52 for all those advanced polls.
00:03:54 Those of us who have voted in advanced polls,
00:03:56 you put it into a scanner, they scan it.
00:03:58 Now, there is still a paper copy, thankfully,
00:03:59 as a backup for recounts,
00:04:01 but the initial count is just done by a machine,
00:04:03 and those results are going to come to us pretty early on.
00:04:08 Let's get your skin in the game. 0.89
00:04:10 What do you think?
00:04:10 What are you expecting to see tonight?
00:04:11 Don't hedge your bets too much.
00:04:12 No, no, and I'm going back.
00:04:13 I'll stick to what we did way back at the start of the campaign with our office pool.
00:04:19 And I said 42-35 at that point.
00:04:21 I'll stick with that one.
00:04:23 And that floated, you know, if you'd ask.
00:04:24 42-35?
00:04:25 Sorry, 52-35.
00:04:29 You know, over the course of the election, in the middle of the campaign, I would have started thinking,
00:04:32 I was a little too generous.
00:04:33 Things are looking a little rough.
00:04:34 But then I'm seeing, you know, the undecideds have closed.
00:04:37 People have just accepted, you know, that I believe are going to move towards the UCP.
00:04:42 So I believe that's where we're going to land.
00:04:45 Yeah, I know my initial bet on the office pool had the UCP at a majority with 53 seats.
00:04:53 My prediction I put out today was at 51.
00:04:56 I mean, so many of these are a crapshoot.
00:04:59 So let's talk about the different paths to victory here, because it's not just which party gets the most votes.
00:05:07 There's actually no Alberta election.
00:05:09 There are 87 Alberta elections tonight, and each one of them is a unique race, even though there'll be some commonalities across them.
00:05:16 So, Nico, why don't we pull up our, from 338, not the map, let's just pull up the list of writings there.
00:05:24 It's a really smart graphic put together by 338.com.
00:05:29 They, no, that's the map.
00:05:31 Let's bring up the list.
00:05:33 There it is.
00:05:34 So what you see here, folks up on the screen, is a list of every constituency in Alberta, the 87, and you need 44 seats to get to a majority government.
00:05:47 The ones you see in really dark blue are the safe UCP seats.
00:05:52 The ones in really dark orange are the safe NDP seats.
00:05:55 and you know you can use your brain and figure it out the lighter the color gets in the shade
00:06:00 of blue or orange the closer it is uh expected to be in that race and you'll see here the number of
00:06:08 toss-ups the light blue those are called ucp leaning toss-ups um the ucp needs to win their
00:06:15 core seats the two likely seats and then only two of the toss-ups that the polls are predicting at
00:06:23 least, are going to go the UCP's way. So just two toss-ups. For the NDP to win, they've got to win
00:06:31 all four of the toss-ups leaning their way, and one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight,
00:06:36 nine of the toss-ups that are expected or predicted to be leaning to the UCP. It's a very
00:06:44 different, the NDP could win tonight, I think, Nigel, but it's a very, essentially, all of the
00:06:50 coin tosses. Every single coin toss in Alberta
00:06:52 has to go the NDP's way just to get to a
00:06:54 bare majority.
00:06:57 And that would, I mean, such things
00:06:58 have happened, but they're rare.
00:07:00 And I'm sure the UCP
00:07:03 is... We can take this screen down now.
00:07:04 I'm sure the UCP is
00:07:06 fairly confident
00:07:08 that that is not going to happen, because
00:07:10 they've done a good campaign, they haven't
00:07:12 made any serious mistakes.
00:07:14 Neither is the NDP, but
00:07:16 nevertheless, for that
00:07:18 degree of change to happen,
00:07:20 is uh it's kind of a generational thing you said earlier 44 is a majority and you're correct but
00:07:28 if you are 44 you've still got to provide a speaker now you're 43 to 43 you better hope nobody gets
00:07:35 cold and stays home yeah that would mean uh you can't have anyone sick and right and the speaker
00:07:41 would have to probably break every single tie vote so you could do it bc did it when they had a
00:07:47 a weird kind of minority slash coalition government, but it's, it's a perilous position
00:07:51 to govern in the legislature. It certainly is. Uh, let's bring up the map from 338.com now,
00:07:59 uh, their predictions. Now I like these guys. I know a lot of people like polls. If the poll
00:08:05 favors the side, they like, they hate polls. Polls are crap. If it doesn't favor their side, 1.00
00:08:08 but these guys are an aggregator of polls. They kind of take an average of all the major polls
00:08:13 out there and try to overlay it as best they can over the ridings to give you an idea of how it's
00:08:18 going to break down. So this is what they're predicting. And you'll see there that they're
00:08:23 predicting 52 seats for the UCP, 35 seats for the NDP. Now there's a lot of coin tosses in there
00:08:30 where perhaps a couple thousand, even a couple hundred votes could flip a seat one way or
00:08:37 another. And what you're seeing is what we've seen so far on the map, the big map of Alberta,
00:08:41 every riding that you can see with the naked eye on that map is blue they're probably all going blue
00:08:47 with the potential exception of uh bamf can and ask us that's a that's that's not a regular
00:08:54 we're running it's got like canmore and bamf a bit more of a urban and progressive pardon and
00:09:00 prittis that's mine yeah prittis but i don't think prittis has got that uh canmore bamf feel to it
00:09:05 no it's it's a very different riding from one end to the other actually yeah but then you see uh
00:09:11 Edmonton, Sea of Orange, and then Calgary.
00:09:14 Everyone's coming down to Calgary.
00:09:16 Northeast Calgary is, you know, trending orange.
00:09:20 South Calgary, at least outside the Beltline, is blue.
00:09:25 The real battleground here, if you're really going to drill down even within Calgary, is northwest Calgary.
00:09:30 Northwest Calgary.
00:09:32 And a few in the southeast.
00:09:34 So, you know, we've got, if the NDP, for the NDP to win, they've got to flip virtually the entire,
00:09:40 I think they have to win essentially every single riding in North Calgary
00:09:43 and even a few in the two Southeast Walgreens.
00:09:46 It's a tough way to get there.
00:09:49 Okay, well, polls are about to close soon.
00:09:52 Why don't we go to Dave Naylor, our news editor in the newsroom.
00:09:56 Dave, have you got anything for us here?
00:10:02 It may be on fire looking at your background there.
00:10:07 But as you say, it's just the waiting game now.
00:10:10 Polls close shortly, and Western Standard's got reporters everywhere they need to be.
00:10:16 So it should be a good night.
00:10:18 Very good.
00:10:20 Well, soon we're going to be, you know, once he gets dressed correctly,
00:10:24 we're going to go to Jonathan Bradley at the UCP headquarters in Calgary.
00:10:32 He's got to work on a few things before we dare put a camera on him.
00:10:36 But we've also got Arthur Green at the NDP headquarters up in Edmonton, going to come in fairly soon.
00:10:46 Dave, sorry, not Dave, Corey, Corey, what are the, give me the top three bellwether constituencies you're looking for.
00:10:55 If you're going to name three constituencies that if a party wins all three, they're likely to form government tonight.
00:11:01 Well, if we're looking at Calgary bellwethers, I would look at Calgary Glenmore, of course.
00:11:06 that was already a tight one. It could swing either way this time around as well. That one
00:11:13 would be very indicative of what's going on if that ends up going to one party or the other.
00:11:18 Calgary Elbow is another interesting one. I mean, that one has swung so many times. It's been the
00:11:23 Premier's riding twice. It was Ralph Klein's. It was Redford's. But then it went liberal for one
00:11:27 odd term in 2007. It went Alberta party for a while. It's gone conservative again. And then
00:11:34 it's been left vacant for a few months so it's strong conservative territory but they might feel
00:11:38 a little abused by the conservatives right now so and again though I mean if that can be clinched
00:11:42 for the conservatives it would look very good if UCP if it doesn't uh it goes NDP then then they
00:11:48 really got to start sweating a lot of those other Calgary uh constituencies give you two more two
00:11:52 more boy so you're saying you said Glenmore did you say elbow I said both Glenmore and elbow yeah
00:11:59 what's your third one perhaps Calgary bow even that one's an interesting one you know you've got
00:12:03 a cabinet minister in there, but you've also got Drew Farrell, who is certainly representative of
00:12:08 the NDP, a very solidly, consistently left-leaning person, but she's got name recognition. She's well
00:12:13 established in Calgary. And again, it's a riding that could kind of go either way, I think. So
00:12:19 if we start seeing results in some of those three, we'll have a pretty good idea what's happening in
00:12:23 this race. I would agree with Glenmore and Bo is the real bellweathers, but I think the UCP can
00:12:29 afford to lose elbow. If the NDP wins elbow tonight, they definitely have to win elbow to
00:12:35 win government. But the UCP does not. The UCP has to win Glenmore. It has to win Bo. But I think
00:12:43 they can't afford to lose elbow. Yeah, I just think if either party gets a strong showing and
00:12:48 one that swings so much that it would be very indicative of the rest. I don't know if he's
00:12:54 ready or not but uh perhaps we can go to uh what our uh western standard alberta legislative
00:13:00 reporter arthur green up in edmonton he is at the ndp headquarters this evening uh let's bring
00:13:07 uh arthur green into the broadcast here arthur uh you're up in uh orange headquarters what are
00:13:13 things up like up there right now uh right now it's pretty quiet in here uh in here derrick
00:13:18 everyone's just getting set up uh it's quite warm here actually i had to run across the street to
00:13:23 it in. But, you know, spirits are high and people are expecting an NDP win tonight.
00:13:31 So you're in Edmonton where, I mean, if you're walking around the streets of Brooks, you're
00:13:38 probably thinking everybody votes UCP. But if you're walking around the streets of Edmonton,
00:13:42 you probably think everyone there votes NDP. So what do you think is driving their positive
00:13:49 mood for their side at the ndp headquarters right now um optimism i would say uh everyone
00:13:58 is quite optimistic that the the ndp is going to form a majority government here in alberta tonight
00:14:04 and you know people are in high spirits eric they really believe in uh rachel notley and
00:14:10 an ndp government and that seems to be the uh the consensus here tonight
00:14:14 um where do you uh you know based on what you're hearing in the room there from uh
00:14:22 at nb ndp headquarters where do they think their their pickups are coming from i know
00:14:26 i know that they think they have to they know they have to win uh calgary but uh are there
00:14:32 any seats the ndp really think they have a shot of picking up outside um some of the
00:14:38 Oh, I think he may be able to pick up is Fort Saskatchewan.
00:14:44 They're looking for a win in Fort Saskatchewan.
00:14:46 Other seats, of course, would be in Calgary, like you said.
00:14:51 But there are some other rural areas.
00:14:53 Grand Prairie is another one that I'm hearing amongst people that they're looking for a win there as well.
00:15:01 Grand Prairie.
00:15:02 Well, I'll tell you, if Grand Prairie ends up in the NDP category tonight,
00:15:07 It's not even close.
00:15:08 The NDP have absolutely trounced things.
00:15:13 Maybe I'll come to eat my words, but if the NDP wins Grand Prix tonight,
00:15:20 you guys can call me Doors Day for a week.
00:15:23 That's better what we call you when you aren't around it.
00:15:25 There we go.
00:15:27 Okay, well, thank you for joining us, Arthur.
00:15:30 We'll check back with you soon.
00:15:32 At some point, we hope to have Jonathan Bradley in from the UCP headquarters.
00:15:37 Um, but I guess, uh, let's, um, why don't we pull up, uh, that, uh, the, from the 338,
00:15:45 we'll pull up that graphic showing the path to 44 again here.
00:15:48 Cause I really want people to understand this.
00:15:51 This is, uh, I think the best visible tool to see, not the map.
00:15:55 The map is nice.
00:15:57 I love coloring in the map.
00:15:59 I've always loved coloring in maps since I was a kid, but this is probably the best
00:16:02 graphic to help understand what we can expect tonight and the path to victory.
00:16:10 So you see all the lightly colored boxes, light blue, light orange. Those are the real
00:16:16 toss-ups. And you'll see here, the UCP have just got a, they've just got an easier path to victory.
00:16:25 Nigel, what would be, I'm going to ask you the same question I asked Corey earlier. What would
00:16:30 be the three bellwethers you look at? The party that wins all three of these ridings you're going
00:16:35 to give is likely to be the government. Well, I was certainly looking at Calgary, Acadia.
00:16:42 Tyler Shandro is defending his seat there. And obviously a high profile cabinet minister,
00:16:49 got a history there. That would be one. I also thought that Calgary, Bo, again,
00:16:55 And it's always been a conservative area.
00:16:59 There's no bad stuff about Demetrius Stigolides.
00:17:04 He's been a very diligent representative for the people who live there.
00:17:09 And if that one goes, then I'd have to say that that's just a general rejection of the UCP.
00:17:17 The one that I'm particularly interested in is Calgary Northwest, where Regen Solny is defending her seat.
00:17:24 She's not defending a seat. She moves seats. She is not defending a seat. She's trying to hold it 0.68
00:17:29 for the UCP, but she parachuted out of her current seat, which was going to be lost to the, is likely
00:17:35 going to be lost to the NDP. She parachuted out to another better seat. Well, we'll see.
00:17:41 But we can't say she's defending her seat. No, you're correct. The reason that I look at that
00:17:46 is it almost struck me that she was on, out of the contenders for the leadership of the UCP,
00:17:52 she was less conservative than
00:17:55 all of the others
00:17:56 with the possible exception of Lila
00:17:58 here. So maybe
00:18:01 she felt she'd go down well in
00:18:02 an environment like that where
00:18:04 obviously the NDP is trending well
00:18:06 but maybe they're
00:18:09 going to decide to go for the real thing
00:18:10 rather than her.
00:18:12 That whole northwest area
00:18:15 I think, I mean, there's a lot
00:18:17 of battlegrounds around Calgary
00:18:18 as we all know. Calgary is where
00:18:21 the vast majority of the battlegrounds in Alberta are right now. But within Calgary, I think it's
00:18:25 the Northwest that's really in play. And the NDP's just got to sweep it. Corey, what do you think
00:18:33 the chances are that the NDP have got to take actually all of North? I think they're going to
00:18:37 possibly sweep the Northeast, possibly. But they've got to sweep, I think, everything in the
00:18:44 Northeast and the Northwest quadrant. What are the chances that they can pull that off?
00:18:48 They're very slim. Northeast, for example, I mean, they're looking good in preliminary polls,
00:18:52 but that's also the most volatile part of the city as far as voting goes in any direction.
00:18:56 That's one of the areas where the local candidates' community connections can very strongly impact the vote in the Northeast
00:19:03 is more than the party can. Quite often, I mean, the candidates can only have so much impact in their own constituency in the campaign.
00:19:09 It's important to get out the vote, meet the voters, but you're still dependent on the party campaign itself.
00:19:14 but northeast calgary it's a lot more candidate related so that could be tough they've you know
00:19:19 some of those things that look orange now i wouldn't be shocked to see a ucp uh win or two
00:19:23 up in there northwest is where it's going to swell well actually let's talk about these calgary for
00:19:26 a second because that's a really good point uh it's a bit of a trope about northeast calgary that
00:19:32 it's the ethnic area that's because it's largely true it is made up of that's where the the big i
00:19:37 think majority of visible minorities and immigrant communities live. And it makes for more complicated
00:19:44 politics makes it much more difficult to predict things. Now, in the aggregate, polling shows
00:19:50 generally visible minority communities lean NDP. I mean, generally, they tend to lean for more left
00:19:55 leaning parties. But there's been exceptions to that. The conservatives have captured it at least
00:20:00 once when Harper won his majority. Kenny did pretty well with them in 20, the 2019 Alberta
00:20:07 election. So there's been exceptions to it. They tend to lean that way. And the polling right now
00:20:10 shows visible minorities tend to lean NDP. But it is a total mistake to think all visible minorities
00:20:18 are just some homogenous group. We got pizza outside the studio here, and it's like a pizza.
00:20:24 It's just so complicated. It's a whole smorgasbord. And I think it makes it really difficult. Anyone
00:20:30 who's ever done politics in northeast calgary you know this cory um it's so difficult to predict it
00:20:37 the way you could say southeast calgary southwest calgary it's a very nuanced area and it can really
00:20:42 depend on who the candidate is and uh community connections and things such as that so i would be
00:20:47 surprised to see any one party sort of sweep the northeast there's going to be a speckling i think
00:20:51 going on up there and the ndp can't afford a speckling they have to have a solid way so we'll
00:20:56 see. Nigel, outside of Calgary, what would be the key writings you're watching that could
00:21:04 actually be in play? Well, Slave Lake is one. That's worth watching. Fort Saskatchewan, I heard
00:21:13 Arthur mention. That one surprised me. I don't think so. Can't see it. If any of you are winning
00:21:21 Fort Saskatchewan, they're winning the election handily. I don't think they're taking it. The
00:21:26 The other one is in Lethbridge, Lethbridge East, where Nathan Newdorf, of course, he's the deputy prime minister, premier.
00:21:33 I'll get there.
00:21:35 And, you know, it was a bit of a, I won't say it was a surprise, but he won that seat when everything was going UCP in 2019.
00:21:47 It doesn't have a long history of being a conservative, a safe conservative seat.
00:21:55 Good man.
00:21:56 I'd hate to see him lose, but I do think that's a possibility.
00:21:58 Okay.
00:21:59 Well, we're going to bring in one of our Western-Centered Calgary reporters,
00:22:04 Jonathan Bradley here.
00:22:04 Jonathan Bradley is at the United Conservative Party headquarters
00:22:08 at the big four buildings down on the Stampede grounds in Calgary here.
00:22:14 Jonathan, what's the mood like there on the ground at UCP headquarters?
00:22:19 Well, Derek, it's pretty tame right now.
00:22:22 Some supporters are starting to come in.
00:22:23 there's been a few people it just kind of feels like there's some excitement and optimism
00:22:27 happening right now I've run into a few of our friends Peter McCaffrey's here there's some other
00:22:32 journalists who we've interacted with in the past who are showing up yeah I mean results
00:22:38 don't start pouring in until eight but right now the mood feels pretty optimistic I know it's a
00:22:44 very general question but what are people telling you on the ground in there are they
00:22:47 are they kind of biting their nails thinking it's going to be close are they thinking this
00:22:52 is in the bag well people seem to think it's in the bag i've been hearing talk about people
00:22:56 thinking that the ucp are going to win obviously not as large as last time i'm thinking people are
00:23:01 saying 50 to 55 seats which is a sizable majority i mean if it's you know 44 seats 45 seats people
00:23:07 aren't going to be too happy but based on what people are saying what the polls are saying
00:23:11 okay uh anything else uh you could tell us uh from on the ground at the ucp headquarters right now
00:23:19 Well, we're being told of results are coming in at eight. There's some screens going up showing all the candidates competing. Nothing really major at the moment.
00:23:28 And yeah.
00:23:30 Okay, thank you very much, Jonathan.
00:23:32 You're welcome.
00:23:36 Okay, Nigel, if you are, I mean, you were speechwriter to Prime Minister Stephen Harper.
00:23:45 Harper. If you were Danielle Smith's speech writer tonight, what are you doing for her?
00:23:53 Well, first of all, I would have two speeches.
00:23:57 That's what we did in 2015. Unfortunately, we got to use the wrong one, as we saw it.
00:24:08 There's a significant difference in the presentation of the NDP and under Rachel
00:24:14 notley and the ucp under danielle smith danielle smith has been upbeat throughout the whole thing
00:24:22 often when the news was not good she would be asked difficult questions she turned away with
00:24:27 a smile and i think that is the brand that she has now established and in victory she would 0.89
00:24:34 use that and be magnanimous to those who who had done their best and then as she would say something
00:24:41 about if you don't have any doubts about the loyalty of the other side to alberta and the
00:24:47 best of albertans so uh you would say that then the other speech of course would be
00:24:55 well we did our best and uh voters are always right okay uh corey i know you're not much of
00:25:02 a speech uh speech writer but you're uh writing for rachel notley tonight what uh kind of speeches
00:25:07 are you writing? Well, I mean, as Nigel said, you'd be writing two of them for sure. If Rachel
00:25:15 Notley doesn't win this election, I mean, she's really going to have to re-examine her future. So 0.95
00:25:19 it won't be just a speech of consolation. I think some people will be wondering if she's going to
00:25:23 indicate whether she's going to stay in as a leader or not. So how much of that she'd want
00:25:29 to cover. As if she wins, well, I guess start to lay out your policy priorities, thanking your
00:25:36 voters. I think she's going to stay pretty 0.99
00:25:38 to the basics there, I would hope.
00:25:41 I mean, if they're tired from the campaign,
00:25:43 try to put out an optimistic thing,
00:25:44 reach out to the rest of Albertans. I mean, both will
00:25:46 have to say it's been such a fear-mongering campaign.
00:25:48 The first thing they have to do is
00:25:50 make Albertans feel comfortable. Don't worry.
00:25:53 You're in good hands, whoever it might be.
00:25:55 Very good. All right.
00:25:56 Well, we're going to be switching out some of our panelists
00:25:58 throughout the night.
00:26:01 We're going to be coming and going
00:26:02 because we have a lot of work to do in the newsroom here.
00:26:06 But we're going to be joined by Corey and Nigel again soon.
00:26:10 But we're going to throw it to Dave Naylor in our newsroom right now, checking in with him.
00:26:16 Dave, polls are about to close.
00:26:19 Tell us what is going on.
00:26:22 Well, I'm sure there'll be a last minute rush at many of the voting stations to get the ballot counted and they were in.
00:26:29 there was a problem at one of the polling stations up in the Sun child area where
00:26:36 the where the polling station didn't open until late so it's not going to close
00:26:44 tonight in 946 so soon as they as soon as eight o'clock passes then the we
00:26:50 should get a good run of votes from the advanced polls because they'll be all
00:26:56 counted and ready to be leased right at eight o'clock. Different this time, Dave, because so
00:27:03 many of the ballots are in the advanced polls. There was so many of them, but also that they
00:27:08 were automatically scanned. Yeah, correct. So hopefully won't be any concerns about
00:27:20 i believe uh our colleague sean said they were all then uh take it up to edmonton and
00:27:29 and count it again so we should get uh fast and accurate results at uh uh seven or eight o'clock
00:27:35 sorry you soon all right well in the studio here uh we've got uh two uh two new panelists we've got
00:27:46 Josh Andrus here from Project Confederation, and David Parker here from Take Back Alberta.
00:27:55 But before we come to them, I'm going to go to Arthur Green up in Edmonton at the NDP headquarters.
00:28:00 Arthur, tell us what's happening in Orangetown.
00:28:04 Right now, Derek, everyone is just starting to pile into the room.
00:28:09 It's mostly media here right now.
00:28:11 If you can't hear me, it's because it's really loud in this room as all reporters are getting together their election coverage.
00:28:20 I'm told the candidates should be showing up here shortly.
00:28:23 Again, everyone seems pretty optimistic about an NDP majority government here tonight in Alberta.
00:28:33 I don't know. What are they making of the polls, though?
00:28:36 Most polls are not pointing towards an NDP majority government.
00:28:38 I mean, there is a possibility of it. There's a path to it.
00:28:41 it's very narrow uh are they just saying the polls are wrong or what are they thinking
00:28:46 um they're not saying the polls are wrong again i mean they're they're saying they're optimistic
00:28:52 eric that they're hoping the polls are wrong uh again the polls say uh that that it would be a
00:28:59 minority government uh other the ndp or the ucp uh depending on the uh the results tonight but i
00:29:07 I mean, the room seems pretty energetic.
00:29:10 We've got lots of people here getting ready for a long horse race tonight, I guess.
00:29:17 I'm not sure what time everything will wrap up here in Edmonton.
00:29:23 Again, the room is starting to fill up and people are starting to trickle in.
00:29:28 Okay. Thank you, Arthur. We'll check back with you soon.
00:29:31 All right. So in the studio now, we've got Josh Andrus from Project Confederation,
00:29:36 David Parker from Take Back Alberta.
00:29:38 I'm going to start with you, David.
00:29:41 Boy, you have become almost a household name in Alberta.
00:29:47 I know you're a longtime Alberta political operator.
00:29:53 You've been on a lot of campaigns.
00:29:55 I guess the two most prominent ones being the campaign to oust Jason Kenney from the UCP leadership,
00:30:00 which was obviously very successful.
00:30:03 and getting people at least involved in voting in the UCP leadership
00:30:09 to replace JC Kennedy, the resultant Daniel Smith.
00:30:12 But you guys have been out.
00:30:14 What have you guys been doing during the campaign?
00:30:16 Because you've been getting a lot of attention in the press.
00:30:19 Well, during the campaign, we've been pretty focused on just encouraging people to get involved.
00:30:24 Our whole policy has been it's not enough to just vote.
00:30:28 It's not enough to just talk about the vote.
00:30:30 what you need to focus on is you need to focus on recruiting people and persuading people on the
00:30:36 ground so like making teaching people how to be organizers basically and we've done 78 meetings
00:30:42 across the province since january 7th in order to do that to grow the movement of course there's
00:30:47 lots of rules around elections alberta and what we're able to do and what we aren't able to do
00:30:51 as a third-party advertiser but we've been mostly focused on just trying to build the movement and
00:30:56 encourage people to get involved. We have lots of people who've chosen to do all kinds of things
00:31:01 from teaching people about election scrutineering. That's not part of Take Back Alberta. People
00:31:05 involved with Take Back Alberta have done that. We have people who have been volunteering. People
00:31:11 have just been getting engaged, and that's really what we encourage people to do is be part of their
00:31:15 democracy. So I guess two-part question. What are you expecting to see tonight, and what are you
00:31:20 hoping to see tonight? I'm expecting
00:31:22 to see about 47 seats
00:31:23 is what I'm predicting for the UCP
00:31:26 That's narrow
00:31:27 I think it's going to be narrower than
00:31:30 I'd hoped, but I would say
00:31:32 my hope would be 55. That would be what I would
00:31:34 really be. I'd be at 55
00:31:36 I also think that it's very possible that
00:31:38 Danielle actually beats Jason 0.73
00:31:40 Kenny's popular vote. I think that is a
00:31:42 real possibility. By percentage or in gross numbers?
00:31:43 By percentage, but not in... By gross numbers, but not
00:31:46 percentage? No, by percentage. I think that it
00:31:48 is possible. I think that is within the realm of possibility. I think she's far more popular in
00:31:53 rural Alberta, and I think she actually has taken the numbers up a little bit in Edmonton. The
00:31:57 question will be what happens in Calgary. Actually, that's an interesting point. I don't
00:32:01 think it's been given much consideration because the polls are showing the UCP is holding pretty
00:32:05 much more or less their vote from the last time, percentage-wise. What's changed is that the
00:32:11 Alberta Party has evaporated and gone. 2015, Josh, the NDP unofficially merged the left
00:32:20 by eating the liberals. And 2019, they digested them. 2023, it looks like now they've eaten the
00:32:29 Alberta Party, which got roughly 8-ish percent in the last election. They're not even running
00:32:34 candidates everywhere. Not even close to anywhere. How much, Josh, how much of an effect do you think
00:32:40 that has. And why do you think the Alberta party vote has skewed almost entirely to go to the NDP
00:32:45 and not to the UCP as that party's collapsed? Well, I think a lot of it is just polarization
00:32:49 within the political system in Alberta. The last four years, we've seen really only two, well,
00:32:54 only two parties of the legislature. So they dominate the storylines, they dominate the
00:32:59 news coverage. Also, this election campaign, I don't think it's going to work for it, but Rachel
00:33:03 Notley has worn blue jeans and blue blazers and pretended to be a conservative. So that kind of
00:33:09 does eat into the Alberta Party's vote. I do think also for just political expediency, you're seeing
00:33:14 a lot of left-wing voters or even left of centre voters. Just look at the NDP as the only other
00:33:20 option to the UCP, which has consolidated the vote and made this a two-horse race. But at the
00:33:26 same time, the UCP doesn't have to be concerned about vote splitting. There are other parties
00:33:30 running. I think they're competing for maybe one to two percent of the vote in the ridings they're
00:33:35 in this is very much a two-horse race and it's going to come down to how much some of these
00:33:40 distractions this campaign how much these distractions are liabilities to the party
00:33:47 vote and do the conservatives come home today is really the question for me okay well I'm told that
00:33:54 our reporter Jonathan Bradley at the Calgary headquarters sorry the UCP headquarters in
00:34:00 Calgary, has UCP cabinet minister Mike Ellis with him? If so, we're going to bring him in. In just
00:34:08 a moment, we'll bring him in. Actually, I'm told that the polls have closed. Let's go to Dave
00:34:13 Naylor in the newsroom before we go to Jonathan Bradley at the UCP headquarters.
00:34:19 Hey, Derek. The bell has told. It is eight o'clock. Voting is over and the counting has begun.
00:34:25 And let's hope they do it quicker than City of Calgary vote counters,
00:34:30 because if that's the case, we'll be here until in the early morning hours.
00:34:35 Very good.
00:34:36 All right.
00:34:37 Thank you, Dave.
00:34:38 And as we've said, we're expecting a real big flurry of results,
00:34:42 quite a few results very early because there's been so much advanced voting,
00:34:46 and it's all been electronically counted.
00:34:48 So it's not going to be poor grandma at the polling station doing it. 0.99
00:34:53 The only thing we can confirm is that Derek Fildebrandt will not win Chester McStraffmore this election.
00:34:57 I don't think I'm going to do very well this time.
00:35:00 Okay, well, we're going to move as soon as he's in front of his camera.
00:35:04 We're going to go to Jonathan Bradley at the UCP headquarters, standing by with UCP Cabinet Minister Mike Ellis.
00:35:13 Jonathan, you've got Mike Ellis there.
00:35:15 What's happening?
00:35:17 Unfortunately, Mike Ellis got dragged aside.
00:35:20 He's grabbed to do another interview.
00:35:21 but what i can say right now is if the arena is filling up uh there's more people coming in
00:35:26 there's just more anticipation and the vibes are coming there's more positive thank you all right
00:35:35 all right uh so uh josh let's actually let's talk uh i'm gonna go to both of you about this but um
00:35:41 the consolidation of the conservative vote uh it was pretty consult almost entirely consolidated
00:35:48 last time under Jason Kenney, but everyone
00:35:50 went on to UCP, gone.
00:35:52 But under Jason Kenney, it also
00:35:54 broke wide open again. We had
00:35:56 the Wild Rose Independence Party,
00:35:58 despite having no seats, no money,
00:36:00 no real profile
00:36:02 or leader with profile.
00:36:04 It was up around 15 percentage points
00:36:06 for a while.
00:36:08 There was a real danger that was going to continue to
00:36:10 grow. They'd probably get some floor crossings
00:36:12 at some point.
00:36:16 But Daniel,
00:36:17 with Daniel Smith's ascension as leader
00:36:19 that's come back in
00:36:21 why don't you tell us about
00:36:23 why you think she was able to
00:36:26 reconsolidate the conservative
00:36:28 and populist vote
00:36:29 and what she did to do it and perhaps
00:36:31 how perilous it is to try
00:36:33 and keep it. Well I think Kenny's issue
00:36:36 was that once he did consolidate
00:36:37 the vote he almost lost
00:36:39 track of what the people were saying on the ground
00:36:42 with the
00:36:43 re-election of Justin Trudeau in 2019
00:36:45 there was a populist wave there was a lot of frustration i think kenny had his eggs in the
00:36:49 andrew sheer basket that didn't work out and as he kind of struggled with uh the fair deal panel
00:36:57 stuff and covid it really created a fracture within the party smith came in and uh with the
00:37:03 wild rose independence party at 20 percent uh made the highlight of her campaign uh the alberta
00:37:08 sovereignty act with uh within a united canada that was passed in november this year or of last
00:37:14 year um and it's it really it's designed to kind of add some protection against federal intrusions
00:37:20 into provincial policy jurisdiction um we've seen that over the years with the impact assessment act
00:37:26 uh the no more pipeline which is otherwise known as the no more pipelines law we've seen it with
00:37:30 the don't with the tanker ban we've seen it with the carbon tax we've seen a whole bunch of federal
00:37:36 policies that directly intervene in provincial jurisdiction it's led to job losses and economic
00:37:41 uh well chaos within within the province of alberta so i think there was a lot of frustration
00:37:46 directed at the federal government we saw that even with the with the convoy to ottawa and the
00:37:51 impact that that had on the policies within the united conservative party uh so i think that's a
00:37:56 big reason why uh canny was forced to side smith did a good job during the leadership campaign of
00:38:01 communicating these issues effectively of putting a policy uh set of policy ideas on the table that
00:38:07 brought these people back into the fold and and really at the end of the day it does come down
00:38:11 to to whether or not these these policies are enough to hold the coalition together whether
00:38:16 it's some of the the pcs that were in that marriage stick around and show up at the polls despite
00:38:22 a lot of the distracting storylines we've seen in the mainstream media uh okay yeah thank you um
00:38:28 I generally agree with that.
00:38:32 But, David, you've kind of alluded to what could happen if Smith doesn't follow through.
00:38:39 So let's just operate on the likely but not guaranteed assumption that she comes through tonight.
00:38:45 Now, we know being an Alberta Premier, it's a good time.
00:38:49 It's not a long time, especially an Alberta Conservative Premier.
00:38:53 I was running the math today.
00:38:55 the last time a conservative premier in alberta finished a term was 2004 uh that was rov klein
00:39:03 his last election that's the last time a conservative premier finished election
00:39:05 i was in high school someone born the last that year the last time if you vote now they can vote
00:39:12 and die for their country now it's been that long the last time a premier uh of any party
00:39:19 left office of their own free will without being pushed out neither an election or their own party
00:39:23 revolt was Peter Lougheed in 1985, the year I was born. It is a perilous job. Now, so just the
00:39:32 history works against anyone who's a conservative leader trying to stay in their job. But, you know,
00:39:36 Smith won the leadership of the UCP on a very populist anti-establishment wave, anti-Ottawa,
00:39:42 anti-lockdowns, anti-mandates. But she's softened a lot of these things to try to appeal to the
00:39:49 general electorate, which, you know, a lot of people said was probably necessary, but she
00:39:53 softened a lot of these things. What risk is there for Daniel Smith? If she comes through tonight,
00:39:59 where's the risk to her leadership? Is it from kind of the Kenneite PC moderates who think she's
00:40:05 too radical? Or is it from the more right-leaning populist Wildrose side of the party that expects
00:40:11 her to pay up with what she got elected on the leadership for? Where's the danger from? 0.81
00:40:15 I think the biggest danger is from the Kenney people, to be honest, because I think they're
00:40:19 the ones that don't trust her i think if you look at the people josh made a good point that uh
00:40:24 the wild rose kind of pop more populous rural uh conservative base is with danielle right now
00:40:31 they're they're the ones that are showing up to volunteer they're the ones that are coming out to
00:40:34 vote and i think that if you look at the people who are upset right now the people who are calling
00:40:39 danielle smith crazy for example why are they calling danielle smith crazy because she supported
00:40:44 that group of people that you're talking about.
00:40:46 So I think after this, if she was to attack really hard to the left
00:40:50 and to try to appease the Kenne-ites, 0.84
00:40:53 then we would probably be in a different situation.
00:40:56 But I think the real risk comes from people who feel like she's crazy,
00:41:01 which, I mean, why are people saying that she's crazy?
00:41:03 Because she stood up for these people.
00:41:05 So I would say right now, the major threat is from the Kenney side.
00:41:10 Okay.
00:41:11 All right, we're going to go to,
00:41:12 uh we're gonna bring in some new panelists soon but first we're gonna go to arthur green
00:41:16 our reporter up in edmonton at the ndp headquarters uh arthur
00:41:23 all right i don't know uh we're gonna have to go to arthur up in uh ndp headquarters in edmonton
00:41:28 arthur tell us what's happening up there right now uh again derek uh people are starting to trickle
00:41:35 into the room here uh i mean there's been there's lots of hugs and uh and handshakes uh being given
00:41:41 tons of interviews uh being done the western standard hasn't been granted any interviews
00:41:47 with anybody from the nvp of course uh other than that i mean the optimism in the room uh
00:41:52 spirits seem high uh people are friendly uh you know it's uh it's it's it seems like
00:41:59 there's about to be a party breakout here uh here jerry but of course we'll have to wait for the
00:42:04 Thank you, Arthur. We're going to go to Jonathan Bradley at the UCP headquarters now.
00:42:15 Jonathan, tell us what's going on.
00:42:18 Derek, it's Mike Ellis here.
00:42:20 Oh, we got Mike Ellis there. Just a strange lighting.
00:42:23 Mike, thank you for joining us tonight.
00:42:26 Very good. Thank you for coming.
00:42:29 Mike, you've been representing Calgary West since 2015.
00:42:35 Actually, no, I think 2014 in the bio.
00:42:37 14, yeah.
00:42:39 14.
00:42:40 Now, you're in battleground Calgary, but your constituency is not considered necessarily a battleground constituency.
00:42:49 Although I know you're going to say you don't take any votes for granted.
00:42:52 I know that.
00:42:54 I don't take any for granted.
00:42:55 You're right there.
00:42:56 But how are you feeling about your chances and the party's overall chances in Calgary tonight?
00:43:01 Yeah, I mean, the reality is, Derek, I'm actually very cautiously optimistic.
00:43:06 You know, I really saw a turning point right after the debate that was really noticed at the doors.
00:43:13 And I would say that it was even reinforced when we had the kind of the get together on Sutina,
00:43:21 that rally where we saw nearly 2,000 people show up very much, I would say, organically.
00:43:28 I mean, I had people stopping me from Calgary West saying, you know, we heard about this.
00:43:33 We just wanted to show up and they just want to be a part of the excitement.
00:43:36 So the reality is this.
00:43:38 I am very optimistic and, you know, obviously cautiously optimistic.
00:43:42 That's the policeman in me, Derek.
00:43:43 But I am optimistic heading into seeing the results here.
00:43:47 uh what do you think is driving the tightness of the race in calgary calgary is long thought of as
00:43:54 a relatively conservative bastion uh you know some downtown pockets have voted liberal in days gone
00:44:01 by or ndp more recently but um and the ndp won a good number of seats obviously in calgary in 2015
00:44:08 but you know that could be chalked up at least in part to a so-called vote split between the
00:44:12 Wild Rose and progressive conservatives.
00:44:14 But what do you think is, because the NDP is obviously competitive right now.
00:44:21 What have you guys, what's been your main counterattack towards the NDP's encroachment
00:44:26 in Calgary?
00:44:27 Well, Derek, I think the NDP have been very successful in their fear and smear, which
00:44:31 is something that, as you know, very well, that they've been very good at that.
00:44:37 certainly over the last time that I've been in office, since 2014.
00:44:43 Look, I mean, we've been offering people hope, hope and optimism.
00:44:48 You know that very much that I have talked about public safety, mental health and addictions,
00:44:54 making sure that we're giving people hope and not heroin,
00:44:58 making sure that we're making sure that people feel safe in Calgary and Edmonton and rural Alberta,
00:45:03 as well as ensuring that we're stewards of the economy.
00:45:07 when it comes to jobs, the economy, and making sure that there is an actual path in the future
00:45:13 to make sure that we have a fiscally stable government, you know, going into the future.
00:45:22 All about your leader and premier, Danielle Smith, saying, you know, you can't trust her.
00:45:29 uh you know she's radical uh the i think your party on the other hand has been trying to
00:45:37 well kind of reflect uh the ndp's own record back at it about their uh their inability to
00:45:45 responsibly steward the economy and and the the books um what have you heard at the doors during
00:45:53 this campaign i know you've been campaigning quite a bit in your constituency and possibly
00:45:56 and others around Calgary,
00:45:57 role helping other candidates.
00:45:59 What was it you were hearing at the doors
00:46:01 and what were the biggest challenges
00:46:03 you were hearing at the doors?
00:46:05 Yeah, well, like I said,
00:46:06 the campaign that the NDP did
00:46:12 as far as fear and spear,
00:46:13 yeah, we were hearing that at the doors.
00:46:15 But again, I would say that,
00:46:16 you know, after the debate,
00:46:19 I think people saw somebody who is reasonable
00:46:22 and somebody who looked like
00:46:24 a real leader of the province.
00:46:26 and we saw an immediate turnaround after that debate um and uh you know this is this again
00:46:33 was demonstrated by the fact that we had so many people show up at that rally
00:46:37 all right well thank you so much for joining us tonight mike and uh best of luck in your calgary
00:46:42 west constituency thanks eric all the best good to see you thank you okay well uh we've got some
00:46:49 new panelists in the studio right now we've got chris sims alberta director of the canadian
00:46:53 Taxpayers Federation. Hey, Chris. Hi, thanks for having us. Thank you for coming. And we've got
00:46:59 D.B. Cooper, that is Dr. Barry Cooper, a political scientist from the University of Calgary.
00:47:07 Maybe I'll start with you, Mr. D.B. Cooper. Okay. The debate, I think was by most measures,
00:47:16 not a huge turning point in the campaign. There was no knockout punch that everyone's looking for 0.98
00:47:21 and almost never comes in these things.
00:47:25 But I think it might be fair to say that the NDP had set,
00:47:28 much of the media had set the bar so low for Danielle Smith, 0.98
00:47:30 they expected her to come out as the Tasmanian devil drooling at the mouth. 1.00
00:47:34 And she came out and appeared, I think, to most reasonable people,
00:47:38 to be reasonable, calm, and measured, and chipper.
00:47:43 How much of a, do you think the debate had much influence on the election?
00:47:48 Well, actually, I think it did.
00:47:49 And partly because the Conservatives' strategy was really not to get into a debate.
00:47:56 It was for Danielle to make the kind of points that she wanted to make, whatever the question was that was supposed to be debated.
00:48:04 And I think she did it quite eloquently.
00:48:07 I mean, she'd been on talk radio for so long, you'd expect her to be eloquent.
00:48:11 And I think she was.
00:48:13 On the other hand, Rachel Notley tended to be much more critical in a bad sense, sort of angry, irritated at Danielle. 1.00
00:48:28 And also, I had the sense that she was irritated that Danielle was doing so well.
00:48:36 I think that was part of her problem.
00:48:39 um chris you um well you've got you've got my old job at the canadian taxpayers federation yeah
00:48:46 this is kind of surreal yeah yeah and i've kind of got your old job you were at sun news network
00:48:50 this is i brought them brought them a coffee mug so similar to the western standard one there we go
00:48:57 um you're you know you're you're a taxpayer watchdog uh i know what you do here but um
00:49:04 this election seemed to be not a lot of talk of fiscal restraint. I mean, conservatives kind of
00:49:11 get a pass on fiscal issues the way the NDP get a pass on social issues, healthcare, education.
00:49:17 We just kind of assume, most voters just kind of assume one party's good at one, one's good
00:49:21 the other. It's just kind of brand affiliation parties have with these things. But both parties
00:49:26 didn't really do all that much, I think, making the case for any kind of real budget restraint,
00:49:32 no? Well, we were happy to see what the UCP government did before they dissolved into an
00:49:37 election. So during the budget, they announced that they would have balanced budget legislation.
00:49:43 And this is a big one. It sounds boring, but hear me out, guys, that they would restrain spending
00:49:49 to the rate of growth of inflation and population growth. That is something you know, Derek,
00:49:55 that the CTF has been asking for since the 1990s. Like the Backstreet Boys were top of the charts
00:50:00 when we were saying, folks, can you please rein in your spending to match population growth and
00:50:05 the rate of inflation? And then they did it. They passed the budget and they passed the law saying,
00:50:11 you know what, we're going to handcuff ourselves. And they said, we're going to pay down the debt
00:50:14 in a serious way. They're going to put 50% of their cash surplus down onto it. And they'd have
00:50:19 balanced budget legislation. So that all happened just before the writ was dropped. And so we were
00:50:24 really pleased with the Taxpayers Federation to see those commitments. Then we heard from the UCP
00:50:29 that they wanted to create a new lower bracket of income tax. So your first $60,000 of earnings
00:50:35 will be taxed at a lower rate at 8% instead of where it is right now at 10%. That was good.
00:50:42 And credit where it is due. The NDP said that they were going to reduce the small business tax down
00:50:47 to zero. Unfortunately, during the same announcement, they also announced they were
00:50:51 going to increase the regular business tax rate from 8% all the way up to 11%. So we were happy
00:50:57 to see some of those commitments. We think it was pretty substantive. It was interesting to see you
00:51:02 mentioned the debate. It was interesting to see Danielle Smith sticking to kind of those points 0.97
00:51:07 while smiling and talking about substance instead of using a lot more rhetoric. And it's something
00:51:13 that I think in communications is important. Show, don't tell. Give substance, don't just talk. And I
00:51:20 think that was the difference during the debate, actually. Okay. Well, I think we've actually got
00:51:25 uh some of the very first polls coming uh very very first results coming in now so why don't
00:51:31 we go to dave nailer our news editor in the newsroom right now uh with uh where we're at
00:51:39 uh starting to get trickle polls uh coming in derek uh right now there's uh just uh there's
00:51:46 1900 polls in total we've got results from uh four of those 1900 polls uh the uh
00:51:53 And the UCP has 46 of those votes, and New Democrats have 17.
00:52:01 The Advantage Party of Alberta charging them right along with one vote.
00:52:07 So early, early days yet.
00:52:10 And those writings are rural writings, Peace River and Drayton Valley, Devon.
00:52:18 So nothing from any cities yet, just the rural ones.
00:52:21 Actually, I'll correct you there. I'm seeing one poll voting, reporting from Calgary, Buffalo. One vote, just one vote from this poll. And it's the UCP. So that means the UCP is winning with 100% of the vote in Calgary, Buffalo, on track to defeat Joe Ceci.
00:52:43 Are we going to declare them elected?
00:52:48 Well, you know, I feel maybe a little more confident about those rural ones, but I'm not going to go on quite a limb and say the UCP is going to win Calgary, Buffalo, the most urban left-leaning riding in Calgary by 100%.
00:53:02 I'm not going to quite go on that yet.
00:53:08 Okay, well, I guess we'll just bring up the initial election map showing our leading right now, minus that.
00:53:15 So, Mika, why don't we just bring up the map?
00:53:17 I know it's not very much, but actually, the two you're really seeing here on the big screen, it might just be one poll in each of those reporting.
00:53:27 But you can almost call those ones right away.
00:53:29 That's Drayton Valley, Devon, and Peace River.
00:53:35 I'll call them now.
00:53:36 I mean, out of respect to the voters, I guess we'll wait for a little more.
00:53:39 But, I mean, it's...
00:53:41 Pretty confident.
00:53:42 It's happening.
00:53:43 Mr. Cooper, what are you expecting tonight?
00:53:47 Beyond the polls, the polls are showing what they're showing,
00:53:50 but what are you expecting at a more granular level?
00:53:54 Well, that's a very good question,
00:53:56 because I actually think that things may be a little more volatile,
00:54:01 particularly in Calgary, than a lot of the polling has suggested,
00:54:05 which means that it seems entirely possible to me
00:54:09 that the UCP might do a lot better in Calgary than they have been, than the pollsters have
00:54:16 said they're going to do. Partly because of the methodology of polling. And what is
00:54:24 missed? Particularly ages. The people that tend to vote more progressively tend to be
00:54:35 under or sort of overrepresented in the polls and the and the people who vote conservative
00:54:41 tend to be underrepresented so we could be in for some very interesting upsets 1.00
00:54:48 or at least upsets in the sense that they're not what is anticipated by the pollsters
00:54:52 okay uh before we go back to you chris uh i want to go to uh the ucp headquarters here
00:54:58 down at the Big Four in Calgary, where we've got Peter McCaffrey standing by.
00:55:04 Peter, thank you for joining us, coming to us from the Calgary headquarters.
00:55:08 I know we're only looking at the very, very, very earliest ones yet.
00:55:13 Practically, this means the UCP is leading in Calgary-Buffalo by 100%,
00:55:16 since there's only one vote counted.
00:55:18 It happens to be the UCP.
00:55:21 Some cheering in the background right now.
00:55:24 What are you seeing there right now?
00:55:27 yeah it's very early i hope you can hear me it is pretty loud here it's very early so far
00:55:32 uh so i won't won't get into any of the details of the actual numbers so far
00:55:36 um but one of the things i will be looking at tonight and this will be where i'll really start
00:55:39 to look at some of the numbers is calgary bow calgary bow is the writing that i'm going to
00:55:44 keep my own i could i could list off all of the tight seats but calgary bow is an interesting one
00:55:48 because if the ndt can't win in calgary i really think that they don't have a path to win here
00:55:54 they already have a narrower path to get to the 44 that they need and if they can't get it in
00:55:58 calgary bow i think they're really going to struggle in a bunch of other areas it's also
00:56:02 an interesting writing because of the candidates so you've got dimitri nikolaitis uh former uh
00:56:06 current uh i guess incumbent uh for the seat uh he's been the advanced education minister
00:56:13 and uh daniel smith and his opponent is drew farrell long long time uh counselor here in
00:56:20 calgary uh so drew barrel can't roll a sitting cabinet minister here in calgary then i think
00:56:31 yes there's a bunch of other types each there's a whole bunch i'll be looking at the numbers
00:56:35 specifically but calgary bow in particular if you want to pick one so i'm going to ask you the same
00:56:40 questions i have some of our other uh guests here um oh boy it's getting noisy there for your top
00:56:47 three bellwether constituencies so bow i would include as you know so like uh where are your top
00:56:52 including bow um if name three constituencies that if one party wins this they win the win the night
00:56:59 so you've already named bow what are the two other bellwethers you're looking for that if you win
00:57:03 that they're likely to die it's hard to name only three but off the top of my head if you force me
00:57:09 pick three i'll go for bow uh glenn moore and calgary cross um if if the if if the ucp pick
00:57:18 up two of those it's over uh if they pick up three then it could actually be quite a big win
00:57:23 uh if you're going to get one of those then it might be a tight night
00:57:28 very interesting um uh what do you expect from tonight overall like i know there's the polls
00:57:36 and we've all got our thoughts but uh what are you what are you expecting to see you know if
00:57:41 if you had a six pack on it uh what would be your best good uh my own personal projection is about
00:57:48 50 seats for the ucp uh but this is such a such a weird election so that 50 seats is based purely
00:57:55 off what the polls are showing and assuming the polls are accurate um but it's such a weird
00:57:59 election that even a small difference between uh what the polls are showing in the reality could
00:58:04 wildly swing it so for example if the ndp outperformed the polls by just a couple of points
00:58:09 we could have a narrow ndp government if the ucp outperformed the polls by a couple of points
00:58:15 we could actually see the ucp get a higher vote percentage than they did under jason kinney in
00:58:20 2019. it would still be a much tighter election seat wise because effectively the alberta party
00:58:25 but you could get a scenario where they used to actually do better than they did in 2019
00:58:31 purely on a vote percentage so that's it's a really weird election couple of points
00:58:36 either way compared to what the polls are showing could give dramatically different results uh my
00:58:41 last question for you is about that alberta party vote um i was saying earlier before you were on
00:58:47 the ndp has managed to completely cannibalize the liberal vote to the point where it is entirely
00:58:53 non-existent now but they in this election appear to have uh digested the alberta party vote the
00:58:59 ucp vote if the polls are to be believed is going to be actually fairly relatively steady compared
00:59:05 to 2019 the difference being that the ndp have eaten up the um uh the alberta party vote uh how
00:59:14 big i guess a two-part question how big a difference do you think that'll make and why
00:59:18 do you think the alberto uh the alberto party vote ndp rather than ucp yeah so you're right
00:59:25 the alberto party vote has really collapsed from the sort of 10 or 12 percent we were seeing
00:59:29 at the last election the polls down to 2 34 percent i think they're going to start moving
00:59:34 at that because they're not even running in most of the seats i think they're only running in less
00:59:38 than a third of the seats so honestly they'll be lucky if they get two percent um almost all of
00:59:43 that vote's gone likely to the ndp based on what we're seeing in the bowls and and like i said it's
00:59:47 It's made it a two-way race, which means, honestly, yeah, the UCP could outperform even how they did in 2019, and it would still, on a seat basis, be a lot tighter.
00:59:56 Very good.
00:59:56 Okay, thank you much for joining us, Peter.
00:59:58 I very much appreciate your time.
01:00:00 No problem.
01:00:01 Catch you later.
01:00:03 Chris, the arena deal.
01:00:06 Very weird.
01:00:08 Daniel Smith obviously supporting it.
01:00:09 She announces it.
01:00:10 But Rachel Notley opposing it, but not necessarily on principle, just that she kind of thinks she'd get a better deal.
01:00:20 I know you probably think of this from a policy perspective, but from put your pundit hat on for a second, if you would be allowed to.
01:00:27 Sure.
01:00:28 Do you think the whole fight over the arena has had much of an impact on the election in Calgary?
01:00:33 I think it has for the casual voter, especially one, obviously, who's an NHL fan, a Flames fan who lives in Calgary, which is why I think they went and did it. So I think it's one of those things where they're trying to get people into what's called the easy politics. So who doesn't like, you know, chocolate? Who doesn't like potato chips? Who doesn't love NHL hockey? Everybody does. You know, only communists don't like hockey, right? And so it's easy for them to wedge the other on this issue.
01:01:01 However, NHL owners and players are multimillionaires. They can fundraise themselves. It shouldn't be coming from taxpayers to pay for NHL rink.
01:01:12 Now, I will say there was a bit of communications craftsmanship that went into this deal because the province, Daniel Smith and her team, got Mayor Gondek and her municipal taxpayers to pay for most of the freight of the NHL rink.
01:01:31 Now, the province just put up taxpayers' money for the amateur baby rink next to the mama rink and for the transit station nearby and for the bridge upgrades.
01:01:40 who doesn't like those things are you opposed to those mom and pop apple pie sort of things
01:01:46 so that was quite clever so what we would have said to that and we did in a opinion editorial
01:01:52 which you your western standard was so kind to run for us is that okay folks if you want to build a
01:01:58 baby rink for amateur sports and you want to build a new shiny transit station and upgrade your bridge
01:02:04 let's talk about that let's have a separate conversation about whether or not you guys
01:02:09 need to spend money on that. But they didn't. They connected it directly to the NHL deal.
01:02:16 Dr. Cooper, I'm going to talk about kind of the smaller parties that we are almost certainly not
01:02:22 going to see up on the screen tonight. One, the Alberta party, which did have a presence in the
01:02:29 last election, had somewhere between eight and 10% of the vote, came in with a caucus of three or
01:02:35 for MLAs, had a prominent leader, former Edmonton mayor and cabinet minister, completely disappearing
01:02:43 and that vote going to the NDP. And then the other, I guess, third party we could say is
01:02:49 Wildrose Independence Party, which kind of flared up since the last election, came to
01:02:56 about 15% in the polls, even without any money in MLAs, threatening the right flank, the
01:03:03 right populist flank of the UCP under Kenney. And that's since completely gone away, it seems,
01:03:09 and come back into the UCP fold. Can you tell us about maybe what the causes of both of those
01:03:15 phenomenons are and what impact that might have tonight? Well, I would guess with the Alberta
01:03:23 party that a lot of their support was up north rather than, say, in medicine hat, whereas the
01:03:30 opposite was true with with WIPA and they I was I knew some of the people involved in that and
01:03:39 they seemed to be very much against what Jason Kenney was doing to their sort of natural home
01:03:46 in a big party and they were they were very upset with him rather than with the sort of stated
01:03:53 principles of the conservatives so when when Danielle Smith became the new leader she pretty
01:03:59 much took the wind completely out of their sails because she did about 98% of what they were going
01:04:04 to do anyway, except for the independence part. And we'll, I'm sure we'll get to that sooner or
01:04:10 later anyway. But I think that's mainly what happened. It was, it was, she, she took the,
01:04:17 the main thing that drove the Wildrose Independence Party, which was just like of,
01:04:24 of what jason was doing and and what about uh maybe a bit more about the alberta party though
01:04:30 because uh it had votes in the last election a significant amount and it's just gone um yeah
01:04:36 is that because the alberta party is at its core a kind of left-leaning party or is it maybe more
01:04:43 along the media narrative that the ndp is the new center i would i would say it's that they were
01:04:49 certainly not a kind of populist party, put it that way. I don't know what appeal they would have
01:04:54 to rural Alberta. And I guess the NDP did a good job of persuading them that they're their real
01:05:03 representatives. And I guess a lot of Alberta party supporters agreed with it. But I mean,
01:05:08 I've got to say, I haven't paid much attention to the Alberta party for some time. And that may be
01:05:13 why. Most of the media is completely obsessed with them, even though they've been really a
01:05:18 non-entity most of this time. Okay, well, we're going to go to, actually, we're going to check
01:05:26 in with Dave Naylor in the newsroom to give us an update on new polls coming in.
01:05:33 Well, Derek, latest count, we have 14 polls in across the province. We have the Alberta New
01:05:40 Democratic Party leading or elected in five seats, and we have the UCP leading and elected
01:05:46 in 14 seats uh in terms of uh popular vote the ndp currently leading at 52.48 percent
01:05:57 the ucp at 43.14 percent so we're getting uh getting a bit uh a few more polls coming in and
01:06:05 just update you on calgary buffalo ucp still ahead by one vote to nil
01:06:11 that's the big one well i'm not putting that one up on the map uh you know i'll actually uh nico
01:06:18 why don't we put the map up on the board right now uh these are writings that have got more than
01:06:24 a single vote reporting there are some constituencies of single vote reporting we're
01:06:28 just not putting those up on the board but these are kind of uh davy you'll see the map here it's
01:06:34 showing largely what we would expect uh it's still very early coming in but you know you got peace
01:06:39 River, Central Peace, Notley, West Yellowhead, Camrose, Cardson-Six-Sica, Calgary-Fish Creek,
01:06:46 early polls all leaning to the UCP right now, and Edmonton Castle-Downs at Edmonton City Centre.
01:06:55 Very much as expected, the early polls there leaning for the NDP. Is there anything not up
01:07:00 on the map yet of note that you should fly for us?
01:07:04 just in terms of the popular vote Derek I'll point out Edmonton Ellerslie almost 800 votes
01:07:13 for the NDP candidate 384 for the UCP so that'll be where that large increase in popular vote came
01:07:21 from from the NDP because because we're just so early in the county yeah I didn't know that
01:07:27 Ellerslie had reported but yeah we've got it up on the board and I would be very shocked if
01:07:32 if that one went out another way.
01:07:36 Just know for our guests in the studio,
01:07:37 you do not need earpieces,
01:07:39 just microphones here.
01:07:41 Okay, Dave.
01:07:44 Thank you for joining us
01:07:45 and check back with us soon
01:07:47 when you got something new for us.
01:07:49 You bet.
01:07:50 Okay, joining us at the Calgary studio right now
01:07:53 are two former progressive conservative
01:07:56 cabinet ministers.
01:07:57 We've got Christine Cusinelli
01:07:59 who represented Calgary Curry
01:08:01 from what year did you first? 2012 to 2015. 2012 to 2015. And you were a cabinet minister in which
01:08:10 portfolios? Tourism, parks and recreation. Yeah. And Jonathan Dennis, former minister of justice
01:08:15 and attorney general representing Calgary, Acadia from 2000, was it eight? 2008 to 2015.
01:08:20 2008 to 2015 in Calgary, Acadia. Both interesting writings tonight. I think the smart money is
01:08:30 curry's probably going back to the ndp it's possible it's a tough riding to win it's a very
01:08:36 urban riding so the demographics are kind of tough for a conservative to come out on but i i have to
01:08:41 say i'm hoping that it's going to be a surprise tonight i live in the riding and you know from
01:08:48 what i can tell people talking to my neighbors and so on and just looking around i think it's
01:08:54 looking not too bad so i've got my fingers crossed for nick milliken and i'm hoping that he can pull
01:08:59 through. So Jonathan, you're representing one of the, you represented one of the writings that
01:09:06 everyone's talking about tonight as a extreme bellwether, Calgary, Acadia. We've got Tyler
01:09:14 Shandro there. He was a health minister under Jason Kenney, shuffled out after, you know,
01:09:20 a lot of the COVID stuff that probably didn't go down so well, shuffled out to justice. So funny,
01:09:25 now we have two justice ministers from the same constituency. I know you've been involved in a
01:09:32 lot of the Calgary campaigns, but maybe we'll start with your old stomping grounds in Acadia first.
01:09:36 What are you expecting to see tonight there? I expect to see that it will be a loss or a victory
01:09:41 by under five points. One of the things to always remind yourself of is that, especially in the
01:09:46 urban ridings, the local candidate matters less than five percent out of the equation. People
01:09:50 typically will either vote for the leader or the party, and there's also the demograph of the
01:09:54 riding. So the southern part of the riding, like Willow Park, will probably go south of the UCP.
01:09:59 Northern part, Fairview, and the western part, Southwood, will probably go NDP. Those were
01:10:05 areas that were lost last time. I'm going to say it's too close to call, but I would say that
01:10:11 Shandra probably will win that by five points. That riding, in my view, would fall before Calgary 0.96
01:10:16 Glenmore. The NDP have put in both strong ground games. I took a drive-through earlier last week
01:10:23 that the sign count is almost equal.
01:10:25 Wow.
01:10:26 So if I get what you're saying correctly,
01:10:29 if the NDP win Acadia, they've probably won.
01:10:32 And if they win Glenmore, they've definitely won.
01:10:34 Yes, I would say specifically Glenmore.
01:10:36 Glenmore was an interesting one in 2015,
01:10:39 again, with a terrible campaign.
01:10:40 Less than 10 votes or something.
01:10:41 Six votes and a judicial recount.
01:10:43 So that was with a vote split.
01:10:45 So the interesting thing is I do think Whitney Isaac
01:10:48 has been a very strong local MLA.
01:10:51 She's well-known.
01:10:52 She's in with a lot of the communities there, and I would suggest that the advantage does go to her.
01:10:57 I would probably call that with about a 10-point victory.
01:11:00 You know what?
01:11:01 We're going to have a reunion of PC Cabinet Ministers here.
01:11:05 We've got standing by Ted Morton, former PC Cabinet Minister, Minister of Finance, Minister of Energy, and leadership contender.
01:11:16 And don't forget, the best Premier we never had.
01:11:18 a man who if he had been become premier we may have never heard the name wild rose before
01:11:23 uh so let's bring in uh dr ted morton uh i think coming to us uh actually i'm not going to disclose
01:11:31 this location i don't think you'd like that uh but uh dr morton thank you very much for joining
01:11:36 us tonight uh what are you expecting to see as the as the first poll start to trickle in here
01:11:42 oh we can't hear dr morton
01:11:48 uh dr martin we cannot hear you i think your microphone might be off
01:11:54 there we are how's that okay there there there we are sir so i said i i don't know what i'm
01:12:03 predicting but i know what i'm hoping and that's for a ucp majority i would hope uh in the range
01:12:09 of 50 seats well that's an absolute shocker sir um i know it's shocking uh in your estimation i
01:12:19 mean you are you're right you've been right in the thick of alberta politics but in alberta's
01:12:23 changing um some would say for the better some would say for the worse but uh what do you think
01:12:28 makes uh explains uh there being such a at least predicted tight race tonight and the early results
01:12:35 are probably two aren't good enough to tell yet but based on the polls why do you think we're in
01:12:40 such a knife fight tonight with with an ndp that against a unified right you know the logic goes
01:12:48 should have no business being competitive the simple answer to that question is simply that
01:12:54 for the past 30 or 40 years the the left of center's vote was split between the ndp and
01:13:00 the liberals so one of the reasons you had a 40 40 uh what 44 year conservative uh dynasty
01:13:09 was the left the anti-conservative vote was split the liberals have disappeared and all of a sudden
01:13:14 you have and then that's what happened in 2015 right the settling vote vote splitting was on
01:13:20 the right instead of on the left um you know i i've talked with some of our previous guests
01:13:27 before you were on about this but um you know kenny uh managed to bring the parties together
01:13:32 in 2017 uh came to a thumping majority in 2019 consolidating the conservative vote
01:13:38 uh but in the years since you know a combination of his stances on ottawa and actions during covid
01:13:46 he uh there was a real splinter at least a real chance of the right splintering again you had the
01:13:52 the Wild Rose Independence Party, which started showing a real heartbeat in the polls. Since
01:13:58 Danielle Smith has come in, that vote has come back to the UCP. How critical do you think,
01:14:06 but some of the criticism has been that maybe she tried too hard to bring that Wild Rose vote back,
01:14:10 and she should have been chasing the Alberta party vote. Do you think that's a fair analysis,
01:14:16 or was it more important to bring that vote back in from the right flank,
01:14:20 rather than chasing the center, perhaps?
01:14:24 Well, first of all, I'd say with respect to Jason Kenney,
01:14:28 it was very unfortunate that he had suddenly out of nowhere came COVID
01:14:34 and something that nobody was prepared for.
01:14:37 He did not handle it well, but a lot of politicians didn't,
01:14:41 and it was unfortunate to lose him.
01:14:43 I would say he picked up some habits, cabinet and executive habits in Ottawa that are probably necessary in Ottawa, stricter party discipline and kind of more top-down control, which do not work in Alberta and do not work in Edmonton and particularly did not work in the new UCP caucus.
01:15:06 So I think it's unfortunate that Jason's still not leading the UCP yet.
01:15:13 But as far as Danielle's strategy goes, I think she's done the right thing is consolidate, you know, talk about the UCP record. 0.65
01:15:21 And part of that, of course, is Jason's record and talk about the NDP record.
01:15:25 The four years under the NDP, they didn't stand up for Alberta.
01:15:29 They raised taxes and did a bunch of things to make us less competitive.
01:15:32 and she is a member of the federal NDP party.
01:15:37 You're a provincial NDP, you're a federal NDP
01:15:39 and the federal NDPs are what crop up Justin Trudeau
01:15:42 and Justin Trudeau is very, very anti-Alberta.
01:15:48 Okay, I'm gonna come back to you in a moment, Dr. Morton,
01:15:51 but I wanna bring in Dave Naylor
01:15:52 for a moment from our newsroom here.
01:15:54 I think we've just had a whole rash of polls closing.
01:15:58 There's now 105 polls closed
01:16:00 and some early results coming in.
01:16:05 Dave, why don't you give us an update?
01:16:08 36 polls closed at the moment, Derek.
01:16:12 UCP leading or elected in 42.
01:16:16 The NDP leading or elected in 22.
01:16:21 So that 42 is very, very close to the needed majority number
01:16:26 with obviously lots more to come.
01:16:30 In terms of the popular vote, it's 51% for the NDP, 46% for the UCP.
01:16:43 So just a bit of a dump there.
01:16:45 And, you know, I don't see any shocks on the board.
01:16:50 Even Calgary Buffalo, we've got another poll coming in.
01:16:53 It's 11 to 8 for the NDP in that writing.
01:16:56 uh okay so i know some of these though are still some of these have got some real results in
01:17:03 some of them are still just one three votes or something what are the some of the ones uh on
01:17:08 that we can maybe put up on the board here as you know reliably leaning one way or another
01:17:14 well it looks like uh calgary fish creek uh is going to uh
01:17:20 i see the last uh
01:17:26 Update. They're going to be staying NDP. Edmonton Meadows, two to one there, 2,246 votes for the NDP, 1,263 for the UCP.
01:17:41 um cameras uh doubling of the uh almost a doubling of the uh the vote for the ucp there now
01:17:51 uh cyprus medicine hat uh 343 for ucp 47 for uh uh the ndp so that's uh off to a good start
01:18:02 drayton valley and devon also a significant lead for the ucp at the moment
01:18:09 Mooranville-St. Albert, 569 for the UCP, 262 for the NDP.
01:18:20 That's an important one to watch.
01:18:22 That one is a bellwether.
01:18:23 If the NDP wins that one, they have a real path to victory.
01:18:26 So if the UCP is holding there, then that would be a sign that that's one of their –
01:18:33 that's kind of a – that's a readout.
01:18:36 They have – like that's one of their final defensible positions.
01:18:39 it is and actually if you look down here that's 865 to 569 that's at the advanced polls and we're
01:18:44 seeing a trend of the last few elections that more and more that parties are pushing people to the
01:18:48 advanced polls uh i don't know if that's an indication before i want to call that i'd actually
01:18:52 like to see an actual poll from today i i wouldn't say that's enough to call it that's leaning that
01:18:58 way but it's enough votes in that it's a reasonable leaning it's not uh two guys and you're absolutely
01:19:03 right i think that that is a particular riding that is going to be an important one to watch
01:19:07 tonight um and in calgary like for me i'm looking at a couple of that's one of them that i'm looking
01:19:13 at um i think that lethbridge east is one that it's not necessarily a bellwether but some of the
01:19:19 ones that are more interesting that i'm watching to see which way it's going to go calgary cross
01:19:24 is going to be interesting um and i kind of think uh as far as bellwether i think that uh some of
01:19:31 the regions just outside of Edmonton uh refer to the donut area in in uh just outside of Edmonton
01:19:38 I think those are very very important for us um even beyond Calgary because we know that we're
01:19:43 not necessarily going to be um owning as many seats perhaps in Calgary as we we did in the last
01:19:49 election uh I want to bring uh Dr Ted Morton back in here um uh Dr Morton um you know you're uh
01:19:58 quite familiar, I think, with how turbulent leadership politics is in Alberta. Before you
01:20:05 were on earlier, I was kind of getting into the history of it. I was crunching numbers earlier
01:20:08 today. The last time an Alberta conservative premier finished a term was 2004. I was in high
01:20:15 school, and someone born that year can vote now. That's the last time a conservative Alberta
01:20:19 premier completed a term, and the last premier period of any party to leave office of their own
01:20:25 free will was the year I was born. That was Peter Loughey, 1985. So, I mean, you know, I'm not asking
01:20:34 you to jinx anything here, but even if Daniel Smith won a thumping majority, as the last
01:20:41 conservative premier did, it's not a very reliably, it's not a job that comes with a lot of job
01:20:48 security. So, if Daniel Smith manages to come out of tonight, small majority or reduced decent
01:20:55 majority. What do you think her chances of hanging on to the leadership for a full four years are 1.00
01:21:01 considering no one's done that in a generation? Yeah, you wonder why anybody would want the job
01:21:11 anymore. Okay, here's a storyline maybe you haven't heard yet. I think if you go from where
01:21:20 I started and ran for the PC leadership back in 2006. And I ran very explicitly on the Alberta
01:21:27 agenda, the firewall, the firewall letter, the reforms, I think are still needed to give Alberta
01:21:34 a fair deal in the way Canada works. I came close, but certainly the PC establishment didn't like me
01:21:41 and they got behind Denning. Of course, Denning didn't win either. Ed Stelmex sneaked up the
01:21:46 middle on second preferences. But if you go through those leadership votes over the past,
01:21:52 all the premiers you just mentioned, the Alberta agenda, the firewall, the fair deal reforms,
01:21:58 which when I advocated them back in 2004, were very much kind of on the margin of the party.
01:22:05 You know, by the time Jason united the party, you have the fair deal panel. The fair deal panel
01:22:11 endorses all of those um i was hoping we'd get to see jason take you know act on those but now
01:22:18 he's gone but uh danielle has gone one step further the sovereignty act so the types of reforms
01:22:25 i think i think the types of reforms that i was talking about 20 years ago uh 20 years ago have
01:22:33 moved to the very center of alberta politics i think the splitting of the right uh in alberta
01:22:40 contributes to the instability of the two parties and i think frankly the conservative party
01:22:44 establishment was very ill-advised to ignore the growing number of albertans you know look at
01:22:52 federal politics federally we voted overwhelmingly for the reform party canadian alliance and then
01:22:58 the conservative party of canada so the the pc party paid a heavy price for ignoring and frankly
01:23:05 treating rather badly uh those of us who came from the reform party roots uh in the past 20 years
01:23:12 but danielle has taken that to the center of the debate i see that as very positive and i think
01:23:19 that's why she's going to win tonight and why i think she's likely to have a more stable majority 1.00
01:23:24 in the next four years all right dr morton well thank you very much for joining us uh if you're
01:23:29 able to join us later i'd uh very much uh appreciate your insight as we get more of the
01:23:35 results uh if you're able to uh thank you uh so much for your being generous with your time
01:23:40 yeah you're welcome uh i'm also going to go to uh we're going to bring in uh dr tom flanagan soon
01:23:47 but first i'm just going to go to the uh floor of the ucp headquarters in calgary with uh
01:23:51 jonathan bradley he's got uh mike solberg here um mike solberg i think from uh northwest strategies
01:23:58 if i got that right new west new west new west affairs i didn't even get it close
01:24:05 uh mike actually i think there's a lot of uh development happening right now isn't there
01:24:12 yeah you know what there is we're starting to see some of the polls come in uh you know trickle in
01:24:18 as they do after the polls close way too early to call most of them but you know some early signs
01:24:24 of some of the riders that the ucb must win uh in order to pull this off but you know way too
01:24:30 early to call anything yeah uh well uh it's too early to call most of these things but uh what
01:24:38 are you expecting uh to see this evening i know you watch this stuff uh very closely the ucb are
01:24:44 going to form a majority movement the story of tonight is whether or not daniel smith is going
01:24:49 to be able to form a large enough party to keep the knives in their seats uh and and have enough
01:24:56 credibility going to the next six months uh that she doesn't have to worry about what conservatives
01:25:00 have done for 25 years which is our leader for four performance whether real or proceed
01:25:07 uh but i expect her to win tonight and she'll have a speech tonight uh and we'll see you know
01:25:12 what message he has for the general population but certainly the base of the party the party members
01:25:19 who hold a lot of sway in her future as well.
01:25:23 So we'll see how it plays out,
01:25:24 but way too early still to make any predictions.
01:25:27 I expect there'll be a long night.
01:25:30 I guess I want to get into that.
01:25:32 What you've alluded to there is the leadership fights.
01:25:34 I'm not sure you may have heard me and Dr. Morton talking about this
01:25:38 and just how short-term a job Alberta Premier tends to be,
01:25:42 particularly if you're a Conservative.
01:25:44 uh actually only one conservative has actually lost an election as premier every single other
01:25:50 one's been done in by their party uh one way or another um how tough if danielle smith wins tonight 1.00
01:25:57 let's and let's just say for the sake of argument it's uh it's not razor tight but it's a
01:26:04 you know she's got five to seven seat majority it's it's comfortable but it's not big uh how 1.00
01:26:11 tough a job is she gonna have keeping her job a tough job a tough job you know let's be clear
01:26:18 the ucp under former premier kenny whether you liked him or hated him had a government that was
01:26:24 overseeing a very strong economy a 12 billion dollar surplus we've seen er times drop under
01:26:31 this government we've seen surgery wait times everybody under this government we've seen jobs
01:26:37 flood back to the province we've seen the Alberta is calling campaign I see great success and people
01:26:43 investing and returning to the province by most accounts this should have been an easy path to
01:26:50 victory by the UCB but through some missteps and other factors it's become close to the point where
01:26:57 we're still watching with vague breath so I think Daniel Smith needs to do very well tonight to make
01:27:03 sure those knives stay in their cheese and that she dwells any kind of potential 1.00
01:27:11 interaction against her leadership and most importantly keeps her caucus
01:27:15 united which is the hard work of the leader the day after this campaign should
01:27:20 Daniel Smith be rewarded with another mandate another 40-year-old all right
01:27:26 thank you very much for joining us Mike and being generous with your time have
01:27:30 good night. Thanks, Jared. Build the absolute man. Anytime. All right. I'm going to bring in
01:27:36 another. We've had a lot of the Calgary school here. I'm going to bring in Dr. Tom Flanagan,
01:27:43 former political scientist at the University of Calgary. He is also, I believe, he was involved
01:27:49 in the early Reform Party, Stephen Harper's Canadian Alliance leadership run, and the early
01:27:55 The Wild Rose Party, certainly no stranger to Alberta politics.
01:27:59 Thank you for joining us, Dr. Flanagan.
01:28:02 What are you making of the early results that we've seen so far?
01:28:07 Well, they're very, very, very preliminary, but you'd rather be ahead than behind.
01:28:13 And the last time I looked, UCP was leading, you know, in something like 40 seats, already close to a majority.
01:28:22 And now that may not hold up as the evening goes on.
01:28:25 But, you know, so the very early results seem to be favorable.
01:28:29 One oddity was that the NDP actually had more votes.
01:28:34 I don't expect that to hold up as the evening goes on.
01:28:37 It's probably just an artifact of which particular polling places have reported.
01:28:43 Yeah, so we'll see.
01:28:45 I've never had the gift of prophecy, so I can't predict the future.
01:28:50 But I will say that I've been watching the polls the last couple of weeks, and almost all polls have converged on a margin of two to three points positive for the UCP, except for Janet Brown, who's reported an eight-point margin.
01:29:12 Now, there's a lot of practical difference there.
01:29:14 Two to three-point lead is a cliffhanger.
01:29:18 Eight-point lead is a comfortable victory.
01:29:20 So we'll see. Janet uses an updated version of the old fashioned methodology of live agent calling, which, you know, many people believe is a more accurate way of polling. 0.83
01:29:35 The other polls, I believe, are all in one way or another. They're all online internet polls. So we'll see. It's interesting for political scientists, you know, just to see which gives a better prediction. We'll find out.
01:29:51 And it actually would be, I think, possible for, I mean, we're in such a strictly two-party system here in Alberta that no other province, even the other two-party provinces, aren't as two-party as we are at least this particular election.
01:30:08 it would seem to be possible that the NDP could even win I don't expect them to but they could
01:30:15 even win the popular vote but still fail to win the most seats because they're the the math on
01:30:21 their path to victory to get to 44 seats plus is just so difficult yeah they have a you know one
01:30:29 would expect them to roll up some very big majorities in Edmonton which you know in a sense
01:30:35 become wasted votes uh you know much bigger majorities than they need uh another ucp has
01:30:41 a small advantage in them in that the average size of the rural ridings is smaller than the urban ones
01:30:48 and the ucp uh you know dominates these ridings so they get more bang for the buck
01:30:54 if you want to put it that way um so a small ucp advantage their
01:31:00 uh ndp disadvantage with their concentration in edmonton so uh yeah it wouldn't be out of
01:31:07 the question for the ndp to get more votes and uh get fewer seats but i don't expect that to happen
01:31:13 because every poll that's been taken in the last few weeks has shown some degree of ucp majority
01:31:20 of votes um you're right about the two-party strict two-party uh competition but that's new
01:31:28 in alberta this is the first time um you know last time there was still a nine percent vote
01:31:35 for the alberta party i think many of those voters have probably migrated to the ndp
01:31:40 um but that in in recent elections the multi-party split has actually been the most important thing
01:31:49 uh when the tories lost it was because wild rose was still running separate candidates
01:31:54 and before then for many years the liberals and the NDP were carving up the left of center vote
01:32:04 you know there was almost always more than 40 percent of voters sometimes more than 50 percent
01:32:09 of voters who were choosing liberal and NDP but because they were more or less evenly divided
01:32:15 they couldn't win very many seats that's all changed now we we have become at least for the
01:32:22 time being who knows for the future but for the time being it's a very strict two-party system
01:32:26 all right well thank you very much uh dr flanagan i appreciate your time and uh if you're able to
01:32:33 we'd love if you could chat back later when we've got some more results sure be i'm home all evening
01:32:38 so uh just tell me when you want to want me to sign in and i'll come back i don't have the
01:32:44 international vibe of ted morton but i'm happy to happy to appear oh i'm being careful not to
01:32:49 disclose his secret bunker location.
01:32:52 Okay.
01:32:53 It's another country anyway.
01:32:54 Put it that way.
01:32:56 Okay.
01:32:56 Bye-bye.
01:32:56 Thanks.
01:32:57 Okay.
01:32:58 We're going to go to Jonathan Bradley at the UCP headquarters in Calgary,
01:33:02 where he has Erica Barutz.
01:33:04 Erica Barutz was the president of the United Conservative Party.
01:33:08 I believe it's first president and also elected as a senator in waiting
01:33:14 during the most recent municipal elections.
01:33:18 Thank you for joining us, Erica.
01:33:20 How are you guys feeling on the ground there?
01:33:22 Yeah, I mean, the momentum is picking up.
01:33:25 Now that the polls have closed and a lot of the Logan campaigns are making their way down here.
01:33:29 We're definitely starting to see some of the early results come in.
01:33:32 They're looking pretty good for the United Conservative Party.
01:33:38 What are the...
01:33:40 Have you seen any surprises yet in the results coming in?
01:33:43 No, I mean, it's still pretty early.
01:33:46 We're seeing, you know, a lot of the rural seats, some of the Edmonton Donut come in.
01:33:51 No, no shops yet, but some positive vibes in the room.
01:33:59 If, let's, if either leader, I'm going to put you on the spot here.
01:34:04 I'm going to give you a nasty question.
01:34:06 I'm going to throw one out.
01:34:06 If either leader does not win tonight, what's the over-under that they, that they step down?
01:34:13 I mean, traditionally, that is something that the leader usually does.
01:34:18 We've seen it in the past where they've stepped down.
01:34:21 But I do say that both of these leaders have kind of made comebacks, right?
01:34:25 Rachel Notley lost and still remained popular within her party.
01:34:29 And Danielle Smith is kind of a comeback kid here over the last decade. 1.00
01:34:33 So I wouldn't say that this is, I mean, it's not a traditional election we're seeing.
01:34:38 it. I wouldn't think that the way that the leaders are going to handle the results are
01:34:42 going to be probably conventional either. Okay. Well, stand by Erica. I know Jonathan
01:34:49 Dennis and Kristin Cousinelli here are about to jump out of their seats. They're clearly
01:34:53 looking at interesting things on their computers and phones. I don't even really know what it
01:34:58 is. I'm just going to put it to you guys. What are you so excited about? Well, you know,
01:35:01 I think that this is starting to look encouraging. I'm not going to tell you how long I've been
01:35:05 the election but it's the long time and you usually sell what's happening in the earlier
01:35:10 polls and the law of averages comes in one thing i'm surprised of one poll has come in calgary
01:35:14 acadia 106 for the ndp uh 63 for the ucp and this is in manchester in uh in the neighborhood center
01:35:22 this is uh uh this is an area that uh could really go either way uh it has traditionally
01:35:28 gone conservative too early to call there in particular but if you look at some of the other
01:35:32 other areas here uh people were saying northwest well we've got 156 ucp to 98 uh there that is
01:35:38 looking encouraging here as well and uh if fish creek obviously i will call that that like we
01:35:44 even won that in 2015 that is ahead as well uh calgary bow uh 50 votes to 21 votes rather
01:35:50 polarizing ndp candidate former in drew farrell there demetrius nicolaitis has always had a very
01:35:56 good ground game i'm hoping for his victory there tonight uh christine and uh well of course i'm
01:36:03 looking over jonathan's shoulder here just like we're at school um and you're the principal i am
01:36:08 i am the principal i am a former principal so he knows not to misbehave um but i'm uh keeping my
01:36:14 eye on calgary bow um and i'm liking what i'm seeing yeah everyone's talking about bow and you
01:36:20 what it was a very contentious race uh we had you know drew has drew farrell um she's got name 0.97
01:36:26 recognition and certainly uh she is a favorite uh within the the ndp uh group there so i i wondered
01:36:34 how that was going to go but i really liked how the polls were trending uh overall um towards uh
01:36:41 you know a more of a victory uh closer victory hopefully for uh dimitrios nicolades who i think
01:36:46 has done a fantastic job in calgary bow um the other um the other thing that uh i'm i'm noticing
01:36:53 too is calgary acadia and you know it is too early to tell right now but as jonathan and i
01:36:59 are looking at these you kind of get a bit of a bullion when you start to see you know even at
01:37:03 these stages that your party is making gains and i don't like the looks of that to be honest i don't
01:37:09 like the looks of that very very quick because all the other polls are looking you know and i know
01:37:13 it's super early to say um but you know i i would prefer i'd feel safer if we were pulling in a
01:37:19 different direction there the last thing i just want to add here calgary falcon ridge last time
01:37:23 we won that by 99 votes there was a judicial recount i'm seeing 110 to 51 there right now
01:37:29 looking down again however that is the special ballot and advanced voting uh before you call that
01:37:34 again you want to see what the live results yeah okay uh real quickly we're going to check in with
01:37:39 dave nailer in our newsroom uh i just while you guys were talking there was a bunch of people i
01:37:44 saw that kind of run across the newsroom huddling over his shoulder must have been looking at
01:37:48 something interesting on his computer so let's bring in dave nailer in the newsroom uh dave
01:37:52 what do you got for us they were just running for the last piece of pizza derek um you told me it's
01:38:00 it's all gone? David took it. David Parker took the last piece. I can give you a bit of an overall
01:38:14 view, Derek. 94 polls reporting. That's 4%. Total of 22,500 ballots cast. NDP leading or elected in
01:38:25 29 calgary leading or ucp leading and elected in uh 45 but you know what polls have been closed
01:38:33 for an hour many writings haven't even filed a single poll yet utterly ridiculous uh yeah it's
01:38:42 just way too early to really get into anything at the moment so we're just gonna borrow your 1.00
01:38:46 credit card and order more pizza oh you son of a bitch do you want me to chip in for that or what 0.99
01:38:55 order some good scotch okay thank you dave uh so the map we've got up here uh just so folks know 0.99
01:39:01 uh this is a combination of common sense and what's leading common sense uh i mean if if
01:39:09 there's you know even one vote reporting in drumheller stetler i mean we're gonna put that
01:39:15 as leaning ucp because we know it's leaning ucp if there's one vote counted in edmonton strathcona
01:39:21 we're called we're putting that as leaning ndp because we know it's going to go ndp uh the ones
01:39:26 where there's just too few or no votes we're not filling it at all right now but that's that's where
01:39:31 we stand uh so based on any results we have real results we have i've got 39 ucp 27 uh ndp uh that's
01:39:41 still extremely extremely uh preliminary uh why don't we go um
01:39:50 let's see here uh uh let's check in with uh you arthur uh up in edmonton at
01:39:56 ndp headquarters uh arthur what can you tell us is happening up there
01:40:00 arthur we cannot hear you arthur you are muted
01:40:07 there i am now can you hear me uh the room here derek is uh is really starting to fill up uh we're
01:40:16 getting a lot of orange and uh motley crew shirts uh into the room again uh not too many candidates
01:40:24 in the room at the moment there's roughly about 150 people in here drinks are flowing and the
01:40:30 party is beginning okay all right thank you uh thank you for that uh update arthur we're gonna
01:40:42 go to jonathan bradley uh he's got an update for us from the ucb headquarters at the big four
01:40:47 building in Calgary thank you okay we're gonna come back to you later okay
01:41:09 okay from where you are um uh thank you uh mr morton uh we're gonna bring you in now
01:41:21 uh i guess uh i want to just get uh your take of where we're at we're starting to see some
01:41:26 some numbers come in um early leads for the ucp in calgary bow a bellwether but also an early lead
01:41:33 for the ndp in uh in acadia uh another bellwether so we've got two bellwethers it's still very
01:41:39 early to tell, but two bellwethers trending opposite directions.
01:41:47 I'm not an expert on specific writing, so I would just say the obvious, that it's a
01:41:56 contradiction, and we'll have to see how it shakes out.
01:41:58 now do you uh yeah i suppose you're more you're more from rural and the kind of the surrounding
01:42:14 area but you know actually one one area i want to ask you about is banff cananaskis because that
01:42:18 includes part of your old former constituency i think it was called um mountain view foothills
01:42:27 rocky view now it's it's a very different constituency than you had uh but it includes
01:42:32 a large part of it namely in the rocky view county part um spring bank area on the west side of
01:42:38 calgary very staunchly conservative but it's been kind of melded together in a way sorry uh our
01:42:45 guests in studio do not require uh earpieces um it's been uh fused together with uh kind of granola
01:42:54 country uh bamf and increasingly canmore so it's it's this really strange fusion of a constituency
01:43:01 that uh that is considered very much up for grabs tonight uh what's your prediction for for how your
01:43:07 old grounds are going to go well but i never represented uh bam for canmore uh there obviously
01:43:14 there's a lot more support for the liberals and ndp there and uh so it makes it a much more
01:43:19 complicated writing for a conservative party. I think, I mean, one of the things that is new
01:43:29 about the Alberta election, but also about politics on both sides of the border now,
01:43:34 is that historically, wealthier, more educated people tended to vote small c conservative.
01:43:40 And in the last decade or 15 years, that's changing. Certainly, both in baby boomers and
01:43:47 and younger generations like yours more educated more affluent people are voting left of center
01:43:53 there's a whole there's a new set of issues and i think you have as you said uh uh you call them
01:43:59 granola eaters i i like granola too but uh but uh i think you have well you have retirement
01:44:13 communities, and you have certainly in Canmore, it's become a retirement community. You have
01:44:17 wealthier, more educated people there that historically would tend to vote conservative,
01:44:21 but in the new constellation of so-called neoconservative or post-liberal politics,
01:44:32 suddenly those indicators are pushing voters in a leftward, so-called progressive direction. So
01:44:41 that's i think that that complicates that writing because i think certainly canmore
01:44:47 has a lot of those types of people yeah it's uh it's it is a real mess and complicated writing
01:44:56 uh for sure that uh i doubt you would recognize considering i think a majority of the population
01:45:01 now is uh from outside of it okay i want to actually uh turn to one of your old colleagues
01:45:06 here uh who's joining us in studio uh mr db cooper um uh so uh dr we had you on uh earlier i think
01:45:14 before we had any results yes i think uh but we've got we've got some results now um the map we've
01:45:21 got going we'll put the map uh keep the map up on the screen for now uh it is a combination of where
01:45:28 of results and some common sense so you know where we've got one five votes in we're not putting it
01:45:35 up unless it's like edmonton strathcona we just if the ndp is leading by one vote in edmonton
01:45:40 strathcona we're calling that and inversely in uh rimby rocky mountain house sundry uh there's
01:45:47 one vote in for conservatives we're putting up as leaning conservative uh so out of what we've
01:45:52 got right now yeah we've got the block of edmonton uh banf cananaskis leaning ndp um i'd say the only
01:46:01 a really interesting one I'm seeing right now is the NDP for the time being has a lead
01:46:05 in Calgary, Acadia. So leading in that bellwether, but the UCP winning in another one of these
01:46:11 two other bellwethers, Glenmore and Bo. So what do you make of what we're seeing so far?
01:46:17 I live in Bo, and I must say I'm not surprised that Dimitri is doing well there.
01:46:24 it's a traditionally it's a very it's been historically a very conservative writing
01:46:32 Drew Farrell as I was mentioning outside to some of the people people who remember her do not
01:46:38 remember her fondly she had more signs up I think than than than Dimitri did but you wonder sort of
01:46:48 how deep the signs are plugged into the ground
01:46:52 because the people who live there,
01:46:57 like my neighbors, basically,
01:46:59 have been conservative since Peter Loughey was there.
01:47:04 And I was surprised when that was considered a bellwether,
01:47:10 quite frankly, because it struck me
01:47:12 as being pretty clearly conservative for a very long time.
01:47:18 All right. Nigel, so when you were in here, we still didn't have any numbers in yet,
01:47:25 but we've got some decent numbers in to give us a good sense of things.
01:47:31 Where do you think things are going right now?
01:47:33 Tell you what, if those numbers were reversed and it was the NDP that had 50 seats and the UCP that had 30,
01:47:41 then I think everybody would be saying, well, there it is. There's the NDP sweep.
01:47:44 so it isn't that it is what it is are we then to say well there may be more results coming in
01:47:53 and there certainly will be some seats you think of one party now will turn out to be the other
01:47:59 but it seems like a fairly clear indication as a sample size of the total voting population
01:48:05 it is a very large number far far higher than you would take a poll and draw conclusions from
01:48:14 So what we've got, I've got up right now for the reasonably leaning one way or another based on some results and just common sense is 43 NDP, sorry, 43 UCP, 29 NDP.
01:48:31 Now it's 44 to your bare majority, you know, where you have to break every time, every vote with a speaker tie.
01:48:38 But we've got UCP of 43 if this holds steady.
01:48:44 And that still leaves a lot of seats up for grabs.
01:48:50 So actually, we're going to quickly turn to Jonathan Bradley, who's standing by the UCP headquarters in Calgary at the Big Four.
01:48:58 Jonathan, what do you got for us?
01:49:04 Jonathan, we cannot hear Jonathan.
01:49:05 we cannot hear jonathan all right well we'll come back to jonathan later uh when he gets his
01:49:12 volume work in there i'm good i'm good i'm good okay bring it back in okay so the crowd's doing
01:49:19 the crowd's energized people are cheering on the use of people as well people are doing when the
01:49:23 mdp uh when an mdp candidate or an mla comes on uh there's a whole bunch of positivity here i do
01:49:31 see people smiling looks like everyone's having a good time uh we've had a few people come on
01:49:36 who we've spoken with and i think it's going to be a ucp win okay all right thank you jonathan um
01:49:48 okay uh so actually uh i'm getting word from uh dave miller our news editor that a big
01:49:54 poll dump has just come in so let's go to dave in the newsroom for an update
01:49:57 After about 20 minutes of non-action, Derek, we suddenly went from 94 polls reporting to 173.
01:50:08 It's almost 10% of all polls.
01:50:11 We've got UCP leading and elected in 51, and we've got the NDP leading or elected in 31.
01:50:20 In terms of the percentage of votes, NDP at 39%, UCP at 57%.
01:50:29 Of course, that's going to waver as the night comes in.
01:50:34 Some interesting writings to point out.
01:50:37 Calgary Acadia has got Tyler Shandro ahead by six votes after two polls.
01:50:45 Calgary both and UCP are...
01:50:47 Sorry, the newsroom is going crazy behind me here.
01:50:55 UCP leading Calgary Bowl 194 to 90.
01:51:00 Calgary Buffalo 76 for the NDP.
01:51:03 UCP 52.
01:51:06 Calgary Fish Creek well into the UCP win category.
01:51:11 Calgary Glenmore UCP 225.
01:51:15 ndp 146 so that's uh looking a little bit better for uh the ucp calgary mountain view the ndp is
01:51:25 leading 235 to 178 uh what else can we bring you edmonton's pretty well going as it is the smallest
01:51:37 of margins, but in Edmonton Southwest, Casey Maddu is, there's only, let's see, 43 votes in,
01:51:48 but Casey Maddu is up by one. And I think we all know if the NDP, so if the UCP is going to hold
01:51:56 on, that is their only seat in Edmonton, and he is expected to lose it, but I mean, the UCP could
01:52:03 focused all their resources on that one running maybe maybe they pull through so for the moment
01:52:10 casey matt it was ahead by one vote yeah in uh in morinville saint albert ucp is ahead by uh
01:52:18 about 170 votes uh 2393 to 2270 uh saint albert ndp well ahead 1373 to 806
01:52:31 uh strathcona sherwood park the ucp has a slight edge 1264 to 966 and west yellowhead the ucp is
01:52:42 ahead by about 200 votes so nice to finally see us getting some figures derek and uh let's hope
01:52:49 they keep counting at this pace now thank you very much dave
01:52:53 all right nigel uh it's shaping up more or less as i think we've expected so far again still so 0.95
01:53:03 much to come in uh acadia for the moment leading ucp but by the slimmest of margins six votes yeah
01:53:13 uh bow i think by fairly slim as well maybe not as slim well actually uh yeah there's 100 votes
01:53:20 in it at the moment, which, given the
01:53:22 number of polls that are reported, is
01:53:24 significant, I think. Yeah, we got
01:53:26 yeah, up by
01:53:28 Dimitri Nikolaitis for the UCP
01:53:30 is up by just
01:53:31 104 votes there.
01:53:38 I'm actually surprised that Astrid
01:53:40 Kuhn is
01:53:41 as close to Joe Ceci as she is.
01:53:45 I mean, this was
01:53:45 there's no way
01:53:48 anything besides an NDP is happening when it is happening there no way yeah but it was supposed
01:53:53 to be a complete wipeout like a zero chance on the 338 yeah but it's still it's still so early
01:54:00 I mean like there are some polls uh in like uh I think carts and six sick showing the NDP in the
01:54:07 league there is a 0.0 chance lead uh you know if uh if my grandmother had wheels should be a wagon 0.72
01:54:16 The NDP is never winning there.
01:54:18 It's just one particular poll is going to be showing that.
01:54:21 So I would imagine that's got to be the case in Buffalo.
01:54:25 I will be floored if it's even competitive for the UCP there.
01:54:29 What's interesting is if you looked at the mood in the room in the NDP and the PC's or CPC.
01:54:40 UCP.
01:54:42 That would tell you what the insiders think.
01:54:44 And I suspect the room is a lot more jolly in Calgary than it is in Edmonton.
01:54:49 Yeah, I think so.
01:54:50 Yeah, actually, that's a good idea.
01:54:52 Let's go to Edmonton right now.
01:54:53 We're going to bring in our Alberta legislative reporter based at Edmonton, Arthur Green.
01:54:58 He is at the UCP headquarters.
01:55:00 I see they haven't given him quite the nice spot as Jonathan was given at UCP headquarters.
01:55:05 You've been put in some kind of, it looks like a padded room.
01:55:09 They must think you're insane if they've got you strapped up your...
01:55:14 I'm in exile corner here at Zurich.
01:55:20 I actually requested interviews with NDP candidates
01:55:23 and I was told they will not be speaking to the Western Standard tonight.
01:55:28 The room is heating up.
01:55:30 We just had quite the boo in the room.
01:55:33 They showed a picture of UCP leader Danielle Smith on the big screen here.
01:55:39 The crowd really lit up in a booing fashion.
01:55:43 They then showed a picture of NDP leader Rachel Notley, and the room lit up.
01:55:50 I mean, it's starting to get more loud in here.
01:55:53 Janice Irwin is just here in front of me. 0.99
01:55:56 She's doing an interview with CTP.
01:55:58 Sarah Hoffman's in the room.
01:56:00 More of the candidates are starting to trickle in, and like I said, the party is starting to be in the room.
01:56:06 well we're talking about the the mood in the room there uh is how are they feeling are they uh
01:56:13 because you know there's a difference between there's a brave face and then there's uh
01:56:19 happy like how are they how do you think they're really feeling right now um right now most people
01:56:24 are smiling i had a young fella come up to me a couple moments ago about 14 years old
01:56:29 uh put his crossed fingers in front of my face and said hope notley becomes premier so i mean
01:56:35 people are optimistic people are smiling um there are people from all walks of life
01:56:41 in this room right now and lots of orange shirts to be seen okay uh thank you very much arthur
01:56:52 uh very i don't think they sound pretty happy up there like yeah i i think things are trending
01:56:57 the ucp's way but i i'd say they still they still got a path at this point it's not over
01:57:02 yeah it's um i think you're right but you also have to remember for a lot of people
01:57:08 uh coming to these uh meetings it's a party period yeah uh and until you know till midnight
01:57:14 they'll be happy uh well they're not yeah they'll be happy on the hopeful spring eternal
01:57:21 until it's like cold against you you're just praying for the miracle um
01:57:28 And, Nigel, you've been in those rooms where you're just praying to God.
01:57:35 Maybe there's one poll.
01:57:37 It's like a little pocket.
01:57:38 You know, pocket aces.
01:57:39 You're waiting for pocket aces.
01:57:41 The right poll reports, flips it over.
01:57:45 What's it like in a losing party's headquarters?
01:57:48 Because you've been in a winning headquarters and you've been in a losing headquarters.
01:57:51 Well, I tell you what.
01:57:52 When you're in a winning party's headquarters, you can't hear yourself talk, think,
01:57:58 you can't put your drink down you just have to stand there and watch the screen and every now
01:58:05 and then there's another piece of good news up goes up and everybody goes yes you know
01:58:08 i didn't get the sense that that was happening up in edmonton i have also been in a losing room
01:58:16 and there people are quiet and reflective and say something along the lines of well
01:58:25 we did our best and i'm proud of my part in it but sometimes the dragon wins i don't get
01:58:33 just picking up the background from young jonathan there in the over there at the bmo center i don't
01:58:39 get the feeling that that's the move down there either so i got a winning room and a losing room
01:58:44 both are putting a good face the losers are putting a good face on it and they'll say they
01:58:50 fold hard and darn it next time it will be better down here everybody is breathing houston i believe 0.91
01:58:58 so i'm looking here uh very early but we've got uh shannon phillips leading in lethbridge west
01:59:06 not by a lot 52.8 to 41.5 but i think she's widely expected to to carry that constituency again
01:59:14 uh lethbridge east there's four votes in the ndp have two uh three of them uh so really not much
01:59:20 there but that's that's going to be a competitive one to watch uh may have canon ask us we've got
01:59:27 enough to do at least a poll of the constituency so if you're doing a local poll of the constituency
01:59:33 you'd want three four hundred that gives you an idea as long as it's spread across
01:59:36 There, we've got the NDP with 288 votes, UCP at 213, so that's 55.7%, 41.2%. I mean, I wouldn't be shocked if that was reflective of the result. I mean, still lots of room for that to move. I know some of the people involved on the different sides of that campaign.
02:00:01 I want a knife fight. And I know in particular, the UCP really want that one. Because when you look at the map of Alberta on Election Day, if they can keep the NDP just in the cities, at least the map still looks all blue, right?
02:00:18 Okay. Dr. Cooper, is there anything in Calgary that's catching your eye right now?
02:00:24 i'm i'm actually uh somewhat surprised not entirely surprised but uh somewhat surprised
02:00:34 that the places where the ndp are supposed to have their strength it it it's not sort of as
02:00:39 overwhelming as as some of my distinguished colleagues at the university were predicting
02:00:44 it would be but they tended to be more um supportive of the ndp than i am put it that way
02:00:52 And with respect to the out in Canmore, I think you have to look at which polls have reported in.
02:01:00 A lot of them probably are in Canmore or Banff.
02:01:03 So it's easier to collect them.
02:01:04 And if they, in the more rural polling stations, they might not, they might not be in yet.
02:01:09 I would go for them.
02:01:13 Yeah, although advanced polls are kind of counted all at once now, it seems.
02:01:18 Although I don't know if we have them in yet.
02:01:20 But people will bring Dave Naylor from the newsroom, although I don't think he can hear us for the moment.
02:01:29 I'd like to know how much of the advance poll is in.
02:01:34 Dave, if you can hear us, we want to bring you back in here.
02:01:38 Okay, well, I guess Dave's just kind of looking around.
02:01:40 Here we are.
02:01:41 Okay, we're going to bring in Dave Naylor now from the newsroom.
02:01:44 Dave, what we want to know is what's happened with the advance ballots?
02:01:48 Have they been tabulated in yet?
02:01:50 or not well we were told somewhere in the neighborhood of 750 000 advanced ballots were
02:01:58 filled in and we've got a grand total of 39 000 reported so somewhere there's been a breakdown
02:02:06 in the system i think uh lots of polls uh across the province still haven't or lots of writings
02:02:13 just still have got zero uh ballots reporting and this is an hour hour and a half after the polls
02:02:21 close you know i was really looking forward to uh a big rash all at once of the event that was
02:02:29 coming in but it doesn't seem to have been so is it no it doesn't uh cory just raised a good point
02:02:35 out here that because of the sun child uh voting station being open until 9 46 perhaps some of the
02:02:44 results are being uh withheld so they don't they can't be uh accused of skewing uh any sort of
02:02:50 voting uh uh on sun child this is sort of like how uh in a federal election now people and people in
02:02:57 the west never be able to found out what uh what happened down east for fear of uh spoiling uh the
02:03:03 voting out here so uh that's just a guess but it uh to me it's a strange uh strange lack of
02:03:10 counting going on interesting okay uh thank you dave uh nigel how many seats do you think smith
02:03:23 has to like how comfortable margin does she have to have to like the knives are coming for no matter 1.00
02:03:30 what if she loses well she probably just walks the plank tonight uh but if she wins i mean unless 0.85
02:03:37 she keeps every single seat which seems to be extraordinarily unlikely almost impossible uh the
02:03:44 knives are coming for but they're more likely to be uh a bit sharper if the majority is smaller
02:03:49 uh what kind of padding majority do you think she needs to have the knives stay away for like a good 1.00
02:03:56 six months only six months you say well i would say look if it's less than 50 the fighting is
02:04:04 the infighting is going to start right away but you know let's say it was 50 that would mean 37
02:04:11 to the ndp a 13 seat spread you think would be a reasonable protection for a leader against a coup
02:04:20 it's only because it is daniel smith that we would rather see something she would rather see
02:04:30 something uh like 55 which of course is a is an unlikely 55 to 32 a pretty unlikely uh result even
02:04:40 though i see some strange numbers up on the glass over there uh but uh you know hope springs eternal
02:04:46 I guess for some punters. But no, seriously, I would say that if she doesn't get the 50, then
02:04:53 she's going to turn from fighting the NDP up to yesterday to fighting the dissidents in her own
02:05:01 party tomorrow. So Barry, I know you live in Calgary Bow. But you spent a lot of time around
02:05:10 Calgary varsity, obviously, is a university professor. I mean, university areas tend to lean
02:05:17 left. You want a constituency to vote left, put a university there. That's what happens.
02:05:24 But the UCP did win it last time. But do you think they really have any chance of holding
02:05:29 varsity this time? They've always got a chance, I guess. But one of the things that is not always
02:05:37 appreciated is that the students vote there and they are not all lefties no but on balance on
02:05:44 balance they are but they the ucp may do better in varsity than um than you would expect on the
02:05:50 normal kind of understanding of that i i honestly i don't know i i go up there every day but there
02:05:56 are very few signs around uh there's there's not much that you can uh the students are gone now
02:06:01 so i can't talk to them about it i was thinking when you were talking about danielle's future
02:06:07 If she gets 50, I think she'd be pretty safe. Even if she's under that, she can also persuade her caucus to back her. You don't want to have the seams of the UCP exposed. We've already got the press against her and the NDP and a lot of other people.
02:06:34 So I think if the UCP has any sense of, let's say, team esprit, they will stick with her.
02:06:45 Do you think they do?
02:06:46 This, I don't know.
02:06:48 I mean, I talk to Brody a lot, and he's got a lot of contacts in the UCP.
02:06:53 And he says that they're pretty divided.
02:06:55 But, you know, we were talking about what can Danielle do about it?
02:06:59 Well, she can rally the troops. 1.00
02:07:02 Now, whether she has the rhetorical as well as the policy skills to do that, I guess we'll find out.
02:07:09 Certainly, her policies, you would think, would appeal to just about everybody in that party. 0.88
02:07:16 Whether they do, we'll find out.
02:07:18 Okay. I'm going to be ducking out of here for a little bit.
02:07:20 But before I do, we're going to go to Dave Nehler back in the newsroom for another update on where we're at in the polls.
02:07:28 Dave, give us the goods.
02:07:29 Oh, whoa, whoa. We just got a whole bunch of polls come in. We're up to 273 polls at the moment, 110,000 votes cast, 50 seats leading and elected for the UCP, for the NDP.
02:07:50 it's 36 seats uh leading and uh elected uh calgary acadia still uh only the uh initials
02:07:59 results before from where chandra was ahead by six uh calgary bow doesn't seem to be anything new
02:08:08 we can tell you that
02:08:13 has been elected in brooks uh medicine hat she's uh where is she sitting at here oh she's got 0.98
02:08:20 1,400 votes to 400 for the NDP, so we'll go out on a limb and declare her elected.
02:08:30 Lethbridge, still nothing updated there. Morinville, St. Albert, the UCP seems to be
02:08:41 lengthening their lead by about 500. There's two polls out of 20 reported there, almost 5,000
02:08:47 votes for UCP, 3662 for the NDP. Red Deer South and Red Deer North both look to be staying UCP
02:09:00 blue. Sherwood Park actually very, very tight. NDP only leading by nine votes and that's after
02:09:08 four 22 have come in saying albert ndp by about 900 votes 2 990 to 2039 and uh west yellowhead the
02:09:24 uh ucp is doubling the ndp vote they've got 4164 votes so another big dump there but really not
02:09:32 much in the calgary area guys all right thanks dave we'll uh check back in here when the next
02:09:38 big spurt of votes happens to land i guess thanks gory thanks so nigel guys i mean just talking 0.93
02:09:48 about this i was speaking a bit outside though this is unusual i mean now we're an hour and 40
02:09:54 minutes after the poll closing and uh there's only about 12 of the votes have been counted
02:10:00 Have you seen anything like this? This is really unusual. The rumors are starting to turn on social media, which is really dangerous these days.
02:10:09 You know, it is unusual, right? I mean, I have seen some slow counts, and Lord knows we've seen them in leadership races especially.
02:10:18 But with the electronic voting, we thought this was fixed, that everything would be coming out quickly.
02:10:26 Certainly the theory that they're holding off on releasing the vote from the advanced poll,
02:10:33 just not to prejudice the voting that's going on up there in northern Alberta.
02:10:41 That one poll didn't open until quarter to ten.
02:10:47 Okay, fair enough.
02:10:48 That may be the whole reason right there.
02:10:51 I guess there's going to be a lot of questions asked.
02:10:53 There will be.
02:10:53 So we're just going to cut away quickly to Jonathan Bradley.
02:10:57 I believe he's got Vidor Marciano on at the UCP headquarters there.
02:11:01 Hello, Vidor.
02:11:02 How's it going over there?
02:11:05 I don't seem to have any sound from Vidor quite yet.
02:11:10 We shall see.
02:11:13 All right.
02:11:14 Well, when we get sound from Vidor, we'll have him on quickly and have a chat with him there.
02:11:20 Very, I mean, mistrust.
02:11:23 I mean, that was something I was talking about on the side.
02:11:25 You know, again, we get the world of conspiracies, the world of worried about results.
02:11:29 I mean, whatever side loses now, there's going to be some actors kind of saying, you know, there was some funny business, even if there really wasn't necessarily anything going on.
02:11:37 Yeah, and it's a different kind of funny business than it used to be because with the electronic stuff, most people don't understand it.
02:11:45 If you're going to mess around with things, you do it in a completely different way.
02:11:48 It's not ballot stuffing.
02:11:50 It's all in a manner that most of us haven't got a clue how to do it,
02:11:54 but those to do.
02:11:57 So that gives it an aura of mystery, if not of conspiracy.
02:12:03 And I know after the last municipal election here,
02:12:06 there was a lot of discussion about that.
02:12:09 And then having the ballots destroyed pretty quickly
02:12:13 didn't make things go away.
02:12:16 I think, didn't the UCP government say that you had to hang on to them for, what, two weeks or something like that?
02:12:22 They're going to be held on to, I believe, for three months, actually.
02:12:23 Three months, okay.
02:12:24 So, I mean, that's a comforting thing.
02:12:25 You know, we've got a backup, but I went in, I advanced, voted, and, you know, I thought, wow, this is kind of slick.
02:12:31 You know, it goes into a counter.
02:12:32 They save the paper.
02:12:34 This is an advancement.
02:12:35 You know, we'll look forward to 8-15, and we'll know what's going on.
02:12:37 But apparently, they haven't.
02:12:39 I are in the constituency in Boa where I voted it was all paper just as it had been like for
02:12:46 thousands of years and but at Flanagan's riding I saw him this morning and he said he did he was
02:12:53 electronic there so it's a it's a mixed sort of system technologically anyway which was again
02:12:59 makes us wonder a little why then there's everything delay yeah yeah maybe it had nothing
02:13:05 to do with the electronic aspects.
02:13:08 Maybe we need
02:13:09 a royal commission to find out.
02:13:10 Or perhaps a special rapporteur.
02:13:12 The first task of the incoming premier
02:13:14 is going to be to investigate the election.
02:13:20 Winning
02:13:20 politicians tend not to investigate
02:13:22 the election.
02:13:24 No, not typically.
02:13:25 They have to appoint a friend to make sure there's nothing to see there.
02:13:28 That's right.
02:13:29 Oh, no, he's disappeared again. I was going to look at Jonathan Bradley.
02:13:32 but uh jonathan's having fun i i see that he's coming and going okay let's see if jonathan's
02:13:38 ready to chat a little bit here and uh he's down at the headquarters of the big four building in
02:13:43 calgary hello jonathan okay let's go away from jonathan again all right so cory you've been
02:13:52 asking a lot of questions about um are you still confident about your own predictions you know i
02:13:58 still am i mean i i've seen a lot of well the results actually for what we have coming in are
02:14:03 sort of reflecting that i don't like reading in any until you get 30 40 you're really you know
02:14:08 you're starting to gamble with it but they're hanging quite closely if anything they're looking
02:14:12 better than what i guessed so here's the question here's the question i would ask if you've got um
02:14:16 1500 how many how many votes would you want sorry how many samples would you require to get a sense
02:14:24 of what a writing was going to do,
02:14:26 what a constituency was going to do.
02:14:28 300, 400?
02:14:29 It would be a pretty good idea.
02:14:30 If you're talking a ground general poll?
02:14:33 Properly distributed.
02:14:35 Properly distributed, I think you could get a good feel out of that.
02:14:38 But, you know, again, in this case,
02:14:39 they're reporting this poll, which was this part of the constituency,
02:14:42 and that.
02:14:43 It's enough to start reading in now.
02:14:44 It is.
02:14:45 I think that we're going to end up with one of those
02:14:48 really interesting situations
02:14:50 where the numerical vote count
02:14:53 is not reflected
02:14:55 by the seat
02:14:57 distribution. You're going to get a lot of seats
02:14:59 that are held, and it could be either party,
02:15:01 a lot of seats that are held by quite slender
02:15:03 majorities.
02:15:05 That's what's going to keep us here until midnight,
02:15:07 until we know. Well, we've got lots of coffee
02:15:09 on anyways.
02:15:11 Let's take one more crack at Jonathan. I see him
02:15:13 standing there at the headquarters. Perhaps
02:15:15 he's got something to add at this point.
02:15:17 No, he doesn't. Okay. So,
02:15:19 well, let's see.
02:15:21 I'll give a quick update
02:15:23 here actually if dave naylor has a moment we'll check back in with him because i do believe some
02:15:28 more votes have come in i don't know if to move the needle very well hello oh no i've got jonathan
02:15:35 hello jonathan how's things going at the ucp headquarters things are going well how's everything
02:15:39 in studio we're fine uh go ahead the crowd's still energized uh people are really excited
02:15:50 there's cheering uh whenever the ucp candidates come on scene people doing well i've been talking
02:15:55 to some people and they seem to think he's going to pull it off um yeah okay um you you did have uh
02:16:04 vedora marciano there for a little while i know we couldn't get him on but you imagine you spoke
02:16:08 with him a bit uh he's easily done his easier things he's maintaining optimism with how things
02:16:14 are looking right now yeah the tour is optimistic he's going to win um he's saying what the polls
02:16:20 are saying like productions are saying 15 to 55 seats uh yeah okay well thanks jonathan we'll
02:16:28 check in uh when something changes down there and uh what's happening all right so that was our
02:16:35 jonathan bradley let's have a quick look yeah so i it's jumping up now i've seen 155 000 votes cast
02:16:41 uh 158 000 now so finally i think we're on the move and uh 57 is where the ucp is saying the
02:16:48 popular vote versus 39 with the ndp uh with this meeting so just as long as we don't so long as
02:16:54 what they're going to be worried about is building up a huge majority in a safe seat and losing by
02:17:02 15 in a in a margin seat so how is that what can we see there yeah the seat by seat's hard i got
02:17:11 I've got to kind of drill down to find which ones are standing out.
02:17:13 You know, some have reported a lot and some a little.
02:17:15 But, I mean, when we're getting up into the 160,000 vote range,
02:17:19 we can, you know, with that overall province,
02:17:22 let's start reading in, it's looking pretty good for the UCP at this point.
02:17:25 So that's about 10% of the likely turnout.
02:17:30 Perhaps, yeah.
02:17:31 Well, that's actually 18% of the voting places reporting.
02:17:34 So, I mean, it depends on the size of the polls.
02:17:39 Yes.
02:17:39 actually when it's when it's double that you'll have a much better idea well yeah yeah okay okay
02:17:45 well i'm gonna check in with mr nailer there and see what's happening on his end he's checked into
02:17:50 a few more of those writings and uh we'll see what's going on out there it's gonna be a few
02:17:54 close ones to talk about hey dave how's it uh looking for you there well i'm getting a bit
02:17:59 frustrated i'm gonna have to leave to go down to the big four building to teach jonathan how to tie
02:18:04 But other than that, yeah, we've got almost 20% of the polls now in, 163,000 votes cast. Current standings are 53 to 33 for the UCP.
02:18:19 I think you just mentioned, Corey, the UCP has now got 56% of the popular vote compared to almost 40% for the NDP.
02:18:32 Calgary Acadia continues to be very close. The NDP leading by six ballots there. Calgary Bow, the UCP has got a bit of a lead, 831-661. Calgary Buffalo, the NDP pulling away, 1,687-971.
02:18:55 Oh, what else do we want to see? Calgary Edgemont, very close. UCP with 1,019 votes compared to the NDP's 954. Calgary Elbow, 1,631 for the NDP, 1,486 for the UCP.
02:19:19 Calgary Foothills, close, 1220 for the UCP, 1063 for the NDP.
02:19:26 Other ridings that have a fair amount of votes in at the moment,
02:19:31 Calgary Varsity has a lead of 150 votes for the NDP.
02:19:37 They're at 981 at the moment.
02:19:41 No real big surprises that I'm seeing in Edmonton at the moment.
02:19:48 Airdrie looks to be at least Airdrie-Cochran, solidly UCP.
02:19:55 Airdrie East still hasn't got a ballot.
02:19:57 And yet, come on, Airdrie East, don't be lost.
02:20:01 Banff-Canonaskis, the UCP, ahead by a couple of hundred, 916 to 699.
02:20:09 We've mentioned Danielle Smith elected in Brooks Medicine Hat.
02:20:14 Drayton Valley, Devon, looks to be a lock for the UCP.
02:20:20 What else can I tell you, Corey?
02:20:25 Moranville, St. Albert, very close, 4,977.
02:20:31 UCP, 4,371 for the NDP.
02:20:35 That's four out of 20 ballots in.
02:20:39 Sherwood Park, 2,457 NDP.
02:20:43 2378 for ucp that one uh too close to call at the moment uh
02:20:54 that's what i got at the moment so that's uh fully 20 of all ballots cast now uh uh
02:21:01 cory or voting places reporting 185 000 votes cast all right dave well thanks for that update
02:21:08 i'm glad that we've got some updates to get from you only go to i imagine they should start pouring
02:21:12 in pretty fast quickly now let's hope so all right so that was dave naylor now i'm joined by
02:21:19 a couple of guests uh back in the studio we've got david parker and chris sims here with me
02:21:25 it's the magic that they swapped out while i was talking to dave uh so finally we got some numbers
02:21:30 to talk about though finally i mean i i'll start a bit just uh with with david we were talking a
02:21:35 little bit outside like the thing i already what i see as a loss in this election for albertans is
02:21:40 now we've had some funny business and i don't i'm not going to read in corruption or fixing
02:21:46 or anything like that but now we've had this odd unexplained delays and people are there's going to
02:21:51 be some people who won't trust the bloody results well yeah the problem here is that the whole idea
02:21:56 behind these tabulators was that they were going to make everything more efficient and quicker and
02:21:59 we get better results and now we're seeing these huge delays i've watched a lot of elections why
02:22:04 were we stuck at 65,001 votes for like half an hour i've never seen that before ever in elections
02:22:11 now i'm sure there's a reason i'm hopeful that they'll give us a reason but the issue here is
02:22:15 not that i think there's cheating because i actually don't think that there's cheating
02:22:18 what i'm worried about is there's a lot of people who have been uh traumatized by their government
02:22:23 and now have a lot of a lack of faith in their government and what we need is an institution
02:22:28 that people can have faith in and that is why i was advocating for paper ballots it's not because
02:22:32 i think that they're you know elections alberta's corrupt i don't think that what i think is that
02:22:36 there's a lot of people who are worried about this and we need to calm their nerves and give
02:22:40 them their trust in their institutions and this is not building trust in institutions this is
02:22:45 this is fodder for conspiracy theory right now it certainly is but i mean uh so i'll go to you
02:22:51 crystal now we've got some updated numbers i think we can start reading a little into this now
02:22:55 so we've got a 21 reporting uh you know i won't go writing right by writing like dave did or
02:22:59 constituency by constituency but popular vote is interesting i mean a lot of people were thinking
02:23:04 the ndp might be even ahead in the popular vote but the seat count would work but right now it's
02:23:09 55.7 ucp and 40.2 ndp that you know and with uh now with 21 reporting we could start to
02:23:17 think boy this is starting to look kind of favorable at the very least for the ucp
02:23:22 you know with our supporters we have thousands of them here in alberta uh by and large they of
02:23:27 of course, want lower taxes, less waste, and more accountable government within the Canadian
02:23:30 Taxpayers Federation. So I think it stands to reason that most of the email and messages we
02:23:35 would get at the CTF would be meat and potatoes issues like balance the budget, lower my taxes,
02:23:42 fight Justin Trudeau's carbon tax, stop him from tripling it, fight just transition. Very economic
02:23:48 and money level issues. And I think the reason why that's speaking to so many people now
02:23:54 is because it's so bloody unaffordable like it's just not an option it's not like you're at the
02:23:59 grocery store and you get to pick between paper and plastic bags if you can't afford groceries
02:24:04 because food is inflating so much you're darn right that you're going to care most about pocketbook
02:24:08 issues and so I think that is what we're seeing reflected here because not picking aside one
02:24:14 party talked a lot about lowering taxes and balancing the budget and putting more money in
02:24:18 your pocket and the other party didn't they focused more on what issues they care about in
02:24:23 their social issues. And so I think this might show that more people are cared about pocketbook
02:24:29 issues right now. Well, I mean, most people aren't like ourselves. We're very ideological. We have
02:24:34 our views. A lot of people, it doesn't matter what you lean this way or that way. If you can't make
02:24:39 the mortgage or if you're worried about buying groceries, it doesn't matter. Then you're starting
02:24:43 to look for who you feel most confident that's going to help you there, even if it perhaps is
02:24:48 holding their nose and voting. You know, a stat that jumps out at me every year, and it's something
02:24:51 i check i have since my talk radio days is the food bank use and food bank use is at record high
02:24:58 levels across canada including here in alberta where we're doing relatively well compared to
02:25:02 other provinces another stat that really jumped out was from the grocers association it came out
02:25:07 last week it might be even worse food purchases are down the volume did you see that i did like
02:25:14 people are buying less less food and so that and so what that means they're getting less nutrients
02:25:20 that's correct because they're skimping and scratching right and so we're seeing and i
02:25:25 spoke with one of the ladies that works at the food bank and she said that they're seeing working
02:25:29 people this is not people who've been thrown out of work you know god love them these are working
02:25:33 people who are saying i still can't make ends meet so if you're dealing with a populace that's
02:25:38 like that i think more people vote with their wallet and i think you know again for what i
02:25:43 would read in i mean there was so much focus on the personality particularly with the mvp that
02:25:47 was the strategy was if we can undercut the other party, that's fine. But my thoughts were towards
02:25:52 the tail end, people wanted to hear, okay, we get it. But now what are you going to do? And they
02:25:56 didn't pivot, you know, if they'd have changed, perhaps. They were really loud on the anti-Smith,
02:26:01 right? All they wanted to talk about was all of the things that Daniel Smith had said and twisting
02:26:06 them, making them look as bad as they possibly could. I mean, the whole pension stuff, I think,
02:26:11 is a really good example, right? They claimed that Daniel Smith wanted to take people's pensions
02:26:15 away. And that is just a blatant lie. If anything, we wanted to give more people more money from
02:26:22 their pensions because Alberta puts way more into the CPP than they get back. But of course,
02:26:26 that's lost in the noise of the constant repeated lie. But I'm quite proud of Albertans. If these
02:26:31 are going to be the results, I don't know if we've seen any more, but it seems like we're seeing an
02:26:35 incredible pushback against these lies of 55% UCP right now. It might not stay that way. But if it
02:26:43 does stay that way i think that will be a a loud critique of the negative campaign that rachel 0.99
02:26:48 notley ran it certainly would and the votes are really coming in at 24 now and it's still holding
02:26:53 56 ucp uh 52 seats looking at you know leading anyways into to 35 going on there i'd point out
02:27:01 that 56 is two or three percent higher than jason kenny got in terms of the popular vote yeah it's
02:27:08 early but uh we're seeing things start to come in maybe i i see uh i'll pull him in quickly uh ted
02:27:13 morton on deck there too and and do you get an interpretation of somebody who's been you know
02:27:17 outside watching from a distance if he's able to come in and talk for a little a little bit there
02:27:21 uh there you are hello mr morton how you doing down there good good i'll just pick up uh on the
02:27:30 on the economic issue uh when the ndp won in 2015 the people who were happy with that so this is the
02:27:37 new Alberta. It's younger. People are coming from other places, more diverse, more ethnically
02:27:43 diverse. It's not the old Alberta of Peter Lougheed and Ralph Klein. And of course, they're
02:27:49 partly right, but they're mostly wrong because people, since the 1960s, 70s, 80s, people have
02:27:59 been coming to Alberta in large numbers. When I moved to Calgary, the population was 600,000.
02:28:06 Today, it's, you know, a million two, a million three.
02:28:11 When I moved there in 1981, everybody I met at the hockey rink, because I had kids in junior hockey, everyone was from Saskatchewan.
02:28:20 Why were they from Saskatchewan? Because the NDP had killed the economy in Saskatchewan for decades.
02:28:25 A decade or so later, there were all sorts of young people from B.C.
02:28:28 Why were they here? Because the NDP was killing the economy in B.C.
02:28:32 So new people, young people, different types of people, immigrants have been coming to Alberta for the last 40 or 50 years, and they're coming here for economic opportunity.
02:28:42 And I think on that issue, as both all of your panelists have said tonight, Danielle and the UCP, both the Kenny record and the Danielle Smith campaign have focused on those issues.
02:28:55 And I think both older Albertans, the majority of older Albertans and the majority of new Albertans and younger Albertans care about those issues.
02:29:03 And that's why you're seeing the positive results.
02:29:06 Yeah. So, I mean, it's still a little premature to formally call it, but it's looking quite good.
02:29:11 But we've also I mean, you can see from that map we've got up no matter what happens to this.
02:29:15 We've got a very regionally divided province, whoever the new premier may be.
02:29:20 They've really got quite something to manage with that.
02:29:23 mean you are there to represent the entire province and it's very clear that edmonton
02:29:27 and area has solidly rejected the ucp so there's a lot of outreach say if it becomes a premier
02:29:31 smith to to try and soothe that there there's nothing very new about that either i mean
02:29:42 i mean the nickname in the pc caucus when i was there it was called not edmonton but redmonton
02:29:48 um right even i've heard that yeah yeah yeah so again that that's really not anything too new
02:29:57 no no it's just a very solid uh red these days but uh well again it's a university town it's
02:30:05 a government town and those are factors that push people to the left because they like more
02:30:10 government most definitely all right well thank you uh we'll we'll put you back there and check
02:30:16 in with the numbers again and see where we're going. I think we're getting towards the turf
02:30:20 where we're going to see some outlets getting tempted to call it. So thank you again Dr. Ted
02:30:28 Morton. I like how you mentioned people moving here for opportunity. I'm one of them. I thank
02:30:34 you very much Alberta for taking in British Columbian here. Our family moved here in the
02:30:40 summer and just speaking personally I can give you a road map. You mentioned the cost of living
02:30:45 in Vancouver it's about 77 cents per liter is taxes on your gasoline here it's around 32 cents
02:30:53 per liter folks if you're filling up a pickup truck in Calgary you're saving 50 bucks every
02:30:59 time you're filling up just in the tax difference between those two cities and so I think that is a
02:31:05 huge draw and if some of these numbers hold maybe that's the right ticket is to focus on economic
02:31:10 issues. Absolutely. And something I've said, you know, many times before and other things is New
02:31:15 Albertans, whether from other countries or they're from other provinces, these are people typically
02:31:19 of ambition. I mean, that takes some courage. You've got to get up and leave your comfort zone,
02:31:23 your friends, your family. You're trying to make something more than from where you came from.
02:31:27 They're not asking somebody to do things for them. And these are people that do things for
02:31:30 themselves. So, I mean, that's just good people to tend to be conservative voters.
02:31:35 And it's interesting that we know that the UCP was trying to make this election about economic
02:31:39 issues. And I think a lot of the pundits and a lot of people said that they weren't being very
02:31:42 successful in that. But I think maybe these results would speak to what you just said. Maybe
02:31:46 the average Albertan, which I've always believed is more intelligent than the attacks and is looking
02:31:51 at the numbers and saying, what is good for me? Albertans love freedom. That's probably part of
02:31:56 why you came here, I would imagine. And I mean, I was in Ontario, but I moved back here because
02:32:02 this was the only place that felt like it could be free. So I think we are seeing Albertans
02:32:08 you have a resounding approval, stamp of approval to the freedom-based message of Danielle Smith
02:32:13 right now. What are the numbers we haven't seen? Yeah, well, I'll go to a quick check-in with
02:32:17 Arthur, but somebody else, one of the commenters, is asking, because the numbers have been updating.
02:32:20 So, well, perhaps while Arthur comes in, I'll give a quick rundown of what I'm seeing now,
02:32:24 because they're changing fast, finally. It was so agonizing. Oh, it was horrible.
02:32:27 So we've got 288,000 votes counted now, 27%. That is working out to a popular vote of, again,
02:32:36 still sitting at about 56% for the UCP, a little over 40% for the NDP. And of course, the other
02:32:43 parties just aren't a factor in this election. And roughly that's translating in the leading
02:32:48 in seats then to 50 for the UCP and 36 for NDP at this time. I guess Rocky Mountain House hasn't,
02:32:55 or is it Airdrie East still? Oh yeah, you probably. No worries. Well, I want to quickly
02:33:01 check in with r3 he's at ndp uh headquarters there hey arthur uh i'm wondering as results
02:33:07 are coming in are you starting to get a feel i mean i it wouldn't be you know you'd be getting
02:33:11 pretty nervous if you're an ndp supporter right now um the broom is quite loud in here uh in here
02:33:19 we just had a huge chair janice erwin is actually just sat behind me uh taking an interview with
02:33:26 with another media outlet, Edmonton Highwood's Norwood, she received 2,417 votes, UCP in
02:33:37 second place at 923, and of course not all of the polls are in yet.
02:33:46 You know, the rule here is starting to get as static as more NDP supporters pour in,
02:33:53 You know, they're completely optimistic that Rachel Notley will be the next Premier of Alberta.
02:34:00 But, I mean, we have to wait until the rest of the results, of course, come in.
02:34:06 Right now, we have a total of 219,000 votes in.
02:34:12 You know, it's 27%.
02:34:14 I have been looking at the spoiled ballots.
02:34:18 We do have some projected ballots, 1,327, and 132 decline ballots.
02:34:27 According to the website, we have 301,000 votes cast number.
02:34:33 So the results are going to come in faster than yours.
02:34:37 Yeah, well, I mean, I guess they're just trying to keep the cheer and keep the optimism.
02:34:42 I mean, it ain't over until the drifts and lady sings, but it's hurting to look in one pretty distinct direction so far.
02:34:50 But, well, we'll see how things go, and we'll check in later.
02:34:56 Yeah, I do believe, Corey, that I'm not well-liked here.
02:35:00 I did ask for some interviews from an NDP staffer, and I was told until the Western Standard apologizes.
02:35:08 We will not be granted any interviews.
02:35:10 So that's why I'm back on here in Exile Corner doing my updating.
02:35:17 It's unfortunate.
02:35:18 I mean, as what's probably going to be an up-and-coming party trying to gain traction,
02:35:21 they'd want a friendly media outlet at some point.
02:35:23 But we'll do an update to Arthur.
02:35:24 Just make sure you pour your own water there.
02:35:26 Don't get somebody to get it for you.
02:35:28 And we'll check in with you in a little while.
02:35:31 I've got my car parked near the front door.
02:35:35 Okay.
02:35:36 Thanks, Arthur.
02:35:37 Do you make him say cart more?
02:35:39 Just like every time he talks.
02:35:40 It's beautiful. This is the diversity of Alberta. Okay. So thanks, Arthur. We'll check in with you
02:35:48 a little later. It looks like Jonathan's going to be speaking to somebody in a few moments,
02:35:52 but you know, we've got a lot to talk about finally, right? You know, it's not just speculation
02:35:57 anymore. We're at 30% and now it's 50, 36, 55, 41 on those percentages. So, you know, I think
02:36:06 it's looking good now the question i have if people are still looking and wondering what's
02:36:11 going to be happening the first is how many of the advanced polls are reporting and how many of
02:36:16 have they reported yet are they even going to report the advanced polls until after they count
02:36:21 all of the first ones yeah i have that okay there we go so uh we have uh regular votes 178 000 of
02:36:30 them uh counted uh 125 000 advance okay so and 13 000 mobile and 9 700 special ballots so we don't
02:36:37 really have any outlying odd ballots now there that can uh can skew things then no no so i would
02:36:42 say like i don't understand the uh the ndp optimism right now they're just united in their loathing of
02:36:47 poor arthur but uh we'll make it worthwhile i gotta switch over to jonathan bradley and then
02:36:52 uh we're uh gonna achieve some things over so i'll check in with jonathan he's got somebody
02:36:56 uh on deck there and uh we'll talk to you guys later okay hello jonathan oh you've lost jonathan
02:37:02 you want us to stay uh well this is the way we're gonna be doing a change up maybe we'll uh
02:37:08 check in with dave naylor and uh go there's jonathan again all right i'm gonna talk to
02:37:14 somebody in a moment and uh okay it looks like jonathan with that brad tenant hey how you doing
02:37:21 Brad? You've got no sound, Brad. All right. So we'll check in with Dave Naylor and see what's
02:37:31 going on with the updated results. I don't think Jonathan's got the sound going. So Dave,
02:37:37 there's room. It's getting a little more lively now.
02:37:41 Yeah, it's getting more interesting. But I know what everybody's wanting to know right now,
02:37:48 Corey is how many votes the commies have
02:37:51 and I can tell you across Alberta
02:37:53 the Communist Party of Alberta
02:37:55 has got 123 votes
02:37:56 so like what the heck's going
02:37:59 on
02:37:59 it's as many as you can slip
02:38:03 when reaching over the ballot
02:38:04 maybe it's he who shouldn't
02:38:07 be named but what the heck if we're going to
02:38:08 punch down any signs of
02:38:10 Ardur Palowski making a breakthrough in this poll
02:38:13 so far
02:38:13 he's the solidarity movement right or is he the
02:38:16 independence party uh something solid coming out of them solidarity 952 uh might as well just run
02:38:24 down a few of these uh cory the liberal party 1025 the alberta party 2946 the commies as mentioned
02:38:33 223. The Greenies, 2,848. The Pro-Life Alberta Political Association, 19. The Reform Party of Alberta, 29. The Buffalo Party of Alberta, 20. The Independence Party of Alberta, 994.
02:38:53 The Wild Rose Independence Party, 286.
02:38:59 Man, what a difference from the last election.
02:39:02 So right now we've got 31% of all polls reporting, 350,000 ballots counted.
02:39:10 And it seems to be holding out now at 51 UCP, 36 for the new Democrats.
02:39:18 UCP with 55% of the popular vote.
02:39:21 uh ndp with uh 41 all right thanks for the update dave uh we'll check in with you soon i'm sure it's
02:39:29 gonna be getting your time to to call this for uh one party or another and uh we'll pivot over
02:39:35 to the ucp headquarters where jonathan bradley has brad tenant i believe uh ready to chat with
02:39:40 us there and we'll see how are you doing oh i'm hearing some noise right on hello brad how you
02:39:47 doing out there excellent good good so I mean the rumors got to be starting to
02:39:55 get pretty jubilant after such a long stalling intention I guess waiting for
02:39:58 our results you know people are people are getting excited here it's going to
02:40:08 sustain UCP lead and I think people are just waiting to see some of the some
02:40:15 more depth for those results to come in to back that up.
02:40:19 Right. So, I mean, with things tonight though, I mean,
02:40:23 it's been quite a nail biter that there's still,
02:40:27 it looks like Edmonton's still going to stick pretty solidly orange.
02:40:30 Do you think there might be a couple of breakthroughs around there though?
02:40:33 I mean, the night's going well, but it can't seem to crack that crowd over there.
02:40:37 Yeah. I think that there's,
02:40:38 there's definitely a number that the UCP is going to play in. You know,
02:40:42 I think that the federal election shows that the Conservatives can usually win overwhelmingly there,
02:40:47 and we were close last Provincial election in a number of seats that, you know, in the last week
02:40:52 where you weren't able to get it done, but there's some good candidates there. I wouldn't count it
02:40:56 out at this point. So much of this is going to come down to advanced polls and still stuff to be
02:41:01 reported. So I think there's still some hope for the UCP in Edmonton. Right on. Well, we got a lot
02:41:09 lot of viewers looking forward to things some people who can't make it down to the rally
02:41:12 themselves uh anything you can uh send their way is it too late to come down or i imagine
02:41:17 the speeches are gonna start pretty uh yeah no i can see in my own view some people screaming
02:41:23 in i think some people are screaming in from local campaign offices too so uh you know still
02:41:28 still getting going here and i think uh at some point tonight we'll have a speech and a pretty
02:41:32 exciting crowd excellent well thanks for checking in with us there and uh your patience with our
02:41:38 audio. I really appreciate it. And well, let's see if you got a good night ahead of you.
02:41:44 Yeah, perfect. Thanks for having me.
02:41:46 Great. Thank you. Well, that was Brad Tennant kind of back there. Okay. So we've refreshed
02:41:52 our panel here. A couple of, well, kind of recycled, I guess you guys have been in tonight
02:41:58 already, but that's all right. And we've got Josh Anders and James Finkbeiner. How are you guys
02:42:05 doing? I'm good. I'm great. Things are looking good. Things are looking solid as the numbers
02:42:11 are coming in. I'm happy with what we're seeing. You know, I'd hope that with the tabulators that
02:42:16 some of the votes would be coming in a little bit more quickly. But, you know, it is what it is.
02:42:21 Every vote's going to get counted. And, you know, it should be wrapped up here, hopefully,
02:42:26 in the next hour or so. Yeah, we'll see. So, I mean, I'll give another quick update because
02:42:30 these numbers are just coming in really fast, finally. They were kind of blocked up at the
02:42:34 damn. So 410,000 votes cast, 35% reporting. We're looking at 42% for the NDP in popular vote, 0.99
02:42:44 55 for the UCP, roughly with the leading in ridings, 48 with the UCP to 39 with the NDP.
02:42:52 So Josh, what do you think, what's happened tonight? Well, it looks like the Conservatives
02:42:57 are coming home. It was touch and go there for a while during the campaign, but we're starting to
02:43:02 We saw the late endorsement by Pierre Polyev, we saw the late endorsement by Stephen Harper.
02:43:07 I think that put a lot of people's minds at ease, and I thought Danielle's performance in the debate
02:43:12 really calmed a lot of fears amongst more, what we won't call the mainstream conservatives,
02:43:17 but more progressive conservatives that were concerned about some of the more extreme rhetoric coming from,
02:43:22 well, more the mainstream media reporting than anything else.
02:43:26 But it is nice to see.
02:43:28 I mean, this election never should have been in doubt.
02:43:31 this is a very conservative leading province with very strong conservative values across
02:43:35 the board so I do think it's just the conservatives are coming home
02:43:39 to roost and it's just kind of part of the course with the united party yeah so I mean
02:43:46 what I think has kind of happened a little bit is I mean they overshot you know they kind of put
02:43:53 everything out in that first two weeks the NDP with the negative and honestly it brought me down
02:43:57 a little thinking wow okay that this has been effective but we'll see I mean just in the sense
02:44:01 of the negativity of it all uh but it seems to in my view I mean they inoculated it they couldn't
02:44:07 move on to becoming a policy thing they were just stuck uh James I think with that that whole
02:44:12 negative we've just got to smear the other team enough and not talk about ourselves well and that
02:44:16 was the thing and and I think Rachel Notley forgot that she was also the premier at a certain point
02:44:20 and she had a record to run on or run against as well and I think when people look back and they
02:44:26 really started to remember how bad things were under the NDP. I think that's where a lot of the
02:44:32 more progressive and the more moderate conservatives looked back and really thought, you know, what is
02:44:37 a 38% tax increase actually going to look like? Because last time it looked like hundreds of
02:44:42 thousands of job losses. And this time modestly, it was looking at tens of thousands of job losses.
02:44:48 And when you still have, you know, downtown Calgary, that's just starting to get back up
02:44:53 on its on its feet. It's just starting to turn the corner. The, you know, the progressives in
02:44:58 Calgary, they're showing up to vote and they're showing up and they're saying, you know, you know
02:45:02 what, we we trust Danielle, we trust conservative math. We trust their fiscal policy to continue to
02:45:09 guide us to prosperity. And that's how we do it in Alberta is by keeping taxes low.
02:45:14 Well, and that was something a bit more of a turning point to me when we finally got a policy
02:45:19 a real solid one from the NDP was that, hey, we're going to hike the corporate tax. And that one just
02:45:24 kind of flatlined a little. It felt like among the populace, you know, they didn't want to quite hear
02:45:29 that. But I think they had to throw some red meat to their own base. I mean, the NDP has really been
02:45:34 working hard to moderate themselves. They wanted to make them sound as if they're a more progressive
02:45:38 wing of a mainstream party. But, you know, they had to do something for their base, for their
02:45:42 union. So the old let's stick it to the corporations tax might have felt like a good idea, but it
02:45:48 It didn't seem to resonate at all the time.
02:45:49 Well, it wasn't just that.
02:45:51 I felt like a lot of, like, the attacks came early.
02:45:53 They came hard.
02:45:54 They came early.
02:45:55 And they seemed to peter out at the end.
02:45:57 I mean, I talked to people, and they were, they keep hearing the same attack ad about, you know, spending for doctor's appointments or having to pay for doctor's appointments or so on and so forth.
02:46:09 And all these attacks, they kind of, they fell flat.
02:46:11 They kind of ran out of steam.
02:46:13 And people just if you if you keep hearing the same thing over and over again, it kind of it disrupts the message.
02:46:19 And I did I do think that the back half of the campaign, I was really impressed with the UCP's message discipline.
02:46:25 They talked about the issues. They talked about what they were going to do.
02:46:28 They didn't focus on the fact that the NDP didn't really have much of a campaign platform other than attack, attack, attack.
02:46:35 So I do think that that these are the factors that are coming in.
02:46:38 The polls showed that the UCP had momentum coming in, and I think it's a lot of that has to do with message discipline and just, you know, the fact that the NDP came out too hard, too fast, and ran out of attacks about midway through the campaign.
02:46:55 Well, to be fair, I mean, Premier Smith gave them a lot of ammunition to work with.
02:47:00 I mean, there were a lot of very questionable statements that there was thousands of hours of podcast time of radio time, you know, shows all over the place. But I mean, you can only dig it up so much. I mean, the people who are going to be put off by something she said in a past radio show or a podcast or something, they were put off in the first week. You know, when you keep compounding, it didn't compound into an added effect, I think, and losing this.
02:47:25 Well, the major attacks were that the UCP is going to make you pay to see your family physician, but we know that that's not even possible. Under the Canada Health Act, it's not even possible. And she's always supported a single-payer public system with mixed private public delivery. And we're already seeing just a few changes. We're seeing ambulances. When was the last code read?
02:47:49 every other day we were reporting on this uh emergency rooms across the province were closing
02:47:53 every other weekend but we're seeing that start to stabilize we're seeing more doctors we're seeing
02:47:58 more nurses come into the province we've had uh the the um most in migration of any province in 0.98
02:48:04 the country right now uh we're continuing to grow and we're seeing some of the first policies that
02:48:11 she put in when she became the premier they're starting to actually have an effect and people
02:48:15 are starting to see these things change in their daily lives so you know if we continue down this
02:48:21 track well how long until the surgical wait times are dropped significantly with uh with the new
02:48:26 system that we're we're putting in place well that was quite a gamble on the part of danielle smith 0.93
02:48:31 when she said she committed back in january said we're going to make these changes to the ems and
02:48:35 she said we're going to see results by spring she was confident in it but that could have backfired
02:48:39 terribly because if those results hadn't been seen i know if i was an ndp strategist i'd be
02:48:43 playing that quote and said, look what she said in January. Obviously, the rest of her health care 1.00
02:48:47 policies aren't going to play. And I mean, it was difficult for her to campaign against herself. I
02:48:52 mean, some of those quotes, if you took them direct, though, she did say outright that perhaps
02:48:56 people should pay, you know, when they just do a doctor's visit or things like that. That scares a
02:48:59 lot of people. The NDP smelled blood in the water with that, but I guess it didn't resonate in the
02:49:04 end. Yeah, I think just because it was such a negative approach that they had throughout the
02:49:09 campaign. They had a difficult time really promoting policies that were positive. So just
02:49:16 by taking such a negative approach, it made it difficult for them to promote the things that
02:49:20 they were going to do to help. I mean, I can't really list off very many that I saw on the
02:49:25 multitudes of TV ads and other media sources where I saw NDP attack ads. I didn't see anything
02:49:32 talking about what the NDP was going to do. And a big reason for that is that they can't really
02:49:36 campaign on their record they for four years they were in government we saw unemployment go up you
02:49:42 know rapidly we saw one of the deepest recessions in the history of this province and and so for
02:49:47 them i think they had to they they the only approach they could take that made sense to them
02:49:52 was it was an approach that really was it was a negative approach it was to try and make
02:49:56 danielle seem like a crazy angry conspiracy theorist and and at the end of the day i think 0.96
02:50:03 that the way that she handled herself throughout the campaign she was very calm she was very
02:50:07 measured she was very academic and intellectual in her approach throughout the campaign and i
02:50:12 think it kind of it eased a lot of fears that amongst the population about a lot of the things
02:50:18 that the ndp were using as attacks um whether that be health care or or the economy or really
02:50:25 or a crime right like we have all yeah that was another big one that was uh really i think that
02:50:32 It probably really affected a lot of people.
02:50:33 We spoke earlier with the last panelists about how, you know, meat and potatoes issues such as paying the bills.
02:50:38 I mean, those resonate with people.
02:50:39 But feeling safe.
02:50:40 I mean, in the urban battleground, Calgary, Edmonton, when at least traditionally the NDP is going to take that permissive approach, things with drug enablement.
02:50:50 I mean, we've got a lot of battles going on in every city, a very bad problem of addiction everywhere.
02:50:55 Again, Premier Smith took a very definitive stance on approaching policing and addictions treatment.
02:51:00 And the NDP didn't say much.
02:51:02 They just kind of didn't put out a counter policy, I didn't think, on that.
02:51:05 No, and kind of surprising, in the Premier's debate against NDP candidate Gwendolyn Dirk in the Brooks Chamber of Commerce debate,
02:51:17 the NDP candidate came out swinging, saying that the UCP's policy of recovery doesn't work,
02:51:23 and that the facilities that they've opened up are a mess
02:51:27 and that they're struggling to treat people properly.
02:51:31 And I mean, I know people personally,
02:51:33 I've had family that have since gone
02:51:35 into these treatment facilities
02:51:37 and people are actually coming out successful
02:51:39 and they're doing better.
02:51:41 And the new Alberta recovery model that's going in place,
02:51:45 like the recovery facility that's opening up in Red Deer,
02:51:48 that has taken some long-term thinking
02:51:50 and it has a long-term goal.
02:51:51 That's not just a 28-day program. That could be up to a year. That could be more, depending on what the client's needs are. You know, this is something that no other government in this country has actually tried, which is taking the addiction crisis head on and actually doing something about it.
02:52:08 so far, they've done nothing but to push it off, you know, to, we started with the needle
02:52:15 exchanges and the clean needles, and then we went to safe injection, and we've just seen nothing
02:52:20 but chaos and deaths. And I think the numbers that came out, I think it was actually a National Post
02:52:26 article that came out in the last week. Right now, just at the beginning of this year,
02:52:32 Alberta's numbers are down significantly, and British Columbia's numbers are almost double.
02:52:36 So when you have, you know, an NDP government that is being echoed by the NDP party in Alberta, you know, they're already failing there and they want to champion the exact same programs here.
02:52:49 Well, you know what? We can compare side by side which program's actually doing better.
02:52:55 And, you know, the NDP didn't come up with a better idea.
02:52:57 They didn't, you know, they said, OK, we're going to keep expanding recovery.
02:53:01 OK, but what else? You know, where's the policing and security that comes with it?
02:53:05 You know, what about the random attacks? What about the stabbings? What about the murders? What about the open air drug use? And these aren't just Calgary Edmonton problems. You know, I did, I lost the nomination in Cypress Medicine Hat. This is a Medicine Hat issue. This is a Lethbridge issue. This is a Red Deer, Grand Prairie, Fort McMurray.
02:53:22 There is not a single community in this province that the mental health and addictions crisis isn't affecting.
02:53:28 And, you know, the UCP has basically built their entire health care and their plan around health care, policing, security, mental health, addictions, everything.
02:53:39 It starts around this recovery model and grows out.
02:53:41 It grows out into jobs.
02:53:43 It grows out into training, into education.
02:53:45 And, you know, that's a full plan.
02:53:47 And that's something that Albertans could sink their teeth into.
02:53:49 And the NDP just had nothing to come back to that with.
02:53:51 if i could just piggyback on now cut in quickly sorry we've had someone on deck for a bit there
02:53:56 so we'll check in because i got a feeling it's going to get too loud to speak to people over
02:53:59 there pretty soon at the ucp uh gathering down there and we've got rebecca shoals there uh hey 1.00
02:54:06 how are you doing over there hi there yeah it's a little loud in here so it's a bit hard to hear
02:54:13 you guys but things are uh going well i think there people are pretty anxious uh to see some
02:54:18 but the results start to roll in great um so i mean this was a uh well i don't want to call it
02:54:25 over yet but you know it's it's definitely been one of the most hard fought elections i've seen
02:54:30 in quite some time i believe it was mr cloutier down south you were running against uh have you
02:54:36 found it to be a more difficult campaign than 2019. you know i would say it's a different campaign
02:54:42 than in 2019 obviously there have been a couple of challenging years here in alberta
02:54:47 uh with what we saw economically speaking but where we are today coming out of this leading
02:54:52 the nation seeing a more diverse uh very strong economy jobs and opportunity more people choosing
02:54:57 to call alberta home i think when people look at where alberta is today versus where alberta was
02:55:02 uh back in 2019 i think that that's the choice that albertans are making tonight
02:55:08 great well and i mean uh you know you you ran for the leadership you made a good goal of it and you
02:55:14 stuck with it which is something you know i would like to see more of i mean while you're young
02:55:18 there's a lot of uh in the future for you uh as part of unity felt uh good i mean it might be some
02:55:24 tense times you've all come through in this last month you know uh it has been a challenging couple
02:55:32 of years like i said but after the leadership race i think our team really came together
02:55:37 uh obviously in the best interest of our party and for albertans uh we solidified behind our
02:55:44 leader Danielle Smith and put forward a platform that built on the work that we had done over the
02:55:49 last four years and what we had released in a spring budget that's really focused on jobs,
02:55:55 economic growth, keeping our communities safe. We balanced the budget not once but twice and
02:56:01 introduced balanced budget legislation which it does matter to Albertans. Albertans know what it
02:56:06 was like to have the debt paid in full and so we were really focused on coming together to keep
02:56:11 Alberta moving forward and you know put forward a platform that Albertans could really get behind
02:56:16 and support. Well it's not over yet but it's getting close so it looks like you have a lot
02:56:23 of work ahead of you either way that you look at it so I appreciate you checking in with us. Is there
02:56:28 anything you'd like to leave our viewers with before I let you go back to the gathering there?
02:56:33 Oh sorry I didn't quite catch that last question there but I also appreciate your time and I think
02:56:40 we're all very much looking forward to the results great thank you very much uh we'll talk again soon
02:56:45 i hope all right so that was uh rebecca shells coming from the the ucp headquarters i'm going
02:56:52 to check in with dave because we've had a lot of numbers coming in and uh it's getting uh yeah
02:56:58 we're getting close to i think being able to to make some strong predictions on how things are
02:57:02 going to come hey dave how are we looking now well corey we're approaching 600 000 ballots counted
02:57:09 44 percent of the polling stations have reported and we seem to be settling in at 52 to 35
02:57:17 writings for the ucp taking a look at some of the closer ones uh calgary acadia the ndp is pulled
02:57:25 ahead but it's only by about 60 votes and that's with less than half of the uh poll stations
02:57:32 recording calgary bow ucp ahead by uh 500 votes uh with seven out of 16 poll stations uh reporting
02:57:43 uh what else is close in calgary calgary edgemont uh that's been back and forth all night currently
02:57:49 UCP ahead 93.13 to 88.75. Calgary Elbow, about 300 vote leading for the NDP there.
02:58:03 Calgary Foothills, the UCP candidate is up only by 200, and that's with more than half of the
02:58:11 polls reporting now. Calgary Northwest, UCP up 35-62, 31-49 for the NDP. So that one's
02:58:23 not over by a long shot. And Edmonton is all NDP as predicted. Looks like Airdrie is going
02:58:36 to be all UCP. Banff Kananaskis, the UCP candidate, up by 1,700 votes right now. So that's a bit of a
02:58:47 shock there, Corey. That was marked down by many as a bellwether riding that was going to be very
02:58:53 close. But UCP seemed to be off to a running start there. Drayton Valley, Devon, the easy win for the
02:59:03 UCP. Both the Fort McMurray
02:59:07 ridings appear to be going the UCP.
02:59:11 What else do we want to talk about? Lethbridge, both of the
02:59:15 ridings down there going to NDP. Lethbridge East
02:59:18 is the closer of the two, 768 to
02:59:22 618. Morinville now
02:59:27 with a 1,100 vote lead for the UCP.
02:59:30 red deer continues to be voting ucp sherwood park it looks like it's going ndp with a
02:59:39 almost a 1500 vote majority there and the rest is the rest so the big surprise to me there is the
02:59:49 the big the big lead that ucp has in banff cory that comes as a bit of a shock to everybody
02:59:56 Yeah, all right. Well, including me, as I said, I live in Bay of Canaanaskis. It is a tricky
03:00:03 riding. You know, Miranda Rosen, that's her first term in it. And the further east you go in that 0.93
03:00:09 one, the constituency starts way out in Prentice where I am, which is very conservative and ends
03:00:13 up in Lake Louise, which is not. So it looks like Miranda's really done her groundwork out there
03:00:19 and then done well with it yep it's uh she's in in the catbird seat right now right on okay well
03:00:27 thanks dave well uh looks like somebody will be calling this one fairly soon i imagine uh you
03:00:32 would think so we have 46 of the ballots uh now cast so you know uh elections uh in previous years
03:00:40 we were able to call them after 30 minutes but uh you know we're now three hours into this one
03:00:45 Yeah, no, nothing's happening fast tonight. All right. Thanks, Steve. We'll check in with you
03:00:49 again soon, I'm sure. Thanks. All right. And I'll just throw one more out there. I saw a commenter
03:00:55 asking about Fort Saskatchewan, Vigraville. That's 3,400 for the UCP and 1,700 for the NDP. So that
03:01:00 one's pretty, pretty solidly UCP. Okay. So we've shaken up our panel again. It's gotten a lot
03:01:06 prettier now. Oh, thank you. Last couple of guys. Oh, Josh, you know, you're looking in the right
03:01:12 light he can either way that's sidetracking so chris sim's back again and christine cusinelli
03:01:19 welcome back to the desk tonight we got some results to discuss now they're really pouring
03:01:23 in uh so uh it's been a while since you've been in uh christina what do you think you know it looks
03:01:29 like we would the conservative ucp uh nail biter hasn't turned out to be quite as much of what they 0.52
03:01:35 thought it well and you know i i didn't think it was going to be too much of a nail biter to be
03:01:39 honest tonight um i feel pretty confident um even arriving tonight i felt really confident because
03:01:45 um you know if you look at how things were played out the media always likes to kind of play oh you
03:01:52 know uh we have a two-party system at the moment really and it's a bit of a like two horse race
03:01:58 right so the media really really played that up and i think that they were more dramatic
03:02:02 um about uh what the result tonight is going to show um my feeling going into this was that it
03:02:07 was going to be a win a solid win maybe we weren't going to be you know a total landslide but it's
03:02:13 going to be a solid win i think it's it's certainly starting to to shape up that way uh again chris
03:02:18 you know uh this was this landing kind of around where your predictions were or it's see i'm in
03:02:23 lethbridge east which looks like a flipping seat back and forth how many votes are in there if i
03:02:29 put you on the spot here because so so for me right outside my front door it felt close
03:02:36 And every time I was listening to the news, it felt close.
03:02:38 So I thought it was going to be closer.
03:02:40 Again, we've only got 46% of ballots.
03:02:42 So Lethbridge East, one of 27 polls has reported.
03:02:46 It was a big one because it has 768 votes for the NDP and 618 for the UCP.
03:02:52 But only one?
03:02:53 Only one out of 27, according to this.
03:02:55 And see, that can be different.
03:02:56 So that can change a great deal yet.
03:02:59 It depends on which part of Lethbridge you're in.
03:03:01 Exactly.
03:03:01 Exactly. And so so I'm on the east side and I live in the north side. Well, you know, we'll see.
03:03:06 We'll see. You know, for me, honestly, what matters is how much money people are keeping in their pockets and how what the size of government is and how, you know, nasty it can become.
03:03:15 And so the north side of Lethbridge, for example, is a bit more working class, whereas the south side, you've got more voter concentration around the hospital, for example.
03:03:24 And so that could, depending on which polling station is in, that could be how it's showing up, depending that way.
03:03:29 I find it again very interesting how for the most part I've been getting messages about issues
03:03:36 people write to us about their pocketbook about not being able to afford to fill up their vehicles
03:03:42 about not being able to afford food what kind of prospects their kid is going to have for a job
03:03:47 what I find interesting is that a lot of us especially those of us who've been in media for
03:03:51 a long time can get kind of caught up in the Hollywood you know back and forth fun game show
03:03:56 thing of politics most normal people don't care about politicians what you know they don't and
03:04:02 i'm sorry to burst people's bubble to me this is just the olympics but most normal people don't
03:04:07 care and so i think that's where they drift away from the whole horse race personality who said
03:04:13 what blah blah blah and they're really about pocketbook issues well and twitter isn't the
03:04:18 real world no and i spend a lot of time there i know that i have a good time on twitter and that
03:04:22 But if Twitter was the reality, we'd have probably 82 NDP seats right now or something already.
03:04:29 So, I mean, they've dominated social media, but Twitter accounts can't vote, thankfully, yet.
03:04:33 There you go. And the real people that are going out to vote, I think,
03:04:36 represent the folks that you're talking about. The real people that are going out to vote,
03:04:41 they're the ones who are motivated because they have concerns about what is happening within
03:04:45 their household, the income that they're bringing in versus what they're going to be having to put
03:04:48 out there and I think that probably the stake in the ground I believe happened to be when the NDP
03:04:55 announced that they were going to be upping a corporate tax because most people understand
03:04:59 that at the end of the day there is only one taxpayer and it doesn't matter where you're going
03:05:04 to go and increase that tax everybody should understand at this point who's going to be the
03:05:08 responsible voter going out there they understand that at the end of the day that means less money
03:05:13 coming into their household. And what's really interesting about that corporate tax hike
03:05:17 bear with me because it sounds counterintuitive when the corporate tax rate is low when it's eight
03:05:23 percent the government took in more money i'll repeat that when the corporate tax rate was at
03:05:30 eight percent it took in around six billion dollars from that tax when it was floating at
03:05:36 around twelve percent it took in around four billion dollars now why is that of course that's
03:05:42 because more people are opening up shop more people are physically moving here more people
03:05:46 are investing and actually starting businesses so it sounds counterintuitive right if you want to
03:05:50 make more money from something just increase the price but that's not how that works because the
03:05:54 corporation the business will find other ways of cutting costs they might leave depends it might
03:05:59 downsize it may not hire those extra folks it all depends but actually at that lower corporate tax
03:06:04 rate you take in more revenue as a government and i think we're going to see that people are going
03:06:09 to gravitate towards that mentality because you know at the end of the day what we're all looking
03:06:15 for is to be able to have make our money go a lot longer so those are the people that i think uh have
03:06:22 gone out to vote today i'm counting on that um and at the at the end of our results today i think that
03:06:27 we're going to see a broader conservative um i guess mindset that is going to be pervasive more
03:06:33 more so across the province i don't think that the ndp coming in in 2015 was going to be something
03:06:40 that was going to trend in the future i never believed that um the the day that i lost my seat
03:06:46 um and and that is because i i think that albertans are by and large people who uh believe
03:06:52 strongly in uh stimulating our economy uh using principles that are conservative principles fiscal
03:06:59 fiscal principles that are that are conservative and you know at the at the end of tonight's show
03:07:05 my thinking is that Rachel Notley unfortunately is probably going to have to decide whether or 0.99
03:07:11 not she'll continue as the leader of the party and they're going to have to do some thinking
03:07:16 about where they're headed in the future. I also think that there's going to be some
03:07:19 interesting makings and certainly some inroads that the Alberta party could make as a result of
03:07:24 whatever happens tonight which I believe is going to be a UCP victory. At the end of the day I don't
03:07:29 really think that similar to Saskatchewan how people have left Saskatchewan to come to Alberta
03:07:35 I believe it was you earlier who said that.
03:07:36 I came from British Columbia too.
03:07:37 Yeah, lots of people came from Saskatchewan, yeah.
03:07:40 I think that those have been the historic trends politically that have taken place.
03:07:47 And Alberta, I think we lost our way a little bit because we looked at the
03:07:51 Progressive Conservative Party as entitled and we had lost our way.
03:07:57 We assumed we were going to continue winning.
03:07:59 But I don't think that people are going to keep the NDP necessarily
03:08:03 in the next election. The Alberta party, I think, has a really, really good opportunity here.
03:08:09 Well, yeah, I'm glad you brought up the third parties, because we've just passed the 50%
03:08:14 mark now. We've got 721,000 votes in, it's 51%. We're looking at 44% for the NDP,
03:08:20 52% for the UCP. It's a 52 to 35 is sort of where the seats are sitting at right now.
03:08:26 Now we've got, I don't know what it is, a dozen or more other parties in this race of varying strength,
03:08:31 and none of them have broken 1%.
03:08:35 I had spoken with Professor Flanagan on my show a little while back
03:08:39 and he pointed out to me, though, he said, look, as I said, with no right split, this should be
03:08:43 easy. He says, Alberta isn't as right as you think it is 0.98
03:08:47 before you had a Liberal Party that was also cutting up things kind of on the left
03:08:51 so you could afford to have this. Right now we are truly two-party
03:08:55 and this might be the, it's been the first time in a long time, might be the first time for a long time coming
03:08:59 because parties will start sprouting up perhaps and expanding,
03:09:02 but it gives a good measure of the province then right now.
03:09:04 So, I mean, if we're looking at a 52% UCP, 44% NDP,
03:09:11 that's a conservative-leaning province, but not overwhelmingly so.
03:09:14 It doesn't look like our federal outlook does.
03:09:15 And it doesn't look like it used to look years ago.
03:09:19 However, I found it interesting, I heard a commentator point this out,
03:09:22 that for the longest time, whatever term you want to use
03:09:26 the Conservative Party that existed here in Alberta, it encompassed so many more people within that,
03:09:32 right? You'd have a much wider range of views within that very, very big blue tent. Now it
03:09:38 seems to be concentrating more into more firm, clear philosophy and ideology, and maybe that's
03:09:44 why we're looking at more of a two-party system right now. No matter what happens, we're at 51%
03:09:50 you said ballots are in it's encouraging to see people get a voice and have some hope one of the
03:09:57 things that we do at the taxpayers federation is try to empower people and give them agency
03:10:01 into voice and tell them you know what you can go to your city council and you can monitor them
03:10:07 uh you can write that letter you can call that mla because you are their boss and i find giving 0.82
03:10:13 people that agency really brings up their level of hope and it involves and includes participation
03:10:19 There you go. And, you know, I love that you brought that up because one of the things that I was hoping to be able to say tonight is about the leadership of Danielle Smith. You know, she didn't have a lot of runway when she won the leadership, you know, back six whatever months, however many months ago. That's not a lot of time. And I'll tell you that that to me is probably the most amazing comeback politically I've ever seen.
03:10:42 And I think that Danielle, her greatest strength, which is also her greatest weakness, is the fact that she is so open minded.
03:10:50 Now, that's very rare, because quite often when a leader gets into the seat, they start to lose touch.
03:10:56 And it's so easy. I can tell you from personal experience, you get sucked into.
03:11:01 We actually call it dome disease.
03:11:03 We call it auto wash at the Ottawa level.
03:11:05 There you go. Dome disease.
03:11:07 I don't know who coined it. I don't know where it came from. But we certainly, you know, we poke each other and say dome disease. And you know what, I think that Danielle is going to have the next if she wins tonight, which I believe she will, the next six to nine months. What I hope to see from her is, I don't feel like I think the people need to rally around and I'm speaking directly to our party. We need to rally around this leader. We need to be able to say to her that she doesn't need to apologize anymore.
03:11:37 for all of the things that she may have said in the past.
03:11:40 Being a media personality versus being a leader of a party are two different things.
03:11:45 And I think that if she continues doing the same things that she has done so far,
03:11:49 which is listen to people, listen to the grassroots of the organization,
03:11:53 she's not always going to be able to say yes to everybody.
03:11:56 She will not.
03:11:57 That's just by virtue of being in that seat of authority and power.
03:12:01 But I know for a fact my experience so far has been she is still reachable.
03:12:07 She is still somebody who's in touch with, you know, if you have her personal cell phone number, she will continue to embrace those people who got her there in the first place.
03:12:16 And I really think that the future ahead for her is going to be great.
03:12:20 Great.
03:12:21 Okay.
03:12:21 Well, we're going to do a check in with Dave and then a little shuffle here and we'll move on with our coverage here.
03:12:27 It's teasing magic.
03:12:28 We're going to disappear.
03:12:29 Absolutely.
03:12:30 So, Mr. Naylor, how are things going?
03:12:33 Going live.
03:12:34 I don't know where he's going.
03:12:37 hey uh cory how's it going good good good sorry sorry didn't wake wake up uh yeah 50 not really
03:12:47 much news cory uh 54 percent of uh writings now uh uh polls now reporting 782 988 ballots cast
03:12:59 which means so far we've got a turnout of about 28 percent where that ends up of course up in the
03:13:07 air and we're holding at 53 seats elected and leading for the ucp and 34 seats elected and
03:13:16 leading for the ndp in terms of percentage of the vote ndp at 52 and a half percent and the ndp at
03:13:26 43.7%. Close ridings, Calgary, Acadia, Tyler Shandro now ahead by 10 votes. So it's more than half of the, or just under half of the polls counted.
03:13:44 UCP ahead by a couple of hundred and actually by 400.
03:13:48 The number just got updated in Calgary Bow.
03:13:52 Calgary Curry appears to be gone to the NDP, 8,211 votes to 6,325.
03:14:02 Calgary Edgemont is still fairly close with the UCP leading by less than 400 votes.
03:14:10 Calgary Elbow is also close with the NDP up by about 150 votes.
03:14:16 Don't trust my math here, though, Corey.
03:14:20 Don't forget I did fail math 10.
03:14:21 That's why I went into journalism, because I can't count.
03:14:26 What else is of interest here?
03:14:30 Let's check in again with Banff.
03:14:33 Banff Kananaskis.
03:14:36 Wow.
03:14:36 the UCP candidate is up 4,824 votes to 2,642 votes. So that's turned out to be not even close.
03:14:49 So that's the latest update from out here, guys. Throw it back to you guys in the studio.
03:14:56 Thank you very much, Dave. All right. Well, some of you are wondering, why haven't we called it yet?
03:15:02 Well, that's because there's a lot of ridings that have results coming in, which makes sense.
03:15:12 It's not, you know, when there's like one vote coming in in Fort McMurray for the NDP, we're not calling it for that.
03:15:19 It doesn't make sense.
03:15:20 But there's a lot of ridings that are on a knife's edge that I think might go the way they're trending,
03:15:27 but there's still way too many polls to come in and could flip at any moment.
03:15:33 Christina, one, so I'll come back to your old stomping grounds, 1.00
03:15:38 Calgary Curry, which you represented from 2012 to 2015.
03:15:43 Calgary Curry right now, it's trending NDP.
03:15:47 I think at this point it probably is going 8,213 votes.
03:15:52 Actually, more just came, yeah, 8,213 to 6,327.
03:15:56 Probably not going UCP.
03:15:59 But it wasn't a bellwether.
03:16:00 The NDP was expected to win this one, right?
03:16:02 Absolutely.
03:16:02 I had hope.
03:16:03 Hope springs eternal.
03:16:06 Yeah.
03:16:07 But maybe we'll look at some of the ones in that neighborhood.
03:16:11 So let's talk Elbow.
03:16:13 Elbow is a must win for the NDP.
03:16:16 It's a nice win for the UCP.
03:16:19 But it's a nice fight.
03:16:21 I actually thought the NDP would run away with a bit more at this point.
03:16:24 Yeah.
03:16:24 48.1% NDP, 46.6% UCP, and still a fair number of votes still to come.
03:16:33 And if you look at the vote split there, I think that may be part of the reason that we're seeing, you know, this kind of like push and pull.
03:16:42 Chris Davis is a great candidate.
03:16:45 He, I think he could, he was able to rival the NDP, who's, I'm sorry, I don't know his name.
03:16:53 You're talking an elbow?
03:16:55 Yeah.
03:16:56 Samir Kayandi?
03:16:58 Yeah, Kayandi, who is also a terrific candidate. 0.58
03:17:03 And of course, Jonathan mentioned this earlier.
03:17:05 So I just want to say it's usually the leader that carries the flag that way.
03:17:10 But nonetheless, if you're going door to door and you're looking down to the vote by vote by vote,
03:17:15 we have two very comparable candidates, evenly matched.
03:17:18 Chris Davis is a very compassionate man.
03:17:21 he has dedicated himself quite a bit in the community and so I didn't think it was going
03:17:26 to be as an easy win for the NDP as I think was portrayed in the very beginning. I live right next
03:17:31 door so I drive around a lot and I so signs don't vote we know that but nonetheless I saw a ton of
03:17:39 support out there on private properties for Chris Davis and again he is somebody that I think would
03:17:44 appeal to people at the doors especially if they're more progressive in nature which they are
03:17:48 an elbow. So I want to come down to talk about writing here that I thought it is definitely
03:17:53 100% must win for the NDP. I thought was going to be in the NDP column. One vote separating right
03:18:00 now. Calgary, Kline, Jeremy Nixon. This keeps on going up and down and up and down. Jeremy
03:18:06 Nixon, UCP. This is not Jason Nixon. They're brothers. Jeremy Nixon, UCP, 4,275. The NDP's
03:18:16 Lizette Tejada 4,274. This is going to be interesting. But this is a must win for the
03:18:25 NDP. The NDP doesn't win this riding. Thanks for coming out. It's over. And I love that it's going
03:18:31 that direction. I actually underestimated this particular riding. I had it a bit on the X and
03:18:36 I was feeling really upset about it because Jeremy is, again, he's a great man. I think he's
03:18:44 he's a very caring person i think he represented his riding really well um he started off as a
03:18:49 brand new mla and i think he really grew into the role so um i'm really happy to see this
03:18:55 um get the like this map up on do you have it yeah okay uh you know nico let's bring up uh let's
03:19:03 bring up the path to 44 uh graphic not the map but the graphic here uh we're gonna put that up
03:19:09 on the screen there we go so this is we haven't showed this yeah we have hours and this is a
03:19:14 great one yeah i just wanted to point out that if you look at the path to victory for the ndp and
03:19:19 you look at the seats that they're currently leading in i it doesn't look good for them
03:19:24 they needed to pretty much sweep a lot of these toss-ups it doesn't look like that's going their
03:19:28 way it is you needed to win just two of the toss-ups they're winning the bulk of them right
03:19:34 now yeah not all of them they're winning the bulk and i i think it goes back to i think the
03:19:38 conservative vote is coming home i think that's what we're seeing here tonight i know it's too
03:19:42 early to call according to but at the end of the day i think i i'm actually really confident uh
03:19:50 right now uh i'm really happy with what i'm seeing i think that the ucp is performing
03:19:56 kind of what we were hoping that we would see yeah um this is your way of trying to stick it
03:20:02 to me saying i'm calling it i'm calling it before the western standard does that's what yeah that's
03:20:07 i'm doing it i mean that's literally the only reason i'm still here we're supposed to be at
03:20:12 the yeah i want to go look um like if you're telling me to put my money down money's hard
03:20:19 down on uc okay but i'm not calling it i'm not calling it but if i'm betting it's like okay i'm
03:20:27 going all in all right i didn't know you were such a rule meister i'm going all in on the
03:20:32 there's policies around here
03:20:35 that we're supposed to follow
03:20:36 we're not trying to be too mickey mouse
03:20:39 about this stuff
03:20:40 so let's look at
03:20:43 Glenmore
03:20:44 still very tight, a lot of votes to come
03:20:47 still leading UCP
03:20:49 Whitney Isaac
03:20:49 51.1% to 46.8%
03:20:53 I think we're seeing
03:20:55 two things Josh
03:20:56 one is the conservative votes
03:20:59 come home, it does seem that
03:21:01 the so-called moderate or progressive conservative vote has stuck with the ucp and smith has uh you
03:21:07 know the first thing she did in her leadership was bring that wild rose vote back in and everybody 0.63
03:21:11 was saying oh she's going to lose the pc vote it does not look like she lost the pc vote what we've
03:21:16 seen and you can speak to this uh you know you're a former progressive conservative cabinet minister
03:21:20 but what we have seen is the ndp brought the alberta party vote home that i think is really
03:21:26 the only change significantly
03:21:28 that we've seen since the last election
03:21:30 that the Alberta Party has now gone
03:21:32 the way of the Liberal Party and has
03:21:35 been unofficially merged
03:21:36 into the NDP. Yeah, and at the
03:21:38 same time, I think you're seeing, like, if you
03:21:40 look at the PC vote that left
03:21:42 the party, it's the Thomas Lukasik vote.
03:21:45 Right? Yeah, it's like
03:21:46 five guys. Technically, it's like, yeah,
03:21:48 they were in the PCs, but
03:21:50 were they really committed
03:21:52 to conservative concept? Well, that's a grass tops thing.
03:21:54 Some of the grass tops left. You saw the same thing when the UC
03:21:56 was created in 2017, between 2017 and 2019, some grass tops left, but most of the voters,
03:22:03 even the vast majority of the activists, they stayed. It was some kind of, some of the elites
03:22:07 moved on. Yeah. And this is to my point that I was saying earlier, that I think that people
03:22:13 in Alberta are voting for the NDP because they might think they are in more of that progressive
03:22:18 side um that that progressive part of the tent the ucp is still um a wide tent um but i think
03:22:27 that a lot of people are looking to oh where where's my home because i used to be a pc and
03:22:32 you know it's danielle smith and that's the wild rose and i mean there is hard and fast conflict
03:22:38 between our parties um so that is still lingering out there you know so speaking of uh an interesting
03:22:45 character uh i know i think i'm seeing someone in our you know what our producer nico or he knew
03:22:50 i was going to go to i didn't even name it we've got a gentleman uh from the ucp headquarters at
03:22:55 the big four uh complex the big four complex at the ucp headquarters here uh i can't make
03:23:03 out quite who it is though but he's got a hell of a hat oh thank you guys uh we've
03:23:09 i'm sorry we could barely make out your audio same i i can hardly hear you here as well so
03:23:18 uh it's just quite loud around us here so oh okay i think we've got you good enough for now
03:23:24 i think we've got you good enough for now okay uh so you i think uh you're from the
03:23:29 the Banff Kananaskis constituency right federally yes but I think you live there provincially as
03:23:38 well right yeah but you know the area pretty well and right now it's it's surprising us this
03:23:51 uh this is tarik and galak um right now this constituency is surprising a lot of us uh most
03:24:00 of the predictions were the ndp we're gonna win it but in a close toss-up so far though ucp is
03:24:07 really pulling away uh miranda rosen 63.4 percent of the vote or 4 837 to the uh to sarah l mingle
03:24:17 I'm sure I butchered that, 34.7%.
03:24:22 Now, I think there's still a lot of votes to come in,
03:24:24 but really encouraging indications for the Conservatives in that writing so far.
03:24:30 Is this surprising to you?
03:24:32 You know what I would say positively surprising, Derek?
03:24:35 I look at it and I say Miranda's worked incredibly hard.
03:24:39 She's knocked on literally every single door in the writing.
03:24:43 The other thing as well as the writing is roughly 50-50 split.
03:24:46 in terms of conservative and orange voters.
03:24:50 You've got a town like Canmore and Bank, which are very orange. 0.95
03:24:53 And then you've got towns like Springbank and areas around Bragg Creek
03:24:57 that are very, very conservative.
03:24:59 So it's really immense.
03:25:00 So it's really who's got out to vote.
03:25:02 And to me, it's a get-out-the-vote exercise.
03:25:05 So we'll see what happens.
03:25:05 If Canmore and Bank didn't get out and didn't get out to vote,
03:25:09 Miranda's going to win this one handily. 0.98
03:25:12 Well, that's what it's increasingly starting to look like.
03:25:15 And if the NDP is not getting Banff Kananaskis, their path to victory gets narrower and narrower and narrower.
03:25:23 If that's the case, because as he was talking, I was thinking the same thing is that, you know, towards the end, there was a lot of a lot of light shone on Miranda's campaign and that, you know, there was a possibility that it was really neck and neck.
03:25:39 And that, hopefully, in my mind, I was hoping, was going to get people to be motivated to head out to the polls.
03:25:47 And I think that might be what we're seeing here.
03:25:51 She did a lot during COVID, too.
03:25:53 Like, she was in the right place at the right time.
03:25:56 She was signing the right letters.
03:25:57 She was speaking out at the right time.
03:25:59 She kind of did go to, maybe not to war with the Kenney government, the Kenney side.
03:26:04 She was poking people in the eye. 0.69
03:26:06 yeah and i i do i actually do think that is beneficial to her because there was a lot going
03:26:11 on at that time that was it wasn't just unpopular within the conservative movement it was something
03:26:16 that was unpopular across the across the board so i do think that that the efforts that she took
03:26:22 to stick to her true values and to really be herself when she was sitting in that legislative
03:26:28 seat really has done her a huge service and and i hope she continues to do that and continues to
03:26:35 really just be herself uh as an MLA and I think she'll be safe there for a while she keeps doing
03:26:41 that yeah I think you've given a great description of her and you know that's not easy to do and in
03:26:46 particular um you know here's my plug for women in politics it's difficult you know and it doesn't 1.00
03:26:51 matter I don't think it matters anyways uh which party you're in and so I she was pretty impressive 0.99
03:26:57 uh to stand up to Jason Kenney um that that takes a lot of courage he is a formidable formidable
03:27:05 politician. He's very intimidating. Yeah, I've found that way. Well, I don't think he's necessarily
03:27:10 intimidating. I'm a JCPenney fan. I try to avoid arguing with him in public settings.
03:27:17 Well, he would probably win, though. He's very intellectual. Yeah, exactly. So, we've got Dr.
03:27:22 Ted Morton standing by. Another favorite. Another favorite. Mr. Morton. What is the saying? I'm
03:27:29 supporting Morton. Yeah, well, you know, he's easy to support. Yeah. I got lost on the highway with
03:27:34 Dr. Morton. Yep, last. I'm not sure it sounds appropriate. Well, it totally is. It was
03:27:42 Len Weber and him and they gave each other the wrong directions. I was in the back seat just
03:27:46 going, yeah, I'm just a candidate. But it was a great ride. We had a great conversation.
03:27:53 We had great conversations, Ted. All right. Well, Dr. Morton, what we're seeing now,
03:27:59 Now, I'm not sure if you heard, but, you know, I told Josh here, if I was a betting man, I'd go all in on blue.
03:28:08 I'm not quite ready to 100% call it yet because I'm stubborn because there's still a lot of polls to come in on some of these key roddings.
03:28:18 But the path to an NDP victory gets narrower and narrower and narrower.
03:28:24 it's starting to look like the hot gates and there's just no way for the ndp to get through
03:28:30 them at this point um uh do you are you seeing any path uh dr morton for the ndp to make it to 44 at
03:28:40 this point no and i'm sticking with my early prediction of 50 seats that i think i made two
03:28:45 and a half hours ago so i think i'm going to be pretty close to that i was just going to add one
03:28:50 thing derek that i think if you go back through a couple hours of your coverage here tonight i don't
03:28:55 think the words oil and gas have even been mentioned by anybody which is pretty crazy uh
03:29:02 you know yeah pretty crazy because this province before oil and gas was discovered there were less
03:29:09 than a million people it was the poorest province in canada and now they're four and a half million
03:29:12 people it's the richest province in canada and a third of the people work directly or indirectly
03:29:18 in it and the rest of us who don't realize that what we do depends on how active that is and
03:29:24 i think danielle's this was a key part of the success because the ndp uh rachel notley belongs
03:29:32 to a party that's holding up uh the liberals and uh justin and his anti-oil and anti-gas policies
03:29:42 and i think people know that and that helped and i think the good news here is there's no reason
03:29:49 the next couple of decades can't be just as affluent just as successful just as much opportunity
03:29:54 for alberta families as the last couple because the events of just the last 14 15 months the war
03:30:02 in europe and what china is doing in the middle east suddenly energy security is easily out of par
03:30:09 if not ahead of climate change. And people realize that both for the cost of living and also for
03:30:15 national security, particularly for the Western democracies and democracies. So the not Western
03:30:21 democracies. So suddenly the door of opportunity is really opening again, not just for Alberta,
03:30:27 for Canada. Canada, we're the third largest oil reserves in the world, fifth largest in natural
03:30:32 gas. Natural gas is the transition fuel on climate change, all sorts of opportunity. I think,
03:30:38 Danielle and UCP communicated that. If we can get Pierre next in Ottawa, it's going to be a great
03:30:46 couple of decades for this country. Josh? Yeah, I just wanted to kind of piggyback on that.
03:30:52 That makes a great point about energy policy. Energy is the industry that powers every other
03:30:57 industry. And we are facing a national and global, not financial crisis, but an affordability crisis
03:31:04 that is driven not just by monetary policy and fiscal policy, but in a lot of ways, energy policy.
03:31:09 And Ted mentioned that the war in Ukraine has impacted energy prices.
03:31:15 Well, that's the downfall of poor energy policy on the behalf of Western governments, including Canada, and probably especially Canada.
03:31:26 Alberta has energy resources that can help alleviate some of these pricing pressures across the world.
03:31:34 We aren't able to export it. We've got export bottlenecks caused by federal policies.
03:31:39 And I thought that the UCP government did a really good job in really highlighting the coalition between not just Jagmeet Singh and Justin Trudeau,
03:31:50 but also with Rachel Notley and Justin Trudeau over her term in office,
03:31:56 where she effectively, that NDP government for four years under her reign, 0.98
03:31:59 was a doormat for the federal government when it comes to their climate change policies
03:32:03 that really hindered our ability to provide reasonably priced energy products
03:32:09 to the rest of the world and even to our own people.
03:32:11 So I'm going to try to make a couple of writings.
03:32:13 Sherwood Park, it looks very likely now.
03:32:17 Jordan Walker goes down to defeat to the NDPs.
03:32:19 kyle kasowski uh marie renault uh expected to be re-elected but the fact that she's 0.98
03:32:28 in the donut of edmonton technically it's like she's saint albert uh she looks to be
03:32:33 say uh pretty securely re-elected but uh it looks like the only two so-called donut seats
03:32:41 around edmonton um the only two that the ndp are winning is one that they already held
03:32:47 st albert and they're picking up just one sherwood park and they're not getting stressed
03:32:52 kona sherwood park there's no donut for the ndp no donut no path no donut no path are you guys
03:33:01 ready for it are we ready are you ready are we ready are you guys ready for it are we allowed
03:33:06 drum roll uh jeez i wish we had the audio ready for a drum roll i'm calling it uh western center
03:33:13 gonna project a ucp majority government tonight oh i mean i'm supposed to be non-partisan sorry
03:33:20 i am you guys are just guessing you guys oh yeah you want you guys i'm trying to i'm trying to play
03:33:25 you guys do whatever you want is there like graphics going on right now there are there are
03:33:31 you know like we're serious we got we got serious graphics yeah all right we got a ucp majority
03:33:36 Are we the first to make a projection?
03:33:40 Maybe.
03:33:42 Got to be close.
03:33:46 Got to be close.
03:33:47 But there's obviously the caveat.
03:33:50 This could shrink.
03:33:51 If these polls are coming in, a lot of the flips go the wrong way.
03:33:55 It could be a tiny, tiny majority.
03:33:58 It doesn't look like it will be, but it could be a tiny majority still.
03:34:00 It's hard to say.
03:34:01 Are there mail-in ballot drop-offs happening in the middle of the night?
03:34:04 don't start don't sorry the conspiracy theory started here right here
03:34:11 I don't think there are I don't know are there I know I'm just kidding I'm just asking questions
03:34:21 just just asking questions uh but yeah I think this is looking like there's just no path so
03:34:30 you're joining us now and the confidence no I've had the confidence for a while but we just have
03:34:35 to be damn sure it's it's different when you're putting a name out there I watch it now now that
03:34:38 I've done it it's jinxed yeah you better not have you better not have but I don't think you have
03:34:44 right okay uh well uh we're gonna go to an update from Dave in the newsroom and uh we're gonna be
03:34:52 bringing in some new panelists thank you for joining us for now guys uh we're gonna go to
03:34:56 dave nailer in the newsroom now uh dave uh we've called it for the ucp but what have you got for
03:35:02 us hi derek yeah we have uh called it for the ucp uh and we've now just passed the one million uh
03:35:12 ballot to be cast mark uh we're closing in we're gonna call it 70 percent of all the polling
03:35:18 stations have counted in now. We've got 52 to 35 for the UCP, and it seems to be settling into a
03:35:28 52.6 versus a 43.7 percentage of vote. Just a quick run through. Calgary Buffalo has gone to
03:35:41 Joe Ceci again.
03:35:43 Calgary Acadia, still too close to call.
03:35:47 It's getting late.
03:35:49 The UCP is trailing the NDP by 150 or so there.
03:35:55 Calgary Cross, looks like it's gone to the UCP.
03:36:01 Calgary Edgemont, still very close.
03:36:03 The UCP up by exactly 400.
03:36:07 I like it when they make the counting easy for me, Derek.
03:36:10 ucp up by 400 in that uh writing uh calgary elbow looks like it will go ndp
03:36:18 uh calgary fish creek solidly ucp uh calgary glenmore the ucp pulling ahead there by about 470
03:36:28 votes uh calgary northeast the ndp looks to be uh have a victory there calgary pegan is the ucp
03:36:39 victory uh they're leading by uh more than 2500 votes uh there calgary varsity looks to be going
03:36:47 ndp calgary west uh don't know what they're doing out there on the west but uh they've only filed
03:36:53 one poll in so uh we don't really know what's uh going on right there that's yeah that's kind of
03:36:59 an anticlimactic one doesn't matter they don't even have to send any ballots all right so and as
03:37:05 mentioned Marin in Banff Kananaskis she's increased her lead to 2,800 Derek so that's
03:37:15 that's amazing nobody saw that coming there's got to be some missing polls from like I don't know
03:37:22 the bagel shop in Canmore that charges like $30 for a bagel that the polling place in there has
03:37:28 not reported I was I was told that it was gonna be close everyone said it was I still think it's
03:37:33 to be you do i still think i at this point but you're still calling it for the uc well overall
03:37:39 yeah but i'm saying miranda rosen and baff canon ask us i think at the end of the day is going to
03:37:43 be significantly closer than looking right now right but i mean you're not picking up 2800 votes
03:37:51 not likely dave lethbridge east is only one still dave no uh lethbridge lethbridge east only the
03:37:58 one poll and that's uh just the advanced poll there lethbridge west looks uh solidly uh ndp
03:38:07 yeah um okay thank you for joining us dave okay guys gotta get writing very good uh all right
03:38:16 nico let's pull up the um the path to 44 the road to 44 graphic this will explain why we've been able
03:38:24 to call it even though there's so many seats that could still flip one way or another there's a lot
03:38:28 that could still flip but we're going to talk about the path to 44. so what you see up here
03:38:35 the dark blue every one of the dark blue you've seen is still dark blue they're solidly in uh
03:38:42 those dark orange they're dark orange they're ndp uh for the ndp to win they had to win one
03:38:52 two so when you see the medium orange and the light orange they had to win all of the medium
03:38:59 orange one two three four five uh right now in fact they're leading in all of those except for
03:39:09 one so one of their pretty strong ones calgary klein yeah jeremy nixon like let's give it to him
03:39:16 he's a hard campaign like that one he's been door knocking for four years actually actually
03:39:20 sorry to bust your bubble. The NDP have taken a minute lead there right now. 4,348 votes through
03:39:28 4,321. So 48.9 to 48.6. Insanely too close to call, but we got to put that in the NDP ever so
03:39:40 slightly leaning column right now. So that's a question mark. There's a question mark. They
03:39:46 might get Klein, they might not. But then in the toss-up column, they have to win Calgary
03:39:53 Northeast. They, at present, are pretty solidly in the lead. Let's see where they're at there.
03:40:02 No, no, that's, let's see, Calgary Northeast. Calgary Northeast, let's see.
03:40:09 Yeah, they'll probably take it. Not by a lot, but they'll probably take it. So Calgary Northeast,
03:40:13 Calgary Elbow
03:40:15 I think they're going to take it
03:40:18 I've called them taking it
03:40:19 The Alberta party, you know, it's weird riding
03:40:22 It's got a weird
03:40:23 history going on
03:40:25 UCP's got an outside chance of taking Elbow
03:40:28 still, probably not
03:40:29 So, let's give them Elbow 0.99
03:40:31 So, we're going to give them Klein 0.98
03:40:33 for the sake of argument
03:40:34 Klein, we're going to give them Northeast 0.99
03:40:36 We're going to give them Elbow 0.94
03:40:38 Calgary East, they must win Calgary East
03:40:42 How's Calgary East doing right now?
03:40:45 Well, I think they're in the lead.
03:40:51 Let's see.
03:40:54 Calgary East.
03:40:55 No, they are not.
03:40:56 Right now, now there's still a lot of votes to come in.
03:40:58 This one could flip.
03:40:59 But right now, Calgary East has got 52.7% UCP Peter Singh, 42.5% NDP Rosman Valencia.
03:41:09 also remember a very low voter turnout generally in that riding and one of the smallest number of
03:41:15 electors in that ride yeah so calgary east uh you don't know yeah question mark must wins
03:41:21 bamf cananaskis we don't know what's going on there it's weird uh i could be wrong maybe i'll
03:41:27 have egg in my face but i i'm putting x on that they're not getting it i don't they're not getting
03:41:33 Now, Calgary-Edgemont is another must-win.
03:41:38 Right now, Calgary-Edgemont, very close.
03:41:41 It could win it, maybe, but the UCP are winning it, 49.6 to 47.7.
03:41:49 Okay, for the sake of argument, let's give them Edgemont.
03:41:54 Yeah, we just give it to them all.
03:41:56 Calgary Northwest, they must win Calgary Northwest.
03:41:59 they are they got a shot but probably not rajansani she has leading uh ejected seats from 0.99
03:42:06 northeast she's now in the northwest in that seat she's leading 10 148 votes to 9 643 0.99
03:42:14 there's not gonna be many more votes there because that's that's pretty that's pretty
03:42:17 topped out so uh calgary northwest no i don't think they're doing it calgary cross
03:42:26 absolute must win for the NDP right now the UCP narrow lead but not a ton more coming in Mickey
03:42:34 Emery leading there 50 to 46.3 and he is a great campaign I'll say Mickey may be one of the greatest
03:42:40 campaigners the UCP has he's just on like his team was amazing not gonna happen but let's let's give
03:42:47 it to them for the sake of the math Calgary Beddington must win don't win Beddington you
03:42:54 You can't win.
03:42:55 Calgary-Bettington right now.
03:42:59 I'm just doing my best impression of Wolf Blitzer.
03:43:01 I always wanted to do this.
03:43:02 I'm going through every single ride.
03:43:04 Calgary-Bettington.
03:43:04 Okay, so Bettington, they've got a small lead.
03:43:07 Josephine Pong going down to Amanda Chapman, likely. 0.85
03:43:11 Let's get them Bettington.
03:43:12 Maybe they get Bettington.
03:43:14 Okay, Glenmore.
03:43:15 One of the bellwethers everyone looked at.
03:43:18 Right now, it's not happening.
03:43:20 Could still turn 51.5% to 46.5 UCP leading.
03:43:27 More than 10,000 votes in.
03:43:29 Probably not.
03:43:31 I'm not giving them Glenmore.
03:43:32 No.
03:43:33 And you know, Whitney is a good campaigner as well.
03:43:37 Yeah.
03:43:37 So I don't think so.
03:43:39 Calgary North must win.
03:43:42 They could.
03:43:44 That one is razor thin.
03:43:46 A lot of votes to come in still.
03:43:48 but the ucp is muhammad yassin 3571 votes 3335 okay now for the sake of the argument give them
03:43:58 that one give them that one lethbridge east we don't know way too early yeah well let's give it
03:44:03 to him okay let's give it to him calgary bow this is a good question i don't think calgary bow i
03:44:08 don't either uh no i don't think they're gonna take it now calgary bow's tight it's a bellwether
03:44:14 The NDP could, but probably not.
03:44:17 I don't think they're winning this one.
03:44:20 How many votes is it at right now?
03:44:22 It's tight.
03:44:23 5,225 to 5,043.
03:44:27 Yeah.
03:44:27 It's close.
03:44:28 It's close.
03:44:28 We don't know.
03:44:29 It's close and not a ton more to come in.
03:44:31 That one was expected to be one of the closest.
03:44:32 Yeah.
03:44:33 So, for sake of argument, let's give it to them.
03:44:40 We're giving them all the gross points.
03:44:42 No kidding.
03:44:44 Acadia.
03:44:45 Another one of those bellwethers we've been talking about all night long.
03:44:49 Deanna Batten, currently leading over Tyler Shandro.
03:44:53 But a lot more votes to come in.
03:44:54 It's hard to tell.
03:44:56 She's winning with 3,910 votes.
03:44:58 His 3,747.
03:45:00 There's a lot more votes to come in there. 0.72
03:45:03 Let's get Acadia.
03:45:05 But they also needed to win Mourneville St. Albert.
03:45:09 Not happening.
03:45:11 No.
03:45:11 Not happening.
03:45:12 Well, yeah, what's Mournville at now?
03:45:14 Mournville-St. Albert.
03:45:15 Let's take a look up there.
03:45:18 But I think that one's totally out of play now.
03:45:22 Well, actually, no, it's closer, but I think Dale McNally's got it.
03:45:28 12,102 votes to 11,054.
03:45:30 Big turnout there.
03:45:32 Yeah.
03:45:32 Big turnout.
03:45:33 I'm impressed.
03:45:34 Can't be a lot more votes to come in there.
03:45:37 You know, he's probably got it.
03:45:40 Probably.
03:45:40 How many polls left to report?
03:45:42 it's not saying here uh and then let's go down to calgary calgary foothills
03:45:49 all right it's calgary foothills here okay this is another must win very close but jason le juan
03:45:57 still yeah still in the lead uh 5 699 5 604 so could could totally flip so we'll put that in
03:46:06 their in their camp here well let's see the ucp need to just win two toss-ups i've got one two three
03:46:17 that are just impossible they're not going to win the yeah so the ucp need two toss-ups
03:46:22 and we've got three toss-ups they're leading in almost all of those yeah the ucp is leading in
03:46:27 most but not all the toss-ups and three of them are off the table which means just at a minimum
03:46:33 ucp's got 45 yeah yeah at a minimum so that's that's minus look on penoni
03:46:41 yeah well uh jennifer johnson for speaker you heard it here first
03:46:47 yeah uh okay i've talked for a long time but i had to run through the math there i need a lot of time
03:46:53 um so i'll put it to you james um and for those of you don't know james was our operations uh
03:46:58 vice uh vice president of operations here at the western standard uh did a great job for us
03:47:03 We used to run cameras when we were a little mom-and-paw shop.
03:47:06 If we could even call those cameras.
03:47:08 The very first election that we did, I was producing it, running the cameras, making sure the lights were on,
03:47:16 and trying to make sure that we did not all overheat die.
03:47:20 It's getting pretty hot in here.
03:47:21 Yeah, but it's still not as hot as that one room with a cell phone camera and a laptop trying to produce a four-hour long live stream.
03:47:30 No, no, that was 11 hours.
03:47:31 That was the first one.
03:47:33 that was the uh that was the cpc leadership and i hadn't started for that one yet no i was there
03:47:39 for it was even before you okay yeah okay so you haven't even seen the worst of it you were in
03:47:44 pretty early but you didn't see the absolute i missed the absolute worst one but i've been here
03:47:48 for every single one afterwards you've seen bad yeah okay uh so back to you now uh
03:47:56 so even with this very generous calculation here unless i'm wrong it just does not look like there's
03:48:02 There's no path, no way forward.
03:48:04 No, I don't think so.
03:48:06 Even with the really, really tight ones,
03:48:08 I think that there's still enough polls
03:48:11 that still need to come in
03:48:12 in some of these constituencies
03:48:13 that I think we're actually going to see
03:48:15 the UCP's number push a little bit higher
03:48:17 than what it's at right now.
03:48:18 I think right now the official number
03:48:20 is somewhere around 52.
03:48:21 I think we're going to see it finish around 54, 55.
03:48:26 I think every single one of these needs to flip
03:48:28 and the absolute max the UCP can pull out right now is 56.
03:48:32 which is upsetting because that was my prediction,
03:48:35 and it looks like I'm not winning the offense.
03:48:36 Well, actually, let's go through the maximum.
03:48:40 Okay.
03:48:41 So, Foothills, Bourneville, St. Albert.
03:48:45 Okay, that gets you to – that's your 44.
03:48:48 Acadia, Bow, Lethbridge East.
03:48:53 Actually, so if they win these toss-ups that they got chances in,
03:48:57 I'm not going to give them elbow.
03:48:58 I just don't see them getting elbow.
03:49:00 but uh but what what kline that's a surprise eh kline kline was supposed to be out of play
03:49:07 yeah people said it was not gonna happen uh win lose or draw i mean jeremy nixon you gotta take
03:49:13 some hats off that guy like a honey badger and has been for for four years yeah well he always
03:49:19 knew he was gonna have to fight like hell there to keep it exactly yeah yeah uh but let's look
03:49:25 What would the maximum UCP?
03:49:26 So they take Foothills, St. Albert, 44.
03:49:30 Take it all the way up.
03:49:32 They take Northwest, 52.
03:49:35 It looks like 3, 4, 5, 6.
03:49:38 I'd say the UCP ceiling is 56.
03:49:42 Probably not.
03:49:43 Yeah.
03:49:44 It would be a really, really good 50. 0.57
03:49:46 I've been saying for a long time it was going to be between 48 and 52,
03:49:50 and it looks like we're going to be right at that.
03:49:52 We're at 52 right now.
03:49:53 52 right now.
03:49:53 So I think this is a great night for the UCP.
03:49:57 I think anyone who says otherwise is not paying attention to the fact
03:50:01 that the Alberta party has collapsed, consolidated behind the NDP,
03:50:06 and yet we're still seeing a massive majority,
03:50:09 potentially a 17-seat majority.
03:50:11 Well, I wouldn't call this a massive majority, but...
03:50:12 17 seats.
03:50:14 Well, at most.
03:50:16 Like, really most.
03:50:18 No, no, 17 is 52.
03:50:20 Okay, okay, yeah, that's comfortable.
03:50:22 Yeah.
03:50:22 that's that's a very comfortable majority yeah uh so i think it's important yeah that this starts
03:50:29 to go into context now um the you know we all expected the ucp to lose seats here and there's
03:50:37 been a lot a lot of guff directed at smith but i guess you have to think you have to put your
03:50:44 victory in context and there's contextual defeats as well i remember 2015 wild rose was supposed to
03:50:49 dead. And we came out
03:50:51 and we won 21 seats and then
03:50:53 22 when we saw a
03:50:55 by-election. We won 21 seats, formed official
03:50:57 opposition, came back from the dead.
03:50:59 Five seats to 21.
03:51:02 We didn't technically
03:51:03 win the election, but we felt like we did.
03:51:06 Well, it was a contextual victory.
03:51:07 It felt awesome.
03:51:09 So both the NDP and the Wild Bros kind of both
03:51:11 felt like they won the election. It was only the PCs
03:51:13 who didn't that night. Turned out that
03:51:15 with the NDP winning, it felt pretty horrible
03:51:17 over those four years. Oh, yeah, yeah.
03:51:19 Even I did not predict how that was.
03:51:22 But even though it was a technical defeat, it felt like a victory.
03:51:26 But I think a lot of conservatives are kind of coming in tonight taking a technical victory and feeling like a defeat.
03:51:32 And I think that might be a mistake.
03:51:33 As you look at 1993, Ralph Klein takes over from Don Getty, and they lost eight seats in a smaller legislature.
03:51:40 So a comparable number of losses from 1993.
03:51:45 but it was called the Miracle on the Prairies
03:51:46 because they were supposed to lose and they didn't.
03:51:50 They lost seats, but they were supposed to lose the government.
03:51:53 A year ago, the UCP was headed for certain defeat, 100%.
03:51:58 So maybe I'll start with James.
03:52:03 Well, first, we have to look back to what was happening
03:52:08 with the NDP's accidental government
03:52:10 and how much momentum they had going into that, right?
03:52:13 and then when we had Jason Kenney going in
03:52:15 he had just united the parties
03:52:17 and he had been campaigning for what two years
03:52:19 at that point so he had a ton of
03:52:21 momentum going in
03:52:22 4,000 volunteers
03:52:23 he had a crazy amount of momentum
03:52:27 going into that election
03:52:28 Daniel Smith essentially
03:52:31 came into a party that was ripping itself
03:52:33 apart if that same sheet
03:52:35 if that same path to victory was there
03:52:37 with Jason Kenney's name on top as the
03:52:39 leader of the party we would be looking
03:52:41 at significant losses
03:52:43 not only would we have lost the government and all of the seats that came with it if he was still
03:52:47 there and even if we were able to sneak out 44 it would barely be 44 danielle smith has been able to
03:52:53 take a party that was tearing itself apart months ago put it back together hold it together and get
03:53:00 some of her policy positions that she ran on for that leadership done er response times are down
03:53:05 healthcare is seeing the most drastic changes we've ever seen to happening to it things are
03:53:10 changing she's getting stuff done and now on top of it um we lost a few seats tonight i think it's
03:53:16 11 i think it's a with this math right now yeah 11 it's going to be 11 down 11 gain for the ndp
03:53:22 but you know um there's still a lot of room for that to move around yeah and and i i i still think
03:53:27 it's going to i still think it's going to be 54 55 i think this number is going to move up when the
03:53:32 final votes come in and i think that's going to be a credit to uh the ucp's campaign manager
03:53:37 Mr. Outhouse and his plans for get out the vote and it's going to be the individual candidates
03:53:44 and the campaign managers and their volunteers who have been out there every single day door
03:53:49 knocking doing the voter ID getting the people out to vote begging the people and I know you've
03:53:54 had 9,000 text messages I know you've had 10,000 phone calls your email you shut it off two weeks
03:54:00 ago and you've had probably three knocks at your door and that is because I know that right from
03:54:07 the top down from this campaign that the ucp intended to earn every single vote and i think
03:54:12 we're seeing that and i think we're seeing that in some of these constituencies tonight that uh
03:54:16 that these ucp candidates really really work to pull this off yeah and i think we're seeing it
03:54:21 especially i think honestly jeremy nixon is a great example right like that is someone who's
03:54:26 never supposed to win that just shows you the how great a good ground game can do yeah i think we're
03:54:32 seeing it with acadia it's super close everyone was saying it was probably going to go the other
03:54:35 way we're seeing it go uh this way that's a testament to tyler shandro and both of these
03:54:42 people are people i don't necessarily get along with but i think i can you know credit them with
03:54:45 the skill that they have and and say that they've done a great job but honestly this all comes down
03:54:50 to danielle smith it all comes down to the fact that there was a dying party and someone came and
03:54:55 they said they were going to try to save it i think if anyone else in that leadership race had
03:54:58 won i think we'd be doing worse because i think she spoke to the people who needed to hear right
03:55:04 The people that needed to be brought back into the fold, the party has been reunited.
03:55:09 Of course, there's going to be people who are unhappy with things that have happened during this campaign.
03:55:13 That's normal.
03:55:14 But I think if you look at this result, she's probably going to get over 50% of the popular vote. 0.70
03:55:18 That is incredible.
03:55:20 It is looking like that.
03:55:21 That is incredible.
03:55:21 It does look a lot like the UCP vote just stayed and the NDP vote took itself and added a large chunk of the Alberta party vote on top of that.
03:55:34 And that's it.
03:55:36 Like, the UCP vote just didn't go anywhere.
03:55:39 We were talking with Christine Cousinelli earlier about this.
03:55:42 Smith brought the Wildrose vote back in
03:55:44 after it was very quickly moving out of the barn.
03:55:46 It was going 22%, remember?
03:55:48 Yeah.
03:55:48 That horse was halfway out the barn with Kenny.
03:55:53 But everyone was saying,
03:55:54 with a progressive conservative vote, it's leaving,
03:55:56 because Danielle's crazy. 1.00
03:55:59 Didn't seem to have really gone anywhere.
03:56:01 It's just the Alberta Party vote kind of moved around.
03:56:04 That's it. And now we have totally, finally consolidated into an ultimate two-party system.
03:56:10 Now, this being Alberta, I expect us to have 20 parties next time because, I mean, this wouldn't be Alberta if nothing ever makes sense more than six months, right?
03:56:20 In six months, none of your assumptions are going to make sense anymore.
03:56:23 But for now, we have the most two-party system of anywhere in Canada.
03:56:27 This is comparable to like an American state election at this point.
03:56:31 Yeah, absolutely. I mean, Manitoba would be the only comparable, I guess, with their NDP PC going back and forth.
03:56:38 But yeah, I'm going to we're going to go to Dave Naylor now in the newsroom.
03:56:42 I know some of the campaigns have got people up on the stage speaking.
03:56:45 None of the leaders speaking yet, but I'm not sure if anyone's ready to tut their victory or concede defeat.
03:56:53 But Dave, do you know yet? Is anyone prepared to concede defeat yet?
03:56:56 Well, not that I've heard, Derek. I just got off the phone with Jonathan Bradley from the UCP headquarters in the Big Four building. He says that Danielle Smith's expected to take the stage any minute, which kind of surprises me. I thought she might wait and let Miss Notley go first with a concession speech.
03:57:18 I haven't heard from Arthur he texted me now says they're just waiting for
03:57:25 not only any moment so I expect though we'll be getting some leaders very
03:57:29 quickly there so we're expect so you're saying that the Smith UCP campaign is
03:57:36 waiting on not Lee to give a concession first that would be my guess that's
03:57:41 than usually the normal protocol but oh your sound is very sketchy Dave are we
03:57:55 hearing anything from Dave okay I guess we've lost Dave for now have we got
03:58:05 Arthur Arthur standing by I'm not sure I can't see his video but waiting for
03:58:10 Arthur here. Okay. Uh, all right. Well, uh, uh, we're going to, uh, Dave, uh, can you give us
03:58:22 a bit of a riding by riding breakdown, uh, for now? Uh, just kind of run us through some of the
03:58:27 key races. Yeah. The Derek not least taking the stage. Okay. Okay. We're going to go to Rachel
03:58:36 Notley right now.
03:58:52 Your compass spins you astray.
03:58:57 You're feeling cold and blue.
03:59:01 You're not grown those tattoos.
03:59:06 find that blood flow by my heat
03:59:08 find that fruit for your feast
03:59:13 there's a sea change coming with that orange dawn
03:59:18 and color so much brighter when it shines on it
03:59:23 thank you thank you so much jody for that wonderful wonderful introduction
03:59:33 And by the way, congratulations, Jody!
03:59:43 Friends, obviously tonight I come before you with mixed emotions.
03:59:49 On one hand, I feel tremendous gratitude and pride in the people of Alberta
03:59:54 and those who stood up and put their support behind building a better future.
04:00:03 As a movement, we have grown our support in every corner of this province.
04:00:14 I'm very pleased that we will be welcoming at least 10 more MLAs to our caucus, who will
04:00:31 form part of the largest official opposition this province has ever seen in its history.
04:00:45 And that as a party, we earned the largest percentage of the popular vote in our party's
04:00:51 history.
04:00:59 we have achieved tremendous growth and opportunity for our future and for the values that we all
04:01:04 share however tonight i also know that we are all very deeply disappointed in the overall result
04:01:11 we had all hoped for a different one moments ago i called premier danielle smith to concede the race 0.94
04:01:19 and I congratulated her party on their victory to all those of you to those who offered their
04:01:32 unwavering support their dedication and their belief in our vision for Alberta in this election
04:01:38 you are the reason that we fight for what we believe in and to our candidates all across
04:01:52 this province congratulations on your campaigns successful or not you have all demonstrated
04:01:59 tremendous leadership i have spent the last few months being so inspired by your dedication by
04:02:06 your heartfelt commitment to standing up for Albertans without a voice for your
04:02:12 honest belief that we can and will come together to be better I commend your
04:02:18 integrity and your perseverance and your unparalleled work ethic and I will never
04:02:24 ever ever stop being deeply grateful for your decision to join our team so thank
04:02:31 you to all of you and to those new mlas i say to you welcome congratulations
04:02:50 get some rest tonight and then get ready to get right back down to work
04:02:55 to my amazing amazing campaign team uh i i can't say enough uh it it they they are unparalleled in
04:03:09 in the work and the achievement that that they have uh and that they have uh done you know across
04:03:16 the country they are just unparalleled in their skill i cannot thank that team enough and i cannot
04:03:22 thank as well our incredible volunteers enough your commitment your hard work your countless
04:03:31 hours of effort have been the absolute backbone of our campaign you've all shown incredible
04:03:45 dedication and passion and i am forever grateful for your support and i need to say this as well
04:03:52 where we fell short the responsibility rests entirely with me
04:04:02 that's that's fine that's that's the joys of being the leader you know it's it's fine it's just it's
04:04:07 a thing uh you know it's part of responsibility and accountability those are things we we care
04:04:12 about here but i do know that at the same time we ran a strong principle campaign and it was based
04:04:18 on our beliefs and it was based on our desire to create a better future for all albertans
04:04:42 NGT! NGT! NGT! NGT! NGT! NGT! NGT! NGT! NGT! NGT! NGT! NGT!
04:05:00 And to my family, these guys, thank you to the four of you for standing by me in this
04:05:08 often very crazy journey thank you to ethan and to sophie for accepting the difference that it has
04:05:15 been meaning in their lives for all this time and ultimately turning it into their own pride
04:05:21 and their own set of beautiful values that make me very proud
04:05:26 and thank you again seem like i'm doing this every four years thank you again to lou
04:05:41 my lifelong sounding board
04:05:56 Oh, for heaven's sakes, give it a round. 1.00
04:06:11 Anywho, lifelong sounding board, sparring partner, and apparently personal cheerleader, but also...
04:06:18 All right.
04:06:19 All right, well, we just heard there from NDP.
04:06:26 leader and official opposition leader
04:06:27 Rachel Notley who has
04:06:29 conceded that she is still
04:06:32 the official opposition leader
04:06:33 and will not win
04:06:34 big gains for the NDP
04:06:37 tonight
04:06:38 estimates are around 10
04:06:41 pickups it's the
04:06:44 biggest official opposition in Alberta's history
04:06:46 it's
04:06:48 definitely the high watermark in
04:06:50 I think even a popular vote I think
04:06:52 they may have exceeded the popular vote when they won
04:06:54 in 2015
04:06:56 I think they over-exceeded even when they lost last time.
04:06:59 Bigger population, too.
04:07:00 Bigger population, but it was a good night for the NDP, but not good enough.
04:07:07 We're going to kind of cut her off here, but I don't know.
04:07:10 Perhaps we'll get ahead of ourselves, but okay.
04:07:13 We'll get into potential resignation in a bit.
04:07:16 Keep that on ice for now.
04:07:17 But, Nigel, your thoughts on Notley's concession speech?
04:07:22 Well, I thought it was very interesting that she actually congratulated the UCP.
04:07:25 the party. She didn't congratulate
04:07:27 Danielle Smith. She said she called
04:07:30 Danielle Smith to congratulate her
04:07:31 on her party's win.
04:07:33 Well, that to me
04:07:35 said she
04:07:36 it was less than warm.
04:07:40 And well, it might have been.
04:07:41 It has not been.
04:07:43 She is, I mean, to give
04:07:45 Rachel Notley
04:07:47 the most
04:07:48 grace that one can, when you
04:07:51 are in opposition, your job is to
04:07:53 attack. And she did. 1.00
04:07:55 And unfortunately for her, blue suit or not, it didn't come off well.
04:08:00 I think she's still wearing a blue suit right now. 0.99
04:08:02 It's the unwilling ghost of Peter Locke, I guess.
04:08:06 She's trying to invoke that mantle of small-c progressive conservatism. 1.00
04:08:13 Anyway, whatever it is that she's trying to message, if she's trying to message anything, of course she feels upset.
04:08:19 She had a tough job to do, and unfortunately for her, she had somebody in Danielle Smith who could take that kind of persifrage and just smile and carry on and say what she was going to say.
04:08:32 We saw it in the debate.
04:08:33 So I'm actually just getting word now from the newsroom, not confirmed, but we believe she's actually just said she's going to stay on as opposition leader.
04:08:42 now being you know conservatives or leaders are not allowed to lose in alberta there's a
04:08:50 like if daniel smith had lost tonight there's a 100 chance she resigns because she doesn't
04:08:55 she's gone like there's no way to stay on uh but i mean the expectations for the ndp in alberta
04:09:01 are very different and the end i think the ndp's culture in general nationally generally has
04:09:06 longer-term leaders who are allowed to lose elections and come on they're not they have
04:09:10 less of an expectation of winning
04:09:12 particularly in Alberta. This is different
04:09:14 though. This isn't somebody who was constantly
04:09:16 ascendant and trying to get there. She's
04:09:18 been there now. And then
04:09:20 this is the second kick at the cat
04:09:22 since. So I mean that
04:09:24 sets the bar at a bit of a different level. You know
04:09:26 it's not somebody who's expected to continue
04:09:28 to keep winning opposition
04:09:30 level wins. I mean
04:09:32 I got a feeling
04:09:34 she say what she may right now
04:09:36 I suspect in the next general election we're
04:09:38 going to see a different face at the front of you.
04:09:40 Well, that's a good question. I know a lot of people think that the NDP will get rid of her. I think she's got a lock on the NDP because she pulls so much higher than the NDP does. If Richard Alley wants to stay and fight a, what would this be, a third or fourth election? See, 2015, 1923, a fourth election. If she would want to fight a fourth election as NDP leader, my gut tells me she'd probably have the backing of the party to do it.
04:10:07 I think you're right.
04:10:09 But will she actually want to do it all again?
04:10:12 Yeah.
04:10:12 Now, she might be saying for now, okay, I'll stay on as opposition leader, kind of doing the opposite of a Jim Prentice, which is, oh, if I can't be premier, I don't even want to be an MLA.
04:10:20 I'm out of here.
04:10:21 I mean, like, everyone remembers how petulant and terribly that went over.
04:10:26 She's very aware of how that kind of thing goes.
04:10:28 So it's fine to say, I'll stay as opposition leader.
04:10:32 Now, does that translate? Does she want to put it another four grueling years to maybe do it again? 0.99
04:10:41 It's no fun in opposition.
04:10:44 I had fun in opposition.
04:10:46 Yes.
04:10:46 But I never got to be a good one.
04:10:47 I don't think she would have fun in opposition.
04:10:49 Yeah. Well, once you've tasted government, I guess it's a bit different.
04:10:54 But do you think she – okay, so she says she's going to stay as opposition leader.
04:10:57 But do you think she'll actually stay the full four years and fight another general election?
04:11:03 No, I'm with Corey on this.
04:11:04 What I think she's doing is that she is going to see that the transition happens in an orderly way.
04:11:10 She doesn't become the story tonight at her resignation.
04:11:15 So, yeah, she'll do things decently and go and taste this thing called retirement. 1.00
04:11:25 59 now is probably looking forward to it.
04:11:27 Yeah, and she's been in MLA since I think 2008 or something crazy.
04:11:34 She's been there a while.
04:11:35 She's been there a long time.
04:11:36 And she's been with the NDP since it was a caucus of two, her and Brian Mason, two.
04:11:41 She was there from two in 2008 to four in 2012 to, I don't know, 50-odd something in 2015 when she was premier and then now through.
04:11:54 um i mean she is without a doubt indisputably known even in her universe the most successful
04:12:00 ndp leader in the history of alberta which arguably might make you the most successful
04:12:06 ndp leader anywhere in canada because she's made the ndp a competitive force here uh i guess the
04:12:13 worry uh for the ndp might be now can they survive without her uh i mean i don't think any parties
04:12:20 too wrapped up in their leader, but she is so much
04:12:24 more popular than the party
04:12:27 itself. And they could go one of two ways
04:12:28 and I want to get to your sense, this is maybe way too far
04:12:31 but I think the NDP post
04:12:33 Notley, assuming
04:12:34 who knows, maybe shows her fourth kick at the camera 0.99
04:12:36 if she doesn't, it's going to go one of two ways
04:12:38 it's going to bring in some
04:12:40 a Calgary
04:12:42 someone from Calgary who
04:12:44 has the appearance of a moderate progressive
04:12:47 conservative. They'll get a Nenshi 0.81
04:12:48 or they'll get a Todd Hirsch
04:12:50 or they're going to go to a Sarah Hoffman or a Shannon Phillips,
04:12:54 kind of go to their more hard left base.
04:12:58 Let's start with you, Nigel.
04:13:00 Which way do you think the NDP actually goes?
04:13:03 Depends who makes the decision, but if it's up to the membership,
04:13:06 I would vote for the hard left.
04:13:09 I am not a Notley fan, obviously,
04:13:11 but I at the same time would say that she is a steadying influence
04:13:17 on some of the crazier people within the party.
04:13:20 Things would be more extreme without her,
04:13:24 given some of the players there.
04:13:26 So without a strong, sensible person to keep a lid on things,
04:13:32 I think the party could go off and become
04:13:34 sort of a left-wing version of a small right-wing Alberta party.
04:13:39 We'll go back to what the NDP used to be.
04:13:41 It used to be, yeah.
04:13:41 It's been for almost its entire history.
04:13:44 They have a beautiful conscience, but they never form power.
04:13:46 Corey, I know we're going to be bringing Rachel Notley in soon. Actually, if Arthur Green is able to sit still for a few minutes, we want to bring him in from the Alberta NDP headquarters. Arthur, if you could just sit. Yeah, we're going to get him in. We're going to bring Arthur in from the NDP headquarters soon.
04:14:04 And soon we're going to be going to the UCP headquarters at the Big Four in Calgary for the victory speech of Danielle Smith.
04:14:13 But, Corey, maybe your thoughts.
04:14:15 If not, Lee, you know, let's say she does a year. 1.00
04:14:18 I would expect maybe in a few months she announces, I'm going to retire as leader.
04:14:22 They have an orderly transition.
04:14:24 Are they going for, you know, you were right about Nenshi kind of auditioning for NDP leader.
04:14:29 But where do you think that party goes?
04:14:30 Is it going to get like a kind of a Calgary so-called moderate liberal like Nenshi, Todd Hirsch, or are they going to go for like a Shannon Phillips or Sarah Hoffman, that kind of thing?
04:14:40 Well, I think a race would really determine that.
04:14:42 You know, if they had a race against a more pragmatic sort of, you know, progressive sort, like Nenshi, as you said, versus Hoffman or even Shannon Phillips, the members will make that choice.
04:14:53 And that choice will be between, are we actually going to try and win government again, or are we going to take up our traditional role of being the voice of left-wing conscience in the legislature and accept that we won't win again?
04:15:05 So that'll really, I think that'll be quite a moment for the members to try and determine which they want.
04:15:10 Because I think a lot of the idealists in there don't like the moderation and the pragmatism, and they want to, you know, unlike the conservative end of things,
04:15:18 they didn't spawn a bunch of break-off parties when the ideologues get frustrated. But all the
04:15:23 same, I'm sure there's a lot of members who would rather they kind of pulled back to their
04:15:26 traditional left spot. So assuming Premier Notley does, you know, pull the pin and bring about a
04:15:33 race, it's going to be quite a decision for that party to make. You know, about 25 years ago,
04:15:38 the NDP in Saskatchewan were the kind of moderate party that Derek is talking about. Romano. Yeah,
04:15:43 those guys. And, you know, they did a good job, actually. Everybody thought we were the NDP.
04:15:49 No, they were kind of more like a social critic, I don't know, to be honest with you.
04:15:53 But I don't think that's what it's – I don't get the sense that that's going to appeal to people like Rodney O'Reilly and the rest of them.
04:16:00 Well, I want to bring in Arthur Green from Edmonton.
04:16:03 He is sort of at the NDP's headquarters in Edmonton.
04:16:08 I know they've put him in a dark closet somewhere.
04:16:13 There was some joking around here that Arthur is in the closet or something like that.
04:16:19 Arthur, you were in the room as Rachel Notley gave her concession speech.
04:16:25 I think a brave face.
04:16:27 I mean, it's tough to lose an election.
04:16:29 It's not very nice.
04:16:30 But, you know, definitely some bright spots for the NDP there.
04:16:34 But, you know, beneath the brave face, what was the genuine sentiment in the room?
04:16:40 The gender and sentiment in the room seemed to be sorrow, Derek.
04:16:45 I mean, they were happy that they are forming the largest opposition that they've ever formed in Alberta history.
04:16:53 But I think there was quite the sense of disappointment that they didn't form the government here in Alberta.
04:17:02 Like you said, I was in the back of the room.
04:17:05 I'm just outside here now as people are exiting NDP headquarters.
04:17:10 here at Edmonton. A lot of somber faces. You know, they really thought that Rachel was
04:17:17 going to be elected as Premier of Alberta. Of course, we all saw that's not the case.
04:17:25 You know, Rachel did say that she did call Danielle Smith, UCP leader Danielle Smith
04:17:30 on the phone. Congratulate her. You know, she was pretty humble in giving her speech. 0.99
04:17:35 She didn't mention if she's going to step down as the opposition leader, but, of course, the future will tell Derek if that happens or not.
04:17:46 Well, she did say she would continue as opposition leader, but I guess it did not give a more definitive answer than that.
04:17:54 I think it kind of leaves the door open for her to get some time.
04:17:58 I mean, as we were saying, conservative leaders are you win or you die.
04:18:03 In fact, even if you win, you might still die.
04:18:07 I think that Danielle's over the line.
04:18:10 It's our conversation earlier.
04:18:12 You asked me how many.
04:18:13 I said 50. 0.60
04:18:14 You got 52.
04:18:16 I'm likely, yeah.
04:18:17 That's great in that area.
04:18:19 Okay, well, Arthur, stay safe.
04:18:24 Yeah, I'm going to try to run to my car as quickly as possible.
04:18:29 Get out of here.
04:18:29 Yeah, I'm sure there's some folks probably not too thrilled around,
04:18:34 but thank you for your work tonight.
04:18:37 Excellent reporting, and we look forward to your stories being filed.
04:18:43 The real work begins now, Derek.
04:18:47 All right, thank you.
04:18:49 All right, let's check in with Dave Naylor in the newsroom.
04:18:53 Dave, you've been watching this.
04:18:56 Did we miss anything on Notley?
04:18:58 We, you know, we kind of, she got into thanking everyone and her dog at some point, which is important, but not terribly exciting for our viewers.
04:19:08 Was there anything we missed?
04:19:11 Oh, you're missing Smith on stage right now.
04:19:14 Oh, well, let's go to her immediately.
04:19:15 What are we doing?
04:19:21 What are we doing?
04:19:22 Let's get her up right now. 1.00
04:19:28 Oh, thank you, thank you, Albert.
04:19:37 Sean, Your Honor.
04:19:40 Oh, boy.
04:19:41 Thank you.
04:19:42 Oh, thank you, my dear friend.
04:19:47 Thank you so much.
04:19:51 Well, to paraphrase our dear friend, Ralph Klein, welcome to another Miracle on the Prairie.
04:19:57 on the prairies.
04:20:03 Hi, friends.
04:20:04 This was the very definition of a hard-fought election.
04:20:09 We face the most extensive, fierce, and coordinated opposition in third-party political campaigns
04:20:15 in provincial history.
04:20:27 .
04:20:57 .
04:21:27 .
04:21:57 .
04:22:27 .
04:22:57 Join me in genuinely thanking her for her public service.
04:23:27 So I would like to thank the hundreds of thousands of Albertans who voted for the UCP today.
04:23:32 I want to speak for a moment to every Albertan who did not.
04:23:36 I want you to know that my oath is to serve all Albertans, no matter how you voted.
04:23:43 And though I didn't do enough in your judgment to win your support in this election, I will
04:23:51 work every day to listen to improve and to demonstrate to you that i can be trusted to
04:23:57 improve on the issues that you care so deeply about now i won't be perfect of course we all
04:24:03 know that but when i make a mistake i will listen correct course and learn from it so that i can
04:24:08 improve and become a better leader and so i invite all albertans regardless of who you supported in
04:24:13 this election to reach out to me with your ideas and your concerns and your questions that feedback
04:24:19 that you give me positive and negative helps make our ucp caucus and i to make better decisions
04:24:25 and that is what a healthy democracy is all about now before i go further i think it's
04:24:35 important tonight to recognize the courageous sacrifice and efforts of our firefighters
04:24:40 and other first responders who are fighting and winning the battle against forest fires
04:24:45 across our province i'd ask all of us to stand here and applaud our heroes of alberta
04:24:54 that is what alberta is all about we look after each other we take care of each other and we must
04:25:00 remember that there is much more much more that unites us than divides us and we will need to
04:25:06 be unified in the days and years ahead because there's so much work to do together for example
04:25:12 we need to make sure that you and your family keep more of your money for the things that you
04:25:16 need especially during this time of high inflation we yeah
04:25:25 we have to make sure that our communities and streets are safe again for our families and our
04:25:29 businesses and we have to keep powering and diversifying our amazing economy and i want
04:25:39 to tell every business owner and investor listening tonight whether doing business
04:25:44 inside or outside of alberta we are throwing our doors wide open for businesses large and small
04:25:55 to make this province a home for your business and its employees enjoy the benefits of the
04:26:00 alberta tax advantage and bring your jobs and investments here because you are both welcomed
04:26:06 and valued and to demonstrate that the first bill of our government in the legislative session in
04:26:11 the fall will be to guarantee that unless albertans say otherwise by referendum the
04:26:16 only direction business and personal taxes are headed in this province is down
04:26:29 because we know that when businesses thrive people thrive and when we grow our economy we
04:26:34 attract the best and brightest from all over the world and we want that we have built the most
04:26:38 powerful economy and diverse population in the country on the principles of free enterprise
04:26:44 entrepreneurship and economic growth let's not ever forget that and let's not ever change that
04:26:53 we also need to ensure that our health care and education systems are the best
04:26:58 in the world not simply adequate not middle of the pack the very best in the world
04:27:06 and that means we need to study the best systems and practices around the world and improve upon
04:27:11 the strong foundation that we've built here but it also means empowering our doctors and nurses
04:27:16 teachers and other frontline professionals along with feedback from patients and parents
04:27:22 to innovate and improve in these areas every single day so i'm asking healthcare and education
04:27:27 professionals tonight i'm also asking parents and patients to work with me and the ucp caucus
04:27:34 to build a healthcare system and an education system that are models for the entire world
04:27:43 i know we can do this together and i am here to listen and to work alongside of you and finally
04:27:49 my fellow Albertans we need to come together no matter how we have voted to stand shoulder to
04:27:54 shoulder against soon to be announced Ottawa policies that would significantly harm our
04:27:59 provincial economy. Now we have been made aware that in the coming weeks Justin Trudeau is planning
04:28:09 on bringing forward new restrictions on electricity generation from natural gas that will not only
04:28:15 massively increase your power bills but will also endanger the integrity and reliability of our
04:28:20 entire power grid which we rely on during our cold and dark alberta winters in addition the
04:28:26 prime minister is already ready to introduce a de facto production cap on our oil and gas sector
04:28:33 that if implemented if implemented will result in tens of thousands of jobs lost tens of billions
04:28:42 in lost investment, damage our province's fiscal position, and bring economic hardship to Albertans.
04:28:48 Now, I've made myself clear on this matter to the Prime Minister in person and in public,
04:28:53 but I feel we need to do it again.
04:29:12 Well, hopefully the Prime Minister and his caucus are watching tonight.
04:29:20 But let me be clear, this is not a road we can afford to go down.
04:29:26 If he persists, he will be hurting Canadians from coast to coast,
04:29:29 and he will strain the patience and goodwill of Albertans in an unprecedented fashion.
04:29:35 and as premier i cannot under any circumstances allow these contemplated federal policies to be
04:29:44 inflicted upon albertans i simply can't and i won't
04:29:48 And so I invite the Prime Minister to instead halt the introduction of these harmful policies
04:30:10 and come to the table in good faith to work collaboratively with Alberta on an energy
04:30:14 emission strategy that will both grow the Alberta and Canadian economies while using the export of
04:30:20 Alberta LNG and emerging technologies to achieve meaningful reductions in emissions because when
04:30:26 Canadians work together there is no challenge that we can't overcome I believe that but it takes two
04:30:31 parties acting in good faith to build that meaningful partnership now Alberta is willing
04:30:36 to be that partner and we need our federal government to show it is willing to partner in
04:30:41 good faith as well and now is the time to do so we are waiting
04:30:51 so in closing my friends tonight is a time for celebration we celebrate
04:31:02 we celebrate the candidates that won their election races and the efforts of those who
04:31:06 did not we celebrate the commitment to democracy of all volunteers and supporters regardless
04:31:11 of party affiliation and we celebrate those who have sacrificed to secure and protect our right
04:31:17 to vote and be a free and prosperous people and we celebrate this beautiful province and all who live
04:31:24 here this uniquely special place where the best and brightest come from every corner of the world
04:31:36 to join us in building one of the greatest places on earth to live and work and raise our families
04:31:41 and where the only things that are larger than our mountains is the compassion and irrepressible
04:31:47 spirit of our people from the bottom of my heart thank you alberta and may our province remain
04:31:53 forever strong and brave thank you
04:31:58 Big smiles from Premier Danielle Smith as her party will return.
04:32:09 All right, while we just finished watching re-elected Alberta Premier Danielle Smith
04:32:19 give her victory speech, short, actually significantly shorter than not least concession
04:32:25 speech but um i think pretty boisterous uh relatively humble though for someone who just
04:32:33 won but she used the term uh that i'm actually kind of angry because people think i plagiarized
04:32:38 my column on this but i wrote it before she spoke uh it was the miracle on the prairies
04:32:44 kind of uh mirroring what happened with uh ralph klein 1993 took over from um don getty lost a
04:32:52 comparable number of seats, but everyone expected them to lose government. Instead, they just lost
04:32:57 seats but held on to government. The miracle on the prairies. Well, she's a big Ralph Klein fan,
04:33:02 so that would have been a very natural thing for her to even have to think of that. It was a nice
04:33:09 speech. It hit exactly the right note. This is now her premiership. Some people say, well, if you
04:33:17 kind of become premier by becoming leader of the party between elections, okay, she campaigned for
04:33:24 this, she's got it, it's what, 52, 35, 51, 36, we're not quite sure at the moment, but this is her
04:33:33 victory, and she can celebrate tonight, so than her husband, Dave. Corey, I mean, it's a loss of
04:33:42 seats but a year ago today uh every poll showed used to be headed for a catastrophic and historical
04:33:49 defeat so uh i don't know should the ucp how down should they be on themselves if they lost a good
04:33:56 number of seats well it's unfortunate they're gonna lose some caucus members there's been some
04:34:00 turnover but uh they pulled it's been pulled out of the fire and and premier smith has as as nigel
04:34:06 said a mandate no more of this undercutting no more saying she doesn't deserve to be there 0.87
04:34:09 she took it to Albertans and now she has a majority mandate to act on what she's been
04:34:15 promising and to govern. I think it's time to push back against it. It's been like that since
04:34:22 the leadership began with every tall forehead and academic, everyone else saying Daniel Smith
04:34:27 was going to be a disaster. Well, I believe it hit a low of 22% supported under Premier
04:34:32 Kenney at one point. And to having a majority government at this point, this is doing quite well.
04:34:39 Yeah, I mean, it's a few things are going back and forth. Actually, let's go to Dave Naylor in the newsroom right now. Dave, I know there's been some shifts going around. The UCP has actually taken the lead for the first time, I think, in Lethbridge East, but has actually fallen behind the NDP by a little bit in Banff-Cananaskis.
04:35:02 Oh, we cannot hear Dave. We are not hearing Dave right now.
04:35:09 All right. Are we going to be able to get sound for Dave?
04:35:13 I blame James for that one.
04:35:16 Yeah, the NDP has staged a stunning comeback in Banff.
04:35:19 They're now ahead by 330 votes or so.
04:35:24 So I think you were right to be cautioning us on that one.
04:35:28 And Acadia is also extremely close.
04:35:32 78 votes, I think, between the two of them with Tyler Shandro in the lead.
04:35:44 And there's only one more polling station to go on that one, Derek.
04:35:50 Overall, we got 1,564,000 votes counted.
04:35:55 That's 91% of all polls reporting.
04:35:58 and it's currently 50 to 37 for the UCP.
04:36:05 All right.
04:36:06 Yeah, there's just a couple of these races that are on a knife's edge,
04:36:10 none of which will change the ultimate outcome of the election.
04:36:12 It'll change how good a night individual candidates in MLAs have,
04:36:17 but won't change things necessarily overall.
04:36:21 We haven't talked too much about Edmonton.
04:36:23 Edmonton's been the least talked about part of Alberta, I think,
04:36:27 because it's just been taken for granted.
04:36:29 The NDB is going to sweep the whole thing, and they did.
04:36:33 We talked about Calgary, and everyone talked about Calgary ad nauseam
04:36:36 for a good reason because that was where it was decided.
04:36:38 But there were some couple battles around that mattered
04:36:42 if the NDB was going to have a path to victory,
04:36:44 Banff Kananaskis maybe, Lethbridge East, the donut around Edmonton.
04:36:51 Edmonton proved to be the Orange Fortress, 1.00
04:36:54 but they got stuck inside that wall.
04:36:56 they did not get out they held St. Albert and but they picked up only one in the entire two in the
04:37:02 entire Edmonton region they picked up Edmonton Southwest taking out Deputy Premier Casey Maddow
04:37:07 and they took uh Sherwood Park taking um what's his name sure who was there yeah uh anyway they
04:37:16 took Sherwood Park they didn't take Strathcona Sherwood Park they didn't take anything else
04:37:21 They got restricted completely to Edmonton there.
04:37:25 They did take the donut.
04:37:26 But it is quite a feat to take every single seat in Edmonton,
04:37:30 as they did the time they formed government in 2015, Nigel.
04:37:34 It's not actually a good thing.
04:37:36 It shows the extent of the division in the province.
04:37:41 I mean, there are two very different visions of how the province should look,
04:37:45 how it should operate, how it should perform.
04:37:47 And you've got this collectivist vision in Edmonton.
04:37:51 and the rest of the province, they want to do things differently.
04:37:56 You know, this is going to be the challenge for Premier Smith going forward,
04:38:04 is to bring people along.
04:38:06 I mean, let's be realistic about our expectations.
04:38:09 She's not going to turn the orange fortress into the blue fortress, but she has to.
04:38:15 Hold on a second.
04:38:16 I want to go back to Dave in the newsroom on Calgary Bow.
04:38:19 Calgary Bow, Drew Farrell, and the NDP have actually just taken the lead.
04:38:25 Dave, can you give us a – how many polls are left to report in Calgary Bow?
04:38:29 Three polls to go in Calgary Bow, and Drew Farrell is up 8,847 to 8,664.
04:38:40 So he's got almost a couple hundred road lead with three polls to go.
04:38:47 You know, this is funny.
04:38:49 some of the bellwethers uh well they've been flipping back and forth all night the ndp could
04:38:54 still win some of these really key bellwethers and not win uh acadia even if they win acadia bow
04:39:03 they're they're still not taking it well we knew this was how it was going to be when we started
04:39:07 that there were a dozen or so seats in calvary that were could go either way and we said that
04:39:13 The NDP would have to win nine of them.
04:39:18 The UCP just had to hold three or four of them.
04:39:21 So that's how it's turning out.
04:39:23 Yeah, it looks like they squeaked by in Calgary Edgemont too.
04:39:27 All the remaining, but they're leading 11,419 to 11,243.
04:39:34 So Panda is going to have to pick up at least a few hundred votes
04:39:38 and then one poll remaining if he wants to.
04:39:40 so yeah and panda was elected for the first time i think um in 2017 so that was he was in the
04:39:48 by-election replacing yeah so that was called calgary foothills at the time but there was a
04:39:51 redistribution there's another running called calgary foothills but it was all kind of chopped
04:39:54 up he was elected in the by-election replace because jim prentice never actually took his
04:39:59 seat so he never technically resided just never accepted the seat i guess it was a never heard
04:40:03 of anything like that yeah um but then he replay uh ran and won the seat for the wild rose um
04:40:10 so you know he's been there for a while and he'd run for the wild rose actually for the first time
04:40:14 in like 2012 under danielle smith i think he might have been the last wild rosers still in there
04:40:19 is there anybody else was an original wild roser still in caucus he was never there is no uh drew
04:40:24 barnes was the last original wild roser well along with prasad well he wasn't original but
04:40:29 Prasad was a Wild Rose.
04:40:31 I'm just saying there's no other Wild Rosers left.
04:40:32 None.
04:40:34 No, there are people who were Wild Rose MLAs.
04:40:36 Todd Lowen.
04:40:37 Oh, sorry.
04:40:37 Thanks.
04:40:38 No, there's a few.
04:40:39 You got...
04:40:40 Todd, yeah.
04:40:40 Brian Jean.
04:40:41 Brian Jean, yeah, it was in and out.
04:40:43 Yeah.
04:40:43 Brian Jean.
04:40:46 Daniel Smith.
04:40:48 Daniel Smith.
04:40:49 Okay.
04:40:50 There's just aren't too many remnants of that original caucus anymore or longer.
04:40:53 Anyways, but look at that couple in there. 1.00
04:40:55 Okay, well, I guess we'll just give time for final thoughts before we wrap it up.
04:41:01 We don't want to abuse the time of our viewers, but final thoughts from you, Corey.
04:41:07 It's been a long night, but the decision's done.
04:41:10 It's over.
04:41:11 And she does, Premier Smith has a majority.
04:41:14 I'm going to write about that.
04:41:16 She's got to treat it like one.
04:41:18 It's no more pussyfooting around either.
04:41:20 No more apologizing for being conservative.
04:41:23 Yeah, that's so true.
04:41:25 Nigel, your closing thoughts.
04:41:26 I just hope the party gets behind her 0.86
04:41:28 and that the people who have their own private ambitions
04:41:31 save it for another day and we actually get things done.
04:41:33 This province needs what this government can deliver
04:41:38 if it's allowed to.
04:41:39 There's a strong stance towards Ottawa
04:41:42 when Ottawa comes calling.
04:41:44 All right.
04:41:45 Well, it's...
04:41:46 Wish her good luck.
04:41:48 It's quite an evening tonight.
04:41:50 I guess another miracle on the prairies,
04:41:51 He's, Smith, pulling this one out of the fire.
04:41:56 You bet.
04:41:56 All right, gentlemen, thank you very much.
04:41:58 I want to thank our whole team, all of our reporters, Dave Naylor, Arthur Green,
04:42:05 Jonathan Bradley, Sean Polzer, all the other staff in the background,
04:42:10 Regina Shakurva, Nick Wiebe, and, of course, our broadcast editor,
04:42:17 Nico Avote, and all of our guests.
04:42:19 We've had just so many people coming through here.
04:42:21 I'm definitely leaving out a ton of people, but I want to thank everybody for their contribution
04:42:26 tonight to giving an independent view of Alberta's election here.
04:42:31 And I think we may have actually been the first media to call this, as hesitant as I was.
04:42:36 Thank you all very much for joining us on this special Alberta election broadcast.
04:42:41 We'll see you soon.
04:42:42 God bless.
04:42:51 You