Western Standard - May 01, 2024


Alberta explores future of rail for 22nd Century

Topics
Mentioned
Supporting Survivors Alberta Invests in Sexual Assault Services Educational elitism has created the shortage of skilled labour we have today

Episode Stats


Length

8 minutes

Words per minute

205.88

Word count

1,771

Sentence count

178

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Premier Rachel Notley wants to build a high-speed rail line between Calgary and Edmonton, Alberta. I don t think this is an idea Alberta should be pursuing. High-speed trains are expensive and don t work in most places.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 almost not surprised but appalled, to see Premier Smith get up and start talking about high-speed
00:00:06 rail in Alberta. This is an idea that there are train fetishists out there. That's really what
00:00:12 they are. They've got a thing for trains. They love trains. They think they're great. Good for
00:00:17 you. You love those things. But it doesn't mean they're economically feasible. And they certainly
00:00:23 aren't economically feasible everywhere. Premier Smith's always loved trains. She even had a
00:00:28 restaurant in a train car for a while. But this is reeking of a pet project. This got studied,
00:00:35 I don't know, 12 years ago. We spent a bunch of money. We did a big study on it. And we found that
00:00:41 high-speed rail won't work in Alberta. It doesn't work. We would need, it felt at that time, a
00:00:47 population of about 10 million people. And the ticket prices, again, if you're guessing on it,
00:00:52 if it got built, might be in the range of $200 to get Calgary to Edmonton. It just doesn't work.
00:00:57 People keep talking about, and I've been debating them online. I don't believe in blindly following
00:01:02 things. You see, that's where people got so upset with me, because I was critiquing Daniel Smith.
00:01:06 Well, I love a lot of what Premier Smith is doing. I've been very supportive of it. But this one's a
00:01:10 stinker, guys. This is bad news. Do not start moving towards this. We studied it. They said it was 0.95
00:01:16 crap. Leave it alone. But she won't. And when they did the way they were talking so gushingly and 1.00
00:01:21 everything, they said, we're just studying it. No, they're starting the groundwork to move towards this.
00:01:25 I get other people saying, oh, but look at how it works in Japan. Look at how it works in
00:01:29 France. Yeah, well, let's look at that. Japan has what, 120 million people in an area that's only
00:01:36 a little bit bigger than half the size of Alberta. That's a rather big difference. We have four and
00:01:42 some million, maybe getting more towards five. Not even close, guys. Meanwhile, France, same sort of
00:01:49 thing. I think they have 60 million and far, far more dense. High-speed rail doesn't work for that.
00:01:56 Think of it. What if building that between Calgary and Edmonton? Okay. And let's say it
00:02:02 costs $10 billion. That means out of your pocket, right off the bat, and trust me, it'll cost more
00:02:06 than that. Think of expropriating all the land required. Think of all of the battles that'll
00:02:12 have to go on. The court challenges the rest. So let's say you got that right of way going. Then you
00:02:17 got the stations built. You got all that done. You got that train in. And let's say it was even
00:02:23 $10 billion. That means every man, woman, and child in Alberta will be shelling out about
00:02:28 $2,000 each just to have it built. That's what the cost would come into. And of course,
00:02:32 not everybody pays taxes. So realistically, if you're a middle-class taxpayer, it's more
00:02:37 like you're going to be shouldering about $3,000 of that. And then you're going to have to pay
00:02:41 a couple hundred to ride this thing. Maybe. Or it'll be subsidized down. So you'll pay all the
00:02:47 time whether you ride it or not. And then get a relatively cheaper ticket. We don't need this.
00:02:52 It's ridiculous. Get on and people say Highway 2 is so crowded and nasty. Yes, it is. So expand it. 0.98
00:02:58 Look at the vehicles on Highway 2 in Alberta. Not all of them are going all the way from Calgary to
00:03:04 Edmonton. Some of them are going Calgary to Panoka. Some of them are going Panoka to Westlock,
00:03:09 you know, and past Edmonton, things like that. And they're people with vehicles. They're people
00:03:12 with families. They're people with luggage. You really want to go through, OK, I'm going to go
00:03:16 from Calgary to Edmonton to visit Aunt Edna there. And I'll take the two kids. So they'll say it's a
00:03:22 family of four. OK, we're going to take an Uber and pay that price. Or we'll drive to this train
00:03:27 station and pay for parking. You know, check in, check our luggage, spend $100 a head. So it's $400
00:03:33 one way to get the family up there without including the Uber and parking costs. And you get to the
00:03:38 other side in Edmonton, maybe half an hour earlier than you would have. You just bloody drove, even
00:03:43 if it's a high speed train, because you had to stop Red Deer. And then you got to get an Uber,
00:03:48 get in that, go all the way to Aunt Edna's. And then you're stuck without a vehicle for your visit.
00:03:52 You know, you got to listen to her in terminal stories about her bad hip and things. And you 0.99
00:03:56 can't even make an excuse saying, I'm going to hop in the car and go to the liquor store because
00:04:00 you took the train. Look, guys, it's going to be a very limited market. And then I've had others
00:04:06 talk about it. Look at Via Rail in Canada. It's a catastrophe. It's heavily, heavily subsidized.
00:04:13 And it's terrible service. And then there's other people saying, well, that's because they
00:04:17 have to share the tracks with CP and they don't get priority routing and things like that. Well,
00:04:21 okay. But then when we want to start talking about costs, when you're talking about, say,
00:04:27 some people saying, well, we would just do Banff to Calgary on a conventional rail. Okay.
00:04:32 Well, then you got to share the track. So it'll have the same problem as Via.
00:04:37 So you're dealing with CP because they own that track or, or you build another track. And again,
00:04:43 for people not familiar with Alberta, drive between Calgary and Banff. What have you got
00:04:48 going on there? For one, there's a whole bunch of mountains you're going to have to blast once you
00:04:51 get into the Canmore-Ekshaw region to get that track in there. The other part is you're going
00:04:57 through the Stony Reserve. Yes. A great big first nation you have to get through and it's their
00:05:02 land and they have every right to negotiate the best deal they can. And again, if you're familiar
00:05:06 with Calgary, we had a ring road that went through the Sutina Reserve. It took 40 years to negotiate
00:05:12 that. 40 years. It cost billions. And that's just a chunk of ring road. How much do you think the
00:05:18 Stony is going to want to have a railroad track doubled through their reserve? It ain't going to come
00:05:25 cheap. Look, we don't want to rule out other areas of transportation. We could talk about extending
00:05:30 the LRT in Calgary. It's not a real long shot anymore from the Northeast to get it to the airport
00:05:35 perhaps. And people have talked about, well, what about to Cochrane? Well, again, it's already moving
00:05:40 up that way up Crowchild. Keep creeping it up that way if you've got the demand and eventually you will
00:05:44 have train transit going those ways. But look in Calgary as well. We've got the green line they're
00:05:47 talking about. The green line. We've been talking about it for years. And they've been ripping up
00:05:52 downtown Calgary doing utility working crap on it for years. And it keeps, you know, they won't make 0.53
00:05:57 the budget bigger, which is five and some billion. But what they keep doing is making the green line
00:06:00 smaller. So, I mean, eventually this thing's only going to be one station at the rate they're going
00:06:05 and taxpayers are on the hook. We've got to remember the world's changing too. Part of the problem with
00:06:10 the green line, people don't work downtown like they used to. The office buildings in Calgary are still
00:06:14 nearly empty all over the place. We've got 30% vacancy going on down here. We've got another
00:06:19 boondoggle going on that showed with Gondek a little while ago, where they were converting an old 0.75
00:06:25 office building into residential units. And it turns out that the contractors aren't getting paid now and
00:06:31 it's getting stalled. And there's a big problem. Of course, the taxpayers are pumping millions into that
00:06:35 as well. Guys, people don't need to live downtown anymore. We haven't had to since the fax machine. That was
00:06:41 kind of the beginning of the end. You don't see the bike couriers running around with maps and documents
00:06:45 from oil company building to oil company building. In fact, a lot of people, that's one thing COVID
00:06:50 changed all around, was people realizing, I don't have to be down there all the time. I can work from
00:06:56 home. I can do a whole bunch of the stuff that I did at downtown on a laptop or on a computer in my
00:07:02 house. And they're doing that. Maybe not full-time, but part-time. So, why are we building more
00:07:06 infrastructure to suck everybody into a centralized city? The reality is we're growing out. Let's build to
00:07:13 accommodate that. Let's get realistic. Let's look at, here's where, okay, to be fair, where some of
00:07:19 the right can go a little wild at times. Let's look at complete communities, I think is the term
00:07:24 they often use. You know, a new development that'll be on the outside of a city, but it's higher density.
00:07:28 And it also has a lot of the services built in for that because that way people don't have to
00:07:32 commute into the center. So, make sure there's a school there, a medical facility there, retail space
00:07:37 there, all of those things so they don't have to move as far. Good stuff. It's just good planning.
00:07:42 And it could sell, but we got to go out, not in, not up. Again, the people, if you care about
00:07:49 affordable housing, high density stinks. Look to every high density city in North America. It's easy.
00:07:56 It's great. You can study these things online. Look at the heavyweight high density cities. Look at
00:08:00 Manhattan. Look at San Francisco. Look at Seattle. High density. Also expensive as all hell for renters and
00:08:11 homeowners. It's not kind of contrary, but they've built up. Yes. So it doesn't matter because the
00:08:17 areas where you can get affordables, where you build out, you want to be affordable, Las Vegas,
00:08:22 Phoenix, Houston, even Tennessee is getting really good out there. You know, these areas where they're
00:08:27 not fixated on this anti-suburban lunacy. They're just letting people build where they want to go.
00:08:34 Let people choose where they want to go.