Western Standard - January 02, 2026


Alberta independence in 2026, and the difference between Eastern and Western Canada

Topics
Mentioned
Food Bank Demand Doubles in Strathcona County as Grocery Prices Soar Western Standard News Update | 05 Jan 2026

Episode Stats


Length

20 minutes

Words per minute

133.54

Word count

2,794

Sentence count

144

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Dr. Barry Cooper, a professor of political science at the University of Calgary, joins us to discuss the possibility of Alberta declaring independence from Canada. Dr. Cooper also discusses his new book, Paleolithic Politics: The Human Community in Early Art.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening everyone and Happy New Year's Western Standard viewers. Today we welcome you to The
00:00:23 Hannaford Show. I am Leah Mashid. I am filling in for Nigel Hannaford today and to help us to
00:00:29 welcome the new year, we have Barry Cooper, a professor of political science at the University
00:00:34 of Calgary. He will help us discuss and understand more about Alberta independence today, which we'll
00:00:40 definitely be seeing more of in the new year, so I thought it would be a great topic to talk about,
00:00:45 as well as his most recent book called The Paleolithic Politics, The Human Community in
00:00:52 early art. So thank you very much for joining us, Mr. Cooper. Yeah, so I guess my first question
00:01:00 for you today would definitely have to be with how plausible do you think Alberta independence
00:01:06 really is? And if you think it is very plausible in the near future, when do you think it might
00:01:13 occur? Well, political scientists almost never predict anything, because politics is about
00:01:26 humans taking initiatives that can't be predicted. It's not a question of behavior. It's a question
00:01:33 of, I would say, leadership. And much of that will depend on how Laurentian Canada responds
00:01:41 to the inevitable, I would say inevitable, or nearly inevitable, likely rejection of
00:01:50 the Memorandum of Understanding, which Premier Smith and the Prime Minister signed, what,
00:02:00 a month ago now?
00:02:02 A lot will depend on how the Laurentians respond to that, because it's not going to work.
00:02:08 Anyone who's taken a look at the text or has performed an analysis of it
00:02:12 realizes that there's so many escape clauses for the government of Canada
00:02:17 that they have absolutely no reason to push either British Columbia
00:02:24 or the Indigenous partners, potential partners, particularly for pipelines.
00:02:32 So it's going to go nowhere.
00:02:34 You know, then what happens? I think that probably Premier Smith will be put under a lot of pressure because it will be coming time for the various referenda to take place sometime in 2026.
00:02:51 And then if that happens and she takes an active role in the pro-independence side of that, then suddenly independence becomes both respectable and in the short term, more likely.
00:03:12 okay well i guess relating to that since you're saying you know political science just can't
00:03:20 really predict that stuff and it's all about human behavior how do you think if the because
00:03:26 there's a petition that just got um approved for signatures for alberta independence sorry if i'm
00:03:32 not speaking loud enough um there's been a petition that was approved for alberta independence
00:03:37 that was approved, I think, late December, right before Christmas.
00:03:42 And if they get enough signatures, it's going to go for a referendum vote.
00:03:47 And say that the referendum vote gets voted as well for Alberta independence.
00:03:53 How do you think Daniel Smith would react to something like that occurring?
00:04:00 This is the big unknowns about politics.
00:04:02 I would hope that she takes the bull by the horn, so to speak, and leads the pro-independence faction, party, group, set of Albertans.
00:04:19 Whether she will or not is obviously up to her and how she reads the political landscape.
00:04:24 But if that happened, then I think it would certainly strengthen the hand of Alberta vis-a-vis.
00:04:33 It's basically about Ontario and Quebec.
00:04:37 We don't care much about what New Brunswick thinks about anything.
00:04:42 And neither do Ontario and Quebec.
00:04:43 They haven't thought much about the Maritimes since about two decades after Confederation.
00:04:49 So it's not really about them.
00:04:51 It's about Alberta and Saskatchewan vis-a-vis the central provinces, the big central provinces, Quebec and Ontario.
00:05:01 And because of the question of Quebec, I mean, you know, they've been talking about independence now as well.
00:05:07 And if the Bloc Quebecois wins or the Parti Quebecois wins the next election there, then the government of Canada will have, let's say, it'll have its business cut out for it.
00:05:24 And, you know, that nothing but good would come of that for this province.
00:05:29 like so when you're talking about alberta and saskatchewan being the central provinces and so
00:05:35 would be dependent on them as well like so do you mean when alberta if alberta were to get 1.00
00:05:41 uh its independence would saskatchewan be a part of that or it would be more likely
00:05:46 that saskatchewan would be a part of that yeah well that's obviously up to the citizens of
00:05:51 of Saskatchewan, but Premier Mo has made comments very similar to those of Daniel Smith and to some
00:06:01 of the, what they call the Alberta prosperity people regarding independence, that it becomes
00:06:07 a viable option. Why? Because Laurentian Canadians don't want to change what benefits them so
00:06:15 enormously um which is you know it's perfectly understandable uh but they have to understand
00:06:22 that we get a vote in this too it's not just up to them what so would it be more beneficial if
00:06:29 alberta was um sorry if saskatchewan joined alberta in independence yeah yeah yeah uh and i think i
00:06:39 I mean, it's hard to tell how these things will play out, but that is certainly a, let's say, live possibility, say sometime late next spring, early summer, when the intransigence of Laurentian Canada becomes obvious even to them, one would think.
00:07:01 But, you know, the barriers to understanding in that part of the country are enormously high.
00:07:06 But let's say they even understood that there's a crisis from which they will not emerge triumphant.
00:07:16 That will be because the economic engines of the country, namely Alberta and Saskatchewan, are united on taking a different path.
00:07:26 And we'll have to see what happens.
00:07:28 But that's certainly a live possibility.
00:07:32 Okay.
00:07:33 Okay. Well, I would also love to know your thoughts on the recent MOU that was signed by Daniel Smith and Mark Carney.
00:07:41 And do you think this will actually go anywhere? Yeah, what are your thoughts on this?
00:07:48 I would say it was a triumph of obfuscation on the part of the government of Canada.
00:07:55 They've left just so many loopholes that everything has to line up.
00:07:59 like the government of bc is going to have to change 180 degrees they're not going to do that
00:08:06 there are well-funded spokespeople for aboriginal communities that are opposed to
00:08:14 any pipelines they're not going to change because they're on the payroll
00:08:19 so what alberta should do if they want to play this game as well is start funding aboriginal
00:08:25 communities that want the pipeline uh and let's hear from them uh that would make a you know an
00:08:30 interesting conversation uh because both sides then would be uh in the back pocket of uh of
00:08:37 third parties either the government of alberta and the government of bc or or all of these uh
00:08:42 you know anti-pipeline uh uh foundations mostly most of which are funded out of san francisco
00:08:50 So, you know, there's a lot of really, let's say, interesting possibilities for a serious debate
00:08:57 sometime in the in the new year. Oh, okay, that's interesting. I guess also you wrote quite a few
00:09:05 articles about Alberta independence in the Western Standard, and one of them you were talking about
00:09:11 how Carney's basically anti-Alberta policies was pushing more Alberta separatists.
00:09:17 yeah, they're for it basically. Morale burdens are for it. So I remember you wrote about how,
00:09:26 this is just because I found it funny, about how Carney plagiarized his PhD thesis.
00:09:34 And I just wanted to know more about that because I thought it would be wild.
00:09:38 These are press reports that came out when he was elected leader of the Liberal Party.
00:09:46 And he wrote his PhD at Oxford, you know, which is quite a respectable university, but somebody did a comparison.
00:09:59 I mean, you can do this now by computer and it takes about, you know, four seconds that indicated that a lot of the quotations without attribution were taken from other sources.
00:10:12 This was brought to the attention of his PhD supervisor at Oxford,
00:10:16 and the guy denied it.
00:10:19 But, you know, I haven't checked it myself.
00:10:23 I mean, God, it's unintelligible economics.
00:10:28 You know, I don't know this.
00:10:30 I was just reporting what was said.
00:10:32 I think it was in the Manchester Guardian.
00:10:34 I'm not sure.
00:10:35 But it was fairly, it was widely circulated, put it that way.
00:10:40 Oh, yeah.
00:10:40 Yeah, I remember reading that the professor or whatever that was supervising him,
00:10:48 yeah, said he wasn't plagiarized, but I was just wondering if he knew more about it,
00:10:52 because I thought it was well.
00:10:53 Okay, anyways, what else?
00:10:56 Okay, when did you start talking about Alberta independence,
00:11:03 and what got you interested in the subject?
00:11:07 Well, that's a good question.
00:11:10 And I suppose the sort of deep roots of this were from my childhood.
00:11:18 I remember going on a fishing trip in Chilkootin in BC when I was about, I don't know, eight maybe.
00:11:27 And my two grandfathers were along.
00:11:30 My dad was sort of organized the thing, and he took my two grandfathers along.
00:11:36 And I remember listening to them talk about social credit, which was the government of W.A.C. Bennett way back then.
00:11:48 And I had one grandfather from Newfoundland and the other was from Nantan, from Alberta.
00:11:55 And they both agreed that this B.C. social credit was not the same as social credit in Alberta.
00:12:02 And they talked about why. And the argument from my Alberta grandfather basically was that it was a way of Albertans taking an initiative because the government of Canada would not.
00:12:19 This was during the Depression when Premier Eberhardt was first elected.
00:12:26 And my Newfoundland grandfather said that he was always slightly mystified by what he called Canadian politics.
00:12:35 And the main thing that I remember from him is that he spoke of Canada as a kind of foreign country.
00:12:41 as, you know, many Newfoundlanders did because of the, let's say, questionable election results
00:12:50 in 1949 about the accession of Newfoundland to Canada. So then, you know, I always started
00:12:58 thinking about, you know, what did these odd political parties mean? Then when I was an
00:13:04 undergraduate at UBC, I had a very, very good professor of Canadian federalism, a guy named
00:13:11 Alan Cairns. And he mentioned in a class one night on Canadian federalism, it took place in the
00:13:20 evening. He thought it was rather odd that social credit and the NDP were called third parties
00:13:28 by Canadian political scientists, when in fact, social credit and the NDP were the major parties
00:13:38 in british columbia and the uh third parties were the liberals and the conservatives
00:13:44 and he just sort of left it there and and uh left us to try and you know figure out this
00:13:50 what this meant um you know needless to say you know none of us undergraduates uh we sort of said
00:13:57 yeah that's kind of weird and left it at that well then you know flash forward another say
00:14:02 i don't know 20 years and i was teaching at york uh and i i couldn't quite understand
00:14:07 the attitudes of my students there because they were so different than the ones that I had thought
00:14:13 of as being normal. And so I taught a course on Canadian political thought. And then a lot of
00:14:21 things became a lot clearer to me, partly in response to the East Toronto students and what
00:14:29 they made of the stuff that I made them read. And basically, the bottom line was that the myths
00:14:37 of Laurentian Canada are not those of the Prairie West. And they're not those of British Columbia
00:14:43 or Newfoundland for that matter either. So I started thinking of Canada not so much
00:14:50 the way it was for my dad's generation. I mean, he was in what was then the RCAF,
00:14:56 close it is again. And he thought of this as a Canadian war effort and so on. But I was struck
00:15:06 by how the self-understanding of Albertans, Westerners generally, is not that of Central
00:15:16 Canada. So, you know, that was the kind of intellectual roots of this view of Canada as
00:15:25 a very tenuous coalition that was established initially in the 19th century by the imperial
00:15:34 ambitions of John A. MacDonald, which he inherited from the Brits, and never really was based on any
00:15:43 self-understanding of people who actually lived here.
00:15:46 So then you can see where if the Laurentians are not
00:15:51 willing to change the legal structure,
00:15:54 and everyone has said since 1982 that it's
00:15:58 impossible to open the Constitution again,
00:16:00 we can't have any more amendments,
00:16:01 which is complete nonsense.
00:16:04 Of course you can't.
00:16:05 The question is, do you have the will to do it?
00:16:08 So then that became the way that I looked
00:16:11 at the relationship between uh albert and saskatchewan um and uh and ottawa let's say
00:16:18 uh and it's not a it's not a it's not a structure that is viable over the long term because
00:16:26 of the enormous wealth uh that has come to the two prairie provinces um so what we do about it
00:16:34 as you know as uh as canadians uh you know we all hold the same citizenship uh is going to be very
00:16:40 interesting. I don't think that the Laurentians are going to do anything. So, you know, it's up
00:16:45 to us. We'll do it by ourselves. And that's where the independence question comes from.
00:16:51 I guess I have a question when we compare, I guess, Canada to the U.S. So it feels like the
00:16:58 U.S. doesn't really have the same issue that Canada does, where some states are wanting
00:17:04 independence from like the whole of the U.S. So you said that Ottawa and like Eastern and you called
00:17:13 it Laurentian, those people don't think the same obviously as like Western Canada does. So how come
00:17:21 there's like this stark difference between the U.S. and Canada if they were both like
00:17:25 from the British Empire originally? Well there are two things that are different in the American
00:17:33 case. The first is that they actually established a new regime from the British Empire after the
00:17:40 declaration and the war against the war for independence. The second is they also had a civil
00:17:46 war. And we have had none of those things. We have never had any serious rebellion against Britain,
00:17:56 you know, despite the rebellions in upper and lower Canada in the 1850s. Those were not really
00:18:02 serious rebellions um and we certainly have not have had a civil war uh for obvious reasons partly
00:18:11 because of the slavery question but also but we've been able to make uh deals with the only um let's
00:18:19 say potentially heretofore anyway potentially secessionist part of the country namely quebec
00:18:25 And that's what the 1982 Constitution basically responded to.
00:18:31 It responded to the growing sentiments in Quebec towards independence.
00:18:37 So we had this, one of the most Machiavellian of our prime ministers, namely Pierre Trudeau, who put together the Constitution Act and put it together in such a way that it became difficult to amend.
00:18:54 And that's why all of these esteemed Canadian political scientists say it can't be amended, we can't open the Constitution again. And as I said, that's not true. They don't want to open the Constitution again and reconsider the position of Quebec in the country because they actually believe that Canada is a bilingual country.
00:19:20 They think that somehow bilingualism and then multiculturalism after that became defining characteristics of the country, which is also nonsense.
00:19:32 Parts of Canada are bilingual, parts of the Ottawa Valley, parts of northern Ontario, parts even of northern or central Alberta, and parts of Quebec are bilingual.
00:19:44 But that's not the country.
00:19:47 Those are parts.
00:19:49 And the myth of Canadian bilingualism
00:19:52 then becomes a kind of moral equivalent
00:19:56 to something that we cannot talk about.
00:19:59 Just as in the, let's say in the 1830s and 40s 0.51
00:20:04 in the United States, nobody wanted to talk
00:20:06 about the consequences of slavery in the South.
00:20:10 But it's still part of the reality.
00:20:14 Wow, that's very interesting.
00:20:17 And I would ask you more about also your book, but unfortunately we're running out of time
00:20:21 since it has to be 22 minutes and my producer just reminded me.
00:20:25 So thank you very much, Barry, for coming in today.
00:20:28 Really appreciate you being able to join us.
00:20:32 And yeah, so if you guys enjoyed this, then you should definitely subscribe to our YouTube
00:20:37 channel if you're watching this on YouTube.
00:20:38 You can also check out our actual website where we have a bunch of news.
00:20:44 So it's westernstandard.news, where you can subscribe for $10 a month or $100 a year.
00:20:50 Yeah, that's all I got.
00:20:52 So thank you, everyone, for joining The Hannaford Show, and goodbye.