Western Standard - December 09, 2023


Alberta Pension Plan engagement update

Topics
Guests
Mentioned
Taking decisive steps to prevent hate-motivated violence Alberta's $31M Funding For Nine New Emission Reducing Projects

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

153.16

Word count

6,352

Sentence count

173


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

An update from Jim Denning, former Minister of Finance and Chair of the Alberta Pension Plan Engagement Panel, on the progress made in the first round of public engagement on the proposed Alberta Pensions Plan. In 2020, the Fair Deal Panel released a report with a range of recommendations for government s consideration, one of which was to explore the potential of creating an Alberta Pension plan and withdrawing from the Canada Pension Plan.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good morning and thank you for joining us today. I'm pleased to be here with Mr. Jim
00:00:06 Denning, former Minister of Finance and Chair of the Alberta Pension Plan Engagement Panel
00:00:10 to provide an update on where we're at with the public engagement process and I'd say
00:00:16 the process overall. Before I invite Jim to the podium for a few words, I'd like to provide
00:00:22 you with a brief summary of what has led us here today. In 2020, the Fair Deal Panel released
00:00:27 report with a range of recommendations for government's consideration one of which was
00:00:32 to explore the potential of creating an alberta pension plan and withdrawing from the canada
00:00:37 pension plan the first step was to engage the expertise of an expert external independent
00:00:43 firm to develop a detailed analysis of the costs benefits and structure of a potential provincial
00:00:50 plan that work was awarded to toronto-based morno chapelle who shortly after became lifeworks our
00:00:57 government committed to sharing the results of that report which we did this past fall
00:01:02 as a starting point to explore the potential of an alberta pension plan with all albertans
00:01:09 using the best information and analysis available and appointing a talented and trusted engagement
00:01:16 panel with jim at the helm we've seen tens of thousands of albertans review the report
00:01:21 and participate in a range of engagement activities where their voices could be heard
00:01:26 i recently met with jim and he provided me with a status update from the panel
00:01:31 that in the continued spirit of transparency i wanted to share with albertans
00:01:36 immediately at this point i'd like to invite jim up to the mic to go over the panel's
00:01:41 observations and recommendations in his own words jim
00:01:45 good morning everyone nice to see you graham it's been a long time um as the minister said my name
00:01:57 is jim dinning i chair the engagement panel for the proposed alberta pension plan and the first
00:02:03 round of our engagement has come to a close and i wanted to provide an update as the minister has
00:02:09 Our panel held five telephone
00:02:11 town hall meetings during
00:02:13 October and November in the
00:02:15 five regions across the
00:02:17 province, about 15,000 people
00:02:19 participated in each session
00:02:21 either by telephone or online
00:02:23 with over 76,000 participants
00:02:25 in total.
00:02:27 If you had the pleasure of
00:02:29 listening in to any of those,
00:02:31 you would have heard 142
00:02:33 people contribute live
00:02:35 during the meetings and
00:02:37 during the meetings, and we logged about 3,800 comments and questions throughout the process.
00:02:44 It's fair to say that we heard from many Albertans who oppose the idea of exiting the Canada pension
00:02:53 plan and moving to an Alberta plan. Many of them quite passionate. There is no doubt that this is
00:03:00 a sensitive issue for a lot of people, but especially those who worry about a vital source
00:03:07 of their retirement income. But we also heard from a number of Albertans who are entirely
00:03:13 in favor of an Alberta pension plan, some of them supporters of the government taking greater control
00:03:20 of the province's destiny, some thinking it a good way of enhancing our financial sector,
00:03:27 And others supportive of an APP because of the savings it might offer either higher benefits or lower premiums or both.
00:03:37 But there are many people, many people who still need more information before deciding.
00:03:44 They're concerned about how an Alberta plan investment fund would be managed, whether their pensions would remain portable.
00:03:52 And of course, the big question is the number.
00:03:55 What is Albertans' share of the Canada Pension Plan assets if an Alberta plan is established?
00:04:03 Albertans want greater clarity around that asset transfer.
00:04:09 From the panel's perspective, uncertainty around the asset transfer is a barrier to moving our engagement discussions forward in a meaningful way.
00:04:19 It is hard for Albertans to provide concrete perspectives when many variables concerning an Alberta plan depend upon the size of that asset transfer.
00:04:31 Our panel had originally intended to host in-person engagement sessions following the town hall meetings in October and November,
00:04:40 and we thought we would host in-person sessions in December, followed by another round of meetings in the new year.
00:04:48 However, we believe it would be prudent to schedule these meetings after Albertans have greater clarity about an asset transfer number.
00:04:58 The federal government has committed to ask the office of the chief actuary for its perspective in this regard.
00:05:06 While that perspective may not settle the matter conclusively, it will provide additional context and assist to making our panel's conversations with Albertans more productive.
00:05:19 In the meantime, our panel will engage in other elements of our mandate, such as how an investment fund ought to be managed, how it ought to be set up, and then how it ought to be managed.
00:05:30 There's aspects around benefits administration.
00:05:34 There are issues around portability both inside Canada and beyond.
00:05:40 And we will continue to explore those aspects through meetings with investment experts,
00:05:46 business groups, and seniors groups over the next few weeks.
00:05:49 As promised, back in September, our panel released a workbook.
00:05:54 It's at albertapensionplan.ca.
00:05:57 that the workbook invites Albertans to read, digest, and comment and complete that workbook.
00:06:04 It offers plenty of space for qualitative feedback, and we have no doubt that Albertans
00:06:11 will be open and frank with their comments as they have been to date, and we strongly
00:06:17 encourage that.
00:06:18 So on behalf of the panel, I want to thank everyone who has participated in the process
00:06:23 so far.
00:06:24 I want to thank them for their patience with us and for the wisdom and thoughts that they have contributed.
00:06:31 Back to you, Minister.
00:06:35 Thank you, Jim.
00:06:37 I'd like all Albertans to know that our government understands the concerns and questions related to the possibility of a provincial pension plan.
00:06:46 When I was first briefed on the LifeWorks report, I had many of the same questions.
00:06:51 I did see the potential and now understand the importance of province-wide deliberation
00:06:57 on the promise the report holds but I also saw the need for assurances while we have these
00:07:02 important discussions. That is why very early in this engagement process I introduced the Alberta
00:07:08 Pension Protection Act so Albertans could rest assured that their future their retirement is
00:07:12 secure no matter what. Albertans have worked hard to build a solid economic foundation for our
00:07:18 province and the entire country has benefited from our efforts it's no surprise then that this topic
00:07:24 has gained so much attention across the country however the federal government has made clear that
00:07:29 alberta just like any other province has the right to explore explore a provincial pension plan
00:07:35 alberta's government is hopeful that the office of the chief actuaries work can be completed
00:07:39 promptly so that albertans can have as much information as possible as they consider the
00:07:44 possibility of a new plan albertans wanted more precise information on the value of the asset
00:07:51 transfer alberta would be entitled to receive if it were to withdraw from the canada pension plan
00:07:56 and we are listening i'm very pleased the engagement panel is taking a prudent measure
00:08:01 by giving the office of the chief actuary the time required to release the findings of their opinion
00:08:06 on the asset transfer amount and any other information on the cpp withdrawal process
00:08:12 from the government of canada that we're waiting for and have repeatedly asked for i also sent a
00:08:18 letter to the office of the chief actuary asking for more details this week alberta welcomes their
00:08:23 actuarial calculation on this important issue and i'd like to thank them in advance for their work
00:08:29 i'd also like to thank all members of the alberta pension plan engagement panel
00:08:34 moyn yaya mary ritchie and of course mr denning for their commitment to listening to albertans
00:08:40 and for their thoughtful approach to responding swiftly to what they've heard today we have been
00:08:46 clear all along albertans will choose what happens with their pensions we will put the interest of
00:08:51 albertans first and respect whatever choice they make it is necessary to receive the office of the
00:08:56 chief actuaries comprehensive analysis to progress this important conversation and my commitment to
00:09:02 albertans is that once we have more information we will share it so thank you i now turn it back to
00:09:07 savannah to moderate the q a great thanks minister we'll now take some questions from
00:09:11 reporters just reminder one question one follow-up state your name and ella for the record
00:09:16 and i do ask if you're in person just to raise your hand dean i see you're ready to go i'll go
00:09:19 with you first yeah yeah minister dean for cp so i just want to clarify something uh that you said
00:09:27 in the house because one of the key questions we've heard at the town hall is how is this fund
00:09:31 going to be matched what is the investment strategy will all the funds be returned to
00:09:36 maximize profits or will we follow the quebec model and perhaps use some of that money to invest in
00:09:41 other provincial projects and so okay go ahead sorry so uh on october 12th you told jesperson
00:09:50 uh quebec model that's off the table we're not doing that in fact i'll bring in legislation to
00:09:55 make that clear which we never saw a few days later your office said no no no the uh the quebec
00:10:00 model is still on the table and albertans will have a decision to make on wednesday you told the
00:10:05 house because the ndp wrote amendments saying we need to clarify your conflicting statements
00:10:10 and you told the house quote i've been clear assets transferred from the cpp to an operative
00:10:16 pension plan and future contributions of employers and employees will solely solely be used to set
00:10:22 up and operate a provincial pension plan so now the quebec model is off the table so i just want
00:10:28 to clarify that so the correct model now is off the table is that correct minister well what bill
00:10:33 2 says it's a simple bill it says that any asset withdrawn from cpp can only be used to set up and
00:10:41 operate an alberta pension plan no yeah but we're talking about future ones minister sorry i need
00:10:46 to clarify future future mr you know what i'm asking you you have told jesperson that we're not
00:10:56 going to use a quebec water your office has told me you are going to use a quebec water you told
00:11:00 the house this week you're not going to use a quebec model are you going to use a quebec
00:11:04 the lifeworks report doesn't say anything about the investment strategy or or who should do it
00:11:11 it's very clear that that's not what the report is about what bill two says is that any asset
00:11:16 withdrawn can only be used for the setup and operation of an app you're hedging the answer
00:11:22 i'm going to make you're hedging the answer you're not answering the question so i'm going to assume
00:11:27 that the Quebec model is still on the table. Which means in the last 10 weeks
00:11:32 you have stated a policy, reversed it, reversed the reversal, and then today reversed the reverse
00:11:38 reversal. So my question sir, with respect, why are you flip-flopping with Albertans on this
00:11:44 critical question? I have never flip-flopped on this issue. Go back to what my comments were. I
00:11:50 have said that they could only be used for the setup and operation of a plan. Now what I said was
00:11:56 i i have no idea what the panel or future albertans are going to advise
00:12:03 a government of the day to do but i've been completely clear that if albertans are to go
00:12:08 down this path of pursuing an app this is what we put in bill two to speak to that that can only be
00:12:15 used for the setup and operation of the plan on the table or off what do you what do you tell
00:12:20 the quebec model if if albertans were to come back if we were to go through this process and
00:12:27 say that this is exactly what they want they would have to have that conversation with the government
00:12:32 of the day for albertans to decide to go down this path it can only be used for the setup and
00:12:36 operation of the plan that's hey thanks minister gramia go ahead and ask you a question come on
00:12:44 over to the podium then it's the follow-up to that um you'd be looking you said you won't be
00:12:51 stopping your work you won't be doing any more public engagement but this whole issue about um
00:12:56 how do we invest the money and you know the cpp better than i think about anybody because if you
00:13:02 worked 30 years ago um the cpp doesn't tie itself to just canadian companies um is a quebec in your
00:13:10 mind when it comes to investing how we invest is a quebec model a possibility that you might
00:13:16 recommend to the government it's a good question uh we've made it clear that we're listening to
00:13:22 albertans and throughout uh our five town hall meetings we heard from some albertans who said
00:13:31 absolutely bloody no do not go down the quebec model route and then on the other hand there
00:13:37 were a number of albertans who said no that using some of those funds this is what they said not
00:13:43 what i'm saying but what albertans said is yes use possibly use some of those funds to build
00:13:51 and enhance the alberta economy so we're listening we're hearing both sides we've not finished our
00:13:59 engagement process and once we get greater clarity around the number we'll recommence in person and
00:14:06 town hall meetings on that issue about the chief actuary the number um it's a pretty complicated
00:14:11 issue the formula is very clear how soon i've talked to some experts who figure this could
00:14:16 take a year to hear back from the federal government and also they may just give you a
00:14:20 range of numbers like not one fixed number but a whole range of numbers how do you see it again
00:14:26 you know how the cpp works you know how complicated this is how soon do you expect to get an answer
00:14:31 from the chief actuary and do you expect it to be one number or a whole range of i have
00:14:37 the the chief actuary will report to the minister of finance for canada who will then report to the
00:14:44 minister of finance for alberta so it's not it's not for for me no no i know you're asking i'm
00:14:50 trying to explain and i know you want me to stop explaining and get to the the nugget you're looking
00:14:55 for but the fact is we don't have an expectation we're hopeful that it can be done hopefully by
00:15:02 mid-february no later than than q1 it graham i learned in government there's no problem we can't
00:15:11 make bigger and i don't think getting this number out of the chief actuary should be a monumental
00:15:20 lengthy task thanks jim yeah no you can't i would just say you know i think it's gonna be
00:15:32 it's very tough to speculate one of the one of the things we're trying to see clarity on we've
00:15:36 reached out to minister freeland's office and the chief actuaries is to how is this
00:15:43 initiative being proposed by minister freeland to the chief actuary you know what are the terms
00:15:47 of reference what exactly is she asking the chief actuary to do so i'd i'd like some details on that
00:15:54 when it comes to the timeline i really don't think we can speculate we know the chief actuary has
00:15:59 better data than the publicly available data that lifeworks had to use but as far as timeline i i
00:16:06 think any speculation would be kind of uh challenging at this point until until we at
00:16:13 least hear back from. Is mid-February something that you might agree with Jim Didding on?
00:16:18 Well, I'd say that is hopeful and I hope to get some clarity when I go to FPT
00:16:24 next week, talk to Minister Freeland. Michelle, yeah, go ahead.
00:16:29 Yeah, I guess this is a larger question. Why are we continuing with this? I mean,
00:16:34 there's been so much pushback and we know there's been a lot of pushback. We know that you have,
00:16:39 you know premier's office has received a lot of emails against this there's a lot of uncertainty
00:16:45 out there and now we're hearing that we're going to sort of pause the the consultation
00:16:52 what's the point of continuing like like why well i think we've we've started this process
00:16:59 you know um we released the report um very pleased that the that the federal government at least
00:17:06 participate in the sense that they want to get the chief actuary involved so i think
00:17:10 it's important to see what the chief actuary comes back with this has been talked about for a long
00:17:16 time in this province so i think getting that number and seeing that through while we obviously
00:17:23 are taking taking some time on the engagement side because we've heard the challenges around
00:17:29 clarity of the withdrawal number but i think it's important to to get that number and and have a
00:17:34 a better understand have a better understanding about this initiative um it would seem premature
00:17:39 to just uh pack it in if that's what you're is it is it really premature i mean we've been talking
00:17:48 about this now for many months i mean it doesn't seem to be seem to see we're not seeing a huge
00:17:53 shift in public opinion well i'd say that's all we've done is talk about it right we've released
00:17:58 a report we've had a conversation about it so i don't see a challenge with getting more clarity
00:18:04 around around the number and then it'll be much easier to determine if this uh has any potential
00:18:10 to proceed or not after that okay great thanks matthew yeah go ahead matthew black with the
00:18:16 journal you talked about some of the feedback you've gotten there's some how many you've gotten
00:18:20 are you able to break down that in favor of pro and against the uh as far as feedback to the panel
00:18:26 Well, I guess I'd ask Jim to comment.
00:18:30 So in round numbers, our take on what Albertans told the panel was that about 50% of Albertans say no, no, don't go to an APP.
00:18:42 About 20, 25% have said we're in favor of it.
00:18:46 And I'd say then 25 to 30% are still undecided.
00:18:53 And they've said give us more information.
00:18:55 And even those who have expressed opposition have said, no, but, no, but I need more information.
00:19:03 So I think the buckets are 50, 25, 25, plus or minus.
00:19:09 There's a question for the minister.
00:19:10 You said in the House earlier this week you were going to request an update from Deputy Prime Minister Freeland on the actuarial.
00:19:16 Did you get a response?
00:19:17 What was the update?
00:19:18 No, we've requested it.
00:19:21 I guess we've sent a letter asking where we're at on this.
00:19:24 but I know I'll see her next week, FPTs in Toronto, so I guess we'll follow up.
00:19:29 We haven't heard back from Minister Freeland's office or the chief actuary
00:19:34 since she made clear that she was going to get them involved in the process.
00:19:40 And through some of her commentary, you know, we kind of expected that they would want to reach out to our department
00:19:47 and at least have an information sharing session, and that hasn't happened yet.
00:19:51 so yeah we just need to get a better understanding if the minister freeland's prepared to give terms
00:19:57 of reference to the chief actuary better we better understand the timeline of that first so
00:20:03 okay great jenna go ahead uh just a question for mr getting um i will listen to at least
00:20:09 three of the town halls where you were really defending this report and this 53 number saying
00:20:15 it was by professional actuaries of a highly responsible firm now it feels like you're saying
00:20:21 oh well people have doubts about that number so we absolutely need to see this other analysis
00:20:26 before we can move forward and take this back to albertans what changed have you lost faith
00:20:31 or do you have no doubts about the life works report conclusion look the there's been one
00:20:38 actuarial report done one more no chapelle did that report a few times actually and uh and concluded
00:20:47 that with their findings it's a gobsmacking number uh there isn't anybody that i know
00:20:56 who isn't surprised by the number but if but as i read through the report uh i pulled out my own
00:21:04 handy dandy calculator and went through the numbers and and found that over that number
00:21:10 over those period of years that contributions by albertans and their employers were x
00:21:19 benefits paid to albertans in column two were y and x minus y adds up to 60 billion dollars
00:21:29 over 55 plus years, and that doesn't include the amount of interest that's earned on the
00:21:37 accumulating balance, and that's how LifeWorks has come up with the number. Lots of dispute
00:21:44 about it. People have disputed it since day one, and what the government has wisely done
00:21:52 has said okay federal government you're you're you're you're overseeing the cpp tell us what
00:21:58 your opinion is of that number and i think asking the chief actuary for canada another actuarial
00:22:06 professional certified actuarial expert to opine upon the number is the smart thing to do and what
00:22:14 as i said in my remarks what we found is that the the the difficulty with that number was was a
00:22:21 a barrier to further and, frankly, better conversations with Albertans about what an
00:22:27 Alberta pension plan could look like. And in that sense, we've learned through the process
00:22:33 that Albertans are concerned about that. And we want to help break down, maybe not totally
00:22:41 eliminate, but at least break down that barrier so we can have productive conversations after
00:22:46 there's more clarity i just want to follow up on matthew's question um first of all 25 plus 30 plus
00:22:53 50 percent adds up to i said 50 i said 50 and then i said excuse me 20 to 25 would be four
00:23:04 and i said look i i don't i don't have i don't have the calculator here with me i'm giving you
00:23:10 a sense of the conversations that we had with Albertans on the five calls and then other
00:23:17 commentary that's come in. So I don't have the calculator number you're looking for.
00:23:26 I'm giving you a sense of what the panel has heard in the first five town hall meetings
00:23:32 and additional engagement.
00:23:34 Is it from your notes or is it a vibe?
00:23:36 I'm sorry?
00:23:37 It's from your notes or?
00:23:38 It is from the notes that all of us took during the town hall meeting.
00:23:43 Okay, thanks Jim. We're going to go to the phones now and we'll come back. Operator, can you put through the first caller?
00:23:51 Jonathan Bradley, Western Standard.
00:23:55 Hello, Mr. Denning. Thank you for taking my question. So you spoke about the large number of people coming out to these panels, but obviously many people aren't.
00:24:07 What are you going to do to try to recruit more people to come and offer feedback?
00:24:14 Plow on.
00:24:16 It's the only way we're going to engage more Albertans.
00:24:20 And I think that there is, I said back in September, that this is a rinsing and soaking process.
00:24:28 The Albertans didn't have the facts that are in the Morneau-Chapelle report.
00:24:33 They now have that.
00:24:34 we put out a workbook at albertapensionplan.ca that asks more questions, leaves more room for
00:24:43 more narrative comments, and ask Albertans if the stars, I'm paraphrasing here, but if the stars
00:24:53 lined up the right way, would you or would you not be in favor of an Alberta pension plan?
00:24:59 And so I think of this, it's an awful lot, like a long project.
00:25:08 God knows I've been through the renovation from hell.
00:25:11 But before we started the renovation, we thought, what do we want?
00:25:16 How much can we afford?
00:25:18 And before the project was done, a long time later, we went through various go, no-go states, positions along that project.
00:25:28 And today, we're really in the design phase of this project.
00:25:34 The government has said, we want Albertans to know about this.
00:25:38 We want them to think about it.
00:25:40 What options do they want?
00:25:42 How much money is involved?
00:25:43 And we're very much in the early phases of where an Alberta pension plan could end up.
00:25:51 And there will be plenty of go, no-go points along that project's development.
00:25:58 Samana, just a comment on Catherine's question on the LifeWorks report.
00:26:04 Just something to make clear, one thing that we're encouraged about the chief actuary being
00:26:11 involved is that LifeWorks, Morneau-Chapelle had to use publicly available data.
00:26:16 The chief actuary has access to a lot more precise data.
00:26:20 So that's something that we think will help as we seek clarity around the calculation.
00:26:28 Okay, my follow-up question is, assuming Albertans don't support moving forward with the Alberta
00:26:39 pension plan, what possible alternative could be reforming the Canada pension plan?
00:26:45 Where do you stand on that, Mr. Denning?
00:26:51 He reformed it once.
00:26:54 Once was enough.
00:26:58 Did you have a comment for the gentleman?
00:27:00 I don't.
00:27:03 We don't have much to give you there, sir,
00:27:07 but I'd say that if that was the direction
00:27:11 or the CPP needed to be reformed for whatever reason
00:27:16 that everyone would have to move that direction.
00:27:19 Okay.
00:27:20 Yeah, thanks, Minister.
00:27:22 Next, we're going to go to the operator.
00:27:25 Operator, can you put through the next caller, please?
00:27:27 Thank you for taking my question. This required exercise was predicated on the $334 billion
00:27:39 and now you're saying, well, people found that number unreal. You budgeted $9.3 million
00:27:46 for advertising and for the consultation. Why did you start this process with a number
00:27:55 that you are now competing is not realistic well i'm not saying it's not realistic i'm saying it's
00:28:02 it's the number that we had you know if you want to equate what this means on to contributions or
00:28:09 benefits that is the best that is the best information we had through the process even the
00:28:15 the lifeworks report shows a range from 260 to 364 billion dollars due to the fact that they're
00:28:24 using publicly available data so i think the important thing is you have to use the asset
00:28:30 number to figure out what it means to contributions and benefits and we were having this conversation
00:28:34 with albertans i think you have to say this is what this could look like now we're in the pursuit
00:28:41 of clarity if the number changes it will change what that means for benefits and contributions
00:28:45 So, after the feds involved the chief actuary, any communications that you would have seen
00:28:54 just drove people to the engagement panel, and the numbers that you spoke of weren't
00:28:59 part of the advertising at that point.
00:29:02 Are you surprised that Albertans rejected the reports that you put forward, or appear
00:29:11 to reject the calculations?
00:29:13 well i think they want certainty they want to understand it's a it's a big number it's it's hard
00:29:19 to get your head around i know it was it was hard for me as well until you dive into how they come
00:29:25 to that conclusion um so no i i don't i think it's uh it's a challenge for for people to to think how
00:29:32 how could this be possible and then you you dig into the report you look at the formula you see
00:29:38 how Alberta's contributions have really dominated the net contributions since the early 80s through
00:29:49 97. I think we had 49% of the pot in 1997. So it would hold that a younger population,
00:29:59 more people participating in the workforce, higher earnings could make those things possible.
00:30:10 And then when Jim helped reform the plan in 1997 to increase contributions to build a wedge
00:30:19 and grow the pot, our net contributions grew a lot of investment income.
00:30:25 Operator, next caller, please.
00:30:27 Tim Burr, CTV.
00:30:31 Hi, thanks for taking my call.
00:30:35 Both of my questions are for the Minister.
00:30:39 First off, I mean, we know that the APP
00:30:43 would need 50% plus one support in a referendum
00:30:47 to pass. The panel finding out
00:30:51 half of all people, 50% of all people are saying no to this
00:30:55 with what most experts are calling a pretty optimistic estimation as far as asset transfers
00:31:01 are concerned.
00:31:02 My question is this, when do we say, okay, that's enough consultation, Albertans don't
00:31:07 want an APP, this is not a road that they want to go down?
00:31:11 Well, I think depending what comes out of the Chief Actuary's office, their opinion
00:31:16 on this, I'm sure we'll have to see if we agree with it.
00:31:22 think they're we will need clarity on what they've actually been asked to do by minister freeland's
00:31:27 office if they've been told how to interpret uh their legislation i think that will that will be
00:31:33 interesting um but i think if we get that number back and it changes the math uh substantially for
00:31:41 albertans and jim goes back and back out in the field and if people say well you know this this
00:31:48 this looks worse, why does it look worse?
00:31:51 Jim will explain it, and then we'll see.
00:31:54 If public opinion isn't on our side,
00:31:57 then it'll be pretty easy to make that decision.
00:32:04 My follow-up question is public opinion,
00:32:07 you know, quote unquote, is a pretty broad statement.
00:32:11 So is there a specific number here that we need to reach
00:32:15 before we scrap this idea and stop spending money
00:32:19 on advertising and public engagement and things like that?
00:32:25 I wouldn't want to speculate in that regard.
00:32:28 We see at the LifeWorks report asset withdrawal number,
00:32:33 we see what it means on the contribution side
00:32:36 and on the benefit side.
00:32:39 If you're asking me to give you a range
00:32:41 of potential numbers where I think it's favorable
00:32:45 for Albertans.
00:32:46 I don't know if I could do that
00:32:47 and probably wouldn't want to speculate, but.
00:32:51 Okay, thanks, Minister.
00:32:52 We'll now go to the next question on the phones.
00:32:54 Operator.
00:32:56 Chris Barco, Calgary Herald.
00:32:59 Hi, my first question is for Mr. Denning.
00:33:04 Mr. Denning, you talked about the feedback
00:33:06 that you've gotten and the split between Albertans
00:33:09 who are in favor and against it.
00:33:11 Can you give me an assess on what feedback
00:33:13 you're hearing from employers that are also involved in this conversation on the ABP proposal.
00:33:20 What percentage are you for, what percentage are you for, and what feedback are you getting?
00:33:23 Chris, we don't have a breakdown yet of employers compared to workers or other Albertans.
00:33:32 I can't give that number.
00:33:34 Okay, separate question for the finance minister.
00:33:40 Minister, just following up on your fiscal update last week and the economic outlook,
00:33:46 I'm just wondering what impact do you think that the oil prices falling below $70 this
00:33:51 weekend, maybe more importantly the emissions tax that the federal government announced
00:33:55 the details on yesterday, are going to have on industry investments next year?
00:34:00 No, great question, Chris.
00:34:01 I think oil did come back to $70 at least, it was down to $68 there, but I know you follow
00:34:06 closely um you i know you know the sensitivities um in our in our analysis of uh what it means for
00:34:14 the forecast it's about 630 million dollars for every dollar of wti uh over the course of the year
00:34:22 mid-year did show that we were projecting uh higher numbers in non-renewable resource revenue
00:34:27 about 1.3 billion that was driven largely by liquids and condensate
00:34:32 but yeah it's the you know opec has a meeting and and says they're going to uh have voluntary
00:34:40 cuts and the oil price goes down so it's a it's an interesting geopolitical time uh especially
00:34:47 around around the price of oil um i think uh i think there's there's some things in in alberta's
00:34:56 favor as well we have um oil sands operations reaching maturity i think there's three a year
00:35:02 over the next three years uh that will help we have tmx uh still pursuing line fill i think in
00:35:09 second quarter 24 which should narrow the differential uh long term uh so we have those
00:35:15 things in our favor but um yeah you're not you're not wrong it's uh it's very very impactful
00:35:21 did that answer chris was there a second part to that pardon
00:35:25 just from the economic standpoint for the province basically but also just for the economy broadly
00:35:34 whether you're thinking or whether you're hearing that the emissions cap for the falling oil prices
00:35:39 are going to impact capital spending rising or falling yes the emissions cap that was the other
00:35:45 part of your question um i met with the chief economist this week uh to go over our forecasting
00:35:51 and theirs um we usually do that annually at mid-year um and i kind of pose the question to
00:35:58 them they're very concerned about productivity in this country generally um you know i think
00:36:05 the emissions cap besides um being an unconstitutional effort by the feds to hinder
00:36:13 the economic potential of the entire country and alberta is a challenge but the economic
00:36:21 it was interesting getting the economists take you know i think their their take is they'd like
00:36:26 to see the opinion of the next federal environment minister because they think that there's going to
00:36:33 be change before this policy could ever be implemented and that it's it's one that would
00:36:39 it would be too impactful to Canada
00:36:41 for a serious government to pursue.
00:36:45 Thanks, Minister.
00:36:46 Operator, next caller, please.
00:36:50 Kevin Stabo, Settler Independence.
00:36:55 Okay, question for the minister.
00:36:58 Your government has said annually
00:37:02 that the Albertans will have their say
00:37:07 there say as far as the Alberta Pension Plan goes through a referendum. However, at every
00:37:16 term when asked, there has been no commitment to make it a binding referendum and I'm just
00:37:24 wondering why that is. Our Bill 2 references the Referendum Act,
00:37:31 Kevin. Only constitutional referendums are binding. I think any government that's going
00:37:42 to ask a question of this consequence, most definitely you should be prepared to follow
00:37:50 through on the wills and wishes of Albertans. But frankly, we're not even to a place where
00:37:57 we're committing to a referendum we're focused on the engagement and the consultation and we'll see
00:38:03 if this initiative has enough support to take take to a referendum or i'm sure a lot of that
00:38:09 can be discussed but uh we're very much focused on getting this number from the chief actuary
00:38:14 and uh seeing if this should should be pursued
00:38:18 thank you okay no follow-up um we're gonna go back to the route or operator actually is there
00:38:29 any more colors on the line okay we'll go back to the room for one more question
00:38:37 i'm just wondering when you do get a number from the chief actually what if you just agree with
00:38:44 are you just going to accept it or are you planning on taking any action to fight it
00:38:48 i it's a great it's a good question but i think it's challenging to to speculate i would like to
00:38:54 see the numbers see their conclusions uh see how they interpreted the the federal legislation
00:39:00 um i think you'd have to go through that entire process um but i i don't uh i could see i could
00:39:09 see places where if the federal government asked them to uh come up with a calculation that we
00:39:15 would say is is outside of the the way their legislation is written i could see us having a
00:39:21 some kind of a challenge over that um but i think it would be too early to speculate we'd have to
00:39:27 see what the number is but more importantly understand how they got to it we the chief
00:39:32 actuary's office uh is very transparent so they will publicly make public the terms of reference
00:39:40 we'll be able to see what they've been asked to do and i think that will give us a lot of clarity on
00:39:45 you know is is this opinion on this number the appropriate one and just to follow up in terms
00:39:52 of investment in management and uh questions about the quebec model i understand from what
00:39:56 you're saying you're saying you're going to leave it till virgins to sort of dictate those terms but
00:39:59 but you've also said that nothing with the Quebec model was really discussed and investment
00:40:03 management wasn't really in that LifeWorks report and that Albertans keep saying they want more
00:40:06 information so I'm just wondering are you planning on providing more information about different
00:40:11 investment models to Albertans so that they have the information to decide or how will that be
00:40:16 incorporated into consultation moving forward? Well as Jim's discussed it comes up kind of
00:40:21 organically in the in the conversations with Albertans and the panel I think what's important
00:40:27 to understand is for in in in our opinion what bill 2 says is that if if albertans want to pursue
00:40:34 that this any any withdrawals that can only be used for the setup and operation of a plan
00:40:40 i think any other question about um investment is is honestly one for a later date i have enough
00:40:48 information thanks minister and thanks everyone for joining us today that concludes our press
00:40:52 conference canadian shooting sports association without the cssa our gun rights would have been
00:41:10 taken long long ago these guys are on the front lines helping to draft smart and intelligent
00:41:16 firearms regulations and legislation in canada and more importantly educating the public about
00:41:22 how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people to become a member it's absolutely worth
00:41:27 Every penny.