Western Standard - May 05, 2025


Alberta Premier Danielle Smith speaks out on independence

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Can the Western independence movement keep it together? Citizen’s initiatives offer true democracy

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

154.99

Word count

6,439

Sentence count

139

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In just a few minutes, Alberta's premier, Danielle Smith, will be making a statement to the Alberta United Conservative Party caucus about the place of Alberta within the Canadian Federation. We're waiting to hear what she has to say.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 .
00:01:00 .
00:01:30 .
00:02:00 Good day, I'm Derek Fildebrand, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:02:09 In just a few minutes, any time now, we're going to be going live to an address from
00:02:14 Alberta Premier Danielle Smith, where she will be making a statement following a meeting
00:02:21 of the Alberta United Conservative Party caucus discussing the place of Alberta within the
00:02:28 Canadian Federation. This comes after a huge outburst of activity and support in support of
00:02:37 Alberta independence. An announcement from Danielle Smith that she is tabling legislation
00:02:42 that will amend the Citizens Initiative referendum legislation that allows Albertans
00:02:49 to trigger referendums on their own. Widely expected now that this is setting the stage for
00:02:57 a referendum in Alberta on independence and the future of our sovereignty. The Uniconservative 1.00
00:03:04 Party Caucus, I think just finished meeting UCP MLA Jason Steffen told reporters at the Alberta
00:03:12 legislature today that he supports Alberta holding a referendum on independence. The cat is seemingly
00:03:19 out of the bag and uh we're into uncharted territory here so we're we're standing by
00:03:25 to uh hear what danielle smith has to say uh but we're just going to chit chat about what's leading
00:03:31 to this what's compelling uh her statement today and what we might expect so i've got joining me
00:03:36 here western standard opinion editor nigel hannaford again derek nigel uh you and i are both
00:03:42 very um vexed because uh the premier's office did not provide us with an embargoed copy of the
00:03:49 speech for those following at home uh you often get budgets or major speeches in advance so you
00:03:56 can you can write your story or write your opinion column and then it's released as soon as you know
00:04:01 the premier starts speaking that kind of thing we did not get that today so you and i are not
00:04:06 pretending to be abusing about what we're about to hear we just don't actually know no we don't
00:04:11 There's probably a reason for that, and that Mark Carney has, of course, just arrived in
00:04:17 Andrews Air Force Base to meet with Donald Trump. So it's an evolving situation, and it wouldn't
00:04:25 surprise me if the speech is still being written, to be honest with you. Generally speaking, these
00:04:30 remarks are prepared well in advance, and they do give them to us, and we read them and start
00:04:35 writing and that's why you get commentary almost as soon as the as soon as the um speech is made
00:04:41 that's not the case today so we're very much uh waiting to see what the premier has to say
00:04:47 yeah so okay let's let's kind of set the table about what's leading up to here so uh monday
00:04:53 last week the liberals were re-elected uh primarily on oh i think we are actually going
00:05:00 to daniel smith right now let's let's stop talking and listen to what the premier has to say
00:05:10 we have fought wars and died defending
00:05:16 opinions of our fellow canadians searching for opportunity many of whom stay and become alberton
00:05:21 and many who return home to their native province all have been welcomed with open arms
00:05:27 our province has contributed hundreds of billions of dollars more to the federal treasury for use
00:05:33 in other parts of the country than will ever receive back in benefits we have allowed this
00:05:38 to occur because quite frankly we know how blessed our province is with an endowment of natural
00:05:43 resources that no other country on earth possesses and we want all of our friends families and fellow
00:05:50 canadians across the country to benefit from it we don't ask for special treatment or handouts
00:05:57 We just want to be free, free to develop and export that incredible wealth of resources we have
00:06:02 for the benefit of our families and future generations. Free to pursue opportunities with
00:06:08 the ideals of entrepreneurship, hard work, and innovation that have become synonymous with the
00:06:14 name of our province. Freedom to choose how best to provide health care, education, and other needed
00:06:20 social services to our people, even if it's done differently than what Ottawa has in mind.
00:06:26 strong and free is more than just our provincial motto it represents who we are and how we want to
00:06:32 live as a people and that is why albertans are so frustrated with the direction of our country
00:06:40 for the last 10 years successive liberal governments in ottawa supported by their new
00:06:44 democrat allies have unleashed a tidal wave of laws policies and political attacks aimed
00:06:50 directly at alberta's free economy and in effect against the future and livelihoods of our people
00:06:57 they have blocked new pipelines with c69 cancelled multiple oil and gas projects and banned the very
00:07:04 tanker ships needed to carry those resources to new markets they have stacked an oil and gas
00:07:10 production cap on top of a crippling industrial carbon tax making new energy and agricultural
00:07:15 projects economically impossible to pursue without massive subsidies from governments which ottawa
00:07:21 has failed to provide and which our taxpayers cannot afford this onslaught of anti-energy
00:07:28 anti-agriculture and anti-resource development policies have scared away global investments to
00:07:33 the tune of a half a trillion dollars driving those investments and jobs out of alberta and canada
00:07:39 to much more attractive investment climates in the united states asia and the middle east having
00:07:45 traveled much of the world these past few years it is evident that canada is not viewed as an
00:07:50 attractive place to invest in resource development manufacturing or agriculture because of our high
00:07:56 carbon taxes endless red tape and the uncertainty and chaos brought about by these and other federal
00:08:03 government policies as a result canada has fallen to dead last in economic growth among
00:08:10 industrialized nations the world looks at us like we've lost our minds we have the most abundant and
00:08:17 accessible natural resources of any country on earth and yet we landlock them sell what we do
00:08:23 produce to a single customer to the south of us while enabling polluting dictatorships to eat our 0.57
00:08:28 lunch for albertans these attacks on our province by our own federal government have become
00:08:35 unbearable as i said these policies have cost albertans roughly a half a trillion dollars in
00:08:40 investment and that loss is growing daily it has and will continue to cost hundreds of thousands
00:08:47 of jobs robbing countless albertans and other canadians of their means of providing for their
00:08:52 families it has cost us a decade of opportunities and tens of billions in lost royalties that could
00:08:59 have been invested in the health education infrastructure and social services albertans
00:09:04 and canadians need and what's worse ottawa continues onward with more destructive policies
00:09:11 they have imposed net zero mandates on our natural gas-based power grid causing investment in
00:09:16 reliable generation from natural gas to flee, thereby endangering the future stability of our
00:09:22 power grid and risking future blackouts and spikes in electricity costs for Alberta families and
00:09:27 businesses. They have attacked our food producers with methane taxes, onerous regulations on
00:09:33 fertilizer, electric vehicle mandates and many other destructive policies that have hiked costs
00:09:39 on our farmers and ranchers and driven billions of dollars of investment in agriculture elsewhere.
00:09:44 they've interfered in provincial jurisdiction time and again from taking over the regulation
00:09:51 of plastics to mandating how we operate child care health care and dental care to harassing
00:09:57 law-abiding firearms owners to dozens of other examples of unconstitutional interference
00:10:03 and of course Alberta has fought back we always have and always will we passed the sovereignty
00:10:10 within a united canada act and have invoked it twice to protect albertans as best we can from
00:10:16 the effects of the net zero electricity regulations and the energy production cap we beat the feds in
00:10:22 court on both the no new pipelines law c69 and their attempt to regulate plastics though they
00:10:28 have ignored both court decisions to this point and we have just announced a court challenge on
00:10:33 the net zero electricity regulations and are further preparing to also challenge the energy
00:10:39 production cap we continue to do all in our power to counteract ottawa's chill on investment in
00:10:46 energy agriculture and our other job sectors through various tax cuts and incentive programs
00:10:52 which greatly strain the provincial budget we have fought these attacks from ottawa furiously
00:10:58 and have won some important battles but the lost opportunities jobs and futures of so many
00:11:04 Albertans are costly and demoralizing, as are the growing number of eastern politicians who choose
00:11:10 to openly demonize and target Alberta for political gain. That is why a large majority of Albertans
00:11:16 are so deeply frustrated with the results of last week's federal election. It's not that our preferred
00:11:22 candidate and party lost, that happens in a democracy, it's that the same Liberal government
00:11:28 with almost all the same ministers responsible for our nation's inflation, housing, crime and
00:11:33 budget crisis and that oversaw the attack on our provincial economy for the past 10 years
00:11:39 have been returned to power now as we all know one thing has changed we have a new prime minister
00:11:46 and i will say that in my first conversation with him since the election he had some promising
00:11:51 things to say about changing the direction of his government's anti-resource policies
00:11:55 however albertans are more of a actions speak louder than words kind of people so while i will
00:12:01 in good faith work with Prime Minister Mark Carney on unwinding the mountain of destructive
00:12:06 legislation and policies that have ravaged our provincial and national economies this past
00:12:11 decade, until I see tangible proof of real change, Alberta will be taking steps to better protect
00:12:18 ourselves from Ottawa. As a start, I will soon appoint a special negotiating team to represent
00:12:26 our province in negotiations with the federal government on the following reforms requested
00:12:31 by our province we hope this will result in a binding agreement that albertans can have confidence
00:12:36 in call it an alberta accord if you will first alberta requires guaranteed corridor and port
00:12:44 access to tide water off the pacific arctic and atlantic coasts for the international export of
00:12:49 alberta oil gas critical minerals and other resources in amounts supported by the free market
00:12:56 rather than by the dictates and whims of ottawa every province in the country other than alberta
00:13:02 and saskatchewan have coastal port access and no province needs it more given the size and value
00:13:08 of our resources this will benefit all canadians to the tune of trillions of dollars of economic
00:13:13 activity including billions for first nations partners second the federal government must end
00:13:21 all federal interference in the development of provincial resources by repealing the no new
00:13:27 pipelines law c69 the oil tanker ban the net zero electricity regulations the oil and gas emissions
00:13:34 cap the net zero vehicle mandate and any federal law regulation that purports to regulate industrial
00:13:40 carbon emissions plastics or the commercial free speech of energy companies these laws are
00:13:46 destroying investment confidence and costing canada and alberta hundreds of billions in
00:13:52 investments each year they need to go third the federal government must refrain from imposing
00:13:58 export taxes or restrictions on the export of alberta resources without the consent of
00:14:03 the government of alberta frankly all provinces should be given that same respect for their
00:14:08 resources and fourth the federal government must provide to alberta the same per capita federal
00:14:15 transfers and equalization as is received by the other three largest provinces quebec ontario and
00:14:23 british columbia we have no issue with alberta continuing to subsidize smaller provinces with
00:14:28 their needs but there is no excuse for such large and powerful economies like ontario quebec bc or
00:14:35 alberta to be subsidizing one another that was never the intent of equalization and it needs to
00:14:41 end if these points can be agreed to by the federal government i am convinced it will not
00:14:47 only make alberta and canada an infinitely stronger and more prosperous country but will
00:14:53 eliminate the doubts a growing number of albertans feel about the future of alberta in canada while
00:15:00 these negotiations with ottawa are ongoing our government will appoint and i will chair the
00:15:04 alberta next panel this panel will be composed of some of our best and brightest judicial academic
00:15:11 and economic minds to join with me in a series of in-person and online town halls to discuss
00:15:16 Alberta's future in Canada and specifically what next steps we can take as a province to better
00:15:22 protect Alberta from any current or future hostile policies of the federal government.
00:15:28 Details of the membership and scope of that panel will be released in the coming weeks.
00:15:34 After the work of the panel is finished, it is likely we will place some of the more popular
00:15:38 ideas discussed with the panel to a provincial referendum so that all albertans can vote on them
00:15:44 sometime in 2026. to be clear from the outset our government will not be putting a vote on
00:15:52 separation from canada on the referendum ballot however if there is a successful citizen-led
00:15:59 referendum petition that is able to gather the requisite number of signatures requesting such
00:16:04 or question to be put on a referendum our government will respect the democratic process
00:16:10 and include that question on the 2026 provincial referendum ballot as well
00:16:24 i also want to state unequivocally that as premier i'm entirely committed to protecting
00:16:29 upholding and honouring the inherent rights of First Nations, Métis and Inuit peoples.
00:16:36 Therefore, any citizen-initiated referendum question must not violate the constitutional
00:16:41 rights of First Nations, Métis and Inuit peoples and must uphold and honour treaties 6, 7 and 8,
00:16:48 should any referendum question ever pass. This is non-negotiable. Now let's talk about the elephant
00:16:55 in the room that being separation we are well aware that there is a large and growing number
00:17:02 of albertans that have lost hope in alberta having a free and prosperous future as a part of canada
00:17:08 many of these albertans are organizing petitions to trigger a citizen initiated referendum as i
00:17:13 mentioned earlier the vast majority of these individuals are not fringe voices to be marginalized
00:17:20 are vilified they are loyal albertans they are quite literally our friends and neighbors who've
00:17:26 just had enough of having their livelihoods and prosperity attacked by a hostile federal
00:17:32 government they're frustrated and they have every reason to be i want to talk directly to those
00:17:37 albertans i know how frustrated so many of you have become with our country and the feeling of
00:17:43 having politicians living thousands of miles away passing laws and rules that have cost you your
00:17:47 loved ones jobs careers dreams and opportunities for a brighter future as most albertans know i
00:17:55 have repeatedly stated i do not support alberta separating from canada i personally still have
00:18:01 hope that there is a path forward for a strong and sovereign alberta within a united canada
00:18:07 and let me explain a few reasons why first alberta already has and can continue to use the alberta
00:18:13 sovereignty within a united canada act and other measures to fight through much of ottawa's
00:18:19 damaging interference and prosper in spite of it we will also continue our successful
00:18:25 battles against these unconstitutional and damaging policies in both the courts of law
00:18:30 and public opinion and there is more to be hopeful for this past election demonstrated
00:18:35 that attitudes across the country especially among young people are changing with respect
00:18:41 to understanding the importance of free markets and the development of our natural resources.
00:18:46 People are pushing back against government censorship and cancel culture. More and more
00:18:52 Canadians understand that in order for Canada to play a role in ending conflict and poverty
00:18:57 at home and abroad, our country must become strong again. And we can only do that by becoming an
00:19:04 energy and economic superpower using the vast and unmatched energy, mineral resources, and fertile
00:19:10 lands of our country. 85% of Canadians in this last election voted for the two leaders promising
00:19:16 to turn Canada into an energy superpower and to build resource corridors, including for oil and
00:19:23 gas, while only 13% voted for the fringe voices in the socialist NDP and block parties and their
00:19:29 extremists leave-it-in-the-ground policies. Obviously, we have a lot of ways to go and it
00:19:34 will take a lot of work to undo the damage caused by these last 10 years of liberal NDP rule.
00:19:40 But that clear change in public opinion gives me hope.
00:19:44 I think it should give all Albertans hope.
00:19:47 Now, none of us knows what the future holds should Ottawa, for whatever reason, continue to attack our province, as they have done over the last decade.
00:19:56 Ultimately, that will be for Albertans to decide, and I will accept their judgment.
00:20:01 But I am going to do everything within my power to negotiate a fair deal for Alberta with the new Prime Minister.
00:20:07 it. And while doing so, our government will work with Albertans on various initiatives to better
00:20:13 protect Alberta's provincial sovereignty and economy from Ottawa should those negotiations
00:20:18 fail and the economic attacks continue. Alberta didn't start this fight, but rest assured we will
00:20:25 finish it and come out of it stronger and more prosperous than ever. In closing, I want Albertans
00:20:31 know how important it will be in the coming months for our province to be steadfast unified and to
00:20:38 refrain from heeding the voices of those seeking to divide albertans against one another there will
00:20:44 be many outside and even inside this province who will try and sow fear and anger among us
00:20:50 they will seek to divide us into different camps for the purposes of marginalizing and vilifying
00:20:56 one another based on differing opinions effectively pitting neighbor against neighbor
00:21:01 and Albertan against Albertan. This is not the Alberta way. It's not who we are and it's not who
00:21:07 I am. There are thousands of Albertans who are so frustrated with the last 10 years of Ottawa's
00:21:13 attacks on their friends and family's livelihoods that they feel Alberta would be stronger and more
00:21:18 prosperous as an independent nation. That is an understandable and justifiable feeling to have
00:21:24 even if we disagree on what to do about it. These Albertans are not traitors nor should
00:21:29 they ever be treated as such they just love their province and family and want a better future than
00:21:35 the one ottawa is offering them right now there are also thousands of albertans that are so
00:21:40 attached and loyal to their identity as canadians that there is nothing ottawa has done to our
00:21:45 province that would justify alberta leaving canada it's not that they think everything is perfect
00:21:51 or that we've been treated fairly they just believe being part of canada despite those
00:21:55 problems has much more value than leaving these individuals are also loyal albertans and should
00:22:01 never be accused of being anything less and then there are hundreds of thousands of albertans that
00:22:06 probably feel a lot a lot like i do that are deeply frustrated with the way our province
00:22:12 has been mistreated and damaged by successful successive federal liberal governments and are
00:22:18 not willing to tolerate the status quo any longer but these albertans still believe there's a viable
00:22:25 path to a strong free and sovereign alberta empowered to succeed and prosper within a united
00:22:31 canada a canada where the federal government actually honors the constitution upholds
00:22:37 provincial rights and empowers provinces to pursue their unique potentials as their people so choose
00:22:44 regardless of what each of us believes about this issue or what path we think is best we as albertans
00:22:50 must be able to respectfully debate and discuss these issues with our friends family members
00:22:56 and neighbors i know that if we do that in the end our province will find the best solution for
00:23:02 this immense challenge we face and come out of it stronger and more free than ever i'll always put
00:23:09 my faith in albertans to find the right path i trust you may our beautiful alberta always
00:23:15 remain forever strong and free all right uh that was alberta premier daniel smith uh
00:23:37 addressing the people of alberta uh in a very interesting and increasingly turbulent time
00:23:44 Nigel. I mean, she had her four demands, guaranteed resource export corridors to port access on both 0.91
00:23:56 coasts, ending all anti-resource legislation imposed by the Liberal government that is in
00:24:08 power now. And there's a long list of those bills, and we'll go through every single one.
00:24:12 no export taxes without Alberta's consent, and that Alberta, this one's a bit oddly worded,
00:24:20 but that Alberta gets essentially the same equalization treatment as Ontario, BC, and Quebec.
00:24:24 Yeah, that's the new one.
00:24:25 Yeah, you know, it's not getting rid of equalization, but it's essentially saying,
00:24:28 okay, fine, equalization only for the small maritime provinces and Manitoba,
00:24:32 but essentially no more Quebec. If Quebec gets something, we get something.
00:24:35 Well, that first three of those is actually a condensation of the original nine demands that
00:24:39 she presented to Mr. Carnegie, I think, before he was even elected as prime minister.
00:24:46 He had been elected prime minister, but hadn't gone through. He'd been selected by the party,
00:24:50 but not yet elected quite. At any rate, she's already put that to him, and I think just for
00:24:57 rhetorical purposes. She's going to appoint a team of negotiators 1.00
00:25:03 to deal with Ottawa and commission the Alberta Next panel chaired by herself.
00:25:08 that's i mean we'll see how different or not that is from jason kenny's fair deal panel
00:25:12 which was not chaired by himself but uh i think this will be a bit more of an involved process
00:25:16 with the premier well you know i think the difference between those two panels is i i
00:25:21 i mean maybe i'm just just a little too pro danielle but i have a sense that she is more
00:25:26 committed to that panel to do what it set out to do uh rather than just be a staller while you know
00:25:35 hope somehow something turns up so i think she actually does mean to make that work yeah i i
00:25:41 was there when jason kenney announced uh his fair deal panel was a canada strong and free uh regional
00:25:46 alberta conference where he announced it and i had written at that time that this was uh this was a
00:25:50 this was a relief valve because the independence movement was picking up steam then yeah uh quite
00:25:55 a bit maybe not as seriously and as well organized and led as it is right now but i saw it as a
00:26:01 relief valve and that's exactly what it was not very much came from it a few things moving the
00:26:05 right directions but kind of just let off the steam um so maybe we'll talk about those things
00:26:11 before we get to the stuff directly on the independence front which she spent i i'm going to
00:26:17 approximate more than half her address talking about yeah um i don't know uh does she think 0.50
00:26:24 there's actually she she said she's encouraged by her opening her first meeting with mark carney
00:26:29 but she wants actions, not words. I don't know. Is she saying this to be polite, give the guy
00:26:37 a chance, or do you think she honestly thinks he's not going to deliver and she just has to be
00:26:43 diplomatic up front here? Well, I don't think that you, as the Premier of Alberta, can go out
00:26:49 there a week after the election and say, I just don't trust this guy and we're going to go and
00:26:53 do whatever we want to do. He has made some moves, rhetorically speaking, in her direction.
00:27:03 Not that it's a provincial thing particularly, but he has also suggested that he'll move up the
00:27:09 by-election date to accommodate Mr. Poliarev. That will be taken as a conciliatory move by
00:27:17 most of the country. And therefore, if she had come out with guns blazing and say, 0.71
00:27:21 this is it we're a liberal government we're all doomed so we're gonna we're gonna man this build
00:27:26 a stockade and man it that would not have gone over well in alberta or the rest of the country
00:27:32 mr carney has made certain i won't call them promises but suggestions as to how he might
00:27:40 move his position on things that are important to us she's going to give him a chance to do it
00:27:46 i don't know whether she's going to give him six months or a year we're talking about uh events in
00:27:52 2026 and to be fair to mr carney which i personally find very hard but nevertheless
00:27:58 to be fair to mr carney you're in government it's going to take a while to do things the canadian
00:28:04 way you can't be like president trump making executive orders doing this this don't know uh
00:28:09 mark carney created the executive order remember he signed a piece of paper getting rid of the
00:28:13 carbon tax that's uh that's easy just sign into sign into uh uh sign just make a paper commitment
00:28:23 sign a piece of paper saying we're going to build pipelines and watch the court cases stand if so
00:28:28 so now he's going to need time to give some evidence that he is in that he's in working
00:28:33 in good faith if he's not well then things happen people will buy that so she's going to chair this
00:28:40 so-called Alberta Next panel
00:28:42 she says some of the more popular ideas
00:28:44 from it are going to be put in a referendum
00:28:46 by the government in 2026
00:28:48 that seems to be
00:28:50 held, she acknowledged, in likely
00:28:52 conjunction with an independence
00:28:54 referendum. That referendum will not be
00:28:56 called by the Alberta government
00:28:58 it will instead be
00:28:59 in all probability be triggered by
00:29:02 a citizens initiative
00:29:03 referendum
00:29:05 they're amending the legislation to make it
00:29:08 actually possible to use that legislation
00:29:09 They're not going to make it easy, but they're taking it from impossible to difficult.
00:29:15 And I think the momentum is clearly there to achieve that difficult threshold.
00:29:18 Well, and I think it needs to be in that order of not impossible, but difficult, because this is not something that you want to play around with.
00:29:26 No.
00:29:26 I mean, sovereignty, independence, separation, whatever you want to call it, you know, you don't play with that.
00:29:32 That would be like going to sea for no other reason than to make yourself sick.
00:29:36 Well, referendums in general, I don't think we should just have really, really.
00:29:38 You know, there should be a fairly high bar to achieve them.
00:29:40 They just shouldn't be effectively impossible as they are.
00:29:44 And she had some words.
00:29:46 In mark contrast to former Premier Jason Kenney, who's been increasingly vocal on the CBC and on X, Twitter, you know, he's just saying these are traitors.
00:29:58 She said specifically Albertans who want independence are not traitors.
00:30:02 The way they feel and why they want out to be their own independent country is understandable.
00:30:06 they are not fringe voices
00:30:09 she said on the
00:30:11 other hand
00:30:11 some Albertans are so wedded to
00:30:15 Ottawa and their Canadian 1.00
00:30:17 identity that there is nothing
00:30:19 Ottawa could ever potentially do that would move them off
00:30:21 of that and that those people are
00:30:23 also equally Albertan so we're trying
00:30:25 to be a bit of a King Solomon
00:30:27 balancing act here I did
00:30:28 notice though that she said that hundreds of thousands
00:30:30 of Albertans are like me
00:30:32 in the middle who want a sovereign
00:30:34 Alberta within Canada
00:30:35 I took the implication from that is that's where she wants to fight, but the implication was she was not a part of the second group, which is the unconditional Federalists for whom there is absolutely nothing that could ever move them towards independence.
00:30:48 It was very carefully worded, but I think you're drawing the correct conclusion from that. The language is interesting. A sovereign Alberta within a united Canada, that is the old Harper language for Quebec's status within Confederation.
00:31:05 It's not the Quebec language, of course, but I think a lot of people would say, well, you know, the problem that we have is not just the money, it's the values that animate the Liberal Party in particular, and therefore which characterize the law that comes out of Parliament, which is not just anti-Alberta, but it's not even in the spirit of Alberta.
00:31:33 like we think differently to the way they do so let us be us if you want to let quebec be quebec 1.00
00:31:39 fine but let alberta be alberta so therefore a sovereign alberta within a united canada
00:31:45 makes sense reasonable people and she is reasonable reasonable people can hold that view
00:31:51 if you believe it can be achieved uh you know as our editorial put it uh the day after the election
00:31:56 and the west wants out uh you know many of us have come to the point of independence because
00:32:02 we do not believe substandard reform of the federation is possible i would note she can't
00:32:07 say that though even if she thinks it which i don't know that she does but even if she thinks
00:32:11 i really hope she doesn't think that because uh come right out and say well look that's it i'm now
00:32:16 i'm now your independence premium yeah um but i would note in her four demands there were not
00:32:22 there was nothing constitutional in there and a lot of the structural issues uh around fairness
00:32:28 and equality for Alberta and Saskatchewan Confederation are constitutional. We have
00:32:33 a vastly greater population than the Atlantic provinces, yet our vote counts for only 55%
00:32:38 of a single Atlantic vote. In the Senate, it's something like each one of their bodies, I
00:32:43 shouldn't say vote for the Senate, because there is no votes for the Senate, as Ottawa is the least
00:32:47 concerned. But in terms of bodies per senator, it's something like 10 to 1. You know, Alberta's
00:32:52 twice the population of all four Atlantic provinces, and we have just a hair over half the
00:32:57 senators of just New Brunswick or just Nova Scotia, yet where many times the population
00:33:01 of both combined. She didn't make any constitutional demands. I think a lot of people
00:33:06 would recognize that as instantly impossible because then Quebec comes to the table with 0.92
00:33:09 all its litany of issues. But I, honest to God, do not think that there is a resolution to the
00:33:16 Alberta question or the Western question without constitutional reform, and she did not put them
00:33:22 on the table. If she wanted no deal, if she wanted to be able to say, hey, we tried and failed,
00:33:29 she would put constitutional reform on the table. She did not put constitutional reform on the
00:33:34 table. All of these demands are quite achievable with enough political will from the carny liberal
00:33:41 government. Maybe. So far, as you were saying, there's no constitutional demands. If I had been
00:33:49 advising her, I wouldn't have said, come up with a bunch of constitutional demands.
00:33:53 The first one is to get the government of Canada to respect the constitution that we have.
00:33:58 And as she pointed out, when some of their legislation, in particular, the No Pipelines
00:34:06 Act, but also that, okay, you know, it's not a big deal, but the plastic straws,
00:34:11 there's a certain mentality that went with that. Those things have been found to be unconstitutional,
00:34:17 and the government of Canada has not acted on those.
00:34:21 So, you know, let's start with getting action on the things
00:34:26 that we can theoretically do under the Constitution
00:34:29 and then perhaps work on the Constitution in the future.
00:34:33 So this came right out of a caucus meeting of the United Conservative Party.
00:34:39 We've been watching this.
00:34:40 I haven't seen what's come since, but at least one MLA, Jason Steffen,
00:34:44 MLA for Red Deer North, I believe,
00:34:47 uh or so one of the radio writings um you're south okay he uh he's come out and i think
00:34:55 more or less declared himself for independence i would be shocked if there are not others uh many
00:35:00 more behind closed doors but i think politically many are afraid to still speak out uh uh politicians
00:35:08 with longevity are afraid to be the tip of the spear on this kind of thing oh mr stefan just
00:35:12 said that he was in favor of a referendum i'm sure he just is actually vastly against separation and
00:35:18 once the matter cleared all together yeah trying to thread the needle yeah that's jason if you're
00:35:23 watching i mean would you say you're for a vote on it i mean you wouldn't be in favor of a vote
00:35:28 on it unless you were for it uh i appreciate you stepping up uh it's more bold than others but you
00:35:36 you may as well just come out for it and uh and then fight for that you know it's uh populism
00:35:43 needs to be listening to the people but it is also showing leadership trying to show leadership
00:35:47 and bring the people uh to where you believe in your heart they need to go and that's that's the
00:35:54 balance of direct democracy and representative democracy and our representatives should show
00:35:59 some leadership and the people have the right to reject that leadership every four years um
00:36:03 I think a big, there was some political objectives in this. We're going to wrap it up soon. I know you have to part. But, you know, there's always been a constellation of independence or quasi-independence parties to the right flank of the Conservative Party in Alberta.
00:36:21 um they've most of the time not been particularly successful as i know but uh it seems the time for
00:36:28 the movement has come and i think what smith is trying to achieve is now that that movement is
00:36:33 very much mainstreaming and becoming an issue on which conservative voters in alberta don't just
00:36:39 say they support it but might actually potentially change their vote or party based upon it she's
00:36:45 trying to make sure that movement stays within the ucp tent without declaring the ucp to be an
00:36:51 explicitly independence supporting party so as to keep the federalists in the tent and the
00:36:57 people who are perhaps for lack of a better term call them conditional federal people who might go
00:37:02 at some point um i'm not sure how i know the caucus is divided on this issue how sharply it's
00:37:09 divided we're gonna have to the coming days will tell uh how well a job do you think she did 1.00
00:37:13 both i guess there's three parts here in trying to thread the needle on this issue
00:37:19 one with caucus, two with party members, and three with UCP voters as three somewhat distinct
00:37:28 but overlapping blocs.
00:37:30 Well, look, I wouldn't have counseled her to say anything different to what she said.
00:37:35 How well it works is another matter.
00:37:38 But what I took from her remarks was that, first of all, she's saying, look, we've told
00:37:44 the federal government, we've told Mark Carney what Alberta needs and wants.
00:37:49 We'll give them a chance to deliver on that.
00:37:53 Secondly, all the little, the Burke's little platoons,
00:38:03 all the people that you've just been talking about are out there thinking,
00:38:06 well, this is the moment.
00:38:07 Now we've got to get organized, and there are lots of them,
00:38:09 and they are not united and left alone.
00:38:12 They will just collapse, and nothing will happen.
00:38:16 She has told them to just cool their jets.
00:38:19 uh that there is going to be a process it'll take a there will be a panel there will be
00:38:27 discussions with the government we will see how the things go and then there might be a referendum
00:38:34 and if they wait a year for a referendum however long it takes i'm saying there will be a referendum
00:38:41 on the assumption on which i know you share that if the government doesn't do it somebody will
00:38:47 bring it forward and we'll meet they will get the what is it 300 000 signatures that are needed
00:38:52 okay so at that point everybody's had a chance to think the leaders have had a chance to emerge and
00:39:01 what will happen will happen but at least it will won't be a total stromash with everything
00:39:07 with people running in different directions and claiming to be the new leader it could
00:39:12 be extremely damaging you think that carney's policies and trudeau's policies are bad for
00:39:18 investment you know try a bunch of of people making wild statements and promising and taking
00:39:25 up arms oh god it just goes on and on and on not good all right well uh the one certainty i think
00:39:34 we do have right now uh in all of this is albertans are gonna have a vote on independence in
00:39:40 In 2026, it is happening.
00:39:42 I think barring some startling chain of events like Smith being overthrown in an internal party coup or something, the Citizens Initiative legislation is going to be amended from an impossible bar to a high bar.
00:39:58 The independence movement is going to meet that high bar.
00:40:01 And in 2026, Albertans are going to have a referendum.
00:40:04 Smith is in a perilous political position here trying to allow for that within the UCP's tent while not forcing an exodus on the other side of the unconditional Federalists or at least some of the conditional Federalists.
00:40:24 She's got to win on that one because if there is a palace coup that brings her down, one side or the other. 0.99
00:40:34 We'll leave the party.
00:40:35 And then you don't have – then you're back to the NDP.
00:40:39 So she has to win on this one.
00:40:41 Yeah.
00:40:42 It's very sensitive.
00:40:44 We are entering – you know, I thought I lived through the most interesting time in Alberta politics with Smith.
00:40:50 You know, when she had joined the Progressive Conservatives and the Wild Rose was blown up and then reborn and then the NDP came in, I thought I was through the most interesting time.
00:41:00 I think I might end up being wrong about that.
00:41:03 I think this, I think right now we're entering potentially the most interesting time in the history of Alberta and potentially Saskatchewan alongside us as we enter this.
00:41:13 I think you're right.
00:41:14 All right.
00:41:15 Well, we're going to wrap it there.
00:41:17 I'm sure you're all sick of us.
00:41:18 Thank you very much for joining us today.
00:41:19 Remember, go to westernstandard.news, click on subscribe.
00:41:23 Membership of the Western Standard and access past the paywall is only $10 a month or $100 a year.
00:41:29 Thank you very much for joining us today.
00:41:31 God bless the West.