Western Standard - March 09, 2024


Alberta RCMP announce conclusion to high-profile investigation

Topics
Mentioned
AB Transportation infrastructure investments included in Budget 2024 Madonna "Oh, OK Politically incorrect, sorry about that..." #madonna

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 28 minutes

Words per minute

69.43

Word count

6,138

Sentence count

140


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we discuss the United Conservative Party Leadership Contest Winner, Jeff Calloway. In July 2017, the Wildrose Party and the Progressive Conservative Party merged into one party, the Unitedterritorial Conservative Party, and a UCP leadership contest was called. . On October 28, 2017, former PC candidate Jeff Callaway dropped out of the race and publicly endorsed Jason Kenney as the new UCP leader.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 .
00:00:30 .
00:01:00 .
00:01:30 .
00:02:00 .
00:02:30 .
00:03:00 .
00:03:30 .
00:04:00 .
00:04:30 .
00:05:00 .
00:05:30 .
00:06:00 .
00:06:30 .
00:07:00 .
00:07:30 .
00:08:00 .
00:08:30 .
00:09:00 don't just the the link that i sent no longer works you have to go right to our main page
00:09:21 and go under live we we haven't sent out that link at all it's just our main page that's what we sent
00:09:29 out yeah can you hear audio okay yeah just one more time stay on the line Craig he's gonna talk
00:09:59 so weird i'm getting i'm getting full audio
00:10:29 Yeah, well, I don't know why this thing yesterday was working.
00:10:54 You can see on camera, Mike.
00:11:24 I just don't understand why the audio isn't coming through, which did not work too.
00:11:54 .
00:12:24 .
00:12:54 .
00:13:24 .
00:13:54 .
00:14:24 .
00:14:54 .
00:15:24 .
00:15:54 .
00:16:24 .
00:16:54 if this is what happens to me it worked fine yesterday and doesn't work today right yeah
00:17:24 Thank you.
00:17:54 Thank you.
00:18:24 Thank you.
00:18:54 Thank you.
00:19:24 you see the audio yes great right oh yeah there is already yeah but where's
00:19:34 this audio coming from from the front podium I've been patched into the okay
00:19:38 right back there yeah so it's like a YouTube thing like this is your receiver
00:19:48 your transmitters back there
00:20:18 .
00:20:48 .
00:21:18 .
00:21:48 .
00:22:18 .
00:22:48 .
00:23:18 .
00:23:48 .
00:24:18 .
00:24:48 .
00:25:18 .
00:25:48 .
00:26:18 .
00:26:48 .
00:27:18 Thank you.
00:27:48 Thank you.
00:28:18 So I'm trying to all stand here.
00:28:48 Thank you very much.
00:29:18 for five microphone check everybody good
00:29:48 .
00:30:18 .
00:30:48 .
00:31:18 .
00:31:48 .
00:32:18 .
00:32:48 .
00:33:18 .
00:33:48 .
00:34:18 .
00:34:48 .
00:35:18 .
00:35:48 .
00:36:18 .
00:36:48 .
00:37:18 .
00:37:48 .
00:38:18 .
00:38:48 .
00:39:18 .
00:39:48 .
00:40:18 Thank you.
00:40:48 .
00:41:18 .
00:41:48 .
00:42:18 .
00:42:48 .
00:43:18 .
00:43:48 Good morning, everybody. Thank you for your opinion, and thank you for your continued patience. I really appreciate it.
00:44:03 In a moment, I will be asking the student at Virginia to provide a statement.
00:44:07 Immediately, probably, I'll ask Dr. Olson-Anne Cowell to provide information information.
00:44:11 Once he's done, we'll open up the floor for questions, starting on my left.
00:44:15 The work of my way to the right is maybe one question and one follow-up.
00:44:19 We are looking to try to use this to take 10 minutes.
00:44:23 I would ask that if you try just a little bit of concern for time,
00:44:27 just not to keep the same question.
00:44:30 If it is answered, you know, you can ask the follow-up on that same question,
00:44:34 but just to kind of get the information that we will pass on to you.
00:44:40 And finally, I ask them to just keep it very respectful and allow everyone to ask the question.
00:44:45 thank you good morning thank you fraser everyone i really appreciate you coming here today
00:44:52 and taking the time to try uh to listen and understand this what is an important issue
00:44:58 and fairly uh complex and unique because as you know we do not normally speak to
00:45:03 an investigation unless charges have been laid the decision to do that in this rare case is
00:45:09 is because of the importance of this issue
00:45:11 to all Albertans and the amount of coverage
00:45:15 and questions that we do not want people to be left
00:45:18 with a picture that is inaccurate.
00:45:23 In July 2017, that's right, I would just say,
00:45:27 my name is superintendent Rick Genay
00:45:29 and I was a monitoring officer for this investigation.
00:45:32 In July 2017, the Wild Rose Party
00:45:35 and the Progressive Conservative Party merged
00:45:38 formed United Conservative Party a UCP leadership contest followed and on
00:45:46 October 4th 2017 Jeff Calloway dropped out of the race and publicly endorsed
00:45:51 Jason Kenney on October 28th 2017 mr. Kenny was officially elected as the new
00:45:57 UCP leader allegations of wrongdoing surfaced after the leadership contest
00:46:04 in february 2019 a complaint was received by the alberta rcmp in relation to these allegations
00:46:11 which resulted in the rcmp opening an investigation into the two separate allegations
00:46:19 allegation number one was that jeff calloway entered the contest solely to attack another
00:46:25 candidate always with the intention of pulling out of the leadership race and endorsing a different
00:46:30 candidate prior to the vote given the allegation that this candidate had portrayed himself as a
00:46:38 legitimate candidate and as a result was able to solicit money from individuals who believed
00:46:45 him to be a legitimate candidate fraud contrary to section 380 of the criminal code of canada
00:46:51 was identified as an appropriate offense to be investigated
00:46:54 investigators reviewed the candidates campaign debates and political advertisements
00:47:00 and also the campaign's financial records which showed that approximately
00:47:08 $95,000 was received by the campaign in financial contributions
00:47:13 as you likely know Elections Alberta investigated Mr. Calloway's campaign finances
00:47:19 under the Alberta Election Finances and Contribution Disclosures Act the
00:47:25 results of the elections Alberta investigation are posted on their
00:47:29 website Alberta RCMP investigators conducted more than a hundred and seventy
00:47:34 interviews with contributors and campaign staff and examined over 25,000
00:47:41 related emails. Following this thorough investigation we did not uncover
00:47:49 evidence to establish that Calloway or any other person committed a criminal
00:47:55 offense. The second allegation was that voter fraud occurred during the UCP
00:48:02 leadership contest. In order to vote a UCP member needed to register and receive
00:48:09 a personal identification number either by phone or email or text message once
00:48:17 the pin was received that member could then cast a vote either by phone or by
00:48:24 using another electronic device to access the voting platform on the
00:48:30 internet the allegations were that initially where that emails were created
00:48:36 in order to receive pins and vote on people's behalf without their consent or
00:48:44 knowledge identity fraud contrary to section 403 of the criminal code was
00:48:51 identified as the appropriate offense to be investigated under the circumstances
00:48:56 the online platform used by the UCP to hold the leadership contest was it was
00:49:02 identified and the rcmp obtained that database through a legal process it contained data from
00:49:09 more than 60 000 voters the rcmp analyzed the data and identified several suspicious cross sections
00:49:20 of votes where multiple votes were cast using the same phone number or originating from the same
00:49:27 IP or internet protocol address similar to an in-person ballot the data did not
00:49:34 show which candidate was voted for but only that the vote had been cast using
00:49:40 that unique identifier we generated a list of these suspicious votes conducted
00:49:49 interviews of more than 1200 individuals and examined their UCP membership and
00:49:55 registration forms to be clear the number of potential votes at issue which
00:50:04 after investigation were less than 200 would not have impacted the outcome of
00:50:10 the leadership contest given that Jason Kenny one with 61% of the vote the RCMP
00:50:18 did not find evidence that any leadership candidate encouraged their
00:50:21 volunteers or staff to engage in identity fraud the service provider for
00:50:30 the online voting platform used by the UCP was not compromised and it worked as
00:50:36 specified this high-profile investigation was extremely complex and
00:50:43 time-consuming due to several factors the sheer volume of data to be analyzed
00:50:48 and investigated took a significant amount of time furthermore a portion of
00:50:55 this data required that judicial authorizations be obtained both
00:50:59 domestically and outside of Canada that the fact that the complainant was not
00:51:06 sorry the complaint was not received until 2019 impacted many witnesses
00:51:11 recollections of the event. The 2017 UCP leadership contest occurred at the same time as other
00:51:22 internal party votes. As a result, some witnesses were unclear about which process the RCMP was
00:51:30 investigating. Even for cases that appear to be fraud, voter fraud or identity fraud, there can
00:51:38 and explanations for example it was not illegal for one phone number or email to receive many pins
00:51:47 it was also not illegal for many votes to be cast from the same ip address or phone number
00:51:54 in for example in certain families living under the same roof this was common
00:51:58 we also saw the same pattern in office buildings and at voting kiosks where many people voted from
00:52:04 the same ip following our comprehensive investigation into a voter identity fraud
00:52:10 the alberta rcmp determined that there were suspected instances of potential fraud however
00:52:19 there was insufficient evidence to charge any suspect and again there was no evidence
00:52:26 that any leadership candidate orchestrated these relatively rare instances the decision on whether or
00:52:34 lay a charge in alberta rests with the police however throughout this investigation
00:52:41 as is normal for a significant investigation the police did seek advice from the crown which began
00:52:46 in alberta but was later referred to the ontario minister of the attorney general who assigned
00:52:52 crown prosecutors all of these crown prosecutors provided valuable and timely advice throughout the
00:52:59 the investigation and their assistance was greatly appreciated it should be
00:53:06 noted that these allegations of possible voter fraud occurred during an internal
00:53:12 political party voting process and in no way represent any possible fraud or
00:53:18 shortcomings in our general provincial or federal elections nothing in the
00:53:23 investigation suggested that the UCP failed to take reasonable steps to
00:53:28 manage their internal process. We hope that the information shared today will further reduce the
00:53:33 risk of similar incidents occurring in the future for any political party. The investigators received
00:53:41 cooperation from the UCP and the leadership candidates, which assisted in moving the
00:53:46 investigation forward. I would like to highlight that in investigating allegations of criminality,
00:53:53 The thoroughness and completeness of the investigation is the standard that needs to be assessed.
00:53:59 And the lack of criminal charges should not be the test of a successful investigation.
00:54:06 In this case, experienced criminal investigators fully tested these allegations.
00:54:12 In the end, Albertans can be confident that a thorough investigation, independent of government, was conducted.
00:54:19 I would now like to ask Corporal Matthew Howell to provide this statement in French.
00:54:49 Howell, et je traduis présentement les dires du surintendant Rick Jeanne, qui était officier
00:54:53 responsable du suivi de l'enquête. En juillet 2017, le Wild Rose Party et le Progressive
00:54:59 Conservative Party se sont unis pour créer le United Conservative Party. Un concours
00:55:04 à la chefferie a suivi. Le 4 octobre 2017, Jeff Calloway a abandonné la course et a
00:55:08 publiquement endossé Jason Kenney. Le 28 octobre 2017, Kenney a officiellement été
00:55:13 élu comme le nouveau chef du UCP. Les allégations de méfait ont fait surface après le concours
00:55:19 la chefferie. En february 2019, une plainte a été reçue par la GRC de l'Alberta en relation
00:55:24 avec ses allégations, ce qui a résulté en l'ouverture d'une enquête sur deux allégations
00:55:28 distinctes par la GRC. Une des allégations revendiquait que Jeff Calloway est entré
00:55:34 dans le concours simplement pour attaquer un autre candidat, ayant toujours eu l'intention
00:55:38 d'abandonner la course à la chefferie et endosser un autre candidat. Considérant l'allégation
00:55:42 que ce candidat se dépeignait comme étant un candidat légitime et, résultant de cela,
00:55:47 a eu l'occasion de solliciter des fonds d'individus qui croient qu'il était un candidat légitime
00:55:52 et il a été déterminé que l'offense appropriée à enquêter était une fraude selon la section
00:55:57 380 du Code criminel. Les enquêteurs ont passé en revue les débats et les publicités
00:56:03 politiques de la campagne de ce candidat. Une revue des dossiers financiers de la campagne
00:56:07 a révélé que celle-ci a réussi à générer environ 95 000 en contributions financières.
00:56:13 Elections Alberta a enquêté les finances de la campagne de Callaway
00:56:17 sous l'Alberta Election Finances and Contributions Disclosure Act.
00:56:21 Les résultats de l'enquête d'Elections Alberta ont été mis sur leur site Internet.
00:56:26 Les enquêteurs de la GRC de l'Alberta ont effectué plus de 170 entrevues
00:56:30 avec les contributeurs et le personnel de la campagne
00:56:33 et ont examiné plus de 25 000 courriels reliés à celle-ci.
00:56:37 L'enquête n'a pas découvert de preuves établissant que Callaway
00:56:40 or any other person who has committed a criminal act.
00:56:44 The second allegation was revealed to a fraud electoral
00:56:47 during the concours of the UCP.
00:56:53 To have the right to vote, a member of UCP
00:56:55 should receive a number of personal personal NIP,
00:56:59 or by phone phone, courier or text message.
00:57:02 Once the NIP received, the member could vote by phone
00:57:06 or by phone or using a exclusive vote on Internet.
00:57:10 Les allégations soulignent la création de courriels pour recevoir des NIP et voter au nom d'une autre personne sans leur connaissance ou consentement.
00:57:19 Fraude à l'identité, section 403 du Code criminel, a été identifiée comme étant l'offense appropriée à enquêter.
00:57:27 La plateforme en ligne utilisée par l'UCP pour tenir le concours à la chefferie a été identifiée par la GRC,
00:57:33 who obtained the data from the legal process, which contained the information of more than 60.000 voters.
00:57:41 The GRC analyzed the data and identified a section of voters where several votes were submitted by the same telephone number or from the same IP.
00:57:53 Just like a vote in person, the data did not show for the candidate the person voted,
00:57:59 but that a vote was submitted by using a unique number.
00:58:04 The GRC generated a list containing these votes suspects and has made interviews with more
00:58:09 of 1 200 individuals and has examined their adhésions and their formulaires of the UCPA.
00:58:15 It is important to note that the number of votes potentially problematic, which after
00:58:19 enquête était moins de 200, n'aurait eu aucun impact sur le concours à la chefferie
00:58:23 considérant que Jason Kenney a gagné avec 61 % des votes.
00:58:27 L'enquête de la GRC n'a pas trouvé de preuve qu'un candidat à la chefferie ou un
00:58:31 autre membre de la campagne ait encouragé des personnes à s'engager dans la fraude
00:58:34 à l'identité. Le fournisseur de la plateforme en ligne utilisée par UCP n'a pas été
00:58:40 compromis et a fonctionné tel que spécifié.
00:58:42 Cette enquête de grande envergure a été extrêmement complexe en raison de certains facteurs.
00:58:52 Le grand volume de données analysées et enquêtées a pris un temps considérable.
00:58:58 De plus, une portion de ces données nécessitait l'obtention d'autorisations judiciaires domestiques et internationales.
00:59:04 Le fait que la plainte n'a pas été reçue avant 2019 a impacté la mémoire de l'événement chez plusieurs témoins.
00:59:11 Le concours à la chefferie du UCP de 2017 a pris place en même temps que d'autres votes internes du parti.
00:59:17 Résultant de cela, certains témoins n'étaient pas certains du processus particulier enquêté par la GRC.
00:59:23 Même pour les cas qui semblent relever de la fraude électorale, il pourrait y avoir des explications innocentes.
00:59:29 Par exemple, il n'était pas illégal qu'un numéro de téléphone ou courriel reçoive plusieurs NIP.
00:59:35 It was not illegal to use the same IP address or the same phone number to vote.
00:59:43 For some families living on the same table, this practice was current.
00:59:49 We also observed the same phenomenon in the immeubles of bureaus or in the kiosks of vote where several people voted from the same IP address.
00:59:59 Suite à l'enquête approfondie sur la fraude d'identité électorale, la GRC de l'Alberta a déterminé qu'il y a eu des cas suspectés de fraude à l'identité potentielle.
01:00:08 Toutefois, il n'y a pas suffisamment de preuves pour inculper un suspect.
01:00:12 De plus, il n'y avait aucune preuve que le candidat de la chefferie ait orchestré ces instances relativement rares.
01:00:19 La décision de porter des accusations en Alberta reste avec la police.
01:00:23 Toutefois, tout au long de l'enquête, la GRC a demandé conseil de la Couronne, d'abord en Alberta,
01:00:29 puis, après y être référé, au ministère du Procureur général de l'Ontario, qui a assigné des procureurs de la Couronne.
01:00:38 Ces procureurs de la Couronne ont fourni des conseils utiles et rapides tout au long de l'enquête et leur assistance a été grandement appréciée.
01:00:45 Il est important de noter que ces allégations de possible fraude électorale se sont produites au cours d'un processus de vote interne du Parti politique
01:00:53 et ne représente d'aucune manière une possible fraude ou lacune dans nos élections générales, provinciales ou fédérales.
01:01:00 Aucun élément de l'enquête ne suggère que l'UCP n'a pas pris les mesures raisonnables pour gérer son processus interne.
01:01:07 Nous espérons que les informations partagées aujourd'hui permettront à d'autres partis politiques de réduire davantage le risque d'incidence similaire à l'avenir.
01:01:16 Les enquêteurs ont bénéficié de la coopération du UCP et des candidats à la chefferie,
01:01:20 ce qui a permis de faire avancer l'enquête.
01:01:24 Nous aimerons souligner que, dans le cadre d'une enquête d'allégation criminelle,
01:01:28 la rigueur et l'exhaustivité de l'enquête sont des critères qui doivent être évalués
01:01:32 et que l'absence de poursuites pénales ne doit pas être à la mort d'une enquête non réussite,
01:01:38 a dit le soeur étonnant Rick Jeannet.
01:01:40 Dans ce cas, les enquêteurs criminels d'expérience ont vérifié ces allégations.
01:01:45 Au final, les Albertains peuvent être sûrs qu'une enquête exhaustive,
01:01:49 it doesn't the elections alberta investigation was independent of the rcp's investigation
01:02:16 where appropriate we cooperated as the law allows but we were not involved in that investigation
01:02:36 um i'm not overly concerned honestly i think that the fact that we've been able to investigate it
01:02:39 we'll be able to talk to any party that asks us about uh these processes you can never
01:02:44 have a zero percent risk and this was not not something that affected the
01:02:51 outcome and so one of the things that I think this investigation reveals is it
01:02:55 is would be challenging for any one individual to orchestrate a very broad
01:02:58 fraud at least them how this invest the offense mechanisms here would have made
01:03:04 that very difficult to to affect the outcome
01:03:14 if i understood your question correctly and it'll be translated uh in response the question was uh
01:03:37 in relation to the 200 potentially suspicious uh votes um why were no charges laid and
01:03:45 because of the fact that no charge is being laid we're limited as how we how much we can discuss
01:03:50 the actual facts in any one of those cases of fraud but i can say generally um it is because
01:03:55 there was insufficient evidence to support um a criminal charge in our opinion so we weren't able
01:04:02 the lay charge. So the votes where, you know, largely many of these votes that are, we're
01:04:19 talking about the 200, it's where we had clear evidence from the person whose identity was
01:04:24 associated to that vote, had no knowledge or did not permit anyone to vote on their
01:04:30 behalf so in those cases obviously we tried to identify either and it was
01:04:35 there was multiple different mechanisms sometimes it was an email address the
01:04:40 pin was delivered sometimes it was through a phone system and then also how
01:04:44 the email how the vote was cast it could be cast through a telephone it could also
01:04:49 be cast by logging into a website in we do not have evidence to suggest that we
01:04:57 evidence suggests that there is potential fraud in the case of those votes but those are it's
01:05:02 important to clarify that those matters have not been tested in court and there was insufficient
01:05:06 evidence to lay a charge and our biggest obstacle was being able to satisfy ourselves that we would
01:05:12 have sufficient evidence around the identity of the persons responsible to prove that and when
01:05:17 you think about how voting works and it's you need a witness often to an offense and if you
01:05:23 don't have a witness you need to tie the device that was connected to the offense if it's even
01:05:27 knowable, because there's ways sometimes it's not knowable, but if it's knowable to that suspect in a clear manner, and we didn't have that evidence at the end of it.
01:05:40 La réponse a été très longue, donc j'ai pas cette mémoire corporative assez grande.
01:05:45 Toutefois, pour répondre à la première section de la question, au niveau de pourquoi il n'y a pas eu de charges qui ont été portées dans ce cas-ci,
01:05:52 En fait, c'est une fois qu'on regarde la totalité de toutes les preuves qui viennent vers nous,
01:05:56 on a réalisé qu'il n'y avait pas assez de preuves, dans le fond, pour aller vers des charges criminelles en cours.
01:06:05 Il faut se rappeler qu'une fois que quelque chose va dans la cour, on doit essayer de prouver ça hors de tout doute raisonnable.
01:06:11 Et si on ne pense pas que la preuve accumulée va mener, dans le fond, à cet aspect de tout doute raisonnable,
01:06:20 We will not be able to put charges to the court for not to put charges without having a conviction of that.
01:06:29 And more than anything that was specified later, we have not been able to identify with certitude
01:06:36 the people who were, in the fond, coupable, or not coupable, pardon me, suspecting of having done these crimes.
01:06:44 Yes, and just to clarify one thing that my colleague said, I do understand French,
01:07:04 you're just not very great at speaking it. He's correct that that's the charge, the standard is
01:07:09 the only reason to let once in court. The standard to lay a charge is reasonable grounds and for
01:07:13 police practically speaking we also need to know that it's it's viable uh we we definitely
01:07:17 investigated this and that's why it took the time that it took to the fullest extent that was
01:07:21 reasonably possible and we did not have sufficient evidence to to to in our opinion lay a charge
01:07:28 now in terms of your question about um and i'll actually ask you to just repeat the part of that
01:07:34 question because i i wanted to clarify that as well so you said there was some evidence
01:07:38 so because we're not going to we're not not permitted to based on you know privacy privacy
01:07:52 legislation to get into the nuanced details of any invest any aspect that where there was a
01:07:59 suspected fraudulent vote it's difficult to answer that question very you know fulsomely
01:08:05 but i will say that you know and nor would it be exactly the same in each case because as i said
01:08:09 the mechanisms that we investigated weren't all identical it wasn't it appeared there was
01:08:14 different mechanisms although they all involved utilizing a pin to cast a vote and
01:08:19 but i do believe that the most common challenge as is always the case well it depends on the type
01:08:25 of offense but in this type of offense the most challenging thing is to identify who is the person
01:08:30 responsible uh for for casting the vote because that is the identity fraud is that is the actual
01:08:36 casting of that vote my crystal ball is always cloudy honestly the uh we fully investigated this
01:08:48 we did not kind of uh we did not end this investigation until we were satisfied that
01:08:53 there was no other avenues that were viable to pursue i think it's unlikely but if new
01:09:00 and for evidence arises we will consider it and if there is a viable investigation we will pursue it
01:09:23 not in terms of individuals who've experienced this um we we were we were we received really
01:09:41 good cooperation from voters that we had approached and we understand that that creates concerns for
01:09:47 them and probably in some ways may even create different and more important and equal concerns
01:09:52 for other Albertans who don't understand the mechanism so what I would say to you is that
01:09:56 this wasn't a widespread situation there was no hacking like technological hacking there was no
01:10:01 use of foreign interference this was a situation where it appears that it is possible that in some
01:10:07 cases somebody obtained personal information that allowed them to register and receive a pin to vote
01:10:15 and then cast that vote and those those cases if they could be proven in court would still be a
01:10:22 very small, small percentage of the overall vote.
01:10:25 Hopefully that answers your question.
01:10:37 The reason we chose to be clear about that is that the,
01:10:42 we could not provide an update without referencing two individuals because just
01:10:47 the nature of the way the allegations came in and I would be unfair and
01:10:51 improper to leave the public of a false impression that we found evidence or we
01:10:55 just we did not find evidence that they uh
01:10:58 participated counsel or was there any way in
01:11:01 organizing voter identity fraud um nor do we find anyone at their right
01:11:06 in their inner circle was uh involved in that
01:11:10 um in terms of possible suspects again given these aren't crimes that are proven
01:11:14 i can't speak to you know what their relationship was
01:11:18 and i will comment that the votes as i said
01:11:21 we can't even be sure who those suspicious cases even cast a ballot for you know because it's not
01:11:28 knowable yes thank you for asking the question the the RCMP and any police service you know
01:11:55 is founded on a principle of separation from the police services function from the government that
01:12:00 that we serve and the people we serve so those principles are always embedded in any investigation
01:12:06 we did not have any reason to believe there would be interference and we were I'm very happy to say
01:12:12 that there was none no pressure from inside the organization or outside the organization
01:12:15 from any level of government we were allowed to properly carry out this investigation
01:12:19 based on the investigators decision making and the tasks that were identified it was never we
01:12:25 need to wrap this up, we need to end this. We did it until we felt that we could not
01:12:30 reasonably gather any further evidence that would be material to our inquiry.
01:12:35 so criminal wrongdoing has to be proven in court we had and of course the RCMP we do
01:12:59 you know we investigate matters uh based on an allegation or discovery of information that
01:13:06 suggests that an offense may have occurred in terms of identity fraud there there was some
01:13:12 evidence that as as has been reported in the media and as we were told by witnesses that they did not
01:13:17 vote or consent to have any else vote on their behalf that unless there's another explanation
01:13:22 that we're unaware of could would would certainly give reasonable grounds to believe that the
01:13:28 offence may have been committed.
01:13:30 The challenge is we do not have anyone charged.
01:13:34 And so speaking about how we come to those beliefs
01:13:37 would be inappropriate.
01:13:38 And I also don't wanna leave the public
01:13:40 with a misimpression that this is a small subset
01:13:43 of the total number of suspicious votes.
01:13:44 There were innocent explanations for some.
01:13:48 And the actual process, I think fortunately
01:13:53 was not impacted by that,
01:13:55 if those offences did actually occur.
01:13:58 if you yeah hacking i use hacking in the terms of computer assisted
01:14:11 internet database no hacking and these are real people's identities that were utilized
01:14:16 that we we investigated
01:14:17 because because there were um some people that had you know evidence potential evidence as a
01:14:30 witness or as a person under investigation in both investigations they did have to be run current
01:14:36 concurrently as i mentioned earlier during the technical brief certainly the callaway investigation
01:14:41 requiring 170 interviews to be thorough and complete would have taken less time had there
01:14:46 been not intersections between uh investigative steps not just interviews but paying court
01:14:52 documents etc so but i don't have a specific comment because it was not over until we were
01:14:57 done everything we didn't we didn't find evidence of a uh like a coordinated effort that's involving
01:15:14 the entire leadership campaign i'm not going to be able to comment on whether or not any of the
01:15:19 individuals taking advantage um may have known each other i mean the alberta politics is not
01:15:24 that broad it would be a statement that i couldn't be sure of but we didn't find evidence of a of a
01:15:30 like a it's the public when the public thinks of a conspiracy you would think of it as like
01:15:35 organized you know that is that would be a misunderstanding of the evidence that we found
01:15:39 um that's all i can say uh in that regard
01:15:44 again we don't we can't discuss what evidence we found if uh of coordination if any because those
01:16:00 matters are not resulting in charges they don't involve any individuals that we've spoken about
01:16:04 here today and it would be improper for me to start to answer detailed questions that would
01:16:09 really require me to the answer would be different potentially for every single
01:16:14 possible suspect and there's not not to suggest that there's a large group of
01:16:17 suspects we 200 votes we're just not saying it's 200 and not to say in every
01:16:23 single case could we be sure and that's one of the reasons we couldn't lay a
01:16:26 charge we don't don't know who's responsible but based on various
01:16:30 factors we we do not believe that this was one person or persons acting in
01:16:35 concert yeah so you know I certainly have no judgment of members of public having opinions
01:17:02 about our service our duty is to serve the public and gather evidence according to the law the reason
01:17:07 i said that the statement that i was quoted as saying in the formal release as well is because
01:17:12 if the if the standard that we are going to be evaluated or that that we evaluate ourselves by
01:17:17 is whether we later charge or not there is risk of police having tunnel vision focusing in trying
01:17:23 to charge people at all costs that our job is equally to clear people as it is to charge of
01:17:28 course that process uh is um like our job is to remain remain open-minded of this throughout the
01:17:35 whole process what i can say is that the investigators and i'm not directly an investigator
01:17:39 i was you know the monitoring officer they are some of the most experienced investigators that
01:17:44 i've ever worked with my career they always put this investigation at a high priority i never had
01:17:50 problems uh getting uh resources and uh time and funding to do this because we all recognized
01:17:58 that no matter how many votes were involved this strikes at the principles
01:18:03 of a fair democratic process and that is not like that needs to be understood by
01:18:10 the public and we also want to make sure we don't end up you know inappropriately
01:18:13 casting blame on on victims like we would in any offense this was not
01:18:17 something that we saw as a result of some clearly foreseeable issue
01:18:28 I never briefed any political official no we met with the crown prosecutors for
01:18:44 legal advice and unless we were meeting with somebody to take a statement from
01:18:48 them as a witness or a suspect that is the only time we meet with people we
01:18:52 they had no contact that was about the investigation.
01:19:22 yeah so the best thing i would advise anyone who's interested in that question is to look at the
01:19:29 criminal code look at section 380 and you know of course you're not lawyers i'm not a lawyer so
01:19:35 getting advice from someone who's an expert in that area can have an opinion what i can say to
01:19:38 you is that for us to lay a charge we need to believe that there are reasonable grounds for
01:19:42 all the elements of that offense it is not unlike a fraud involving selling a vehicle that you don't
01:19:47 own or a house you don't own you have to prove which requires intent as well
01:19:51 knowledge and intent we found no evidence in our inner conversations and
01:19:57 interviews and we had cooperation from the candidates that there was not a
01:20:00 willingness to take on the leadership role if mr. Callaway had won the
01:20:03 election a contest leadership contest and that's that is was is very very
01:20:08 relevant to whether or not this would have been a fraud under the criminal
01:20:12 code. Not to my knowledge.
01:20:42 so I don't believe it is I mean because it's not just what the criminal code
01:20:57 allows we have numerous provisions under the criminal code to allow us to gather
01:21:01 evidence lawfully I fully respect the constitutional requirements around
01:21:06 search around interviewing processes but I didn't feel that way so
01:21:36 I think that the the investigation was necessary the amount of money that was
01:21:42 necessary I I definitely do not have any concerns like that obviously can't
01:21:50 speak for a taxpayer but this clearly was an important investigation we took
01:21:54 it seriously from day one there were even investigators that were promoted and
01:21:58 could have left the unit could left the investigation they all remained all the
01:22:01 key investigators remained engaged because we recognize the importance of
01:22:04 having this done in as timely manner as possible and as thoroughly as possible
01:22:08 numbers like that are can seem shocking when they're taken out of context
01:22:13 involved in numerous criminal investigations complex investigations
01:22:16 it costs money to investigate things thoroughly and this is not not an
01:22:22 outlier so based on that now of course a tax
01:22:25 who doesn't have that context may have any opinion they want and can we do that
01:22:40 at the end maybe because I think like while you're not gonna remember to
01:22:43 either yeah so why don't we have uh matt i i can understand everything he's saying so if he says
01:23:09 anything that needs to be corrected, I'll correct it in English, but…
01:23:39 La confiance des Albertains en un processus démocratique, c'était important dès le début de vraiment prendre tous les aspects possibles de cette enquête, de prendre tous les avenues possibles pour enquêter et de mener vraiment cette enquête au bout.
01:23:53 Donc, l'importance, en fait, peu importe l'enquête qu'on parle, que ce soit ceci ou une autre, c'est vraiment de prendre tous les éléments de preuve et de faire un canevas complet de ce qui s'est passé.
01:24:07 And that's what we've done in this inquiry. We've done all the elements surrounding the inquiry, and we've really managed to make the final image.
01:24:16 And it's with this that we can say that we're confident in our results, we're confident in what the investigators have achieved in this inquiry.
01:24:25 And we hope that the Albertans have also confidence in this process and in the efforts that have been made in this inquiry.
01:24:33 Yep, that's correct.
01:25:03 I can't really because I don't first of all I don't have what exactly was told
01:25:10 the journalist what I what I can just say is restate what I said which is we
01:25:14 would need clear evidence or sufficient evidence to allow us to know that there
01:25:18 was no intention for a person to take off take the role of the leader should
01:25:24 they win that should they win the contest that it was that there was no
01:25:28 hope no no possibility of that being um something they would be willing to do
01:25:47 just know that they they did nothing wrong um identity fraud occurs in our society often not
01:25:52 often in this context but but in other contexts your private information relating especially your
01:25:57 date of birth phone number your full name you know have value protect them as best you can but
01:26:03 but what person who experiences identity fraud has not done anything wrong they shouldn't feel guilt
01:26:07 or shame i don't know i honestly i as a police officer i investigate i don't really worry about
01:26:17 the i try to focus on getting the facts and whether or not there's a reason for a charge i
01:26:22 I do not turn my mind to the criminal sanctions for that.
01:26:26 It probably is a range that's in the criminal code,
01:26:29 but even that is often a very broad range.
01:26:31 You'd have to look at actual sentences
01:26:32 to give you an idea of what could have occurred.
01:26:35 I will say on individual counts,
01:26:37 you're not looking at lifetime in jail or anything like that.
01:26:40 Thanks.
01:26:41 This is our last question.
01:26:43 I'm sorry, this is my last question.
01:26:44 Sorry, did you ask the numbers question?
01:26:46 Didn't give us a clear breakdown of what the salaries were
01:26:49 for every investigation involved,
01:26:50 But, I mean, looking at publicly available information, is it fair to say this investigation is possible?
01:26:57 Well, honestly, I would want to do some math on that because, again,
01:27:01 while the five core investigators spent a significant amount of times over those five years,
01:27:06 there were natural bottlenecks that occur in these types of investigations awaiting judicial authorization,
01:27:10 especially multilateral legal assistance treaties.
01:27:13 And during those times, those investigators were actually working and contributing to investigations in other areas.
01:27:19 and so it's not as simple as taking five multiplying and I'll just yeah so that's
01:27:24 that is a challenge with that it would be a guess a complete guess thank you
01:27:49 Canadian Shooting Sports Association, without the CSSA, our gun rights would have been taken long, long ago.
01:28:08 These guys are on the front lines, helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms regulations and legislation in Canada.
01:28:15 and more importantly educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong
01:28:20 people to become a member. It's absolutely worth every penny.