Western Standard - October 07, 2025


Alberta teachers get nothing from union during strike

Topics
Mentioned
CORY MORGAN: Alberta Teachers’ Strike Looms Time to SMASH the Alberta teachers’ strike

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

144.61

Word count

3,320

Sentence count

253

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of the Western Standard, host Leah Musha Chaudhuri is joined by John Hilton O'Brien, the Executive Director of Parents for Choice, an advocacy organization dedicated to informing parents on Alberta's education system.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hello, my name is Leah Musha, a reporter here at the Western Standard, and today I have with me
00:00:09 John Hilton O'Brien, the Executive Director of Parents for Choice, an Alberta-based advocacy
00:00:15 organization dedicated to informing parents on Alberta's education system. So today, obviously,
00:00:23 the big issue is the teacher strike, which just began yesterday, October 6th. So yeah, that's
00:00:31 mostly what we're going to be talking about. He's obviously an expert on the subject, so we're just
00:00:35 going to get straight into the topic. So thank you very much for joining us, John, today. Thank you,
00:00:41 Leah. Yeah, very nice for you to be here. So the first question I have for you is very general.
00:00:47 Is this strike about pay, or is this about something else? The strike is about a lot of
00:00:54 things, but you know, it's all about the numbers, really. The Alberta government's budget is just
00:01:01 short of $80 billion. It's running a deficit of $6.5 billion, and that's a bit of a problem. Now,
00:01:10 education is roughly a $10 billion spend. That's our annual budget for it, 9.6, I think, plus capital
00:01:19 spending of $2.6 billion. Now, what's going on with the teachers? Well, the latest offer from the
00:01:26 government is 12% of new salary over four years. They're talking about hiring 3,000 new teachers,
00:01:35 which I presume is over and above the amount that our population will increase, and 1,500 new EAs.
00:01:43 Our population has risen by 17% over the last six years, so it's short spending, relatively speaking,
00:01:52 to our population growth. But there's not much we can do about that. What we can do is build a lot of
00:02:01 new classrooms, and to that end, the government has proposed massive new spending, $8.6 billion of new
00:02:09 capital spending so that we can get the schools in place for our public schools to have enough space
00:02:15 to hire still more teachers to keep our classroom sizes reasonable. Now, that's going to cost us
00:02:23 $2.6 billion. That's the offer to the teachers, is $2.6 billion, plus the $8.6 billion.
00:02:34 Well, that's going to add $11.2 billion to our deficit of $6.5 billion. So you can understand that
00:02:41 the government is offering what they're offering, and they're fairly unlikely to budge farther than that.
00:02:47 And there's reason. The numbers tell the whole story here.
00:02:52 Okay. Well, on that note, I guess, yesterday, Jason Schilling spoke at a press conference,
00:03:01 and he was talking about how, basically, I think summarized that teachers don't feel like they're
00:03:06 being supported, even with the deal that they rejected. So I guess you were talking mostly about
00:03:12 the financial stuff, but what are they thinking when they're saying they're not supported?
00:03:16 Well, teachers are very worried about difficulties in classrooms, right? I had one teacher talking
00:03:24 about the fact that he has an autistic kid in his class, moderate to severe. And what he said was,
00:03:32 this student spends his entire time playing in the sink and screaming. That is all he does.
00:03:40 And, you know, I've spent some time working with people with developmental disabilities. It's really
00:03:46 what qualified me to work with politicians. And I'd have to say professionally, I think that that
00:03:52 gentleman is talking about a student who's beyond his classroom's ability to care. And perhaps we should
00:03:59 exercise a little more caution about our mainstreaming policies and make sure that we have the support needed for
00:04:05 children like that. They perhaps shouldn't be in a mainstream classroom. So there's two sides of this
00:04:12 sort. Yes, we do need more EAs, but also we need to take more care with what students are in what classrooms.
00:04:21 Discipline is also a problem. A child who strikes a teacher is right back in the classroom, the same
00:04:28 classroom three days later. And so teachers aren't being supported in that way. Now, part of the problem
00:04:35 with EAs is also that the Jordan Principal funding from the federal government ended. And that cut several
00:04:43 hundred EA positions out of the province. And many school boards had been accustomed to the funding.
00:04:51 Jordan's principle is funding that attaches to First Nations children who are in classrooms. And many
00:05:00 school boards were using it to hire educational assistance for the classroom. And they may have
00:05:06 been relying on it a little more than they should have. So the cancellation of that program for public
00:05:12 schools caught them off guard. But seriously, we had as many EAs under Jordan's principle as we were
00:05:21 hiring new EAs every year. So it's something like three or 4% of the total number of EAs were cut by the
00:05:29 federal government in a heartbeat this spring. So that's created a lot of extra trouble. These aren't
00:05:36 things that the provincial government didn't deal with very much. All they can do is increase the funding
00:05:43 we have for EAs. They've added 1,500. Well, that almost keeps pace with growth. But we're growing so
00:05:51 fast because of our immigration policies nationally that it's a problem. But there's another place where
00:05:58 teachers might not feel supported. And they're feeling it today very much. You see, the Alberta Teachers
00:06:08 Association does not have a strike fund. The strike pay they're getting, and again, I'm coming back to
00:06:15 the numbers, strike pay is zero. And this is shocking. Why is it happening that way? Well, the special
00:06:24 emergency fund that the ATA would normally be taking strike funds out of is only 19 million dollars. Now,
00:06:33 again, by the numbers, if this was the Canadian Auto Workers Union, their strike fund for this size of
00:06:40 budget would be 160 million dollars. So we're looking at a strike fund that's roughly 10 percent of the
00:06:47 size that a well-functioning union would maintain. Well, why is it so low? Well, part of the reason
00:06:56 is that in 2022, the Alberta Teachers Association safened 16 million dollars out of that fund to create
00:07:06 what they called the Defense Advocacy Fund, which is basically a political slush fund. They plan to use
00:07:12 it for intervention and politics. They plan to use it for lawsuits, whatever they can do. And that's why 0.63
00:07:22 there's only 19 million dollars in what should be the strike fund. And the ATA has advised teachers
00:07:30 that they're not going to use their strike fund, their special emergency fund for strike pay. Instead,
00:07:37 they're spending it on advertising. I'm seeing lawn signs. And of course, ATA's favored candidates can put
00:07:45 those lawn signs right beside their own lawn signs. So I think we can see how that works.
00:07:52 Wow. Wait, so advertising, ATA advertising for lawn signs and stuff. So are you talking about the
00:07:57 candidates that they're endorsing? Or are you talking about lawn signs for the ATA, like the strike?
00:08:02 It's for the strikes. Things like Stand With Education and so on, StopTheExcuses.ca. They have
00:08:08 websites. They have a website for candidates. And it's not entirely clear whether they're endorsing
00:08:17 candidates, but they do have a website for candidates that candidates can put their information on,
00:08:23 which is tantamount to an endorsement. And they also produced a very, very professional campaign
00:08:35 strategy book. It's weighty. It would do the UCP or NDP parties very proud. And it carefully explains
00:08:45 to ATA locals how they should get involved in politics. And there's some, there's some arguments
00:08:53 about the legality of that. But the truth is that in 2021, the ATA spent $1.1 million as a third party
00:09:02 advertiser. Not directly, admittedly. Also in Calgary, Calgary's future was funded by the Canadian
00:09:12 union of provincial, or sorry, of public employees. And those guys spent close to $2 million. They
00:09:19 endorsed every seat on council and the entire public school board and six out of seven of their
00:09:25 candidates won. So the unions won and control the Calgary public school board. There's no denying that
00:09:34 really. Edmonton Labour Council did a similar thing with Edmonton, but we don't see the money there so
00:09:41 much. They got five out of the eight candidates they put up, which was enough to control Edmonton public.
00:09:48 Between those two boards, that's two and a half mil, sorry, two and a half billion dollars in funding
00:09:54 they control. So the prize is really worth the pursuit for them. Now this year, the government
00:10:01 has attempted to tamp down spending on third party advertising. They say you can only spend, put $5,000
00:10:10 into it by any organization or person. And the total spend for the province is only around 50 cents per
00:10:18 person. So they can only spend about two and a half million dollars this year, maybe 3 million if you
00:10:25 count pre-writ spending. But there's a little caveat about the donation. You see, as long as they made the
00:10:32 donation before the first Monday of May, then they could have put any amount they wanted into a third
00:10:41 party advertising fund. Okay. And we know that the ATA has that money put aside and we know that the strike fund
00:10:50 isn't being used for strike pay. Oh. So it does seem possible that the ATA may have put some money into a third
00:10:59 party advertiser. We won't know until this election is over, possibly not for months. So that would explain the sheer
00:11:08 intensity of their advertising right now. Wow. Okay. As well as the professional materials they prepared.
00:11:15 Hmm. Like, so you're talking about like what they're spending the, what they should be spending on like
00:11:21 first strike to compensate the teachers instead, but they're not. So why I'm kind of confused a bit as to
00:11:29 like, why did the teachers, like 90% of the members vote, rejected the vote for like to agree to the deal with
00:11:37 the government. If they knew they weren't going to get paid, like they weren't supported by the union.
00:11:43 I don't believe most teachers realized that there wasn't any strike pay. I'm pretty sure people were
00:11:49 flat-footed. Most of the teachers that I've spoken to were absolutely shocked when I told them there was
00:11:56 no strike pay. This was not common knowledge. And they didn't inform the teachers at all before,
00:12:01 like they were rejected. Oh, there was a memo, but you had to go onto the ATA website and it was a
00:12:07 little bit buried. Hmm. And of course, when you belong to an association and they send you a lot of
00:12:14 emails, especially over the summer, a lot of that's going into your spam folder or it's coming while you're
00:12:22 on vacation and you're not going to get around to that. It's just buried in your inbox. So I can
00:12:28 understand why teachers would not realize that. And along with that, the ATA's communications to
00:12:35 teachers for two years have all been about, we're going to strike. So everyone expected a strike. Okay.
00:12:42 Yeah. And then, you know, almost one in three teachers is not actually a classroom teacher. They're,
00:12:51 they're in administration. Hmm. Right. And that's going to be a problem for them. Yeah. There's 55,000
00:13:00 ATA members, 41,000 of them are active, 8,000 or so are substitute teachers, although they also vote on the
00:13:07 strike vote thing. So they're not directly connected, but there's only 29,000 or so classrooms in Alberta
00:13:15 by the numbers. So that means there's 12 or 13,000 people who are active members of the ATA who are
00:13:24 actually administrators. And those folks tend to have more education than the rest of teachers.
00:13:32 And they may have a little more time and they get to go to school to school
00:13:36 and they would be the primary advocates for a strike because they're more concerned with ideology
00:13:43 naturally because they have the academic background. So there's a lot ideologically pushing
00:13:50 ordinary teachers to vote yes to strike. Even if they're not sure it's a great idea,
00:13:56 there's so much pressure on them. Wow. Okay. Well, on that note as well,
00:14:02 I just have another question about the compensation they were going to get by the government,
00:14:11 um, which they rejected, which was the 12% over four years. So what, like, especially like you said,
00:14:19 the amount of money the government would be spending on the deal if they had agreed to it,
00:14:24 it's already like, what do you say, 11 billion or something? Oh, it would be 2.6 billion.
00:14:29 That's the, if any fact the government's offered to the ATA. Okay. Now I've come out and print in
00:14:36 the Western standard supporting increasing pay for teachers. And let me explain where I got to that
00:14:43 position from there are 735,000 students in union schools. Okay. Um, there's about 87,000 K that are out
00:14:57 in charter public and private schools, a number that's increasing, which should concern us, especially
00:15:03 since when we look at the wait lists, it looks like a quarter of the population has either left the public
00:15:09 system or are trying to leave. There's a massive loss of public confidence in the public schools
00:15:16 and people are, as they say, voting with their feet. But what we're really seeing here out of those
00:15:24 numbers is if there's 29,000 classrooms, that means we're approaching $350,000 per classroom as a total
00:15:33 cost. And that's not including in the capital spending. That's a lot of money per classroom.
00:15:41 But what shocks me is the average teachers only paid 85,000 of that. If you told me that you were
00:15:48 running a service organization or service company where you only paid your main frontline staff a quarter
00:15:56 of your budget, I would be knocking on your door in the morning demanding that you allow me to invest
00:16:01 because you're clearly making a lot of money. So the government has to ask, well, where's the money
00:16:07 going? And my point to the government is, well, salaries for classroom teachers are the smallest
00:16:15 part of the problem. You can afford to bump them. And apparently the government has hurt me at least a
00:16:21 little because in the salary grid offer, they gave a disproportionate bump to the teachers at the bottom
00:16:29 of the scale. And the ones with less education who are more likely to be the classroom teachers and
00:16:36 less likely to be administration. So they've at least heard me there. But I would support, indeed,
00:16:44 giving a little more money to teachers. That's the smallest problem. But ultimately, you know,
00:16:50 when we're looking at this pattern, looking at these numbers, the ATA is not acting like a union that's
00:17:02 negotiating in good faith for their members. When we're looking at spends in the millions of dollars,
00:17:09 and the ATA and their allied unions who sit on boards like Public Interest Alberta or the Parkland
00:17:16 Institute, between them, they spent $4.4 million as third party advertisers in 2021. That is more than
00:17:25 UCP spent in their running provincial election campaign. The ATA is not acting like they're
00:17:32 negotiating in good faith as a union. They're acting like a rival political party. And I am absolutely
00:17:41 floored by how generous the government is being in that context. I would think they would recognize
00:17:50 that the adversarial approach taken by the ATA is in fact adversarial. But the government appears to
00:17:59 understand that this is not about teachers. The people who have the adversarial relationship
00:18:05 are the people at the top of the union, the officers that teachers elected. But you know,
00:18:12 it's costing your average teacher $400 or $500 a day for this strike. And if I was a teacher,
00:18:20 I would be giving serious thought to impeaching the leadership of the ATA that dragged me into this.
00:18:27 Well, for impeaching, like how would that process go? Do they need to get us a number of signatures or
00:18:34 something? I'm not sure how they would do it. But I do know that I hear rumors from teachers who are very
00:18:41 angry with the ATA administration. And I think after their next paycheck, they're going to be angry indeed.
00:18:49 Yeah. Also on that, because the government announced that they're going to do a lockout on,
00:18:55 I think it was October 9th. And that's obviously a negotiation tactic because they want to get the
00:19:03 negotiation going probably. The reason for that is that what a real union would,
00:19:10 a real union administration would do when they're low on a strike fund is they would call for
00:19:16 rolling walkouts. So you only strike at these four schools on Monday, you strike at those four schools
00:19:25 on Tuesday and so on. So you only have to pay strike pay on those days and your members aren't affected
00:19:32 so badly. And the government has said, we're calling your bluff. There's none of that. If you're on strike,
00:19:39 you're on strike. No rolling walkouts. I think it's a waste of effort on the government's part because
00:19:47 the ATA has got, well, the top end of the ATA has absolute tunnel vision on this and they want a
00:19:55 general strike come hell or high water. Hmm. Okay. So no matter, like, I just want to know more about
00:20:03 the rules on how that strike works. So say like, I don't know, the majority of teachers out of school,
00:20:09 they want to go back to work. They, they hate the fact that they're not getting paid. Like you said,
00:20:12 there's 400 or $500 a day or something off their paycheck. And well, I mean, they're not getting
00:20:17 paid, but yeah, like you said, they all want to go back, but they can't because they're a part of
00:20:22 the union. So could they, they can't like just quit the union, right? Like that's not how it works.
00:20:27 We set the ATA up in legislation, in fact, under the Teaching Professions Act. Honestly,
00:20:35 they should be subject to FOIP requests. If you ask me, anybody that's set up in legislation should be.
00:20:43 But they're not. So a bigger problem is that even if the majority of the teachers,
00:20:50 the classroom teachers wanted to go back, the administrators of the school,
00:20:55 the management is part of the union and they want to stay on strike. Okay. Yeah. Makes sense. Okay.
00:21:06 Yeah. So you're talking about the advertisers, how much they spend on third party advertisers.
00:21:11 And you also send me information about operate operational costs in general, they're spending
00:21:16 like, or usually like 30 million for the past few years or so on average. So no, why do they need to
00:21:24 spend that? Like, besides third party advertisers, what are they doing with all that money? That's so
00:21:30 necessary. That is an open question that I don't think I can speculate on. Although I know that they,
00:21:38 they do pay handsome salaries to their executives. Hmm. Oh, I have a good question. I don't know if
00:21:44 this is online because unfortunately I didn't research this prior, but do you know how much
00:21:48 Jason Schilling gets paid by chance? Not entirely. No. He's subject to a range same as anybody else.
00:21:57 They, they take the salary scale idea seriously. He's paid well over a hundred thousand dollars though.
00:22:03 Hmm. Okay. Well, let's see. I think that's all I had to ask you, unless you want to add anything else
00:22:12 that you think would be good and informative. I think we've said enough. Yeah. I think so too.
00:22:17 I think we covered a lot. So that's good. It's a lot of numbers, but this strike is really all about
00:22:23 the numbers and the numbers don't look good. They don't. From what you told me, they don't. So,
00:22:29 well, thank you very much, Don. I appreciate it. Thank you, Leah. Yeah. Well, if you guys enjoyed
00:22:35 this video, you can subscribe to the Western channel, Western Standard YouTube channel,
00:22:40 as well as subscribe to our actual news website, which is $10 a month or $100 a year.
00:22:47 And yeah, that's about it. So thank you for joining us and goodbye.