Western Standard - August 22, 2025


American advice for Canada's PM - 'Get rid of DEI!'

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Another day, another residential school mass grave hoax How sustainable is Canadian municipalities' spending?

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

162.36

Word count

3,676

Sentence count

167

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Almost every week since President Trump was sworn in seven months ago, he has announced that as part of his strategy to rebuild America s industrial base, foreign companies and even countries are pledging significant investments in the United States. According to a recent White House statement, these pledges now exceed a massive $8 trillion. And since that statement, there s been a $550 billion country-to-country deal announced with Japan. But are these promises leading to real on-the-ground activity in the U.S.? Is it all a show? Are we about to lose our Canadian automotive manufacturing industry? With me today is Andrew Hale, a senior policy analyst in trade policy at the Heritage Foundation.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:21 It is Thursday, August the 21st. Almost every week since President Trump was sworn in seven months
00:00:27 ago, he has announced that as part of his strategy to rebuild America's industrial base,
00:00:33 foreign companies and even countries are pledging significant investments in the United States.
00:00:39 According to a recent White House statement, these pledges now exceed a massive $8 trillion,
00:00:45 and that's in just seven months. And since that statement, there's been a $550 billion
00:00:50 country-to-country deal announced with Japan. But are these promises leading to real on-the-ground
00:00:57 activity in the U.S.? Is it all a show? Are we about to lose our Canadian automotive manufacturing
00:01:06 industry? With me today is Andrew Hale, a senior policy analyst in trade policy in Washington's
00:01:13 Heritage Foundation. Good evening, Andrew. Hello. Good evening. Andrew, is this real?
00:01:19 when do struggling americans in the rust belt or anywhere actually start getting good jobs out of
00:01:25 all this and is part of the good jobs that they hope to get jobs that are presently in canada
00:01:32 making motor cars well i think that um you know it takes literally years to build factories it can
00:01:39 take up to 10 years to build a nuclear reactor um so yes we do want to make more infrastructure
00:01:45 here in the United States. We definitely want to expand manufacturing, but I don't necessarily
00:01:50 agree with the approach. I think you could do a lot with deregulation here in the United States.
00:01:55 To give you an example, in 1990, we had 57 blast furnaces in which to make steel. We're now down
00:02:01 to 11 blast furnaces, and that's largely because it's so difficult to build new blast furnaces
00:02:07 given the regulations. And even just last year, the Biden-Harris administration imposed new
00:02:11 regulations on the emissions of steel production, and steel production and net zero targets don't
00:02:17 mix. So we're actually purchasing 40% of our steel from Canada, our refined steel, because in Canada
00:02:23 you have green steel. You're making your steel from nuclear power in Ontario, and of course the
00:02:30 steel and aluminium being made in Quebec with hydroelectric power. So again, if we want to
00:02:35 compete with that, we'll have to build new nuclear reactors. But of course, they take about 10 years
00:02:41 to build. So I'm afraid it would be better to free up the regulation of a focus on that
00:02:46 as opposed to a focus on the tariffs. Yes. Well, I actually found an article that you
00:02:52 co-wrote with Dr. Stern in the New York Post just last year. And I think you made very much that
00:03:00 point talking about the trade in the United States. And we're talking about the U.S.,
00:03:08 but obviously we're a Canadian outlet.
00:03:10 I think we suffer from some of the same things in this country.
00:03:17 And you made the point that economic gains need to come through merit,
00:03:20 not be conferred by government favoritism.
00:03:24 Yes.
00:03:25 Do you think that President Trump is actually addressing that?
00:03:32 And further on in that same article, you did speak quite positively about tariffs.
00:03:37 So when did when I spoke positively about a border adjustment tax, which is a tariff like tax.
00:03:43 I didn't specifically speak about tariffs in general.
00:03:46 I was specifically talking about a border adjustment tax, which would be like a GST that you have in Canada.
00:03:52 OK, the you know, you explained that China routinely violates American patents and foreign countries often restrict U.S. companies.
00:04:06 they restrict Canadian companies as well, and use tariffs and subsidies to funnel investments
00:04:11 and jobs out of the United States. Well, I think what Mr. Trump is trying to do is reverse that
00:04:17 process. But maybe you think otherwise. Where do you and he part company on this?
00:04:27 Well, I was expecting, when President Trump was going to be elected, I was expecting this,
00:04:32 which was Ambassador Robert Lighthizer's no-trade-is-free changing wars taking on China.
00:04:37 That's what we were told was going to be the playbook for the Trump administration number two,
00:04:42 second-term administration. And Ambassador Lighthizer hasn't returned yet. He didn't,
00:04:47 of course, join the first Trump administration at the beginning. There's still time for him to come
00:04:50 back. And remember, of course, the USMC negotiations, or KUSMA, as you'd say in Canada,
00:04:55 were going nowhere. So we were expecting a real emphasis on China. I wasn't expecting a tariff
00:05:01 war against all of our friends and allies. And I have to, like I said, I think that's because
00:05:06 the driving force is not Ambassador Lighthizer in this term, as he was very much in charge of
00:05:11 trade policy in President Trump's first term. We have Peter Navarro, and he basically is someone
00:05:17 who doesn't see tariffs as a means to, as a negotiating tool, which clearly they are. But
00:05:24 he also sees them as a means to pay off the national debt and raise revenue. And I would
00:05:28 like to address that because we have, what, now $37 trillion in national debt in the United States,
00:05:34 and you could abolish every government department except the Pentagon and the entitlement programs,
00:05:39 and you'd only take off $1 trillion off the national debt, and tariffs are not going to
00:05:44 pay down the national debt. And I'd have to address the actual methodology behind this,
00:05:51 I think, is somewhat flawed. We have to ask ourselves, what was the methodology behind
00:05:54 the tariffs against Canada and Mexico, the initial 25% they announced earlier this year,
00:06:00 as well as the Liberation Day tariffs in April. They did not actually calculate tariff rates
00:06:06 and non-tariff barriers as they said they did. Instead, for every country, they just took our
00:06:10 trade deficit with that country of only goods and not services and divided it by the exports to us.
00:06:17 And I think it's important to remember that our trade deficit is the flip side of a demand for
00:06:21 assets. So here in the United States, instead of exchanging exported goods for imported goods,
00:06:25 we make financial assets. And we all seek foreign investment, but some deride the trade deficits.
00:06:30 And to put it a different way, if you have a capital account surplus, you must have an equal
00:06:35 and opposite signed current account deficit. And most of our current account involves trades and
00:06:39 goods and services. So in other words, we have an investment surplus and God help us if we lose that
00:06:44 because that's a sign of a very wealthy country that people want to invest in. Also, proportionally
00:06:48 speaking americans have more purchasing power we purchase stuff as a wealthy country with wealthy
00:06:53 citizens purchase the world that's okay now that's a very degree level analysis is which is what i
00:07:00 would expect from the heritage foundation thank you but let's bring this back to uh first of all
00:07:07 the canadian auto industry i mean the idea i think is that if you put tariffs on uh canadian
00:07:15 manufacture then eventually it will make more sense it may be a messy process it
00:07:20 may take a little while but eventually it's going to make sense for the the
00:07:25 auto industry to establish itself back in Detroit back south of the border
00:07:30 anyway Louisville Kentucky maybe a lot of them seem to be going there that's
00:07:35 where my car came from so this and of course Canada can't sustain an auto
00:07:43 industry on its own market of 40 million people now it's messy but given time is that actually
00:07:53 a viable strategy on mr trump's part and should we be frankly if we're a canadian auto worker
00:08:00 looking for something else to do well i think when president trump initially told the auto
00:08:05 manufacturers in detroit they had 30 days in which to rejig their supply chains back united states i
00:08:11 think that what wasn't understood at the time was the fact that it takes literally years to build
00:08:16 factories, and it takes decades to establish, in some cases, supply chain. And remember that on
00:08:22 average, in the auto industry, auto parts crisscross the U.S. Canadian border on average five times,
00:08:28 sometimes as much as 10 times in the manufacturing process. So we really do need to have
00:08:32 no tariffs on intermediate goods to facilitate that process. Already, we've had some bad news
00:08:40 in Michigan. They've closed five plants already. Stellantis has closed a plant. And Cleveland
00:08:46 Cliffs, the steel manufacturer, has idled one of its blast furnaces. So again, we've had some bad
00:08:53 news as a result of this. And this is with most of the tariffs currently being in abeyance before
00:08:58 this data came through before we had the full force of the tariffs. So again, I think that as
00:09:05 this, we get more and more bad news going forward. If the tariffs are fully implemented
00:09:10 and maintained, we will get a recession. And that will, of course, have an effect on the
00:09:15 midterm elections next year. And of course, I think a lot of Republican congressmen centers
00:09:20 are being quite quiet now, hoping that the courts will shut down the use of IEPA, emergency
00:09:26 legislation, to implement tariffs. And because they're frightened, they don't want to be primary
00:09:30 right now so again but i think the markets will be a moderating force because we have had some bad
00:09:35 news so uh canadian auto workers do they have a career to look forward to or not i think they do
00:09:43 um i think that canada does need to diversify its trade export markets and not be dependent on a
00:09:48 single market like the united states i i would i would call for that in any situation i do think
00:09:54 canada is too heavily dependent upon the united states uh and remember canada does have free trade
00:09:58 agreements all around the world indeed i worked um on the seat agreement um between canada and
00:10:05 the european union um so that canada can take advantage of trade with europe asia and all
00:10:11 around the world given that you know certainly the harper government and others have um you know
00:10:16 were very activist in promoting free trade and getting comprehensive free trade agreements
00:10:20 they certainly were that um i actually worked for mr harper during those years and that was pretty
00:10:27 much while I was writing for a couple of years, is releasing trade agreements.
00:10:31 So we were free traders then, we're free traders now, but except that we're not dealing with
00:10:37 a free trade United States anymore.
00:10:42 I have to wonder whether at a given time, nevertheless, notwithstanding all of the arguments
00:10:48 that you've made, the idea of erecting a tariff wall around the United States is actually
00:10:54 ultimately going to serve the US well. I wasn't there to listen to the radio broadcast, but we
00:11:04 were all taught early on about President Roosevelt, Franklin D. Roosevelt, talking about America as
00:11:12 the arsenal of democracy. I don't think that's true anymore. Certainly, that enormous industrial
00:11:21 base that enabled the united states to take the war across the pacific to japan in 1941 42 45
00:11:29 doesn't we i don't think america could do that today um do you think it could or whether it
00:11:36 could or when it wants to i think if you're looking for example i mean president trump
00:11:41 certainly has had more of a focus on home as well as um not getting entangled in forever wars abroad
00:11:48 Remember, in his first term, he didn't want to intervene in Syria to the anxiety of Prime Minister David Cameron, who's very keen to do so, keeping on the Blair Doctrine of Humanitarian Intervention.
00:11:59 I think the United States is pivoting its resources more towards Asia.
00:12:03 Ukraine is not in America's backyard, and I don't think it's not electorally favorable to invest in the war in Ukraine, the billions of the Biden administration invested.
00:12:14 I think the United States sees more of investing towards Asia because they see China, the people's world of China as more of a serious threat. 0.99
00:12:21 So and of course, making other countries pay for their own defense.
00:12:25 I mean, Canada, you know, should spend more on its defense, but not just to appease the United States.
00:12:31 The United States isn't paying for it.
00:12:33 So it can be independently responsible for its own seas, land and skies, as Stephen Harper recently said.
00:12:39 I think that if you look at just one country in Europe, like the Kingdom of Denmark, they have a very, very generous social welfare system, and they were able to have that throughout the Cold War to the present day because they weren't spending money on their own defense.
00:12:55 They're relying upon the United States security umbrella.
00:12:59 And I think President Trump is right to say, and others,
00:13:02 to say it's time for other countries to step up the plate
00:13:04 because the United States does have $37 trillion in national debt,
00:13:08 which is unsustainable, and we can no longer afford to pay
00:13:11 for the entire world's security, nor should we.
00:13:14 Yes. Well, I must say, Andrew, you're speaking to a true believer here
00:13:20 and to a lot of true believers who watch this program.
00:13:23 everybody thinks, everybody except our own government thinks that we should have done more
00:13:30 and should in the future do very much more in terms of our own defense. Promises have been made
00:13:37 to spend enormous amounts of money. It's one thing to promise it, it's another thing to actually do
00:13:43 it, to A, provide the funds, and B, provide the mechanism to buy the equipment. Canada has a very
00:13:50 bad record of doing them but anyway that's that's a slightly different uh project i'm just
00:13:55 i'm just trying to focus on whether this actually makes sense for america given the time make the
00:14:03 adjustments bring the industrial base back onto the continent from where it's been a lot of people
00:14:11 will be affected by it but in the long haul is this not a good thing to do well i think is if
00:14:19 Like I said, I refer to the former ambassador of the United States Trade Representative Office, Ambassador Robert Lighthizer, in his book and his focus on China.
00:14:27 And I would have thought we would be doing this.
00:14:29 I actually believe that these duties, these tariffs harm America's global leadership, and it undermines our progress in establishing resilient supply chains in this region and outside China in particular.
00:14:42 I think the trade war also has the potential to push our allies into the arms of China.
00:14:47 So, for example, if you want to convince the Dutch, the Kingdom of the Netherlands, not to transfer critical chip-making technology to the peoples of local China, don't tariff all their stuff.
00:14:58 And I just think that the approach on Liberation Day, by just announcing these tariffs, I've already mentioned I don't agree with the methodology, but also I just think it was the wrong approach because we want to trade with these countries and have our allies be able to influence them away from and decouple and de-risk for the peoples of local China. 0.63
00:15:15 And I feel that that actually has had a very negative effect.
00:15:21 I mean, look, if you look at some very, very hyper-protectionist groups like Coalition for Prosperous America will be one of them.
00:15:28 And actually, their head of the trade program is actually Canadian.
00:15:30 And he said to me, he says, oh, I think Canadians should just buy local and Americans should just buy local.
00:15:35 Look, we're not going to build factories here, for example, to make rope.
00:15:38 We wouldn't even employ people to do that.
00:15:40 We would just automate that.
00:15:41 it's best that we purchase rope from India or Africa or somewhere else. We can buy legacy
00:15:47 products from other countries. We don't want Americans to work in those factories. And often 1.00
00:15:51 cases, we wouldn't even employ Americans to work in those factories. We would just automate that. 0.99
00:15:55 And of course, the unions are opposed to automation. So I just don't think what they're
00:15:59 talking about being a sort of totally self-sufficient United States is possible. What we do
00:16:05 want to do is near shore and friend shore away from the people's republic of china and and trade 0.93
00:16:12 with our allies and friends like canada not tariff them and declare trade wars on them okay fair
00:16:18 enough point well made now let's turn back to canada you've lived in canada you have strong
00:16:23 canadian connections i even went to school here so you understand the situation very well you know
00:16:28 how we think north of the border and of course you're working for the heritage foundation so
00:16:33 very au fait with how things are done in washington andrew if you had 10 minutes with
00:16:40 prime minister carney and he were to ask you what you thought canada should be doing how we should
00:16:48 approach this situation what would you tell him i would say give up the net zero scams i would say
00:16:54 They give up all of the ESG and DEI programs.
00:17:00 I just feel that there's too many navel gazing on what I would call luxury beliefs and net zero targets manufacturing don't mix.
00:17:11 I call it not zero. And I think that's going to be a huge problem going forward between and it has been between the Trump administration and the current liberal government in Ottawa.
00:17:21 And it's obviously caused friction between the aspirations of provinces like Alberta and Saskatchewan and the federal government in Ottawa.
00:17:31 I just feel that there is an obsession with net zero targets and really it's counterproductive.
00:17:37 I would say to Prime Minister Carney, look, your windmills, your solar panels are being made in China and they're building two new coal fire power plants a week.
00:17:47 And it's the dirtiest coal in the world.
00:17:49 So good luck with that one.
00:17:51 That is not helping the environment.
00:17:54 So I agree with President Trump when he says, drill, baby, drill.
00:17:57 We have false natural resources here in North America.
00:17:59 I believe in, you know, we have this, I believe that the United States should be purchasing Canadian energy as we do.
00:18:05 And I believe in a great single market here between, under KUSMA, between Canada, the United States and Mexico.
00:18:13 And I think that we need to build pipelines as well to export that energy down here in the United States and abroad.
00:18:19 obviously not be totally dependent on the u.s market but also open up markets abroad for
00:18:24 canadian energy and i know that on the provincial level there's been a lot of outreach and that's
00:18:28 being done i've spoken to danielle smith she's doing a great job as scott moe is doing as well
00:18:33 in saskatchewan um i would just simply i mean i think that would be fallen deaf ears to finish
00:18:38 because i mean mark connie's wife who's brilliant she works for the um eurasia group as does
00:18:42 gerald butts they're brilliant people but i think this obsession which is almost like a new religion
00:18:48 with these people on ESG is just really a non-starter for discussions between the United
00:18:55 States right now and Canada under the current Trump administration. Okay, just for the benefit
00:19:01 of people who don't keep up with acronyms, I think a lot of people know ESG is something that's not
00:19:06 good, but environmental social governments, how does that actually interfere with what Canada
00:19:14 needs to be doing now to get his house in order? Well, I mean, so with regards to the net zero
00:19:22 targets, I mean, net zero targets in manufacturing, as I already said, don't mix. They kill industry.
00:19:30 I mean, right now, Canada has very, very high energy to a degree and a much higher, for example,
00:19:36 Europe has literally outsourced much of its manufacturing to China. And of course, their 1.00
00:19:41 The United Kingdom has some of the highest energy in the world now, and it's killing what's left of British industry.
00:19:48 I was speaking to an auto manufacturer, parts manufacturer in Northern Ireland, and he showed me his energy bill.
00:19:55 And I just was shocked compared to the energy prices we pay here in the United States.
00:20:01 And so basically, if you want to engage in that ESG, Mark Carney has even written in one of his books that to achieve these net zero targets and goals and to fully implement ESG and make it a success, we have to become poorer and there will be losers.
00:20:17 I don't agree with him. Like I said, it pollutes and poisons everything. So for example, just last year in the United States, we were trying to renew the generalized system of preference, which is a trade preference program for developing countries.
00:20:34 And we have the Democrats trying to impose ESG regulations in the renewal of that legislation. Now, in India, gender parity requirements perhaps wouldn't work culturally. In Africa, LGBT requirements perhaps wouldn't work culturally either.
00:20:52 And the environmental regulations would make this trade preference program so prohibitively expensive for these developing countries, people will just trade with China anyway. 0.95
00:21:02 So, again, I just don't think it's feasible.
00:21:05 And quite frankly, I don't actually believe in the climate hysteria either.
00:21:10 Well, I think you're speaking for a lot of people who watch this program
00:21:15 and lose exactly the prescriptions that we offer here through the Western Standard.
00:21:22 Let's get rid of the climate change nonsense.
00:21:25 Let's get rid of the ESG, the DEI,
00:21:28 and concentrate on doing a good job of what we do best,
00:21:30 which is producing energy and exporting it.
00:21:34 Andrew, this has been a great conversation.
00:21:36 I really appreciate you taking the time.
00:21:38 Heritage Foundation, of course, is a really good group. Congratulations on being a member of that,
00:21:46 and I want to thank you again for coming on and explaining some of these basic things to us.
00:21:54 Thank you so much for having me on. It's been a pleasure.
00:21:56 It has been a pleasure. For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.
00:22:08 Thank you.