Western Standard - January 05, 2021


BREAKING: Kenney sacks Allard, slap on the wrist for other snowbird MLAs. Will it be enough?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
January 2, 2020 Jan 5, 2020

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

161.73

Word count

6,433

Sentence count

146

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

13

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Tracy Allard has resigned as Municipal Affairs Minister, and 15 other UCP MLAs have been fired as a result of the scandal. This is a special edition of The Pipeline, featuring Western Standard editor Dave Naylor.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:30 Good day, I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:02:53 You're here for another special edition of The Pipeline.
00:02:57 I'm joined today by Western Standard News editor Dave Naylor.
00:03:02 How are you doing, Dave?
00:03:05 Dave, we can't hear you.
00:03:06 You've got your mic muted.
00:03:08 Well, that's not a good start.
00:03:10 I'm doing great, Derek.
00:03:11 Been a busy day, been a busy weekend.
00:03:13 Indeed.
00:03:14 Well, very busy weekend.
00:03:17 Neither of us had terribly much of holidays, not just because we're worried about cops kicking in our doors during Christmas dinner,
00:03:25 but because there's been so much happening in a traditionally very slow time in the news cycle.
00:03:31 Last night, you, for Western Standard, had the exclusive story, breaking news.
00:03:39 Actually, you were the only news at all that was able to confirm that today,
00:03:45 UCP Municipal Affairs Minister Tracy Allard, the MLA for Hawaii Grand Prairie, would resign.
00:03:53 That has just happened.
00:03:55 Dave, why don't I just throw it over immediately to you to let people know what's happened.
00:04:00 Yeah, it's a crazy day, Derek.
00:04:03 Our sources last night confirmed that Allard was going to be resigning,
00:04:08 but we had no indication that it was going to be such a political bloodletting
00:04:13 that we've seen out of Edmonton just after the lunch hour.
00:04:17 By any standards, call it what you want, Night of the Long Knives,
00:04:21 It's unprecedented.
00:04:24 So I'll just give you the quick rundown, Derek, of what we know at the moment.
00:04:27 Tracy Allard has resigned as Municipal Affairs Minister.
00:04:32 She said she went to Hawaii to, quote, continue a 17-year holiday tradition.
00:04:38 So she was down there with her family soaking up the sun and the rays.
00:04:42 Jamie Huckabee, Kenny's Chief of Staff who flew to the United Kingdom, he's been fired.
00:04:48 Kenny asked him to resign, and he did so, so he's now out of a job.
00:04:55 Jeremy Nixon, Parliamentary Secretary for Civil Society, whatever the hell that means.
00:05:00 Derek, you may have a better idea than me, has lost that post because of traveling to Hawaii.
00:05:07 Red Deer MLA Jason Steffen is out as Parliamentary Secretary to the Treasury Board
00:05:12 because he headed for warmer climates in Arizona.
00:05:16 and Tanya Furr, Pat Wren, and Tani Yao have all lost their legislature committee jobs
00:05:26 because of their traveling to a nice warm holiday destination.
00:05:31 In a statement today, Kenny wasn't made available to the press,
00:05:35 but in a statement he said that, quote,
00:05:37 these individuals demonstrated extremely poor judgment
00:05:40 and that he had certainly heard loud and strong
00:05:44 the anger that Albertans were feeling over this
00:05:47 that has grown since it was discovered last week
00:05:51 about the snowbird UCP MLAs and staffers.
00:05:57 Political scientist Dwayne Bratt from Mount Royal University
00:06:03 was quick to chime in saying,
00:06:05 Kenny's statement is too little too late.
00:06:08 He said if this had happened on Friday,
00:06:10 the statement in the firings it may have uh limited some political damages uh careful to
00:06:17 say it wouldn't have eliminated uh but it does say it would have limited so so there you have it uh
00:06:23 an absolute uh bloodletting in the alberta ledge this afternoon uh derek uh indeed yeah it's i can't
00:06:32 recall seeing something like this uh scandal involves so many uh obviously there are controversies
00:06:38 where leaders will sack someone for good reasons or bad whatever they are but I've rarely seen a
00:06:45 bloodletting that involves such a large number of the caucus and and and a large number of very
00:06:53 senior staffers although as far as I know only one staffer got the axe I don't think the other
00:06:58 staffers who were off enjoying their non lockdown lockdown got the axe as far as I could tell but
00:07:06 um it's uh it's quite they had to do something there was absolutely no way for them to do nothing
00:07:14 that that was their plan uh kenny's never had a scandal he couldn't walk away from he's walked
00:07:18 away from some pretty significant uh controversies before but they've always tended to be much more
00:07:24 complicated uh much more difficult to explain uh people can rightly or wrongly dismiss it as saying
00:07:31 oh this is just the leftist media uh this one they couldn't uh this one stung them it was
00:07:37 uh easy to explain and while people are very personally feeling pain uh while the government
00:07:44 says uh if you if we find you uh having too many people over for christmas dinner who are not in
00:07:49 your household we're gonna send cops gatineau style kick down your door and arrest you um
00:07:54 the same time as the government's doing something as wickedly authoritarian as that
00:07:59 uh to have uh i think more than 10 of their of the entire legislature so probably uh close to
00:08:05 15 or so of the ucp caucus and a bunch of their staffers overseas um i mean not to make too
00:08:13 dramatic of a comparison but uh can you just imagine in uh an east german communist official
00:08:19 with the ultimate lockdown of people uh from stopping people from leaving their own country
00:08:23 but then heading off to West Germany to buy good cheeses and meats in West Germany,
00:08:30 something that they would deny their own citizens. That's something they did all the time, 0.72
00:08:33 something that undermined the Berlin Wall. Not to compare as quite apples and apples, 0.67
00:08:38 I think it's matters of degrees, but I think it's that kind of wicked, wicked hypocrisy.
00:08:45 And Kenny was hoping that this would just blow over. Dave, I know your news, but give me your
00:08:51 sense do you think this is going to be enough uh to to make this all blow over now i i don't think
00:08:57 so derek and i think it all goes back to bumbling by kenny himself his statement that he came out
00:09:03 with on friday almost beggared belief uh he took the blame for all these ucp people traveling by
00:09:10 saying he had not made it clear enough to them that hey perhaps you might not want to jet off
00:09:14 to hawaii when the rest of the population is in lockdown i mean come on that's a silly silly reason
00:09:23 that left the question open well okay if you left it up to these individual judgments do you really 0.99
00:09:28 want a cabinet minister who's stupid enough uh when she's help helping roll out the uh the vaccine 1.00
00:09:36 province-wide that she's stupid enough to go on a holiday tradition to hawaii should these people 1.00
00:09:42 be in your cabinet and the answer was it was obviously no um kenny bumbled it from the 0.99
00:09:48 beginning he bumbled it by sitting quiet over the weekend and not saying anything and the anger grew
00:09:55 and the anger grew and the anger grew and you know it's to the point now we've even got songs
00:10:01 being written about the allard family tradition and if you want to give a listen to that just
00:10:05 just go on our our website westernstandardonline.com and and just listen to the song there is an anger
00:10:13 build up in the province derek like i've never seen before uh politically wise and you know
00:10:18 you can comment on your time in politics and and certainly as a close observer but uh
00:10:23 have you seen anger like this before uh the closest i can think of would be allison redford's 0.64
00:10:29 um fakes on a plane and allison redford sky palace um but those came when she was already
00:10:35 effectively on her way out the door um they did not happen midterm like this where it's expected
00:10:42 someone's going to continue on um and the it's not just a controversy it's the cover-up or lies
00:10:49 about it i mean uh people screw up politicians screw up i can tell you personally they screw up
00:10:54 The question is, do you take responsibility and fess up and show some accountability for it, or do you muddy the waters, try to politician your way out of things, blame other people, or even lie about it?
00:11:08 Now, you just said you were referring to Kenny's statement where he says, I did not I'm going to take responsibility for this because I didn't tell my MLA's cabinet and staff in clear enough terms that they're not supposed to travel abroad for non-essential reasons during a lockdown.
00:11:28 Well, let's go to a story you had yesterday.
00:11:32 Here is a tweet from Jason Kenny.
00:11:34 This was during the first lockdown.
00:11:35 it seems pretty clear to me day why don't you read off the tweet tell us what the context was
00:11:43 this was a Kenny tweet in March Derek when the when the pandemic was was first starting to take
00:11:50 a hole he put out a tweet saying he couldn't stress enough do not leave the province cancel
00:11:56 your traveling if you're outside of Canada come home and isolate if you're in Alberta and this
00:12:01 is key please follow the advice of health officials and that was played on cbc news nationally
00:12:08 at the time with the breathless announcement that alberta is expected to announce
00:12:14 seven new cases imagine those days again derek when we were announcing good old days of seven
00:12:21 so now you've got kenny urging people to listen to what the health care authorities are saying
00:12:27 well as you say 15 of his caucus isn't smart enough to do that and they're just going uh
00:12:33 golfing or uh to vegas or you know wherever they can uh work on their suntans it's uh like i said
00:12:40 the mind just boggles on uh on stuff like this and i you know i don't see it going away i think
00:12:45 kenny's uh personal leadership will plummet uh into the dangerous areas he's he's around 30
00:12:52 before this happened and it's going to plummet to the 20 percent uh level and derek you know what
00:12:58 happens uh when that happens you start to get rumblings in caucus from mlas who are worried
00:13:03 that if kenny stays on as leader we may lose the next election yeah uh well actually on that that's
00:13:10 a great segue uh we want to pull on this we are um well actually we'll get the proper link up here
00:13:16 in a second uh we are uh the western standard is trying to commission a poll we want to see what
00:13:22 Albertans think about this right now we want to see um has this uh affected Kenny's approval
00:13:28 ratings i think there's a pretty good bet that it has um has this affected very importantly how
00:13:33 people intend to vote are people just angry but gonna at the end of the day um we want to hear
00:13:38 from you in the comments section uh are people at the end of the day uh two years from now just gonna
00:13:44 uh hold their nose and uh vote ucp anyway because it's not the ndp or are they going to be looking
00:13:50 somewhere else the mainstream media's pollsters are notoriously bad at
00:13:56 actually figuring out if there is any other option in alberta
00:13:58 other than the ucp and ndp uh polls show consistently that the third place
00:14:03 party in alberta is other well we want to figure out what is the
00:14:06 other so we want to do polls on that uh we
00:14:09 want to ask about uh recall uh we're going to get into that
00:14:12 just a little bit here um should albertans have the right to
00:14:16 recall their mlas this is a long-standing promise of the ucp
00:14:19 which they have not kept despite it being one of the easier pieces it's just a simple piece of
00:14:23 legislation um we want to pull about that so we um i'm going to bring up a link here in a second
00:14:30 but we uh we we need you to go to westernstandardonline.com hover over the membership
00:14:36 section and go to donate and you can donate to um help us uh crowdsource for a poll we're
00:14:42 going to come back to that in a second when we've got a link um so what we saw here was um
00:14:49 Uh, you know, Kenny sacked his minister.
00:14:52 She was the only one in cabinet that we're aware of so far overseas.
00:14:56 Sonia Savage, the energy minister, was found in Kelowna, B.C.
00:15:00 I'm a bit more forgiving of that.
00:15:03 It does break the travel advisory, but I think by degrees going to Kelowna, it's not much
00:15:09 of a difference between going from, you know, Calgary to Kelowna is not much of a difference
00:15:13 from going from Calgary to Edmonton.
00:15:15 I don't see a big difference there.
00:15:16 so she's gotten the pass and I think that might that that's probably reasonable but you know
00:15:23 you've got a large number of other MLAs who are in Hawaii who were in who are in Mexico in the
00:15:31 American Southwest why don't you tell us about what Kenny's Kenny's rap on the wrist for them
00:15:39 is about well they're losing uh legislature committee jobs uh derek the uh you know being
00:15:47 the parliamentary secretary to this cabinet minister or or that cabinet minister and sitting
00:15:53 on legislature committees all of which brings in extra cash for them um derek you may know
00:16:00 more than i do you know what it's going to cost allard losing a cabinet minister 0.98
00:16:04 job, but it will be a significant haircut for her. The other ones will be less harsh. 0.75
00:16:13 But it's more than the loss of money, it's a loss of reputation. In Grand Prairie, Hawaii
00:16:22 writing now, the Tracy Allard supporters are in for a very big fight. They've got protests
00:16:28 in front of her office, they've got a Christmas tree adorned with suntan lotion as a decoration.
00:16:36 And they're expecting protests because they've already put up a sign saying,
00:16:40 hey, protesters, keep off our sidewalk.
00:16:42 So all these MLAs are going to have to deal with that at the next election,
00:16:47 the loss of face, and it's going to be hard for them to overcome it.
00:16:54 And if I was thinking about running against them in the nomination, you know, for the UCP party, I might seize on this already and get to work on it.
00:17:04 Well, I can tell you from experience, UCP nominations have a lot less to do with the local members than they do tend to do with who has the support of the leader.
00:17:12 The question will be, does Kenny want to replace some of these MLAs?
00:17:15 If that's the case, then you will get a nomination in that riding.
00:17:19 But if Kenny is still, if these MLAs are still on Kenny's good side, I can tell you, you can get all the memberships you want.
00:17:27 Nominations won't defeat an MLA, only a general election will.
00:17:31 I'm not sure how they could be on Kenny's good side.
00:17:33 I mean, talk about landing your boss in the muck.
00:17:37 You know, and where was the chief party whipping all of this?
00:17:40 Why didn't he know all these people were leaving the province?
00:17:43 He did.
00:17:43 I can tell you right now particularly in a government caucus at the very Kenny
00:17:52 it is possible Kenny didn't know where the backbenchers were it is probably not
00:17:56 but it is possible and I think we're gonna do some digging around Dave to
00:18:03 see if we could find some confirmation on this front I think that's an
00:18:05 important point because now we're into the cover-up part of the story what they
00:18:08 knew and when they knew it who done it exactly ministers cannot leave the
00:18:15 country they can't even leave the province without the premier knowing the
00:18:19 chief and especially the chief of staff to any minister especially the premier
00:18:25 the first minister there is a 0% chance that the premier didn't know about that
00:18:30 and he claims ignorance and this is where it could where the story is
00:18:35 definitely not done I think a lot of people are gonna say that slaps on the
00:18:39 wrist losing a committee job that no one really cares about anyway that you don't
00:18:44 get extra pay for and the committees have no power in any case they do what
00:18:48 they're told the two parts of this story I think that are going to continue is
00:18:53 is this enough is Allard's the only one Allard and the chief of staff Huckabay
00:18:57 are the only ones who really have blood on the floor everyone else I think got a
00:19:01 slap on the wrist by comparison um that's going to continue and uh what kenny knew and when he
00:19:08 knew it that's going to continue um well you remember the uh the the speaking of the cover
00:19:14 up derek what happened in ontario with their wayward finance minister rod phillips he left
00:19:19 for st bart's and uh premier ford when it broke he claimed he only heard about this two weeks ago
00:19:27 And then when reporters started digging deeper and deeper, it turns out he knew.
00:19:31 Yeah, sorry.
00:19:32 Let me rephrase that.
00:19:33 He only found out about it the morning that the media did when he was in St.
00:19:37 Port's.
00:19:38 But it turned out that he knew two weeks ago when it happened.
00:19:41 And that's causing all sorts of problems in Ontario.
00:19:45 Sorry for the mixing up there.
00:19:47 So, yeah, this story is not going away.
00:19:49 When Kenny found out, you know, who was traveling, who told who is going to continue, unfortunately,
00:19:55 for uh for the ucp indeed um well let's talk about what's happened with uh we'll bring up an image
00:20:05 here in a second uh recall legislation this was a marquee promise by uh jason kenny in the last
00:20:11 election uh he's going to give albertans the right to fire their mlas um they're two years in and this
00:20:18 is one of the easiest promises for them to keep they don't have to consult they don't have to do
00:20:22 a bunch of stuff and studies uh they already knew what they were going to do apparently um yeah can
00:20:28 you can he we're two years into this and they haven't done it can you tell us what's happened
00:20:32 on this front yeah kenny promised it both during and after the election on his ucp platform during
00:20:39 the election there was you know pages devoted to uh the recall legislation now everything
00:20:45 involving recall is being scrubbed uh from the government ucp site so if you go looking for
00:20:51 their platform it's not there anymore well what we understand derrick from western standard
00:20:56 sources is the old the old tory guard uh within the ucp is uh dead set against this and they're
00:21:04 trying to make any sort of legislation if it does if and when it does come through to have such a
00:21:09 high threshold like like you would have to get 80 of all residents or something like that and
00:21:14 in a writing uh to make it go forward that it wouldn't just make any sense so that seems to
00:21:20 the fight in caucus at the moment is uh are they going to do it and how high are they going to make
00:21:25 the recall uh threshold but it's come to light again after all this uh canadian taxpayers uh
00:21:32 federation alberta had uh franco terrazzoni put out a release saying look this if kenny doesn't
00:21:37 want to judge these politicians then let albertans judge them uh because they would have something to
00:21:42 say about uh about the you know the holiday uh holiday horrors that the ucp is facing now
00:21:48 Yeah, so some tweets age better than others. Jason Kenney, I think during or right before
00:21:56 the 2019 provincial election, put up a tweet saying that we will give Albertans the right
00:22:06 to fire their MLAs if they lost the confidence of their constituents. Now that was working until
00:22:13 pretty recently I think but all of a sudden if you click on the link in that
00:22:19 tweet onto the party's website where the details of that recall platform
00:22:23 commitment are this is what you get you got a 404 error and it's got a I think
00:22:30 an amusing picture of Rachel Notley says 404 error oh no that link is as
00:22:34 broken as the NDP's carbon tax now that's got an extra layer of irony right
00:22:41 now I think do we have any sense that that's all I think you've already kind
00:22:47 of said the Tories probably have no choice politically but to go forward
00:22:51 with it but it appears that they're probably going to bring in like a recall
00:22:58 legislation late in their term before it can be used against them and they'll
00:23:02 probably set the threshold extremely high we could be wrong but this is what
00:23:06 people in the Tory caucus are telling us right now who are not happy about the
00:23:10 old the pc old guard uh getting away in the way of this platform commitment and this is
00:23:16 this is in general part of what kenny's problem has been talking to ucp supporters they're very
00:23:22 very frustrated very angry that the kenny that they were promised in the election and in the
00:23:28 campaign is not the kenny that has acted that way when he became premier uh he hasn't been very hard
00:23:36 on ottawa uh all the promises of the own provincial police force and uh own tax uh
00:23:44 system all kenny has done is set up panel after panel after panel uh to even do more studies on it
00:23:51 and kenny voters voted for him specifically because they wanted some action uh they wanted
00:23:58 kenny the action man and they got kenny the ditherer and i think that's a lot of why his
00:24:04 popularity is going down the toilet at the moment well uh let's talk about uh the political
00:24:10 consequences of this obviously uh it's still hot now it's questionable about if this is going to go
00:24:16 away or not uh i mean people who are angry right now are going to say no it's not going to go away
00:24:22 it's going to continue but i mean anger at anything eventually does go away uh even if
00:24:27 it's not been addressed uh i think kenny had uh two sorry three options uh he could do nothing
00:24:37 which is what he did do for uh this scandal until uh well until uh we got word last night from a
00:24:43 source that he was going to fire allard and he he did fire her this morning uh so he had the first
00:24:48 option which is nothing the second option was to offer up a token head or two uh that is what he
00:24:54 did do he offered up the heads of allard and huckabay and gave a very small slap on the wrist
00:24:59 to the other uh ucb snowbird mlas although apparently nothing to the press secretaries
00:25:04 that were found overseas um and then the third was the nuclear option which is to fire all of
00:25:10 them from the caucus uh and we've seen uh you know the nova scotia pc leader today said if uh he has
00:25:18 any Snowbird MLAs in his caucus, they will be kicked out. You're one and done. These are kind
00:25:24 of the three main options I think he has, and he's gone for the middle option. I don't think it's
00:25:30 going to be enough for people to say, okay, he's done right. It's over. Let's move on. But it's
00:25:37 not nothing. I mean, the firing minister is a big deal. And I can tell you, Jason Kitty does not like
00:25:43 admit he's wrong or to lose a battle and he I think he is admitting now he has
00:25:49 lost he's trying now to mitigate the damage he's trying to essentially save
00:25:52 the furniture at this point Dave the political fallout I think it's gonna be
00:25:57 quite different on the left the right and the center maybe let's move from
00:26:02 left to center to right and talk about the fallout what do you think what
00:26:06 effect do you think this is gonna have with support for the NDP or parties on
00:26:09 laughed well obviously this is a a godsend for ndp leader rachel notley she couldn't have asked
00:26:16 for a bigger more uh you know more you know angry scandal than what she's got here so
00:26:24 ndp have been tweeting out daily horror stories and i'm sure this will continue and i think it'll 0.63
00:26:29 even be ramped up because they are probably going to go with the angle of the the soft slap on the
00:26:36 wrist a couple of people lost their ledge job that as you say nobody cares about or couldn't name
00:26:41 anyways they want uh they they're going to push for the nuclear option and uh have them expelled
00:26:47 from caucus um you know and i i think that that is going to help the ndp because i think that's
00:26:54 what a lot of people wanted uh before kenny made the announcement today they wanted him to to do
00:27:00 the nuclear option uh and he hasn't done so i think that's going to disappoint the the right
00:27:06 and the center and and the ucp supporters and i think some of them may move to the left when they
00:27:13 say you know what rachel notley's got the right idea she should have done that and by the way
00:27:18 she's come out and said there have been no ndpmla's that left the province she was very clear on that
00:27:24 yeah that has allowed them to throw some stones uh because they didn't do it right away because
00:27:29 because they wanted to make sure they were not in a glass house on this one.
00:27:32 They were very cautious coming out of the gates. 0.99
00:27:36 They're like, oh, shit, what if we've got some? 0.99
00:27:38 We can get caught up in it, too. 1.00
00:27:40 Federally, you can't see...
00:27:42 Well, the three major parties federally,
00:27:46 the Liberals, the Tories, and the NDP have all had people.
00:27:50 As far as I know, there's been no discipline on the Tory side,
00:27:54 but there has been on the Liberal side and the NDP side,
00:27:58 Which just made it more uncomfortable for Jason Kenney that the bar for accountability for a Trudeau Liberal or a Jagmeet Singh New Democrat Socialist is higher than for an Alberta Tory.
00:28:14 Derek, when you see Liberals voluntarily stepping down and UCP guys in Alberta doing nothing but trying to hide, then yeah, that's a huge problem for UCP Party.
00:28:25 i think one reason he may have waited so long wasn't just that he thought it would blow over
00:28:30 but potentially because they still just didn't know how many were out i mean uh i mean if it
00:28:36 was just tracy allard and they were confident it was just tracy allard maybe she would have
00:28:41 been fired right away but they had no idea how many it was and if you fire one you have to fire
00:28:45 others uh so i think they would they wanted to have discipline come down all at once rather
00:28:50 than piecemeal because if you fired allard and then it came out nixon or fur or one of these
00:28:58 others we're doing it then you have to fire each and every single one of them and eventually you
00:29:02 get down to a minority government caucus um last i heard they haven't even been able to find uh
00:29:08 uh ford mcmurray mla yow he's in mexico somewhere but they haven't even been able to contact him to
00:29:15 to say get your ass home so i know tany personally uh he's a likable guy but he is in for a very bad
00:29:22 moment when he gets back to cell reception and turns on his phone uh that is going to be uh 0.98
00:29:28 that'll be a rough that'll be an unfortunate day yeah he's going to be going from about plus 30
00:29:35 minus 15 celsius when he lands in uh in fort max so talk about a chilly reception yeah indeed um
00:29:43 well let's talk more about uh political fallout on the right um the uh you know broadly speaking
00:29:51 not to overly simplify things but i think fairly break things down um uh you know peter mccaffrey
00:29:58 from the alberta institute i think put it really well there's roughly 35 percent of the left tribe
00:30:03 in alberta which identifies with the ndp that have been angry that lockdowns aren't hard enough they
00:30:09 they weren't fast enough, that they want more draconian measures. You have 35% roughly of
00:30:16 Albertans who are from the old Wild Rose tribe who believe that the lockdown and the restrictions
00:30:23 have already been too draconian, too authoritarian, that the government is just caving to political
00:30:28 pressure, and they've already not been happy. And then you've got roughly 30% of the, let's call it
00:30:33 a center or progressive conservative tribe. And they kind of, more or less, they generally thought
00:30:41 Kenny has made the best of a bunch of bad options. All three of these tribes are very, very pissed 0.96
00:30:47 off right now. And the one that's very dangerous is that right Wildrose populist tribe. You know,
00:30:55 they're now able to say, I think very correctly, this was already too far. We don't think you even
00:31:02 believed it when you did it, but then you didn't even abide by it yourself, you need to end the
00:31:06 lockdown now. And cabinet renewal of the lockdown is coming up in just a few days. I cannot see how
00:31:15 the government has the political capital right now to renew the lockdown. If they renew the
00:31:20 lockdown, the friggin' legislature will get burned down. People are going to say, you have no moral 0.97
00:31:26 right to lock us down when you're doing this. You may have cut off the head of one minister,
00:31:30 but what about the other uh five or six mlas and the other staffers who have had just a tiny slap
00:31:36 on the wrist if i have uh dinner with my christmas dinner with my family i get cops at my door and i
00:31:41 could get arrested um so i think i think this is the end of the lockdown i cannot see how they have
00:31:48 the political capital to renew this now oh yeah i think the key is going to be the number of reported
00:31:53 cases of covet that we're having over the next couple days today should be a very very high
00:31:59 number because we didn't get reporting or accurate reporting over the weekend you look at ontario
00:32:05 three thousand plus cases today it's out of control the virus is out of control in ontario
00:32:11 and they're bringing in even harsher lockdowns uh scotland back in lockdown as of tonight great
00:32:17 britain back in lockdown as of tonight so if these numbers continue to rise in in uh in alberta and
00:32:25 And, you know, I tend to agree with you.
00:32:27 I can't see Kenny extending the lockdown.
00:32:29 Then is he going to lift it when the pandemic is still raging?
00:32:35 And I wouldn't want to be in his shoes.
00:32:38 Well, he's going to have a hard time from either angle.
00:32:41 If he does end the lockdown, because he doesn't have a political capital for it,
00:32:46 the NDP, from their perspective, will be able to say,
00:32:49 you're not following the science, you're not following the advice of Henshaw.
00:32:54 you're ending the lockdown, which is necessary because of your political scandal. So your
00:32:59 political scandal is now getting in the way of public health. That's what the left is going to
00:33:03 say. And from their perspective, they're going to have a real argument to make about that. That's a
00:33:08 fair point from their perspective. But from the other perspective, much more dangerous, I think,
00:33:14 politically for Kenny, is he has no way of extending this lockdown further after what has
00:33:21 just happened. I mean, if you think, you know, a couple of hundred freedom marchers in downtown
00:33:27 Calgary, Edmonton, and Red Deer are a problem now, you just try extending this lockdown when
00:33:32 we've just come through a scandal like this, or we're still in the middle of a scandal like this.
00:33:37 I think he's between a real rock and a hard place here. Well, Wild Rose leader, Paul Hinman,
00:33:42 in an exclusive column today that's on the Western Standard website at the moment, Derek,
00:33:47 he calls on Kenny to immediately lift the lockdown.
00:33:52 And he's been opposed to it since day one.
00:33:56 And you're right.
00:33:57 If Kenny does continue it, then he's looking at leaking support
00:34:02 from that hardcore Wild Rose grouping that you've talked about
00:34:05 into the hands of the Wild Rose Independence Party.
00:34:09 And, yeah, it's, like I said, as you've said,
00:34:13 rocking a hard place for Premier Kenny, that's for sure.
00:34:16 Indeed.
00:34:17 So a reminder here, we want to know what Albertans are thinking about this. I got a pretty good idea, but it's one thing to watch the comments on this broadcast or comments on Facebook or Twitter, social media.
00:34:31 While we appreciate it, it is not a representative sample, a scientific sample of what people at large think. We want to get a really good idea of people who are not necessarily as engaged in current issues as all of our viewers might be right now.
00:34:44 as might be right now. So we're going to commission a professional independent poll on this and we
00:34:49 need people to donate to do it. Remember, we don't take a penny from the federal government's media
00:34:54 bailout. We are funded completely by, as a private business, by advertisers and by voluntary members
00:35:01 like you. If you want to contribute, go to Western Standard Online, click on membership and become a
00:35:06 member. Or if you're already a member, please go westerncenteredonline.com slash donate dash poll
00:35:13 slash and there you can make a donation to help us commission the poll we want
00:35:18 to get it out in the field tonight we want to know what people are thinking
00:35:20 right now do they think that there needs to be more resignations here do people
00:35:27 think that we need recall legislation do people think we need to end the lockdowns
00:35:31 does the government have the moral authority to continue lockdowns and we
00:35:35 want to see what the political fallout has been in terms of how people actually
00:35:38 intend to vote are people just angry right now but come election time gonna
00:35:42 say well i guess that's the we have to pick the lesser of evils or are people going to do something
00:35:48 different we want to know so if uh you know uh we understand a lot of people are out of work right
00:35:53 now but if you are able to afford it please go to the website become a member or donate to help us
00:35:59 get this poll done um god we just got comments pulling in here we can hardly uh stay on top of
00:36:07 it but we're we're seeing a hell of a lot just a reminder to folks uh we will only display your
00:36:12 comments if they're relatively short uh here i'll find an example of one we cannot display here see
00:36:19 if it looks like we're drowning in comments we don't show comments like that it's not because
00:36:24 of the content of what you're saying it's just because it's too big keep it nice and short and
00:36:29 then we can put her up on the screen uh also without swear words too would be nice yeah we've 0.98
00:36:35 got one the very latest comment right now sorry we can't show uh we'll allow shit shit's allowed 0.99
00:36:43 ass asshat um but uh we're gonna draw the line somewhere unless you're particularly funny if 0.99
00:36:51 you're if you've got a cuss in it and you're particularly funny and if dave and i have been 0.98
00:36:56 drinking maybe maybe we'll put you up but uh so just just be aware there's some ground rules uh
00:37:06 dave anything else before we wrap up i'd like to ask you a favor if you could derek could you turn
00:37:11 off the news taps for just like an hour or so this afternoon so we can all watch canada russia
00:37:16 in the junior year oh uh you got to take that up with the government uh god it has been exhausting
00:37:22 um i haven't had much of a weekend i'm not sad about it because our our readership numbers are
00:37:28 off the chart uh you know some of our viewers might know last month we had 1.3 million readers
00:37:36 on the western standard that makes us one of the biggest news websites in all canada not just the
00:37:41 west but on a national stage uh it's absolutely phenomenal and it's thanks to our members who
00:37:47 are contributing to help us do this without government bailouts and to our great journalists
00:37:51 and columnists uh like dave who is just an absolute machine uh you were working at midnight
00:37:57 last night uh i think the last one of the day was the um where you had the inside scoop on
00:38:04 allard resigning the western standard was the only source in canada that was able to confirm
00:38:08 uh that she was expected to resign today and that turned out to be true uh although between you and
00:38:13 me dave um even if she didn't uh even if it turned out not to be true i think it was inevitable
00:38:18 that our story would eventually be right so even even if our source was bad we
00:38:23 would the story would probably still be correct so like we could have like a
00:38:29 broken clock you only have to be right twice a day right indeed indeed all right
00:38:34 well thank you very much Dave and thank you all our viewers who have joined us
00:38:38 today to our members thank you so much from the bottom of our hearts for
00:38:42 contributing to us bailout free media and all of you who enjoy the work of the
00:38:47 Western Standard who enjoy having an independent Western media outlet that refuses to accept the
00:38:53 Trudeau government's media bailout dollars, please become a Western Standard member. We can only do
00:38:58 this with your support. We can continue to grow our operations, hold governments to account,
00:39:03 and provide important stories to Westerners. Go to westernstandardonline.com, click on membership
00:39:09 for just a couple bucks a month. You can ensure that you've got a Western media outlet that's
00:39:14 on your side. Thank you all very much for joining us today. God bless. Enjoy the end of your holidays.
00:39:44 You