Western Standard - November 20, 2025


Budget Vote: The secret Liberal–Conservative coalition?

Topics
Mentioned
Western Standard News Update | 19 Nov 2025 Anonymous letter blocks new Calgary councillor from key board

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

177.88

Word count

8,458

Sentence count

430

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Toxicity

36

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

William Barclay and Nigel Hannaford join us to talk about the Alberta Teachers Union strike, the use of the notwithstanding clause, and the controversy surrounding gender identity and sexual identity politics in Canada's largest media outlets.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day, today is November 19th, 2025.
00:00:28 I'm Derek Fulibrand, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching The Pipeline.
00:00:33 We've got our usual lineup in the Calgary newsroom here.
00:00:36 Western Standard, former opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford.
00:00:40 Here we are.
00:00:41 And Western Standard, senior Alberta columnist, Corey Morgan.
00:00:45 Always a pleasure.
00:00:46 Back by popular demand, we have our new Western Standard Parliament Hill correspondent, William Barclay.
00:00:55 Hey, everyone. Great to be back.
00:00:56 all right uh well we got some fun stuff from both ottawa and alberta where we're at here
00:01:03 um the secret liberal conservative coalition uh i think i'm probably overstating it a little bit
00:01:11 when i say that but uh the federal budget passed with i think it was just some the theater around
00:01:18 it it passed with the conservatives voting against it but really wanting it to pass so
00:01:23 people hiding behind curtains, literally
00:01:25 to make sure it was closed, but not
00:01:27 too close.
00:01:30 So, you know, how the Liberals are
00:01:31 now staying in power,
00:01:33 strangely, with the support
00:01:35 of the Conservatives. We'll talk about that.
00:01:38 Alberta's
00:01:39 healthcare revolution, the Global Mail reporting,
00:01:42 I haven't seen
00:01:43 comment from the government yet, but in Alberta,
00:01:45 Global Mail reporting
00:01:46 that the plan is to
00:01:49 allow doctors
00:01:51 to practice in both
00:01:53 the public and private systems which i think would constitute a pretty big breach of the
00:01:58 canada health act which i think is awesome because ottawa has no damned business uh telling doctors
00:02:06 what they can do in provinces because health care is under strict provincial jurisdiction
00:02:10 uh so that that's big news and the usual suspects their heads are blowing up right now it's glorious
00:02:18 to watch. But first, we'll start something also closer to home here in Alberta. The notwithstanding
00:02:26 clause was used just the other week to legislate the Alberta Teachers Union back to work. They were
00:02:33 being obstinate, just not even negotiating. They were offered massive raises. So that, nope, not
00:02:39 good. We're not even talking. It looked like this was a strike. They could have drawn out forever.
00:02:44 I think they actually wanted to be legislated back to work.
00:02:47 I just don't think they expected the government to invoke the notwithstanding clause to do it.
00:02:51 Now we find out that the notwithstanding clause is going to be invoked to protect three pieces of legislation
00:03:02 that passed last spring around legislation that involves trans issues,
00:03:08 around keeping biological males out of biological female sports,
00:03:12 restrictions on stopping people who are minors from transitioning
00:03:20 and banning schools from hiding the fact that their child might be using different pronouns
00:03:29 and going by a different gender than the one that they were born with
00:03:32 and that nature has assigned to them.
00:03:35 Those pieces of legislation have already passed in a normal, civilized country.
00:03:41 That legislation, Corey, would easily withstand a charter challenge, but in this country, with these judges, with their rather liberal view of the charter, you never really know.
00:03:57 It would not be beyond the pale for them to say that, no, it is a violation of your, you know, your equality rights under the Charter to not be allowed to, you know, wrestle against little girls when you're born a man or born a male.
00:04:16 So preemptively protecting these pieces of legislation from Charter Challenge, I saw a bunch of weepy people on the CBC.
00:04:26 The CBC was so deferential.
00:04:29 I mean, you know, you have hostile interviews.
00:04:32 You have friendly interviews.
00:04:33 I've done friendly interviews.
00:04:35 It's fine.
00:04:36 But I'm not working for the national broadcaster, as they call themselves, the state broadcaster.
00:04:42 Just these, oh, how does this make you feel?
00:04:46 You know, they're interviewing some woman who claims that I think her boy is a girl.
00:04:53 I don't know their particular circumstances.
00:04:56 Mathematically, it's probably just not actually the case.
00:04:59 You know, it's a nosering, usual, what is it, reverse Munchausen-looking person.
00:05:10 But I can't say, I don't know the details of that case. 1.00
00:05:13 But most of these cases, it's bullshit. It's made up. 0.99
00:05:16 And they had this weepy interview.
00:05:17 The CBC is running the normal propaganda line on this,
00:05:21 even though the overwhelming majority of Albertans support this legislation,
00:05:24 keeping biological males out of female sports, 0.93
00:05:29 stopping minors from transitioning, that kind of thing.
00:05:35 But, yeah, it's the usual suspects lining up on it.
00:05:39 But, I don't know, Alberta had not used the notwithstanding clause ever
00:05:42 until extremely recently, and now we're,
00:05:46 well, if there was eight in the chamber, we only got four left.
00:05:48 Yeah, they didn't hesitate, and it's not just the CBC.
00:05:51 I torment myself with some conventional talk radio
00:05:53 in the mornings on the way here.
00:05:55 And they were interviewing a similar Munchausen by proxy mother
00:05:58 who was talking about her preteen child
00:06:00 who now is just going to be devastated and ruined
00:06:03 because apparently they weren't allowed to interfere
00:06:05 with her development chemically for drugs.
00:06:09 It's absurdity.
00:06:10 And I appreciate the Smith government
00:06:12 saying the quiet part out loud with this.
00:06:15 European countries have brought in similar legislation.
00:06:17 You hear silence from the left from that
00:06:18 in the world of progressiveness that, you know,
00:06:21 Let's quit pretending that interfering with a natural body's progression from childhood to adulthood, which is called puberty, isn't a radical intervention, isn't potentially dangerous, you know, will not lead to permanent consequences.
00:06:35 Let's quit pretending that boys can compete in girls' sports and not cause risk and damage and things. 1.00
00:06:41 I mean, as you said, the majority of people looking at that know that this is not, it's absurd that we even had to legislate to stop these things.
00:06:48 but it also shows us as you said that the lack of trust in the courts we don't expect common
00:06:53 sense from our courts anymore do we want to have to waste the time of having all the hearings from
00:06:57 these lunatics from the activists from the weepy swords from the ninchies uh only to have some
00:07:03 crazy court rule against it perhaps and then you have to invoke the notwithstanding clause then so 0.73
00:07:07 let's just do it right now get it out of the way and we're done but uh boy you know the reaction
00:07:12 in canada when alberta uses the notwithstanding clause as compared to quebec using the laws no
00:07:16 Sure is night and day, isn't it?
00:07:18 Yeah.
00:07:19 You know, I'll go to William.
00:07:23 I'm generally supportive of this.
00:07:26 I mean, this is kind of the legislative nuclear option.
00:07:31 But I don't want us to be over-trigger happy about use of the notwithstanding clause.
00:07:35 The Charter has some good purposes.
00:07:39 I think it's been a very weird constitutional ingredient into a Westminster Parliament.
00:07:46 where normally Parliament is supreme and not a written constitution.
00:07:51 That's an American import into our system, but it's there,
00:07:54 and it has sometimes been beneficial, sometimes not.
00:07:59 But, I mean, the courts have done themselves no favors here.
00:08:03 You know, when they argue in the court's rule that,
00:08:05 yeah, we're going to give this guy a lighter sentence
00:08:07 so that we don't compromise his ability to stay in Canada
00:08:10 and he doesn't get deported, that is pure.
00:08:16 that no reasonable person, I think, would support.
00:08:19 I mean, it'd be a very small percentage of the population
00:08:21 back in that kind of thing.
00:08:23 The courts are supposed to be above politics.
00:08:25 They're supposed to be above the sentiments of the mob
00:08:27 because the mob can very often be wrong.
00:08:31 So I want to be able to trust the courts here.
00:08:36 The problem is we can't.
00:08:38 But are we, by starting to, you know,
00:08:42 preemptively use the notwithstanding clause here,
00:08:45 is it does that run the risk of making the charter meaningless making judicial independence
00:08:51 meaningless your thoughts uh so for me first of all i think it's crazy when we're talking about
00:08:57 the charter of right and charter and this kind of stuff like that it's crazy when the liberal
00:09:00 government was busy literally violating the canadian charter of rights and freedoms invoking
00:09:04 the emergencies act uh using the law canada's democratic processes illegally and unreasonably
00:09:09 it's not just me saying that's a federal court uh no one on the left had anything to say in fact
00:09:13 they defended those actions right but now when we have the law right and canada's fundamental
00:09:18 democratic purposes they're being used legally like the way that they're intended to be used
00:09:21 right um albeit in a way the left isn't like they're they're up in arms and i think that
00:09:25 speech volumes has never been about human rights it's always been about imposing your beliefs on
00:09:29 others and for their own good no left and i think less and i think that's the modern left for you
00:09:33 i think that actually like one of the things that's kind of funny to me is that we've heard
00:09:36 this talk about this uneasy alliance between like let's say islamic extremists and left-wing radicals
00:09:41 not a communist, right? But I don't think it's an uneasy or tense alliance at all. It's really
00:09:44 quite an intimate relationship. And they share a ton of ideological similarities. They're more
00:09:49 similar, I think, in fact, than not. They both espouse a rigid gender ideology and impose it on 1.00
00:09:54 all and sundry. They both think that fundamental human rights, like free speech and freedom of
00:09:59 belief, mean nothing. And violence to them is ultimately the answer to any disagreement with
00:10:03 their dogma i guess the same same to you nigel i i would i support the use here these are common 0.87
00:10:10 sense pieces of legislation overwhelmingly supported by most albertans the ndp of you know
00:10:16 this is one of those it's not even a 70 30 issue it's an 80 20 like overwhelmingly people are on
00:10:21 side with this kind of stuff the ndp is is captured by the hard end of its base that happens to
00:10:27 parties sometimes uh i maybe have been a part of it myself but uh they've taken the 20 side of an
00:10:33 question here.
00:10:36 I'm not sure.
00:10:38 I guess they just can't bear to piss off
00:10:41 their kind of radical progressivist 0.65
00:10:43 sex Marxism. 0.96
00:10:46 I don't know what the hell you call this. 0.95
00:10:49 But
00:10:49 they still remain on that side.
00:10:54 The legacy media
00:10:55 seems almost...
00:10:57 There'll be a couple of columnists who dissent here and there.
00:10:59 I'm guessing. You'll see a Rick Bell
00:11:01 speak out in support
00:11:03 dissenting from the rest of the media
00:11:04 but the legacy media
00:11:07 are still overwhelmingly on that side
00:11:09 I don't know why
00:11:11 they're as captured though as say the
00:11:13 NDP. The NDP has political pressures
00:11:15 internally that are going to keep them
00:11:17 on the 20 side of that AD question
00:11:19 I don't know
00:11:20 why is the CBC still
00:11:22 doing this? They don't have
00:11:25 market pressures, they don't have some kind of
00:11:26 political pressures. Well I don't know that that's
00:11:29 the case actually Derek
00:11:30 because, you know, Canada's national semi-official news agency
00:11:34 is funded by the government,
00:11:37 and Heritage Canada definitely has a point of view on these things.
00:11:43 You might recall that when we were speaking with John Hilton O'Brien
00:11:46 the last couple of months, 0.92
00:11:49 he was explaining how some of the gay sex books
00:11:54 that we object to in the school libraries,
00:11:57 Actually, the plan originates, it's funded through Heritage Canada.
00:12:01 Well, why would they care?
00:12:03 You know, I honestly don't know, but they clearly do.
00:12:06 And the same people would be talking to CBCs.
00:12:10 Put that together with the fact that women tend to be empathetic more than men do.
00:12:17 and will see perhaps the painful dilemma that some poor kids going through puberty all mixed up to hell
00:12:28 and just say, well, totally unwise, but say, well, let them change.
00:12:35 Danielle Speth, to her credit, is a little bit more hard-nosed than that. 1.00
00:12:39 She realizes that with parental support and good counsel, they'll get through it.
00:12:43 and they'll come out at the end of it the other side with a perfectly normal disposition you just
00:12:49 have to stop them from doing something that's going to ruin them for life when they're 13 years
00:12:55 old what knows we don't let them drive why would we let them make a decision like you're not allowed
00:13:00 to get a tattoo you shouldn't allow it to be uh you mess it with your kids uh yeah that's a pieces
00:13:06 another analogy i mean the chemicals used to stunt puberty are the same used for chemical
00:13:12 castration in places where they do that with sex offenders and that was found to be inhumane for
00:13:16 sex offenders but we're talking about putting it into 13 14 year old kids i mean this is just such
00:13:22 a bizarre it's all the intent doesn't it but anyway the point is she used the she she knows
00:13:28 what the voters want the thing that the charter cost us is the as uh represented the representational
00:13:36 democracy basically if you have a problem you get a lawyer and go to court you don't go to see your
00:13:42 MP. They'll get overruled by the
00:13:44 courts anyway. But the
00:13:46 notwithstanding clause was there for this
00:13:48 express purpose of taking back
00:13:50 control. Well, she took
00:13:52 back control. Power to her. 1.00
00:13:54 All right.
00:13:57 So,
00:13:58 the fight here is
00:14:00 with courts.
00:14:02 The next fight,
00:14:04 I think, is
00:14:05 Danielle spit this pick in here. 1.00
00:14:08 If this globe story is in fact
00:14:10 accurate. I have not seen it denied, so
00:14:12 I'm going to go on the basis that it is, because I hope very much that this is true.
00:14:19 You know, during the UCP leadership, I moderated a debate between herself and two of the other
00:14:25 leading candidates, and I asked them all, including Smith, you know, everyone talks
00:14:31 about, oh, I'm going to fix health care, and I'm going to tinker here, and I'm going to
00:14:34 tinker there.
00:14:36 And, you know, it's been 54 years, and the system is worse than ever.
00:14:40 I mean, you've had 54 years to make single-payer government monopoly healthcare work, and it has failed.
00:14:48 And I asked them, you know, are you willing to break the Canada Health Act?
00:14:54 And all of them either said no, or variations of dancing around the question to more or less say no without saying it explicitly.
00:15:05 This looks like it.
00:15:06 So the Globe is reporting that they're going to allow doctors to practice in both the public and the private system.
00:15:17 That opens the door to a lot more private.
00:15:19 Now, I mean, pearl-clutching types in Canada are going to say, oh my god, this means two-tier health care.
00:15:25 The whole planet has two-tier health care.
00:15:28 Canada has two-tier health care.
00:15:29 It's called America.
00:15:30 The extremely wealthy, I know a couple of them, they just go to the United States.
00:15:36 get an MRI. They get cancer screening. They get this stuff done. I pay out of pocket. They could
00:15:43 do that by allowing it to Canada, allowing private insurance. That's going to be what we now need is
00:15:47 private insurance for primary care, not just secondary care and bells and whistles, if I can
00:15:55 call it that. But this is a big, big step that would be a direct violation of the Canada Health
00:16:00 Act. Now, for those
00:16:02 following at home,
00:16:05 Alberta is not
00:16:06 bound by the Canada Health Act, because that is
00:16:08 federal legislation. That just
00:16:10 says that the federal government could then
00:16:12 stop healthcare transfers
00:16:14 to a province that breaks the
00:16:16 Canada Health Act. A normal
00:16:18 person looking at the Constitution would say, that's
00:16:20 unconstitutional, but our courts, being
00:16:22 our courts, ruled it's fine
00:16:24 because it's just giving money around. It's not telling them
00:16:26 what to do.
00:16:29 But yeah, Nigel, I think
00:16:30 uh this is a ballsy one um like this is the this has been the third rail of canadian politics
00:16:36 uh for my entire life proceeding even out a bit uh to the point where even stockwell they had to
00:16:43 hold up a sign during a national leaders debate when he was a leader of the alliance saying no
00:16:47 two-tier health care uh is the taboo broken i hope so i assure your sentiments entirely when
00:16:55 were pounding the desk there a moment this i mean this is a very old daniel smith idea from way back
00:17:01 when she was in the calgary herald editorial board shoes and saying you know one of many things that
00:17:07 we can do to get the system moving is let doctors pick up work on the side i think she probably 0.96
00:17:12 phrased it a little more elegantly than that but that was the essence of it um you know what's the
00:17:18 point of having medical facilities ready to go but you're not allowed to use them because there
00:17:22 isn't a budget for them here you are you're waiting for a medical procedure there is the
00:17:28 operating theater there is the empty slab there is the doctor who's reading a book why because
00:17:35 the government doesn't have the funds to put him to work all right hey what i got funds fix me
00:17:44 why would you not do that why would the government and this is true of governments right across
00:17:49 calendar they'll let you spend your money on all kinds of things that are bad for you but you try
00:17:55 and spend your money on something that's good for you like getting a i mean it's illegal uh
00:18:00 can't have that you know uh i mean what's the matter with these people this is absolute common
00:18:05 sense i i hope like you i haven't seen any documentation i haven't seen a i haven't seen
00:18:11 the draft i haven't seen the leaked document uh i've only got the globe and mail to go on and
00:18:16 usually the bloke has got something before they go to press so i'm inclined to think that this is a
00:18:21 real story i haven't denied it so well no they haven't denied it so let's hope it's going to
00:18:26 happen now the question is when uh when rolf klein years and years ago you'll remember this
00:18:33 he had a plan to try and take care of the problem in waiting rooms where people were frankly abusing
00:18:40 the system uh showing up on a sunday night with a sniffle they could have come in on friday they
00:18:45 I could have, you know, like people who didn't need to be in emergency,
00:18:48 was showing up in emergency.
00:18:49 I said, all right, we'll charge you $10 just for coming in for a visit.
00:18:55 Just a little bit of money out of pocket, people adjust their behavior.
00:18:59 Well, that was terrible.
00:19:00 We couldn't do that.
00:19:01 That's a violation of the Canada Health Act.
00:19:04 We're going to withhold the CHST, as it was called in those days,
00:19:07 Canada Health and Social Transfer, famous.
00:19:10 And, well, I mean, I don't know whether anybody would have done any different,
00:19:15 but Mr. Klein said, all right, and that was that.
00:19:19 And then he doubled down and introduced Bill 11 to actually outlaw private hospitals in Alberta,
00:19:26 and that law was still in effect.
00:19:28 So I like the idea of this.
00:19:29 I'd like to see Bill 11 abolished, and maybe we put some hospitals in Alberta
00:19:37 and go looking for business outside of Alberta,
00:19:41 bring the cost of procedures down through competition
00:19:48 and really start to make a difference 0.73
00:19:50 because what's happening now is ridiculous.
00:19:53 Well, William, if we do this in Alberta, 0.72
00:19:56 we're going to have some competition
00:19:58 because we're not the first, actually.
00:19:59 Quebec allows this.
00:20:01 There was the Chiouli decision.
00:20:03 God, that must have been, what, 20 years ago?
00:20:05 2002, I think it was.
00:20:06 Okay, yeah, over 20 years ago, we had the Sheoli decision, found it was, I forget the exact one, but it was found that access to a waiting list does not cost you access to health care, and banning people from then going and paying for their own health care was therefore a violation of security of the person, your right to liberty and life, and as I write to life and all that.
00:20:30 But Quebec has had this for a long time, but no one likes to talk about it.
00:20:37 It seems to fly below the radar.
00:20:40 So the fact that Quebec's been doing this for 20 years, I don't know.
00:20:45 Do you think this gives Alberta some cover from reprisal from Ottawa?
00:20:50 That if Alberta goes for this, they can't turn around and penalize Alberta 0.98
00:20:54 if it's already been allowed in Quebec for over 20 years?
00:20:58 You know, it should, but, you know, Quebec is treated very uniquely.
00:21:01 I think the other thing is that Alberta is being rendered kind of synonymous with the
00:21:04 conservative and the right in Canada.
00:21:06 And so they can't do anything right.
00:21:07 They're ultimately the cause of every problem.
00:21:10 But you're right.
00:21:11 It shouldn't be controversial at all.
00:21:12 In fact, the strongest, the best health care systems in the world in Japan and Europe use
00:21:16 similar system.
00:21:17 I'm in America a fair bit, and I'm plugged into a lot of conversations and you hear it
00:21:20 everywhere in the States.
00:21:22 Amongst the socialists, our Canada's public health care system is so great.
00:21:24 everybody gets to see the doctor not just a rich and it's simply not true nobody gets to see the
00:21:28 doctors here i think that's the problem rich poor no one uh they're years long waiting lists for
00:21:33 even urgent operations and people routinely die on the waitlist without getting to see their doctors
00:21:37 and it's so bad they're offering just to they were offering to kill people ourselves now with
00:21:41 maid right uh because uh and our most vulnerable populations at that i thought that we're trying to
00:21:45 be the most european of nations you know why the opposition it's just weird to me maybe the
00:21:49 weirdest thing is that it's alberta that's suddenly so progressive uh you know but you hit it on the
00:21:53 the head. All the opposition is because it's
00:21:55 a conservative idea. And again, from
00:21:57 Danielle Smith, who is, again, that
00:21:59 avatar of all that's bad 1.00
00:22:02 in Canada, all conservatism, populism,
00:22:04 and that's why it's been so rejected.
00:22:08 Corey, as I was saying with Nigel,
00:22:09 this has been the third rail
00:22:11 in Canadian politics forever.
00:22:14 Ralph Klein had his third way
00:22:15 he proposed, and that
00:22:17 obviously hit a brick wall,
00:22:19 politically.
00:22:21 This hasn't been announced. It's just come out
00:22:23 through the globe because it's carrie tate in the globe i'm guessing this is not a strategic leak
00:22:28 this was not intentional someone in the government i don't know it could be a political staffer could
00:22:33 be a member of the legislature could be a bureaucrat uh someone who doesn't like it
00:22:39 probably gave it i think this was intended to be a negative story but i i'm i'm like oh well
00:22:45 this is some of the best news we've gotten more of this um but i mean it's it's not going to be
00:22:52 without political controversy.
00:22:55 I think there's, you know,
00:22:57 especially among, I think, younger people,
00:23:00 the cult status of universal healthcare.
00:23:06 Young people today have never remembered
00:23:08 a time where it worked
00:23:09 because it never has worked.
00:23:12 It's never worked in my time.
00:23:14 I don't know if it's ever even worked
00:23:16 in your guy's time. 1.00
00:23:17 It's always been crap. 0.99
00:23:18 I mean, you know, 0.99
00:23:19 when I crashed a motorcycle
00:23:20 and I was in really serious, critical condition,
00:23:23 I'm pretty good.
00:23:25 As soon as I was kind of patched back together
00:23:26 and I needed to start learning to walk again, 0.97
00:23:29 turned to crap, and I just went to private. 0.93
00:23:30 I exited the public system at that time. 0.98
00:23:33 But for the most part, you know,
00:23:34 I've had non-life-threatening issues. 0.99
00:23:38 It's crap. 0.99
00:23:38 I've sat in an emergency room bleeding out, 1.00
00:23:41 trying to hold blood inside
00:23:43 from passing out in the waiting room.
00:23:49 But I don't know.
00:23:50 Do you think we're at the time where this is now entered the politically possible, or is this still just too much of a sacred cow?
00:23:58 I don't know.
00:23:59 I hope that, you know, the thing that has to be done is we've got to chip away at the orthodoxy.
00:24:02 And maybe the next generation hasn't been as trained, at least, as we were when we were younger.
00:24:07 It was always Canada has the best system in the world.
00:24:09 Canada has the best system in the world.
00:24:10 And it's not.
00:24:11 It's not by any measure any longer, not even close.
00:24:14 It's low and it's plummeting.
00:24:16 uh we want to we've got to become to use the leftist term non-binary let's bring this discussion
00:24:22 people even non-binary yeah let's bring it out of the there's just the american and canadian
00:24:28 systems because that's the narrative they've put together and in reality there's dozens and
00:24:32 dozens of universal systems all over the world many if not most of which are outperforming us
00:24:37 but we've got to start looking at them i mean we've got to bring that discussion to that why
00:24:41 can't we look at the netherlands why can't we look at france why can't we look at singapore
00:24:45 We can't wait to look at any other system on the planet other than North Korea and Cuba, which are the only other two that ban private health care.
00:24:53 Exactly. But we need to change that narrative for this to get through so it won't be as controversial.
00:24:57 We need to have that rational discussion without the screaming of the unions and the rest to say, look, let's emulate what's working best and bring it here.
00:25:05 That's a rational discussion. You've been around long enough.
00:25:08 I'm asking for a lot long enough. That's not going to happen.
00:25:10 Well, and the punitive aspect from the feds, we should turn that around and at least point
00:25:14 at, yes, the Canada Health Act says this, but it also initially said the feds were going
00:25:17 to cover 50% of our healthcare and they only cover about 20, which is not insignificant.
00:25:22 If they cut that out of a transfer, it's going to hurt the province dearly in health provision
00:25:26 if this came to that kind of battle, but the feds aren't holding up their side of it either.
00:25:31 If they think it's affordable for us to maintain this system, then they should think they should
00:25:35 be able to afford to fund 50% of it and they aren't even close.
00:25:38 So we've got to take that back to them.
00:25:41 Unfortunately, it starts through a leak.
00:25:43 It starts at the same time that it looks like the provincial government might have messed up the laboratory contracts and things such as that, which reduces trust when it comes to these things.
00:25:54 But as I said, we welcome the discussion, but that's us.
00:25:58 Will the public?
00:25:58 That's the bigger question.
00:25:59 Anyone from the premier or health minister's office watching, you should have just leaked it to us.
00:26:06 The globe got it anyway.
00:26:07 you should have just given it
00:26:09 to us
00:26:10 although I don't think the global article was
00:26:13 it wasn't terribly unfair
00:26:14 it was actually a fairly fair piece
00:26:18 a veteran journalist
00:26:19 yeah
00:26:20 it wasn't some torqued up
00:26:23 the world, the sky is going to fall
00:26:25 I think it was actually
00:26:27 a fair piece, I know some of you are going to hate on me
00:26:29 for saying that
00:26:31 credit where it's due, I think it was fair
00:26:34 alright
00:26:36 Right. I think, too, like you guys have all hit on a very important point.
00:26:39 I think it's like Canada has changed, right?
00:26:41 Maybe a long time ago in Canada, far, far away, like one that wasn't crippled by a crumbling economy, rampant crime and unbridled, unregulated international migration.
00:26:49 Maybe there and then a completely public health care system worked, but it hasn't worked in this Canada, our Canada for quite some time.
00:26:55 You know, never mind what happened during COVID.
00:26:56 I think that's the other kind of lurking ghoul in all this, right?
00:26:59 COVID, the pandemic has eroded the public's trust in the state health care apparatus collectively.
00:27:04 I mean, I don't think there's really any going back from that.
00:27:07 Yeah.
00:27:07 Also, you've got to remember, we've imported a ridiculous number of people into this country lately, 1.00
00:27:12 and they have not been propagandized that Canada has the great...
00:27:16 Oh, actually, it's funny.
00:27:18 The federal government actually is advertising that Canada has free health care to migrate.
00:27:22 They're like, come here, work for not a lot of money, so you're also not paying a lot of taxes,
00:27:27 and enjoy free health care.
00:27:28 We're advertising free health care, free.
00:27:31 but they're not
00:27:33 they haven't spent their life being propagandized
00:27:35 with this
00:27:36 Canada's got the 0.89
00:27:38 crappiest, wimpiest myths 0.97
00:27:41 countries are
00:27:43 some have described countries as
00:27:45 a group of people with shared myths and stories
00:27:47 well
00:27:49 we've gotten rid of all the real ones
00:27:51 that we were down to
00:27:52 and where we have this great universal health
00:27:55 the greatest healthcare system in the world
00:27:57 and we're peace and order
00:27:59 we don't have peace and order in our streets 1.00
00:28:01 our healthcare system is dog shit 1.00
00:28:03 all of these 0.99
00:28:04 myths that come out of the Trudopian 0.98
00:28:06 era of Trudeau the first
00:28:08 I don't think they have a lot of
00:28:11 currency anymore
00:28:12 present company excluded
00:28:14 I think it only holds
00:28:17 with segments of the boomers
00:28:19 and that's about it
00:28:21 at this time
00:28:22 I don't think people my age and younger
00:28:25 think around yeah that's what makes
00:28:27 me Canadian
00:28:28 free grade health care and public order in the streets because yeah that's that's what we're
00:28:33 getting in this country right now well i don't think anybody would be able to really define what
00:28:37 it means to be canadian right now outside of without using not american in some way i think
00:28:41 you went to the average canadian on the street all the pillars would have meant to be canadian
00:28:44 have eroded and collapsed spectacularly right um i think that one of the best points is all of our
00:28:49 doctors are actually leaving to go to these other health care systems they've lost faith in canada
00:28:53 systems uh in our political apparatus as a whole i think it's half of canadian youth uh they were
00:28:58 in favor of becoming america's 51st state at the at the close of the last election i think that's
00:29:02 telling that's their entire future half of our future please no future in canada okay well i'm
00:29:06 gonna come come to you first on the next one william uh the secret liberal conservative
00:29:12 coalition i i say that a little tongue-in-cheek you know the conservatives were always talking
00:29:17 about the the liberal NDP coalition that was a it was strictly speaking a coalition government in
00:29:24 the old sense but it was a formal working agreement that I think you could say fairly
00:29:29 constitute a coalition of a kind uh the conservatives can do not want to be seen
00:29:35 as the successors to the NDP in that coalition we saw how well that worked for the NDP in the
00:29:40 last election when they were utterly obliterated didn't even get official party status and had the
00:29:45 worst result, not just in
00:29:47 the history of the NDP, and not
00:29:49 just in the history of even the CCF, but
00:29:51 even the precursors to the
00:29:53 CCF, what they're, you know, kind of the odd little
00:29:55 radical Labour Party around.
00:29:57 They got annihilated. The Conservatives
00:29:59 voter base do not
00:30:01 want to be seen to be propping up the Liberals.
00:30:03 But, they don't
00:30:05 want an election right now. The polls are not great.
00:30:08 They went into the last election
00:30:09 doing pretty well, and then
00:30:11 obviously kind of blew it.
00:30:13 Their voter code, they got
00:30:15 a lot of votes. Their vote went up, but obviously
00:30:17 the Liberal vote went up even more with the
00:30:19 disillusion of the NDP.
00:30:21 The Conservatives wanted to desperately
00:30:23 avoid an election. The Liberals got
00:30:25 Elizabeth May's vote,
00:30:27 but the Conservatives had, I think,
00:30:29 two abstentions. One
00:30:31 was Shannon Phillips,
00:30:33 who they said was having
00:30:35 a medical procedure
00:30:37 or something. I don't know.
00:30:39 I haven't talked to her, but
00:30:41 often when that's the case, if you
00:30:43 when that's the case, the
00:30:45 whips will coordinate and say fine we have someone who has a very serious medical issue
00:30:48 then you pair off someone on your side i mean that that's the way these things have gone on for
00:30:55 over a hundred years the liberals did not have a similar abstention on their side and i'm not
00:31:00 aware of the conservatives making any effort to get one uh but i've not talked to shannon phillips
00:31:05 no idea about the actual circumstance but that's that's what's been said the other one was matt
00:31:10 Jenneru.
00:31:13 There's a riddle wrapped
00:31:14 inside an enigma of a news story
00:31:16 about what actually happened. Word
00:31:18 was he was going to cross the floor to the liberals
00:31:20 and then he says, no, I'm not.
00:31:22 I'm retiring, but I'm not retiring
00:31:24 right away. Doesn't really
00:31:26 say what for. The whole thing
00:31:28 smells. I haven't
00:31:30 made heads or tails of it, but the thing smells.
00:31:32 And he didn't vote, but he hasn't
00:31:34 resigned from parliament yet. He has not
00:31:36 resigned. He is still sitting as a conservative
00:31:38 MP and he didn't show up on the budget.
00:31:40 And then, adding to this, the conservative, I think, Andrew Shearer's house leader, right?
00:31:49 No, it's, what's her name?
00:31:52 Oh, Lanceman.
00:31:53 Well, she's a deputy leader. 0.51
00:31:54 Oh, house leader, yeah.
00:31:56 She's a deputy leader.
00:31:57 She is the house leader.
00:31:59 That's the guy responsible, along with the whip, for making sure everything going on in the house goes according to plan and everyone's there on time, etc.
00:32:07 He was
00:32:09 found
00:32:12 on the camera
00:32:14 watching Parliament. You could see him
00:32:15 kind of hiding
00:32:16 beneath, behind those curtains
00:32:19 that are behind the back benches in
00:32:22 there, and
00:32:22 then I guess when it looked like, okay,
00:32:25 we don't have enough votes to actually
00:32:27 defeat the budget and therefore trigger an election,
00:32:30 then he came out to vote
00:32:31 God on the record is voting against.
00:32:36 Okay, guys.
00:32:37 I know the conservatives don't like the budget.
00:32:40 It's not a conservative budget.
00:32:41 It does cut taxes, doesn't really cut spending.
00:32:45 It's not a great budget.
00:32:46 But they don't want an election.
00:32:48 William, I don't know.
00:32:51 Am I just too much of a bloody conspiracy theorist here?
00:32:54 Or did the conservatives intentionally not defeat the budget?
00:33:00 No, it reeks to high heaven.
00:33:02 I think you're bang on.
00:33:02 I think that this is exactly why Trump and draining the swamp,
00:33:06 what people call populism nowadays, which is really just a democracy relabeled,
00:33:10 why it all became so popular a decade ago. Corruption abounds. There appear to be no
00:33:15 real alternatives. And let's be clear here, it wasn't just the Conservatives. Every party
00:33:19 participated in the subversion of Canada's democracy, the NDP, the Green Party, everybody
00:33:23 was party to the plot. And you could even say that this kind of corrupt undemocratic garbage, 0.99
00:33:28 because that is what it is, let's call a spade a spade, is what underlies the current incredible 0.99
00:33:32 popularity of the secessionist movement in Alberta. I mean, even Quebec, if I understand
00:33:36 correctly, rumblings are starting. And the big problem, the major problem is that Pierre
00:33:40 Belyab is either party to it all or powerless against it, or at least that's how it looks 1.00
00:33:44 to everyone in Canada. And I think the budget passing and not having an election is ultimately
00:33:48 going to be framed or justified as something not good for Canada. But what are we really
00:33:51 talking about here? Is the Liberal government good for Canada? No, not at all. And so to
00:33:55 me, I think the really only recourse is to have the election. I mean, I know that we
00:33:58 don't want it. It isn't the right moment. But then we turn around, we start complaining
00:34:02 about how bad things are in Canada. The only way to fix
00:34:04 it, the only way to get through it, is through an election.
00:34:07 Sorry.
00:34:08 We just had a test
00:34:10 of the Alberta emergency alert
00:34:11 system coming through, so I believe that
00:34:13 in the show. Let people know. It works.
00:34:15 That was a lot. I thought it was my mic again.
00:34:17 No, then they're going to see we pre-report it.
00:34:20 Because everyone's going to have gotten it
00:34:22 earlier in the day, or at least for our Alberta watchers.
00:34:24 I got too passionate or something.
00:34:25 Yeah, Corey
00:34:27 did... They voted against it.
00:34:29 You know, so it's not like the NDP who stood up voting that, you know, Jake Meatsing would stand up and be like, this government has failed Canadians, it sucks, it deserves to go.
00:34:41 And then he stands up and votes, yes, I'm keeping them in power, yes, I'm voting for the budget.
00:34:45 It wasn't that.
00:34:47 They voted against the budget, they spoke against the budget, but they allowed the budget to pass.
00:34:52 I think that's pretty transparent.
00:34:54 But for the average, I think the average person, is this going to get through the average Canadian voter that the Conservatives let it?
00:35:04 No, I think your average Canadian doesn't really watch how parliamentary sausage gets made.
00:35:09 I mean, this is done in minority governments.
00:35:11 It's been done a lot, many, many times.
00:35:13 As I said, I think the term used to be the parliamentary flu.
00:35:16 They come along, and as you said, the whip or the House leader is going to be watching.
00:35:19 Normally the House leader is more than halfway behind the curtain.
00:35:22 So usually a little more discretion, but then suddenly a couple of members get the Hershey squirts and vanish until they can't pass that vote possibly under any other circumstance.
00:35:32 And then they get a full recovery and come back.
00:35:35 But this can't go on too, too long, or they will suffer the fate of Jagmeet Singh.
00:35:39 You know, you can kick that can down the road because you aren't in a position to hit an election, you know, and play both sides.
00:35:45 Say that you oppose the budget yet, make sure it kind of passes.
00:35:48 but they will have to try and find themselves or they will get weakened every time this happens so
00:35:54 I mean you can't rail and say we're going to bring the government down then carefully make sure that
00:35:58 you don't actually do it too many times before you've cried wolf too many times you just look
00:36:03 too weak and people will say the same thing they did with the NDP well if the NDP is just going to
00:36:07 be liberal I might as well just vote for the liberals and it'll happen that way with the
00:36:11 conservatives I think what the conservatives would have to worry about is weakening themselves
00:36:14 so much that the liberals
00:36:17 feel they can manufacture
00:36:18 a loss of confidence
00:36:20 and go to the polls and really nail them when they
00:36:23 really don't want to go. That's what I wanted to ask you,
00:36:25 Nigel, was there was some
00:36:27 speculation the liberals would have been just happy
00:36:29 for the budget to be voted down,
00:36:31 get an election. They're higher in the polls.
00:36:33 They're only two seats away from a majority right now
00:36:35 because there was one conservative across the floor
00:36:37 of the liberals.
00:36:39 They have a de facto majority, as we've
00:36:41 been saying, but it's a tight one
00:36:43 and, you know, you have one grumpy member of caucus,
00:36:46 he's got leverage over you all of a sudden.
00:36:49 If you have an actual majority with some space,
00:36:53 you could afford, you could tell them,
00:36:55 okay, yeah, well, yeah, go ahead and vote against the budget.
00:36:57 We're kicking you out of your riding.
00:36:59 Your political career's done.
00:37:01 They don't really have that kind of leverage right now.
00:37:04 How much do you think the Liberals would have been just fine
00:37:08 for this to be defeated, go to election?
00:37:10 Oh, I think, yeah, they would have come through on it all right.
00:37:14 The polls seem to indicate that they would have had a good start.
00:37:18 But don't, everybody gets very focused on this majority.
00:37:23 Well, you've got one, or maybe you've got a majority of two or whatever.
00:37:27 Stephen Harper governed from 2006 to 2011 from a minority position.
00:37:34 That is not to say that it is fun.
00:37:37 It is hard work.
00:37:38 everyone wants a majority everybody wants a majority obviously but you're constantly wheeling
00:37:43 and dealing and making arrangements here and in some ways that's kind of good for democracy
00:37:48 and you know if you actually have to work things out with the other side
00:37:52 the result is not always bad so carney with or without a majority well he did obviously the
00:38:01 government will fall on all his budget but if he's in a minority position should somebody change
00:38:07 their mind you know he can he can still get things done it's been done before many times so um what i
00:38:14 do uh deeply deplore is why conservatives are allowing any kind of discussion over the leadership
00:38:25 of the peer polyev uh the i mean there's one thing to do it behind closed doors but it's constant
00:38:32 sort of jockeying and showing polls and people going on the tellers as well you know he's a i
00:38:37 like him but he's actually i don't like him he shouldn't be leader anymore he's had his chance
00:38:42 you're going to work with a guy this is why they're down in the polls is they're not presenting
00:38:47 a united front i don't know i it's natural they lost the election they blew a gigantic lead
00:38:54 uh i'd say the dissension is pretty mild compared to previous what leaders have faced after previous
00:39:01 defeats. Harper faced more backlash
00:39:03 after he lost his first election
00:39:05 in 2004, but he had made huge
00:39:07 gains. It was the first election of the United
00:39:09 Federal Conservative Party.
00:39:11 They had brought the Liberals from a
00:39:13 big majority down to a minority.
00:39:16 You know, in
00:39:17 you know,
00:39:19 think of British Columbia right now.
00:39:21 We're not talking about John Rustack, but you know,
00:39:23 more news broken from our
00:39:25 man, Jared Yager,
00:39:27 our reporter in BC.
00:39:29 More dissension coming there.
00:39:30 There, they're just ripping themselves apart, and that is affecting the polls.
00:39:36 But I don't think it's unhealthy for a party.
00:39:40 I think Polly Ebb is probably the best guy to lead them right now. 1.00
00:39:43 I think conservative members would be well advised to vote to renew his leadership.
00:39:47 But I think it's healthy for a party to air this in a civil way after a defeat.
00:39:56 Well, let's hope you're right.
00:39:58 i i with a uh with the leadership review coming up in january there's too many people look like
00:40:04 they're trying to position themselves for something ah that such is the nature of the
00:40:09 politics but yeah okay well what depending on that go to our parting shots first parting shot
00:40:15 to cory sure i'll start with one just something that surprised me on x it's something i railed 0.89
00:40:20 about before but i i reminded people that jody gondek and her council of clowns there had it
00:40:26 renamed Fort Calgary into the confluence a year and some ago.
00:40:30 Yeah.
00:40:31 What, I mean, people were upset with that, which is fine.
00:40:33 But what surprised me was how many people said I didn't realize she'd done that.
00:40:36 They really slid that one under the radar.
00:40:39 Uh, so I've written a, you know, some self-serving things.
00:40:42 I've written a column in the standard that came out today on that.
00:40:45 You know what?
00:40:45 This would be a good start for this council to reverse that ridiculous thing.
00:40:49 Even if it's costly, we can't let this erasure of history keep happening.
00:40:53 Rename Fort Calgary to Fort Calgary.
00:40:56 the new mayor and council have a chance to do that and set an example for these self-serving
00:41:00 ones who have their vanity work project. You're going to have it reversed if you push it through.
00:41:04 So just stick to council business and quit renaming it. I actually asked
00:41:07 Jeremy Farkas about that in an interview very soon before the election
00:41:12 and he didn't say no, but he definitely didn't say yes either
00:41:16 saying, you know, that some of the chiefs in the area would consider it a declaration
00:41:20 of war. I don't know.
00:41:24 But, I mean, Mayor Farkas, new council, show some balls.
00:41:30 Fort Calgary is pretty important to the history of Calgary, 0.99
00:41:34 and that's what it's always been until a couple of jackasses came around 1.00
00:41:37 and decided to sanitize the name.
00:41:40 I don't think it's a particular...
00:41:42 There's no statue of General Lee there, like, for God's sakes.
00:41:46 It's Fort Calgary.
00:41:47 It's the namesake of the city.
00:41:49 If you're ready to change that, the next step will be changing the actual name of the city.
00:41:52 Yeah, but you won't be able to pronounce it.
00:41:53 see the spelling element it'll be a vancouver street yeah yeah yeah okay uh william parting
00:42:00 shot cool so as y'all know i was recently invited to speak and present my essay uh canada's right
00:42:05 wing response to a decade of liberal oppression at the toronto democracy forum confronts what
00:42:09 everyone in canada the right wing of the political spectrum conservatives in canada been going
00:42:12 through over the past decade um we should have the but as i understand on the western standard
00:42:17 website sometime soon um and or y'all can head over to my twitter x to check it out my handle
00:42:22 is will barclay pcbg um please do give it a read um it's being well received so i hope you guys
00:42:27 enjoy it nodule yeah yeah so i keep i keep tabs on the bc news and there's bc human rights chief
00:42:35 one of these empathetic ladies that i was talking about earlier declares that it's colonialist to 0.99
00:42:41 stigmatized drug use drug use is i guess so legitimate anyway look at it it's just crazy
00:42:52 in bc it's not the drugs that are dangerous only the people who notice that they're dangerous are
00:42:57 wicked colonialists you know what a weird world the british empire fought several opium wars
00:43:02 to make the chinese do drugs we the empire fought wars to make sure people are doing their drugs and 0.99
00:43:10 staying docile.
00:43:12 Somehow it's now
00:43:14 colonialist
00:43:16 or imperialist to say
00:43:17 perhaps you should not
00:43:20 be addicted to drugs and have a productive life.
00:43:22 Yeah, that stooped over fentanyl addict
00:43:24 is just living his best life and we're not to
00:43:26 criticize that. That is racist, Corey.
00:43:29 Alright.
00:43:32 You've already heard it.
00:43:33 I just gotta get it off my chest.
00:43:36 The Epstein Files.
00:43:40 Oh, it's coming.
00:43:42 You know what?
00:43:43 I'm going to get...
00:43:44 We're going to get disappointed somehow.
00:43:46 Somehow, no matter what laws get passed,
00:43:48 I feel like we're just never actually going to get it.
00:43:50 I hope I'm wrong. 0.96
00:43:52 The Democrats did not give a crap about Jeffrey... 0.99
00:43:56 Actually, no, they probably did give a crap. 0.99
00:43:57 They didn't speak a word, I should say, 0.99
00:43:59 of Jeffrey Epstein for four years while Biden's in.
00:44:01 They were silent about it when Trump was in the first time.
00:44:04 They did not want it out.
00:44:06 They were silent during four years
00:44:07 when they had Biden in the White House,
00:44:09 including when they had majority control of congress um then all of a sudden they got religion
00:44:15 and they wanted out because they saw it was a big defied within the republicans the harder uh you
00:44:21 know the more mega side of the republican party wanted this out trump had been campaigning hard
00:44:26 i'm gonna release it you know this is a part of draining the swamp we're gonna release the epstein 0.85
00:44:30 files everyone's gonna get to see everything and me wins and then we got this dog you know this
00:44:36 dog and pony show of fake release of files that were already released and don't show very much
00:44:41 and then there are no files and then uh maybe there's files but if you want the files you're
00:44:46 a traitor to me and traitor mega and i don't want your support and then you had a couple of brave
00:44:52 republican members of the house break away to side with the democrats because it's a pretty
00:44:56 thin majority they used their leverage they made a power play um and then it started an avalanche
00:45:02 And Trump was saying, this is just one where he's just dead wrong.
00:45:07 And for what reason he's doing this, I don't know.
00:45:09 He's dead wrong.
00:45:10 And he was saying, you know, to his closest allies like Massey and Marjorie Taylor Greene,
00:45:14 like the people who would take a bullet for Trump, say they're traitors.
00:45:18 He called her Marjorie Trader Greene.
00:45:21 Not a bad nickname, but very imprecise, I think, in this case.
00:45:25 And we started an avalanche where you then had more than 100 Republican defectors
00:45:31 where they were able to force it to a vote on the floor.
00:45:35 Trump threw up his hands and says,
00:45:36 actually, it's good.
00:45:37 Yeah, let's actually vote for the bill
00:45:38 to release the Epstein files.
00:45:40 And then it was unanimous, except for one guy,
00:45:43 some guy, it's one lone Republican down in Louisiana
00:45:45 who voted against it.
00:45:48 I want to see what's on that guy's hard drive.
00:45:51 And then it's expected to get unanimous support
00:45:53 now in the Senate.
00:45:55 Theoretically, the Department of Justice
00:45:57 is going to be required by law
00:45:59 to release everything other than like
00:46:01 explicit images that should
00:46:03 obviously be protected for people's privacy
00:46:05 because, you know, um
00:46:07 I don't know. I don't know
00:46:10 how, but I feel like
00:46:11 an asteroid is going to come or something
00:46:13 and hit Congress. I
00:46:15 something's going to happen to stop
00:46:17 us from getting these files. I'm not
00:46:19 going to believe it until they're in my hands
00:46:21 but boy, I'm giddy.
00:46:23 Okay. Sweaty palms. Yeah.
00:46:25 You bet. Okay. Well, that's it, gentlemen.
00:46:28 Thank you very much. Okay.
00:46:29 Nigel, Corey, William, Jonathan in front of the studio here.
00:46:34 And thank all of you for joining us today on the Pipeline.
00:46:37 Remember, the Western Standard relies on people like you to support our work.
00:46:41 If you're not yet a member, go to westernstandard.news right now.
00:46:44 Click on subscribe.
00:46:45 It's $10 a month or $100 a year for unlimited access to all Western Standard content.
00:46:51 You won't hit that pesky paywall.
00:46:53 You'll get the newsletter from us in the morning.
00:46:55 You'll see us on your social feeds.
00:46:57 You click it.
00:46:57 You hit the paywall. 1.00
00:46:58 Ah, damn it. 1.00
00:46:59 well, you gotta pay. It costs money 1.00
00:47:01 to run this newsroom behind us here
00:47:03 and with our people sprinkled
00:47:05 across Canada like we got William
00:47:07 and Ottawa now. Thank you very much for joining us
00:47:09 today, and God bless.
00:47:29 We'll be right back.