Western Standard - September 19, 2025


Buy now while prices last

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Canada can’t afford free housing THE PIPELINE: Parliament is back. Is Canada on the right track?

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

157.59

Word count

3,605

Sentence count

165

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Prime Minister announced the first five projects to be fast-tracked through the Major Projects Office, and we took note that the Conservative opposition has been more focused on cost-of-living issues than major projects. With all that power, what could a budget possibly look like? What is the outlook for industrial development that is important but doesn't qualify as a major project? With me today to talk about it is Dr. Tim Sargent, an economist and former federal deputy minister who is now Director of Domestic Policy at the McDonnell-Laurier Institute in Ottawa.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:21 It is Thursday, September 18th. Parliament resumed earlier this week, and a budget is
00:00:27 set to be tabled on November the 4th, the first budget we've seen since April the 16th, 2024.
00:00:34 The Prime Minister also announced the first five projects to be fast-tracked through the
00:00:39 Major Projects Office that he has established, and we took note that the Conservative opposition
00:00:44 has been more focused on cost-of-living issues than major projects. I'm sure a lot of Canadians
00:00:51 would like to think that adults are back in charge. Perhaps they are, but what are they
00:00:56 doing with all that power? What could a budget possibly look like? What is the outlook for
00:01:01 industrial development that is important but doesn't qualify as a major project? With me today
00:01:07 to talk about it is Dr. Tim Sargent, an economist and former federal deputy minister who is now
00:01:14 Director of Domestic Policy at the famous McDonnell Laurier Institute in Ottawa. Dr. Sargent,
00:01:20 welcome to the show thank you for having me good to see you dr sargent five mega projects roll out
00:01:28 of the major projects office as parliament resumes how impressed are you well this isn't just low
00:01:36 hanging fruit this is fruit that's fallen to the ground and it has been neatly arranged in piles
00:01:41 for people to pick it up the reality is that these five projects were already through the system
00:01:47 and Darlington and Makovena are already being built. That's how far along they are.
00:01:52 Kitimat, it's an issue of financing. ContraCare is almost done. So there's really nothing special
00:01:59 about these projects. There's not a lot that really needs to be done. The risk, of course,
00:02:03 is that some of these project proponents may turn around and ask the government for
00:02:08 a financial contribution given how important the government thinks they are. Now, of course,
00:02:14 you did also have other projects talked about in that press release um but they are really at the
00:02:21 other end of the spectrum um the government's talking about the pathways project port of
00:02:26 churchill high-speed rail i mean these are projects that are really not not really thought out at all
00:02:32 i mean some of them are just a glint in a politician's eye at this point they all have
00:02:37 massive cost overrun written on them. So for me, I was hoping to see projects that are in the
00:02:45 middle of the spectrum, projects that are rail prospects where the proponents have put them
00:02:49 forward, but that are still trapped in the environmental assessment system that we have
00:02:54 in this country. Take a project like Deltaport, for instance. This assessment started about five
00:03:01 years ago. It's still only in stage two of the five-stage process for environmental assessments.
00:03:07 The time limit that the Impact Assessment Authority has put on that is 2028.
00:03:13 So we're talking about eight years for approval for a major expansion of the Port of Vancouver
00:03:19 that could have enormous economic benefit for the whole country.
00:03:23 Well, I thought the idea of the Major Projects Office would speed things up.
00:03:29 So I guess not necessarily.
00:03:33 Well, it's certainly not being used for that right now.
00:03:37 perhaps they'll have a role. But the challenge is you're adding a level of bureaucracy onto
00:03:42 a bureaucracy that's already overbuilt, that already has lots of levels. So you're just
00:03:46 introducing a new character into this play, as opposed to a wholesale reform of the system.
00:03:53 And so what we're ending up with is, yes, there's a couple of projects that end up on the wish list
00:03:58 that the prime minister likes, prime minister's office likes, some provincial premiers like,
00:04:04 and the system is focused on them,
00:04:06 but what about all of the other projects that are out there
00:04:09 that could really provide quite a big boost to the economy
00:04:12 if they were all able to move forward a lot faster?
00:04:15 Well, that, of course, is one of the things that we thought
00:04:18 right from the very beginning.
00:04:19 And I think sort of from the economic studies that we took 50 years ago
00:04:24 or 20 years ago, there's an assumption that the big projects
00:04:30 will start the ball rolling
00:04:34 and all the little projects
00:04:35 will just get swept along with it
00:04:37 because it's spinoffs, isn't it?
00:04:41 But that's not what I'm hearing you say.
00:04:43 These major projects may or may not go far fast,
00:04:47 but the other ones are getting left behind.
00:04:51 Well, that's it.
00:04:51 And the reality is what Canada needs to do
00:04:54 is it needs to change the investor sentiment
00:04:57 towards Canada.
00:04:58 It needs to change the story about Canada out there in the world, which is that you just can't get projects done.
00:05:05 And if we're going to convince people that we really have turned the page and that we really are now serious about moving ahead and developing our resource sector and our energy sector in particular,
00:05:17 we're going to have to show people that all of the things that got in the way of projects, all of the political opposition,
00:05:25 And that we're willing to stand up to that and actually say, no, we're making a choice as a country that we're going to value the resource sector more and we're going to work a lot harder to develop it.
00:05:37 And we're going to stand up to people who, for various reasons, don't want development to go ahead.
00:05:43 And the FAQ projects that are announced, this isn't showing that Canada has the intestinal fortitude and the government has the intestinal fortitude to stand up to all of these special interests.
00:05:53 because they're all ones that everybody supports.
00:05:56 One of the special interests is obviously the indigenous interest,
00:06:01 and it's indeed built into the major project's office.
00:06:07 It seems to me and has seemed all along that Mr. Carney is very good about stating an intention
00:06:14 but then putting a condition on it.
00:06:17 When we come to these very large projects that we want to see and would be good for the country,
00:06:22 would be a great flywheel to generate activity. Nevertheless, there's always, well,
00:06:29 there's an indigenous office that has to be satisfied. There are provincial interests
00:06:33 that need to be satisfied. Does he have a plan for getting around that, or is that his actual
00:06:44 get-out-of-jail-free card when he finds himself confronted with something that's not in accord
00:06:49 with his green plan. What was he sort of promised to do? What do you think is going on there?
00:06:55 Well, I think the Prime Minister has made the transition to being a politician in the sense that
00:07:01 politicians like to be all things to all people. And they don't want to annoy anybody. They want
00:07:07 to live in a world where everyone will be happy with the decisions that they take.
00:07:11 And that's not the reality of governing. The reality is that, as the French Prime Minister
00:07:16 once said to governors to choose um i'll put another way thomas soul the great economist once
00:07:22 said um there are no solutions there are only trade-offs um so at the end of the day you're
00:07:27 going to have to you if you're wanting a lot of projects to get done um you're going to have to
00:07:31 make some of those trade-offs um at the moment though what we seem to see is you know a project
00:07:37 needs to not only do all indigenous people anywhere near the project have to agree to it 0.75
00:07:42 We also have to have provincial agreement. So that means the province of BC has to sign off on any pipeline that goes to tidewater from Alberta. And there's also a Greenland. So you've got these three constraints. So I don't think there's a lot of camels that can go through the eye of that needle.
00:07:59 And I think the instinct from politicians, and I think the prime minister is in this space, is, well, if there's a problem, we're going to throw money at it.
00:08:11 And so we're just going to provide a subsidy here or a subsidy there to move the project along.
00:08:17 So a year ago, as we all remember, Mr. Carney was advising the former prime minister, Mr. Trudeau.
00:08:24 So many of the things that he has inherited are the consequence of the years during the decisions taken during the time that Mr. Trudeau was Prime Minister.
00:08:37 And I myself am still wondering whether Mr. Trudeau was given good advice that he ignored, or that the advice that he took came from Mr. Carney, and we are now witnessing the consequences of that advice.
00:08:56 Do you care to speculate upon that?
00:09:00 Well, you know, at the end of the day, what matters is the actual results.
00:09:06 And, you know, we have, you know, a system, an environmental system, assessment system that is very, it was already complicated.
00:09:15 The Trudeau government made it even more complicated, even more inaccessible.
00:09:22 Certainly, you know, Mark Carney, before he was prime minister, was pressing very hard for Greenland to worry very much about climate change impacts.
00:09:31 You know, we haven't really heard him backtrack on that.
00:09:34 So, you know, in some ways, yes, I mean, this is a system that he has certainly been involved with.
00:09:41 But I will say that it's probably only now that he's getting to grips with exactly what this system is doing to resource development in this country.
00:09:51 And, you know, you see him with the Bill C-5, for instance, look for a way to get around the system.
00:09:58 But the reality is what's really needed is a wholesale reform of this system.
00:10:02 And a big part of that would be getting the federal government out of a lot of areas where it's really the province's responsibilities.
00:10:11 Do you think Mr. Carney is behaving like somebody who thinks there is a business case for selling Alberta natural gas to Germany?
00:10:22 Yes, I think we are.
00:10:25 We're talking about somebody who has obviously a lot of a lot of economic experience, a lot of financial experience.
00:10:30 And I think who gets that the resource sector is important to Canada's economy.
00:10:36 If you look at the objectives that he laid down in the letter that he sent to all ministers in a speech from the throne,
00:10:44 I mean, they're the right objectives.
00:10:45 They are developing the resource sector, talks about cutting the size of government.
00:10:50 There's a bunch of other things that I think every economist would agree with.
00:10:54 The real question is, how are you going to get there?
00:10:57 And, you know, if you're going to make this omelette, you know, what eggs are you willing to break?
00:11:03 So, everybody has, before he became prime minister, everybody liked to call him a technocrat.
00:11:11 And certainly somebody who has managed two, not one, but two national banks probably is something of a technocrat.
00:11:19 But if we then translate technocracy into running a country, do you see in the things
00:11:28 that he says and the actions that he has so far taken, the mind at work of somebody who
00:11:36 thinks that government is best advanced when decision-making is concentrated in a small
00:11:43 group of people but that small group of people are the most competent and the cleverest and
00:11:50 of course the most virtuous then that they will make good decisions and everybody else
00:11:55 will will come along i mean this is a government that seems to want to make
00:11:59 investments decisions that would normally made by private companies again what do you think his
00:12:06 game is here well i mean prime minister comes from central bank world i mean that's kind of
00:12:13 the pinnacle of technocracy. You have a very, very small group of people that are deciding on
00:12:18 interest rates, which is crucial for the economy, very much shielded from political input, and
00:12:24 there's a lot of good reasons to do it that way. But that's in the context of the Bank of Canada
00:12:29 or the Bank of England. These are elite institutions, they're full of PhD economists,
00:12:34 and at the end of the day, you're looking at just one segment of the economy. The federal government
00:12:41 is a very very different beast it's it's it's huge you're talking about more than 400 000 public
00:12:46 servants um and of course he's not just thinking about interest rates he's there's a whole range
00:12:51 of policies tax transfer substitutes all kinds of things so you're dealing with something that's an
00:12:56 order of magnitude more complicated and you know i think certainly uh you know he certainly you're
00:13:05 a very competent individual. He has a great CV, as we all know. But you just can't manage
00:13:11 the government of Canada even the way you manage a central bank. And the federal government can't
00:13:17 manage the Canadian economy the way a central bank can manage interest rates. Just too big,
00:13:22 it's just too complicated. Okay, I want to turn shortly to the budget that's coming on November
00:13:28 the fourth but before we go there two things the united states has backed away from the green
00:13:34 agenda even europe is backing away from it but mr carney seems to want to stay green
00:13:45 even as everybody else is changing their minds um does he know something that they don't know
00:13:51 I think it's more that Mark Carney has written a whole book in which climate change featured
00:14:02 very strongly. He spent a lot of years invested in a climate change issue, especially since he
00:14:07 left the Bank of England, putting together coalitions of businesses to advance net zero.
00:14:13 So when you invested a lot in an idea, it's hard to move away from it, certainly hard to move away
00:14:20 from it very quickly. But the reality is, as you say, the rest of the world by and large is moving
00:14:27 away from it. And we've seen the prime minister having to move away from some of the elements of
00:14:35 that agenda, at least like the EV mandate, for instance, because he's reduced the consumer
00:14:40 carbon tax to zero. But we haven't yet seen him go all the way on a lot of that agenda. I think
00:14:48 He's still hoping that by making these kinds of concessions, by making a few changes like this,
00:14:56 that he'll still be able to have something that he can hold up as a proper green agenda.
00:15:01 But he's going to be in a pretty lonely spot internationally doing that.
00:15:06 In Alberta, we have some hopes of what Premier Daniel Smith calls the grand bargain.
00:15:12 And that is where somehow we find a way to bury enough carbon dioxide to achieve net zero as we increase production of oil and natural gas.
00:15:26 I'm told that it is technically feasible.
00:15:30 Do you have any sense of whether this is something that Mr. Carney is advancing, not just Premier Smith?
00:15:38 Do you think they can actually make money at it?
00:15:41 Or is this just another exercise in bait and switch?
00:15:44 Well, the last price tag I saw for this was $16.5 billion.
00:15:48 And I don't think anybody believes that that would be the final number.
00:15:52 I'm sure it would be much higher than that.
00:15:54 Technically feasible is not the same thing as economically feasible.
00:15:58 The reality is companies are only going to get involved with this
00:16:02 if the governments pick up the tab for that cloud and capture and storage.
00:16:06 and I wouldn't be surprised if Premier Smith thinks the federal government's going to pay that
00:16:12 tab and the federal government thinks the Premier Smith is going to pay that tab and I think the
00:16:17 reality is fiscally provider level of government that's just that's just not on so the thing about
00:16:25 carbon capture and storage is it's it's this mythical beast that will solve everyone's problems
00:16:31 It allows the prime minister to be able to say he's still fully on with a net zero agenda, while at the same time providing Premier Smith with a way to providing that social license from the federal government to ship hydrocarbons to Tidewater.
00:16:52 So the politicians very much want this to exist.
00:16:55 They want it to be feasible.
00:16:57 But at the end of the day, I'm not sure anybody's really willing to pay for it.
00:17:01 Well, it's pure speculation as to what it might do to the price of a barrel of oil,
00:17:07 but one thing is for sure, it would apply to Alberta oil,
00:17:11 but I'm not aware of any plan to apply it to oil that is imported
00:17:17 from places where net zero is not a consideration,
00:17:21 which of course would be the case in eastern Canada.
00:17:24 Do you know if there's any plan to square things up and make it a fair fight?
00:17:29 um i don't think so i mean you you hear ideas and the european union was thinking about putting
00:17:36 tariffs on uh things that come in that have a high carbon content but in the current environment i
00:17:43 can't see is putting tariffs on on imported oil and even if we did we'd just be shooting ourselves
00:17:48 in the foot because we're making just making life more expensive for our for our businesses and for
00:17:53 our consumers so um as you say it's just uh putting a a disadvantage on on alberto oil
00:18:02 unless you know some um some fairy government is going to come along and just pay for this
00:18:08 okay dr sergeant let's switch through the budget obviously we've all been told to expect
00:18:15 that it's going to be a frightening announcement when it comes hundreds of billions of dollars
00:18:22 in deficit, accumulated deficits are already north of $2 trillion.
00:18:28 How much worse is it going to get?
00:18:31 But really is the question, confronted by this kind of enormous cost overrun,
00:18:40 it seems like any government, this one in particular,
00:18:46 has the choice between raising taxes, cutting expenses, or allowing inflation to run its course
00:18:56 and pay off what they owe in devalued dollars.
00:19:02 From all that you have seen, what do you think is the most likely strategy to be followed by this government?
00:19:12 I think the most likely strategy is going to be the latter. I mean, that's what governments
00:19:20 usually do, at least for as long as they can get away with it. You know, you have higher inflation
00:19:27 that reduces the real value of your debt, and your revenues go up, it enables you to pay your
00:19:32 debt. The other things are really hard to do. Raising taxes, I think Prime Minister is smart
00:19:38 enough to know that taxes are already pretty high in this country and you know the more the higher
00:19:43 you raise them the more people are going to find ways around paying those taxes or you know just
00:19:47 simply not work simply not invest cutting spending i mean you know that most economists would say that
00:19:54 would be the place to go but you know it's this government certainly a lot of the prime minister's
00:20:00 cabinet colleagues are the ones who helped massively increase spending over the last 10
00:20:05 years because we saw public service grow by about 40% or 0% over that period. So it's hard for me
00:20:14 to see that they're going to drastically reduce the size of civil service, even putting it back to,
00:20:20 even on a per capita basis, back to where they were. So I suspect that the easier roads will be,
00:20:27 the politically easier road will be the one that they follow in the near term until the financial
00:20:33 markets say enough and that's usually how this ends. Well, it's hard to make a cheerful picture
00:20:39 out of any of that, so let's just say the average person who's got a little bit of
00:20:45 financial flexibility, is there anything? What do they do? Buy gold? What can a person do to
00:20:52 insulate themselves somewhat from this tide of bad news that's coming our way?
00:20:58 Well, they don't call economics the B.L. science for nothing.
00:21:03 And I don't have a lot of good news for people.
00:21:06 I mean, it used to be that the U.S. Treasury bills, for instance, where U.S. debt was a safe haven.
00:21:13 But you look at the U.S. now and the deficit is huge.
00:21:19 I don't think the U.S. is going to default, but I think they're seeing inflation creep up as well.
00:21:25 So there aren't really a lot of good places left to put your money.
00:21:30 I mean, gold could certainly be one, but even that can be quite volatile.
00:21:37 The first best would be that we actually had sensible fiscal policy,
00:21:42 and so people could invest with confidence in Canada.
00:21:47 But during the financial crisis, when it was really the property sector,
00:21:53 which was ground zero, you could move into government bonds.
00:21:56 I mean, those were relatively safe.
00:21:59 But I think this time around, it's government itself
00:22:02 that's the most vulnerable to financial markets.
00:22:06 Well, isn't this a cheerful way to conclude an interview?
00:22:10 We're all doomed.
00:22:13 Dr. Sargent, I suspect that people will be buying gold or buying silver.
00:22:21 i'm not recommending it but it is uh there seems so few options unless you trust bitcoin but uh it
00:22:29 is uh perhaps we can have you come back again on november the 5th after the after the budget has
00:22:36 been presented and uh we'll just go over and see whether all our all our doom and gloom was
00:22:41 justified thank you so much for coming on the program thanks for having me oh it's been fun
00:22:48 For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.