Western Standard - February 13, 2026


Can Canada be defended at all?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Western Standard News Update | Petition to Defund Private Schools Misses Mark | 12 Feb 2026 Western Standard News Update | Rhode Island hockey shooting shocks community | 17 Feb 2026

Episode Stats


Length

24 minutes

Words per minute

152.83

Word count

3,676

Sentence count

126

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Roy Rempel served as a policy advisor to Prime Minister Stephen Harper for several years. He is now the senior policy adviser to the Minister of National Defence, Rob Nicholson. In this episode, he talks about Prime Minister John R. Carney's defence strategy and the challenges facing the Canadian Armed Forces.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standards viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show
00:00:21 of the Western Standard. It is Thursday, February the 12th. My guest this week is Roy Rempel,
00:00:26 And our subject is national defense, as Mr. Carney sees it.
00:00:33 Full disclosure, Roy and I served together in the Harper Prime Minister's office for several years,
00:00:38 where he was policy advisor on defense.
00:00:43 Miss speechwriting was the better for his advice, I should tell you.
00:00:47 Roy, welcome to the show.
00:00:49 Thanks, very nice to be here.
00:00:51 Well, good to have you.
00:00:53 Over the last six months, Roy, Prime Minister Carney has said a lot of things that I think
00:00:58 we could both agree with about national defense, which may be a bit of a surprise to those
00:01:04 watching this show. But we would think that. He has made several references to strengthening
00:01:09 Canada's capabilities, our ongoing commitments to NATO, and raising spending significantly,
00:01:17 significantly, by looking at the numbers here, doubling it by 2030, in fact. But is any of this
00:01:24 credible, or is this just talk? The Canadian Armed Forces is way under strength, so he is starting
00:01:31 from behind. People are actually leaving because they don't like the feminization and the disrespect
00:01:38 for the warrior culture that's been handed down as government policy for the last few years.
00:01:43 And as you found in your tenure under Mr. Harper, even with a prime minister who is highly sympathetic to the military corps, it's hard to buy equipment.
00:01:55 Now, assuming Mr. Carney is sincere, is what he says he wants to do possible?
00:02:03 Well, I think some of it, you know, you're talking about sort of credibility.
00:02:06 I think some of it is credible, particularly some of the immediate measures to stop the bleeding within the Canadian defence establishment.
00:02:19 You know, of the $9 billion that Mr. Carney announced last year, about $2.6 billion of that is for pay.
00:02:27 And that's particularly vital because, you know, we've had a situation particularly, well, for the last 10 years, the Department of National Defense has not met its recruiting targets.
00:02:40 One of the factors is pay.
00:02:42 So there are measures to increase pay significantly in order to address particularly the retention issue and the ability to attract people.
00:02:55 um you know there's things money for health for improved health benefits there's money for repair
00:03:03 and maintenance of equipment which is particularly important because some of our equipment is very
00:03:07 old uh the um the halifax class frigates are in the range of about 30 years old uh the victoria
00:03:16 class submarines are in the range of 35 years old and uh the cf-18s are as much as 40 to 45 years
00:03:23 old so you're going to need money in order to uh just maintain a certain level of uh capability
00:03:32 and to stop the bleeding you may recall former um defense minister uh bill blair talked about the
00:03:40 canadian armed forces being in a death spiral and that's very much the case even uh this year the
00:03:46 The commander of the Pacific Fleet, Admiral Patchell, said that the Navy is about one quarter under its authorized strength level, and it's short about 1,000 Marine technicians.
00:04:02 The Auditor General talked about serious shortages of pilots and aircraft technicians.
00:04:09 So pay is one way to address that.
00:04:12 And it's probably been long overdue.
00:04:15 well it has been long overdue and so those elements in what Mr. Carney is talking about
00:04:22 and in a different approach by the current liberal government over the previous liberal
00:04:27 government that that is credible I would say you know in the long term if what Mr. Carney said at
00:04:34 Davos is what he actually believes is that you know we are now in a world of predatory great
00:04:42 powers, great powers that don't believe in the current international order. And I think there's
00:04:47 considerable evidence for that. Well, then it's going to require an enormous effort and it's going
00:04:52 to have to start with a clear defense strategy, a clear identification of threats and a clear
00:04:59 identification of what we can count on our allies for and what we can't count our allies for. And
00:05:05 filling that gap of what we can't count on our allies for could be, well, is likely to be an
00:05:11 extremely large undertaking. Well, certainly pay is vital. I don't think anybody begrudges
00:05:22 the troops getting a pay raise. I understand that comparatively speaking is pretty low
00:05:27 what they've been receiving. So that is good. But do you think that men and women actually
00:05:32 join the armed forces for the sake of the money in any case? Isn't there something more driving
00:05:39 them a sense of national obligation maybe a lust for adventure maybe a number of things like that
00:05:46 but everything that's sort of subsumed in the two words warrior culture uh the the warrior culture
00:05:53 has been under considerable pressure in the last few years symbolized i think in everybody's minds
00:06:00 by the tampons in the men's washroom because lord knows well who knows do you think that that's
00:06:07 actually what drives people to serve is a sense of duty and honor and if so do you think mr carney
00:06:15 has any real sense of that that he would emphasize that how is dei going to do with mr carney at the
00:06:25 helm well i think that is part of the challenge in the sense that what what the prime minister
00:06:30 has said so far is very high level um he's talked about a new world order uh and he's talked about
00:06:37 the need to adjust to that new world order um but if you look at the details of what is actually
00:06:45 occurring you know i've sort of looked at some of the equipment purchases over the past um
00:06:51 over the past year or so and uh we bought high mars uh multiple launch rockets from the united
00:06:58 States. We bought new army tactical vehicles from the United States just yesterday. The government
00:07:05 quietly indicated that it was buying long lead items for another 14 F-35 aircraft in addition
00:07:13 to the 16 we're already contracted for. So that's obviously notwithstanding the review
00:07:18 of the F-35 purchase. So it seems like if you look at what they're actually doing,
00:07:25 the prime minister is talking about diversification but what they actually seem to be doing is uh
00:07:31 continuing with a lot of the same old same patterns of equipment purchases and i think
00:07:39 that's really where the details are going to have to start to match the rhetoric otherwise the
00:07:44 rhetoric is going to look particularly empty and when you're talking about um personnel policies
00:07:51 like you know you've mentioned um we've had very little about you know the if you're going to buy
00:07:59 all this equipment we're talking about buying 12 submarines we're talking about buying new corvettes
00:08:04 in the future well you actually have people have to have people to crew them so your personnel
00:08:08 policy has to match your procurement policy and so far i see very little political attention
00:08:14 being paid to that sort of level of detail.
00:08:19 And what we do know, if you look at recruitment policy over the past 10 years, is that it hasn't worked.
00:08:24 It's been very focused on diversity, equity, and inclusion, but it hasn't actually worked.
00:08:32 We haven't met a single recruitment target in the past 10 years.
00:08:35 Now, last year, they're saying that things have started to pick up.
00:08:39 but the hole that we've dug for ourselves,
00:08:42 the death spiral that former minister
00:08:45 Bill Blair talked about is still there.
00:08:48 So the DND, I'll put it to you,
00:08:51 the DND needs to drop the DEI.
00:08:53 Agree, disagree.
00:08:57 Well, I think that, you know,
00:09:00 there should be only two priorities.
00:09:02 If we're really living in the world
00:09:03 that the prime minister is talking about,
00:09:05 there should be two priorities in terms of recruitment.
00:09:07 The operational needs of the Canadian Armed Forces
00:09:09 and merit. Who can make the operational needs? If you look at all the various other recruitment
00:09:15 objectives, 25.1% females, I'm not sure why it's 0.1% requires that level of precision. We're 0.98
00:09:24 nowhere close to meeting those kinds of targets that have been set, and they were set a decade
00:09:27 ago. We're at about 18%. So despite strenuous efforts, I think you can say the current policy
00:09:32 is not working. If you want an armed forces that's going to be effective, you have to focus on two
00:09:38 things the operational needs of the armed forces and the people required to fill those needs
00:09:44 that should be pretty much about it but it's going to be cycle it's going to be very difficult for
00:09:48 them to abandon policies that they are so highly committed to i i don't see any indication that
00:09:54 there's any willingness to do that at all quite frankly well maybe they should have a chat with
00:10:01 Pete Hexeth. I want to take you back to what you said about the F-35 purchase. That first
00:10:08 tranche of 16 jets, when are they supposed to arrive? I believe deliveries are supposed to
00:10:18 start in the next few years, but in the next year or two, really. But if you're talking about,
00:10:24 you know, first aircraft being delivered, that doesn't necessarily translate into a capability.
00:10:29 And if you're talking about real capabilities, then you're talking a few more years down the road. I think they're sort of setting the objective of the early 2030s to stand up a real capability and finally phase out the CFA teams. But again, you're going to need to address what the Auditor General talked about in terms of pilot shortages and technician shortages. So again, your personnel policy has to match your procurement objectives.
00:10:56 There's been much discussion, Roy, about the possibility of the Swedish Griffin fighter being considered as a main replacement.
00:11:05 But it strikes me that they're not going to want to run a mixed fleet. 0.99
00:11:07 So once we start receiving F-35s at all, it's not like we're going to get 16 F-35s and then fill out the inventory with something else.
00:11:17 so is that a reason am i right to say that if they take delivery of the first one they're going to
00:11:24 take delivery of all of them uh that's not clear yet from the uh review it's supposed to be a
00:11:31 review you know are we going to have a mixed fleet are we going to have all f-35s or are we going to
00:11:35 switch to something else like the like the griffin fighter um i think what's been indicated yesterday
00:11:41 is really the the rcaf and the dnd really do want the f-35 which is why they're putting money into
00:11:48 the long lead items so that's clear the direction that dnd wants to go uh whether uh you know the
00:11:55 government is going to be prepared to do that i suspect they're maybe holding it as part of a
00:11:58 broader uh negotiation with the united states on trade issues and so on you know we'll move forward
00:12:05 with some of these defense acquisition with the defense acquisition like the f-35 if we get some
00:12:10 movement on trade issues i don't know but i suspect i think it's mostly a bargaining chip
00:12:14 that mr carney is using and we're almost certainly going to stick with the f-35 i'd be very surprised
00:12:20 if we didn't because that would be a major change in our defense relationship with the united states
00:12:25 so why is it so hard to buy equipment i want to just insert an anecdote that will undoubtedly be
00:12:33 familiar to you, and that is that when we had forces deployed in Afghanistan, they were
00:12:41 getting blown up as they drove the roads because the other side would plant an explosive device 0.94
00:12:48 in the culvert, or a LAV would drive over it, and they'd press the button, people would
00:12:53 be killed, the vehicle damaged.
00:12:55 So we really needed helicopters to get around, but we couldn't get any somehow.
00:13:00 And it was only when we worked out a deal with the Americans to pick up six of their hard-worked helicopters in theater,
00:13:11 and then the RCAF technicians made a heroic attempt, a successful attempt, to get these things flying and reliable.
00:13:21 Only when we did that did we actually have helicopter in capability in Afghanistan, and that's when there was a war on.
00:13:28 In peacetime, it seems to be incredibly difficult to buy equipment.
00:13:33 Why is that?
00:13:35 Well, you have a very cumbersome procurement process, as the previous government, our government, found.
00:13:41 You have a military which is focused on getting the best equipment.
00:13:45 You have a finance department that's interested in keeping costs down.
00:13:50 You have Industry Canada, whatever the current iteration of that is now.
00:13:58 but Industry Canada in our day who are interested in getting the maximum industrial benefits.
00:14:05 That process can become extremely laborious and very, very long term.
00:14:11 And I think in Afghanistan, we just didn't have the time to go through those procurement process.
00:14:16 So we just started buying equipment very much off the shelf as rapidly as possible,
00:14:20 not just for the mission in Afghanistan, but also address pressing needs in Canada,
00:14:24 such as, you know, procurement of tactical transport aircraft and so on.
00:14:31 So, you know, we just simply went to buying off the shelf and buying very quickly
00:14:35 because in Afghanistan it was an urgent need where we had slipped far behind
00:14:39 the capability that was required to sustain that mission.
00:14:42 And I think it is something that the current government is going to have to look at now.
00:14:46 You know, if you're really talking about the buildup that they're talking about,
00:14:50 you know you're going to have to move very quickly and at a speed level that we're not
00:14:57 accustomed to at all for instance in acquiring the submarines for instance which are you know
00:15:03 you talk about acquiring the submarines but they're probably a decade maybe even a decade
00:15:07 and a half down the road in terms of actually seeing them delivered simply because foreign yards
00:15:13 you know are also there's a lot of orders for foreign yards so it's not easy to get in the
00:15:19 procurement pipeline. So you're gonna have to move very fast at a speed that we're not used to.
00:15:25 So here again, you know, we have these big aspirations, but you need to actually have
00:15:31 policies in place that are going to A, get the stuff bought quickly, and then B, have the
00:15:37 personnel there to actually run the equipment when it's being delivered. And we have massive
00:15:45 shortages in personnel right now. Now, I seem to recall reading that Mr. Carney has established
00:15:53 a fast-track office for the purpose of defense procurement. If he was prepared to take
00:16:02 a question from the Western Standard, I would want to ask him, what difference is this going
00:16:07 to make? Whose toes are you prepared to step on in Industry Canada or in finance, for that matter,
00:16:14 in the armed forces themselves in order to get this done.
00:16:18 Do you have any reservations about a fast-track office for military procurement?
00:16:27 No, but I think here, again, the sort of dilemma confronting defense is the dilemma we're facing
00:16:35 across the board with respect to, for instance, getting energy corridors built.
00:16:41 we're going to have to move at a pace
00:16:43 that we're not
00:16:45 accustomed to and so far I see very little
00:16:47 evidence that we are prepared
00:16:49 to move at that pace
00:16:50 you know there are all sorts of
00:16:53 challenges that are going to emerge that
00:16:55 the current government isn't even
00:16:56 fully aware of yet
00:16:59 so
00:17:00 you know and we found that when we
00:17:03 launched the national shipbuilding strategy back
00:17:05 in 2010
00:17:05 pardon me
00:17:07 so what
00:17:10 uh what kind of unforeseen challenges might emerge well they're talking about um you know
00:17:18 uh building up canadian industry to deliver the types of capabilities that canada requires
00:17:24 a very canada canadian industry focused um strategy that's very important but we can't under
00:17:33 underestimate the complexities of actually doing that and i think you know our government found
00:17:37 that out when we launched the national shipbuilding strategy which is rolling out ships today but that
00:17:43 national shipbuilding strategy was launched in 2010 we found it was incredibly complex to
00:17:50 modernize our existing shipbuilding in canada to get the infrastructure in place in halifax
00:17:58 in british columbia and um the the timelines that we had initially set proved very difficult to meet
00:18:08 so uh if you're now talking about doing that sort of across the board in terms of defense
00:18:14 procurement you're looking at a massive undertaking that is really going to have to
00:18:20 to have a government with will to cut through red tape,
00:18:24 to have a very hands-on, detailed management
00:18:29 of day-to-day procurement challenges,
00:18:32 and to simply override obstacles when they emerge.
00:18:38 And I think a defense industrial strategy,
00:18:42 I understand, is going to be launched today
00:18:45 as we're talking, and that's what I'd be looking for in there.
00:18:48 what extent are they uh looking at you know the management challenges and the measures that are
00:18:55 in place to actually speed up the process uh in a marked way and we'll have to look for that in
00:19:02 today's announcement i think okay so yeah roy i'd like you now to take you to what mr carney said
00:19:11 about defense in davos uh i think it's generally acknowledged that mr harper our guy was the only
00:19:18 Prime Minister spend much time in the Arctic. Since 2016, when the Liberals came to power,
00:19:26 they've not gone there very much at all. So, not north of the Arctic Circle.
00:19:33 But Mr. Carney had this to say at Davos. He says, so we're working with our NATO allies,
00:19:39 including the Nordic Baltic Eight, to further secure the Alliance's northern and western flanks,
00:19:46 including through Canada's unprecedented investments in over-the-horizon radar and
00:19:55 submarines and aircraft and boots on the ground. Now, we've just said, or you've just said,
00:20:02 that the submarines and the aircraft are a long way off in the distance and that they've got a
00:20:07 serious issue with recruitment. So I have to ask you, without being partisan, was Mr. Carney really
00:20:17 making any sense? We don't even shoot down Chinese weather balloons, but he is talking about securing
00:20:24 the northern flank. What do you say? Is he knowing us? Well, I think some of the things
00:20:33 that have been announced are important, like over-the-horizon radars. But again, you look
00:20:37 the delivery timeline you're looking at the early 2030s and that was announced a few years ago
00:20:40 already so and that's that's very much short and medium term in a lot of ways because that's about
00:20:46 the same time that we would have the f-35s coming online if we switch to the grippen well or the
00:20:51 griffin that's going to be that's going to be a gripping that's going to be a uh that's going to
00:20:58 be another uh delay probably as we switch to a new fighter aircraft um if you're talking about
00:21:05 the submarines well the submarines are not going to be arctic capable really because they're not
00:21:09 going to be nuclear power and then to operate in the arctic you really need a nuclear capability
00:21:14 so it's maybe going to be more on the fringes of the ice uh and and there you're talking about as
00:21:21 i mentioned i think at least 10 to 15 years down the road as in what sense do you think mr carney
00:21:28 means to secure the northern flank well again i'm not sure that they've gotten into that level of
00:21:34 detail to be quite honest i think there are a lot of aspirational uh statements that have been made
00:21:41 but the actual policy and heart procurement and uh personnel uh improve improvement of the personnel
00:21:50 situation that's all going to have to catch up with the aspirations and i think they're going
00:21:56 to find that the challenges are far more monumental than they uh have anticipated the
00:22:03 The capabilities that we have in the Arctic now are basically capabilities that the Harper government initiated back in, you know, the period prior to 2015.
00:22:12 That's how long it takes to bring systems online.
00:22:15 I mean, we launched the NanoCivic naval refueling port.
00:22:20 That's still not fully operational.
00:22:23 You know, the Arctic offshore patrol ships, those that's really a peacetime sovereignty protection capability, again, launched in the Harper years.
00:22:30 Those are just sort of coming online right now.
00:22:33 if we can find the people to crew them then you could say we will have sort of a peacetime
00:22:37 sovereignty protection capability but in terms of actual hard defense capability that's going to be
00:22:44 uh that's a much longer time frame and quite frankly it's why the americans are very frustrated
00:22:50 with us um because you know we are flying 40 to 45 year old uh cf-18 fighter aircraft and uh it's
00:22:59 it's going to be a while before we have capabilities that are, you know,
00:23:03 sort of fit the 21st century.
00:23:06 So there's a lot of work to do that the government simply hasn't really got to yet.
00:23:14 And we'll see what the defense industrial strategy says today in terms of, you know,
00:23:19 are they actually getting into these detailed challenges?
00:23:23 Well, Roy, I so wanted to believe, obviously I'm not a liberal,
00:23:28 but on when it comes to national defense uh i i was hoping that the prime minister actually had
00:23:34 something substantive to offer here kind of doesn't really look like it does it look thank
00:23:42 you for coming on the program i really appreciate it it's great to see you again there at the uh
00:23:48 the harper events last week and uh we'll have you back again when there's more to talk about roy if
00:23:55 if you're willing to come.
00:23:57 I'd be very, very honored to be back on the show.
00:24:00 For that Western Standard, I'm Nigel Haniford.