Western Standard - July 18, 2025


Can independence solve Alberta's 'Ottawa problem?'

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
NDP faces financial apocalypse Local organizers bring 'Lemonade Day' to Calgary

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

160.49

Word count

4,037

Sentence count

166

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Premier Danielle Smith told a panel of 400 people in Edmonton that Alberta has an Ottawa problem. From the response, it seems a lot of people in the room felt the same way. But outside the UCP membership, and the people who give up a Wednesday night to go to a political meeting, how widespread is that sentiment? With me tonight is UCP Founding President Erika Barutis, who is also Department Head of Applied Politics and Public Affairs at Macamay College.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:21 It is Thursday, July the 17th.
00:00:24 Last night in Edmonton, Premier Danielle Smith told about 400 people in an Alberta Next panel
00:00:31 that Alberta has an Ottawa problem.
00:00:34 From the response, it seems a lot of people in the room felt the same way.
00:00:38 But outside the UCP membership, and the people who give up a Wednesday night to go to a political meeting,
00:00:44 how widespread is that sentiment?
00:00:47 With me tonight is UCP founding President Erika Barutis.
00:00:52 She's also Department Head of Applied Politics and Public Affairs at Macamay College.
00:00:59 Welcome, Erica.
00:01:00 Thanks for having me.
00:01:02 It's always a pleasure.
00:01:03 Erica, you know the Premier fairly well, I think, founding president of the party.
00:01:11 Why does the Premier think that Alberta has an Ottawa problem?
00:01:14 We reported last night that she said that, well, you tell us.
00:01:21 I don't think many people should be surprised. Premier Jason Kenney also said we had an Ottawa problem. He used a different term, which was standing up to Ottawa. This has been a decade long thing. I think Premier Smith is just maybe more direct in her communication.
00:01:38 And from my understanding of last night, that sentiment by the 450 individuals really resonated that even though Mark Carney may be better for Alberta than Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, that you can't just flip a decade of frustration in a month or two.
00:01:58 And so I think that this is a position where the government and this Alberta Next panel is looking to find pathways, have conversations since both the Fairdale panel and just since getting a pulse check of what the sentiment by Albertans still truly is.
00:02:18 Well, do you get the sense that enough people care about this to actually give the premier the kind of support that these panels are supposed to generate?
00:02:26 I mean, we've only had two so far. I hope that they'll do a series over the time, especially in those urban centers. You know, it's all published. They're doing a lot of road showing for this over the summer months, similar to what the Fair Deal panel said.
00:02:43 But I don't know if it's going to just be an echo chamber of validation or what will come out of it is the bigger thing.
00:02:50 So they can have the conversations. What are they doing to address what has been done since the Fair Deal panel?
00:02:56 What can be done? What will be done differently?
00:02:59 And what does that mean to Albertans in a landscape under Prime Minister Mark Carney than Justin Trudeau?
00:03:08 Because, you know, the chessboard is different now.
00:03:11 You said something a moment ago that I wasn't expecting, and when you said that there was a thought that maybe Mr. Carney would be better for Alberta than Mr. Trudeau.
00:03:21 I mean, obviously, Mr. Trudeau was not good for Alberta, but is there a little optimism within the government?
00:03:28 I mean, you saw it even with how all the elected officials and leaders of our country, including premiers and prime ministers, were playing nice during Stampede.
00:03:38 There has been some movement towards perhaps who I believe Mark Carney to be more so with secrets and scandals.
00:03:47 But I will say he did build the Building Canada Act, pushed it forward, you know, probably upset some of his base, some of his colleagues, but held on that commitment that he ran on.
00:04:01 And that opens up opportunities for consultation for large infrastructure projects, including pipelines, to once again be feasible, which were not the case under Justin Trudeau.
00:04:12 And so I think there is optimism. However, it devils in the details with how these consultations with Indigenous peoples go, how consultations interprovincially go.
00:04:25 So there's still a lot of runway to see how much Kearney is willing to push.
00:04:30 But I think the fact that he even introduced it, tabled it, and actually got it through is a sign that he's going to do differently than Justin Trudeau.
00:04:41 Okay.
00:04:42 Well, if that's the feeling within government circles, that's great.
00:04:47 You said the devil was in the details.
00:04:49 And quite frankly, down here, when we wrote about it, we were saying, well, really nothing has changed.
00:04:55 He's got lots of exits if he doesn't want to go through with it.
00:04:58 But anyway.
00:04:59 And that's the thing is I'm being optimistic because we had a communist prime minister operating under a liberal banner. Now we have a, let's say, progressive conservative might be a stretch or a true liberal under a liberal government. 0.85
00:05:11 So I think the fact that at least on the spectrum, we've seen a shift back to the values and the beliefs that that party operated on is a little bit more comforting for someone like me that looks at, OK, the predictability, the sustainability of this and the feasibility, whereas Justin Trudeau was just on his little climate change course.
00:05:33 well i think he was on one that was largely laid out and explained to him by by the president
00:05:40 incumbent you know mr carney has been pushing this for 20 years and this is why i think so many
00:05:44 of us find it so difficult to think that he's it's all changed now no and i think to that point
00:05:51 i'm trying to be an optimist to say i'll give the chance but you can't expect and you and i are in
00:05:57 the policy details where an average Albertan hasn't seen the proof in the pudding or the
00:06:03 devil's in the detail. And so until there's a pipeline built, until there is autonomy within
00:06:09 the province and return to how the constitution is written, I think that the sentiment that
00:06:15 probably came out in that meeting last night will still resonate in large circles across Alberta.
00:06:21 Well, that's actually the next thing I wanted to ask you about. It's pretty clear by the nature of the policy resolutions coming forward for the party convention in November that there are a very large number of members of the UCP who are actively looking at a path to independence, what it could look like, what the destination would be, how far they prepare to go.
00:06:50 there's an interest there. Do you have any sense of what the sentiment is more widely in Alberta
00:07:01 among people who aren't members of the UCP? Now, obviously, anybody who voted NDP, I'd say they
00:07:08 were poor market for the idea of independence. A lot of people did vote for the NDP. On the other
00:07:15 hand, there's probably, I would guess, a lot of UCP voters who have a sentimental, maybe a
00:07:24 practical attachment to the government of Canada. So, as these meetings go forward, to what extent
00:07:33 are they actually seeking input, and are they promotional, and where do you think people are
00:07:38 in alberta on the on the matter of independence i think that there's a few different circles i
00:07:45 think the unfortunate thing is what the ndp is trying to do is say and even broader circles of
00:07:52 saying like separation equals 51st state which is very different than i think what a lot of people
00:07:57 that may be coined separatist or separatist curious or whatever you want to call it that
00:08:03 you'd want to know what that path looks like but that doesn't mean that you're going to go become
00:08:07 the 51st state there's individuals that would want to explore separation under a dominion versus
00:08:16 true independence so still respecting and working with the monarch which has its own pathway
00:08:22 challenges one way or the other the others are looking at you know what does independent look
00:08:27 like with a market access um and so there's the sentiment of separate separation which i think
00:08:35 there's more people than you'd think feel that way because of the frustration that we had for
00:08:39 the last decade there's some people that like myself would love to explore that but at the same
00:08:45 well at the same time seeing what carney does um and so my hope is that not only are we looking
00:08:53 here was what the fair deal panel put forward here is our current environment this is what we've
00:08:58 learned this is what we should be looking at these are the questions we missed or the the perspectives
00:09:03 we missed. Again, I think that there's going to be maybe, you know, less exploratory of how this
00:09:13 is done by these conversations. But I hope that the Alberta Next panel comes up with what that
00:09:19 would look like to present to Albertans to get, I want that full understanding before I would go to
00:09:24 a ballot box to make a decision. I don't vote by my sleeve or my heart. I vote with my gut and my
00:09:31 brain. And so without that information, I think it's very difficult. Similarly to, I think, how
00:09:37 a lot of people felt about leaving the CPP. There's a sentiment there, but how you actually do it is a
00:09:42 heck of a lot harder in reality. And there just wasn't that roadmap that I think a lot of people
00:09:50 that maybe have the sentiment towards can actually tangibly understand. I'm wondering, Erica, whether
00:09:57 I'm right in assuming that many people think, well, we have the referendum, and then if we
00:10:02 vote for independence, we're on our way. I don't think it's quite that simple, is it?
00:10:07 Absolutely not. And like I said, there's different versions of what does independence look like?
00:10:12 Is it independence from all of Canada and removing the monarch? Is it independence there? Is it,
00:10:18 like you said, with the UCP policies, I wish they had more sessions on how to write good policy,
00:10:23 but i digress um but you know you're going to get a lot of you need to go to your school
00:10:29 exactly you can sign up for applied politics and public affairs and learn how to actually write
00:10:34 either convention floor policies or public policy but um thank you for that that underhand pitch
00:10:40 and promotion of the program um but yeah so i think there's going to be some confusion there
00:10:44 but it's not a to b it's a to b c d e maybe f and so that's where i'm hoping that these
00:10:52 conversations get the sentiment of the true direction Albertans want to go again people
00:10:59 that are looking for separation may be more inclined to attend these versus what the you
00:11:06 know attending one of these NDP pro Canada whatever they're running in contrast to what
00:11:13 the government is proposing. Yes so I think the Clarity Act would be triggered would it not that
00:11:20 would be the first step yes yeah you'd have to do that you'd have to go through i mean i don't even
00:11:27 know from how you'd establish once you do the clarity act i mean should it go past that what
00:11:33 does it look like for um decisions of constitutional change what does it look like for infrastructure
00:11:40 right you need to establish a police force a banking system a pension um and that's where i
00:11:46 think a lot of people look and they're like, well, that's why 50 first state is easier because that's
00:11:50 already established. But conforming to that, I mean, I would hope if we ever got there, we looked
00:11:57 at what Texas has and some of their exemptions from the Constitution. But I really don't get
00:12:02 the sentiment that people want to join the U.S. I think that the message is more we're really
00:12:07 frustrated. We feel like we're not respected in confederation. I think Saskatchewan's right there.
00:12:13 It's just they're not as loud as maybe Alberta has been or is currently.
00:12:18 And that regardless of Carney being in office, a, you know, parting of the clouds of Trudeau, that there is maybe opportunity.
00:12:27 We can't just all of a sudden lean in with false hope that or, you know, optimism guiding us.
00:12:34 Well, there's still people that are frustrated and want to see our premier and our province push for more equality in confederation.
00:12:43 You have used the word frustration a number of times in the past 10 minutes.
00:12:48 And there are two things that legitimately could frustrate people.
00:12:54 One is the sheer amount of money that goes out of Alberta and, quite frankly, keeps the rest of the country going.
00:13:02 The other is the lack of interest or respect even for the dominant values of Alberta
00:13:10 that we don't get from the rest of Canada.
00:13:16 I'll just go out on a limb here, and I say the money is an irritation,
00:13:19 but it's not the main thing for me.
00:13:21 But I do find it deeply offensive that what seem to be social attitudes
00:13:29 that are prevalent in eastern Canada come through Parliament and then get directed to the rest of
00:13:36 the country, amongst whom is Alberta. Like, I don't think that the, probably the PEI isn't too
00:13:44 happy with some of the things they do either. But anyway, we're talking about Alberta, and you have
00:13:50 this uh this lust for control and authoritarian dictates that comes out of ottawa that is you know
00:14:00 we don't want that we're we're a freedom loving people i think uh so where do you see the center
00:14:07 of gravity for all that frustration that you're talking about i mean if we had a case study i'd
00:14:13 look at the fact that quebec seems sees themselves as a distinct society when you look at alberta and
00:14:19 And I would extend it to Western Canada.
00:14:21 We don't have the cleavage of Western alienation for no reason.
00:14:25 We are treated differently.
00:14:26 We have, you know, less seats in the Senate.
00:14:30 The four provinces equal one Quebec or one Ontario.
00:14:34 There's distribution of seat count, seeing elections be decided before our polls close.
00:14:39 There's a lot in the parliamentary democratic system that isn't working right now.
00:14:45 the way confederation was set up is that the dictatorship isn't like the federal government
00:14:50 is the same value as the other provinces that they work in collaboration i think that when you
00:14:57 talk i talk about the frustration listen i'm actually i'm quite a realist even though i have
00:15:02 some optimism for carney because more of a fingers crossed uh approach but i don't think equalization
00:15:08 formula will be reformed i don't think senate's going to be reformed because that causes us to
00:15:14 open up the constitution which we technically really haven't done since 1867 because we just
00:15:21 added the charter of rights and freedoms like it was very minor we tried to do a bunch of stuff
00:15:25 leading up to that and even in the 80s so i don't think that if albertans are sitting here being
00:15:32 like well we just need constitutional reform i don't think that that's realistic but what i think
00:15:38 the biggest thing that frustrates alberta is get the hell out of our lane and stick to what your 1.00
00:15:44 constitutional jurisdiction is don't try and jump over the province to deal with the municipalities 0.97
00:15:51 like just stay in your darn lane and do what you're supposed to do as a federal government 0.51
00:15:56 well and let provinces do what provinces were designed to do and i think that that would be 0.98
00:16:03 a big sentiment shift from what we currently are frustrated with um so to your point money's
00:16:12 annoying and a grievance because we see it in dollars and figures but the true sentiment to
00:16:17 feel valued and appreciated would be get the heck out of my house yes well you know we tend and the
00:16:25 premier herself tends to use the traffic analogy a lot staying out of a lane the other thing that 1.00
00:16:30 we might be reminding otto is when you see a red light you're supposed to stop and that's uh the
00:16:35 The red light is when you are, in fact, poaching on the burglars.
00:16:40 And to be clear, I mean, I think our biggest default is we always talk about pipelines, but that has to do with property rights.
00:16:46 That has to do with transportation, corridors, a lot of like investments that we have for research, innovation, anything at the post-secondary level.
00:16:56 Like to a lot of people, they just think, oh, Alberta wants you just to allow us to build pipelines from coast to coast and and say F you to everyone else in between Alberta, like Fort McMurray, perhaps, and the ports.
00:17:10 That's not the case. We've seen Saskatchewan actually go ahead with a constitutional complaint and looking at using notwithstanding clause against the federal government on things like even property rates or carbon tax or these types of things that are impacting industries that thrive.
00:17:26 So I think it goes beyond building pipelines and it's like, let us give you money.
00:17:32 Like we're happy to play into that as long as if we need help or we need, um, policy
00:17:39 that allows us to thrive, that you're not getting in our way.
00:17:42 Yeah.
00:17:43 Um, pure speculation, but from an informed source, how, how many, uh, how much of the
00:17:50 caucus is sympathetic to separation independence and how much is how many members of caucus
00:17:58 are what you might call fiercely federalist that's probably i'm not going to pull a number
00:18:07 out of the air because i think that's hard and i think that there's sympathy to separatism
00:18:12 because you'd have large pockets of your collective especially in rural alberta that
00:18:17 would want to explore that, especially on land rights and our agriculture and forestry
00:18:24 industries that also are harmed by federal interference. So I think that there's a lot
00:18:29 that are sympathetic to it and again would like to explore and see what comes out of this Alberta
00:18:36 Next panel. I have been critical that I don't think elected officials should be leading this
00:18:40 because it politicizes it as opposed to working with the industries that are impacted and make
00:18:45 policy suggestions or a roadmap for government to explore. And so I think it muddies the waters on
00:18:52 the intention of this panel, unfortunately. However, I do think that there are a lot that,
00:18:59 again, you can still be interested in separation, but love the monarch and support the monarch. So
00:19:06 or the federalist federalism system. So I think it's not as black or white of are you a separatist
00:19:13 equaling you want complete autonomy and leaving Canada altogether or versus I am happy with how
00:19:22 the order goes I think we're most probably people sit is in that gray in between yes well
00:19:27 and caucus probably reflects that yes and people probably should at this stage be in the in that
00:19:34 gray scene because there's so many things that we that we don't know uh I see I see we're coming
00:19:41 close to time, Erica, but there is this one last question that I'd love to hear your thoughts on.
00:19:48 Whether the referendum, which I think is going to be sometime in the first half of next year,
00:19:53 let's see, I think that's the latest information we have, the referendum on independence comes in
00:20:00 the first half of next year. If it passes, that's one set of consideration. If it fails,
00:20:11 That is that people say, no, we're not interested, or a majority of Albertans who vote say they're
00:20:16 not interested. Does that not still attach to the Premier anyway? As we've said earlier,
00:20:26 her predecessors never did this, Mr. Kenney, Mrs. Notley, and I think they wouldn't have done it.
00:20:37 so she did does that not say to people or could it not be interpreted well she's actually in
00:20:45 favor of of independence but doesn't want to say so and so we have this referendum so even after
00:20:52 losing a referendum she could get up and say oh that's it the people have spoken but it's still
00:20:57 her issue do you think she's going to carry that into the next election well two interesting things 0.99
00:21:01 Kenny did bring forward a referendum on equalization. So I agree that it is not the
00:21:06 question of separation, but he did bring forward a policy to push back on Ottawa. It failed and
00:21:13 we're still having that conversation. So I don't think that the issues that maybe are brought under
00:21:18 a certain administration stick to that leader. However, hers is more open to not just let's
00:21:28 reform the constitution which i think many folks realize is very very difficult as opposed to
00:21:33 separation i think to me it's what is the question because i think the equalization question was
00:21:38 poorly written and confusing for people as well as the time zone um or the daylight savings changes
00:21:44 so i think again it's how the question is written is there also a question that's you know by thomas
00:21:51 Sukazic brought forward on the opposite. Is that confusing? I would be very discouraged if it's
00:21:58 brought as a standalone referendum because I think it's like an inappropriate use of taxpayers when
00:22:04 you could just wait till they're already going to a ballot. And so there's a lot of pieces there
00:22:12 that I think will be very indicative. Now, let's play the hypothetical that it does pass. I think
00:22:18 the question is by how much that you do you truly have the support? There'll be a lot of pushback
00:22:24 because not every voter, you have an option to vote in the referendum. And so that might be
00:22:29 hypercritical that she'll have to navigate. I would say if it was held today in the form in
00:22:34 which some groups have presented it, I don't think it's going to pass. Because again, like you said,
00:22:39 we don't have enough education that even something like me who would like to explore what that looks
00:22:44 like? How much would it cost to do this? What is like a business case for being our own entity?
00:22:51 I just don't know where that information is going to come to between now and potentially 2026. So
00:22:58 there's a lot of roadblocks regardless of what happens if it goes forward. I think that it would
00:23:06 be political suicide for Danielle Smith to double down on something where she said this is up to 1.00
00:23:11 Albertans to decide. And they decided no, but I'm still going to go forward with it. I think that
00:23:17 that would be very career limiting move. So I don't think that she and she's also said that
00:23:23 she's not a separatist. So whether people want to paint her with that brush, because from an
00:23:27 opposition standpoint, that sounds great. And it's an easy target or that she's like wants to be 0.96
00:23:32 a Trumpite, whatever narrative they're driving. She's said it, she's giving it to Albertans.
00:23:39 um and so but there's a lot of runway between now and then and a lot of things that could influence
00:23:44 people like me uh if you do it a standalone i might just vote no because i hate the context
00:23:51 in which it was presented last question erica what would you say to people who uh say yeah
00:23:57 let's vote for independence and then see what sort of a better deal we can get out of ottawa
00:24:03 Be careful what you wish for, because it could be very detrimental. I mean, we look at Quebec,
00:24:13 and we have someone that's gone through it, been very, very close. And there was no real roadmap
00:24:19 of how you would do that. So you're going through uncharted territory. And that comes with a lot of
00:24:28 of, um, unanticipated consequence. And we might just be told by all of our colleagues,
00:24:35 F off, get out of here. And then we're on a landlocked Island, um, you know, with,
00:24:41 with very little to do. So this is where I think it's very important to be proactive,
00:24:45 to explain the how to Albertans. Um, and maybe don't always just vote with your sentiment.
00:24:52 Look at, look at the path. Good words, Erica. Thank you very much for joining us today.
00:24:58 Yeah, thank you for having me. And good luck with teaching the next generation
00:25:03 to do politics better. For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.