Western Standard - October 03, 2025


Canada just gave away its public health sovereignty

Hosted by
Mentioned
The Sixties Scoop saved lives Teachers vote down proposed deal, strike action imminent in Alberta

Episode Stats


Length

26 minutes

Words per minute

152.28

Word count

4,022

Sentence count

176

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Just two weeks ago, with no fanfare or parliamentary debate, Canada quietly ceded operational control of public health in this country to the World Health Organization (WHO). So it s now the WHO that will tell us when we have an emergency, what we should do about it, and demand speedy answers back when we ve done it, on the double. If that sounds like handing over Canadian sovereignty and control, I think it is. But I m known for overreacting. With me today is Alison Piovich, a constitutional lawyer whose work is funded by the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good evening western standard viewers and welcome to hannaford a weekly politics show
00:00:21 it is thursday october the second just two weeks ago with no fanfare or parliamentary debate
00:00:29 Canada quietly ceded operational control of public health in this country
00:00:34 in the event of another medical emergency to the World Health Organization.
00:00:40 So it's now the World Health Organization that will tell us when we have an emergency,
00:00:47 what we should do about it, and demand speedy answers back when we've done it,
00:00:52 on the double, according to the regulations.
00:00:55 If that sounds like handing over Canadian sovereignty and control, I think it is. 0.69
00:01:02 But I'm known for overreacting. With me today is Alison Piovich, a constitutional lawyer whose 0.56
00:01:10 work is funded by the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms. Welcome to the show,
00:01:16 Ms. Piovich. Hi, Nigel. Thank you very much. It's great to have you here.
00:01:20 Look, let's then talk. Am I overacting, do you think?
00:01:26 No, I mean, when we went through COVID, that was a big shock for most of the world,
00:01:32 and certainly for many Canadians, for what happened. And a lot of what occurred in this
00:01:39 country through governmental action was really looking to the WHO and what they were telling
00:01:47 countries to do and the international health regulations have been in place since 2005
00:01:55 but now they've brought forth some amendments which make it even more
00:02:02 difficult for you know provinces to take a different approach.
00:02:06 Well let's talk about some of the things that we experienced during COVID that we can trace
00:02:12 directly back to these regulations and then maybe you can take us to where they've actually made
00:02:18 them more onerous. Sure well during COVID the chief public health officers of the provinces
00:02:26 through different public health acts which gave them power to do so made public health orders
00:02:31 which did a variety of things as you know imposing lockdowns on society you know you can't go to your
00:02:38 your parents' house for dinner, you can't have people over, you can't stand outside and protest
00:02:43 with more than five people, you can't go to church at all in a province like Manitoba.
00:02:48 So this all started with the World Health Organization?
00:02:51 Well, the World Health Organization was telling countries what to do,
00:02:58 telling leaders of countries what to do, but it's actually in these international health
00:03:02 regulations from 2005, they actually, at Article 18, I've got it in front of me, they recommend
00:03:09 to countries to require proof of vaccination during a public health emergency, place suspected
00:03:18 persons, people suspected of being sick under public health observation, implement quarantine
00:03:24 or other health measures for people.
00:03:26 So these hotels, you fly back from somewhere
00:03:30 and you end up going at your own expense to a hotel.
00:03:33 A quarantine hotel.
00:03:34 That was a horrifying experience.
00:03:37 That came from the World Health Organization?
00:03:39 Yeah, they've got it right here at Article 18
00:03:42 and this was drafted originally in 2005.
00:03:45 Okay, now you've got me really scared.
00:03:47 I'm obviously not overreacting.
00:03:49 If that's what it was like in 2005,
00:03:51 What have they done now that's going to really upset us?
00:03:55 Right.
00:03:56 So they've made some amendments last year and Canada has agreed to them.
00:04:02 And they've added a lot of wording in here, which requires countries who've signed on to move even more rapidly than before.
00:04:12 So you thought that things were happening quickly when COVID started in 2020 and all of a sudden, you know, kids can't go to school.
00:04:18 Businesses are shut down.
00:04:20 Churches are shut down.
00:04:21 That happened very quickly, and it was very shocking to all of us.
00:04:26 But the World Health Organization wants countries to move even more rapidly and just shut everything down immediately.
00:04:34 And, of course, when you do that, there's little time to react and say, well, wait a minute.
00:04:41 What is the science telling us so far?
00:04:44 Let's talk to a variety of sources and try to ascertain whether these measures are necessary.
00:04:51 And they just want to steamroll over the process of getting different opinions,
00:04:57 getting people together. And you can do that fairly quickly, but when they say as rapid as
00:05:03 possible, they're going to act immediately and they expect countries like Canada to act immediately.
00:05:09 Well, do they have any power to enforce that?
00:05:13 Well, it's Canada.
00:05:15 They don't have an army.
00:05:17 Well, no, but I mean, Canada has agreed and these regulations are binding.
00:05:25 And so Canada has a dualist system. So they have to sign on to these international agreements and
00:05:30 then implement them through domestic legislation. So it would be through the Public Health Acts
00:05:36 that these are you know once they're ratified in parliament they would they would show up through
00:05:40 the the quarantine act and the public health acts and so it's really it's the it's the federal
00:05:46 government um you know taking that taking the lead with this but what else they've done here
00:05:52 is they've actually have language in these amendments that requires countries to respond
00:05:59 um and to coordinate responses nationally and you know for a country like canada and united states
00:06:05 You know, we've got, you know, multiple different areas, we've got provinces, the US has states. And so what they want is they want provinces just to, you know, hand over authority to the federal government to take care of everything, take care of their response, tell us what to do. And that really, and this is a, this is a federalist society, there's a separation of powers here.
00:06:29 And so different provinces, you know, I'm going to suggest Alberta might be one of them in a future pandemic might want to have a different response.
00:06:38 We saw uniform responses last time with COVID. But like, look at Florida, Florida, Governor DeSantis took a very different approach.
00:06:47 So did Kristi Noem. She's the governor of South Dakota. 1.00
00:06:51 and when you look at the outcomes of Florida versus say California Florida fared better in
00:06:59 terms of the total COVID deaths and I know that because it was evidence in our in one of the
00:07:05 cases that I that I argued and my experts talked about Florida and use it as an example of a place
00:07:10 that actually locked down early but lifted the lockdowns realized the harm they were causing to
00:07:15 the population and actually fared very well.
00:07:19 Well, let me just take you back to Canada for a moment.
00:07:24 During COVID, Bonnie Henry, the public health officer in BC, mandated that churches should
00:07:32 be closed and the restaurants should stay open.
00:07:36 And as soon as you got into Alberta, it was the other way around that the churches stayed
00:07:42 open and the restaurants were closed for periods of time.
00:07:45 Now, it was the same virus, and whatever the science was, I guess it was the same science.
00:07:52 Now, some people might say, good, at last they're getting their act together, it's going
00:07:57 to be the same all over.
00:08:00 Maybe that's a good thing.
00:08:02 And you say?
00:08:03 I would suggest it's not a good thing to leave all that immense power to the federal
00:08:10 government to control, dictate what happens all across the
00:08:16 country. We've seen what this government has done during
00:08:19 COVID, exercised its power, for example, over travelers, trying
00:08:26 to go visit their family in Europe and, you know, South
00:08:30 America, internationally, you need to get on a plane, you can't
00:08:33 take a boat. And people weren't, people weren't allowed to get on
00:08:38 a like a cruise ship. People weren't allowed to get on an airplane to see their loved ones unless
00:08:44 they received the COVID vaccine, which during that time was still in the testing phase. And now we
00:08:52 know that there are significant adverse effects from the vaccine. Absolutely. Their science is
00:08:59 there. The United States is taking a very careful, critical look and as it should at the horrendous
00:09:06 side effects that some people have experienced from this vaccine you know heart problems
00:09:11 myocarditis strokes blood clots so these are it's really is there a benthamite argument that yes
00:09:19 some people got hurt as a result of the vaccine but overall it it saved a lot of lives can you
00:09:25 argue that uh you know we've we've had experts during cases where we argued that the unless
00:09:32 you're talking about people who are immunocompromised or the elderly, when you look at the risks of COVID
00:09:38 to the population, for younger people who are not senior citizens, not immunocompromised,
00:09:46 middle-aged younger people with no pre-existing conditions, they typically fared pretty well
00:09:54 with covid and the vaccines uh had a very um uh had a risk profile for myocarditis for young males
00:10:05 meaning adolescent males young males up to age 30 were negatively affected by the vaccine in their
00:10:14 heart and i do have experts that uh you know relied on peer-reviewed research to show that
00:10:20 the vaccine's negative effects on the heart is worse, was worse than the risk to them from COVID.
00:10:27 And of course, you know, experts on the other side will say, well, COVID also presented a risk
00:10:33 to the heart of myocarditis. So you might as well get the vaccine anyways,
00:10:38 to protect you from COVID. But I mean, that's a ridiculous argument. And I know there are studies 0.97
00:10:43 since I argued those cases at court that are that have definitively found that the risk to
00:10:49 your heart from covid um is far less than the risk of the vaccines to your heart well let's
00:10:56 come back to the uh keeping the regulations harmonized uh you are you i think we're in
00:11:03 manitoba at the time and uh i believe the winnipeg jets had a very different experience
00:11:13 of covet than anybody else they sure did and so did actors and actresses so these
00:11:17 These, you know, industries that were making a lot of money for Manitoba, such as NHL and the movie industry, they were allowed to continue.
00:11:28 Winnipeg Jets were allowed to practice inside with their coaches, teammates, you know, whoever needed to be there at the Winnipeg True North Centre, still live there.
00:11:38 They were allowed to continue. They were allowed to play against opposing teams.
00:11:43 And as you know, if you watch hockey, I'm sure you've seen a hockey game or two, these guys get roughed with each other, they get their faces smashed up against each other. And that was just fine. That was safe. And it was fine. But it is also safe to act in a scene in a movie in Manitoba inside where you are doing, you know, intimate things with another actor as part of the scene, or, you know, getting into fistfights and rolling around brawling as part of a violent movie, that was okay.
00:12:13 but it was not okay to go to church you couldn't have two people sitting in a church in a grand
00:12:18 cathedral in winnipeg because that was that activity was too dangerous and i recall uh during
00:12:24 when i was arguing uh the gateway bible uh versus manitoba case where we um we also my clients uh
00:12:33 churches sued the former chief medical health officer dr brent rusen while we were arguing that
00:12:40 case, we had to do it on video. So we were all sitting at home. My team, we were sitting at home
00:12:47 on our screens. The judge was sitting in the courtroom. There were no people in the courtroom
00:12:53 other than a few journalists, as I understand. We weren't allowed to go to court to be the case.
00:12:58 But the team of government lawyers who I used to work with, wonderful people, they were sitting in
00:13:05 a boardroom together. There were four of them in a boardroom I could see on the camera, I used to
00:13:10 sit in that boardroom because I used to work there. And they were allowed to sit there, the four of
00:13:14 them in a boardroom, probably not much bigger than this room. But you couldn't have two people in a
00:13:20 giant church, cathedral, mosque in Winnipeg. And so when you see things like that happen, it shakes
00:13:30 the confidence of the public in the seriousness of this virus. And therefore, when the public is
00:13:37 asked not to come over, not to get together at Christmastime, remember the creamier Brian
00:13:42 Felster got on camera and he was tearful, telling Manitobans, he couldn't believe he had to do it,
00:13:48 but he had to tell Manitobans, you can't visit your loved ones over Christmas, you can't have
00:13:52 Christmas dinner together. While these movie sets were going on, while the Winnipeg Jets were playing
00:13:57 together while you couldn't go to church at christmas time as a citizen you couldn't go to
00:14:03 church could you go to the jets game no you couldn't go to the jets game either no no it was
00:14:08 but the teams could get together and the teams could get together in the change room gee and
00:14:13 families didn't form their own hockey teams to get through that's yeah that's how do you think that
00:14:19 officials square these kind of inconsistencies in their own minds because i mean i don't want to
00:14:23 start from the premise that everybody is inherently dishonest and a charlatan so they must have had
00:14:27 some sense yes this is doesn't really make sense well yeah no in in fairness uh the excuse given
00:14:34 by dr rosen uh in his sworn evidence yes was that um people who go to church engage in dangerous
00:14:42 activities after church such as hugging um sharing utensils if they have lunch together in the
00:14:49 basement of a church. And in his experience, many people at
00:14:56 church embrace each other, ignoring the fact that, you
00:15:00 know, that could be one of the, when you come to church, there
00:15:03 could be a request from the minister, from the priest, from
00:15:06 the pastor to say, if you don't mind, we're so wonderful, you
00:15:11 know, thank you for coming, you know, despite the fact that
00:15:14 there's this virus going around, but wouldn't mind not not
00:15:19 embracing in the church. Outside is different, and we're not going to have lunch in the basement
00:15:24 today or something like that. But the act of getting together and worshiping together communally
00:15:29 in person is so critical for the right to worship, which is protected under the charter,
00:15:35 and it was just thrown away. Did anybody ever compare the outcomes in Manitoba and Alberta as
00:15:41 a result of people who did go to church and didn't go to church? I'm sure somebody has. I don't have
00:15:46 that. I don't have that statistic. Well, there's more things buried in this wretched document that
00:15:51 you have there. And there's one thing that really concerns us here at the Western Standard, and it
00:15:59 has to do with the suppression of information. The World Health Organization seems to have a
00:16:09 fixation about disinformation and they want to take measures. What is it that we have now agreed
00:16:19 to in this revised version of the international health regulations that we've done a really bad
00:16:28 thing? Right. And before I answer that, when I hear the phrase misinformation and disinformation,
00:16:35 I can see and hear very clearly Prime Minister Trudeau on the TV very slowly enunciating the words that is misinformation and disinformation regarding the public's questions about the vaccines or the lockdowns or anything else that went against what he was telling us we had to do.
00:17:01 And so, you know, perhaps that came from the language of the WHO behind closed doors.
00:17:09 I don't know.
00:17:10 But the fact that they've used the exact same phrase here is interesting.
00:17:14 So this is a section called Core Capacities Requirements for Prevention, Surveillance, Preparedness and Response.
00:17:21 It's in Annex No. 1.
00:17:23 And what they have got here as part of the amendments is each state party shall develop, strengthen and maintain the core capacities for risk communication, including addressing misinformation and disinformation.
00:17:41 So in plain language, what are they actually, what is the government of Canada signed up for with that?
00:17:46 Well, I think what it's intended to mean is when the, you know, chief public health officer of Canada and or the provinces gets on the camera and tells the public, you know, as we saw in COVID almost every day, an update on case counts.
00:18:04 And, you know, we've got all these cases.
00:18:06 We have to do X, Y, and Z.
00:18:07 I'm really sorry.
00:18:08 We have to.
00:18:09 You can't see your loved ones this weekend.
00:18:12 You can't go to restaurants.
00:18:15 you need to get the vaccine before we do x y and z and but because the risk of this virus is is so
00:18:23 high when you're communicating the risks of these activities and that's why we have to to shut them
00:18:27 down when you're communicating the risks of the unvaccinated as an example uh you don't want to
00:18:33 sit next to somebody on an airplane who's unvaccinated we're going to make sure that you 0.99
00:18:36 don't have to do that because they're dangerous right that's kind of the the theme right that's
00:18:43 the theme of what we heard from the Prime Minister and so if you challenge that statement you're
00:18:52 hearing disinformation. So addressing misinformation and disinformation to me sounds like censorship
00:18:56 and is that going to come in the form of you know censoring people online and if people are
00:19:06 standing in a street corner holding a sign up that says you know lockdowns are harmful or whatever
00:19:11 Are you going to be, you know, given a ticket and told you that you can't, you can't protest
00:19:16 there?
00:19:18 You know, silencing voices is something that we saw during COVID, but it struck me recently
00:19:24 I saw a clip on social media of, I believe it was the CEO of YouTube.
00:19:32 And she seemed quite gleeful in saying that during COVID, and I believe, if I recollect
00:19:42 correctly, that she said it was due to the request by the Biden administration at the
00:19:48 time, that she censored and scrubbed, removed, thousands of dissenting voices during COVID,
00:19:57 videos of people.
00:19:58 I'm going to assume that that means scientists, doctors, because I would see scientists and
00:20:04 doctors. And there were many who had expressed questions, serious questions and doubts with
00:20:11 what was happening. And they had a message they wanted to get to the average person to
00:20:18 step back and say, wait a minute, do we really need to do these things? And there were freedom
00:20:24 freedom types who would like to do videos and talk about, you know, how they were made to feel
00:20:31 during COVID. And, you know, when you're told to put a mask on and go to the grocery store,
00:20:38 follow the arrows on the floor, you're not talking to the person next to you. You're not engaging in
00:20:43 conversation. When you're not allowed to visit your family, you're not communicating. And when
00:20:48 you shut down communication, when you shut down dissenting voices, people are left isolated.
00:20:54 and they're left looking at the TV, listening to the messaging, not perhaps realizing that
00:21:01 there are other people who are also questioning what's going on. And maybe they hadn't thought
00:21:05 about an inconsistency or that there might be other science that is not being pursued. And,
00:21:12 you know, I mean, the science is not, you know, a dictator saying this is the way it is. It's
00:21:18 a discussion and debate. And there's always going to be new studies coming out. And when
00:21:23 scientists get together and debate that's how science is shaped so really now so what we're
00:21:28 so what we're seeing here i'm putting words into your mouth so if i'm wrong say so but what it's
00:21:37 looking like is that the government of canada which we know would prefer it if everybody just
00:21:43 accepted what they said in a variety of uh of fields as the gospel truth has now got the world
00:21:53 health organization on side and and wants you to think whatever they say in the name of the
00:21:59 world health organization cannot be challenged should not be challenged and if you do challenge
00:22:04 it you are a bad person is that is that sort of what's happening here yes prime minister trudeau
00:22:09 did say those things yes if you're vaccinated uh it was all so odd because it doesn't make 0.76
00:22:17 any sense an unvaccinated person is also misogynist and racist and takes up too much space
00:22:23 that's what he said. Um, so yeah, I mean.
00:22:27 Okay. So we, it is actually a fairly black, uh, outlook.
00:22:32 One thing that I noticed in the appendix to all this,
00:22:36 there were 11 countries that actually didn't buy into the improved, uh,
00:22:42 and some of them are fairly substantial countries. One was the United States.
00:22:46 What was there? I think, um,
00:22:49 Health Secretary Kennedy put out a statement explaining why they weren't going to go along with these new arrangements and what they would do instead.
00:23:01 What was his reasoning?
00:23:04 From my recollection, he was concerned about the language, which I haven't actually addressed in this discussion,
00:23:11 the language in the new amendments that talks about how health products, and they define health
00:23:16 products as medicines and vaccines and, you know, ventilators or whatever, something like that,
00:23:22 that you need if there's a, you know, a public health emergency, a virus going around,
00:23:27 that those are going to be distributed not equally, but equity, equitably.
00:23:35 What's equity?
00:23:36 So equity is different than equality. So equality is what we fight for under the Charter of Rights, under Section 15. Everyone should be treated equally. You know, one group shouldn't be treated differently than another group based on your skin color, based on the fact that you're disabled, based on the fact that, you know, your heritage or something like that.
00:23:58 But equity is putting one group ahead of another for, could be a variety of reasons. Perhaps the government says, well, this group has been disadvantaged, therefore they need, you know, special, they need to get paid more.
00:24:15 You see that in some some government jobs. If you're a member of a disadvantaged group, you can have employment equity. But in terms of equity in supplying people with lifesaving treatments, medicine, for example, he was concerned.
00:24:34 what does that mean? The document doesn't explain what it means. It's very general. So he didn't
00:24:40 want to, what I take from his statement is he didn't want to sign up for potential discrimination
00:24:47 not knowing what that means. Does that mean that the people who are immunocompromised will get the
00:24:53 first round of medicines? Okay, you can understand why that might be okay. But does that mean that a
00:24:59 certain racial group, a certain religious group, a certain, you know, a minority group will be
00:25:05 singled out and offered the first round of medicine. Well, it probably does. So yeah,
00:25:09 that's concerning. So that's, I think that was one of his main concerns. I think he was also
00:25:14 concerned with the speed at which the World Health Organization wants countries to respond
00:25:20 instead of slowing it down a little bit. I mean, you can only slow it down so much when you're
00:25:25 faced with an incoming virus. But when they want things to go so fast, as I said before, there's
00:25:31 really little room for any dissenting opinion and gathering the science and sitting down and
00:25:37 discussing and also debating as part of what we do. Therein is the problem. That's how this
00:25:44 doesn't fit our democratic way. I could go on for a long time, but we only have 20 minutes. So
00:25:53 i think we've even roared past that but i do want to thank you for coming into the john galt studio
00:25:59 here at the western standard talking to us about these things i know that this this story is not
00:26:05 over because pandemics and epidemics keep coming around we're going to have to deal with this
00:26:13 at the next time around right absolutely okay you thank you as payovich for coming
00:26:19 For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.