Western Standard - July 13, 2023


Canada’s system of racial apartheid needs to end

Topics
Mentioned
BRADLEY: I'm the King of the Balls! Biden terrifies a little girl

Episode Stats


Length

6 minutes

Words per minute

186.65

Word count

1,176

Sentence count

86

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Life expectancy for Indigenous people in Canada is at an all-time low, and it s only getting worse. How can we not see this as a crisis? And why is there no action being taken to fix it?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 So, the life expectancy for an Indigenous man in Alberta is now plummeted down to 60 years of age, and for Indigenous women it's down to 66.
00:00:09 So, if you want to see the comparison of what that means, the national life expectancy for a non-Indigenous man in Canada is 80, and women 84.
00:00:17 And the story across the country isn't any different with Indigenous populations, it's just a matter of give and take a couple of years. 0.92
00:00:23 And this issue hasn't garnered the headlines it should have, because it forces people to face a reality they'd rather avoid.
00:00:30 Canada's system and policies with Indigenous people, it's a complete catastrophe. 1.00
00:00:35 And how bad does it have to get before people admit this?
00:00:40 Think about that, Indigenous Canadians can expect to die 20 years before everybody else, and that number's getting worse.
00:00:47 The population should be screaming for systematic reform from the rooftops in light of this kind of number, but the silence is deafening.
00:00:54 Now, the opioid addiction epidemic is responsible for how fast it suddenly increased.
00:01:00 It increased by a seven-year drop in life expectancy in the last few years.
00:01:04 But again, those expectancies were already low, and they were already dropping.
00:01:09 And again, it's indicative of some big, serious problems.
00:01:12 Indigenous people have always had lower life expectancy than the rest of Canadians.
00:01:16 We shouldn't accept this.
00:01:17 They're dying younger than other citizens, though, because of an assortment of causes, ranging from diabetes to prostate cancer to murder.
00:01:24 In fact, with every single aspect, when you measure the standard of living, Canada's Indigenous people fall short. 1.00
00:01:32 Whether it's income, health, addictions, crime, education levels, mental health issues, housing, domestic stability, they're lagging by every measure.
00:01:40 And it isn't getting better.
00:01:43 But what do people expect?
00:01:45 How can somebody look at Canada's system of racial apartheid, and that's exactly what it is, and not see a socioeconomic disaster in the making?
00:01:53 How could a person think that keeping a race of people separated from the rest of society, on what are usually isolated reserves, with little to no local means of generating income, and think that these people are going to fare well under these conditions?
00:02:05 Does anybody really believe there's a sustainable future for people living on these enclaves of dependency and misery?
00:02:13 I mean, what do they envision?
00:02:14 Do they think citizens and residents on reserves will suddenly find and develop local resources and begin to live functional lives independent from government management and dependency?
00:02:23 Some people really believe those things might happen.
00:02:26 But all that tells me is they've never actually spent time on a reserve in Canada.
00:02:30 I'm not talking about somebody who's gone and attended the odd powwow or done a corporate retreat that had a sweat lodge attached to a resort in a native reserve somewhere.
00:02:38 I'm talking about getting off the main road and seeing how our First Nations populations are really living on those reserves. 0.99
00:02:46 Have a look at the dilapidated houses, the wild dogs, the crime, the trash strewn about.
00:02:51 And it's common, guys.
00:02:52 That's the reality of Canada's reserves.
00:02:54 And it's not improving.
00:02:55 For most indigenous people on reserves to make a living, they have to leave the reserve.
00:03:01 Unfortunately, many of those residents from the reserves are ill-equipped to adapt to town or city living.
00:03:06 And then they fall off the rails when they've gotten off the reserve.
00:03:08 It's terrible.
00:03:10 A lifetime of economic dependency in a tight and often dysfunctional social environment handicaps indigenous people when they try to break free.
00:03:17 And we've got to face that reality.
00:03:19 The reserve system is an inhumane policy failure, and it has to come to an end.
00:03:23 And I know that won't happen overnight.
00:03:26 It can't.
00:03:27 It's going to take decades of policies modeled to transition people away from the reserve system and into society in general.
00:03:33 People will need compensation, training, and adjustment for it.
00:03:37 Individual property rights need to be applied for people on reserves to break them out of the collectivism that's destroying them today.
00:03:43 And, of course, there will be legal challenges, too.
00:03:45 Many people have misconceptions about what treaty obligations the country actually has to indigenous people.
00:03:50 Now, most of those obligations, if you read a treaty, they just have to do with things like providing education, determining some land boundaries, and some minor payments.
00:03:58 We could apply private property rights and come up with some final settlements and still abide by treaties.
00:04:05 Most of the policies applied to indigenous people right now come from the outdated and terribly racist Indian Act.
00:04:10 That gross piece of legislation needs to be repealed.
00:04:13 And as a society, we need to move away from all race-based policies.
00:04:17 It fails the people every time.
00:04:20 There's a giant parasite class living on the backs of Canada's indigenous population. 1.00
00:04:25 There's bureaucrats, civil servants, and many lawyers. 0.65
00:04:27 They find the status quo very lucrative, and they'll defend it vigorously. 0.75
00:04:31 People calling for changes to the system will always be called racist, among other things, by those other parasites invested in the current bloated and corrupted system.
00:04:40 Nobody's calling out a race.
00:04:41 What needs to be called out, though, is a system failing an entire race.
00:04:44 Nobody's calling for assimilation, either.
00:04:47 Cultures can be preserved without being locked in an isolated reserve away from the rest of society.
00:04:53 And spending more money alone, it won't solve the issue.
00:04:56 Federal spending, just federal, on indigenous programs in 2021 was $24.5 billion.
00:05:02 That's above and beyond every other dollar it's spent, as it's spent on Canadian citizens in general.
00:05:07 And that doesn't include the spending from provincial and municipal governments on top of that.
00:05:11 And what are the results?
00:05:12 It's not the spending I'm begrudging.
00:05:15 If it was actually making the lives of indigenous Canadians better, I would accept it. 1.00
00:05:18 It's the lack of results.
00:05:20 It's failing.
00:05:21 I mean, again, they're dying 20 years younger than the rest of us.
00:05:24 Come on.
00:05:25 We could triple spending on indigenous programs tomorrow, and things wouldn't noticeably improve.
00:05:30 Unless the system's replaced, we're just tossing money into a black hole.
00:05:34 Canada's system...
00:05:34 I'm right on this.
00:05:35 Racial policies and segregation needs to be phased out.
00:05:38 And the best thing that could happen for indigenous Canadians suffering under the mess we have right now, this is the best thing we could do.
00:05:44 If one really did actually hate indigenous people, I could think of a few things more terrible that can be done than to maintain the current system. 0.98
00:05:51 We can't repair damage caused through race-based policy through applying even more race-based policies.
00:05:58 Anyway, guys, it's time to start talking about it, frankly, okay?
00:06:01 It's really failing.
00:06:02 I mean, how can we look at those numbers and say, we can fix this.
00:06:05 We can't, guys.
00:06:06 It's already failed.
00:06:07 If you really do care for Canada's indigenous people, it's time for some courageous, frank discussion on changing the entire system, and significantly.
00:06:15 And it's awful to watch it keep carrying on as it has been.