Western Standard - August 07, 2025


Carney: A decision if necessary, but not necessarily a decision

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Calgary man rebuilds life after receiving more than $1M in auto insurance settlement Ottawa's eternal quest to shape what Canadians say and think

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

165.88

Word count

8,236

Sentence count

398

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

27

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hannaford retires for the second time, Cory Morgan returns, and Derek Fildebrandt and Erika Barudis discuss why federalists are so afraid of the Alberta flag.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day and welcome.
00:00:27 Today's August 6, 2025. I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:00:32 You're watching the pipeline. I've got my usual crew of homies here. 1.00
00:00:37 Western Standard opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford, who is on his, he's got only two and a half days of work left until he is officially retired for the second time.
00:00:47 Officially retired for the second time. Yes. Drink it all in. The cup is running dry.
00:00:52 but like uh every good former employee uh he intends to be reincarnated come back as a
00:00:59 contractor still doing work with us you heard it here first ladies and gentlemen and another
00:01:05 former opinion editor who did the same uh we've got western standard senior alberta columnist
00:01:09 cory morgan it's hard to escape it's actually a career track this i thought it's just because
00:01:16 you love me yeah this must be it all right and uh coming back to us after an absence of a few
00:01:22 weeks we missed her dearly uh we've got erica barudis who is uh apparently got gas 0.85
00:01:29 okay that's a weird thing for people look over your i know i understand what the sign behind me
00:01:36 says yeah i don't have gas i'm in the presence of gas all right erica who's in the presence of gas
00:01:43 yes and what is my title derek what do i do i'm not doing it i just gave up on it
00:01:47 it's on the screen ah yes uh department head of applied politics and public affairs as
00:01:53 mackamy college i knew that not because it was on the screen yeah and i'm just here for nigel 0.74
00:01:58 that's why i'm here today as his farewell you break my heart you break my heart okay i think
00:02:06 it's good for ratings that i keep you in your place i think people like it yeah i think they
00:02:12 do. So let's continue. People, okay, people like the mean girl. All right. Well, we're going to
00:02:17 talk about why are federalists so terrified of the Alberta flag? The self-appointed leader of
00:02:27 the federalist stay in Canada side of the forthcoming maybe sort of referendums and former
00:02:36 deputy premier to Allison Redford, Thomas Lukasik, was caught. I don't know if caught's the right
00:02:44 word, but he's bragging about it, but we certainly picked it up once Cory Morgan found it. Caught
00:02:49 petitioning Safeway and other stores to take down that symbol of hate on a flag. No, it's not that
00:02:58 flag. It's the Alberta flag, old blue, ordering that they have to take down this symbol of
00:03:06 fascist oppression from stores, lest people look at Old Blue and seethe with hatred at Ottawa
00:03:16 and decide to become their own country. Or I'll talk about that. A pipeline, if necessary,
00:03:22 but not necessarily a pipeline. Mark Carney saying one thing, but setting up potentially another,
00:03:29 playing on kind of that old Canadian political trick of not appeasing those who need to be appeased,
00:03:39 but not really quite doing anything.
00:03:42 Speaking of which, where we're going to start, a Palestinian state, if necessary,
00:03:47 but not necessarily a Palestinian state.
00:03:51 Nigel, just last week, Prime Minister Mark Carney saying that Canada,
00:03:59 will recognize, intends to recognize a Palestinian state.
00:04:04 He hasn't formally recognized a Palestinian state yet.
00:04:08 But attaching certain conditions to it that make me think that if he does keep those conditions,
00:04:15 he'll never be recognizing a Palestinian state.
00:04:18 That's how I read it.
00:04:19 Well, that's called having your cake and eating it, too.
00:04:22 And that seems to be, I believe we're going to go into this a little bit more deeply later,
00:04:28 But by and large, Mr. Carney says what he would like to happen and then places conditions on it so that he's got an escape route if things change.
00:04:38 Now, in this case, it's not indigenous agreement and Quebec agreement that he's looking for.
00:04:45 That would be a pipeline. 0.87
00:04:47 But he wants to set three conditions on it.
00:04:52 that but hamas would not be part of any forthcoming uh going forward any uh palestinian state that the
00:05:03 hezbollah in in west bank will also disarm which to the some extent they've been disarmed but they
00:05:12 don't like it i can't imagine that they would ever want to to stay that way so you know you
00:05:16 you put these conditions out there and maybe they happen,
00:05:20 maybe they don't.
00:05:21 And if they don't,
00:05:21 you try.
00:05:24 Corey.
00:05:25 So,
00:05:25 yeah,
00:05:26 you did,
00:05:26 you know,
00:05:26 you put these kind of put down these conditions and as did some heads of
00:05:30 other governments around the world,
00:05:32 Hamas has to be disarmed.
00:05:34 It has to play no role in the government.
00:05:35 The Palestinian,
00:05:36 the hostages have to be released and said Palestinian state has to recognize 0.59
00:05:42 the right of Israel to exist.
00:05:44 I mean,
00:05:45 where the border should get drawn,
00:05:46 To some extent, it's a fair debate. To some extent, it's a fraught debate. But these conditions are actually under those conditions, if they were theoretically possible. I'd say, okay, actually, those are pretty reasonable conditions, I think, to recognize a Palestinian state. The Palestinians have to recognize the Israeli state and not go to war for maybe a period of, I don't know, two weeks, if they can do that.
00:06:10 for two new record yeah yeah um they're actually fairly i think reasonable demands to make that
00:06:17 if met i think would be you know a good you know grounds for which to recognize palestinian state
00:06:23 but i don't think there's any chance like hamas is uh i mean the gaza strip lurks worse than
00:06:33 tokyo or dresden right now it's gone and they're still fighting they're not disarming they're not
00:06:39 giving out the hostages. I'm not really sure. The only reason I can see them continuing to fight
00:06:46 is it's imposing an increasingly great political price on Israel and the Israeli government,
00:06:52 turning world opinion against them, not necessarily in favor of Hamas, but at least
00:06:58 against the Israelis. That's the only reason I can see why they still keep fighting at this point. 0.98
00:07:04 well they're ideological maniacs and you're asking for reason from them i mean their response to
00:07:10 having world countries saying okay let's reward them for their terrorism if they would just be
00:07:15 nice again and we'll give you your own state and what they do they released videos showing them
00:07:19 torturing the prisoners they still have in custody right now like yeah carney is no fool whatever he
00:07:26 may be there is no reasoning with hamas hamas made it pretty clear right off the bat no we aren't
00:07:32 disarming no we aren't releasing uh you know they've extended a nice big middle finger to the
00:07:38 countries asking for that and they want nothing less than the complete obliteration of israel 1.00
00:07:44 so i i don't know where this is going to end but carney won't he's just trying to play both sides
00:07:49 and he's playing weak i mean what do people expect israel's supposed to just leave them
00:07:52 there to keep firing more rockets and grabbing more hostages the reality is the world's going
00:07:57 to start calling for hamas to bloody well put the blame where it is well this is only going to end
00:08:02 when they stop. The Arab 1.00
00:08:04 League just came out.
00:08:06 They've come out, yeah.
00:08:07 That's a big blow against Hamas when even the Arab 1.00
00:08:10 League is like, guys, the jig
00:08:12 is up. Time to go.
00:08:14 The other thing that has to be understood, as you pointed out,
00:08:16 most of Gaza is rubble, and guess what? Hamas 0.99
00:08:18 is still hiding hostages and still launching rockets.
00:08:21 Gazans are complicit.
00:08:22 Not every one of them, but let's
00:08:24 not pretend that Hamas isn't operating 1.00
00:08:26 without the blessing of a large
00:08:28 part of the civilian population as
00:08:30 well. And I see it's showing
00:08:32 clearly that it doesn't seem to matter how much
00:08:33 abuse they take. The civilians won't turn 0.98
00:08:36 on Hamas. But this isn't
00:08:38 ending until Hamas is done. There's no other way 0.86
00:08:40 about this.
00:08:42 Erica, if
00:08:43 say Palestine 0.68
00:08:45 and I put that in air quotes, there's
00:08:48 two Palestinian governments. There's
00:08:50 Hamas in Gaza and the Palestinian Authority
00:08:52 in the West Bank and then
00:08:54 arguably Israel as well as a
00:08:56 third order of government there.
00:08:58 But if Palestine
00:09:00 if we can call it that, you know, disarmed Hamas. Hamas did play no role. The hostages are released
00:09:07 and they agreed to recognize Israel. They probably wouldn't recognize their claim on Jerusalem,
00:09:12 but let's say they recognized everything but, and that was just left as a point of negotiation for
00:09:17 later. Do you think, you know, Carney and others would be right in recognizing a Palestinian state
00:09:25 if those conditions could be fulfilled well i think we're talking about sunshines and rainbows
00:09:31 so sure and yeah and and and so sure but like cart before the horse and right now we like you
00:09:40 said but all the three of you separating hamas from the state of palestine is i see it pretty
00:09:48 unrealistic in the current state there's lots of what ifs that have to happen in order for that so
00:09:54 for our prime minister to come out and say, okay, all of these conditions, this, this, and this,
00:10:00 which an average Canadian isn't going through the fine print of these conditions that are
00:10:04 hypothetical to some degree. He's now sitting here saying all that Canadians pick up is I am
00:10:11 going to recognize in September with other nations. And I will say there is some Eastern
00:10:17 or Western European countries that are also saying the same, but that we're going to recognize
00:10:22 Palestine as a state. I can tell you from the left leaning people that I know and follow on
00:10:26 social media, that was the whole message was like, regardless of that fine print, the prime minister
00:10:32 is going to recognize Palestine as a state. And I think what that did was really divide our country 0.92
00:10:38 even more. It also, you know, resulted in tariffs from the south to respond to that decision that
00:10:49 our prime minister premeditated or preemptively stated before even getting to September. So
00:10:56 sure, I think that we could say that's an appropriate thing if A, B, C, D, E, F, G
00:11:03 happen. I just think we're still at A. And so for what this means for Canada, we've already got
00:11:11 some backlash of taking that position. I also think it's setting a tone where if you've ever
00:11:17 gone to ottawa in the last year or so um the disruption of their protests um we've seen it
00:11:25 all across the country we've seen post-secondaries be taken over um to stand out for the palestinians
00:11:33 the fact that we are canada and we have taken an aggressive position on either side
00:11:40 is disappointing to me at best i i do agree with that i mean it's i think we've got to get out of
00:11:47 habit particularly of those of us on the more conservative side of thinking we actually really
00:11:52 have a stake there we don't it's a different country it's a different part of the world
00:11:55 i i wish everyone there well wish them peace and for everyone there's there's side both sides have
00:12:03 been very guilty of hurting innocent people and i just i think us taking a stance either way
00:12:08 especially when you said to what benefit of us exactly what is in our national interest what
00:12:15 national interest is being served. So, Nigel, this raises the question, why? Why did Mark Carney
00:12:22 say this? I think Erica is correct that most people just heard Canada is going to be recognizing
00:12:29 Palestinian state. I think, you know, how many people see people do this all the time? They just
00:12:35 read the headline on X or wherever. They don't read the story. If they read the story, I actually
00:12:41 don't think it's a particularly unreasonable way to go about it. I don't think there's any chance
00:12:46 Hamas ever agrees to it, because it's too reasonable. They won't agree to it. Maybe I'm
00:12:52 wrong. But like, why? Is it simply the domestic voting audience that he's trying to appeal to,
00:13:02 you know, the combination of kind of campus lefties and, you know, the large and growing
00:13:07 Islamic vote in Canada by saying this, but then attaching conditions to it that make
00:13:13 it highly unlikely that if he sticks to those conditions, that Canada will ever be recognizing
00:13:17 a Palestinian state in the near future.
00:13:19 Well, I think after the events of October the 7th, 2023, nobody wants to see Hamas rewarded 0.99
00:13:26 with its own state.
00:13:28 But Carney is correct.
00:13:30 Mr. Carney, I should say, is correct in this much that a two-state solution has always
00:13:37 been Canada's policy, even during the ministry of Stephen Harper, who was famously very,
00:13:44 very pro-Israel, and therefore by definition opposed to Hamas and Hezbollah.
00:13:51 He was, I pulled it off the files here, he made this statement in West Bank during an
00:13:57 interview back in 2014, and he said, let me just say the position of the government of
00:14:04 Canada, I think, as you know well, is we favor and indeed believe that these matters can only
00:14:11 be resolved through a two-state solution with two states. And of course, here came his conditions,
00:14:19 which are essentially the same as Carney's, just differently worded, two states that are viable,
00:14:24 prosperous, secure, democratic, and living in peace. So this has always been the Canadian
00:14:31 position. Mr. Carney, why did he say it now? That puzzles me deeply. I have a theory, but
00:14:39 it isn't actually worth much. Why did he say it now when we were in the middle of tariff
00:14:48 negotiations with the United States? First, he encapsulated supply management into law,
00:14:57 And then he said he was prepared to recognize the Palestinian state under certain conditions, knowing full well that President Trump, A, hates supply management, B, is strongly pro-Israel. Why would you poke him like that at such a sensitive time? Like it was the day before the August, July the 31st and the time limit there.
00:15:19 So, all I can think of is that perhaps Mr. Carney thought there isn't going to be a deal anyway.
00:15:28 We're never going to close the gap on steel and aluminium tariffs.
00:15:32 So I'll pick up a little bit of free goodwill from people who don't like me
00:15:39 by saying that under certain conditions I'm prepared to recognize a Palestine state.
00:15:43 Maybe he even thinks that's the right thing to do.
00:15:45 But if he does, well, I guess other prime ministers have thought the same thing under the same kind of conditions that he outlined.
00:15:53 He didn't think there was a big political cost in doing so.
00:15:58 Well, OK, before we move on to the pipeline side of things, Corey, I still haven't found a satisfactory answer to why he's done this.
00:16:10 i'm not sure i agree with you nigel on on the trump thing disagreement on the pipeline is 0.86
00:16:18 a good thing yeah yeah i'm not sure i agree uh on that like look israel i the united states is not
00:16:25 acting in its national self-interest on the israel question right now uh it's in the united states
00:16:30 united states of self-interest to have peace in the region i i don't think netanyahu was a big
00:16:38 fan of that. I think while he was
00:16:40 appalled by the October 7th attacks, he also
00:16:42 saw it as the perfect excuse
00:16:43 to invade. I think he
00:16:45 it's pretty amply clear that he wanted
00:16:47 to. And I think his intention
00:16:49 is ultimately to annex Gaza 1.00
00:16:51 and expand the borders of Israel.
00:16:54 That
00:16:54 seems to align with where he's going
00:16:57 on this. But
00:16:59 Canada's national interest is
00:17:01 served primarily by getting a trade deal.
00:17:03 That is by far the most important foreign 1.00
00:17:05 policy goal for the Canadian national interest
00:17:08 right now and it's not in canada's national interest to piss off trump but it's uh well
00:17:15 i'm sympathetic to trump on a lot of these things i don't think that's necessarily his business
00:17:19 about our foreign policy on on that issue so i i i don't think it was that i think it's more likely
00:17:28 he's he's trying to shore up you know a domestic islamic voting bloc it's a very very large block
00:17:37 in Canada. And by saying this, he's, you know, making them happy. But by attaching these conditions
00:17:45 to it, he's making it unlikely that he would ever have to act on it and alienate Jewish voters,
00:17:50 which have traditionally made up a large block of liberal voters. Yeah, well, they made no bones
00:17:55 about that. There was a couple of liberal members who said, I mean, there was a lot of candid
00:17:57 conversation with one who said, you know, the demographics of my riding, I have to keep the
00:18:03 Islamic community happier. I'm not going to win my seat. And before Carney came out with that
00:18:08 statement on potential statehood for Palestine, it was said that he's dealing with caucus
00:18:12 pressures. He has a number of his own members of parliament who were pressuring him to do this.
00:18:18 He gave himself an out with the conditions that he attached to it. But yeah, there's a lot at play
00:18:24 in this. And some of it's just pure politics in keeping his own caucus happy. The Jewish vote
00:18:30 has always been a tiny vote, though they probably
00:18:32 donate $1,000 for every dollar
00:18:34 that an Islamic person puts forward. So, well, you want the 0.98
00:18:36 money or the votes? He chose the votes for now.
00:18:38 But there's just
00:18:40 less, when you're looking at it politically, there's less
00:18:42 to gain in Canada by
00:18:43 something divided between Jews and Muslims,
00:18:45 taking the Jewish side versus the Muslim? 0.90
00:18:49 Well, we're
00:18:50 going to...
00:18:51 I think we've got a nice, neat theme here.
00:18:55 You know, we're kind of
00:18:56 Canadian...
00:18:57 People in Canadian media, especially colonists, do this way too often.
00:19:00 I'm guilty of it twice today, you know, paraphrasing William Mackenzie King
00:19:06 and saying, conscription if necessary, but not necessarily conscription,
00:19:09 which really was just the most Canadian political thing to say ever,
00:19:14 which is why we use it so often.
00:19:16 It's this equivocation of not having to really take one side.
00:19:19 You know, the Canadian generals in the Second World War were demanding conscription.
00:19:22 We need more troops, but there was huge opposition to it in Quebec.
00:19:27 So we had conscription, sort of, but only volunteers would actually go fight.
00:19:32 The conscripts would stay and, you know, guard a warehouse in Quebec City somewhere, you know, before the ships leave.
00:19:41 So, yeah, a Palestinian state if necessary, but not necessarily a Palestinian state.
00:19:45 Same goes, I think, for pipelines.
00:19:48 Nigel and I were talking about this this morning.
00:19:50 You know, he's brought forward.
00:19:51 He said, we're going to build pipelines.
00:19:53 We're going to be an energy superpower, and that includes oil and gas, which require pipelines now.
00:19:58 We're going to build pipelines.
00:20:01 Asterisk.
00:20:02 If everyone agrees.
00:20:04 As long as, yes, we will build pipelines.
00:20:07 As long as Quebec is okay with it.
00:20:10 As long as every single indigenous group, even vaguely and peripherally affected, agrees to it.
00:20:18 We'll build pipelines.
00:20:20 I don't know.
00:20:22 you could take it from here. Yeah, I mean, I think the big thing with Carney is what we're
00:20:27 learning is he's a little mushy middle. He doesn't want to take sides on anything. He is trying to
00:20:33 not be the bad guy in the conflict in Gaza. And so he's hoping that he'll be like, okay, here's
00:20:41 all the conditions. Oh, sorry, Hamas couldn't separate themselves from the Palestinian people
00:20:47 or couldn't remove themselves from this conflict.
00:20:51 Therefore, don't blame me, blame them.
00:20:53 I think the same thing is, oh, I'm going to be pro-energy,
00:20:56 like renewable and traditional.
00:20:59 But if it's going to be someone's fault,
00:21:02 it's going to be Quebec's because they won't give you market access
00:21:06 or it's going to be the Indigenous that are going to, you know,
00:21:10 stomp and scream and fight saying that they're not getting their fair share
00:21:15 or whatever it is.
00:21:16 And so I think he's trying to be something for everyone and half baking all of these policies that he's announcing or positions he's announcing.
00:21:25 And the pipelines where we've already seen his first meetings with indigenous groups, mainly in northern B.C., have basically said, like, nice try, guy, but like, we're not going to entertain this.
00:21:39 See you later. He can now point to them to be the bad guys.
00:21:43 And I think that's what he's trying to set up.
00:21:44 He's trying to be this prime minister for everybody.
00:21:47 And he's going to end up being prime minister for nobody.
00:21:51 Corey, I don't know.
00:21:54 We haven't seen, we have seen a bill on this, actually, you know, the National Infrastructure
00:22:00 Priorities, whatever the building Canada, the building Canada.
00:22:03 Yeah.
00:22:04 We've seen something, but it's, it still seems nebulous.
00:22:09 We haven't had the application for a pipeline come in yet.
00:22:13 but requiring essentially unanimous consent of everyone gives everyone a veto and when you have
00:22:19 a veto you could demand so much more to the point where it might not even make sense to go forward
00:22:24 um i mean provinces should be consulted i guess for pipelines going through i don't think that's
00:22:30 unreasonable uh first nations should be consulted if it goes to their land there should be some
00:22:35 benefit to them uh but if everyone's got a hard veto uh it ups everyone's negotiating power to
00:22:42 the nth degree, to the point where the proponent is facing so many roadblocks that it could be
00:22:50 damn near impossible to make a profitable case to do these things. Yeah, he has to, again,
00:22:55 it's an effective theme. He's got to show a stance, yes or no, because this wishy-washy thing,
00:23:00 companies aren't going to commit billions to that. He's got to stand up and define the difference
00:23:05 between consent and consult. Sean Fraser, his own minister, dared to do that, what, a couple of
00:23:10 months ago and he got pilloried for it and apologized because he actually stated the law
00:23:15 that I'm sorry, but we don't need consent from indigenous people. We are obligated to consult 0.90
00:23:20 and they went bananas and he retracted it and apologized, but he was absolutely right. So
00:23:25 if they can't even say it out loud, no company's going to put the money in. No application's going
00:23:31 to come. And I fear what he's building up is he's an ideological leader as well, though he can say,
00:23:36 well, look, I tried, but it would be similar to like Justin Trudeau. There's obviously no business
00:23:39 case because no private interest has stepped up and he'll lay it on that rather than the reality
00:23:44 that nobody in the right mind would invest in that climate. Why spend hundreds of millions,
00:23:48 possibly billions on the studies and the applications and all of that only to be
00:23:53 hitting a brick wall as other companies have done? Nigel, I think building up what Corey said,
00:24:00 I think in both cases, recognizing a Palestinian state on pipelines, I think he actually
00:24:08 wants a no on both, I think. Just judging by what he's set up as the criteria for both,
00:24:15 he just doesn't want to be the one to say no. On a Palestinian state, hey, look, I want to 0.95
00:24:21 recognize a Palestinian state. I want to go there. But look, these are the reasonable conditions I
00:24:26 set out. Hamas won't disarm, etc., etc. Sorry, it wasn't my choice. That was them. Similar on a 0.78
00:24:34 pipeline. I think he wants to know because we know he's got a long ideological track record.
00:24:39 He's written books on this stuff. You know, was he a sudden convert to pipelines? No,
00:24:45 he's a sudden convert to political reality. And if you keep Alberta in Canada, you can't just say
00:24:51 no, no pipelines. If you want to appear to be the reasonable moderate guy who's not as crazy as the
00:24:57 ideologue Justin Trudeau, you can't just say no to pipelines. But he can go through this,
00:25:02 set up a new set of roadblocks
00:25:04 to the point where other companies
00:25:06 aren't willing to go forward. They don't have to be projected.
00:25:09 They're going to say, hey, these roadblocks are
00:25:10 we just can't get through it.
00:25:12 And then they withdraw, as Corey said.
00:25:14 He is not the one saying no to pipelines.
00:25:16 It's just, ah, those pipelines couldn't
00:25:18 meet these reasonable conditions
00:25:20 that I've set out. I think this is
00:25:22 actually just very smart
00:25:24 politics. This is
00:25:25 3D chess that he is
00:25:28 able to get a no on these things he
00:25:30 wants a no to by just setting
00:25:32 you know setting a line that he knows no one's going to meet you know on those two particular
00:25:40 items i think you may be right i mean before you came in this morning we were having a discussion
00:25:46 about sometimes just doing nothing until you're absolutely forced to do something is smart
00:25:53 politics the issue i have with that is that sometimes you want a politician to actually
00:26:04 say this is what i believe in and although there is opposition i am going forward you know one of
00:26:10 the one of the things that is helping us right now is that quite a steel and aluminium except
00:26:17 that a lot of Canadian exports are presently protected by the US and Mexico-Canada Trade
00:26:26 Agreement, otherwise known as CUSMA, and it is a successor to what? To the North American
00:26:34 Free Trade Association, which Brian Mulroney won, of course, back in the 1980s. Well, if
00:26:41 If Brian Mulroney had taken the Carney-esque approach to politics, he would have probably
00:26:47 found a reason not to complete the negotiations that led to NAFTA, because a lot of people
00:26:54 didn't want it.
00:26:55 The unions were dead set against it, the NDP were campaigning on it, the Liberals didn't
00:26:59 like it, but Mulroney stuck to his guns, he got NAFTA, and today we have the advantage
00:27:06 of that through the legacy treaty that still protects some Canadian exports from the tariffs
00:27:16 that Mr. Trump has applied over and above.
00:27:19 So there is a value to a politician believing in something, going forward, making it happen,
00:27:25 making it work, and staying the course.
00:27:27 What we see from Mr. Carney is actually a recipe for the Canadian drift that we have
00:27:35 been experiencing since certainly since the uh start of mr trudeau's uh coming to office back
00:27:42 in 2015 it's getting us nowhere it's taking us nowhere maybe if you actually want to build a
00:27:49 stronger canada i think mr carney may find he's going to have to be a little stronger himself
00:27:54 but how did brian mulrooney's prime membership ship end he did take big bold gambles it paid
00:28:02 off on NAFTA, but he also
00:28:04 took a big, bold gamble on the
00:28:06 GST, and ultimately that
00:28:08 policy did endure. It endures
00:28:10 to this day. It was a very
00:28:12 it was wildly unpopular,
00:28:15 but in hindsight, everyone agrees
00:28:16 that was a no-brainer
00:28:18 fix to the economy
00:28:20 and the finances of the country.
00:28:22 He took big, bold
00:28:24 gambles on the Constitution at Charlottetown
00:28:26 and at Meech Lake.
00:28:29 I think they were well-intentioned,
00:28:31 but they were terrible, and right
00:28:32 defeated but um they ultimately blew up his political coalition and left him politically
00:28:40 radioactive until pretty much near the end of his life um making big bold decisions i think is the
00:28:47 reason you should be in politics to change things but it invariably i think shortens your political
00:28:53 life it it's going to make you unpopular it's going to it's going to limit your time in office
00:28:58 It's going to limit how many people like you.
00:29:01 If your goal is power over the long term, the more indirect, some would say cowardly approach,
00:29:10 but, you know, the indirect, you know, maybe more, it's the Sun Tzu indirect approach.
00:29:14 Perhaps that is better.
00:29:15 I'm not sure Brian Mulroney is a great example of big political gambles paying off very well.
00:29:20 Well, it paid off for the country.
00:29:21 I mean, when you're choosing a prime minister, you're going to either pick a guy who wants to be the prime minister, or you can pick a guy who wants to get something done.
00:29:32 The guy who wants to get something done may well pay the political cost.
00:29:37 You use up your political capital, and then you disappear.
00:29:40 It's unfortunate.
00:29:42 But, you know, I've never been a big Brian Mulroney fan.
00:29:46 But right now, I can see where what he did is paying off for Mr. Carney, little people.
00:29:54 Erica, this might be a good pivot to where we're going to go.
00:29:58 You know, I've said that Mark Carney is, you know, on both Palestine and pipelines.
00:30:02 He's putting up these conditions that he doesn't, I suspect he doesn't think will be fulfilled.
00:30:09 And these ideas can be shot down, not by himself.
00:30:12 He could say, ah, it was out of my hands.
00:30:14 Some would accuse Danielle Smith of doing the same thing with Ottawa. 0.94
00:30:18 She has put down conditions by which Alberta would be happy and content in Confederation.
00:30:25 That's ending equalization essentially to Quebec and Ontario, that we build pipelines,
00:30:30 we end Ottawa's meddling in areas of jurisdiction under the guise of the environment, etc.
00:30:36 She has her seven big conditions, or 11 if it's parsed out more.
00:30:41 Some would say that she knows Ottawa.
00:30:45 I've read some of these lefty columnists who say she knows Ottawa.
00:30:49 We'll never say yes to these things.
00:30:52 I always consider those to be an extremely low bar for accepting rule by Ottawa.
00:30:58 Yes, of course, we should not be funding Quebec from Alberta tax dollars.
00:31:03 We should not be allowing Ottawa to meddle in our provincial jurisdiction, etc.
00:31:07 For me, those conditions are not enough to make me content with Ottawa rule, but she's been accused, and I can see where they're at least coming from, of maybe similarly setting up these conditions that she knows cannot be fulfilled, and that acts as a cause for her potentially to come out in favour of an independence referendum at some point. What are your thoughts?
00:31:31 Well, I think a few things. First off, she is playing by the rule book of how the Constitution is structured, where in this case with pipelines, the federal government, to many of our points, is consulting versus consent, working if the provinces are asking for it and they're okay, like that's their natural resources falls to the province.
00:31:54 And so I think she's playing the game a little bit more by the playbook where the jurisdiction of those national projects or our international relations is up to the jurisdiction of the prime minister.
00:32:10 So I do sympathize with what you're saying on is it, you know, pot calling kettle black.
00:32:16 I actually don't think it really is as clear as that because she's looking at things that should be reset to ultimately get back to, say, equalization where the province are equal partners to the federal government, where each of them stay in their own lanes.
00:32:32 So, but to your point, is it ever going to actually like, is an equalization formula change really realistic? Who knows? But I would say-
00:32:43 Well, even Paul Yeager doesn't, he says he won't change it.
00:32:45 No, or looking at different things. So, yeah. And so where I think Alberta is going and I think where we want to take the conversation is, okay, what does that mean for Albertans? I mean, I still get really happy that she's standing up for that because there's other provinces that do.
00:33:01 I'm in Saskatchewan where I was born and raised right now, and they feel the same way.
00:33:04 They're just not as good about advocating for it vocally on the national stage.
00:33:10 So we'll see, you know, how that plays out.
00:33:13 She's also making very bold moves here that could play out really well for her or not.
00:33:18 So I think we also kind of were foreshadowing Alberta from some of the Brian Mulroney decisions,
00:33:23 how health care reform is going to play out, how looking at some of these exploring pension,
00:33:29 that kind of flopped. Now we're looking at the provincial police and the Alberta next panels.
00:33:34 I'm actually going to the one in Edmonton on the 14th. So I should be able to report back how that
00:33:40 lands. But either way, how we started this show is you talking about one of my least favorite
00:33:46 politicians or wannabe politicians, Thomas Lukasik. I don't care how you feel about federalism. I love
00:33:52 federalism on how it's actually supposed to be constructed. But the fact that we have an
00:33:57 individual that's trying to say that the Alberta flag is a negative thing is, I think, completely
00:34:04 distasteful and something that our viewers should be hearing more about to really educate themselves
00:34:11 on what that means for unity and for our province. Yeah. All right. We're transitioning beautifully.
00:34:18 Corey, it was actually your tweet that brought this to my attention. You found, okay, so just
00:34:25 people know most people don't know who this guy is i'm thinking i don't know he was the first
00:34:30 politician at the legislature i worked for oh yeah he was the first politician i worked for him
00:34:36 sorry you worked for him yeah when he was the minister of education my first job at the
00:34:42 legislature so it's a whole yeah thank god you found jesus all right um well okay so just so
00:34:50 people know most people don't know who this guy is he uh i guess he was a progressive conservative
00:34:58 mla uh when allison redford comes to power uh wins in 2012 she makes him deputy premier uh with no
00:35:07 other portfolio can we just mention that he is the deputy premier with no other portfolio basically
00:35:12 giving someone a make-believe job so they'd be quiet yeah yeah generally when i was there i can
00:35:16 say it yeah when you see a leader a deputy leader of a party without a portfolio it means uh they're
00:35:23 probably not very good normally um so uh but anyway this he fell out of that office with
00:35:30 alice redford's collapse and you know you have like a twenty thousand dollar phone bill or
00:35:34 something always on vacation that he put the taxpayers and so he was out he lost his seat
00:35:37 in 2015 when the ndp came in uh and i don't know if he's had a job since i think he's just been on
00:35:43 Twitter. I don't know how
00:35:45 he's been paying his bills. Maybe CFC makes a lot.
00:35:48 I don't know. I don't know.
00:35:49 I'm not aware. He's a kept man. That's 0.98
00:35:51 his business. Yeah. But as far
00:35:53 as I know, he's just been tweeting for the last decade
00:35:55 or so. But
00:35:57 he has fashioned himself.
00:35:59 Captain Canada here. He
00:36:01 is...
00:36:02 Yeah. So he was up to
00:36:05 something. You found it. We've done a bunch on it
00:36:07 since. But just tell people exactly
00:36:09 what happened. Yeah. And to be fair to Luke Kassig
00:36:11 and I find him as odious as most of us here
00:36:13 do. It wasn't him
00:36:15 directly who decided it was 0.67
00:36:17 a good idea to crap on Alberta's flag. 0.77
00:36:19 It was one of his followers on 0.90
00:36:21 his Facebook group for
00:36:23 I guess I've got to give some more backstory.
00:36:25 Lukasik is trying a counter petition to the
00:36:27 independence movement to hold
00:36:29 a fake referendum which would just
00:36:31 say we're all happy we're going to stay in Canada, which
00:36:33 doesn't change anything. It's like a trolling move.
00:36:36 They have a book that they call, or a
00:36:37 Facebook page they called Forever Canadian, where they
00:36:39 were organizing and gathering
00:36:41 other members to push this petition and get it going. And I just checked it out and I scrolled
00:36:47 my way down. I guess more of it curiosity. And I found this posting from one of their supporters
00:36:51 who had put a picture up on that group days before saying, yeah, I'd found this Alberta flag
00:36:57 hanging in a Safeway Medicine hat. And I complained to the Western managers and they pulled it down
00:37:03 and we got to stop, you know, getting, we got to get these symbols torn down of this separatism
00:37:07 this terrible thing is the Alberta flag. Part of why I lay this on Lukasik's feet is, hey,
00:37:13 if you're going to head the movement, you wear what your supporters do and you control their
00:37:17 communications on a page that you is representing you. I mean, you can't control this one dingbat, 0.98
00:37:23 but I thought he was, he was pushing. No, no. But if he'd done that five days before, by then,
00:37:30 somebody should have said, you know, we might want to pull that off there before some clown 0.97
00:37:34 like Cory Morgan spots it and throws it out on X and completely embarrasses you. This went bad to 0.58
00:37:39 the point that they shut down that Facebook page. Lukasik has reopened his old campaign page from
00:37:44 2014 to use as a new Facebook hub to try and rejuvenate because you don't attack the symbol
00:37:52 of a province. I mean, symbols are important. They're emotionally, they're attached to people.
00:37:58 You can attack the independence movement. You can attack the individuals, but when you start
00:38:02 besmirching the flag of Alberta that had the exact opposite effect of what they were looking to do,
00:38:09 but it does show the mindset of the following, because it wasn't just this gentleman who did
00:38:14 that to Safeway, which by the way, Safeway put it right back up once the backlash hit them.
00:38:17 I think they just wanted to sell groceries. They didn't want to get in the middle of them. Yes,
00:38:20 it was just a flag, but it was all the other people commenting below, gee, where do I contact
00:38:25 my local Safeway? I better do this for other businesses. That also started to show, and that's
00:38:29 why they had to get rid of that Facebook page, because it's not just
00:38:31 one nut, it's Lukasik's
00:38:33 gang of little elbows-up minions 0.83
00:38:35 started going after the Alberta flag.
00:38:38 And they actually had
00:38:39 to crash their whole page to get out of the mess they stepped
00:38:41 in. It says a lot about how well-organized
00:38:43 his little movement is, too.
00:38:45 Erica.
00:38:47 Okay, so Lukasik, I guess, wasn't behind
00:38:49 the campaign itself to remove Alberta
00:38:51 flags, so if I miss...
00:38:53 Yeah, no, I thought the same, but that was
00:38:55 because I read the same thing.
00:38:57 But it is his organization,
00:38:59 and i i half agree with you cory that you have to wear what your supporters do i have to i mean like
00:39:05 anyone who's ever been a part of a big movement or in a political party knows you've always got
00:39:09 some nutters but if someone goes particularly far off the reserve you've got to make the point that
00:39:15 no that guy doesn't represent us i i think that's fair and you don't have to do it for every little 0.99
00:39:19 asshole who says something stupid but if you've got something and you've left it up there and 0.99
00:39:23 your people are clearly ginned up and excited about it no you have to wear that if you if you're not 1.00
00:39:28 going to condemn it. But I, okay, coming back to you, because I didn't know you worked for
00:39:33 Lukasik. But when I was discussing this, when I was discussing this with Nigel and Corey this
00:39:41 morning, when we're figuring out what we're going to talk about, I thought, isn't it incredible that
00:39:46 Thomas Lukasik is the face of the Federalist cause here? And I thought, you know, if I was
00:39:51 running like the, an Alberta counterintelligence agency, like Daniel Smith created the Alberta
00:39:57 cia and i was in charge of it or something and i got to do all sorts of subversive counter
00:40:02 intelligence things i would have planted thomas lukasik as as like the boss of the federalist
00:40:10 side if i could have picked like which greasy unarticulate inarticulate uh 0.97
00:40:18 disreputable guy can i get to lead the other side so it's sort of discredit that side i'd
00:40:25 been like, ding, ding, ding, Thomas Lukasik. That's the guy we want. How in the hell have
00:40:32 the Federalist side seemingly accepted Thomas Lukasik as their captain in Canada here?
00:40:39 Well, I think he's been positioning himself by seeking a job for the last decade of becoming
00:40:45 very much a, you know, distancing himself from what he once was, which was a red Tory to a
00:40:52 pure red liberal. And so he has been very vocal, hated Jason Kenney, like when they were both
00:41:01 ministers, they fought very publicly, as I think many might remember, he didn't like Daniel Smith
00:41:10 ever. So this was a great opportunity to give someone that wanted it a platform. Now, I will
00:41:16 say Thomas worked really hard, like he was a very hardworking MLA, very good to his constituents,
00:41:22 So ideologically, I disagree with everything that he said, but he is a hard worker.
00:41:31 So I think from the left, they're like, well, this is a guy that will actually roll up their
00:41:35 sleeves and pound pavement and be loud about it.
00:41:39 And, you know, not being born and raised here or coming here at a young age has a story
00:41:44 that might be relatable to a lot of people we want to get behind this movement.
00:41:49 And so I can see on paper or maybe just doing a quick search of him. But you're right. If I was running like oppo research or like behind the scenes stuff, I also would put Thomas Lukasik there because I think it actually does help contrast between Danielle Smith or even any of the individuals working towards looking at what separatism or independence would look like.
00:42:16 I would love to have Kamas Lukasik as the alternative because I don't think it helps
00:42:20 their cause. I guess just quickly before we go to our
00:42:24 parting shots, Nigel,
00:42:26 the federalist conservatives in Alberta, I mean a majority, a pretty big
00:42:32 majority of Alberta self-identified conservative voters say
00:42:36 they support independence, but there's a pretty sizable minority
00:42:39 who do not, who are federalists.
00:42:42 and that's disproportionately a higher number
00:42:47 the higher up the political food chain you go
00:42:49 you've got your Jason Kenney's, etc.
00:42:52 How do you think those guys are going to feel
00:42:54 marching in Thomas' little band?
00:42:59 Well, you know, they don't have to wait
00:43:01 to march in his band to feel a bit awkward
00:43:03 because they may still be Federalists
00:43:06 but that doesn't mean they like the values
00:43:09 that the Liberals are pushing
00:43:12 and imposing on the rest of the country they don't want that in here in alberta so there's
00:43:17 not willing they're just really not quite ready to uh to raise the revolutionary flag but
00:43:24 you know people aren't happy i think thomas is gonna be the gift that keeps giving oh i'm
00:43:31 planning on making a match i think he's the next nenshi like that was a great gift for conservatives 0.50
00:43:37 to have Nenshi as the NDP, and now
00:43:39 we have Thomas
00:43:40 leading Loud and Proud, the
00:43:42 You don't think one Nenshi 0.76
00:43:45 is enough?
00:43:46 If it helps our movement,
00:43:49 they can both do whatever they want.
00:43:51 Okay.
00:43:52 Alright, well let's move it into
00:43:54 Parting Shots, since you've been missing
00:43:56 from us for some time.
00:43:59 Erica, why don't you start? Well, I was here when you
00:44:00 weren't, just for the record, and we had quite a time.
00:44:03 That was one week, and you guys
00:44:05 said, I know Derek's not watching,
00:44:06 i watched no i think we don't miss him i think that was different and i don't remember but
00:44:12 something along those lines anyways okay my parting shot is not directed at you derek
00:44:17 um it is directed at elections canada uh i think it's actual complete and an insult to democracy
00:44:23 that after what happened in the carlton riding of pierre polyev that they weren't looking to
00:44:30 streamline or make this process or disregard or like make some quick changes in regulations
00:44:36 or something to address the fact of having 200 candidates, all 180 or so that have the same
00:44:44 CFO, the same official agent, all of these things, same signatures. Like to me, that is not a
00:44:50 democratic reflection of how Canada is supposed to work. And so I know that they've made this piss
00:44:58 poor attempt to list all of the candidates. Now you have to write them in. But as a result,
00:45:05 I will personally be going and scrutineering to make sure that every vote for Pierre and the Conservatives is clear and counted and that they can't make excuses for misspelling or any of that sort.
00:45:18 So I think it's like a, you know, half assed solution to something that they should have addressed from the outset.
00:45:25 OK, Nigel. Oh, no, no. You're going to be the last one today because today's your last parting shot.
00:45:30 Corey? Well I'll be quick here
00:45:32 Travis Donridge is the latest
00:45:34 senior CBC reporter who
00:45:36 has left and
00:45:37 has been speaking out about the working conditions at the
00:45:40 mother corp there and Catherine
00:45:42 Marshall's his lawyer and I caught her in an interview
00:45:44 where she's speaking of some of the things she's
00:45:46 learning about the working conditions and this just says
00:45:48 so much about the CBC
00:45:49 apparently they have
00:45:51 designated crying rooms
00:45:53 for staff within the CBC
00:45:55 if you're overwhelmed, if it's all
00:45:58 just too much. If you just can't take it anymore, we shouldn't have you crying around the rest of
00:46:02 you. So go to your designated crying room, have a good cry and get it out. What a pathetic 0.97
00:46:07 organization. Well, that's what I call your office here, the crying room. I mean, when you make me 1.00
00:46:10 cry, we have it right in public in front of everybody. And if I didn't hear you, we play it.
00:46:15 Your desk is actually not at all. You're in the middle of the newsroom. So when you cry, we all
00:46:19 hear it. That's right. Yeah. I'm going to take mine real, real quick. You get the last one.
00:46:25 and it's not really a regular parting shot
00:46:28 but I just want to say I've become addicted to the
00:46:30 Tucker Carlson podcast lately
00:46:31 it is so
00:46:34 taboo and so in
00:46:36 depth
00:46:36 he's just the most
00:46:40 incredible guests on
00:46:41 exploring
00:46:43 I'm listening
00:46:46 on the Oklahoma City bombing right now
00:46:48 I thought I knew everything about it
00:46:49 in quite a bit of detail
00:46:51 I'm learning all sorts of new stuff
00:46:52 so it's not a regular parting shot in the news
00:46:55 I just want to call attention to it. I normally don't
00:46:57 listen. I don't consume a lot of American
00:46:59 news content. I'm very much
00:47:01 an exception to most Canadians who actually
00:47:03 prefer American news over Canadian.
00:47:05 But I just want to flag attention to that.
00:47:07 That has become a phenomenal
00:47:08 program to listen to.
00:47:11 And for his
00:47:12 final parting shot, we will have him
00:47:15 back in the future, but his final parting shot
00:47:16 as opinion editor of the
00:47:18 Western Standard before he arrives
00:47:20 into retirement sunset, Nigel.
00:47:22 I feel like I should say something terribly
00:47:24 profound and but really what i what i need to say is what a incredible three years it has been here
00:47:31 at the western standard what an honor to work having started in newspapers that still had led
00:47:37 presses to come out where it's all online but above all to present a conservative point of view
00:47:42 to a conservative audience you know a chance to say what you want to say
00:47:46 phil lebron has never censored me that i appreciate so thank you for that beric
00:47:52 You're not allowed to say that.
00:47:53 Cut the camera.
00:47:55 Thank you, Nigel.
00:47:57 Nigel, no, it's been a profound privilege working with you.
00:48:00 You've really upped the quality of debate and argument and polemics here.
00:48:08 I am so glad to have had you, and we're very sad to miss you.
00:48:13 But we're going to get you back in for the pipeline from time to time here,
00:48:17 and we're still going to be counting on your calls.
00:48:20 All right.
00:48:21 thank you all right uh everyone in the comment sections you should leave uh some nice thank
00:48:27 yous to Nigel if you like him if you don't like him say some mean things we like mean things here
00:48:31 too it's okay all right Nigel Corey Erica thank you thank you John on production thank all of you
00:48:39 who have uh joined us today we appreciate the time you've shared with us thank you for everything
00:48:45 you've done go to westernstandard.news right now click on subscribe it's only ten dollars a month
00:48:49 or $100 a year for unlimited access
00:48:52 to all Western Standard content.
00:48:54 That is how we're going to keep the doors open
00:48:56 and the lights on here at the Western Standard
00:48:58 as the rest of the media goes through an apocalypse
00:49:01 and turns into a desert of broken down presses and cameras.
00:49:05 We'll survive because we've got people like you
00:49:08 willing to put in a few bucks a month to support our work.
00:49:11 Thank you very much for joining us today, and God bless.
00:49:19 We'll be right back.