Western Standard - November 07, 2025


Carney budget to bring inflation, cut debt while you can

Topics
Mentioned
GOOD BOY!: Mighty canine Titus joins Calgary fire department as new arson detection dog CORY MORGAN SHOW: Albertans want an independence referendum

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

161.89

Word count

4,059

Sentence count

165

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

To talk about what the Bank of Canada's 2019 budget means to you, I'm pleased to welcome back Dr. Tim Sargent, an economist and the Director of Domestic Policy at the McDonnell-Laurier Institute in Ottawa.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:21 It is Thursday, November 6. To talk about what the Mark Carney budget means to you,
00:00:27 I'm pleased to welcome back Dr. Tim Sargent, an economist and the Director of Domestic Policy
00:00:33 at the famous McDonnell-Laurier Institute in Ottawa. Dr. Sargent, welcome back to the show.
00:00:39 Thanks for having me, Nigel.
00:00:41 It's a great pleasure. Tim, once upon a time you were a Deputy Minister,
00:00:45 you were in the PCO, the Privy Council office, you were in finance, you're used to the salesmanship
00:00:51 that goes with these things. So can you strip away the syrupy words and tell us what they
00:00:57 just did here with this budget happy to nigel and there's a lot of words it's forward in six pages
00:01:04 um even i have trouble going through it and i helped used to help write them as you said
00:01:08 um the most consequential budget in canadian recently in history is the 1995 budget which
00:01:13 is less than half the length of this one um so in terms of the budget itself i mean there's
00:01:19 lots of graphics lots of political message but to strip away i mean you basically got to ask
00:01:24 three questions about what the government is trying to do here. Firstly, are they focusing
00:01:29 on the right problem? And I think for many years, certainly over the Trudeau government,
00:01:34 they're actually not focusing on the right problems. But I think this budget does. The real
00:01:39 problem, we have two problems in Canada. We have a short-term economic problem coming from the Trump
00:01:43 administration and its attack on our trade. But then we have a more important long-term problem
00:01:51 with productivity in this country, which has been lagging behind the United States for at least a
00:01:56 decade. Underneath that is low investment. We simply have not been investing as a country,
00:02:04 and here I'm talking about the private sector. I think the budget recognizes that. It recognizes
00:02:10 that these two economic problems are serious, and the government needs to address them.
00:02:16 The second question you would have is, okay, we've got the right problem.
00:02:20 Do we understand what's causing the problem?
00:02:23 And I would say, I think most economists would say that the challenge of the last 10 years
00:02:28 is government has gotten too big, immigration is too high, taxes are too high, there's too
00:02:34 much regulation.
00:02:35 I think the budget recognizes some of those problems.
00:02:40 There's an attempt to cut the size of government, reducing immigration, something on taxes.
00:02:46 until you talk about regulation so i think that they mostly understand the problem um understand
00:02:53 what's causing the problem but the third and most important part of it is what are you actually going
00:02:57 to do to address the problem um and do you have do you have the strength the willpower and do you
00:03:03 have the right ideas to address address those problems it's all very well to you know have a
00:03:08 problem understand the causing but the main thing is to actually go ahead and deal with the problem
00:03:13 And here, I think, is where the budget really comes up short.
00:03:17 I think you have a bunch of half measures.
00:03:20 They cut the public sector, but by nowhere near as much as it's grown over the last few years.
00:03:26 They cut taxes, but not as much as I think that they could.
00:03:30 And it's focused at the low end.
00:03:34 This cuts to see corporate income tax, but perhaps not as big as they need to be.
00:03:38 Immigration is cut, but by not as much as it should to be.
00:03:40 So there's a bunch of half measures.
00:03:42 There's also a fair amount of waffle about the emissions cap.
00:03:46 Do we have an emissions cap? Don't we have an emissions cap?
00:03:48 It's a bit like Schrodinger's cap right now.
00:03:49 It's sort of, we don't really want to open the box and see if it's there or not.
00:03:53 Electric vehicle mandate, is that staying or not?
00:03:56 Well, they're going to do a review. They're going to tell us a bit more later.
00:04:00 And then there's a few areas where I think they're clearly doubling down on the wrong policies.
00:04:05 On housing, for instance, it's not government that's going to build the homes to solve the housing crisis.
00:04:11 You've got to be cutting regulations, making sure that interest rates aren't too high.
00:04:16 If you look at the direction of climate policy overall, I mean, they're still very much focused on 2050 and net zero.
00:04:24 We want to increase the industrial carbon tax to $170 at a time where a lot of our businesses are going to be struggling, throwing a lot of money at infrastructure.
00:04:34 sure um so you know if you if you strip away a lot of the salesmanship um i think they're trying
00:04:41 to get into problems but a lot of these solutions are either they're either not enough or they're
00:04:45 going in the wrong direction well let's uh there's a number of things there that are particular
00:04:51 interest to our audience let's go back to the first to the emissions cap i mean for those are
00:05:00 the people not involved in the oil industry directly.
00:05:04 That's a bit of jargon.
00:05:05 What it means is that the large oil companies,
00:05:09 especially those involved in extracting oil from the oil sands,
00:05:14 are being told that they can't emit as much carbon dioxide
00:05:19 because of the climate change narrative.
00:05:23 And that is a constriction on production.
00:05:26 So to give them their due, the oil companies have got quite creative about how to produce the same amount of oil with less carbon dioxide, even pushing the stuff underground with massive pumps and incredibly low temperatures, so carbon sequestration.
00:05:46 But even after you've done all that, there is still carbon produced.
00:05:53 And so the issue seems to be that the government in this budget is predicting, is promising,
00:06:00 that it will increase the price of carbon that will be charged to the producing companies
00:06:07 from $80 now to $170 in about five years' time.
00:06:11 my question is how does that flow out into the marketplace does it mean i don't see how it can
00:06:23 fail to mean the higher prices for gasoline and other energy products uh and then more generally
00:06:30 does this give the industry a chance to even stay afloat because they're producing for export
00:06:38 And this is going to push the price up.
00:06:40 Absolutely.
00:06:41 And it's a very, very competitive market for oil, for gas, for refined gasoline.
00:06:48 What's interesting is if you look at the budget, the budget actually, the section of the budget that talks about climate starts out by saying how good our companies are at actually having low emissions and how much progress that they've made.
00:07:02 and they compare Canada to many other countries around the world that haven't made the same
00:07:07 progress in reducing emissions in the oil and gas sector. So you could say, well, Canada's so good,
00:07:13 why do we need to go further? Why can't we just wait for everybody else to catch up with where we
00:07:17 are? But the government, of course, it's intent on squeezing every last carbon dioxide emission
00:07:26 out of the Canadian economy.
00:07:28 Only in the Western Canadian economy.
00:07:31 You can still import all the oil you want from Nigeria or Kazakhstan,
00:07:37 and this doesn't apply.
00:07:40 That's right.
00:07:41 I mean, the world wants high economies.
00:07:43 How do they square those things?
00:07:45 And, of course, at the same time, they want to see more investment.
00:07:48 The whole budget is supposedly about incenting private sector investment,
00:07:51 and oil and gas sector is a huge investor in the Canadian economy.
00:07:57 So unfortunately, what this is going to do, if they're serious about it, is it's just going to
00:08:03 make further oil and gas investment in the Canadian economy uneconomic. Private sector
00:08:09 investors have lots of places to put their money around the world, including in places that have
00:08:15 very high emissions in their oil and gas sectors. But international investors really don't care
00:08:21 about that. And one thing that we've seen over the last few years is that even just over the last
00:08:26 years, they've stopped pretending to care. You've seen the whole ESG, environmental, social and
00:08:34 governance movement, which is designed to put pressure on companies and financial institutions
00:08:39 to not invest in so-called dirty industries. That has really ground to a halt. So investors right now,
00:08:47 they're being very hard-nosed and they won't value money for that dollar and that dollar won't come
00:08:51 to Canada if the condition is outright. It's very obvious from the big numbers that have been
00:08:59 committed to what they describe as investment. The number of $115 billion was given out for
00:09:07 infrastructure. Well, what's the infrastructure going to be? It doesn't seem like there's going
00:09:13 to be much need for pipelines, but in any case, this is all government investment.
00:09:20 it seems to me that that is probably if you wanted to build an economy the last people
00:09:25 you would want doing it would be the government you would want to attract private capital
00:09:29 and 20 years ago we were we were even 10 years 10 years ago we were attracting it like crazy
00:09:37 it's gone away so is there actually do you think uh reading for reading between the lines as much
00:09:46 as you can you you think that this government actually has a comfort with being in charge
00:09:52 of the economy and rather than just being a keeper of the rules actually wants to run things
00:10:00 i think that's right um i mean you do because if that's if i'm right i'm scared
00:10:06 because they they see the problem and you know it's great to have smart people at the top of
00:10:11 of government. Mark Carney is very smart. I've worked with him for him, been across the table
00:10:17 for him. The challenge with being very smart, though, is that you think that every problem has
00:10:22 a solution and that you need to be that solution. And the reality is, however smart you are,
00:10:28 the real way to get investment is not for somebody at the top of government, however smart, to say,
00:10:33 well, we need to invest here or we need to invest there. You don't have all of the information
00:10:37 needed for that. You're not the actual person on the ground who knows what market demand is,
00:10:44 knows what the costs are, and has that market discipline that forces you to make correct
00:10:50 economic decisions. Governments can afford to indulge themselves and often end up investing
00:10:58 in things that the private sector doesn't want to invest in, but for good reason, because they
00:11:03 actually don't make any economic sense. You can see this on housing as a good example.
00:11:09 We're going to be spending billions of dollars to build a very small number of houses because
00:11:16 when the government builds things, it's always a lot more expensive. The government's not very
00:11:20 good at getting value for money for its dollar because it's not the government's dollars,
00:11:24 they're ultimately taxpayers' dollars. But when it's individual, when it's a company,
00:11:28 it's their dollars or they're responsible to their shareholders and they will actually make
00:11:33 much better decisions than government. Well, you know, you're making it sound,
00:11:37 and I think perhaps you intend to make it sound like a technocrat's budget,
00:11:43 and of course that is one of the frequent criticisms of Mr. Carney, that he is
00:11:51 slightly less than human and therefore a technocrat. It's an unkind thing to say, but
00:11:58 but, you know, he doesn't do well on personality.
00:12:01 So the thing is, I'm looking through this budget,
00:12:04 and I confess I haven't gone all through 493 pages,
00:12:07 but I look through the budget and I go out and I think,
00:12:11 well, who is this really trying to please?
00:12:13 If I was a liberal, what would I look at in there and say,
00:12:17 ah, that is going to be good for me, and he gets my vote.
00:12:22 what what do you think that is what is there there that you could actually go out and sell
00:12:30 to your liberal voter base i mean the i mean there's not a lot there if i mean if you are
00:12:37 let's say a trudeau liberal um which probably means actually in your heart and any peer
00:12:42 just an any peer likes to be in government um you know there's not a lot there and in many ways
00:12:48 So they're going in the opposite direction from the two-door government.
00:12:52 The cuts to the public sector, maybe not as big as some economists would like to see,
00:12:56 but they're definitely there.
00:12:59 The emissions caps in question, the EV policy is in question.
00:13:04 We're seeing cuts to immigration, significant cuts.
00:13:08 I mean, there's definitely some more spending there.
00:13:10 As I say, there's on housing, there's on infrastructure.
00:13:14 There's $5 billion, for instance, that's going to be spent on building hospitals.
00:13:17 Now, you know, I like hospitals as much as an ex-person, but I don't think it's the federal government's job to build hospitals.
00:13:24 That's why we have provincial governments. 0.99
00:13:26 But, you know, if you're a liberal, you often, liberals tend to care less about what the federal provincial division of powers should be and are always keen for the federal government to interfere in areas of provincial competence.
00:13:40 So you do have some of these, you know, nice little spending items.
00:13:45 But it's certainly not the same as we've seen in some previous liberal budgets.
00:13:50 Well, and so I'm wondering if, in my own mind, whether I can honestly portray this as the whole thing,
00:14:00 as an extension of federal government involvement and control in the Canadian economy overall.
00:14:08 Is that a fair assessment?
00:14:12 I think that's right.
00:14:13 I think they're trying to catalyze investment, as they put it, across a whole series of sectors, including areas where we should really see the provinces take the lead.
00:14:26 Natural resources is a good example where, I mean, really they should be pulling back and allowing the provinces to manage their natural resources and decide what appropriate emissions cuts are, for instance.
00:14:38 And that's basically what the Constitution says.
00:14:42 It should be provinces that manage the natural resources
00:14:45 and provinces that decide what infrastructure they need.
00:14:49 Now, if it crosses a provincial boundary, that means you need a pipeline,
00:14:53 then, yes, the federal government should step in.
00:14:56 But, of course, we're not actually seeing anything really in this budget about pipelines.
00:15:01 They stay away from that particular infrastructure investment,
00:15:04 even though they want to double exports to the rest of the world.
00:15:07 well, I don't see how you can do that without exporting more oil and gas,
00:15:12 particularly over the Rockets to the Pacific Ocean.
00:15:16 Okay, just to be the devil's advocate for a moment,
00:15:20 if I were a liberal flack wanting to present this in the most attractive way that I could,
00:15:27 I'd build the argument something like this.
00:15:29 The global markets might give this a passing grade
00:15:32 because strong for investment, trade and stability,
00:15:37 we're sending a clear signal that we have ambitious capital incentives, bold infrastructure
00:15:44 plans, pragmatic resource strategy. Did I say tragedy? It all sets the tone as the country
00:15:53 pivots to compete both in North America and beyond. And not all debt is bad. Sometimes if
00:16:00 you put it to good use, then debt is the right thing to do. If I were to write that,
00:16:07 would you grudgingly endorse it or would you come back and say,
00:16:11 no, no, no, you clearly missed the point?
00:16:15 Look, I mean, there's some of that in there.
00:16:18 The problem is they're trying to have their cake and eat it in many ways.
00:16:22 They're trying to have, yes, we've got some corporate tax incentives
00:16:26 like expensing or manufacturing and processing, for instance,
00:16:29 but we also want to spend more and increase the deficit.
00:16:34 We also want to put money into housing and infrastructure.
00:16:39 So which is it?
00:16:40 Is this a making government smaller budget or is it a making government bigger budget?
00:16:44 At the end of the day, if we look at what's happening with spending, if we look at the deficit, which is going to stay around 2% of GDP for the foreseeable future, you see debt charges going up, debt charges, the cost of the nation's credit card.
00:16:59 it's going up 40%, 40% over the next five years, reaching around 70 billion. I mean, that's a lot
00:17:07 of money. So you're saying that our annual debt charges that the federal government will pay to
00:17:13 the people who lend it money are going from to $70 billion. What are they today? That would be
00:17:21 about $40 or $50 billion.
00:17:24 So almost, not quite half as much again, but getting that way.
00:17:30 Yeah, exactly.
00:17:31 Well, you know, one of the things that as a conservative opinion writer,
00:17:36 we tend to keep coming back to say is that government borrowing is inflationary.
00:17:43 And certainly we've seen outright increase in borrowing for the next, well, actually
00:17:51 they're not ever forecasting a balanced budget.
00:17:58 Now, there used to be a time when they say, give us three or four years to amuse ourselves
00:18:03 and then we'll get back to a balanced budget.
00:18:05 Well, now I think this year's deficit is going to be $78 billion.
00:18:11 dollars they will borrow that next year is i think i'm right 65 billion dollars which they will then
00:18:17 go to the market for and 50 billion another 50 billion um a couple of things about that one is
00:18:25 that um mr carney when he was campaigning before the last election actually said he would go out
00:18:32 and do that he said he would borrow nearly a quarter of a trillion dollars well now he is
00:18:38 planning to do that and i just um i'm rather struck generally speaking you don't uh you
00:18:45 don't campaign and go out and say you're going to get yourself into horrible debt
00:18:48 so did he have this in mind all along
00:18:52 well i think he is very bought into the arguments yes that if you you know there's good spending
00:19:00 and bad spending good spending is investment spending and bad spending is current spending
00:19:05 if you like um the question is and i don't think economists would disagree with that the question is
00:19:11 is where you draw that line and the problem is government starts saying rather than spending
00:19:17 good and all kinds of things suddenly become investment where all you really do is subsidizing
00:19:22 industries or writing checks for municipalities to build community centers or high-speed rail
00:19:28 networks that we don't necessarily need um it's it's a very very slippery slope um and you know
00:19:36 the politics will always push you into wanting to spend more and more and therefore you're just
00:19:42 going to try and run as much as you can under that investment banner and those those governments
00:19:47 that have tried to you know use this investment you know this capital but interpreting capital
00:19:53 budgeting from from operating and trying to deal with them separately um as happened in alberta
00:19:57 of course, when Alison Redford was premier, it's happened in the UK, they've always gone into
00:20:03 trouble and financial markets will always look through that. Well, what financial markets care
00:20:07 about is what you said. It's how much money does the government have to borrow? And from an economic
00:20:12 perspective, those are resources that can't be used in the rest of the economy. So that's the
00:20:17 government taking money away from the rest of the economy from Canadians and saying, instead of
00:20:21 letting you spend that, we're going to take that through taxes or we're going to borrow it in this
00:20:26 case, and that's money that isn't available for other things. And what that can do, as you say,
00:20:33 is it can push up demand in the economy, and that can push up prices.
00:20:37 Well, you say that money is not available for other things. And of course, you're absolutely
00:20:42 right. When the government is borrowing money, I believe I'm correct in saying that makes it
00:20:49 more expensive for the private sector to borrow, because somebody got there first, so now they
00:20:55 have to pay a premium to to get what they need um that's right if you want to yep if that is the
00:21:02 case what does that mean and here i want to really get particular about what this budget means for
00:21:10 ordinary canadians who probably haven't paid as much attention to the details of it as you have
00:21:16 um we've already talked about increasing the price of carbon to the producers which cannot fail
00:21:25 to translate into higher energy prices for the user.
00:21:31 And now we're talking about the government borrowing money,
00:21:34 forcing up the interest rates as it does so.
00:21:38 What advice would you give to that mythical, ordinary Canadian 1.00
00:21:43 about how he can prepare himself for a new round of inflation and high interest?
00:21:50 well i think uh you know we're seeing governments around the world borrowing more
00:21:57 um that's pushing up interest rates um and that's that's your signal to to look at how much debt
00:22:04 you're carrying pay down that debt um and just not be borrowing borrow less and save more um
00:22:09 because governments are doing the opposite you know i i'd like to be as fair as it could be
00:22:18 to any government that is working in our favor.
00:22:23 The key to all of this heavy spending, however,
00:22:28 is going to be effective implementation.
00:22:32 They seem great at setting up funds and agencies
00:22:35 to do great things.
00:22:38 Your opinion, two opinions, actually.
00:22:41 One, do they actually have the nose to do it?
00:22:44 And secondly, if you were grading this budget
00:22:47 like a teacher grades the essay where where would you put where would you put it well i think the
00:22:53 challenge for them is it it's not enough to have just a couple of small people very small people
00:22:58 at the top of government um it's not even enough to bring in a couple of people from from the
00:23:03 private sector which they've done with the major projects office with a couple of other
00:23:07 new institutions that they've that they've set up um that doesn't help if the rest of the
00:23:13 government machine just doesn't work very well and what we've seen over the last few years is
00:23:17 that government machine atrophy and not be able to do basic things like getting passports to
00:23:22 canadians on time for instance or asking their tax questions so the reality is you've got this
00:23:28 machine that doesn't that's creaky it doesn't work well and it actually you know to make it
00:23:33 would work well it takes several years of you know swapping out senior managers changing how you do
00:23:38 things improving performance getting rid of poor performers so i don't think you've got the right
00:23:44 machine to you know to implement this agenda at the speed that they want to to implement it um and
00:23:52 so you know the other challenges you know a lot of this you need to go a lot further on um getting
00:24:00 the government out of the way so that the private sector can actually produce prosperity because
00:24:05 only the private sector can do that reliably. So in terms of grading the budget, I applaud
00:24:12 the ambition, but I'm not sure that they're doing all of the things that they need to do.
00:24:19 So I think, and I'm not the only one I think who would come to this conclusion, I think we're
00:24:24 probably looking at a C. It's not a fail, but it's not the VA that the country needs at this moment.
00:24:30 all right well there's a lot of consensus around that so just to repeat that last uh bit of advice
00:24:37 that if you can do it reduce your debt and uh and uh brace yourself for another round of inflation
00:24:46 because it's on its way dr sergeant thank you very much for coming on the program great insights as
00:24:53 always and uh we may be seeing more of you in the near future as this thing unfolds thank you
00:25:00 for being here thank you for the western standard i'm nigel hannaford