Western Standard - July 03, 2025


Carney folds to Trump

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
German politician's Alberta freedom tour Christian political leaders launch Alberta summer tour

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

171.32

Word count

8,137

Sentence count

404

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hannaford and Senior Alberta Columnist Corey Morgan join host Derek Fildebrandt and Senior Editor-in-Chief Editor-In-Chief Corey Morgan to talk about Canada's new police force, the Alberta Police Service, the Digital Services Tax, and much, much more.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 G'day, today is July 2nd, 2025.
00:00:28 I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching The Pipeline.
00:00:33 I'm joined, as usual, by my two good friends here, Western Standard opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford.
00:00:39 I'm regular Wednesday slot.
00:00:41 Yes.
00:00:42 And Western Standard senior Alberta columnist, Corey Morgan.
00:00:45 Always a pleasure.
00:00:46 Actually, maybe a bit of housekeeping first.
00:00:48 We should announce that at a to-be-exactly-confirmed date in August,
00:00:55 Nigel Hannaford is going to be retiring
00:00:57 for a second time in his career.
00:00:59 Hail and farewell.
00:01:01 You've done a hell of a job,
00:01:03 and you've unfortunately just left me
00:01:05 with a pickle of trying to find
00:01:07 someone who can fill those shoes.
00:01:09 Good luck.
00:01:13 Well, we're going to miss Nigel very much,
00:01:17 but I don't know.
00:01:19 Well, for the confidence of yours,
00:01:20 it will be for another five, six weeks anyway.
00:01:22 Indeed.
00:01:23 okay well uh two great canadians uh bonnie henry and theresa tam are being honored with canada's
00:01:35 highest honor entrance into the order of canada we'll be talking about them and uh i i think we're
00:01:42 standing by uh don don cherry is being put in too right finally yeah sure yes yeah uh okay today so
00:01:49 So, yeah, the kind of Laurentian carĂŞme de la creme that is the governing body of the Order of Canada, deciding to put Bonnie Henry and Teresa Tam to join them in this highest of high honors.
00:02:04 Alberta announced just today it is creating its own police force.
00:02:09 I think it's called the Alberta Sheriff's Police Service.
00:02:15 Danielle Smith says this is not to replace the RCMP.
00:02:19 Critics of the sovereignty agenda say it is to replace the RCMP.
00:02:26 And people like myself who love the sovereignty agenda say, I hope it's to replace the RCMP.
00:02:34 The old Progressive Conservative Party of Alberta might be back.
00:02:39 two exiled uh mlas from the ucp have uh registered the name for the progressive conservative party
00:02:47 with uh elections alberta uh there might we'll get into if they actually technically will succeed
00:02:53 in that or not but they might um they have said that uh the ucp is so corrupt and so big spending
00:03:01 that the answer to it is to bring back the party with the highest spending and the most corruption
00:03:06 in the history of Alberta.
00:03:08 Before we get to that, though,
00:03:10 we're going to start, Nigel, with elbows up.
00:03:15 Mark Carney promising he's going to fight the bad orange man,
00:03:18 and we're going to do what we want, and he can't stop us.
00:03:22 And then he folded like a cheap tent in trade negotiations
00:03:25 just, I think, less than a day after saying
00:03:30 the digital services tax is here.
00:03:34 We're going to impose it on Canadian consumers using American products.
00:03:38 It's here forever, and Donald Trump can't stop us.
00:03:41 Trump walks away from negotiations.
00:03:44 Carney folded like a cheap tent.
00:03:45 I was just hoping that Mr. Trump's next demand will have something to do with supply and management.
00:03:53 So look, the digital services tax, I mean, it's actually a Trudeau-era legislation that was due to come into effect yesterday, June the 30th.
00:04:04 it was retroactive to 2022 but what it was it was to apply to companies that operate online
00:04:10 marketing and and online advertising services social media platforms
00:04:16 and streaming like netflix well this is how it would have gone supposing that you had actually
00:04:24 booked into a book booked into airbnb and then you had um when you got there you decide to sit
00:04:32 down and relax with with something from netflix and by the way you had amazon drop off something
00:04:39 or a or a fast food drop off something you'd have been paying three percent on all of that
00:04:45 yeah that's a digital services tax you order online you you pay the tax so the thing was
00:04:52 that everybody's oh well you know just fold it like a cheap wheat he certainly did fold he should
00:04:57 have but i mean the thing was it's not like this would have been taxing american companies no it's
00:05:02 That's kind of Canadians using it.
00:05:03 Canadians do use American companies.
00:05:05 That's like sort of putting a tariff on American food and then say, there, we showed them.
00:05:10 No, you didn't.
00:05:11 You showed us that we're now paying a dollar for something that used to cost 75 cents.
00:05:16 So this was never a good thing for Canadians, even if you sort of like the idea that people shouldn't be able to just come in and do business here without paying tax.
00:05:29 We would have been the ones paying the tax.
00:05:31 so that's what they did and when mr trump was notified about it told me i don't know maybe
00:05:38 howard levitt walked in and said you know what they're doing up there in canada digital service
00:05:43 tax and by the way sir it's retroactive to 2022 so some of your biggest fans are going to have to
00:05:49 come up with a couple of billion dollars to give mr carney and he said no deals off we're not talking
00:05:55 to those guys until they get rid of it and so it's gone so i think really the takeaway from this one
00:06:01 Derek, is if you want something, never mind
00:06:03 talking to your MP, never mind
00:06:04 talking to your lawyer, send a note to the White 0.97
00:06:07 House, and things
00:06:08 happen. Yeah.
00:06:11 The kind of
00:06:12 the beginning of this tax
00:06:16 came from Trudeau
00:06:19 before he became Prime Minister.
00:06:20 He was kind of talking about this, and
00:06:23 Stephen Harper,
00:06:24 we'll recall, talked about Trudeau's plan for
00:06:26 a Netflix tax, and the media
00:06:28 roundly laughed. They were rolling
00:06:30 in laughter at this crazy conspiracy
00:06:33 of Stephen Harper
00:06:35 claiming that Trudeau would impose
00:06:37 a digital
00:06:39 services tax or a Netflix tax.
00:06:41 And of course, they did impose
00:06:43 the Netflix tax. This has been coming down the pipe
00:06:45 for a long time. The Americans have been 0.92
00:06:47 unhappy about it. Under the
00:06:49 Biden administration as well.
00:06:51 They've been unhappy about it.
00:06:53 The Biden administration
00:06:54 did not really do much besides
00:06:56 huff and puff about it.
00:07:00 But
00:07:00 It was due to come in.
00:07:04 The Canadian government said this is our business, it's not America's business,
00:07:07 even though it acts as a de facto tariff against American products paid for by Canadians.
00:07:12 And the Canadian government is rightfully pointing out to the Trump administration that,
00:07:16 well, you know who pays tariffs?
00:07:19 It's American consumers who are making life more expensive.
00:07:22 That argument does not seem to have applied in reverse when the Liberals were talking about this tax.
00:07:28 um but this was largely pushed by the quebec cultural industry that likes to keep out anything 0.65
00:07:35 american um and then uh and we're just 24 hours before the liberals were adamant no this is here
00:07:43 to stay this is happening nothing you can do about it trump administration walked away from
00:07:48 the negotiating table and then they just folded cory the liberals i've seen put out some propaganda
00:07:56 around this claiming that they played trump here how have the liberals played trump here
00:08:03 they're trying to polish a turd to be blunt and you can't do it but they're trying to save a
00:08:09 little face where there's none to be saved i i guess there's there's people will take the
00:08:12 statements or the liberals at face value you know the the ones we see online they'll just believe
00:08:17 you know somehow do some mental contortionism to call this a win and uh they have no other
00:08:26 answer for it I mean it's a terrible loss it's a backtrack it shows weakness unfortunately in
00:08:31 the face of the guy who is the biggest bully on the international block right now and and we kind
00:08:36 of know that when you capitulate to a bully he doesn't stop he pushes further eventually
00:08:44 Carney has got to actually show
00:08:46 this elbows up thing of his
00:08:48 I mean, as we said, we're not too sad to see the end
00:08:50 of the digital services taxing anyways
00:08:52 It's a win for consumers
00:08:54 in Canada. It's a loss for the government
00:08:56 Yeah, but the point of principle on the part
00:08:58 of the government showing that they can be slapped
00:09:00 over on things they said were not going to ban
00:09:02 or in the course of 24 hours
00:09:04 you know Trump's just going to come for another bite at something
00:09:06 and they're really going to start building
00:09:08 a revenue problem soon because they were counting on
00:09:10 a big gouge out of this and they're not going to get it
00:09:12 $7 billion over five years, I think it was, wasn't it?
00:09:15 Yeah, something like that, or as much as I think I saw over, you know, $3 billion a year, perhaps.
00:09:19 It's hard to tell, but I mean, it's a big chunk of money when he's been spending like crazy,
00:09:24 and he's not cutting anything, and he's just going to be printing money.
00:09:29 They're in a bad position.
00:09:30 Well, let's talk about what might come next.
00:09:34 Let's pray Canada continues to get out-negotiated here,
00:09:37 because the more Trump demands in concessions from Canada,
00:09:42 the better it seems to be for Canadians.
00:09:45 Trump demanded that Canadians get a tax guide,
00:09:48 and we got a tax guide.
00:09:50 That's an odd thing.
00:09:53 But the next big pee under the mattress in these negotiations 0.55
00:09:59 is supply management, as you touched on, Nigel.
00:10:03 Canada's Soviet-style 0.70
00:10:05 quota, command and control system
00:10:08 of dairy, eggs, and
00:10:10 poultry. And it's
00:10:11 particularly most damaging
00:10:12 in the poultry, sorry,
00:10:15 in the dairy side
00:10:18 of it.
00:10:20 Trump?
00:10:21 No, one Wisconsin.
00:10:23 He won some of these
00:10:24 dairy, not Vermont,
00:10:26 but Wisconsin's the big one.
00:10:28 They want to be able to export 0.98
00:10:30 into Canada freely.
00:10:32 that's impossible with the trade
00:10:35 with the supply management system
00:10:37 they're demanding it go
00:10:38 now the liberals have said
00:10:40 it's not up for negotiation
00:10:42 it's off the table
00:10:43 elbows up
00:10:45 but they already said that about
00:10:48 digital services tax
00:10:49 but the liberals voted with the bloc 0.71
00:10:51 and half of the cowardly half 0.71
00:10:54 of the conservative caucus 0.86
00:10:55 to pass a bloc bill
00:10:57 that makes it illegal
00:10:59 to negotiate away supply management
00:11:03 and have any kind of free trade and dairy, etc.
00:11:06 But, ostensibly, the trade bill will be a bill,
00:11:11 and a bill can amend other bills.
00:11:13 So I'm not sure that bill that the Liberals just passed
00:11:16 with some of the other parties, including half the Conservatives,
00:11:19 actually is going to...
00:11:20 You can't stop them from talking about it.
00:11:22 No bill could stop politicians from negotiating it.
00:11:25 But the final deal will then be put into legislative form
00:11:28 to be brought before Parliament,
00:11:30 and that can simply abolish that bill that just passed.
00:11:34 Exactly.
00:11:35 It's just legislation.
00:11:37 You know, have you given any consideration
00:11:39 that just having sort of a chiro
00:11:41 across the bottom of the screen says,
00:11:43 got a problem with Canada?
00:11:45 Here's the White House number called gunner.
00:11:47 All right, we should do that, just to make a point.
00:11:51 And so the thing with supply management,
00:11:54 maybe one of you guys can understand,
00:11:56 tell me what it is that keeps it alive,
00:11:58 because there's something like 10 000 dairy farmers before i go any further i eat cheese i
00:12:02 like butter and i drink milk and it's a you know i got nothing but good things to say about well-run
00:12:08 professional farmers doing a good job but the thing is you have to buy into it you have to buy
00:12:15 the license it's like the way the taxis work you have to buy your license before you get in and
00:12:20 then you're told how much you can produce how much you can sell and what price you're going to get
00:12:26 for it so as long as they don't have expensive tastes they are extremely secure in what they do
00:12:33 good for them it's worked for a long time there's no animus here but there are 10 000 people
00:12:41 producing milk and butter in canada and there are 40 million people who need it and our need to pay
00:12:49 perhaps as much as five times the price if you go on to the government of
00:12:55 Canada website and look up the trade page you will find that they admit that
00:13:02 they pay let they charge as much as two hundred and thirty percent tariffs on
00:13:08 American dairy products that I guess what it takes to keep the Canadian
00:13:14 farmers competitive and secure. And I just say, you know, 230% is clearly too much. I don't know
00:13:22 whether 23% wouldn't be a bit much, but 230%, that $10 a pound, $9 a pound butter shouldn't be
00:13:31 costing $9 a pound. It should be costing a lot less. And I just filed a column on that, actually.
00:13:36 I mean, I do not understand, therefore, I understand that the dairy lobby has got an incredibly well-organized system for keeping MPs on side.
00:13:56 That's good for them, clever.
00:13:58 I admire something professionally done, but it's not working for the rest of us, and I don't know why nobody moves on it.
00:14:04 I got two kids.
00:14:08 My three-year-old still drinks hot bottles.
00:14:11 I go through so much bloody milk.
00:14:14 I've put...
00:14:15 Each one of my kids, I think, is put through a dairy farmer's kid through college.
00:14:21 I mean, it is criminal what we are paying, and a lot of our stuff is not great quality.
00:14:24 Like, butter? 0.99
00:14:26 Canadian butter is crap. 0.99
00:14:27 You've got to buy the European stuff if you want good butter. 1.00
00:14:29 And people don't see the whole cost of it.
00:14:31 When I owned my pub, one of my biggest sellers actually was pizza.
00:14:34 I sold loads of pizza.
00:14:36 I bought $10,000 a month worth of cheese.
00:14:39 Cheese is expensive.
00:14:40 That's the most expensive part of a pizza.
00:14:42 And we actually had a rebate program that was given to restaurants.
00:14:47 You had to register for it and they would knock off about 10% of the price for commercial mozzarella for my restaurant because they had a cheese smuggling problem happening in Montreal.
00:14:57 This is how bad it is.
00:14:59 This is how absurd as it is.
00:15:00 if you look it up, organized crime
00:15:02 mafia was smuggling cheese from New York
00:15:04 into Montreal, and
00:15:06 when you're talking $10,000... Which organized crime?
00:15:08 The mafia? The actual law?
00:15:10 Or Dairy Canada? Yeah, that's the other mafia, right?
00:15:13 You know, the guy's coming to your back door,
00:15:14 hey, I got some mozzarella here.
00:15:16 It's one car company undermining another.
00:15:18 You know, they were paying cash out the back door for cheese.
00:15:20 It's that, when the system
00:15:22 is collapsing that badly that you've got
00:15:24 underground cheese markets going on,
00:15:26 it's terrible. The irony here
00:15:28 used to be that we were,
00:15:29 we were distilling whiskey
00:15:32 sneaking it into the northern states
00:15:34 and now they're producing cheese
00:15:36 and sneaking it into this
00:15:37 government creates contraband
00:15:39 this supply system is just terrible
00:15:41 and judging by how seriously the government
00:15:44 takes the issue
00:15:45 I mean your decoy should be drugs
00:15:48 you know
00:15:50 I mean
00:15:50 yeah you won't get lunch from with pot
00:15:54 but as long as there's cheese hiding underneath all that weed
00:15:56 so what have we got
00:15:58 like speedboats full of cheese zipping across lakes who buried their ears and truckers but who
00:16:02 knows it might have been that exciting you know the cheese interdiction force with the dogs sniffing
00:16:06 it out across it's just bizarre but we also know the regional aspect quebec dominates the production
00:16:12 of the dairy industry and there's the only thing that makes federal government uh mps shiver more
00:16:18 than taking on indigenous people is taking on quebec with anything i mean speaking about 0.96
00:16:24 capitulation, where Quebec asks
00:16:26 for Quebec cats.
00:16:27 They've got these dairy farms in Ontario as well.
00:16:30 They're not siloed.
00:16:31 Quebec benefits most by having, 0.86
00:16:33 because the quota system locks in incumbent
00:16:36 players, and that has always been to the
00:16:38 benefit of Quebec proportionally. We can't expand
00:16:40 ours. I mean, Saskatchewan, Alberta, we've got
00:16:42 the space, the cattle, the feed.
00:16:44 We could be a dairy powerhouse,
00:16:46 but we can't expand our quotas.
00:16:48 Our dairy farmers, I get
00:16:49 hate mail from dairy farmers all the time,
00:16:52 and poultry farmers, when I
00:16:53 rail against supply management if you are in a supply managed industry in alberta you stand to
00:17:01 gain from the end of supply management particularly in dairy because you're not going to be subject
00:17:07 to the same kind of quotas anymore if you're good at what you're doing if you're not competitive
00:17:13 no matter where you are in canada the end of supply management is probably the end of your
00:17:17 farm but if you are competitive if you are good and you're in a position to expand your operation
00:17:23 with the end of the quota system,
00:17:25 you stand to make a lot of money.
00:17:27 Is he a much bigger operation?
00:17:28 And that's it.
00:17:28 It's a terrible, terrible policy.
00:17:30 And speaking of, like you're talking about,
00:17:31 Trump could save us from ourselves with this one.
00:17:33 Something that we couldn't accomplish domestically 1.00
00:17:35 over decades of this stupid policy, 1.00
00:17:37 maybe Trump is going to do it. 1.00
00:17:38 Well, he saved us on our military.
00:17:40 Canada is getting a better,
00:17:41 is going to rebuild its military
00:17:42 because Trump demanded it.
00:17:44 He's given us a tax cut from the DST.
00:17:47 We might get supply management.
00:17:50 I mean, he doesn't need to take over Canada.
00:17:51 And he's already dictating the policies here.
00:17:53 And so far, they're kind of for the better.
00:17:55 Doubles up.
00:17:57 Maybe he'll take on our immigration system next.
00:18:00 That could go different.
00:18:03 He's just going to start dumping them here on us.
00:18:05 Oh, God.
00:18:06 Yeah.
00:18:08 Okay.
00:18:10 Well, let's bring it real close to home here.
00:18:14 So the UCP removed from its caucus two MLAs.
00:18:19 Peter Guthrie.
00:18:20 He represents Airdrie Cochran.
00:18:23 He kind of went to war with Danielle Smith and the UCP over some of the questions around some health care contracts and the restructuring there.
00:18:35 Perhaps he's correct.
00:18:36 Perhaps he's not.
00:18:37 We haven't seen evidence of it, but maybe he's on to something.
00:18:39 I don't know.
00:18:41 The other one, not very well known.
00:18:43 He's from, I think, the Slave Lake region.
00:18:46 What's his name?
00:18:47 Sinclair.
00:18:47 Yeah, Sinclair.
00:18:48 Sinclair.
00:18:48 he was removed
00:18:50 Scott Sinclair
00:18:51 he was removed because he said he would not vote
00:18:54 for the UCP's budget, which is a confidence issue
00:18:56 if you don't vote for your party's budget
00:18:58 you are by convention, you can't be a part of it
00:19:00 it's not like, those are never a free vote
00:19:02 I think he went further, he actually voted with the NDP
00:19:04 against it, he didn't just not vote
00:19:06 no, he voted against it
00:19:08 yeah, so by
00:19:09 most things I think should be free votes, but the budget
00:19:12 never is, it's a matter of confidence, constitutionally
00:19:15 so these two guys
00:19:16 have been in exile for some time
00:19:18 sitting as independents uh cory uh they're telling us the bc party's back explain this
00:19:26 well you know this isn't new i mean we see this with conservatives when they go in exile you're
00:19:30 quite familiar with it it's a lonely place to be if you're just a one or two or three person
00:19:35 caucus in the corner of the legislature you get limited resources you have difficulty getting
00:19:40 time so in bc they formed a new party out there with the ones that have broken off and now these
00:19:46 two are announcing that they're going to form a party, I guess, to try and strengthen themselves
00:19:51 and maybe build something that they feel would bring people over. That's not that surprising,
00:19:56 really, when they've been sitting, as you said, in the wilderness, it doesn't look like they're
00:19:58 going to get back. But why they would want to go back to the sour PC brand I'm flummoxed with,
00:20:06 like, you're taking on the baggage of people who got basically kicked out in shame. You know,
00:20:11 people haven't forgotten Alison Redford's visage, and they don't look at it fondly. And you guys
00:20:16 are embracing that brand it reminds me of david orchard you know trying federally he just beat
00:20:21 himself against the wall over there this is a dead brand you're trying to resurrect at least
00:20:25 come up with a new party name and say it's something better but well you know of course
00:20:29 not only is it a dead brand but you have to wonder about the forethought that went into this because
00:20:35 i don't think that it is legally possible to revive that progressive conservative party okay
00:20:42 so there's a lot of it tells you
00:20:44 but it just tells you about this kind of
00:20:46 wisdom that went into this proposal
00:20:48 okay so
00:20:49 I don't want to get too deep into the weeds
00:20:52 but I fear I'm going to have to a little bit
00:20:54 because I was a part of the negotiations
00:20:56 that created the United Conservative Party
00:20:58 I know how it was structured
00:20:59 at that time you could not
00:21:01 formally merge political parties
00:21:04 in Alberta so
00:21:05 a smart lawyer guy
00:21:08 cooked up the idea that
00:21:09 because these parties
00:21:12 are also not-for-profit
00:21:13 corporations or societies under the
00:21:16 Alberta Societies Act,
00:21:17 you would create a new party
00:21:19 and the Wildrose
00:21:22 Party and the PC Party would be
00:21:24 owned by
00:21:26 the new party.
00:21:28 Because there's the not-for-profit
00:21:30 society or not-for-profit corporation
00:21:32 entity, and then there's the entity
00:21:34 registered with Elections Alberta.
00:21:36 They're more or less the same, but there's a
00:21:38 legal difference between them.
00:21:39 um and so the ucp owned the wild rose party it owned the pc party and ran a paper candidate
00:21:46 with no campaign to keep them registered through that first election the ucp won
00:21:51 and then they uh they amended the legislation to allow for a formal unification and at that time
00:21:59 the pc party the wild rose party then officially disappeared from being paper parties just gone
00:22:04 uh but one thing i remember in that whole process uh because we were looking forward to it in the
00:22:11 future so that it couldn't happen again is the new ucp would obtain the trademarks of the
00:22:17 progressive conservative party and the wild rules party um but elections alberta ruled uh i was able
00:22:24 to do this when i registered the freedom conservative party i was able to use the word
00:22:28 conservative but i argued that's distinct there's already two conservative parties on paper progressive
00:22:33 conservative and united conservative so no one has a monopoly on the word conservative so i
00:22:37 argued you could have the word freedom conservative and then afterwards as i was leaving and helping
00:22:42 bring together wexit with them uh we got in wild rose independence party which was distinct from
00:22:49 wild rose party or wild rose alliance because it had some modifiers in the name um
00:22:55 i am so elections alberta said that they can use the name progressive conservative association of
00:23:02 Alberta, which was the exact word-for-word name of the old PC party. That's an odd thing for
00:23:10 Elections Alberta to agree to, but even if so, this could run into legal problems on the other
00:23:15 side because the UCP owns the trademarks of the Progressive Conservative Party, and it owns the
00:23:20 trademarks of the Wild Rose Party. And so if you're trying to pass yourself off as the same thing,
00:23:25 you know, not Freedom Conservative or Wild Rose Independence, but as just Wild Rose or just
00:23:31 progressive conservative, there's a good chance
00:23:33 there's going to be some trademark issues there
00:23:35 independent from whatever elections Alberta decides.
00:23:38 So, for now,
00:23:39 the media is taking it as a granted
00:23:41 that, yes, they're going to be called
00:23:43 the PC Association of Alberta.
00:23:46 Maybe they do get away with it, but I'm
00:23:47 not convinced that this is the end
00:23:49 of it. I think the UCP's lawyers
00:23:51 are going to invoke their trademarks
00:23:54 here, and there's going to be a trademark dispute about
00:23:55 if they're allowed to be called that. And so, anybody
00:23:58 who contributes to the new entity is going
00:24:00 to see their money going into
00:24:01 a trademark dispute instead of
00:24:03 into active politics.
00:24:05 I guess that's for sure, but what
00:24:06 confidence can you have
00:24:09 in a couple of people who would embark
00:24:11 on a scheme like this?
00:24:13 It's strange. I mean, again, you'd think
00:24:15 they would have seen this.
00:24:17 It's going to be a tough task.
00:24:19 It's a two-member caucus
00:24:21 to have a party that's functional.
00:24:23 Why bring on a bunch more headaches and
00:24:25 baggage when the one
00:24:27 advantage you have is a clean slate, if you just
00:24:29 come up with something new.
00:24:30 yeah and well i i do get you know as i did you know tapping into a somewhat of a known brand
00:24:37 wild rose or conservative there's there's something to begin with there like the republicans are
00:24:42 tapping into a totally i guess it's kind of a new break but they took on baggage of a completely
00:24:47 different political party uh but they got some name recognition out of it um starting your brand
00:24:55 from absolutely nothing,
00:24:57 that's a huge task for
00:24:58 a small party. You know, you were in the
00:25:01 early Wild Rose. That took a long
00:25:03 time. It went through a few incarnations. It was
00:25:05 Alberta Alliance, and it was Wild Rose
00:25:07 Alliance, and then it was just Wild Rose,
00:25:09 and still your average person
00:25:10 had an outgone.
00:25:13 So I can see if these guys
00:25:15 wanted to call themselves something
00:25:17 conservative or progressive
00:25:18 something, but progressive conservative,
00:25:21 you're just trying...
00:25:22 I don't know. I think it's taken on a lot of baggage
00:25:24 And I'm not sure it's legally sound.
00:25:28 Lawyers are going to have to wade into that, who know more.
00:25:30 But I do know this was something very directly considered in the lead-up to
00:25:35 and during the negotiations that created the United Conservative Party
00:25:38 so that exactly this kind of thing could not happen.
00:25:42 I don't think they're out of the woods on actually calling themselves this yet.
00:25:45 It's sort of a, well, it's a rough one.
00:25:47 Same rationale of the Bolsheviks getting rid of the royal family in whole 0.77
00:25:52 and the descendants and the works just so you don't have
00:25:54 that seed there to pop
00:25:56 up and grow again, it's
00:25:59 been eliminated. Not as
00:26:00 vicious with
00:26:02 this, of course, but the point was to
00:26:04 make sure there's just no remnants of that party
00:26:06 to blossom again and become
00:26:08 a pain. So let's
00:26:10 talk up to either of you.
00:26:12 Is there a market for
00:26:14 a progressive conservative party?
00:26:16 We're now in a strict two-party
00:26:18 system. The left has
00:26:20 united without mergers, but the left has
00:26:22 most certainly united around the NDP in Alberta
00:26:24 the Liberals are dead
00:26:26 dead, the Alberta Party is
00:26:28 for all intents and purposes
00:26:30 finally dead, but the Alberta Party
00:26:32 was trying in the last two cycles
00:26:35 or three, three cycles
00:26:36 they were proclaiming
00:26:38 we are the heirs to the progressive
00:26:40 Conservative Party, in
00:26:41 2019 they got Stephen Mandel, former
00:26:44 PC Cabinet Minister and left wing
00:26:46 mayor of Edmonton
00:26:47 he led them from
00:26:50 four seats to zero
00:26:51 and they did
00:26:53 zero and then they've done zero again
00:26:55 I put
00:27:00 it that
00:27:00 there's no, like every other province
00:27:04 in western Canada
00:27:05 there is no market for someone in the mushy middle
00:27:07 between them, we're now clear center left
00:27:10 and clear center right parties
00:27:11 Well, I think there might be
00:27:13 room if we're going back to kind of the balance
00:27:16 we had in the 90s, but it's a real dangerous trip
00:27:17 to get there
00:27:18 I mean, the political makeup in Alberta then was actually a strong liberal opposition, a strong progressive conservative, and the NDP would have two to four seats on and off throughout.
00:27:30 But still, there was never quite a threat to the balance.
00:27:33 In fact, the liberals and NDP tended to scrap for their votes rather than the PCs, so the conservatives could kind of comfortably stay in power and have that opposition.
00:27:42 If that sort of balance could be reachieved, but the risk is where they're going to draw their, where are they going to draw their support from? If they come from the left, they pull their support from Ninchy because some people aren't necessarily comfortable with him or the NDP, then actually in some ways it could work okay.
00:28:00 They could get a couple seats, but the UCP would still dominate the legislature. 0.91
00:28:04 If they draw from the UCP, though, we know that their win was pretty darn narrow, and that could turn into something that brings the NDP in.
00:28:12 I think there's a possibility of a balance, but it just depends on where they draw their support.
00:28:17 So, Angel, new and small parties are always, they almost always fail.
00:28:23 Every once in a while, they succeed.
00:28:26 But in the modern history of Canada,
00:28:29 I cannot think of a single successful example
00:28:32 of a new party succeeding from the middle.
00:28:35 It's always from the margins.
00:28:37 Tom Flanagan wrote about this.
00:28:39 He called it invasion from the margins.
00:28:41 You have to peel off something from a flank,
00:28:45 the right flank or the left flank,
00:28:46 or in Quebec, it could be something ethnic
00:28:48 and linguistic politics.
00:28:50 But you have to offer something that no one else is
00:28:52 because the middle is where everyone's fighting.
00:28:56 It's like Switzerland trying to join the First World War.
00:28:59 They would just get crushed from both sides.
00:29:01 It's like joining as a third party in the First World War.
00:29:04 It'd be insane.
00:29:05 You have to join from one flank or another to ever successfully invade.
00:29:10 And even then, it normally doesn't work.
00:29:14 Switzerland must better hold the gold of both sides.
00:29:17 uh you know there's a it's a it's an unfortunate characteristic of the conservative mind
00:29:24 that we favor being correct according to our own preconceptions and you know i'm with you here and
00:29:35 here and here but not here so i've got to start my own party and that's it is the achievement of
00:29:43 the everybody who put the ucp together and who now put the the term premier into office they
00:29:52 managed to get past and say well the important things of these and the unimportant things can
00:29:59 stay unimportant and we'll deal with them if they come up and what you have here is very similar to
00:30:05 the problem federally where again conservatives federally separate
00:30:11 themselves out got to have a consistent position on this or that and it's
00:30:17 wonderful you live in a state of virtue that you never hold power and these
00:30:23 gentlemen bless their hearts I mean I and they may be right they may be wrong
00:30:27 I really don't know the issue well enough but there's if if they want to be
00:30:35 right, they can be right, but they won't be
00:30:37 elected. Okay,
00:30:39 but they're not leaving over
00:30:41 some great particular piece of
00:30:43 policy, as far as I can tell. No, they're not.
00:30:45 That's my point. We divide over little
00:30:47 things.
00:30:49 Tenaciously to
00:30:50 those little things.
00:30:53 We've had the Reform Party and the Wild Rose.
00:30:55 Successful breakaways on the
00:30:57 conservative side are
00:30:58 exclusively, exclusively,
00:31:01 not just in Alberta, but even federally,
00:31:03 exclusively on the
00:31:05 right flank of the party that is it is the rebellious side and sometimes it came from
00:31:09 Mary from the right and then as you put it out the Alberta party has played that mushy middle
00:31:13 game and they've had legacy media just loves them they've been the darlings of them for a decade
00:31:17 they just don't go they've never you've got to have something carved out but then that's part
00:31:22 of what Nigel's saying too this is going to be difficult for these guys because they don't have
00:31:25 a they are seeming to be looking at the Alberta party turf which is a path to nowhere and unless
00:31:32 you can find one big issue to cling to,
00:31:34 which they don't seem to have. It's not looking
00:31:36 good.
00:31:38 I mean, the only
00:31:39 big policy difference I see is that
00:31:42 Guthrie and
00:31:44 Sinclair, I guess the PCs,
00:31:46 they're unconditional federalists.
00:31:48 They sound kind of like
00:31:50 Jason Kenney in that any talk
00:31:52 of independence is treasonous, and
00:31:54 we want nothing to do with it.
00:31:56 And that's okay.
00:31:58 That's not what they're offering.
00:31:59 There was corruption and toxicity in the
00:32:02 party, you know.
00:32:04 I mean, okay, so, yeah, 0.91
00:32:05 the UCP is so corrupt,
00:32:08 we're going to sit under the banner 0.91
00:32:09 of the party that was the most corrupt
00:32:12 in the history of all Canada.
00:32:14 Like, we... It keeps circling back to that
00:32:16 bizarre choice of embracing the
00:32:18 pressure of conservatives. Yeah, or, you know,
00:32:20 you know, UCP is running a deficit,
00:32:22 something they should be slapped up for. So let's
00:32:24 sit under the banner of the party that
00:32:26 returned Alberta to deficits?
00:32:29 It's
00:32:30 just...
00:32:30 It just... I don't know.
00:32:33 Corey, you've got to get these guys on your show
00:32:35 because, I mean, there's... I'll try.
00:32:37 I mean, I already posted on X, oh, look who they're
00:32:39 trying to resurrect, and I had a picture of Redford
00:32:41 and Lukasik together just to keep in mind
00:32:43 everybody.
00:32:44 You had a better choice of getting them about half an hour ago.
00:32:47 Yeah, so we'll see.
00:32:49 I've had the one gentleman...
00:32:50 It'll be an easy interview, but you'll be fair
00:32:52 and reasonable. I'll certainly reach out.
00:32:55 It's worth talking about, absolutely. I'm curious.
00:32:57 I'll check. Yeah.
00:32:59 Okay, well, let's see what happens.
00:33:02 They might not get it under that name, though, in the end.
00:33:05 Maybe they will, maybe they won't.
00:33:06 But either way, they're creating a party, and good on them.
00:33:11 But also remember, that was just the name.
00:33:13 To actually create a party is actually fairly difficult in Alberta.
00:33:15 Yeah, that's a whole other analogy.
00:33:16 You generally, what you do is you take over a defunct party.
00:33:19 That's what I did.
00:33:20 You take over a defunct party, and you change its name and its constitution.
00:33:23 I think with two seats in the legislature, they might...
00:33:26 Is it two or three you need?
00:33:27 It's like three or four. Is it that many okay?
00:33:29 Because I know where the certain number of seats.
00:33:31 If you get official party status in the legislature, which is four,
00:33:33 then you get automatic party status.
00:33:36 Otherwise, you've got to petition and go through
00:33:37 that whole process. Yeah. Or you
00:33:39 have to run like 60 on candidate.
00:33:41 It's got to be over half of the amount running. Yeah, but if you want to have
00:33:43 your party
00:33:45 registered before in Electriam's,
00:33:47 which is kind of the idea of it, to organize
00:33:49 around it, you
00:33:50 need to do it by petition, which can
00:33:53 be done, but it's tough. Or you've
00:33:55 got to, I think, have four in LA.
00:33:57 Republicans did it with the Buffalo 0.58
00:34:01 Party. They grabbed that.
00:34:04 Wilder's Independence
00:34:05 Party was Freedom Conservative Party, which was
00:34:08 many days.
00:34:11 It's had many days.
00:34:14 There's a whole Alberta cottage
00:34:15 industry of this stuff, of which
00:34:17 we're guilty of participating.
00:34:20 Very guilty.
00:34:22 All I'm saying is have fun, guys.
00:34:24 Have fun.
00:34:25 It's not fun.
00:34:26 No, I like this chair better.
00:34:28 Yeah, it's a bit easier.
00:34:29 Okay.
00:34:31 Speaking of comfy chairs,
00:34:33 Bonnie Henry, the former
00:34:35 Chief Public Health Officer
00:34:38 of British Columbia,
00:34:40 and Theresa Tam,
00:34:42 Chief
00:34:43 Public Health Officer
00:34:46 of Canada and
00:34:47 Translator,
00:34:49 they are being appointed
00:34:51 to the Order of Canada, Corey.
00:34:54 I bureaucrats are getting the order of Canada for doing their job and people are questioning
00:35:01 whether they even did the job well or not it's unfortunate you know every country I mean it's
00:35:06 human nature I think we like to have awards recognition for our most outstanding citizens
00:35:12 or people who made a mark or made a difference and they have medals they have awards the order
00:35:17 of Canada is ours I think there's there's the different breakdowns there's the member of and
00:35:21 the fellow two and the officers yeah officers there's a few different levels of it but it
00:35:26 starts to really cheapen it when you're really kind of throwing it out so easily i mean it really
00:35:32 should be very very exclusive and i i know there's a lot of debate on whether or not bonnie henry or
00:35:38 theresa tam were good at what they did but even if they were good they're just bureaucrats who did 1.00
00:35:44 their job i i mean they got caught in the circumstances it was different but again
00:35:48 where Bonnie Henry, her job prior to COVID was trying to track down syphilis outbreaks at high
00:35:53 school dances. I mean, this is not a high level position as a health officer. Was that actually
00:35:57 what you did? Well, I mean, you're just tracking disease outbreaks wherever they might be.
00:36:02 That's one of the speculative ones. So, I mean, I guess it's landed more spotlight to their
00:36:11 positions from where they used to be in the basement area of the legislature as the health 0.61
00:36:15 If Premier Daniel Smith is watching, I want to nominate Corey for our next public health talk.
00:36:21 I don't want to do those interrogations, so maybe it is worth an order of Canada.
00:36:26 Somebody has to do it.
00:36:27 But it just is odd choices.
00:36:30 I don't know if they're trying to stir people up or if they really think these guys were heroes for just doing what was kind of in their mandate as bureaucrats.
00:36:38 It's a political statement.
00:36:40 It's an endorsement that that was the way to do it.
00:36:42 And if it happens again, that's the way we'll do it next time.
00:36:45 Alberta's officer didn't get, what was her name again with the bowl cut there?
00:36:49 They got fired Dina Hinshaw. 1.00
00:36:51 Hinshaw, yeah.
00:36:52 But that was kind of, that was some of the absurdity of the COVID time too.
00:36:56 I remember people were going around with Dina Hinshaw t-shirts on
00:36:59 and with a little superhero cape behind her, you know, Super Dina. 1.00
00:37:04 Thankfully, you know, unlike, you know, the Rachel took off 0.99
00:37:07 from what's her name with Friends, Hinshaw's haircut never took off
00:37:10 as a style following.
00:37:11 But these are just unusual people who were usually kind of backroom bureaucrats
00:37:17 that became public personas due to that period.
00:37:19 But whether that rates here or Canada, I find it pretty questionable.
00:37:23 Well, you know, I've got to draw your attention to Barry Cooper.
00:37:26 Dr. Barry Cooper, you know, he wrote an article.
00:37:30 We published it earlier this morning, and he asked this very question.
00:37:33 The motto of the Order of Canada is they sought a better country.
00:37:41 that's the so that it's in latin but that's what it means they seek a better country so then you
00:37:47 have to think if you get the order of canada it's because you were seeking a better country
00:37:53 is and he asked the question what is their vision of a better country then based upon
00:37:59 how they conducted themselves during the highly traumatic um covid uh you know this is and then
00:38:08 This is an endorsement by the government of Canada
00:38:12 who appoints people to the selection board
00:38:15 who can be relied upon to know what would be a better country.
00:38:20 They are now saying, these guys did great.
00:38:23 Here's your order of Canada each.
00:38:26 Anybody else who wants a guide on how to get things done,
00:38:30 how public health should be administered,
00:38:32 what is the relationship between the state and the citizen?
00:38:35 Is it one in which free citizens elect a government or is one where a government has authority over the citizens?
00:38:43 That's what this, there's a deeper significance to this award.
00:38:48 There's echoes here, I think, of when Henry Morgenthaler was given the order.
00:38:54 Whatever you think of him, whatever you think of the abortion issue, it was a decision for the Canadian establishment to put a stamp of approval on him and what he did.
00:39:05 uh and and try to end debate retroactively and i think it's somewhat succeeded i i i see this
00:39:13 as in some form the canadian political laurentian establishment uh fighting against
00:39:20 you know those of us who do not accept uh you know the official narrative here and say you know
00:39:28 they want to say overall yeah things were pretty good and we're going to honor those who were the
00:39:33 public faces of this. Yeah, I'm not sure
00:39:35 I would tie that to the Laurentian elite
00:39:37 particularly. There was a lot
00:39:39 of people in Ontario who didn't like this either
00:39:41 and it's more when
00:39:43 we get into economics and the
00:39:45 relationships between provinces
00:39:47 and the federal government where the Laurentian
00:39:49 thing and of course
00:39:51 unequalization is where that comes into
00:39:53 play. But I do think that there
00:39:55 is a spirit of authoritarianism
00:39:57 and a desire for control that animates
00:39:59 the people who do well
00:40:01 in the federal government. It is killing other senior
00:40:03 bureaucrats yeah they are saying this is the way we want it done thank you very much you two here's
00:40:08 your here's your little snowflakes but they toss it out to celebrities left right and center as
00:40:13 well obscure other players who get to that yeah there we go and they exclude others that really
00:40:20 says a lot about uh what they do you know like if i don't know i maybe i'll be wrong but like
00:40:26 Like, you know, if I asked Grok to make a video for me of the most Canadian guy in the world, it conceivably could spit out Don Cherry, and it doesn't even need to invent the guy.
00:40:37 You know, he's just an old-school hockey hoser, and, you know, he's never been a—not particularly political.
00:40:45 He's just been considered political because he has, you know, what are now considered to be retrograde old Canada views.
00:40:53 But it's a significant impact on our culture.
00:40:56 Huge!
00:40:56 he is a cultural icon and beloved by most people in canada yet he he doesn't get on and and and
00:41:05 it's full of these c-list celebrities you know the kind of like i don't need to be disrespectful here
00:41:10 but like think of like okay thinking like the junos and stuff jan arden and the other cbc darling
00:41:16 but even ones way below that people who like no one's heard of unless you go to like the toronto
00:41:22 folk festival or something you know it's like people no one's heard of for crappy like cbc
00:41:28 shows with actors that one percent of canadians could probably still not name uh these c-list
00:41:34 canadian celebrities who never made it internationally they're in there as cultural
00:41:38 icons of our cultural sovereignty and they don't put in the one guy everyone can name everyone can
00:41:45 look look at his face and say i know who that is and what he's about well yeah and it's i look at
00:41:49 kind of like almost the time person of the
00:41:51 year or whatever, if you want to put it that way. It doesn't mean
00:41:53 you have to like or dislike, but if they were significant
00:41:55 and had an impact,
00:41:57 it's worthy of a degree of recognition.
00:41:59 And when you exclude Cherry, it really
00:42:01 shows the bias.
00:42:02 It shows that they don't really value diversity.
00:42:05 No. No.
00:42:06 Well, he's their own kind of not.
00:42:10 Okay.
00:42:10 Well, I wanted to get into the Alberta Police
00:42:13 Force. We're just not going to have time today.
00:42:15 It's twice as to say we're going to have one.
00:42:17 Little bit by little bit.
00:42:19 We're taking the incremental approach and good on it.
00:42:21 We're getting it done.
00:42:22 As long as we're making progress in the right way
00:42:25 and it's aggressive enough, it's good.
00:42:26 It's a step in the right direction.
00:42:27 So when you get a ticket, you're going to smile.
00:42:31 As long as it's going to a proper Alberta cop, not a Fed.
00:42:36 Okay.
00:42:37 Also, I wouldn't have time.
00:42:40 This is also a step in removing federal control of police
00:42:43 to seize our guns.
00:42:45 Yes.
00:42:45 That needs to be recognized.
00:42:47 God bless you
00:42:49 everyone behind creating the Alberta
00:42:50 Sheriffs here. Prioritize
00:42:53 their service. Thank you
00:42:54 for your service. Okay,
00:42:56 we'll get into that more next week. Party
00:42:58 Shots, Nigel. Oh, well, you
00:43:00 know, maybe it's not fair to
00:43:02 keep picking on the CBC, but
00:43:04 let's do it. So, you
00:43:06 know, they've got
00:43:07 an internal issue going on there
00:43:10 and they want to exclude
00:43:12 other media from reporting
00:43:15 on what they would cheerfully
00:43:16 report on if it was the other media and you know they've got some good people but thus much only
00:43:23 they they shoot themselves in the foot conceptually at the upper levels all the time
00:43:27 you just can't trust them all right bang that's my shot all right well just backs get sort of the
00:43:34 old progressive conservatives and their icons thomas fabio lukasic people remember as part of
00:43:40 the left flank of the progressive look servatives and admitted lucasher yeah well if you want to
00:43:45 pronounce it the Polish, Lukasz.
00:43:47 Either way, he's come up.
00:43:49 I'm kind of mixed on it. Okay, you pulled the trigger
00:43:51 early on the referendum, petitioning,
00:43:53 and he's sort of playing the game
00:43:55 of the act, trying to turn it into
00:43:57 a negative, saying, well, campaign
00:43:59 is a, would you
00:44:01 agree to stay within Canada?
00:44:03 And it looks like it might have thrown sand in the gears
00:44:05 of the Alberta Prosperities
00:44:06 efforts. Maybe. It's kind of bizarre.
00:44:09 It shows that there's more to be
00:44:11 ironed out on what this process is going to do.
00:44:13 but as I said I don't know how well that's going to work
00:44:16 for him at the worst that's going to happen
00:44:18 it's going to be held and it just means that
00:44:20 the independent side will have to take the no
00:44:22 on their campaign rather than yes
00:44:23 but either way there's going to be a referendum
00:44:26 on if he gets the 300,000
00:44:28 which is very very unlikely
00:44:30 I actually you know
00:44:32 a lot of the legacy media are crowing about how much they love this
00:44:34 we get to crow
00:44:36 when the federalist side in Alberta
00:44:38 can't get enough people to sign
00:44:40 a petition saying we should stay in Canada
00:44:42 The people who think it's easy are people who have never done a real petition before.
00:44:48 Yeah.
00:44:48 I tell you what.
00:44:48 This is not an online click, you know.
00:44:51 Getting 100 real signatures on a petition, an official one physically, is a 10-hour day of work.
00:45:01 So $300,000, good luck, Fabio.
00:45:05 Yeah.
00:45:05 So we're going to come back to this when it's done because we're going to be able to say
00:45:10 Thomas Lukasik and the NDP
00:45:12 all these guys working together
00:45:13 could not get 300,000 people
00:45:16 in a province of 4 million
00:45:19 to sign a petition to stay in Canada
00:45:20 we get to say that now
00:45:22 exactly
00:45:22 it's delayed gratification but I think
00:45:26 maybe I'll have to eat my words
00:45:28 but I don't think
00:45:29 we'll have our I told you so is more than likely
00:45:31 speaking of I told you so
00:45:33 Leah Thomas has had his
00:45:36 medals
00:45:37 stripped for winning
00:45:40 in women's swimming in the United
00:45:42 States.
00:45:45 This is just
00:45:46 I don't know. What's his proper name?
00:45:48 I don't know. I'm just Thomas.
00:45:50 Sure.
00:45:52 So, I mean, this has been a
00:45:54 big controversy.
00:45:55 He has taken medals away
00:45:57 from women who have rightfully
00:46:00 won in women's sporting
00:46:01 competitions.
00:46:03 And this is not a dainty little
00:46:05 trans person this is a man yeah this is and he's still got all the bits and pieces he didn't have
00:46:12 any surgical alteration you know uh it could have made it more aerodynamic for swimming so
00:46:16 he was thinking it was a bit of drag i don't know yeah yeah yeah i don't know about you derrick but
00:46:21 when i was at school if you tried to win a race against the girls they'd laugh you tricked you
00:46:25 was they left the school branch yeah yeah i'm surprised he didn't remove the keel from the
00:46:30 boat for the roof. 0.99
00:46:32 Yeah, anyways, that's
00:46:34 good news for women, 1.00
00:46:36 for sportsmanship, no pun intended,
00:46:38 and for science and sanity.
00:46:40 The world
00:46:41 returning to a little more
00:46:43 balance. The force.
00:46:47 Balance returning to the
00:46:48 force. Sometimes it can happen.
00:46:50 Nigel, Corey, thank you very much.
00:46:52 And thank all of you for joining us
00:46:54 today. Remember, if you're not yet
00:46:56 a member of the Western Standard, you're freeloading.
00:46:58 Don't be a freeloader. Go to westernstandard.news right now.
00:47:01 Click on subscribe. It's only $10 a month or $100 a year
00:47:04 for unlimited access to all Western Standard content
00:47:07 to support the work that we are doing here right now.
00:47:10 In the newsroom behind me, we've hired a rash of new reporters.
00:47:13 We've got more new reporters starting
00:47:16 next week and I think the week after that.
00:47:19 We're beefing up the number of reporters we've got on staff.
00:47:23 And we're going to have to try really hard to find someone
00:47:25 who can fill Nigel's shoes here.
00:47:27 Thank you very much for joining us today, and God bless.