Western Standard - January 30, 2026


Carney talks big in Davos, delivers little at home

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
What the hell is wrong with the Manitoba PC Party? WATCH LIVE: Pierre Poilievre Takes the Stage at the 2026 CPC Convention

Episode Stats


Length

27 minutes

Words per minute

159.66

Word count

4,416

Sentence count

181

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

David Knight-Legg, a former speechwriter for Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, joins me to talk about his Davos keynote, and why he thinks Canada should be leading a multipolar world in place of the old rules-based order.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show
00:00:21 of the Western Standard. It is Thursday, January the 29th. Just over a week ago, Prime Minister
00:00:27 Mark Carney delivered a widely acclaimed keynote speech at Davos, Switzerland, to the World Economic
00:00:33 Forum, and he declared the old world order dead and committed Canada to be leading a new one.
00:00:41 Technically, as a speechwriter from the old days for a Canadian prime minister, I must say that
00:00:46 his remarks were well prepared and delivered. But is his analysis correct? And is the strategy that
00:00:54 And he's proposing for Canada capable of restoring the country's status in the world.
00:01:00 Joining us now is David Knight Legg, a strategic advisor to the Alberta government, energy
00:01:06 and financial services firms.
00:01:09 And he is no stranger to the Western standard.
00:01:11 Good to have you back, David.
00:01:13 Great to be here.
00:01:14 Great to see you again, Nigel.
00:01:16 And likewise, David, like everybody else who listened to Mr. Carney's speech at Davos,
00:01:21 I was impressed with the remarks as a piece of prose.
00:01:24 Aristotle applauds from the grave, and perhaps Thucydides too. And yet I have that feeling
00:01:30 there's something off here, that I'm missing. I'm being conned. And as I thought about it,
00:01:35 it occurred to me that Mr. Carney is lamenting something, that is, the international rules-based
00:01:41 order, that never really was. He even says so in a kind of way later. So when he remarks that we
00:01:48 knew the story of the international rules-based order was partially false,
00:01:52 So his basic takeaway was that Trump, we didn't actually name, had ended this apocryphal international rules-based order, and the new reality was a multipolar world in which the big powers did what they wanted.
00:02:06 To me, that sounds very much like the world before the Second World War.
00:02:10 So first question, isn't Mr. Carney's multipolar world actually just business as usual?
00:02:16 Yeah, of course it is.
00:02:18 Yeah, I think the appeal of his speech took two or three different vectors, and I think, you know, it was appealing.
00:02:32 The thing that surprised me about the speech is it was a speech that would be given by a well-informed spectator.
00:02:38 It was a speech of a political science professor, a law professor.
00:02:42 in an odd way it wasn't a speech that struck me as being given by a world leader and in some ways
00:02:50 i think people find that refreshing uh it was it was long on description uh you you've noted it
00:02:57 quoted aristotle thucydides hero of mine vaslav havel i think deeply misquoted vaslav havel
00:03:03 but as as a piece of art it was compelling because it described very effectively the state of the
00:03:11 world to some extent. I think what is odd for a world leader like Mark Carney is that it did
00:03:18 not draw any clear prescriptions, courses of action, and to the extent that it would have
00:03:23 his actual actions over the last nine months have been completely contrary to the theory of the
00:03:31 speech. And that's what's deeply problematic about it. The speech is excellent, but it's almost
00:03:38 like listening to somebody um that's a good cover band you can recognize the song you like it
00:03:45 but it's not the person who wrote it it's not what was intended by the person who wrote it
00:03:51 and it's being delivered by somebody who in many ways represents to my mind the opposite
00:03:56 of us mark carney mark carney wrote an op-ed in the middle of the freedom convoy
00:04:02 calling canadian citizens seditious that was carefully chosen language by somebody that knows
00:04:07 better it was followed through on as a as a matter of sedition and that his theory of the case which
00:04:15 he wrote in the op-ed was then shown to be deeply problematic for civil rights for freedom totally
00:04:21 totalitarian in every way the exact opposite of what someone like vassal pavel would have thought
00:04:28 was appropriate for people that were obviously political dissenters of mandates that ended up
00:04:36 being very quickly thrown out for being unscientific.
00:04:39 These were the people, these were the shopkeepers that had tossed the sign
00:04:42 out of the window, decided to stand up against totalitarian overreach
00:04:46 in their, in their country.
00:04:47 And the first person to oppose them and demand that the politically correct
00:04:52 totalitarian framing of COVID be enforced by a police state was Mark Carney,
00:04:59 who just gave a speech quoting Vassilov Havel.
00:05:03 So I'm going to come back.
00:05:04 I'd like to come back to Vaclav Havel in a minute, but for those people who actually
00:05:12 did listen to the speech, Mr. Carney did appear to offer a path forward, a path between what
00:05:21 he would say submission and isolation. It all sounds good, but it was supposed to be a coalition
00:05:28 of middle power countries coming together to do what they could given the polarity of China,
00:05:36 the United States, and Russia. But this kind of middle power alliance sounds a bit like the deer
00:05:46 forming a coalition against the wolves. Is that what you're getting at when you say that it's a
00:05:54 a bit delusional yeah look i think canada has the greatest opportunity economically in the planet
00:06:01 because we're only you know 45 50 million people we have 77 to 80 percent of our trade depends
00:06:10 entirely on the united states uh the next largest trade block we have is about 10 percent which is
00:06:17 all of the EU and the UK together.
00:06:20 And after that, China is around 4%, and then you've got, you know, single
00:06:25 digit percentages around the world.
00:06:28 Uh, so far, since Mark Harding was elected, we've had virtually no serious
00:06:33 progress on the most important trading relationship that we have.
00:06:37 So you can, you can give a speech citing Thucydides, and this is what you'd
00:06:41 expect of a law professor, political science professor, is an excellent
00:06:44 speech for somebody who's a spectator. It was a terrible speech for somebody who's got to
00:06:49 renegotiate Kuzma in the summer. It was a terrible speech in multiple levels. First of all,
00:06:55 it was the wrong speech to give because it drew a false moral equivalence between
00:06:59 great powers as if China and the United States are the same sort of problem because they're
00:07:04 hegemons. That's deeply reckless for anybody who's sailed out. It's especially reckless for 1.00
00:07:10 the leader of Canada, we have a series of actions that are being taken by his government
00:07:16 that are deeply counterproductive right now in the relationship that we have with the
00:07:20 United States.
00:07:21 They're counterproductive on the three things that matter most, energy, national security,
00:07:27 and economic security and trade.
00:07:29 So again, a speech is very important, but the person who gives the speech is as important
00:07:36 as the speech when the purpose of the speech is to outline or compel action.
00:07:42 And what had happened with this speech is this speech had followed very quickly after
00:07:47 a series of concessions were made to the world's most totalitarian state, China, in a juxtaposition 0.75
00:07:57 with the relationship with the United States, very intentionally drawn by the prime minister
00:08:02 and recklessly so.
00:08:04 So I think that the problem with the speech is not the quality of the speech. The delivery of the speech was exceptional. Aspects of the speech were very, very appealing in that it described the current moment in the way that a great political science professor would describe it.
00:08:19 But for Mark Carney, the prime minister of Canada, to have given that speech in light of the deep confusion around his interpretation of what the shopkeeper with the sign in the window in Vassal Havel's book, Power of the Powerless, was intended to address, Mark Carney himself represented in his op-ed against the Freedom Convoy, complete totalitarianism in the name of natural political dissent.
00:08:46 But in the current moment, that Václav Avel comment is all about the political correctness that is dominant in a place like Davos and has been dominant in the rhetoric and the positioning that Mark Carney has had on green issues and finance and things like GFADS.
00:09:04 So it's very awkward for someone like Mark Carney to be the one giving a Václav Avel quote.
00:09:11 The Thucydides quote on strength is fascinating,
00:09:15 but Thucydides, but he seemed to draw an unusual parallel.
00:09:18 Thucydides' arguments on strength weren't Nietzschean.
00:09:21 Thucydides' arguments and strengths were descriptive,
00:09:24 and they were descriptive in a way that was compelling courage
00:09:27 in the face of challenges.
00:09:29 And what I've seen in the Carney government is so far,
00:09:32 and I'm hoping that this will change,
00:09:35 especially in the next few weeks, and I hope quickly,
00:09:37 uh there there has to be a new level of honesty in this government on the cause of our economic
00:09:45 decline and our problem with trade the the rapid rise in the decline of canadian cities
00:09:51 and the rapid rise in violent crimes in across canada the rapid rise in uh physician-assisted
00:09:59 suicides the 50 000 kids that have died out of fentanyl and opioid overdoses in the last
00:10:05 decade of this complete nihilism with respect to drugs and the drug trade, the rapid growth
00:10:14 of criminal and terror syndicates across the country. Donald Trump is not to be blamed for
00:10:20 any of this. This has happened under a government that's adopted deeply progressive flawed ideas
00:10:26 about what to do in the face of crime. They've created more debt in, I think it's the first
00:10:34 seven years of their government than all their governments put together. And Mark Carney's just
00:10:38 delivered the worst peacetime deficit or the worst non-emergency deficit in the history of the
00:10:46 country. So you've got extraordinary debt. You've got the worst performing GDP per capita performance
00:10:53 in all 40 OECD nations, the worst performance in GDP growth in the G7 for the last 10 years.
00:11:01 you've got extraordinary problems with crime. You've got the worst results in the public service
00:11:06 in spite of the fact that in the last 10 years, they've bloated the public service more than 45%
00:11:12 and made it 75% more expensive. There's almost no metric right now that you can point to that
00:11:19 you could say the problem that Canada faces is Donald Trump. Almost every single one of these
00:11:24 metrics that are affecting our quality of life, our national security, the ability of people to
00:11:30 feel safe walking in our cities, you know, the rise in anti-Semitic crime, it just goes on and
00:11:36 on and on. This has to do with a series of failed policy ideas and failed presumptive ideological
00:11:41 ideas that Mark Carney has been in the forefront of in his party and that his party is responsible
00:11:47 for. And what they discovered when they ran the last election is that people, especially the older
00:11:55 demographics that depend on mainstream media that is funded by the government will see their lives
00:12:01 and see their opportunities through the lens of the framing that the government's given. And what
00:12:06 was convenient was to say, you know, there's a scary person running the United States and we're
00:12:11 going to stand up to him. And I think there's a certain amount of sort of political real politic
00:12:18 and strategic nous in the way that they ran that election. But I also think that that's bordered
00:12:24 very quickly on complete cynicism, and the fundamental problem with Mark Carney's speech
00:12:29 is not that it wasn't an excellent speech or that it was descriptively accurate of the moment we live
00:12:34 in. It's that the person giving it doesn't represent remotely the ideals behind what
00:12:40 Václav Evel was speaking about, and as a result, it struck me very much like the elbows up thing,
00:12:45 tactically effective but deeply cynical so what is the the game is he a true ideologue there are
00:12:55 things that he has has been associated with that would make you think that he was a green prime
00:13:01 minister and that was all that mattered we have to save the planet when there are so many arguments
00:13:06 if the planet has to be saved there isn't going to be canada doing it uh is is he just getting
00:13:13 Do you want electric cars from China so that we can have lower emissions?
00:13:18 Or is there something more deeply cynical?
00:13:20 Is he trying to make Canada a different kind of, intentionally,
00:13:23 trying to make Canada a different kind of place?
00:13:27 Look, I don't want to believe that of anybody that gives a lot of their time
00:13:33 and energy and effort to public service.
00:13:35 I think that at the end of the day, they must want to create a better world
00:13:41 for our kids to inherit, right?
00:13:43 I mean, I think that's the point and that's the purpose of most people that engage.
00:13:47 I think that what happens is the first order sort of instincts of anyone in politics is to win elections, hold the power so that you can then exercise it in the manner in which you think can secure the future for our kids and create a better society.
00:14:03 I think one of the things that I was hopeful about with Prime Minister Carney is that when he ran for the election, coming from outside the country, as he did, I was actually hopeful that that was a strength and that he would see that certain things about his party's ideological positioning, particularly with respect to energy and energy security, had gone way beyond any sort of rational rapprochement between the environment, energy, and economy.
00:14:29 and it had become completely dogmatic in ways that were just ridiculous.
00:14:34 The C-48, C-69 represents that.
00:14:36 But he got rid of the carbon tax.
00:14:38 He got rid of the capital gains tax,
00:14:40 some of the things that were deeply harming the economy.
00:14:44 And so my hope was, and it still is obviously because he is the prime minister,
00:14:51 that he has great people around him that are giving him good advice,
00:14:54 that the mistake that he made
00:14:58 by calling the Freedom Convoy seditious,
00:15:01 the enormous mistakes they've made
00:15:03 by maintaining C-69 and C-48,
00:15:06 which are just poking the bear in Alberta
00:15:11 in terms of the new run for independence.
00:15:15 You know, these are things that I am hoping
00:15:17 that he will see his way through
00:15:18 to something that's far more centrist
00:15:21 and far more representative
00:15:22 where most Canadians are at.
00:15:24 I thought the speech was excellent.
00:15:26 Most of my friends have sent me notes saying,
00:15:28 we really like your speech.
00:15:29 Congratulations.
00:15:31 You've got a great prime minister.
00:15:32 So it's hard for me to say.
00:15:34 I think the speech was morally confused
00:15:36 and that it's like a cover band covering a song that I like.
00:15:41 I love hearing anybody give Václav El's Power of the Powerless airtime.
00:15:47 And I think there's something deeply moving about his language.
00:15:50 And I think there's a lot about his language that's pertinent
00:15:52 to the current moment, especially if you think about these unbelievable places
00:15:56 like Iran and Russia and China under socialist Marxist
00:16:02 or Islamo-Marxist catalytarian regimes.
00:16:06 You hope that there's more Václav Havel and Thucydides
00:16:10 and some of those comments going on.
00:16:14 But what I hope in the case of Mark Carney is that he looks at the opportunity
00:16:18 right now to change Canada, to upgrade Canada's current political approach
00:16:24 and policy approaches to a freer economy where we can go back
00:16:28 to being one of the most prosperous nations
00:16:30 instead of the least prosperous in the United States.
00:16:31 Well, but that takes us back to the very public choice
00:16:34 that he made to go and embrace China.
00:16:37 I mean, this is, with his earlier experience through Brookfield with China,
00:16:43 No doubt he knows his ways around the corridors where the decisions are made.
00:16:49 But I find, just speaking for myself here, the idea of dumping the United States,
00:16:56 even if you don't like Mr. Trump, who won't be there in three years' time, to embrace
00:17:04 a nation with the ideals and practices of the People's Republic of China, I find that quite
00:17:09 abhorrent we have a bad history with china uh that makes me suspicious of what mr carney's
00:17:20 goals really are and you're making the case that we should give him a chance i think and
00:17:26 i think we've given him a year why are you not as cynical as i am david well look i i think there's
00:17:34 I don't think you're cynical,
00:17:38 Nigel, first of all.
00:17:40 A lot of people do.
00:17:42 Well, I think you're hopeful, and I think
00:17:44 one of the things that you're very good at is
00:17:46 pointing out what you think is
00:17:48 not working, and I think that's the appropriate
00:17:50 role of a good journalist, is to
00:17:52 sort of find whatever you think
00:17:54 the gaps are between
00:17:55 what's being said and what's actually being done.
00:17:59 And I think that's the biggest
00:18:00 challenge for the Carney administration
00:18:03 in Canada right now. I think
00:18:04 that uh that canada needs to do business with china china is a very important trading partner
00:18:10 because it's only four percent of our export gdp the united states is 77 the issue is not
00:18:17 whether or not mark carney has a conversation with china about you know their tariffs on canola uh
00:18:23 would that it was a conversation that needed to happen the issue is the craven way in which
00:18:28 Canada seems to naively bend the knee to China so easily and so often and in so many ways. 0.72
00:18:37 You know, the open border with respect to Chinese tribes in the port of Vancouver, 0.60
00:18:42 the fentanyl trade is disgusting.
00:18:45 And it's something that has been allowed to metastasize.
00:18:49 It's one of the worst cancers in Canadian society.
00:18:51 And yet it's somehow swept under the rug and not talked about very openly.
00:18:55 we have 50 000 kids that are dead because of the fentanyl and opioid crisis in this country
00:19:01 and when this was raised by the americans as part of their concern on the border
00:19:06 it was poo-pooed by our media it was treated as a pretext uh and instead of us just acknowledging
00:19:12 we have a huge crisis and it's a moral crisis so 50 000 young lives are gone in this country
00:19:18 where where do you read about this you know i find it absolutely extraordinary that we have something
00:19:23 death at that scale with a known supply chain that we seem completely incapable of actually
00:19:30 changing our laws to deal with. It's well known across Vancouver that the Mexican cartels and
00:19:35 the Chinese triads are in bed with each other. The Chinese look after laundering and they look 1.00
00:19:40 after the port and the cartels do whatever they want. The embarrassment to me of this issue being
00:19:45 raised and having our leadership scoff at the idea that we were potentially a fentanyl problem
00:19:51 when they knew it was all the southern border.
00:19:53 And yet the amount of fentanyl that they said
00:19:56 that we had found crossing the border
00:19:58 was less than the amount sitting on one shelf
00:20:00 in one super lab that gets busted
00:20:02 with the help of the FBI six months later.
00:20:05 I mean, it's just, it's extraordinarily embarrassing
00:20:07 when you look at the crisis,
00:20:10 the different pillars of crisis,
00:20:12 the relationship between China and the United States.
00:20:15 I was stunned when Meng Wanzhou was taken by Canada
00:20:19 and put under house arrest
00:20:20 at one of her three mansions in Vancouver,
00:20:23 and they illegally took hostage two of our diplomats.
00:20:27 The fact that their ambassador wasn't sent packing the next day
00:20:30 was extraordinary to me.
00:20:32 The Chinese see Canada as incredibly weak and pliable, 0.99
00:20:34 and I don't know why, and I know there's a lot of good work done.
00:20:37 There's an incredible young journalist, Sam Cooper,
00:20:39 who does exceptional work on Canada's overall security issues,
00:20:45 but he is very...
00:20:46 Yeah, we know Sam.
00:20:48 Yeah, and there's others that have done that too,
00:20:50 But I think he's exceptional. And so I think that for Canada to do any kind of business with China, we've got to not be seen as weak and naive. And unfortunately, I think we are seen that way. And I think we're seen that way with respect to their secret police stations. We're seen that way with respect to the way that they have been able to override any kind of common sense on some of the people that are put out for parliament. And, you know, CSIS has talked about this. So that's in the background. I understand why you would say you're cynical.
00:21:20 I think that as a nation, we've got to be able to do deals with all countries.
00:21:24 I'm a free trade maximalist.
00:21:27 You know, I think Canada should be working very hard at creating global market infrastructure.
00:21:31 I think that, for instance, when China, when the U.S. took over Venezuela, and I wrote an op-ed on this defending it as illegal, that what they did was legal when they renditioned Marduro.
00:21:45 You know, China lost around 550,000 barrels a day.
00:21:50 from that uh incident from venezuela venezuela heavy crude um alberta can actually provide all
00:21:58 of that if we reinstate the northern gateway uh we could provide all of that back to china it would
00:22:03 be a 16 billion dollar a year trade for us it would give us additional leverage in china would 0.66
00:22:09 go as 15 more of our output uh going in the direction of a uh another uh superpower other
00:22:17 than the United States. It would give us diplomatic leverage in China that actually matters to the
00:22:21 Chinese. And it would have been something that I would have loved to have seen come out of the 1.00
00:22:25 China conversation. So I don't want to be hypocritical in saying there are things that
00:22:30 I would love to see us do deals with China on. I think the Americans would have expect us
00:22:33 to do that. The President Trump was asked about this in Seattle. I'm glad they're doing deals to
00:22:38 China. People are realists and Canada needs to be realistic. But I didn't see us do a massive 0.98
00:22:44 energy deal with China. I saw us allow EVs into our country. The problem with EVs, by the way,
00:22:50 for those who think that the Americans are simply trying to be economic bullies, EVs are like
00:22:56 iPhones on wheels. They are extraordinary data collection machines. All of the BYD EVs have been
00:23:05 kicked out of one country in particular because of the security risks in the metadata that gets
00:23:10 transferred back to china uh there's a lot that i think canada has just been on a vacation from
00:23:15 history and and is therefore naive about china and the reason for that is because we're completely
00:23:22 protected by the united states from the geopolitical realities that they take on and so i
00:23:27 would go ahead i would love to see us just understand what the americans have told us
00:23:35 several times, which is they're integrating energy security with military national security with
00:23:42 trade security. And Canada continues to make a series of steps that I think are just naive to
00:23:49 the point of reckless with respect to all three. And so we've got to finish our F-35 purchase
00:23:55 instead of holding it up for yet another, after 20 years, you know, internal, you know,
00:24:04 able-gazing around what we're going to do on this. I think we have to expand NORAD to include
00:24:08 naval security in AUKUS. I think we have to integrate what we're doing in the Arctic with
00:24:13 what the Americans are going to be doing with Greenland. I think we have to get on with a 0.99
00:24:17 proper trade negotiation that acknowledges some of the risks that the Americans want us to address.
00:24:23 And I think we have to get rid of this decade-long experiment with green alarmism and get on with just building Canada's global energy infrastructure.
00:24:34 And if we don't, we're going to start to see the country fragment.
00:24:37 Well, I think that's what a lot of people are speculating about right now for all the reasons you've given.
00:24:43 We're almost out of time.
00:24:45 Let me just ask you this.
00:24:46 I believe you're traveling.
00:24:48 You're on a business trip to the Middle East.
00:24:50 Where are you today?
00:24:51 i mean abu dhabi right now yeah uh how are you finding it that's incredible it's uh
00:24:58 you know uh the the emirates were a dream uh back in the 50s and they they made it into an
00:25:06 extraordinary reality uh there are there are several countries in the uae dubai is very well
00:25:12 known abu dhabi is the largest and the and the energy rich uh nation um you know alberta alberta
00:25:21 could easily be the wealthiest nation in the world, actually, with 5 million people and more
00:25:27 oil than Russia, China, and the United States put together, and as much gas as Qatar. And this is
00:25:34 what I think Prime Minister Carney has got to be very careful about right now. You can't continue
00:25:39 to tie the hands of one of the world's largest energy superpowers, Alberta, behind their back
00:25:48 out of some dated idea of what eastern-based federalism looks like much longer before you're
00:25:54 going to start to just create strains that will crack. The first thing we should do is build
00:25:59 something in Calgary that's taller than the Brookfield building. That's what we say.
00:26:05 Well, the Burj Khalifa here is, you know, Dubai built the Burj Khalifa actually as a tribute to
00:26:12 to the gentleman from Abu Dhabi who built the Emirates.
00:26:17 And, you know, it's extraordinary to see what that level of vision can create.
00:26:21 And that's what I hope for Canada.
00:26:23 It's what I hope for Alberta.
00:26:26 And I think that Mark Carney has a lot of potential.
00:26:30 I was one of the very few.
00:26:31 I liked, like you, the speech, the way that I like a song,
00:26:36 but I thought that it was being played by a cover band,
00:26:39 not somebody that can speak for Vassilov Havel after writing about sedition
00:26:43 when it came to Canadian dissent on COVID.
00:26:47 David, we'll leave it there.
00:26:48 And thank you for that.
00:26:50 When you get back, if you want to be finding a 57 Buick
00:26:54 so you don't give all your personal information to the Chinese,
00:26:58 you'll join a few.
00:27:00 All right, ladies and gentlemen, thank you, David.
00:27:04 For The Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.
00:27:09 For more honors terms and more levels,
00:27:10 uh,
00:27:11 um,
00:27:16 uh,
00:27:18 am
00:27:37 the
00:27:39 average