Western Standard - September 12, 2025


Charlie Kirk Assassination

Topics
Mentioned
Tristin Hopper urges conservatives to fight back and ‘Don’t Be Canada’ THE PIPELINE: Charlie Kirk Assassination

Episode Stats


Length

51 minutes

Words per minute

157.69

Word count

8,108

Sentence count

311

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

22

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Former Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hannaford, Senior Alberta Columnist Corey Morgan, and BC Columnist Elise Mills join me to discuss the death of Turning Point's founder, Charlie Kirk, and his impact on the conservative movement.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, today is
00:00:27 September 10th, 2025.
00:00:29 I'm Derek Phil de Brandt, publisher of the
00:00:31 Western Standard, and you're watching The Pipeline.
00:00:33 I'm joined by our usual
00:00:35 roundup of guests today.
00:00:38 Former Western Standard
00:00:39 opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford.
00:00:41 Hello, everybody.
00:00:42 Western Standard Senior Alberta columnist, Corey Morgan.
00:00:45 Good day.
00:00:46 And BC columnist,
00:00:50 Elise Mills.
00:00:51 Hi.
00:00:53 So, normally I start
00:00:55 these off a bit more chipper, but
00:00:57 uh today is i think going to be a bit more of a serious talk um i'm sure most or all of you have
00:01:05 seen by now uh the video of the assassination of charlie kirk uh the founder of turning point
00:01:15 uh usa a major figure on the american right probably best known for holding these kind of
00:01:24 prove-me-wrong
00:01:25 powwows on American college campuses
00:01:29 where he
00:01:30 likes to stream videos
00:01:32 of hapless
00:01:34 college socialists
00:01:36 getting shredded in debate
00:01:39 with him.
00:01:41 And, you know,
00:01:43 actually recently, he was
00:01:44 featured on South Park.
00:01:46 And they did a pretty good, fun job
00:01:49 poking at him, but I think
00:01:50 he took it well as a great actor to be
00:01:52 become one of the characters on South Park
00:01:55 so
00:01:57 he
00:01:58 was sitting
00:01:59 he was holding one of his prove me wrong
00:02:03 events returning point
00:02:04 at the University of Utah
00:02:06 today when
00:02:08 he was assassinated
00:02:10 shot right in the neck
00:02:12 we've seen
00:02:14 some of the videos we're going to show you
00:02:16 some video now so
00:02:19 definite
00:02:21 extreme graphic
00:02:23 content warning.
00:02:28 This is a tough one to watch,
00:02:30 but we're going to show you some of the
00:02:32 footage here right now.
00:02:35 Counting or not
00:02:36 kind of game-wise.
00:02:39 Oh my god!
00:02:49 um yeah uh we did not show you the the close-up video um which is significantly more graphic but
00:03:09 you can see him uh he the video has him and the last word out of his mouth was violence
00:03:17 he was talking about gang violence
00:03:19 we finished the sentence
00:03:21 with the last word, violence
00:03:23 and you can hear the crack of a shot
00:03:25 and you can see the bullet
00:03:27 enter his neck on the left side
00:03:29 and streams of blood coming out
00:03:31 and
00:03:32 yeah 0.85
00:03:34 we're assassinating 0.83
00:03:38 media funders
00:03:41 and political organizers now
00:03:43 not just presidential
00:03:45 candidates
00:03:46 It's, it's, it's a dark, I feel like America's headed into a really dark time right now.
00:03:56 People are extremely polarized.
00:03:59 People feel very strongly, you know, whatever I say is not, never may do an equivocate or in any of this, but, you know, at least one, both sides of America, I think,
00:04:16 feel that they're under mortal threat uh republican america uh sees itself as a mortal threat
00:04:23 from global threats mass migration replacing itself uh and liberal america sees it under
00:04:31 threat from trump uh but he is you know a dictator and uh all sorts of isms and phobes etc and
00:04:41 And people, at least some people now, feel justified in the use of political violence.
00:04:50 Elise, you know, I think you've met Kurt before, right?
00:04:54 I have. I have.
00:04:55 And I'm sure I'm one of hundreds of thousands of conservatives in Canada and the United States that have met him.
00:05:03 I wouldn't say that we were close by any measure.
00:05:07 Um, but if you've ever been to CPAC or, um, a turning point event, like I have, he obviously
00:05:14 turning point was his organization or is his organization.
00:05:18 I apologize.
00:05:19 Um, you then know, then, you know, Charlie and he's affable.
00:05:25 He is so amazing on his feet, um, love or hate him or, or, well, I guess, you know,
00:05:33 that that's the point uh but disagree with him or agree with him you cannot disqualify his
00:05:40 spectacular array of skills his ability to litigate debate his understanding of the constant the
00:05:46 american constitution his understanding of the society that he lives in his willingness to
00:05:51 engage with young people whether people like it or not i think changed uh the course of the
00:05:57 conversation many many times um he was never one to try and embarrass somebody he was simply there
00:06:05 even though i think some of the kids that came along that tried to debate him their intent was
00:06:09 to embarrass him they sorely misunderstood who he was and sorely misunderstood or underestimated
00:06:16 his abilities to see charlie kirk in action is quite spectacular a lot of people obviously have
00:06:22 seen what he posts on his social media and youtube but to actually see a debate with charlie kirk
00:06:29 or a charlie kirk presentation or speech and then his engagement with the audience
00:06:33 is something to behold i am very envious of his skill set i like to think i'm a good public
00:06:40 speaker and i'm good at a debate but he is in a whole other league and his heart is in the right
00:06:46 place he is not hateful uh unlike what some liberals or the left the extreme left want to
00:06:52 say he's not a purveyor of hate he is somebody that believes ultimately in the freedom of speech
00:06:58 um and he believes in the and that conversations and dialogue can change our discourse
00:07:05 and i support him in that i didn't always agree with him and and it would be strange if i did
00:07:11 um you don't always agree with even your best of friends your loved ones your families i mean we
00:07:15 all know that but i am incredibly impressed and um envious of his incredible skill set
00:07:23 his character and his ability to be strong enough to want to connect with young people
00:07:30 today in a way that politicians are too afraid to do um we should uh you know in here let's play
00:07:38 that clip from south park uh where he's uh he was enshrined as a character as i said earlier he
00:07:44 took it really well. He's like, I know I've made it now. I'm a
00:07:46 self-part character.
00:07:48 And then, you know, Eric Cartman
00:07:50 kind of essentially becomes Charlie
00:07:52 Kirk. He's a
00:07:55 master debater.
00:07:56 You can guess where that...
00:07:59 So, I won't
00:08:03 get much further into it.
00:08:04 Everyone who hasn't watched that episode of Self-Part,
00:08:06 it's just a couple weeks old, maybe
00:08:08 a month at most. I'd recommend
00:08:10 you go back and watch
00:08:12 charlie kirk slash eric hartman as the master debater it's uh it's it's good um they're playing
00:08:20 it on twitter right now it's a lot of people have posted that supporters of his i think it's a rally
00:08:26 something to rally around right now sorry to interrupt you jerek but uh it's it's rolling on
00:08:30 my twitter feed right now yeah it's it's i mean i think he saw no greater compliment than being
00:08:38 spoofed on South Park.
00:08:42 Nigel,
00:08:43 Kirk was
00:08:44 sitting, you know, he sits under his
00:08:46 kind of, have a little tent
00:08:48 set up thing to keep out of the sun
00:08:50 and it said, prove me wrong on it.
00:08:54 They couldn't prove him wrong.
00:08:55 This was,
00:08:56 you know, this was their only way.
00:08:59 It was the only answer they had.
00:09:01 You know, but I mean, first of all, I think we should just remember
00:09:04 there's a young widow and a 0.98
00:09:06 child here. Young child.
00:09:07 young child we still have to be careful it's looking very likely that he's passed but at this
00:09:14 point yes still i mean uh based on a close-up footage or something yeah i'm uh yeah just
00:09:21 that he survived can't fully presume yet well may it be so um so the left you look you know
00:09:30 about two months ago there was a guy by the name of luigi angione who decided they didn't like the
00:09:35 healthcare system. Went to New York, shot a healthcare executive in the back. Cold-blooded
00:09:43 murder. In the Wild West, you didn't, even in the Wild West, you didn't shoot somebody
00:09:48 in the back. But instead of being reviled, there is a very large portion of the American
00:09:58 population who think that he did something heroic indeed he is as he has inspired others to embrace
00:10:10 violence including the gunman behind last month's deadly attack on the nfl headquarters in manhattan
00:10:18 so the possibility that this kind of casual assassination of people with whom you profoundly
00:10:27 disagree is going to go mainstream in the united states i mean how many more did this have to be
00:10:34 before you say this is what it's like down there and if you are a public figure or a pundit uh
00:10:41 never mind a political candidate such as the uh republican guys who were gunned down at a baseball
00:10:48 match about what was it five during the first trump presidency i think yeah so or or right
00:10:55 before somewhere around yeah it was around a decade anyway they were politicians so
00:10:59 politicians are known for a long time that they've got a target on their back
00:11:04 journalists often do get killed in the line of duty but this is different this is saying i don't
00:11:10 like what that guy thinks so let's take him out and obviously the loss to the conservative moment
00:11:17 is considerable kirk is not irreplaceable but he was tremendously effective and a lot of people
00:11:22 really liked him and it did my heart good to hear at least praising him the way she did and the kind
00:11:27 of observations she made this is a very different world that we're coming into um corey i'm trying
00:11:37 to put myself kind of in the shoes right now of uh if maybe the situation had been reversed
00:11:44 where a prominent and effective figure on the left
00:11:48 had been assassinated, presumably by someone on our side.
00:11:54 That is an uncomfortable position to be in.
00:11:59 And it is generally unfair to blame everybody on one side,
00:12:06 any kind of shared guilt, shared responsibility.
00:12:10 Sometimes, not always, perhaps,
00:12:12 the rhetoric used by one side
00:12:14 could
00:12:15 incite people
00:12:18 to do something
00:12:19 the attempted assassination
00:12:22 of Trump
00:12:24 twice
00:12:25 must have been incited
00:12:28 in some measure
00:12:29 by Kamala Harris
00:12:32 and the Democrats saying
00:12:33 this man is the next Hitler 0.99
00:12:36 he is here to 0.53
00:12:37 slave America etc etc
00:12:39 I mean
00:12:41 Because if those things aren't true, then political violence would appear to be legitimate to stop this thing from happening.
00:12:50 But at the same time, you know, the Democrats didn't say, go out, pick up a gun and shoot Trump.
00:12:55 And ultimately, it's the person who pulls the trigger or clicks the button on a bond who is responsible for what happened.
00:13:02 So I don't know if there's any clear answer in this kind of thing.
00:13:05 But, you know, how how do you think? And this is just presuming it was a leftist who shot him.
00:13:12 But there is a suspect in custody. For all we could tell, it was just looked like an older white guy.
00:13:18 We we don't know anything yet.
00:13:21 So but we're making a broad assumption that is probably at least in some measure likely correct.
00:13:28 You know, Charlie Kirk was very strong on pro-life issues.
00:13:31 You know, he could have any number of things.
00:13:35 But, you know, presuming that this was someone on the other side, how do you think, you know, liberal and leftist America should be reflecting and thinking about what's happened right now? How should you be reacting?
00:13:48 Well, of course, they most definitely should condemn this as harshly as possible to make it clear that this is just not an acceptable approach in a modern democratic world.
00:14:01 I mean, torqued rhetoric, you know, we should try and say that we want to have less torqued rhetoric that works up somebody who's unhinged to go out and do something.
00:14:11 It's not unprecedented.
00:14:13 If you remember in the 80s, or maybe you wouldn't, but Alan Berg was a radio host.
00:14:17 He was a left winger and he was assassinated by white nationalists.
00:14:23 That wasn't the order.
00:14:25 Yeah.
00:14:25 And that wasn't a reflection of conservatism in general.
00:14:28 And anybody sane immediately would say that was just not what's to be done.
00:14:32 And thankfully that didn't snowball into something more.
00:14:35 Though the world is different today.
00:14:37 It is more polarized.
00:14:38 There is more for the people who really truly are the word fringe and extreme, I think is abused, but there really are people who are fringe and they are on the extremes. And there's more access, I guess, to the type of material or the type of discourse to set somebody off the edge.
00:14:58 I mean, whether it was the person who took a shot at Trump or in this case with this,
00:15:04 I, you know, just as for how the left can react, I mean, again, we don't know the motivation of
00:15:09 the shooter himself. They should just, again, watch for their own extreme because there's
00:15:14 going to be people dancing on the grave. We know that. We see that every time this happens.
00:15:18 And they best tamp it down. I worry. I mean, the United States is,
00:15:24 I don't see an open civil war coming out, but people are getting pressured.
00:15:28 and and i could see more people going off the edge um we're seeing some lesser known
00:15:39 online news outlets saying he's confirmed dead but uh no one major yet uh knowing that i would
00:15:45 have trust you should trust the mainstream media but i mean if you if they're reporting it it's
00:15:51 life through a little higher likelihood yeah um i just picked up something here from the uh
00:16:02 governor of illinois prisker just said this is all i've been able to find nearly an hour after the
00:16:08 attack of left-wing response to this and he says uh the attack on charlie kirk is horrifying
00:16:15 political violence has no place in this country and should never become the norm
00:16:20 i'm sending my sympathies to his family and friends at this time he said the right thing
00:16:25 so far he's the only one i see saying it i i expect we'll see fraud condemnation of it
00:16:31 from all sides and they'll probably be the odd nutter who who says something that's going to
00:16:37 get them in trouble um yeah i you know i i don't think uh it'd be fair to paint you know one side
00:16:45 broadly is favoring us.
00:16:47 That being said, the left has
00:16:48 tolerated political violence in its
00:16:50 camp to a greater extent
00:16:53 than I think the right for some time
00:16:55 now. You've got the Antifa times now.
00:16:57 Look at the protests, it's true. I mean,
00:16:59 when you get conservative-minded
00:17:00 protests, it tends to be marching
00:17:03 down the street, you know,
00:17:05 chanting, yelling, whatever, a typical protest, 0.73
00:17:07 and maybe some trash 0.97
00:17:09 will be left behind. Leftist 1.00
00:17:11 protests tend to be smashed windows,
00:17:13 turned over police cars
00:17:15 and not everyone, I shouldn't
00:17:17 I'm blanketing as well, but if there's a
00:17:19 propensity for that highly
00:17:21 charged approach
00:17:23 it seems to be more predominant
00:17:25 or Antifa types
00:17:29 that's a very small number of people
00:17:31 who actually engage in that kind of thing
00:17:33 the worry is though that
00:17:35 the broader left seems to turn a blind
00:17:37 eye to it, you know, most
00:17:39 liberals, socialists
00:17:41 etc, whatever you want to call them, they're not engaging
00:17:45 in acts of vandalism or violence, street violence, going up and beating
00:17:49 people. The overwhelming majority of people do not do this.
00:17:53 But they seem to turn a blind eye
00:17:57 very casually towards that problem in their ranks.
00:18:02 I think you see that less on the right.
00:18:05 I don't have the numbers in front of me, but there's polling in the last
00:18:09 year that is showing that the number
00:18:11 of Americans who approve
00:18:13 of the use of violence for
00:18:15 political ends on both ends of the spectrum
00:18:17 is getting dangerously high. And you
00:18:19 don't need a large portion of the
00:18:21 population
00:18:22 to engage in that kind of thing
00:18:25 to end up in a pretty bad situation.
00:18:27 You can think of, you know,
00:18:29 people only vaguely know of the Spanish Civil
00:18:31 War. The Spanish Civil War broke out
00:18:33 due to an escalating
00:18:35 there's a lot of reasons, but
00:18:36 in large measure to
00:18:39 an escalating tit-for-tat
00:18:41 of assassinations between
00:18:43 the Republican,
00:18:45 generally Communists on one side, and the
00:18:47 Nationalists and Catholics on the other. 0.54
00:18:50 And it was a tit-for-tat
00:18:51 of growing political
00:18:53 violence. Who actually started it?
00:18:55 No one can know. History will never
00:18:57 really decide that. But what really
00:18:59 broke out is when the rightist
00:19:01 nationalist presidential candidate
00:19:03 was assassinated, and
00:19:05 then the left
00:19:07 ended up winning the presidential election afterwards.
00:19:09 as the main nationalist candidate was assassinated.
00:19:12 The nationalist side said,
00:19:13 well, we don't accept that as a legitimate election outcome
00:19:16 because you killed or died.
00:19:18 And then you had civil war.
00:19:24 This kind of thing ends up in, you know,
00:19:28 what do you at least say?
00:19:31 Violent re-violence.
00:19:33 And it's very easy to say,
00:19:35 well, we're going to stay above that.
00:19:36 We're not going to engage in it
00:19:38 or we're not going to engage in reprisal.
00:19:41 That's not the way history normally works.
00:19:44 No, and the setup for what has made
00:19:48 some of our worst moments in history
00:19:52 is all on the table now.
00:19:54 And I'm not moving away from
00:19:57 what's happened to Charlie personally
00:19:59 because his beautiful wife,
00:20:02 his beautiful baby boy,
00:20:03 his beautiful baby girl.
00:20:05 Oh, I'm sorry, guys.
00:20:06 it just i'm horrified second anyway i apologize um but everything's on the table for civil war
00:20:18 or for increased violent acts as we're seeing today and i and i mean people will probably
00:20:27 wonder why i'm bringing up job numbers when you look at the economic conditions of the united
00:20:32 States, and they've been veiled. And President Trump's camp, you can't deny, has tried to make
00:20:39 the situation look a lot better than what it actually is. But almost a million jobs are off
00:20:46 the table today in the United States. And those are not C-suite. That's not Jeff Bezos. That's
00:20:51 going to be hardworking Americans that voted for Trump. You're seeing rapid decline of Trump
00:20:57 supporters in the hispanic community but across the board with young men and they are not going
00:21:03 left they're going further right they're going into their trenches and that creates uh i think
00:21:10 that that level of social and economic chaos is the perfect recipe and i also let's bring our
00:21:16 attention back to what we saw last month and i i know it feels like many moons ago but what was
00:21:21 happening on the streets in california and especially in los angeles that wasn't just
00:21:26 turned over cars that was that that was molotov cocktails that was weaponry that should only be
00:21:33 in the hands of the armed forces or certain police departments um that was mexican immigrants 0.80
00:21:41 or illegal or going through the process be not being arrested while committing crimes the message
00:21:48 is really loud and clear if you're saying anything against trump you're off the hook tell i don't
00:21:54 don't know if any of you can tell me how many people were actually arrested and are facing
00:21:59 serious jail time for the absolute destruction of downtown Los Angeles. It was horrifying.
00:22:06 California is a breeding ground for this. I don't think it's a coincidence that Charlie was very
00:22:12 vocal about ICE and President Trump's use of the military. And I think that could be what just sort
00:22:21 have lit this all off i think it might have just been the final straw that broke the camel's back
00:22:25 so to speak charlie had been extremely vocal in the past few months about that his support for
00:22:32 president trump's actions uh for ice coming in and and picking people up um there was a lot of
00:22:40 chatter on social media uh that was i don't want to repeat some of it obviously very against what
00:22:46 Charlie was saying, I, I supported some of those policies, I know what I got in return,
00:22:54 you know, but you sort of that you move it along, because if you're someone like Charlie, even,
00:22:59 even myself, you're used to getting veiled threats or direct threats. And it's just it's
00:23:05 really disconcerting. But somehow, it's not as important when it's the person on the right of
00:23:10 the political spectrum. But when it happens to somebody on the left, even the most, you know,
00:23:15 asinine comment becomes headline news and uh i would say that just circling back for poor charlie
00:23:22 and his family i think the table was set for this disaster today this horrendous event today and
00:23:28 and um i i pray with all my heart that he is not he has not passed that he's going to get through
00:23:35 this somehow um and sorry to get emotional guys i just am so sickened by the violence
00:23:43 i'm so horrified even the pile up of of the violence that we've seen in canada especially
00:23:48 in the last few weeks innocent fathers murdered uh men defending their property put into jail
00:23:54 it's upside down world and i think for me this is just a very scary time for both the americans and
00:24:01 for canadians you shouldn't apologize for feeling emotional about the young father getting shot
00:24:07 is life in danger that's uh the sad thing is that it is now happening more frequently and people are
00:24:16 prepared to excuse it you know the thing that at least you're referring to the los angeles riots
00:24:25 i do not understand the logic that is used to say it is a bad thing to enforce the law
00:24:35 You have illegal immigrants, you take them out. 1.00
00:24:38 What's the problem with that?
00:24:39 You have riots or you have a severe crime problem in a major city.
00:24:46 The local authorities aren't doing anything about it.
00:24:49 Somebody comes along and does it.
00:24:51 They're the good guy in the situation.
00:24:53 The left does not get that, does not want to get that.
00:24:56 And I think this is where the divide that you're speaking of is.
00:25:00 I think one thing that's so terrifying about this is there is no practical protection against what's happened here.
00:25:09 When I was in politics, I got a fair number of death threats.
00:25:14 I wouldn't report most to the Sergeant-at-Arms of the legislature unless they were more serious.
00:25:19 Most of them just...
00:25:20 And they weren't all death threats.
00:25:22 They'd just be threats of attack and whatnot.
00:25:24 But I applied. I didn't want a security detail. It costs taxpayers a bunch of money and it intrudes on your privacy.
00:25:33 So I applied with the RCMP for a concealed carry permit. They denied me.
00:25:39 So, no, I wasn't allowed to carry. But I thought that was a very reasonable thing. 0.99
00:25:46 And it shouldn't be just the politicians allowed to carry.
00:25:49 Right. Everyone who's got a clean criminal record and is trained in the use of firearms, doesn't have, you know, psychological issues going on, should be allowed to carry and protect themselves.
00:25:59 But in this circumstance, I think Charlie Kirk could have been carrying and it would not have saved him.
00:26:05 He this looks like it was a sniper. I mean, if you've seen it zoomed out, I guess it was a very large gathering.
00:26:12 It looks like thousands of people around and someone it was a sniper shot.
00:26:19 There's very little defense from that.
00:26:21 Even President Trump, you know, that was a sniper shot.
00:26:27 And that was what the Secret Service ran.
00:26:29 Although I have a feeling that was not the Secret Service at its very best.
00:26:34 Sorry, Derek, can I just add that Charlie had very limited security.
00:26:42 I think even those who haven't seen him in person can see from the videos that it's very limited.
00:26:47 And the whole point that Charlie, what Charlie was committed to was face-to-face verbal combat, right?
00:26:56 I don't know if I could say it like that on a day like today, but he wanted you to see him.
00:27:00 He would even say those who were wearing masks or trying to hide their identity under the guise of COVID, he'd say, drop the mask.
00:27:06 I'm okay. I'm back today. I'm good.
00:27:08 I, you know, he, that's the whole point of Charlie Kirk.
00:27:13 Yeah, he couldn't, he doesn't have the Secret Service around them.
00:27:16 And even the Secret Service has a hard time stopping snipers, it seems.
00:27:22 So, you know, like, what hope do the rest of us have?
00:27:26 If someone decides to assassinate you as a sniper, there's just not a ton of defense against that.
00:27:34 Unless you're going to be in, like, a polvovil under bulletproof glass constantly.
00:27:38 Normal people with normal budgets, and yeah, he probably makes pretty good money,
00:27:41 but he doesn't have Secret Service level budgets for defense,
00:27:46 for protection, Corey?
00:27:47 No, there's no protection for that
00:27:50 unless you just stopped all public appearances,
00:27:52 which is the intent, I think, of some people.
00:27:54 And then I think dedicated people to their causes
00:27:57 aren't going to stop those appearances.
00:28:00 Everybody else who does things like this
00:28:04 is now going to be thinking long and hard,
00:28:06 and it's going to become less economical for them to be able to do it.
00:28:09 He's going to have a chilling effect.
00:28:10 The only preventative thing I can think of, it has to be social and I don't see it happening.
00:28:14 And that's stop having everything always treated as an existential threat.
00:28:18 That sort of rhetoric.
00:28:19 Every time somebody doesn't disagree with, you know, or doesn't agree with me, the social media rhetoric from people, from some pundits, from others, as you said, that person is literally Hitler or that person, the environment, you're all going to die.
00:28:30 Because if we don't change that, we're all dead.
00:28:32 And if this doesn't happen, we're all dead. 0.89
00:28:34 And it's a genocide in schools because trans kids can't play in other sports. 0.60
00:28:38 It's like every single subject is being framed as something that's going to cause death and misery.
00:28:43 It's so torqued.
00:28:45 And again, still, most sane people will never pick up a firearm and take it out on somebody.
00:28:52 But the ones who are sitting on the edge and when they're constantly barraged with that, but I don't know what's going to stop that.
00:28:58 That's the environment of discourse these days.
00:29:01 And we've got social media platforms where, unfortunately, the most unhinged and, you know, inflammatory of people can really get their messaging out there.
00:29:10 We've been seeing this on colleges for a long time where the radical mob storms the lecture theater and prevents the visiting speaker who they don't like from speaking.
00:29:24 This is just upping it one notch.
00:29:27 Well, certainly.
00:29:27 I mean, you know, we do a lot of...
00:29:29 So the damage is not only to, but it's also to free speech and the idea that we have a society where you can actually hash things out and make a good decision.
00:29:41 That's not what people who shoot speakers are all about.
00:29:46 No, and as Derek was saying, you can't help but have a little bit of chill.
00:29:49 I mean, you know, we do a lot of public events.
00:29:51 We do a lot of places where we're speaking in front of a crowd.
00:29:54 we stir up some some pretty crazy people at times you can't help but have that thought maybe in the
00:30:01 back of your head a little if you're standing on that stage and who's that over in the background
00:30:05 over there who's doing that and for some people they might just say you know what i'm just not
00:30:09 going to do those anymore and that's that's tragic so you know in terms of we have to be careful not
00:30:16 to overly incite people and i mean we're in the news business and you want to get people engaged
00:30:22 in the issues that you care about and sometimes an issue might be existential i mean the left
00:30:29 genuinely believes the global warming is existential we will all die i disagree with
00:30:35 them but many of them believe that genuinely in their hearts and it is an existential issue to
00:30:41 them and so you know they might use some existential rhetoric and most people will not
00:30:47 who are receptive to that rhetoric, are not going to engage in violence,
00:30:51 but maybe someone will go out and knock off the head of an oil company, etc.
00:30:55 But on the other side, there are issues that I believe are existential.
00:31:02 I think immigration, particularly in Europe, is an existential issue.
00:31:09 Most people on our side are not going to engage in political violence over that,
00:31:13 But, you know, someone, someone might. People do.
00:31:17 A really good example of this is you'll think of Greta Thunberg heaving with tears, crying.
00:31:27 And then you think about the report that was issued today.
00:31:31 I believe it's by doctors and nurses and First Nations leaders where they're they're targeting oil and gas companies saying that they're going to be the cause of death.
00:31:42 or the cause of your cancer in very recent years to come.
00:31:47 Then again, there was another report today by another environmental organization.
00:31:51 And remember that all of these groups, including Greta and her crazy flotilla,
00:31:56 all require a level of torque to be able to make the hundreds of thousands
00:32:02 and millions of dollars that they do.
00:32:05 Today's report actually named the companies that they believe
00:32:08 are killing the earth and killing human beings. 0.88
00:32:11 they named the ceos they named the board of directors that to me is ultimately a crisis
00:32:18 of morality considering what we're seeing and i and people may wonder how i'm connecting this to
00:32:24 charlie kirk charlie kirk's the crime against the the crime against charlie kirk is a case of
00:32:32 twerking and exactly cory everything you said i absolutely agree with you that is the number one
00:32:38 problem this call to war that we have over a very reasonable discussion um this idea that if trans
00:32:47 kids cannot or a trans a trans woman cannot pay play in my daughter's soccer league that it's a 1.00
00:32:55 national disaster i apologize that was my golden retriever puppy putting her little face in there 1.00
00:33:01 um but i think we need to think about we need to read these reports and what these organizations
00:33:06 are putting out through a very different lens at least it's the lens that i've been viewing it
00:33:11 through for a while and when you ask the regular citizen a regular canadian what do you see with
00:33:15 those reports if you really explain to them what this is about it's a environmental industrial
00:33:21 complex consider it consider the dangers associated with that the names the addresses
00:33:26 people have been doxed today well if they're putting i mean if putting out addresses that's
00:33:32 Completely doxing.
00:33:33 If, you know, and I'm trying to be as objective as I can,
00:33:37 how would I think about it from my own side?
00:33:40 You know, if, you know, when I was at the Canadian Taxpayers Federation,
00:33:45 you know, the organization had been fighting to scrap or reform
00:33:49 the Member of Parliament pension plan for decades,
00:33:52 hadn't been working because they'd always release pensions of people
00:33:55 who were defeated or retired.
00:33:57 And we decided, no, we need to put the pressure on the guys who are in office.
00:34:00 So we calculated the pension eligibility of every single individual MP, and then we emailed it to everyone.
00:34:05 We had an email address.
00:34:06 We're in there writing to say, here's how much your MP is eligible for, because we wanted to put the political pressure on the individuals to force reform.
00:34:14 And it worked.
00:34:15 We actually did get reformed.
00:34:16 The MP pension plan, still rich, but it's reformed and more reasonable now.
00:34:22 That is putting the pressure on people with positions of power or privilege.
00:34:28 and I don't think there's anything wrong with that
00:34:30 but it obviously does come with the
00:34:33 danger then that another is going to see
00:34:35 this and come after them
00:34:37 now in the case of Charlie Kirk
00:34:38 that didn't take anyone necessarily pointing out
00:34:40 look at this guy Charlie Kirk
00:34:42 he was already well known
00:34:44 everybody knew who he was
00:34:46 no one needed to publish a list like that
00:34:48 but you know he had some
00:34:50 hardcore critics and they said he's a hateful person 0.99
00:34:53 he hates women he hates minorities 0.99
00:34:55 he 0.97
00:34:55 uh exactly yeah um i i to be then self-censor you know and again trying to think it from our side
00:35:06 to be then self-censor ourselves from hard criticism where we feel hard criticism is
00:35:12 warranted i i don't think so i think we self-censor from not dehumanizing the opponent or or trying to
00:35:20 justify that i mean again i think most rational pundits and media will do that even we're ramping
00:35:25 people up, sure we are, we stir people up with headlines
00:35:27 we, you know
00:35:29 especially when it's commentary
00:35:30 you know, you raise it up, but I don't think
00:35:33 we go out to
00:35:34 try and cast the other person
00:35:37 as a
00:35:37 less than human, or you know 0.95
00:35:40 worthy of dying
00:35:42 that's a whole different level. Let's think of this
00:35:45 maybe
00:35:45 for 10 years
00:35:48 Justin Trudeau has been hated by a large
00:35:51 portion of this country
00:35:52 and especially in the latter years
00:35:54 hated by most
00:35:56 of the country.
00:35:58 Yet there was not a single
00:36:00 serious attempt to assassinate
00:36:03 him, at least that we know of.
00:36:05 I mean, you know, I'm sure there was always a couple 0.99
00:36:07 of jerks trying to get too close to him or 0.99
00:36:09 do something. 1.00
00:36:10 Those don't get reported as much.
00:36:13 But there was, no one got shots off at him.
00:36:15 No one got close to him with a gun
00:36:17 that any of us are aware
00:36:19 of. Ten years, and that man
00:36:21 was hated. And yeah,
00:36:23 I consider him an existential threat to Canada.
00:36:26 I think he actually succeeded.
00:36:28 I think it's already done.
00:36:29 He has left this place a smoldering ruin
00:36:32 that it is unlikely to ever recover from,
00:36:34 no matter who's a power.
00:36:36 But no one tried to kill this guy in 10 years.
00:36:41 Honestly, I'm kind of shocked
00:36:43 that no nutter got it in his head to go do this.
00:36:46 And happily so.
00:36:47 Maybe we should examine some of that.
00:36:48 What are the social differences?
00:36:50 What's going on?
00:36:50 Because the areas where it didn't happen,
00:36:52 we should be looking at yeah i i don't know but i'm glad it didn't i mean i got no love of trudeau
00:36:58 but i would never of course never wish so no i don't think that trudeau pressed the button on
00:37:05 the volatile demographics and their communities the way that someone like pierre polyev would
00:37:11 or the way that someone like me in a limited way does or what cory or nigel or you derek do 0.55
00:37:18 we talk about issues that trudeau never talked about really anything the argument was get your
00:37:26 hands off my guns then it really got into serious territory uh the most that we saw was the truckers
00:37:32 convoy and even then it was really peaceful and the conversations were economic issues people
00:37:38 fearful that they couldn't pay their mortgage or they would have to sell the family farm um but we
00:37:45 he what those communities are not the communities that we press the button on i'll be very frank we
00:37:51 talk about immigration some of the harshest abuses that i receive is when i talk about the muslim
00:37:57 community not show it not issuing a statement when um when the woman was attacked in the ottawa or
00:38:03 the jewish woman was attacked in the ottawa grocery store for example i will get tens and tens of 0.84
00:38:09 messages of hate um or threats to rape me sexually assault me that's been going on since i started my 0.68
00:38:16 pundit career charlie kirk pressed put his finger on the button of all well all the hot buttons
00:38:22 all the communities and i will say this to our viewers this is the difference between what i
00:38:27 call the pros and the trolls not one of us out of the four of us here and the tens of other pundits
00:38:33 that we all have in common or that we personally know what may hate someone like justin trudeau
00:38:40 but i can tell you if justin trudeau had needed my attention or my help pulling you know picking
00:38:46 him up if he tripped or was in danger i'd be right there but the trolls don't under the lines get
00:38:52 blurred the hate is fanatical it's crazy and when you add religion and you add something like the
00:38:58 ICE detainees or the sort of like religious crusades that some some American groups are
00:39:06 pumping millions into and it's happening in Canada those are the hottest hottest of the buttons and
00:39:12 Trudeau was silent on every bit of social decay and economic decay in this country I am I'm not
00:39:19 surprised that there was never a serious threat to his life he was ballless from the beginning 1.00
00:39:26 I mean, we had God knows how many churches burned to the ground, and the man didn't even condemn it.
00:39:32 People close to him even condoned it, in a sense.
00:39:36 That it was understandable.
00:39:38 Yeah. I think that was Gerald Butts who said that one.
00:39:41 But he never condemned it himself, really, in any kind of serious and forceful language.
00:39:47 No question that I'm aware picked up a gun or a knife to get him.
00:39:51 We had a man who was passionately hated by many, particularly in the West, and then later on across most of the country.
00:40:00 There was just no violence, and many probably wished him ill, but no one actually did anything.
00:40:12 I was going to make a comment about Joe Biden, but he's old enough.
00:40:17 People thought maybe he'd just go on his own any day.
00:40:20 But anyway, I don't want to say or act like...
00:40:26 Well, to your point about Biden, nobody actually took a run at him.
00:40:31 No, but I mean...
00:40:32 And there are lots of people on the other side of the political spectrum who are good shots.
00:40:37 Yeah.
00:40:39 But, you know, okay, Barack Obama was not at any risk of dying of nephra causes any day.
00:40:43 As far as I know, there was no real shots at him.
00:40:47 but even take George Bush who waged
00:40:49 wars, one of at least
00:40:51 is broadly considered
00:40:53 by most to have been unjust in hindsight
00:40:55 no major assassination
00:40:58 attempts, we haven't had actual
00:41:00 shots fired I guess, a presidential candidate
00:41:01 since Reagan
00:41:03 to be fair too though, the amount
00:41:06 and levels of protection, we don't hear about
00:41:08 what they've prevented quite often
00:41:10 since Reagan
00:41:11 yeah, they haven't been shots fired
00:41:14 that's where the Charlie Kirk thing you mentioned earlier
00:41:16 is a little more distressing on top, too,
00:41:18 because pundits don't have that sort of
00:41:20 protection. They don't sweep an area
00:41:22 before they get there. They don't screen people
00:41:24 coming to the event. They don't have that
00:41:26 ability.
00:41:27 And it's not feasible.
00:41:29 The United States cannot provide
00:41:32 a secret surface detail
00:41:33 to everyone with a podcast.
00:41:35 Okay, Charlie Kirk's is not just any podcast.
00:41:38 It's amongst the biggest
00:41:40 ever.
00:41:41 Okay, fine. Joe Rogan gets one now.
00:41:45 Theo Vaughn.
00:41:46 but then obviously that it'd get into partisan fine one side gets protection the other there's
00:41:50 no practical way to do this there is there is no defense there is no defense against this
00:41:56 actually you know there is one case of a political violence in uh gun violence in canada it's 2014
00:42:05 the deranged individual i mean he was deranged in the leftist kind of way yeah but he was a
00:42:12 there's a nutter and uh he shot it shot the soldier in the back standing there on guard 0.89
00:42:18 at the war memorial he drove his car across the road ran away from it entered the uh entered 0.67
00:42:26 center block and started firing and eventually it was the surgeon at large and alarms that brought
00:42:32 him down now the point being that uh even in canada when you are looking around and say well
00:42:40 are we like this could this happen here and the one example of something where you could say well
00:42:45 there was that again it turns out to be somebody who is against the system uh the the people who
00:42:54 who hated what trudeau did sucked it up and waited for the election that's our system
00:43:00 so i guess we have enough uh update um cbs news uh reports that occurred according to turning
00:43:08 point, USA, Charlie Kirk's organization.
00:43:10 He's in the hospital, but it
00:43:12 quote, it doesn't look good.
00:43:14 I mean, that's not really
00:43:16 new. It's just finally
00:43:17 some kind of official statement from his organization.
00:43:20 But anyone who saw,
00:43:22 and we didn't show it here, because it's just
00:43:24 it's too damn graphic.
00:43:26 The close-up video.
00:43:28 I
00:43:28 would be shocked if he was alive
00:43:32 when he was put in the ambulance.
00:43:34 I've hit my quota of bloody graphic
00:43:36 videos this week, but that just
00:43:38 that that's the new change for today too you know we didn't we don't we didn't even see it like you
00:43:42 know a generation ago you didn't see that and yeah we haven't gotten to it but that horrible horrible
00:43:47 murder on the train and i keep seeing that video over and over again and now i've seen this and i
00:43:52 just you know i i'm a a harsh tough talking pundit but i still have no use for for seeing
00:43:58 humans murdered and and abused and and hit and maybe that's something else to study too though
00:44:05 Because we didn't get the exposure to this sort of thing 30, 40 years ago.
00:44:08 Not as regularly, not as graphically, not as instantly as we do today.
00:44:12 You see it for real.
00:44:14 It's for real.
00:44:15 And it's got to be.
00:44:17 I think that's why I agree with you, Corey.
00:44:19 I think that's why I broke down.
00:44:21 It's just being, you know, seeing the story of the father in Vaughn that, was it Vaughn, that defended his family and to actually see family, just his home videos.
00:44:31 That somehow touched me today.
00:44:32 um you know we have out here the lapu lapu uh murderer there's no other way to say it his court
00:44:40 appearance has basically eclipsed most news stories and then of course we have to see the
00:44:45 footage over and over and over again which is horrifying um and then to see this and it just
00:44:51 the list goes on and i feel like maybe as i'm getting older i'm getting more emotional i i
00:44:58 understand what the meaning of life really is the gift of life is and um and but then to also know
00:45:04 how little his band his children are as well and Charlie Kirk is so young and he has a young wife
00:45:11 and little tiny children you know it's it's unbelievable to me and I think that just to me
00:45:18 is so heartbreaking to see a good father a good man go down as we saw and I believe uh it was Vaughn
00:45:23 a good father defending his family went down and uh it's violence no matter how you what
00:45:31 wrapping paper you use it's all about violence uh yeah i saw this earlier uh but you you got
00:45:38 something yeah just something to feed into it here i mean we're talking about the difference
00:45:42 in the way we perceive things the way things are reported the left the right msnbc which of course
00:45:47 a prominent... One of the pundits
00:45:49 on episode 2. One of the pundits
00:45:51 says, Charlie Kirk
00:45:53 Shooter might have just been a supporter
00:45:55 who was firing off his gun in celebration.
00:45:58 Why do we...
00:45:59 You know... He should be fired
00:46:01 for that.
00:46:03 Well, with modern
00:46:05 online swarming, chances are that pundit might...
00:46:07 Yeah.
00:46:10 Unbelievable.
00:46:11 I mean, I don't know if he was
00:46:13 on Alec Baldwin and he'll be set.
00:46:16 These events have
00:46:17 a tendency to bring, these events have the tendency to do us one courteous favor, is to
00:46:25 bring forward the people in the media, because we've seen this even as soon as October 7th
00:46:31 happened. We saw this with reporters from CBC, Global, CTV, CTV and CBC being the primary
00:46:37 problem. We saw the anti-Semitism. We saw what their political beliefs were. We saw
00:46:43 their inability to support the Jewish community and understand that this was a crisis of real
00:46:49 hate and terrorism, this situation will also bring those forward. And I think you're right,
00:46:57 Derek, there will be online swarming to have that person fired. And there'll be more,
00:47:03 other people will fall to the same demise as well. It's the one favor that a terrible event
00:47:09 like this gives us well um we're i guess we're we're pretty much out of time uh we had and we
00:47:18 spent all this time coming up with show notes to talk about all these different topics today i mean
00:47:21 that's done uh so uh i don't know i'll just i guess we include with real rice editorials
00:47:30 yeah um don't know what we think but i think uh you know it's not a term often used in our culture
00:47:38 and I think it's over-abused in
00:47:40 some other cultures or faiths
00:47:42 but I think Charlie Kirk
00:47:44 has been martyred
00:47:45 he is someone
00:47:46 assassinated
00:47:49 not just for doing but while he was doing
00:47:52 what he loved, debating
00:47:54 the cut and thrust
00:47:55 the combat of ideas
00:47:57 as Elise put it
00:48:00 literally
00:48:02 sitting under a sign that said
00:48:04 prove me wrong
00:48:05 and there is no greater evidence
00:48:08 that someone could not prove him wrong
00:48:11 all they could do was silence him
00:48:14 and when you do this kind of thing
00:48:17 I don't think
00:48:19 when people engage in this kind of thing
00:48:21 they often don't think about the martyr they create
00:48:24 you create many more who come after them 1.00
00:48:28 you have to kill us all 0.99
00:48:30 unless they're prepared to do it, they can't win 0.92
00:48:33 so uh anyway uh so cory nigel at least thank you for uh being a part of this cheery episode
00:48:44 um please invite me back for this ever another one i'm joking yeah i can i just say that i think
00:48:53 we all agree it's very unlikely charlie will survive this so i just want to say this charlie
00:48:58 Charlie was in a galaxy to his own in the world of pun entry, debate, litigating, as we were talking about the combat, the verbal combat that went back and forth.
00:49:09 He was a champion. He was respectful. And again, I didn't always agree with him.
00:49:14 But if you saw him in person, if you do what we do or come from the world of punitry like I have, you will, as we as we all have, you will see how extraordinary his skill set was.
00:49:29 He could call facts up and he was so polite and careful with those he was debating.
00:49:36 I saw him hug many people at the end of it.
00:49:38 Those who came in as adversaries left with a handshake or a hug.
00:49:43 and the media is never going to tell that story but it's all there on youtube to see so thank you
00:49:49 for letting me just say that because it has this has really shocked me today um so we're not going
00:49:55 to do regular parting shots today uh don't seem to be in poor taste um but i'm going to put nigel
00:50:03 on the spot and ask you uh maybe just to say a brief prayer very good and that's how we'll close
00:50:10 today happy to do it we often talk about thoughts and prayers heavenly father dear lord we do love
00:50:15 you and we we come to you in shock and horror at the at that the attack on this decent man
00:50:23 father even if he was not a decent man we would still be shocked and horrified by the attack and
00:50:30 so we we pray first for him you don't know he's dead yet we pray for his survival we pray also
00:50:36 for his uh his wife and his children who are going to be devastated but above all we pray that there
00:50:43 will be a revival of respect for life and for for liberty but for life and for your name in this
00:50:53 country because people who who are truly committed to following the ways of jesus don't do things
00:51:01 like this lord we just pray that that spirit would come across that land and this land in the name of
00:51:08 christ amen amen amen well guys i hope that we see each other under better circumstances next week
00:51:16 thank you for letting letting me join you again this week okay okay thank you well thank you
00:51:22 everyone. God bless
00:51:24 and amen.