Western Standard - August 24, 2023


CMS: Austerity is inevitable

Topics
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update Aug 23, 2023 Fawcett v. Fildebrandt: Should Alberta hold wind & solar hostage until Ottawa relents on oil & gas?

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

175.74

Word count

8,483

Sentence count

542

Harmful content

Misogyny

14

sentences flagged

Toxicity

29

sentences flagged

Hate speech

20

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of the Cory Morgan Show, I sit down with economist Dr. Danny Laroise to talk about supply management and the impact it has on the economy. We discuss the parallels between the current economic and political situation in Canada, and how supply management has impacted the economy in the past and what it means for the future.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good day and welcome to the cory morgan show i am cory morgan we put a lot of thought into the name
00:00:13 for this show it gets to the point though i tend to get to the point throughout the course of this
00:00:17 show this is our weekly western standard produce news and opinion show and we always have plenty
00:00:23 of news and i have plenty of opinion to share throughout it so to those of you joining us
00:00:28 live as we broadcast this please by all means use the comment thread there i love seeing them
00:00:34 i love seeing the interaction comment with each other send questions my way send questions towards
00:00:39 the guests i really appreciate it i don't necessarily read them all out but i do see
00:00:42 them all in it lets me know somebody's out there and i'm not just talking to myself like i do when
00:00:46 i'm driving around in my car just keep things civil with each other of course so we don't have
00:00:51 to be at each other's throats we got twitter for that or x as it is called these days i should try
00:00:56 to keep up with things so uh yeah as always i like to think they're always good shows i got another
00:01:01 good one coming up today i'm gonna have as a guest uh dr danny laroise is an associate professor of
00:01:07 economics with an agricultural specialty at uh university of lethbridge and we're gonna talk
00:01:13 about supply management i know it sounds dull to people but it does impact you every one of you
00:01:17 actually and it costs you at the table so we're gonna have a little more discussion on it and i'm
00:01:21 I'm sure I'll get all the crabby emails from dairy farmers after we have that discussion,
00:01:27 but that's fine. That's part of the discourse, part of the chat. It needs to be talked about.
00:01:32 So I'm going to start with what's got me going a bit today. I'm going to put on my
00:01:36 prognostication hat and my crystal ball here and try and guess what's coming up in the future.
00:01:41 And it's pretty easy because what's going on right now in politics has already happened before. I
00:01:46 mean, the parallels are almost chilling. We got a Trudeau as Canada's prime minister right now,
00:01:51 Western resource development's under attack.
00:01:53 Government spending is out of control.
00:01:55 Inflation harming citizens and interest rates are on the rise.
00:01:59 It sounds just like the 80s, late 70s.
00:02:02 The current economic path now, though, is unsustainable
00:02:04 and is going to come to a crashing halt eventually.
00:02:07 And, you know, there's lots of blame to throw around.
00:02:09 Conservative governments are usually a little better than liberal ones in times like this.
00:02:13 I mean, Mulroney continued with spending increases and deficit budgets
00:02:17 when Pierre Trudeau exited the scene.
00:02:18 In Alberta, the Progressive Conservatives, under Premiers Lougheed and Getty, they borrowed heavily while pouring tax funds into a series of failed corporate welfare schemes.
00:02:28 Now, the bubble finally burst in the 1990s for pretty much everybody.
00:02:32 Debt servicing costs were taking a massive bite from government budgets, while citizens just weren't ready to accept more tax increases.
00:02:39 So governments at all levels, with every political stripe, had to cut spending. There was no getting around it.
00:02:44 Federally, the Chrétien government balanced the budget.
00:02:47 Well, provincially, we had Ralph Klein and Mike Harris bringing spending under control in Alberta and Ontario.
00:02:53 And yeah, in Saskatchewan, even the NDP out there, they had to face economic reality.
00:02:58 Roy Romano cut spending by 10% in one budget.
00:03:01 He managed to balance the books in 1994.
00:03:04 It wasn't easy, though.
00:03:05 Unions, lobby groups, individuals, they screamed bloody murder through the 90s as the cuts were applied across the country.
00:03:11 But at that time, at least their protests were unheeded.
00:03:13 Canadians wanted to see balanced budgets, and they wanted to see governments cutting spending.
00:03:19 Eventually, though, the cycle turned.
00:03:21 With balanced budgets, times became good again.
00:03:24 Economies picked up, and the governments began to open the spending floodgates again.
00:03:28 Even in Alberta, under Klein, the spending began to rise quickly at the end of the 90s.
00:03:33 Ironically, it was when Klein started increasing expenditures when his provincial support started to flag.
00:03:38 You know, citizens are fine with low government spending,
00:03:40 but politicians just can't resist increasing the budgets.
00:03:44 It's an easier way to manage the government than being fiscally responsible.
00:03:48 Just toss more money at it.
00:03:49 That administrative sloth, though, does come with a price over time.
00:03:53 And in 1999, the federal government returned to deficit budgets,
00:03:56 and in Alberta, it took till 2008, but deficit financing has returned here as well,
00:04:01 and we haven't managed to produce a balanced budget since.
00:04:03 Low interest rates, they allow governments to get away with deficit financing for a time,
00:04:07 but as we're seeing today, the rates don't stay low forever. What goes down must come up. Just
00:04:13 servicing the federal debt alone is going to cost an estimated $34.7 billion in 2022-2023.
00:04:20 That's assuming interest rates stop rising, of course. And every province is flushing money
00:04:25 down the toilet on debt servicing, too. It's interest costs, guys. It's money on the credit
00:04:29 cards that we could really spend in better places. Now, the Trudeau government, this is what got me
00:04:33 going on this, recently called for departments to find $15 billion in savings. I thought,
00:04:37 wow, are they finally going to do like Kretchen and be responsible liberals and do some cuts?
00:04:42 But no, then they quickly pivoted to say, oh, we're not going to cut $15 billion in spending.
00:04:46 We just want to find those savings and we'll shift it to other departments.
00:04:49 In other words, they won't even talk about cutting the spending.
00:04:52 The hard reality governments and citizens need to face is that governments spend too much.
00:04:56 And yes, I'm including citizens in that statement because, hey, we're the ones who keep turning to the government for every service or problem.
00:05:04 People want every pet project funded, every foreign cause supported, and every industry subsidized, or they'll take their votes elsewhere. 0.59
00:05:10 I know it doesn't apply to everybody. It applies to enough of them.
00:05:13 Whether we like it or not, people tend to vote for whatever politician blows the most sunshine up their butt at election time,
00:05:19 and they tend to shy away from politicians offering a realistic fiscal platform.
00:05:24 People won't change their demands of governments until they start directly seeing the cost of spending, but we are starting to see it now.
00:05:30 Deficit spending is fostering inflation, while taxes increase to try and keep up with the spending.
00:05:34 The rising cost of living is hurting everybody, along with the taxes.
00:05:38 Taxes alone right now eat up 45.3% of the average family's income.
00:05:43 While food, clothing, and shelter only make up 35.6%.
00:05:46 Citizens are loath to admit it, but they can't hide from it forever.
00:05:49 When enough people realize the government is the largest expense in their life,
00:05:53 and they just can't afford it anymore, they're finally going to start demanding cuts.
00:05:56 The question with spending cuts and austerity isn't a matter of if they're going to happen,
00:06:01 it's a matter of when. I mean, the laws of economics are as immutable as those of gravity,
00:06:05 and the spending will have to be brought back into check eventually. We just can't keep living
00:06:09 on the credit cards. The longer we wait to cut spending, though, the harder it's going to be
00:06:13 when those cuts come. An increasing segment of the population has become dependent upon government
00:06:18 jobs and programs, and that segment's going to suffer when the government's spending starts
00:06:22 contracting. It's going to be ugly as they try to adapt. But the sooner the better. We're on a slow
00:06:27 motion collision course with an inevitable fiscal reality check. The sooner we can ring the alarm
00:06:33 bells, the better. And right now is the time. We've got to start reining and spending and reducing
00:06:38 future pain. Right now it feels like the warnings are falling on deaf ears, but hopefully citizens
00:06:42 start to get the wax out and start listening soon. Because when the citizens move, the politicians
00:06:46 will follow. Eventually they always do. All right, that's what's got me going today. Just some
00:06:52 dry economic topics, but it's important stuff. Let's get on to the other news because a bunch
00:06:56 of stuff's been breaking and check in with our news editor, Dave Naylor, and see what else is
00:07:01 going on out there. Hey, Dave, how's it going? Good day, Corey. I'm well, yourself?
00:07:05 Pretty good. Nice day. Oh, it was a beautiful day. I was driving in this morning going down
00:07:10 Deerfoot and this, you know, in the back mirror, all I see is this rental car zooming by me like
00:07:16 about 140. I took a quick look. I thought it might be Christian Freeland, but I don't think
00:07:21 it was. I think she's back in Ottawa. Well, she'll make sure that she's chauffeured again from there
00:07:27 on forward. Maybe this is why she doesn't have a car, Corey. She lost it through speeding
00:07:32 suspensions and all that sort of good stuff. Well, I wish she would be as ambitious about
00:07:38 managing our budget as she is about making it fast on the highways. Indeed. As you say, Corey,
00:07:44 really busy last hour. I'll lead off with some international news.
00:07:50 Evgeny Prigozhin, the leader of the Russian mercenary group Wagner, has been killed after
00:07:57 his plane was shot out of the skies in Russia. You remember, Corey, he rebelled against Putin and
00:08:03 all his troops were marching towards Moscow when he suddenly decided to stop and go into exile in
00:08:11 Belarus. And we all knew his days were numbered, but I certainly didn't have him being killed by
00:08:16 a Russian missile. I had him falling out a window in the office, the office bingo. So that's a big 1.00
00:08:23 breaking international story. Closer to home, the Liberals, as you know, were having their
00:08:28 cabinet retreat in lovely Prince Edward Island. Trudeau today issued some more word salad on the
00:08:36 the housing crisis, Pierre Polyev, leader of the opposition, came out afterwards and was very strong
00:08:43 and gave some actual possible solutions to the housing crisis. So we've got that up there now.
00:08:50 The CRA, which is normally used to suing people, is in fact being sued themselves in a class action
00:08:56 lawsuit by people who had their identities stolen during a massive breach of CRA computers a year
00:09:05 or so ago. So that is up there now. OPEC, we always knew there were a bunch of slimy people,
00:09:14 but the former head of OPEC has been arrested in England and charged with bribery. So that shows
00:09:21 you the type of people that they are. And the International Weightlifting Federation has decided
00:09:29 that they need to change their rules. This is after a Canadian male weightlifter recently won
00:09:34 a championship by entering the female side of the competition, and he won by lifting
00:09:41 more than 450 pounds more than his nearest competitor.
00:09:43 So the federation said, well, that's enough of that.
00:09:47 We're going to change that and change our policy.
00:09:50 So it's going to be women versus women and men versus men. 0.94
00:09:54 We've got a story up there on Jordan Peterson, everybody's favorite psychologist.
00:09:59 Court in Ontario ruled today that the regulator can send him for sensitivity training
00:10:06 over some tweets that he sent out a while ago.
00:10:10 And our energy expert, Sean Polzer, has got a story that Canadian oil output
00:10:16 will be the highest in five years.
00:10:18 So drill, baby, drill, oil as well. 0.58
00:10:21 And a couple of stories that we're working on will be up shortly.
00:10:24 a voice from the past you remember calgary uh catholic bishop fred henry uh cory uh he's
00:10:32 retired now but he came out he wrote a letter saying he's demanding the feds uh find out if
00:10:38 even one residential school child uh is missing and uh and murdered perhaps uh all those years
00:10:46 ago and uh some people around colonna are going to be happy because they've been given the all
00:10:50 clear to go back home after the latest wildfire. And I'm sure they're all anxious to get back home
00:10:55 and see what damage was caused, Corey. I'm certain they are. I can't imagine. I've never had to be
00:11:00 evacuated before, but it's got to be stressful and terrible. I'm glad, you know, with all these
00:11:04 fires and these evacuations and everything that's happened, still a surprising amount. I mean,
00:11:08 it seems like we're erring on the side of caution because, you know, the fires haven't swept through
00:11:12 any really densely populated communities yet anyway. So I'd rather they erred that way myself.
00:11:18 well after what happened on maui a couple weeks ago it's obviously better safe than sorry
00:11:24 that's right all right dave well thanks for the check-in i'll let you get back at it and
00:11:29 i'll talk to you after the show thanks gory that is our news editor dave naylor and this is when
00:11:34 i like to remind you look at all those stories dave is busy he's got stuff constantly coming
00:11:38 up there it's coming up as it breaks lots of opinion and all sorts of content on there guys
00:11:43 the reason we stay independent is where i nag you this way shake the cup and ask for the money 0.95
00:11:47 is because of subscribers. $9.99 a month, $100 for a year. It's just, again, we never thought
00:11:53 twice about subscribing for a newspaper in the past. Well, that helps us keep going. We don't
00:11:57 take government funding, and the government has, you know, we can't even share our content on Meta
00:12:02 and some of those other sites now. The battle is going on, and you guys have been great. To those
00:12:06 who have already subscribed, thank you very much. We really appreciate it. And if you haven't already,
00:12:11 come on, guys, get on there and share us. That's part of the other thing, too. This ridiculous C-18, 0.62
00:12:16 this stopping of links for news sites. The problem is it's harder to reach out and get to new people.
00:12:21 It's harder for them to find us in the first place. After that, they can come directly to
00:12:25 the site, which is westernstandard.news. But share on Facebook. You can share it. You can share it on
00:12:32 X, formerly Twitter, and all those sites. And this is how we can beat the government regulation
00:12:36 and allow independent media to keep going and keep those stories rolling out there. And there's a lot
00:12:41 going on. So yeah, that's interesting in Russia. It was almost an office pool. I mean, this was a
00:12:47 guy who stood up to Putin with that Wagner group, the mercenary. And the only question was when he 0.72
00:12:55 was going to die and how. It sounds like they didn't even bother trying to sugarcoat this.
00:13:00 They just shot him out of the sky. Usually they try for an accidental death of poisoning or maybe
00:13:04 choking at a fancy Russian restaurant, but no, this time they just blew him down. There's not a
00:13:09 good retirement plan, working for Russian oligarchies and other such places like that.
00:13:17 Let's see. So yeah, you know, the talk, the talk, the starting monologue, the things that are going
00:13:23 on, it's cost of living. You know, we're all hurting right now. As we said, Polyev is coming
00:13:28 out. He's talking about the housing. I mean, people are having a heck of a time finding a home. I can't
00:13:32 imagine how, what it takes for a young person to get that down payment together, you know, get your
00:13:37 credit up to speed. The whole works. I mean, getting in on a house right now, way out of
00:13:41 control or renting, of course, the rents are going through the roof. Everything is going up. And again,
00:13:46 there's a lot to be discussed. It's a lot of it comes down to oversized government. That's what
00:13:50 I started the monologue with. A lot of it comes to bad policy, over-regulation. I mean, that's
00:13:56 a lot of it, whether it's home construction, like Polyev has been talking about, or whether
00:14:02 it's in food production. And I'm, you know, sort of segueing into my guest here, because this is an
00:14:06 area. I've talked about it on the show before, but we don't talk about it enough. And we've got
00:14:10 a supply managed system in Canada. And I'll kind of lead and save him some of the explanation.
00:14:16 You know that the bottom line is dairy, poultry, eggs, they are all tightly, tightly controlled.
00:14:23 You can't produce over a certain amount or even start producing in some cases, unless you have
00:14:27 a government issued quota. Those quotas have become a commodity in themselves. But what they
00:14:31 do is artificially, I mean, some would say keep the price stable, but they also keep the price
00:14:36 high. We pay some of the highest prices when compared to comparable countries for those sorts
00:14:40 of food items than anywhere else. And those are going up. This isn't protecting us when times get
00:14:45 tough. And it's one area I think, we'll see, we'll talk to my guest about that, where maybe some
00:14:51 quick changes can help make some things affordable for Canadians from the government right away. So
00:14:55 let's bring them in. As I said earlier at the start of the show, it's Danny Leroy, he's an
00:15:01 associate professor of economics. Boy, that's a tongue twister at University of Lethbridge
00:15:05 and specializing in agricultural economics. So thank you very much, doctor, for joining us today.
00:15:13 Oh, you're welcome, Corey. I'm very glad to be here.
00:15:16 So you kind of heard me starting out in there. Maybe if you could expand a little. I mean,
00:15:20 what is Canada's supply management policy and maybe a little bit of why? Why was it brought
00:15:26 in i like to think the intention was good very good intentions uh supply management was uh
00:15:33 first introduced in canada uh in the uh in the dairy industry in the late 1960s the early 1970s
00:15:43 and the aim of the uh of the program was to enhance and stabilize the returns to raw milk
00:15:50 producers. At the time, there was a lot of price variability in raw milk, and people who
00:15:59 produce milk tended to be in parts of the country where alternatives weren't very good in terms of
00:16:06 production of other commodities. So it was a way of providing assistance to individuals engaged
00:16:14 in agricultural activities in challenging areas.
00:16:21 The idea behind how it works is that prices for producers are determined based on cost
00:16:31 of production formulas so that producers have, most of them, have an opportunity to
00:16:37 earn a living and a return on their enterprise.
00:16:42 I said this was first introduced in dairy in the late 1960s early 70s. Eggs became supply managed
00:16:50 in Canada in 1972, turkeys in 1974, chickens in 1978 and broiler hatching eggs in 1986. So there's
00:17:01 five commodities in this country that are strictly controlled in terms of their production and the
00:17:07 the prices that producers receive. Okay. So, I mean, at this point though,
00:17:13 do we need these policies? I mean, I have seen some papers put out and studies
00:17:18 showing that we're paying quite a premium for those products in Canada when perhaps,
00:17:23 you know, if those policies were lifted, we could see some reductions in some of our food costs.
00:17:28 Well, it's an interesting way you phrase that. You use the royal we, do we need this?
00:17:33 Well, there are some producers that do. Right. Over the course of the last 50 or more years, many intergenerational farms in the supply managed area, they've become quite dependent on the continuation of this program.
00:17:52 right uh it enables supply management enables them to sell uh a product into uh into a protected
00:18:00 market privileged market at a price that they know that they're going to receive if they meet
00:18:06 the specifications in terms of quality and quantity right there's so there's um they don't
00:18:11 have to worry about some of the risks that other producers face in terms of marketing their
00:18:18 commodity right they don't face the same price risk for example that raw milk producers or egg
00:18:25 producers or poultry producers they don't face the same price risks as a as a producer of cattle
00:18:30 or or grains or oil seeds do in in Canada now there would be some advantages right if these
00:18:39 policies were were removed or were changed one of the things that is a pretty clear
00:18:51 fact about economic science is that whenever there is free trade between individuals each
00:18:57 counterparty to the transaction wins right so if it were possible to remove the impediments
00:19:03 between willing buyers and willing sellers there could be more wealth created in markets for raw
00:19:08 milk, eggs, turkey, chicken, and so on. So, I mean, if we moved away from it, I mean,
00:19:15 it was a bit of a trend. A lot of nations brought in supply management policies during that time as
00:19:19 well. New Zealand, Australia are examples we hear about a lot. I mean, you can't just flick a light
00:19:24 switch and say, okay, we've stopped the policies. It would disrupt the producers terribly. I mean,
00:19:29 quotas became a commodity, even an artificial one. So they would need to be bought out or
00:19:34 eased out of the system that's also that's also a political question right uh so the choice of
00:19:40 subsidizing somebody to to help them exit the industry is is also a form of a subsidy but this
00:19:46 was used and you're correct it was used in places like australia where the supply managed system
00:19:53 that once existed was phased out over a period of time and consumers helped to finance that
00:20:00 So in view of helping farmers transition to a more open market, there is a surcharge levied
00:20:09 on consumers at retail level that helped finance the transition for primary producers of raw milk
00:20:17 in Australia. So this enabled them to move with, I guess, less financial pain for the producers
00:20:26 than would otherwise be the case.
00:20:30 But it's a great example of Mansur Olson's, you know, the logic of collective action.
00:20:36 In these circumstances, there's a small number of beneficiaries who have a very concentrated self-interest
00:20:42 in maintaining the status quo, where the costs are dispersed, on the other hand, over a large number of people.
00:20:49 So you were mentioning in the introduction, you know, we pay higher prices.
00:20:52 Canadians, depending on where you're located, pay higher prices for for supply managed products in the grocery store, like butter, for example.
00:21:02 That's one that's been in the headlines a lot and fluid milk and so on.
00:21:06 Yeah, we we do. We do pay some higher prices for that. 0.90
00:21:11 But most people are more concerned about their mortgage payments.
00:21:16 So, yeah, maybe I'm paying 50 cents, 75 cents more for a gallon of milk at the grocery store.
00:21:23 I'm not going to get too much in a twist about that.
00:21:26 Whereas a dairy producer, a raw milk producer would if supply management was terminated, right?
00:21:32 There's a big impact on their enterprise compared to a few dollars a week for a family of four consuming groceries.
00:21:43 Yeah, well, it's always though that case gets made.
00:21:45 it's just a cup of coffee a day it's just a little bit here a little bit there but that's
00:21:49 suddenly we find that we're but but that adds up it adds up right um and it also adds up for the
00:21:57 for producers themselves right so when you're insulated from from international competition
00:22:03 uh you don't fit you don't have the same incentives in terms of changing your business and
00:22:08 in terms of processors in Canada, producing the products that consumers want, right?
00:22:16 If you're selling into a protected market, you don't face the same incentives as others
00:22:21 who compete not with just their next door neighbors and other processors or producers
00:22:29 domestically, but it's international competition.
00:22:33 So one takeaway is that while people often say, well, supply management has been put in place to help support and protect the farmer in Canada against foreign competition.
00:22:48 In fact, these barriers to trade protect farmers in Canada from their fellow Canadians and the decisions that they would make in terms of the goods that they would produce if they were left free to do so.
00:23:01 if there weren't impediments to international trade.
00:23:04 Well, right back to the beginning statements you said,
00:23:07 you know, in a true free market,
00:23:08 both the buyer and the seller are going to benefit
00:23:10 if they're just allowed to deal directly with each other.
00:23:13 I think of back an example with the wheat board.
00:23:16 There was a group in Saskatchewan
00:23:17 when we still had the wheat board going
00:23:19 and they wanted to start actually a pasta company
00:23:22 in their small little town.
00:23:23 They were going to use their own wheat.
00:23:24 They were going to manufacture the pasta.
00:23:25 If we bypass all these middlemen,
00:23:27 we can come up with a really good product
00:23:28 and employ some local people.
00:23:30 and, you know, diversify what we do.
00:23:33 But it turns out they would have had to sell their wheat
00:23:35 to the wheat board, buy it back from the wheat board
00:23:38 at an inflated price, and they would have lost all advantage.
00:23:41 So they threw the plan out the window.
00:23:43 But, I mean, talking about with, I guess,
00:23:45 supply-managed industries, it stifles creativity.
00:23:48 I mean, there's a lot of producers probably have some good ideas
00:23:50 or areas where they can broaden what they do,
00:23:53 but they're pretty constrained with where they're sitting.
00:23:55 They are.
00:23:56 In fact, the only – and raw milk is the most stringent of all of them, all of these supply managed commodities.
00:24:04 The only legal buyer of raw milk in every province is the Provincial Milk Marketing Board.
00:24:10 It's – while a farmer can consume raw milk that he or she has produced on their own enterprise,
00:24:18 they're precluded legally from selling that raw milk to anybody else other than the Provincial Milk Marketing Board.
00:24:25 and that's not true for the other supply managed commodities which is why when you go to a farmer's
00:24:34 market or you might see some some very small producers that have small flocks of chicken
00:24:40 they can sell directly to consumers or eggs right you can have a roadside stand sell sell farm fresh
00:24:47 eggs as long as you're not of commercial scale and every province specifies what that threshold is
00:24:55 in some provinces it's it's it's actually quite a big number in other places it's small but
00:25:00 raw milk is the only one where that opportunity for a primary producer doesn't exist to sell
00:25:08 something that they have produced themselves that they cannot legally sell that to anybody
00:25:13 else except the government agency. Well, and that's led to cases of dumping. I've talked on
00:25:18 this show about before my wife grew up on a small dairy farm, but her father only had a quota for
00:25:22 cream. And so he would skim the cream. He would sell that the household would drink as much milk
00:25:28 as they could feed some to the pigs, but the rest would get dumped because it was illegal to sell
00:25:32 the milk. And that was, it's illegal to sell the milk, but we want to be careful, right? So with
00:25:39 With respect to that high-profile case that fell in Ontario who video recorded himself
00:25:44 of dumping milk, there probably isn't a single producer in Canada that hasn't done that
00:25:50 at one time or another.
00:25:52 There's a quality issue where the milk has to be dumped, or it's the less expensive alternative.
00:25:58 If producers supply more than their quota allotment, they're penalized, and sometimes
00:26:06 that penalty is quite expensive.
00:26:08 So the best course of action is to to dump a little bit.
00:26:12 Now, in this particular case, the timing, I suppose, was very bad because, you know, just coming through the pandemic and prices for commodities or prices for groceries were quite high.
00:26:29 And this poor fellow has to dump his milk because he's produced too much of it.
00:26:34 So it was the optics weren't very good, but he was making a point.
00:26:38 You certainly, and I mean, you know, social media gives a new way to make a point rather than
00:26:43 just say, or transferring the oral stories like I did with my wife, for example.
00:26:47 So, I mean, getting a little into the political side, though, and that, you know, that's the dairy
00:26:51 cartels, if you want to call them such, are very, very effective political lobbyists. They influence
00:26:57 parties of all stripes. They protect that supply management system very jealously. Do you think
00:27:05 there's ever going to be a political will to start easing out of it. I interviewed all of the
00:27:10 conservative leadership candidates back when they were running for the leadership, and only one of
00:27:14 them said he would challenge the supply management system, not another. The others were all terrified
00:27:17 as soon as it came up. They'd rather not touch it. No, one of the things that we do know in this
00:27:22 country is that, to their credit, they have one of the most effective lobbying organizations around,
00:27:29 right uh and that this is manifest itself in in some of the subsidies that the producers are now
00:27:36 receiving because of uh trade agreements the federal government has signed with the european
00:27:43 union with the trans-pacific partnership and more recently the canadian u.s uh free trade agreement
00:27:51 NAFTA 2.0 right producers of supply managed commodities are are receiving subsidies for lost
00:27:59 market share uh as a consequence of of signing these agreements when in fact there's very little
00:28:06 evidence to suggest that uh that there has been market share that that they've lost
00:28:12 new zealand and the us are currently uh they've got a case that uh the amount of access that's
00:28:19 that's that has been set aside isn't being filled right so raw milk production this past may was set
00:28:29 record level so that you know we're producing as much as as we have ever have in this country of
00:28:37 supply managed commodities uh there's never been fewer primary producers of supply managed
00:28:42 commodities there's fewer than ten thousand raw milk producers now in this country there's fewer
00:28:48 than 500 dairy farms in the province of Alberta. And there's about a couple of thousand primary
00:28:56 producers of the other supply managed commodities. So in terms of the politics, getting back to your
00:29:01 point, there's maybe 12,000, 13,000 producers of supply managed commodities that wield enormous
00:29:10 political influence. Well, and that's another aspect. I mean, some people, defenders of the
00:29:15 supply management policy said it helps protect the family farm now i wouldn't necessarily blame
00:29:19 supply management but at least evolution and economies of scale i mean it used to be over
00:29:23 a hundred thousand producers i believe a couple decades ago and now it's contracted down to
00:29:28 as you said about 12 000 so they are becoming just of necessity larger corporate enterprises
00:29:34 the romanticized family farms is long gone yeah i agree with you well we'll see if we can start
00:29:41 solving you like i said a lot of people when you you talk about supply management though the eyes
00:29:44 glaze and then they tire and as there's not a lot of will on the ground necessarily from the public
00:29:49 but it is something that's costing it is and i i think it's important to remember all the people
00:29:55 involved right uh there there are beneficiaries of the continuation of this policy and there are
00:30:02 people that do stand to lose at least in the short term uh so um one of the things that's really
00:30:09 important in economics is that there isn't this royal we there's you and i and each of us make
00:30:15 our own decisions with respect to what we produce what we consume and whom we we interact with
00:30:20 i'll have to avoid triggering you with that uh we term
00:30:25 appreciate the correction and it's a good very valid point so uh before i let you go where can
00:30:31 people find your stuff i know you've done some work with the fraser institute and you're at the
00:30:35 university of lethbridge uh do you write for other publications or anything like that i do on
00:30:40 occasion if you do uh if you want to find me online go to the university of lethbridge department of
00:30:46 economics um i coordinate the agricultural studies program here and uh as you mentioned at the outset
00:30:54 one of the my areas of interest is uh agricultural production marketing and trade and that's
00:31:00 That's certainly, it's very important in Canada with supply managed commodities.
00:31:06 And of course, in southern Alberta, where we are, it's particularly important for beef and for grains and oilseeds and crops grown under irrigation.
00:31:16 Lots of issues in agriculture and agri-food and lots of opportunity.
00:31:20 Absolutely.
00:31:21 Now, there's much more than we could cover in 15 minutes.
00:31:23 That's for sure.
00:31:23 I hope we can have you on again to talk about these kind of things down the road then.
00:31:27 That would be my pleasure.
00:31:29 I look forward to it, Corey.
00:31:30 Enjoy the rest of your day.
00:31:31 Excellent.
00:31:32 Thanks for taking some time with us, Danny.
00:31:34 You're welcome.
00:31:36 All right.
00:31:36 So that was Dr. Danny Leroy, yes, from the University of Lethbridge.
00:31:39 So you've gotten my torqued and wound up rants about supply management and things like that,
00:31:44 but I'm bringing in a reasoned and educated individual to talk about those policies.
00:31:48 And they do impact everybody, whether we want to talk about them or not.
00:31:53 And it's not necessarily that dry.
00:31:54 It's interesting to see, as we said, it started with good intentions, but again, so many bad
00:31:59 policies always do start with, I think, noble intentions. And it was good to have some balance
00:32:05 pointing out there's going to be beneficiaries. And I guess you could say, you know, people who
00:32:10 certainly don't benefit if it changes. It's good to see a free market person speaking from a
00:32:17 university, though, and coming out of those spots and, you know, breaking a bit of that mold of what
00:32:20 we're seeing from academia these days. I guess when you're in economics and agriculture, I mean,
00:32:25 You've got to be a common-sense, grounded sort of person to maintain what you're doing.
00:32:30 Now, something that came down today, Dave mentioned that with the news check-in earlier,
00:32:34 you know, and it kind of ties into that.
00:32:35 Dr. Jordan Peterson, the Ontario court has upheld, I guess, you know, the,
00:32:43 I don't know if you'd call it a ruling, but you see, what has happened is the cancel mob 1.00
00:32:47 has been trying to get Peterson for years.
00:32:49 You know, they hate him.
00:32:50 They hate him.
00:32:50 I mean, they're frothing, raging people.
00:32:53 They want to cancel him.
00:32:55 He dared.
00:32:56 This was just back when he was a professor.
00:32:58 All he did, University of Toronto, though, as a psychologist, a professor was dared.
00:33:02 When he was mandated, people were saying, you've got to start referring to individuals as Z and Zer.
00:33:07 And this was back in 2016.
00:33:08 I guess they're ahead of their time.
00:33:09 I think it was 2016. 0.98
00:33:10 And he said, no, no, it's ridiculous. 1.00
00:33:13 It's stupid. 1.00
00:33:14 I won't do it. 1.00
00:33:15 And they went bananas.
00:33:16 They went bananas.
00:33:17 They were crazy on them.
00:33:18 How dare you?
00:33:18 How dare you?
00:33:19 and they screamed and they threatened and other professors sanctioned him and wrote up things and
00:33:24 demanded and he's still the thing that drives them so mad with Peterson is that he won't apologize
00:33:30 he won't back down too many do too many people just cave and cower and he won't and the other
00:33:39 part is ironically and I know uh you know Dr. Peterson was already a successful professor
00:33:44 But boy, it took him and turned him into an international celebrity
00:33:47 because people found it refreshing.
00:33:49 They found an academic speaking out about political correctness
00:33:53 and speaking out against identity politics 0.99
00:33:55 and speaking out about how stupid it is to call somebody Z or Xer, 0.99
00:33:59 much less to mandate somebody to call them Z or Xer. 1.00
00:34:04 It's stupid. It's stupid. 1.00
00:34:06 Hey, if you want to be called Z, Xer, 1.00
00:34:08 if you ask me politely, I'll say so.
00:34:09 I'll call you that. Fine. I don't care.
00:34:11 call you an artichoke if that's your preference, but don't tell me what I have to refer to you.
00:34:17 That's the big difference. Either way, Dr. Peterson did great. His books were selling
00:34:22 like crazy. He was speaking to sold out functions all over North America, around the world. But you
00:34:28 see, the mob couldn't relent. They couldn't let off him. So how can we punish this man? How can
00:34:33 we get this man who dared to break orthodoxy? Then they realized we can go after a professional
00:34:39 association. You see, he is a psychologist. He had patients. He did do still see patients. He's a,
00:34:47 you know, a licensed registered psychologist. So they went after the association. They pressured,
00:34:52 they demanded, they threatened, they scared. And of course, you'll get these professional
00:34:56 associations. They get scared fast and they get scared easily. So they ruled. They said, you,
00:35:04 Dr. Peterson must take this course on social media behavior and sensitivity and garbage like that. 0.99
00:35:12 That stinks. 0.99
00:35:14 It rings of re-education camps.
00:35:15 It's thought crime.
00:35:17 You don't have to like what Dr. Peterson said.
00:35:19 But, I mean, the association, the only time they should be sanctioning is if he was truly doing something unprofessional.
00:35:25 If he was being a pervert online.
00:35:27 If he was breaking laws.
00:35:29 If he was abusing people.
00:35:31 But what he was doing was speaking out with a view they didn't agree with.
00:35:35 That's all.
00:35:37 You got to remember, these associations are populated and managed by the nutless.
00:35:41 I tell you, I know this from working in the oil field.
00:35:45 Because, you know, when you get these professional associations, even in the energy sector, private market,
00:35:49 and they get these industry associations and they got to hold a conference once a month or do this and do that,
00:35:57 you don't send your best and brightest to sit on the boards of these associations. 0.99
00:36:00 You send the brother-in-law you were forced to hire because, you know, get him out of my hair, he's a moron, and he'll put him to work doing something else. 1.00
00:36:07 Unfortunately, when the oil companies are sending their dead weight all to these associations, then these associations, of course, tend to be dominated and populated by morons and cowards and things such as that. 1.00
00:36:19 Get the woke guy out of your boardroom and stick him out, you know, spending some time with your professional association. 0.99
00:36:24 That's great until that association turns on you.
00:36:27 And that's what happened with Peterson.
00:36:29 You don't have to like what he said.
00:36:30 He dared to point out with an overweight woman and say it doesn't look attractive. 1.00
00:36:36 Hey, some guys love the chunkier gals. Good for them, too. 1.00
00:36:40 But that's his opinion. He's allowed to have it.
00:36:43 And yes, he's questioned some of the trans-orthodoxy.
00:36:47 Either way, that led down to now the courts.
00:36:50 The Ontario court ruled today and said, no, they are allowed to basically say,
00:36:55 either we're going to pull your license, you will no longer be a practicing psychologist,
00:36:59 or you go to this re-education course, re-education, we will drill it into you. We will make you look
00:37:06 at your shoes in shame. We will tell you what you're supposed to think and most certainly what
00:37:10 you're supposed to say. And it sounds already like Peterson said, get stuff not happening.
00:37:16 He's going to be pushing back, but they will take away that part. He'll be fine. His books are
00:37:22 selling fine. His lectures, it's a point of principle at this point, but it's a big point
00:37:25 of principle. And not everybody can afford to stand up to the cancel mob when they turn their
00:37:30 head towards you as Dr. Peterson could. Some people can and do get bankrupted once that mob
00:37:37 gets swirling around them, those unrelenting hornets of self-righteous. I got to watch for
00:37:44 the swearing. You know, being on the Cowboy Network and everything, we are still under the
00:37:49 CRTC, so I got to behave myself. But the court held it up, said, yes, you can take away this
00:37:55 man's career because he was politically incorrect online. It's a scary precedent. And you know,
00:38:01 those frothing, self-important jerks who feel they should control the speech and thought of others 0.99
00:38:06 are just tickled pink right now. They're going to go after others. They're going to find others, 1.00
00:38:12 and they're going to ruin people. They're bullies of the worst sort. And as I said, 0.99
00:38:18 they have no remorse. They don't care who they crush. So this was a big, big deal with that
00:38:25 court ruling today. Basically, it wasn't even court ruling. They didn't even hear it. I think
00:38:28 they threw it out as he was challenging against it. So yeah, we got a big problem. And look at
00:38:33 some of the stuff that we won't be allowed to, well, I don't say we, Danny corrected me on that.
00:38:38 None of that we stuff, but people won't be able to speak out without a punishment on a lot of
00:38:44 issues when common sense should prevail. And that case Dave
00:38:48 mentioned with the power lifter. So this was in Canada. I'm
00:38:52 not going to beat around the bush. It was a man. It was a
00:38:55 insecure, pathetic man, who suddenly said, I'm going to 0.99
00:38:59 identify as a woman and enter a sport that is clearly purely, 0.99
00:39:05 you know, gender wise, there's a huge advantage to being male.
00:39:10 When you go into that powerlifting, there's no beating
00:39:12 around the bush. It's not a matter of opinion. God, the loony left likes to tell us to follow
00:39:17 the science. Well, let's talk about science. Men tend to be stronger than women. That's why we 0.99
00:39:24 broke up athletic events on gender. So this man came in and he didn't just beat the women who'd
00:39:31 spent all that time, did all that work, all that dedication, training for this event. He didn't
00:39:37 just beat her a little. So he lifted, and I guess it's something where you squat and deadlift. I
00:39:42 I don't know. I don't do all that stuff. You could tell by my build. Uh, I'm sure most of the women 1.00
00:39:45 in that event, the real women would still outlift and beat the snot out of me. That's fine. But when 1.00
00:39:50 you're getting to the high levels of these things, you know, men who do that similar training will
00:39:55 outperform the women. He outperformed it. So by 200 pounds over the next closest woman, 200 pounds, 0.96
00:40:02 like it just completely removed the element of competition whatsoever. So that's just absurd.
00:40:09 Yeah, 597 pounds versus the next person's 387.
00:40:13 What an insult.
00:40:15 What an insult.
00:40:16 And that we even have to discuss it.
00:40:18 That we even have to say, this is absurd.
00:40:21 This is unfair.
00:40:22 This is an actual assault against women. 0.97
00:40:25 This is getting towards the end game of the woke. 1.00
00:40:29 This is how dumb they are. 1.00
00:40:30 This really is. 1.00
00:40:31 I mean, the woke began with women back in the 60s and 70s 0.95
00:40:35 when they weren't getting rights that they should have,
00:40:38 when they were being underpaid for the same job that men were doing and things like that,
00:40:42 there were rights that were being abused. Women were being left to hang if a husband took off on 0.98
00:40:48 them, things like that. But now it's come all the way around, all the way around, and the woman 0.98
00:40:54 loses her rights as long as a man says, you know what, I think today I'm going to identify as a 0.64
00:40:58 woman. We're not even talking about somebody who's dedicated a life to being trans. We're not talking
00:41:03 about somebody who's had, of course, some of the surgical or drug transitioning or any of those
00:41:09 things changed their lifestyle. They just have to say, sometimes you feel like a nut, sometimes you
00:41:14 don't. That's nuts. Yeah, I'm going to lay off the nut thing for a bit here. But you know,
00:41:20 self-identifying? No. No. It's crazy. And at least some of these sporting associations are saying
00:41:28 that's enough. But there's going to be pushback. I'm forgetting some of the names, but you know,
00:41:32 the case in the States with that man who's down there swimming and blowing all the women out of 0.90
00:41:37 the water as far as the races go. You know, defeating them all over the place down there.
00:41:44 And one of the competing women dared to speak out. She said, this is nuts. I can't compete with this
00:41:49 guy. And plus he's standing around in the change room. I turn around and there's male parts behind
00:41:56 my head, because this is a fully intact man. I'm not going to call him a her. Somebody who identifies
00:42:03 as a her, who's truly trans, wants to live that way? Absolutely. But this clown? No, this is an 1.00
00:42:08 insecure, pathetic wretch who couldn't make it in his own gender competitions. He has a girlfriend, 1.00
00:42:14 by the way. So he thought, I'll just go beat the women. It is almost a form of beating women, isn't 0.83
00:42:21 it? We saw that case that I guess it did turn out there was some truth. There's a guy joining a
00:42:25 women's rugby team. And we're supposed to deny reality. We're supposed to say there isn't an 1.00
00:42:31 inherent advantage. Of course there is. The best of all was that purple haired soccer beast from
00:42:38 the United States. Again, I'm terrible with names. I can't remember her name, but she was the woke of
00:42:42 the woke and heading the American team and the works. Yeah. And saying, you know, on these
00:42:49 trans issues and all the rest of it. But her team, her top women's team in all of the United States,
00:42:54 I believe they were at the top in the world at one point, got beaten by a high school team of boys.
00:43:01 They did. Check it out. Look it up.
00:43:04 These were highly trained women, fantastic players, but they can't step over that physiological reality 1.00
00:43:11 that male bodies, physiques in those kinds of sports have an advantage.
00:43:17 And it's ruining it. And it's going to ruin it all around.
00:43:21 I mean, somebody else was talking about going into the WNBA, you know, the basketball.
00:43:25 Again, look at the tallest man ever and the tallest woman. 0.99
00:43:28 There's going to be height advantages.
00:43:30 It's got to come to a stop.
00:43:30 Now, getting back on a side rant about this whole thing, this is what the cancel crowd comes after.
00:43:36 We won't be allowed to have this conversation.
00:43:39 Somebody saying that man shouldn't be competing against women in a sport might suddenly get the cancel mob.
00:43:45 They might get phone calls to their professional association saying,
00:43:48 sanction this person, put this person out of work, bankrupt this person, this person doesn't
00:43:53 deserve to earn a living, because they hurt my feelings by stating physiological realities.
00:44:00 And the courts by the precedent that Ontario says, set, say, yeah, that's perfectly fine.
00:44:05 Go on welfare, I guess, or, or find a new or of course, or of course, go for reeducation. 0.95
00:44:12 Go in, hang your head in shame, do like the Chinese did with the shaming, hang the card 1.00
00:44:16 off your chest. You had wrong think. You were bad, naughty. Change your thoughts. You're not 1.00
00:44:24 allowed to independently think. You have to think with the wall. Guys, this is important.
00:44:27 This is really, really important. You don't have to like Peterson. Not everybody does.
00:44:32 You don't have to agree with him. Lots of people don't. But protect that right for not just
00:44:39 academics, but it's pretty important with the academics, but for everybody to speak out on
00:44:44 these things. You don't understand. This mob will turn on you. They'll turn on you. They will eat
00:44:49 their own. They will eat the woke. It doesn't matter if you try to pander to them. It doesn't
00:44:53 matter if you try to, you know, stay woke. You slip even once. They will eat you alive. They're
00:44:59 parasites. They're hyenas. And the courts are affirming these hyenas. And it's disgusting. 1.00
00:45:06 We've got to speak up, guys, because they will come for you. They will come for you. So we can't
00:45:12 it quietly on these things. Well, that kind of eats up a lot of the time today, guys. So yes,
00:45:19 it went fast. Thank you very much for joining me. Look, I got to remind you one more time,
00:45:23 get on there, westernstandard.news slash membership, take out a subscription, share it on X,
00:45:29 share however you can on Facebook, things like that meta, get the word out. Independent media
00:45:35 can still shine through.
00:45:37 We don't have to lose
00:45:39 to the subsidized media
00:45:41 and we can keep talking about things
00:45:44 that the other outlets
00:45:45 are just too cowardly to address
00:45:47 and we can have these kinds of conversations.
00:45:49 So thanks for supporting us, guys.
00:45:51 Thanks for joining me today
00:45:52 and I will see you all again
00:45:54 next week at this time.
00:45:56 Here's an update on commodity prices
00:45:58 in Lethbridge where we've had
00:45:58 about an inch rain over the past few days.
00:46:01 Cash barley is down $5 at $3.65.
00:46:03 feed wheat is steady at $3.79 and corn is down $5 at $3.76 per metric ton. In the milling wheat
00:46:10 market, September Minneapolis futures added $9.5 at $7.83 per bushel, with local hard red spring
00:46:17 bid for August movement at $10 per bushel. Looking at canola, November futures are higher at $6.40
00:46:22 at $8.0240 per ton, with delivered vice for September movement at $17.85 per bushel.
00:46:29 In the Pulse markets, nearby red lentil prices remain at $0.33 per pound and yellow peas are
00:46:34 trading at $10.20 per bushel. And looking at cattle, October live cattle are up $0.35 at $1.78.30
00:46:41 per 100 weight. For more information on pricing or picked up options, give me a call at 403-394-1711.
00:46:50 I'm Matt Busiekum at Marketplace Commodities. Accurate real-time marketing information and
00:46:54 pricing options canadian shooting sports association without the cssa our gun rights 0.97
00:47:00 would have been taken long long ago these guys are on the front lines helping to draft smart
00:47:06 and intelligent firearms regulations and legislation in canada and more importantly
00:47:12 educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people
00:47:16 If you become a member, it's absolutely worth every penny.
00:47:46 Thank you.