Western Standard - September 28, 2023


CMS: Canada’s government is in total disarray under Trudeau

Topics
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update Sep 27, 2023 Damage caused by school closures for COVID

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

185.97

Word count

9,120

Sentence count

574

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

19

sentences flagged

Hate speech

14

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A Nazi is introduced to the House of Commons and the entire chamber applauds it. Also, the government shut down schools for a week and forced parents to pick up their kids from school. And a Ukrainian war hero was inducted into Parliament.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Good day. Welcome to The Cory Morgan Show. This is my weekly hour to bend your ears,
00:00:36 do a little ranting, interview some guests, and cover some issues that are breaking. And I tell
00:00:41 you, they're really breaking this week. It's just been an orgy of issues to try and keep track of.
00:00:48 Usually, you know, throughout the summer anyways, it was hard. You're trying to things to come up
00:00:52 with things to write columns on in the political realm and things like that, and it's slow.
00:00:55 right now the hard part is trying to figure out what exactly to cover there is so much going on
00:01:01 it's just been a bizarre crazy couple of weeks in canadian politics and news in general
00:01:07 so i've got a good packed show today a little later i'll have page mcpherson on it'll cool
00:01:14 things down a little bit but it's a very important discussion she's with the fraser institute and
00:01:19 released a study on the impacts of the school closures due to covet over that period of time
00:01:25 we know we haven't had enough people looking back say, well, was it worth it? Were the shutdowns
00:01:29 worth it? Were there benefits to be had? And of course, most importantly, what sort of damage was
00:01:34 done? You know, having children out of school for weeks and weeks and weeks at a time was not good
00:01:39 for them. It came at a cost to them. And they've studied that and put out a report on it. So I'm
00:01:43 looking forward to that. Of course, we'll have our check-ins and things such as that too. And yes,
00:01:48 this is live for a lot of you. Use that comment section, guys. Send those comments my way,
00:01:52 questions my way, things like that. Discuss things with each other. I like seeing things being active
00:01:57 in there. Just remain civil, that's all. We can be good to each other. So yes, I'm going to get on
00:02:02 about, of course, the biggest event of the week, a really unbelievable one. It was one of those times
00:02:07 the world really was watching, and we had Ukrainian President Zelensky. He was a guest to the House
00:02:13 of Commons. The Liberals were celebrating another injection of 600 million Canadian tax dollars
00:02:19 going into the Ukrainian war effort. It was a big feel-good moment. Then the entire house rose and
00:02:25 they gave an ovation and an applause to a Nazi. Yeah, I didn't have a slip of the tongue. I'm not 0.71
00:02:33 talking about a figurative Nazi or a comical Nazi like the soup chef in a Seinfeld episode. Not some 0.59
00:02:38 goose-stepping neo-Nazi idiot with a shaven head and a swastika tattoo. No, this wasn't even a 1.00
00:02:43 conscript from the German army in World War II or a simple member of the Nazi party from those times.
00:02:49 No, the fellow they were plotting actually served in one of Hitler's SS Waffen units in World War II.
00:02:55 This was a true, dyed-in-the-wool, literal Nazi. 0.84
00:02:59 I mean, that term gets thrown around so much that we really have to couch it this time with,
00:03:03 no, this is the real thing.
00:03:05 And due to the passage of time, thankfully, it's actually quite difficult to find real Nazis these days.
00:03:10 But credit where due, the government managed to dig one up and bring him into the House of Commons.
00:03:15 House Speaker, or I should say former House Speaker, Anthony Roda,
00:03:18 has fallen on his sword for the issue now and claims the invitation of the Nazi was solely his own action.
00:03:24 Now, while Roda certainly appears culpable,
00:03:26 it beggars belief that this Nazi slipped through the vetting into the House of Commons with no examination. 0.87
00:03:32 It's no coincidence that a Ukrainian veteran happened to be introduced to the House by the Speaker
00:03:36 on the same day the President of Ukraine happened to be there.
00:03:39 It was a staged, jingoistic event that was supposed to show a common front of support for Ukrainians against Russian aggression.
00:03:47 The problem was with which war Yaroslav Hanke fought against the Russians in.
00:03:53 I'm going to speculate on what probably happened. I could be wrong. This is what I figure happened.
00:03:57 I imagine an order went out to Liberal members just to ask him, try and seek out a Ukrainian veteran, you know,
00:04:01 who stood up to the Russians to celebrate in the house while we have Zalyski here.
00:04:07 Some staffer went scurrying about and managed to find Yaroslav Hanka.
00:04:10 It was probably a young staffer.
00:04:12 If you go to Ottawa, you see them all the time.
00:04:13 You know, they're usually rushing around in ill-fitting suits.
00:04:15 And it didn't occur to him that if a person's 98 years old, Ukrainian, and fought against the Russians,
00:04:23 it's almost a sure thing he served in one of Hitler's Waffen-SS units.
00:04:27 And he volunteered to join that unit.
00:04:29 He wasn't conscripted.
00:04:31 I've seen some liberal supporters doggedly trying to point out how Hanka wasn't among the worst of the Nazis.
00:04:36 That's absurd, and it's not doing their cause any favors.
00:04:39 I don't care if nowadays Honka is the sweetest father and grandfather on the planet,
00:04:43 you know, and did a good job later in life.
00:04:46 I don't care if he was the friendliest Nazi in his unit, 0.94
00:04:48 that he never forgot anybody's birthday or won the Mr. Nazi Congeniality Award
00:04:53 every time there was an SS convention.
00:04:56 He was a Nazi and never should have been invited to the House of Commons, 0.97
00:04:59 much less applauded.
00:05:01 Some actions and life choices lead to a permanent stigma being applied.
00:05:06 Joining one of Hitler's SAS units during World War II is one of those life choices. 0.64
00:05:11 The leader of a nation in the middle of a war was a guest in the House of Commons,
00:05:14 and he unwittingly found himself joining the rest of the room and applauding a Nazi.
00:05:18 The damage done went beyond just humiliating Canada and a guest on the world stage.
00:05:23 Vladimir Putin was surely laughing for hours as Canada managed to create a public relations coup for him.
00:05:29 While Justin Trudeau wasn't directly involved in this latest national embarrassment,
00:05:33 it still happened on his watch.
00:05:35 The Prime Minister's office surely was behind the planning for this grand event,
00:05:39 and if their office didn't vet attendees, it must be asked why they didn't.
00:05:43 Could any MP just bring in whoever they please
00:05:45 and have them recognized by the House without any question or vetting?
00:05:48 I doubt it.
00:05:50 This is just one debacle piling onto a year of embarrassments from the Trudeau government.
00:05:54 Every policy they touch becomes a mess, and every event becomes a controversy.
00:05:59 We're seeing a government in its dying stages.
00:06:01 They're tired out and in disarray.
00:06:03 They're directionless and basically leaderless. Rather than trying to address the issues,
00:06:08 of course, Trudeau went into hiding. He's trying to distract from things. The Liberals tried and
00:06:13 failed even to get unanimous consent to have the whole incident stricken from the public record.
00:06:17 Yeah, they actually wanted to get that thrown out just so we pretend it never happened.
00:06:21 Thankfully, a Conservative member said, no, no, no, no, that's going to stay in there,
00:06:24 as embarrassing as it is. The Canadian government under Justin Trudeau is dysfunctional and
00:06:28 unsustainable. Trudeau's days as prime minister are clearly numbered. Even if Trudeau never gets
00:06:33 it, his caucus had better bloody well figure it out and fast. The scandals are piling up faster
00:06:38 and the embarrassments are hitting new heights with every month that they allow him to keep
00:06:43 sitting as the liberal leader. If Trudeau isn't removed by the next election, the liberal party
00:06:47 is going to be utterly decimated. While that sounds appealing, I don't like to imagine the
00:06:50 damage that dingbat could cause if he had two more years in power. Wake up, guys. Think about
00:06:56 I mean, just back up and think for a moment. We had a standing ovation and an applause for a true,
00:07:05 literal living Nazi in our House of Commons. You can't make this sort of thing up. This government's
00:07:10 just a mess. All right. Well, of course, everybody heard about that. And as somebody else pointed out,
00:07:14 yeah, Justin Trudeau, I believe, is making a statement. Finally, he's popped his head up.
00:07:17 That's happening right now as I speak. But we'll get the highlights of that a little later, I'm
00:07:21 sure. And we'll check in with the newsroom and see what else is going on. And maybe there's been
00:07:24 a few words out of Trudeau worth mentioning from our news editor, Dave Naylor, and see what's
00:07:29 happening. Hey, Dave, how's it going? It's going well, Corey. Yeah, Prime Minister Trudeau just
00:07:33 seconds ago finished a statement where he apologized on behalf of the Parliament.
00:07:39 Didn't really apologize on behalf of himself, but on behalf of the Parliament, he said it was
00:07:44 obviously a very embarrassing situation. So that story is being typed up right now
00:07:50 by Jonathan Bradley.
00:07:52 But, hey, I'm more excited what the beer fairy
00:07:54 or the bee fairy brought this morning.
00:07:58 Yes.
00:07:59 That's direct from your hive, eh?
00:08:01 It is genuine, pretty honey.
00:08:05 I'm looking forward to it.
00:08:06 Actually, I'm going to give it to my daughter
00:08:07 because she's the honey expert. 0.99
00:08:09 But I'll let you know what she thinks.
00:08:12 Well, I appreciate it.
00:08:13 It's had good reviews so far.
00:08:14 Good.
00:08:15 Awesome.
00:08:16 Lots of news this morning, Corey.
00:08:18 Where to begin?
00:08:18 We'll begin in Paris, shall we, where Jonathan Wilkinson has released these sort of guidelines that Canada is committing to to cap emissions.
00:08:31 He confirms that there will be an oil and gas cap, but he doesn't say when.
00:08:37 It says it's still under development.
00:08:39 And if you remember, this is the line that Premier Daniel Smith drew in the sand and said, you guys better not cross it.
00:08:46 Well, they haven't crossed it quite yet, but it seems pretty obvious they're on their way.
00:08:53 Lots of news on the E. coli scandal in Calgary, where hundreds of young children have been stricken down.
00:09:00 Turns out it was bad meatloaf that led the way.
00:09:04 That seems to have caused it, combined with a vegan meatloaf.
00:09:08 And the city of Calgary has charged the kitchen with operating without a license.
00:09:15 And that's a fine of up to $120,000 if convicted.
00:09:21 We've got some good news out there.
00:09:24 The Taylor family has put in an additional $3 million to the new polar bear exhibit.
00:09:30 That's going to be opening up very, very quickly.
00:09:33 And it brings their combined donation to more than $11 million.
00:09:40 So these polar bears coming in from Winnipeg,
00:09:42 They're going to have a life of luxury that no other captive polar bear probably has.
00:09:48 And some amazing scenes last night in Philadelphia where basically you can go shoplifting anywhere you want now in the United States and not get charged.
00:09:59 And they had some mob scenes where people were, we won't call it shoplifting, we'll call it looting, looting stores.
00:10:07 And this comes on the heels of Target announcing they were closing stores across the U.S. to try and battle some of this economic loss that they're being faced with mob looting.
00:10:20 So tons of stuff already up, Corey.
00:10:23 We've got a column by our own Paul Forseth, who actually used to be a speaker, fill in for a speaker in the House of Commons.
00:10:33 So that's an interesting insight found only on the Western Standard, Corey.
00:10:38 So as mentioned, Jonathan's typing up the Trudeau stuff,
00:10:42 and no doubt we're going to have a lively question period kicking off in about 15 minutes.
00:10:47 Great. Well, thanks for the update.
00:10:50 And again, the plug for that Prittis honey, I'm afraid.
00:10:53 Yeah, I don't make quite enough to make a commercial venture of it,
00:10:55 but it's good to know somebody out there might be appreciating it.
00:10:58 Yeah, I'm sure we all do. Thanks. Thanks, Corey.
00:11:00 Thanks, Dave.
00:11:01 So that is our news editor, Dave Naylor. And yeah, you can see those stories just keep piling up. And, you know, lots to cover. We've got Jonathan Bradley out there hammering away and Sean and others. The stories are behind a paywall, but it's only $9.99 a month, guys, $100 for a year. And that's how we can stay independent. That's how we keep putting these stories out, whether the government likes us to or not. We don't take any tax dollars.
00:11:27 So again, subscribers have been fantastic so far
00:11:31 and that's why we're still going,
00:11:32 but we always need more and we can expand,
00:11:34 we can cover more stuff.
00:11:35 So check it out if you're not a subscriber yet,
00:11:37 go to westernstandard.news slash membership,
00:11:40 take one out.
00:11:41 We really appreciate it.
00:11:42 And it's an investment for yourself.
00:11:44 You get all that full access to all of those stories
00:11:46 as they come out and break.
00:11:49 Let's see, somebody commenter, Theo Thurm saying,
00:11:52 Trudy's blaming everyone but himself right at this moment.
00:11:54 Yeah, that's not to be too surprised at the conference.
00:11:56 We didn't really expect him to take responsibility.
00:11:59 That's not been a hallmark.
00:12:00 But, you know, I just would have thought eventually somebody's got to be twisting that guy's arm,
00:12:05 saying, look, that's enough.
00:12:06 That's enough.
00:12:06 You've got to go.
00:12:08 There was that caucus meeting late last night or cabinet meeting, something going on.
00:12:11 Some people were speculating maybe.
00:12:13 Looks like nothing's changed.
00:12:15 They feel they can manage to right this ship and hold the course.
00:12:18 It's like I said at the end of my opening.
00:12:21 I mean, I think they'll get themselves down to single-digit numbers if they keep at this pace by the next election.
00:12:26 which would be nice. I'd like to see the Liberals obliterated from the House of Commons, but
00:12:30 look how much more damage can we sustain from these hammerheads? Two more years? Boy, or possibly 0.93
00:12:37 three. Don't forget, we're in the parliamentary system. He can actually hang on for five years if
00:12:42 he really wanted to stretch it out as much as possible. So let's see. Dave D'Souza saying,
00:12:49 what are the chances of a vote of confidence so we can get Trudeau on the road? I'd say
00:12:52 practically none. You would need the NDP to participate in that. And Jagmeet Singh has
00:12:58 shown no interest in breaking up the agreement that he has with the liberals right now, because
00:13:04 that's the closest the NDP will ever get to power, and Singh knows it. So he'll talk big and act low,
00:13:10 as he always has been. He'll critique Trudeau, but he'll never bring him down. The only thing
00:13:15 that's going to bring Trudeau down, clearly it's not himself, because he's too stupid to realize 1.00
00:13:19 how stupid he is, is his own caucus. They have to do it. You know, conservatives are always 1.00
00:13:25 criticized because they tend to pull down their own leaders, and it's true, and they do it perhaps
00:13:29 a little too quickly and with a little too much damage. But at times with every party, eventually
00:13:34 you've got to show the leader the door if they don't realize that they need to go to it. And
00:13:40 these liberals in caucus, they're going to end up on the unemployment line just as much as Trudeau.
00:13:46 I mean, look at the disgraces that are happening right now. 0.98
00:13:49 I'm sure some of them have got to be getting ready to say, look, I got to save my own butt. 0.96
00:13:52 This guy's got to go. 0.96
00:13:54 That'll be the only chance.
00:13:55 And that wouldn't lead to an election.
00:13:57 That would just lead to a new liberal leader and a period in between.
00:14:02 But it wouldn't necessarily mean a big change immediately either.
00:14:06 But it would be the end of him, at least.
00:14:08 Because, I mean, again, like I said, this party is floundering.
00:14:10 They really are.
00:14:10 The government is out of control.
00:14:12 They don't know what each arm is doing.
00:14:14 They don't know what's happening. 1.00
00:14:15 Everything they touch turns to crap. 1.00
00:14:18 And we're paying the price for it. 1.00
00:14:20 See commenter David Fleischman saying,
00:14:22 many ex-German soldiers, in brackets, Nazis, emigrated to Canada after World War II.
00:14:26 They lived and worked in Canada.
00:14:27 The government at the time led them into Canada.
00:14:29 Do we blame the past government on this?
00:14:31 Well, you know, if you look back on it,
00:14:34 there were a number of people who fought in the war.
00:14:37 And yes, on the side of Germany with the Waffen-SS,
00:14:39 actually, I believe that was covered in the 50s.
00:14:42 They determined that they hadn't, they weren't going to call these guys war criminals, but they
00:14:46 weren't exactly sanctioning them either. But they were saying, okay, it's done. We're leaving it
00:14:50 where it is. And, and, you know, there's no sense turning back the clock. And at this point, going
00:14:54 down, chasing down 98 year olds and trying, because some people are saying you should be 0.98
00:14:57 arrested or, you know, sent back to Poland for, to face justice. You know, no, it's just let him 0.72
00:15:04 and his God, if he has one in his conscience, deal with whatever happened then along with the others
00:15:09 at this point. The bottom line, though, is they aren't appropriate to bring in front of the House
00:15:13 of Commons. That's the issue. That's the problem. You know, you should have let the, nobody should
00:15:18 have ever heard of this guy outside of his own friends and family until he passed on of old age,
00:15:22 but now suddenly he's one of the most famous men on earth and not in a good way. All right, let's
00:15:28 turn the page and get onto something, though I have been looking forward to this conversation.
00:15:31 Like I said, we get distracted with all of this, this haywire stuff coming out of the House of
00:15:35 Commons, but we've got a lot of important stuff happening otherwise. So we've got Paige McPherson
00:15:39 with the Fraser Institute on, and they put out a great study recently, and I'm looking forward
00:15:45 to discussing this. We aren't talking enough. We didn't talk enough before the pandemic measures
00:15:49 happened on cost-benefit, but at least now that we have the benefit of hindsight, let's look at
00:15:54 these things and what the impacts were so that presumably if there's another such event, we can
00:15:59 do things differently. Hello, Paige. Welcome to the show. Thanks so much for having me.
00:16:03 Well, I really appreciate it. I'm glad you came on. So kind of as I framed it there, so you called it the forgotten demographic, and you focused particularly on children in school with the amount of lost time and of the impacts that had. I mean, we can't pretend there was zero impact, but you guys actually dug in to see what those impacts were then.
00:16:23 Yeah, absolutely. We've often heard the refrain that policymakers when it came to COVID and school closures were doing the best with the information that they had at the time. So what our report really looks into is what information exactly did policymakers, including governments across Canada, we looked at each provincial government, including in Alberta, where you are, looking at what did they know exactly, and also when did they know it?
00:16:51 Did they have any information that would guide their policymaking or were they really just flying blind?
00:16:57 And I think it's very reasonable to say that, OK, within the first, let's say, one, two, maybe even three months, there wasn't a lot of good data.
00:17:05 There was a lot of uncertainty and fear during that period in the pandemic.
00:17:11 And so school closures happened.
00:17:13 But the reality is that in Canada, and including Alberta, schools were closed in Alberta well into January 2022.
00:17:22 So that's spanning three school years.
00:17:24 In other parts of Canada, they were closed up until February 2022.
00:17:28 And so just to put that into context, that is 110 days minimum that Alberta students missed due to school closures related to the pandemic, which began in March of 2020.
00:17:41 And our report really found that there was a no good reason, no evidence informed reason to believe that school closures would help in terms of the health and safety of children or even necessarily stopping the spread of COVID-19.
00:17:58 And certainly, we knew very early on, if we're being really, really conservative in what we're saying, by December 2020, at the latest, that there was almost no significant health risk to children of COVID-19, and yet governments continued to close schools.
00:18:19 So they really didn't let the data inform their response.
00:18:22 So, I mean, we all, well, again, there was a lot of conflicting stories and everything going on at the time.
00:18:27 but as you said, it was starting to become pretty clear. We kind of got very fortunate that among
00:18:31 infectious diseases, this one was one that seemed to leave children alone, at least for the most
00:18:36 part. But I mean, another, when that was brought up, often people would say, well, yes, but they're
00:18:41 putting the teachers at risk or they're adding to spread and they'll bring it home to their
00:18:45 household and put grandma and grandpa at risk or things like that. So did open times with school
00:18:50 contribute to the general infection of the population or could a link be found?
00:18:55 The short answer is that we there's really no clarity in the data. There's really no good
00:19:00 evidence to say yes, school closures worked. When we're looking in hindsight now in terms of
00:19:06 stopping the spread, there's certainly some speculation that they might have had some
00:19:10 impact, but there's really no good scientific data showing that they worked. And that's
00:19:16 from the epidemiological review, that portion of our paper. Also, it wasn't like we had never
00:19:22 thought about school closures before 2020. School closures had been studied in terms of a review of
00:19:30 the existing data when it came to coronaviruses, SARS and MERS, but before COVID-19, also in the
00:19:39 context of influenza. And those are the same. It was very inconclusive. Really, like I said,
00:19:44 there was no good evidence that school closures would work for what we had hoped that they would
00:19:51 do or what policy makers had hoped that they would do. What was also very clear from the start was
00:19:56 that school closures or in other words missed classroom time would have negative impacts on
00:20:03 children from an academic perspective, from a mental health perspective, social outcomes,
00:20:10 severe absenteeism. These are all of the things that we are now seeing and the other side of our
00:20:15 paper what we look at following school closures the consequences that children have faced and
00:20:20 are continuing to face but the fact is that policy makers in the Alberta government and
00:20:26 right across Canada and the western world if they had done their due diligence and looked into this
00:20:32 information it was there ahead of time we know that missed classroom time does have severe
00:20:38 consequences for kids and like I said 110 days minimum of missed classroom time in Alberta
00:20:43 that's not including if your school had an outbreak which would be two kids or more with a positive
00:20:48 COVID test, or if your kid had the sniffles and therefore they couldn't go to school because they
00:20:53 had a COVID symptom for however long it took them to get over the sniffles. So that is a minimum.
00:20:59 Kids actually, in effect, missed quite a lot more time than that. And that does have a negative
00:21:03 impact. Well, absolutely. And I guess something that probably lended to your study, though,
00:21:10 was the fact that every province was quite different for the amount of time. You had a
00:21:13 widespread. There was 10 weeks in BC at a minimum and 27 weeks in Ontario and sort of everything
00:21:19 in between. So I imagine that gave you some data and information to really see the differential
00:21:23 and impacts with the provinces that have less closing, fewer closures than the others.
00:21:29 Absolutely. So in terms of the academic impact, for example, what I will stress is that this is
00:21:35 a very preliminary look. A lot of what I do in my role at the Fraser Institute is look at
00:21:40 standardized test score data and provinces more or less halted standardized testing during COVID
00:21:46 and that during sort of the school closure period which we know is a very long period
00:21:50 and they're only just starting to reinstate and get those tests back into action so the data that
00:21:56 we have is sort of a preliminary peek into the window but we do know that there was impacts
00:22:02 particularly on math scores is something that we found quite striking in our paper it was in
00:22:09 Ontario and Nova Scotia, which are the two provinces which did close schools for the longest
00:22:13 period of time, that math scores did seem to be quite impacted. In Alberta, we looked at the grade
00:22:21 six provincial achievement test scores. Across all subjects, there were some minor declines between
00:22:27 2018-19, so the first or the last year not impacted by COVID school closures, compared with
00:22:35 2021-2022, which was the first year where you're not seeing the, or well, I guess there were still
00:22:45 school closures, but where we have that good test score data that we can look at. So we did see a
00:22:49 minor decline across all subjects. In addition, the Calgary Board of Education reported that the
00:22:55 number of students who pass the diploma exams, which are a necessity for graduation, so this is
00:23:01 very important exam for students and therefore this is quite a significant result in math 31
00:23:06 it declined by 18 percent um so in 2021-22 only 63.6 percent of alberta grade 12 students who
00:23:14 took that exam actually passed it and in 2018-19 uh and that was the that that was the same change
00:23:21 from 2018-19 to 2021-22 they also saw a decline in the english 31 exam a decline by uh by nine
00:23:30 percent so we we did see some significant learning loss in provinces that did close schools for long
00:23:38 periods of time but really any lost classroom time even if the school closures were short
00:23:44 would have an impact and we also saw impacts in terms of severe absenteeism students who were
00:23:49 actually out of school more than they were in school the only province that really reported
00:23:55 that um in a formal way was ontario they did see an increase in severe absenteeism but we've seen
00:24:00 from the uk and the us that where severe absenteeism so students not coming back to school
00:24:08 where it actually increased in the first school closure year it actually grew even larger um in
00:24:14 the the following year even if school closures hadn't continued so those those effects were
00:24:19 really compounding we also saw that mental health impacts in kids in terms of stats can data the
00:24:25 mental health commission of canada did a broad survey and found that the youngest kids who were
00:24:30 at the lowest physical health risk from covid19 actually faced the greatest rates self-reported
00:24:38 of severe anxiety and depression and other really negative mental health impacts and they actually
00:24:45 were the longest lasting. Contrast that with the oldest segment of the population who was the most
00:24:52 at physical health risk of COVID-19. They had a spike at the start in terms of their severe
00:24:59 anxiety, but it quickly dissipated and the rates were actually significantly lower than we saw in
00:25:04 the youth. So that's why we called the paper the forgotten demographic. It's really that children
00:25:10 are bearing a lot of the burden of these COVID-19 school closures and lockdown policies. It's
00:25:16 actually lasting quite a long time in terms of those impacts on kids, whereas we're just not
00:25:21 seeing that in the older demographics. Yeah, and I mean, the academic impact is somewhat easier to
00:25:28 measure when we have standardized testing and we can see some correlation. The more difficult, but
00:25:32 possibly more distressing, is the social impact. You touched a little upon, I see one of our
00:25:36 commenters, Ann McCormack, said their 14-year-old committed suicide, you know, the weekend before
00:25:42 school starts September 20th. You know, the individual cases vary all over the place,
00:25:47 but it's certainly, there's a lot of vulnerable children. They're suffering from, you know,
00:25:51 anxiety. It's a difficult time. Suicide is always a risk and things such as that at the best of
00:25:57 times. And when you disrupt it with something like this and so much fear and separation from
00:26:03 their social peers there's it's unquestionable that there's been an impact but you know it's
00:26:09 I guess difficult to quantify just how much it was. Yes you're right and that's that's a that's
00:26:14 a really tragic outcome it's it's also not an isolated thing we did see that there were
00:26:20 emergency rooms for example in Calgary said that there was an emergency the emergency room doctors
00:26:25 there I forgot which hospital it was but they reported a significant increase in people who
00:26:32 came in youth who came in um due to suicide attempts and self-harm um those those mental
00:26:38 health commission of canada surveys and stats can surveys and also um complemented by um kmh
00:26:44 the center for addictions and mental health in ontario did ontario specific studies all really
00:26:49 finding the same things that kids were certainly facing um severe anxiety and depression they they
00:26:55 were those rates went up um rates of reported self-harm or thoughts of suicide did go up
00:27:01 amongst youth. And that is a really, really tragic outcome. The other thing that I found
00:27:08 interesting when I was reviewing that survey data, because this was another common refrain that,
00:27:12 oh, it's just anxiety because of COVID-19, because of the pandemic, they're afraid of the virus,
00:27:17 they're afraid of the impact that the virus is going to have on their loved ones. That was not
00:27:21 what the youth survey data showed. It really showed that youth were much more concerned about
00:27:28 isolation. Family stress from that isolation of being, you know, inside the house, not seeing
00:27:34 their friends, missing school. It was not, you know, the fear of COVID-19 of the virus itself
00:27:40 was actually quite low on the list of concerns for youth in this survey data. And that is, you know,
00:27:47 that's really the tragic outcome is that it wasn't the virus. It was the policy response
00:27:51 to the virus by governments, including the Alberta government, that that really negatively
00:27:58 impacted children. So as you said, there was already data on how school closures impact
00:28:03 children. Now there's certainly a whole much larger set of data to look at and the impact.
00:28:10 Have you seen indications that governments are going to be embracing this? I'm certain you've
00:28:14 been sharing it and sending it their way, but do you think hopefully they've learned from this? So
00:28:18 if there's another similar event, they won't necessarily react as quickly with school closures.
00:28:23 Well, I certainly hope that that is the case. The fact is that, you know, there really hasn't been any sort of official national account of school closures. Okay, let's look at exactly what happened. You know, our paper is really one of the only of its kind that are looking at this. And there really hasn't been any kind of government level official assessment of that. And that is sort of a depressing fact. And maybe governments are working on that behind the scenes, and I'm not aware of that.
00:28:53 but certainly learning from their mistakes would be good I think that you know we really like I
00:28:58 like I said in terms of the academic student success you know we see that there has been
00:29:04 learning loss but it is very preliminary and we really won't know the full impact of school closures
00:29:11 until you know maybe 10 or 20 years from now because effective even the World Bank has has
00:29:19 data showing that if you actually have missed classroom time for kids it results in basically
00:29:27 years of effective schooling lost which means that their their outcomes in life are going to
00:29:33 be worse they're going to be worse off so it's going to decrease their lifetime earnings at an
00:29:37 individual level and it actually contributes to a decrease in GDP for the country as a whole
00:29:43 when kids are not in school the amount that they should be in school when they're not learning
00:29:48 Of course, you know, I'll give the caveat that there are some kids who probably did really well in this environment that actually discovered that they loved homeschooling or something as a result.
00:29:58 But there was a lot of kids whose parents had to continue to go to work.
00:30:02 They had nobody at home helping them with with their schoolwork.
00:30:05 And this is what we see. There are kids who basically disappeared, who just fell out of the school system completely.
00:30:10 And so we won't know exactly the societal impacts of that for many years to come.
00:30:15 But hopefully governments will pay attention to the fact that school closures are the root issue in a lot of what we are facing today and what we will face in the years to come.
00:30:26 Well, I appreciate you guys studying that and compiling it.
00:30:29 I mean, we know it's a matter of if and when.
00:30:31 There seems to be some people just eager to hit the panic button at every possible opportunity and react to things.
00:30:37 At least there's that much more data that some of us can pull up and say, no, hang on a second, hang on.
00:30:42 This might not be worth it.
00:30:44 here's what happened last time let's let's consider a little further before we do something
00:30:48 like closing up a school uh there's much more of course you covered in that and it's a great piece
00:30:53 where can people find the the full study and then your your other work yeah thanks so much so they
00:30:58 can find the full study it's called the forgotten demographic at fraser institute.org and you can
00:31:03 find all of the rest of our education policy work and all the other policy work that we do i appreciate
00:31:07 it great thanks page i really appreciate you coming on to talk to us about it and uh the you
00:31:12 know the fact you guys went in and dug that up so we have that resource available and we can't undo
00:31:17 the past but hopefully we can learn from it. Thank you I agree. Great thanks I'll talk to you again
00:31:22 I hope soon. So as we said that was Paige McPherson with the Fraser Institute and yes it was a very
00:31:29 important piece and a very good one you know you can't overstate the amount of impact with kids
00:31:34 it's different with them they're in a developmental stage you know the impact on one of us a two three
00:31:39 year period when you're in your 30s 40s 50s we see the world differently by then we've developed it
00:31:44 still disrupts our lives but remember when you're a kid I mean a week was an eternity back then so
00:31:50 when you're talking two years of strangeness of fear of masking of closing of in school and out
00:31:55 of school I think the best analogy of showing the children's view of timelines we all know as we get
00:32:01 older you know is looking at life is like a roll of toilet paper I know it's an odd analogy but
00:32:05 you know you start pulling it it just keeps coming and coming but once you're getting closer and
00:32:08 closer to the end, it's going faster and faster. That's your perception of time as a child. That's
00:32:13 why a month just seems like years to you when you're a child and a month blasts by us now that
00:32:18 we're, you know, some of us in our fifties. But again, these are times that you can't get back.
00:32:23 You know, you can't undo what happened to that child in that period. It's a big percentage of
00:32:29 their life was living in that world. I really, you know, children are impressionable. They trust us.
00:32:35 They want, I think it's, you know, ingrained into us to be listening to our elders and learning from them.
00:32:40 So when they're getting this messaging of there's a virus that could kill you if you take your mask off or if you don't wash your hands enough times, you're going to kill your grandma.
00:32:50 Or, you know, I mean, that's the sort of things these kids were terrified.
00:32:53 I mean, we want to be responsible during the pandemic.
00:32:56 I can certainly understand we want to reduce transmission.
00:32:59 You want to encourage, you know, common sense ideas, hand washing, things like that.
00:33:03 but shutting down the schools for weeks and weeks on end.
00:33:07 And as we're seeing, we saw very little benefit.
00:33:10 If this was an infection that had been predominantly harming children,
00:33:15 that's a different story.
00:33:16 If you look at the history of the Spanish flu, for example,
00:33:18 actually, it was children were some of the ones getting terribly hit by that flu.
00:33:22 That was a different virus.
00:33:23 Perhaps closing schools would make a heck of a lot more sense
00:33:26 if it was something like that.
00:33:28 But we seem to be stuck on this notion that everybody from cradle to elderly grave
00:33:33 should have been separated and we did a lot of damage. And it wasn't just in the schools. You
00:33:37 know, that's what got me too. I mean, remember the imagery of arresting people for playing hockey,
00:33:42 for kids, for getting out again, for socializing, for, you know, roped off playgrounds. They filled
00:33:47 a skate park in one city with sand, you know, so the skateboarders wouldn't get out. It was just
00:33:54 insane. And it's like we always say, if we don't learn at least from these past things, though,
00:33:59 we will repeat them. There are people ready to panic. We see that, whatever her name is, Neely
00:34:06 whatever, the unusual school board member out in Ontario who's always causing a ruckus out there,
00:34:12 Kaplan Murr or something like that. But I mean, she is terrified of COVID. She's masked everywhere
00:34:19 she goes. She's kind of like Alberta's Dr. Vipon. She's certain there's a boogeyman around every 0.94
00:34:23 corner, people like her will close a school in a heartbeat, given another chance. So, and people 1.00
00:34:30 fear for the safety of their children. If you're getting told by the authorities, you're getting
00:34:33 told by the news, you're getting told by everybody, we have to close these schools for their safety.
00:34:36 Well, parents will comply, but the impact is huge. That's what we needed was cost benefit throughout
00:34:42 the entire pandemic. And we never did it. We didn't do it before, but at least we're starting
00:34:46 to do it after, at least the Fraser Institute is. So I appreciate that on their part. So okay,
00:34:52 turned the page onto something similar though. And some Dave mentioned that for people across
00:34:56 the country might not have heard about it, but yeah, Alberta had a huge E. coli breakout in
00:35:01 daycares. You know, again, speaking of the safety of our children and the irony and weirdness of it
00:35:08 with a vegan meatloaf being part of the cause, the E. coli. I mean, it just sounds like it's
00:35:15 an oxymoron rate to begin with, but the real meatloaf had a infection as well, but it's not
00:35:20 funny at all. In reality, hundreds of kids got hit with bad infections. I mean, a number of them
00:35:26 were in hospital, a number of got dialysis, they could have some very permanent, you know, kidney
00:35:31 damage, things like that. It's terrible, terrible mess. And everybody's scrambling and pointing
00:35:35 fingers and trying to get to the bottom of that. At least they found the root of it. And I guess
00:35:42 we got a caution against overreaction. That was the most appalling and terrible thing we can think
00:35:48 of happening with children in care, daycare. I mean, you put your kids there, you don't want
00:35:52 them dying of poisoning from bloody food. But people are saying we need more inspectors,
00:35:56 we need more cracking down, we need more of this, we need more of that. I listened to one person
00:36:00 saying every restaurant and kitchen in the whole province needs to have every employee trained in
00:36:06 food safety. Okay, we need to make sure these things don't happen as very little as reasonably
00:36:14 possible. I know people say zero, never. Well, that's not going to happen. We can only mitigate,
00:36:17 We can minimize. And we do want to keep up. Like I owned a pub and restaurant. We were regularly
00:36:23 inspected. EHS was very thorough. If we'd have been doing things that were really beyond the
00:36:29 pale, we would be shut down. I mean, some people are saying, why wasn't this place shut down
00:36:33 earlier? It had roaches that were found in it and some other things. Yeah, there's some questions to
00:36:38 be asked. Ironically, I mean, that's an indication of a dirty kitchen. There's no doubt about that.
00:36:43 But the roaches probably wouldn't have been the cause of the E. coli. If you really look at the
00:36:46 roots that it means somebody was infected wasn't washing their hands after using the washroom
00:36:49 they're preparing food yeah disgusting subject matter on a lunch time show but uh like everything
00:36:56 else and again when we get children involved while i'm saying is let's not uh i mean we should
00:37:01 react strongly but let's not uh overreact in the sense of bringing in a bunch more legislation and
00:37:06 pressure when we don't necessarily need it remember if you put that expense i as i said i own a pub
00:37:12 your average margin in that, it's just like the grocery world, it's like 5%. And if you suddenly
00:37:19 put that new staff training cost up where you had to train each and every one of them on that
00:37:23 multiple day course in food safety, and there's rules, you have to have some staff members with
00:37:27 it so that somebody in that kitchen knows how to properly manage the kitchen. That's already there
00:37:30 and it's good. If you're requiring that for everybody from the dishwasher to the prep cook
00:37:35 to the line cooks and everything, you're going to shoot the cost of operation through the roof
00:37:40 in a narrow margin business.
00:37:41 It will put some restaurants over the edge
00:37:43 and it will put the price of everything up again.
00:37:46 Everything comes with a cost.
00:37:48 So yeah, let's find out what happened
00:37:50 with the kitchen with those kids and things like that.
00:37:52 But let's not let the legislators and bureaucrats 0.98
00:37:55 go too wild with extra controls to respond to this.
00:38:00 Likewise with school closures.
00:38:03 You know, if we're not seeing as much benefit
00:38:05 as we should out of it,
00:38:06 then let's not be doing it again.
00:38:10 And it depends on the infection.
00:38:11 Things are different every time.
00:38:13 If it's a different bug, we might have a different reaction to it.
00:38:19 All right, let's talk about government efficiency, right?
00:38:22 So let's see, Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation.
00:38:25 Is this one of the announcements?
00:38:26 This one kind of just flew away.
00:38:28 I mean, as the government talked about, it wasn't a bad policy, to be honest.
00:38:31 They're talking about giving a GST holiday for the construction of rental projects.
00:38:37 What does that mean exactly?
00:38:38 it sounds like if you're building an apartment building, I guess you'll get a GST break on
00:38:42 the materials or some of the contracting or services you got when you built it. And it could
00:38:47 add up to about $383 million a year. But they have no idea how many units that will actually
00:38:53 lead to. Like I said, reducing taxes is always a good thing. It'll always help. It'll bring down
00:38:58 the expenses. But they figure the cabinet estimates on how many units this will help facilitate is
00:39:03 between the thousands to millions. Yeah, that's how wide the spread is. In other words, they have
00:39:08 no idea. But hey, error on the side of tax cuts, guys. I'll give you credit for doing one thing
00:39:13 right once in a while because it doesn't happen bloody often. But yeah, they got no clue. They
00:39:17 got no clue. It just matches with everything else this government's doing. They're fumbling along.
00:39:21 They're just shooting in all directions, trying to do, trying to save their own butts at this 0.97
00:39:28 point. The post office, speaking of inefficiency, right? Canada Post, you know, they kind of made
00:39:34 a bit of a comeback. For a few years, they were making a bit of a profit. But now, for some years
00:39:39 running, they've been losing and losing and losing. The last year, they lost $548 million.
00:39:44 It's time, I think, to really start seriously considering retiring that dinosaur.
00:39:49 We don't need it. You know, look at how private industry has filled the void. I mean, we don't
00:39:56 need letters like we used to. We don't need paper bills like we used to. I know some people still
00:40:01 rely on that stuff, but we can start phasing that out. We really don't need it. You can get
00:40:05 everything on your phone now. And as far as packages go and everything, Amazon is delivering
00:40:09 directly. Pure later is part of Canada Post. But FedEx, all of those other private couriers are
00:40:14 doing the job and they're making money. Canada Post, which you would think with such an already
00:40:20 established network to be able to deliver packages, should be able to take advantage of this new age
00:40:25 of so much online ordering and things being delivered, but no, they can't. They can't
00:40:28 efficiently do it. They're too bloated with their unions and inefficiency and old ways of doing 0.62
00:40:32 things, and they're losing hundreds of millions of dollars a year. Again, government just can't
00:40:38 do things right, and they won't. So either way, I just say, let's start looking towards pulling
00:40:44 the pin on those guys. We can get to an end on it. Cocaine on a plane. Odd statement, isn't it?
00:40:52 you might have seen some of the news. Toronto, the Toronto Sun published a story. I think,
00:40:58 you know, it was almost a media trolling. Hey, I'm not above trolling on Twitter and social media
00:41:03 and things like that to just kind of poke the hornet's nest a little bit and everything.
00:41:06 But there was an internet rumor. It started way back when Justin Trudeau, again, like, you know,
00:41:11 his constant catastrophes and problems everywhere and everything he does, he got stuck in India for 1.00
00:41:17 two extra days because his plane broke down and he was sitting there. And there was a rumor,
00:41:20 somebody started probably on Facebook or Twitter saying the reason that plane's down is because
00:41:25 the Indian authorities found cocaine on it and they're not letting him fly out. It was ridiculous. 0.90
00:41:31 You know, I think it's impossible that Trudeau was taking coke. It might explain a lot of things 0.91
00:41:35 actually, but look guys, that didn't happen. Even as much as India doesn't like Justin Trudeau,
00:41:43 they weren't going to send the drug sniffing dogs on a foreign leader's plane while he's
00:41:47 the G20 summit, even if there really was a bunch of coke on there, they wouldn't have been in there 0.95
00:41:51 looking for it. But the Indian media, I did a few interviews on some Indian television networks last
00:41:58 week, and it's an experience, I'll tell you. They are very, they're very biased. I mean, all media's
00:42:05 got some biases and everything, but holy cow, these guys are really something else. I sat on those
00:42:08 panels, and it's so torqued and high energy. It was kind of fun to sit on them, but they play very
00:42:13 loose with some facts and things. Remember, I am far from a defender of Justin Trudeau. I spend
00:42:19 a large part of my shows all the time ripping into him. But somebody on one of those Indian 1.00
00:42:24 shows the other day said that he had, I love the irony he was playing with, he said there was
00:42:29 credible evidence that there was cocaine on Justin Trudeau's plane, and that's why it was held up.
00:42:34 This was a former diplomat from India. He used the credible evidence term purposely. That was
00:42:43 the term that Justin Trudeau used when he stood up and said that India had assassinated somebody
00:42:48 on Canadian soil. So there was credible evidence. Well, you need to prove it. And
00:42:55 yeah, yes, you know, so Trevor is saying, yeah, India news channels seem to think he was, you
00:43:01 know, yes, that's what I mean. Those channels get a lot of traffic. The amount of followers from
00:43:04 India I got after doing the, you know, on Twitter and such, after doing those interviews was
00:43:08 something else. But don't take that one to the bank, guys. I, you know, there's a million reasons
00:43:13 to get rid of Justin Trudeau. The mythological story of the cocaine on the plane, though,
00:43:19 is probably not real, as funny as it kind of sounds to begin with. Other stuff up on the
00:43:25 Western Standard site, Dave mentioned it earlier with Target. There's a video showing one of the
00:43:29 mobs, as he said, they're not thieves, they're looters, breaking into stores and just stealing 1.00
00:43:35 everything they can and going to the door. This idiotic left-wing policies of enablement, whether 1.00
00:43:40 it comes to drug use or shoplifting or any of those things have led, of course, to high crime 1.00
00:43:46 and high drug use, yet they still seem mystified about it. So Target, yeah, they're closing stores.
00:43:51 In San Francisco and throughout the West Coast, there's been Walmarts and all sorts of other
00:43:56 stores. They're folding up. They're pulling out. They say, we can't do this. We can't make money
00:43:59 and it's unsafe to staff. It's a nightmare to work there. And you watch some of those videos.
00:44:03 it's disturbing. And then there's the other bleeding heart, piss and moan and liberals. 0.97
00:44:08 Oh, well, it just shows how hard up people are and they're desperate. No, they aren't.
00:44:12 The video showed that in the recent one, it wasn't food they were stealing. It wasn't clothing. It
00:44:18 wasn't necessities. They went to Foot Locker because they wanted Nikes. They went to Lululemon
00:44:22 because they wanted yoga pants. And they went to the Apple store. Not for apples. This is food.
00:44:28 Apple electronic products. Come on, guys. They're thieves. They're looters. It's intolerable.
00:44:34 And until people start pushing back, these stores are going to keep closing. And guess what?
00:44:38 Stores like Target and that, those were ones that helped people who really were on a lower income
00:44:42 because they worked with large volumes of products and they can afford to get things to you cheaper.
00:44:49 Now, those retail outlets won't be there. Jobs are lost and people are going to pay more prices
00:44:53 for goods. Why? Because of idiotic, liberal enablement policies of crime. That's why. You
00:45:00 have to charge people if they steal things. You have to punish them. I'm not talking about public
00:45:05 whippings and hangings, but you can't let them off with nothing, and that's what's been happening
00:45:08 down there. And this is the consequence that anybody with a quarter of a brain could have
00:45:12 seen coming, but a quarter of a brain is a big ask when it comes to people in government on either
00:45:17 side of our border. One final thing we're seeing as things heat up, Dave mentioned that too, with
00:45:22 the announcements of emissions caps and things like that.
00:45:25 This will be something changing the dynamic in Canada
00:45:27 because it's been found now that Ontario, the average household,
00:45:32 is going to be paying another $3,300 a year
00:45:35 if they get rid of natural gas out there.
00:45:37 So it's not just Alberta is the whipping boy anymore.
00:45:39 It's going to hurt Ontario.
00:45:41 That changes the dynamic.
00:45:42 If it was Quebec, we already would have thrown out the emissions caps 1.00
00:45:45 if they found it was going to hurt them that much. 0.98
00:45:47 But yes, these caps is banning this idiocy of stopping natural gas
00:45:51 when we sit on that resource, it's costing everybody from coast to coast, including Ontario. 0.97
00:45:57 And I think, think if voters are going to push back, this liberal government, this tone deaf
00:46:02 government doesn't realize why they're dropping in the polls like a stone. It's things like this.
00:46:07 People can't pay the rent. They can't buy food. They can't get mortgages. And you morons are just
00:46:11 adding to every expense with your ideological insane push against the use of fossil fuels, 1.00
00:46:17 even if they make life affordable and livable.
00:46:20 Oh, well.
00:46:21 All right.
00:46:22 That's all I've got for you this week, guys.
00:46:25 Make sure to tune in a little later.
00:46:26 The pipeline will be on.
00:46:27 It'll be our panel show.
00:46:28 We'll cover a lot more of this sort of stuff.
00:46:30 And hey, share all this stuff on your social media channels.
00:46:33 We need to get it out there.
00:46:34 It's important.
00:46:35 So I appreciate everybody tuning in with me today.
00:46:38 And I'll see you all again next week at this time.
00:46:40 And we'll see what sort of new craziness we'll have to rant about.
00:46:43 Here's an update on commodity prices in Lethbridge for today.
00:46:50 Cash barley remains at $3.35, feed wheat is steady at $3.50, while October corn is unchanged
00:46:55 at $3.50 and November-December corn is trading at $3.18.
00:46:59 In the milling wheat markets, December Minneapolis futures dropped 13.5 cents to $7.53 per bushel,
00:47:06 with local hardwood spring bid for October movement at $9.40 per bushel.
00:47:10 Looking at canola, November futures added $11.90 at $7.2610 per ton, with delivered
00:47:16 buys for October movement at $16.12 per bushel.
00:47:20 In the pulse markets, nearby red lentil prices are holding at $0.365 per pound, and yellow
00:47:25 peas are higher at $0.25 at $10.75 a bushel.
00:47:29 In the cattle markets, October live cattle are higher at $0.45 at $1.8525 per 100 weight.
00:47:35 For more information on pricing or picked up options, give me a call at 403-394-1711.
00:47:41 I'm Matt Musicum at Marketplace Commodities, accurate real-time marketing information and pricing options.
00:47:48 Canadian Shooting Sports Association. Without the CSSA, our gun rights would have been taken long, long ago.
00:47:55 These guys are on the front lines helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms regulations and legislation in Canada.
00:48:02 and more importantly, educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong
00:48:07 people. We've become a member. It's absolutely worth every penny.
00:48:32 Thank you.