Western Standard - January 28, 2021


Cory Morgan interviews UCP MLA for Cypress Hills Medicine Hat, Drew Barnes

Topics
Mentioned
Jan 20, 2021 The Pipeline February 3, 2021

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

178.73

Word count

3,280

Sentence count

211

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, I sit down with UCP Member of Parliament for Cypress-Medicine Hat, Drew Barnes, to talk about the ongoing crisis in our mental health system and the need for a regional approach to dealing with it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Okay, I'm sitting today with Drew Barnes, who's the UCP MLA for Cypress Medicine Hat. He's one of
00:00:07 the remaining original Wild Rosers and he's stayed pretty dedicated to those grassroots principles
00:00:14 now even while being in big government in a different sort of seat and role. So it's really
00:00:21 been appreciated, Drew. You've been outspoken when we really don't hear a heck of a lot from
00:00:26 individual caucus members, unfortunately, on a lot of trying issues right now. I guess I might
00:00:33 as well start though, you know, well, thanks for joining me and address the big elephant in the
00:00:38 room. It's the COVID restrictions, the pandemic restrictions on small business. You're one of
00:00:42 the few who has been at least speaking up saying, hey, we've really got to lighten up on these
00:00:46 businesses. We're crushing them. Maybe you can expand a bit on where your stance has been on that lately.
00:00:52 Yeah, Corey, thanks. Thanks for what you do and thanks for talking to me today.
00:00:57 Yeah, it's clear to me that we need more of a regional approach. You know, first of all,
00:01:04 let's start in Cypress Medicine Hat in the southeast part of the province. Yesterday, we're down to 24 cases.
00:01:10 Unfortunately, in long-term care by far and away the most. Saskatchewan, right next door, gyms are open.
00:01:21 You can have in-person dining and restaurants. And the real sad part, maybe to the main part of this,
00:01:31 is we've had a mental health and an economic crisis down here, at least as big as the COVID crisis.
00:01:38 So sad about our overdoses and our mental health effects. And, you know, it's created a lot of
00:01:47 hardship for families and the people down here. And Corey, the other thing is everywhere you go,
00:01:52 people are so respectful. You know, masks are worn, even though it's debatable about the effectiveness,
00:01:59 social distancing is everywhere. People are following the rules, you know, as best as people
00:02:06 can. And we're in a situation where, you know, like one case in Cypress County,
00:02:12 none in 40 Mile County, to my knowledge, 24 in Medicine Hat. So in an area of 400 by 300 miles,
00:02:21 you know, and there's not a COVID problem, there's a mental health problem. And secondly,
00:02:26 our hospital, by all accounts, our hospital is not overwhelmed, our hospital is not overfilling.
00:02:32 You know, for goodness sakes, we've got whole floors empty in the hospital, that something
00:02:37 could happen if they had to, we've been in this for 11 months. And it's disappointing that Alberta
00:02:42 Health Services hasn't come up with more ways to handle in the event that the hospitals get
00:02:49 overwhelmed, which seems to be the main fear. Yeah, we need a regional approach, we need an open
00:02:55 approach. Corey, if I can continue, I put out yesterday about South Dakota, that has kept their
00:03:01 economy open. And now their unemployment rate is 3%. And possibly this focus on the locking
00:03:12 everything down hasn't allowed us to focus on things like Florida has done. I understand in
00:03:17 Florida, if you're a long term healthcare worker, you take a five minute rapid blood test, which is 94%
00:03:23 effective before you go in to work in the long term care centre. You know, of course, we're hearing
00:03:29 here that our tests may be 50% ineffective. You know, and it's, you know, it's, let's open up things,
00:03:38 let's engage in our economy, let's have a regional approach. Let's focus on long term care. Thank you.
00:03:44 Yeah, well, we know the damage that COVID-19 can do, I mean, for to a vulnerable person, a senior, or some
00:03:52 of those even young, healthy one in a million people who get taken down by it. I mean, it's tragic.
00:03:57 We want to protect and reduce that as much as possible. But I appreciate you bringing up,
00:04:01 there is a cost, people keep talking about the cost of COVID. But they're not talking about the cost of
00:04:06 these lockdowns. And those costs are growing. And they're really pressuring people, as you said, with
00:04:11 mental health, and financially, I went out yesterday, actually, to a restaurant in Bathsha
00:04:17 there. And at a great meal of Mexican food. And their point was, if Walmart can do it, we can do
00:04:28 it. You know, they had masks set up at the front door, they had hand sanitizers, the tables were
00:04:33 spread out, they're doing everything by the rules. They're not, they are taking it seriously. But they
00:04:37 say, Look, we've got to pay our bills, we've got to stay solvent, or we're going to go bankrupt. So it's
00:04:43 this selective nature of the lockdowns, which is really frustrating. A lot of people, as we said,
00:04:48 you know, I can walk into a crowded Costco, and they are crowded. But I can't go into a small local
00:04:53 restaurant and sit down six feet from another patron and eat a meal. So is I know there's been
00:04:58 some discussion. Is there some discussion in caucus and government about trying to get some
00:05:03 consistency? Or as you said, perhaps regional, you know, implementation?
00:05:08 Oh, absolutely. There's there's lots of talk there. There's lots of ideas being looked at.
00:05:13 And that's it exactly when Premier Kenney and the government first came out,
00:05:18 saying businesses had to be essential versus non essential. He later apologized said safe versus
00:05:24 non safe should have been the requirement. And that's exactly where we're at. I can't count the
00:05:30 number of people I know, particularly young people, whose lives are totally derailed because of the
00:05:35 COVID crisis, who at least we're finding some opportunity to to vent some physical energy or
00:05:42 get mental energy in gyms. And now gyms are closed. And as an example, you know,
00:05:48 the gym operators I know wipe down consistently keep the social distancing have huge square footage. And
00:05:57 and now a lot of these people are meeting on their own and doing their own thing because, you know,
00:06:02 physical health is mental health. Social is mental health. And yeah, and then we've seen it too,
00:06:09 from, you know, from the traffic's in the malls, to to the big box stores. And again, we're we're in
00:06:16 Medicine Hat and Cypress Medicine Hat people are totally respectful everywhere you go. The mask wearing is
00:06:20 very, very high. People do everything they can to social distance. And, you know, the again,
00:06:27 the yeah, let's make safe the the requirements. I'm seeing what the CFIB put out the other day.
00:06:35 40% of businesses in Alberta are closed. I think it was 24% in Saskatchewan are closed.
00:06:41 When we look at what governments and utility companies provided for deferrals. Yeah, it was it
00:06:47 was something but a short term, you know, 90 day or 180 day deferral on your taxes or your utilities.
00:06:54 But at the end of the day, you still have to pay in full. Think of the hardship for for these employers.
00:07:00 And Corey, think of the hardship for their employees, people that day in day out show up,
00:07:05 work hard, provide us great service, who if there's not revenue there to to pay,
00:07:10 this hardship is going to magnify. And yeah, and again, the the economic crisis,
00:07:17 the mental health crisis is at least as big as the COVID crisis.
00:07:20 Yeah, there's a lot of kicking the can down the road. And as you said, people in retail or gyms or
00:07:27 restaurants, these typically aren't high paying positions either. These aren't people who had a
00:07:31 lot of savings to fall back on necessarily, they might have been younger people just getting going or,
00:07:36 or people who were on fixed incomes, just making some extra money. So this hurts them a heck of a
00:07:40 lot more. I think there's a lot of misunderstanding. A lot of people really support the lockdowns are
00:07:44 people with stable salaries that aren't directly feeling that don't understand the stress of not
00:07:49 knowing how you're going to make your rent or a mortgage payment or just get your kids clothed
00:07:53 for school for the year. It's being forgotten. So I appreciate some people bringing it up. And
00:07:59 now with the opposition with Rachel Notley though, she's spoken and I kind of agree in a yes or no,
00:08:04 yes and no. She's very frustrated with businesses opening, she wants them to remain closed. That's 1.00
00:08:08 standard for I guess, that type of ideology. But if the state is going to force a business to stay
00:08:15 closed, then that's the one situation where I see the state obligated to at least pad that
00:08:22 damage that they've been causing. I'd rather just have the place open because we just can't afford
00:08:26 to keep spending like this though. We can't just keep pouring money in and it's just a bandaid solution.
00:08:31 So you've spoken recently while you've always been outspoken on getting spending under control,
00:08:36 which is a sort of a voice in the wilderness with a massive spending increases on every level of
00:08:41 government with this pandemic. How do you feel we can approach getting some spending restraint and
00:08:46 control while still dealing with this, this ongoing nightmare?
00:08:49 Okay. Well, thanks for that. Yeah, Corey, we absolutely have to, you know, taxes were too high
00:08:55 to begin with and governments were running deficits at least as big as the tax revenue they were taking
00:09:02 from individuals and individual families. Lots of things we can do. Back up to one of your original
00:09:10 points, when the second lockdown hit in Alberta, I know families who husband and wife both got laid
00:09:16 off the same day and some of their working and adult children. Can you imagine the hardship of that?
00:09:23 You know, what a problem that is. So one of the reasons that I decided a short time ago,
00:09:30 excuse me for a sec, to, during the pandemic, I'm donating 20% of my MLA wage to charities. My first
00:09:40 one was to the Salvation Army. My second one is going to be the United Way. And one of the reasons for
00:09:45 that is exactly what you said. The, the rift between public and private has grown considerably
00:09:52 during this. It's a lot of private employees have lost everything, uh, from their businesses to their
00:10:00 jobs. Uh, a lot of loss significantly. And, and when, when, you know, all levels of government
00:10:07 we're spending too much to begin with, uh, it removes our freedom. It removes our competitiveness
00:10:13 and it removes our opportunity to be productive. Uh, Corey, I've said to lots of people in the last
00:10:17 while, three of my good friends who have been, been successful here in Southern Alberta have all told me
00:10:24 in, in the last two or three months, they are moving their money out of Alberta, out of Canada.
00:10:29 And it's because of too much regulation and the fear of, of high taxes. Of course, you know, today
00:10:36 we're, we're social media, media, the fact that our CPP premiums are up substantially. Um, and of course,
00:10:44 Trudeau announced that about six months ago, Alberta was already sending 3 billion more and collecting
00:10:50 less to the rest of Canada. Now this is more money out of Alberta. This is more money out of families
00:10:55 and free enterprises pockets, uh, to a CPP fund that I understand if you start investing today, your
00:11:01 return might be 2.1%, uh, you know, 20 or 40 years from now. Uh, Corey, we, we lose a lot when money is
00:11:10 taken out of families, when money is taken out of free enterprise, when money is taken out of communities.
00:11:15 Um, and, and so that's one of the reasons we have to get it, get it in line, but you know, in Alberta,
00:11:22 the, the most often talked about thing is the fact that per capita, we spend 20% more per capita than,
00:11:28 than other big provinces like British Columbia and Ontario. Um, do we get value for that 20%? Uh,
00:11:35 a lot of the studies show we don't. And as a conservative, I believe in choice, let families
00:11:41 and communities keep more of their own money so they can decide where it goes.
00:11:44 Not so much appreciated. And that plays into something that is difficult. Your government
00:11:50 can't do much about, uh, in, in one sense is the Ottawa, that there's our big, uh, a problem and,
00:11:56 and hindrance. And now some of it's mixed. I've been very critical. I got to admit, I'm not too
00:12:00 thrilled. And I wasn't, and I did actually speak with premier Kenny on that a couple of months ago in
00:12:04 an interview with our tax dollars going into the Keystone line. Uh, I don't like seeing tax investment
00:12:10 in businesses. And unfortunately, as we see it, it tends to seem to blow up no matter what. It's
00:12:14 almost like it curses it. But I mean, part of our problem too. And a part of, uh, of premier
00:12:19 Kenny's response was that, well, Canada is so, uh, uneconomical right now, we can't get private
00:12:25 investment to get these projects done. Thus the government's forced to. So this is a huge problem,
00:12:30 though. I don't want government to keep getting into it. We've got to get government out of things.
00:12:34 And Ottawa has no interest in getting out of things. So we've struck the fair deal panel,
00:12:38 and there's been a number of recommendations. Uh, we're all getting kind of frustrated on
00:12:42 waiting to see some action on these. It seems that we talked to talk to come with a conclusion
00:12:45 to talk about some more and we're getting sick of talking. Uh, where do you think things are going
00:12:49 with, uh, some of that with, uh, the police force and such? Yeah. Thanks Corey. Uh, yeah. Like
00:12:54 corporate welfare government using your tax dollars, uh, the $1.5 billion that, uh, premier Kenny put into
00:13:02 the TC pipeline. Keystone is in great jeopardy now. Let's not forget that, uh, Rachel Notley and her
00:13:08 oil by rail, um, was another $2 billion loss that, uh, the NDP had just put us in. Let's not forget
00:13:16 that the progressive conservative started the sturgeon red water upgrader, which I think was
00:13:21 just a $5 billion right down on, on last year's budget. Uh, and some economists are estimating this
00:13:27 could be a $26 billion loss to Alberta families before it said and done. Corey, it doesn't work.
00:13:33 You're, you're, you're so right. Um, and then the fair deal panel, um, you know, like I was so
00:13:40 pleased that I had the opportunity to listen to hundreds of Albertans say what they said. And 80%
00:13:46 said we're not getting a fair deal and they want to take the risk. They have the courage to push Ottawa
00:13:53 for a fair deal. And, and I said, there has to be consequences and that consequences includes that
00:13:58 if Ottawa doesn't give us a fair deal someday, we have to have, have a referendum on independence.
00:14:04 Um, and at this point, you know, it's been a year since the fair deal. It's been 20 years since,
00:14:11 uh, Tom Flanagan, Ken Buzigal, Andy Crooks, uh, Steven Harper first penned the fair deal,
00:14:19 the firewall letter rather saying that we should have Alberta should build its own,
00:14:23 its own infrastructure, its own pension plan, its plan, its own police force,
00:14:27 its own tax collection, its own more, more control over immigration. And it just hasn't been done.
00:14:33 And, and it's time to push back. Um, I think Premier Kenny at this point has, has put out, uh,
00:14:39 applications for a chief firearms officer. That's a start. Corey, I think we should go one
00:14:44 further and let permit holders elect their chief firearms officer, somebody who will be directly
00:14:49 accountable to the needs and the wants and the ideas of Albertans. Um, we have a $2 million study
00:14:57 going on right now to look at our own police force. Uh, again, I, I understand that, uh, the cost of
00:15:03 policing, uh, through union negotiations and that kind of thing is about to rise substantially for the
00:15:09 RCMP. Uh, so if that's the case, that's going to make any subsidy we get from Ottawa and jeopardy.
00:15:16 Anyway, you know, my goodness, Corey, Ottawa's $430 billion deficit this year is going to put
00:15:21 everything in jeopardy. So, so, so let's Alberti be strong and rural crime. We could talk forever
00:15:27 about the problems of rural crime. Uh, I was in a community, uh, a year ago during the fair deal
00:15:33 and that night, 17 pickups were stolen, 17 pickups. Like, like, are you kidding me? Um, and anyway,
00:15:40 so, so that needs addressing that needs more accountability and more responsiveness to the
00:15:45 people of Alberta, which means the premier and the cabinet of Alberta. Um, yeah. So,
00:15:50 so we absolutely have to put Ottawa on notice that we need resource movement. Uh, and that includes
00:15:56 energy East that includes Northern gateway, uh, probably Eagle spirit. Uh, so, so we can be
00:16:02 productive and we can grow. Um, we need, uh, we need Ottawa to understand clearly that, uh, 25 billion a
00:16:10 year in transfers out of Alberta is not going to continue. We also need some constitutional changes.
00:16:15 Uh, the number of people that went to the mic during the fair deal, Corey, that are so frustrated
00:16:19 that we don't have a Senate that, that can counterbalance so frustrated that the elections
00:16:24 are decided long before Albertan votes are even counted. And, uh, we see it every day where the
00:16:30 liberals and the conservative party of Canada play to the, the bigger population bases in, in,
00:16:36 in Eastern Canada. And, and that's not how you protect individual rights. That's not how you
00:16:40 protect families and free enterprise. Yeah. Well, it's, it's a whole lot to unpack. And again,
00:16:47 I mean, we're, we're in agreement on it. So, I mean, I think, and I think most Albertans are in
00:16:50 agreement on it. What we're looking for now is we just want to see some actual movement on it.
00:16:55 Uh, I, I hope to see it. I, you've been an active voice, uh, inside and outside of caucus,
00:17:00 uh, trying to get the gears turning on this. I appreciate that and, and, uh, hope you, you carry on
00:17:06 with it. So, uh, where can people, uh, keep an eye on you and your activities outside of, you know,
00:17:10 just, uh, the direct channels of media there? Okay. Well, yeah, absolutely. Um, through,
00:17:15 through the social media, uh, through Facebook and Twitter, uh, through Instagram, uh, or you can
00:17:21 email me at any time at drew.barns at assembly.ab.ca. I I'd love to, to converse. I'd love to hear your
00:17:29 ideas to make Alberta the freest, most prosperous place in the whole world. We have the people,
00:17:35 we have the resources, you know, we're risk takers. We're, we're creative. Uh, we, we,
00:17:40 we can get that job done. Uh, there's a lot of work ahead, Corey, but, but as you're alluding to,
00:17:45 Albertans have been woken up like never before. Uh, Albertans know that nothing's going to change
00:17:50 unless it's pushed. And, um, every day I hear it in Alberta in Cyprus medicine hat that, uh, they're
00:17:57 more frustrated, but they're, they've risen to the challenge and, and they want change.
00:18:01 Great. Well, thank you very much, Drew. I hope we can, uh, check in again down the road here and
00:18:07 have another talk and, uh, maybe we'll have some, uh, progress updates to report at that time and see
00:18:12 how things are going. Sounds great, Corey. Thank you very much. I appreciate it. Thanks.