A new petition to recall Calgary Mayor Jody Gondek has been launched, but it's unlikely to get enough signatures to get her on the ballot. What will it take to invoke the Recall Act? And will it be enough?
00:01:30.400Again, I mean, Alberta's energy rich, yet we seem to have energy shortages.
00:01:34.460Alberta's energy rich, yet I paid far less for my fuel while I was driving through the states, even after exchange was put into account, than I pay in Alberta.
00:01:42.160I should talk about some of these things, because I don't think we're doing a real good job with energy up here.
00:01:46.800Of course, I'll have my news check-ins and other things going as well.
00:01:50.100So I see some of the commenters there, Tom Hamilton already in there saying, we're going to talk about the recall process.
00:01:55.080And he's saying it was written by politicians for politicians to give the appearance of, you know, accountability.
00:02:13.380So let's talk about recall, because it's come up in news in Alberta, quite a bit in Calgary, due to a new petition to recall Mayor Gondek.
00:02:24.840I've always been a strong supporter of direct democracy through citizens-initiated referenda and accountability through citizen-led recall initiatives.
00:02:33.420And Calgary Mayor Jody Gondek is the worst mayor in living memory.
00:02:37.540She's only halfway through her first term in office, and she's that bad.
00:02:42.700As voters have realized, Gondek wasn't who she purported to be when she ran for the job.
00:02:47.740And we're seeing massive buyer's remorse as Gondek lurches from one disaster to another, offending people left and right, while taxes continue to rise.
00:02:56.100Polls are reflecting a very strong majority of Calgarians want the chance to fire Gondek as soon as possible.
00:03:02.120But with all that said, the current recall initiative launched against Jody Gondek is doomed to fail and may actually, unintentionally, even help her.
00:03:11.260I mean, to begin with, the bar to recall a civic politician is impossibly high.
00:03:16.900You need over 514,000 signatures from eligible Calgarian voters, and they need to be collected in 60 days to invoke the recall.
00:03:24.840Anybody who actually thinks this is possible has never actually done real petitioning.
00:03:29.120It's a slow process and takes a lot of work.
00:03:31.820To garner half a million signatures in two months would take a massive organizational machine that just doesn't exist out there.
00:03:38.740You've got to remember, these signatures required aren't digital.
00:03:40.840They have to be handwritten and witnessed on an official petition sheet with a name, address, and phone number of the person signing so the signature can be verified later.
00:03:49.860A lot of people aren't going to be comfortable sharing that information with a petitioner, even if they support the cause.
00:03:55.360Many signatures garnered as well are going to be rejected later because the name or the address might not be legible or the person's residency couldn't be confirmed with the electors' lists.
00:04:03.780The petitions you see are checked when they're submitted.
00:04:05.440That means the real number required, if you were going to be realistic, would actually be more like 550, 560,000 signatures.
00:04:10.740Now, a hardworking, effective petitioner going door-to-door, a really good one, could get perhaps 100 signatures a day.
00:04:19.560It would take nearly 100 people working full-time hours, seven days a week for two months, assuming all those 500 and some thousand are existing out there, to round up the required signatures in time.
00:04:30.080Coordinating that many workers would require management personnel, transportation, some kind of office to ensure they aren't overlapping territory.
00:04:35.960They'd need to track where they've been to do second and third rounds in neighborhoods to catch the people who weren't home the first time.
00:04:43.140Petitioning in public places like malls, events, transit stations, it could be effective, but it won't be enough.
00:04:48.980So to put it in perspective, only 390,000 people even bothered to vote in the last mayoral race.
00:04:54.500Even if 100% of those people were now opposed to Gondek, you'd still need more than 100,000 on top of all that to sign the petition, and you've got to find them to make the recall work.
00:05:07.840The legislation guiding citizen-initiated referenda isn't much better.
00:05:12.340The creation of the Recall Act was the final straw, actually, for me when it came to supporting former Premier Jason Kenney.
00:05:16.740I used to be a strong supporter of his, but that was a cynical nod to those who voted for him based on his campaign of accountability and citizen empowerment.
00:05:24.940Kenney promised recall and referendum legislation to Albertans, and he purposely crafted the legislation to make it useless and impossible to invoke, as we're seeing today.
00:05:34.380He misled people when he promised that legislation.
00:05:36.980He had no interest in letting citizens hold their elected officials to account, but he didn't hesitate to promise that to win the votes in the first place.
00:05:44.300I just, I despise that kind of bait-and-switch type of politics.
00:05:47.100Either support citizens' referenda or don't, but to give this garbage legislation to us was a slap in the face of the supporters.
00:05:53.580So the people behind the petition to recall Gondek, I mean, they're well-meaning, that fellow who's gotten that going, and I don't doubt I agree with them on almost everything, probably.
00:06:02.600But the efforts would be better spent putting pressure on UCP MLAs to fix the broken recall legislation.
00:06:16.100Further, when the petition fails, and it will, Gondek and her few supporters are going to claim it's because Calgarians actually support her.
00:06:23.060It'll be actually a public relations win for the mayor, who really hasn't earned a win in her entire time in office.
00:06:29.320Also, those who signed or worked on gathering the signatures for the petition, they're going to have built up cynicism and apathy, and it's going to entrench it more.
00:06:37.640They're going to feel like it was a wasted effort.
00:06:39.100And they're going to be less inclined to participate in democratic exercises in the future, even if the legislation gets fixed.
00:06:45.420Look, I hate crapping on good grassroots efforts made by citizens.
00:06:48.820We need to see more of it, and I admire the gumption among those who have gotten the petition to recall Gondek going.
00:06:53.720I've got to call it as I see it, however, and it's an initiative that won't lead to a productive outcome.
00:06:58.900I hope the folks involved redirect their efforts to helping Albertans get the legislation they need.
00:07:03.680Then they can, and I can, get fully behind those recall efforts against those politicians that have earned those efforts.
00:07:09.680Until then, though, they're just wasting good shoe leather going out there getting signatures for something that's just not going to change.
00:07:16.000So, either way, sorry to, you know, poop on the parade, guys, but it's just not going to go anywhere.
00:07:21.700All right, let's see what else is going on out there and check in with Mr. Naylor in the newsroom.
00:08:12.840We've had a really busy morning out here in the newsroom, Corey.
00:08:15.620We've got probably about 15 news stories up already.
00:08:19.540Right now we're leading off with a reaction on Conservative leader Pierre Polyev has finally commented on the transgender policy that Alberta is bringing in.
00:08:30.360And he says he is also against giving puberty blockers to children, says they should wait until they're adults.
00:08:38.400We got some more facts and figures from StatsCan on just the massive number of people moving to Alberta, mainly from Ontario and B.C. to escape their tax regimes.
00:08:49.64045,000 people have moved to Alberta recently.
00:09:08.120They don't get paid a lot to begin with.
00:09:09.640A $450 a month rent increase is a horrible thing to put them through.
00:09:16.240We've got our columnist Jaime Rubenstein talking about the ousted B.C. Cabinet Minister who was forced to quit this week.
00:09:25.560And we've got a Liberal MP, the Justice Minister, the Federal Justice Minister, apologised for calling Pierre Polyev a very, very bad word in the House of Commons.
00:09:41.560And we've got my two favourite stories of the day are already being punched down the list a bit because of all the other stuff.
00:09:48.940All those killer whales trapped in the ice in Japan, there was about 12 or 13 of them.
00:09:54.680Some heartbreaking footage yesterday of them all trying to squeeze in this little maybe 10-foot square hole in the ice.
00:10:01.780But it turns out they have managed to escape and now appear to be swimming free.
00:10:08.100And the Criminal Genius of the Year award goes to an alleged Calgary drug dealer who was handing out his business cards with free little baggies of cocaine attached.
00:10:20.740Free samples of cocaine for whoever wanted it.
00:10:25.000Needless to say, it didn't take Calgary police long to investigate and find him with a whole bunch of drugs.
00:10:31.420And he now got a laundry list of charges.
00:10:34.840So criminal minds at their best there, Corey.
00:11:27.180So, yeah, that is our news editor, Dave Naylor.
00:11:30.940I see lots of stories always breaking.
00:11:32.940This is what I like to remind and nag everybody.
00:11:35.080The reason we can do it, the reason we've got these stories coming up, the reason we're sending reporters all over the place is because you guys have subscribed.
00:11:41.420We don't take any government cash, guys.
00:11:54.520You know, just like an old newspaper subscription will get you past the paywall and allows us to keep producing these shows and writing those stories that we know the legacy media isn't going to give them to you.
00:12:02.900And, yes, it's going to be good to have feet on the ground in Edmonton at the legislature.
00:12:06.660We've got an office actually in there.
00:12:08.280We are, you know, an accredited outlet.
00:12:10.160Arthur Green used to be up there, but he got snatched away.
00:12:15.480So there's going to be a lot of fantastic legislative coverage coming out of Edmonton, plus our reporters all over the country and columnists.
00:12:23.880So, yeah, quite a bit on the go, guys, and lots to keep me busy.
00:12:28.520So just to get back a bit to that recall again.
00:12:31.580Yeah, the fellow, and I want to give him credit.
00:12:46.980And, hey, you know what, if he proves me wrong and gets hundreds of thousands of signatures and even manages to, you know, come close to invoking the referendum, I'll eat the words.
00:12:57.500But, you know, there's things we could be doing if you want to change things in the meantime.
00:13:02.980I mean, that legislation needs to be fixed.
00:13:04.400I think email, phone, nag your MLA and Premier Smith.
00:14:00.440What you want to do, what you could do then if you've got those volunteers, get out there and do voter ID.
00:14:05.700Go door to door and find out who is really strongly determined to replace Jody Gondek and get that and list it and database it.
00:14:13.760You see, the recall petition, you can't use that for anything else.
00:14:17.680You can't take those names and numbers.
00:14:19.100And that's what Gondek's already implying.
00:14:20.620She's implying that the data is going to be shared because that will make people scared to sign as well, scared to commit their name to this initiative and things like that.
00:14:28.260And, you know, and you're not supposed to use it for anything else, which is fair, right?
00:14:32.280A person didn't sign to be spammed by other initiatives or things like that.
00:14:36.500They signed that petition with the intent of getting a recall on the go.
00:14:40.120But you can go, nothing is stopping you from going door to door and doing voter ID.
00:14:45.580As Daryl, one of the commenters saying, voter turnout is barely breaking 30 to 50% of eligible voters.
00:24:59.020It's going to go up 10 cents a liter plus, more or less, because I can't determine how much a gas retailer is going to charge as far as their margin is concerned.
00:25:13.520No, certainly none of the mainstream media took interest in it until it actually happened, at which point I got one, and you're the second media that's actually called me on it.
00:25:21.460And I suspect that they probably don't want to hear the fact is that we're paying a lot more than we ought to because the federal government has destroyed the, in many respects, scuppered the value of the Canadian dollar.
00:25:31.500That's adding 20 cents a liter of gasoline.
00:25:33.800Of course, the carbon tax at 14.31 cents a liter.
00:25:36.880So between the two of them, that's an extra 30, 35 cents a liter.
00:25:39.660I don't think a lot of people would be complaining if we're paying a buck a liter.
00:25:55.020Electricity went down, caused some damage, and that caused a short temporary supply problem, if you will, on the gasoline side.
00:26:04.100We're still going to see another 2 cent wholesale price increase come tomorrow.
00:26:08.040Diesel, we're still not out of the woods yet.
00:26:09.740That jumped 5 cents a liter, which you'll see at most gas stations, eventually passed on, whether you're in Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Alberta, or B.C.'s interior.
00:26:29.300But sometimes you can see that coming down the pipe, and maybe you can kind of stock up a little and save a few bucks because budgets are tight right now for most people.
00:26:36.200I mean, these are not the best of times.
00:26:38.000And that was something frustrating when I crossed the border into the States as well.
00:26:42.140I mean, I was driving through Arizona that, you know, has next to nothing for oil and gas resources.
00:26:49.840Yet, even with the bad Canadian dollar, when I would do the conversion, I was still paying a good 20 to 30 cents a liter less for fuel there than I do in Alberta when I can see an oil pump every time I look to the left or the right.
00:27:00.200Yeah, look, a couple of things to keep in mind, and that's the big one, because as a country, we've accepted the blocking of pipelines as policies and frustrating our resources from getting to the market.
00:27:10.760No one wants to buy Canadian dollars, nothing to trade with.
00:27:16.840Of course, we're talking about housing, and we know that there's a lot of questions now emerging as to how the housing bubble occurred.
00:27:22.500But beyond that, the real danger in Canada is the fact that we don't have a lot of interest in what we have, and therefore currency takes a beating.