Corey rants about Bill C-18 and the state of Canadian media and the mess the federal government is making with it. Plus, a look at the alarming decline in Indigenous life expectancy across the country and why we should all be worried.
00:00:30.000Good day. Welcome to the Corey Morgan Show. This is my weekly platform to rant, rave, read out some new stories and check in with thought leaders and opinion creators from across the country. As you probably might notice, I'm dressed a little differently than usual. It's Stampede Week in Calgary. Viewers outside of Calgary might not know this, but most probably do. This is when we take advantage of this event to be able to cosplay for a week and pretend to be cowboy.
00:01:00.000It gets me out of having to wear the old outfits and everything. Nico's made a great Stampede background there and it's been going really well in Calgary this year. Really good Stampede. A lot of people out having a good time.
00:01:11.940And yeah, I know. We were on the Cowboy Network, RFD TV, other spots, and you guys, come on. It's the nerve of this guy trying to dress up like that as this caricature of a cowboy. Oh, come on. Let us have our fun. Hey, I am an Alberta boy and I've been near cows before.
00:01:26.660So, it's as close as it gets. Okay, I got a good show today, as always, I think. But we've got a former CRTC chair and newspaper executive Peter Menzies on.
00:01:35.820We're going to talk some more about Bill C-18 and just the state of Canadian media and the mess that the federal government's making with it.
00:01:43.560And of course, there'll be the check-in with Mr. Naylor and lots of other things coming along.
00:01:48.160But I'm going to start out with what's got me wound up today. And I saw, you know, some numbers that came out recently from Alberta Health Services.
00:01:55.860And the numbers are shocking. So, the life expectancy for an Indigenous man in Alberta is now plummeted down to 60 years of age.
00:02:04.100And for Indigenous women, it's down to 66. So, if you want to see the comparison of what that means,
00:02:08.700the national life expectancy for a non-Indigenous man in Canada is 80 and women, 84.
00:02:13.640And the story across the country isn't any different with Indigenous populations. It's just a matter of give and take a couple of years.
00:02:20.920And this issue hasn't garnered the headlines it should have, because it forces people to face a reality they'd rather avoid.
00:02:27.380Canada's system and policies with Indigenous people, it's a complete catastrophe.
00:02:33.200And how bad does it have to get before people admit this?
00:02:37.560Think about that. Indigenous Canadians can expect to die 20 years before everybody else.
00:07:32.800Racial policies and segregation needs to be phased out.
00:07:36.060And the best thing that could happen for Indigenous Canadians suffering under the mess we have right now, this is the best thing we could do.
00:07:41.600If one really did actually hate Indigenous people, I can think of a few things more terrible that can be done than to maintain the current system.
00:07:48.860We can't repair damage caused through race-based policy through applying even more race-based policies.
00:07:55.460Anyway, guys, it's time to start talking about it, frankly.
00:08:05.200If you really do care for Canada's Indigenous people, it's time for some courageous, frank discussion on changing the entire system, and significantly.
00:08:13.060And it's awful to watch it keep carrying on as it has been.
00:08:15.280All right, that's what's got me wound up today.
00:08:18.100But let's see what else there is to get wound up with and check in with our news editor, Dave Naylor.
00:11:36.880And labor organizers are telling the prime minister he better not get involved.
00:11:42.700So, while all the other premiers have got together, basically, and said, you know, get parliament back and order them back to work, the labor types don't want anything to do with that.
00:11:53.060So, those are the highlights up at the moment, Corey.
00:11:56.840There's a lot more to come this afternoon.
00:11:59.220And I guess we'll see you on the pipeline tonight.
00:12:12.640This is what I'd like to remind everybody the reason we've got all those stories.
00:12:15.520We've got those reporters, whether it's Jonathan and his skill with the bull testicles, or Arthur Green reporting on, yeah, the crazy crime rate in Edmonton.
00:12:26.300It's because you guys have been subscribing.
00:12:27.760So, please, please, if you haven't already, get on there, westernstandard.news slash membership.
00:12:44.960If you've subscribed already, thank you very much.
00:12:47.640And if you haven't subscribed yet, come on, $9.99 a month, $100 a year, you get past that paywall, get in there, and just keeps things rolling like this show and our reporters going all over.
00:12:59.080Yeah, that has been, I'll just, you know, sidetrack a little bit before we get to our guests.
00:13:03.180We're going to talk some media stuff here in a few minutes here.
00:13:06.060Arthur Green, yeah, he's the friend of our copy editors in a big way here at the Western Standard.
00:13:11.060Very prolific writer, but one of the things he's been covering a lot of in Edmonton has been the crime that's up there.
00:13:16.900I mean, we're seeing it in every city, and there just seems to be a wave hitting up there right now.
00:13:22.420And at the same time, rather than dealing with these things, though, rather than admitting what's going on, these progressive city councils, we have it in Calgary as well, just, they're in this world of denial.
00:15:48.060So, I mean, most of my listeners are pretty aware due to many repeated rants out of me and what C-18 is.
00:15:53.160But perhaps if you could run down in a nutshell what that bill is about and where it's been.
00:15:58.320Yeah, it's an effort to redistribute advertising income earned by social media and platforms and search engines to newspapers and other news organizations, qualified ones that have been making the case.
00:16:39.060But, I mean, I guess maybe we'll talk a little more, though, I mean, into the I would consider it as a libertarian, more of a devil's advocate point of view.
00:16:47.320But, I mean, you've seen the decline of revenue and ability in the media industry.
00:16:51.620You know, I mean, it's been dramatic this last 10 years.
00:16:53.540And it's a people will call it a problem that needs to be solved, whether or not the government should intervene to do so or not.
00:17:05.520Yeah, I mean, I guess there's a couple of arguments there.
00:17:08.540News is certainly at risk because it's a time of disruption, right?
00:17:11.920But times of disruption tend to sort the men from the boys in these kinds of things.
00:17:16.420So the companies that are well-equipped intellectually and willing to invest in their product tend to find their ways through these things.
00:17:25.200Companies that aren't tend to struggle more.
00:17:29.360I mean, it's going to be a struggle for everybody, but some make it and some don't.
00:18:11.160And so, you know, and yet at the same time, through the Internet, we have access probably to more news than we've ever had before.
00:18:21.000Yeah, and I guess there's what the one of the bigger risks with the government getting in this way, particularly with C-18, is it'll stunt the evolution of outlets.
00:18:30.940I mean, it doesn't give them that incentive then to change or be innovative or try new models.
00:18:35.000And it also strangles the little ones like us or the ones that may not qualify as the government's going to pick and choose who is a qualified outlet and who isn't.
00:18:44.320Well, it's actually got worse than that.
00:18:46.260I hate to break it to you, but this week it appeared like the government was sort of backing down.
00:18:52.420And it is because I think I think Meta, Facebook and Instagram, unless something dramatic changes, they're gone for good.
00:19:00.980They're out of the business in Canada, everywhere.
00:19:22.740But what they've done is they've changed from a per links, which was really problem sort of way of charging people, charging the social media, the web giants,
00:19:31.800to sort of putting a cap on it, making a calculation.
00:19:35.700And then the big thing problem for guys like you is that they're really restricting the number of people to whom they may have to distribute money.
00:19:45.280So I still think it's a long shot that any money gets distributed through this.
00:19:49.220But if it does, here's who it's going to Videotron Bell, the CBC, probably the biggest, probably the biggest bunch.
00:19:57.860Rogers, you know, maybe Black Press might be the biggest one that gets out of there.
00:20:03.900But innovators, startups, entrepreneurs like Western Standard, Black Locks, Halifax Examiner, you know, Narwhal, they're on the left, they're on the right.
00:20:40.060I don't know if they'll get rid of us that easily.
00:20:41.500Well, that's where you need, you know, like you gave a little pitch there.
00:20:43.880That's where you need your readers, your readers support, you know, like if, if, if, and that's really the thing that people are going to have to get their heads around.
00:20:51.180If they want the sort of content they're looking for, if they want local product, if they want, right now you have the only online newsroom in, in, in, in Alberta, I think, other than the CBC, in terms, in terms of doing that.
00:21:07.200There's no Calvary Herald, no Calvary Sun, no Edmonton Journal, no Edmonton Sun newsroom that I'm aware of.
00:21:12.740If people want that, it's 10 bucks a month.
00:21:20.360If they're not willing to put that forward, they'll lose.
00:21:23.560I try to, you know, remind people, at least those of us in a vintage, remember, we never thought twice of spending that much or more to have the paper boy bring that to us, to our household every day.
00:21:34.660You know, for that sort of price, you can get the same thing.
00:21:37.120And I'm hoping Canadian consumers learn to adapt that way.
00:21:39.760They realize it's a product to pay for.
00:21:41.420And a lot of our subscribers have so far, it just, just takes some time.
00:21:44.860Yeah, and you know, you don't need to get everybody, you just need to get enough, right?
00:21:48.720I mean, that's, that's basically the, the, the way that needs to go.
00:21:52.400And I mean, the Globe and Mail has, you know, really shuttered down with the, with the paywall and that sort of stuff.
00:21:59.120And all the other papers I mentioned have done that.
00:22:01.640But you got to have the quality, you got to have the value proposition, right?
00:22:04.900So, you know, you guys are doing a good job on that and others are too.
00:22:08.540But, you know, some, I mean, it's, it's very difficult, you know, I don't like calling names out, but it's very difficult for a post media product these days to make a value proposition.
00:22:20.040Half of it is not, you know, half of your local paper is the National Post.
00:22:26.260So why would you buy your local paper when really, I mean, school board doesn't get covered, city council get covered, courts, now and then, right?
00:22:39.000So, I mean, do you think maybe though, I mean, the government backed down a little bit.
00:22:42.780And as you sort of point out, the government really doesn't have the leverage they pretend to have or think they have with the social media giants.
00:22:49.680I mean, it was 3% of the content they provided.
00:22:52.380I can't see Facebook and Google back and down.
00:22:54.840People keep saying, well, that happened in Australia.
00:22:56.380But I think that just says all the more, they're not letting that precedent get set because every country with a greedy government is going to come in and try and snatch some from them in the future.
00:23:04.480So, I mean, do you think the government will swallow some pride maybe and just get this bill or are they just going to keep on this standoff and no news gets provided on those giants at all?
00:23:51.720But they also found that they were probably going to be insulted whether they made a philanthropic decision and said, okay, we'll help anyway.
00:23:58.700Because let's face it, none of them set out to kill newspapers or to kill news products, right, in terms of that.
00:24:04.520So, what they're trying to do now is salvage some sort of deal with Google, which will put a cap on it.
00:24:12.060And right now, my understanding is there's a huge difference between what News Media Canada and some of the other lobby groups lobbying for the loot are expecting and what Google's willing to pay.
00:24:27.940So, you know, the best case scenario, this ends up with them making some kind of deal with Google, who then get exempted from the act.
00:24:35.540And then they maybe never even bother bringing the act into force, which allows Facebook Meta to still carry news, which they might decide to get it.
00:24:44.840They might decide to get out of the business anyway.
00:24:46.680Or, as it stands, they don't get any deal with Google.
00:24:53.680And as it stands, they're not going to get one, near as I can tell.
00:24:57.720And we play this drama out through the fall.
00:25:01.420And then we'll see what probably the best case scenario for everybody is that the government amends Bill C-18 so that the coming into force date just gets extended into eternity.
00:25:15.120And you just kind of – nobody, they don't withdraw the act.
00:25:29.360And it's been – I wrote on it recently – a difficult environment for established journalists.
00:25:35.340They put in their time and everything.
00:25:37.060And then, you know, there just isn't the demand for their product as there used to be.
00:25:42.000But, I mean, I see it as almost – some of the outlets are really jumping on the government bandwagon.
00:25:48.100I think Post Media has said they're going to stop advertising on Facebook and the shots go back and forth.
00:25:53.480But it feels – it's just sad to see such large institutions getting down to that rather than seeking changes in their ways to try and get out of the soup they're in.
00:26:43.940They've got elderly parents to care for.
00:26:45.720They've got all those things that everybody else does.
00:26:47.680So, it's not like, you know, we shouldn't empathize with their predicament.
00:26:52.340And I can understand their despair and their desperation in terms of that.
00:26:57.420But news, there hasn't ever been a great deal of money in news.
00:27:02.000The fact of the matter is those big old newspapers like the one I used to run, it wasn't just the news that people bought it for, right?
00:27:09.900It's like those were the days when if you wanted to rent an apartment, you had to buy the paper.
00:27:13.660If you wanted to, you know, sell your car, you had to put an ad in the paper.
00:27:19.500And if you wanted to buy a car, you had to buy the paper.
00:27:21.700If you wanted to do virtually anything, if you want to find out who had a kid, who had the births, deaths, whose daughter got engaged, who got married, whose grandma died, you had to buy the newspaper.
00:27:32.060If you wanted to see the comics, the horoscope, that sort of stuff.
00:27:35.500I mean, I got back in the day when Catherine Ford and Peter Stockland were both writing on the Calgary Herald editorial pages, and everybody thought this was great controversy.
00:27:49.040The fact of the matter is, though, I got more phone calls when the Canadian Tire Flyer wasn't delivered to somebody's door on a Thursday morning than over anything Peter Stockland or Catherine Ford ever said.
00:28:00.620Well, yeah, I mean, it's the world has changed so dramatically.
00:28:03.100I mean, it's good to remind everybody it was just such an it was a need.
00:28:06.840It was an integral pipeline to information that you couldn't go without it.
00:28:11.940But those days, the Internet products that really killed newspapers, it's not so much Facebook.
00:28:17.240I mean, Facebook didn't start making money until 2012.
00:28:39.940All of a sudden, something you're, you know, like a product like the Globe and Mail, if you wanted to rent an apartment, it cost you 80 bucks to put a classified ad in.
00:36:19.660So, and speaking of some of the fun, kind of tying in with everything else we've got going on with the crime I was talking about that Arthur Green writes about quite often and things like that.
00:36:46.500So, yeah, Calgary's downtown, as I said, we've got some serious, serious crime challenges right now.
00:36:52.640I think the reason we're not hearing about a lot of them right now is that, you know, the Stampede is overwhelming everything with news coverage.
00:37:00.720When we were sitting there, it was at least six ambulances went by on 10th Avenue where we were down there, enjoying ourselves on the patio, having a fun time.
00:37:09.860And we know the majority of that was for overdoses.
00:37:11.840There's no easy solutions, but we've really got to address those things and quit kicking the ball down the road and can down the road and trying to procrastinate with it.
00:37:20.380But in Calgary, they're coming up with even more stupid things.
00:37:23.620There's always room for municipal politicians to come up with stupid.
00:37:27.180And, you know, everybody in just about every city can nod their head because they know they've seen idiotic, anti-automotive policies like this come up.
00:41:59.760It's also got loads of for lease signs because the city won't stop the social disorder and nightmare that's going on there.
00:42:04.720And they've throttled all the parking so badly that people don't come down there to visit those businesses because it costs too bloody much.
00:42:11.780Either way, the whole bottom line of what I'm getting to is we see this everywhere.
00:42:16.460But the part of having these progressives winning these civic elections, the problem isn't that they're winning.
00:42:24.500It's that they're winning because only 20, 30, at tops, 40% of people are bothering to get off their butts and vote in municipal elections.
00:43:23.400So could be Edmonton, Saskatoon, Winnipeg.
00:43:27.720But we've got to apply common sense to these cities, not try to be something else.
00:43:31.400Take what you are, take your strengths, expand on them.
00:43:34.220One of your strengths should be common sense on the part of the voters, meaning they're not going to vote for these twits any longer.
00:43:39.620You're going to bring in people who are going to actually represent you.
00:43:43.300You're going to bring in people who want to make your place better, not rip it down and build it into some crazed globalist hipster model that they have in their mind.
00:44:19.760And unless they change, well, that's a separate discussion.
00:44:23.760Unless we change our climate dramatically enough, we're not going to see a large demand for year-round bicycle infrastructure in these major cities.
00:44:33.100But now I've seen, you know, maybe there's some benefits to global warming if it's coming along.
00:44:37.780If you guys really want to generate support for your bike lanes to expand and have people riding their bicycles around in February, January, then we should be warming up the earth faster.
00:44:50.940That's the only way it's going to happen.
00:44:52.440Then, I'll ride a bike downtown in February if it's 20 above.
00:44:57.700But I'm going to have to burn a heck of a lot more coal and wood to get there, I guess.
00:45:05.880But I mean, yes, that case, you know, where's the common sense?
00:45:10.820Especially when it comes to the crime, the enablement.
00:45:13.320And we're seeing our cities getting worse and worse in our centers.
00:45:15.940Look to the entire West Coast because that's where the imbeciles and city councils seem to look for inspiration.
00:45:20.700Look to what San Francisco, Portland, Vancouver have done with enablement of crime of every kind, whether it's drug-based or even shoplifting and theft.
00:45:29.360It's turned every one of those cities into uninhabitable crap holes downtown.
00:46:58.900If they were giving me shots of whiskey when I'd go to all my AA meetings, I'd probably still be a drunkard today and probably wouldn't even have a job.
00:47:06.700I'll be back to my normal outfit and ranting and raving about all sorts of other things next week at this time.
00:47:12.080So thanks for tuning in, and we will see you then.
00:47:13.980The current Lethbridge feed grain prices read as follows.
00:47:19.900Cash barley is at $4.28, feed wheat is at $4.18, and corn is down $3 at $3.90 per metric ton.
00:47:26.880In the milling wheat markets, September Minneapolis futures lost $0.15 at $8.49, with local hard red spring bids for July movement at $9.75 per bushel.
00:47:36.820In the oilseeds, nearby canola futures increased $11.20 at $7.98.30 per ton, with delivered values for August movement at $18.33 per bushel.
00:47:48.860In the pulse markets, nearby red lentils are trading at $0.34 a pound, and yellow peas remain at $11.50 per bushel.
00:47:56.120In the cattle markets, August slide cattle are down $0.22 at $1.78.60 per 100 weight.
00:48:02.020For more information on grain marketing, call me at 403-394-1711.
00:48:08.320I'm Sean Smith at Marketplace Commodities, accurate real-time marketing information and pricing options.