Western Standard - November 21, 2026


Could this bill let you legally kill a home invader? MP Sandra Cobena responds

Carney Talks Energy—But Where Are the Pipelines?

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

139.4

Word count

2,517

Sentence count

37


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 so you've got a mother who's woken up in the middle of the night right her children are down
00:00:06 the hall she hears somebody breaking in she's got mere seconds to make a decision
00:00:14 where are my children and i need to protect them if the intruder
00:00:22 is there they have entered force themselves in knowingly and unlawfully and the mother shoots
00:00:29 to defend herself and kills the intruder so uses lethal force that it is presumed to be reasonable
00:00:50 i'm going with conservative mp from aurora newmarket sandra cabina to discuss her bill
00:00:55 c 270 the stand on guard act sandra tell me why are you delivering this bill and what exactly
00:01:01 are you trying to accomplish with it thank you yes so the standard guard act is my private
00:01:07 member's bill and essentially creates the presumption that a homeowner when they are
00:01:15 awakened in the middle of the night by a home invader a criminal that comes into their home
00:01:21 knowingly and unlawfully. The force that they use to defend themselves and their family is deemed
00:01:26 to be reasonable. And this is a bill that has been long coming. We've seen the home invasions
00:01:37 and crime as a whole increase over the last few years in Canada. But we have also seen a number
00:01:44 of cases where you have a homeowner who chooses to defend themselves from an intruder and they
00:01:52 are the ones with charges and drag through the justice system and they have to spend not only
00:01:59 time but also money defending themselves because there's legal costs and so on and so forth only
00:02:07 to prove that they were in fact uh defending themselves uh and so this this um uh bill
00:02:18 provides that clarity that it is presumed to be reasonable that a homeowner in defending
00:02:26 themselves from an illegal uh intruder is acting reasonably and that reasonableness is presumed
00:02:34 up front okay so ultimately that comes down to the homeowner or to a judge
00:02:41 so the reasonable test is there so the judge still has to review evidence right evidence
00:02:47 still matters but the clarity up front uh to the judges the prosecutors and police
00:02:54 that the homeowner is using force and it is deemed to be or presumed to be reasonable
00:03:01 that is what the law clarifies. So under your bill could a homeowner illegally
00:03:08 shoot and kill someone for invading their home that hasn't threatened or attacked them but has
00:03:14 intruded on their private property? So let's use an example for that so you've got a mother who's
00:03:21 woken up in the middle of the night right her children are down the hall she hears somebody
00:03:27 breaking in she's got mere seconds to make a decision where are my children and i need to
00:03:35 protect them if the intruder uh is there they have entered force themselves in knowingly and
00:03:46 unlawfully and the mother shoots to defend herself and kills the intruder so uses lethal force
00:03:55 that it is prison to be reasonable so if someone breaks into a house again another example here
00:04:02 steal something then tries to run away would your bill connect a homeowner who suits them
00:04:07 while they're fleeing the scene yes so when the when the uh intruder has entered the home okay
00:04:16 so that's that's the presumption uh once they have entered the home knowingly and unlawfully
00:04:23 if the homeowner, in an effort to defend themselves, shoots and kills the intruder,
00:04:31 the presumption is that they acted reasonably. Of course, again, the reasonable test is there,
00:04:39 there's evidence to be collected by police, the judge will be, and the prosecutors will be
00:04:47 reviewing that evidence but of course if you think about it when the homeowner has to react
00:04:57 right in the middle of the night for instance they have mere seconds to make a decision
00:05:03 a life or death decision for them the police the prosecutors will have
00:05:11 have hours in the middle of a calm day to review evidence and to consider the reasonableness
00:05:23 of all the actions. But what the bill does is it provides that clarity to a homeowner
00:05:34 That if they are awakened in the middle of the night and they need to defend themselves, they should be defending themselves.
00:05:45 They can defend themselves.
00:05:47 And particularly within the home, right?
00:05:50 Because this bill applies strictly to the home.
00:05:55 Because, of course, that's when we are most vulnerable.
00:05:59 It is not the same as a park.
00:06:01 It's not the same as a bar.
00:06:02 is not the same as a commercial property even it is a home so within your home you do what you need
00:06:10 to in that moment to defend yourself and your family i'm not sure if you're aware but i mean
00:06:18 within the cultural element when i hear self-defense coming from your end in this context
00:06:21 i'm also i'm drawn to think about the american castle doctrine and i understand that there are
00:06:26 cultural differences between both societies i know obviously as well legal differences that
00:06:31 exist in paper today. Um, but there was once, I think it was probably a few years back when the
00:06:37 Toronto police, um, official told the public, uh, in Toronto, there was the time where probably the
00:06:43 height of the auto theft, uh, you know, trend, I would think it was 2022, uh, when a lot of people
00:06:50 were just losing their SUVs in the GTA. And, uh, you know, the Toronto police official said that
00:06:55 people should leave their key fobs near the door to avoid confrontations. And of course, uh,
00:07:01 You know, some Canadians on social media specifically on conservative social media circles would often post that clip side by side with a clip from, I think it was a Florida police chief or sheriff who mentioned that they would appreciate if homeowners would shoot the intruders because that would make their job a lot easier.
00:07:18 In the unlikely event that you find yourself the victim of a home invasion, we are urging citizens not to take matters into their own hands.
00:07:25 While we don't want homeowners to feel powerless, we urge you to call 911 and do everything you can to keep yourself and loved ones safe until police arrive and be the best witness possible.
00:07:37 As to the person, we don't know which homeowner shot at him. I guess they think that they did something wrong, which they did not.
00:07:46 If somebody's breaking into your house, you're more than welcome to shoot them in Santa Rosa County. We prefer that you do, actually.
00:07:50 so whoever that was you're not in trouble come see us we have a gun safety class we put on every
00:07:58 other saturday and if you take that you'll shoot a lot better and hopefully you'll save the
00:08:03 taxpayers money and of course there's a great discrepancy rhetorically between police advice
00:08:08 and also between the law and between a few other things but also the culture at the end of the day
00:08:12 canadians do have a different system of governance a different system of law and a different culture
00:08:17 that adapts to those differences so i'm asking you relative to the american castle doctrine
00:08:25 what discrepancies exist with what you're trying to push for if if any and what do you want
00:08:29 canadians to know in terms of any differences in that and you know across the border that you
00:08:34 would be still retaining that's an excellent question so castle law in the u.s does not have
00:08:43 the reasonableness test okay and so in Canada we have it it will remain to be there the reasonableness
00:08:57 within my bill that reasonableness is presumed up front and essentially that is there because it
00:09:06 would prevent homeowners from having to go through the justice system and the delays and
00:09:15 charges being pressed, even if they're eventually dropped. We have that case where we have a
00:09:22 Canadian who defended himself. He ended up in jail for six months. The charges were not dropped
00:09:29 until two years later he had received uh uh eviction notice so he lost his his uh his home
00:09:38 in the meantime and you know the charges were dropped he he he was able to prove that he had
00:09:45 uh just been defending himself but there is a cost to whom the homeowner and he did nothing
00:09:51 nothing wrong he was in his home and he was attacked again to go back to your question
00:09:57 the difference is that reasonableness right like the presumption within canadian law can still be
00:10:04 rebutted in the u.s there is no uh reasonable reasonable next test the difference to with uh
00:10:14 stand your ground and instead stand on guard my my bill is that my bill applies strictly to the home
00:10:24 so the home is a special place where we are most vulnerable and stand your ground in the u.s
00:10:35 applies anywhere so this is why i was explaining to you that within this bill and stand stand on
00:10:45 guard applies strictly to the home right your home should be your safe place not the place
00:10:53 where the law stands against you. So yesterday your bill was debated of course in the house and
00:10:59 you know I heard from members of opposition as well as their concerns. Of course an example I
00:11:05 think was raised perhaps just thinking I can even make this example up myself it doesn't have to be
00:11:10 a real one but let's say you know teenagers or people who are associated with each other, friends
00:11:15 you know people that have a bit little more of comfort in terms of familiarity but of course
00:11:21 they're not the homeowner uh maybe entering a home without explicit permission to retrieve a
00:11:26 forgotten item or to you know um there can also be disputes about this within people but
00:11:31 kind of where where do you draw the line again in the permission of the use of violence and again
00:11:38 would you consider amendments to distinguish accidental entry from genuine home invasion
00:11:44 because ultimately there could be that gap of uh intent yeah and i think that's why you see
00:11:52 the two key distinctions knowingly right not that uh accidental entry knowingly and unlawfully
00:12:02 uh and they have to have entered the home those are very important uh uh specifications within uh
00:12:12 within the the act uh in so that it does not apply to you know people often ask uh well the
00:12:20 the what about the delivery men uh well hopefully the delivery man is not entering your home
00:12:27 all right and in what i oftentimes um get in terms of questions is you know well what if somebody
00:12:36 enters and then they are unarmed and and and what about if the intruder this if the intruder that
00:12:44 well we need to start thinking about the homeowner right if the intruders do not want to be harmed
00:12:55 do not enter someone else's home uh and this stand on guard act provides again this clarity
00:13:05 in this certainty to homeowners that the force that they use to defend themselves and their
00:13:12 family is presumed to be reasonable well you know that theft happens in different places
00:13:18 home invasions auto theft is also a big thing happening in ontario i think it is cooling down
00:13:23 however just from the political angle and from your work as a member of parliament for new market
00:13:29 aurora what are you hearing for constituents in terms of feedback and also from police
00:13:34 associations i mean you said before that this is receiving very positive feedback from police
00:13:39 tell me a bit more about what you're hearing from your community and what you're hearing from police
00:13:44 thank you for that i will be very honest with you when i first tabled this uh bill back in march
00:13:52 i was overwhelmed by the amount of attention that it received
00:13:55 and it is it was very clear to me how Canadians want that certainty they want to know that the
00:14:08 law will stand with somebody in their home that they're just you know is simply defending
00:14:15 themselves in speaking to the broader community into law enforcement of course when it comes to
00:14:22 crime oftentimes the feedback is well criminals need a deterrent and this will be a form of
00:14:34 deterrent because it signals to them you could get killed if you break into someone's home
00:14:43 do not break into someone's home enough is enough there is no uh you know if you're breaking
00:14:53 into someone's home normally and unlawfully there's no gray area you could get killed um
00:15:02 and uh and the law will presumed presume that the homeowner is using reasonable force to defend
00:15:11 themselves lastly you know the government has majority do you have any indication so far at
00:15:19 this stage that any liberal mps would be willing to vote for this bill and the liberals overall
00:15:23 as the government would be willing to take this at least to the stage of committee
00:15:27 i haven't uh received a a direct um signal from the government i think it would be a missed
00:15:35 opportunity a missed opportunity and i often think about obviously the house reviews a lot of
00:15:42 different bills but when it comes to crime it is people's life at risk even with that delay
00:15:52 there are lives on the line and also usually what you see is bills are
00:16:04 complicated several pages most certainly this this government loves their omnibus bills and
00:16:11 so they're several hundred pages long this bill is two pages long one and a half to be exact it is
00:16:19 is targeted, it is clear, it is precise, and it creates the presumption up front that when
00:16:29 a homeowner is defending themselves against an unlawful intruder who's there knowingly,
00:16:38 they're acting reasonably to defend themselves and their family.
00:16:42 Excuse me to encroach on the final moments we have, but just lastly, I was at, as you
00:16:46 mentioned before we recorded, I was at Pierre's press conference this afternoon. I still notice
00:16:51 the use of language from Pierre Polyev on security and safe homes or safe streets. I think that's the
00:16:57 term he uses most often, the safe streets. It's still part of that kind of reputational rhetoric
00:17:02 in his speeches. Do you think the messaging on safety, public security is still an effective
00:17:09 political message today, given maybe change of scenarios and crime stats across the country?
00:17:13 i think so uh and i can tell you i do a lot of door knocking with the new market of aura
00:17:20 a lot of door knocking and when i'm talking to people at the doors and i say you know i
00:17:25 want to represent you effectively uh what is most important to you and the two things that come up
00:17:34 are affordability and crime they are by far the biggest priority for Canadians
00:17:41 member of parliament sandra kabino from newmarket aurora ontario thank you so much for your time
00:17:48 i appreciate you speaking to the western standard today thank you very much all right
00:17:54 so let's cut the recording here