Western Standard - April 29, 2025


Election Night Coverage

Topics
Mentioned
Pierre Poilievre Calgary Whistle Stop Preston Manning on debating Western independence

Episode Stats


Length

6 hours and 22 minutes

Words per minute

155.96

Word count

59,678

Sentence count

2,146

Harmful content

Misogyny

49

sentences flagged

Toxicity

34

sentences flagged

Hate speech

45

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Live from the Western Standard's live stream of the federal election results, we have a lineup of panelists, analysts, and guests to help you live stream the results of the election tonight. We have a great lineup of guests, and a great evening planned.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 .
00:00:30 .
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Transcription by CastingWords
00:02:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:02:30 We'll be right back.
00:03:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:03:30 We'll be right back.
00:04:00 We'll be right back.
00:04:30 Transcription by CastingWords
00:05:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:05:30 Transcription by CastingWords
00:06:00 We'll be right back.
00:06:30 Transcription by CastingWords
00:07:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:07:30 Transcription by CastingWords
00:08:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:08:30 We'll be right back.
00:09:00 We'll be right back.
00:09:30 We'll be right back.
00:10:00 We'll be right back.
00:10:30 .
00:11:00 .
00:11:30 .
00:12:00 Good evening. I'm Derek Fildebrand, publisher of the Western Standard. You're here joining
00:12:16 us for our live stream of the election results for today's federal election on April 28th,
00:12:23 2025 we have got a great evening planned uh well i can't plan for the election results but we're
00:12:30 gonna give you the best of you might not like the evening you might like it who knows but we're
00:12:34 gonna we've got a great lineup we've got great panelists great analysts uh great reporters and
00:12:40 great great guests let's just start with uh those joining us tonight i've got in studio for the
00:12:46 the first time, and the newest panelist for the pipeline, Erika Barutes.
00:12:51 Hello, how are you?
00:12:52 I was struggling.
00:12:53 It's Barutes, you don't know my title.
00:12:55 Barutes, Barutes, Barutes.
00:12:56 Maybe by the end of tonight.
00:12:57 No, no.
00:12:58 It's been a while together.
00:12:59 So if he's the head of the political management.
00:13:04 Do you want me to just talk about myself?
00:13:07 So, department head for the applied politics and public affairs program at McAbee College.
00:13:13 college so we might have some new students based on the election results that want to get involved
00:13:18 and be a part of uh maybe some change or or how democracy is working so all right we'll see uh
00:13:26 we've got next in line corey morgan senior alberta columnist and uh nigel henneford uh our opinion
00:13:35 editor staying up late yeah now uh doing his best impression of uh wolf i'm gonna call him welfare
00:13:42 There's no sound.
00:13:44 Well, no sound?
00:13:46 According to the commenters, no.
00:13:48 Alright, studio, can we get this fixed here?
00:13:51 People are saying no sound.
00:13:53 No sound, yeah, they're saying no sound.
00:13:55 Still no sound.
00:13:56 Come on, production! 0.92
00:14:00 Alright.
00:14:00 Okay, no, yes, there is sound
00:14:03 and they're saying it's tinny, it's the fan.
00:14:04 Alright, maybe it's the fan.
00:14:06 Here, take the camera off me for a second.
00:14:08 Take the camera off me.
00:14:09 Alright, now bring the camera back on me.
00:14:12 Okay. All right. Well, introducing Welfare Wolf. Doing his best impression of Wolf Blitzer tonight in the green screen is our business. Oh, I can hear an echo back on me. That's not very good. I'll have to take my ear for a moment here. We've got Western Center business and energy reporter Sean Polzer. Let's go to Sean. Show Sean. Oh, there you are. Yeah. Say hi, Sean.
00:14:40 Hey, how's it going, everybody?
00:14:42 Yeah.
00:14:43 I was in Western Standard Land.
00:14:45 All right.
00:14:45 Well, so this is Welfare Wolf doing his best impression tonight.
00:14:49 He'll be running us through the maps, giving us results as they come in.
00:14:55 Do we have Dave Naylor on?
00:14:57 Can we get Dave?
00:14:58 Do we have Dave anywhere?
00:14:59 Okay, well, we're going to have Dave Naylor from the newsroom coming in.
00:15:01 We've got Jared Yager, our reporter in Vancouver.
00:15:05 He's going to be at the headquarters of NDP leader Jagmeet Singh.
00:15:10 We've got Jen Hodgson. 0.86
00:15:11 She's in Ottawa, so she'll be at the headquarters of both Mark Carney and Pierre Polyev.
00:15:15 She'll be spending some time at both of them, and she'll probably finish the night most likely at whichever one wins the election tonight. 0.92
00:15:23 Serves the most booze.
00:15:25 Whoever has the best booze.
00:15:26 Yeah.
00:15:26 Okay.
00:15:27 And we've got Chris Oldcorn, our Saskatchewan reporter.
00:15:30 He'll be watching things on Saskatchewan and Manitoba come to us live from Regina.
00:15:37 We've just got a great lineup of guests.
00:15:39 Nigel, can I have a list of our guests here?
00:15:43 Yeah, you sure can. We just happen to have a...
00:15:45 Actually, I should probably have one of those. Thank you. Okay. I'm very organized.
00:15:53 All right. Well, we've got former Alberta Minister of Justice Jonathan Dennis,
00:15:58 Canadian Taxpayers Federation Federal Director Franco Terrizano, former BC Premier Gordon Campbell,
00:16:03 uh kevin lacy uh he is with uh canadians for affordable energy nadine wellwood a ppc supporter
00:16:13 kent hair a um former alberta liberal mla yes they used we used to have those at one time before they
00:16:19 went extinct um but he was also a captain minister for the trudeau government and was a alberta and
00:16:26 calgary mp we've got former saskatchewan premier brad wall that's going to be a very interesting
00:16:31 one tonight uh john thompson one of our columnists uh yaroslav baron what was his title in the harper
00:16:37 government he was a policy advisor and then he was struck out on his own afterwards and
00:16:43 now pendulum the pendulum group they're political advisors yeah we've got db cooper with us that's
00:16:49 uh dr barry cooper oh it's dr no he had to scratch on yeah okay no db cooper we've got
00:16:55 Shea Anderson, a former Alberta NDP captive minister.
00:17:00 Yeah, yeah, I know.
00:17:01 I know.
00:17:01 He's NDP.
00:17:02 But he's got a great beard.
00:17:04 I got along with this guy pretty well.
00:17:05 He might be an outraging socialist, but he's actually a pretty good guy to have a beard
00:17:09 with.
00:17:10 And for a new Democrat, one of the more clear-minded ones you're going to meet.
00:17:14 So I think you'll like it.
00:17:15 We've got Ted Morton still?
00:17:17 Yes.
00:17:17 Okay, we've got former Alberta finance minister Ted Morton, Mike Solberg, political consultant
00:17:26 Daniel Dufour from the...
00:17:28 There's been a switch there, and one of his colleagues has taken over at his request.
00:17:32 No Dufour?
00:17:33 No Dufour, Michel Renaud.
00:17:35 Okay, well, we got a French guy. We got a French guy who will tell us about the Frenchies
00:17:41 and how they're going, okay? All right.
00:17:49 And we've got Professor Trevor Tucker, a professor at the University of Ottawa and a...
00:17:54 Frequent columnist. So really great lineup. Why don't we throw it straight to Sean here.
00:18:04 We've got the early vote coming in from the Atlantic provinces. Anything from Quebec yet?
00:18:11 No, nothing from Quebec yet. All right, we'll run it through what we've got in Atlantic so far.
00:18:15 What do we have here in Atlantic so far? Well, just let me get set up here. This is going to be a bit of a
00:18:24 technical. Well, why don't we come back? We're on. We're on. Basically what we got is most of the
00:18:29 Maritimes. Liberals are ahead in about 16 leading. I think they're only actually elected in one,
00:18:36 which would be this big blob right there. Otherwise known as Labrador. But we've got
00:18:45 some of these other results coming in through looks like most of Nova Scotia, New Brunswick.
00:18:52 It's a good thing I studied geography in high school.
00:18:56 I'm going to tell you about Labrador.
00:18:57 But we haven't gotten anywhere into Quebec yet.
00:19:01 Okay.
00:19:01 So, but there's only a few polls reporting in each, right?
00:19:04 These are not...
00:19:05 Yes.
00:19:06 Yeah.
00:19:07 Let's see.
00:19:08 What are we looking at in terms of polls?
00:19:10 511 out of 75,932 polls.
00:19:14 For the whole country.
00:19:15 About 0.1% of the vote.
00:19:18 Okay.
00:19:19 Well, so one thing we're going to be doing tonight, I'll mention it so we don't get sued,
00:19:22 um the cbc might not be the greatest news organization around but it has a lot of money
00:19:30 and therefore it has a lot of resources to build uh good tech or pay for good technology around
00:19:36 these election trackers so that's what we're using tonight uh let's put that lecture tracker
00:19:41 back up on screen so people can see it it it's well that's the elections canada yeah i'm on
00:19:45 elections canada now yeah you want me to go back yeah go back go back to the cbc one okay so cbc
00:19:50 it's a great aggregator of the data as it's coming in now where it says elected that's where the cbc
00:19:57 election desk has declared it so that's not us and that's not elections canada that's a call from
00:20:02 the cbc and whatever you think about them that stuff is going to be generally pretty accurate
00:20:07 there's no sense in calling it wrongly because it doesn't won't actually change it you'll just
00:20:11 have to make an embarrassing uh correction later so there's the cbc has no incentive to call that
00:20:15 wrong. So let's try to be fair where it's deserved to be fair. But let's look at, zoom in on those
00:20:21 numbers over there. The vote that's in so far, it's not a lot yet. I'd say less than 70,000
00:20:28 ballots counted. So it's very, very early. And the Liberals ever so slightly ahead in total vote,
00:20:36 48.9%, oh, 49%. The Conservatives at 45.2%. NDP keeping up with where they've been in the polls,
00:20:44 which is dead, 4.4%. Atlantic has never really been their strongest area, though, eh, Nigel?
00:20:52 No, this actually tends to be liberal territory. I just have the numbers here from the previous
00:20:58 election. This is what we've got to compare it with. In 2021, Nova Scotia elected eight out of
00:21:05 11 MPs as liberals, 3 as conservatives. New Brunswick, 6 out of 10 as liberals, 4 out of 10
00:21:17 as conservatives. Newfoundland and Labrador, 6 out of 7 as liberals, 1 conservative, and Prince Edward
00:21:24 Island, all 4 MPs were liberals. Yeah, the NDP, Erica, have not traditionally been a major player
00:21:32 in the Atlantic. Under Jack Layton, they had some breakthrough in like the Acadie Bathurst area.
00:21:38 They were able to appeal to some of the non-Quebec French vote. They've had some presence,
00:21:44 but it's traditionally old school liberal and very old school, I won't even say conservative,
00:21:48 it's old school Tory. Yes, yeah, definitely. I think this is, I mean, I go back to 2015,
00:21:54 this is looking a lot better for the Conservatives than it was then. But you're right, it's going to
00:21:59 be kind of a two-man races the entire night is going to be and and you know it might be better
00:22:06 for the conservatives uh than maybe anticipating which is kind of nice because they they close so
00:22:11 early we won't really have any trends to go off of until we get ontario and quebec you know erica
00:22:17 not to be um patronizing to the herring jokers but it is uh i guess i just have haven't i um but you
00:22:25 know they tend to be very family orientated there and if granddad was a liberal then the odds are
00:22:30 that the grandson is going to be a liberal as well we did a we did some bowling back there i
00:22:36 can't remember which year but we had around saying here are some policy positions do you agree with
00:22:41 this do you agree with this you know everybody said oh yeah we're that's exactly what we think
00:22:46 well you must be a concern oh no no we always vote liberal so that's what you're getting a
00:22:50 generational there with maybe sometimes no uh explanation why hey listen i live in edmonton
00:22:58 so i get that a lot yeah uh actually the atlantic uh this was somewhat in old ontario as well
00:23:05 um it was religious you know the tories would be the protestant party the liberals would be
00:23:11 the catholic party and then there'd be some people who would switch based on actual politics
00:23:15 not who won the election but it was it was very much a cap of protestants for a long time i don't
00:23:20 think that bears much anymore other than that you know families that were stridently protestant
00:23:27 might tend to still be conservatives but not because they're protestant from the orange lodge
00:23:34 well the orange lodge must be ndp now that should be the name of like a donor club for the ndp the
00:23:39 orange. That'll go over the heads of some. So what have you guys seen then as strategies
00:23:47 in order, I mean, NDP aside, for that vote split of these generational issues? Like from your time
00:23:56 even with harbour government, like what was the angle then for Atlantic Canada to try and
00:24:02 convert generational voters? Tell you what it wasn't, it was you didn't mess around with 0.98
00:24:08 with employment and assurance qualification.
00:24:10 That one cost Mr. Chrétien dearly in the 97 election.
00:24:15 What have you got, Derek?
00:24:16 Okay, so right now in the Atlantic,
00:24:21 let's get the screen up there, the numbers.
00:24:24 The Liberals have been declared elected in three.
00:24:30 Does the leading, what it says, leading and elected,
00:24:33 is the leading include the elected
00:24:35 or is that a separate category?
00:24:37 Meaning it's 10.
00:24:38 elected and leading and elected elected leading and elect okay uh the conservatives are leading
00:24:43 11 leading uh some history when harper won his majority he won 11 seats in atlantic um
00:24:52 that is um i mean that's not winning it but that's a strong enough presence i remember
00:24:58 you know early very early in the evening when justin trudeau won his majority of 2015
00:25:02 he won every single seat in the east and it was immediately apparent apparent it was just a
00:25:08 red tide coming from the atlantic and you're like well we don't know what else is coming but if you
00:25:13 want every single seat that was showing it was bad momentum this uh again still a ton of polls to
00:25:20 close way too early to call most of those seats but the conservatives are leading in 11. that's
00:25:26 probably a good early uh sign for polio well they only won in eight in 21. so if they're leading in
00:25:33 11 yes a good early sign
00:25:36 I have to note for the record
00:25:39 our director of operations for the company Michelle Cundy
00:25:43 she was sick last week now her mom's sick she's staying with her 0.99
00:25:47 she's demanded that Michelle Cundy and Mama Cundy get a shout out tonight 1.00
00:25:51 so I'm going to do that but that comes at the cost of
00:25:55 she's going to have to be on coffee duty for the next couple weeks 1.00
00:25:59 I think we should just do it
00:26:01 I wanted to make one little note here, and that is that Conservatives are leading in
00:26:10 two out of three Newfoundland writings that they didn't have before.
00:26:14 Oh, two pickups.
00:26:16 Because I looked at the map over here, and I've got last map, and you can see
00:26:25 that they only had one of the four seats, five seats on the main island there. Now this
00:26:35 is all blue except for the Avalon there. Okay. Novus Corsi is about the same. Our New Brunswick
00:26:43 we haven't seen yet. Why don't you step out of the way so we can see them and zoom in.
00:26:47 The last election so right now this is all blue with the exception of the Avalon here
00:27:09 which is the gooseneck is what they call it in Newfoundland Nova Scotia looks pretty much the
00:27:16 same as I can recall. I guess we've got eyes on New Brunswick here and then we're going to start
00:27:20 heading up the gas bay as we go along. So let's compare it to CBC. And. Stand in front of Quebec.
00:27:30 Stand in front of Quebec so we can see the back. Your other Quebec. The other Quebec. There you go.
00:27:34 I'm getting I'm working my way. Okay. So these dark colored ones are the ones that have been
00:27:40 elected and then the other ones are leading so you can see that the liberals have really only
00:27:46 been elected in a couple of them yeah now keeping in mind uh it probably it looks more conservative
00:27:51 than it actually is because conservatives tend to do better in rural ridings which
00:27:55 are obviously bigger on the map uh leftist parties will do better in more urban
00:27:59 ridings that are smaller on the map also prince edward island uh inexplicably has four seats its
00:28:05 population entitles it to maybe one and a half but it's got it's it got a pretty sweet deal in
00:28:10 the constitution when it entered confederation a deal that we did not get in the west um so they
00:28:15 get four seats despite their population doesn't hasn't changed much no no well that'll be discussion
00:28:22 uh for tomorrow possibly it actually looks like in new brunswick looks like the conservatives
00:28:26 have picked up this uh big one uh matahuasca restagouche
00:28:34 we're gonna get better as we get west say it more french than that
00:28:43 matahuasca matahuasca matahuasca restagouche okay i don't know that sounds more italian but
00:28:49 anyway so that's a pickup yeah concern itself a very slim lead there yeah so prince edward
00:28:55 island pretty much the same nova scotia pretty much the same shaking out newfoundland picked up
00:29:01 one two three so i want to point out this one let's uh go back to new brunswick come back to
00:29:06 new brunswick i want you to zoom in on that dark red one there yep yeah where they've been elected
00:29:11 that's acadete bathurst so we were just talking about that that used to be an ndp constituency
00:29:15 the ndp won that several times under jack layton uh even before his big sweep uh the ndp used to
00:29:22 to win that seat. The NDP there
00:29:24 right now is at only 4.6%
00:29:26 of the vote. They used to win that
00:29:28 constituency. They're at
00:29:30 4.6%. They're only
00:29:32 twice the vote of the PPC
00:29:34 at 2.2% right now. That
00:29:36 is bad news for
00:29:38 Pierre Polioff, I think, Corey.
00:29:41 Sorry.
00:29:42 If you weren't listening.
00:29:44 Sorry to throw in somebody else to
00:29:46 post it from Nova. Sean Fraser
00:29:48 is trailing by
00:29:49 30 votes. That guy likes to steal our 0.52
00:29:52 Yeah, Central Nova.
00:29:56 Somebody had asked one of the commenters.
00:29:57 That's why I was looking that up at the time,
00:29:59 and it's a horse race going on in that one right now, actually.
00:30:03 And Sean Fraser, for those who might not remember,
00:30:05 he said he was stepping away to spend more time with his family,
00:30:08 and then he spent some time with it. 1.00
00:30:09 They thought, these guys are assholes. 1.00
00:30:10 I'm going to go run for office politics. 1.00
00:30:12 Or it might have been related to the polls swinging back up for the Liberals.
00:30:15 I'm not sure.
00:30:16 Which riding was he in?
00:30:17 Central Nova.
00:30:18 Central Nova.
00:30:18 but there's a lot of people who don't think highly of them for that opportunism and uh
00:30:23 it might reflect in this poll it's gonna be one to watch actually i think that's the thing that
00:30:27 people don't care about your ideology when you're like i'll just uh get rid of you guys if you're
00:30:31 not advantageous to me but to your question derek um yeah this is i think the the biggest challenge
00:30:38 for pierre as we start to move left is that votes but we need like the conservatives need
00:30:45 jay meet saying in the ndp to perform better uh i think we're going to see that a lot with some of
00:30:50 the votes especially in alberta when we eventually get there yeah um but yeah it's not a good time
00:30:55 i'm just looking across some of these uh some of the constituencies that have the liberals leading
00:31:00 right now uh so there's um jeez um okay no that's a bad example but you're just as bad as me i'm
00:31:13 I'm looking, okay, Cumberland, Closestershire.
00:31:17 Clumberland, that's got to be Prince Edward Island.
00:31:19 No, no, no, that's Nova Scotia.
00:31:22 Liberals are at 52, Conservatives at 40.6.
00:31:25 The NDP is only at 5.2.
00:31:27 Traditionally, the NDP should be strong enough that that would be neck and neck,
00:31:30 and the Conservatives could take that in a nail-biter. 0.72
00:31:33 Right now, they're 12 points behind.
00:31:39 That's going to be a lot for them to catch up on.
00:31:41 Still a lot of polls to close there. 0.76
00:31:42 Maybe it could go.
00:31:43 but based on that trend line that should be a competitive conservative seat if the NDP had a
00:31:48 heartbeat at its traditional levels right now they don't the interesting thing though is I mean last
00:31:54 election we saw the PPC stealing enough percentage to make a difference in some areas and it was about
00:32:01 like now you also see a relevance from the PPC so it should be naturally a more higher boost for
00:32:09 conservative but like you said with this dying orange it might impact some of these what should
00:32:16 be neck and neck ridings you know to your point the nova scotia riding of sydney victoria in the
00:32:21 last election if you took the ppc vote and added it back to the the conservative party of canada
00:32:31 the cbc would have won that by more than 100 votes now you can't always make it quite so
00:32:37 need there are other reasons why people might have voted ppc and still not voted conservative
00:32:42 if the ppc wasn't there but i mean this is the area we're talking about this is one of the
00:32:47 one of the seats that will turn on the on an erratic vote but all together i think there's
00:32:52 probably 15 to 20 writings that turned on a ppc taking votes away from the conservative uh just
00:33:01 so production knows everyone's i'm going to bring my own map in once in a while so i don't have to
00:33:05 tell production what to do or tell welfare wolf i'm still learning yeah uh all right our first
00:33:12 guest is going to be uh kevin lacy uh so kevin lacy's not here yet but uh this guy knows atlantic
00:33:17 politics very well uh he's the best kind of atlantic guy uh because he's in alberton now
00:33:22 uh so he's a former former eastern bastard uh but knows atlantic politics very well uh he's he's
00:33:29 going to be in um about five minutes here uh so why don't we check in is that production is dave
00:33:37 from the newsroom ready yeah all right let's go to dave in the newsroom for a moment uh just check
00:33:41 in on what poor dave is doing dave what do you got for us that's lonely out here in the newsroom
00:33:50 derek well actually you can see the camera you can see dave background back there wave dave
00:33:56 there you go hey babe it's just me and three boxes of pizza uh so yeah we're having fun with our
00:34:03 our live blog uh at the moment it was uh quite the excitement when it was all tied up in the
00:34:08 maritimes the tories obviously performing a little bit better than they did in the 2021 election and
00:34:16 you know now the next big thing to happen is the polls closing in quebec and ontario and uh you
00:34:23 know we'll that'll be the that you know that's going to tell a lot so uh that's the next big
00:34:29 thing to keep an eye out for okay uh we also got to work on your sound if it's a bit muffled uh
00:34:34 wouldn't be able to get back in i'm not sure what to do about that but it's in your hands
00:34:40 okay um so yeah newfoundland is actually looking fairly conservative right now uh liberals declared
00:34:47 elected in labrador conservatives uh declared elected central newfoundland liberals in avalon
00:34:53 but leading in Terra Nova, the peninsulas, and Long Range Mountains.
00:34:58 Here, actually, let's just, where's my thing?
00:35:02 There it is.
00:35:03 There it is.
00:35:04 All right, here's the new fees.
00:35:06 All right, so we'll see.
00:35:07 I think the Conservatives had, what, one incumbent seat?
00:35:10 Yes.
00:35:11 Okay, so they're looking at two pickups, potentially, there.
00:35:15 Liberals leading in St. John's East here.
00:35:19 That, yeah, no, the Liberals are leading pretty strongly there.
00:35:23 but yeah they're looking at two pickups in newfoundland um that's traditionally strong for
00:35:28 the conservatives conservatives not been traditionally very strong in newfoundland
00:35:32 uh it looks like only two in nova scotia though but one two three four five new brunswick this is
00:35:38 not a bad start if these trends hold on for the conservatives exactly it's uh i mean it's too early
00:35:44 to tell much but everybody i mean let's face it the polls have been hanging over us like a dark
00:35:51 cloud now for about three weeks and as we came into this room i think a lot of us thought well
00:35:56 how are we going to get through six hours of talking about how terrible it is the answer is
00:36:02 it may not be as terrible as we think and it's going to be interesting in a few hours time to
00:36:06 actually talk about how close the polls did or didn't come but right now this is not a conservative
00:36:14 wipeout this is conservatives actually looking to pick up a seat in newfoundland maybe in nova
00:36:20 scotia as well uh sorry in new brunswick as well i mean let's give this thing a chance
00:36:26 are you coming with the optimistic tone today well i am because uh i have money riding on it
00:36:33 i have to talk about my position but yes no i've thought all along with something really funny
00:36:38 about the numbers because here is going out there having these huge rallies and yet the polls say
00:36:45 that he's about to lose this, where Mr. Carney goes and has pea and cucumber sandwiches with
00:36:51 150 people, and there he is, that's the leader, and the Liberals are going to take this. So I
00:36:59 just cannot imagine how this is all going to fit together in the end.
00:37:02 Well, this is a good time for us to get our money on the table, so to speak, with our predictions.
00:37:09 Guys, the pollsters aren't intent, unless it's Frank Graves, the pollsters aren't intentionally
00:37:14 lying uh because they look bad and it's bad for their business if they're wrong if they cannot
00:37:20 accurately predict the election it's bad business no you don't want to hire them afterwards because
00:37:25 they're seen as less credible um so if you blow it you have to spend years trying to recover that
00:37:29 uh in your reputation so i don't think these guys are actively lying the polls on aggregate
00:37:35 are showing the uh the liberals ahead um abacus has showed the conservatives really closing it
00:37:40 i've generally gone into tonight before i saw any results thinking the conservatives have one in
00:37:46 three shot of winning government of some form uh because i i think there's a sick you know people
00:37:52 have talked about the shy tory voter there's us i think a huge uh enthusiasm gap here because half
00:37:58 the people telling pollsters that they intend to vote liberals liberal said they were voting
00:38:02 conservatives six months ago those people can't be burning with passion when they're flipping
00:38:07 between parties whereas conservatives right now are white hot angry and ready for change so i
00:38:14 think the conservatives are likely to outperform the polls that doesn't mean the polls are wrong
00:38:18 but that i i expect you look at the rallies and then what i just said about the enthusiasm gap
00:38:24 i think the conservatives will outperform the polls but you can only outperform it so much
00:38:28 you might get a two percent bounce three if you're really lucky basically closing it on a margin of
00:38:35 error which the conservatives though to their defense are pretty darn close in some of the
00:38:40 polls i think you know i am leaning into the oh tomorrow's gonna suck um but i do think that there
00:38:51 is a lot of quiet conservatives out there and there's a lot of people when i think how many
00:38:56 polls i've how many phone numbers have showed up on my phone that i don't know and i didn't answer
00:39:00 the people that answer on landlines are baby boomers and they typically vote
00:39:06 liberal so I do right but there they've shifted to voting liberal in the last
00:39:14 little go here so I do think that there is this quiet group now like am I just
00:39:30 picking who wins. Yeah, who's going to win tonight? Your early prediction. Before you
00:39:35 even saw this, like, what? I thought it was a liberal majority. Okay. Cory? Liberal minority.
00:39:40 Liberal minority. Conservative minority. Conservative minority. What does Welfare Wolf
00:39:47 say? I was leaning towards the liberal minority, but after seeing some of these numbers coming
00:39:52 from the amount of Canada. Just to give an update though, and I'm glad somebody brought up Central
00:40:00 Nova because we've got an interesting one to watch because it's a real horse race. And this
00:40:03 is a grudge one because Sean Fraser was considered an up and comer in the Trudeau government. He was
00:40:08 a senior cabinet minister. He did that opportunistic back and forth. He should
00:40:12 have been though, as a senior minister, very strong there as an incumbent. 45 of 229 polls
00:40:18 reported the conservative bryson jenkins is leading with 47.7 over sean fraser at 45.9
00:40:26 and i don't know much more we can read into this the ndp is completely irrelevant on
00:40:30 and the ppc uh is at 48 votes just to throw that in there too so that this is a two-party race
00:40:36 and uh we're seeing i think some personal opinion or or you know the the individual candidates
00:40:42 value is coming out that the polls didn't reflect back going in do your numbers reflect anything
00:40:47 or whether this is rural or urban uh this is central nova so it's kind of i don't know the
00:40:52 cities in there but i mean it's a large riding so it came in right yeah we're only at 50. that's
00:40:58 right but it's it's a good trend with that many coming in i hope that i eat my words guys it's
00:41:03 like i'm not hoping for well it's not what you want it's just what you think it's just
00:41:09 who did the exact same thing she said she was going to leave to spend time with family but 0.93
00:41:12 bounce back and i was the family i was very offended i want those two you were planning 0.99
00:41:16 but you know this this number of 3.4 for the ndp i think is is the real story here like um even if
00:41:23 assuming that those went to the liberal then i mean it's kind of neck and neck now but uh it
00:41:29 wouldn't even be close the ndp the margin of error actually you know the 50 out of 29 that's you know
00:41:36 it's only 50 out of 29 but that's actually a heck of a size sample how would you feel if
00:41:41 you were the you know if you're the underdog and already fit nearly a quarter of the polls had uh
00:41:47 had reported you you're feeling a little anxious unless you knew something about the character of
00:41:51 the ones who still have to come in oh that's actually an optimistic look on them so dave
00:41:56 naylor in the newsroom uh just sent a message he's predicting conservative minority uh could happen
00:42:02 uh i think the minority government is going to be a really weird one tonight though because the
00:42:07 The NDP have just melted down, but it's still entirely possible.
00:42:11 The block is expected to have not a great night as well,
00:42:14 but probably not facing as much of a wipeout as the NDP.
00:42:18 The block is still going to be there.
00:42:19 I don't think it's possible.
00:42:20 That's why.
00:42:21 The block is still going to have official party status after tonight.
00:42:24 The NDP, well, we don't know yet, but I mean, based on this,
00:42:28 it's not looking too good.
00:42:30 As Erica put it, the NDP might be the new margin of error in polls.
00:42:35 So Kevin's in the lobby scene.
00:42:36 Oh, okay.
00:42:37 Well, let's bring in our next guest, our first guest, Kevin Lacey is, he is there.
00:42:48 Okay, Kevin Lacey is with the Hyde Park Group, but he was also a comrade of mine at the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:42:55 He was the Atlantic Director, so responsible for all four Atlantic provinces in that organization.
00:43:01 but making him an even better Atlantic Canadian is the fact that he's now
00:43:06 actually an Albertan. So that's what happens to the best of them.
00:43:10 Kevin, thank you for joining us.
00:43:12 Thanks so much for having me.
00:43:14 Oh, your sound is a little funky. Say hi again.
00:43:17 Hi, Derek. How are you?
00:43:19 There you go. Okay. I love his Atlantic twang.
00:43:24 I just put it on for the night, Derek.
00:43:27 Come on, dance monkey. 1.00
00:43:28 all right so we've got early results coming in tons of riding still not called but we've got
00:43:35 the leading elected ones what's your initial impression on the results in the Atlantic
00:43:43 provinces so far well look if you were tuning in tonight to see the conservatives fall off the map
00:43:48 there's some really encouraging results here early on the first one I look at that long-range
00:43:52 Mountain seat. That is traditionally a liberal seat. It's Gail Hutchings was the MP prior to now.
00:43:59 She's held the riding for three terms. Sorry, which riding is that? The riding of Long Range
00:44:05 Mountains in Newfoundland. It's on the west coast of the province. Yeah, here, I'm going to bring in
00:44:10 a map here. Here, kick my face off of here. I'm going to bring the map in. Yeah. And so when you're 0.95
00:44:17 seeing conservatives do well here. This is untraditional vote. This is areas that the
00:44:22 conservatives have not really competed in the past. In fact, in about 2015, the liberals got
00:44:28 about 75% of the total vote in that riding. So that's one of the pickups. The second one is the
00:44:36 one in Newfoundland, that Terra Nova seat. That's the seat that just as you cross the peninsula
00:44:41 from newfoundland um you get uh that riding and that riding was held by anthony germain the former
00:44:47 cbc radio host head of the he hosted i think the house if anyone ever listens to that uh anywhere
00:44:53 anymore um on cbc and he's running in that seat so those two ridings are really key for conservatives
00:45:00 and i think might be a harbinger we saw in 2015 with atlantic canada that when the stephen harper
00:45:07 was wiped out kind of atlantic canada kind of led the way uh in that election because all 32 seats
00:45:14 went liberal and it kind of showed you what was going to happen as we went across the country but
00:45:18 there's some really good signs here the other one to look at derek is south shore nova scotia um um
00:45:25 seat where rick perkins the member of parliament conservative member of parliament is running
00:45:30 that riding the ndp candidate failed to get their papers in and there's no ndp candidate in that
00:45:36 riding so that's one that i think a lot of us had kind of wiped out as a result they're separated by
00:45:42 just a few votes it's 47.5 to 47.4 uh for rick perkins the conservatives leading by a nose hair
00:45:50 yeah look rick's a former head of uh public relations the nova scotia liquor corporation
00:45:56 um and he's got really good marketing um skill and background in that riding uh but that's one
00:46:02 where as you talk about these splits as we start to get into ontario just flip back to liberal
00:46:10 night but the fact that we're even talking about that riding tonight is a good sign for the
00:46:14 conservatives because traditionally the ndps score somewhere between 15 to 20 of the vote
00:46:20 uh in that riding um the last one derek i'd ask you to look at is the riding of mass of matta
00:46:27 Madawaska-Restagouche. And that seat... Oh, that's a... How do you say that last part again?
00:46:32 Madawaska-Restagouche. Oh, okay. I was over-frenchifying. I was like,
00:46:36 we should go. We had it darn near now. You weren't here when I butchered that one earlier.
00:46:42 That riding there, you see the Conservatives doing well. That's in an area that... I mean,
00:46:47 the Conservatives should get entirely wiped out here. So the fact that they're even
00:46:50 getting vote in this riding is really, really good. So I think if you're watching this tonight,
00:46:57 as a conservative early on, there's some really encouraging signs here, and I wouldn't quite,
00:47:03 as we get into Quebec and Ontario, there's some signs here that the vote is coming in
00:47:08 in some of these areas that you wouldn't necessarily expect it to.
00:47:12 I want to ask you about, oh, actually, we're going to go to our first Quebec one in a second.
00:47:15 I was going to say.
00:47:15 Yeah, but first, Acadie Bathurst, we were talking about this before you came on.
00:47:19 The NDP used to win this for at least several terms under Jack Layden and maybe Mulcair,
00:47:26 i'm not sure but the ndp uh despite this used to being a fairly any an ndp stronghold ndp is down
00:47:32 to 4.8 percent uh that does not pretend well for the conservatives across the country yeah that
00:47:38 and that was a personality riding ivan godin was the was the member of parliament in that in that
00:47:43 riding um and he held it for two terms and derek i think what you're gonna you see across the region
00:47:48 is that ndp vote entirely falling off now traditionally that vote goes almost entirely
00:47:54 to the liberals but even look at conservative seats if you take a look at the riding of st
00:47:59 um st john st croix which is a renamed riding of new brunswick southwest held by conservative mp
00:48:05 john williamson that's an area where the ndp two elections ago we're getting 15 to 18 of the vote
00:48:12 and that's continued to fall and as it has the liberal vote has increased but as you see tonight
00:48:18 what what the liberals are really banking on is that ridings like that that were traditionally
00:48:23 conservative that that NDP vote would entirely come over to to their side of the ledger and that
00:48:29 they would be competing in more conservative seats but as you see here in Atlantic Canada
00:48:33 that simply hasn't happened it's we've essentially ended up with a status quo and sure as we count
00:48:39 more ballots there's going to be a little bit of changes here and there but that and that the
00:48:46 the liberal hope of that NDP vote entirely coming in on their side is not playing out in the early
00:48:52 results okay uh we're gonna go to sean real quickly for the first results uh from quebec
00:48:57 there's literally two polls from a single riding in quebec but it's something new and shiny so
00:49:03 let's go to welfare wolf for the update well uh no surprise block is ahead 219 votes 46 right here
00:49:11 Sorry, I want you to say the name of this contingency.
00:49:15 Gaspésie l'île de la Madeleine.
00:49:19 I'm sorry.
00:49:21 Gaspésie l'île de la Madeleine.
00:49:27 If we hit a French audience, they'd be pissed off at this point. 1.00
00:49:35 Yeah, that's me.
00:49:37 What's noteworthy here, I think, is PPC and the NDP are tied at six votes each, 1.3% of the vote.
00:49:46 You know, conservatives were probably not expected to do as well there, 17%, liberal 33%.
00:49:53 That's hardcore block territory, though, right, Erica?
00:49:56 Like, that's, they're not, all right, conservatives are never winning there.
00:50:00 No, but I'll take the block over the liberals any day for numbers. 0.99
00:50:05 Yeah.
00:50:05 Okay, well, let's go back to Kevin while we still got him.
00:50:09 Kevin, how long do we have you for?
00:50:11 You can have me as long as you want, Derek.
00:50:13 Put on here, baby.
00:50:15 All right.
00:50:17 All right.
00:50:19 I mean, let's take a look at Prince Edward Island.
00:50:22 I mean, no surprises there so far.
00:50:26 No surprises.
00:50:27 The only Conservative MP that has been elected in recent memory was in the far riding of Egmont.
00:50:35 I'm sorry, the far riding of Egmont.
00:50:38 And that's where Gail Shea held the seat. 1.00
00:50:39 She was a former provincial minister, but in 2015 was almost wiped out.
00:50:44 Really, the Conservatives hasn't been in competition there at all.
00:50:47 Now, they did nominate some good candidates.
00:50:49 In the riding of Malpec, Provincial Cabinet Minister Jamie Foxx is running in the seat.
00:50:53 But I don't expect that the Liberals tend to, the Liberal vote tends to come in for all four each and every election.
00:51:03 So it's kind of playing as we would expect it to.
00:51:07 Sorry, Egmont, Egmont, the westernmost constituency in Prince Edward Island.
00:51:13 They're in an exact tie right now.
00:51:16 28 out of 99 polls coming in.
00:51:18 99 polls because these are very small constituencies.
00:51:21 Each vote counts for approximately four Albertans.
00:51:25 We'll get there.
00:51:26 We'll get to that.
00:51:27 Oh, we will.
00:51:29 We will.
00:51:30 So, but they are, okay, no, they're no longer exactly tied.
00:51:34 No, they were exactly tied a moment ago.
00:51:36 But 47.5% for the Liberal, 47.2% for the Conservative.
00:51:41 Is that a surprise for you?
00:51:44 Or do you still expect that to stay Liberal tonight?
00:51:47 These, they traditionally go all four.
00:51:50 it now in this one and a lot of these maritime seats we're talking about and even in that one
00:51:55 there's quite a difference in where the polls are for example that's where the air the city
00:52:00 of Summerside resides so that vote that tends to vote more liberal than some of the rural areas
00:52:06 which is likely what you're seeing in that vote early on Derek the other riding I'd kind of point
00:52:12 you to is Miramichi Grand Lake which is in New Brunswick Mike Doss or the Conservatives have
00:52:18 held the seat there was a former provincial cabinet minister who was holding it he mysteriously quit
00:52:26 the race and there was a battle internal battle between a number of candidates in that riding
00:52:32 and there was some belief that maybe that riding would be thrown kind of up in the air Lisa Harris
00:52:38 a former provincial member of the legislature is running for the liberals early again early on that
00:52:45 one's also going back to the conservatives and it's writings like this where you kind of watch
00:52:50 we should be watching as we head into the bigger areas into ontario because you would expect that
00:52:56 once you've lost you know a prominent candidate or prominent name this and added a good liberal
00:53:03 candidate that these writings would start to slide particularly in an environment where
00:53:07 we're keep being told that the liberals are going to do so great in the election
00:53:11 um again holding it for the conservatives um um one in one more riding so the conservatives are
00:53:18 essentially coming out pretty much what they went in with which is a pretty good sign as we head
00:53:22 across the country uh that writing just flipped back liberal but by just a few votes it's wildly
00:53:29 close that uh gaspy incomprehensible quebec named uh constituency is that one on the atlantic time
00:53:37 zones because of where it's it or it is that that is on the atlantic time zone and it actually um
00:53:43 borders the new brunswick border and then it kind of goes around through the through the atlantic
00:53:48 and and that area sits in the time zone which is why the results come in a little early okay i was
00:53:54 just going to note um that one has got uh dual incumbency so it's uh was must have been a new
00:54:02 writing that was comprised of a block and a liberal writing so you've got uh both of those
00:54:07 candidates listed as incumbents with the block ahead now nigel you look like you you you you're 0.96
00:54:16 pondering something well i'm pondering dual incumbency i think we need to explain what that
00:54:21 is for the uh for the viewers do you want to explain that john well i just invented the term
00:54:28 no because i looked on there well i was looking at the previous map here and it seemed to me
00:54:36 that it was uh previously liberal at least on the tip of the gas bay and then on the
00:54:41 interior it was uh block so but when you switch over and then on the list here it says
00:54:49 you've got uh two incumbents uh so did the guy cross the floor or something you know wouldn't
00:54:55 this just be boundary redistribution oh that's possible that must be one of the new five ridings
00:55:01 dual okay there's the worst rendition of the starship enterprise
00:55:07 who's doing the starship enterprise oh you guys uh the camera cannot catch erica's doodle pad
00:55:13 it's a family show uh
00:55:18 um back to to incumbent for our listeners every 10 years election canada and they'll be doing it
00:55:24 in alberta for the next election does boundary redistributions based on population are you on
00:55:29 the boundary commission no oh i thought you okay i missed something i said alberta will okay yeah
00:55:35 we got three seats this time yeah so we got three um a lot of changes over but yes this is one of
00:55:41 those new boundaries that's why you will have two incumbents no one crossed the floor dual
00:55:45 incumbents uh it turned out actually sean made sense well thank you yeah could you do you want
00:55:51 to say the name of that constituency again no especially with the laryngitis so erica
00:55:59 if we have three new writings in alberta is that an advantage for the conservatives uh
00:56:05 privilege uh federally yes uh so one that i live in like edmonton center uh had some rejigging uh
00:56:13 there was i would say from that writing a little bit more uh advantage there's the new edmonton
00:56:19 northwest riding and then it kind of it impacted very very large rural ridings which would be very
00:56:28 hard to either campaign or or be the mp for um and so yes in theory it did kind of wayfair even
00:56:36 though the liberal government so what about a new one in calgary calgary mcnighters in the northeast
00:56:41 Yeah, so it kind of split up some of where George Chahal was, Skyview, which also, or that's where he was. So it does, but I would still say the challenge for the conservatives is that they are heavier weighted in or perform better in rural settings where these are because of the concentration of population and it's about 110,000 people per riding that a lot of it would be concentrated.
00:57:09 Like I said, the rejigging of Edmonton and then kind of a pocket of Calgary that you saw.
00:57:15 Well, that's it. It's not just a Calgary writing. It's a no better term for it. It's an ethnic writing.
00:57:21 It's a high, high immigrant concentration.
00:57:24 A lot of newcomers.
00:57:25 Yeah, which skews more often than not, but not always liberal or towards leftist parties like the NDP does well in northeast Calgary.
00:57:33 The liberal, the liberals hold one seat in Calgary. It's in the northeast.
00:57:37 um they hold i think is it two seats at edmonton uh two ndp and then one uh liberal or one liberal
00:57:43 right now yeah and so they'll they'll tend to do uh better in areas uh that are have a high
00:57:48 concentration of immigration one of the new alberta seats is in one of those areas so high
00:57:55 migrant population point liberal uh but it's alberta point conservative so i mean those those
00:58:01 writings could go any either way mp michael cooper was involved and i'll say his historical
00:58:06 knowledge of boundaries uh came into play very helpful for the conservatives the northeast too
00:58:13 and those writings are hard to pull because it's based more on who connects with their community
00:58:18 a heck of a lot more than a party line so i mean that same writing could very well flip
00:58:26 derek if i can add to this conversation which i think is interesting about demographics and what
00:58:30 we're going to see tonight about demographics we keep hearing about the blue collar boat which has
00:58:36 never been um a strong conservative uh vote getter and and erica i'm sure knows this too it used to
00:58:43 be when i used to go canvassing door-to-door you saw a driveway you could pretty well count on a
00:58:47 voting conservative and there's a lot of areas in edmonton and other wealthier cities that you
00:58:53 know i think of uh rosedale and toronto i mean that used to be a rock solid conservative riding
00:58:58 and over time wealthier canadians have voted more and more liberal younger hard-working canadians
00:59:04 have become more and more conservative i think one of the questions tonight is how far is that
00:59:09 demographic going to change we saw in the united states with donald trump his demographic was
00:59:15 largely and he won that election largely on the blue collar working vote and is that now going to
00:59:22 impact on the canadian election the exact same way i think that's one of the things we're going
00:59:26 to watch and then if we look at some of these ridings even some of these maritime ones
00:59:30 if we go back to central nova like that's a riding which has the community of stellerton
00:59:34 stellerton is a former um steel mining it also has made um heavy uh gear in it and so there's
00:59:42 a lot of working people in that riding and so the cons the fact that conservatives are seemingly
00:59:48 doing better may play to that change in demographics and that change in demographics
00:59:53 when we look at these riding boundaries may also affect which ridings were competitive in
00:59:58 and which ones were not i think that's going to be one of the interesting stories as we go through
01:00:02 tonight is how that impacts on on individual writings so let's let's talk about where we're
01:00:09 at right now um so newfoundland uh labrador i mean that's always been solid solid liberal it's an
01:00:16 extremely low population constituency um but there's some adjuster rules in these things like
01:00:23 Like, Labrador is kind of a self-contained unit, and it gets to be a riding no matter what its population is.
01:00:28 Same with, like, you know, Northwest Territories, Nunavut, Yukon, et cetera.
01:00:33 So sometimes there is a case to be made for it.
01:00:35 I think Labrador probably is one, even though it goes liberal.
01:00:38 The conservatives are doing really strong in Newfoundland.
01:00:41 So pick up conservatives smashed the liberal incumbent.
01:00:46 uh carol antsy uh the conservative has been declared elected with 53.4 percent of the vote
01:00:53 liberals way down at 39 um that's a pickup for the conservatives uh incumbent clifford small
01:01:02 from central newfoundland declared elected conservatives leading uh narrowly uh but uh
01:01:09 this would be a pickup jonathan rowe picking up the liberal seat from anthony germain that one is
01:01:15 not yet there. The Liberals have declared elected in Cape Spear and Avalon, leading in St. John East.
01:01:23 If the Conservatives would have the seats in Newfoundland, Kevin, I think that's a good sign.
01:01:29 Well, that Long Range Mountain seat is a great sign. The Liberal candidate in that riding was
01:01:34 a 32-year newspaper journalist. Sorry, which riding is this? In Long Range Mountain. And so
01:01:42 a lot of people kind of expected him to have the kind of the name recognition to allow him to win
01:01:47 that seat even in a tough election let alone a good one um now this is a significant change even
01:01:53 in the old confederation debates derrick like back in the day it was the crosby's and the pro
01:02:00 canada movement from saint john and then it was the separatists and the anti-comfederates in the
01:02:05 world and and that always voted liberal that's where joey smallwood was from he's from gander
01:02:10 which is just down the road from Long Range Mountains in Clifford Smalls area.
01:02:16 And then you always expected the city to vote conservative.
01:02:20 And that's, as you can see, has shifted significantly,
01:02:24 which goes again to talk about that demographic changes that we're seeing in these ridings.
01:02:33 Kevin, can I just interject here and ask you this?
01:02:37 the conservatives are very strong when it comes to housing, immigration, all of those issues that
01:02:44 are perceived to be holding the younger voters back, and actually part of what you're talking
01:02:50 about there. Now, I never pictured Newfoundland as being a place where you can't find a home.
01:02:57 so what is driving that conservative we won't call it a you know we won't call it a boom but
01:03:07 they're doing better than everybody expected and it's not the issues that would make the
01:03:12 conservatives popular in toronto what's going on that that's a great question and i think i think
01:03:18 one of the things that's happening across the country is rural canadians are there many of
01:03:22 of the issues that are the same for people in newfoundland are exactly the same as the ones
01:03:27 that are in rural alberta um so it's affordability it's about finding a job it's about those those
01:03:34 nuts and bolts issues um that affect rural canadians all across the country and i think
01:03:39 one of the things we're going to see here is that the old way of thinking i think it used to be that
01:03:44 everyone would think employment insurance when it comes to comes to uh atlantic canada now
01:03:50 employment insurance isn't really an issue because the way it's been shifted and changed over the
01:03:56 years um it has it's lost its political bite um but a lot of in a lot of these seats the issues
01:04:03 are exactly the same no matter what part of the country you come from like nigel i don't think 1.00
01:04:09 like for someone like yourself who's been all over the country and knows the country really
01:04:13 really well if we were to go to place like um stephenville newfoundland which is in that long
01:04:19 Range Mountain riding, it's not going to look and act or our political discussions are not going to
01:04:24 be substantially different than, say, if we're outside of rural Red Deer. And that's just the
01:04:29 way the country, I think, is changing. But I also think it's an opportunity for conservatives,
01:04:34 because in some of these seats where they didn't really compete because of traditional voting
01:04:38 patterns, those voting patterns are starting to move with the rest of the country. We just might
01:04:43 be a little bit blind. All right. Well, I want to bring in a second Eastern bastard here. 1.00
01:04:48 We've got our replacement Frenchman, Raynaud Broussard. 0.97
01:04:53 I know Raynaud.
01:04:54 He also is a veteran of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
01:04:57 We're having a reunion here.
01:05:01 Michel Kelly Gagnon switched on us.
01:05:03 Then we got Daniel Duport.
01:05:08 But Nigel promised me a Frenchman, and we got one. 0.92
01:05:11 Raynaud, thank you for joining us.
01:05:13 Bonsoir.
01:05:14 Well, it's my pleasure to be here.
01:05:15 uh honestly it's good to see you good to see kevin good to see uh you know everybody on the
01:05:20 team and i'm i'm glad to be the token french manager tonight thank you uh so we've only got
01:05:26 uh thank you uh we've only got just water just water this is not vodka yet yet we'll see how
01:05:34 the results go um we've got right now uh i'm getting messages from james finkbunner old
01:05:42 staffer of ours asking why did dave just really hand you water why aren't you drinking beer are
01:05:48 you guys okay uh james we uh levels of alcoholism have significantly decreased since you stopped
01:05:55 working here uh we're we're on the wagon at the standard now uh it'll probably make for a lesser
01:06:01 entertaining show so if our numbers start to go down i will start drinking uh take one for the team
01:06:07 yeah uh okay uh reno we've only got one quebec constituency reporting so far not very much uh
01:06:13 we got 11 polls reporting on it uh that's oh i want you to say hold on i'm gonna bring this
01:06:19 writing up and you're gonna say the name of this constituency um gasp i'm happy to help it's
01:06:29 I can't say three times in a row without messing up.
01:06:38 Okay. Well, that's really all we got to work on. 11 polls reporting. That starts to get
01:06:44 somewhat of a decent sampling here. We've got Alexis Deschamps of the Bloc leading at 47.3.
01:06:53 uh this is the double incumbency uh constituency uh that uh sean here was talking about because i
01:07:01 guess the redistribution you've got incumbents fighting each other those are always interesting
01:07:04 battles uh diane uh diane diane diane yeah okay okay okay uh but these ones are not surprising
01:07:16 at all if you look at the writing so so the reason why you've got two incumbents is because the
01:07:22 I've got a French word, the redicoupage
01:07:26 but the electoral card has changed a little bit
01:07:30 and essentially part of the writing
01:07:32 that was very, very pro-sovereignty, pro-Kobac independence
01:07:38 got put into Le Boutier's writing
01:07:41 so this is really like, it's not surprising that the bloc
01:07:45 would fall ahead in this one
01:07:48 and that the liberals and conservatives
01:07:51 will be a little bit further behind.
01:07:53 But again, you know, it's kind of early on in the night.
01:07:55 I think what will be interesting to see
01:07:58 is once we start getting the results
01:08:00 from around Quebec City, Saguenay,
01:08:03 but also especially Trois-Guyvières.
01:08:05 The conservatives have had a candidate there
01:08:07 who's the former mayor of Trois-Guyvières.
01:08:10 He's been running in that writing for three times.
01:08:12 Every single time he's running there
01:08:14 has been really, really close.
01:08:16 He's been polling very, very well.
01:08:18 Now, recently, what we see is really a three-way tie
01:08:21 where both the Liberals and Conservatives
01:08:23 and the Bloc as well are polling at roughly 30%.
01:08:26 So this is going to be a really fun one to follow at tonight.
01:08:29 If you can, you know, once the results start coming in from Quebec,
01:08:33 the writing of Squawk Viet will be one of the most closely watched, I think.
01:08:38 The Bloc has not fared well in this election,
01:08:42 not nearly as badly as the NDP,
01:08:45 But how worried should the bloc be tonight?
01:08:49 You know, definitely not as worried as the NDP.
01:08:51 You know, the NDP is not sure whether or not they're still going to have official party status.
01:08:55 I think the bloc is not looking in a situation where we wouldn't have official party status, which is having 12 elected officials.
01:09:04 But for the bloc, I think this is going to be a, this is rather hard election, because a lot of the more nationalist sentiment has become a more Canadian nationalist sentiment recently, simply because of the tariff threats coming from down south.
01:09:20 So there's a lot of people that say, you know, maybe we don't want to be part of Canada, but we especially don't want to be a part of the US.
01:09:27 So I think that's one of the things that has hurt the block quite significantly.
01:09:35 Again, it's not nearly as bad as it is for the NDP, but the block is probably not having a good night tonight.
01:09:42 You know, they're most likely looking at the drop.
01:09:44 The last I saw from some polling aggregators in terms of how much they thought the bloc was going to get was 24 seats.
01:09:58 If you compare it to last time around, they had 30, well, to when Parliament was dissolved, they had 33 seats.
01:10:04 So it's still a significant drop for the bloc.
01:10:08 But it is nowhere near the apocalypse that must be going on in the NDP of our room right now.
01:10:13 Sean, whenever you, if you've got an update to make, you just flag me and we'll bring you in.
01:10:18 Have you got anything?
01:10:19 I don't have an update, but I've got kind of a point to make.
01:10:23 So this is, let's see, let me figure out how to get out of my own.
01:10:29 Why is there a riding in Alberta reporting?
01:10:31 No, you know what? This is 70% of the population in Canada lives here, here, and here.
01:10:37 Oh, okay, okay.
01:10:38 What I'm about to say is that this is where it's going to start to get real here within the next probably 15 minutes or so.
01:10:47 What running is that? That's about this lower St. Lawrence Valley down into Niagara.
01:10:54 Yeah. Yeah. Okay. All right. Well, whenever you've got an update, you just flag me.
01:10:58 Okay. We'll do it.
01:11:00 Kevin, let's look back at the Atlantic provinces, how they're coming in.
01:11:08 uh newfoundland is looking uh i mean the terra nova the peninsulas uh is still very close
01:11:19 still holds to come in that could still go either way but uh three three seats in newfoundland is
01:11:24 that about as conservative as newfoundland can get in a federal election i think that is about
01:11:29 as conservative as you can get um and if you look at the particular that terra nova seat that was
01:11:35 also uh like long range mountain previously held by the conservative by the liberals excuse me for
01:11:40 a number of years um so again these are good signs for the conservatives that they're picking up these
01:11:45 seats um that were traditional liberal seats i want to pick up on a point though derek that
01:11:50 were now mentioned about the ndp because we can take a little look at at some of that um in this
01:11:56 and if we look at riding oh sorry sorry one one second i want to bring uh dave nailer in here
01:12:01 we've got some interesting news out of uh vancouver and jake beat singh's headquarters
01:12:07 let's uh let's put dave you're off the bench what do you got
01:12:13 dave dave your sound is not on oops sorry dave's a boomer yes 0.90
01:12:22 the ndp have been uh real dicks this entire election uh they uh haven't responded to any
01:12:28 of our emails haven't told us when any of their events are well we find out where jagmeet singh's 0.97
01:12:34 uh so-called victory celebration will be in burnaby tonight and we get kicked out uh so we
01:12:40 asked why they haven't been uh giving us any information and uh they replied just because
01:12:45 you're the western standard so uh remember ndp those who laugh those who laughed last
01:12:51 laugh the loudest yeah uh okay uh well two things dave one you still got to fix that microphone
01:12:59 uh two make sure uh jared doesn't leave he should just park outside of jake meets uh headquarters
01:13:05 there um give us the best he can from there that is some wild stuff though uh in production we're
01:13:12 set up to bring in the uh speeches from the leaders when they take the stage later tonight right
01:13:16 let's put a keffiyeh on 1.00
01:13:20 bring him right in
01:13:22 tell Jared to put a keffiyeh on 0.98
01:13:25 and start jumping up and down
01:13:28 around cripples 1.00
01:13:30 I will give him that advice
01:13:35 tell him to do that
01:13:37 he'll get it no problem
01:13:38 sounds good
01:13:40 sorry to interrupt you there Kevin
01:13:44 Well, that's a really good segue, Derek.
01:13:47 It's probably important we probably spend a little bit of time on the NDP because there's some numbers in here, I think, also tell a really compelling story.
01:13:54 So if you look at the riding of Halifax, Halifax is, if you look at Atlantic Canada, it is traditionally the hotbed of support for the NDP.
01:14:03 They're running Lisa Roberts.
01:14:05 She's a provincial MLA, a supposed star candidate for the party in this election.
01:14:12 They've held this riding.
01:14:14 And they traditionally do very, very well here.
01:14:17 They're running third in Halifax tonight in these early results.
01:14:22 In Halifax West, another riding that they've traditionally competed well in.
01:14:28 They're scoring about 7% of the vote in that seat.
01:14:33 SACFIL, which was long held by an NDP MP, Peter Stouffer, very popular in Nova Scotia.
01:14:41 Tonight, the party's getting just 5% of the vote.
01:14:44 so these numbers if you're an ndp supporter tonight you would kind of look at those ridings
01:14:50 um in these early results to see how you're doing and as you can tell they're not doing very good
01:14:56 in fact they're doing abysmal they used to hold derbeth coal harbor as well right was that uh
01:15:01 that was the lady with the glasses uh that's right that's exactly right and and this writing was also
01:15:06 held um uh there was mayor from halifax who held this riding he lost the riding to robert chisholm
01:15:15 a former provincial new democrat who then turned it back over to the liberals but this is again
01:15:21 this is prime ndp territory not just in the atlantic canada but across the country because
01:15:28 this was the area that alexa mcdonough used to hold when she was ndp leader back in the 90s so
01:15:34 they've always done very very well here and if you look at those early results they're not just
01:15:38 doing poor derek uh they're not even competitive um you know they're ranging somewhere between 10
01:15:44 and 5 percent uh in those ridings and if if for all of you know for all if we were to go look at
01:15:50 those seats i think we would assume that they're strong um ndp ridings and they're just not doing
01:15:56 very well um a second here so presumably kevin they're going to lean more to the liberals than
01:16:05 to the conservatives if they're starting from an ndp orientation well yes in fact the writing
01:16:11 of halifax west which was close in the last election uh in this election the ndp vote has
01:16:17 almost entirely gone to the liberals early on um so the lib the liberals scoring about 62 61 of the
01:16:25 vote the ndp are scoring just seven percent of the vote and the question is is as we get into
01:16:30 ontario um other urban seats like this one and particularly in the 905 what is that decline in
01:16:37 ndp support going to do in ridings that conservatives would traditionally need to win
01:16:42 in seats like the mississaugas and the bramptons and things like that that as um as you were
01:16:47 showing in the previous graph of where the the election is really won and lost uh in those seats
01:16:55 that's where the ndp has always played a major role it doesn't appear like they're going to
01:17:00 tonight and if and knowing that how are those results going to look an hour or two from now
01:17:05 okay uh i want to bring in uh sean here uh he has an update so uh yes um gasp easy
01:17:16 however you say it why don't we just call it g-i-m-l anyway so it's flipped over to liberal
01:17:25 here uh but going back to what we were talking about the ndp 1.5 percent i'm not even sure who
01:17:32 rp is like is that like the rhino party it's polling they're competitive um wow uh orange 0.91
01:17:42 is the new green the or the ndp i mean based on the atlantic results so far is essentially where
01:17:49 the the greens are when they're having a good election four to seven percent is a good green
01:17:55 election that's where the ndp is at right now um and and you know you remember if you remember back
01:18:02 in 2011 when there was the orange wave in quebec uh look the ndp was bowling nowhere near what it
01:18:09 is right now uh it back in 2011 the ndp got 103 seats they got uh seats in places like uh bertie
01:18:17 vale with true flan brosso um in quebec that party has just has gone through a complete meltdown
01:18:24 Even with the last election, you know, last election, they had 10% in province. They only had one writing. This year, again, they're only looking at one writing. And it's not a writing where they're strong because they're the NDP. It's writing where they're strong because their local candidate is strong in that writing.
01:18:40 If that local candidate switched conservatives tomorrow, you know, very unlikely it would happen, but that writing would switch conservatives right away.
01:18:48 So, you know, the NDP has been collapsing in the rest of the country, but the NDP collapse in Quebec was probably the story we have from 2019 and 2021, even 2015.
01:19:01 Yeah.
01:19:04 Sorry.
01:19:05 Raynaud, what time are we going to get results coming out of Quebec?
01:19:09 We should be getting them soon, shouldn't we?
01:19:10 Oh, in about 20 minutes.
01:19:12 Polls are closing at 9.30 here.
01:19:14 There was one exception for Gaspis-Laisille
01:19:16 that closed a little bit earlier,
01:19:17 but the rest should be, well, I'm saying 9.30,
01:19:20 but, you know, 7.30 amount of time, I guess.
01:19:22 Yeah.
01:19:23 Yeah.
01:19:24 And just the results aren't going to be that slow
01:19:26 coming out in the West
01:19:27 because the polls will close earlier out here.
01:19:30 So we have less voting time,
01:19:32 but most people have voted by 8.30, you know.
01:19:34 What time did we close here?
01:19:35 I thought it was 7.30.
01:19:36 Did we close by 7.30?
01:19:37 7.30 or, yeah.
01:19:38 You know, most people should have voted. Well, I think it's because when we look at the 715, I was running a local campaign and it was quite depressing to know that you already knew how the election was going. And then you just sat there for an extra two hours. So I do think that they put a lot of the closing times a little shorter. And from everyone I hear, I don't know who you guys folks have talked to today, but polling stations are quite quiet. And I don't know if that's the case for others, but advanced polls were crazy.
01:20:07 Yeah, like quite absurdly busy.
01:20:10 Now it might have been the Easter weekend, but that might also, you know, meaning that there's slower, like the quicker count and less people standing there past 730.
01:20:23 Yeah, I think the polls were something like 1.5 million in the early polls in the last election.
01:20:32 This time it's been 7 million.
01:20:34 And so that tells you that an awful lot of people made the decision to go early.
01:20:40 But the 1.5 was in itself a big jump on the election before that.
01:20:44 So it's like advanced polling has come into fashion in a big way.
01:20:48 Have you ever voted on Election Day? I never have.
01:20:50 I have never voted on Election Day.
01:20:52 You know you're a political security when you've never voted on Election Day.
01:20:54 I also go to the returning office, or usually when you have to write the name in.
01:20:58 So, yeah.
01:21:00 See, like in 2019, it was a million people turned out for the advanced polls.
01:21:04 In 2015, it was only 600,000.
01:21:07 Now it's seven and a half million.
01:21:08 So it's an incredible number.
01:21:13 How campaigns are going to change, too.
01:21:15 I mean, as this moves into a larger voting period, you've got to be intense in that first three weeks now.
01:21:20 You don't, you're not waiting for everybody to vote on that last day.
01:21:23 Like, you've got to have your.
01:21:25 I hope from this we also learn if that's the case.
01:21:27 like parties need to release those platforms before that was a conservative mistake they
01:21:34 released their platform a week after seven and a half million people voted i mean that's
01:21:38 a bad tactical yeah and i mean even the debates like do they really need to happen that close to
01:21:43 the end of this is what well we should have more debates but at least have one that's not like a
01:21:47 two days away from or the day before advanced voting starts because advanced voting uh is both
01:21:53 more available now and it's become a part of people's civic habits where it's it's now not a
01:21:58 oh i'm only going to vote on advanced polls if i'm away on vacation or something now now it's
01:22:02 very common when it was what six to seven percent was the undecided by the debate which
01:22:09 ideally was more strategic for the conservatives and also if they'd released their platform earlier
01:22:14 because there has been some pretty significant policies that the conservative party has released
01:22:20 but to who? Yeah, well, actually to you and to us, but I wonder how many people actually say,
01:22:28 ah, there it is. That's what I've been looking for. There is the liberal platform. There is
01:22:32 the conservative platform, and now I'm going to go through them, and I'm going to make a careful
01:22:37 decision. Do you think that happens? No. No. But your strategy on the back last few days,
01:22:46 and we know like the significance of the GOTV that you're getting into it's now like your GOTV
01:22:53 needs to be heavier and more strategic before advanced polls then what's GOTV get out that boat 0.91
01:22:58 oh I've heard Jenny Byrne say that once you know what do not compare me to Jenny Byrne
01:23:04 let's uh you know what let's uh compare some of the results I'm the only woman here 0.51
01:23:10 let's compare some of the results as we have them uh from 338 uh canada uh 338 canada.com
01:23:18 uh that's uh i think uh this has got to be 343 here pretty quick yeah yeah they have to get it
01:23:25 he he plays a real gamble and uh what domain names uh he gets um there there are pretty good
01:23:31 uh polling aggregator and predictor um there goes my glasses uh i generally have a lot of faith in
01:23:39 it but it can be wrong but so far let's you know let's look uh avalon he called liberal is liberal
01:23:47 uh cape spear central newfoundland he listed as a toss-up uh leaning liberal uh that has gone
01:23:57 conservative uh uh terranova the peninsula of peninsulas he listed as likely liberal uh it is
01:24:05 at this moment leaning conservative still narrow it could go liberal but it's 49
01:24:11 conservative 36.8 liberal uh he listed that as uh really list that one as as likely liberal
01:24:21 so it's it's pretty rare when he says likely or strongly you can generally take that to the bank
01:24:26 the toss-ups obviously more likely to go either way but i mean like the conservatives are winning
01:24:33 some things that were called in the polling aggregators as likely liberal. That's rare.
01:24:37 Yeah I was gonna ask Kevin actually on that if that speaks to what you were talking about before
01:24:42 with the blue-collared vote or maybe some of those demographics that are leaving their traditional
01:24:48 vote and leaning more conservative now that that's maybe the answer. We said before you joined that
01:24:55 you know none of us answer the phone to answer a poll so that might be part of why our conservative
01:25:00 votes not getting weighed properly but do you want to comment on that kevin about what you're seeing
01:25:04 in the maritimes and what could be attributing to the lack of accuracy yeah i think there's two
01:25:10 things the first is kind of the point that nigel made which is rural canada is just more conservative
01:25:16 that is just a fact and i think the differences between the regions as time is going on
01:25:23 is becoming less and less and less um so i think that's the first one and then erica i think you
01:25:28 hit the nail right on the head i think these demographic changes are significant and i think
01:25:32 as we kind of look through the the voting patterns and and how these elections turn out which is then
01:25:39 what are our parties going to be all about because traditionally conservatives were always the big
01:25:44 business rich people party the conservative party today is likely to be very very different after
01:25:51 this election primarily because the supporters who will support it will be significantly different
01:25:56 and as we kind of look through leadership and who's going to lead and the types of things we're going
01:26:01 to talk about all of this is going to have a big impact and i think this is just playing out now
01:26:07 in the early results the future will be different from the one that is well actually i think the
01:26:18 conservative party of the future is the one that we're actually seeing now bringing its vote out
01:26:23 to the table and my impression broadly is that the modern conservative is a young working man
01:26:33 who is concerned about his home his family his security on the street all of those things that
01:26:41 used to be the concern of the old conservatives but now the older conservatives and i'd love you
01:26:47 to tell me whether it's the same back east, but they seem to be so anxious and fearful about the
01:26:55 future that they're looking for a safe place. And somehow or other they see the liberals as safe,
01:27:01 they see Mr. Carney as safe and reassuring, whereas the young guys kind of like that
01:27:07 zip that Pierre Polyev brings to the argument. You know, he's kind of sassy and puts people in
01:27:13 in their place young guys like that a lot what do you say i agree in fact i'm glad reno's here
01:27:19 because i know he's done a lot of research and writing on this very topic um and so i'll i'll
01:27:24 actually defer to him on this um but i think as we kind of go through the night we're going to hear
01:27:30 speeches tonight from the various leaders um somebody's going to win somebody's going to lose
01:27:34 i think two things that if we're into a four-year liberal majority government that is going to change
01:27:42 our discussion about liberal or excuse me about conservative leaders and ideas after this um
01:27:50 and the second thing it's going to do is if we're going to have just a two-party system
01:27:55 the choices are going to be far more stark which i think given you know your conversation with erica
01:28:01 is really really important because i think now suddenly we're going to be able to have
01:28:06 two very distinct choices very similar to south of the border which i think for a lot of
01:28:12 will be a lot easier to to to what you're saying you were saying kevin you know how they used to
01:28:20 say uh there's this old saying like if you're not a liberal by the time you're 20 you have no heart
01:28:25 but if you're not conservative by the time you're 40 you have no brains uh you know looking at the
01:28:30 polling numbers it sort of feels like that has inverted and i think a lot a large part of this
01:28:36 is you know when when conservatives talk about this last liberal decade uh not everybody has
01:28:41 experienced it in the same way as, I believe, as Trevor Toon that wrote this not so long ago.
01:28:48 But essentially, if you're a young person starting out in your career, you're the one that sees the
01:28:55 lack of wage growth, the lack of opportunity, the home ownership that becomes even more
01:29:00 unattainable every single day. But if you're somebody that's later in your career, you've
01:29:06 already got your assets, you've already saved up and you're just a couple of years away from
01:29:11 retirements well the last couple of years for the for you know people that have assets they've been
01:29:16 pretty good uh the stock market has been going has been going well except the last few months
01:29:20 uh the when you look at the price of housing uh you know if you own a home the more the price of
01:29:26 housing goes up the more your savings go up uh it's if you look at it after uh inflation the
01:29:32 price of a home you have the price of the average home in canada increased by 43 every single day
01:29:38 after inflation uh for the last decade so for people that own these homes for people that are
01:29:42 older voters uh you they just don't have the same uh lived experience to borrow a term from uh from
01:29:50 the left uh than uh the younger folks and i think that's why the concerted message has resonated
01:29:56 so well with the 18 to 34 we did 34 uh to 55 uh with people that are you know either starting
01:30:03 in their career or right in the middle of it is because these are the folks that just don't see
01:30:08 this chance to advance or this opportunity that other generations used to have in Canada and that
01:30:14 Canada used to be known for. So Kevin, I want to, I got a question for you, kind of going back to
01:30:20 the 338 here. It's, it has, so Terranova, the Peninsulas was, and Newfoundland was listed as
01:30:30 a pretty solid liberal writing.
01:30:33 It is now leaning
01:30:33 conservative. It's not
01:30:38 done yet, but that was listed as solid.
01:30:41 Central Nova was
01:30:42 listed as likely liberal.
01:30:45 Central Nova
01:30:46 with incumbent Sean Frazier,
01:30:48 a guy, gun owners, could be very
01:30:50 familiar with.
01:30:53 Okay.
01:30:55 The conservatives
01:30:56 are leading
01:30:57 in that constituency. Again,
01:31:00 uh a little less than 100 polls to close and then uh what was the next one uh cumberland
01:31:06 gloucestershire was listed as leaning liberal uh conservatives have a healthy but not insurmountable
01:31:14 lead in that constituency so the conservatives have so far won every toss-up riding in atlantic
01:31:21 uh and are leading although haven't yet been elected but leading in two solid uh liberal
01:31:28 writings uh what's this telling you well i i think i think this is good fortunes for pierre
01:31:34 poliver early on you'll remember in 2015 when we sat around and watched the results coming in
01:31:40 everyone looked to the maritimes first was the first results that come in and was stephen harper
01:31:44 going to be able to keep to a minority was he not and 32 liberals were returned on that night
01:31:50 and it just started the stream of what was going to happen afterwards what we're seeing here is
01:31:56 largely the status quo let's be honest and so uh we're not going to see the decline but we're also
01:32:02 not seeing derrick the conservative pickups like look at the riding of frederickton for example
01:32:07 in new brunswick that is a riding that bounces between the various parties it's kind of a
01:32:11 bellwether brian mcdonald the conservative candidate is a former provincial member of
01:32:17 the legislature and he's running against david miles who's a jazz musician famous in the region
01:32:23 actually and uh and so that's one that if the conservatives are going to have a really good
01:32:28 night that you would start to look at them winning saint john as well blue collar town people that
01:32:34 work in moosehead brewery or the or the mill again that one's going liberal so it's essentially the
01:32:41 status quo i would warn on central nova if you look at the kind of the area the near the white 1.00
01:32:47 near the ocean that's along the number old number seven highway that area is like this twisty turny
01:32:53 old road with houses on it that traditionally is more conservative that vote and then if you go
01:33:02 into the towns again that tends to be a little bit more liberal so it really depends on where
01:33:08 the vote is coming from in that riding and you're not going to know that for a little bit so this
01:33:14 one tends to go up and down my experience on election nights because i get excited about
01:33:19 results like this and then uh kind of a flip flip a different way that other riding cumberland
01:33:25 colchester the conservatives are going to win that um that's bill casey's old riding who's a
01:33:30 conservative then he flipped to the liberals um and uh steven ellis won it in the last election
01:33:37 this is like this is as close to what rural alberta would look like that being said again
01:33:44 going back to the ndp that is also a riding that has been that has traditionally in more recent
01:33:51 history some good ndp vote and when you take that away it changes the dynamic a little bit which
01:33:57 makes it a little closer than it should but that central nova one i wouldn't is going to be a long
01:34:02 night watching that result because a lot of those ballot boxes along the number seven highway are
01:34:07 to take a long time to get to get them counted uh kind of a funny story i was doing poll uh
01:34:14 poll counting and leaders tour on the number seven highway and there's no cell phone coverage
01:34:18 i thought we were lost to the earth uh one election night so there's a lot of people you
01:34:22 can't even call in to get those results in all right uh update from uh sean
01:34:28 um so interesting note here um cbc has assigned this writing of montcalm i can actually say that
01:34:40 one because it's north of montreal um as bq even though there's zero two yeah zero votes
01:34:47 they haven't called it they're saying the blocks are leading yeah they said yeah they're leading
01:34:52 in it they haven't said they haven't called it as a life okay okay sorry sorry that is not
01:35:00 that is not the writing of mongalm that is that it's the one it's the one where uh they've got
01:35:05 the block leading's writing of terbonne mongalm is just a little bit further north uh oh oh yeah
01:35:12 no i'm looking here that's called terrible was that terrible it's it's close enough you know
01:35:23 it's uh how do you say it how do you say it terrible okay actually i'm looking here here
01:35:27 i'm gonna bring this in uh there actually are some results coming in uh one it is one poll
01:35:34 okay so that's maybe that's an advantage oh here we go here we go here we go it's it's one poll
01:35:38 but this is the sort of area that the Liberals were looking at consolidating. So if you look
01:35:44 at Quebec's electoral map from the previous election, they sort of have the highlight of
01:35:48 Montreal and Laval, except a couple of exceptions. But outside the island, that was very much block
01:35:54 Quebecois territory. And this is one of those places where they're looking to make some gains.
01:35:59 Look, the reason why this is block Quebecois territory, if you look at it provincially,
01:36:03 you know, these writings right now, they're being represented by the Coalition Amir Québec,
01:36:06 the cac uh before that they were pq forever uh especially the writing of terbonne and now it's
01:36:13 it's it's expected that provincially that writing or at least a good part of that writing is going
01:36:18 to fly back to the pq so this is a writing that's been very pro-sovereignty for a long time
01:36:24 it's bordering montreal uh though it's it's it's off it's just on the north uh side of the island
01:36:29 but it is so so it's on the north side but you know much like we talk about uh you know downtown
01:36:35 toronto versus the suburbs you still have the same dynamic with montreal where the suburbs uh
01:36:40 especially the north shore suburbs are a lot more heavily frank and founder a lot more uh heavily
01:36:45 pro-sovereignty typically or at least they they vote for the party quebec without necessarily
01:36:49 being pro-sovereignty um if the if the liberals are to make major gains these are the ones they're
01:36:56 looking to flip uh because they're essentially profiting from the the drop in the bloc cubico
01:37:02 votes so look this is just one poll reporting out of 208 like this is not a definitive result by far
01:37:09 uh but if the uh block manages to keep it like this is this is a good uh this this is a bad sign
01:37:17 for liberals and i would say as such a good sign for conservatives and here again we've got uh ndp
01:37:23 at about five percent um they're pulling with the people's party and the greens geez okay um
01:37:32 can i just point out this is random but i'm checking on elections alberta because i wanted
01:37:36 to check what time bc polls close um they're apparently having technical difficulties you've
01:37:41 You've got one day to do your job.
01:37:45 Conspiracy.
01:37:46 Yeah.
01:37:47 Can you start on this one?
01:37:48 Apparently.
01:37:51 Okay.
01:37:53 I guess the big theme so far is the NDP.
01:37:57 They're just gone.
01:38:00 And that doesn't bode well in Ontario, though.
01:38:02 I mean, if that collapse continues into Ontario, we know just by nature.
01:38:08 I mean, you can't assume with votes when they leave one party and go to another.
01:38:10 But when it's NDP going somewhere else, chances are really good they're going to go liberal.
01:38:14 So, I mean, yeah, things are looking pretty promising off the bat, more than we expected in the Maritimes.
01:38:19 But that NDP collapse is something to be concerned about.
01:38:22 It appears that we'll see a lot of strategic voting.
01:38:24 We're praying that nobody shows up.
01:38:26 Oh, we have a really interesting guest in the wings right now.
01:38:31 Let's bring in my old friend here.
01:38:35 Kent Hare is a former liberal member of the Alberta legislature.
01:38:40 back when those used to exist and uh he was a liberal member of parliament for calgary center
01:38:47 and a member of uh the trudeau government's cabinet uh from 2015 to 2019 how you doing kent
01:38:54 hey i'm doing great how's the team at western standard doing tonight it's getting a little
01:38:59 sticky uh they tend to turn off the air conditioning after regular work hours here
01:39:02 no matter how hard i beg them but uh well you know you you just gotta go you gotta go grease
01:39:07 the the landlord a little more there try and be uh that guy what hey nevertheless i roll by your
01:39:14 office all the time maybe i'll go talk to him derek okay i appreciate that you can put in a word
01:39:19 uh so kent uh have you been watching the results as they're coming in at audi so far
01:39:24 uh i actually just got uh back uh doing some uh last minute campaigning for the calgary uh center
01:39:31 team here with Lindsey Lou now. So I haven't been privy to those results, but I heard that the NDP
01:39:39 are struggling mightily, which it is not surprising to me and the like. But if you could refresh me
01:39:48 on the other stuff, I think I can give some opinions. Yeah, here, well, let's, we'll throw
01:39:53 the map in here. So the Conservatives are, they're winning the toss-ups in the Atlantic
01:39:59 provinces right now the liberals stand to you know they're still leading with the most seats
01:40:05 it's it's a strong liberal region but the conservatives are uh leading and leading are
01:40:10 elected in three in newfoundland uh looks like three in nova scotia one two three four in new
01:40:17 brunswick uh they're they're holding every one of their incumbents uh they're picking up some of the
01:40:24 swings, and even picking up some that were not considered to be swings, but it's certainly far
01:40:29 from a blue wave. But the big thing we're seeing is the utter annihilation from the NDP polling.
01:40:36 Some ratings as low as 2%. The highest I think I saw them was 7 or 8 in the very highest. Maybe
01:40:44 I'm wrong, but the highest I can recall seeing them in any Atlantic constituency so far was
01:40:50 like seven or eight percent um why i mean by perception and kind of narrative mark carney
01:40:59 is thought to be a less hard left leader than justin trudeau yet he's completely
01:41:06 folded the ndp vote in how the hell did he do that well i i think uh for the better part of
01:41:13 the decade the the trudeau liberals uh pushed uh jagmeet so far to the left that he was falling
01:41:19 off a cliff. And then when Mr. Carney came in with the NDP weakened to the point they were,
01:41:28 he was able to pivot to a more centrist or even slightly right of center campaign that I think
01:41:36 the country sort of appreciated that approach and saw it as real change, not just window dressing.
01:41:44 I believe also that, you know, Mr. Carney, with the issue being national unity and Donald Trump, that's an issue that plays into Mr. Carney's strengths more than it did to Pierre Polyev's.
01:41:58 And I think with the NDP rendered nudigatory almost right from the start or right from Mr. Trudeau leaving, I think it gave them a lot of room to the right for them to pivot to.
01:42:12 And I think that's why you're seeing them, the NDP fall off the cliff.
01:42:18 Okay.
01:42:19 Oh, we'll jump up there. 0.99
01:42:20 Do we have an update from you, Sean?
01:42:22 Yeah, we do.
01:42:23 All right.
01:42:26 I'm standing in front of it.
01:42:27 battle for deloitte minister metal lake something i can pronounce and it's on
01:42:31 the alberta border as we know i know it's just an outlier but we got no
01:42:38 surprise 85 percent 12 percent liberal 10 percent liberal i'm looking right now
01:42:44 well i think that's a lower than what people were even expecting i think they
01:42:47 were expecting maybe a higher number but here again ndp one vote that's a
01:42:51 Rosemary Falk. Wow. 0.2% for the NDP. Yeah. And we've got, actually here, I'm going to bring
01:43:00 the map back here. I'm going to bring in Raynaud. Raynaud, we've got some of the, some Quebec
01:43:07 results starting to trickle in. Again, a lot of these are just one poll. We've got LaPays,
01:43:14 and hot.
01:43:16 Liberals with a big lead.
01:43:17 Again, one poll in.
01:43:19 Really small poll.
01:43:21 Yeah, like, there's like less than
01:43:23 30 people who have voted. Can't really read
01:43:25 anything into that.
01:43:28 Yeah, okay, well,
01:43:29 this one's actually got some numbers in.
01:43:32 Saint-Marie-Champlain.
01:43:34 Liberals with the
01:43:35 commanding early lead. Three of 296
01:43:38 polls in. Liberals at
01:43:39 53.8. Conservatives
01:43:41 22.6. Block 20.1.
01:43:44 Lac Saint-Jean
01:43:48 Block Ahead
01:43:50 and
01:43:51 well this one's got some more
01:43:53 Chicoutimi La Fjord 0.99
01:43:55 I don't know if they say Fjord like that in French
01:43:57 but what are you taking from this
01:44:00 Reno? Forget the ones 1.00
01:44:02 that have a single poll reporting
01:44:03 Honestly it's still
01:44:05 kind of early. The only one with more than a single poll
01:44:08 is Saint-Maurice Champlain
01:44:09 and that one I could have called for you
01:44:11 six weeks ago
01:44:13 It's François-Philippe Champagne's writing.
01:44:15 It's one of the writings where liberals are very strong.
01:44:17 If you're not doing well in Saint-Maurice-Champlain,
01:44:21 they're not doing well anywhere else in the country.
01:44:24 So this is not exactly a surprising start.
01:44:26 I think the interesting race is to follow.
01:44:29 So you alluded to Chicous-Limmy-Lafiard. 1.00
01:44:33 So that's Richard Martel's writing, conservative.
01:44:36 He has been hammering the liberals
01:44:39 for the handling of the woodland caribou fowl for a certain time.
01:44:46 And so have the Bloc Québécois as well.
01:44:49 So I think this one will be quite interesting to follow
01:44:51 to see which of those two parties actually ends up on top,
01:44:57 especially with the...
01:44:59 There's always this perception that Quebec is a very liberal place.
01:45:06 I tend to disagree.
01:45:07 I tend to say that there are sort of two different conservative parties, but that appeal to two different conservative demographics.
01:45:17 And the bloc would appeal more to nationalists, whereas the conservatives would appeal a little bit more to economic and fiscal conservatives.
01:45:24 So I think this will be an interesting one to follow, especially because the bloc has been putting a lot of effort into trying to take that writing for a long time.
01:45:33 all right uh kent uh yeah turn this thing off here um what is it uh i saw the polls have just
01:45:45 closed everywhere from quebec to alberta uh bc is the only place still voting at this time
01:45:51 well maybe yukon um uh what do you what do you think how do the liberals gonna do in alberta
01:45:59 tonight uh it's never been obviously the strongest place uh you uh you are a bit of a unicorn uh the
01:46:06 first liberal elected in calgary uh well in my lifetime um what are you expecting to see tonight
01:46:14 for the liberals in alberta you know i i think they've uh they've run some strong candidates
01:46:19 you know our good friend eric uh cory hogan uh who's been a the been the uh communication
01:46:26 director for
01:46:27 two premiers, two very
01:46:30 different premiers. Premier
01:46:32 Notley and Premier Kenney
01:46:34 is running in Calgary
01:46:35 Confederation. I think he's got
01:46:38 a great opportunity. I think
01:46:40 Lindsay Lou now in
01:46:41 Calgary Centre has a real opportunity.
01:46:44 I think they can win up
01:46:46 seven seats here in Alberta.
01:46:48 That's where I... Seven.
01:46:51 That's your
01:46:52 ceiling. What's your
01:46:53 floor for the Liberals in Alberta?
01:46:56 puts your room i'll go four uh i think they they won't win less than four uh they won't win that
01:47:04 less than four no i i think uh uh i think you gotta be optimistic for your own team i get it
01:47:10 no i i i i no no it's not it's not even that i i i actually think uh confederation and uh
01:47:18 george jahal's writing calorie mcknight are are locked i think you think confederations
01:47:23 a lock i think confederations a lock i think confederations a lock i i was uh door knocking
01:47:30 there over the course of the campaign the ndp vote has cratered you got to remember when matt
01:47:36 grand almost won that riding in uh 2015. he worked like a mofo he worked hard for like two years to
01:47:44 do that but but the but the ndp got eight percent eight percent of the vote that election i think
01:47:50 that's going right down right down to I think the vote for the NDP in that in
01:47:59 the Confederation will be too slim and none and I think slim just left town 0.94
01:48:04 Derek so I really think Confederation goes I think Calgary Centre has a chance
01:48:12 to go but I think because good Lindsay's a strong candidate lives up in 1.00
01:48:16 her riding and done a lot of things at City Hall and community building. So I think that one's
01:48:23 on the edge. It could be close, a thousand votes either way. And like I said, I even think Skyview
01:48:30 can go in Calgary. If you look at the demographics there, it was a riding that George actually was
01:48:39 in and then switched over to mcknight and if you look at so he and edmonton center um this is uh
01:48:47 there's six right there and i could probably find one more that's why i'm getting a seven but my uh
01:48:52 i'm having a little bit of a brain freeze here i think they win seven tonight kent if i can
01:48:57 challenge you because at first you kind of came at it from you know it's because of carney's message
01:49:03 and quote, unquote, real change. But do you think that that's actually because people support the
01:49:11 liberals? Or do you think it is the disastrous decline of Jagmeet Singh, who might be neck and
01:49:17 neck for unpopularity, close to Justin Trudeau? So and maybe how that applies to Alberta as well,
01:49:25 that it's actually not an increase in liberal support. It's just a dissatisfaction with the
01:49:32 NDP and how you think some of those ridings even Strathcona and Griesbach are gonna play out in
01:49:37 Alberta? Well I think Albertans have largely been conditioned at least center center left voters
01:49:45 have been conditioned to vote for the party that's best able to beat the conservatives. This has been
01:49:52 even a provincial strategy when the provincial liberals did well they galvanized more of that
01:49:59 vote. When the provincial NDP did well, they galvanized more of the progressive vote. So I
01:50:05 don't think this is anything new, but the NDP federally weakness, I don't think Mr. Singh has
01:50:12 resonated in his now almost eight years in politics or really been to stake out some territory
01:50:20 because the Liberals under Trudeau were very center-left I sense that Kearney
01:50:27 is is change enough okay change enough and simply put the this election may
01:50:47 have been a lot closer should have the American president not said making Canada a 51st state
01:50:56 or making it part of the United States. I believe that that was the big issue. And let's face it,
01:51:04 the media then showcased Mr. Carney's response to Mr. Trump. And it was very difficult for Mr.
01:51:12 polyab to break into that to change his messaging from what it had been for the last four years and
01:51:19 and frankly it sort of took him off his game and gave uh the liberals some wind in their sails and
01:51:25 when it comes to the national unity issue and things of this nature the liberals are
01:51:31 are are the warm blanket that canadians rightly or wrongly crawl back into the conservative party
01:51:38 yeah oh and uh we're gonna go to uh sean for an update here there's a lot of results starting to
01:51:44 to flow in um okay okay we've got a lot of results pouring in but because we've been
01:51:49 fixated so much on the ndp they're finally on the board folks they got uh 57 27 votes in kenora
01:52:03 can you do that one but i think the interesting point here is that the
01:52:06 conservative is the incumbent and he's only got four yeah but that you know like that's one hole
01:52:12 in a constituency oh ndp just scored again leduc with taskman all right katherine swampy oh i'm
01:52:19 sure they're gonna win there yeah they're also reading uh in the arguably most the liberals are
01:52:28 leading the most uh arguably most conservative writing in uh ontario algonquin rent from pembroke
01:52:34 that is uh the ottawa valley for those of you who do not know that's where guys like randy hillier
01:52:39 are from or where i'm from uh it does not elect uh liberals at least once the party unified again
01:52:46 buybacks happen in there as we speak yeah yeah that's cheryl gallant cheryl gallant uh there 0.63
01:52:52 were only two uh canadian alliance uh mps elected east of manitoba in 2000 both were from the ottawa
01:53:00 valley scott reed and cheryl gallant and they're both still there uh but let's let's let's put up
01:53:06 the big national map here okay see now now it's conservative um but it was uh briefly listed as
01:53:12 liberal okay so results coming in um my constituency yellowhead that's where i get to
01:53:18 yeah any bitty thing right western calgary all the way up to jasper that is one hell of a riding
01:53:26 it goes from well south of Calgary
01:53:29 to well north of Edmonton
01:53:31 big chunk, mostly mountains
01:53:33 and cattle
01:53:34 mostly moose, a lot of moose voting there
01:53:37 they've got both national parks
01:53:38 I don't know how this has not been called by the CBC yet
01:53:41 like literally as soon as the first one comes in
01:53:43 the Conservatives at 80%
01:53:44 call it
01:53:46 we've got Battleford's Law Administer
01:53:48 Meadowlake in Saskatchewan
01:53:50 the incumbent there has done the Liberals
01:53:52 to Falkoff
01:53:53 that's Rosie Falk
01:53:55 80 almost 85 percent of the vote uh bow river uh back area area i used to represent uh conservatives
01:54:04 are at 87 those numbers are not likely to change much uh this is where it just becomes the battle
01:54:11 of conservatives of who can have the higher percentage and two of those what is it davian
01:54:15 turex is another one that's uh up there for how high can you get of support yeah so actually
01:54:22 Bow River here. That's David Bexley. That's the father of Kian Bexley of Counter Signal and Juno News.
01:54:29 Yeah, there's really nothing that interesting in Alberta yet.
01:54:34 We're really going to have to get into Calgary and Edmonton with a decent number of polls reporting in some of those either hyper urban constituencies or heavily ethnic constituencies where you could have some battle.
01:54:48 But we're seeing lots in Quebec. We're seeing lots in Ontario.
01:54:51 I was just going to say
01:54:53 Alright, let's go to Sean
01:54:55 Let's go to Welfare Wolf
01:54:57 Welfare Wolf
01:54:58 I guess what's striking me about what's going on in Quebec
01:55:01 Is how well the Bloc is holding up 0.61
01:55:03 They're leading in about a dozen seats
01:55:05 And looks like
01:55:07 The Lower St. Lawrence is becoming a real battle
01:55:10 Between the Liberals and the Bloc 0.56
01:55:11 Okay, so
01:55:13 Let's bring in Reno
01:55:14 He knows about Quebec, I'm told
01:55:17 I've been there for most of my life
01:55:20 Yeah, I think that qualifies.
01:55:23 You sound like you know Quebec.
01:55:25 You're watching the results as they're coming in?
01:55:27 Absolutely.
01:55:29 You know, in a lot of those cases, we're still looking at writings with only one poll reporting.
01:55:35 So it's still very, very early on.
01:55:38 But really, if you want to know whether or not the Liberals are having a good night tonight, look at the writings around Montreal.
01:55:44 So not Laval, not the island of Montreal, but everything around it.
01:55:49 This is where liberals tend to make some gains against the Bloc Québécois.
01:55:53 If they're having a good night, this is where I'll go.
01:55:57 So far, there's not a lot of results coming from there.
01:56:01 Otherwise, what we're seeing in terms of results are from writings where we know roughly what to expect.
01:56:06 You know, in Quebec City, Gérald O'Dell's writing of Louis Saint Laurent,
01:56:11 it's not hard to know how that election is going to go.
01:56:16 is most likely going to go conservative.
01:56:18 Same with the Bols writing where 0.97
01:56:20 Maxime Bernier used to be.
01:56:22 This is likely going to go conservative.
01:56:24 It's some writings where the conservatives
01:56:26 stand to, or are
01:56:28 hoping to meet some gains.
01:56:30 The first one would be Momoros-Charlevois.
01:56:33 So this is...
01:56:34 Where is that?
01:56:35 This is right in between...
01:56:38 Oh, a little bit further
01:56:40 to the northeast.
01:56:43 Mostly east.
01:56:43 yeah there this one so yeah nothing there yeah there's and and there's a lot of so so where if
01:56:49 you want to understand where the conservatives get elected in uh the province of quebec is the
01:56:54 sagney like saison area is the quebec city area and it's the bose area and the moment i'll see
01:57:00 shall have was one writing that they've had that conservatives have had in the past uh they have
01:57:04 had they haven't had it for a couple of elections now but there's a possibility that they could get
01:57:09 it uh whether it is uh over there or in chicago the whole issue around logging around the woodland
01:57:17 caribou has been a significant issue because that's a significant employer for that region
01:57:22 uh the liberals uh came in with a plan where they uh sort of to try and save the caribou
01:57:29 were trending up to 2 000 jobs in those areas uh these people uh have been concerned about the uh
01:57:37 about these regulations the effect it would have on their livelihood they've had a couple of rounds
01:57:41 where whether it was the feds or the province that imposed some limits that have had some
01:57:45 effect on their livelihoods that have caused some job losses so maybe that's having the effect the
01:57:51 other part though uh is that these uh these places there uh there's a lot of softwood lumber that's
01:57:57 being uh cut down in the in those areas so it'll be good to see whether uh you know is the woodland
01:58:04 caribou issue and all the environmental green regulations giving jobs that uh matter most to
01:58:09 people or whether it is the issue of the tariffs and softwood lumber uh issue with us yeah uh all
01:58:16 right uh let's bring kent uh kent hair back in uh kent uh former liberal mp and cabinet minister
01:58:21 from alberta one of the few who have ever existed uh especially from especially from calgary um
01:58:27 So, okay, let's see. Do we have any results in from Confederation yet? I'm interested in Confederation.
01:58:36 It's my writing.
01:58:37 Okay, that's Sean's writing. I'm interested in that one. It's urban. It's a central city,
01:58:44 sorry, central urban constituency. So, I mean, you could naturally, you know, the NDP is competitive
01:58:50 have been it provincially so there's definitely some some leftist voters there um well i think
01:58:56 hogan is a strong candidate but he's um he didn't really he's very late to the game so is the
01:59:02 conservative uh nixon yeah uh they're both late to the game so i i just don't think the low i don't
01:59:07 think the local candidate is going to play a huge role there because they just haven't had time to
01:59:11 spend a year not overlap with where jeremy was though yeah in the northern part so he does have
01:59:17 some of that writing a little bit more name recognition probably some good data
01:59:24 yeah well corey being uh who he is he he has chops in the ndp and the liberal party
01:59:31 uh he ran that uh canada's uh best uh well-known uh podcast they're the strategists and i've been
01:59:39 no second sorry what's well okay then second best okay nevertheless he had a huge huge following in
01:59:47 that regard and if you look at if you look at then uh the number of people that came out and
01:59:52 volunteered the number of id votes they had uh had uh out in a 30-day campaign i was uh very
02:00:01 surprised at the total that they had and they were they were running up the good numbers and i and i
02:00:07 just think with the strength of his resume as well as uh uh the the lot of volunteers that i saw
02:00:15 And when I door knocked, there was a strong NDP candidate there, Kiara Gunn, and she had 0.95
02:00:22 been out campaigning.
02:00:24 She had signs all over the riding at the start of the campaign. 0.95
02:00:27 Every door I knocked that had an NDP sign said they were voting for Corey or already
02:00:34 had this weekend.
02:00:37 So that's where I look at really the cratering of the NDP vote.
02:00:41 Matt Grant almost won that riding, and I get it.
02:00:44 he did work for two years in it but i think it's also a more progressive riding possibly now than
02:00:52 it was uh uh almost a decade ago when matt run there so uh there's uh someone you served with
02:00:59 uh here i'm going to bring the map up uh back here um this is uh okay so erica was just talking about
02:01:07 how you know conservatives especially rural alberta and saskatchewan conservatives they're
02:01:12 all competing they're running against themselves and each other just for breaking rights about you
02:01:17 know how insanely conservative can your writing go uh funny enough the first uh constituency in
02:01:24 alberta actually called as elected is in calgary it's michelle remple michelle remple uh she's a 0.92
02:01:30 door knocker machine she is um i mean she she can't get the same numbers as someone in yellow 0.99
02:01:36 head or you know bow river it's not that kind of insanely rural hyper conservative writing but uh
02:01:45 60.1 um sean can you check on what she got in the last election that might be indicative she's
02:01:51 competing against herself she is and and sean sean can you can you check too on what the ndp
02:01:59 boat was in that writing last time okay what was the name of the writing calgary nose hill
02:02:04 every nose yeah now the ndp in that writing are at 2.3 percent they are in fringe party territory
02:02:14 at this point how many of you how many has the ppc got in there uh uh ppc actually is being beaten
02:02:21 by the marxist leninists and the rhinoceros party at this moment actually i'm not sure if they have
02:02:25 a candidate uh i can't i can't tell if they have a candidate but the marxist leninists are at 0.1
02:02:31 percent of the people uh and vanessa wang of uh the rhinoceros party point three you know i've
02:02:38 never voted rhino but i i've voted for some uh smaller parties and things in time one of these
02:02:44 days i'd like to vote rhino if there's a conservative candidate i don't like i'm
02:02:48 gonna do something i'd like a rhino i love that you just answered my question it's if you vote
02:02:53 ppc you vote for the rhino i i haven't voted federal until this election i have not voted
02:02:59 conservative federally since 2011. It's been a long time. But it's been over a decade.
02:03:06 Yeah. Okay. All right, Sean, you got something? Got some results. Okay. So this is a writing
02:03:11 that has been redistributed. So in the 2021 election, Michelle Rempel got 55% to the vote, 0.80
02:03:20 uh liberal 21 let's say new democratic 17 and then on a redistributed basis it's pretty much
02:03:30 the same yeah and you'll see that with a lot of calgary and edmonton writings where
02:03:35 by 10 blocks or whatever it looks like i want to bring kent in kent uh kent's kind of sticking
02:03:41 with us here yeah but so if you take a look at that ndp vote there you're talking it was 17
02:03:47 percent in 2021 and you're down to two percent now that that's a cratering of epic proportions
02:03:55 that i think uh carries uh the four four four seats in calgary and uh uh three up in edmonton
02:04:04 uh the the numbers just the math doesn't work for conservatives in those areas if the ndp
02:04:12 craters to that extent uh which i think it will um i think what's interesting here too is uh
02:04:21 rumple garner the incumbent spent about 100 grand the ndp spent nothing yeah well there's no point
02:04:27 in them spending money there uh party spend yeah well here i i want your reaction kent to uh some
02:04:33 more writings we got some early results coming in uh from edmonton edmonton southeast uh jarshan
02:04:41 Singh. He is going to hold that for the Conservatives. I mean, there's only one poll in,
02:04:47 but it looks like a fairly big poll. He's at 65. He's going to hold that. Edmonton Northwest.
02:04:54 That's a new one.
02:04:55 Okay, that's a new one. But there is a Conservative incumbent because it's been
02:04:58 redistributed around. Billy Morin. Again, only one poll in, but fairly big poll, 55.5. Edmonton
02:05:07 center that's obviously one uh we need to watch that is um saeed ahmed a former mayor of edmonton
02:05:16 nope there's a communist there they've got a communist i went and voted and it's quite a long
02:05:25 marxist leninist too yeah they do there's a communist this is the one if you guys were
02:05:30 watching twitter that there was an individual that showed up with like a half bottle of booze
02:05:35 now the type of liquor is going to escape me but uh he showed up with half a bottle and then the
02:05:41 moderator had to ask him to take it out because it was not like a licensed venue so they've been
02:05:47 making it i have his brochure of 150 policies like this one when i went to vote is like it's
02:05:52 quite a robust it's no pierre paulie of 95 candidates erica there's probably a lot of
02:05:58 people who would uh would like a bottle of booze when they go vote yeah who's here
02:06:05 I'm looking here.
02:06:08 So Edmonton Center has both a communist and a Marxist-Leninist candidate.
02:06:14 I think that goes back to the old split between Stalinists and Maoists
02:06:18 and Leninists and all these things.
02:06:20 It sounds like a kind of mirror image for the conservatives
02:06:22 and the people's party, doesn't it?
02:06:24 So my question is, are the communists and Marxist-Leninists
02:06:27 splitting the NDP vote?
02:06:28 Is that why they're losing so much?
02:06:30 Well, it could be close.
02:06:32 That could be part of the reason up there in Edmonton Center.
02:06:34 But I, you know, I'm actually surprised.
02:06:37 I don't know how many polls have been reported in there.
02:06:42 Just one.
02:06:43 You hit the big poll, but just one.
02:06:45 It's a big poll.
02:06:47 Yeah, I'm surprised.
02:06:49 Look, if you look at the NDP vote there, it's held up to that extent.
02:06:54 And that's a good number for them.
02:06:57 And if the NDP vote continues at that pace in Edmonton Center,
02:07:02 I think it might be a tough night for Eleanor up there.
02:07:06 I would be surprised if it sticks in at that number, but that's a big number.
02:07:11 That's a big hurdle for that candidate to get over.
02:07:14 Yeah, I will give a little context.
02:07:15 I was the president of that riding for six years,
02:07:18 so I do know this pulled inside and out and ran the 2015 campaign.
02:07:23 This was the former riding of both Randys, Boisdeneau.
02:07:28 and um and then eleanor came over from edmonton strathcona and so she was a late drop in as if 0.98
02:07:38 you live in this writing you've got a mailer for re-elect randy boss you know on day one of the
02:07:42 election uh so he didn't know what's happening she moved over on the saturday i think before
02:07:48 like the day before the writ dropped saeed amed ran in edmonton decor for the united conservative
02:07:53 party in the last election he's a door knocking machine i hit a lot of doors in some of the pools
02:07:58 were actually more favorable for the Conservatives than I thought. But this is a prime example
02:08:05 to Trisha Estabrook who is also a public school trustee and has been campaigning for two years.
02:08:10 This is probably the one where we'll actually see a vote split on the left and she will probably 1.00
02:08:17 get a very high NDP vote in comparison to I think what's Kent saying is some of those confederation
02:08:23 and maybe even some of the more
02:08:26 northeast ridings in
02:08:28 Calgary. I want to point out, if you look along the top
02:08:30 here, you'll see whether
02:08:31 the different parties have candidates leading and
02:08:34 elected. The NDP has only one
02:08:36 leading, and that one, I guarantee you
02:08:38 they have a 0.0% shot of
02:08:40 Leduc, Wetaskawin.
02:08:43 There's just
02:08:43 three small polls in there. The NDP
02:08:46 are... And they have what? Is it Mike Lakes,
02:08:48 right? Is that Mike Lakes?
02:08:50 Yeah, because it got redistributed. Yeah, Mike
02:08:52 It's like there's a 0.0% chance of the NDP winning there.
02:08:55 So in reality, the NDP is not leading in a single constituency across Alberta, Nigel.
02:09:01 Really?
02:09:03 No, across the country.
02:09:04 Just before I bolt, guys, I just want to hear your numbers, each of you,
02:09:12 and who you think, how many seats in Alberta you think the Liberals are going to get.
02:09:17 Start with you, Derek.
02:09:20 One to three.
02:09:23 Okay.
02:09:24 That's a range.
02:09:26 Yeah, I'll go.
02:09:27 I hate prime numbers on numbers, but I'll say three because they'll hold the two that they have plus one.
02:09:34 I'll stick with three as well, actually.
02:09:37 Yeah, I'm going to go with three as well, Ken, because I'm an optimist.
02:09:40 Well, I'm an outlier, but there we go.
02:09:44 Hey, but I've really appreciated my time here with you tonight.
02:09:48 All the best in your election coverage.
02:09:50 and uh uh we'll see uh well i'll see if i can talk to your uh landlord for you derek
02:09:56 next time thank you next time i'm rolling by your office okay hey you got it take care guys
02:10:03 all right thank you kent thanks kent all right uh now just uh just got word for the newsroom
02:10:09 polls have just closed in bc so we're going to start to get bc results soon uh let's bring up
02:10:15 the big map just you know renault's gonna bounce here oh okay uh we're gonna go to renault uh
02:10:21 before he has to go because there's lots of results in quebec uh we should be getting a
02:10:26 pretty good idea of how that is shaping up it's it appears to be looking pretty good for the
02:10:32 liberals in quebec it appears right now it appears like that uh it for for a lot of writings that
02:10:38 the bloc was hoping to uh to hold on uh it seems like they haven't been able so far again still
02:10:44 early on in the night. But if I may take you to one writing that I think is of part of their
02:10:49 interest, it's writing of Trois-Guyvières. So sort of like midway between Montreal and Quebec City.
02:10:55 So that writing, based on the latest polling aggregators, this was one of those writings
02:11:02 where they were polling at 30% for the Liberals, 30% for the Conservatives, 30% for the Bloc.
02:11:09 The Conservative candidates there has been trying to win it for three elections in a row.
02:11:13 And so far, there's 14 polls reporting. So we're still early on, but we're starting to get an idea. It seems like the Liberals are very far ahead in that writing. The story there is, so the Bloc candidate, René Lippe-Villemure, who's their current MP, found out he had cancer a little bit before the election and was not able to campaign.
02:11:36 Yves Levesque from the Conservatives has tried and has been campaigning.
02:11:41 You know, the last couple of times around, he managed to get, within only a couple of votes from winning.
02:11:47 But now, like, the Liberals have a significant, like, a 20-point lead on both the Bloc and the Conservatives.
02:11:58 So, you know, when we say that the liberal, the bloc vote doesn't seem like it's holding as much in Quebec as they were expected or as they were hoping, this is one of those writings that's showing that.
02:12:12 okay uh all right uh anything else that's uh standing out in quebec for you right now
02:12:21 um i mean i'm looking around quebec city uh that's kind of conservative territory uh montreal
02:12:27 i mean lower montreal on the island liberal i mean like if the liberals are not getting wiped
02:12:33 out in quebec they're gonna hold that north shore of the island uh leaning block so far uh let's
02:12:40 look at this one. Not enough votes there to really say. It's leaning
02:12:44 blocks so far in a couple of areas. But if you look at every single
02:12:48 one of those writings, not a lot of them have a lot of
02:12:52 polls reporting. So that's why it's still very early.
02:12:56 Right now, a lot of those are advanced voting polls. They're not necessarily
02:13:00 so they're not E-Day polls. The advanced
02:13:04 voting seem to be going very well for the liberals. So maybe the block is going
02:13:08 do a little bit better than what we're
02:13:10 seeing right now.
02:13:12 But if I was with Block right now,
02:13:14 if I was
02:13:15 at their party watching the election,
02:13:19 I think this is about the time
02:13:20 where I'd be switching to Hard Licker
02:13:22 right now.
02:13:24 Ooh, that's a way to finish it.
02:13:26 Were you talking to us to do that?
02:13:30 Not yet, not yet.
02:13:31 Okay, just checking.
02:13:34 But thank you so much for having me.
02:13:35 This was an absolute pleasure, and
02:13:37 And best of luck with the rest of your election coverage.
02:13:41 And fingers crossed, let's hope we get a good result.
02:13:45 All I wanted is a block for the West.
02:13:48 So I don't get to have that.
02:13:50 That's not the cards, unfortunately.
02:13:52 Renault, thank you very much.
02:13:54 I really appreciate your insights,
02:13:56 helping to explain what's happening in Quebec for us.
02:13:59 Happy to help. Have a wonderful day.
02:14:02 All right.
02:14:03 We're going to come back to Kevin Lacey soon.
02:14:07 But we have another great guest.
02:14:11 We're going to bring in Franco Terrazano.
02:14:13 Franco Terrazano is the federal director of the Canadian Tax Federation.
02:14:17 Even more importantly, he was also the Alberta director before that.
02:14:21 In my opinion, he's the more senior of the jobs because that's the one I held.
02:14:25 Thank you for joining us, Franco.
02:14:26 Derek, did you just have to look down on the piece of paper to remember my name?
02:14:30 No, no.
02:14:31 I was seeing if there was anyone in the line before you because we've got some other guests.
02:14:34 And we're just seeing if that other guest is before or after you
02:14:37 You're first in line
02:14:38 So they were actually first
02:14:40 But you're just so pretty that we had to put you on
02:14:43 Oh guys
02:14:44 Well hey, it's really my pleasure to be on the show
02:14:46 With you tonight, I think we're going to have a fun chat
02:14:48 Right on
02:14:50 Okay
02:14:51 I know the caveats for you
02:14:53 Your group is non-partisan
02:14:55 But I mean, holds fiscally conservative views
02:14:58 But isn't affiliated with any political party
02:15:00 So I know the rules around you
02:15:02 but uh we're gonna get you to play i know your boss scott doesn't like you playing pundit but
02:15:07 i'm gonna make you play pundit because that's what we're doing tonight um let's look at the
02:15:11 ontario results i'm gonna pull up the map here uh we're starting to get quite a few results coming
02:15:16 in from ontario uh some of it's still early some of it's not but we're getting we're getting an
02:15:21 idea uh anything standing out for the ontario results for you right now well you know before
02:15:25 i go to ontario let's actually go back to atlanta canada for just a quick sec the last i checked
02:15:30 I don't know if it's been updated, but were the Conservatives winning, what, 10 seats out there?
02:15:34 Is that correct?
02:15:35 That looks about right.
02:15:36 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10.
02:15:40 Yeah, they're leading or elected in 10.
02:15:42 So some pretty good pickups.
02:15:44 They're winning all the toss-ups.
02:15:47 They're even picking up two ratings.
02:15:49 The 338 Canada had predicted were actually pretty solidly liberal.
02:15:53 So that's a two-seat gain, but also drastically different than many of the polls were showing, right?
02:15:58 So look, if that trend holds, and if the polls are wrong, well, why is that? So if that happens,
02:16:05 it's because people are ticked off, right? Over the last 10 years, the Trudeau government doubled
02:16:10 the debt, made the necessities of life more expensive, where people struggled to get groceries.
02:16:15 For how many years now, people wanted to win every time they went to a gas station or saw
02:16:20 their heating bill, right? So if the polls are off, it's because people are fed up with the cost
02:16:24 of living like that's that's going to be what it is at the end of the day if all the mainstream
02:16:28 polls what they're reporting which showed a liberal majority or a liberal minority if they're
02:16:32 off at the end of the day it's just that people were fed up with a government that printed money
02:16:37 like crazy like high taxes and ran crazy deficits so i guess we're still early in the night so to
02:16:43 speak but uh if the polls are wrong that's why okay well the the results in um ontario you got
02:16:50 something yeah okay we're going to quickly switch to shown here for an update well um i'm just
02:16:57 looking at some of these border ridings in ontario so here we got essex uh which was a conservative
02:17:02 riding incumbent who's down mind you again it's still pretty early but the endp used to be
02:17:09 competitive there well and these would be the writings that would be affected by uh tariffs
02:17:13 so here again here's another conservative that's down uh to the liberal uh you know in in the heart
02:17:19 of the automaking uh territory um here's another one conservative incumbent oh okay okay uh okay
02:17:28 we gotta actually go back to show we've got some bc as well yeah okay we're gonna get we'll get the
02:17:32 bc soon but we have a limited time left with uh kevin lacy uh our uh atlantic albertan um uh kevin
02:17:41 the numbers in atlantic are starting to firm up uh there's still some that are not yet called
02:17:47 but uh we're getting a pretty good idea of things there right now look just to pick up on what
02:17:52 franco said i think if you were tuning in tonight you're expecting to see a large liberal victory
02:17:58 with dear oliver's numbers going significantly down the atlantic numbers really don't tell that
02:18:05 story and in fact and i think the big story tonight is going to be about the ndp and derrick
02:18:10 i'm going to actually steal an ontario riding to kind of illustrate this if you look at the
02:18:15 riding of toronto danforth toronto danforth was the riding that jack layton helped it is his seat
02:18:20 tonight the ndp are running third in that seat and that is changing the map but even despite that
02:18:28 the conservatives are hanging on so for all the waxing on twitter by conservative pundits and
02:18:34 others criticizing care poliver tonight he's hanging on so far and i think that's when we
02:18:40 we look at the election and what we're a lot was discussed about what's going to happen after this
02:18:45 election um polymer's numbers remain very very strong and uh i think we're going to see that as
02:18:52 this election plays out that we're going to essentially hold the second thing we're going to
02:18:57 see is we're going to go back canada is going to go back to a two-party system and when it goes
02:19:01 back to a two-party system that will also change the political dynamics and the discussion and i
02:19:07 think in a good way because we'll have a very clear division on issues and people will be able
02:19:14 to easily see you know which side of the fence that they're going to sit on. All right anything
02:19:23 else before we let you go let's just just maybe a bit more on the Atlantic itself because we're
02:19:28 going to start to turn our attention away from there as as things settle in. Again conservatives
02:19:33 I think it's fair to say have won all the toss ups and have even pulled off, but not confirmed yet, but are poised to to pull a few one to two upsets in Atlantic.
02:19:47 Anything big stand out in Atlantic before we let you go?
02:19:51 Yeah, the big one is that central Nova seat.
02:19:53 So that's Peter McKay's former riding that he held during his time in office.
02:19:58 It was held by Sean Frazier, largely on the cult of personality, to be fair.
02:20:03 Peter McKay threw every hour he had into that riding to win it for the Conservatives.
02:20:10 And if they hold on tonight, it's a bit of a retribution for Peter because he's put so much effort into holding that one for the Conservatives.
02:20:20 And also, as you look kind of across where the Liberals are going to have their support, they need to win these seats.
02:20:26 This is where, in order to grow their mandate, they need to win Conservative seats.
02:20:31 and they're not doing it anywhere the only seat they've won uh that i can see on this map so far
02:20:36 is south shore st margaret's and that's a riding that didn't have an ndp candidate um so you know
02:20:43 when you kind of look at the the how this is playing out um these two story lines are going
02:20:48 to be significant in how we look at the vote afterwards and how politics is going to look
02:20:53 in this country afterwards because i think the debates are going to be significantly different
02:20:57 um without the smaller parties involved okay uh all right well kevin lacy thank you very much for
02:21:05 your insight uh atlantic has uh given us a few uh few surprises appreciate your time thanks so much
02:21:12 for having me derek you guys do a great job thank you uh franco um so i want to talk ontario you you
02:21:21 thus far refused i asked him on ontario went straight back to atlantic i'm sick of atlantic
02:21:25 We've been talking about Atlantic all night.
02:21:28 Not a ton of firm numbers in Ontario yet, but we're getting a good sense.
02:21:34 It's looking, the map of Toronto I've got here, it's got the Conservatives.
02:21:40 Sorry, one second.
02:21:44 CBC apparently has just.
02:21:45 So has CTV.
02:21:46 Yeah, I'm seeing that as well.
02:21:48 And I just saw that on Twitter too.
02:21:51 Looks like CTV is saying liberal win.
02:21:54 i just saw that on majority or minority yet they're not sure yeah it says well they report
02:22:00 123 which i have no idea how they got there on ctv but you only have 108 108 uh i'm i don't know
02:22:08 i'm not seeing it yet uh i'm not seeing a liberal majority in these numbers yet i mean it could be
02:22:15 pulled off because they're gonna uh it depends on what kind of gains they make at the expense
02:22:19 of the ndp and the block well you're not gonna tell much from quebec because the ndp only ever
02:22:23 had one one seat there in the last parliament so there wasn't a lot of ndp votes to like eight or
02:22:30 nine percent of it so that wasn't going to tell you much i thought that what was in the happened
02:22:35 in the maritimes is very interesting and if that actually held through ontario then i think cbc
02:22:42 may be regretting calling their giving their result so quickly in fairness ctv says they want
02:22:48 not a majority oh okay yeah they're declaring liberal victory like liberals win
02:22:58 that threshold yeah i saw cb i see you guys just posted it on uh on this chat too it says cbc
02:23:04 nctv now um but yeah i haven't seen online if they're calling anything more than just that
02:23:11 yeah uh well let's look at the map i'm i mean it's the most likely scenario but i
02:23:16 It might be a bit premature.
02:23:19 So looking around Toronto here, it looks so far as it predictably does,
02:23:25 except it's not going to have a single orange seat in Toronto, I think.
02:23:31 Probably safe to say at this point.
02:23:33 But the Conservatives are leading Mississauga Centre.
02:23:38 That would be a pickup.
02:23:39 Etobicoke North, that would be a pickup.
02:23:42 Again, there's not enough yet in on these polls.
02:23:47 But the Conservatives do appear to be advancing inward on Fortress Toronto.
02:23:54 Skirmishing in the suburbs.
02:23:55 Skirmishing in the suburbs.
02:23:58 You know, New Market Aurora is kind of one of the must-win for the Conservatives.
02:24:02 That is razor-thin right now, 49.2 for the Conservatives, Sandra Coben, 0.72
02:24:07 and for 49 for the incumbent liberal, Jennifer McLaughlin.
02:24:14 I don't know.
02:24:18 Daniel, is it a premature call yet?
02:24:21 Or, you know, they have a bigger staff than we do.
02:24:24 Maybe they're seeing something that we're not.
02:24:26 Well, you know, we all tend to see what we want to see.
02:24:29 I mean, anybody who's watching this program knows that we tend to favor the conservative outlook.
02:24:36 so we're hoping for a conservative win in the cbc they have every good reason actually 1.6 billion
02:24:43 of them 150 yeah plus a little more coming to uh to anticipate as a liberal win okay but it's it's
02:24:53 very embarrassing i mean calling it doesn't mean that will be the doesn't affect the actual result
02:24:58 it'd be very embarrassing for cbc and ctv to have to call it back it's not very pleasant to so they
02:25:03 they must have a fair degree of confidence in doing so it's it's sticking your neck out there
02:25:08 if you're wrong especially when you're the cbc i think you can see enough now though that there
02:25:13 really isn't a good path to a conservative win i mean they're kind of i think doing it in a
02:25:16 reverse order in a sense not that there's a big bunch of liberal strength but now with the way
02:25:20 things are lying out in quebec and ontario uh it's hard to envision how especially when it's
02:25:27 those more dense urban areas that are waiting on the results for they're taking a safe bet
02:25:31 hey guys do you have um do you guys have where like the the seat totals in quebec right now
02:25:37 among leading and expected to win yeah like how many how many are the block at because they were
02:25:42 at 32 heading into this election sitting at 15 right now well yeah thank you block and ndp for
02:25:50 showing up thanks for coming out guys and i mean that's that's like where the story i think really
02:25:56 lies as as kevin was kind of saying right just the absolute collapse of the ndp from being like so
02:26:02 close to the polling with the liberals back in the fall session to just being completely decimated
02:26:07 right like orange orange crushed you know what i mean so you know i think that's probably the
02:26:12 most obvious place to look right now is what happened to those uh secondary parties yeah i
02:26:18 think even i don't know what ctv has it but they have the ndp at three which is even lower than
02:26:23 every poll i think every poll i saw had them at least six as halfway to party status so like this
02:26:30 is and if you talk to any ndp pundit they were like they're gonna at least have six um because
02:26:36 they show up more and they've only focused on holding their seats so they need 12 to be an
02:26:42 official party within the house yeah yeah so they were saying yeah yeah but okay so they're leading
02:26:47 they're leading in three nationally but uh look at what they are like some of them are ones that
02:26:51 that they have a 0% chance of winning.
02:26:53 There's just one random pull-in.
02:26:56 Like, Leduc-Wetaskiwin, 0% chance.
02:26:59 Oh, yeah.
02:26:59 Seattle River Crowfoot.
02:27:01 The Conservatives are going to get, like,
02:27:04 it would be a terrible election for Damian Couric there
02:27:07 if he got 75%.
02:27:08 He will be humiliated if he gets only 75% in that riding.
02:27:12 That is a mega-conservative riding.
02:27:14 So take that out of the cards.
02:27:17 Churchill Kiewetnogaski, that's an incumbent.
02:27:21 seat liberal uh NDP uh Nikki Ashton uh yeah they got a chance of holding that one uh maybe
02:27:27 uh then uh then who knows territories those are weird elections up there uh but I mean they have
02:27:33 two which I I would think Strathcona they're gonna hold um Griesbach I think will probably
02:27:39 go conservative um because I think both them and and then Edmonton Center is a toss-up so
02:27:45 hey I got a question for you guys I got two questions now I get to be the interviewer
02:27:49 um hey so two questions are you guys with your data that you're seeing are you guys seeing the
02:27:53 same thing as ctv and cbc and now the only question is vote share and if they get a minority or
02:27:58 majority is that what you guys are seeing with your data uh well it's got the liberals leading
02:28:04 in 108 now that does not mean you can look a lot further because it depends where you're leading
02:28:10 like if the liberals are leading uh strongly in saskatchewan well that means it's probably just
02:28:17 a good night for them if the conservatives are leading in toronto it's gonna be a good night so
02:28:21 you don't actually have to have all the results in to be able to predict because you can build
02:28:25 out on your model you know uh it's easy even easier to do an american presidential elections
02:28:30 because you okay these ones are predictably here these ones are there if this state goes this way
02:28:35 then there's a good chance that state will go that way and do we have any do we have any red
02:28:39 in alberta showing yet like is there any because i saw some points there might be some pickup uh
02:28:44 Edmonton, Riverbend, but there's only a single poll out, less than 100 votes.
02:28:48 So can't put much on that reliably.
02:28:53 Well, that's Matt Jennerou, who, even with the boundary redistribution, he got heavier into conservative territory.
02:29:00 Yeah.
02:29:01 Like he lost some of the champagne socialists he had before.
02:29:05 If the liberals win that, they're looking at mega-majority government.
02:29:08 Yeah, oh, for sure.
02:29:09 And we're not looking at mega-majority government.
02:29:10 I don't think that's right.
02:29:11 These are just low polls coming in for the colors that we see.
02:29:15 Yeah.
02:29:16 You know, we should get some of our reporters in here.
02:29:20 Dave, if you're listening, why don't you queue up, we don't have them in the stream yet,
02:29:24 but let's get, if you want to start getting some of our reporters lined up to come on
02:29:29 in here.
02:29:30 In the meantime, let's bring in Nadine Wellwood. 0.85
02:29:33 Nadine, I think, correct me if I'm wrong, I think is from Cochran or the Cochran area.
02:29:38 Am I right about that, Nadine?
02:29:40 You are indeed.
02:29:40 All right, Cochrane, for Easterners watching, is a lovely little town west of, just northwest of Calgary.
02:29:49 Is that a part of the Yellowfoot? Which riding is that a part of now?
02:29:54 That is the Cochrane, so Banff, it used to be Banff Airdrie. It is now Cochrane Airdrie.
02:30:01 Okay, okay, so it narrowly missed out on being a part of the Yellowhead riding,
02:30:04 which goes from south of Calgary, south of Banff, all the way up to Jasper.
02:30:11 It includes part of Rocky View County west of Calgary and things like that.
02:30:16 All right, so Nadine, I don't know if you still are,
02:30:19 but I've generally always considered you kind of a People's Party supporter.
02:30:23 So we wanted to bring in for your perspective tonight,
02:30:26 it's not the greatest night for the People's Party.
02:30:30 I'm looking at BOSE that has been called for the Conservatives.
02:30:33 Maxime Bernier running fourth at 5.3% of the vote.
02:30:39 I think some of us, you know, from the regular pipeline panel, we've been kind of operating under the assumption that the last election was probably the high watermark of the PPC.
02:30:52 You had a very left-leaning conservative leader who was running on vaccine passports, who was running on a carbon tax.
02:31:01 uh really you know then you had the outcry uh against covid restrictions those kinds of things
02:31:09 really playing to ppc strengths and then the conservatives running on the least conservative
02:31:14 platform in the history of the modern conservative party since its unification of 2004 uh i don't
02:31:22 mean to sound delicate but do you think was that the high watermark of the ppc uh is it kind of
02:31:27 looking like the party's over? Well I don't know if it was a high watermark for the PPC but I
02:31:31 certainly know this election and I knew this going in that it would be the low watermark for the PPC
02:31:36 because the Conservative Party is so strong in mimicking some of the policies of the PPC. I mean
02:31:42 if you wanted to look at the PPC and you want to do a comparison on parties just on policy like
02:31:49 take the emotion the party politics out and just look at policies um the ppc has the ideal platform
02:31:57 for albertans but unfortunately you know for better or for worse uh people don't vote for
02:32:03 policies uh they vote for people and they vote their party so you know i think uh i wouldn't
02:32:09 say that necessarily the people's party is out um i do agree that this uh candidacy and this campaign
02:32:19 all the way along is was a two pony race this is a two horse race between the liberals and
02:32:23 the conservatives um have always been a strong advocate for the people's party of canada their
02:32:29 their policies but they didn't stand a chance in this election it's um i i'm sympathetic with uh
02:32:37 you know suicidal fringe party runs uh in a two-party race i'm i'm highly sympathetic to
02:32:43 The PPC is not the only one losing in this. The block is down. NDP is gone. I mean, they're wiped
02:32:50 out. And if you want to look at the numbers before I came on here, I did look at, I snuck over to CBC
02:32:56 to see what they were saying. And they made up a very interesting point. The liberals only had to
02:33:02 pick up 18 seats for a majority win. So I think tomorrow morning in the Alberta legislature,
02:33:10 We need to be discussing Alberta pension plan, police force, collecting our own taxes, and we need to get on with it.
02:33:17 I'm tired of the roller coaster, and I think a lot of Albertans are going to be very, very disappointed, I think, with the results of tonight's election.
02:33:27 I have a feeling we're going to be talking about more than just pensions.
02:33:31 i didn't know i think the uh the time would uh you know bring in home our pension plan
02:33:38 would uh placate uh albertans i think that time has passed significantly uh i'm really hopeful
02:33:46 it is i think albertans are going to take a very strong stance i mean mark carney is not going to
02:33:54 be a friend of alberta mark carney is a globalist i mean you look at what he did with g fans um his
02:34:00 net zero, UN envoy. This is going to be a disaster for Albertans. So I am truly, and I know there's
02:34:09 some people on your panel and yourself probably included, but I think separation is going to be
02:34:14 on the minds of an awful lot of Albertans tomorrow morning. Well, I mean, you'd put it to you
02:34:19 directly. Is it on yours? It is. There's a reason I did not run for the PPC this time around.
02:34:26 You know, I'm a big advocate.
02:34:28 It wasn't about winning or losing.
02:34:29 It was about holding the space for the ideas.
02:34:33 But my heart wasn't in it.
02:34:34 The more I looked at it, the more I realized that honestly,
02:34:38 and being a chartered investment manager,
02:34:40 somebody who follows the economics,
02:34:41 who's now been involved in politics for a very long time,
02:34:44 the only thing that I think Alberta can honestly do
02:34:48 if it truly wants to have a secure future,
02:34:51 not only for, you know, you and I, Derek,
02:34:53 but for our children, is to separate.
02:34:56 all right uh we're gonna bring you back uh but we're gonna oh do we still have franco
02:35:00 yeah yeah derek i'm here but i gotta i gotta jet pretty soon on to the next thing but yeah i want
02:35:05 to get you in before before you've got to go uh you're watching this from uh from ottawa i know
02:35:09 you're in albertan but you've been exiled to do the uh out to mordor you're doing god's work out
02:35:15 there but uh you're living in exile right now um maybe let's talk big picture if if we're looking
02:35:23 at another liberal government tonight uh this would appear to be the east disproportionately
02:35:30 the east voting to double down on what we've been doing for the last decade uh i think it's
02:35:39 there are grave implications not just for taxpayers but for the fabric of the country
02:35:43 itself at this point well look i mean for a long time now alburns have been you know the cash cow
02:35:50 of confederation what is it now like probably more than 20 billion dollars every year leaving
02:35:55 alberta not coming back right you have politicians calling alberta's economic engine dirty energy
02:36:02 right how many like the no more pipelines law the discriminatory tanker ban right the government
02:36:06 rejecting the northern gateway pipeline moving the regulatory goalposts on energy east you know
02:36:12 i remember uh the winter of 2015 when people were leaving their offices in downtown calgary and
02:36:18 droves, cardboard boxes in hand. So I remember the devastation firsthand and then add on top of
02:36:25 that disastrous government policies that kicked out burdens while they were down. And look,
02:36:30 we talk about all these different energy policies. Another thing you have to remember is who's going
02:36:36 to be paying the overshare of all this government debt? Well, the Kearney government or the Kearney
02:36:41 platform wanted to add more debt than Trudeau. Kearney's talking about $225 billion of extra
02:36:48 debt over the next four years. Well, guess who's paying a large share of that? It's you guys. It's
02:36:53 Albertans. It's my family. It's my friends back in Calgary. So yeah, I mean, I think it's no
02:36:59 surprise that there's going to be many people in Alberta and the prairies that are going to
02:37:04 feel pretty awful right now. There's a lot of work to do. And as I mentioned, $225 billion
02:37:09 in extra debt from Carney, right? He's supposed to be the banker, but you know, the banker's budget
02:37:15 was worse than the drama teachers right carney's gonna add almost a hundred billion dollars of more 0.99
02:37:20 debt than trudeau well you know who's gonna love this debt bankers yeah i was gonna say
02:37:26 the bond fund the bond fund managers on bay street that's who's gonna be happy 0.99
02:37:34 uh it's just wild to me that these could do something this stupid i just have a question 0.99
02:37:42 for Franco. Do you have a book? I do. Yeah. You're good. You're good. Well, and you know what? It's 0.93
02:37:50 timely now more than ever, axing the tax, the rise and fall of Canada's carbon tax. And it
02:37:56 details the fight ahead, right? Because as everyone knows, Carney doesn't want to scrap
02:38:00 carbon taxes, right? He wrote essentially a 500 book praising carbon taxes. He wants to change
02:38:06 the carbon tax. He wants to hide the carbon tax and hit our businesses with it. And he hopes you
02:38:11 won't notice when your life gets more expensive and when it pushes canadian businesses and jobs
02:38:17 to set up shop south of the border uh so thank you so much for that plug axing the tax the rise
02:38:22 and fall of canada's carbon tax and also folks thank you so much for having me on your show
02:38:27 today i do have to jet but it's always fun talking to my friends back home in calgary it's a pleasure
02:38:32 and uh i know who else has a book that might be in high demand uh tomorrow i'll be talking about
02:38:37 my book a little bit i suspect all right all right thanks everyone thank you very much bye
02:38:43 okay uh i can see some of our reporters uh standing by uh let's see what time is oh actually
02:38:51 we have uh before we go to our reporter uh some of our reporters around the country i want to bring
02:38:55 in uh yaroslav baron uh he was uh i think the senior policy advisor for stephen harper uh at
02:39:04 least sometime of the government uh i guess you would have worked with nigel when nigel was uh 0.93
02:39:09 the prime minister's speechwriter in his day sure nigel and i go way back way back way back yeah i 0.64
02:39:17 was running comms for harper through three elections and i remember nigel's uh silver
02:39:22 quilled speeches very well when he was back back when he was a speechwriter all right well you know
02:39:28 what since you guys are old chums uh nigel why don't you take it with uh with uh yaroslav well 0.99
02:39:33 Jaroslav, I mean, every month or so I have you on The Hannaford Show and I say, well,
02:39:37 how are things going in Ottawa tonight? I'm afraid to ask. CTV has apparently called it,
02:39:43 and Apple News, not necessarily the first place I'd go to for an election prediction,
02:39:50 but they've called it CBC. So what do you think? Are we in for another liberal minority?
02:39:56 Well, nobody's called it a majority or minority yet, so fingers crossed. I mean,
02:40:02 the uh we've still got a little bit of time before it comes in but you know what there's still a lot
02:40:05 of unknowns i was just doing some checking and like you know some you know a whole bunch of
02:40:09 cabinet ministers you think would be a shoe-in they haven't even started reporting on their
02:40:13 writings yet so you know we may be in for uh for a bit of a long night still and there might even
02:40:18 be some surprises like the conservatives had a pretty strong uh pretty strong start to the
02:40:22 evening in atlantic canada at least bucking the predictions from the polls and you know
02:40:27 You know, a whole bunch of results are still trickling in some of the writings where we're seeing declared for, you know, for the liberals or, frankly, for the conservatives, for that matter, are based on, you know, three or four polls having reported in so far, which really means nothing.
02:40:44 So it's a little bit early. It's a little bit early to be making out of a call, any kind of a call.
02:40:49 Well, that's certainly what I've been quietly telling people who are just texting in and saying, is it really this bad?
02:40:56 And I said, well, not yet, not yet.
02:40:58 Don't jump.
02:40:59 Don't jump.
02:41:00 Yeah, don't jump off the building yet.
02:41:02 But if the numbers didn't change much and we go back with the same liberal people led by a different liberal leader, are we going to get the same policies or is Mr. Carney going to take things in a different direction?
02:41:24 well look let's let's hope that there will be some change in policy um i'm going to be an
02:41:32 optimist here nigel i'm going to be an optimist uh the liberals know that if they were still running 0.88
02:41:39 justin trudeau and running the same platform they would have been nose diving off of a cliff right
02:41:47 now they know that they're not dumb they get that they change leaders they got a centrist leader
02:41:53 somebody arguably you know a red Tory leader type and they ran a much more centrist they would argue
02:42:03 center-right platform okay so they realized that they needed to do that to win so it's really
02:42:12 risky to pull on a full-on bait and switch to present to present something in the lead up to
02:42:19 the election and on election day and to go right back to the way it was before so here's me being
02:42:25 the optimist that they recognize that the public didn't want to buy their krap anymore so they
02:42:34 needed to change up the menu and i would like to think that they're going to continue with the menu
02:42:40 that they now served up because they want to stay in the public's good graces right they don't want
02:42:45 want this to be the last election that they won. So that's me being an optimist, that they recognize
02:42:50 the public has shifted and that they're going to continue to shift with it. Well, you know,
02:42:56 obviously we want to say, Arislaff, we hope you're right. But Mr. Carney has made his whole career,
02:43:03 certainly the last 20 years, has been all about climate change all the time. And he's been quite,
02:43:09 that's one of the few things that he has been forthright upon on the campaign trail.
02:43:13 Well, as Franco said, I think, were you with us?
02:43:18 Well, Franco Teresano, yeah.
02:43:21 Like starting off with a $250 billion borrow.
02:43:25 I mean, Mr. Trudeau must be thinking, well, why wouldn't they have let me do that?
02:43:30 That's amazing.
02:43:31 It's outrageous.
02:43:33 Actually, remember, Nigel, back in 2015, do you remember what a big gamble it was for Justin Trudeau to say, hang on, folks, hang on.
02:43:43 i know that we're all supposed to be fiscally responsible we're all supposed to be running
02:43:47 valid judges i'm gonna run a 10 billion one zero uh deficit every year for three years and then
02:43:57 i'm gonna rebounce the books and that was a heck of a ban of a gamble for us and it paid off he won
02:44:03 but he it was risky i mean a whole bunch of liberals were freaking out because they were
02:44:08 proposing to add 30 billion dollars to the national debt right and how how things have changed since
02:44:16 then you know that he can run a quarter trillion dollar deficit platform or debt you know out of
02:44:23 debt platform and the public went for it i don't know sorry just i i want to bring nadine in uh
02:44:30 just one last time before we let her go uh i just kind of want to wrap up the talk around the ppc
02:44:34 here uh so i as we discussed this is obviously not the ppc's night uh maybe i i think last time
02:44:43 was probably the high watermark because they had such a great set of issues to go on and they had
02:44:46 such a great foil in erin o'toole as this faux conservative um but you know the party is max 1.00
02:44:55 it's it's both the policies but it's also around the personality and figure of maxime bernier
02:45:01 um do you think it's time uh if not to either to kind of fold the party or at the very least
02:45:09 is it time for new leadership well it's definitely time to have a discussion about that um you know
02:45:15 for me you know the ppc party was never really a part of this election process you know to yarrow's
02:45:22 point yarrow i do believe his point here you know he's being optimistic about the liberals i am going
02:45:26 to i i am a chartered investment manager i work in the world of finance um carney is a centralist
02:45:31 he's a global banker and you know he is going to a quarter of a trillion let's let's get out
02:45:38 of the billion language he is going to print because we don't have the money so he's going
02:45:44 to print borrow you know a quarter of a trillion dollars um just this year in his budget and we
02:45:51 is this money that we don't have we're already at 1.2 trillion in debt and that's unsustainable
02:45:57 we're printing out 50 billion dollars a year in interest payments um you know we have a small
02:46:01 population of 41 million people and the reality is carney is who he is he's never been shy to
02:46:07 explain even in this camp campaign he's told canadians what he's going to do and he's told
02:46:13 canadians in his book values that um he is going to make life harder for canadians expect a drop
02:46:21 in your standard of living expect things to get more expensive expect taxes to go up more
02:46:25 regulation less free speech um firearms he's already after saying he's going to come after
02:46:31 you know guns how is all this going to affect albertans um this and he's been very honest
02:46:36 about that already in this campaign so imagine what he is going to do when he wins a majority
02:46:43 government and he has four years to execute on this uh i mean that it's it's really for alberta
02:46:49 This is a very, very, it's kind of interesting.
02:46:52 It's going to be a great opportunity for the separatist movement, I think,
02:46:57 to really kind of fight for what is right for Alberta
02:47:01 and an opportunity to either get something that is an appropriate representation and or get out.
02:47:10 And so I'm quite excited.
02:47:12 I think it's going to be a very interesting day come tomorrow.
02:47:14 And I think we're going to have some interesting conversations
02:47:17 moving forward here over the next few months.
02:47:21 Nadine, thank you very much for joining us.
02:47:23 My pleasure.
02:47:24 Anytime.
02:47:25 I'm always around and happy to share an opinion,
02:47:28 as you very well know.
02:47:29 And I'm glad to see, Derek,
02:47:31 that the political correctness
02:47:33 has not changed at the Western Standard.
02:47:36 It is so refreshing.
02:47:39 Yeah, that's kind of our policy.
02:47:42 Thank you.
02:47:43 Nadine, it's just a different political correctness.
02:47:46 can i just come back to um yaroslav you know yaroslav a pendulum group which i think is
02:47:55 what you you've called your your your group um your business is advising politicians now
02:48:02 when i look at the way that the conservatives have conducted the campaign they were basically
02:48:07 on message with the things that people care about their jobs their security their homes
02:48:12 all the things that, and yet it didn't take, or at least it didn't take insufficient numbers.
02:48:19 So would you advise them to do something different for the next campaign or stay the course because people will come round?
02:48:28 Yeah, well, I mean, these are good questions.
02:48:31 There's an ongoing debate inside the conservative camp throughout this campaign.
02:48:36 Was it do we stick with the message that's been working for us, you know, cost of living, cost of tomatoes, cost of bread, cost of rent, availability of houses, you know, all these issues that propelled, you know, that propelled the conservatives into a strong lead over the liberals.
02:48:53 and you know as we as we watch the liberals implode after you know finally after nine years of Trudeau
02:48:58 um so do we stick with that because it works or do we jump on the new bandwagon which is oh my
02:49:05 goodness Donald Trump and who's going to protect us from the big orange menace right um there it 0.70
02:49:11 was genuine debate and what we saw in the end was something of a hybrid uh for the first couple
02:49:18 weeks, Mr. Poliev stuck to his original script. He eventually started to hybridize his message.
02:49:24 He didn't let go of the cost of living stuff, but he started to talk about defending Canada
02:49:29 against aggression from the South. And he kind of stuck with that hybrid right through the end.
02:49:34 I mean, some people are going to argue in the end that he didn't pivot enough,
02:49:38 that he should have gone full on against Trump. Others are going to say you watered down your
02:49:42 message. You should have stuck with the stuff that really works for you. In the end, probably
02:49:47 what happened here it's a little early and there's going to be a whole bunch of tea leaves to read
02:49:51 over several months but what probably happened here is that we didn't have one ballot question
02:49:57 uh supplanting uh the original ballot question we ended up with two ballot questions for some people
02:50:03 it was still a cost of living election right through the end and for other people it was oh
02:50:07 my goodness donald trump and who's going to protect us right and on one of those questions
02:50:13 the Liberals had a big advantage over the Conservatives. On the other one, the Conservatives
02:50:21 had a big advantage over the Liberals. It's a question of the relative weight of those two
02:50:27 ballot questions. Which one of those two issues motivated what proportion of the public?
02:50:33 So some of this is really just kind of act of God, force majeure, came out of, you know,
02:50:39 came at you sideways and, you know, the best laid plans can't really prepare you for everything.
02:50:45 Okay. Sorry, we'll come back to Baron, but I want to check in with Jared Yager, our
02:50:50 BC Bureau chief. He is coming to us from Vancouver or Surrey. Jared, are you outside of
02:51:01 J.B. Singh's headquarters there? No, I'm actually in North Burnaby right now at a campaign event
02:51:07 for Mauro Francis of the Conservative Party.
02:51:11 So when I got kicked out of the NDP event,
02:51:14 they made it pretty clear that they didn't want me
02:51:16 anywhere on the premises.
02:51:18 So we should make clear here.
02:51:21 The Carney campaign started off
02:51:23 during its leadership campaign
02:51:24 by refusing admittance to Western Standard Reporters.
02:51:28 They got some bad press on that,
02:51:29 and they reversed course.
02:51:30 And actually, Mark Carney would take questions
02:51:32 from Western Standard Reporters.
02:51:34 They were tough, but we tried to keep them fair
02:51:36 and reasonable, and so
02:51:39 good on Carney for that, but
02:51:40 Jameet Singh is a bit of a
02:51:43 princess, it seems, and
02:51:45 they refused
02:51:47 to send us news releases, they wouldn't tell us where
02:51:49 events were, and if we got to events,
02:51:51 they'd toss us, so
02:51:53 yeah, you were, Jameet Singh
02:51:55 had you escorted out of his
02:51:57 campaign headquarters, I guess.
02:51:59 Yep, and they
02:52:01 said it was because I didn't have media accreditation,
02:52:03 and then I pointed out to
02:52:05 them that I tried to get in touch with them numerous times throughout the campaign and never
02:52:10 got a response and then they admitted yes it's because Jagmeet Singh doesn't want to engage
02:52:15 with the western standard and it's only the NDP that I've had this problem with you know I've
02:52:20 covered events during this campaign the conservatives the liberals and even during the provincial
02:52:27 election the bc NDP they were fine the bc greens the bc conservative it's only the federal NDP
02:52:35 where i've had the the ndp uh leader in um uh saskatchewan takes our questions uh even now
02:52:42 the alberta ndp leader takes our questions uh jegme is just a bit uh made of more sensitive
02:52:49 stuff i guess uh well what was the mood for the brief time you're in there uh the ndp are facing
02:52:56 very possibly their worst election in the history of that party you'd have to go back to maybe early
02:53:01 CCCF right now. They're not declared elected in a single riding in Canada. Nada. One.
02:53:12 From the New Democrats you were talking to when they weren't trying to escort you out,
02:53:18 what kind of vibe were you getting from them? I mean, I was there pretty early,
02:53:22 so there weren't too many people there yet. But the ones who I saw, they had smiles on their faces.
02:53:26 So I think they were optimistic. And there's some writings here in BC that I think the NDP might pick up, but not nearly as many as they did last time, for sure.
02:53:38 Yaroslav, I want to come to you on this question. We can talk in a second about the implication of the NDP collapse for the Liberals and the Conservatives.
02:53:48 And there's a there's a ton there, obviously. But the NDP, I think it's safe to say that one call I'll make confidently right now is that they will not achieve official party status.
02:53:59 They're going to get annihilated. I'm hesitant to put a floor on it yet because there's still some of their core constituencies like Jaymeet Singh's own writing in Burnaby that have not yet reported.
02:54:12 but that floor uh is looking like a basement right now yeah you got it look uh 12 seats is
02:54:21 a magic number to be uh to be officially accredited as a party as in the house of commons and you're
02:54:27 right uh the way things are tracking for the nbp right now it does not look like they will be a
02:54:31 recognized party in the house of commons this means a couple things first of all pretty brutal
02:54:36 times uh ahead for the nbp they're basically going to have to live off the charity of their
02:54:40 provincial parties just to, you know, pay the rent, keep the lights on, keep a little bit of
02:54:45 core staff at party headquarters. So it's not going to be pretty for them. It's kind of like
02:54:49 back in 1993 when the progressive conservatives were wiped out of the House of Commons. They
02:54:55 basically had to live off the charity of their senators to sort of share some of their budgets
02:55:01 to try to cobble together a little bit of a pool for head office. So that's, you know, that's the
02:55:06 internal politics consequence of it. So it's going to be tough for them to rebound when that
02:55:10 happened um electorally ultimately frankly you know a long-term collapse of the ndp is not great
02:55:17 for the conservatives because like the last time that we saw an election where the both the liberals
02:55:23 and the conservatives were coming in on ebay like around 40 or more in the polls was something like
02:55:30 1930 so um the presence of that junior third party um gobbling up a bunch of center-left votes
02:55:40 tends to help conservatives get elected.
02:55:42 You know, there are a whole bunch of writings
02:55:44 where the conservatives get elected on the splits.
02:55:47 You eliminate them,
02:55:48 and it provides a whole bunch more ballast
02:55:50 for the liberals,
02:55:51 which means it's tougher long-term for the blue team.
02:56:00 Noisy word.
02:56:00 Here it is.
02:56:02 I thought there was a raccoon in the garbage can.
02:56:05 Oh, man.
02:56:08 Sorry, man.
02:56:08 I think no matter what, even if he wins his seat,
02:56:13 Jaymeet Singh is done tonight.
02:56:16 I don't think there's any scenario where this guy stays on.
02:56:21 You know, speculation will begin quickly about who's to replace him.
02:56:25 But what path forward?
02:56:28 How the hell did Mark Carney consolidate the NDP's vote
02:56:33 when he is perceived, at least, to be a more centrist than Justin Trudeau.
02:56:42 He moves right, at least in appearance, and maybe not in substance,
02:56:46 but he moves right perceptually, and the left follows him.
02:56:51 How the hell did he do that? That's magic.
02:56:54 It's one of the big mysteries of this campaign.
02:56:56 And frankly, my theory on it is this,
02:57:00 that they successfully spooked the public into thinking that this was an existential election.
02:57:07 The future of Canada hinges on the outcome of this election. So is your, you, the people of Canada,
02:57:13 the poor peasants of Canada, is your champion going to be this guy or this guy? Because we know
02:57:19 it's only going to be one of these two that's going to be prime minister. So they successfully
02:57:23 spooked the public into thinking, oh my God, Canada's in jeopardy unless we get this globalist
02:57:31 banker to represent us and face off against Donald Trump. And that really seemed to have spooked a
02:57:37 whole bunch of NDP voters who ironically, counterintuitively fled the left-wing party and
02:57:44 moved to the left center, left center, center, left somewhere party. It's really ironic. I think
02:57:53 I think that's the explanation.
02:57:55 Well, I think the existence of Canada as we know it was on the ballot,
02:57:59 just not in the way that the Liberals are describing it right now.
02:58:03 Nigel, do you have anything?
02:58:07 No, it's the whole business of what do you tell the Conservative Party to do next.
02:58:12 But I guess there will be time enough for that discussion.
02:58:16 Do you think that they're actually going to lose?
02:58:19 lose like i just got the numbers here that in the in the last election they can the conservatives
02:58:24 have 5.7 million votes yeah um the liberals had a whole 5.5 obviously the liberals are going to
02:58:32 pick up the the ndp slack do you think that the the conservatives are going to come out a little
02:58:39 ahead on this on the they're going to pick up votes that just will translate to seats well
02:58:45 Well, right now, the way it's tracking, it doesn't look as though the Conservatives are going to win the popular vote as they did the last two times.
02:58:55 Last election, 2021, the Conservatives won the popular vote narrowly, but they won the popular vote.
02:59:00 Same thing in 2019, when Andrew Scheer was leader, they won the popular vote.
02:59:05 Not sure we're tracking in that direction this time, but it's still pretty outstanding.
02:59:11 in, you know, to have a conservative party finish an election at 40% in the polls, like
02:59:19 normally conservatives are popping champagne corks and celebrating because they've just
02:59:24 won a majority government if they pulled off 40% of the vote.
02:59:27 It's pretty astounding to see this kind of a, by any normal standard, successful, successful
02:59:35 outcome and still not form government.
02:59:37 That's going to be the really frustrating thing.
02:59:39 Yeah. What is it about the liberals and what is it about the conservatives? Because we know what it is with the conservatives. They're very strong on traditional values. What's a liberal voter think like?
02:59:57 the the ethos of the liberal vote i don't know maybe not it's uh like i'm wondering with some
03:00:05 of the people that i've met around here who are tell me they're voting liberal they don't think
03:00:10 about much yeah yeah nigel there seems to be a pretty significant difference in you know in the
03:00:19 generational spread in this election and with no disrespect to the boomers uh the baby boomers
03:00:26 cut liberal in this election at least that's what that's what all the polling you know before today
03:00:30 was telling us in the last in the last week or so the baby boom generation which normally is 1.00
03:00:36 pretty solidly conservative they went liberal under mark carney why you know we can we can
03:00:43 analyze that we can speculate we don't have the data yet but i'm speculating it's because this
03:00:48 is a generation that's already built up its assets they've already built up their nest eggs 0.65
03:00:51 They're invested in the market, whether it's their pension fund or their RRSP or their tax-free savings accounts or whatever it is, it's tied in the markets.
03:01:00 And they see this kind of market volatility, a trillion dollars of wealth globally being wiped out because Donald Trump sneezed and whatever.
03:01:07 So they're freaked out.
03:01:09 They want to protect their assets.
03:01:11 They want a banker type to try to neutralize this chaos that they're seeing in the markets.
03:01:18 This banker type is likely to bring in a home equity tax.
03:01:21 Yeah, I mean, that's that's you being that's you being rational, Nigel.
03:01:26 But this is fear, right?
03:01:30 This is fear. But the millennials, the millennials, the people who have not yet bought a home, the people who want to get married, but are freaked out thinking I can't afford to.
03:01:39 The people who want to have a first kid and think, can we afford to do this?
03:01:43 this they have tacked conservative like that that demographic the millennials the gen zedders
03:01:49 disproportionately are voting conservative so it would appear in the according to the polls leading
03:01:54 up to today it's a really interesting phenomenon normally you get old people voting voting 0.77
03:01:59 conservative and you have the you know the young people uh you know voting ndp and everything seems
03:02:05 to be topsy-turvy like mr paulie have really struck a nerve with young canadians worried about the
03:02:10 future of this country and worried about their own well-being and worried about having a standard of
03:02:14 living that's less than than what their parents enjoyed and so those young canadians are voting
03:02:20 blue and the older canadians are kind of out of fear again to your earlier point you know
03:02:29 existential fear of canada may not be the right fear uh but they're they're voting for the banker
03:02:35 guy to give them some stability so the conservatives are the part of the future as these young people
03:02:41 move up through the true the demographic pipeline so uh all right well uh uh you know slav uh thank
03:02:48 you very much uh i really really appreciate it um uh yeah uh thank you very much for your time
03:02:57 i've i just got a text from my dad hey dad uh saying ctv has just called it as a liberal
03:03:04 minority government so not a majority uh minority um i actually don't that calling it a minority
03:03:12 is a tougher call right now because we don't know what the end the ndp we know it's gonna be terrible
03:03:18 but yeah like it's it'd be a minority government but the third party would be so damn small so
03:03:24 it's gonna rely on the block um watch it carney is gonna try and bring the conservatives in
03:03:30 and coalition. I know it's my craziest thing I've
03:03:32 said. It won't be the
03:03:34 craziest thing I say tonight.
03:03:36 But watch it. He's going to declare
03:03:38 he wants a national unity government.
03:03:40 And they're going
03:03:42 to try and bring the conservatives in.
03:03:44 And the conservatives would be mad.
03:03:46 Mad to take it.
03:03:48 New reform party.
03:03:50 No, no. That was the West
03:03:52 wants in. This time
03:03:54 it's going to be the West wants out.
03:03:56 We've wasted enough time.
03:03:57 Yeah, I think we've spent enough time
03:03:59 Okay, back in a good time.
03:04:01 Okay, maybe I have got, I see Ted Morton in the stream,
03:04:06 but we're not scheduled for Ted for quite some time.
03:04:09 Does this mean we get extra Ted Talk?
03:04:11 Give him a try, Ted Talk.
03:04:13 Do we get some Ted Talk?
03:04:14 Okay, yes?
03:04:16 I don't think he said no.
03:04:17 That's a no.
03:04:18 Okay, no Ted Talk for now.
03:04:20 Ted's just enjoying watching for now, I guess.
03:04:23 Let's go, okay, let's check in quickly with Jared.
03:04:27 let jared get back to work and then we're going to go to jen hodgson in ottawa
03:04:34 all right uh what do you see are you safe have you been who's that guy is staring
03:04:38 in our camera right behind you who's that guy oh just an attendee uh it's quite packed down
03:04:44 there at the pub yeah at the pub that the ndb headquarters is the pub this is conservative
03:04:51 no no this is uh oh okay oh yeah up in northern bernambi yeah yeah okay okay uh i mean i okay so
03:05:00 the cdc site is updating less fast than the uh ctv site elections canada's down yeah i'll watch
03:05:06 it down for a while you have one job guys one day one day your website really really just needs to
03:05:14 work for one day every roughly four years and you couldn't do it uh do we know how james doing in
03:05:20 his writing in i don't think there's any results no results nothing from the lower main line yet
03:05:27 i think that's on if he keeps his writing i think he's gone gone there's a honestly i think he's
03:05:31 done too yeah sir what's that i heard i think he's done you know he was pulling third for
03:05:37 quite a while so do you guys we've got a couple lower main line brothers but they're like lower
03:05:43 yeah do you guys think that he just doesn't care like he was like i got my pension like he actually
03:05:51 wants to lose his seat so he has resigned himself to losing it like this last 10 days or even since
03:05:56 the debate it's just now let's run the clock and do what damage i can on the way out right i mean
03:06:01 that was not a debate performance trying to win support that was a debate before i was trying to
03:06:05 drag somebody else down yeah that's not somebody trying to win his seat that's that's somebody
03:06:08 is giving up like do you think he just wants because he doesn't want to sit there he's got
03:06:13 his pension oh yeah you don't want to win it yeah is he is is he in a three running no he's
03:06:20 no burnaby okay okay that's what i'm talking about he'll end up in the corner of a law office
03:06:25 somewhere and you can definitely be wealthy drive his macerati and look at his rolex oh yeah he'll
03:06:32 be fine it was nice kid uh peter julian long time ndp mp uh losing although not too many in yet
03:06:42 pardon go back to central central jay meet singh yeah okay so there's only three polls reporting
03:06:51 still pretty early but uh jay beat singh in second uh no tied for second and third place
03:06:58 with the conservative uh but still way too early to tell from those numbers that's that's not very
03:07:03 reliable he was pulling third for the last well that's based on aggregators they're they're not
03:07:08 pulling in the actual running the ndp itself probably has internal polls that would be much
03:07:12 more accurate to the right working liberal on something than they were now when we're talking
03:07:17 about polling and rotting we're talking projections and it's i mean they're they're normally in the
03:07:23 right neighborhood but they're not very accurate but you know you've lost yeah you know you have
03:07:28 lost when you come in behind the guy who always used to be third there's no second conservative
03:07:36 that is the judgment on the ndp i don't know how long do you think how does the party come back
03:07:42 from that uh another cycle or two they'll be yeah they don't go away there's a natural place for the
03:07:49 ndp like so they're they'll be back they'll be back but they're going to go through a rebound
03:07:56 i mean they're going in may 1st here in alberta to decide what they look like as a provincial
03:08:02 versus federal party at their convention that they're very hush hush about because they don't
03:08:07 want to draw attention to their potential divorce with their um federal partner but so we will see
03:08:15 that, but then they'll have to rebuild of what does a federal, I mean, Trudeau basically became
03:08:20 a communist himself. So now that if you have Kearney, there's probably more opportunity to
03:08:25 Corey's point in the next two election cycles to truly take up the socialist part of the spectrum.
03:08:32 I want to actually go to the CTVs right now. I'm going to bring this in. This is Carlton.
03:08:40 Minority. Yeah, liberal minority. So this is the writing of Carlton, Pierre Polyev's writing. Still fairly, only two, 266 polls in, but roughly just a little over a thousand votes counted. Liberals are leading in Polyev's writing. I mean, if you're going to be the leader of a party that wants to reduce the size in government, it's not good to have a lot of bureaucrats living in your writing.
03:09:09 Right.
03:09:10 But, I mean, he has held this riding since the unification of the Conservative Party's first election, 2004.
03:09:15 He took it from a Liberal Cabinet minister.
03:09:17 David Pratt.
03:09:18 David Pratt.
03:09:19 Defense minister.
03:09:19 Yeah.
03:09:20 It's a fairly traditionally conservative riding.
03:09:24 Ottawa might have a lot of bureaucrats, but not on the outside, especially as you push towards the Ottawa Valley.
03:09:29 It starts to get actually pretty conservative.
03:09:31 But Ottawa's growing.
03:09:33 The government has ballooned massively.
03:09:35 So I still expect he's going to win tonight.
03:09:38 but it's not a good start well you know when when that story first broke i thought that that was
03:09:45 just the mainstream media trying to create a story out of out of uh rumors and very little else but
03:09:52 it does seem there was some there was some merit in their argument something to it yeah yeah as
03:09:57 you say i think it went in the end but yeah i'm not gonna bat an eye on two out of 266 polls yeah
03:10:03 yeah all right uh anything else for me jared uh before we let you go
03:10:10 we have some calgary results
03:10:15 jared anything before we let you go nope that's it for now okay uh we're gonna go uh to uh
03:10:22 welfare wolf blitzer here welfare will uh for some uh some updates
03:10:28 okay i'm uh just looking at some calgary numbers we've got some calgary numbers coming in
03:10:34 so uh calgary mcknight uh george to hall still pretty early only six and 196 polls but uh he's
03:10:40 hanging in with about 48 percent uh calgary confederation which is the one that kent had
03:10:47 mentioned uh cory hogan i'm kind of surprised because this is my writing i've never heard this
03:10:52 guy did you vote i did vote i'm not going to say who i voted for but i did vote but uh jeremy
03:11:00 nixon um provincial stalwart under uh ed stomach or not at stomach well i guess he was no he just
03:11:08 lost in his last election yeah but he's uh he's down and let's see we got one more calgary center
03:11:16 uh lindsay do you know her lindsay let's just call her lindsay
03:11:28 um edmonton's looking i'm kind of surprised here at edmonton because edmonton's looking
03:11:32 fairly solidly blue edmonton griesbach uh like you're saying uh edmonton center surprise surprise
03:11:39 uh this is kind of a big surprise heather mcpherson well maybe not she's been in before
03:11:45 You think she's going to win? 0.96
03:11:46 Yeah.
03:11:47 I mean, she's pretty close right now, but there's only 13 of 217.
03:11:49 He's not leading.
03:11:50 I think the only one that would would be Blake up in Griesbach to unseat them.
03:11:54 I think the one that everybody was looking at, though, was Amarjeet Sohee.
03:11:59 How many calls?
03:12:00 This doesn't – I mean, we're only five of 159.
03:12:04 He's in second, but he's trailing pretty much.
03:12:07 Amarjeet Sohee is –
03:12:09 Former mayor of Edmonton or the current mayor of Edmonton who's running.
03:12:13 Yeah.
03:12:14 So he will still have a job after tonight.
03:12:16 Well, this is odd if...
03:12:18 He will until October, which is a shame for democracy.
03:12:20 Yeah.
03:12:20 I win for democracy, yeah.
03:12:23 Depending on how you look.
03:12:24 Yeah.
03:12:24 Okay, so we're looking at Alberta here. 0.61
03:12:28 It is a bit odd.
03:12:29 I mean, it's still...
03:12:30 The Edmonton and Calgary numbers are still up for grabs.
03:12:33 Everything outside of that, painted blue.
03:12:36 That's no surprise.
03:12:37 Of course, yeah.
03:12:38 Three hoop...
03:12:39 Oh, no.
03:12:40 Now we're down to only two Liberals.
03:12:42 Two Liberals.
03:12:43 Okay.
03:12:44 Well, yeah, it's looking pretty good for the Conservatives in Edmonton.
03:12:47 It would be odd for there to be more leftist MPs in Edmonton than in Calgary, though.
03:12:52 That doesn't make a lot of sense.
03:12:54 I mean, I haven't lived in Calgary for 12 years now, but I did live here for about eight.
03:13:02 And the difference, I think, for when we're looking at Edmonton and Calgary is that Edmonton is very blanket Conservatives.
03:13:09 So there's not an area that doesn't have Conservatives in the court.
03:13:12 And so why a lot of them, even you remember door knocking, you know, years ago, where you'd have a federal NDP or a federal or a provincial, sorry, NDP or liberal, but you'd have them go conservative federally.
03:13:26 And again, I think that's just the way that kind of the cookie crumbles with larger electoral districts that you saw in Edmonton with those no true pockets, like with the exception of Edmonton Strathcona.
03:13:40 But even then, in the 90s, it was a conservative riding.
03:13:44 I want to check in with, have we still got Chris Oldcorn here?
03:13:47 He's been waiting patiently here.
03:13:49 Where is Chris?
03:13:50 We got Coldcorn.
03:13:51 Okay, let's bring in Coldcorn.
03:13:52 um i want to talk about uh oh where's the green candidate so yeah do we have uh
03:14:00 jonathan dennis is on jonathan dennis is on okay you know what we're gonna talk to both
03:14:04 jonathan dennis and cold corn because uh one is a former saskatchewanian who's an alberton
03:14:11 and the other is a former ontarian who became a saskatchewanian um so we're gonna talk about
03:14:17 saskatchewan we just haven't yeah you guys are just so awesome in your voting that you're just
03:14:21 not interesting you're the new alberta uh where it's just not that interesting it didn't always
03:14:27 be it wasn't always like that derek it wasn't always like that i'm aware okay so right now
03:14:32 the conservatives are leading or elected in every single riding in saskatchewan with the exception
03:14:37 of desnethy missinipi churchill river that must be a new name on that riding they keep on making
03:14:46 the names weirder um let's just call it churchill river because that's what everybody calls it
03:14:50 because they can't pronounce the other words.
03:14:52 Yeah, yeah.
03:14:53 Okay, that's an agreed policy for tonight.
03:14:56 Okay, so for that riding, I mean, 48 of 88 polls.
03:15:00 Good for Liberals, but it's still pretty low.
03:15:02 What's actually interesting there,
03:15:03 Buckley Belanger is a longtime political figure in Saskatchewan.
03:15:06 He was elected in 1995 as a Liberal, then went to the NDP.
03:15:11 He served with the NDP until a few years ago.
03:15:13 That's the second time that he has run there.
03:15:15 I think he has quite a personal following.
03:15:17 I think he's probably carrying that more than the party grant.
03:15:22 Yeah, and Jim was a South Party MLA up until the fall election when he lost the seat there.
03:15:28 So, Saskatchewan, there's really no surprises.
03:15:32 Let's take a look at the more urban ridings.
03:15:36 We've got Regina.
03:15:37 That's where I grew up with, Derek, right?
03:15:39 You're resuming it right at my old home.
03:15:41 Yeah, we're going to win that riding.
03:15:43 That's my riding.
03:15:45 Okay, good.
03:15:46 Okay, so yeah, Regina was up. So that was, what's his nuts? The liberal. Ralph Goodell was a very,
03:16:02 very long time liberal who held that. He held it until 2019. And then Michael Cram, who I grew up
03:16:12 with you took him out and he's still there yeah so uh he's in the lead still uh still quite a few
03:16:19 polls to come in uh are any of are any of these regina or saskatoon writings looking interesting
03:16:27 to you guys could the liberals pick any up not university i thought saskatoon university i
03:16:32 thought liberals were only said to be there but they're close close there it's close um the the
03:16:40 The more interesting one is the Regina Wiscana due to the fact that Jeff Walters is very well known.
03:16:47 And him and Cram have actually been as close as three votes apart at one point.
03:16:51 They were 44.1% to 44% about 10 minutes ago.
03:16:56 And that one's flipping around, but it does look like it's going to stay with Cram.
03:17:01 But all the big names in Saskatchewan have held their seats.
03:17:04 Andrew Scheer, Kelly Block, Kathy Wagenthal, all the big ones have firmly won their seats.
03:17:10 We're going to bring in another Saskatchewan boy, John Thompson, Western Standard columnist extraordinaire.
03:17:18 Thank you for joining us, John.
03:17:19 Yeah, my pleasure. Thanks for having me on.
03:17:22 All right. Well, right now, we're talking Saskatchewan, which has become a very uninteresting political place in a good way, I think.
03:17:30 um right now all the rural ridings except for churchill river uh plus uh are trending conservative
03:17:39 uh or have been called hard conservative yeah um so that one in the far north um i mean that's a
03:17:46 that's a different kind of beast as a far north riding it's huge it's bigger than
03:17:51 many countries in the world it might be part of its own soon um then we've got uh three saskatoon
03:17:58 and two Regina urban seats, all leaning conservative, but not yet called.
03:18:05 Your thoughts, the conservative is going to take all of Regina and Saskatoon,
03:18:09 and your thoughts on Churchill River, trending liberal, at least at this moment.
03:18:15 Yeah, I guess I think with Churchill River, that's probably a shoe-in for the liberals at this point.
03:18:21 Like it was previously mentioned, you know, Bucky Belanger is super popular up there,
03:18:26 and he is carrying that win based on his reputation, I think, more than the party brand.
03:18:32 And Jeffrey Walters, same thing, a super well-known individual here in Saskatchewan
03:18:37 who, you know, did yeoman service for the Saskia Liberal Party before it changed names.
03:18:43 And I wouldn't be surprised to see him carry that riding as well.
03:18:48 And I think, you know, it'll be interesting to see what Mark Carney and the government does
03:18:53 with those two ridings if they get them both.
03:18:56 in terms of allocating cabinet positions to one of the two
03:19:00 and having more representation in Saskatchewan
03:19:03 to offset what's likely going to be a surge in, you know,
03:19:08 independence movements.
03:19:12 So I want to note here,
03:19:15 there are still zero New Democrats declared elected in all of Canada,
03:19:20 anywhere.
03:19:21 They are leading in 10 constituencies.
03:19:24 um and yeah we're starting to get more reliable numbers at this point they're leading in 10 but
03:19:30 they have not been declared elected in a single constituency uh so this is embarrassing for the
03:19:38 ndp uh embarrassing is losing a few seats uh like i don't know i don't know what how to describe
03:19:46 losing nearly all of your seats when you've been in a de facto coalition government well the one
03:19:53 thing i would add to that is traditionally in canada the junior partner in a coalition loses
03:19:59 their identity but there's a caveat here as much as we don't like the ndp on this podcast me included
03:20:04 i will say that the last two conservative majorities 1988 there were 43 ndp seats 2011
03:20:11 103 ndp seats it would seem that as much as we don't like them that without them we don't form
03:20:19 a majority government as a conservative yeah uh you know i want the i i i need one of you three
03:20:27 can jump in on this um we also maybe bring in the former premier of this lovely oh my god we're
03:20:35 talking about saskatchewan and we've got sitting in the green room uh former saskatchewan premier
03:20:41 brad wall and we have not uh we're just kind of uh talking over him uh let's make brad a big head
03:20:49 big head for brad uh not just one of the little ones here talk about a successful conservative
03:20:53 he's right here all right uh former premier uh wall thank you very much for joining us
03:20:59 uh we're we're just going through saskatchewan right now and uh it's looking pretty solid uh
03:21:07 your initial reactions on it looks like it's all going conservative except for uh churchill river
03:21:12 in the far north yeah i think but three belanges leading liberals in that that was uh that was my
03:21:18 last bit of information uh of course i said the legislature would probably he was a i think he
03:21:23 first ran mla and then uh former premier romano got him to cross the floor and he became part of
03:21:29 that uh 2000 or that 1990 government that's when i was first elected anyway so yeah west was for a
03:21:38 while but it is that was with this barrier maybe one or two poles and i think it's okay now
03:21:44 so uh pretty interesting evening i heard you got what you guys were talking about
03:21:47 uh with respect to the ndt and what a remarkable collapse uh and pretty much entirely self-inflicted
03:21:56 uh i'm gonna ask maybe a bigger picture question across the west um the uh primarily the east
03:22:05 has doubled down on, I guess, the last decade of Liberal rule.
03:22:12 They've voted for more of this, backed in large measure by NDP voters
03:22:17 flocking to the Liberals.
03:22:20 But the East has doubled down here.
03:22:24 Preston Manning wrote a piece in the Globe and Mail saying that, you know,
03:22:28 if Canada votes, a vote for the Liberals is a vote for Western secession.
03:22:35 I know you're the former premier of Saskatchewan. I think few people have a better read on the situation than you. I'm in Alberta and my idea of Saskatchewan mostly comes from Chris on a daily basis here. But what's your sense of how are people in Saskatchewan or the Prairie West, maybe more broadly, going to react to this tomorrow morning?
03:22:58 Well, it really depends what the Kearney minority government, although if you take a look at the board now, I've been down here in your in your green room, by the way, there are no 148.
03:23:08 I want to point that out. But I, I was watching the board just before I came down here. And it's, it was tightening at the time, I would say, and you have, you put the block in the and the conservatives together, you get a, you get a
03:23:26 but the answer to your question i think is this it really depends what if it's carney if it's a
03:23:37 carney minority government minority parliament what he does if he does what he said he was going
03:23:43 to do in the campaign uh and prior to the campaign uh where he's writing books and making public
03:23:49 comments uh that could answer your question about how intense western unrest unrest or
03:23:58 western alienation and i say that because you know he he talked a big game uh in the campaign about
03:24:06 canada being an energy superpower when you dig down into the comments
03:24:12 fossil fuels because the rest of the liberal policies they were proposing
03:24:17 where things like C-69 stays, the ban stays, the emission cap stays, the ban on fossil fuels
03:24:25 starting with a quota next year and then completely in 2035, that stays. The clean energy,
03:24:33 the clean electricity regulations probably stay. These will be, these will be, and they are
03:24:41 antithetical to the Western economy, though it really will depend on what a minority Kearney
03:24:49 government does. Alberta Premier Daniel Smith met with Kearney soon before calling the election,
03:24:58 and she presented him with a list of, I think it was nine conditions or demands,
03:25:05 said if they're not fulfilled, Canada will face an unprecedented unity crisis. Some in the press,
03:25:11 said that was a threat. You could also interpret it as a warning, I think, that maybe you want to
03:25:20 do some of these things. But, you know, her list of demands actually struck me as pretty low-hanging
03:25:26 fruit. We're not talking anymore at all about structural reform to the Federation. We're not
03:25:31 talking, I'm sitting beside a senator-elect right now. She's been waiting a lot longer. Yeah, who is
03:25:36 not sitting in the senate um i mean it's a pretty low ass that you know the people we elect to go to
03:25:42 the senate go to the senate instead they elect i don't know i don't want to get sued i'm just
03:25:46 gonna say real weirdos real weirdos you're not gonna get sued for that derek yeah i'm not not
03:25:53 that's because i'm using the term weirdos i'm not saying what i really think uh but um you know
03:25:58 we're not talking about uh you know reforming the senate so that you know province like alberta with
03:26:04 twice the population of all four Atlantic provinces, which has just barely more than half the senators
03:26:10 of just Nova Scotia or just New Brunswick. We're not talking about fixing that. We're not talking
03:26:15 about fixing equalization. We're not talking about big structural change anymore. These are pretty
03:26:21 low-hanging fruit asks from Premier Smith. I don't know. Do you take it as more of a threat
03:26:28 or more as a warning what she said? I think the Premier was doing her job. She was making 0.95
03:26:33 what she needed from the whoever the next government of canada was i think she was
03:26:39 doing her job when she was engaged with the uh with her contacts uh and and others in the united
03:26:45 states uh during and since the inauguration so um those structural things weren't on the list
03:26:55 of demands because they are not possible this is the problem we have what we're witnessing tonight
03:27:03 the challenge of this sort of this federation where the feet of the federal government in the
03:27:09 federation is de facto a unicum rep by the house of commons because the senate sorry if you get
03:27:17 there sorry the senate is is not a thing uh i know how you feel about it i called you when i was
03:27:22 running currently constituted brad didn't you pass a motion when you were premier to abolish
03:27:28 the Senate? We did. I thought so. He did. That's why I said I know how he feels.
03:27:34 I've always thought that a functional federation requires a functional upper house to function.
03:27:41 But I mean, if the two options are the status quo feudal Canadian Laurentian Senate versus no
03:27:47 Senate, of course, no Senate is better. Under the current state, I think we can all agree it
03:27:50 doesn't operate in the way it's intended. I hope we don't get distracted by the Senate
03:27:55 because my point is this it can change it requires a constitutional amendment that's never going to
03:28:03 happen and the constitutional amendment is is another notional rep by pop process that needs
03:28:10 to be the queen's park or assembly and it happened so for western canadians who have a i would say a
03:28:18 disproportionate economic interest or a contribution for the country certainly that they do a political
03:28:23 influence what is the remedy get into the house of commons unless you just get lucky and get a
03:28:29 government like we hope to get tonight that might even have a cold you know that's amazing
03:28:35 that does not very happen very often in the country equalization can't change it's hardwired
03:28:40 in the institution so the remedy the reason that 35 according to angus reed in saskatchewan more
03:28:46 than alberta were expressing western alienation a few weeks ago 30 in alberta the reason that the
03:28:51 number is that high without a campaign without a leader without answers to tough questions about
03:28:57 how you know how how did this sort of end this western alienation without any of that 35 and 30.
03:29:06 uh what do you i mean uh it's look okay the networks have generally called uh liberal
03:29:13 minority government here uh probably but i mean leading and elected the liberals are 154.
03:29:20 the conservatives are 151 and the popular vote the conservatives are slightly behind but that's
03:29:26 because the west is reporting later actually do have a chance at winning the popular vote here
03:29:32 still uh i'm i'm not sure if there's been a case you know with the last two elections there's been
03:29:37 uh liberal minority governments with the conservatives win the popular vote i'd have
03:29:41 to look back and see if it's ever happened that someone has won a majority government without the
03:29:46 popular vote that's a trickier that's a trickier one to pull off uh but the the electoral math is
03:29:52 just completely out the window since there's a weakened block and a completely devastated
03:29:56 if not annihilated NDP um uh but I just got a text that I saw on the tablet here from my former
03:30:05 senior advisor who made the point I was talking to him earlier tonight about the very thing you're
03:30:11 talking about which is this call even a bit premature and his comment at the top was you
03:30:17 know they're in the game and they're in the score at the bottom right now and um so if i didn't know
03:30:22 it was 151 it was in the low 140s when i when i came down to jump on the show that's very close
03:30:30 and i don't still out there so um very very very interesting numbers if it's 154 151 right now
03:30:38 i'm guessing the block still in the low 20s and the adp are at 10. uh no the block is at like 17.
03:30:47 oh leading and elected in 25 elected at 17 but leading and elected 25 yeah
03:30:51 well elizabeth may won her writing our way did she yeah she's got 43 percent 0.99
03:30:59 sorry go ahead here's actually still behind in his writing so if he
03:31:03 that went over uh i guess that we're pretty there are only two polls reporting there so
03:31:07 So there's a long way to get that.
03:31:09 China has five polls, and Pierre's writing right now, 72 to 657.
03:31:15 Now, that's still very early days.
03:31:17 Yeah.
03:31:18 But if that flips, because it's in their numbers right now, that shows us a liberal lead.
03:31:23 It does show us a liberal lead.
03:31:25 Yeah.
03:31:26 So that's going to take the liberals down one and the conserves up one, and then all of a sudden we're basically tied now.
03:31:32 I mean, this is the closest election we've had in a long time.
03:31:34 Sorry.
03:31:35 Which Syria? 0.60
03:31:36 uh oh no i was looking at the burnaby is what you're looking at thank you sir can i ask you
03:31:42 this if um if we end up with something that close what are the alliance possibilities to form a
03:31:48 government that's a great great that's a real question uh launch it is going to have a lot to
03:31:55 say about that obviously and and then the conservatives would have a debate uh let's say
03:32:02 for instance the conservatives move into maybe it ends in a tie and so then it's an open question as
03:32:08 to make the best case to the governor general about forming a parliament that has the confidence of
03:32:13 the house but conservatives and the block uh because there's no way the ndp are going to
03:32:19 support the conservatives in the new parliament so the party would be the block and what would
03:32:24 they demand what would they want from from the conservatives what what concession no pipeline
03:32:32 might be better with the liberals then yeah if it if it is a tie number of seats uh the
03:32:37 constitutional convention is that the party that was the governing party before will have the first
03:32:42 chance of forming a government uh the last time i believe that happened was in nova scotia the late
03:32:47 1990s uh no it's not even if it's a tie you can govern from second or even theoretically third
03:32:53 place as long as you can format an independent could technically technically be the prime minister
03:32:57 that independent can hold the confidence of the house uh so technically it doesn't matter where
03:33:01 you're where you rank uh formation i think what he's saying is they would give it to the party in
03:33:06 power they would have the first chance yeah they perform it the chance goes to the party that won
03:33:13 the most yeah i i want to note here uh nine out of 200 polls reporting burnaby central so we're
03:33:20 we're getting a we're getting a sense of where it's going but still a long ways to go jay beat
03:33:24 singh is running in a fairly distant third place right now uh liberal bye it's a 38 conservative 0.76
03:33:31 james yan at uh about 35 jay beat singh is at 25 that is tough shit you know but like i said in 0.82
03:33:43 the chat that you know nikki acton is the bellwether for the ndp uh she's been an mp for 0.90
03:33:48 you know the northern manitoba for 15 years and she's trailing the liberal candidate by 0.64
03:33:55 1500 2000 votes at this point with 50 polls reporting so i mean if she can't hold her seat 0.96
03:34:02 no no chance that thing can no uh mr mr wall uh so i mean i'm not 100 sure the liberals actually
03:34:13 get a minority here i think they i lean that way but i i'm not 100 sure i'm not ready to
03:34:19 completely call it but i i think that's where things are leaning if that's where we're headed
03:34:24 though another uh liberal government primarily propped up by the east and then lower mainland bc
03:34:31 what does saskatchewan and alberta do are we are we uh let me just hunker down again or what do we
03:34:40 do? Well, really, as I said, off the top, it really depends on what the county government
03:34:44 does or doesn't do. I see moves on all those things I said off of the top of. Then we've
03:34:52 got some tough choices to make, because these things are really material to our ability
03:34:57 to make a living, to have a kind of economy that we want to have for the families here
03:35:04 saskatchewan of the families that live in the province of elsa so i it's a it's a hypothetical
03:35:11 question that begs an answer after we know better what government did to do all right yeah i think
03:35:20 what we could best hope for in a scenario with a liberal minority in order to hold the confidence
03:35:26 of the house is that like quebec gets you know he changes some of these policies because he's
03:35:30 talk from both sides of his mouth on, I want to be an energy sector. He gives us a corridor,
03:35:35 but that corridor goes to BC and doesn't go, and what is it, the port of Churchill up in Manitoba
03:35:43 that we're, but we're not getting a pipeline to Quebec. And I think that's the only way that he
03:35:48 can try and appease this Western alienation by getting our product to market, but while not
03:35:56 pissing off Quebec and the block through a pipeline out east. I think that's the only
03:36:03 scenario where he can actually dance between keeping the block on side and giving Alberta
03:36:09 and Saskatchewan and those prairies and not a reason to leave. I want to put a wilder
03:36:20 potential governing scenario
03:36:22 following up on Erica
03:36:24 than Nigel's question to you earlier,
03:36:26 Mr. Wall.
03:36:29 It's going to sound
03:36:30 crazier, but
03:36:31 the temperament of Carney
03:36:33 leads me to think that if he's got a minority
03:36:36 here, he might
03:36:38 try to form a so-called
03:36:40 national unity government
03:36:41 with the
03:36:44 Conservatives.
03:36:46 I mean,
03:36:47 I saw Jonathan Dennis
03:36:49 uh look like you bit a lemon when i said that uh i think it was easier than that comment okay
03:36:56 yeah uh but i i i wouldn't put it past them to try uh you know what are your thoughts
03:37:05 i i don't see it jonathan i'm probably eating the same way jonathan i don't i don't see him
03:37:11 doing that i don't know how the conservatives can do that if the if these policies are going
03:37:17 to remain unchanged if they're going to continue as as i expect to continue i just i don't see that
03:37:24 happening and then i'll go back to what i said earlier remember i mean that angus reed poll
03:37:30 was stark and to me and should be for everybody uh i think albertus a western uh western alienation
03:37:41 or more something more intense than that at 35 percent in fast and 30 percent in alberta
03:37:48 if a carney government proceeds as he says he'll proceed that number's going to grow uh and and
03:37:54 it will grow with the support of a more organized campaign with more organized leadership uh with
03:38:02 some of the objections you hear to uh to what the west really could do if it was on its own
03:38:08 and that number will that number will grow it will absolutely grow because if that is the highest
03:38:15 base i i can remember it in in contemporary history in our two provinces and again that's
03:38:22 without any organization that's without a spokesperson that's without a campaign
03:38:25 or spoke spokespeople or any kind of a process uh that maybe consults uh with albertans and
03:38:31 saskatchewan people but it'll depend on policy but it's not i don't think that none of this happens
03:38:37 if Carney has some sort of Damascus Road conversion about fossil fuels and modern age and mining.
03:38:47 If he doesn't, then I think all bets are off. There's one other thing that I would want to
03:38:52 point out from a Saskatchewan perspective, the hidden carbon tax that he wants to,
03:38:57 that he's going to basically continue with, even as he's at least temporarily paused the
03:39:02 the public-facing carbon tax, is potentially the greatest risk to our economy,
03:39:10 much greater than just a tax on fuel, a direct tax on basically a tax on fuel,
03:39:19 because of what it would do to our resource sector.
03:39:23 Think of the potash mines in Saskatchewan, uranium mines in Saskatchewan,
03:39:27 of the the large-scale industrial products that are going to pay this hidden carbon tax and it
03:39:33 sounds like i mean there's hints that his his view is that that can that can be ratcheted up uh and
03:39:40 that's another thing to add to the list of potential carny actions that will result
03:39:46 in some sort of reaction i believe in uh in the west
03:39:51 and one thing one thing uh further to brad's point the hidden carbon tax guess who pays that
03:40:00 it's all passed on to the consumer anyways so it's just a shell game it gets passed on to the
03:40:07 consumer and if it's high enough those jobs are at a lot absolutely so uh i'm gonna break in just
03:40:14 note here, in Jagmeet Singh's writing, the Conservatives have now taken the lead. Jagmeet
03:40:22 Singh's share of the vote continues to fall. Now it's still 15 out of 200 polls, a lot of room to
03:40:29 grow, but Singh is down to 22.5% in his own writing, trailing the Liberals at 37, the Conservatives at 39.
03:40:35 Yeah, Pierre Polyev actually falling behind a little in his riding. 59% for liberal Bruce Fanjoy. Polyev at 38.3. I think it's only 10 polls reporting there. So again, a lot of room to grow. But that's, there's a decent sampling size now looks like for a bit over 6000 votes. That gets to be a pretty good sampling. But again, yeah, it depends what part of the riding is it from.
03:41:05 i don't really know i haven't seen the breakdown yet um there's a really good rural portion to
03:41:10 that riding the thing is uh it said earlier quite correct there are a lot of civil servants in that
03:41:15 area so that is just by way of self-interest is going to be a bit of a drag it's a weird riding
03:41:21 it's got bureaucrats working in downtown ottawa and it's got farmers and gun nuts it's a weird weird
03:41:29 uh kind of l-shaped riding uh the closest that he's come he's held that riding since 2004
03:41:37 the closest that he's come before is in 2015 it was about 3 000 votes there
03:41:41 and that again was uh when uh when the uh when the ndp were a little we're a little bit lower
03:41:47 so it'll be interesting to see what happens here now you're also pulling up calgary
03:41:51 calgary actually has really only elected a couple of liberal mps in the last 50 years
03:41:56 uh we're seeing the northeast could flip but also the calgary confederation and calgary center uh
03:42:02 greg mclean has been a very good mp unfortunately in some of these cases the local candidate doesn't
03:42:07 really factor much into it more than plus or minus five points yeah yeah actually uh right now the
03:42:13 conservatives are leading in uh both of the northeast calgary writings uh one of those uh
03:42:19 calgary mcknight you know there was a big redraw there uh it's kind of funny because most of it's
03:42:23 former skyview yeah george george yeah so george jehal the incumbent is uh trailing that that
03:42:30 surprises me honestly yeah the conservatives are really looking around the nominations there that
03:42:36 that actually matters up in those in those writings um i uh of course i'm hoping for a
03:42:41 conservative victory there i was kind of expecting the other that you would have conservatives
03:42:45 leading in the center writings and maybe the northeast uh the opposite with the liberals
03:42:50 it uh looking looking down into calgary center for example uh there's a 300 vote margin between
03:42:56 greg mcclain to the liberal challenger in calgary confederation there's about a 500
03:43:00 vote margin you may very well see some recounts here yeah um that's a good point yeah those are
03:43:07 those margins are tight and how many 75 out of 230 polls and the conservatives are looking to
03:43:15 make major gains in edmonton uh liberal wipeout possibly there is still still still votes to come
03:43:22 in uh heather mcpherson uh leading uh the sole ndpc oh no no no yeah uh the ndp have lost edmonton
03:43:32 griesbach uh down i called that it was a very close race between carrie the odd who ran again 0.98
03:43:39 this time and uh the ndp challenger there reality reality is with the ndp dropping off
03:43:44 we were going to take that ride in interestingly interestingly enough that it's doesn't seem that
03:43:49 political because in carried out's nomination there was maybe only 400 500 total membership
03:43:53 votes cast it's uh it was a late nomination too and care karen principe uh counselor was running 0.73
03:43:59 against him but they the conservatives held that one for quite some time i'm not surprised on that
03:44:04 one like either the interesting one selfishly is coming back to edmonton center where i live
03:44:10 And it's looking like a vote split. Yeah, but the vote split is looking stronger than anywhere else in the province for Tricia Estabrook. She's probably going to be the reason that Syed Ahmed can pull it off as actually being the highest percentage we might have seen of NDP.
03:44:26 100 votes between between Syed Ahmed and uh and the Liberal challenger there like that
03:44:35 that isn't over yet that writing has flipped quite a bit because uh Anne McClelland always
03:44:39 would win that 20-30 years ago by very small moments and Laurie Hahn ran twice and took her 1.00
03:44:45 out in 2006. So I'm going to bring the conversation back to Saskatchewan for a moment here uh
03:44:50 conservatives are declared elected in all the rural ridings except for uh churchill river
03:44:58 i was gonna call that for ease uh for ease those are really cool total numbers there
03:45:04 yeah i mean this is a really low population riding uh it it's like three and a half uh
03:45:10 4 000 people voting there really low uh uh 62 of 88 percent uh is that part of the redistribution
03:45:21 has that affected it i'm not sure uh but maybe uh brad ball has something to say uh the
03:45:28 conservatives have taken all the rural ridings except for churchill river they've swept saskatoon
03:45:33 entirely and uh looking down at regina uh the two urban regina seats are yet to be called but
03:45:41 the conservatives have got a very strong lead in regina louvan and a pretty decent lead in uh
03:45:49 wascana uh maybe uh thoughts from rebel well and in the northern riding where the liberals are
03:45:55 are going to win. As I said, he was a cabinet minister with the NDP, used to be a liberal
03:46:03 MLA when he was first elected. And he's got a good, you know, he's like, and he's got
03:46:10 a history. And I know, you know, we would tell our candidates back in the day, you know,
03:46:16 we, a good, a really good local candidate might count as high. A really good one. Buckley's
03:46:23 higher than that i think plus that riding that that northern riding wouldn't be would wouldn't
03:46:29 be predisposed to voting conservative uh so it's not a surprising result up there yeah yeah the
03:46:35 provincial ndp does well up there uh you know saskatchewan jeremy harrison held that riding
03:46:41 he was part of your cabinet uh brad uh he held that riding 2004 to 2006 and then and then it
03:46:46 flipped over there was all sorts of allegations then but uh for the most part i i do think that
03:46:51 the local candidate matters in that area particularly when you see such low numbers
03:46:55 voting well well it's it's the least populated uh riding in all of canada i believe and i think it's
03:47:01 also the third largest outside of uh the northwest like the northern territories okay okay i i gotta
03:47:07 ask you guys about this weird riding i actually have not nerded out enough i guess on the
03:47:12 redistricting but this looks to be uh selkirk interlake uh eastman is that's a non-contiguous
03:47:21 contiguous constituency are they allowed to do that apparently look at that that is a non-contiguous
03:47:28 constituency that is incredibly rare I've actually have never seen that before uh Brad wall have you
03:47:34 ever seen a non-contiguous constituency I've seen some funny ones in America where they
03:47:39 really gerrymander it but I have never seen that we uh we used to joke about how it might be nice
03:47:45 have that happen if some of those want some of our small part way but no i don't think i've ever
03:47:54 seen that that is some very advanced gerrymandering there uh derek uh like that's next level but not
03:48:02 going the way of those that probably gerrymandered it well they've got a contiguous writing from
03:48:07 all right okay uh let's see uh do we have james standing by is james uh james here james james
03:48:15 james is here okay we're gonna bring james in um where uh james is coming to us from edmonton james
03:48:21 where are you in edmonton derek how's it going good uh word is namarjeet so he uh just did it
03:48:29 yeah that's uh i'm actually quite surprised obviously he's a high profile candidate uh
03:48:37 being the mayor of edmonton so a significant disappointment to him slaughtered you know
03:48:43 what's the more disappointing part is he's going back to be mayor for his last five months and i
03:48:49 gotta deal with him still so that's the more disappointing service in that public service
03:48:55 announcement yeah absolutely and you know there's uh there are other surprises too at
03:49:01 at uh edmonton greensbach there is uh edmonton center um with the former riding of randy bossano
03:49:15 no the randy split the vote there was two randy that's right good randy and bad randy yeah
03:49:22 I'm going to bow out here.
03:49:24 Thanks for having me on tonight.
03:49:25 Thanks.
03:49:27 Bye.
03:49:28 Oh, who did we just lose?
03:49:31 You got me?
03:49:33 Premier Wallsley.
03:49:34 Oh, okay.
03:49:36 Eric, go and check out Carlton.
03:49:38 I'm on Election Canada's website.
03:49:40 I know there's only 12 polls reporting, but Bruce Fangio is pulling ahead with a 1,700-vote lead.
03:49:47 Yeah, yeah, I'm looking here.
03:49:48 um and there's going to be nail biters in calgary confederation and calgary center there's uh
03:49:54 less than 200 votes either one of them that's going to pop up and down all night yeah here
03:49:59 let's look at okay calgary center uh effectively tied the liberals have the slight uh the slightest
03:50:09 of slight leads no was it 20 it was 2015 when cantera won right yeah yeah he held it for one
03:50:15 term uh during yeah that's when randy bosno run won his first go and i ran that campaign and it
03:50:21 we lost by 1200 votes so i think these are going to be those repeats jonathan that you're talking
03:50:26 about confederation very close in 2015 that can't hear one by and uh ray mclean has held very very
03:50:34 strong margins 2019 2021 again the collapse of the ndp is the biggest factor there yeah uh let's go
03:50:42 over into the ottawa area there's only one riding in the entire ottawa area not yet called the
03:50:51 leading liberal uh bruce fanjoy uh leading over pierre pauliev let me tell you east if you guys
03:51:01 don't even elect him in his constituency you're saying something take him out here
03:51:06 yeah we'll take him back he can be prime minister or something else
03:51:11 this is crazy can we just talk about how crazy these election results i feel like i've gone
03:51:18 through with so many emotions tonight i was like atlantic canada surprised us and quebec was
03:51:23 obviously like where we thought it'd be but yeah and even i think to many of the discussions that
03:51:30 we'll have this evening but like the western vote like the western alienation vote i think is
03:51:38 showing the ndp have won a single seat oh where uh uh no it says two they've elected two oh i'm
03:51:45 seeing one where are they so like we had early calls on declaration of who's gonna win and now
03:51:52 we're yeah it's pretty crazy i mean there are some crazy governing coalition scenarios that
03:51:59 take place here i think yours is not gonna happen no no i i don't think so that would kill the
03:52:04 conservative party oh it would be the end that would be the end of the conservatives the end of
03:52:09 it all yeah i don't think probably revitalization of the reform party i could see an erin o'toole
03:52:14 doing that you know this circumstance trump boogeyman national unity i could see an erin 0.99
03:52:19 o'toole trying to lead the conservatives into a national unity government uh you try and pick
03:52:25 off block people and have them we tried that in alberta 2014 how did that work out it swept even
03:52:31 me out uh yeah yeah don't don't don't do that it's not good um no erica you're working with me in the
03:52:41 building come on no no i was gone by then the conservatives have now take uh taken all the
03:52:48 seats in saskatoon all three are now all solidly conservative so there's just the two uh left in
03:52:53 in Regina that are up for grabs.
03:52:55 But both are being led by the service.
03:52:58 They're looking pretty conservative.
03:52:59 Oh, there's no way my riding's going liberal.
03:53:01 I mean, I literally saw...
03:53:02 What are you, Oskar or Lubin?
03:53:04 I'm Lubin.
03:53:05 And I've literally seen three liberal signs.
03:53:09 Three liberal signs.
03:53:09 We're both like a few kids, Jonathan and Dennis and I.
03:53:12 Three liberal signs is all I've seen in the entire election.
03:53:14 Come on, Erica, don't sell me out. 1.00
03:53:17 Now, look at these idiots. 1.00
03:53:19 Look at these idiots. 1.00
03:53:20 Toronto. 1.00
03:53:22 Toronto.
03:53:22 Why does it say the genre on the website?
03:53:24 Some conservative pickups.
03:53:26 Vaughn Woodbridge, conservative pickup.
03:53:29 Thorne Hill, conservative hold.
03:53:32 That's Melissa Lastman.
03:53:35 Conservatives leading.
03:53:37 Pretty decently-ish.
03:53:38 And Roman Babber.
03:53:41 That's an interesting guy to get in.
03:53:44 He's just an interesting guy.
03:53:47 He's an interesting guy.
03:53:48 We're competitive in that area.
03:53:51 i wasn't picking that up just looking at elections canada 164 to 146 is the seat count
03:53:57 so uh these are beating pundits they're beating the 338 website in terms of seats liberals eight
03:54:03 short of a majority the question is is what happens in pierre's riding like i'm looking
03:54:07 here at 6800 to 4900 to get here like that's the real enigma here the guy has increased their seats
03:54:13 from 129 to 146 but unfortunately maybe carlton's not one of them like that's that's bonkers that
03:54:21 His writing is actually in play.
03:54:26 Check Carney's.
03:54:27 Just for fun.
03:54:28 Okay, well, he's next door.
03:54:30 Oh, that's kind of there.
03:54:31 There's Nepean.
03:54:32 Carney got it pretty hard.
03:54:34 60, elected with 63.3%.
03:54:37 Conservative Barbara Ball at 33.7%.
03:54:41 You know, the west end of Ottawa, Nepean. 0.97
03:54:45 I've got a lot of family from that area.
03:54:48 Ottawa West, Nepean, 62%.
03:54:49 that area of ottawa didn't use john baird used to represent represent ottawa west european
03:54:54 uh in a slightly different configuration it's now a super liberal majority writing what the
03:55:01 hell happened they all worked for the government that's what happened yeah or was it the like
03:55:07 the hundreds of thousands of increase in public servants in the under the last nine years i can't
03:55:13 hurt a little bit erica on that one they they literally bought that writing by just throwing
03:55:19 out government jobs like they were candy on halloween jeremy nixon and greg mcclain both
03:55:24 pulling ahead here guys oh let's go back to alberta oh let's bring in uh peter coleman for some fun
03:55:32 here uh actually hold on uh first yeah okay peter coleman's next up that's let's throw them in the
03:55:38 mix i'm very happy with this peter spin of events yeah uh peter we are seeing an absolutely crazy
03:55:47 night here gonna come to you in a second we're just gonna talk about calgary this is the map
03:55:51 of calgary right now now it doesn't mean it's gonna stay that way but northeast uh that looks
03:55:58 to be a conservative hold i i think skyview is going conservative but that's a redistributed
03:56:03 calgary skyview that's that's essentially a new riding calgary mcknight uh still close uh 75 of
03:56:12 196 polls reported conservatives uh with about four point lead they could do it calgary center
03:56:20 uh greg mcclain incumbent conservative pulled ahead again narrow lead calgary confederation
03:56:26 jeremy nixon former alberta ucp mla uh represented part represented part of that riding but lost it
03:56:32 in the last provincial election uh very slight 0.9 lead uh so that would be a that would be a
03:56:39 calgary recounts guys i'm telling right now okay but when do we call oh no go away edmonton center
03:56:48 is back to a liberal lead uh but still less than half there's a lot of champagne socialists in
03:56:52 there so yeah uh peter uh so peter coleman is the uh president of the national citizens coalition
03:57:01 for those paying attention at home that uh that was the organization that stephen harper led during
03:57:06 his interregnum away from parliament between 97 and 2001 ish uh uh peter uh i have no idea what
03:57:14 to make of tonight uh your thoughts a crazy night i mean at uh atlantic county it went well we're
03:57:21 not really sure i mean um like mixing uh pretty expensive for the country when he stayed to get
03:57:28 his pension and uh the party the bed for lack of better terms i mean uh like i think paulia's
03:57:34 percentage of votes the highest for conservatives since uh brian moroni you know uh yeah he might
03:57:42 uh where are we at with popular where's popular vote right popular vote 42 so he's beat stephen
03:57:48 harper he has beats like it has been a insanely long time in canada where a party has won 40
03:57:55 of the voter more and not won a majority government that just doesn't happen anymore so okay just to
03:58:00 that point, Derek, Stephen Hartford did win 5,600,000 votes in 2015. It was Andrew Scheer who
03:58:09 took him over 6 million in 2019. But lower percentage of the vote.
03:58:15 And then Aaron O'Toole lost a half a million votes. So it's going to be interesting to see
03:58:22 where the Conservatives end up this evening against those competitors. But for what you're saying,
03:58:30 And it would be the ultimate irony for Pierre Polyev to lift the party back up, lose his own seat, and see another conservative, another liberal minority.
03:58:41 Peter, let's talk about Pierre Polyev tonight.
03:58:45 It's not a given he's going to lose his seat, but it does seem to be in the cards.
03:58:49 Oh, we've got Mike Silber.
03:58:51 That's not Mike Silber.
03:58:51 That's still just James.
03:58:52 Okay.
03:58:53 Sorry.
03:58:53 You look like Mike.
03:58:54 Does he look like Mike Silber a bit there?
03:58:56 I honestly thought that for a second.
03:58:57 Mike doesn't dress that well
03:59:00 No, and Mike doesn't comb his hair
03:59:03 But he is going to be on the program
03:59:05 So I thought that was it
03:59:06 Peter
03:59:07 Alright, well, it's a bit of a hypothetical
03:59:11 Here, if Polyev 0.95
03:59:13 Loses his seat
03:59:14 Does he stay on as leader, do you think?
03:59:18 Yeah
03:59:18 That would be crazy if he loses his seat
03:59:21 With all that's going on, because I know the people
03:59:23 At West are always frustrated with what happened
03:59:24 In and around Toronto, but
03:59:26 But, you know, downtown Toronto is not going to vote any other than a liberal NDP.
03:59:29 But there's a bunch of ridings in and around Toronto that went conservative this time.
03:59:34 And their share of the vote is much higher percentage-wise than it has been in a long time.
03:59:37 So it'll be fascinating to see what happens because if he loses his seat, then I think that's trouble for him for sure.
03:59:43 But, I mean, you know, I don't think anybody would have predicted the NDP would have fallen this far if he'd asked me a couple months ago.
03:59:51 You knew they were going to be, you know, they were broke, so they couldn't call a campaign.
03:59:55 but it's going to be really interesting too because the conservatives try and work with
04:00:00 the bloc and some things too that carney has not got carte blanche to um to do what he wants and
04:00:05 behave what he wants and you know i've been on your show your show your folk shows a few times
04:00:10 i don't think carney's the brilliant economist that people think he is i don't think his record's
04:00:15 all that great i think his hold is going to be tenuous in power i mean you know they're trying
04:00:20 to the media's trying to say there's a big sweeping victory for the liberals it's not really
04:00:25 it's not really it's it's disappointing if you're a conservative for sure but um
04:00:30 a liberal majority government would have been absolute unmitigated disaster so um jade meet
04:00:37 singh still trailing very badly in his writing in a definite third place uh he deserves to lose badly
04:00:46 Sorry, what?
04:00:48 He deserves to lose badly.
04:00:50 Yeah.
04:00:52 Oh, there we go.
04:00:54 Yeah, I mean, still
04:00:56 35 of 200 polls there.
04:00:58 Maybe he pulls something out of the hat,
04:01:00 but that's a big, big gap
04:01:02 to close.
04:01:03 He's toast. Elizabeth May,
04:01:06 I actually thought
04:01:08 that writing could go elsewhere.
04:01:11 Liberals are non-
04:01:12 NDP are non-existent, 3.8%.
04:01:14 Right.
04:01:14 uh it's the drop off of the ndp look at pierre's writing one and a half percent one and a half
04:01:21 wow like wow i don't know if i've ever seen bottom of the barrel of support like that for the ndp
04:01:27 ever no no uh look in here yeah uh yeah they're they're barely double the green party in that
04:01:34 riding um then there's a million independents there was some kind of uh 95 or something
04:01:39 candidates yeah there's uh that was some it's like a protest against the first past post system or
04:01:44 something uh yeah the ballot was four pages long yeah but they didn't do it against mark carney
04:01:50 in nepean where there are one two three four or five candidates no independence at all they
04:01:57 they seem to be very selective about who they do this with uh guys i've i've just been called by
04:02:01 uh a uh a candidate's uh official agent uh in a very close riding here i've got a i've got to
04:02:07 sign off here thanks very much for the opportunity and uh i'm looking forward to some interesting
04:02:13 times thank you for joining us that's uh donathan dennis uh lawyer here in calgary and former uh
04:02:19 pc cabinet minister and minister of justice all the best guys thank you all right um
04:02:29 all right uh how many do we know how many the uh ndp are elected in uh okay ndp are elected in two
04:02:35 seats leading and elected in eight so their ceiling right now is probably around eight seats
04:02:46 yeah that's best case scenario that's the best case scenario like we're talking best case here
04:02:51 is eight yeah yeah hey uh sean do you want to pull up the math find out the last time
04:02:57 the ndp have had eight seats or less please okay uh you just find it let me know when you've got
04:03:02 that yeah um but if you had eight seats in say 1993 that's more like having uh 10 or 11 today
04:03:09 because it was a small parliament so your proportion of parliament with eight seats you
04:03:14 know 20 40 years ago is more uh i mean we even have five more from lasco yeah yeah uh do we
04:03:21 remember anyone recall like how many seats the ndp get in 1993 because they got pretty wiped
04:03:26 I think 1993 was the previous low point of the NDP, and then they kind of slowly crawled back up.
04:03:42 But then they had their long march that began under Jack Layton, pulling them up into political relevance all the way to a huge official opposition.
04:03:49 pretty big bump in the road with Thomas Mulcair
04:03:54 but then wow they really
04:03:56 were lucky with Thomas Mulcair
04:03:58 they didn't know
04:04:01 how good they had it
04:04:01 yeah their record
04:04:04 was nine in 1993
04:04:06 nine in 1993
04:04:08 nine in 1993
04:04:10 okay so that was a
04:04:12 smaller parliament
04:04:13 so nine then is more
04:04:16 an equivalent of nine out of 295
04:04:18 under Audrey McLaughlin.
04:04:21 Okay, so if you want
04:04:23 to also just maybe do the math
04:04:24 on that, and then let's keep going
04:04:26 further back. We may have to go back to the
04:04:28 CCF. I'm not positive. We may
04:04:30 have to go back to the CCF.
04:04:32 How many seats are there? 299?
04:04:35 CCF, 19, 265.
04:04:37 17, 265.
04:04:39 21, 265. This is
04:04:40 Tommy Douglas. Are we going to have to go back
04:04:42 to the Socialist Labor Party?
04:04:44 31, 264.
04:04:46 16, 264, David Lewis.
04:04:49 that broadband never had lower than 226 out of 282 audrey mclaughlin 9 295 so alexa mcdonough
04:04:58 21 301 13 301 that might be close alexa mcdonough in 2000 okay so please go back in history you may
04:05:06 have to go into the ccf canadian commonwealth federation predating the ndp as a predecessor
04:05:10 party let's go back uh once the last time they had eight seats and then calculate as percentage
04:05:16 uh and that i'm doing like long division here yeah and we're at about 10 c long division required
04:05:22 the lowest seat camp the ccf ever had was 1958 and they had eight seats out of a much much smaller
04:05:30 much much smaller yeah 1958 things tonight is likely to go down as the least successful
04:05:39 socialist leader in the country's history yeah well they did it sounds like they did
04:05:45 he's going worse than trudeau did yeah i guess he could have been the leader of the opposition
04:05:54 right now wouldn't be the first time they're getting allied too closely with justin trudeau
04:05:58 is bad for your political career normally that's a woman but yeah it's bad for most people after 1.00
04:06:06 the 1958 election oh all right so give us your number here and then we're going to bring in
04:06:11 shay anderson in a moment okay after the 1958 election they got eight seats they picked up one
04:06:15 in a by-election sorry eight seats in 1958 right and then they won a by-election in 1960 to give
04:06:22 it nine but they changed the party they changed it to the new party but there there's one big
04:06:29 thing tonight though it's it's the doubles and ndp aren't 172 the conservators and block have more
04:06:34 it's gonna be a fast right yeah so it's not necessarily a given i mean it'd be a weird
04:06:38 We should bring in Shea because as much as we as conservatives might be upset by the loss, his party is decimated.
04:06:45 Okay, let's bring in Shea. Make Shea a big head. We'll be small heads. Make Shea a big head because he's got a big beard.
04:06:54 I've always been jealous of the size of Shea's beard.
04:06:59 You're working on it.
04:07:00 Yeah. Shea was elected as NDP member of the Alberta legislature in 2015, the time I came in, and he worked his way on up to become minister. He might be a New Democrat, but he's among the least crazy ones I know. You can at least understand what he's saying. And I always got along with him. Thanks so much for joining us, Shea.
04:07:24 Derek
04:07:26 Never mind
04:07:32 it looks like Karl Marx with
04:07:34 a shaved head
04:07:35 Thanks for having me
04:07:45 Can you hear me?
04:07:46 Yeah we hear you just fine
04:07:47 You didn't need to make it a big head
04:07:50 My head's big enough
04:07:51 Alright
04:07:53 All right. Shay, you're a long-time new Democrat. Tonight, it might not be a great night for
04:08:02 the conservatives, but it is a devastating night for the NDP.
04:08:11 It would appear that the high watermark, based on the results we're seeing right now,
04:08:18 the best case scenario for the NDP is probably eight seats and uh we're trying to run the math
04:08:24 on here and that is that would probably be the worst record result for the NDP uh slash Canadian
04:08:31 Commonwealth Federation since possibly the second world war maybe even earlier um I don't know uh
04:08:39 how does that make you feel how does that make you how do you feel about that
04:08:43 oh we can't we can't hear you anymore okay no oh there we are i'm getting like double
04:08:52 i'm getting a repeat of your you talking so it's kind of hard to
04:08:56 pick it up here just a second okay
04:08:59 well i mean obviously it's not great geez i mean that's that's another statement oh
04:09:09 uh where did the party go wrong or or singh uh i mean uh if if singh had you know he said he's
04:09:19 ripping up the agreement with justin trudeau but then didn't move did we just lose uh shay yeah
04:09:23 we just lost him yeah no he just got it he just got it okay let's bring it back in in a moment
04:09:30 um okay so that one elected seat is in uh edmonton strathconer yeah that's yeah oh is that
04:09:39 declared elected now that's declared elected yes okay uh which was i think a given yeah i mean
04:09:45 that's i mean that was rachel notley's seat like it let's try yes they will vote for carl
04:09:50 and heather has been there forever she's been there a long time yeah uh stalin could win that
04:09:55 riding uh perhaps good liberal edmonton center edmonton center uh it's not called though yet
04:10:03 not called uh a little fair bit to go could go okay we've got shay anderson back hey sorry i had
04:10:08 uh i had another tab open so i was hearing double it was my fault okay i hear double all the time
04:10:13 it's okay um all right so the the ap uh its best case scenario based on the numbers we're seeing
04:10:20 right now is eight seats probably going to be lower uh we've got sean running some numbers here
04:10:25 we're going to get a better sense soon but that if so that would be the worst result for the ndp or
04:10:32 its predecessor the canadian commonwealth federation since the second world war
04:10:37 maybe going back even earlier getting close to the first world war this wasn't around i mean like i
04:10:43 don't know how does that make you feel like uh what are your thoughts like where did it go wrong
04:10:49 yeah well i mean obviously it's not great it's not what anybody wants ever um you know
04:10:56 it's it's when you look at it and you look at the polling beforehand you look at some of the
04:11:02 things were going on with center let's say center-left voters and and what their thoughts
04:11:07 on poly of were you understood we were going to lose some seats because you know people believe
04:11:13 in strategic voting and so you saw a lot of that out east and say um right around edmonton maybe
04:11:19 where we thought we might have like Blake's seat, which is unfortunate.
04:11:22 I think he's a good MP.
04:11:25 But I think we lost a lot of that vote to the Liberals, unfortunately.
04:11:31 People were worried.
04:11:32 You look at some people down here on the south of the island right now,
04:11:36 and we got a couple of Liberals I think they're going to be winning seats,
04:11:39 which is, I think it's been 17 years since the Liberals won a seat on the island.
04:11:44 We're usually staunchly NDP.
04:11:47 And so, yeah, it's not great.
04:11:49 uh i think you know people count us out all the time they've counted us out over the years you
04:11:54 guys were crunching the numbers there and seeing what was going on um in the past and how we've
04:11:59 come back and gone up and down and i think that we'll come back from it uh we have to we we don't
04:12:05 give up we're stubborn you know what i'm like eric so uh you know most of us staunch ndpers
04:12:11 are pretty stubborn that way and but it is hard to take obviously i mean who who wants to lose
04:12:16 seats and especially there's some good mps of lawsuits regardless of your political affiliation
04:12:20 there's going to be good people that are losing seats that bring a good strong voice to the
04:12:25 legislature to the parliament sorry and so yeah it's it's it's not great however i slice it so
04:12:30 so where do you think the ndp went wrong here um i mean if if sing uh so before we got cut off i was
04:12:38 uh i was saying you know if back in the fall around october saying said i'm ripping up the
04:12:44 deal it's over but that didn't seem to do to change anything continued to vote confidence in
04:12:50 the liberal government if he had voted to bring down trudeau at that time uh he would have stood
04:12:56 at a very good chance of becoming the leader of the opposition at least uh and then now he is on
04:13:04 track to come in third place in his own seat uh and bring the ndp down to its worst result by far
04:13:10 the party's history including its predecessor parties uh from before um is it is this all on
04:13:18 is this mostly on singh uh well you know who should wear the blame tomorrow morning in the
04:13:24 ndp i mean what's happened like like obviously i'm not going to talk on behalf of the part of
04:13:29 the federal party or our provincial counterparts but you you make a good point like in the fall
04:13:34 when the agreement was there and and he had said about um possibly ripping it up and then and you
04:13:41 know you see what he said in the campaign the reason why he didn't is because the fears were
04:13:46 that pauliav was going to get rid of pharmacare and dental care which has helped millions of
04:13:50 people across canada and traditionally the ndp is the one like i was listening earlier and you guys
04:13:55 were talking about or somebody was talking about about the social voice and they have traditionally
04:13:59 been the voice of working people and the social voice um and he didn't want those programs to go
04:14:05 away because people like like us that you know for example out of benefits and can afford benefits
04:14:10 and things like that we we don't notice these things but people that don't have benefits uh
04:14:15 value those types of things that the ndp fights for on a day-to-day basis in a in a big way and so
04:14:21 he didn't want to he didn't want to lose that but your point is is valid as well and i think that
04:14:27 you're not wrong that in the fall if he had to rip that up and they pulled you know they pulled the
04:14:31 rug out and there was a vote i think paulia probably would have had a majority and i think
04:14:37 the ndp probably would have had more seats by doing what he did and maybe some people not
04:14:42 understanding it in the party maybe they pulled their vote to the liberals as well you know what
04:14:47 i mean like hard to say but i think probably that's probably part of the case okay we're
04:14:52 gonna go to nigel just a moment i just want to check with production are we standing by to bring
04:14:56 on Pierre Polyev, Mark Carney, and Jagmeet Singh when they take the stage?
04:15:02 We're set up for that? Okay, when they come, make sure you interrupt me.
04:15:06 It's going to be a while. Yeah, Shay, we haven't met, but anyway, hi.
04:15:12 The expectation is that the NDP will not do well on Vancouver Island.
04:15:16 now to what extent is david eby responsible for the fortunes of the ndp in british columbia
04:15:27 generally rather than jagmeet singh well that's a tough question i mean i think that
04:15:34 you know the the provincial ndb ndp did very well here um we have had a lot of change in population
04:15:41 people come from different provinces and things like that over the last few years so
04:15:45 i think that's partly to play with it when i moved home five years ago to duncan i was working up
04:15:50 island and there was a lot of mainlanders a lot of people from alberta uh northern bc that were
04:15:55 probably traditionally conservative so i think part of the vote has changed as well we've been
04:16:01 pretty staunchly ndp for a long time for the most part um but it's getting a little more more diverse
04:16:06 now so i i don't think there's i don't think you can say oh it's david evey to blame or it's
04:16:13 Jagmeet Singh to blame I think that um I think things have changed and I think that in my my
04:16:19 opinion but this is just me and Derek and I have talked about these things before is is you know
04:16:24 sometimes for example the conservatives I find take uh the voters for granted in Alberta because
04:16:31 they mostly just vote blue well the NDP has done that sometimes with working people as well
04:16:35 and union workers uh and taking that for granted and i guess not spoken to them and and you know
04:16:43 laid their fears and laid out um a plan you know a logical plan for them sometimes and i think
04:16:49 maybe that's part of it as well because i have union workers here that i know that were voting
04:16:54 conservative and that used to be unheard of right like yeah well uh like i i've got a i got a buddy
04:17:03 who is a union leader and he's voting conservative uh he voted conservative uh because he hunts uh
04:17:10 he works with his hands and you know all parties are are coalitions and you have to stitch them
04:17:16 together but now you come from the more union labor background uh wing of the NDP there are
04:17:24 other wings there's kind of the environmentalist uh kind of hardcore environmentalist wing and then
04:17:31 there's, you know, kind of the downtown, you have to forgive my probably pejorative terms,
04:17:36 I don't know how else to describe it, kind of the woke, urban, yuppie. And that seems to have
04:17:43 captured kind of progressivist parties across the West, but the NDP has not been immune from that.
04:17:50 The NDP, you know, it's still got that union wing, but at least to me, it seems to have become
04:17:57 overshadowed by uh you know the environmentalist wing uh the kind of social uh social progressivist
04:18:08 wing that kind of thing um i don't know do you how would you respond to that analysis no no i i
04:18:15 yeah i totally understand what you're saying and i could i could understand why it looks like that
04:18:19 obviously and and you know it's part of what i was saying is i think that the ndp has a lot of value
04:18:25 for working people and union people but we have to make sure that we lay that plan out there a
04:18:30 little more coherently to be honest i think that sometimes we just even we did this when we were
04:18:35 in government we were doing a lot of good things we thought and we're working hard and we had some
04:18:39 good things for working people but you sometimes think oh we're doing all these things so they must
04:18:44 realize it or they must read it or they they see what we're doing well everybody's busy they have
04:18:49 families they're they're paying their mortgage and their bills and and and they don't have time for
04:18:53 that so you have to keep things pretty simple uh and straight to the point and that's where
04:18:57 conservatives actually do a very good job of of you know you can make fun of slogans and all these
04:19:02 things and acts attacks and whatever but people hear it and they remember it right and so i think 0.78
04:19:06 that we need to do a better job of um outlining what we're doing for people and how it actually
04:19:11 affects everybody on a day-to-day basis because like really when it comes down to it i think
04:19:16 you know you you're looking at what's going to be better for you and your family and how you
04:19:21 uh take care of your of your kids and and the people around you right and so you know if somebody's
04:19:27 speaking to you and empathizing with you and showing you a way even if you're not sure if
04:19:32 it's actually going to happen or it's just a promise that you don't think is going to get there
04:19:37 you know it it speaks to you sometimes right and so i think we need to do as ndp is a lot better
04:19:42 job of that i we have some very good leaders and some very good speakers and i think that people
04:19:47 can do that um you know but i think we just need to do more of it okay um i want to talk about uh
04:19:55 pauliev and singh right now so we're i'm going to bring in peter coleman as well uh we're going to
04:20:00 start with singh so we'll just we'll stay with shay for a second uh jb singh it's not called
04:20:07 yet it's only 55 of 200 polls in but he seems to be dropping further and further behind 19.4
04:20:14 percent trailing both the conservative and the liberal in that constituency. I would imagine,
04:20:22 even if he were to miraculously come back and win that riding, I think the only reason it's not
04:20:28 been called is because it's between the conservatives and the liberals. I think
04:20:30 Jagmeet Singh's out of the race at this point. But even if he were to win his seat,
04:20:34 do you think he's toast his leader tonight? You know, like I've heard a bunch of people
04:20:40 asked me that before this um and it's not really my place to say yes or no i mean it's up to him
04:20:46 i'm asking for your opinion yeah there's different ways there's different ways to go about this and
04:20:53 the way the way i look at it is um there's something he said the other day and i heard
04:20:57 one of our another ndp talk about too about um about he was talking about some of the things
04:21:05 we were working on and he was okay with losing some seats or power i'm just paraphrasing here
04:21:12 um if there was going to be good things and good wins for canadians right and
04:21:17 and so i look at it that way and he is principled and he stood by that and i appreciate that and
04:21:24 he's done some really good things as party leader um now the membership is going to make this
04:21:30 decision i'm not going to do it on here and i'm not going to speculate because i don't like to do
04:21:34 that um but yeah they're gonna have to you know we as a party and and and jug meat are gonna have to
04:21:41 have a long look and at the results and and obviously go over them and and see where we
04:21:46 went wrong and figure that out and it's i mean it's a tough it's gonna be a tough conversation
04:21:51 no matter which way you slice it so i uh i don't know uh erica i even if you want to see and i
04:21:58 don't think he's winning a seat i think he's he's on track for third even if you want to see i think
04:22:03 he's toast. He has led the NDP
04:22:04 to the worst result
04:22:06 in its history.
04:22:08 And even the CCF's history.
04:22:11 We've probably got to go back to
04:22:12 possibly between the First and Second World Wars
04:22:14 to find... 1932.
04:22:17 Okay.
04:22:18 Let's go to welfare
04:22:20 wolf here for a second.
04:22:23 Is our wolf
04:22:24 blitzer on a budget?
04:22:26 Welfare wolf.
04:22:29 Okay.
04:22:30 Alright. So when is the last
04:22:32 comparable election for the ndp or its predecessors well the party was founded in 1932 we're talking
04:22:38 the ccf yeah ccf and uh even back then it looks like they had about a dozen you have to go back
04:22:43 to 1958 58 yeah so yeah i mean that's okay no 58 they won how many seats eight seats eight seats
04:22:51 okay and that's one ccf won a seat in 1960 to give it nine yeah okay but hold on which would
04:22:58 surpassed what they're on track for tonight eight seats is their best case scenario tonight it would
04:23:04 it would seem uh so even if they won eight as i'm saying earlier that's out of a much smaller
04:23:09 parliament 299 right yeah yeah so not even so that is proportionately a lot less that's a lot more
04:23:17 higher so it's proportionately yeah it's proportionally higher so and in 1962 they
04:23:21 became the ndp okay so i want you to keep going back through history because eight seats out of
04:23:26 a small parliament i want you to try and find it where it's proportionate as a percentage of
04:23:30 seats in parliament oh my god you're gonna ask me to do some math yeah okay we're gonna come
04:23:34 back in a moment i'm gonna let keep scrolling keep scrolling and uh get us an answer here
04:23:40 oh we're trying to manifesto 1933. yeah uh yeah i we're gonna so now can we come back to another
04:23:46 hypothetical that i just had in a texting conversation was the advanced polls so those
04:23:52 haven't been counted no don't they well you're likely not yet not yet they're usually among
04:23:59 the last to come in yeah so like and this is so pierre apparently is like 43 000 in his writing
04:24:05 uh yeah okay yeah so so let's if we're looking at the numbers like i mean in alberta i don't know
04:24:10 what they are everywhere about 110 000 votes per eda in alberta give or take 100 to 110 000. so
04:24:21 So right now in his running of Carleton, Polyev is trailing about six points, but only 64 of 266
04:24:30 polls reporting at this time. Yeah. And it apparently- Let's say you got 20,000 votes.
04:24:36 Well, there's a long way to go. Yeah. And it had a record for all of Canadian history for
04:24:43 advanced voter turnout. Yeah. Now that could be- So advanced also counts for special ballot,
04:24:49 all of that we last election in edmonton center had to go two days after two or three days after
04:24:55 to count all those and that confirmed randy now like advancements typically actually do favor the
04:25:02 liberals over conservatives however there's also a significant what did we say seven million and a
04:25:09 half million compared to a million and a half that is a huge increase also remember like 40
04:25:15 it's a total vote. I remember last time it favored leftist parties because leftist progressivist
04:25:21 party voters tended to be more worried about COVID. You know, you want to vote in the mail,
04:25:27 all those things. They were more worried about it than conservative-leaning voters.
04:25:31 Same with the United States for the 2020 presidential election favored Biden.
04:25:37 So that's why I think it's so interesting that a lot of these places are being called early.
04:25:41 like some of them i think are early without this caveat but now we're looking at even early with
04:25:48 a bunch of advanced special ballots all of that being uh oh you mean so the advanced ballots are
04:25:55 basically i'm saying that i think a lot of this is bs across the country there were seven and a
04:26:00 half million a bunch of ndp votes in the early ballots but there could be a bunch of conservative
04:26:05 round level votes change so in 1958 we're gonna get you want me to get up here get wolf okay now
04:26:17 now i got my uh oh and uh stephen gilbeau and sean frazier have both been re-elected sean frazier
04:26:24 too yeah okay well that's i'll tell you what carney's going to be doing uh in terms of
04:26:29 environment um okay so doing my scrolling uh 1958 uh ccf uh which was founded at the
04:26:42 oh i can't get it it's on two separate pages okay um because the ndp started in 1962 but they got
04:26:47 three percent of the seats and then um today they're on track for about two percent so they've
04:26:53 lost about a third relatively speaking compared to what year uh 1958. okay so but they went down
04:27:00 a percentage yeah so they're down so i want you to keep going backwards until you find
04:27:05 a worse result than the ndp is like beating a dead horse i want to know
04:27:10 you know this is something you talk about a week after the election i don't know it's a it's a
04:27:15 wipeout we're going back to probably conservatives really and what was it 1988. 1993 is when they
04:27:23 got two seats. Under Kim Campbell.
04:27:25 Yeah. I mean, that would probably
04:27:27 go down in history as the worst electoral
04:27:28 Well, that was the worst electoral defeat
04:27:31 for a governing party in the
04:27:33 history of the world. Well, it's
04:27:35 got to be one of the worst in Canadian
04:27:36 history for any party.
04:27:38 It was the worst in world democratic history
04:27:40 in 1993 for the PCs.
04:27:42 Yeah.
04:27:44 Alright, Shay, I'm going to operate on the assumption that
04:27:47 tomorrow morning,
04:27:48 Jay Meatsingh has resigned
04:27:50 or announced his intention to be gone.
04:27:53 ago from Toronto Star. What? Uncertainty and questions ahead for Jagmeet Singh.
04:27:58 Oh, yeah, that's been his whole election. I haven't subscribed, unfortunately.
04:28:01 All right, so I'm going to go to the paywall. He'll be the first to do it.
04:28:04 I want to go to Shay here. Shay, I'm going to operate on the assumption Jagmeet Singh is not
04:28:09 going to be here, so let's operate in this hypothetical. What's next for the NDP? They're
04:28:15 They're looking at between, I don't know, four and eight seats right now.
04:28:21 They're going to lose official party status under any of these circumstances.
04:28:27 The long march began under Jack Layden has finally come to an end, it seems.
04:28:35 What's next for the NDP?
04:28:36 What does it need to do to get back in the game?
04:28:40 Yeah, I mean, I don't think it's come to an end.
04:28:42 Like I said, we've gone up and down before.
04:28:44 I didn't say the party's come to an end.
04:28:45 And I'm saying the long march began under Jack Layton.
04:28:47 Yeah, so, yeah, you know, it's going to be a hard look in the mirror, to be honest,
04:28:53 like to say, like, where did we go wrong?
04:28:55 Where did we slip up?
04:28:56 Where did our messaging not resonate with people?
04:29:00 Like I said before, like we traditionally have been, you know,
04:29:03 a party of working people, union workers and things like that,
04:29:07 and social workers, teachers, and health care.
04:29:10 And we've done some really good things there,
04:29:12 and we've pushed the Liberals to do some really good things that help people.
04:29:15 um that even a lot of conservatives agreed with which was great but yeah we got to figure this
04:29:20 out we got to sit down and um we got to dissect what happened here and see if our like where our
04:29:28 messaging didn't honestly where it didn't resonate like it's i think it comes down to that and um
04:29:33 what we thought were the priorities and going in and and what ended up being the priorities i mean
04:29:39 affordability kind of is over everything right and and housing and and all these types of things and
04:29:45 how how didn't we frame things properly i think um yeah i don't i don't have the answers to be
04:29:53 honest i i mean i've been talking with people about it and and trying to figure it out and and i
04:29:58 i just think there's some good things there and we have some really good people in the party but
04:30:02 um maybe maybe some of the inner circle we all need to take a look at
04:30:06 that and everybody take a look at themselves and just be straight up and honest right like
04:30:12 you know we can't obviously it didn't work so we have to sit down and and be honest with ourselves
04:30:18 and be truthful and it's gonna hurt it's gonna really hurt but yeah you don't get better if you
04:30:23 don't if you're not truthful with yourself right like we didn't do well in this election we got
04:30:29 beat very bad you can't you get you know you can't say that we didn't and so did we do some
04:30:36 great things? Sure. Awesome. But now we're missing a lot of really good MPs in the house and
04:30:41 we got to fix that quick. Yeah. Shay, I want to pick your brain 0.97
04:30:45 about like what that means for the federal party versus all of the provincial counterparts. I mean,
04:30:51 you were part of a pretty, probably the most centrist of all NDP parties. Like what does
04:30:58 this mean? I mean, even Alberta, the NDP are talking about the federal relationship on May
04:31:03 first i think what does this look like from ndp across the board and do you think some of those
04:31:09 provincial um that have been successful ndp parties um do they distance themselves now too
04:31:17 or is there a big kumbaya moment that's coming that we just don't know about
04:31:22 um i don't think i don't think either one of those i don't think there's a kumbaya moment i
04:31:27 really don't uh i don't think we should just throw the baby out with the bath water on this one either
04:31:32 but i do think that we have to look at the successes of different provincial parties
04:31:39 like manitoba and wav canoe right like what they did there and how well they're doing and
04:31:44 how well people are taking what they're implementing um you know you look at doug
04:31:48 ford for the conservatives he's when he first got in i didn't give him a chance and quite honestly
04:31:56 he's done some pretty good things over the last couple of years and that's why we don't like him
04:32:00 yeah no but he's learned but he's learned he's yeah he's a little different than right than
04:32:08 paulia is and and we can have those debates on the levels of of conservatism and nd peers and
04:32:13 all that kind of stuff but like he he learned in his province what he needed to do to be successful
04:32:20 and and he's done a pretty good job of it and so for us as any peers i think our federal party
04:32:26 and and the provincial and territorial parties need to really look at each other and go okay
04:32:30 what works and what doesn't like don't just throw it all out because there's obviously things that
04:32:34 do work and that don't but it's it's going to be tough like honestly it's going to be really rough
04:32:39 after this and um i mean i'm looking forward to it because i think i've always been honest about
04:32:46 that derek and i've had many conversations about what we did in alberta that worked and didn't
04:32:50 you know you have to do that or else you're never gonna come on the other team and both of you at
04:32:56 that time yeah and it didn't involve it for me either um all right i want to bring uh peter uh
04:33:05 peter coleman uh president of the national citizens coalition into this conversation
04:33:08 um uh shay just mentioned a name that i have a feeling we're going to hear more of
04:33:14 Wob Canoe. He's a likable guy. And he's gotten over some history that most politicians can't.
04:33:23 You know, he's he's had some stuff. And but he's a likable guy. He comes across as genuine.
04:33:30 You know, he's yeah, I'm probably not the target voter for for him. But, you know, that
04:33:36 but geez, does he want to take that on at this point? Like he's he's a pretty successful now,
04:33:42 i think two-term premier of uh of manitoba i think he's just one just one just oh yeah yeah
04:33:49 oh sorry yeah yeah but uh people like him uh i you know i i talk to uh like liberal strategist
04:33:58 campaigners they really like the guy uh that they thought maybe he would be a good liberal
04:34:04 federal leader um but yeah you know i can actually i think she makes a point uh peter that
04:34:11 But he's kind of a Doug Ford of the left. He's a little less hardcore. He's not a little less ideological. He's still on the left. He's probably more of a new Democrat than Doug Ford as a conservative. But he's got that people's touch. People like him as a kind of normal guy.
04:34:30 But is this the guy we're going to see replace Jagmeet Singh?
04:34:35 Or who do you think would be the most likely candidate?
04:34:40 Maybe Rachel Notley.
04:34:42 I think he – no, heaven forbid her.
04:34:44 I think he's a very likable guy.
04:34:47 I think he presents well.
04:34:49 And, you know, when you're in politics long enough,
04:34:51 you realize you just want good, competent people running.
04:34:54 I mean, you want them to be there and be empowered.
04:34:57 I think Singh's done like dinner.
04:34:59 I mean, I think that he should have called when he didn't.
04:35:03 Everybody that has gotten too close to Trudeau, too close to the fire, has been burned.
04:35:09 All those cabin ministers and doing what he wanted to do got too close.
04:35:15 And his dislike of Paulie have cost the party because they would have had a lot more seats.
04:35:20 And I do know if I'm spending a lot of time with Harper over the years,
04:35:24 he always would rather work with the NDP than the Liberals.
04:35:27 He had no problem.
04:35:28 And he and Leighton were pretty good friends and could do some things together.
04:35:31 And you wish you had that back because, you know, we all know that all the liberals care about getting elected.
04:35:40 You know, they don't care about anything else.
04:35:41 And I think that the NDP have an opportunity to just look and do some soul searching and say, we've got to raise a lot of money now.
04:35:48 How are we going to do that? We don't have official party status.
04:35:51 Where are we going to go?
04:35:52 And I don't think the party can bring back seeing again because I think there's too many skeletons in the closet for him.
04:35:59 So the Premier of Manitoba would be somebody that he may not want that.
04:36:04 I mean, he'd say, I'm going to sit this out for a bit because you have to believe there's going to be an election within two years because they can't get to 172, the Liberals and NDP.
04:36:13 And there's no way Carney can behave like Trudeau did and just ignore the Conservatives or the Bloc anymore.
04:36:19 so that dynamic in house of commons is going to be fascinating uh do we still have chris old corn
04:36:25 old corn still there we're not sure um no no okay i wanted to touch on manitoba
04:36:34 let's touch on manitoba really quickly uh hey shay i just i just got to point this out to you
04:36:40 i didn't geek out on the um oh all right well we're gonna oh yeah we're gonna bring that in a
04:36:46 moment here um you gotta look at this on the map here i'm gonna bring up my fun map here again
04:36:51 i did not notice this oh uh where's my map why is my map not showing put my map in
04:37:01 i want map okay well that's happening okay okay anyway there's a seizure here okay uh well let's
04:37:10 bring in uh oh here we are okay uh we'll talk manitoba really quickly and i'm gonna bring in
04:37:15 ted morton look at this a non-contiguous constituency in manitoba towards the north
04:37:21 selkirk interlake eastman has this little gerrymandered piece of jigsaw you ever seen
04:37:28 anything like that jay no i saw that earlier when you brought it up and i i saw that i was like
04:37:33 what i didn't i never noticed that before i don't think i've i don't think i've ever seen
04:37:37 national park or reserve or something it must be must be but like why not connect it why not
04:37:44 connected yeah i've never seen that before even with the american ones where there's so many weird
04:37:49 ones oh yeah you can want to just go down the highway linking yeah uh this neighborhood with
04:37:54 that neighborhood to you know make strong red or blue pull uh i've never seen it where it's
04:37:58 non-contiguous that is that's a good point that erica makes a good point though that i it's got
04:38:04 to be something weird like like a park or something but even if it was a park wouldn't it
04:38:09 just be joined up but it maybe it's just like or a big gap of yeah like a reserve because you get
04:38:14 new settlements on claims and then they'll give individual land outside of there and they're not
04:38:18 going to split a reserve on two different ridings so they would jump in yeah yeah it's got to be
04:38:24 something weird like that that could be that could be very well okay uh okay so before uh we're gonna
04:38:29 bring in ted morton in a minute but before i let you go uh i don't know uh kind of you're just your
04:38:34 high-level thoughts for tonight um you say the ndp has got to do a big rethink uh maybe let me just
04:38:42 put it this way do you think new democrats broadly jake meet singh in particular regrets
04:38:50 not working down the government the fall
04:38:54 no i don't think so because of what i pointed out before about the pharma care and dental care
04:38:59 i think the biggest worry was that those programs that we were trying to get pushed through
04:39:04 in that minority government we're not going to be going through to help people and for us as
04:39:09 new democrats um that's a big deal right we don't do this we talked you know as mentioned a couple
04:39:16 minutes ago we don't do this for power we don't do this for getting our name in the in the media
04:39:20 or anything like that it's it's to help people right and if you're not gonna if you're not gonna
04:39:24 help people what are you here for so i don't think we're gonna um we're gonna regret it in that
04:39:31 sense um more just the sense of like maybe communicating things a little bit better but uh
04:39:37 no man good things got done and and i'll always appreciate that part and
04:39:41 now i'm gonna do some soul searching and move forward so all right that's shay anderson former
04:39:47 uh alberta ndp captain minister and uh carl mark's beard affectionato thanks for having me guys i
04:39:54 appreciate it you guys have a good night all right all right thank you shay yeah be well
04:39:58 All right. And maybe just a last word to you, Peter, we're going to bring in more Ted Martin in a moment.
04:40:05 But your your thoughts on just where it's looking tonight with a liberal minority government.
04:40:12 I don't think they have the mandate they think they have.
04:40:15 And I think it's going to be a much more interesting part of it because it's going to have to be a lot more give and take.
04:40:19 And the NDP aren't going to have the balance of power.
04:40:21 So I think it's fascinating that dynamics are going to play through.
04:40:24 And I bet we're back in the polls in 18 months.
04:40:27 And the Trump factor won't be a factor then.
04:40:32 It won't be a factor because it definitely hurt the conservatives this time through.
04:40:35 And I thought Paul Yev was much stronger as the campaign got longer.
04:40:39 But he was behind the eight ball a bit with the media and the Trump factor.
04:40:43 And it waned as people got to know Carney because I thought Carney actually ran a terrible campaign.
04:40:49 Very few ideas.
04:40:51 And we'll see that, you know, he thinks he's going to stand up to Trump, but nobody can do that.
04:40:56 We've had that conversation, even people's own party.
04:40:59 So when the Trump factor leaves, I think the conservatives will be in better shape than they are now.
04:41:03 Oh, all right.
04:41:06 How do you square the massive rallies that Polyampton was able to pull off compared to the little gatherings that Mr. Carney did?
04:41:14 And Mr. Carney still seems to have the higher vote.
04:41:18 How did that work out?
04:41:20 Yeah, I mean, you know, I think the dynamic change in Ontario, a lot more writings went to the to the Conservatives this time and the Liberal vote is obviously in and around Ontario is very efficient. And I think that that's always been a problem for people. And I just, you know, I think it's, I think Paulie came on late.
04:41:41 if the campaign lasts another week or two
04:41:44 I think it would have been to his benefit
04:41:46 more than Kearney
04:41:47 but sometimes it's a funny game
04:41:50 as you know now it's hard to score those two things
04:41:52 yeah
04:41:54 okay
04:41:54 oh okay
04:41:57 all right thank you very much for joining us
04:42:00 tonight Peter you take care good night
04:42:02 all right
04:42:03 one last delay of getting before getting to Ted Morton
04:42:06 we're going to go to Western Standards
04:42:08 Wolf Blitzer
04:42:09 Oh, he's just standing in front of a green screen.
04:42:12 Now he's naked. 0.90
04:42:12 He's naked.
04:42:13 Production.
04:42:15 Fail.
04:42:16 Okay, here we are.
04:42:17 Now it's frozen.
04:42:21 Okay.
04:42:22 Anyway.
04:42:22 Okay, you know what?
04:42:23 Why don't we come back to Wolf Blitzer after?
04:42:26 Let's at long last bring in Ted Morton.
04:42:30 Ted Morton's former finance minister of Alberta,
04:42:33 professor at the University of Calgary,
04:42:35 and
04:42:36 one of the men who's really helped
04:42:39 chart the Alberta
04:42:41 agenda forward here
04:42:42 coming to us from an undisclosed
04:42:45 caves compound
04:42:46 somewhere
04:42:47 light on half of your face
04:42:51 thanks for joining us Ted
04:42:52 Derek
04:42:54 I've enjoyed listening for the last hour
04:42:57 Thanks for joining us.
04:43:07 You've been listening for the last hour.
04:43:09 You see the angst that we're all going in here is, how did this happen?
04:43:16 That's one question, and the other question is, what does it mean for Western Canada?
04:43:23 I answer the first question first. Like all of you, I'm happy to see that support for socialism appears to be declining across Canada. Like all of you, I think I'm happy to see that the liberals did worse than we feared. We feared a majority government.
04:43:45 but i'm concerned and i'm concerned about what the collapse of the ndp means going forward
04:43:54 as jonathan pointed out about an hour ago the harper majorities the two harper majority
04:44:01 governments depended and were built upon vote splitting on the left between the nds and the
04:44:06 liberals and uh if if what's happening today is the new normal and there's no more ndp then there's
04:44:13 no more vote splitting on the left and you know pierre whoever comes next gets 40 42 percent of
04:44:21 the vote but uh with no vote splitting the liberals could win in ontario and quebec
04:44:27 uh majorities and what's worse the liberals they want to rescue the economy they obviously have to 0.96
04:44:37 embrace oil oil and gas and coal and make all the promises that he talked about but none of us
04:44:43 But if he just wants to win elections, which the liberals are pretty good at, he could tell Alberta and Saskatchewan to screw off, do what he's always done, and that would then divide the federal conservative party.
04:44:57 You've got a separatist, a block west, and then the liberals, you get vote splitting on the right instead of vote splitting on the left, and things get pretty crazy.
04:45:10 okay sorry uh we're gonna come back one second uh jb singh is uh taking the stage are we ready
04:45:16 for him yet production okay we're gonna go to jake meet singh uh just as soon as we're ready here
04:45:23 uh but oh you just started to get real interesting ted
04:45:26 you see the you see the risk not only without vote splitting on the left 42 of the vote what
04:45:34 pierre did was really really good but he still doesn't have a majority and and what's worse is
04:45:39 the uh the liberals and certainly carney uh it would be in his instinct to use anti-energy anti-oil
04:45:47 and gas policies to divide geographically divide the conservative vote and then you have vote
04:45:53 splitting on the right and uh well then you have a very active separatist movement in the west but
04:46:00 you still have liberal governments in ottawa and and what's the bad news for all of canada is
04:46:07 is that all the uh all the capital all the investment that's sitting on the sidelines
04:46:11 right now and has been sitting on the sidelines both in the u.s and across the world about
04:46:16 uncertainty about investing in oil and gas and uh in canada it's not sitting on the sidelines
04:46:22 it's going to just go elsewhere and uh the whole country will suffer i got a feeling that uh oh
04:46:28 are we ready oh okay uh geez why did this have to happen when ted comes on he's getting all right
04:46:34 that's good that's fine all right i hope you'll stick with us uh we're gonna go to
04:46:38 jagmeet singh addressing his supporters right now uh hopefully we've still got ted when we come back
04:46:48 in the honor of my life to represent the people of burnaby central
04:46:53 tonight they chose a new member of parliament and i wish them well
04:47:08 obviously i know this night is a disappointing night for new democrats we had really good
04:47:13 candidates that lost tonight i i know how hard you worked i spent time with you you're amazing
04:47:18 um i'm so sorry you're not gonna be able to represent your communities i know you're gonna
04:47:22 to continue to fight for them i know on how many doors you knocked how many family dinners you
04:47:27 missed how many nights your kids went to bed without you there to tuck him in i know it was
04:47:31 a tough sacrifice and i just want to thank and we can give round applause to every single candidate
04:47:46 thank all those incredible candidates and their incredible teams because no candidate can do
04:47:51 without a team the volunteers the staff you know thank you to all those candidates and
04:47:56 their incredible staffs one time one more time
04:48:07 choosing to commit your life to politics obviously comes with some sacrifice
04:48:11 but we choose this life because of the chance to change the country you love for the better
04:48:17 we may lose sometimes and those losses hurt you know it's tough but we are only defeated
04:48:23 if we stop fighting we're only defeated when we believe that those that tell us that we can never
04:48:29 dream of a better canada a fairer canada a more compassionate canada i have met new democrats
04:48:36 from coast to coast to coast who will never back down even when they're told that there's no room
04:48:42 at the table. We make room for everyone because we believe that there is enough wealth in Canada
04:49:01 for all of us to live the life that we deserve.
04:49:12 Honestly, I've got to avoid making eye contact with certain people, because then it's going
04:49:17 to get too emotional up here, so I just made the mistake of doing that, so I'm going to
04:49:21 look away now.
04:49:22 You know who you are.
04:49:23 Don't look at me again.
04:49:28 Almost eight years ago, I was elected the leader of this incredible party, this incredible
04:49:34 movement.
04:49:42 I've worked really hard to be worthy of this trust, to live up to the legacy of our movement.
04:49:49 Hold on a sec, I guess.
04:49:54 One more sec, one more sec.
04:49:59 Tonight, I've been forward to a party leader that I'll be stepping down as party leader
04:50:11 soon as an interim leader can be appointed now i could not have done this incredible job without
04:50:18 here's a point i'll give me a second to break down a bit i couldn't have done it without the
04:50:22 incredible support of my wife could get in 0.99
04:50:26 she has been my rock she's been my foundation uh for the past couple years i've been regretting
04:50:43 that i didn't thank her on the night of the last election so this is my opportunity to make up for
04:50:49 it uh she has literally been my rock i couldn't have done this without her she's backed me up
04:50:56 she has made she has made so many sacrifices she convinced me that she's
04:51:09 enjoyed them all but I don't know but she's amazing I'm just so so thankful
04:51:15 Thanks for being on this journey.
04:51:16 I'm gonna give you a hug.
04:51:17 Hold on.
04:51:31 Also, I might break down this part because,
04:51:34 and Anhad and Dhani, my daughters,
04:51:36 remind me of the future. 0.96
04:51:38 God damn it, that we are fighting for. 0.96
04:51:45 That's just because I get emotional any time I talk about my kids. 0.99
04:51:51 I'm very sappy when it comes to my daughter, so I get a little emotional.
04:51:56 I've also been supported by my family, and I've got to thank my parents who are here
04:52:00 today.
04:52:01 They're amazing.
04:52:02 Love you both.
04:52:07 My brother, I wouldn't have been on this journey without my brother, so big shout out to my
04:52:13 brother and honestly this may sound funny but my in-laws I literally could
04:52:25 have done this without my in-laws they're amazing where are my in-laws
04:52:29 they're somewhere here wherever they are they're here I wanted to like look at
04:52:37 them and point at them to you oh there they are yeah I couldn't have done it
04:52:39 without them literally if you if you're a parent you know how important your
04:52:43 parents are and your in-laws too, it turns out. So huge thank you. They've supported us. They've
04:52:49 kept me grounded, given us great advice. I'm just so thankful to my family. You can't do this work
04:52:54 without great people and you can't do this without a great family supporting you. So thank you to my
04:52:59 family. I'm spilling my water and everything. It's getting a little bit trying to be graceful
04:53:11 first um i also want to thank my ndp caucus this is this is a team that together we brought
04:53:17 historic change for people we brought real change the lives of canadians i know that people are
04:53:22 concretely better off because of our work over the last eight years and no election results will
04:53:27 ever diminished that. So thank you so much.
04:53:41 My caucus, honestly, I'm
04:53:43 so thankful to
04:53:45 them all. We did some incredible work together.
04:53:47 Seriously, every one of you, thank you from the bottom of my
04:53:49 heart. And I might break down this part
04:53:51 too, forgive me if I do.
04:53:53 I can only do this,
04:53:54 and we can only do this work because of a great staff and you all just poured
04:53:59 your heart into me into the work that we did
04:54:24 It's a good thing that there's water here.
04:54:30 This water is very strategically placed for me, so it's very lucky that I have.
04:54:34 I might need a couple more glasses, so if anyone can help me out on that, that'd be great.
04:54:39 Y'all brought your talent, your heart to the fight every day.
04:54:43 We treat each other with respect and dignity and kindness, and I love y'all.
04:54:54 all right we're almost there folks we got a couple other things i really want to get off
04:55:08 my chest here one other thing is uh nothing's too spicy it's just good stuff i i often speak
04:55:14 about something my mom taught me it's a sick teaching of jardikala and this is something
04:55:19 fundamental to who i am uh and it means the words break down means rising and kalah means spirits
04:55:26 and it's something that is it it captures a big part of who i am and it's the idea that
04:55:31 in the fight for justice in the fight for for fairness in the fight that we that we fight
04:55:37 we want to have optimism in the face of struggle we want to have a defiant optimism it's like this
04:55:43 eternal resilience and this is the spirit that i carry tonight obviously i'm disappointed that
04:55:48 we could not win more seats but i'm not disappointed in our movement i'm hopeful for our party i know
04:55:54 that we will always choose hope over fear and optimism over despair and unity over hate new
04:56:02 Democrats literally built this country you Democrats built this country we have
04:56:22 built the best of Canada and we aren't going anywhere thank you thank you so
04:56:29 much love you all you're amazing merci infiniment appreciate it so much appreciate you all so much
04:56:34 thank you you're amazing love you all every one of you you're amazing thank you thank you
04:56:39 thank you
04:56:59 NTT! NTT! NTT! NTT!
04:57:29 Thank you.
04:57:59 c-pack thing off there get c-pack out of here close out okay so uh that was ndp leader jagmeet
04:58:12 singh came in third a distant third place in his constituency um on track for the absolute worst
04:58:21 result in the history of the ndp and the history of any socialist party in canadian history
04:58:27 at least back till roughly around the first world war uh that's the this is the trivia you learned
04:58:34 tonight that you're so excited for i was plenty actually i've been talking about this for a long
04:58:38 time thinking this is the way it's gonna go um i okay uh dr morton i guess you've heard what
04:58:44 jagmeet singh had to say um i mean you have to put lipstick on a pig but wow it's relevant to
04:58:51 what I said before, the NDP's problems go deeper than Jagmeet Singh. The NDP is a party based on
04:58:59 unions. And today that means public sector and private sector. But there's a big gap between
04:59:07 private sector unions and public sector unions. The public sector unions are the teachers and
04:59:12 civil servants who all have university degrees and are pretty heavy into the DEI woke green
04:59:18 revolution policies uh and they feel they can feel pretty comfortable moving over to the liberals
04:59:25 and the uh the blue collar wing the blue collar unions of the ndp uh who work uh in either small
04:59:33 small uh companies or in the in resource industries uh are want want economic growth
04:59:41 they want investment they want they want the economy to come back and they can see uh and
04:59:46 And that's how, in fact, that's one of the areas it appears that Pierre made inroads tonight to get to that 42%.
04:59:54 There's some unprecedented union support for a federal conservative party tonight.
04:59:59 So I think the NDP is kind of coming apart right in the middle, which in one sense makes me happy.
05:00:07 But on the other hand, it creates, I think, a pretty serious risk to the federal PCs going forward.
05:00:16 Can I ask you the same question I asked Shea Anderson just now?
05:00:23 In British Columbia, they've had a provincial NDP government for years now, and it is interesting
05:00:32 the divide in the party that you just mentioned between the, you know, the people, the woke
05:00:38 people who work for the government and are teachers and the public sector.
05:00:42 Public sector versus private sector unions, yeah.
05:00:45 It just seems to me, and I'm asking you if I'm on the right track here, I guess, is that
05:00:50 a lot of the problems that they're having in BC with the NDP vote right now, probably
05:00:56 to do with the administration of the provincial government, which has tended to favor the
05:01:02 woke end of the spectrum.
05:01:04 So you're talking about BC in particular now?
05:01:08 David Eby.
05:01:09 David Eby in particular, I believe, it was just the last...
05:01:12 Okay.
05:01:13 follow B.C. politics carefully enough, other than their wine and their nice beer.
05:01:19 They just had an election and they lost their majority, basically.
05:01:22 I know. I know. I know. I saw that. That made me happy, too.
05:01:27 So, yeah, maybe the same forces are at work there.
05:01:32 But I think for the federal NDP, it's potentially kind of an existential threat.
05:01:37 if if if they're a union based party and the unions are going into public sector and private
05:01:42 sector unions are going in two different directions that plus they don't even like each other right
05:01:47 teachers and civil servants don't like their beer drinking cigarette smoking uh hockey yelling fans
05:01:54 from the uh from the blue collar unions so uh i think the i think the ndp problem is deeper than
05:02:01 in Jagmeet's thing. But then
05:02:03 that creates a
05:02:05 potential problem for the Conservatives
05:02:07 going forward.
05:02:10 Yeah, some interesting
05:02:13 just a little bit on BC. Aaron
05:02:15 Gunn has picked up
05:02:17 North Island Powell River
05:02:19 from New Democrat
05:02:21 Tennille Johnson.
05:02:24 That was a three-way race.
05:02:25 The NDP was still in second there.
05:02:27 But Aaron Gunn, that's
05:02:29 It's a path to a pipeline.
05:02:34 But Skeena, Bulkley Valley, not yet called.
05:02:38 Still a ton of polls to come in.
05:02:41 But unfortunately, it looks like Alice Ross, former BC Liberal cabinet minister, really, really solid guy.
05:02:48 Running for the Conservatives.
05:02:49 He's behind by eight points there.
05:02:52 Okay, I want to pick up, Dr. Martin, on where we were before we were so rudely interrupted by Jagmeet Singh.
05:02:59 He had something to say about buy.
05:03:02 Last time.
05:03:03 Yeah.
05:03:03 Yeah, we're not going to have to hear that anymore.
05:03:07 Tomorrow morning, I mean, there's Alberta and to a lesser extent Saskatchewan have always had nascent independence movements.
05:03:16 But it's normally been disorganized, lacking credible leadership, lacking money, that kind of thing.
05:03:25 Does that change tomorrow morning?
05:03:27 I think it definitely does. 0.99
05:03:29 and i think uh both uh the premiers of both provinces are well well ted i'm an asshole uh 0.88
05:03:37 pierre paulieva speaking uh i'm more than happy to give space to pierre you know that as we bring
05:03:44 that i'm sorry yeah okay are we got it going because i was gonna say as we load it i think
05:03:49 it's super important to say like 44 000 votes were cast in his advanced poll that doesn't usually get
05:03:56 count until after that's 40 of his vote is not in yet so yeah all right here we go
05:04:10 spoke in their voice and exercise their democratic
05:04:16 all right uh it was there have we got beer here
05:04:20 I had to interrupt
05:04:25 we don't have that screen on we need a video
05:04:33 and cherish you and our little ones more than you'll ever know
05:04:43 and I could not have done any of this without you thank you so much
05:04:46 cut the mics
05:04:49 now my message to canadians
05:04:54 the promise that was made to me and to all of you
05:04:58 is that anybody from anywhere could achieve anything
05:05:01 that through hard work you could get a great life
05:05:04 you have a nice affordable home on a safe street
05:05:07 my purpose in politics is
05:05:10 and will continue to be to restore that promise
05:05:14 Thank you.
05:05:35 To the candidates who ran under our banner as Conservatives,
05:05:39 to the volunteers who knocked on the doors,
05:05:41 made phone calls, put up lawn signs, rallied at our events, donated their hard-earned money to
05:05:47 our cause. I thank you from the bottom of my heart. To the millions of people who voted for
05:05:53 the Conservative Party and put their hopes and dreams in our vision, thank you. It will be an
05:06:00 honour to continue to fight for you and to be a champion of your cause as we go forward.
05:06:11 It would be a great honor to continue to fight for you, because it is an honor to be your
05:06:33 voice.
05:06:34 It is an honor to fight for the conservative values for which you voted.
05:06:40 And especially, it will be an honor to continue to advance the promise of Canada that everyone
05:06:46 here in Canada who works hard can have a beautiful life, a beautiful home in a safe
05:06:52 community. That's our vision and we will bring it home. Thank you very much.
05:07:01 To my fellow Conservatives, we have much to celebrate tonight. We've gained well over
05:07:08 20 seats. We got the highest share of vote our party has received since 1988. We denied
05:07:20 the NDP and Liberals enough seats to form a coalition government meeting.
05:07:30 And we did all this in a very difficult environment. That said, we are cognizant of the fact
05:07:38 that we didn't quite get over the finish line yet we know that change is needed but change
05:07:46 is hard to come by it takes time it takes work and that's why we have to learn the lessons of
05:07:52 tonight so that we can have an even better result the next time the canadians decide the future for
05:07:57 the country. Canadians have opted for a razor-thin minority government, a virtual tie in the vote
05:08:19 count. So I would like to congratulate Prime Minister Carney on leading this minority 1.00
05:08:25 government no no we'll have plenty of opportunity to to debate and disagree but tonight we come
05:08:33 together as canadians we will do our job yes we will do our job to hold the government to account
05:08:39 but first we congratulate people from all political backgrounds on participating in
05:08:48 the democratic process and as i said while we will do our constitutional duty of holding
05:08:54 government to account and proposing better alternatives, we will always put Canada first
05:08:59 as we stare down tariffs and other irresponsible threats from President Trump. Conservatives will
05:09:06 work with the Prime Minister and all parties with the common goal of defending Canada's interests
05:09:11 and getting a new trade deal that puts these tariffs behind us while protecting our sovereignty
05:09:17 and the Canadian people.
05:09:24 I want to thank my Conservative team, my caucus, my members of the Conservative staff and others
05:09:32 who've helped reshape the entire political landscape in this country.
05:09:37 Conservatives have achieved major breakthroughs tonight.
05:09:40 We brought in record support from blue-collar and unionized workers, youth, new Canadians.
05:09:46 we gave voices to countless people across this country who've been left out and left behind for
05:09:54 far too long we won the big debates of our time on the carbon tax on inflation on housing on the
05:10:00 drug crisis on crime conservatives have been leading the debate and we will continue to put
05:10:06 forward the best arguments to improve the lives of our people right across this country but we
05:10:11 will not stop there. Every single day, our Conservative caucus and I will be holding the
05:10:17 government to account on behalf of the millions of Canadians who believed in the message of change.
05:10:23 En tant que parti, on a grandement élargi notre soutien et chaque jour, le caucus conservateur
05:10:31 et moi allons travailler Ă  Ottawa pour rendre des comptes du gouvernement au nom des millions
05:10:38 of Canadians who have decided to vote for a real change.
05:10:42 I have had the honour to talk to thousands of people who have
05:10:47 shared their preoccupations, their pain, their espoirs.
05:10:52 Everywhere I went, hard-working people took precious time out of
05:10:55 their day to tell me about their struggles, their pain, their fears,
05:11:01 but also their hopes and dreams.
05:11:04 Elders and waitresses, farmers and factory workers, seniors, small business owners, and single mothers.
05:11:12 Young Canadians and young families pleading for the chance to own a home.
05:11:16 Parents who worried that their kids would never be able to move out of their home.
05:11:21 Grandparents who saw their grandchildren suffering from the shortfalls of our economy.
05:11:27 And countless others who were afraid to go outside because of the rising wave of crime.
05:11:32 All of these stories touched my heart and gave me inspiration to work towards something better.
05:11:41 These people continue to need voices, and I will continue to fight for them every day and every day.
05:11:48 We will never give up on fighting for the Canadian people.
05:11:57 Thank you.
05:11:58 we hear your stories we will carry those stories with us into parliament
05:12:05 you will not forget the people for whom we work and for whom we fight every day
05:12:10 now i know that some of you might be disappointed that change did not get over the finish line
05:12:16 tonight change takes time most of all it requires that we never give up because our people and our
05:12:24 country are worth fighting for.
05:12:34 I heard you and brought your stories with me throughout this campaign.
05:12:40 And your stories will remain with me when I fight with my conservative team
05:12:46 to defend you and to advance your interests.
05:12:51 I will never give up on fighting for everyone who stood with us today and the millions of
05:13:17 people who voted for other parties.
05:13:19 So my message tonight for the single mother working two jobs but still has an empty fridge 0.96
05:13:28 and an empty bank account, for the young people who despair at never being able to afford a home,
05:13:34 for the seniors on fixed incomes whose savings are eroded by inflation and no longer feel safe
05:13:41 in their local neighbourhood parks, for those who are now living in fear and terror because of crime,
05:13:48 for those worried about losing their jobs because of unacceptable tariffs from the United States of
05:13:53 America, for all of those who feel left behind and forgotten, my message is one of hope. Change will
05:14:00 take time, but we will fight for that change and we will deliver that change and we will never
05:14:06 give up on fighting for the great Canadian promise that anyone from anywhere can achieve anything.
05:14:13 This hard work gets you a great life in a beautiful house on a safe street protected by our brave troops under our proud flag.
05:14:24 Canada first. Canada always. Let's bring it home. Thank you very much, Canada.
05:14:29 Merci beaucoup, Canada.
05:14:43 Thank you, everyone. Welcome. I'm Rick Perkins, the Conservative candidate in South Shore St. Margaret's and the Member of Parliament for that writing.
05:14:54 I'm not sure what we are listening to. Come on, production. Turn that off.
05:15:00 Okay. Well, we're back to Dr. Ted Morton. I hope to God we have a little more time before Mark Carney comes to interrupt us again.
05:15:12 When he comes, I'm leaving.
05:15:15 Okay.
05:15:17 God's sign that you're just not meant to get to complete a full thought on the program.
05:15:22 I have a question for you.
05:15:24 Can your numbers guy break down the – how many conservative MPs are elected, 146?
05:15:33 The number we're seeing is 148.
05:15:36 148, right.
05:15:36 Leading or elected at 148.
05:15:38 I'd like to know how many are from Alberta, Saskatchewan, and how many are Alberta, Saskatchewan, and BC, and how many are from the rest of Canada.
05:15:47 Do you want the, do you say Manitoba, too, or no?
05:15:50 No.
05:15:51 Okay.
05:15:52 The West ends at Selkirk to attend.
05:15:58 All right.
05:16:00 So, sorry, I want you to maybe just complete the thought that got interrupted that I asked you right before Polyev came on.
05:16:08 does the independence movement move uh from the fringe to the mainstream as a as a real thing
05:16:15 tomorrow morning yeah it's going to definitely move a few more degrees and then how how fast
05:16:21 and how far it moves depends on a number of things the big one will be uh whether or not
05:16:26 carney delivers on his on his commitments to uh to undo a lot of the uh trudeau liberal uh damage
05:16:37 on the energy sector.
05:16:40 I think Daniel Premier-Smith has done a good job
05:16:44 of laying out her 11 conditions or so
05:16:47 that she's demanding that be addressed.
05:16:50 We'll see what he does on that.
05:16:52 She has the Sovereignty Act already enacted,
05:16:56 and she has already started motion
05:16:59 or movement on a number of the Alberta agenda items,
05:17:04 policing tax collection uh pension those should move forward too and uh i think i think you give
05:17:14 carney or i think she should give carney albertans should give carney western canadians should give
05:17:19 carney uh the rest of the year what is that eight more months to see is he gonna is he gonna work
05:17:27 for all of canada or is he gonna continue what he's done for the last decade and a half and try
05:17:31 shut down the oil and gas industry if he does that it might help him win an election because
05:17:36 it'll break the federal conservative party in half but it'll send uh western separatism
05:17:44 western disillusionment through the uh through the ceiling so uh i think to begin with uh smith
05:17:51 mo uh people should say you've made these commitments here's what the premier of alberta
05:17:57 has asked uh let's see you do it let's we want to see action not talk personally i'm sort of
05:18:03 skeptical that he'll do that and i also worry that he won't do it because by not doing it if
05:18:08 he continues down his uh green dream path uh it electorally politically that might be the winning
05:18:16 path because then it would sure as hell you're going to get a a block a block west and many get
05:18:22 a block west and the liberals win yeah so we're looking if we look at the map now there's actually
05:18:29 kind of a path to get our product to market if uh the polls end up playing out how we see
05:18:36 so i didn't think that that was going to be possible i thought we were going to get more
05:18:40 just the interiors oh yeah look at that um and so maybe break this down because there's we were
05:18:47 talking earlier on the show about the demands and he has said to premier smith that he was going to
05:18:54 repeal c69 then he said that he wasn't going to so i think it's like what are you expecting him
05:19:01 to actually say and come out and commit to that would maybe diffuse some independence
05:19:10 versus giving us the you know all the nine demands
05:19:13 well i think he better give us more than just one or two uh because if he doesn't uh there's
05:19:21 going to be no investment in western canadian oil and gas repercussions uh in the potash and
05:19:27 the agricultural sector everything and uh that will push that will push alienation and uh
05:19:36 dissatisfaction with the status quo higher and the minute it gets to a certain point so i think
05:19:43 we should strongly resist a supporting a new western separatist party now but i i i i'm i'm
05:19:52 i guess i've been in politics long enough and i i see the dark side and i'm very concerned that
05:19:59 he'll purposely try to push western canada out with uh with the policies he spent his whole life
05:20:04 uh supporting and if that happens then uh the issue of western western separation will be just
05:20:13 as well frankly everybody in your room western canada could do a lot better as an independent
05:20:20 nation than quebec could because we have we have what the world needs but i mean if this is going
05:20:27 to happen don't we need to begin an artist while the spark is lit i mean if if if we just wait eight
05:20:33 months so you know i mean we kind of lose them the spark that lights the fire i i i think uh
05:20:42 eight months goes by real fast and if he doesn't deliver it and plus uh if he wants to get
05:20:48 investment coming back into canada uh he has to start moving at eight months in politics is eight
05:20:56 days uh yeah but i i would challenge you on the fact that i have received texts i'm a saskatchewan
05:21:03 girl i have friends that live in bc i don't know if anyone else's phones are starting to go off of
05:21:09 like do we need to move to alberta what does this look like and if i'm getting those types of things
05:21:15 i think there's probably a lot of frustration out there and a lot of people looking for a solution
05:21:23 now now i you and i have been in poly like we all have and for a long time that you don't want to
05:21:28 just act on sentiment or emotion but i think that carney can make a pretty quick like he's going to
05:21:37 have to make a decision in which lane he's going to play in uh pretty quick that i think you know
05:21:43 the discussions are going to happen how do they take the right narrative about what even could
05:21:48 this look like and then also play out his scenarios like i just i i want to challenge the
05:21:55 eight months because he's gonna have to i think alberta saskatchewan or western canada is going
05:22:01 to be like okay look at this map like something's wrong here what are you gonna do that's why that's
05:22:08 why i asked for the breakdown between the federal mps yeah that's what we've got him now sean's got
05:22:15 these numbers let's bring him on but there's a lot of blue on that map you know i say happily
05:22:24 all right you can't bring him in you took that one out
05:22:35 okay well basically what happened was in bc service went from 17 to 26 so that's just
05:22:41 Just give us the high level.
05:22:43 9, Alberta 34-34, SAS 13-13, Manicova 7 versus 7, Ontario 72 versus 45, net gain of almost 27 seats.
05:22:56 Okay.
05:22:57 Even in Quebec, 11 versus 10.
05:22:59 So how many seats are in the West versus the East?
05:23:01 That's the question.
05:23:03 West versus the East. 0.73
05:23:04 That's what we want to know.
05:23:04 Conservative seats in the West, conservative seats in the East.
05:23:07 Yeah, that's what I'm giving you, conservative seats. 0.61
05:23:08 Yeah, but you're...
05:23:09 So he's seen 26 seats versus 17 last time.
05:23:13 Okay.
05:23:13 I don't want the breakdown.
05:23:14 It's just total.
05:23:15 The East versus the West. 0.95
05:23:17 Yeah.
05:23:17 Okay.
05:23:18 All right.
05:23:18 He'll be back soon.
05:23:21 All right.
05:23:24 Okay.
05:23:24 Before we bring in Mike Solberg here,
05:23:29 did you guys have anything else for Dr. Morton before we bring in Mike
05:23:32 Solberg?
05:23:33 Not yet.
05:23:34 Good to see you.
05:23:35 All right.
05:23:37 Dr. Morton,
05:23:37 I think we're going to have a lot to talk about.
05:23:42 There's going to be a lot to talk about and a lot to do in the next eight months.
05:23:47 And in the next eight hours, in the next eight days, in the next eight weeks.
05:23:52 Yeah.
05:23:52 I'm just warming up.
05:23:53 I think that the budding new coalition between the Liberals and the Bloc de Vecroix
05:23:58 is only going to grist the mail.
05:24:02 Thank you very much, Dr. Morton, for joining us tonight and sharing your insights.
05:24:06 Good night.
05:24:06 You're welcome.
05:24:07 all right we're gonna bring in uh mike solberg now mike solberg is a uh political uh well he
05:24:16 works in public relations uh government relations partner in a company you're very bad at that
05:24:21 partner in uf public affairs sorry i'm just not good at plugging here and they also they also
05:24:26 actually just launched a communication branch that mike i think you should tell people about
05:24:30 yeah well thank you erica yeah i i also had a creative and digital agency
05:24:37 called shift media strategies which i run with a couple of partners as well but no happy to be on
05:24:42 guys thank you for having me um okay so i want to actually pick up where we were just finishing
05:24:47 there with dr morton uh the ndp is gone they're finished uh they'll be back someday but it could
05:24:55 be a while uh there are only three uh there are technically three configurations parliament could
05:25:03 take the liberals with the conservatives unlikely but technically it could happen yeah the liberals
05:25:10 with the bloc or i guess the conservatives technically with the bloc would also form a
05:25:15 majority as well uh the most likely configuration i think we're going to see is the liberals governing
05:25:19 uh maybe not with a formal agreement supplying confidence agreement the way they had with the
05:25:26 ndp but probably on a case-by-case basis with the bloc québécois that seems to be the most likely
05:25:31 scenario um well i don't know so the liberals go ahead well i don't know if i agree with that
05:25:37 necessarily phil the uh you know the we still have advanced polls to count here uh a leading elected
05:25:45 with the ndp the liberals have a workable majority as well so the do they can be part of it just
05:25:50 jump to the point the liberals gain more seats so actually as long as everybody stays on the
05:25:55 same page they could pull off 172 exactly yeah okay very shaky i mean it's like we said
05:26:04 then they got one seat buffer yeah the price the price to pay with working with the ndp would be a
05:26:09 lot lower than the deal that mark carney would have to strike with the block i think yeah uh
05:26:15 so if they can work with the ndp uh leading in a lot they're leading in looking seven i don't know
05:26:21 Maybe, maybe a bare, bare agreement.
05:26:24 Top seven, maybe a hard four.
05:26:26 Yeah.
05:26:27 And then you probably need to throw in the Greens on top of that.
05:26:30 That comes with an enormously high price there,
05:26:34 where the Greens literally kind of hold a balance of power in the House of Commons.
05:26:38 That would be absolutely mad.
05:26:40 So, I mean, there are two, okay, maybe two scenarios.
05:26:43 The NDP plus the Greens, to give yourself a one-seat margin.
05:26:48 Oh, sorry, the Liberals plus the NDP and Greens.
05:26:50 or Liberals with the Bloc Québécois.
05:26:53 Which of these scenarios does not result in revolution in Alberta?
05:26:58 No, I think we're headed for some significant Western angst, 0.84
05:27:03 significant malcontent, I think,
05:27:05 regardless of kind of the options that Mark Kearney has here to try and survive.
05:27:11 I mean, of course, he'll be given the opportunity to form and govern.
05:27:15 But if he wants to govern with any kind of stability, you're absolutely right.
05:27:19 is going to need to to work with one of the opposition parties and it certainly won't be
05:27:23 the conservatives so um no i i don't know if there is a great uh scenario here for alberta and for
05:27:29 the west um but i think the most likely scenario here uh well if if the the trend continues here
05:27:37 will be to work with the new democrats um and form a very very tenuous parliament uh here um i i
05:27:44 I think regardless of kind of what shakes out the next couple of weeks in terms of kind of deal making, we're probably headed back to the polls here in as few as 12 months and probably closer to 18.
05:27:55 But this war is not over.
05:27:57 I think that this was a major battle in that war.
05:28:01 But I think the war will continue. 0.55
05:28:03 Well, I mean, this is the color of the map across Canada.
05:28:10 There's going to be people who have given up on the federal war and they're going to introvert.
05:28:14 The strength that Polyev drew from on the prairies, it's going to be hard to motivate them again.
05:28:21 And I understand that that's not the ones that they need to make a difference in the election.
05:28:24 And that's the problem.
05:28:28 There's going to be a lot of complications from this election.
05:28:32 And we're going to see it provincially, too.
05:28:33 Premier Smith is going to have her hands full because there's going to be a lot of people calling now for a heck of a lot more provincial, federal battling.
05:28:42 And that puts, again, Polyev on the spot.
05:28:44 because are you going to be supporting smith as she's making more demands of the federal government
05:28:49 or distancing alberta from it which again would just it's just an ugly scenario all around it
05:28:54 that there's going to be a heck of a lot of thought to have to go into the next couple of weeks
05:28:57 for sure we're definitely we're definitely seeing a fractured country uh and and the you know and
05:29:05 you know what i'm going to be doing in the next few weeks oh yeah sorry uh how did i get the only
05:29:10 frickin' liberal seat. 0.93
05:29:13 Yeah, that's your fault. 0.95
05:29:15 Okay, actually, Mike,
05:29:16 hopefully you can stay with us. Mark Carney is coming on
05:29:18 right now. We're going to go to him.
05:29:20 Hopefully you're still here when we get
05:29:22 back. You bet.
05:29:23 Let's do this again.
05:29:32 Have we got Mark Carney?
05:29:37 Is Mark Carney ready to go?
05:29:38 He's working on it.
05:29:40 I hope that you now have come to appreciate that alongside his capacity for dealing with
05:30:03 the most serious of matters, there's a great line for trivia, a wicked glance of humor,
05:30:08 and a wonderful smile he's been that that way since our very first date that when we were
05:30:17 young grad students when we went to that dinner and he said to me he stopped the conversation
05:30:25 and he said to me i want you to know i'm committed to move back to canada and to work in the public
05:30:31 service so here we as his partner I could not be more proud of him and as a
05:30:44 Canadian I'm so thankful that the man I met more than 30 years ago has held
05:30:50 tight to that strong commitment the service I'm lucky to have him we're
05:30:55 lucky to have him now more than ever without further ado it's my great
05:31:00 pleasure to introduce my husband, the Prime Minister who will make Canada strong, and
05:31:30 That is Nepean, that is the spirit of Nepean behind me right there.
05:31:50 I have a question, who's ready, who's ready to stand up for Canada with me?
05:32:18 who's ready? Who's ready to build Canada strong? Okay, we got that settled. That's good.
05:32:28 Before we start, I would like to congratulate the other members of the party, of their campaign,
05:32:36 and all the work they have done. I would like to thank them for their service to Canada
05:32:43 I want to thank the leaders of the other parties.
05:32:52 I want to salute the contribution of Jagmeet Singh, leading on progressive values.
05:33:03 Elizabeth May, who will be returning, and Francois Blanchet.
05:33:09 And I want to congratulate him on a hard-fought, fair, good campaign, his commitment to the
05:33:14 country that we both love.
05:33:21 They all have many, many more contributions to our land.
05:33:25 Thank you, Diana.
05:33:26 Thank you, Diana, for your work on this campaign.
05:33:33 Thank you, Diana, for the commitment and compassion you bring to everything that you do.
05:33:40 Tonight simply would not have been possible without you and without the support of our
05:33:47 four children who inspire me to service every single day.
05:33:56 I also want to salute the women and men who put their name on the ballot from all parties.
05:34:04 Thank you for standing up to serve our country at this critical time.
05:34:10 And for those who were elected, particularly those Liberals who were elected, I am looking
05:34:18 forward to working together to deliver for Canadians.
05:34:22 Bruce, I'm Bruce, yes, Bruce Vandreau.
05:34:27 I'm looking forward to working with Bruce Vandreau.
05:34:34 Fantastic.
05:34:35 He is a great, he will be a great MP.
05:34:38 We're going to have fun tonight.
05:34:40 Yes, we're going to have fun.
05:34:42 Bien sûr, je tiens à remercier les milliers de bénévoles
05:34:47 here tonight and across the country who have given their time to fight for the port, to
05:34:54 make calls, to exchange with their neighbors and members of their community, to give us
05:35:04 a strong government.
05:35:08 You know, I chose to enter politics because I felt we needed big changes in this country,
05:35:19 but big changes guided by strong Canadian values.
05:35:25 Values that I learned at the dinner table from my parents, Bob and Burleigh, and from
05:35:29 my siblings.
05:35:30 I appreciate this more in retrospect from my siblings, Brenda, Sean, and Brian.
05:35:38 Values that I learned on the ice from my coaches.
05:35:41 Values that have been reinforced as I've met with Canadians across this great country.
05:35:49 And those include three values that I want to highlight this evening.
05:35:52 Humility.
05:35:53 It's Canada after all.
05:35:56 Ambition.
05:35:57 It's Canada after all.
05:35:58 And unity.
05:35:59 It's Canada.
05:36:00 I love you.
05:36:01 Right back.
05:36:02 Right back.
05:36:03 I love you. Right back. Right back. These are good values. These are Canadian values.
05:36:14 Values that I will do my best. I'm just getting worked up here. These are values that I will
05:36:19 do my best to uphold every day as your prime minister. You betcha.
05:36:27 Okay, well, you have to judge after this next section, because I am going to begin.
05:36:33 I am going to begin with the value of humility, and by admitting that I have much to be humble
05:36:40 about.
05:36:41 That's true.
05:36:42 Over my long—that's not an applause line, it's just a statement of fact.
05:36:48 Over my long career, I have made many mistakes, and I will make more.
05:36:55 I commit to admitting them openly, to correcting them quickly, and always learning from them.
05:37:07 Humility underscores the importance of governing as a team in Cabinet and in caucus,
05:37:15 and working constructively with all parties across Parliament.
05:37:20 of working in partnership with the provinces and the territories and with Indigenous peoples.
05:37:31 And at this time, it underscores the value of bringing together labour, business, civil society
05:37:36 to advance the nation-building investments we need to transform our economy.
05:37:43 Humility is also about recognizing that one of the responsibilities of government
05:37:50 is to prepare for the worst not hope for the best
05:37:55 as i've been warned america wants our land our resources
05:38:01 our water our country
05:38:06 never but these are not these are not idle threats
05:38:11 president trump is trying to break us so that america
05:38:16 can own us that will never that will never ever happen but we
05:38:26 but we also must recognize the reality that our world has fundamentally changed
05:38:35 there is also for me as i stand before you this evening humility in recognizing that well many
05:38:43 Many have chosen to place your trust in me, trust in the Liberal Party.
05:38:50 Millions of our fellow citizens preferred a different outcome.
05:38:55 And my message to every Canadian is this, no matter where you live, no matter what language
05:39:01 you speak, no matter how you voted, I will always do my best to represent everyone who
05:39:07 who calls Canada home.
05:39:15 You know, during this short campaign, I went to Saskatchewan and Alberta a couple of times.
05:39:23 Even though, you know, we're Liberals, it's tough out there, I grew up there.
05:39:29 But I went because I intend to govern for all Canadians.
05:39:34 And at the core of this campaign, the Québécois and Québécoises have opened their doors,
05:39:42 have given me their confidence.
05:39:45 I am deeply touched on it, and I thank you very much.
05:39:50 The French language, the French culture, is at the core of the Canadian identity.
05:40:03 They define the country that I don't like, and I will defend them without a relief.
05:40:17 With the strong team of Quebec candidates that you have just sent to Ottawa, we will
05:40:25 We want to make sure Quebec will continue to prosper within Canada.
05:40:37 And that you are a worker of the sable bitumineux at Fort Mac, an infirmary of Joliet, or a comptable
05:40:46 to Toronto.
05:40:47 You have to do your contact at Toronto.
05:40:50 Mon gouvernement
05:40:51 va travailler pour vous tous.
05:40:55 So,
05:40:56 as we come here
05:40:57 after this consequential,
05:41:00 most consequential election,
05:41:02 let's put an end.
05:41:04 Let's put an end to the division
05:41:06 and anger of the past.
05:41:11 We are all
05:41:12 Canadian, and my government will work
05:41:14 for and with everyone.
05:41:16 I began with humility, but Canadians are ambitious.
05:41:29 And now, more than ever, it is a time for ambition.
05:41:32 It is a time to be bold, to meet this crisis with overwhelming positive force of a united
05:41:39 Canada. Because we, we are going to build. Build, baby, build.
05:41:53 Exactly. Throughout, well, no, we're building now. We've gotten over that bit.
05:42:04 Throughout, throughout our history, there have been turning points. Throughout our
05:42:09 history there have been turning points when the world's fortunes were in the
05:42:11 balance. That was at this that was the case at the start of the Second World
05:42:16 War just as it was at the end of the Cold War. And each time Canada chose to
05:42:23 step up to assert ourselves as a free sovereign and ambitious nation to lead
05:42:29 the path of democracy and freedom and because we are Canadian to do so with
05:42:37 compassion and generosity we are we are once again we are once again at one of
05:42:47 those hinge moments of history our old relationship with the United States a
05:42:52 relationship based on steadily increasing integration is over the
05:42:58 system of open global trade anchored by the United States a system that Canada
05:43:05 has relied on since the Second World War, a system that, while not perfect, has helped
05:43:11 deliver prosperity for a country for decades, is over.
05:43:19 But it's also our new reality.
05:43:22 We are over the shock of the American betrayal, but we should never forget the lessons.
05:43:33 We have to look out for ourselves, and above all, we have to take care of each other.
05:43:49 When I sit down with President Trump, it will be to discuss the future economic and security
05:43:56 relationship between two sovereign nations.
05:44:04 And it will be with our full knowledge that we have many, many other options than the
05:44:12 United States to build prosperity for all Canadians.
05:44:16 Nous allons renforcer nos relations avec des partenaires fiables en Europe, en Asie
05:44:27 et ailleurs.
05:44:28 Et si les États-Unis ne veulent plus jouer un rôle de premier plan dans l'économie
05:44:34 mondiale, le Canada le fera.
05:44:38 We will leave North America.
05:44:42 Nous sommes mètre chez nous.
05:44:44 Nous allons bâtir des millions de logements, une superpuissance énergétique, de bonnes
05:44:50 carrières dans les emplois spécialisés, et une seule économie canadienne patrèce.
05:44:57 We will chart a new path forward.
05:45:00 Because this is Canada, and we decide what happens here.
05:45:13 We will need to think big and act bigger.
05:45:18 Your phone's ringing.
05:45:23 All right.
05:45:24 Just hang on.
05:45:25 It's okay?
05:45:26 Yeah, okay.
05:45:28 It might be important.
05:45:34 We will need to do things previously thought impossible
05:45:38 at speeds we haven't seen in generations.
05:45:42 It's time to build twice as many homes every year with an entirely new housing industry
05:45:48 using Canadian technology, Canadian skilled workers, Canadian lumber.
05:45:58 It's time to build new trade and energy corridors working in partnership with the provinces,
05:46:03 territories and Indigenous peoples.
05:46:09 It's time to build hundreds of thousands of, not just good jobs, but good careers in the
05:46:15 skilled trades.
05:46:19 It's time to build Canada into an energy superpower in both clean and conventional
05:46:23 energy.
05:46:26 And it's time to build an industrial strategy that makes Canada more competitive while fighting
05:46:32 climate change.
05:46:38 We will build a Canadian economy, not 13, with a government committed to free trade
05:46:43 in Canada by Canada Day.
05:46:47 The point is that we can give ourselves far more than the Americans can ever take away.
05:46:58 But even given that, I want to be clear.
05:47:00 The coming days and months will be challenging, and they will call for some sacrifices.
05:47:07 But we will share those sacrifices by supporting our workers and our businesses.
05:47:13 The challenges in front of us are intimidating, and it's normal.
05:47:20 The big changes, like those that we live in, are always worrying.
05:47:27 We have a lot of paths to do, but I have confidence.
05:47:31 I have confidence in you.
05:47:33 I have confidence in Canada.
05:47:37 Because Canada is more than a nation.
05:47:43 We are and we always will be a confederation.
05:47:47 A sacred set of ideas and ideals built on practical foundations.
05:47:53 That we know we're not always perfect, but we always strive to be good.
05:47:59 We do things because they're right, not because they're easy.
05:48:06 we see kindness as a virtue not as a weakness most importantly we know that our strength lies
05:48:13 in our resolve to work together as a country it relies on our unity you know on the second day of
05:48:21 this campaign i went to gander we're nine where on 9 11 they welcomed thousands of passengers
05:48:29 into their homes without question or hesitation i sat down with two of the many heroes of the time
05:48:36 Diane Davis and Beulah Cooper.
05:48:39 And during our conversation, they showed me a thank you card
05:48:42 that they'd received from a young girl called Ellie,
05:48:45 who wrote,
05:48:46 your kindness motivates me to use my kindness.
05:48:52 That touching phrase captures
05:48:55 what Canadians instinctively know,
05:48:58 that virtue is like a muscle that grows with its exercise.
05:49:03 We become just by doing just acts,
05:49:06 brave by doing brave acts when we are kind kindness grows when we seek unity unity grows
05:49:14 when we are canadian canada grows
05:49:24 and united united our history we have done hard seemingly impossible things
05:49:31 united we have built one nation in harsh conditions
05:49:36 despite a sometimes hostile neighbor.
05:49:39 Yes, they have forum on this, the Americans.
05:49:42 United, we have confronted our own past
05:49:45 with indigenous peoples.
05:49:47 Uni, nous avons bâti un pays qui rassemble des langues,
05:49:51 des cultures et des croyances différentes.
05:49:55 Uni, nous avons bâti des institutions culturelles essentielles
05:50:00 comme CBC Radio-Canada.
05:50:06 United, United we have created universal public health care and now, and now in the face of
05:50:15 this crisis, United we are buying Canadian.
05:50:18 We are exploring everything this country has to offer.
05:50:20 We are supporting our friends and neighbours in the crosshairs of President Trump through
05:50:25 a crisis that we did not create.
05:50:28 United we have to build the strongest economy in the G7, an economy that works for everyone.
05:50:36 We will fight back with everything we have to get the best deal for Canada.
05:51:06 We will protect our workers and businesses.
05:51:10 And above all, we will build an independent future for our great country.
05:51:16 A future that makes the greatest country on the earth even better.
05:51:21 Together, we will build a Canada worthy of our values.
05:51:24 We will build Canada strong, Canada free, Canada forever.
05:51:30 Vive le Canada. Thank you very much. Merci beaucoup.
05:51:36 we call him he's prime minister uh did mention the word pipeline once he didn't say things like uh
05:51:59 energy corridors uh he did he did say con clean and conventional energy that's the closest he
05:52:06 came to which no one applauded yeah yeah a lot of applause for everything he was saying isn't that
05:52:12 yeah uh just couldn't say it like it was voldemort um uh nigel your uh your impression 0.93
05:52:22 of carney speech you mean the ai uh generated uh collection of the bot whatever bot was just
05:52:31 i mean there's a when you're making a victory speech there's a certain time you have to take
05:52:36 and you say nice things and things that are going to please your supporters but that was a bit heavy
05:52:40 that was that was hard to take um you know i was just looking at um just looking at truth social
05:52:48 president trump's thing right as carney was uh mr carney oh mr carney right as he was talking
05:52:55 about all the good things that uh they were going to do i don't know how they're going to do them
05:53:00 uh trump was saying it just got five trillion dollars worth of investment
05:53:05 announced in the united states 465 000 jobs we don't have the ability to do that kind of thing
05:53:12 but i'm not too sure that we have the ability to do even a tenth of that and then he moved on to
05:53:18 talk about the sacrifices and then i thought about the butter that's ten dollars a pound that's going
05:53:26 to be eleven dollars a pound and the gasoline they won't call it carbon tax but they'll make
05:53:31 it more expensive yeah there'll be sacrifices and all this uh purple prose is going to seem very
05:53:39 get adequate just give it a month so uh very soon we're gonna go to jen hodgson uh a reporter who
05:53:47 we have at uh i think what looks like probably pier polio's headquarters as soon as she gets 0.95
05:53:53 her camera right there i've seen her fiddling with it for hours i'm not sure when it will
05:53:58 work yeah yeah we're getting some blair witch vibes uh from there okay uh jen are you already
05:54:03 there uh hi yes i'm ready here and in fact i've been moving my camera around so that i can access
05:54:12 your texts and things like that i have been here the whole night i i'm aware but every time i look
05:54:18 down at your feet it looks like you're setting up your camera so that makes sense all right uh so
05:54:24 you're at uh polyevs headquarters yes i'm at polyevs headquarters we now have the cleaners coming
05:54:30 around and people picking up the chairs so we have nothing left to show you here tonight
05:54:36 we have been rather booked yeah yeah you're the last there uh yeah uh well we've had a lot of
05:54:43 guests we haven't had a lot of time to get our reporters in uh what was it like in the room
05:54:46 there tonight as paulia gave his concession yeah it was quite emotional near the end uh you could
05:54:52 see uh his wife anna on the stage she was visibly emotional uh proud uh his family paulia's family
05:54:59 was in the front row uh his mother was weeping um it was quite an emotional moment just because
05:55:07 of all the hard work that you could see that he put in uh over this past election campaign and
05:55:13 much longer than that too since he became the conservative leader in 2022 so a lot of mixed
05:55:19 emotions uh holly f put on a brave face got on the stage and uh and said you know we're not this
05:55:25 this isn't the end. We're not done working. We're going to keep going with all of the values that
05:55:30 we've put forward throughout this campaign. I mean, I guess, did you get a chance to talk
05:55:39 to many people in there? I know it's a real difficult time. It's a little premature. We
05:55:44 don't know if he's going to maintain his seat or if he isn't. But do you think there might be a
05:55:50 mood I mean for change I know they made gains they did well I mean when you crack down all those
05:55:55 numbers but really when you look at what people expected two months ago this was not what they
05:55:59 anticipated this this is not a victory for them tonight by any means yeah Corey you're right there
05:56:05 is definitely that sense of disappointment um as you mentioned the Carleton riding seat is still
05:56:12 up in the air so I think the last time I checked um it was maybe close to half the polls have been
05:56:19 submitted and poliev trailed by about five and a half percent so it's not looking great but also
05:56:27 there could be a lot of factors for that he very well still could pick up his riding he didn't
05:56:32 mention that in his speech but that is definitely something significant to look forward to hearing
05:56:38 about probably tomorrow now it's already tomorrow here in toronto in the toronto time zone here in
05:56:44 ottawa but uh we'll be able to get um a clear picture of what is happening in that carlton
05:56:51 writing i guess in the hours to come yeah did anyone mention something that we kind of flagged
05:56:57 earlier was that 44 000 votes were cast in that advanced poll and it's about 40 percent of the
05:57:06 total voter uh count for carlton so was there any talk on the ground that there was no sense of
05:57:12 worrying because of maybe some geo tv they had done around easter weekend yeah his supporters
05:57:19 still seemed confident that the seat belongs to him that he has that support in that riding so
05:57:25 among the supporters yes erica however among the other media there was a lot more skepticism
05:57:32 especially i spoke to one journalist who has focused specifically on the carlton riding and
05:57:39 she she was rather doubtful about how things are playing out we speculated about on those
05:57:46 advanced polls and it's not really known that uh liberal voters go out to vote in advance and
05:57:52 that's why those results are coming out already uh so it is it is a bit of uh it's a bit confounding
05:58:01 um and it's a bit of an upset really that he doesn't he hasn't secured his own writing the
05:58:07 the election night has come and is now gone there's you know chairs being set up taken
05:58:12 down behind me and the cleaners are going around and the journalists are unplugging all their
05:58:17 computers so it's really winding down here tonight and there's still that unknown factor
05:58:23 so i did not see that coming uh oh you know i just got a message from a buddy of mine he's
05:58:29 actually not very political but i guess somehow he ended up working as a poll counter for elections
05:58:35 canada uh he just said the they just finally finished the advanced bull counting that's
05:58:40 somewhere in calgary i want to find out what riding that was but uh because we've still got
05:58:45 calgary confederation is uh as a toss-up um and then um i meant it's under a stun oh what was
05:58:52 the other one you were thinking uh the other calgary one in the northeast uh portugal mcknight
05:58:58 yeah okay yeah uh conservatives are pulling up a bit there uh jen
05:59:05 i mean uh you're you're in carlton you're in polyam's riding he's gonna have a lot of fans
05:59:10 there um was did you get a sense of you know how genuine or not support was for him to continue on
05:59:18 as conservative leader yeah for sure actually derek it was very genuine when i was last night
05:59:25 at the carlton rally his last rally of his campaign it was held out at a farm in a rural
05:59:31 area in the carlton riding and i went around and spoke with many people in the crowd who
05:59:38 who said that they vehemently support polyev and you know many of them actually said that
05:59:43 they've watched him grow up that they've known him personally they've interacted at some level
05:59:50 and he's actually had widespread support um i've never really seen anything like it at the rally
05:59:56 last night uh the enthusiasm and just uh the heart the heart for what polyev is trying to accomplish
06:00:03 a lot of people said they were eager for that change that he's promising and young people i
06:00:09 spoke with several young people and some of them even still not old enough to vote but they're
06:00:14 already so involved i think uh we're getting our video compiled there so we can release it to our
06:00:20 viewers to see what the people of that writing actually are saying uh because there's a lot of
06:00:26 faith in what polyev is going for so that is actually another reason why i'm a bit confounded
06:00:33 that he hasn't secured his seat in his own writing now notable notably about that is that there were
06:00:40 91 candidates on that ballot which is just absurd well yes that is that is exactly
06:00:52 that's right that that is why it's taking so long and so you can ask oh is it just a coincidence
06:00:58 that there's that many names on the ballot or is there some kind of agenda or angle happening there
06:01:04 but yes that is why it's taking such an absurd amount of time and i've been told that the carlton
06:01:11 riding they started counting that in advance for that they got special permission for that
06:01:16 specific reason is because there are so many on the ballot yeah you can by rules i think it's an
06:01:23 hour two hours you can start two hours of advanced polls counting before that but even that i can't
06:01:31 imagine it's going to be an easy like task for anyone it's a lot to go through staffers are
06:01:38 earning their money tonight that's right or maybe they're the volunteers i don't know
06:01:43 but whoever is doing that hard work yeah it definitely wouldn't be an easy task
06:01:51 um all right uh anything else you've got for us from uh poly upset quarters there
06:01:57 Yeah, just the mood in the room when Paliyev was giving his speech, it did tug on the heartstrings a little bit just because you saw all the hard work that went into it.
06:02:07 But there is still a hope for what's next, which is difficult given the fact that the riding is still up in question.
06:02:15 So there's just a lot of factors that went into the mood in this room.
06:02:20 At the beginning, it was very energetic.
06:02:24 uh there were cheers that went out whenever um a candidate uh won the seat and they got that
06:02:32 check mark right because uh you see as the votes are being counted um it's projected winners of
06:02:38 the ridings but then when they got the check mark like jamil javani uh in the durham riding he got
06:02:44 his check mark i got a quick story up about that because he really just ripped into ontario premier
06:02:50 doug ford for supporting liberals basically three minutes of him crapping on doug ford
06:02:57 i think it was brilliant it was yeah it really got a lot of attention in the room especially
06:03:02 among the reporters over at the media desk yeah so definitely a notable evening right
06:03:09 that's right yeah and the cbc and the cbc pundit said oh well you worked with him as though like
06:03:14 why should you be criticizing him yeah and jivani said yeah i know i have first-hand experience
06:03:21 okay all right uh that's jen hodgson the western standard reporter that we have exiled to ontario
06:03:26 for the duration of the campaign thank you for your good work uh thank you let me go get some
06:03:31 oh you gotta file a story maybe but then you gotta get some sleep it's two o'clock in the morning
06:03:35 where you are already filed my story then sleep sleep it is all right all right thanks for having
06:03:42 me on everyone all right uh just a little update so my friend who was counting advanced uh advanced
06:03:49 polls that was calgary center uh so that's just been counted so those will probably start to show
06:03:55 up in the database pretty soon congress center uh conservative greg mclean still got a
06:04:00 five point lead so looking good for him could go sideways but looking good calgary mcknight uh
06:04:07 with George
06:04:09 Javall. That's a good spread.
06:04:11 It's a pretty good spread. For nine
06:04:13 polls, or 11 polls left.
06:04:15 Yeah, that one's not a lock for the Conservatives yet.
06:04:17 Looking good. It's probably advanced.
06:04:19 Yeah. Calgary Confederation,
06:04:22 1.9%
06:04:24 1.1%
06:04:27 separates Conservative
06:04:29 Jerry Monix and from Liberal
06:04:30 Corey Holcomb. So who's got the upper hand?
06:04:33 Corey Holcomb. Yeah.
06:04:35 Yeah, they tend to do better than the advanced polls
06:04:37 too. So it doesn't look good. And special ballots. Yeah. Yeah. So we'll see. We'll see the way that
06:04:43 goes. Do they even live in Confederation? I do. Okay. So you have another liberal like we can
06:04:49 complain to each other. Yeah. And Pierre Polyev is closing the gap. Three percentage points behind
06:04:56 liberal Bruce Fanjoy now. There's not been new polls coming in for a while now though.
06:05:03 like that's well in that writing that did those clowns did that long ballot crap so i mean yeah 1.00
06:05:08 counting votes when you got 90 names on yeah because of those idiots it's it's gonna make 1.00
06:05:13 it grandma's putting her glasses on going through them all and the confederation uh 1.00
06:05:18 the liberal leader was actually running against you know all the literature was against uh
06:05:26 i hope she's right sovereignty sovereignty yeah independence okay well uh we don't know
06:05:37 pauliev's uh we don't know paulio's writing but we have a pretty good idea of pretty much everything
06:05:44 uh the liberals will at most likely take two seats in alberta uh they had much much higher hopes for
06:05:53 alberta and what were they deeming six seven yeah uh some love that guy though they were talking up
06:05:59 to eight uh some liberals were saying uh publicly they're they were saying uh they had a real
06:06:04 realistic chance at eight they have one for sure possibly two that's it and one ndp and one ndp uh
06:06:13 NDP was at two.
06:06:15 In Edmonton, they're down to one.
06:06:19 Saskatchewan, total conservative sweep, except for the Churchill.
06:06:23 It's like such a big red thing, though.
06:06:25 Yeah.
06:06:25 Yeah.
06:06:26 Yeah, really.
06:06:26 Here, I'll show the map.
06:06:28 Thanks, Northern Saskatchewan, for, like, messing with the map.
06:06:31 Yeah.
06:06:31 I like nice, clean maps.
06:06:33 Yeah.
06:06:33 And you really mucked that one up.
06:06:35 Thanks a lot, Northern Saskatchewan.
06:06:37 That's a weird writing.
06:06:38 Like, so few voters actually there.
06:06:41 But, you know, writings of that massive geography, you give some a lot of that.
06:06:47 Yeah.
06:06:48 And then I guess Churchill here, that's always been a Nikki Ashton, long time NDP MP.
06:06:57 It hasn't been called yet.
06:06:59 I don't know how that's not called.
06:07:00 No, I don't know.
06:07:00 140 of 181 polls and the liberals.
06:07:03 So that's a liberal seat.
06:07:04 That's probably going liberal.
06:07:05 nikki ashton is long time ndp mp for the area likely going down she won't be missed yeah uh
06:07:16 so let's uh take out the map for a minute actually no the map back in i'm just going to show you all
06:07:22 toronto and ontario so uh conservatives picking up some ndp seats in uh in the northern ontario
06:07:30 like timmons area that is like ndp was religion up there that was blue collar union workers uh ndp
06:07:40 have fallen to 10 in timmons no no i'm okay with it like those are steel workers but weren't those
06:07:54 the ones that all endorsed yeah i was gonna say with the unions that endorse pierre i'm pretty
06:07:59 sure that that changes sudbury look at sudbury it's another one uh oh my god sudbury used to be
06:08:07 ndp northern ontario heartland ndp are eight percent that's the end of the ndp as a major
06:08:15 force in canadian politics when the ndp changed i mean those are labor writings those are union guys
06:08:20 these are lunchbox people who don't want to hear about a guy pretending to be a woman they're sick 0.96
06:08:26 of the woke crap too they want to wear they're worried about their jobs they're worried about 0.99
06:08:29 their mortgages feeding their family and for years the ndp that was their labor represented 1.00
06:08:35 representation was too busy off on these stupid social justice uh ndp uh jesus the ndp got a 0.97
06:08:42 single seat in ontario uh i'm not seeing it uh london they used to win seats around there gone 0.99
06:08:51 uh windsor all conservative uh london liberal and conservative hamilton center ndp in hamilton
06:09:06 center 28.8 percent that's steel town that's goddard dameron of the ndp that's the end
06:09:14 holy hell not a single ndp seat in toronto it's almost all liberal conservatives
06:09:21 pushed in on the margins you can see them uh kind of poking in but not obviously not getting there
06:09:29 not touching the water um they're gone i don't see single ndp where are the ndpc they're all in bc
06:09:38 Oh, oh my God. They kept that one in Montreal. That's okay. Well, I don't, I don't know Montreal politics. I can't, I can't explain that. Is that might be the only seat the NDP has in the East. All the other seats. There's one, one in Winnipeg Center, Winnipeg Center, Edmonton, Edmonton, Stratkona, and Island. Oh, there's one in.
06:10:08 Courtney Alberni
06:10:12 that one's still not secure though
06:10:14 they probably
06:10:16 hold it but I'd be not
06:10:17 and then one Vancouver East
06:10:19 whoever is Jenny Kwan
06:10:21 never heard of her
06:10:23 okay 1.00
06:10:25 she's a drug lover 1.00
06:10:28 okay
06:10:29 they're just all gone
06:10:33 but they came to us
06:10:37 mm-hmm well okay so uh let's talk about the governing scenarios here oh my god i thought
06:10:50 you're gonna say it's bedtime uh real soon but just um technically yeah they could work the
06:10:57 liberals could work with the conservatives that'd be a mega majority together of 312 seats
06:11:01 for about five minutes until the Alberta
06:11:03 and Saskatchewan MPs defect and
06:11:05 form an awesome block.
06:11:08 We would encourage them to do.
06:11:10 Yeah. They can work
06:11:11 and form a comfortable majority with the block.
06:11:14 That's 100. So you need 172
06:11:15 tweets. Based on his speech, that is
06:11:17 his play. Like, so
06:11:19 hard.
06:11:23 Oh, I thought
06:11:23 his speech about, like, if you were listening
06:11:25 to what he was saying in French.
06:11:28 Yeah.
06:11:28 then he has two realistic options block or ndp or ndp with elizabeth may uh because you need
06:11:42 it there's a third option he goes it alone and just does it on a case-by-case basis which is
06:11:48 pretty much how harper did it in 2006. i i think it's unlikely he does a formal deal the way trudeau
06:11:53 and sing did i don't think that's happening but you need a general dance partner uh harper
06:11:58 was able to mostly govern with the NDP, sometimes with the Bloc, and rarely once in a while
06:12:03 with the Liberals.
06:12:04 Well, that's what you do in minority government.
06:12:08 Every day you're thinking that it's, this could be the time when we go to a staff election.
06:12:13 We're going to lose confidence and we'll be off.
06:12:15 But he has two real dance partners here.
06:12:18 The Bloc, which is a clear majority, or the NDP, which would give him only 173, if these
06:12:26 numbers fold.
06:12:27 don't forget he's going to provide a speaker as well a speaker so now you want yeah he needs
06:12:32 a green now he needs the green he needs elizabeth may oh she can't be a speaker she's no no no no
06:12:38 but you need her vote so you need to buy her off sorry i just
06:12:44 that's a huge fu to alberta if those are your coalition neither like both of these are
06:12:51 uh recipe for gravity uh any thoughts on which of these kind of generally two options uh working
06:12:58 with the block or working with the ndp and the greens uh any thoughts on which of those is more
06:13:04 incendiary the blocks more incendiary to the west but i mean the ndp is not exactly appreciated either
06:13:12 i mean they're a rump now there's nothing to them i think we've just said what we think of the ndp
06:13:17 to actually then run the government with their help, especially after all that Jagmeet Singh
06:13:22 did for us in the last two years, that'd be pretty unpopular. I still think the way...
06:13:28 The NDP would be hesitant to work with the Liberals, like they were just punished terribly
06:13:32 for it. Did he not come out and whether he's the leader or not anymore, he said,
06:13:36 don't trust a Liberal, and that resonated in lots of NDP, you know, the bleeding orange groups.
06:13:44 who do you even do a deal with they don't have a leader anymore yeah yeah who gets to make these
06:13:49 decisions for them like who's in this negotiating room i think well they're going to elect an
06:13:54 interim leader probably yeah thanks but like i just mean don't get too sassy with me come on
06:14:01 i i think if i was doing this like and hearing what he said in his speech in the french components
06:14:07 about a distinct society and some of the cultural things and the official language like it spoke to
06:14:13 me that he had basically done what he did in the english french debate and said two different things
06:14:17 when he was talking in english and french and that his play is the block it's the only safe
06:14:22 thing for him do you think this do you think he can govern for 12 months regardless of who he makes
06:14:28 an alliance with you know what i actually think the conservatives won't push for it because we
06:14:32 need to re-strategize and reposition pierre or whatever that looks like um i think that there's
06:14:39 you know three months of either probation for what happens within the caucus um but also he his the
06:14:47 criticisms of pierre i think were just in the fact that he didn't show that he could be prime
06:14:52 minister-esque and in 12 months you probably dealt with the trump stuff so so uh we're gonna
06:14:58 work towards wrapping up here i think it's it's getting pretty late um i'll just uh let people
06:15:04 know in the comments we want to hear from you i'm seeing a lot of it already uh in the comment
06:15:08 section all night uh but we want to hear from you guys in the comments section does the west
06:15:13 want out is that the answer or uh you continue to slag it on and heather mcpherson will be the 0.98
06:15:21 interim leader it's actually not the worst night uh she's probably the only one whose name i can
06:15:27 remember i don't i don't know the name of a single other ndtmp no um okay but anyway let
06:15:32 let us know in the uh let us know in the comment section does the west want out uh so okay let's
06:15:39 kind of go around to final uh maybe kind of final thoughts uh no we don't even have your camera
06:15:45 working sorry i would go to uh welfare uh welfare uh wolf but just say watch who he puts in the
06:15:53 cabinet what's jibble what's real and what champagne and what portfolios they get because
06:15:58 that's going to determine what the judgment is all right nigel final thoughts for the evening
06:16:05 yeah all right i mean this is not a new thought we've written this several times but here's the
06:16:11 proof it's a very different mindset back in uh in eastern canada i don't think that pierre should
06:16:19 slink away feeling like he's failed we've gone from 99 seats in 2015 to 121 in 2019 to 119 in
06:16:29 2021 to 147 and that is that is building it shows growth there's a direction there next election
06:16:39 it goes over the edge but we gotta wait and see what mr carney actually decides to do
06:16:45 with the victory that he's got and he has the choice between doing things that satisfy western
06:16:54 aspirations or just talking about it and doing the complete opposite i fear that and if that's what
06:17:02 happens um like ted morton said we've got some really interesting times ahead of us
06:17:10 corey your final thoughts on the election tonight i don't give a what happens in ottawa anymore
06:17:14 i i've been through this i'm 54 now it's been the same story it's been the same story for my parents
06:17:21 central canada buggering the west this is a scandal-plagued government that doubled the debt
06:17:28 that uh has been an international embarrassment that somehow they cut the head off and stick
06:17:36 somebody else on and toronto said oh cool we'll give you another crack at it no you know what i'm
06:17:40 done i'm done we got to look out for ourselves out here because they're not going to look out
06:17:45 for us out there uh they're playing that game but you're playing us on this with a stacked deck
06:17:50 and uh you know i i wish the best i know paulia means well and there's a lot of good conservatives
06:17:55 in ontario but we're not going anywhere this way we're just running on ice and and sliding so i
06:18:01 know i'm i'm looking at what we can do in the west ourselves i'm i there's no sense wasting
06:18:06 more energy and money trying to win the east erica i think carney's gonna have to pivot one
06:18:13 he's got to pick his team in the next 30 days so i i think he's gonna try and play nice and play
06:18:22 very stalwart um-esque but i i don't think we should look kindly or expect anything from him
06:18:31 so onward and upward
06:18:34 yeah all right um
06:18:40 we tried uh but honestly i don't think a conservative government actually fixes the
06:18:52 critical problems i think the problems in canada are so deep so structural they're baked into the
06:18:58 constitution that the west is just never going to get a fair shake no matter who's elected
06:19:03 the conservatives would screw us less than anyone else and they would at least say thank you for the
06:19:10 money they take they're at least appreciative of it um they don't want to stop us from developing
06:19:17 our resources they want to be able to milk the west and they say thank you for it now that's
06:19:23 appreciated, I guess. But, you know, Polyev promised no change to equalization. Harper could
06:19:31 make changes to equalization substantially, because it's required to build a national
06:19:38 winning conservative coalition. Still not enough. The East just doesn't get it. And they've just
06:19:45 voted to keep doing
06:19:47 what we've been doing. And I feel
06:19:49 like Alberta, Saskatchewan,
06:19:53 a bunch of
06:19:53 B.C., I feel like
06:19:55 we're tied to a drowning man
06:19:57 who's intent on diving
06:19:59 deeper. And at some point
06:20:01 you just got to cut them loose.
06:20:03 Let them, they've made their choice and that's fine.
06:20:05 Wish them the best. Interesting way
06:20:07 you put that, Derek.
06:20:09 I'm still trying to understand how a dying
06:20:11 man dies deeper.
06:20:12 They are thinking about us. Dying, not
06:20:14 there. Sorry, what?
06:20:16 It's as if you think that they
06:20:19 are even thinking
06:20:20 about us.
06:20:23 Yeah, I just
06:20:25 don't think they thought that there's
06:20:26 a country west of
06:20:29 Mississauga.
06:20:32 All right. Well, it's been a
06:20:34 slice. We've had some really stellar
06:20:36 guests. We've been booked really solid.
06:20:39 I've actually felt a bit bad sometimes
06:20:40 getting everybody on airtime.
06:20:43 But
06:20:43 But thank you all, Nigel, Corey, Erica, Sean, John, Dave is gone, and our reporters, Jen, Jared, James, Oldcorn, and all the guests who joined us.
06:20:59 I think all of you. I'm humbled by just the huge number of people we've had watching us following along tonight.
06:21:07 and you could have selected the big state-supported networks you've chosen to spend
06:21:14 this important evening with the Western Standard. I can tell you that we have a mission ahead of us
06:21:20 as, I think it's fair to say, the largest Alberta-owned and operated media organization
06:21:29 in either Alberta or Saskatchewan. We have a mission of providing a voice for Western interests
06:21:35 and concerns that get overshadowed by the Eastern-owned corporations.
06:21:42 You're going to have a lot more to hear from what we have to say in the coming days, weeks,
06:21:47 and months, and I hope that you'll be with us. We've taken down the paywall during this election
06:21:54 because so many of you stepped up and donated so that we could make the Western Standard free
06:21:59 for every voter in Canada to read. That paywall goes back up, maybe tomorrow, maybe the day after.
06:22:07 But we need your support. If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard,
06:22:11 we need you to step up and support homegrown, independent Alberta, Saskatchewan, BC and
06:22:17 Manitoba Western media. Go to westernstandard.news before you go to bed tonight, click on subscribe.
06:22:24 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year to get you full access to all Western standard content, and you'll be helping to support the West's leading independent voice.
06:22:34 Thank you very much for joining us tonight, and God bless the West.