Western Standard - July 11, 2024


Elizabeth May running again “because Boomers F**@cked the planet”

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Trudeau Addresses NATO on Climate Change Who Is The Real US Commander In Chief?

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

162.13

Word count

7,083

Sentence count

398

Harmful content

Misogyny

13

sentences flagged

Toxicity

27

sentences flagged

Hate speech

13

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Western Standard's Derek Fildebrandt and Corey Morgan Ganaford discuss the dumbest thing Justin Trudeau has ever said, and the candidates who could have said it, but didn't even bother to write it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day. Today is July 10th, 2024. I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:00:28 you're watching the pipeline as always i'm joined by western standard opinion editor
00:00:34 nigel hannaford howdy howdy and western standard uh senior alberta callus cory morgan yahoo
00:00:42 there we go you're really into it oh yeah i i got uh bugged by these guys for not having my uh
00:00:47 kind of lid on for the show but i've been wearing it for days and i got like a rim
00:00:53 forming i got like marks forming around my forehead i just that's worse than a stampede rumor
00:00:58 Well, I mean, we may as well end the show right there, folks.
00:01:05 How are we going to top Corey?
00:01:07 We're talking the tops of glasses for margaritas and...
00:01:11 Oh, salt.
00:01:12 Yeah.
00:01:13 Salt.
00:01:13 Yeah, I don't know where you were going.
00:01:16 All right.
00:01:18 All right, well, we've got a good show.
00:01:22 You're not going to believe it.
00:01:24 We're going to show the video to you as soon as we get into it.
00:01:27 You're going to love it. 0.78
00:01:28 It is, I think, the dumbest thing I've ever heard Justin Trudeau say, and that is, I mean, there is a video vault the size of the Library of Congress on that to go through, and Justin Trudeau is at the NATO summit right now, and our allies are extremely angry at Canada for being complete deadbeat freeloaders on defense. 0.90
00:01:54 A lot of pressure to increase defense spending. 0.96
00:01:57 And Justin Trudeau goes to the microphone and gave a written, prepared speech at length going on and on and on about how Canada is defending NATO by putting a carbon tax in place on its people.
00:02:13 That we are fighting climate change, and that is the most important defense that we can make.
00:02:19 God help us if Russia raises its carbon tax.
00:02:22 They'll overrun us in no time.
00:02:24 Elizabeth May, a federal Green Party leader, says she is running again as the leader of 1.00
00:02:30 that party because baby boomers, quote, effed the planet. 0.97
00:02:38 I'm trying to keep it a little more family friendly than... 1.00
00:02:40 There's six words you can't say on television, that old routine...
00:02:43 That's one of them, yeah, that's one of them. 1.00
00:02:44 Yeah, but yeah, she's running again because baby boomers effed the planet. 1.00
00:02:51 She said that in front of the National Press Theater. I mean, she's nothing if not colorful, green, green, green, colored green. 1.00
00:03:00 So it's an interesting remark we're going to get into there.
00:03:04 Saskatchewan, many of you know, we've got a lot of people from Saskatchewan here, is they refuse to collect the federal government's carbon tax ever since they brought in an exemption that most mostly just applied to Atlantic Canada and screwed everybody else.
00:03:21 By not collecting the carbon tax, they've brought their natural gas rates for consumers down to the second lowest in Canada and have cut their consumer rate by 25%.
00:03:30 So it pays to not pay Ottawa.
00:03:36 And as you see, all of us dressed up here for the Calgary Stampede.
00:03:39 And Pierre Polyev was in town barnstorming through, gave a beleaguer the metaphor a little bit more, gave her a barn burner of speech at the annual conservative barbecue.
00:03:51 You know, he did. And one of the interesting things about Mr. Polyev is that it's absolutely off the cuff.
00:04:00 There were no bat wings. There was no piece of paper on a podium. He just stood there and let it out.
00:04:06 I mean, I realize that this is a stump speech, and he has given something like it before.
00:04:10 Well, we're going to get into it when we talk about that topic.
00:04:13 What a performer.
00:04:14 Yeah, that was quite something.
00:04:16 So we'll get into a speech there.
00:04:18 All right, well, let's begin with a speech from his main adversary, Justin Trudeau.
00:04:24 As I said at the top, I mean, 0.96
00:04:27 And the candidates for the dumbest thing Justin Trudeau has ever said is, I mean, it'll take you longer to go through it than mapping the human genome. 0.98
00:04:42 But there is a new serious candidate for the dumbest thing he has ever said. 0.98
00:04:49 And unlike many of the dumb things he said, this was not off the cuff. 0.99
00:04:54 off the cuff. This was prepared remarks, speech written by people like yourself. You were a 0.98
00:05:03 speechwriter for... Not exactly like me. No, but you know, you were chief speechwriter for Stephen
00:05:08 Harper. He ostensibly has at least a nominal equivalent in his office, paid a bunch of money
00:05:17 to write things that make him sound smart. And this is what they came up with. Let's roll at
00:05:24 some of the highlights addressing a global problem like climate change requires a global response
00:05:31 a global response which we've been coordinating in close partnership with our 31 fellow member
00:05:37 states in nato our government has been a strong advocate for ensuring that climate change is an
00:05:44 integral part of nato's agenda and that together we act to make it a reality in 2021 the alliance
00:05:53 published the NATO Climate Change and Security Action Plan, a plan which recognized the risks
00:06:00 that climate change poses to NATO and pledged to take action to address those challenges.
00:06:07 In 2022 and 2023, Canada co-led a climate change working group with Denmark and Norway to identify
00:06:15 and establish NATO's climate research priorities. And we spearheaded the NATO Climate Change and
00:06:22 Security Centre of Excellence, which we were proud to launch last year. It will be housed in
00:06:27 downtown Montreal. This centre serves as a critical research platform to ensure that NATO
00:06:34 allies and partners are equipped with the information they need to succeed in a climate
00:06:40 changed world, to plan for and adapt to and mitigate the security risks and impacts caused
00:06:48 by climate change, and to forge strong partnerships with organizations like the Munich Security
00:06:54 Conference and the CDA Institute that are committed to addressing the security challenges posed
00:07:00 by the climate crisis. So today I'm excited to celebrate with you all the important milestone
00:07:08 for the center. Woo! That! That's a cooker, isn't it just? You know, that almost tops if a man
00:07:17 says he's a woman then he's a woman we were talking about different things that mr trudeau has
00:07:24 said to excite us all so the question there's a lot of questions about that the first one i would
00:07:29 ask is all right we're spending more money what did you get for it like in the he he accused the
00:07:35 harper administration of underspending under one percent well that was true of the last year we'd
00:07:41 just come off the afghanistan campaign and there were some things that we were not spending that
00:07:46 we had been spending in the previous years but all right what did you get for your money did
00:07:52 you get a whole bunch of new ships did you get an f-35 fighter plane i don't believe you did
00:07:58 we have a single submarine that can submerge well we bought them before uh i mean we need
00:08:03 to do but they still well they don't go underwater whatever they do the thing is we do not have a
00:08:10 bunch of new military equipment which is really what that two percent is all about and the other
00:08:16 thing that we don't have is people recruitment is plummeting because they have made the armed forces
00:08:23 into a social justice enterprise the social justice league yeah so there you go it's uh
00:08:31 it's it was absolutely pretty shameful i don't don't blame the you know mike johnson the speaker
00:08:35 of the house they actually called it shameful now johnson is third in line because president
00:08:41 the vice president if they're both killed mike johnson is effectively president so the third
00:08:46 highest guy in the united states accused canada of riding on america's coattails and said it was
00:08:52 shameful i reckon you'd find a lot of canadians who would say yes to that you know actually uh
00:08:57 just uh just the other week i took uh i was a family uh family cottage uh out east and uh
00:09:04 saw my cousin i haven't seen my cousin for about 12 years since he last time i saw him was just
00:09:09 days before he went to boot camp and went into the artillery as a bombardier and, you know,
00:09:18 proudly served in the forces. And I asked him why he left. He said, same reason as everybody else.
00:09:24 It's not the army anymore. It's a social justice daycare. This is a guy who was not political
00:09:31 before he left. Didn't care about any of this stuff. And, you know, we don't have an army,
00:09:37 Air Force and Navy. We've got a weird social justice league that incapable of defending us
00:09:44 from Denmark if they stormed Hans Island or something. So let's go to Trudeau's remarks
00:09:52 more specifically here, Corey. I mean, politicians are going to put the best spin on things possible
00:10:01 And, you know, they they want to answer the question they want to answer, not the one that was asked.
00:10:08 And everyone's asking Canada, like, when are you going to put on your big boy pants?
00:10:13 And, you know, you're I think someone put it this way.
00:10:15 Canada is riding a first class in a first class train with a third class ticket right now.
00:10:23 We're the laughingstock of data over just so far below our commitments we've made as a country.
00:10:31 spent on defense and his answer just going into um when i first saw this video i thought
00:10:38 this was just uh kind of a quick little deflection like well you know uh climate change is important
00:10:43 and i was like i rolled my eyes a bit but then the video kept going and he kept on talking and talking
00:10:49 and as you see is it is very apparent he might even believe this he might actually believe the
00:10:58 the words coming out of his mouth that Canada is defending NATO, keeping the Russians and the
00:11:05 Chinese at bay and the ran at bay by taxing people's home heating and gasoline. Do you think
00:11:17 he actually believes this or is this just pure deflection? I think he does. I think he's in a
00:11:23 cloistered, delusional world of his own making now. I mean, it's a reflection of a lot of what
00:11:27 we've been seeing in his politics in general. Even liberals are saying, this guy has got to get out
00:11:32 of here. We're done with him. It's not working. We're going to lose our jobs. And instead of
00:11:37 listening or examining, he's just gathering more nodding heads around himself who will
00:11:42 still continue to act as his political fluffers for him and keep him imagining that he's popular
00:11:50 and on the right course. I mean, he's ignoring other things. Senators, what was it? Over 20
00:11:56 senators a week ago sent a letter, they don't do this very often, before the NATO summit stating,
00:12:01 Canada, you have to start pulling your weight. We've had it with this. Yes, this is the opportunity
00:12:07 for you to say you're going to do something. And instead, he drifts off answering a question that
00:12:13 nobody asked him into something that's completely irrelevant to the summit. Who is going to
00:12:20 appreciate what he just said there, aside from maybe Greta Thunberg? But he believes his own
00:12:25 garbage. He's been drinking his own bath water, and it shows it when he's ostensibly represented 1.00
00:12:31 Canada at NATO. It's an embarrassment. Nigel, even his kind of natural allies around the NATO
00:12:36 table that are still there, you know, you got Joe Biden, Emmanuel Macron, Olaf Scholz,
00:12:45 you know, all left or center-left major leaders in NATO. They have essentially given a figurative
00:12:54 eye roll to this. And they're all global warming crusaders. You know, they take it maybe almost as
00:13:01 seriously as he does. But they understand that they're saying, well, that's nice. But how about
00:13:08 some guns and some ships and some planes? Because a carbon tax, you know, doesn't scare Russia very
00:13:16 much. This isn't even being received at all seriously by his own ideological allies within
00:13:25 NATO. They're telling him to pony up guns, not talk of carbon taxes. Well, you wouldn't expect
00:13:30 them to, would you? Really? I mean, that is not an argument that any of those people who you have
00:13:35 just mentioned would want to advance and take credit for, because it's just plain wrong. And
00:13:41 some of it is, apart from the fact that that is philosophically flawed at a foundational level,
00:13:48 it's not even honest. I mean, he'll say that we're now spending more money on defense. We're up to
00:13:55 one point, whatever, 3% or whatever it was that he said. Well, actually, one thing that they do now
00:14:01 is that they count veterans affairs under defense spending. So they added $7 billion and said, oh,
00:14:08 spending more money on defense but it didn't buy it look don't get me wrong veterans watching
00:14:13 veterans deserve what deserve their uh their pensions matters but it doesn't count as
00:14:17 but it is a country today it it is not a defense expenditure in the sense that buying a fighter
00:14:24 plane or even a parcel of new rifles is a defense expenditure and yet uh they just puts out this
00:14:31 number and expect oh well i'm spending more no they're not it's also worth noting that our real
00:14:36 GDP hasn't grown under most of the time Trudeau's been in power so you know spending as a proportion
00:14:42 of GDP I mean GDP is not growing very much so actually you know the the denominator is making
00:14:49 the number artificially big we're we're behind where we were relative to global GDP 10 years ago
00:14:55 oh and this is a should have been a relatively easy spend I mean if you're concerned about
00:15:00 Ukraine and things like that still participation in NATO is that deterrent effect it's showing
00:15:05 where you're at. Trudeau hasn't hesitated to give direct cash and equipment and things to Ukraine,
00:15:11 which people can debate whether or not that's a good idea or not. But Canada could do its part by
00:15:16 spending that money here and building its own defense force and taking part in NATO exercises
00:15:21 and things over there, which would be ostensibly more effective. And he could fulfill, but he would
00:15:27 prefer to cherry pick where he wants to spend these resources rather than put it into our
00:15:32 domestic defense it's just disconnected from reality yes yeah i don't know this this is
00:15:38 this one is uh like i mean if he was you know older i i could have been convinced this was
00:15:47 just a senile biden speech like it was just crazy which is it was off off the map yeah
00:15:55 you know one of the arguments that he made was that um climate change is going to cause
00:16:02 rising sea level and that's going to flood our military facilities i mean i i don't know who
00:16:10 goes over that and i mean there's a fact check well maybe that our submarines will finally get
00:16:15 underwater well that's true close the hatch guys there's a you know there is such a thing as a fact
00:16:20 check is this literally true and then there's just a reality check and that's the one that doesn't
00:16:25 seem to have been done here because long, you know, long before a skymalt is under 20 feet of
00:16:32 water, we're going to have sorted things out with a number of foreign powers who are bad for
00:16:38 business. It's just, I mean, who looks at this stuff before he gives it? 0.54
00:16:46 Yeah, I think he's lost the plot a long time ago and it's just getting increasingly sad and
00:16:51 delusional now all right uh speaking of uh sad delusional and past the prime elizabeth may 1.00
00:16:58 i mean for a hard lefty i got a weird soft spot for her because it's crazy as she often is 1.00
00:17:07 she's a rare genuine politician that speaks her mind and she did that uh she spoke her mind uh 0.97
00:17:16 I think it was, uh, I think, was it yesterday?
00:17:19 Yes.
00:17:20 Earlier today.
00:17:21 Yesterday.
00:17:21 Uh, well, first let's just show some of the clip of, uh, Elizabeth May.
00:17:26 Uh, she's at the, uh, the National Press Gallery.
00:17:28 It's, uh, it's a, it's a big room in the lower, uh, level of parliament buildings where, uh,
00:17:34 she announces that she is going to be running again and leading the Green Party the next election.
00:17:39 Let's hear why. 1.00
00:17:41 Baby boomers have f***ed this planet. 1.00
00:17:44 I mean, she's talking about her. She has another grandkid coming. I mean, I don't know how she's going to tell the grandkids to watch their mouth when they start using foul language around the house at Christmas. 1.00
00:17:57 But, yeah, because boomers, F you see something, something, ED it up. 1.00
00:18:08 Oh, F'd up the planet. 1.00
00:18:13 Okay, Boomer.
00:18:15 Some of you, Corey.
00:18:16 I mean, just her being angry that the, I guess, the carbon tax crusade,
00:18:25 When she entered politics, no one was talking about carbon taxes.
00:18:28 No one wanted it. 0.72
00:18:29 Steph and Dion tried it, got slaughtered.
00:18:31 Justin Trudeau gets elected without a plan for carbon tax, but then gets one.
00:18:35 And then it becomes established, so established, in fact, that Erdo Toole ran as a pro-carbon tax candidate as conservative leader.
00:18:43 The last federal election, obviously lost.
00:18:47 Many of us couldn't vote for a party, but that's carbon tax.
00:18:50 But she has gone from seeing government tax go from non-existent to so-existent that even the Conservative Party campaigned out at the last election to 2024, where its death warrant has all been signed.
00:19:05 Do you think she's maybe just very angry that kind of her life's career's work is about to come to a crashing halt in about a year?
00:19:14 I don't know. She'll always find something else to, you know, a windmill to tilt at.
00:19:17 I mean, she's always been a kooky activist, and she's still a kooky activist.
00:19:21 She's got her little base of support there in BC that will re-elect her no matter what the David Suzuki types, the champagne socialists. 0.93
00:19:29 And she'll say those just ridiculous sort of statements.
00:19:32 That's the leisure somebody has when you're not seriously actually thinking you're going to form government or do something.
00:19:38 I mean, it got her a bunch of ink when really, otherwise, who really cares what Elizabeth May says?
00:19:43 I mean, if she just kept on putting out rational, basic statements, nobody's really going to pay attention.
00:19:48 So if she tosses something like that out, well, we're talking about it.
00:19:51 She's not getting anything done. 0.99
00:19:52 She's just crazy Liz being crazy Liz. 0.93
00:19:58 Dodger, do you think? 0.95
00:20:00 Yeah, correct. 0.93
00:20:01 This is an important point.
00:20:02 We're talking about it.
00:20:03 I mean, if you said the same things but didn't say Boomer is effed up the planet, yeah, maybe there'd be no press.
00:20:09 i don't know she's she's getting some ache now um did you think it was maybe just very planned or
00:20:16 maybe just genuinely kind of despondent that you know she built up the green party got
00:20:23 became the first one elected built a small caucus that caucus is a little bit smaller but still
00:20:28 there um but as of october 2025 uh pretty much her her big uh achievement playing a big role
00:20:38 and the establishment of the federal carbon tax is about to be completely erased.
00:20:43 You know, Elizabeth May is a good person, but she is not reliable when it comes to policy.
00:20:55 And, you know, there are some great clips of her at public events that would also make a good play on the...
00:21:07 oh she's had lots of she's had lots of dingers so i would imagine that this was one of those
00:21:12 situations where she had prepared herself gone out there and then just said what she really thought
00:21:20 and in her view it like the prime minister she thinks that everything is about climate change
00:21:28 nothing else really matters it is the green party when all is said and all is done that's their
00:21:34 brand and her mouth ran away with her but uh you know yes we're talking about it but i don't think
00:21:43 anybody who is listening to that and talking about it is going to come away with the idea well
00:21:53 finally somebody is representing what i really think when she used the f word then i was with
00:22:02 her. I don't think that's how people come at that. They, you know, we all have adult
00:22:07 conversations. She caught attention by dropping an F-bomb in the press theater. 1.00
00:22:10 Yeah, but how much of that attention is going to be positive and how much of it is going to
00:22:13 translate into votes? I think so. No attention, media and attention is oxygen politics. You know,
00:22:21 they say money is the blood of politics. Well, attention is the oxygen. If you're getting no
00:22:27 attention, you don't exist. And I can't remember the last time I actually heard of the Green Party
00:22:31 in the press.
00:22:33 They've gotten pretty overshadowed.
00:22:35 Well, actually, it was just a couple of times.
00:22:36 Trudeau has out-lefted the NDP on Global Warming.
00:22:39 You know, that's a party, actually, it has made press,
00:22:42 but for all the wrong reasons, their internal divisions are significant.
00:22:46 They've been losing.
00:22:47 Deputy leader just left.
00:22:48 Deputy leader just left.
00:22:52 This is not going to save them.
00:22:54 No.
00:22:55 This was bad politics.
00:22:56 Well, I guess, before we move on to the next topic,
00:22:58 just a little just quickly chat about the green party because we never really think about them.
00:23:03 You know they're a caucus of just two but how do they get about 5% of the national vote it's not
00:23:08 insignificant. Is there still place for the greens now that because the the liberals have gone all
00:23:23 in on global warming hysteria and these kinds of things uh none of the lefty parties tend to talk
00:23:32 about basic uh conservation anymore protecting protecting uh yeah reasonable uh reasonable
00:23:39 policies for protecting endangered species and um you know uh certain environments uh
00:23:47 they they only seem to talk about global warming or climate change whichever they call it
00:23:51 But the liberals have gone all in.
00:23:55 They're as fanatical as Elizabeth May.
00:23:58 Actually, Justin Trudeau's comment saying that our defense policy is a carbon tax, essentially.
00:24:04 I mean, that's too crazy, I think, even for Elizabeth May to say at this point.
00:24:10 Are the Greens redundant at this point?
00:24:12 Yeah, well, they've been redundant for a long time because any party that is kind of a one-issue party,
00:24:18 You may elect the odd person just because they're a good candidate
00:24:23 or you want somebody to represent that point of view.
00:24:26 Actually, she represents the writing where my grandson lives.
00:24:30 You know, he's politically aware.
00:24:33 And he says, what, grandfather, what is she saying?
00:24:36 Like, what is this woman about?
00:24:39 And, you know, I have to say there is a place, maybe one
00:24:44 or two seats in Parliament for people who've got a particular issue that they really want to bring
00:24:49 forward, because maybe it is important. But she has been totally eclipsed. By the way, so has the
00:24:54 NDP. By the Liberal Party, it's just like the Borg has absorbed everybody. You know, they cannot
00:25:02 resist. So why would you need a Green Party? Why do you even need the NDP? Well, actually,
00:25:07 Single-issue candidates, actually, I'd say there's probably at least several dozen of the people who are mostly focused on a single issue.
00:25:17 They just tend to run in bigger parties.
00:25:20 You know, the conservatives, you'll have, you know, some people who are mostly just concerned with just abortion or something.
00:25:26 You'll have, you know, parties will have some global warming stuff.
00:25:30 But, you know, you've got, you know, a number of members of parliament who are just concerned about, you know, the cause of Hamas and anti-Israel stuff.
00:25:43 So, you know, single issue MPs actually, I think they exist in far greater number, probably a few dozen at least.
00:25:49 They just tend to land more successfully in the bigger parties that align maybe with their issues.
00:25:55 Well, then they've got to sign on to a number of other things as well and at least have an opinion and be prepared to defend them.
00:26:00 But for Elizabeth May, I don't know who takes her seriously anymore, other than the voters of Saanich.
00:26:08 I'm actually not convinced that her constituency is safe.
00:26:11 That area has voted Reform Party in the 90s.
00:26:15 I think that was Gary Lund's seat, right?
00:26:17 It was.
00:26:17 Yeah, Gary Lund.
00:26:19 You know, it was conservative up until, what, roughly 2008, circa, around there.
00:26:25 in a big conservative wave, possibly could go conservative.
00:26:32 Especially if she issues more statements like that.
00:26:36 People say, yeah, I agree, but no.
00:26:39 Yeah.
00:26:40 All right.
00:26:42 Well, let's bring it a little closer to home.
00:26:45 On the other side of the carbon tax here.
00:26:47 So Saskatchewan, Saskatchewan Premier,
00:26:51 Scott Bowe, I know you'll recall, how long ago was this, when the Liberals brought in
00:26:57 the carbon tax exemption for Atlantic Canada.
00:27:03 Oh, good Lord, that's before Christmas.
00:27:05 Yeah.
00:27:05 That last fall.
00:27:06 Yeah.
00:27:07 Yeah.
00:27:07 So, you know, they bring in, the Liberals brought this in, the Liberal MPs were lobbying,
00:27:13 or Atlantic Liberal MPs were lobbying for an exemption for home heating fuel, it was.
00:27:17 that's used overwhelmingly just in Atlantic Canada.
00:27:23 It's not used at any significant amount, really, outside of Atlantic Canada.
00:27:28 And they get this big exemption.
00:27:30 And I think it may have been on CTV.
00:27:33 You know, they were, a reporter asked, a Liberal cabinet minister from Newfoundland,
00:27:39 well, what about the West in Ontario?
00:27:42 Should they get an exemption?
00:27:44 How come they didn't get one?
00:27:44 And the Liberal ministers said something, I think, to the effect of, well, maybe they should elect some more MP, Liberals, and then they can be in the tent and ask for these things.
00:27:55 That triggered a pretty immediate backlash from Saskatchewan Premier Scott Bowe, who said, okay, well, we're just going to give ourselves an exemption here on home heating fuel.
00:28:07 Mostly natural gas, you know, west here.
00:28:10 So we're just not going to collect it. 0.91
00:28:11 Saskatchewan was able to do that where Alberta wasn't because Saskatchewan for very silly
00:28:19 reasons is still mostly got all these crown corporations running things that most of the
00:28:24 world realizes the private sector should probably do. In this one very unique set of circumstances
00:28:31 I'm kind of envious that Saskatchewan had a crown corporation because unlike a private corporation
00:28:36 the federal government can't really do much about it. It's a government entity so that it's not
00:28:39 not collecting the carbon tax. And yeah, the news just came out from SaskEnergy and the
00:28:46 government there. They've now brought their natural gas and home heating fuel rates down
00:28:52 to the second lowest in Canada, and a 25% commodity rate cut. Corey, and this comes
00:29:03 just, I think it was just yesterday, they succeeded in getting a stay from the courts.
00:29:08 The federal government is trying to garnish the accounts, the bank accounts of the government of Saskatchewan as if, you know, there's someone, you know, some guy who doesn't pay his credit card bill or something.
00:29:19 Papa Trudeau wants you to pay your bill.
00:29:23 I don't know.
00:29:25 I think we're getting here, Corey, a pretty politically useful data point that Paul Yev will be able to point to in the next federal election,
00:29:33 saying, on this one item that Saskatchewan did not follow through with Trudeau's policy on,
00:29:40 here's how much money it saved people. Now let's do that everywhere. Yeah, it hurts. I mean,
00:29:46 the beginning of the end of the carbon tax really was when Trudeau made that exemption for Atlantic
00:29:52 Canada, because that was his admission that, yes, it is actually harming the pocketbooks
00:29:57 of average Canadians. I mean, if it wasn't harming them, then the exemption wouldn't do
00:30:01 any good. So it showed that he's just basically, they've been lying for a long time, saying that
00:30:06 it's revenue neutral, saying that it doesn't harm people paying their bills. And that inspired
00:30:10 Scott Moe, who, as you said, is the only one kind of utility empowered to be able to say,
00:30:15 well, we're just not sending you that anymore, and we're not going to do it.
00:30:19 And the injunction was interesting. This is an interesting standoff, and it's one that
00:30:22 Polyev can play with, because he's not directly in the midst of it. But it's showing, you know,
00:30:27 again, to more Canadians that this carbon tax is harming them in paying the bills. And people are
00:30:31 struggling all over with, you know, utility costs on top of their mortgages and rent and everything
00:30:38 else. So it's a battle that Polyev is going to benefit from and utilize. And we'll see where it
00:30:44 goes. It's an interesting standoff. I mean, there's other ways the federal government can punish
00:30:47 Saskatchewan. They could start cutting transfer payments, but that looks pretty rough. You know,
00:30:51 if they cut a hundred million from the health transfer, Moe is going to go off the rails,
00:30:56 as well as our Saskatchewan voters.
00:30:58 So, yeah, Trudeau painted himself in a corner here.
00:31:01 Well, it's interesting.
00:31:01 It didn't stop Trudeau putting the rate up on April 1st as planned.
00:31:07 You know, right when we were all talking about 10% to 20% inflation
00:31:11 over the previous 18 months.
00:31:13 Well, here's a little bit more.
00:31:15 Yeah, that's totally like the old fanatic who won't change his mind
00:31:21 and won't change the subject.
00:31:22 Couldn't see his way forward to a different policy.
00:31:26 You know, I wonder if anybody has gone through the same exercise as I have, which is, what is this actually costing me?
00:31:34 You know, I got the NMAX bills.
00:31:35 You know, in Calgary, we have a company called NMAX.
00:31:38 For those who are watching from elsewhere, that's the people we get our natural gas from.
00:31:43 And to their credit, they're very good at breaking out everything that you're paying for.
00:31:47 So all the stupid little extra taxes, levies, charges, whatever it is that you can see how little you pay for energy and how much you pay for just about everything else. 0.62
00:31:58 The Hannaford household has this year, the first six months, paid $424.77 in carbon tax. 0.96
00:32:09 So I guess for the year...
00:32:10 Just for home heating, not for everything else.
00:32:12 Yeah, that's just for home heating.
00:32:13 This is the NMAX bill.
00:32:16 So for the year, it's going to be north of $800 because it's going up, not down as we go ahead.
00:32:21 And so to that, you have to add what you're paying in carbon tax on gasoline that you put in the truck.
00:32:30 And, of course, you can see it reflected through the price of your groceries because all the truckers and the farmers and everybody who has anything to do with bringing you food is also passing it on through.
00:32:42 But just taking that $800 a year, you know, folks, you know what your annual income is.
00:32:48 Do the maths.
00:32:50 If that's an $80,000, if you have a household income gross of $80,000, that $800 is probably going to be pretty typical of what you are spending on.
00:33:01 That's 1%.
00:33:02 That is a 1% increase in your expenses.
00:33:06 And that is on your before tax income.
00:33:12 if you're using my numbers.
00:33:13 This is an astonishingly large amount of money.
00:33:16 And for people who don't have that high gross income,
00:33:18 it's probably just the same
00:33:19 because it costs what it costs to heat a house.
00:33:21 Yeah.
00:33:25 It's the only time I've ever been jealous
00:33:26 of anywhere having a Crown Corporation.
00:33:29 I actually want to sneak in a little side topic here
00:33:32 with the LCBO strike in Ontario,
00:33:35 Liquor Control Board of Ontario.
00:33:38 I'm sorry, it's just so funny with their liquor store.
00:33:41 Whenever I go, like, so I was just back visiting family just the other week, and, you know, I never feel so superior and snobby as when I strut into an LCBO and, you know, look at, you know, here's the government-approved stuff.
00:33:58 It's got very limited hours, very limited service.
00:34:03 I was a student when I was in university, I went to Carleton University in Ottawa.
00:34:07 Remember, we wanted to go get some beers and liquor for New Year's Eve.
00:34:13 And the liquor store in downtown Ottawa closed at 11 o'clock on New Year's Eve.
00:34:19 And there was a lineup, like, almost around the block.
00:34:22 You had to wait for hours. 0.99
00:34:23 I mean, that kind of thing would start a damn riot in Alberta. 0.98
00:34:27 But Ontarians have got this bizarre... 0.99
00:34:30 They just break the windows.
00:34:32 Yeah.
00:34:33 Yeah.
00:34:33 Yeah.
00:34:34 I suppose that's...
00:34:36 That's our act of action.
00:34:36 Yeah.
00:34:37 Yeah, that's mostly peaceful.
00:34:41 But yeah, and then, you know, Doug Ford, you know,
00:34:44 hadn't done a lot of great, I'd say,
00:34:46 but he's at least cracking the window open
00:34:48 on beer and wine sales and grocery stores and stuff.
00:34:51 I mean, he should just go do what Klein did
00:34:53 and just say, oh, you're gone.
00:34:56 Sell the things, get rid of it overnight. 0.98
00:34:59 In Alberta, we, you know, we turned these parasites 0.98
00:35:03 of the state working in government stores 0.79
00:35:07 into entrepreneurs overnight because tons of these stores were just bought by the people working
00:35:10 into them they became they became capitalists overnight and then they became the defenders
00:35:15 of the private system um and just i don't know why ford doesn't go that way it's it's actually
00:35:22 politically easier than going piecemeal but yeah they're on they're on strike again one of the big
00:35:27 demands is that they stop private sales of liquor because only the government uh could do anything
00:35:32 right. And it was a Robin Urbach had a great column. Just the other day, just the opposite
00:35:40 of the union is making Doug Ford's case for him that no, they shouldn't have a monopoly.
00:35:48 And, and I think the headline was there was some activist organization that was saying that
00:35:55 alcoholics like street people were going to be dying if they couldn't get their access because
00:36:00 they were drinking something else you know i mean how many times have i said i'll try if i don't get
00:36:04 a drink but uh the and probably as many times as derek but um you know i i had i had to laugh at
00:36:13 that the whole thing is obvious a union shop protecting its turf pushing back at the first
00:36:22 sign that there may be a problem down the road like you said you should just do it it works great
00:36:27 or bend it off. Ford's got a simple win here. I mean, talk to any Albertan over 50 who got to
00:36:35 endure the warm beer from the cranky overpaid bums in the Alberta government stores, which were
00:36:42 six to a city the size of Calgary that closed at four on a Friday afternoon. Ask any and say,
00:36:48 would you like to go back to that? And you even the hardest of lefties. No, no, those days are
00:36:54 gone. This was a positive evolution. It's done. So Ford, you know, I don't think the Ontario
00:37:01 government has the marijuana stores, does it? They tried to. So when Kathleen Wynne was in power and
00:37:08 cannabis was legalized, she was going to essentially build ill CBO style bricks and 1.00
00:37:13 mortar government drugstores. Not a single one got built. There was a period where Bonass, 1.00
00:37:23 Little tiny neighborhood in the west end of Calgary had more cannabis shops than all of Ontario, because Alberta didn't do it the way Ontario was.
00:37:36 They did it private.
00:37:37 And that was under an NDP government here, because in Alberta, even the NDP knows, yeah, the government should probably not be selling the liquor and the drugs.
00:37:46 where they did try to have a private
00:37:48 government monopoly on
00:37:50 cannabis sales in Alberta was online
00:37:52 sales, which is the single most difficult
00:37:54 place to establish a monopoly.
00:37:56 It didn't work. I was in the
00:37:58 legislature at the time, and I told the Minister
00:38:00 of Finance, Joe Ceci, I said,
00:38:02 the NDP are the first people in the
00:38:04 world to lose money selling drugs.
00:38:07 But yeah,
00:38:08 even the NDP in Alberta would never
00:38:10 dream of going back to a government
00:38:12 monopoly. 0.99
00:38:12 it's uh it's nearly as dumb as a trudeau defense speech all right um well let's speak of a 0.99
00:38:20 talk about a different speech uh stampede season right now i'm about stampeded out uh i mean it's 0.98
00:38:28 it's fun but it's uh it's it's hard on you it's hard when you get older
00:38:34 hard enough at my age i can i can just imagine um so uh you and i went to go see the uh
00:38:42 polyab speech there's the big annual conservative stampede barbecue down at heritage park uh every
00:38:49 year it's one of the big fundraising events for that party every year um and the leader always
00:38:56 comes and speaks and uh this is a pretty good one i mean i don't think he said anything particularly
00:39:01 uh new i mean we've heard hundreds of polyab speeches they're more or less different but
00:39:08 But the tone of this one was particularly aggressive.
00:39:13 Took a pretty direct shot at Calgary Mayor Jody Gondek.
00:39:17 He's actually kind of, I've never seen a federal leader do this before.
00:39:20 He likes to go around to cities that have left-wing mayors and bash their mayor in their city.
00:39:26 Well, it's kind of a good reason to do that, because one of the characteristics of left-wing mayors is that they tend to see their city,
00:39:33 other cities like them, as kind of the new political center of culture.
00:39:38 And this has been talked about at the World Economic Forum and other places where people who mean well for humanity at other people's expense tend to gather and sort out what they're going to do next.
00:39:51 But the idea is that the city is really the place where all the big decisions should be made.
00:39:57 Well, no, that's not what our Constitution says.
00:39:59 and it but it is the basis upon which mr trudeau for example can go to the mayor of calgary and
00:40:05 say we'll give you 200 million dollars but you have to change your rezoning laws well i don't
00:40:10 know that anybody wants the federal government getting that involved in the rezoning laws in
00:40:16 the city where they live but that's how it works so really it is a good thing that somebody is
00:40:21 calling the mayors and the federal government on this kind of behavior good here i mean i'm a big
00:40:28 supporter anyway, but what he was on the right track there.
00:40:33 He was also in the stampede parade, riding a horse, I think
00:40:36 alongside his wife. I mean, not surprising that a conservative
00:40:40 leader is going to get a pretty warm welcome in Calgary, but it
00:40:43 was, it was a particularly warm welcome. Justin Trudeau, as far
00:40:47 as I know, has never, even at the height of his popularity when
00:40:50 he elected 2015, was smart enough not to go in the parade. I
00:40:56 it's Calgary. So normally he'd fly into town generally unannounced publicly and go to a small
00:41:04 curated very controlled event. I remember last year there was no notice given to the press
00:41:10 he just showed up at Calgary MP George Chahal's he had like a pancake breakfast or something for
00:41:18 liberals only and he came in did a little thing and left immediately. Only friendly left-wing
00:41:24 press were quietly tipped in advance, and he was gone. And so it's low risk, and he can say,
00:41:30 I was in Calgary, I was at the Stampede, sort of, you know, snap a picture. This time, he's not even
00:41:36 doing that. The media is actually catching on to the reason, some of the legacy media is catching
00:41:41 on to the reason you gave, like a week or two ago for this, which makes sense that he's a rebel.
00:41:47 So George Charles is a rebel. The one and only MP from the Liberals here, basically, is kind of
00:41:52 encouraging Trudeau to resign. So it doesn't encourage him to come out. Yeah, so he's not
00:41:56 coming at all. And I think also part of it, I mean, it's just, it was smart politics, do your
00:42:02 quick in and out show that you were there, but he's had a point to this little gain out here now
00:42:05 anymore. Well, they're going to lose Chahal's seat very, very likely. I think that's pretty
00:42:10 good money at this point. There's nothing electorally for him here. If he shows up to
00:42:15 anything, and it's not the most curated, protected event, which he's kind of lost now with Chahal
00:42:19 as one of the rebels in caucus.
00:42:24 Is he really going to expose himself
00:42:26 to the Calgary mob?
00:42:27 I mean, he would have been booed
00:42:30 and went at the height of his popularity in 2015.
00:42:33 Coming here in 2024, I mean,
00:42:35 I would not want to be in charge of the security detail.
00:42:39 No, it was one of the few smart moves on his part.
00:42:41 Anyways, when you got nothing to gain,
00:42:43 don't waste your time.
00:42:45 All right, well, we're going to wrap it there.
00:42:48 Corey, Nigel, thank you very much.
00:42:49 It was a pleasure.
00:42:51 All of you, I hope you're having a great stampede if you're in southern Alberta.
00:42:54 If you're not, you should get down here.
00:42:56 There's still some time.
00:42:57 The natives like me are tiring out.
00:43:00 The crowds are going to thin from the locals.
00:43:04 We're about out of energy.
00:43:06 My batteries are about done.
00:43:10 So if you haven't been to the stampede, you should get down to Calgary.
00:43:12 Enjoy yourself.
00:43:14 If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, go to westernstandard.news right now.
00:43:17 Click on subscribe.
00:43:18 it's only $10 a month or $100 a year, it is critical that if you want to support some of
00:43:23 the very last independent media left in Canada, media that doesn't take Justin Trudeau's media
00:43:27 bailout subsidies, then you need to support it. You'll get unlimited access to all Western
00:43:31 Standard content, and you'll be helping to support one of the last independent non-government media
00:43:36 left in Canada. Thank you very much for your time. Happy Stampede, and God bless.