Western Standard - June 17, 2025


Energy politics, immigration, and the crisis of the West

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Trump Fields Questions After Bilateral Meeting with Canada at G7 Leaders' Summit Not our war?

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 6 minutes

Words per minute

137.42

Word count

9,161

Sentence count

310

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

48

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Tony Abbott is the former Prime Minister of Australia. He served as the leader of the opposition from 2009 to 2013, and as Prime Minister from 2013 to 2015, as the Leader of the Liberal Party. In this episode, he talks about his political career and the lessons he learned from his time in office.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:00:28 I'm joined today by a very special guest, Tony Abbott.
00:00:31 He is the former Prime Minister of Australia.
00:00:34 He served as the leader of the opposition from 2009 to 2013
00:00:39 and as Prime Minister from 2013 to 2015 as the leader of the Liberal Party.
00:00:49 Welcome, Mr. Abbott.
00:00:50 I know what you're going to say. You're going to clarify what liberal means.
00:00:53 Yes. In Australia, the Liberal Party is a conservative party, broadly.
00:01:00 Certainly, we are the most conservative mainstream political party in Australia.
00:01:05 Well, you've got the Nationals.
00:01:06 Well, the Nationals and the Liberals are traditionally in coalition.
00:01:10 And I used to say that a National is a country Liberal and a Liberal is a city National.
00:01:16 So there's a difference in culture between the Liberal Party and the National Party,
00:01:21 but there's not normally a sharp difference in politics
00:01:25 and the Liberal National Coalition in Australia
00:01:28 is the equivalent of the Conservative Party here in Catter.
00:01:32 And if I may say so for the benefit of your listeners
00:01:34 who aren't familiar with Australian politics,
00:01:38 my government did two unique things.
00:01:40 First, we stopped a wave of illegal migration by boat.
00:01:46 We're the only Western government in recent times to have done that.
00:01:49 And second, we repealed a carbon tax, and that's pretty rare as well.
00:01:56 You did it before with Kool.
00:01:57 A government that genuinely repeals a carbon tax doesn't just pretend to repeal a carbon tax while leaving the worst carbon tax in place.
00:02:08 We had to give them that right in a start because any conversation I've ever had with an Australian about politics immediately begins with explaining that the liberals are not liberals as we would see it. 0.94
00:02:18 I think maybe a holdover from when the liberal parties coming from the British Commonwealth were classical liberal parties, which they no longer, they're now social democratic parties.
00:02:27 Well, we had much the same development in Australia in the late 19th century. You had New South Wales liberalism, which tended to be free trade liberalism, and you had Victorian liberalism, which tended to be big government liberalism.
00:02:43 And of course, in Australia, liberalism has developed more in a free market way, whereas
00:02:52 in North America, liberalism has developed very much into a big government movement.
00:02:58 Look, I suppose if you go back to the roots of liberalism, it's about human flourishing.
00:03:06 And some of us think that humans flourish best when most free.
00:03:10 others think that humans flourish best when most helped typically by government and I guess
00:03:18 you know this is one of those arguments which waxes and wanes and it develops differently
00:03:23 in different places but it is I guess one of those things that we humans will never get beyond
00:03:31 our disputes on issues like this where often enough there's something to be said for either
00:03:38 side uh yeah i i suppose i would probably understand the political nomenclature a bit
00:03:43 more than most people from canada because uh i know a few hardline libertarians here who still
00:03:47 call themselves liberals they're like i'm not giving up the term i think it's a pretty dying
00:03:51 battle in north america but i i get it uh uh also i i actually used to play footy uh rugby union no
00:03:59 footy rules football aussie in canada i played it i played in the ontario league and very very
00:04:04 briefly in the alberta league wow uh didn't i never knew that aussie rules was played it's not very
00:04:09 big no very big but uh i might have been a champion aussie rules player if i came to canada oh you
00:04:15 would have been the australian because i was a hopeless aussie rules player in australia there
00:04:19 were guys who were uh you know just all the australians were always stars on the team and
00:04:23 they um you know you over a couple years they admit they probably were not very good there
00:04:28 uh i've probably played half a dozen hockey games not not even that in my life but if i went to
00:04:32 to australia i'm sure i'd be a superstar just because i i theoretically know how to skate if
00:04:36 you could find an ice hockey rig in australia you do bloody well yeah yeah exactly uh okay so uh
00:04:43 i'm going to talk about your political career and you know how there might be parallels or
00:04:49 lessons for what's happening and what has just taken place in canada uh you served as the leader
00:04:56 of the opposition from 2009
00:04:57 to 2013. He formed
00:05:00 government in 2013.
00:05:05 I think you're aware, Kierpolyev has been the leader
00:05:08 of the Conservative Party of Canada here.
00:05:09 He was a very different kind of leader than we've had
00:05:11 for some time.
00:05:14 He was certainly more bellicose
00:05:16 and
00:05:17 populist than, say, Stephen Harper was.
00:05:22 Probably had a more
00:05:23 finely honed Conservative
00:05:25 platform than say Andrew Scheer
00:05:27 and certainly a hell of a lot more conservative than we had
00:05:29 with Aaron O'Toole, the previous
00:05:31 conservative leader
00:05:32 he was widely, widely
00:05:35 expected to win
00:05:36 a mega
00:05:38 sweeping super majority government
00:05:41 until the liberals swapped
00:05:44 out Trudeau with Carney and then
00:05:45 to the surprise of
00:05:47 pretty much everybody, the liberals came with a hair
00:05:49 of winning majority, Polyev did not
00:05:51 even win his own seat, he's now running the bio-action
00:05:53 here in Alberta in a very safe conservative seat
00:05:55 um do you think do you see any parallels between your time in opposition and uh and Pierre Polyev
00:06:02 and you know and if so what was the maybe the inflection point where your career has diverged
00:06:09 where you failed to win the election but you you did win in 2013 well it's far too soon to write
00:06:17 Pierre off because he's going to come back into the parliament we hope and almost certainly will
00:06:22 be the leader of the opposition. And while, yes, the election result was a dreadful disappointment
00:06:29 for the Conservatives, the Liberals certainly didn't have a smashing win either. They just
00:06:35 scraped back. Look, the fundamental point to make is that no election is unlosable. No election is
00:06:43 unwinnable. Every election turns very much on the circumstances of the time. And two, significant
00:06:51 circumstances changed between late last year when the Conservatives were 20 points up in the polls
00:06:57 and the actual election date. First of all, the Liberals swapped out unpopular Trudeau for
00:07:04 kind of fresh face, at least in a local context. And second, Donald Trump took office in the United
00:07:13 States and immediately waged what looked like a tariff war against Canada. New Zealand was not
00:07:19 threatening to annex Australia. No, Australia was not threatening to annex New Zealand. So
00:07:23 look, when people feel that their country is under serious threat, they tend to rally around
00:07:33 the flag and they tend to rally behind the government of the day. So I think Carney
00:07:41 benefited on two counts. First, he was a fresh face and people wanted to give him a chance,
00:07:49 a fair go. And second, he looked like he was standing up for Canada against the bully in
00:07:56 Washington. So I think that largely explains the loss of the election. Nevertheless, I've got to
00:08:06 say that as an anglosphere conservative it disappoints me greatly that there is not a strong
00:08:16 tough-minded conservative government here in canada and i think that's what pierre would have led
00:08:22 a tough-minded conservative government that made big changes to the energy madness
00:08:32 wanted Canada to take advantage of its natural advantages
00:08:37 in fossil fuel, didn't want to impose unnecessary costs
00:08:41 on people through all of these various carbon taxes
00:08:46 and other measures, and I think he also would have been
00:08:50 a very proud Canadian who didn't allow the constant dilution,
00:08:58 if you like, of core Canada, which is almost inevitable when you've got sustained record
00:09:06 immigration. And I think on these two critical topics, Pierre would have run a very different
00:09:13 and very much better government than we're likely to get under Mark Carney.
00:09:18 So I want to come to immigration, but first I want to touch on carbon tax. You've already
00:09:22 mentioned it here uh you repealed your carbon tax i sometimes we 2013 2015 well as well your
00:09:30 prime minister um at that time uh i mean carbon tax hadn't even yet become so-called popular in
00:09:39 canada we had them we had one in british columbia and it was at least for some time actually revenue
00:09:45 neutral uh it but they never stayed revenue neutral it became a revenue collector and then
00:09:50 we had the imposition of Alberta carbon tax and then a federal carbon tax on top um you know
00:09:56 Trudeau came to power 2015 not campaigning on a carbon tax but he just ended up doing one anyway
00:10:01 and then people accepted it Canadians are often like that don't accept the policy imposed without
00:10:06 a mandate because once it's there and the sky doesn't fall they they just go with it um and it
00:10:12 built such a consensus in the media and the Laurentian expert classes that by the 2021
00:10:21 election federally, even the Conservative Party of Canada under Erin O'Toole was running on a carbon
00:10:25 tax itself. One that was actually even worse and more interventionist than the liberal one.
00:10:31 Between 2021 and now, the consensus radically changed to the point where Mark Carney repealed
00:10:38 Well, at least the consumer portion of the federal carbon tax, the industrial portion is still there and it could get worse.
00:10:44 But you repealed it at a time when globally they were very much in vogue at all the major international conferences.
00:10:52 This is how it is to cure all.
00:10:55 How did you in Australia is not known as a major fossil fuel producer.
00:11:01 We are. We're the world's biggest coal exporter.
00:11:04 and until recently we were the world's biggest gas exporter as well we were we rivaled guitar
00:11:14 okay well maybe you are i just not known for it at least uh shame on me and for not maybe not
00:11:20 knowing it but um i mean but it plays less of a role as a proportion of its economy than in an
00:11:26 alberta certainly uh our three biggest exports are iron ore coal and gas so fossil fuels one way or
00:11:35 another are incredibly important to australia not lamb i can't buy lamb it's not from you or not
00:11:40 our agricultural exports uh are i think if you if you add up all of our different agricultural
00:11:48 exports, our beef, our sheep, our wheat, our wine, that all of them together would not be
00:11:57 more than maybe a third or a half of our coal exports in value.
00:12:03 Okay. So, but you took on the carbon tax, just as it was becoming very popular globally,
00:12:11 particularly in the West, where you're really the only places that oppose these things.
00:12:15 um how did you build a coalition against it when you're really swimming against the tide before
00:12:21 the kind of global tide have turned against these things global warming climate change hysteria is
00:12:27 reaching its peak um that's a difficult time to take on that issue was there a political cost
00:12:35 to be paid for it or was it a political winner well derek uh if climate change is approached
00:12:42 as a moral issue, the left wins. If climate change is approached as an economic issue,
00:12:49 the right wins. And what I said to people was, look, of course, we have got to respect the
00:12:56 planet. We only have one. And yes, I accept that climate does change, that mankind does make a
00:13:06 difference and that we should do what we can to reduce emissions. But I would always add this
00:13:11 critical rider, but not if it costs you your job, costs us our industries, and puts up your cost of
00:13:22 living. So I said that, sure, let's do what we can to reduce emissions, but let's not do it by
00:13:30 making a great big tax on everything, which is what an emissions trading scheme or a carbon tax
00:13:36 is. It's a great big tax on everything. And when I finally abolished the carbon tax about
00:13:43 nine months into my government, it was the one and only time in the last two decades that there
00:13:52 was a substantial fall in electricity prices. They fell by well over 10% in a quarter because
00:13:59 the carbon tax was making such a difference. So what you've got to do to win this argument
00:14:06 because people will often tell you that the so-called science is settled.
00:14:12 Now, I don't think that's true.
00:14:15 Any time you say it's settled, you've been very unscientific.
00:14:18 But nevertheless, it's hard to win an argument on so-called climate science,
00:14:25 but you can very readily win an argument on the impact of climate policy
00:14:31 if the impact of climate policy is to destroy your job
00:14:37 and to put your cost of living through the roof.
00:14:40 And every time there has been an election in Australia
00:14:44 where the centre-right fought hard on this issue
00:14:50 against the centre-left's climate cultism,
00:14:54 the centre-right has done well.
00:14:56 In 2010, in 2013 and in 2019,
00:15:00 we in the Australian Liberal National Coalition
00:15:04 fought hard on climate and energy
00:15:07 saying that we are not going to do anything
00:15:10 that is going to badly damage our economy
00:15:12 and in all three of those elections
00:15:14 we did much better than expected
00:15:18 and we had a smashing victory in 2013.
00:15:20 So look, politics is always about a contest.
00:15:25 If you aren't prepared to create a contest
00:15:28 on policy it becomes a beauty contest and what's the point of being in a beauty contest
00:15:36 particularly when politics is show business for ugly people um so you've got to create a policy
00:15:41 contest and i think the most important immediate policy contest is energy where
00:15:52 this climate driven mania for renewables is a form of economic self-harm. I'd put it even
00:16:02 stronger than that. In countries like Australia, we are on the verge of committing a form of
00:16:08 economic suicide by moving rapidly away from reliable 24-7 fossil fuels to intermittent
00:16:16 renewable power because while batteries and solar panels can run a house they cannot run a modern
00:16:24 industrial economy and yet that's what we're trying to do in australia and it's insane
00:16:29 uh that's a great segue to where i want to go uh with you know there's few countries in the world
00:16:38 that are as similar as canada and australia roughly similar geographic size uh vast tracts
00:16:45 of our country is for all intents and purposes not practically habitable for area of a land and
00:16:51 whatnot so we have you know thin strips of population and huge tracks of uh wilderness
00:16:57 wilderness now that's why we put it politely i guess in both countries um you know we're english
00:17:03 speaking westminster democracies federations under the crown yeah i mean uh i think the biggest
00:17:10 difference in our political systems is that you have a rational senate of some kind we have an
00:17:15 elected senate as opposed to a kind of a house of lords type senate ours is even worse than the house
00:17:20 of lords because it's it's not even based on if your parents did something if your great
00:17:24 grandparents did something of note ours is just did you donate the right amount to the liberal
00:17:27 party and it's a very powerful senate unlike the house of lords in britain which can yeah delay but
00:17:33 it can't deny yeah uh but overall there is but even the shapes of our economies are very similar
00:17:40 heavy heavy in the primary resource extraction and agriculture export focused i mean as an island
00:17:48 you're by necessity export focused but we're export focused um you know we've been struggling
00:17:56 probably one of the defining issues uh in canadian politics over at least the last 15 years has been
00:18:03 resource extraction versus climate change uh hardline environmental protection and the debate
00:18:13 appears to be swinging more back in favor of resource development wealth creation right now
00:18:19 away from kind of radical green ideology uh at least rhetorically the government the new federal
00:18:27 government here is rhetorically more
00:18:29 at least less
00:18:31 implacably anti-resource development
00:18:33 but it's still far too early
00:18:35 to see how it's going to
00:18:37 manifest itself
00:18:38 you know we have
00:18:40 actually it's a major Australian project
00:18:43 just south of here in the Crowsnest
00:18:45 Pass in the Rocky Mountains
00:18:46 I think it's
00:18:49 a metallurgical coal project
00:18:51 and there's you know
00:18:55 the opposition to is actually not even from the locals
00:18:58 they had a referendum there
00:18:59 something like 70% supported it
00:19:01 but then you've got folks in cities who actually don't live
00:19:04 anywhere near this kind of thing who are
00:19:05 up in arms saying this is going to destroy
00:19:08 everything
00:19:08 as is the case, it's not actually
00:19:12 the locals, city dwellers
00:19:13 but
00:19:14 what are some of the Australian lessons
00:19:18 in building consensus around
00:19:19 you also have indigenous
00:19:21 issues that you face
00:19:23 similar to us. It's another one of the major parallels, especially as it develops our economy
00:19:27 and resource development. What were some of the major challenges you faced that Canada also faces
00:19:32 and perhaps some of the lessons that we can take from the successes you have?
00:19:37 Well, Derek, I think that all of the Anglosphere countries face similar problems today.
00:19:46 Depending upon the government of the day, they deal with them differently. But I think all
00:19:51 the major Anglosphere countries have the problem of economic stagnation, a problem of social
00:19:59 fracturing and a problem of strategic peril. I think all of us are in a similar boat and
00:20:08 I think that at the heart of the economic stagnation is the politics of climate and I think at the
00:20:17 part of the social fracturing is identity politics.
00:20:23 So I think we've got to tackle both the politics of climate
00:20:28 and identity politics head on as serious centre-right politicians
00:20:35 and political movements.
00:20:37 And look, as I said earlier, if you approach climate
00:20:43 as a moral issue, you're on hiding to nothing
00:20:46 because if the climate really is changing
00:20:49 and we really do have to reduce emissions to zero
00:20:53 as quickly as possible or die, 0.60
00:20:56 yes, there's an imperative.
00:21:00 If the climate is changing,
00:21:02 I don't think it's changing that fast.
00:21:05 And to the extent that it's changing,
00:21:08 I think it's far from clear
00:21:09 that human beings are the key factor.
00:21:12 I mean, one of the challenges I always put
00:21:14 to the climate alarmists is, how do you explain the ice ages? Because it was a very different
00:21:20 climate then, and obviously human beings had nothing to do with it. I think it's far more
00:21:25 likely that the biggest impacts on climate are less atmospheric carbon dioxide and sunspot
00:21:32 activity and oscillations in the orbit of the Earth around the sun. I mean, it stands to reason
00:21:38 that the biggest impact on the Earth's climate is the sun.
00:21:42 So you'd think that changes there would be what matter most.
00:21:47 But let's put the so-called science of climate change aside for a second
00:21:52 and look at the economics of it.
00:21:55 If you try to eliminate fossil fuels,
00:22:00 not only do you make your energy far more expensive and far less reliable,
00:22:06 but you're also in peril just about every aspect of daily life.
00:22:11 I mean, look around this room.
00:22:13 There's plastic, there's glass, there's steel, there's synthetic cloths.
00:22:20 All of these are critically dependent on fossil fuels.
00:22:25 I mean, fossil fuels are the feedstock, not just of our power system,
00:22:31 but of just about all the things we take for granted in modern life.
00:22:36 I mean, these things that are ubiquitous and that every climate activist spends half his life on, these things are impossible without the oil and the gas that goes into making the things that comprise them.
00:22:54 So we've got to understand that this emissions fixation is going to cause us to live like the Amish or worse if we take it to its logical conclusion. 1.00
00:23:08 I think we just have to keep reminding people that energy is the economy, that you cannot have a community without an economy to sustain it.
00:23:20 And if we drive fossil fuels out of our economy, we are making modern life almost impossible.
00:23:28 I just think we've got to, I mean, I suppose if you're living in the city, you might think
00:23:34 that water comes out of a tap as opposed to a dam.
00:23:39 You might think that milk comes in a bottle as opposed to out of a cow.
00:23:44 All this stuff comes out of fossil fuels and we've just got to understand that.
00:23:50 Okay, I want to switch gears to immigration, kind of tangentially touch on it a little bit so far.
00:23:58 You know, wealthy countries are magnets for migration, legal and illegal.
00:24:08 There's been a huge shift in public opinion in Canada pretty recently, where we've generally always been,
00:24:17 It's been verboten to even talk about having even a mid-level of arrivals, but we just essentially abandoned all controls whatsoever, and we had wild numbers of people just pouring in to a saturation point that we simply couldn't absorb.
00:24:38 but it's contributed, it's been one of the major
00:24:40 contributing factors to the housing crisis,
00:24:42 cost of living crisis.
00:24:45 You know, we're
00:24:46 not just taking the cream of the crop
00:24:48 from other countries now.
00:24:50 Some ways we're scraping the barrel.
00:24:52 We're getting people who are not good
00:24:54 candidates to become members
00:24:56 of Western civilization.
00:24:59 But that's a very
00:25:00 recent
00:25:00 transformation of public opinion in Canada where anyone
00:25:04 who even, if you even mentioned it
00:25:06 in any context other than Moore,
00:25:09 you were called a racist, the xenophobe, 0.96
00:25:10 bigot. Now even 0.82
00:25:12 the Liberals are backing away from what they've done.
00:25:15 The Conservatives
00:25:17 will raise questions about how the Liberals are coming
00:25:18 along on their targets and they'll say, well, you're a racist.
00:25:21 Some of their rhetoric
00:25:22 hasn't changed. But you cracked
00:25:24 down on a lot of illegal
00:25:26 migration,
00:25:28 which by necessity has to walk
00:25:30 across the border into Australia.
00:25:33 What kind of political
00:25:34 pushback did you get
00:25:36 for that, because that was at a time, actually, it would have been just at the time when the
00:25:43 migration consensus in Europe was just changing. Angela Merkel had just bullied her EU partners
00:25:49 into throwing open the gates and allowing tons of so-called refugees, many of which were not
00:25:56 legitimate refugees, just to pour into Germany and to pour into the rest of Europe, straining 1.00
00:26:01 social services straining housing and obviously creating major major cultural issues as well
00:26:07 um but you were kind of at the tip of the spear there before there had been a i don't know what
00:26:13 kind of were australians already on that on that page or were you kind of uh going against the
00:26:19 grain by cracking down on migration at that time well what i cracked down on was illegal migration
00:26:25 by boat and the problem with illegal migration by boat is a it's illegal but b it's also very
00:26:35 dangerous because you get a lot of people drowning at sea so by stopping it you are actually being
00:26:41 a humanitarian we'd had a wave of illegal migration by boat in the late 1990s which
00:26:49 which was effectively stopped by the Howard government.
00:26:53 There was a change of government in 2007
00:26:55 and the incoming Labor government reversed the Howard government policies,
00:27:03 which had stopped the boats.
00:27:04 And naturally enough, the boats started up again.
00:27:08 And in the six years of the Labor government,
00:27:11 a trickle of illegal migrant boats ultimately became a flood.
00:27:16 and I said in opposition that we would stop the boats.
00:27:23 I said we would do it by any and all means in our power,
00:27:29 including turning boats around and sending them back to Java,
00:27:34 which is where 99% of them were coming from.
00:27:37 And the response of the then Labor government was to say,
00:27:40 A, it's immoral, B, it's illegal, and C, it would cause tension, perhaps even conflict with Indonesia. 0.99
00:27:50 And I said, well, I'm sorry, a country which loses control of its borders has ultimately lost control of its sovereignty.
00:27:59 It's ultimately subject to a peaceful invasion, and no self-respecting country can put up with that.
00:28:05 So when I was elected in 2013, I said that we were implementing these strong border protection policies.
00:28:18 One stage, I was told that we'd had advice that this was against international law.
00:28:24 And I said, well, let's get better advice, which we did.
00:28:28 One lawyer says X, you can normally find another lawyer to say Y.
00:28:33 and what we called Operation Sovereign Borders
00:28:39 essentially involved stopping these illegal boats
00:28:43 on the high seas
00:28:45 and instead of bringing them to Australia
00:28:48 which is what had happened under the previous government
00:28:50 we would send them back to Indonesia 1.00
00:28:54 Now, the people of Smokeless were smart
00:28:57 so they soon worked out
00:29:00 that when an Australian naval or customs vessel hove into view,
00:29:05 they would scuttle their ships and our sailors, 0.88
00:29:09 being decent human beings, would pick them up.
00:29:14 The expectation was we'd then take them to Australia.
00:29:18 Well, no, we had a different plan.
00:29:21 We put them in a mothership, kept them at sea,
00:29:25 And then on a suitably calm night would put them into unsinkable orange life rafts, take them to within a mile or two of Indonesian territorial waters with just enough fuel to get back to Indonesia.
00:29:40 So that's a good one.
00:29:42 And that's what happened.
00:29:44 So look, you know, within maybe three or four months of coming into office, the illegal boats completely stopped.
00:29:53 And from early 2014 until, I think, 2022, when the government changed, there wasn't a single illegal boat.
00:30:05 We've had a few illegal boats since then, not very many, because the new Labor government, to its credit, having been ferociously opposed to our policies when we put them forward and when we implemented them,
00:30:20 And they reluctantly conceded that that actually worked.
00:30:25 And while I think there would be some pressure inside the green left to go back to what are effectively open borders, the more sensible people in the current government know that this would be political suicide.
00:30:38 And so any illegal boats that have made it to Australia, the occupants have swiftly been deported, which is the only way to approach this.
00:30:51 So, look, we sorted illegal migration by boat.
00:30:55 What we haven't sorted is mass legal migration.
00:31:00 Yeah, that's where I want to go.
00:31:01 And over the last decade, legal migration has gone up
00:31:07 from about $200,000 a year to about a half a million a year.
00:31:11 Even at $200,000 a year, it was far too high.
00:31:15 At half a million a year, it's just putting massive downward pressure
00:31:20 on wages, massive upward pressure on housing costs,
00:31:25 severe strain on physical and social infrastructure,
00:31:30 and yes, there are also integration issues
00:31:35 with some of the people who are coming
00:31:37 and I think what we need to do
00:31:40 is first radically scale back the numbers
00:31:45 and second, be much more insistent
00:31:48 with all of our migrants
00:31:50 that if they're coming to Australia,
00:31:52 they've got to join Team Australia.
00:31:55 They can't simply live in Hotel Australia.
00:31:58 Australia has flourished as a country with a predominantly Anglo-Celtic culture
00:32:04 and a country with an overwhelmingly Judeo-Christian ethos
00:32:08 they are both precious
00:32:11 they have to be preserved
00:32:13 and no one should come to Australia 0.99
00:32:16 without an expectation of living
00:32:19 in an Anglo-Celtic culture with a Judeo-Christian ethos
00:32:23 and we've got to be crystal clear about that
00:32:26 yeah uh i mean canada doesn't have or didn't have quite the same issue with illegal migration
00:32:33 because uh the boat uh like how would you get to canada by flow it's a very long journey i mean
00:32:38 it's it's a bit further from uh afghanistan to canada by boat is a pretty big trip yeah it's
00:32:45 a little further than java to uh queen sorry what's the one christmas island okay java to 0.88
00:32:52 Christmas Island is about 200 miles.
00:32:54 Yeah, so it's a bit more of a jump.
00:32:57 So, you know, we've had some illegal migration,
00:33:00 but it's generally people who are being kicked out of the states
00:33:03 because they're illegal migrants there.
00:33:05 And then, you know, they trade us over the border.
00:33:06 They just declare MBG status,
00:33:08 and our bureaucracy is too overwhelmed to be able to process that.
00:33:11 But it's a relatively small number.
00:33:13 It's legal migration. 0.61
00:33:15 It was very high for a long time, even under Stephen Harper,
00:33:18 but it was a generally merit-based system.
00:33:21 had a bunch of family re-indication stuff
00:33:22 which is problematic because you'd bring
00:33:25 over older people who've never paid into the social system 0.93
00:33:27 and then they're on the healthcare system
00:33:28 but it was at least manageable
00:33:31 but then legal
00:33:33 migration like in Australia 1.00
00:33:35 has just peaked
00:33:37 far beyond any previous records
00:33:39 completely swamped things
00:33:41 same issues with housing
00:33:43 downward pressure on wages
00:33:45 but also now major
00:33:47 cultural conflict we're starting to see 0.84
00:33:49 because we're we used to be on a merit-based system we were attracting at least the upper
00:33:54 crust or upper mid-level crust of people in other countries uh which isn't very good for those
00:33:59 countries when we're sucking all the best away from them to begin with but uh we're not getting 0.65
00:34:04 just the best now and uh it's not it's just not very compatible uh in general and so it is
00:34:12 taking people like me who used to be pretty unabashedly pro reasonable levels of migration
00:34:18 And to the point where I think we need to pretty much seal the border for a decade with, yeah, we'll take your top engineers and doctors, we'll take like 5,000 people a year of the absolute cream of the crop.
00:34:29 We'll take refugee nuclear scientists from Iran or something, you know, where we've just got to almost stop migration for at least a period of a decade to digest it and catch up. 0.98
00:34:41 And Australia is facing a similar issue.
00:34:43 You're making very good points.
00:34:44 I mean, like Canada, Australia is an immigrant society, and the glory of Australia is that people have been able to come here from all over the world and make a wonderful living for themselves and for their kids.
00:34:59 but just at the moment as I said it's getting almost completely out of control
00:35:07 mostly because government has effectively subcontracted out immigration to educational
00:35:16 institutions that use overseas students as the cashed out have become part of their business 0.87
00:35:21 model, at the heart of their business model, and to, I think, slightly unscrupulous businesses
00:35:29 that would rather import people from overseas, allegedly on a short-term basis, than pay
00:35:38 locals what the locals would expect to do the relevant job, or to train up locals to
00:35:45 do the relevant job. So essentially, we've been bringing people in often to do relatively short
00:35:53 term English language courses, to work in menial jobs. Most of them are managing to stay one way
00:36:03 or another. I don't blame them for wanting to come to Australia. Who wouldn't? I don't blame
00:36:09 them for wanting to make a good life in Australia who shouldn't but at these numbers it's just not
00:36:17 fair to the Australians who are already here because of the impact on wages, the impact on
00:36:23 housing, the impact on infrastructure and yes the impact on social cohesion because at least some of
00:36:31 the recent migrant communities have tended to bring their troubles with them, to bring their, 1.00
00:36:39 if you like, prejudices with them. And I dare say many people in Canada noticed the
00:36:45 day of infamy, October the 9th, when you had a large and angry crowd gather outside the Sydney
00:36:53 Opera House screaming obscenities against Jewish people and shouting what sounded very much like
00:37:00 gas the Jews. Now, that was largely recent immigrants to our country. I guess you've 1.00
00:37:09 got an unholy alliance between recent immigrants from Muslim countries and the cultural Marxist 1.00
00:37:19 left which sees Israel as a settler colonialist obscenity and sees Jewish people as manifestations
00:37:32 of white privilege etc. So you've got this ugly alliance which has produced a real
00:37:40 outpouring of anti-Semitism or Jew hatred in our country which I think is
00:37:46 Well, it's sad, it's despicable, it's un-Australian, and it's been exacerbated by migration. 0.99
00:37:55 yeah and we've
00:37:57 seen it right across
00:37:58 the western world
00:38:00 it is just a bizarre
00:38:03 alliance where you've got people who are
00:38:05 practically medieval
00:38:07 barbarians
00:38:08 by
00:38:10 depending on how you're defining the political spectrum you could put
00:38:13 them as the furthest possible right
00:38:15 in some kind of way I guess
00:38:17 allied with cultural Marxists
00:38:21 but it's
00:38:23 yeah it's a whole other topic
00:38:25 Look, it's, I mean, what are we going to do here?
00:38:30 I mean, we've got to get back to common sense.
00:38:34 And a common sense view is that countries like Australia, Canada, Britain, America,
00:38:42 are the least racist, most colourblind countries on earth.
00:38:46 And yes, if you look back into our history, there was the British Empire, there was slavery,
00:38:52 there was Indigenous dispossession.
00:38:54 and other than slavery I think there's a lot to be I mean let's put slavery to one side
00:39:02 which was a dreadful blot on America but Indigenous people in Australia in the long 1.00
00:39:11 run are much better off thanks to British settlement yeah I presume the same as it's 1.00
00:39:16 very much the same we don't we don't like to admit it but it's true the British Empire yes
00:39:22 there were exploitative elements yes there was a degree of paternalism maybe even racism
00:39:28 but in the end the british empire has been good for the world parliamentary democracy the rule of
00:39:36 law respect for human rights all of these things were byproducts well even slavery it was the first
00:39:44 major power to end slavery the royal declare little war on it the royal navy spent the best 0.80
00:39:50 part of a century stamping out the transatlantic slave trade and thousands of british sailors
00:39:58 untold wealth was consumed in this essentially moral project to stamp out slavery i mean much
00:40:09 of the british empire in africa was a result of the flag following missionaries who were there
00:40:15 specifically to stamp out man's inhumanity to man,
00:40:19 of which slavery is the most obvious and gross manifestation.
00:40:24 So, honestly, we should be so proud of our record.
00:40:32 And Britain in particular, no country on earth has had more impact
00:40:38 on the modern world for good than Britain.
00:40:40 I mean, when you think of the mother of parliaments,
00:40:42 the industrial revolution the emancipation of minorities all that the world's common language
00:40:51 all originated in britain and yet there's this epidemic of self-doubt even self-loathing
00:40:59 across the anglosphere right now and it must end because in the end
00:41:05 national
00:41:07 self-loathing
00:41:09 is just as toxic as
00:41:11 personal self-loathing. I mean,
00:41:13 low self-esteem is
00:41:15 personally poisonous
00:41:17 and low national self-esteem
00:41:20 is no less
00:41:21 toxic. Civilization
00:41:23 doubt. I think it goes well beyond
00:41:25 the angle of fear. I think it's
00:41:27 Western civilization in general with
00:41:29 a few exceptions,
00:41:31 perhaps Poland, Hungary,
00:41:33 Sometimes Australia
00:41:36 Sometimes America
00:41:38 Or portions within them
00:41:40 And perhaps even France
00:41:42 Some of the French are still pretty damn proud 1.00
00:41:45 Of being French 1.00
00:41:46 But in general it's a problem that plagues
00:41:49 The Anglosphere
00:41:50 But also I think the West in general
00:41:52 It does plague the West in general
00:41:54 But it's most acute in the Anglosphere
00:41:57 And this is the paradox
00:41:58 The Anglosphere countries are the most successful
00:42:01 Countries and yet they're the most
00:42:03 plagued by by doubt and it's almost like it's success guilt that we're suffering from and we've
00:42:10 got to get we've got to get over this and the sooner the better you mentioned countries like
00:42:15 poland i think the reason why it's different and better in places like poland is because
00:42:23 in very recent times they've had existential struggles to deal with i mean the one western
00:42:29 country that still absolutely has a national project is Israel, because Israel is constantly 0.99
00:42:35 subject to existential threat. For a couple of generations now, we in the main Anglosphere
00:42:45 countries have not been subject to existential threat. We've had it very, very good. And this
00:42:53 is again one of the paradoxes of these times um well you're i think you're making the uh the good
00:42:59 times create weak men argument materially uh we've never been better off spiritually we've
00:43:08 rarely been worse off okay uh well i want to i think that transitions somewhat to uh i guess
00:43:19 what's just happening now with uh you know war breaking out between israel and iran potential
00:43:26 war uh you know so often we have exchanges of military assets we don't declare it an actual
00:43:31 war uh grossest example possibly being vietnam but you know what could certainly escalate into
00:43:37 a more conventional war here or we could have a special military operation special military
00:43:41 a war that's now lasted more than three years yeah yeah uh i'm not even sure iraq and afghanistan
00:43:47 were declared officially war.
00:43:49 There was a war on terror in general.
00:43:50 It was a war on an idea.
00:43:54 But we don't declare war on states anymore
00:43:56 for some reason.
00:43:58 But, you know,
00:43:59 so when I was speaking with folks
00:44:01 who were helping set up the interview here,
00:44:03 I said, well, here's the different areas
00:44:04 I want to talk about.
00:44:06 I said, potential war between Israel and Iran.
00:44:08 Well, that changed last,
00:44:10 yesterday evening when,
00:44:12 our time at least,
00:44:14 when Israel launched,
00:44:15 what it says are preemptive strikes
00:44:17 on Iranian nuclear
00:44:19 enrichment
00:44:21 facilities, research facilities,
00:44:23 decapitated much of
00:44:25 the general staff of
00:44:27 the Iranian military
00:44:28 complex.
00:44:32 It's
00:44:32 obviously got a
00:44:35 response from Iran. Iran's not 0.85
00:44:36 been particularly successful so far, but
00:44:39 it's been less than 24
00:44:41 hours. I'd be pretty shocked
00:44:43 if this does not escalate further.
00:44:47 The question, I guess, is open.
00:44:51 I'm pretty skeptical of, well, any country that says it's launching a preemptive strike.
00:44:58 And there is a role for preemptive strikes.
00:44:59 The Seven Days War that Israel launched, well, Israel launched a preemptive strike for the Seven Days War.
00:45:05 It very likely would have been either a loss or a near loss like Yom Kippur if they had not. 0.96
00:45:10 but they provided evidence post facto
00:45:13 that it was necessary that
00:45:15 its Arab neighbors were
00:45:17 preparing to launch an attack but they
00:45:19 provided that evidence
00:45:20 but you know we have
00:45:23 the example of the 2003 invasion of
00:45:25 Iraq by the United States and its allies 0.75
00:45:27 that turned out
00:45:29 to be if we're being charitable
00:45:30 incomplete intelligence
00:45:34 if we're being less charitable false
00:45:37 intelligence and we
00:45:39 certainly toppled a
00:45:41 brutal
00:45:43 dictatorship. 0.51
00:45:44 A murderous and 0.98
00:45:46 an evil regime. 0.67
00:45:48 Absolutely. But I mean,
00:45:50 the Middle East is a different region here
00:45:52 where it's difficult
00:45:53 to simply roll in.
00:45:56 Here's McDonald's and
00:45:58 car washes, cable TV
00:46:00 and democracy. It didn't take.
00:46:03 That's an
00:46:04 open argument. Would Iraq have just been better 1.00
00:46:06 living under the brutal dictator?
00:46:07 it's a difficult question to say
00:46:10 but
00:46:10 regardless of who it was overthrowing
00:46:13 it was based, the caustic belli of war
00:46:15 was false
00:46:16 and
00:46:17 I think it's incumbent upon Israel 1.00
00:46:21 to provide some pretty solid evidence for this
00:46:23 the Iranian regime
00:46:24 is arguably even
00:46:26 significantly worse than the regime
00:46:29 the Ba'athist regime of Saddam Hussein
00:46:32 it's about as bad a regime
00:46:33 as it gets
00:46:34 but I think it's incumbent on
00:46:36 And is it not incumbent on Israel, though, to provide some real tangible evidence that there was an imminent threat of Iran acquiring, what they're saying, between 10 to 15 nuclear devices?
00:46:46 my understanding is that unlike iraq prior to 2003 there have been inspectors going into iran
00:46:58 in recent times and they are reporting the physical evidence of centrifuges and others
00:47:05 which are producing weapons grade material as far as i am aware that is simply incontrovertible
00:47:14 It's as realistic as the evidence of the Holocaust, for instance, 0.96
00:47:20 which some people will still deny.
00:47:22 That's my understanding.
00:47:24 And I think Israel has every right to take preemptive action 1.00
00:47:30 against a regime which has been threatening for decades
00:47:35 to wipe Israel off the face of the earth, 1.00
00:47:37 which has been the sponsor of numerous acts of terrorism against Israel
00:47:42 and which has been hell-bent on getting a nuclear weapon
00:47:47 for at least two or three decades.
00:47:49 I think this is as justified a strike as any can be.
00:47:55 Yes, let's expect Israel to produce appropriate evidence 0.90
00:48:03 of exactly what it's done.
00:48:05 let's hope that the strikes succeed in their objective and then end let's hope that there are
00:48:19 minimal civilian casualties and let's hope against hope that the Iranian people might 1.00
00:48:27 rise up against their oppressors and install a better regime let's dwell for a moment though
00:48:34 on the Iraq War, which has cast a shadow across the contemporary psyche
00:48:41 in the same way that the Vietnam War appeared to cast a shadow
00:48:44 across the psyche of Americans growing up in the 1960s.
00:48:49 Look, I was part of the Howard government,
00:48:53 which joined the Anglo-American assault on Iraq.
00:48:58 We all thought that there were weapons of mass destruction.
00:49:02 even the opponents of the war thought they were weapons of mass destruction
00:49:06 Saddam kept telling us that he had weapons of mass destruction
00:49:10 and he wanted to use them
00:49:12 we knew he'd used gas
00:49:14 on his own people
00:49:17 and I thought that was an eminently justified
00:49:21 assault to topple the regime
00:49:24 I still think it was eminently justified
00:49:28 the americans who were running the show made two cataclysmic and fundamental mistakes
00:49:37 they disbanded the iraqi army which meant there are half a million unemployed guys with guns
00:49:43 and they disbanded the barthes civil service which meant that no one knew how to run anything
00:49:48 and the country swiftly descended into anarchy we had a plan for the war we didn't have a plan
00:49:57 for the peace. The Americans, and regrettably the British and Australian governments went along
00:50:02 with this, the Americans had facilely assumed that windbags in exile, like that Shalabi guy, 0.98
00:50:12 had far more support than they really had. And in retrospect, the best thing would have been
00:50:21 to restore the Iraqi monarchy
00:50:23 because the only countries in the Middle East
00:50:27 that work are the monarchies.
00:50:30 That would have been very much in contradiction, though,
00:50:33 to kind of the neoconservative push at the time
00:50:37 of spreading democracy,
00:50:39 that we're going to plant the seeds of democracy
00:50:40 in the Middle East and it's going to flower.
00:50:42 Which is a nice ideal,
00:50:46 but but centuries of experience uh disproves it uh i mean democracy is a desirable
00:50:57 further state of development but you can't simply impose democracy it was like a heart transplant
00:51:06 on on what on what is effectively a medieval society i mean as i said the the the only
00:51:12 countries that really work in the middle east are the monarchies um democracy in the middle east
00:51:20 tends to be one man one vote once uh and it becomes a dictatorship and it's usually a much
00:51:27 worse dictatorship um than the monarchical regimes because the king wants his grandson to be
00:51:35 in the same position that he's in one day he's never going to completely alienate anyone
00:51:42 In practice, monarchies are negotiated societies rather than societies ruled by fear or force.
00:51:52 And unfortunately, America is still neuralgic about monarchy because of the experience of George III.
00:51:59 It's hard to imagine the American. I think you are right. 0.84
00:52:01 Because of the experience of George III.
00:52:02 But that would have been a weird to see the Americans do it. 0.68
00:52:04 But if they weren't prepared to come at a monarchy, which would have been the best outcome,
00:52:10 they should have found the least bad of Saddam's generals and said, mate, you're in charge
00:52:15 and we will back you on two conditions.
00:52:20 One, no genocide against your own people.
00:52:23 And two, no terrorism against ours.
00:52:26 But instead, yes, they tried.
00:52:29 It's the argument. 1.00
00:52:30 It's the arson of a bitch. 1.00
00:52:31 They tried to impose a quasi-Western democracy. 0.99
00:52:39 It's now got to, I think, a tolerably good position,
00:52:46 but it's taken two decades, the best part of two decades,
00:52:52 and in the process there's been a ferocious civil war
00:52:57 which has cost hundreds of thousands of Iraqi lives.
00:53:01 thousands of Western lives, and it's spilled over into Syria, which is an ongoing
00:53:09 issue. So look, you're right, but just because things have had bad consequences
00:53:21 doesn't mean that they shouldn't have been done.
00:53:26 And I don't think, even with the wisdom of hindsight,
00:53:34 that overthrowing Saddam Hussein was a bad thing to do.
00:53:39 It's just that there should have been much more realistic planning
00:53:42 going to it.
00:53:45 I can see it.
00:53:47 I can see it.
00:53:48 I'm just not sure it was worth
00:53:50 you know, the human
00:53:52 the cost and blood and treasure to get
00:53:54 here, but I can see where
00:53:56 you're coming from. But
00:53:58 Iran is, I believe
00:54:00 two to three times the population
00:54:02 of Iraq. It's roughly
00:54:04 90 million people off the top of my mind
00:54:06 It's military, I think
00:54:08 with reserves, is at a million
00:54:09 This is a substantially
00:54:12 more powerful
00:54:13 power to
00:54:16 confront
00:54:17 like Iraq it's got a very divided population
00:54:20 less so ethnically
00:54:21 Iraq had the Sunni domination 0.85
00:54:23 the majority of Shiites
00:54:26 Iran is almost entirely Shiite
00:54:29 and has a few minorities
00:54:30 but not major components
00:54:32 the way Iraq has the Kurds 1.00
00:54:34 but it's divided between
00:54:35 a large minority of fairly liberal
00:54:39 westernized people
00:54:40 who tend to leave in large numbers
00:54:43 and then the more theocratic
00:54:46 religious
00:54:48 fundamentalist side
00:54:50 there does not seem to be a way to
00:54:53 outright
00:54:54 march in and liberate it
00:54:56 Iraq style here
00:54:58 sort of an utterly cataclysmic war
00:55:00 and I know that's not what you're advocating
00:55:02 my concern though is that
00:55:05 if they were on the verge of a bomb
00:55:08 I think Israel was totally justified 1.00
00:55:10 that's the big question mark for me
00:55:13 right now
00:55:13 If they were imminently on the verge of a bomb, well, then Israel really had no choice. 0.60
00:55:21 They had to do what they did.
00:55:22 If they were not, though, or Israel does not provide sufficiently convincing evidence of that,
00:55:29 my concern is then that they have potentially just ignited a major regional war that could pull the Western powers in.
00:55:39 Well, that's all possible.
00:55:41 And, of course, Iran has always denied that its nuclear program was for military purposes, but it's always insisted that it did have a very active nuclear program, supposedly for peaceful purposes.
00:55:58 And I don't think it's realistic to equate the Saddam situation in 2003 and weapons of mass destruction with the current Iranian situation. 0.52
00:56:15 Why not?
00:56:16 Well, because IEA inspectors have been in Iran and they've brought back reports of what they have seen with their own eyes.
00:56:26 Now, as I said, the Iranians have always denied that this is for military purposes, but you do not need highly enriched uranium for anything other than military purposes.
00:56:40 And it's clear, it's as clear as anything can be, that they were increasingly advancing towards highly enriched uranium.
00:56:51 And look, all Israel wants to do, I mean, there are lots of things Israel would like.
00:56:58 I mean, Israel would like a friendly regime in Tehran.
00:57:03 Israel would like the kind of relationship with Tehran that it has with the Emirates, for instance.
00:57:10 But all Israel is actually doing is trying to stop Iran's nuclear program from further progressing.
00:57:20 and i think that's a perfectly reasonable objective and let me also say this derek
00:57:27 there's been no condemnation of these israeli strikes thus far from the saudis from the
00:57:33 emiratis from the jordanians because well none of these guys like the iranians these guys are
00:57:38 look they all they are all in in in fear in existential fear of the apocalyptic ayatollahs 0.98
00:57:48 of Tehran. And I tell you this, Derek, if Iran did get a nuclear weapon, within months,
00:57:58 the Saudis would be buying one off the Pakistanis. Turkey would be buying one off the Pakistanis.
00:58:05 I mean, the whole global security arrangements and architecture would be radically deranged.
00:58:14 So, look, provided it's been successful and provided it doesn't substantially escalate, I think the Israelis have done us all a favor.
00:58:25 But those are two still big questions.
00:58:27 Was it successful?
00:58:28 There are no certainties in this life.
00:58:31 But sometimes it's just got to be brave.
00:58:34 And was it justified?
00:58:35 Were they on the imminent threat of it?
00:58:36 I mean, there have been reports that Iran was on the verge of a bomb for 30 years now.
00:58:41 That doesn't mean they wouldn't actually eventually get there.
00:58:43 but it means I'm
00:58:44 I want to see the proof
00:58:47 I think you're like Thomas
00:58:50 in the Gospels
00:58:52 all right
00:58:55 well I certainly can be convinced
00:58:57 well let's maybe
00:59:00 wrap it with a discussion
00:59:03 of the G7
00:59:04 I mean fortuitous time that you're here
00:59:06 it's Friday right now
00:59:08 on Sunday
00:59:09 just west of where we're sitting
00:59:13 right now, we're in downtown Calgary
00:59:15 just west of us in Kananaskis
00:59:16 close to where I live
00:59:18 the leaders of the G7
00:59:21 are going to be meeting
00:59:22 I mean, Iran 0.72
00:59:25 is obviously, I don't know how
00:59:26 high on the agenda it was going to be before
00:59:28 but it's going to be probably pretty top now
00:59:31 anything big
00:59:34 I mean, every time Trump's at the table
00:59:36 it's so hard to predict anything
00:59:38 that's going to take place, you know, even as big
00:59:40 as supporters will admit it's
00:59:42 i i i can't imagine who actually has to take care of planning this guy's agenda every day
00:59:48 it's kind of the chaos um it's but a particular particularly at this moment where carney actually
00:59:55 has him i think in large measure to thank for being in the prime minister's chair with his
01:00:00 talk of 51st state the trade war that took place um but at the same time he's got to be
01:00:06 really nervous about what trump might do because um well there's a lot of similarities between
01:00:11 canada and australia i think one of the big differences is there's no major secessionist
01:00:15 movements in australia i don't know where they would really want to go um you know but in addition
01:00:20 to quebec it's now very very real in alberta here uh we have a citizens initiative law uh that's been
01:00:26 amended here and it is near certainty we're going to be having a referendum on independence here in
01:00:31 alberta potentially even saskatchewan soon after uh on independence uh no one really in either
01:00:38 Alberta or Saskatchewan talks about joining United States. It's not really something most people are
01:00:41 interested in. But Trump could look at this as a kind of power play for closer union with at least
01:00:50 Alberta and Saskatchewan. What do you, I don't know, do you know the man and do you,
01:00:57 what opportunities for mischief do you see there where he's going to be literally be
01:01:01 and sell in Alberta kind of the heart of the movement of the independence movement in Alberta
01:01:06 at a time where he's been just dropping bombs on Canadian domestic politics?
01:01:12 Well, I think that there's two Trumps, effectively.
01:01:16 There's domestic Trump, who's largely a positive force,
01:01:21 and there's foreign Trump, who has often been a negative force.
01:01:25 And most obviously, foreign Trump has been a negative force 0.89
01:01:28 via his stream of insults against Canada,
01:01:32 which I think were a key factor in the defeat of the Conservative Party here.
01:01:40 Look, you're right.
01:01:44 Any event involving President Trump invariably becomes the centre of attention.
01:01:56 He loves that.
01:01:58 He loves keeping everyone off balance.
01:02:02 and uncertain as to his next move.
01:02:08 I think, frankly, the best thing for anyone to do
01:02:12 in responding to Trump is just keep calm and carry on.
01:02:18 Keep calm and carry on.
01:02:20 And I think that Trump's tariffs on Canada,
01:02:25 in the end, are going to hurt America,
01:02:27 at least as much as they hurt Canada.
01:02:29 and I think over time they're going to get rethought.
01:02:33 I think the risk in America at the moment is a recession
01:02:36 brought on by the uncertain investment climate
01:02:41 and the price hikes that the tariffs inevitably will bring with them.
01:02:48 And if Trump wants to secure his legacy,
01:02:53 he's actually got to produce economic success, not economic chaos.
01:02:58 and at the moment it's been much more the latter than the former.
01:03:04 So what's going to come out of the G7?
01:03:07 Well, they will obviously talk a lot about Iran
01:03:10 and they will note that urge both sides to de-escalate,
01:03:15 which is fair enough, as long as Israel's objective 0.96
01:03:18 of preventing an Iranian bomb has succeeded.
01:03:24 I hope that for the first time in years,
01:03:28 The G7 might actually talk more about energy security and less about emissions.
01:03:37 And if that happens and we've got Drill Baby Drill Trump coming together with a Kearney who at least says he wants to see resource development.
01:03:49 so let's hope that we get
01:03:51 at least more
01:03:53 common sense on energy
01:03:55 out of this G7
01:03:57 than we have out of recent ones
01:03:59 this final question
01:04:01 have you seen the movie on the emu war
01:04:03 I haven't
01:04:04 I haven't seen it yet either
01:04:07 the emu war
01:04:08 when your country fought a war against
01:04:11 emus, birds
01:04:12 and lost
01:04:14 I nearly has only lost one war
01:04:17 and it was against birds
01:04:18 Now that you mention it, there was a campaign, I think, in Western Australia in the 1930s to eradicate emus.
01:04:30 It was a special military operation.
01:04:32 It was a misguided campaign.
01:04:35 I think very few people were aware it was happening at the time, and they quickly worked out that it was a failure.
01:04:42 i think i think the i think the emu wars might ultimately be a bit of a piss take
01:04:50 uh my favorite thing whenever when i meet australian most australians don't seem to
01:04:55 know about it i if i bring this up i make take out their phone in google emu war and
01:05:00 there's a wikipedia article and it literally is structured like regular wars like world war ii
01:05:05 has like the belligerents on one side with casualties listed uh i mean it was kind of
01:05:11 like vietnam you beat the emus on the casualty account but ultimately it was unsuccessful
01:05:16 there we are well that's fun that's one more i'm glad to be lost all right uh tony abbott uh i've
01:05:24 taken you way longer than was expected here uh but i really appreciate your time it's uh fascinating
01:05:29 and uh i hope you enjoy your time here in alberta thanks jerry good on you thank you
01:05:33 all right that's tony abbott the former prime minister of australia uh joining us for a wide
01:05:40 Raging Talk. Thank you for your time. Remember to go to westernstandard.news, click on subscribe.
01:05:44 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year to get unlimited access to all Western Standard content.
01:05:49 Thank you for joining us today, and God bless.
01:06:10 Thank you.