Western Standard - November 17, 2026


EXCLUSIVE: Danielle Smith warns UCP against splitting over Alberta independence

Did the Iran War Cost Republicans the Midterms? Danielle Smith Defends the UCP's Independence Pledge

Episode Stats


Length

19 minutes

Words per minute

203.25

Word count

3,937

Sentence count

155

Harmful content

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 I know people are frustrated with the relationship with Ottawa.
00:00:02 I'm frustrated with the relationship with Ottawa.
00:00:05 There's a couple of things we've been able to find and that we can work together on,
00:00:08 but there's a number of things that still are causing frustration.
00:00:11 But I do truly believe that conservatives are stronger together,
00:00:15 that our conservative movement,
00:00:18 we sadly always seem to try to find the things that blow us apart.
00:00:21 I keep on wanting to try to find the things that will draw us together
00:00:24 and we can change the conversation.
00:00:26 And that's what I'm looking forward to having at the AGM
00:00:28 is a really robust, fun conversation about policy
00:00:31 and about the direction of the country
00:00:32 and how we can stay united
00:00:34 so that we can beat the NDP in the next election.
00:00:41 Okay, well, today we've got a rare guest coming on
00:00:45 and I really appreciate her taking some time
00:00:47 during the legislative session.
00:00:48 We've got Premier Daniel Smith coming on to talk
00:00:50 and it's been a while.
00:00:52 So thanks for coming on to discuss a few things
00:00:55 with me tonight, Premier Smith.
00:00:57 Yeah, nice to see you, Corey.
00:00:58 So it's been quite a year. And wrapping up the year, we're coming off of an unprecedented set of referenda, followed by what's going to be the largest AGM in probably Canadian political history.
00:01:14 But you've got quite a hangover from what the referenda sort of created and put together that's overshadowing this AGM. And I kind of want to start there. Some people are starting to get concerned that this general meeting might be derailed.
00:01:28 Well, I'm not as concerned about that. I know that there's still people who have a lot of emotion about the October 19th result and are still processing that. And that doesn't surprise me at all. But what I took from it is that Albertans want us to focus on the battles they think we can win. And they want us to do that within the structure of the United Canada with the political and constitutional measures that we have.
00:01:55 They don't want us to spend a whole pile of time on constitutional reforms that may not go anywhere, but they do want us to spend time on trying to fix immigration and addressing very practical things where we can work with the federal government to get them out of our jurisdiction and assert more of our own.
00:02:12 So I thought it was a very thoughtful referendum. I don't think anybody voted 100% down the ballot one way or another. And that shows me that Albertans really gave a lot of thought to. And I know that there's difference of opinions and people all had different policies that they hoped would have been passed. But I think that we have to accept the results of what Albertans told us, because that's what Citizen Initiative is all about. And that's what referenda are all about.
00:02:37 Yeah, well, speaking for myself, I make no secret about where I land on the unity issue and such,
00:02:41 but I fully respect and understand three quarters of Albertans said, no, they're not ready to go down that road yet.
00:02:47 If the time is going to happen, it's going to be some years away at this point.
00:02:51 So it's now time to start focusing on what's happening here rather than that.
00:02:55 I understand that.
00:02:55 And I know there's some people in the independence movement who still quite haven't accepted that.
00:02:59 But all the same, when we're seeing some of the crackdown happening on people who are independence leaning,
00:03:05 and particularly with your constituency presidents.
00:03:09 I mean, to be honest,
00:03:10 it looks a little ham-handed almost
00:03:11 with how that's being dealt with.
00:03:13 Have you started communicating with some of them,
00:03:14 perhaps to calm that down?
00:03:16 Because signing letters on a political viewpoint
00:03:19 can really, it just rubs conservatives
00:03:21 the wrong way a lot.
00:03:22 Well, I guess, you know, the way I look at it
00:03:25 is that anytime you're in a leadership position
00:03:27 or a spokesperson position,
00:03:28 you've got to represent the views of the party.
00:03:31 And so if you're the president
00:03:33 of a constituency association,
00:03:34 you're you're kind of the leadership in in that constituency that that's who local media might be
00:03:40 turning to to to get an idea of what it is that the ucp stand for if you're on the provincial
00:03:44 board same thing they'll be looking to you to see what the ucp stands for and certainly our
00:03:48 candidates as well so if you want to seek one of those positions then then you have to accept the
00:03:52 policies and principles of the party and and the policies and principles of the ucp or we accept
00:03:57 what albertans told us they gave us a mandate to pursue change within a united canada um i mean
00:04:02 And it's only a very small number of positions that we're asking for people to abide by the results of the referendum.
00:04:10 Because I think the case that you made is the case in point.
00:04:14 If you have riding presidents that are out there saying, I don't care what Albertans decide and I'm going to fight for separation anyway, then it becomes a media story.
00:04:23 It becomes what Rick Bell writes about.
00:04:25 It becomes what Don Braid writes about.
00:04:27 And that's not consistent with what it is that Albertans told us.
00:04:31 Suburbs told us they want to focus on the things that they care about and the things that we can
00:04:36 make a difference on. And it's incumbent upon a political party who puts itself out saying, hey,
00:04:42 vote for us because we'll implement the things you tell us to do. You have to take what the most
00:04:47 recent mandate is. And most recent mandate is to operate within the United Canada and then work to
00:04:52 make sure that we've got greater control over immigration. Those were pretty strong mandates
00:04:57 that we got. Also, I might add, work to end equalization. If you look at all the votes that
00:05:02 we got, that one that was done by Jason Kenney still had a 62% mandate, which tells me that a
00:05:07 lot of people in Alberta continue to want us to have more fairness in the federation. And those
00:05:12 are the things that I believe, anyone who wants to speak for the UCP, those are the things we
00:05:17 should be talking about. So there's been a balancing act. I mean, three quarters of Albertans,
00:05:22 as I just noted, said no to moving forward towards the full independence, but 25% said
00:05:26 they'd like to move in that direction. That's not insignificant. And we do understand that within
00:05:31 the party itself, there's probably, well, not probably, there will be a higher proportion of
00:05:34 people who support that. How do you keep that element happy, though? There's a large group of
00:05:41 people who do feel, though, that Ottawa is a problem that needs to be dealt with, not necessarily
00:05:45 somebody to be getting tighter with. I can't help but note, I haven't heard the word sovereign coming
00:05:51 from you as much as it used to be in the past, for example. I mean, that's not taking the
00:05:55 secessionist stance but it was certainly one speaking for Alberta sovereignty. Is that now
00:06:00 going away as well? Well our first bill was Alberta sovereignty within United Canada
00:06:04 and we've had a reason to bring forward two motions under that and it may well be that we've
00:06:09 got reason to bring forward additional motions because of some of the fights that we're having
00:06:15 with Ottawa and a few different fronts. I mean we're in court right now fighting with them over
00:06:19 what we think is an abusive process in targeting hunters and sport shooters and collectors
00:06:25 on their firearms. We don't believe that that is a proper use of the criminal law power and
00:06:30 public safety power. We're going to be having a negotiation with them around having more of a
00:06:36 Quebec-style immigration program. We just won again on Bill C-69. Now they've got to rewrite
00:06:42 their law so that it is in compliance with the Constitution. We're fighting with them
00:06:47 in court as well over their overreach when it comes to the designation of plastics as toxic.
00:06:53 So we will continue to fight for our areas of provincial constitutional sovereignty. That's
00:06:59 what the Sovereignty Act was all about, is maintaining our areas of authority where we
00:07:04 have exclusive jurisdiction and telling Ottawa to bug out and to keep focused on theirs. And so
00:07:09 every time we find that they've overstepped the line, you bet, we'll be there to fight them.
00:07:14 Yeah, well, C-69 has really chilled a lot of investment over the years,
00:07:17 and the courts have certainly come down on the right side of that,
00:07:21 but now they aren't getting rid of it.
00:07:22 They've committed now to stop appealing and to rewriting it.
00:07:25 Will the government of Alberta be sending suggestions to Ottawa then on how to rewrite it?
00:07:31 Because, I mean, they could come back with something that's even worse.
00:07:33 You know, just because they're going to rewrite it doesn't mean they're going to improve it.
00:07:36 Well, the main thing that we were fighting was to make sure that intra-provincial projects,
00:07:41 everything that takes place within the borders of Alberta that we have the authority to run our own
00:07:46 regulatory processes over. And they rewrote it and the court said not good enough, so they struck it
00:07:51 down again. So the fact that they're not appealing it and trying to argue that they still have some
00:07:55 jurisdiction over the projects that take place in Alberta, I think that's a victory. And so you bet,
00:08:00 we've already sent them some suggestions about how they can rewrite the law. Because remember,
00:08:05 They do have the ability to govern intra-provincial infrastructure, whether that's rail lines or whether that's transmission lines that go across borders or whether that's pipelines that go across borders.
00:08:19 Part of the reason why we're partnering with them to build the Pacific links to the southern B.C. coast is because there is a jurisdictional issue there.
00:08:28 But there's a lot of projects within Alberta, whether it's oil sands, whether it's SAG-D, whether it's being able to build our own pipelines to get gas from one place to another within Alberta, whether it is highways, any number of projects that take place within our borders.
00:08:44 Courts agree with us. That's our jurisdiction and the federal government shouldn't be interfering.
00:08:48 So, yes, we will absolutely work with them on how they can rewrite it so they can stay in their own lane.
00:08:53 So one of the mandates that you did get through the referenda was on some changes,
00:08:58 at least for what the province can do to manage immigration to a degree and changes that can happen here.
00:09:03 I know you had said that that's going to wait until after the fall session to get rolling.
00:09:07 But, well, for one, I mean, it is a mandate. 0.52
00:09:10 We should be moving, you know, some red meat you could give people who did participate in the referendum. 0.99
00:09:14 And I just saw Blacklock's reporter story today, you know, the fantastic stuff those guys break. 0.97
00:09:19 but they went digging and found out that Canada permitted 42% more landed immigrants last year
00:09:25 than the Prime Minister claimed. He sort of covered up the number. That means the immigration issue
00:09:30 is still very acute and kind of tightening up those holes for us. Wouldn't it be better to do 1.00
00:09:36 that sooner rather than later? I mean, obviously the influx isn't slowing down anytime soon.
00:09:39 Yeah, I mean, we intend to move very quickly. You have to remember the sort of a pace of
00:09:43 legislation. We normally do our legislative work for what we introduce in the fall over the summer.
00:09:49 we didn't have a mandate yet. And so now that we have a mandate, we'll be able to do the work
00:09:54 over the winter break so that we can put some legislative framework in place in the spring.
00:09:59 And we've already started. I mean, we've already done some work on putting in a governance
00:10:04 structure over immigration consultants. I think there's a lot of immigration consultants who
00:10:08 were offering, I think, false information to especially international students coming here
00:10:16 about their likelihood of being able to to stay after getting a diploma program a lot of those
00:10:22 folks ended up disappointed so we need to make sure that we're governing the people who are
00:10:26 representing what the opportunities are in in Alberta and in Canada so we've already begun
00:10:31 down that pathway but the next big step is making sure that we've got clear line of sight on who's
00:10:37 getting a permit in the province does an Alberta worker have the first dibs on that job does a
00:10:42 canadian worker have second dibs on that job is there still a shortage and if there is then we
00:10:48 can go internationally find somebody who's a can fill the position temporarily and if it works for
00:10:54 the company and the individual find a pathway to permanent residency that that is always how the
00:10:59 system was supposed to work is that you fill gaps in the temporary basis if they're going to be a
00:11:04 long-term gap then let's find a pathway to get somebody to become a permanent resident so they
00:11:08 make a lifetime commitment to being a taxpayer and that's when they're able to be eligible to
00:11:13 get the programs that that we offer so we want to uh to move quite quickly on that uh we've got a
00:11:19 number of of things that we have to consult with the businesses and as well as with the cultural
00:11:23 communities on that we've got to consult with all of the universities as as well as understanding
00:11:28 where the gaps might be and so it'll take a little bit of time but we intend to move very quickly on
00:11:33 it okay now kind of getting but just a bit back to the the potential party division i mean we we've
00:11:40 we've seen the lessons as hard as anybody has and what happens if we split things up too much
00:11:44 and and if we stand too hard on principle with a second party then suddenly a third party kind
00:11:48 of slides up the middle and with the numbers being as tight as they are right now there's
00:11:52 certainly not a majority support for an independence type party but one could gain
00:11:55 enough steam to really impact our electoral front like i i just feel maybe the best way to keep that
00:12:02 from happening is giving some sort of concrete thing to the people who want to see more autonomy
00:12:07 coming like are we moving towards something like we've you know you sort of tested the waters on a
00:12:11 provincial pension plan we've talked about provincial police forces but again the patience
00:12:16 is a little hard for for some of us albertans on those things like are we going to be moving
00:12:19 on some of that someday well to be clear we have moved on an alberta provincial police force it's
00:12:24 called the alberta uh sheriff's police service where we're putting the structure around it
00:12:28 training them up to the same level of a police officer we've already deployed them in special
00:12:33 units not only at the border but also fugitive apprehension surveillance scan they shut down
00:12:38 drug houses we've had them embedded with officers in calgary as well as in edmonton and guess what
00:12:43 no one else can do that because they are a true provincial police service and so we are able to
00:12:49 have them operate uh across jurisdiction working with uh with with the uh the local um police of
00:12:56 of record. And remember, like 80% of people in Alberta are already policed by a municipal police
00:13:01 service. So we have a number of different municipalities that have requested sheriff's
00:13:08 detachments. It just takes time. It takes time to train officers up, and it takes time to have
00:13:14 the municipalities do their own due diligence to determine what kind of police service makes sense
00:13:19 for them. Grand Prairie just did this, and they managed to transition away from the RCMP earlier
00:13:25 than they expected with their own municipal police service we want to work with the municipalities
00:13:28 on what makes the most sense for them but by all means uh the alberta provincial uh sheriffs are
00:13:34 going to be one of the the key aspects that they have is one of the choices that they can make
00:13:38 when it comes to a pension plan like i'll be i'll be frank with you corey we you know i although i
00:13:43 i looked at the numbers myself and i thought this looks like it makes a lot of sense uh when you
00:13:47 look at even uh morneau chapelle was the company that that determined what the the split of assets
00:13:53 should be uh it seemed to make sense but every consultation we did found that albertans were not
00:13:58 interested in it you look at the result of the remain vote being 75 i can i would i would hazard
00:14:04 a guess that if we'd put the pension question on the ballot it would have been equal or even higher
00:14:08 than that uh sometimes you you just are not able to to make a case that's compelling to albertans
00:14:13 and if um albertans don't want it you can't be forging ahead with it so um at the moment there
00:14:18 does not seem to be an appetite for that which is why we didn't put it to a vote okay quickly before
00:14:23 we wrapped you know this was the first really large exercise of a number of referenda in alberta
00:14:27 the initial intent though was to have a number i think of citizens initiatives that had gone through
00:14:31 and have the people drive it but that never quite happened down the road i mean obviously it's not
00:14:35 going to happen in the next year and some but is there perhaps an intent to fix up that legislation
00:14:40 so we can get a workable direct democracy sort of legislation in the future and have referenda
00:14:45 that citizens initiate without it perhaps being as contentious as it has been well like what do
00:14:50 do you think needs to be changed? Well, in this case, it wasn't actually, none of them were
00:14:55 exactly a citizen's initiative ones. They came from the government itself. I understand the ones
00:15:00 with the petitioning, there were court issues that held those up. And in general, I mean, my thoughts
00:15:05 also was maybe having that many questions on one ballot was just a little much for one bite. And
00:15:09 if we did future exercises, there might be fewer. I mean, I'm just saying, is there more room to
00:15:12 discuss perhaps if these things could be held, that they could be a little more streamlined,
00:15:16 whether it's an independence thing
00:15:17 or just other policy initiatives?
00:15:19 Well, I would say, I mean,
00:15:21 if you look at what happened in California,
00:15:23 California, you routinely has,
00:15:25 I think even just this most recent result,
00:15:27 I think they had 10 proposition questions.
00:15:29 If you go back, they've been doing
00:15:30 these kinds of propositions since 1911.
00:15:32 So they've got a lot of experience with it.
00:15:34 So I think people can sort through
00:15:36 a number of different questions
00:15:38 and are able to deal with them independently.
00:15:41 And question 10 was the result
00:15:43 of two citizen initiative petitions.
00:15:45 The first one was, do you want to remain, yes or no? I suppose we could have put that on the ballot as is, but then it would have been unclear what no meant. And then the other petition was asking for a binding referendum on separation. It is, of course, going through the court right now, but that was why option two was structured the way it was. It was, do you want to entertain that question? And Albertan said that they want to remain. They want us to work within United Canada to solve some of these issues.
00:16:11 So I would say that there were two other petition campaigns that weren't successful. There was the coal petition. There was also a petition to defund independent schools. And so there have been a number of initiatives that have gone forward. And so you can make the arguments. You know, the ones that people don't like, they said, oh, the rules are too lenient. The ones that people do like, they say, oh, the rules are too hard.
00:16:34 I think that where we found ourselves is we probably have to look and see whether we have to make some adjustments.
00:16:41 But I think the fact that four different citizens groups thought that they had enough backing to start the process,
00:16:48 I think that that's pretty encouraging that the exercise does work.
00:16:52 And maybe there can be some tweaks, but I think that that's actually positive that citizens feel that the process is something that they wanted to take part in.
00:17:02 Great. Okay. Well, I thank you again for your time tonight. I mean, before I let you go,
00:17:05 is there a message you'd like to send to us, you know, crabby independence types as we
00:17:08 head into an AGM just to hopefully, you know, keep things a little more unified because it's
00:17:12 still, it's going to be a heck of an event. And I really do hope it goes smoothly, even if it
00:17:17 doesn't cover every question. Well, you know, it's the same argument that I made when I ran in
00:17:22 2023. I know people are frustrated with the relationship with Ottawa. I'm frustrated with
00:17:27 the relationship with Ottawa. There's a couple of things we've been able to find and that we can
00:17:31 work together on, but there's a number of things that still are causing frustration. But I do
00:17:36 truly believe that conservatives are stronger together, that our conservative movement,
00:17:42 we sadly always seem to try to find the things that blow us apart. I keep on wanting to try to
00:17:46 find the things that will draw us together. And I think what can draw us together is let's identify
00:17:50 the things that we can pursue so we can get greater autonomy within United Canada, greater
00:17:55 sovereignty around our constitutional areas of jurisdiction and and see if we can if we can move
00:18:01 the dial we've moved the dial so much on so many things the the rest of the country is rooting for
00:18:05 us we've got 81 of our fellow canadians saying yeah we need to build energy energy infrastructure
00:18:11 and we've got 63 or first nations saying the same threat is the same thing 63 i mean that that is a
00:18:17 sign that doesn't happen by accident that happens because we got loud and we we made sure that
00:18:22 everyone knew how important this industry was and they made sure that they knew how important
00:18:26 Alberta was. So there's lots of ways that we can change the country and we can change the
00:18:30 conversation. And that's what I'm looking forward to having at the AGM is a really robust, fun
00:18:34 conversation about policy and about the direction of the country and how we can stay united so that
00:18:39 we can beat the NDP in the next election. Great. Well, thank you one more time for
00:18:43 your time and we'll see you again, I guess, at the AGM in a little less than a couple of weeks.
00:18:47 Thanks, Corey.
00:18:52 Thank you.