Western Standard - May 22, 2022


EXCLUSIVE: Tom Harris talks about Climate Change and Renewable Energy issues.

Topics
Mentioned
Triggered: The ongoing persecution of Tamara Lich WATCH: Trudeau met with booing hecklers during visit to Kamloops memorial

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

187.42

Word count

4,416

Sentence count

—

Harmful content

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of the podcast, we talk to the International Climate Science Coalition Canada's Executive Director, Dr. Andrew McPherson, about climate change and the current election campaign in Canada. Andrew is an expert in the field of climate change, and has been involved in climate change issues for a long time. He is also the founder of the ICS Coalition Canada, a non-profit organization dedicated to bringing real climate scientists into the media and to the public so they can hear what's really happening in the climate science field and also talk about energy.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Since 2007 we have been working with the International Climate Science Coalition
00:00:05 which was founded in New Zealand because they wanted a more international voice at conferences
00:00:10 and we've been running as I say since 2007. I joined them in 2008 as their executive director
00:00:16 but we realized recently that there had to be a more Canadian focus for specific Canadian issues
00:00:21 so in January of 2021 we started the International Climate Science Coalition Canada which is a
00:00:27 non-profit organization dedicated to getting real scientists into the media and to the public so
00:00:34 they can hear what's really happening in the climate science field and also talk a lot about energy
00:00:39 because the greatest threat to Canadian oil and gas for example and coal is the climate scare I mean
00:00:46 one of the troubles is the Conservative Party many of them candidates especially except for Roman Baber
00:00:51 who hasn't really expressed himself on the issue they all support the climate scare but they also
00:00:56 support Canadian energy and yet the thing that's most risk most threatening Canadian energy is the
00:01:02 climate scare so it's kind of like saying I'm left right like which are they yeah yeah now what is your
00:01:09 uh overall message here today you seem to acknowledge that climate change is happening although you're
00:01:13 saying that it's not a human-made phenomenon it's actually the sun that is causing it what what's the
00:01:18 main message here yeah sure well my main message is that climate change is naturally climate change
00:01:24 occurs all the time and if it weren't for climate change here in Ottawa we'd be under two kilometers
00:01:28 of ice still stuck in the last glacial period so yes of course climate changes all the time and we do
00:01:34 have to adapt if we look at uh societies that did not properly adapt uh they're no longer with us I mean
00:01:40 the Greenland Vikings for example they they did not take up the methods of living that the Inuit had
00:01:46 and they were wiped out because the little ice age was just too miserable for them to survive we do think
00:01:52 that humans caused some climate change we know that for example we cause the urban heat island effect
00:01:58 where the city is warmer than the country so there's no question that we cause that we're probably causing
00:02:03 some co2 induced climate change but the point we make is that the amount of change has to be very very
00:02:10 dangerous and very significant to be worth spending literally trillions of dollars uh trying to actually
00:02:17 stop it and we simply don't think that's the case what are your thoughts on uh carbon
00:02:22 capture technology do you think that it has merits and it can be useful or do you think it's sort of
00:02:27 a waste of time yeah I think it's a waste of money and it's interesting that even people like Elizabeth
00:02:31 May oppose carbon capture and what she says well it's kind of like putting something bad under your
00:02:36 pillow and it's going to escape eventually and of course that's the point is that carbon dioxide is
00:02:41 heavier than air so if you live near a carbon dioxide sequestration location where they actually put it
00:02:47 underground they compress it into a liquid and try and store it underground it can leak and of course
00:02:53 no geologic formation has no fractures in it I mean they worry about the possible leakage of
00:02:59 radioactive water near radioactive sites that are buried underground but in the case of co2 which is
00:03:06 a gas it's going to escape a lot easier so a couple of things one is that it's extremely expensive to
00:03:13 collect the carbon dioxide to compress it into a liquid to pump it long distances put it underground
00:03:19 that's going to add a lot to electricity prices and of course we don't think the co2 is a problem
00:03:25 because carbon dioxide is not a pollutant first of all okay they keep calling it carbon pollution
00:03:30 but in fact it's actually the stuff of life I mean in since 1940 we've seen a massive increase in crop
00:03:37 yield across the world and 40 percent of the crop yields since 1940 has been because of increasing
00:03:44 carbon dioxide levels in our atmosphere so there's really nothing bad about carbon dioxide
00:03:50 we interviewed a physicist from Princeton University who works with us off and on that's
00:03:55 that's William Happer who's one of the top radiation experts in the world he looks at how much
00:04:02 energy could carbon dioxide absorb you know and what would be the worst possible effect
00:04:07 of a doubling of co2 to from today's level if we went from 420 to 840 that would be a massive increase
00:04:15 what would be the effect on the greenhouse effect and what he says is that it would change the
00:04:21 outgoing radiation it would reduce slightly by about one percent one percent with a doubling of co2
00:04:28 so I asked him because we were interviewing it's on the icsc-climate.com website right now
00:04:34 we asked him what would be the impact on temperature of a doubling of co2 which is much more than people
00:04:40 are forecasting and he said it wouldn't even be one degree so what we're saying is if that's the case
00:04:46 and he's literally one of the absolute leaders in the world on the impact of increasing carbon dioxide and
00:04:54 methane and other things if that's the worst that can happen one degree celsius it's simply not worth
00:05:00 trillions of dollars trying to stop i see so tom why is it that um we always hear that the science
00:05:06 is settled on climate change and 97 percent of oh yeah uh you know scientists say that it's a human
00:05:12 made phenomena why is that uh that your message is not uh more mainstream or not accepted well it's
00:05:17 interesting when i first started writing in the field with professor patterson tim patterson from
00:05:21 carlton university who's a climate realist as we call him he says climate change is all the time the
00:05:26 only constant about climate is change i mean it changes all the time and so you know um when i
00:05:32 started writing with him in 1999 we were published literally from coast to coast you know halifax herald
00:05:38 montreal gazette vancouver sun right across canada but what's happened is they've closed ranks behind
00:05:45 david suzuki and behind the climate scare and and you know i i've asked various well we asked the cbc we said
00:05:52 okay show us that there's a consensus in the climate science community that there's a dangerous
00:05:57 climate change happening and of course they tried to ignore us so i wrote to the president he eventually
00:06:02 assigned the omswoodsmen for the cbc this was back in 2000 they uh assigned him the job of showing me
00:06:09 that there was a consensus and so a few weeks later i got 10 pages from the cbc omswoodsmen and he went
00:06:15 through all his details showing this great consensus in the climate science community the trouble was he
00:06:20 didn't interview a single scientist or a single scientific organization he quoted other media
00:06:28 so he quoted the new york times he quoted the la times and the guardian and all the different media
00:06:32 sources saying there was a consensus in the climate and who are they quoting well that's the coin i was
00:06:38 saying well show us the original sources i mean i don't care what the new york times says so i wrote to
00:06:43 the uh back to the president of the cbc and i said well he certainly has showed there's a consensus in
00:06:49 the media that there's a consensus in the climate science community but he hasn't actually shown any
00:06:54 consensus in the climate science community and the president said i'm very satisfied with mr bazay's
00:07:00 answer the case is closed and at that time i got a job as the legislative assistant for bob mills who
00:07:06 was the opposition senior environment critic and bob said oh no no don't go after the cbc because of
00:07:11 course he didn't want negative coverage but since then to give you an idea how varied the opinion is in
00:07:17 the real scientific community i have here a document which is one of several that's put out by the
00:07:23 non-governmental international panel on climate change you know it's not the ipcc it's the nipcc
00:07:30 and this includes literally thousands of references i mean thousands look at the end of any chapter
00:07:36 you can see you know many many references from peer-reviewed journals from scientists all over the world
00:07:42 talking about temperature records or talking about forcings and feedbacks that's the big one i'll tell you
00:07:47 something about that in a second and what they show is there simply is no climate emergency and in
00:07:53 fact it's interesting we were interviewing pat michaels who's one of the leading uh climate modelers
00:07:59 in the world and this was last week it'll be on our website on monday and he said that within the
00:08:05 climate science community there are not a single scientist who says that we face a climate emergency
00:08:11 he said the big problem is that because they say that because the media says that then they get
00:08:17 more funding so he said he's angry that scientists don't stand up and say no we're not saying that
00:08:23 there is a range of possible outcomes some of which are more serious than others but not a single
00:08:28 scientist he said is actually saying that we're in a climate emergency and so that's why in our on our
00:08:34 um on our banner we say there is no climate emergency and and of course common sense would tell you that
00:08:40 there isn't because since 1880 even the un are saying that the so-called global average temperature
00:08:46 has gone up 1.2 degrees 1.1.2 degrees i mean it may have gotten that hot that much hotter in here
00:08:53 since we started talking you know i mean you just simply wouldn't notice it and in fact it's funny
00:08:58 because uh people like uh richard lindsen from mit who's also a climate realist as we call him he says
00:09:04 no there's no climate emergency he says the small change we've seen is so insignificant that if there
00:09:11 weren't climatologists and meteorologists telling people about it no one would notice in their entire
00:09:16 lifetime because the changes are so small and you know the idea that we could double co2 which is far
00:09:23 beyond what we have now and there wouldn't be anything except good things happening you know more
00:09:28 increase in crop yield a trivial increase in temperature this makes some of the people quite angry
00:09:34 you know it's interesting i posted on the chat for this conference the fact that william happer says
00:09:39 the worst that could happen with a 100 increase in co2 the worst that can happen is a one degree a
00:09:46 little less than a degree rise and i got immediately a response from a california conservative a young man
00:09:54 who actually said oh this is all complete bogus and so i said okay well what part do you disagree with
00:10:00 no answer so i'm still waiting for his answer so you know the trouble is right now many of the
00:10:06 conservatives and i know the grassroots would love it if their leaders would stand up to the climate scare
00:10:12 because they recognize that the greatest threat to canada's prosperity is the destruction of our oil
00:10:17 and gas industry and the greatest threat to that is the climate scare because these people want to
00:10:23 completely end all fossil fuel usage okay that's the outcome that will happen if we get to net zero
00:10:30 they want to go to literally zero and you know this will ruin canada because this is our major source
00:10:36 of revenue you know when it comes to income for the country at large so what we say to them is okay look
00:10:42 there were studies in the united states and canada which actually showed what would happen if the
00:10:49 leaders of the opposition party started to speak out against the climate scare and here's the result
00:10:54 it was a study that was done with mcgill university ohio state and drexel university they
00:11:00 found that when conservatives and liberals both said the same thing in the united states this case
00:11:05 it was democrats and republicans and they both supported the climate scare then the support in
00:11:10 the public was very high for taking strong action on climate change but when the republicans dissented
00:11:16 when they said well we're not so sure about this the science is out let's take a look at it again
00:11:21 you know that kind of thing the support in the public went way down so the conservatives are
00:11:26 constantly saying in this conference for example well we've lost the war we've lost the battle we have
00:11:32 to basically look for less expensive ways of reducing co2 so we have a market-based solution but you know
00:11:38 to me that's a little like somebody saying uh i'm being encouraged to commit suicide and i'd like your
00:11:44 help like what do you think i should do now if they're really serious and you know you might
00:11:51 suggest well taking an overdose of sleeping pills is less painful than cutting your wrists but you
00:11:55 don't want to encourage them to commit suicide you know so i mean to a large extent the conservatives
00:12:01 are encouraging it for example in the emissions debate in the last five minutes i started counting how
00:12:07 many times they called carbon dioxide which most people know is invisible and benign
00:12:13 they they called it carbon you know carbon footprint carbon tax carbon pollution and yet that is the
00:12:19 language of the climate alarmists they want you to think of it as carbon which is graphite or soot
00:12:26 you know that is dirty if you call it carbon dioxide and i say this for timid conservatives who don't want
00:12:31 to contest the climate scare at the very least stop using the language of people who want to kill
00:12:37 our oil and gas industry call it a carbon dioxide tax now it might sound trivial but you remember in
00:12:43 the book 1984 there was an appendix 10 pages at the very end all about newspeak newspeak and duck speak
00:12:51 and how they would change the language and get people to use words that would actually change the
00:12:57 thinking patterns of the population so what they've done the environment environmentalists are very smart on
00:13:02 this they've called it carbon pollution they've called it green energy now green energy does that
00:13:08 make any sense in other words we're reducing carbon dioxide which is plant food that's supposedly green
00:13:15 i mean anything that increases carbon dioxide is actually green because it's you know carbon dioxide
00:13:22 is plant food you know massive increase in crop yield you have people like patrick moore who was the
00:13:27 previous head of greenpeace and he now puts out presentations in which he says we should hope co2
00:13:33 continues to rise because we've seen a massive benefit across the planet with regards to crop yield
00:13:39 you know and in fact he shows a graph that shows co2 going down naturally from its high because of
00:13:44 course right now we're at one of the lowest levels in earth's history um people don't realize that but
00:13:49 we were as high as 5 000 parts per million you know in the past and right now it's about 420.
00:13:56 so he says that if humans hadn't come along and this is pretty controversial i agree but he said
00:14:02 if humans hadn't come along and boosted co2 by releasing it from you know the bedrock from
00:14:07 releasing it from coal and everything else that co2 was headed down to a level that would end all
00:14:12 life on earth so in his presentation he's saying well thank god that we've actually come along and
00:14:19 liberated co2 so yeah there's no consensus it's a media manufactured thing a government
00:14:25 manufactured thing to make people stop arguing oh my god there's a consensus you know they do
00:14:30 this on covet they do this on all kinds of things um you know scientists agree uh yeah well show me
00:14:36 them yeah yeah with a lot of aspects of science lately what do you think is behind this push for
00:14:41 the climate scare as you call it do you think um it's well-meaning do you think there's something
00:14:45 more sinister going on are they simply misinformed what's what's happening here well there's all kinds of
00:14:50 different motivations i mean i think that there are a lot of well-meaning people who truly believe
00:14:54 that we have a climate crisis and it's funny because the easiest way to defeat that is ask them
00:14:59 well you know how much has it warmed in the last century and they say oh it must be five degrees
00:15:04 eight degrees no no it's just about one degree oh they don't believe it you know when do you think
00:15:09 we had the most extreme weather uh well it's right now i said no no in the 1930s take a look at the
00:15:15 records how many polar bears do you think there are well actually there's more now than ever since
00:15:20 we started counting you know so i think that those people just simply don't understand and so our job
00:15:26 is to help educate them there are nefarious motives out there as well i mean if you control world energy
00:15:33 which is what you do if you control fossil fuel emissions you control the world you know we can see
00:15:38 that with russia i mean russia by supplying natural gas to a lot of the a lot of western europe they have a
00:15:45 huge influence you know i mean uh so i think there is a one world government government control
00:15:51 type aspect to this in fact it was david anderson i believe the previous environment minister under
00:15:57 jean christian who said that the kyoto protocol was the flagship of world governance and there are
00:16:02 people who believe that we would be better off with a un-directed world government and of course the
00:16:08 best way to do that in many cases is to control world energy so yeah that's a motivation too
00:16:14 there are even extreme groups who see humans as a cancer on the planet believe it or not there's a
00:16:20 group called the voluntary human extinction movement and they have thousands of members i mean they're not
00:16:26 just a fringe group well they are pretty fringe they think that humans are literally a cancer and that we
00:16:32 should not reproduce we should not have children and we should die out to return the earth to its natural 1.00
00:16:38 pristine condition which of course makes you wonder well then what are humans are we supernatural like
00:16:44 if we're not natural but yeah so there's all kinds of different motivations one of the biggest drivers
00:16:50 is the people who are making a fortune out of this i mean absolute fortune there is more than a billion dollars
00:16:56 us a day being spent on what's called climate finance and the main recipients of that are wind and solar power
00:17:04 manufacturers so yeah there's a huge benefit i think also china and russia they'd love to see us
00:17:10 do this eh because i mean they're they're actually funding russians especially um environmental craziness
00:17:17 in the west because if we destroy our fossil fuel industry we're more dependent on them and then they
00:17:22 can actually dictate what happens here so there's a lot of nefarious motives but i think the majority of the
00:17:28 public just don't know you're just misinformed interesting yeah uh do you think there are a
00:17:33 lot of other environmental issues such as soil degradation the pollution of our waterways you know
00:17:38 flora and fauna being destroyed across the world that are legitimate but don't get enough attention
00:17:43 because it's all focused on the climate crisis and carbon wow that's true in fact in earth day you
00:17:48 know i did an interesting search i did a search for earth day and different categories of environmental
00:17:54 protection i talked about air pollution water pollution land pollution species at risk and
00:17:59 climate change climate change was over 80 percent of the hits okay the same thing for earth hour the
00:18:05 same thing for um earth month which was uh you know in you know april and the same thing for environment
00:18:12 day which comes up on june 5th if you do a search for any of those categories you know by far the majority
00:18:18 of hits are all for climate change and i wrote an article the other day it's on the cfac.org website
00:18:24 cfac they're friends of ours committee for a constructive tomorrow and and i showed how the
00:18:28 environmental movement has been entirely hijacked by climate change and how this is a real problem
00:18:35 because climate change is a bogus concern i mean we should help people adapt to climate change you
00:18:39 know as it occurs but the idea that we control the climate i mean it's just silly and the fact is
00:18:46 when that collapses it'll disgrace the whole environmental movement because they have
00:18:50 really put all their eggs in that basket a friend of mine on the other side of the river here in
00:18:54 you know in gatineau he's an expert in water resources and he's very angry about the climate
00:19:00 scare because he says as the funding goes up up up for climate it's going down for water resources
00:19:06 because they only have so much money to spend you know gibault the environment minister for canada
00:19:10 you know the ex-greenpeacer he says he was being criticized on ctv news a few weeks ago only nine
00:19:17 billion went into i think it was nine billion went into climate change in the budget and so he
00:19:23 defended himself by saying well since 2015 when the liberals came in they've spent 110 billion 110
00:19:31 billion on the so-called energy transition to try to stop climate change so the amount of money is
00:19:37 just unbelievable and how much money has china and russia and india spent on that well you know in the case
00:19:43 in china that's a really good question because china puts out twice as much greenhouse gases as the
00:19:47 united states and so if they're not doing anything our little 1.6 percent doesn't really matter even if
00:19:53 you do believe the science and it's interesting because china essentially has an unlimited get out 1.00
00:19:58 of jail card free okay get out of jail free card and that's this uh people say well by 2030 china has to
00:20:06 stop stop increasing emissions so that doesn't sound too bad 10 more or eight more years of china 0.99
00:20:12 boosting emissions through the sight through the sky but in fact they don't even have to reduce
00:20:17 emissions then because what people don't realize is that under the paris agreement is something called
00:20:22 the framework convention on climate change it's the original rio treaty that was signed in rio de
00:20:28 janeiro in 1992 and it's what all the u.n treaties are based on it's called the fccc framework convention
00:20:34 on climate change and it treats developing and developing countries completely differently it says that
00:20:41 developing countries first and overriding priority and they still include china even today even today
00:20:47 in 1992 china had no billionaires i mean now they have i don't know maybe a hundred or something
00:20:53 they're pretty wealthy a lot of them and so china actually was asked at the un climate conference in
00:20:59 peru would they renegotiate the framework convention underlying the paris agreement the negotiator said
00:21:07 no no the purpose of the paris agreement is to enforce the framework convention not to change it
00:21:13 so they know they've got a sweetheart deal they can literally increase emissions forever and if anyone
00:21:19 ever contests them they say no no article 4 in the framework convention says that our first and
00:21:23 overriding priority is poverty alleviation and development and we can't do that if we have to shut
00:21:29 off our cheapest form of power which is coal so they're gonna it's crazy but we actually have to do it
00:21:36 even if it totally ruins our economy so yeah china and russia you know they think it's great you know
00:21:42 especially china absolutely uh before we wrap up here tom what would you like to see from the
00:21:47 conservatives in terms of their policies around uh the climates around the environment well step
00:21:53 number one is stop calling it carbon or carbon pollution carbon dioxide you know it's carbon dioxide
00:21:58 start calling it that don't use the enemy's language you know there's generals old chinese 0.99
00:22:03 generals said you never fight a battle on your company or your sorry your your opposition's terrain
00:22:09 or using their standards okay so stop calling it carbon it's not carbon it's carbon dioxide
00:22:14 and the second thing is start advocating for adaptation that's a sensible approach that will
00:22:20 actually give us benefits okay the idea that we are going to help stop climate change even if you
00:22:25 believe the science makes no sense at all because canada's uh commitment to kyoto and pro you know the
00:22:31 paris agreement they are literally trivial contributions to world greenhouse gas emissions so
00:22:37 focus on adaptation and that'll also help them kill the idea that they're climate deniers because
00:22:42 it's you know of course climate changes and we have to help people the other thing of course is to
00:22:47 increase our resilience and we do that by having our strongest cheapest and most reliable forms of energy
00:22:54 very strongly protected okay so we need to do that and whenever they say well do you think humans are
00:23:00 causing dangerous climate change you can say very clearly well the jury's still out and until it's
00:23:06 more solidly determined what is actually going on in the atmosphere we're advocating a no regrets approach
00:23:12 which is to reduce air pollution which may at times reduce co2 as well and to save energy and to have
00:23:20 adaptation but stop calling it carbon pollution very interesting well thank you tom harris from the
00:23:27 international climate science coalition of canada thank you for having me for being on the show yeah
00:23:31 thank you matthew