Western Standard - September 18, 2025


FILDEBRANDT: The independence question: Parallels between Quebec and Alberta

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
Canadian students fear consequences of expressing their views in class CORY MORGAN SHOW: Canada can’t afford free housing

Episode Stats


Length

50 minutes

Words per minute

153.8

Word count

7,786

Sentence count

500

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Paul St-Pierre Plamondon, better known as PSPP, is the leader of the Parti Quebecois and is widely regarded as the front-runner to become the next premier of Quebec. In this episode, we talk to him about the challenges faced by his party and why there might be some commonality between Alberta and the West.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I'm Derek Fildebrand, publisher of the Western Standard. Today is September 11th, 2025.
00:00:17 Today I'm joined by Paul St. Pierre Plamondon, better known as PSPP. He is the leader of the
00:00:25 Parti Quebecois. He took over the leadership of that party when it was down to just three seats and at
00:00:32 its lowest level of support ever, but has since grown it to the first place in the polls and is
00:00:39 widely considered to be the frontrunner to become the next Premier of Quebec. He is in Alberta right
00:00:46 now. Just this morning he was speaking at the University of Calgary, speaking about the
00:00:53 challenges of Quebec and where there might be alignment and some commonality with Alberta
00:00:57 and the West. His team reached out to us and I think it was a fantastic opportunity to speak
00:01:04 to someone outside of our normal comfort zone, outside of our bubble, getting a different
00:01:09 perspective on the kinds of issues we face in the West from someone who leads a party trying
00:01:15 to address the similar-ish challenges that they have in Quebec. Paul, thank you very much
00:01:24 for joining.
00:01:25 My pleasure.
00:01:27 So I'll pick up kind of from our pre-camera conversation.
00:01:31 Yeah.
00:01:33 You know, I think outside of Quebec, there is an extremely simplistic understanding of the
00:01:39 party Quebec law and in most provinces, the politics are lined up broadly along a left-right
00:01:48 spectrum. You know, NDP, liberal, conservative, you know, fit green in there in some provinces,
00:01:54 sometimes not. In Quebec, its politics have, at least since the quiet revolution in the 60s,
00:01:59 been defined along a more nationalist, federalist axis and, you know, there's places to go along
00:02:07 that. But it's also still got left-right that does play into it, just not as neatly as in
00:02:15 other places. In Alberta, the nationalist, federalist spectrum lines up very neatly on
00:02:24 a left-right, because, you know, because our nationalist movement is not so much based on
00:02:31 culture, language, that kind of thing. It's more of an economic and civic nationalist thing.
00:02:37 So, I don't know, maybe if you could just start with, you know, where does, how should an
00:02:43 English Canadian understand the party Quebec law?
00:02:46 Let's try the, let's give it a shot. I think you're correct. So the Parti Québécois is a party
00:02:53 founded upon a willingness of the population in Quebec for self-determination.
00:03:00 So what it is about is democracy and making our own choices, not sending money to Ottawa for them,
00:03:09 with only 20% of the seats, for them to decide what we ought to do with that money.
00:03:14 It's particular, of course, in the case of Quebec, you're correct to say that the linguistic and
00:03:19 cultural aspect of it is important, because if you can't make your own policies and spend your own
00:03:25 money where you think it belongs, you will see very important challenges in terms of sustaining,
00:03:33 having durability for the French language, the Quebec culture, but it goes also to emigration,
00:03:38 the place of the judiciary power that is always, almost always aligned with the Liberal Party of
00:03:44 Canada. So we'll not rule in favor of what would have been the democratic choice of Quebec.
00:03:50 So you have several topics where the democratic will of Quebecers is overruled by a federal government
00:03:58 that tends to abuse its powers by spending in fields that should be the fields of the provinces.
00:04:06 In terms of right and left, Quebec in general tend to be centrist. So you'll see if you compare to
00:04:13 France, England, United States, elsewhere, there is radical left and there is radical right.
00:04:19 But the behavior in general is more towards the center. Parti Québécois has had periods where it was
00:04:28 quite to the left, other periods that were qualified as more to the right of the center. But it's always
00:04:35 close to the center, you can say that. And as for the current Parti Québécois, it will be now five years
00:04:42 this fall that I'm the leader of the Parti Québécois. I think you could say we're anti-radical left,
00:04:48 social democrats, which is, which is... You don't say moderate left? It's... Yeah, you could say
00:04:55 moderate left. And sometimes we're right. So it's very difficult to read from a more standard left-right
00:05:01 spectrum because of many factors. But one model that I think would be comparable is a few Scandinavian
00:05:08 countries who came to the conclusion that radical left ideas had the catastrophic impact on their
00:05:16 social peace and on their services and so on. And yet they are pursuing the idea that it should be a
00:05:24 free, a market-based free market society where the richer will contribute to a safety net to services
00:05:31 that are available to everyone. So that's what I would call social democracy, not the same than socialist,
00:05:37 socialist, because socialist is not believing in free market. And yet a very strong criticism from my part
00:05:44 of the direction Canada took under Trudeau, not only the abuse of power, but the ideology, the
00:05:52 counterproductive ideology during that period. And it's still on. I think under Carney, it's still the same
00:05:59 people and the same ideas, I think. So nationalism is, broadly speaking, on the right, sorry, within
00:06:10 the Western civilization, generally associated with the right. But for lack of a better term,
00:06:18 subnational nationalism is more often than not associated with the left, but not always. You know, if we look at,
00:06:28 say, the Scottish National Party, it's a left party. Yeah.
00:06:32 Um, uh, you know, uh, in Catalonia, uh, you know, the, the independence and autonomous movements in
00:06:39 Catalonia associated with the left. Um, uh, and then in Quebec, imperfectly, but I think it's broadly
00:06:48 associated a bit with the left. Uh, Alberta is different where it's, it's almost uniform, like, you know,
00:06:55 among, uh, United Conservative Party supporters in Alberta, 66% support independence, 33% are opposed.
00:07:02 But then among NDP supporters, it's 99% are federalists.
00:07:07 Which, which from Quebec's perspective is incomprehensible. Because if your pretension
00:07:14 is that you should have funding for services to the population and that safety net could be better,
00:07:22 why would you send a substantial part of your income tax to a government that just duplicates or is
00:07:31 wasting your money, giving you very few services in return? Why would you do that? So, so, so, um,
00:07:40 yeah, I, I, I, I don't understand that.
00:07:43 I, I agree. But I think from their perspective, um,
00:07:46 think of the left in Alberta, the way we would think of Anglophones in Quebec, they're a minority and
00:07:54 they rely on the national government to protect them. That if Alberta was its own country, uh,
00:08:00 the left would be permanently shut out of power and it would have overall less influence, that they
00:08:05 use Ottawa to counter, uh, the Alberta government. I, I think that's, that's from their, from their
00:08:10 perspective.
00:08:10 I don't think it's a valid argument, but, uh, it's for them, it's for them to decide.
00:08:16 I'm trying to speak on their behalf, which is obviously a subpar. Um,
00:08:21 right. So you've said you're committed, uh, if you form the Parti Quebecois under your leadership
00:08:25 forms government, you're holding a third referendum on sovereignty. Um, I think you've been pretty
00:08:31 unambiguous about it. It's not, uh, as Lucien Bouchard said, not waiting for winning conditions.
00:08:37 It's we're, we're gonna do it. Um, but what sovereignty or independence means is, um,
00:08:47 sometimes ambiguous. The, uh, the first two referendum questions were, were criticized for
00:08:52 being ambiguous, not very clear cut, uh, in Alberta. Uh, I, if I can give myself a little
00:08:58 credit, the Western standard, I think is imported a lot of the language around independence and sovereignty
00:09:04 from Quebec. Um, when we say independence in Alberta, we mean a Republic of Alberta or, or I
00:09:13 guess technically could be another constitution, but it would be a, a separate independent country
00:09:18 completely on its own, severed, uh, from all direct state ties from Canada. Yeah. Um, it's, it's exactly
00:09:26 the same right now for the Parti Quebecois. Yeah. Now, Daniel Smith has also talked about sovereignty
00:09:31 within Canada, um, with more independence, but not the term independent. But when, when you say
00:09:37 sovereignty, are, are, are you talking about, uh, some kind of sovereignty association or is it like,
00:09:44 no, there's a Republic of Quebec and it is its own country. I say independence. That's it. Um, and
00:09:50 here's what's, what's going to happen if Alberta, uh, continues in the sovereignty association
00:09:57 model, or at least discourse. That discourse will be met in Ottawa with, it's giving Ottawa power to
00:10:06 respond by saying, oh, you think we'll collaborate? You think it will go well? It's going to be terrible.
00:10:12 And then the fear takes all the place because you're dependent on the interpretation of a
00:10:20 regime that feels, uh, threatened or that feels there might be losing powers, so they will not help you.
00:10:29 So, uh, I think I've, I've never discussed, I work with, uh, uh, the people, uh, very close to
00:10:36 René Lévesque, uh, that were very close to René Lévesque. I never understood why they, they came to
00:10:42 that idea of sovereignty. That means that you're still, that you're not really independent. But when
00:10:46 I mean independent, I mean a country with a hundred percent of their capacity from a financial
00:10:52 standpoint, from a law standpoint, and from a standpoint of foreign relations. Now, once you're
00:10:58 a country and you have those foreign relations, nothing is preventing you from making a deal or
00:11:03 inventing a framework with another independent province that say, I think we might, I think we
00:11:08 should work on this together. We have a common interest. The difference in that model is that you
00:11:14 respect the democracy and the legitimacy of both those parliaments. Whereas the current model is
00:11:21 an illegitimate government that will tell you, based on not much, because oftentimes they're
00:11:29 ultra virus of their own constitution. They will tell you how it should be done and your voice will
00:11:34 not be heard, which is pretty much anti-democratic. So I think independence is, it's important to have
00:11:41 that word or that name because it's within independence that you have foreign relations. And
00:11:46 once you have foreign relations, you can set a deal based on your own will, based on self-determination,
00:11:53 democratic self-determination is very different from the current model. And I don't see Canada
00:11:58 stopping ever the abuse of powers that we've seen over and over, over so many decades. Human nature
00:12:07 never leaves power on the table. They might make a deal with you and be nice with you right now. If
00:12:14 they see that Alberta's independence project is getting serious, they might give you a few presents and
00:12:21 give you a break for a while. But once your autonomous government will be out and will be replaced by a
00:12:26 more federalist government, it will start again. That's the history of the Parti Québécois. The
00:12:32 irony with our party is that it's when the Parti Québécois is in power that we make the most gains
00:12:39 from the federal government. So people are just, it's working. But it's not because as soon as you're out of
00:12:45 power, the overall picture is that we've been in decline in terms of invasion of the federal in our
00:12:53 fields of competence, but also decline of the French language, the decline of our culture in our
00:13:00 many aspects that are important for us.
00:13:03 So, uh, if I don't know if you've announced the wording of what your question would be,
00:13:08 but I mean, so you're saying that this, the third referendum is going to have a clear question.
00:13:14 It's something along the lines of should Alberta become an independent country? That's it. Like,
00:13:20 that's it. Yeah. Okay. Well, I should address the first part of the Clarity Act.
00:13:27 No, no, no, it will not. It will not because the federal government is not, has not done the Clarity
00:13:34 Act and has not tried to get the judicial power. I know I made a can of worms as soon as I said that.
00:13:38 But they've not done all that because they worry about fairness. They worry about keeping their
00:13:44 power, their regime. So I do not expect them to stop at this. They'll find something else to say
00:13:53 at the end that they don't recognize it and that it doesn't work. They were not. So they lied during
00:13:59 the referendum of 94. They lied on several things, but they lied on the idea that they will recognize
00:14:04 the result. They said that during the campaign, but we know for a fact from declarations afterwards,
00:14:11 one of Jean Chrétien, that they were not going to recognize it. And so abuse of power doesn't stop
00:14:17 overnight. And I'm not naive about it, but to answer your question, yes, it's about independence
00:14:23 and the question will be very to the point. Okay. Well, since we opened the Clarity Act can of worms,
00:14:29 uh, I guess we'll go down up a little bit. Um, you know, I, uh, I think the only two, uh, places
00:14:41 in Canada as it's currently constituted where there's any kind of number of people who have
00:14:46 actually really looked into it is in Quebec and Alberta because we're the ones who would have to
00:14:51 deal with it. Um, you know, I, I've, I generally thought the first two points of the Clarity Act
00:14:56 are reasonable, a clear question, clear majority. Okay. I mean, that's pretty hard to disagree with,
00:15:01 but it's after that where it just says, but even the clear majority, it's just that could get hazy.
00:15:07 I generally say it's, it's written abuse of power all over it because I mean, what's democracy if
00:15:12 it's not to win or to lose in power with 35% of the vote, sometimes any, and he gets almost all the
00:15:17 power. So what's clear majority? There are defensive mechanisms to keep power, but we're the,
00:15:23 the big problematic area to me is where, where I've seen is that, okay, say Alberta or Quebec
00:15:29 had a clear question and a clear majority. Let's just say it's an argument. It was 80% overwhelming.
00:15:33 You know, no one's going to get that, but let's just say that. Um, but then all it does is oblige
00:15:39 Ottawa to negotiate and you would need unanimity of all the other provinces and Ottawa together.
00:15:45 And at that point, I feel like it's designed by design, uh, to just bog us down in negotiations and
00:15:54 they can make unreasonable demands of that or unreasonable demands of Alberta and say,
00:15:58 well, you know, we're just not agreeing to it. And that leads to two possible outcomes at that point,
00:16:05 which is either we just give up on it and accept status quo despite what people have voted for or
00:16:13 the magic word, you know, a unilateral declaration of independence. Of course. Uh, is that something
00:16:20 you're prepared to do in the event where you enter into negotiations, which would be reasonable, but
00:16:25 those negotiations are maybe not in good faith. Would a government after a successful referendum on
00:16:31 independence and negotiations breaking down is a unilateral declaration of independence, something
00:16:37 you would, uh, be prepared to make. Um, the whole question here is legitimacy of a government
00:16:46 that controls or nominates the judicial power and that will not let it happen and will find any reason
00:16:54 or excuse not to recognize the legitimacy of that change. And that change is currently being
00:17:00 discussed in Alberta and Quebec and might be discussed elsewhere, um, depending on how, uh, where this leads.
00:17:07 I don't find myself obliged by a regime that I don't find legitimate. My only loyalty is towards my people
00:17:20 who elected me. The rest for me is a foreign regime out of a colonial mentality and framework. And so 0.77
00:17:30 when I refused to give an oath to the King of England, people told me, oh, the constitution won't let
00:17:35 you. And I was just, I don't care. I mean, what legitimacy for that constitution? If Quebec never agreed to it,
00:17:44 it's clearly the out, the spinoff of the colonial regime and the willingness to make Francophones a minority
00:17:53 in that new ensemble. Why should I accept to lie and give my loyalty to a foreign king just because you tell me a constitution
00:18:03 that is illegitimate tells me so. So I didn't decide to, to put a knee down and, and, and to make that oath. I just
00:18:09 continued. And I said, this is not legitimate. So legitimacy in democracy is much more important than, um,
00:18:19 um, um, legal documents that actually were never consented upon by the different members of that
00:18:30 ensemble. So, so that's, that's where declaring the independence of Quebec, if I have a majority of my
00:18:36 people supporting me is not only, uh, what, uh, what I'm going to do. It's my devoir. It's my obligation,
00:18:44 because I know that there's no future. The policies of Canada are working against Quebec's interest in
00:18:51 so many ways. There's no future for French speaking with a Quebec culture. Uh, that kind of Quebec will 1.00
00:18:57 not exist in a hundred years if I don't do anything. And financially speaking, I don't want charity from
00:19:04 any other province. And I don't feel it's normal to send almost half of my tax income to a government
00:19:11 that duplicates or wastes the money I've gained. I disagree with that. So, so legitimacy, I think,
00:19:18 is really important in understanding what's coming, whether it comes from Alberta or it comes from
00:19:23 Quebec, because otherwise you see it from other governments in the world. Like there's, there's no end
00:19:28 to being in bad faith using legal instruments that you've created yourself to protect yourself and
00:19:34 protect your power. I mean, democracy is much more about popular legitimacy than, uh, a power that
00:19:41 tries to hold on to, uh, what they have. Uh, I'm going to get into the, uh, the finance side of
00:19:47 independence, et cetera, in a bit, but, um, uh, that's interesting. Um, you've said
00:19:55 that Alberta's independence or more broadly speaking, nationalist movement, because we have a spectrum
00:20:00 as well. We've got hardline autonomists who want to still fly the Maple Leaf, but want as little control
00:20:06 from how it was possible to people who are full independence, we've got a, we've got, we have a
00:20:10 spectrum like yourselves. Yeah. Um, but you've said that Alberta's independence or nationalist movement,
00:20:17 um, uh, benefits Quebec's independence movement. Um, but a lot of our independence movement is
00:20:27 on different sets of issues as yours, which is perfectly normal. Yeah. I mean, Quebec's is,
00:20:33 um, you know, I, I grew up with a pretty unfavorable view of Quebec and that's really
00:20:40 changed over the years. Um, as I've come to understand Alberta struggle and also as I've come
00:20:45 to Quebec, you know, when I visit Quebec city, I get such a different feeling there than it almost
00:20:51 in the Anglo city. It's, it's a place where you can feel the history in the air, in the architecture.
00:20:59 There, there is a old people with a culture worth preserving there. You can feel it. And,
00:21:05 and I, uh, and I'm, I'm somewhat envious of it. I think, uh, Calgary is one, one of the very few
00:21:12 other, you know, Quebec city and Calgary have a real unique sense of culture. I think Calgary
00:21:17 is losing it very quickly, but I, I've come to understand, uh, Quebec's need to preserve what
00:21:23 it has. Uh, sometimes that irks us in terms of how it flows out of its borders and from our
00:21:28 perspective, some dull standards, but I've, I've come to very much understand the struggle you're
00:21:32 having and why you do it. Um, but you know, our, our nationalist or independence movement, uh,
00:21:40 is less cultural, more focused on economics, um, and fiscal issues. So when we fight about
00:21:48 equalization, uh, and a large part of the bone we pick is with Quebec, how does even, because we're,
00:21:55 we're picking a bone is largely in terms of, you know, we don't, we'll get into the numbers a bit.
00:22:01 Uh, we don't want to be seen as subsidizing Quebec. We're angry at Quebec for opposing pipeline
00:22:07 construction to get our products to market. How does us picking fights on fronts that are
00:22:12 largely with Quebec benefit Quebec's nationalist movement? Well, I think one of the reasons why
00:22:21 I'm in Calgary today is that I was kind of, um, tired of non-conversation that pertains to whether
00:22:31 Alberta would make the same choices of Quebec than Quebec and vice versa and financial disputes 0.90
00:22:39 that are all the consequences of a system that you didn't agree upon and I didn't agree upon.
00:22:46 So from my standpoint, um, I don't want Alberta's money. I, um, think that if Quebec stopped sending
00:22:57 90 billions a year to Ottawa for little services and a lot of dysfunctionality, a government that always
00:23:06 contradicts our own government and always very too often for me, uh, a lot of waste, a lot of
00:23:13 mismanagement. If we get rid of that, I mean, I don't want equalization payments. It's not good for
00:23:19 our economy because getting money is the worst strategy in terms of entrepreneurship and the
00:23:26 growth and economic value. But you have said, I don't know the exact words because I can't read
00:23:32 or speak French, but, uh, so correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe you've said that Quebec isn't
00:23:38 reliant on equalization from Alberta. Uh, but Alberta's contributed 67 billion to equalization since
00:23:43 1957. Quebec is at least in gross terms, not per capita, but gross terms, the largest recipient.
00:23:49 Yeah. Um, so I want to try to make sense with what you've said. You said we don't want equalization.
00:23:55 No. And we're saying, um, Quebec is not reliant on equalization. Uh, I think I see those two as
00:24:02 incongruent. Yeah. Um, I have a wonderful document. I might find it right now. So this is the finances
00:24:11 of an independent Quebec. You have, uh, six economists from different universities in Quebec
00:24:17 who oversaw the, the works. Basically what that says is that if you limit your analysis to equalization,
00:24:27 if you limit your analysis to equalization payments, then you'll say this is a scandal and
00:24:32 everything. But the, the way the federal government works is that it takes a lot of money out of our
00:24:38 pockets. And then it just spends, it spends much more than what equalization payment is overall.
00:24:44 Yeah. But we have to talk about total net, uh, in the net. So you have to look at investment,
00:24:49 direct investment in the economy. You have to look at, uh, how the government, uh, the federal government,
00:24:55 government investor does not invest in assets in infrastructure because it's very unequal
00:25:02 depending, uh, and you have to look at how much there's obvious duplication and obvious waste.
00:25:10 Because if you're in a scenario where Alberta is independent and Quebec is independent,
00:25:16 you will not be spending for two ministers of health and you'll not be spending for doing two
00:25:22 times the same thing and arguing about it because you disagree. You'll, you won't have that anymore.
00:25:27 I agree with that. So they're with very, very conservative and prudent standards. We come to
00:25:32 the conclusion that then, even though we wouldn't get equalization payments, other factors such as
00:25:39 direct investment in the economy, other factors such as stopping this duplication in this waste and
00:25:46 other factors such as having our own monetary strategy, our own international commerce strategy
00:25:53 would make us more rich because the truth about equalization payments is that it hinders our
00:25:59 economy, our entrepreneurship. The Canadian dollar is also very much related to oil and gas, which has
00:26:07 an impact on our exports. So overall to say that Quebec at the level of wealth and productivity we have
00:26:15 couldn't stand alone as a country is just undefendable. Obviously we will find a way, but it will be
00:26:22 our strategy, our, our way, and we will not need foreign money. And, and I don't want to, but we will not
00:26:31 take the contempt that goes with it too, because the public discourse on those, there is, it's just pure
00:26:39 yeah. So is it good for us? No. So I'll be glad that all this stopped and you'll be glad.
00:26:45 So, and then afterwards. Now, now we're talking Turkey. Yeah. And then afterwards we can sit down
00:26:51 and say, okay, so now we decide for ourselves, we're responsible for ourselves. Uh, but are there
00:26:57 fields or things that we really want to work together on a common framework? Cause it just makes sense.
00:27:03 Yeah. And then you'll get something that is effective and useful, but the current federal government is just
00:27:08 raising taxes and they weren't, they, they were not doing this before the first world war. They didn't
00:27:14 need, they didn't need, but it's a source of power. You just raise taxes and then you use that money as
00:27:20 power saying, Hey, you want something for your new university? Here's my requirement. You need to do
00:27:25 this. You need DEI everywhere. You want something for your, uh, really learn to talk to Albertans.
00:27:30 But it's, it's a huge debate in Quebec because it's, it's about freedom of research. And, and, and, uh,
00:27:37 sometimes I would even say, uh, false knowledge that is forced by the federal government who has
00:27:43 all sorts of requirements for money that is ours. They take it in our pocket and instead of sending it
00:27:49 back, so back, so for healthcare, we ask for 6 billion based on historical contributions of the
00:27:55 federal and our, and the healthcare systems, but they're so busy starting new programs and inventing
00:28:01 things. They don't have any more money for, for fundamentals such as healthcare. So are we better
00:28:07 off just keeping all the money in Quebec and just managing it? And if we make mistakes with it,
00:28:13 our responsibility, are we bidding better off in that system? Obviously, yes.
00:28:16 So, so, so is that available in English? I'd like to, uh, no, it was published in the official
00:28:23 language of, but, um, uh, figures are figures. So, so, uh, but you know, if, if you guys were able
00:28:31 to send me a digital version, I could run it through like Google translate. I think we can do
00:28:34 something. I'd be interested to see. Just calculations are calculations. Yeah. I, I'd be, uh, uh, I've been in
00:28:40 politics and I was the finest critic. You can make a calculation, say anything. One thing I want to say to
00:28:44 those listening to us who are interested in the independent, the possibility of the independence
00:28:48 of Alberta, bear in mind that when you're going to make calculations and obviously you're going to
00:28:54 come to the conclusion that if you stop sending money into Ottawa and you keep it here and you
00:28:59 make choices more aligned with your commercial strategy or industrial strategy, you'll be richer.
00:29:04 That will be the conclusion. What the agents of the regime, because I call them like that. So you'll
00:29:09 have agents of the federal regime everywhere in society that will say it's never going to work
00:29:15 and you should fear your freedom. You should fear your self-determination. It's going to be a disaster.
00:29:20 What they'll say is, oh, all the variables are not certain. So you say that this and that variable
00:29:28 is like that, but you have no certainty. But the trap here is what certainty had Justin Trudeau in power
00:29:36 in terms of economics for the past 10 years. What certainty Mark Carney has. I mean, we had zero
00:29:41 growth during 10 years based on really an ideological drift from immigration and commerce and economic
00:29:50 strategies. I mean, just so people understand, sound calculations will be met by the regime
00:29:59 with arguments on uncertainty of variables. The truth is, variables are always uncertain. What
00:30:07 counts is the fundamentals. Is the reasoning sound? Are the fundamentals solid? And then, of course,
00:30:13 things happen and things change in terms of context. But if your fundamentals make sense, obviously,
00:30:21 there are so many countries in the world. Obviously, countries get along and they make their own choice.
00:30:26 So I'm getting a better understanding of what you're saying.
00:30:31 That yes, Quebec is maybe a net recipient of federal dollars, but Ottawa is just so inefficient
00:30:39 and duplicative that independence, even without a net influx of federal dollars, you'd still be ahead.
00:30:47 Slightly ahead. That's what the figures say. Slightly better off.
00:30:50 But then you would have total autonomy to do it as you see fit.
00:30:54 Our own strategy.
00:30:55 Yeah. And, you know, you would have, I guess to kind of come back to what I was saying earlier,
00:31:01 you know, more autonomy or total independence to protect your culture, your way of life, language,
00:31:07 etc. When I'm having discussions about Alberta independence versus Quebec independence with people,
00:31:15 I use, it's an imperfect analogy, but I, you know, there are very different kinds of nationalism.
00:31:23 As I've said, Alberta's tends to be more civic nationalism, although defending our culture is
00:31:29 becoming an issue as mass migration becomes a huge issue. That's actually becoming an issue here now,
00:31:34 where it wasn't really previously. But, you know, I, I, I've, I've said that, you know, Quebec, for Quebec nationalists,
00:31:46 or people who might be in the middle on that, you know, their heart tells them independence, but their brain tells them Canada,
00:31:53 because, because of the, because of equalization, things like that. And you've made, and you've made your point on it.
00:31:58 Yeah, but I think it's the opposite. But I've said their, their brain will keep to the conclusion that we should be a country,
00:32:03 and then fear will come into play. So I would place it rather that way.
00:32:08 Yeah, I'm speaking very generally, and imperfectly. But I've said that, you know, Quebecers, because it's more of a cultural nationalism,
00:32:17 their hearts. Yeah, their hearts are in it, but their brains, and this might be the fear part,
00:32:25 the brains say, ah, it's uncertain, we're going to lose equalization, etc. So their brains say no.
00:32:31 And then in Alberta, it's the opposite. We broadly understand that we are massively subsidizing the
00:32:37 rest of Canada, that our brains say, we would be significantly better off as an independent country.
00:32:42 But our hearts, well, we're English-speaking Canadians. We, our hearts are in Canada,
00:32:48 but our brains are independent. So, so that it, you know, these are opposite.
00:32:52 They are, because in Quebec, the federal government is not there. It's very strange. Our government is in
00:33:00 Quebec City. It's the National Assembly. And the space for what happens in the House of Commons in Ottawa,
00:33:06 and the news cycle is, it's totally absent. It's, it's not there, because we don't feel it's our
00:33:13 government. And sometimes you hear Quebecers talking about money that the government of,
00:33:18 the federal government sends, or it's as if it's foreign money. We've been paying taxes, right?
00:33:24 Our brains are increasingly feeling like it's foreign.
00:33:26 Well, we just agreed that this was not healthy. What I want to say is that you are maybe entering
00:33:34 a new phase where you are now in Quebec's position, where you would like
00:33:40 something else than the Liberals in power. And then you realize it's not going to happen,
00:33:46 even in extreme circumstances. That's Quebec's situation with the Bloc Québécois for decades.
00:33:53 If we express what we want at the federal level, oftentimes, the vast majority of times,
00:34:01 the answer will be Bloc Québécois. That Bloc Québécois cannot rule, cannot be in power. It can
00:34:08 basically act as a defensive mechanism. Many of us are envious of the Bloc. Against 0.93
00:34:16 abuses of powers. And there are so many, so they do their best. But it's not sustainable. It's not
00:34:22 something you want forever. So the Bloc Québécois was meant to be a very short term mechanism.
00:34:27 So I'm not from Alberta, so I don't want to. But I imagine that after Trudeau,
00:34:35 Trudeau's government, if you end up that there's no alternative, there's no rotation,
00:34:42 it might trigger questions that we have for a long time. Thinking if we cannot have,
00:34:53 if we don't have any probabilities or reasonable rotation of what we think cures what we dislike
00:35:01 with, for instance, the Trudeau government, people will start asking themselves, okay,
00:35:06 so what are the other options? Because we're pretty not heard. We're pretty much out of the system.
00:35:14 And it's the case as well with judiciary power. So the more the judiciary power takes power over
00:35:20 democratic choices of parliaments, if those judges are almost all aligned with the Liberal Party of
00:35:27 Canada in terms of way of thinking and ideology, those questions exist in Quebec for decades.
00:35:33 They might become more present and relevant in Alberta, given what I've just mentioned,
00:35:39 as a political development in Ottawa.
00:35:47 We're limited on time, so I'm trying to figure out which one I want to get at. Your staff is going to
00:35:51 get angry at me if I go too far over. So maybe you could be a real short one on this.
00:35:56 Yes. Certain areas, part of my family comes from Bavaria in Germany. And Bavaria has a different
00:36:04 title that it calls itself. It's not just a lander, a state in Germany, it calls itself a free state,
00:36:09 Freistadt. I know you want independence, but as an interest, I've talked about Alberta should stop.
00:36:15 One thing I've really admired is Quebec, especially Quebec national politicians,
00:36:20 they never call Quebec a province. That's something I've picked up in the link.
00:36:23 But you know what province means? Conquered land.
00:36:27 Yeah. Oh, it comes from Provence, which was conquered by the Roman Republic.
00:36:30 Yeah, it's from Provencia.
00:36:31 Yeah, exactly.
00:36:32 So it's a conquered land. So of course, we don't consent to a conquered land.
00:36:36 I'm kind of letting slip in our style guide here. I've picked this up. I've taken a lot of the Quebec
00:36:40 language and I don't refer to Alberta and Saskatchewan as provinces as much as I can in our own pages here.
00:36:45 But sometimes the language gets different because they are provinces. So I've thought that Alberta and
00:36:52 Saskatchewan should unilaterally, even without changing the constitution, at least call themselves
00:36:59 a free state. It's the same power as a province. It is changing what Quebec calls itself. The symbolism
00:37:05 matters and the Quebec nationalist movement is decades ahead of Alberta. Would you, as an interim
00:37:11 step, do something like call Quebec a free state or something like that? It's a title change.
00:37:17 The problem we have right now is that at the pace things are going, the way the federal
00:37:23 policies are oriented and the impact it has in Quebec, the specificity of Quebec from a
00:37:31 linguistic and cultural point of view will not last for very long. A bit like what happened to
00:37:37 Francophones in every other province. We're losing it in English Canada, even.
00:37:41 Okay. So then you understand that in the history of the Parti Quebecois and you have that with the
00:37:47 CEQ that is the current government in Quebec, you'll have a tendency to say, what can we do that is
00:37:54 symbolic? But we know it's not going to change much, but at least we have our own party at that point.
00:38:01 You know, we'll say, oh, we did that. So we'll change unilaterally a part of the Canadian constitution
00:38:10 to say we're a nation. And then we'll say it's a historic moment and it's great. It's awesome. So
00:38:16 let's say we start calling ourselves free states. If we're not free and we haven't achieved any change
00:38:25 in a system that abuses powers over what should be ruled and decided by our respective parliaments,
00:38:34 what good do we get? I mean, what's so I don't oppose it. Of course, I will not never be against
00:38:40 initiatives that show that we're not a province in the sense of the Latin word. But I'm somewhere else
00:38:48 at this point because I don't think there's any future for French speaking Quebec if we don't get 0.92
00:38:54 out of Canada as soon as possible. So given that analysis or diagnosis I've made, don't expect the
00:39:04 government of the Parti Quebecois to do some things only because it looks good or feels good.
00:39:10 And I'm afraid that sometimes in symbolics, we're not going forward. You can be declining very,
00:39:17 very fast while making symbolics that feel good. And I think that's a good resume of what the CEQ has
00:39:24 done. It's huge decline under the CEQ in all respects, housing, French language, culture, but they've done
00:39:31 things like they have, they have done things that probably were in good faith, but the impact of those
00:39:37 things are not proportional to the level of challenge under Trudeau's government, under the
00:39:43 liberals. And I don't see things changing under Carney. It's the same people, the same mentality
00:39:49 of them deciding instead of us on fundamental things for our cultural and linguistic sustainability.
00:39:56 So I'm just going to fit one last question in before your staff member goes and pulls the plug
00:40:01 at our microphones here.
00:40:02 Sure. Well, she's not, she's not very aggressive. 1.00
00:40:05 She's very, she's friendly. She's not, she's, she seems nice. Um, you know, as I've said,
00:40:11 Alberta and Quebec both want decentralization and more power at home, but we tend to want different
00:40:18 kinds, Quebec, more cultural, uh, Alberta, more physical, but we, we do to some extent we both.
00:40:24 Yeah. And things are changing. I mean, yeah, I increasingly want more here. Uh, immigration is 1.00
00:40:29 not just a fiscal issue. Now it is very much a social issue. And, um, uh, so, you know,
00:40:36 we've talked about where, so building those alliances I find has pretty, you know, the,
00:40:40 the, the two big decentralist provinces, to use a dirty word. Um, but we've wanted different kinds
00:40:47 and I, and in large measure, that is why Meech Lake and especially Charlottetown accords failed.
00:40:52 Um, you know, Quebec and Alberta were the two leading areas of Canada that voted down
00:40:57 Charlottetown, but we voted it down for very different reasons. Uh, Albertans and Westerners 1.00
00:41:03 broadly voted it down, uh, because it was seen as, uh, creating asymmetrical federalism,
00:41:10 giving special deals to Quebec. Uh, and there was also some first nations issues in it. There was,
00:41:14 you know, it was a huge, huge agreement. Um, and, but we voted it down for one set of reasons,
00:41:20 seeing it being seen as overly appeasing Quebec, Quebecers voted it down, at least as I perceive it as
00:41:26 it didn't go far enough in defending Quebec's culture and autonomy.
00:41:32 I know you prefer independence. Uh, I prefer independence. Um, but I mean, you've tried twice,
00:41:40 didn't work. We, we haven't even had a shot at it. And even then we'd have a, it's a long shot for us to
00:41:44 achieve it. Yeah. Failing independence. Is there some kind of grand bargain? We call it Charlottetown
00:41:59 two that could, uh, okay. Poor us. Yeah. But like if failing independence, if independence is not
00:42:08 successful, is there a kind of grand bargain from your perspective that you think you could make
00:42:15 that would make, uh, the Quebec nation happy and content within Canada that would work for you?
00:42:25 To the question, what does Quebec want? The answer is clear, crystal clear. Quebec wants self-determination,
00:42:33 democratic self-determination. Why? Because it's the only model that gives a future to our specificity,
00:42:41 linguistic and cultural. Other financial reasons have joined the reasons, but basically that's it. So,
00:42:50 I mean, the only reason why
00:42:55 federal prime ministers engaged into such complicated negotiations and talks
00:43:02 was that they felt there was a direct threat to their power
00:43:07 and their regime. They didn't do that in good faith because they just like to improve the life
00:43:13 of Quebecers or Albertans. So, it might happen that as Quebec's sovereignty movement,
00:43:20 independence movement, grows in strength, and probably Alberta's same movement grows in strength,
00:43:26 in good faith. You'll find federal politicians nervous saying, okay, let's renegotiate in good faith.
00:43:35 I think we've been through that and anything under self-determination in terms of our laws,
00:43:41 our finances and international relations will not work for Quebec because it will not work for our
00:43:49 linguistic, cultural, and financial specificity. However, once it's done, so once Quebec declares
00:43:58 independence, I think if Alberta declares independence, Quebec will follow, same here,
00:44:04 vice versa. If Quebec goes, I think Alberta will say, okay, I'm also independent. In which case,
00:44:13 we will talk to each other about what framework would be useful on a number of topics,
00:44:20 but without the federal trying to grab money and grab power and defend their privileges, without them,
00:44:27 without interference and constant abuse of power since 1667, a constitution that we never voted or agreed
00:44:34 upon, it's in direct link. It's really about the colonial regime for Quebec. So, I think it's the other way
00:44:45 around. You become independent and a bit like Norway and Sweden or Slovakia and Czech Republic or in many,
00:44:52 like, of course, in the following days, I will not be wanting to negotiate with the federal.
00:45:01 I will want to negotiate with other provinces who think actually mostly the same thing as I do
00:45:06 about how it should work. It doesn't mean we agree on our priorities, but we agree that a framework
00:45:13 that would respect our respective, would show respect to our respective parliaments is much
00:45:19 better than abuse of power based on an old and dysfunctional constitution. And you have to add to
00:45:26 that that we were, during the patriation of the 1982 constitution, we were totally out of it. It's just
00:45:35 the end of the contempt is a better start for a new framework than trying to deal with people who have
00:45:44 have been abusing their powers, begging them to stop abusing their powers. And take the immigration 1.00
00:45:50 situation. So, Justin Trudeau out of the blue, but not out of the blue. You had a group called the
00:45:56 Century Initiative on Bay Street. They decided that we need to be 100 million Canadians based on whatever
00:46:02 fluke economics. They don't consult anyone. They just start doing this by saying, hey, come to Roxham.
00:46:09 And they changed the criteria at the airport. They really sabotaged our immigration system that was
00:46:17 working well. They were warned by provinces. They were warned by their own public servants. You will
00:46:23 create the worst housing crisis we've seen in decades. Don't do it. And they did it anyway. So why would
00:46:31 I negotiate with these people? Why would I give them legitimacy? They're abusing their power and they're 0.51
00:46:38 toxic for the public good in Quebec. And I think many Albertans are starting to think the same in
00:46:45 regards of their conception of public good in Alberta. So I'd rather have independence. And then we make a
00:46:52 deal and we talk because I expect collaboration to be ongoing on so many things. Simply, we're used to it.
00:46:59 And there are so many things we can work. And that's why I'm here. So just to say, by the way,
00:47:05 the door is open. We have many things to talk about. But going through a new Charlottetown or a
00:47:11 new Meech Lake, I just don't see where it could lead that is positive. I just don't see it.
00:47:18 Okay. Well, I'm just going to sneak one last one because it's really quick. You've convinced me on a lot
00:47:23 of things. So when you have that third referendum on independence, are you going to let Albertans vote in it?
00:47:28 Yeah. Well, you know that the federal government cheated on the second referendum by bringing in
00:47:35 people that were not from Quebec in order them to vote in a result that was so close.
00:47:40 Yeah. So among the things that maybe people listening to us in Alberta don't know.
00:47:44 Letting us vote could help you.
00:47:45 I mean, they arrested members of the Parti Québécois. They stolen the list of members.
00:47:52 They cheated during the patriation of the Constitution. They cheated during the referendums.
00:47:57 They, I mean, at some point, yes, there could be some kind of solidarity or some common understanding
00:48:06 of the fact that serving genuine democracy is serving public good. And that's why when you're
00:48:13 asking me about how the federal will react in terms of Clarity Act and so on, there's been so many instances
00:48:19 where the federal cheated and was dishonest. So I don't expect anything else. And yes, some form of
00:48:29 collaboration on the fundamentals would be useful. And I think that's why I'm here. I'm just
00:48:36 your self-determination in Alberta is yours to determine. It's yours to decide. And if you feel you
00:48:43 have a common identity and common interests that are worth becoming a country, good for you. And it's
00:48:50 not for me to have a judgment on it. But if I can be useful to democracy or if we can be useful to our
00:48:58 both our interests, economic interests in the short term and so on, why not talk instead of being in that
00:49:05 weird equalization and federal framework where nobody agrees because the interests are just not
00:49:12 compatible and the abuse of power is so constant, it creates frustration. So I think in a way,
00:49:17 the reason I'm here is exactly that. So we can talk at least and see what positive could come
00:49:26 in the next decades, given the decade we just experimented under the liberals, federal liberals.
00:49:32 Well, I think there's been a fascinating conversation. I think this is the kind of conversation,
00:49:38 the whole dynamic of it is not something that Quebecers, Albertans, Westerners or Canadians
00:49:43 broadly are very used to. So I really appreciate you coming in.
00:49:46 And I salute all of those who listened and I might be back. So there'll be other opportunities to think
00:49:55 about this. Our invitation is open. We'd love to have you back. Thank you very much.
00:49:59 My pleasure. Thank you. All right. That's Paul St-Pierre Plomondon, leader of the Parti Québécois,
00:50:10 sharing his thoughts. Thank you very much for joining us. Remember, if you're not yet a member
00:50:15 of the Western Standard, go to westernstandard.news, click on subscribe. It's only $10 a month or $100 a
00:50:20 year to support our work and get full access to all Western Standard content. Thank you very much for
00:50:25 joining us today and God bless.