Western Standard - January 13, 2021


Franco Terrazzano with the Canadian Taxpayers Federation

Topics
Mentioned
Megan McCaffrey with Common Sense Calgary petitions to Reopen Calgary Jan 13, 2021

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

185.56

Word count

2,120

Sentence count

82


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A special broadcast with Franco Terrazano of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation discussing a release from a Freedom of Information request from the Alberta government on how much was spent on pay raises for government workers in 2019 and why it needs to stop.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Hey, everybody. Welcome to a special broadcast just after our weekly live broadcast. I'm
00:01:13 chatting with Franco Terrizano, the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. They put out a press
00:01:18 release today on some stuff they got from a FOIP request that is really worth talking
00:01:24 about in these tough times because we're just seeing so many areas of a double standard,
00:01:29 as the common folks are struggling and the not-so-common folks seem to be still benefiting and doing well.
00:01:36 So good to see you, Franco. Can you expand a bit on what you guys released today?
00:01:40 Yeah, for sure. Well, thank you so much first for having me on, Corey.
00:01:43 So we got Freedom of Information requests back from the Alberta government.
00:01:47 And, you know, 2020 has been really such a tough year.
00:01:51 But economically, it's clear that we're really not all in this together, right?
00:01:55 So we've had people who have lost their jobs, we've had people who have taken pay cuts, we've had businesses close down their doors, but we found more than 7,000 provincial government bureaucrats that received a raise in 2020, right? During the lockdowns, during the economic nosedive. And why that's so important is that that means families and businesses who are struggling are going to have to pay higher taxes for this, right? And, you know, we are struggling. We need relief. We don't need bigger bureaucrat salaries here in Alberta.
00:02:26 Yeah, well, at a time like this, we're all taking cuts.
00:02:29 We're tightening our belts.
00:02:30 I mean, at the very least, you'd think they would freeze salaries.
00:02:33 Yet, what were those numbers that was getting into some high millions there with a great
00:02:37 number of people getting some salary increases?
00:02:40 Well, the cost in 2020 for these pay raises for provincial bureaucrats was a little over
00:02:45 $18 million.
00:02:47 But really, that's just the tip of the iceberg, right?
00:02:49 Because that freedom of information request that we put in, we also asked for the cost
00:02:53 going back to 2015 for pay raises. And we found out that those costs are $245 million. So since
00:03:01 2015, when the downturn really began in Alberta, Alberta taxpayers have had to pay an extra $245
00:03:08 million for bureaucrat pay hikes in the provincial government. Yeah, and you would think with a,
00:03:16 I mean, the scaling down has got to come soon. I mean, we've, everything else is contracting,
00:03:22 We can't afford to keep increasing and increasing, not just the pay rates, but the numbers of these people.
00:03:28 Do you think there might be a willingness on the part finally, though, for some of these for the government to show the will to start cutting things?
00:03:35 And perhaps some of the union has to realize if we don't stop this excessive compensation for bureaucrats and some of these civil servants,
00:03:42 that we're going to have to start just outright laying them off eventually.
00:03:45 Well, I mean, Premier Jason Kenney has to tackle the labor costs here.
00:03:48 Right. So by the end of the year, we're looking at one hundred billion dollars in provincial government debt.
00:03:53 So the obvious question is, how are we going to pay for all of this?
00:03:56 And it's just it's not fair to be asking struggling families who are having a tough time just getting groceries on the table,
00:04:03 living from paycheck to paycheck or to go to small businesses and ask them to pay higher taxes because government bureaucrats and government union bosses don't want to take a pay hike.
00:04:12 Right. So just in terms of fairness, it's time for the provincial government.
00:04:16 it's time for kenny to cut back these costs but then we also have to look at the budget problem
00:04:20 you know i talk about that 100 billion dollars in debt that we're going to have to pay back well
00:04:25 you know the biggest expense the biggest day-to-day expense for the alberta government
00:04:28 is this labor costs so as a really premier kenny um our finance minister travis taves they have
00:04:34 very little option um to balance the budget if they're not willing to take some air out of these
00:04:39 ballooning labor costs yeah so we're getting a well we've seen a lot of it with the do as they
00:04:45 say, not as I do. And we'd really need to see some leadership by example. I mean, we've seen
00:04:51 that with the recent vacationing elected officials and staffers. And now, again, we're seeing it with
00:04:57 a different class of folks, but they're still enjoying job security, plus actual increases
00:05:04 in compensation at a time like this. So you guys have also been pushing for something that might
00:05:08 help spur our government to feel a little more inclined to listen to the electorate between
00:05:12 elections uh can you expand a bit on that yeah so i mean we're all we're all upset with this uh
00:05:18 this vacationing scandal right and we have every right to be upset here i mean these politicians
00:05:23 they they they lock down businesses uh people people's jobs might be at risk from that they ask
00:05:29 families to spend the holidays apart and then we find out these some politicians have been traveling
00:05:34 abroad and you know people are really upset but the key is how are we going to move forward with
00:05:38 this and at the kane taxpayers federation we think that this shows that we need recall legislation
00:05:44 in alberta right because right now we have to wait until 2023 to hold politicians accountable
00:05:49 and yeah sure um there was a cabinet minister that lost her position there and yes there was
00:05:54 some mlas who lost their committee positions but at the end of the day the real question is should
00:05:59 these mlas continue to be mlas and only albertans us voters only we have the right to make that
00:06:05 decision and the only way that we can make that decision unless we wait for 2023 is by having
00:06:11 recall well on a number of fronts i think we should have it i mean for one the ucp government
00:06:16 promised to give it to us so uh you know we kind of want it before the end of your term it really
00:06:21 doesn't mean anything uh in the same sense i could almost see this as a good time for
00:06:26 jason kenny and the ucp fine to give it to us because he's under a lot of pressure we've seen
00:06:30 with some Western Standard polling that Albertans want more done to these MLAs and elected officials
00:06:37 who've been vacationing while we're locked in our homes due to their legislation. This way,
00:06:43 in a sense, politically, he can hand it off. Say, well, it is up to Albertans. Here you go. Here's
00:06:46 the legislation. If it really is that odious, you can fire your elected official. But I don't know
00:06:54 if we're going to see that coming. It's a promise. They seem to have slid under the back burner. I
00:06:59 think even on their website they made the recall promise disappear well i mean this this whole
00:07:04 issue of how we deal with this should be up 12 birds right we shouldn't have to rely on backroom
00:07:09 political brokering um and it really goes back to the important principle of the people are supposed
00:07:14 to be the boss not the politicians and if the people are the boss then we should be able to
00:07:18 fire them when they misbehave and you brought up another really good point here and that's that
00:07:23 premier kenny when he was campaigning when he was trying to get her votes in 2019 he promised
00:07:27 recall legislation um and then again last year in its february 2020 throne speech the government
00:07:33 doubled down on that promise it promised recall legislation again and very importantly um it
00:07:39 promised recall legislation extended to the local level now i mean fortunately premier kenny has
00:07:44 recently said that they are going to be bringing forward recall legislation in the upcoming session
00:07:49 so we're going to keep holding their feet to the fire there but another thing that we all need to
00:07:53 watch out for is to make sure that we're actually able to use recall legislation right we need to
00:07:58 make sure that the thresholds they're not so onerous uh so to make it that nobody can actually
00:08:03 use this important tool yeah like when i was vp policy with the wild rose party we had recall
00:08:09 and we adjusted and worked a lot on that one because it is a complicated one i mean you don't
00:08:13 want to make it too easy because the day after the election suddenly you just got people from
00:08:17 the other party out there running and starting the process and you don't want to set the bar
00:08:22 so high that it's impossible. So it's a tough balance. But I mean, you know, finding a petition
00:08:27 level can be can be done. That's reasonable. I mean, you only want to invoke if people have if
00:08:33 they've done something so odious that we just can't wait two, three more years to get the chance
00:08:37 to replace these people. Some people say, oh, petitioning is easy. Well, no, not if you've
00:08:42 actually done it on the ground. Real petitions on a piece of paper. It is darn hard. A lot of people
00:08:46 don't want to put their name on it. And it would be tough in a time like this when we're not allowed
00:08:50 to go door to door so they certainly do have to make it achievable while not being too easy but
00:08:56 it's not like it's ground we haven't studied before they know how to do this they just need
00:08:59 the will well that's well that's right um and and so what it sounds like is going to be happening
00:09:05 again nothing's set in stone yet we're still waiting to actually see the legislation but it
00:09:09 sounds like it's going to be similar to british columbia so there's that 40 threshold there
00:09:13 and you know it is important to have to strike the right balance but the 40 threshold is is too
00:09:19 high and uh you know the canadian taxpayers federation we made a presentation to the alberta
00:09:24 government's democratic accountability committee and we stressed that it had the thresholds need
00:09:29 to be lower than 40 and we proposed a 25 threshold right and um so here's the key right bc has had
00:09:37 recall legislation since i believe 1995 um there's only been one successful recall campaign there and
00:09:44 And that's when they found out one of her MLAs was writing fake letters to the editor.
00:09:49 So they held them accountable there.
00:09:51 But there's only been one in B.C.
00:09:53 And one of those reasons is because a threshold is too high.
00:09:57 And, Corey, let me just make one more very important point about recall legislation, right?
00:10:01 It's more than just about being able to force a by-election because recall legislation, I mean, it doesn't take a Ph.D. in psychology for someone to realize that a politician is probably going to think twice
00:10:13 before they dip their hands into the taxpayer cookie jar if they have to face the voters tomorrow
00:10:19 rather than in four years. Yeah, there's a preventative aspect to it. I mean, we'd rather
00:10:25 not be recalling politicians all the time. We'd just like them to act like the rest of us in the
00:10:29 working world. If we screw up bad enough, we're going to get fired. It's a simple concept. As you
00:10:35 said, you don't need to be a psychiatrist or psychologist to figure that out. Well, I hope
00:10:40 keep that pressure up because another thing i could see is they're going to throw it to another
00:10:43 panel or another committee and death by committee like he's been doing with so many other aspects
00:10:47 of his election promises right now is getting a little frustrating for a lot of albertans so
00:10:51 hopefully you guys can keep holding their feet to the fire so they actually follow through on
00:10:54 that in this legislative session uh where can we find more information on what uh you and the
00:10:59 canadian taxpayers federation are up to these days oh well please uh please head over to taxpayer.com
00:11:04 and go to our newsroom tab that's where we're keeping all of our information there and it'll
00:11:09 give you some suggestions on what we're doing to hold our politicians accountable.
00:11:15 Great. Well, thank you very much, Franco. I'm looking forward to seeing you guys
00:11:18 keeping them accountable as much as we can with what we've got right now. And I'm sure
00:11:22 we'll be talking again soon. Yeah, sounds good to me. Thanks, Corey.