Western Standard - May 30, 2024


Genocide Scam: 3 years on, no bodies

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
CMS: Trudeau's immigration policies are crushing Canada Trudeau 'Our new Housing Design Catalogue will make it possible to build more homes faster'

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

176.67

Word count

8,271

Sentence count

525

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

17

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Pipeline, we discuss the shocking revelation that there may be up to 300 unmarked graves at a former residential school near Kamloops, BC. We also discuss Justin Trudeau's $12 million deer hunting trip that you are not invited to, and the Canadian flag flying at half mast on Parliament Hill.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day. Today is May 29th, 2024. I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard,
00:00:28 and you're watching The Pipeline. I'm joined, not as usual, filling in for Mr. Henniford.
00:00:36 I've got Western Standard News Editor Dave Naylor. Welcome to The Pipeline, Dave.
00:00:40 Thanks. Good to be back.
00:00:42 But still, here as usual, Western Standard Senior Alberta columnist Corey Morgan.
00:00:47 Thanks for being here, Corey.
00:00:49 Always happy to appear.
00:00:51 All right. Well, we've got great topics on the show today.
00:00:55 The genocide scam, I think yesterday, marked three years since the shocking revelation of unmarked, 200 to 300 unmarked graves at a former residential school near Kamloops in British Columbia.
00:01:16 It's been three years.
00:01:18 That's a lot of time to dig up the bodies.
00:01:21 And how many bodies have they found?
00:01:24 No bodies.
00:01:25 Zero bodies have been found at any of the so-called mass graves located across Canada.
00:01:31 So we're going to talk about the moral panic, the national meltdown that we have, flags flying at half-mast for nearly half a year over this stuff,
00:01:41 and the very quiet shrinking away of Canada's legacy media and progressive political parties from what has proven to be a pretty embarrassing non-genocide.
00:01:55 We're going to talk about Justin Trudeau's $12 million deer hunting trip that you are not invited to.
00:02:04 That's right, Justin Trudeau has paid $12 million for Americans and New Zealanders
00:02:09 who come to Canada and shoot deer from helicopters with guns that are now illegal for you to use in deer hunting.
00:02:18 Apparently, it never occurred to him to just talk to the VC government and issue a special tag for these deer.
00:02:24 Could have dealt with the problem in, I don't know, an afternoon for precisely $0 to cost the taxpayer.
00:02:32 The Alberta NDP leadership race is entering its final stretch just a little less than a month from now.
00:02:38 June 22nd, I believe, Alberta new NDP members are going to be voting on who their next Nahid Menchie will be.
00:02:50 And back to, I guess, the federal government, the Liberals have originally said they're going to bring in 1,000 Gaza refugees.
00:03:00 Then they upped that to 5,000, so five times over.
00:03:05 And then they just said now it's 5,000 families.
00:03:08 Well, we've had experience with this kind of thing before. We remember the so-called Syrian refugee crisis that swamped Europe with a bunch of 20-something men not bringing their families in most cases, overrunning much of Europe and many, many of them not having ever been to Syria in their lives.
00:03:28 So that's where we're going to get into today. So we'll start with the genocide scam.
00:03:37 So three years ago yesterday, one of the First Nations in the Kamloops area performed some ground radar penetration and said that it found circa 250-odd unmarked graves.
00:03:59 Now, I took them pretty seriously when this came out. We know that residential schools, for the most part, were not very great places to be. Many of these kids were scooped up from their families without that family's permission. Some kids were sent there with their family's blessing.
00:04:13 But overall, these were generally not great places to be. Fairly often abuse. But, you know, we had coming from the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, language had already been started to be used, bending around some pretty powerful words like genocide.
00:04:32 That was already pretty crazy, but the announcement of 250-odd unmarked graves of children sparked overnight a national outcry.
00:04:48 And, you know, if so, it certainly would have been a shameful part of history that would have to be accounted for.
00:04:56 I mean, these places were often very overrun with tuberculosis.
00:04:59 There was a, you know, certainly some people probably died in abuse, but more likely they'd be dying just because of bad conditions like tuberculosis, things like that.
00:05:09 But then, but it was straight on to the genocide bandwagon, a narrative that the federal government itself has bought into.
00:05:19 And Justin Trudeau orders that the Canadian flag flying on the Peace Tower on Parliament Hill fly at half mast.
00:05:26 And it stayed there all the way until Remembrance Day when the absurdity of flying this thing at half mass for five months without yet a shred of proof became absurd.
00:05:38 So, Dave, before we get into the media backing away from this and whatnot, what was the main reaction to this?
00:05:50 Let me just try to capture for us, summarize for us, the national moral panic that set in the national self-shaming ritual that Canada went through.
00:06:02 Well, that's what it is. It was like a feeling of national shame.
00:06:05 Went on for, I guess it's been going on for three years now.
00:06:09 Three years to the day this week that, as you say, the first allegations of unmarked graves came out.
00:06:16 They didn't use the word alleged at the time.
00:06:18 No, no, it was. And neither did the legacy media at the time. Some foreign media kind of questioned it, but certainly not any of the Canadian legacy media. And I haven't found a single thing, as you know, and as we'll talk about. But the ludicrousness continued this week with the Indigenous chief for, that represents all of BC, saying the bodies couldn't be found because they were incinerated. They were put in incinerators.
00:06:47 incinerators. No mention of, well, then what are these unmarked graves? Yes, exactly. Just couldn't
00:06:53 be found because they were incinerated. And another BC native leader came out just yesterday
00:06:59 and said, well, the bodies couldn't be found because the missionaries and the nuns actually
00:07:03 took them off-site and disposed of the bodies off-site and just left them to a lot. So
00:07:08 certainly the indigenous folks aren't really backing down. They've changed a little bit of
00:07:15 their wording. But you know, it's it's still affects Canada to
00:07:19 this day. More land land acknowledgements than we ever
00:07:23 had. We've got the National Day of Mourning, which is a stat
00:07:27 holiday for federal workers. So it has left a lasting staying
00:07:33 across the country without a doubt.
00:07:37 Corey, they've, you know, we're now seeing this, these almost
00:07:41 silly excuses, you know, well, they're taken off site, they
00:07:44 incinerated but zero actions to even paper over their claims that were not that they were quite 0.69
00:07:52 categorical they were not well we think they might be a margrave and I was open to the possibility
00:07:58 certainly open to the possibility is not good places for the most part and but no attempt to
00:08:06 account for well what about your claim that these are very large sometimes they would even use the
00:08:12 the word mass graves. There was never actually any indication ever of mass graves. You know,
00:08:17 we have images, I guess, of like Khmer Rouge or, or, you know, the Belson concentration camps,
00:08:23 things like that. But no accounting of, well, what are these alleged sites then? They've just
00:08:30 now dismissed and say, well, the murders were there. There were murders. The bodies were
00:08:34 disposed of others. Okay, well, your key evidence was the so-called unmarked graves. Tell me about
00:08:40 unmarked graves. Has there been any attempt to explain what these things were then? Not to my
00:08:45 knowledge, and they don't want to know. I mean, seriously, this is as simple as taking a spade,
00:08:53 a handful of people going out to even one of the anomalies found by the radar and digging a hole.
00:08:59 That's really all it comes down to. You don't need years, you know, they got 7.9 million dollars to
00:09:04 do this, which they haven't answered what they've done with that 7.9 million dollars, but it wasn't
00:09:08 digging. The other part that people gloss over is that, and I think that's where some people are
00:09:15 realizing there's probably nothing in these, there were meticulous records kept. That's how the
00:09:20 Catholic Church was paid. They knew where the children were. If children passed away, where
00:09:24 they would be buried, where there were records. There's no records of any 200 and some children
00:09:30 disappearing in Kamloops. There's no family saying, my cousin, my brother, my whatever
00:09:35 disappeared in this, you know, school that there's no evidence whatsoever. Because again, even if
00:09:41 there were bodies, and if you exhumed them, well, we want to return them to the family so they can
00:09:45 be properly interred. Well, you don't have any families raising their hands saying, I wonder
00:09:49 where little Susie went. We could easily DNA test this stuff and say, okay, well, this was someone
00:09:54 who was lost and they're part of your family. Let's give them a proper burial on a marked grave.
00:09:58 I think where finally things were starting to get muted, they start doing the research and realize
00:10:01 there's just there's really unlikely there's any bodies in this thing plus a lot of other studies
00:10:06 were coming up showing that there'd been past excavations that had never found things there
00:10:09 before there'd been an apple orchard there'd been septic tiles put down there there were a whole lot
00:10:14 of things under that ground that if you're going to do a radar survey would show anomalies but
00:10:19 you know you got to dig it up no evidence of a grave and and we got to remember dave that
00:10:26 it wasn't just cam loops cam loops was kind of the starting gun on this thing but then there
00:10:30 was a bunch of claims elsewhere. I know there was one First Nation in Saskatchewan, I can't recall
00:10:37 them. They were much more cautious and reasonable about it. They use much less inflammatory language
00:10:43 to their credit. They use photoradar underground, ground penetrative radar, and they found some
00:10:51 anomalies. They said, could be something here. Let's look into it. And that was to their credit.
00:10:58 And so there's no way on their face. I think they were full well within their rights to say, you know, I think we should look into this and look into it and turned out it was not so good on them. They were they were cautious. They didn't try to jump on a hype bandwagon. But, you know, there is a lasting legacy in this. We had hundreds of burned churches across Canada and Trudeau and the federal government's only result was, well, it's understandable that they're angry.
00:11:25 Well, no, it's not, because the federal government banned that anger, and it's kind of postmodern style that Canada is an inherently evil and genocidal country, because they bought into the Truth of Reconciliation Commission's language on this.
00:11:38 We had more places of worship burned in that period of time than any time and period since Kristallnacht in 1939, and we didn't even have a word of condemnation from the federal government.
00:11:52 So there's a lasting legacy to this, Dave.
00:11:56 How is Ottawa going to wrestle with this now that it's essentially been completely debunked?
00:12:00 Well, I think there's going to go quiet on it.
00:12:03 Corey will tell you the reaction to his tweets in the last little while.
00:12:08 And don't forget, we even had the Pope, those images of the Pope in his wheelchair,
00:12:12 you know, asking for forgiveness and expressing his regrets and stuff like that.
00:12:17 So it was a worldwide story.
00:12:21 uh and you know we're gonna have truth and reconciliation day uh every uh every year
00:12:27 uh i mean if they never find bodies do they revoke the holiday you know it's it's just
00:12:32 gonna be a tangled mess it's good time for surfing yes good time for surfing in tofino
00:12:36 uh hopefully maybe by the end of next year he'll be surfing full-time there uh but uh yeah i mean
00:12:43 what a mess what a mess i mean your tweet your twitter followers have gone silent well yeah that
00:12:49 was the interesting thing. Because I mean, I like everybody else, I was horrified when I first heard
00:12:53 it. Like, Oh, my God, everybody thinks that same instinct, children murdered. I mean, that's the
00:12:56 worst thing in the world we could ever imagine. And I was, boy, let's get to the bottom of this.
00:12:59 Let's get exhuming. Let's see if we can find the perpetrators or just resolve. And that's part of
00:13:06 why I'm as upset as I am now, because nobody likes being fooled. And as the evidence came coming in,
00:13:11 so then once I started questioning and others online, I used to get just attacked.
00:13:16 You're a denier, as if you're like,
00:13:18 Ernst Zundel saying the Holocaust didn't happen. 0.88
00:13:20 But I've been more vocal than ever
00:13:23 this last couple of weeks, and you know what?
00:13:25 They're quiet. They're not
00:13:26 coming at me anymore. There's a handful.
00:13:29 But I'm not getting...
00:13:30 You used the analogy earlier,
00:13:32 it's like Homer Simpson, just, I'm going to sink back into
00:13:34 the trees now, because I hate
00:13:36 to say it, but it sounds like Morgan might be on to something.
00:13:39 And don't forget, the liberals
00:13:40 were considering making it a crime.
00:13:42 Yeah, they considered making this a crime.
00:13:44 Residential school denialism.
00:13:46 right well okay show us a body and then i'll agree with you but don't tell me one one body exactly
00:13:52 right now i'm going to be a denier until they can show me a body or at least a skeptic you know
00:13:57 that's a fair term let's just yeah we got to see some evidence guys it's time yeah it and you know
00:14:05 we'll just kind of wrap this part of the discussion up with the legacy media's treatment of it so
00:14:10 Well, they took it as gospel out of the gate. I mean, it was certainly newsworthy to report on.
00:14:17 This was a claim coming. It was a report on, but they didn't say alleged unmarked graves or suspected.
00:14:26 They have located unmarked graves. They took it uncritically whatsoever.
00:14:33 And I think it was City TV. City TV had the biggest screw up yesterday on the third anniversary of this.
00:14:40 Three years later, when this has now been pretty thoroughly debunked as a scam, a, I'm not sure if it was a hoax, because they probably, I'm getting, they're probably legitimately fine.
00:14:52 An unintentional hoax, perhaps.
00:14:54 Yeah, I mean, I think the guys who made the initial announcement believed it was.
00:14:58 And it was plausibly, it was certainly worth looking into.
00:15:02 It was worth allocating funds for and looking into.
00:15:05 But it's now been pretty thoroughly debunked as, at least what developed into a hoax.
00:15:10 eventually. And City TV still reported on it as if none of this evidence has come to light. It's just still three years ago. They changed the headline. They eventually quietly changed some of their wording, but none of the media have retracted these stories and said story was wrong. The story was false. They've just tweaked them a little bit and said, now they're suspected graves. They're not even really, I'm not even driving home suspected graves anymore.
00:15:40 or alleged graves anymore.
00:15:43 At this point, they're just ground radar anomalies, Dave.
00:15:46 Anomalies.
00:15:47 That's all they are, anomalies.
00:15:49 And, yeah, the City TV had one of them nasty community Facebook notes saying,
00:15:55 well, actually, no, your headline and story is 100% wrong.
00:15:58 But to give credit where credit's due, I think it was what Terry Glavin with the National Post did an excellent series.
00:16:05 And he got shredded for doing that.
00:16:06 And he got shredded for doing that.
00:16:07 Oh, he was called it.
00:16:08 Every racist name in the book.
00:16:09 Yeah.
00:16:09 Yeah. So he was sort of the first mainstream media guy to maybe start backtracking a little bit and was carved for doing so.
00:16:18 Yeah. And, you know, and it it took a lot of courage on his part to stick his neck out.
00:16:22 I mean, I mean, we were pretty cautious before we stuck our neck out on this stuff.
00:16:27 And, you know, we're independent, so we're going to be more bold than the legacy guys we could afford to be.
00:16:32 But even we were pretty cautious.
00:16:35 And I think we were rightfully cautious to stick your neck out because there was something worth looking into.
00:16:40 It's sensitive. I mean, you don't want to get in there and say this is a hoax and it didn't happen and everything else.
00:16:44 And then a week later, they exhumed the bodies as three children.
00:16:47 I mean, we're just adding insult to an even already terrible situation.
00:16:51 So no, we waited until we saw evidence or a lack thereof for some time before we really start questioning it.
00:16:57 Well, we would have just we would have been as irresponsible as those who claimed it was matter of factly.
00:17:00 These are unmarked graves. And if you are even skeptical of it, you're a racist. 0.67
00:17:06 Well, let me ask you guys a question. Do you think maybe a future Pierre Poly of government would stop the funding and say, no more funding until you show us a body?
00:17:15 Well, I'm not sure what there is to fund until they can show some bodies.
00:17:19 I'm all for funding, excavation, exhuming of potential bodies in these places.
00:17:26 And also, there's going to be graveyards in some of these places.
00:17:29 People died at these places. Many people were abused, and some people probably were, as a result, even murdered by it, but certainly not in these kinds of numbers.
00:17:39 But there were bad conditions, as I was saying. Tuberculosis was something we don't really have in a big way anymore, but it was a huge thing back then.
00:17:48 It killed a lot of people, especially in cramped communal quarters like you would have had at a residential school.
00:17:53 So I don't know how Polly addresses this, but I can't imagine him being able to look taxpayers in the eye and say,
00:18:00 I'm going to continue to fund this stuff until you can show us some bodies.
00:18:04 I couldn't see new funding.
00:18:05 If there was more, I think it would be at a point of conditional then.
00:18:08 Okay, here's what the grant is going to be, but it's going to be for this, a backhoe, an archaeologist, a forensic investigator, an elder to supervise, fine.
00:18:17 But not what they did before was, here's $8 million, give us a report in a few years.
00:18:22 well it disappeared yeah so i'm all for funding proper uh investigations of this stuff because
00:18:28 you know there was wrongdoing at these places and and justice should be done and and if there are
00:18:33 bodies you know they deserve a proper burial with the family yep so all right um a little more
00:18:42 lighthearted as our next topic justin trudeau's 12 million dollar deer hunting trip oh uh
00:18:52 I like deer hunting as much as the next guy, but I normally do it pretty close to home here.
00:18:59 You know, we've got some nice areas in the foothills and whatnot.
00:19:03 Anyone who, you know, especially those of you watching this on wild TV, I don't need to tell you.
00:19:07 Anyone who claims that they hunt to save money is lying.
00:19:10 At the end of the day, by the time you eat a pound of venison, it's more expensive than getting a filet mignon at the grocery store.
00:19:18 It's not cheap once you factored everything in.
00:19:22 But, you know, there's, on Vancouver, I think northern Vancouver Island, there's some invasive species of deer.
00:19:32 I think they might be from Europe or something.
00:19:33 Somehow these European deer, they're fallow deer.
00:19:36 Yeah, so it's actually on a little island off of that.
00:19:39 Oh, yes.
00:19:40 They're contained even.
00:19:41 Yeah, yeah, so it's not even real, well, I guess they could swim, but it's relatively contained.
00:19:45 But, you know, it's an invasive species and a particularly tasty invasive species.
00:19:51 So it should be a pretty easy problem to take care of.
00:19:55 The province of BC could simply issue a special tag for this.
00:20:02 They probably might even have to do a draw because there'd be so much.
00:20:05 You could make it an open season on it.
00:20:07 You just have it like a bag limit.
00:20:09 You do it like ducks, you know, instead of saying 12 ducks,
00:20:11 you've got a limit of two or three of these black tail deer or something.
00:20:17 No, no, the locals are black tails.
00:20:18 I forget the name of the invasive one, but I think it's from Europe.
00:20:21 or something. And no, the federal government, which has some jurisdiction over foreign invasive
00:20:28 species, didn't work with the BC government to just issue a special tag and have the issue
00:20:34 probably dealt with maybe not an afternoon, maybe a weekend, because if it's an island,
00:20:37 you know, it's gonna be less than, more than just a little drive.
00:20:40 Yeah. And you don't want hunters shooting at each other.
00:20:43 No.
00:20:44 In the crossfire.
00:20:45 No. But you know, you could do this over a weekend or two. And it could be done with
00:20:50 virtually zero. Actually, you can make a revenue positive. People will buy tags and people pay to
00:20:55 hunt. That's not what they did. Instead, they spent $12 million, according to the Canadian
00:21:01 Taxpayers Federation's Access Information Act requests, to bring in, I guess, professional
00:21:09 hunters from the United States and New Zealand to hunt these things from helicopters using rifles
00:21:16 that are illegal for us to hunt with in Canada, since Trudeau banned a bunch of these guns
00:21:21 for, because they look scary. And turns out they weren't even that good at it.
00:21:27 Huge numbers of these were not the invasive species. They shot the local one. They shot
00:21:30 the local correct deer that are supposed to be there. A bunch of them they couldn't identify.
00:21:37 I mean, like these guys would have faced wildlife charges.
00:21:39 Part of the reason we're typically not allowed to hunt from helicopters is it's kind of hard
00:21:43 to distinguish the nuanced things of what you're shooting.
00:21:44 Yeah, like I've never shot from a helicopter. I mean, sounds kind of fun, but I mean, it's never occurred to me to try.
00:21:51 You can go to Texas. They do the wild boars from the helicopter.
00:21:55 Swinemageddon. Yeah. But Dave, yeah, this information comes from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:22:02 Do we have any idea why Ottawa chose to contract this out for $12 million rather than just say, hey, hunters, go kill these ones?
00:22:11 uh not a clue this is one of these stories derek where if you don't laugh you're gonna cry
00:22:15 uh 12 million dollars uh down the toilet didn't didn't succeed in what they were doing so that
00:22:22 was just phase one they're now about to launch phase two yeah where they're gonna set uh hunters
00:22:27 with dogs and actually gonna set foot on the island and they're gonna hunt these things down
00:22:32 with dogs and uh and kill them all so it's it's been a fiasco from start to finish uh i don't know
00:22:38 know what a helicopter costs to rent but it's several thousand dollars an hour yeah and uh you
00:22:43 know all these hunters from from foreign countries because i guess aren't you you canadian hunters
00:22:48 aren't good enough shots no uh so yeah imagine sitting there in the pub in new zealand and you
00:22:54 see this ad from the government of alberta hey we'll fly you up to canada put you in a helicopter 0.77
00:22:58 and give you an automatic weapon you go kill things i mean sign me up that sounds pretty 0.99
00:23:03 awesome. Sign me up. So yeah, I mean, good work by our friend Franco at the CTF to to uncover all 1.00
00:23:11 this stuff. And it's just a head shaker, just a head shaker. Kurt, you know, it's one of these
00:23:16 things. It's like, what do you say? And we just kind of sit here shrugging like, what about the
00:23:20 idiots? It's just an example of government can't, can't do anything simple. They can't take a simple 1.00
00:23:26 concept and bring it to fruition. It's like public art, you know, hey, we've got a new development
00:23:32 over there we've got some money we want to source an artist to put up a sculpture great let's put
00:23:37 it out to tender get some german artist who's going to spend you know a million dollars to 0.71
00:23:41 make some ugly thing and you know uh rocks on sticks or something and meanwhile you've got
00:23:46 10 starving domestic artists say you know i i would have done that for a lot less than that
00:23:49 they can't they can't bring themselves to it they got to make it complicated they've got a
00:23:54 it's impossible to simply solve but my daughter keeps asking me about the big blue ring every
00:23:58 time we drive by it she's like daddy what is that thing it looks ugly i'm like that's art sweetie
00:24:04 um it does have a great twitter site it used to it used to it's still around it's quite fun it's
00:24:10 still there he kind of politicizes other yeah i think it's it's it's fast he used to parody it
00:24:16 quite well it used to be very good yeah uh yeah and just the complexity of this and phases like
00:24:21 you know first they have like they're planning this thing like it's a desert storm
00:24:24 you know like because they got you because it increases the cost they can build taxpayers for
00:24:29 it you know like saying first they're doing these helicopter assaults you know sending
00:24:32 the air cavalry you got like Mel Gibson training the air cavalry going in there
00:24:37 scene from the Valkyries a ride of the Valkyries hey I'd love to hunt deer with ride the Valkyries
00:24:44 with a minigun you know that sounds it's not very sporting where do they didn't import a
00:24:50 bunch of hyenas or some other foreign thing to try and bring them in and naturally take 1.00
00:24:54 care of the population i mean that's a government sort of idea then we have to hunt the hyenas
00:24:58 so that's what i mean you know when they compound problems whether it's
00:25:03 grizzly bears in there yeah well actually bc is getting over popular with its grizzlies uh now
00:25:08 since they ended the grizzly hunt so that's another topic one thing at a time yeah okay
00:25:17 well we're gonna bring it a little closer back to alberta here um the alberta ndp is having its
00:25:23 leadership race. You know, they lost the last election. That was Rachel Notley's third kick
00:25:29 at the can as NDP leader. She lost to Jason Kenney in 2019. She lost to Danielle Smith in 2023.
00:25:37 She's hung up her estates. Who knows what's going to happen to her now, but the NDP are picking a 1.00
00:25:42 new leader on, I believe, June 22nd. Readers, listeners can correct me if I'm wrong on that
00:25:48 one but um they're gonna be picking a a new uh a new nahi nenshi dave yes uh my sources say it's
00:25:57 basically a done deal uh the former mayor of calgary will win apparently the uh the ganley
00:26:05 camp is in full panic mode uh wondering uh wondering what they can do deadlines passed for
00:26:10 uh for membership sales uh so it's you know the the damage has been done if you want to say there
00:26:17 There's going to be, you know, you can't buy a whole bunch of votes in the last week.
00:26:21 But I think it's been actually a fairly quiet campaign, Derek.
00:26:26 We did have a story of note today on the website that both Nenshi and Sarah Hoffman were accused of lying at the Calgary debate.
00:26:36 This goes back to the Mid Park trailer chaos 14 years ago.
00:26:41 The city of Calgary came in and booted all the people out of the Midfield trailer park.
00:26:46 Nenshi and Hoffman said they went to the park and specifically met with this one family
00:26:52 who was having all sorts of troubles.
00:26:54 And then the family guy saw the debate and said, well, wait a minute.
00:27:00 He never met with me.
00:27:01 She never met with me.
00:27:02 And says they're lying.
00:27:05 We contacted the Nenshi campaign, and they say they're sticking by their candidate statement.
00:27:11 We haven't been able to reach Sarah Hoffman yet.
00:27:13 She doesn't really talk to us.
00:27:15 But yeah, other than that, there's been no slings and arrows, no fiery debates.
00:27:20 It's sort of almost gone under the radar.
00:27:23 Yeah, Corey, it's, I mean, what a contrast to the UCP leadership, both of the different UCP leadership races we had, particularly the last one.
00:27:33 Both races featured an outsider coming in, Daniel Smith, the outsider, who was pretty strongly against the record of the Kenney government.
00:27:43 the Sovereignty Act and getting away with vaccine mandates and things like that.
00:27:49 And there was really a big anybody-but-Smith movement to stop her.
00:27:54 And to be fair, they did hold her back from an easy first ballot win,
00:28:00 which looked like she was headed towards.
00:28:01 But it was also a dozen candidates, many of which didn't even get a single percentage of the vote.
00:28:06 But are you seeing any Nenshi movement here?
00:28:14 Or have they just accepted it's kind of inevitable?
00:28:17 So maybe we shouldn't fight him too hard because we're going to want good spots on the front bench of a Nenshi shadow captain.
00:28:23 I think maybe there was one, but it was quiet.
00:28:25 I mean, yeah, it's becoming clear that this is turning into coronation.
00:28:31 Edmonton versus Calgary.
00:28:32 It was Nenshi versus the established NDP.
00:28:35 But just with the overwhelming Calgary membership sales, if Ganley wasn't raising her hand saying, hey, I sold a bunch of those, then it's pretty clear that his team has just, you know, done what had to be done to win in a one member one vote race.
00:28:48 But it doesn't mean this is over or that, you know, if it is a coronation, that he's out of the woods by any means.
00:28:54 He's got a party that still is going to view him as an outsider, that you're going to have some noses out of joint.
00:29:01 And any of us who have dealt with an inch, you know, too, he isn't one to smooth feathers.
00:29:05 He's there to pick at people and take them off.
00:29:07 His arrogance, his first talk is meaning, unless he learns a little bit of humility, I got a feeling his lessons in party politics are going to be pretty hard at first, actually.
00:29:16 Because, you know, nobody, especially when you feel an outsider came in and it starts talking down to you as only an inch he can.
00:29:24 There's going to be some grumpiness in that party.
00:29:25 It doesn't mean they're going to fall apart.
00:29:27 You know, the left-flowing parties stick together instead of unlike conservatives.
00:29:29 You remember our friend Gil McGowan withdrawing from the race out of the big labor movement in Alberta.
00:29:38 And there was some Nancy correspondence that came to light that basically showed he was anti-union.
00:29:43 So, you know, that was a good chunk of the NDP support.
00:29:47 So he is going to inherit probably what could become a more fractured party than he thought.
00:29:53 Also, interestingly, Calgary now has more NDP members in Edmonton, which is a first.
00:29:59 You know, let's pick at that one a bit.
00:30:02 I mean, it's an interesting dynamic.
00:30:04 Traditionally, and especially in more recent history, as we've had more of a competitive multi-party or two-party system,
00:30:11 you know, you had Wildrose and then the UCP, where the rural is its locked-up base,
00:30:16 and the NDP have Fortress Edmonton, and then the battle is decided in Calgary.
00:30:24 Calgary decides then who's got it.
00:30:26 Now, I don't think Denchy is on his way to turning Calgary into fortress NDP. I mean, it's still Calgary. It's not Edmonton. But I think he is probably the NDP's best bet of making Calgary as competitive as possible for the NDP in winning seats.
00:30:44 Then this raises the question, does this weaken the NDP's hold on Edmonton?
00:30:50 Edmonton is traditionally a less conservative city than Calgary.
00:30:55 Still, by Canadian standards, at least on the federal level, pretty conservative, but provincially less so.
00:31:01 But the NDP, because they've really only ever had Notley in their modern history,
00:31:06 but even there's, you know, the leaders predating that with, you know, Brian Mace and whatnot.
00:31:11 and Mesa whatnot, it was an end, it was always a party of downtown and it was the party of downtown Edmonton.
00:31:18 Well, now they would have a leader who's Mr. Calgary.
00:31:23 So I'll start with you, Corey.
00:31:25 Do you think this presents any opportunities for the Conservatives, not to break, you know, to take dominance in Edmonton?
00:31:32 I don't think that's really in the cards, but to maybe break back through and make Edmonton a more competitive battleground
00:31:39 now that, you know, they're no longer led by an Edmontonian?
00:31:42 We have some select constituencies around the ring of outside of Edmonton.
00:31:46 Well, they still own most of the ring seats.
00:31:47 Yeah, and they might encroach a little further, you know,
00:31:50 because we see that the left mix tends to go the more dense the urban area,
00:31:54 the stronger that orange color gets, whether it's in Calgary or Edmonton.
00:31:57 So they might encroach a little.
00:31:59 But I think a lot of Edmonton is still, though, so deeply orange,
00:32:03 especially provincially, even if they don't like Nancy,
00:32:06 they'll hold their nose and vote for him before they would vote for a Smith-led party.
00:32:10 So I can't, I don't, I don't see Nenshi coming in and sweeping through Calgary. Don't forget,
00:32:17 he's got a legacy. When he left, he was very unpopular and he lost his pet project on the
00:32:24 new Olympic bid. He has a legacy of taxation and, you know, look at your property taxes
00:32:31 before and after Nenshi and you're going to see a huge increase. He wasn't a friend of the
00:32:36 business community with high business taxes. So he's got a lot of people against him already in
00:32:42 Calgary. But I'll tell you who the people that are most looking forward to Nenshi being elected
00:32:47 is the UCP. They are going to unload an attack barrage of things against Nenshi, mainly because
00:32:54 record in Calgary, but we haven't seen the likes of before. I mean, the UCP are going to have a lot
00:32:59 ammunition i think uh we're very quickly uh probably as soon as he is officially crowned
00:33:06 ndp leader and then through the next campaign roughly three years from now yeah we're gonna
00:33:11 see charts comparing your taxes in calgary before nancy your taxes in calgary at the end of nancy
00:33:17 i know it's gonna be a pretty powerful message to get it through to calgarians and albertans
00:33:21 more broadly but i still think he's probably their best bet he he's a relatively polished
00:33:26 politician he has some track record and because he's not an old-time NDP minister or MLA he
00:33:33 doesn't have to quite wear the record of the Notley government which was a fairly unpopular
00:33:40 four years he doesn't have to wear that record the way that say Sarah Hoffman would have to or 0.70
00:33:44 Kathleen Ganley would have to he's not gonna be sweeping Calgary but he probably makes them
00:33:50 more competitive.
00:33:53 So I don't know.
00:33:54 I don't think the UCP would rather fight
00:33:57 Nenshi than, say, Hoffman
00:33:59 or Ganley. I think he probably
00:34:01 is the strongest candidate for
00:34:03 the NDP, as long as he can hold it together.
00:34:05 Yeah, maybe. They're
00:34:06 certainly getting their guns in a row.
00:34:10 Two questions I have is
00:34:11 assuming Nenshi
00:34:13 wins, which Calgary MLA will give up their
00:34:15 seat? I figure CC.
00:34:17 I figure CC. And
00:34:18 if Nenshi loses,
00:34:21 will he commit to running for the NDP in the next provincial election?
00:34:25 Well, he's not going to lose.
00:34:27 No, I wouldn't think so.
00:34:29 And if he did, I couldn't see him ever sitting in a second banana roll.
00:34:33 His pride wouldn't let him do it.
00:34:35 No, no, I don't think he would.
00:34:36 You know, CeCe's an interesting one because he was finance minister.
00:34:39 He spent his first four years as one of the most powerful men in the cabinet.
00:34:43 And he's been kind of riding the deep back benches ever since.
00:34:47 He's been super quiet.
00:34:48 and he's a downtown urban seat that the NDP would be likely to hold on to in a by-election.
00:34:55 You get further outside the core, I mean, it'd be pretty bad for the leader to not win a by-election,
00:35:01 for the UCP to take that seat away.
00:35:03 That'd be crippling to someone's moral authority as leader.
00:35:07 He needs those two things.
00:35:08 I mean, he needs a safe seat, and he needs, of course, somebody to open it up for him.
00:35:14 And Edmonton might have some of those seats, but parachuting him to Edmonton would not work out well.
00:35:18 You know, I think he could in the shorter term.
00:35:21 I mean, like, he probably wouldn't commit to staying in the NDP seat for the general.
00:35:25 But, I mean, you know, Smith's by-election was Medicine Hat Brooks.
00:35:30 She's not from Medicine Hat Brooks.
00:35:32 But it was a conservative seat that wanted her and wanted to have the premier.
00:35:37 So I don't think he'd have much trouble winning with an Edmonton seat.
00:35:40 I think he'd be more comfortable with a Calgary seat.
00:35:42 Yeah, it wouldn't do him favors.
00:35:43 I mean, when you're trying to win that Calgary move over those three years that you're sitting,
00:35:47 it's still better if you're entrenched. I think for his long term it's better to be in Calgary
00:35:50 because he can say I'm representing Calgary. His organization is here. People have got an
00:35:55 elected mayor. People are selling all the memberships. They're in Calgary.
00:36:01 It'll be interesting to see him in the legislature too. We haven't seen him perform in that
00:36:04 role. I mean as the leader of the opposition it'll for political viewers I got a feeling it'll be
00:36:09 interesting viewing. I'm looking forward to it because you know Notley I got pretty tired of
00:36:17 not laying in question period. I just couldn't watch it very often. But, you know, Smith versus
00:36:20 Nietzsche, these guys knew each other back in university. They were debating each other back
00:36:24 as like early 20-somethings. So this is
00:36:28 It'll be heated. Sparks will fly. This is going to have some history.
00:36:32 It's going to be good. I'm looking forward to Alberta politics. Alberta politics is
00:36:36 so much more fun than I think most other places have got. It's not boring anyway.
00:36:40 Actually, you know what? Let's, not even scripted. I'm going to add in
00:36:45 one topic before we get to our last one here quickly in BC. Because all of a sudden, BC
00:36:51 politics is interesting again. And it's been so boring for so long, because you had, you
00:36:57 know, a crazy NDP, you had a crazier Greens, and you had an ever so slightly less crazy
00:37:01 Liberal Party to change his name to BC United. It was just so boring. Then, Kevin Falcon,
00:37:10 the BC United slash liberal leader, kicked two MLAs out, and it turned out to not be a good idea.
00:37:16 These guys became conservatives, and the conservatives have completely eclipsed several times over the liberals in the polls.
00:37:23 Liberals are down to like 12 percent.
00:37:25 BC conservatives are right on the heels and sometimes even tying the NDP in polls.
00:37:30 So there's been a lot of talk about how to unite the right in BC to prevent vote split,
00:37:34 to not just have the BC conservatives come up, but to outright defeat the NDP.
00:37:40 And so talks have been kind of underway and they thought, OK, well, maybe there's not enough time to merge a party.
00:37:49 So let's have some kind of non-compete. And the B.C. Liberals slash United put forward a bat scheisse crazy idea.
00:37:59 So the way the electoral math works is the seats that the B.C. conservatives are more likely, most likely to pick up are the seats currently held by the B.C. Liberals.
00:38:06 The B.C. Liberal proposal was, yeah, you can't run in any of those seats.
00:38:10 You could run in, like, downtown Vancouver where you're not going to win anyway.
00:38:14 And so the B.C. Conservatives had to reject it.
00:38:17 At the same time, the B.C. Conservatives can't surrender their current seats that they currently have MLAs in.
00:38:22 So I don't think there really was a path, Corey, to any kind of successful merger or non-compete with this map.
00:38:29 I think these parties are just going to have to fight it out, and maybe the B.C. Conservatives can win in their own right.
00:38:35 Maybe not.
00:38:35 Yeah, Rustad was on my show a couple of weeks ago, and I did ask, you know, are you even negotiating?
00:38:41 And I think there might be more room in plucking a few floor crossers. 1.00
00:38:44 We saw that before with the Wild Rose, too.
00:38:46 The BC United is just looking weaker and weaker. 0.92
00:38:49 Falcon is not, you know, with their ridiculous things, their stubbornness.
00:38:52 But if they get knocked low enough in the polls, I think they'll also see the lesson from Alberta.
00:38:56 What happens if you dicker too much with splitting things?
00:39:00 I think most conservative-minded people were just going to say, that's enough.
00:39:02 then they're just going to gravitate around that conservative party.
00:39:07 So if they're not going to have a formal negotiation,
00:39:09 I don't think there's a hope by the looks of the way things are going.
00:39:11 He could really get them, though, I think with a few seats and they'll move forward.
00:39:15 It'll be like a rump left of the unity party.
00:39:18 And the B.C. conservatives are nominating candidates fast.
00:39:21 It's like it's kind of running out of time for the B.C. liberals slash united to come over.
00:39:26 But these guys have got a bit getting itchy in their seats.
00:39:29 thinking like things are not like they're looking like a wipeout or near wipeout. They're looking at
00:39:34 losing, like I'd say the ceiling for the Liberals right now is like five seats. That's the ceiling
00:39:40 and their floor is zero. If that, I mean, it was a political Hail Mary from Falken that I think
00:39:47 Rustad was right to shoot down. And as you say, they've got candidates in every single riding now
00:39:51 in BC. So it wouldn't surprise me to see the Liberals wiped off the electoral map.
00:39:57 I guess the big question is, can the Conservatives win? Because the BC United slash Liberals are still going to hold on to some vote. 12% is not enough to be anywhere close to competitive. But it's enough to deny the Conservatives the ability to win a government in their own right. And, you know, but, you know, the BC United is, it's only a couple points ahead of the Green Party right now. They're flirting with last place.
00:40:22 I think it can collapse lower yet. You know, people will get pragmatic once it gets towards push and come to shove, I think.
00:40:29 It's increasingly looking like that. Okay, well, we'll get to our last topic now, since I just decided to throw that one in there, because all of a sudden BC got interesting.
00:40:39 So, you know, we've got the war in Gaza going on since the October 7th attacks, and the Netanyahu government is not settling for just giving Hamas a bloody nose.
00:40:51 Their intent to destroy it. They will end Hamas here. 0.99
00:40:56 And that's proved to be fairly controversial, especially as they move on Rafa, the city in southern Gaza, full of refugees.
00:41:05 I think they tried to evacuate like a million refugees out of there before the assault began.
00:41:10 But anyway, it's a tough situation.
00:41:14 But anyway, the Trudeau government here said we're going to take a thousand refugees from Gaza.
00:41:19 Now, you've got to be careful with refugees from this part of the world, because guess what? 1.00
00:41:23 You know what Rafa's full of right now? Hamas!
00:41:27 No doubt, some of them are going to try and come through.
00:41:29 Both active Hamas militants and terrorists, and even just Hamas sympathizers.
00:41:35 And I don't even think we want Hamas sympathizers coming here.
00:41:39 They're already here.
00:41:41 They're literally parked in front of Parliament Hill right now as we speak.
00:41:44 We don't need more of them.
00:41:46 Yeah, we don't need more Hamas sympathizers in Canada.
00:41:48 I think we should say, they up this from 1000 to 5000. And then from 5000 individuals to 5000
00:41:55 families. Now, when I say refugees, I guess those of you not watching, if you can't see me, I'm using
00:42:02 finger quotes when I say refugees, because I have a strong suspicion this will be similar to the
00:42:07 quote, Syrian refugee crisis, when a bunch of young men in their early 20s show up without women,
00:42:15 without children and they show up many of them having never even been to Syria let alone being
00:42:22 Syrians and they it was a problem here but a particularly problem in Europe where you know 1.00
00:42:27 Angela Merkel just essentially had the whole continent washed over with people that should 1.00
00:42:31 have been declared illegal so you know and and those people turn out to be problematic you had
00:42:38 mass gang rapes in cities in the New Year's following this influx of people. I guess the good 0.98
00:42:46 news from Trudeau moving it from 5,000 refugees to 5,000 families is most of these guys aren't
00:42:53 bringing their families with them. They're leaving the women and children behind and just coming on 1.00
00:42:57 their own day. So might not actually much more than 5,000. Yeah, who knows if the liberals don't
00:43:03 increase it to 10,000. It seems to be a moving target. Also, very few of them are able to get
00:43:09 out at the moment. Israeli government obviously controls who comes and who goes out of Rafa,
00:43:15 and they're not letting too many... No, so does Egypt. But Egypt is even harder on not letting 0.87
00:43:20 anyone through. They don't like that border open enough. No, they don't want any Palestinian 1.00
00:43:25 refugees there. So at the end of the day, it remains to be seen how many actually come.
00:43:31 And, you know, if 5,000 people each bring, 5,000 families each come with a family of four, that's, you know, 20,000 people right there, but you're right.
00:43:43 Well, a family of four would actually be a small family.
00:43:45 Yes, yeah, but you're right.
00:43:47 It'll be, as we've seen in Europe, it'll be single, young, military-age men.
00:43:52 And, you know, not only Germany, but you've seen what it's done to other countries in Europe.
00:43:56 You know, Stockholm in particular has no go zones for police already in high density Muslim areas and it's just been handled a mess through Europe and apparently Justin Trudeau wants to import it here too. 0.96
00:44:11 And, you know, by being so haphazard with refugee policy and immigration policy, Corey, it creates a backlash against otherwise good immigration and refugee policy.
00:44:24 Like, you see what's happened. Gert Wilders is about to be sworn in as the prime minister of the Netherlands.
00:44:30 The Netherlands, historically the most liberal anything-goes country in Europe for the last hundred years,
00:44:37 has just elected Gert frickin' Wilders as their prime minister.
00:44:43 And that is by far the biggest reason is unchecked, open borders,
00:44:50 allowing people in who don't share the values of your country and who try to impose the values 1.00
00:44:54 of the old country on the new. And that's why you've got the friendly little Dutch taking off 1.00
00:44:58 their wooden shoes and throwing them. And it's also a front and center in the ongoing British 0.92
00:45:04 election, which party can stop the migrant boats from coming across the channel. So it's a huge
00:45:10 political issue every day in Europe. We should worry about right now we're already dealing with
00:45:16 an immigration crisis with too many people legally coming over, regular immigrants, temporary 1.00
00:45:20 immigrants, other refugees. We're having difficulty housing them. We're having difficulty integrating 1.00
00:45:25 them, taking in thousands more from what is one of the most dysfunctional hornet's nests on the 1.00
00:45:30 planet right now, to be blunt, is stupid. I feel for it. There's some people in dire straits. I 1.00
00:45:35 mean, the military operation has kettled them down in the bottom. There are some innocent people
00:45:39 stuck in that crossfire. But you know what? We've done a lot and we've done enough. If you really
00:45:45 want to do something lobby to Egypt to Jordan to Lebanon to
00:45:49 bring them in. What did you say on your show today 1.3 million
00:45:52 immigrants this year in 2023 1.3. So this is just ridiculous to 0.98
00:45:59 reach out for more. It's it's virtue signaling in a 0.90
00:46:01 dangerous way. Yeah. All right. Well, gentlemen, good show.
00:46:05 Thank you very much. And thank all of you for joining us on the
00:46:07 pipeline today. Remember, if you're not yet a member of the
00:46:10 Western standard, you really need to be the Western standard is
00:46:12 one of the very, very few and very last media outlets in Canada that does not take the federal
00:46:18 government's media bailout. We are funded by advertising and from people willing to step up
00:46:24 and put a little bit of money down to support the work we do. It's only $10 a month or $100 a year
00:46:30 for unlimited access to all Western Standard content by becoming a member. Go to westernstandard.news
00:46:35 right now and click on membership to support the work we do and support one of the last
00:46:39 independent media left in canada thank you very much for joining us and giving us your time today
00:46:43 and god bless you can become a western center member for just ten dollars a month or 99