Western Standard - December 24, 2024


HANNAFORD: A walk through Trudeau's mind

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Trudeau must be removed HANNAFORD: A new year promises hope for a Canada that has suffered the want of it so long

Episode Stats


Length

21 minutes

Words per minute

149.52

Word count

3,175

Sentence count

125

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this week's show, political consultant Nigel Baran and I discuss the fallout from Justin Trudeau's surprise ouster of his finance minister, Jane Philpott, and why it may have been the most humiliating move of all.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to this week's edition of Hannaford.
00:00:21 With me today is political consultant Yaroslav Baran. He's the principal of the Pendulum Group,
00:00:26 And he's been doing Ottawa for 25 years in government and out of it, helping people understand
00:00:31 Ottawa. Yaroslav, thanks for joining us again. Always a pleasure, Nigel. Yaroslav, you have an
00:00:37 amazing franchise on Justin Trudeau. So far, just about everything you've said about the Prime
00:00:41 Minister has been bang on. But did you see this coming? On Friday, he fires his finance minister
00:00:48 on Zoom, not even a text, but still expects her to deliver the fiscal update on Monday. And when
00:00:54 she quits he acts surprised what's going on in his head yeah that's quite the breakup you know
00:01:01 you break up with somebody on zoom and then and then you're shocked that they got offended by it
00:01:06 um based on what we know he he did tell her on friday on a zoom call that the fiscal update
00:01:14 the public economic statement would be her last public act as finance minister she was still
00:01:20 expected to do it, but she would be shuffled out shortly thereafter and replaced by the person 1.00
00:01:26 about whom PMO had been proactively leaking for several months now, Mark Carney, that he would
00:01:34 be replacing her. So any sensible, normal person would be pretty offended by that turn of events.
00:01:43 I think not expecting that that would be perceived as offense and humiliation
00:01:50 is a little bit short-sighted, a little bit lacking on the EQ, as the kids say.
00:01:56 You know, this has been said before, but it's ironic that just two days before,
00:02:02 three days before, he had criticized the Americans for not electing a woman president.
00:02:08 Well, I guess this is not exactly showing respect for women. 1.00
00:02:13 is it well and you know liberal mps themselves have started to comment on that that this is
00:02:19 becoming something of a pattern that uh strong women around him get unceremoniously pushed out 0.73
00:02:28 of the way uh at any moment uh we saw this with jody wilson ray bolts we saw it uh you know we
00:02:35 saw it with others along the way we've heard the criticisms from people like his former parliamentary
00:02:41 Secretary, Cesar Chavanis, and others. So, you know, remember Jane Philpott, there have been a
00:02:52 lot of strong women in and around cabinet who have been pushed over the cliff. 1.00
00:03:02 It certainly does invite a new definition of feminism, doesn't it? In October, he had a
00:03:10 challenge from his caucus. And basically, he just waited it out. And in my own head, I can sort of
00:03:18 construct a way that he could wait it out again. Everybody's gone home for Christmas, you know,
00:03:24 come back, the heat's off at the end of January, start doing business. Gosh, you know, pretty soon
00:03:31 you're getting into the writ period. You don't have to hang on for that long to hold your job.
00:03:36 Now, maybe that's not the right way to look at it.
00:03:40 What do you think is going on in his head?
00:03:42 Well, first of all, there's a significant difference
00:03:45 between the caucus coup earlier in the fall compared to now.
00:03:51 What we saw earlier in the fall was a move by caucus
00:03:55 to start to circulate a petition.
00:03:58 They tried to be discreet about it somewhat.
00:04:00 They tried to be respectful, do it behind closed doors,
00:04:03 asked him earnestly to think about his future and whether his leadership is really in the best
00:04:09 interest of the party. So there was a stressful caucus meeting at the time, a whole bunch of
00:04:17 people vented, but there was no mechanism to force him out. It's not like in the United Kingdom where
00:04:26 we've seen people walk into a caucus meeting as prime minister and then walk out two or three
00:04:31 hours later as a backbencher with a pool of political blood in the middle of the floor.
00:04:37 There is no mechanism to do that here in Canada unless a party adopts measures in the so-called
00:04:45 the Chong Reform Act that was passed several years ago. But a party has to adopt those
00:04:52 mechanisms at the beginning of a parliament, which the Liberals refuse to do. So the Conservatives
00:04:57 can do that because they chose to to apply those rules to themselves the liberals haven't
00:05:03 there is no mechanism to push him out so back in october it was a big venting of steam
00:05:08 but then there was really nothing that the caucus could do when he said okay i heard you but i'm
00:05:15 staying and interestingly after the trump election all those discussions about liberal leadership
00:05:24 just suddenly vanished because they were overtaken by new pressing emergent events this week
00:05:31 changed all that and also demonstrated that that steam had not bent it they had just put the lid on
00:05:39 but what happens when a when you've got a pot of boiling water with the lid on sooner or later
00:05:46 it's going to go kaboom that's what happened this week and do you think yaris laughed that that's
00:05:52 going to hold until the end of january which is when parliament resumes well back in october
00:06:02 going back to this liberal caucus petition back in october they had what some 25 maybe 30 names
00:06:09 out of a caucus you know pushing you know 150 mps um so that's a pretty small number we knew
00:06:17 that there were more people but a lot of people were unwilling to actually put their name on a
00:06:22 piece of paper because they know the party leader has to sign your nomination papers you don't want
00:06:26 to get in the leader's bad books if he's the guy who decides do i get to run again or not so um
00:06:34 that list that petition is now at about 60 names it's getting pretty close to 50 of his caucus
00:06:43 once it hits 50 that really kind of becomes a moral tipping point for him it's hard to imagine
00:06:50 being a prime minister going to work every day knowing that most of your caucus is against you
00:06:57 or we we may be at that point now but not in written signed form if we get to that point
00:07:05 that should be a game changer for most people it would be i get the sense there's something
00:07:13 different about this man well there is uh in that um and i'm not saying this necessarily as a you
00:07:24 know criticism of him or whatever this is just a fact he unlike most party leaders has less
00:07:33 attachment to his party brand than you would expect ultimately sees this as the trudeau
00:07:41 government. He does not see himself as a temporary occupant of the great liberal throne. He sees
00:07:49 himself as Justin Trudeau and this is the Justin Trudeau government. Most party leaders would be
00:07:59 far more attuned, sensitive to the state of the party that they will be leaving behind after
00:08:07 I'm not sure there's a lot of that kind of consideration going on under the present circumstances.
00:08:14 Do you think, Yaroslav, that he is convinced of the rightness of his mission,
00:08:20 thinking here perhaps principally of climate change, but there are a number of other issues that seem very important to him,
00:08:28 To the degree that he will actually carry on just to see that through
00:08:33 and cement in the things that he believes that he has accomplished.
00:08:40 Yes.
00:08:40 Until now, that has been his driving consideration.
00:08:43 He is, you know, you've got two different kinds of prime ministers historically.
00:08:47 You've got the managerial, transactional kind of steward prime ministers.
00:08:54 And then you have the big vision, we're going to change the world together.
00:08:58 kind of prime ministers he is definitely more in the latter he's got and he's being he's driven by
00:09:04 by progressive ideology he sees pierre pauliev as the great barbarians at the gates who must be
00:09:10 stopped at all costs and until now what has kept him going is that he has felt that he is best
00:09:16 positioned out of all the liberals you look around you think yeah she's pretty okay he's pretty good
00:09:22 he's kind of strong but i'm still better than any one of them so uh if we're going to stop the
00:09:27 the angry barbarians at the gates, 0.57
00:09:31 it really makes sense for me to lead the liberal party
00:09:34 because I'm gonna be better than anybody else
00:09:36 or sitting around my cabinet table.
00:09:39 That has kept him going and he's very much believed that.
00:09:42 But again, if we get to the point
00:09:46 where we have a majority of his caucus
00:09:50 telling him that they have lost confidence, right?
00:09:52 The whole fall has been a discussion
00:09:55 about when does parliament lose confidence?
00:09:57 But when you get to the point where your own where where your own caucus has lost confidence in you, it really makes it hard to continue with that kind of line of thinking.
00:10:08 And, you know, liberals in Ottawa right now, they're past the point of thinking, how can we win it back?
00:10:15 How can we turn the polls around? How can we how can we cling to power?
00:10:19 They are now in save the furniture mode.
00:10:23 So backbenchers are thinking they're making their calculus along the following lines.
00:10:29 If he stays and I run again with him as leader, I'm toast.
00:10:33 I'm going to lose my seat.
00:10:35 And I represent a fairly safe liberal seat.
00:10:38 But if he goes, I might have a chance of getting reelected.
00:10:43 That's what a whole bunch of liberal MPs are saying and thinking right now.
00:10:48 So that means that they can't simply vote against him in a non-confidence vote because he would still be the leader taking them into the election.
00:11:00 And the disaster scenario that they're predicting would actually come about.
00:11:05 They would lose their seats, even the very safe seats like they've lost in the last six months.
00:11:10 Well, we just saw yet another by-election this week on Monday.
00:11:14 I mean, we were all focused on the on the high drama with with former finance minister, Christopher, Deputy Prime Minister, Christopher Freeland walking out on him.
00:11:24 So as we were all focused on that, there was a by-election in just outside of Vancouver, where a previously held liberal seat in Langley City, another liberal seat was lost and went to the Conservatives.
00:11:40 Conservatives. So think about it. At the end of the spring sitting of Parliament, at the very end
00:11:45 of the spring sitting, there's a by-election in Toronto, a safe, quote-unquote, safe Liberal seat
00:11:51 that the Liberals lost to the Conservatives. They opened up the fall sitting with another
00:11:57 by-election in another safe Liberal seat in Montreal that they lost. And now they're closing
00:12:04 out this sitting of Parliament with yet another by-election loss of a Liberal seat. That's a
00:12:10 bad track record and believe me none of that is lost on anybody sitting in the liberal caucus
00:12:16 right now which brings me to the person of dominic lebon yeah um obviously as a as a liberal and a
00:12:25 progressive he's not said very much over the past years that i've wanted to congratulate him for
00:12:32 but he is a serious player he's not a fool that's true mr trudeau walked down the corridor knocking
00:12:41 on doors trying to find somebody to take on the finance role he finally after three other attempts
00:12:47 arrived at uh at mr sorry two other attempts he finally arrived at mr leblanc's door and mr
00:12:55 leblanc took the job in addition to several other portfolios yes he holds now what's in it for
00:13:04 dominic leblanc to do that for justin trudeau yeah you know frankly it was probably a very good move
00:13:12 to ask dominic leblanc to take this job i mean there's there was some technical uh you know
00:13:18 process procedural drama uh that unraveled according to tradition and the so-called order
00:13:23 precedents and so on. You always need a finance minister. There needs to be a finance minister
00:13:29 because there's certain statutory obligations that there needs to be somebody designated to
00:13:32 discharge them if and when required. There's certain key roles in cabinet that cannot be
00:13:38 vacant at any time. That's one of them, finance. So there's a process whereby if you find yourself
00:13:45 without a finance minister, it defaults to the industry minister, the minister of the economy.
00:13:49 They then automatically sort of become the finance minister.
00:13:54 Minister Champagne said, no, thanks.
00:13:57 My hands are full.
00:13:58 I got plenty on my plate.
00:13:59 I'm not doing it.
00:14:01 Interestingly, the next in line would have been Randy Boiseno, who was actually punted
00:14:07 from cabinet about a month ago over, gosh, three scandals, four scandals, five scandals.
00:14:12 I've lost count how many scandals he was suddenly embroiled in.
00:14:16 So he was, he was out of play where he would have been automatically the next in line as sort of a junior minister within the finance portfolio family.
00:14:24 So they found themselves scrambling to figure out what are we going to do?
00:14:28 We're unveiling a mini budget today and we have no finance minister.
00:14:32 I was talking to journalists who went to the media lockup.
00:14:36 You know, there's, there's a thing called a lockup where journalists get sequestered into a room.
00:14:41 they they lock their cell phones in a cubby and then they get a thorough briefing before a budget
00:14:47 or a mini budget comes out with the departmental officials so that they're ready to report on it as
00:14:52 soon as you know as soon as it's showtime and journalists showed up at the lockup and they
00:14:57 were told by finance officials um we don't even know if this thing is going ahead today because
00:15:04 the political order of government was scrambling to find a finance minister to actually deliver
00:15:09 thing. It was, Mr. Qualia nailed it. The quote of the week is, this is a clown show. And it really
00:15:19 was a clown show. The scrambling, the damage control that we saw on Monday, it was just 0.93
00:15:24 nonstop. I thought the quote of the week was when he said in during question period,
00:15:29 would the minister for Nats please identify himself? Yes, exactly. With a real slim shady,
00:15:34 please stand up. That's right. I'd like to ask you, we're running out of time, Yaroslav, but
00:15:40 I'd like to conclude on this note. There is a disaster scenario that you could speculate upon.
00:15:46 It may not, in fact, be likely, but let's just say that convinced of the rightness of his cause
00:15:53 and the sheer inadequacy of the people around him, in what would other circumstances even look
00:16:00 rather admirable the prime minister chooses to carry on and will not step aside there being no
00:16:08 mechanism for his removal he doesn't and tries to carry on what would february and march look like
00:16:20 as we prepare for a budget with a prime minister who was totally out of sorts with his caucus
00:16:26 trying to continue to govern well right now we've got two opposition parties the conservatives and
00:16:33 the bloc quebecois who are on record repeatedly and as freshly as yesterday saying we need to
00:16:39 put this government out of its misery as soon as possible so they are ready to vote non-confidence
00:16:44 as soon as parliament reconvenes at the end of january they may not have an option on day one
00:16:50 they need to last week yeah they yeah they they need to wait for an opposition day or
00:16:57 or an intrinsic confidence vote like a money bill something like that they can't just walk
00:17:01 in on day one and say non-confidence there needs to be you know a tool to do that uh but they're
00:17:06 ready to bring down the government asap all eyes now are on jagmeet singh uh it's in his hands
00:17:14 Will he join Mr. Kualiev and Mr. Blanchet to say enough is enough.
00:17:19 We're voting on confidence. We are actually codifying what is plainly evident to everybody
00:17:26 that this parliament is dysfunctional and the government has lost confidence.
00:17:30 He's unwilling to vote that way, even though everybody realizes that it's true.
00:17:36 What's holding him back is poor polling and poor fundraising.
00:17:39 He actually doesn't want an election. He's trying to differentiate himself
00:17:42 and the ndp from the liberal brand because they're about to fight an election against them but they're
00:17:47 not ready to have an election because the polling suggests that they they might even lose seats
00:17:51 that's yeah that's that's pretty bad shape to be in for an opposition party especially in these
00:17:56 kinds of circumstances so all eyes are going to be on on Jagmeet Singh there's one tool there's
00:18:01 an additional tool that the prime minister has to buy himself more time he could prorogue parliament
00:18:06 that's like hitting the big pause button that would prevent the house of commons reopening on
00:18:11 January 27th he can buy himself several months he could pause on right up until say the government
00:18:20 needs to pass another appropriations bill which isn't until the end of march he could buy himself
00:18:26 that much time if he wants but then as soon as it opens you're opening up with confidence votes
00:18:30 and that would probably end up being the trigger so he's got a prime minister has to weigh these
00:18:35 options do i buy more time and then almost guarantee that i fall as soon as we get back
00:18:40 Or do I reopen normally, whistle past the graveyard, pretend none of this has ever happened and just somehow try to limp along?
00:18:48 And one other observation I'll make, Nigel, is that the seat projections and pollsters and astrophysicists who design algorithms who are far smarter than I am have these elaborate systems of taking commercially publicly available polls, putting them through computer simulations to predict how the polling numbers would translate into seats.
00:19:18 that different parties win and most of the seat projections that we're seeing right now
00:19:24 show the liberals and the block quebecois roughly coming out around the same so there's a credible
00:19:32 a very plausible chance that the liberals could even fall to third party status and that we'd end
00:19:39 up with a conservative majority government a block quebecois official opposition and with
00:19:45 with the Liberals in third place.
00:19:46 That's what's going to happen.
00:19:48 The NDP rejected entirely because of its cynical actions
00:19:51 of its leader.
00:19:53 Yeah.
00:19:54 Well, it's a lot to look forward to, isn't it? 0.95
00:19:58 It's been a clown show. 0.95
00:19:59 It's been a clown show. 0.80
00:20:02 Well, that's, look, thank you very much
00:20:05 for your analysis on this.
00:20:06 I dare say it won't be the last given what you've just said.
00:20:10 We'll be looking out for the prorogation.
00:20:14 Meanwhile, on behalf of everybody who's here at the Western Standard,
00:20:17 Jaroslav, we wish you a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.
00:20:21 Thank you, and to you as well, my friend.
00:20:22 Thank you very much.
00:20:24 Bye-bye.
00:20:25 For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.
00:20:44 Thank you.