Western Standard - November 15, 2026


HANNAFORD: Carney’s budget is a gamble on Canada’s future

Why Ottawa’s Budget Is a Gamble Did the Iran War Cost Republicans the Midterms?

Episode Stats


Length

26 minutes

Words per minute

157.87

Word count

4,191

Sentence count

260

Harmful content

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Good evening Western Standard viewers and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics
00:00:20 show of the Western Standard. It is Thursday, November the 12th. Last week, Finance Minister
00:00:26 Champagne delivered the budget, but really it was Prime Minister Carney's
00:00:30 budget. It seems to Canada's commentariat that it landed with a dull FUD. In the
00:00:36 Globe and Mail, Andrew Coyne called it a strange budget, as opaque as it is
00:00:41 complacent. But what about the investment community and the people who manage
00:00:46 your money? What do they say? With me this evening is our old friend Peter
00:00:53 Piovic. He is Senior Portfolio Manager at Piovic Bighill Private Wealth and Wellington Altus.
00:01:00 Peter, it's great to have you here.
00:01:02 Nigel, thank you once again for having me on your fine show. It's both an honour and a privilege.
00:01:07 You are too kind, but I've never retaliated on people who are too kind.
00:01:13 Of course.
00:01:13 Look, let's talk about the budget. What do you make of it? It seems to me that if you
00:01:22 take on debt, you become the slave to the lender. I mean, is this smart?
00:01:28 You're talking about the masters of our destiny budget?
00:01:30 Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And being, are you quoting the Bible there? Proverbs by chance,
00:01:38 Nigel? I may have been. You may have been. Yeah. Yeah. So of course, you know, it is true,
00:01:44 the more and more debt uh you you accrue uh you do become a slave to those who hold your debt
00:01:52 and uh in this budget as most other budget let's be honest like there's very few budgets we've had
00:01:57 in the last you know dozens and dozens of years that didn't increase uh debt can't think of one
00:02:03 since 2015. yeah it's been a while right so so it's uh i might almost phrase it uh as a gambler's
00:02:11 budget. A gambler's budget. A gambler's budget, yes. So essentially there's been a criticism of
00:02:18 Canada for many years now, at least 10 years, maybe even more, where it has not been a friendly
00:02:24 place for capital, whether it's private capital or foreign capital to come to. Because the tax
00:02:33 regime for that capital in Canada simply wasn't as competitive as it is in many other parts of the
00:02:39 world. So capital flows essentially to where it's treated best. And it hasn't been treated best,
00:02:46 you know, in Canada for a long time. So this budget, you know, to its credit, actually aims
00:02:53 to correct some of those old ills and create an environment that's more conducive for capital
00:03:00 to come into. However, and this is a huge however, it's going to rest so much on execution and so
00:03:08 much on trust, so that capital needs to trust Canada that it's actually going to be able to
00:03:12 execute and deliver such that there's profit. Well, that, I guess, is a given. But when we're
00:03:20 dealing with the particulars of the case, why would people, given this excellent budget,
00:03:28 from your perspective, it's everything the investment community has been asking for for
00:03:34 years. All right, there it is. Now, what's the problem?
00:03:40 So, I mean, I wouldn't say that it's everything you've been asking for for years. I didn't see
00:03:46 a lot in terms of tax deductions for, let's just say, people in Canada that are very much
00:03:53 overtaxed, which are now going to continue to be overtaxed. But at least both on the capital
00:04:01 expenditure side. So, um, there's, uh, there's actually, uh, in this budget, you know, measures
00:04:07 to create tax deductibility of capital expenditures that is, that is actually very
00:04:13 similar to what we have in the U S right now. So that's, I find that a little bit interesting,
00:04:17 whether it's almost like an aligning of policies, uh, in some respects with the U S so that if you
00:04:23 are, uh, going to do a large project, a pipeline or, you know, uh, dig new oil wells, uh, electrical
00:04:29 infrastructure, you're going to have very, very favorable tax deductions on the capital
00:04:37 expenditures to make sure that project gets off the ground. Furthermore, for capital that does
00:04:43 come in, under certain circumstances, they're going to allow a much higher, up to $50 million,
00:04:49 when we're talking about capital gains exemptions. So conceivably, as an investor,
00:04:58 You know, your first $15 million of gains, you know, could be considered tax-free.
00:05:03 And that's a good reason for foreign capital and private capital to show up.
00:05:08 But again, it'll hinge on trust and execution.
00:05:12 Trust and execution.
00:05:16 Another way, certainly as far as execution is concerned, what I think you are saying to me is that these projects do have to get approved.
00:05:28 or else the whole thing falls apart you still have the debt correct and the interest and that's
00:05:33 your risk right because to to allow for these tax deductions they're going to need more debt because
00:05:40 that's revenue that's not coming in well let me be let me be a little provocative here um
00:05:47 it's it's not that nobody has said this before but you usually sort of say behind your hand
00:05:53 it's all very well to say we're going to build a something but if it involves indigenous owned land
00:06:02 or even if it just these days it's become very fashionable just to consult with indigenous
00:06:08 people because you ought to talk to them whether they own the the the land or have a stake in it
00:06:15 or not i mean that's one thing right there it's one thing i mean there there are well
00:06:22 Okay. Tell me about Lemoore and maybe just elaborate a little on the risk to us, the
00:06:29 taxpayers. What's this going to look like if it doesn't work?
00:06:35 You can create all the tax incentives you want for capital to come into Canada. We allow
00:06:41 higher limits for capital gains as an example, or you allow, you know, deductions on capital
00:06:47 expenditures, but it's really all for naught if, if we don't get picks and shovels in the ground
00:06:53 and get projects approved. Uh, and wet, and right now the concern or what the concern has been for
00:06:58 years, um, you know, uh, possibly, you know, uh, that, you know, because of a dispute, say with a,
00:07:05 a band, you know, that maybe that project doesn't get approved or maybe it's intra-provincial trade
00:07:11 barriers or, you know, arguing between Alberta and BC or Alberta all the way to Manitoba in terms of
00:07:17 whether you can get a pipeline through or not, um, that's a problem.
00:07:21 Um, you know, uh, ultimately, you know, announcements are nice, but we need a
00:07:27 lot more than just announcements.
00:07:28 We need projects actually approved and picks and shovels in the ground.
00:07:32 Now, um, one of the first things that Mr.
00:07:34 Carney did was to establish a special projects office, and, uh, that was
00:07:40 intended to cut the corners on a lot of, on a lot of the kind of projects
00:07:45 that we're talking about here.
00:07:46 And it's not just pipelines, there were other things that were-
00:07:50 Electrical infrastructure.
00:07:50 Electrical, yes, and so forth.
00:07:52 I believe the Quebec icebreakers project was also part of the initial lineup.
00:07:59 And that there was an announcement on a couple of weeks ago.
00:08:02 So that at least seems to be on track.
00:08:05 How many of these projects have been approved on Agile?
00:08:08 I'm asking for an exact number, but-
00:08:10 Well, I mean-
00:08:12 Not enough?
00:08:12 None as far as I know.
00:08:14 other than other than the sort of the general blessing that the Davies shipyards got yeah and
00:08:20 I do think that probably is is is happening but where's my pipeline where's my electrical
00:08:26 infrastructure where's my railway to the Churchill to so that we don't have to export gas through
00:08:34 Quebec because Quebec there's another roadblock that yes you know we often talk about I often talk
00:08:41 about the indigenous bands but darn it quebec is not exactly a team player in the in this and now
00:08:47 by the way we have a new government in british colombia which is not ideologically opposed to
00:08:54 pipelines but they've got their hands full on the indigenous file as well yes so i have to wonder um
00:09:02 And how long, you can borrow the money as soon as you want, but how long can Mr. Carney take to actually produce a project and say, we're going to start work on it on this date and it's a close date?
00:09:22 Yeah. So it's what I mentioned earlier about trust. And the lack thereof of trust probably stems from the last 10 years of just simply the lack of approvals or difficulty in approvals of getting projects done. Mr. Carney has promised to expedite that, as you mentioned. We still haven't had a lot of actual action on that.
00:09:45 Now, in fairness, though, to get that action, it's not like you flick a switch. There's a road that has to be paid first. And you could argue that this budget is a start. By creating the tax regime, which allows capital to come in in a favorable manner into Canada, that's a start.
00:10:10 That's definitely a good start, but it's a gambler's budget because that involves taking on more and more debt, too.
00:10:16 And if the capital doesn't come, essentially, then we're just saddled with more debt.
00:10:22 Well, they'll find a use for the money, I'm sure.
00:10:25 In fact, I believe they've just had a windfall, thanks to, Mr. Carney would hate to admit this,
00:10:32 but thanks to the actions of President Trump in the Gulf of Hormuz, oil is up.
00:10:38 So money is flowing into the producer country's coffers.
00:10:43 We are a producer country.
00:10:45 Alberta certainly has gone from a deficit situation for this fiscal year to in the black.
00:10:52 And there has been a substantial windfall to the federal government.
00:10:57 What did they do with that?
00:11:00 Didn't they spend it?
00:11:01 The federal government?
00:11:02 Yeah, the federal.
00:11:03 Alberta is a different discussion.
00:11:04 Yeah, so the budget did cite windfalls from oil and gas revenues, which of course is primarily Alberta and Saskatchewan.
00:11:14 And they're using that to essentially, and it was a very nice windfall, actually, which is ironically, again, caused by the Iran war, which you can chew on that in terms of what that means.
00:11:30 You know, but they use that mainly to pave the way for some of these tax incentives.
00:11:38 It's not being used to pay down debt, if that's what you're asking.
00:11:41 Yes.
00:11:42 You know, but it is creating room in the budget for these tax incentives.
00:11:47 Now, that's also a very, you know, risky thing as well because, you know, the reason we had this surplus was because of, largely, is because of the Iran War.
00:11:59 What happens if that war ends, you know, tomorrow? 0.87
00:12:03 And I hope it does in many respects.
00:12:06 You know, you never want to see, you know, wars, you know, perpetuate long term.
00:12:10 But if it does, presumably the price of oil comes down.
00:12:14 And then what?
00:12:15 And the only real way, you know, we're going to be able to maintain that surplus of cash is to increase production.
00:12:25 Okay.
00:12:26 That lays it out very well.
00:12:28 But there's one other big thing going on right now that bears into this, and that's Mr. Carney's affection for Europe, his approach to Europe, the discussion as to what kind of associate membership Canada may have with Europe one of these days.
00:12:44 But I would put it to, I mean, I've written this already,
00:12:47 I would put it to Peter that the Europeans are in worse shape than we are. 0.96
00:12:52 They owe more money. 1.00
00:12:52 They can't control their borders.
00:12:54 Their defense posture is weak relative to the threats
00:12:58 that they think they face from Russia.
00:13:00 We're talking about wars ending. 0.58
00:13:02 It would be great to see the things wind up in the Ukraine too.
00:13:05 I'd like to see that.
00:13:06 So how much sense does it make?
00:13:11 Well, I don't think it makes much sense at all.
00:13:13 Well, what are the risks that Mr. Carney is prepared to accept in nudging up to Europe and developing closer relations?
00:13:23 So, Nigel, are you asking essentially, does he really wish to acquire closer relations, possibly an EU membership or associate membership, you know, with the EU?
00:13:34 Or is this mostly bargaining theater aimed at getting a better deal with the United States?
00:13:41 I think that is what I'm asking.
00:13:43 Go ahead.
00:13:43 Yeah, yeah.
00:13:44 So if it is theatre, I've used this term before, it's called statecraft.
00:13:49 So, you know, which essentially is a form of political theatre.
00:13:54 So which is it, you know, essentially?
00:13:57 So, but let's kind of parse through some of the facts.
00:14:01 So if this is what Mr. Carney really wants, like if he actually really wants, you know, closer associations with Europe, especially if it's a membership in the EU.
00:14:13 facts, Europe is in a far worse fiscal and monetary position than Canada. So for all Canada's
00:14:22 faults and problems, we are a much cleaner dirty shirt. Cleaner dirty shirt? Cleaner dirty shirt.
00:14:28 We're all dirty shirts. Show me a country that's not a dirty shirt. Is this the talk inside the
00:14:35 finance industry? I didn't invent it. I did not invent it. It's something that's been thrown around.
00:14:40 Canada is a cleaner, dirty shirt.
00:14:42 Everybody's got dirty shirts on.
00:14:44 But our shirt is a little bit cleaner than a lot of theirs. 0.96
00:14:49 So, I mean, just it may be evidence of that is recall that not long ago, you know, five countries in Europe were labeled as pigs, you know, which is pigs. 0.98
00:15:00 Pigs, yeah. 0.87
00:15:00 So that's a very unflattering term that's used to describe the finances of Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Greece, and Spain.
00:15:07 But that was, you know, 10, 15 years ago now.
00:15:10 You know, today, you probably want to throw France in there, too, as well, and probably a few other countries, you know, maybe even to some degree, UK.
00:15:19 Is this a good place for us to be?
00:15:21 Well, you know, let's just kind of like continue on.
00:15:24 And so, you know, a fact.
00:15:26 So Europe is, let's be honest here, Europe is constrained on energy and resources.
00:15:32 Canada is abundant in energy and resources, including bulk water.
00:15:35 I mean, we always think about oil and gas, but, you know, there's bulk water and there's lumber and so forth as well.
00:15:40 So, it is undergoing very serious political strife these days.
00:15:46 Just think of France.
00:15:47 What's going on in France today?
00:15:50 It's a little frightening in some regards.
00:15:54 And while some in Canada may indeed have hopes and aspirations of an EU-inclusive passport,
00:15:59 which we can just travel freely and so forth, that comes at a huge cost.
00:16:04 you know, I mean, the regulatory burden in the EU, many would argue, and I would, and I would
00:16:12 myself, is completely incongruent with oil and gas development in Canada. And ultimately, if we had
00:16:18 to adopt those regulations, it would stifle our own growth. So, you know, why would we want to do
00:16:24 that? You know, kind of moving along as well. So if Mr. Carney is serious about Canada joining the
00:16:33 EU in any way, shape, or form, I would argue that the EU would gain monetary and fiscal
00:16:41 stability. So the EU would gain the monetary and fiscal stability by integrating Canada's
00:16:47 cleaner balance sheet onto its own. The EU would gain substantial energy and resource
00:16:54 assets and revenue. Okay, you know, because we have it, they don't. Canada's economic
00:17:01 growth may likely be hampered by EU regulations as as we as we spoke earlier and we can't forget
00:17:06 about that so is the EU a prairie winner in such an environment um you know or what do we gain out
00:17:13 of it you know other than maybe access you know to different parts of Europe um so this is where
00:17:20 some may question Carney's Mr Carney's intent you know does he really want that especially if it's
00:17:27 at the expense of tighter relations uh with the united states uh who are you know who are our
00:17:33 friends and have been our friends to the self for for decades so um so i i i'm thinking of uh
00:17:44 a scene in a drawing room of men and women and there's a woman who uh is actually interested
00:17:51 in this guy over here but he's not taking a lot of notice so she pretends to flirt with a guy over
00:17:56 here in the hope that he will suddenly you know is you call it statecraft statecraft yeah 0.81
00:18:04 that is a great analogy nigel so so therefore the other possibility is statecraft um so is
00:18:11 mr carney merely using a closer association with the eu and possibly china as well uh as political
00:18:19 theater statecraft uh get a better deal uh so um this can include things like uh talks of buying
00:18:26 swedish sob gripins if that makes sense i'm not sure that it does you know um with talk of pipelines
00:18:33 to the east and the west along with construction of ports uh in the east and the west uh to export
00:18:39 energy overseas and while you know that may make sense for diversification you know the pipeline
00:18:45 end to the self is a lot shorter and easier to, uh, but you're not saying there's no business
00:18:50 case. I'm not saying there's no business case. Uh, although I would add that if the costs of,
00:18:57 uh, of the end product, um, becomes so great, uh, whether it's due to carbon capture or just like
00:19:04 long transmission difficulties, uh, and getting approvals, uh, it just becomes too expensive.
00:19:10 Then maybe there isn't a business case. Well, come on, let's Mr. Trudeau pass on that.
00:19:14 Yeah, no, exactly.
00:19:16 I mean, I think it was a business case, but without a doubt at the time, the general
00:19:19 shouldn't have paid anything.
00:19:20 Yeah, especially to the east.
00:19:22 Yes.
00:19:23 You know, that would be probably the bigger one or the easier one to sell.
00:19:26 Is this all to obtain a better trade deal with the United States by providing artificial
00:19:33 competitive bids?
00:19:35 You know, maybe.
00:19:35 um so and also during a u.s midterm election cycle uh which mr uh trump lost uh largely
00:19:44 and quite spectacularly in some in some respects which uh some may say it's i mean it's unclear
00:19:49 yet but some may say might leave him in a bit of a vulnerable position um so you know is this
00:19:55 statecraft is this theater basically to ultimately lead to a much better deal with the united states
00:20:00 than what we would have received
00:20:03 had we just signed the first offer
00:20:04 that came across our desks.
00:20:07 And obviously we don't know.
00:20:08 I mean, it's a big maybe.
00:20:10 What's your spidey, sir?
00:20:13 I mean, then this gets a little,
00:20:15 you know, obviously, you know, tough,
00:20:17 where on one hand,
00:20:18 what makes sense to me
00:20:19 is the second option,
00:20:21 which is that this is statecraft.
00:20:22 And that's what makes sense.
00:20:23 Because of course, I mean,
00:20:24 like it's United States,
00:20:26 the largest, our largest trading partner,
00:20:28 largest economy on the earth.
00:20:29 and they're right to our southern border
00:20:31 and it's not even that far.
00:20:33 And so much of Canada's population
00:20:35 is pretty much within spitting distance
00:20:37 of the U.S. border.
00:20:38 That's a much easier route,
00:20:40 much easier sell.
00:20:43 That's what makes sense.
00:20:44 To what degree does it make sense
00:20:46 for us to give up sovereignty to the EU,
00:20:49 for us to ship goods
00:20:50 on much, much farther distances
00:20:52 to an economy that's much weaker?
00:20:56 I don't know, but here's the rub though.
00:20:58 how often do politicians, you know, do what makes sense? And that's where I get stuck.
00:21:03 All right. Well, that's a very good point to say. What everybody is hanging on your words here for
00:21:11 is what do I do about my own investment profile? Assuming everybody's got a particular plan.
00:21:18 Now, how do you save yourself from going bust given this particular dilemma at this particular
00:21:25 time. What would your advice be? Yeah, it really hasn't changed all that much, you know, over the
00:21:30 years and even with this budget. So, you know, obviously based on your own objectives and your
00:21:36 risk tolerances as the, is the usual disclaimer, you know, have enough cash and fixed income to
00:21:42 meet short-term liabilities. So make sure you have that as a reserve, you know, own good quality
00:21:48 equities, not just in Canada, but globally speaking in Canada, United States and abroad
00:21:53 that you can live with for many, many, many years.
00:21:56 What about Brookfield?
00:21:58 That's a controversial one.
00:22:00 Yeah, you probably don't want to give specifically.
00:22:02 Carry on.
00:22:02 Yeah, but short answer, probably.
00:22:04 Probably yes.
00:22:07 There's some risks in that one too,
00:22:08 but the short answer is probably yes.
00:22:10 But then you want to hedge some of those risks
00:22:13 by owning precious metals like gold bullion,
00:22:15 silver bullion,
00:22:16 because when you mix that together with equities,
00:22:19 it actually reduces your overall risk,
00:22:21 plus it's on sale right now. Gold and silver are both very much on sale today. And then for people
00:22:27 with a much higher risk tolerance that understand it, maybe even a small amount of Bitcoin. Who
00:22:32 knows? Because blockchain technology is being integrated more and more into the global economy.
00:22:38 Are you spooked by that recent incident where apparently the North Koreans got away with
00:22:43 $6.5 billion in Bitcoin? It's the same as every other previous hack. It's never Bitcoin that 0.86
00:22:50 that gets hacked and it wasn't this time either it was the exchange that got hacked um you know
00:22:56 this time it was binance you know years ago it was mount gox you know and there's there's been a few
00:23:01 but it's always the exchange that gets hacked it's not the actual bitcoin so as so if you're
00:23:06 if you're self-custodying your bitcoin in a in a reasonably stringent manner generally you're fine
00:23:13 so hold a little well if it meets your your uh your plan okay and you understand the risks
00:23:20 But maybe a little bit's not so bad.
00:23:22 The last thing I'll add on that is, you know, in the budget, specific to the budget, I mean, there was definitely an allocation towards electrical infrastructure and just general infrastructure spending.
00:23:35 So investing potentially in infrastructure, especially electrical infrastructure for the next number of years.
00:23:40 I mean, if the plan is to double electrical capacity by 2050, probably investing in that area is not a bad idea.
00:23:48 But not necessarily in natural gas generating plants, then what do you invest in if you want to take advantage of that?
00:23:58 Yeah, so copper.
00:24:01 So, for example, one of our holdings is actually raw copper.
00:24:03 We just own copper.
00:24:05 It's because whoever and whatever is done is probably going to involve copper.
00:24:10 So sometimes you can invest wisely in ways where you're not necessarily taking company-specific risk, but you're investing, we call it in the picks and shovels or materials that go into projects no matter what.
00:24:22 But in general, short term, a lot of this electrical energy production will be driven by natural gas, save for the next 10 years. Longer term, call it 10 years plus, it's probably more likely it'll be delivered by nuclear.
00:24:40 whether it's fission or fusion, that's a whole other argument, you know, uh, down the way.
00:24:44 Uh, but, uh, initially, uh, gas, longer term nuclear.
00:24:50 So a gambler's budget is funny thing going on with Europe that might turn out to be brilliant.
00:24:59 Either way, we could be in trouble, but this isn't the worst budget that you've ever seen.
00:25:06 No. As an investor, it's allowing capital to come, at least paving the path for capital to come back to Canada, private capital and global capital. I like that.
00:25:18 And for the individual investor, think about what you're doing, but stay the course. Don't overreact.
00:25:25 Don't overreact and don't be overexposed and have an absolute stringent risk management plan when you're investing so you're not overexposed to any one thing.
00:25:36 Because there's major execution risk in this budget.
00:25:40 If it is executed properly, things could be pretty good.
00:25:44 But if it fails, we're just going to be saddled with more and more debt.
00:25:49 Back to your initial opening statement from Proverbs.
00:25:56 This financial show just got religious.
00:25:58 Peter, thank you very much for coming in today.
00:26:00 It's been great to see you.
00:26:01 your advice is always thought-provoking and people need to people need to
00:26:08 consider exactly what is going on here but I think what you've given us here
00:26:11 is something that you might not have got for them the rest of the what I call the
00:26:15 commentary at all the people whose job it is to write about this today and
00:26:18 something else tomorrow you know they do their best as do we but you're on it
00:26:23 this is your this is your whole life so thank you for sharing sharing your
00:26:27 thoughts. Thank you for having me. It was a pleasure. For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.