Western Standard - January 14, 2025


HANNAFORD: Nobody but Trudeau has tried to escape scrutiny for this long

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE PIPELINE: Trudeau's post-national state is now prey to become a post-state nation Alberta in the Crosshairs

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

137.03

Word count

3,465

Sentence count

173

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, constitutional lawyer John Carpe joins me to talk about whether Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's decision to prorogued Parliament was wise, and whether it will be upheld by the Supreme Court of Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:02:30 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:02:37 It is Monday, January the 13th, and my guest today is constitutional lawyer John Carpe,
00:02:44 and we're going to be talking about whether what Prime Minister Trudeau did last week
00:02:49 in proroguing Parliament was even legal, never mind wise.
00:02:55 Welcome to the show, John.
00:02:56 Good to see you. Thanks for having me.
00:02:58 Well, always a pleasure, John.
00:03:00 First, though, a word from our sponsors.
00:03:05 This episode of Hannaford is sponsored by New World Precious Metals, based right here in Calgary.
00:03:12 Years of inflationary money printing and rising debt have decimated the savings of the average Canadian.
00:03:20 Gold and silver are the only currencies that have held their value for thousands of years.
00:03:27 last year alone saw 30 percent gains new world precious metals offers unique platforms to help
00:03:37 protect and grow our hard-earned wealth with gold and silver check them out at newworldpm.com
00:03:47 Again, that is newworldpm.com.
00:03:53 John, a week ago today, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau prorogued Parliament and told Canadians he intended to resign as both party leader and as prime minister after the party selects its next leader.
00:04:09 When will that be?
00:04:11 Supposedly March the 9th is when the Liberals want to have their leadership vote.
00:04:16 Parliament is prorogued until the 24th, and our court action is based on the view that he is abusing prorogation for the benefit of the Liberal Party of Canada, and prorogation should not be used in a partisan fashion that way.
00:04:32 John, for those of us who aren't constitutional lawyers, can you talk a little about what prorogation means in terms of the powers of the government?
00:04:44 as opposed to, well, I guess the members of Parliament have no power if they've been sent home.
00:04:51 What does it really mean, and why is it there at all?
00:04:55 So prorogation is shutting down Parliament, but without an election following immediately thereafter.
00:05:03 So if you want to look at it, one way to look at it is on the one extreme you've got dissolution,
00:05:09 Parliament is dissolved, and there's new elections.
00:05:11 On the other side, you can have a recess or an adjournment, so there's going to be no question period, but otherwise Parliament does continue to function with its committees.
00:05:21 Prorogation is halfway between the two, where you shut down Parliament, like it's dissolved, but there's no election.
00:05:28 And it is ordinarily done when the Parliament is completed.
00:05:35 You know, they've been sitting for a year or two and they're done with all their legislation.
00:05:44 They've done their best to implement what was in the throne speech and it's kind of come to an actual conclusion.
00:05:51 We don't want an election yet because we're only two years into the term, but we're going to prorogue parliament.
00:05:56 Parliament's going to really take a break.
00:05:58 Now, when Parliament is prorogued, the government, during that time, functions without accountability to Parliament, because the government and Parliament are not the same thing, right?
00:06:11 In the British system and Canadian system, based on that, the government must enjoy the confidence of the House of Commons, the majority of MPs.
00:06:21 That's where the confidence vote comes in.
00:06:23 So you have a minority government, but if the majority of MPs do not have confidence in the government,
00:06:28 the government falls and elections are called.
00:06:32 So what's going on here on January the 6th is that Prime Minister Trudeau prorogued Parliament,
00:06:39 so he and his government are not accountable, there cannot be a vote of confidence,
00:06:44 and it's for 11 weeks, which is a very long time.
00:06:48 Now, I think there is a British precedent, a relatively recent one, which you mean to draw on.
00:06:56 Can you just talk about that and tell us how likely it is that the, I guess it's the federal court, isn't it?
00:07:02 Not the Supreme Court of Canada. The federal court is going to hear this.
00:07:06 Yes, it's starting, we filed the application in the federal court.
00:07:09 And the precedent we rely on is the Miller case, Miller versus the Prime Minister, 2019 Supreme Court of the United Kingdom.
00:07:20 And in this case, Boris Johnson was the leader of a minority conservative government.
00:07:27 He had just become the new party leader and the prime minister.
00:07:30 and it was three years after the majority of voters in the United Kingdom had voted to leave
00:07:38 the European Union. The leave side won the referendum by a narrow margin over the remain side
00:07:44 and Boris Johnson was of the view that it was taking way too long. These negotiations were
00:07:51 going on and on and on and on and he said look the only way to move this ahead is to tell the
00:07:57 European Union that if necessary, we will leave without a deal. So he was willing to do a no deal
00:08:03 exit. Majority of MPs disagreed with him on that point. They wanted to keep on negotiating. Anyway,
00:08:11 he prorogued Parliament in the three months prior to when they were supposed to leave,
00:08:21 which was October 31st, Boris Johnson prorogued parliament for five weeks, which was longer than
00:08:28 the usual one to three weeks. And immediately court application was filed. And a few weeks
00:08:34 later, it went up the chain quickly. And the United Kingdom Supreme Court said that it was
00:08:42 an unlawful prorogation of parliament because Boris Johnson was trying to avoid parliamentary
00:08:48 through scrutiny, of his conduct as he was taking Britain out of the European Union.
00:08:55 And so the supremacy of Parliament, the sovereignty of Parliament,
00:08:59 accountability to Parliament were principles that were being violated
00:09:02 by a prorogation that was for five weeks.
00:09:05 So that is our precedent that we're putting before the Canadian courts.
00:09:09 So, John, it seems to me as one of the uninitiated
00:09:13 that the profiles of the case you've just described
00:09:17 What we have here before us now are very similar.
00:09:21 That should be persuasive.
00:09:22 But why would any Canadian court look to the British court system for guidance?
00:09:33 Well, Canadian courts routinely look at foreign court rulings
00:09:37 if there is no Canadian precedent on it, right?
00:09:41 So it could be any issue.
00:09:44 it could be, you know, contracts or torts or criminal law or something unusual or human
00:09:49 rights or whatever, if there's an issue before Canadian courts where there's no Canadian
00:09:53 precedent, because we've never had a case like that, the courts will look to, particularly
00:10:01 the United Kingdom and the United States would be, you know, because of historical friendship
00:10:07 and commonality and historical traditions, those decisions are persuasive, but they're not binding.
00:10:15 So the United Kingdom Supreme Court ruling, it's very well reasoned.
00:10:23 The court's not required to accept it.
00:10:24 I find it very persuasive.
00:10:26 And I was sympathetic to Boris Johnson's position on a no-deal Brexit.
00:10:31 I actually agreed with him.
00:10:33 But the court said it's not about Brexit.
00:10:35 it. It's about not abusing Parliament as a means of avoiding the government, avoiding scrutiny.
00:10:43 I see. So let's, so we have a Prime Minister in Canada who clearly has come to the end of his
00:10:53 rope. He has three options, one of which is to prorogue. He could have gone straight to an
00:10:59 election, which is what I think 98.5% of the country would have recommended if they could
00:11:05 have communicated that to him. He could have gone to an election. He could have also put
00:11:10 Parliament in recess, but then he would still be under some level of scrutiny from the opposition.
00:11:18 But by proroguing, he has just concluded the order of business. He's got 11 weeks,
00:11:24 during which, what, he governs without scrutiny? Yes. There's no, not only is there no question
00:11:30 period, because during an adjournment or a recess there's no question period.
00:11:35 But the committees are not functioning, so the committees are not in a position to ask
00:11:39 questions of ministers that ministers have to answer.
00:11:44 Parliament is just shut down completely, the way it is when it's dissolved.
00:11:48 But for 11 weeks, this is just a gift to the Liberal Party of Canada, which obviously if
00:11:54 you're a Liberal supporter you'd be happy with it, but that's not the purpose of prorogation.
00:11:59 don't do that for the benefit of one political party. Prime Minister Trudeau has described the
00:12:05 Liberal Party as an institution of Canadian politics, and he's probably correct, it's been
00:12:10 around for so long, and it's certainly some institution, but constitutionally, neither the
00:12:17 Liberal Party nor any other party has any status whatsoever. Constitutionally, you're looking at
00:12:21 the MPs in the House Commons, we could have 338 independents in the House Commons, there's no
00:12:28 special role that is recognized for political parties under Canada's constitution. So they do
00:12:37 exist. But, you know, the fact that this might be unhappy for the Liberal Party to suddenly have an
00:12:46 election forced on it through a non-confidence vote, and they don't have a leader, from a
00:12:51 constitutional standpoint, that's irrelevant. So you say a gift to the Liberal Party is the gift
00:12:58 that it has a period of time
00:13:00 to select a new leader
00:13:01 or is it actually a gift
00:13:03 to the leader
00:13:04 who is about to leave us
00:13:06 that for the next period of time
00:13:08 he can govern
00:13:10 with really nobody
00:13:12 to put the brakes on him?
00:13:15 That too, yeah.
00:13:16 Well, I think that worries me
00:13:17 more than the other
00:13:18 to be quite honest.
00:13:20 What are the limits
00:13:20 on his abilities
00:13:23 during a prorogation period?
00:13:25 well there isn't the scrutiny or the accountability so for example we've got the
00:13:33 president-elect trump is uh seems to be quite serious about these 25 tariffs so the prime
00:13:41 minister and the cabinet will handle that as they deem best but with parliament prorogued
00:13:49 they don't really have to answer to anybody they don't have to answer questions about it
00:13:53 it, neither through question period or otherwise. So, you know, will they govern differently
00:14:01 than what they would have if Parliament was still in session? I mean, we don't, it's
00:14:05 hypothetical, you know, we're not seeing that. But yeah, for the...
00:14:09 Well, it's only been a week, give them time.
00:14:12 Well, 11 weeks is a very long time. I mean, in the UK, Boris Johnson wanted to pirogue
00:14:16 for five weeks, and the court stepped in and said that that was way too long.
00:14:20 No, it does seem to be power without accountability,
00:14:25 and I'm just not sure what power the government has to spend money
00:14:31 to make a binding arrangement on tariffs.
00:14:37 I'm not asking you to speculate on this particularly,
00:14:41 but can they unilaterally, in a period of prorogation,
00:14:46 put an export tax on Alberta oil
00:14:51 but not on somebody else's oil.
00:14:54 This is unknown territory
00:14:56 and I think there will be books written about this in the future.
00:15:01 Tell us about the federal court.
00:15:03 Many people don't get the difference
00:15:05 between the federal court and the Supreme Court.
00:15:07 Why did it go there
00:15:09 and what process do you expect out of this?
00:15:13 So the federal court is a lower court
00:15:15 similar to say in Alberta, we've got the Alberta Court of King's Bench, and then the Alberta Court
00:15:23 of Appeal, and then the Supreme Court of Canada. Or in British Columbia, it's the BC Supreme Court,
00:15:28 BC Court of Appeal, and then the Supreme Court of Canada. You have a federal court trial division,
00:15:33 federal court of appeal, and then the Supreme Court of Canada. So the federal court is analogous
00:15:38 to what's in place in each province and it was created for the purpose of uh dealing especially
00:15:45 with federal issues so if you sue the federal government over something uh you may want to do
00:15:52 it in federal court because that's their specialty uh although you can sue the federal government in
00:15:57 the alberta court of king's bench as well so it's it's a it's two levels trial and appeal and so we
00:16:04 filed in the uh trial court and um we are going to see to what extent uh the government's going
00:16:13 to use delay tactics uh right now at this moment we're we're waiting to hear their position on
00:16:20 whether or not this application should be expedited so that already tells you a little
00:16:24 bit about where they're coming from well yes i i'm sure that um canadians generally other than
00:16:32 those who are irredeemably committed to the liberal cause would probably say yeah this
00:16:37 sounds fairly urgent we've got the americans that we need to deal with we got our own issues to deal
00:16:43 with um why why wait so uh is there a reason why you went first to the federal court and not
00:16:52 directly to the supreme court of canada we have to go to the lower courts first do you okay yeah
00:16:58 Yeah, the Supreme Court typically will not hear, say, well, we're a court of appeal fundamentally.
00:17:06 But it is possible in theory, whether this happens, we'll have to wait and see.
00:17:10 But in the United Kingdom, court cases also take errors like they do in Canada.
00:17:16 But the court got this through from the initial, there was an application filed in Scotland, another one in Wales.
00:17:24 There were two different outcomes.
00:17:26 It moved up the system very quickly.
00:17:27 So from the time of filing of the first court action against Prime Minister Johnson's prorogation of Parliament, up until when the United Kingdom Supreme Court issued a ruling was about four weeks in total.
00:17:41 And there's no reason why we can't have that in Canada as well and get an early ruling from the trial court and whichever side is lost could appeal it, get an expedited appeal.
00:17:55 And again, in principle, there's no reason why we can't get a Supreme Court of Canada ruling in four weeks.
00:18:02 So then the obvious question is, let's say that we had a timely, without putting a limit on it,
00:18:08 let's say we had a timely decision on this, and the decision was against the government.
00:18:14 What happens? Does everybody just, all the MPs come back and take their seats?
00:18:17 They come back the following day, take their seats, and if they so wish, they can have a motion of non-confidence and vote on it and force an election the same day that the MPs get back.
00:18:30 Because the court will say, if it rules in our favor, or favor our side, the court will say,
00:18:38 prorogation was illegal, therefore it's null and void, therefore we deem it to have never happened,
00:18:43 therefore Parliament is still in session, therefore Parliament can meet tomorrow,
00:18:47 Therefore, we can have a non-confidence vote tomorrow.
00:18:51 Now, one last thing, John, before we run out of time,
00:18:55 I'm going to give you a bit of a chance to do a commercial
00:18:59 for the Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms here
00:19:02 because what intrigues me about this case
00:19:04 is that the people named as the litigants in this case,
00:19:08 I've never heard of them.
00:19:10 I mean, maybe they're prominent where they live,
00:19:11 but they are not figures whose names you're going to find
00:19:15 in the press, radio, and television every day.
00:19:18 They seem to be ordinary citizens who just have a concern.
00:19:23 And they've looked around and said,
00:19:26 how do I address this concern?
00:19:28 What do I do?
00:19:29 How can I make these people pay attention?
00:19:33 Is it the case that any citizen can do that?
00:19:37 And how do they fund it?
00:19:40 What goes on here?
00:19:41 Well, any citizen of Canada can challenge any law of Canada as being unconstitutional.
00:19:49 In this particular case, we are challenging the advice that the Prime Minister gave to the Governor General,
00:19:57 saying the advice was incorrect, was illegal.
00:20:03 Um, and so, but if there's a law that violates, you know, your freedom of expression or religion
00:20:11 or association or whatever, any citizen can go into court. Now, in practice, it's very hard
00:20:17 because if you don't know what you're doing, uh, you know, it's pretty hard to, to, to do a court
00:20:22 action. If you need to hire a lawyer, you're going to be needing to look at 50,000 or 250,000
00:20:29 over time and so the justice center has has a team of lawyers and they're full-time practicing
00:20:37 constitutional law and so um in this case they're two citizens in nova scotia not very famous one
00:20:46 of them's medical doctor the other one i forgot what line of work he's in but just ordinary
00:20:50 canadians and we could have had one from alberta and one from quebec or whatever so we have the
00:20:55 two Canadians who live in Nova Scotia. They're the clients. And then our lawyer, James Manson,
00:21:01 who's based in Toronto, he filed the papers. They've consented to be named as the applicants.
00:21:07 They don't have to pay money for that. They're not paying money for this. And James Manson is
00:21:13 bringing the court application into court. So they're not paying for it. The Justice Center
00:21:19 doesn't print its own money,
00:21:22 so I'm assuming that this actually rests on the willingness
00:21:25 of other very ordinary citizens
00:21:28 to contribute money to pay for these kinds of cases.
00:21:32 I can't imagine that this is funded by
00:21:34 a division of the federal government.
00:21:37 Well, you know, there is a thing called the Court Challenges Program.
00:21:41 You don't qualify, do you?
00:21:44 You know, if we did, I'm not sure if we would want the money,
00:21:47 But, yeah, there's about 10,000 Canadians from BC to Newfoundland, and they donate, you know, some people give us $100 a year or $1,000 a year.
00:21:56 Some people are able to give more, other people less.
00:22:00 And so you've got 10,000 people that are donating to the Justice Centre.
00:22:05 And then from that money, we pay our team of staff lawyers and paralegals and communication staff.
00:22:12 And then when there's a case like this, you know, the applicants, they don't need to have their own $50,000.
00:22:20 We could just move ahead and hold the government to account.
00:22:25 So actually, the system does work if people want it to work.
00:22:30 It could work better, but fundamentally, yes, the system does work.
00:22:34 It is possible to do governments in court, and it's even possible to win.
00:22:40 We've had some setbacks with the lockdowns in recent years,
00:22:45 but we've had our share of victories as well.
00:22:47 You can't win them all.
00:22:49 Well, how true that is, John, but it's encouraging to know.
00:22:53 There was one case that I think got a lot of traction.
00:22:57 It was a chap who wanted, he dressed as a woman and wanted... 0.97
00:23:02 The Brazilian bikini wax.
00:23:04 That was one of your cases, right?
00:23:06 It was.
00:23:07 Okay.
00:23:07 Nobody else is willing to help these visible minority immigrant women who are doing Brazilian bikini waxes out of their home for women. 1.00
00:23:18 And then they get human rights complaints filed against them by somebody who's got the twig and berries. 0.78
00:23:27 And, you know, they couldn't get legal help.
00:23:30 Is that a legal phrase?
00:23:31 Twig and berries.
00:23:32 I guess it is now.
00:23:33 yes we're getting a little far from prorogation i guess but it's perhaps my my fault for leading
00:23:38 you down a blind alley so to sum this one up john we've got a we've got a couple of citizens
00:23:44 who feel strongly funded by 10 000 other citizens who feel strongly who have actually come together
00:23:53 to use your organization the justice center for constitutional freedoms to challenge something
00:24:00 that is of national importance to 40 million canadians that's it you've summed it up well
00:24:05 wow i i wonder how many people actually know that these things are even win or lose that
00:24:11 is even possible to try um if that's a subject for another day but you know i do recognize the
00:24:19 and i think i should for western standard viewers just remind them that your organization was front
00:24:25 and center in in challenging many of the worst aspects of the covert regulations that came down
00:24:31 2021 well 2020 actually and uh that you've also been very forthright in looking after the little
00:24:42 things as well as the big things so john i'm sorry to drag you away from your desk i i pray
00:24:48 that we do not lose a court case because you are here talking to me but uh thank you very much for
00:24:54 coming in yeah it's my it's been great to have you it's my pleasure and the court case is handled
00:24:59 very ably by a toronto-based lawyer james manson so you know this this interview the short interview
00:25:07 is not going to do any damage i assure you thank you john thank you ladies and gentlemen
00:25:13 For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.
00:25:16 Good night.