Western Standard - May 17, 2026


HANNAFORD: Once, we did immigration right – and we can do it right again

Topics
Mentioned
CORY MORGAN SHOW: Alberta’s humiliating negotiations with Carney have gone on long enough Western Standard News Update | Brian Jean: new carbon tax deal “hits the sweet spot” | 18 May 2026

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

134.44

Word count

3,161

Sentence count

102

Harmful content

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

John Weisenberger served as the Chief of Staff to former Prime Minister Stephen Harper's immigration minister, Diane Finley. He's been around the block and has some ideas on what went wrong with Canada's immigration system and how to fix it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show
00:00:21 of the Western Standard. It is May the 14th. Welcome to the show.
00:00:30 If you say there's something wrong with Canada's immigration system or its policies,
00:00:35 there will probably be somebody nearby ready to call you a racist. Well, the fact is,
00:00:43 whether you're for immigration or against it altogether, we are not as a country doing a
00:00:49 very good job of it. With me today is somebody who understands the big picture. That's John
00:00:57 Weisenberger. He was Chief of Staff to a Harper-era Minister of Immigration, Diane Finley. He has some
00:01:09 ideas on what went wrong and how to fix it because he's been there and done that. John, welcome to the
00:01:16 program. Thank you, Nigel. Pleasure to be here. Good to have you. John, once Canada selected
00:01:23 immigrants primarily on their ability to contribute financially to the success of
00:01:29 the country and upon their ability to fit in, to be culturally appropriate, if you want to
00:01:36 call it that. In fact, in a recent article of yours, you referred to a US observer who said
00:01:44 that Canada was ruthlessly smart. Can you enlarge on that a little bit and how that contrasts with
00:01:52 the last 10 years when quite clearly the Trudeau government replaced objective points-based merit
00:02:02 with some other set of considerations? Right, so the system you're referring to,
00:02:09 kind of known colloquially as the point system was brought in in the 1960s and it was meant
00:02:17 to be kind of an objective way of selecting through the the hundreds of thousands of people
00:02:27 who have applied and wanted to come to Canada so again as you mentioned that was done using a set
00:02:34 criteria that again would select for quote-unquote better suited candidates
00:02:45 or applicants. So we had criteria like level of education, language proficiency
00:02:51 that would be in French and or English, skills in terms of you know what
00:03:00 particular occupation they had and how that would match with Canada's economic needs.
00:03:05 Now, what the viewers should know is that that only applied to about 50% of the immigrant
00:03:15 stream coming in.
00:03:17 So that was called the economic stream.
00:03:18 Then you had family reunification.
00:03:21 So people applying for relatives to come over, people who are already here, and then a smaller
00:03:27 refugee stream.
00:03:27 But still, the economic stream would be the most significant and the most impactful in terms of the Canadian economy.
00:03:35 Well, I can certainly speak to that.
00:03:38 When I applied to come to Canada myself, I told them who I was and my professional attributes.
00:03:44 They weren't that interested.
00:03:45 And then I said, I put me down as a farm laborer.
00:03:47 They said, oh, okay, you're in.
00:03:49 Because they wanted farm laborers, you see.
00:03:51 It's so much for this business to be the best and precious business.
00:03:53 Yes.
00:03:53 and so i ended up on my uncle's run spent the first summer as a cowboy my horse knew more
00:03:59 about it than i did but right it was not a bad way to enter canada i think that really has been the
00:04:06 um has that not been the experience for so many people that they they come here and they do what
00:04:10 they got to do to get started well it's interesting you say that because i i mentioned in the article
00:04:16 uh i lead off with actually the story of my father who had a similar experience
00:04:20 after the war when he applied the first time he marked down teacher
00:04:25 because he had been trained as a teacher prior to the war.
00:04:28 But he was rejected because Canada didn't need teachers.
00:04:32 And then the second time around, he asked people,
00:04:34 and they said, well, you know, put down laborer
00:04:36 because Canada needs laborers,
00:04:39 which apparently was the case with you as well.
00:04:43 Oh, no, Calvary is still trade.
00:04:43 Right?
00:04:44 And when he put down laborer, he got in.
00:04:47 Okay.
00:04:48 Well, yeah, so the system sort of worked.
00:04:50 But look, it's not working now.
00:04:53 I mean, in your article, this article, I think you published this in C2C,
00:04:57 but you're putting these thoughts out elsewhere,
00:05:01 and I think you're going to be running something here in the Western Standard on this as well.
00:05:04 So you know that the Trudeau government, there was a real change there.
00:05:10 You were with the Harper government, and you did things a certain way.
00:05:15 What was it that the Trudeau government actually changed?
00:05:18 how quickly did they set about it took them about a year well tackle the first thing first
00:05:25 took them about a year and as far as i know they didn't completely abandon the point system so they
00:05:32 may have loosened the criteria somewhat and there's evidence they did that specifically
00:05:38 in terms of the french-speaking candidates so they loosened that but then they overall expanded
00:05:46 the category dramatically from a level of about 250 000 coming in every year to between 400 and
00:05:54 500 000 so they almost doubled it so that was really the issue and it wasn't only in that stream
00:06:02 one area that again that's mentioned in the article and that's been in countless news stories now
00:06:09 is the explosion in the number of temporary permit holders so that would be both temporary foreign
00:06:15 workers foreign students etc and the huge influx of asylum seekers for which we have control it's
00:06:23 just never shows up at our border so all of those numbers just interrupt you there when somebody
00:06:29 says hey take me i'm being persecuted at home do we actually check up on that i mean a lot of these
00:06:35 people apparently are not asylum seekers at all they just want a better job right and and we clamp
00:06:42 down on that significantly under the harper government for instance we had a situation 0.89
00:06:48 we had no visa requirements with mexico so we had a lot of mexican citizens in fact entire mexican
00:06:56 families coming here claiming asylum status um even though clearly by their appearance they were
00:07:02 not um asylum or valid asylum seekers what our our our policy was what we tried to do because of
00:07:12 of course, there are hundreds of thousands of legitimate refugees living in camps all over the
00:07:16 world, is we tried to work with the UN to focus on bringing the most needy people in and not just
00:07:24 whomever, whoever happened to come to the Canadian border. So you know that the Trudeau government
00:07:33 fast-tracked low-skill workers and students while bypassing point rankings. Was this primarily
00:07:41 ideological or was there a deliberate political calculus about future voters
00:07:47 well i think it was mismanagement primarily uh plus their philosophical view if there is one
00:07:58 um i believe is that that more is better so uh better for whom and in what way just
00:08:07 well it's hard hard to get in the heads of these people but I mentioned in the
00:08:17 article that one of my staffers had a conversation with a UN official ironically
00:08:25 an Israeli fellow and he basically told her that Canada in his opinion had an
00:08:32 unlimited capacity to take migrants. So that's the view of a certain type of
00:08:39 person. It's quite concerning in my in my opinion that it would be someone with
00:08:44 the UN since we were you know working with the UN trying to work with them. But
00:08:50 I think that's quite prevalent on the on the left side of the aisle is that we
00:08:55 should take as many people as we absolutely can take and economic
00:09:00 consequences are secondary well that certainly appears to be what happened yes and so uh there
00:09:07 it is um still this explosion to 3.2 million uh this is your number i presume you got it from
00:09:16 statscan or generation but non-permanent residents is central to your critique like in this poll
00:09:23 argument you say well they took all these people uh non-permanent residents well i suppose the
00:09:29 theory is they have their own permits who use their visa they go home except that's not being
00:09:35 tracked so that's that's been the other scandalous uh a piece of information that's come out in the
00:09:42 last few weeks i think there was a parliamentary hearing on it just recently where the minister
00:09:50 admitted that there were at least 500 000 of those that they essentially didn't know where they were
00:09:58 if they had stayed if they had gone back etc and that they didn't have the capacity to even
00:10:05 investigate that so this sounds like an argument for digital id it's a huge it's a huge scandal
00:10:11 well it's really well how many would be the right number 3.2 million who you can't track is too many
00:10:19 how many that you can track would be about right and sort of keep the mcdonald's open well i mean
00:10:25 I think we need to go back to the numbers we had more than a decade ago. As I mentioned,
00:10:32 we had about 250,000 in the regular immigration stream. Because we were
00:10:40 doing much better and more stringent oversight in the asylum area, we had only about 16,000
00:10:48 claimants in 2015 whereas that number has gone up almost well almost I'd say
00:10:58 five fold six fold and then on the temporary side the numbers I don't have
00:11:07 have them at my fingertips but the numbers were quite a bit lower and there
00:11:12 were things like market need assessments that were done that would kind of keep a
00:11:18 lid on those numbers the other thing of course they did is they the the Trudeau government that
00:11:23 is is they failed to put a cap on foreign students so universities of course charge foreign students
00:11:32 significantly more for tuition so they had an incentive to bring in as many as they possibly
00:11:39 could and we've seen several again scandals emerge how that system was exploited the most recent one
00:11:46 think was in conestoga college in ontario so these things definitely had serious negative consequences
00:11:54 so you you talk also about court rulings uh expanding citizenship claims and we're all
00:12:03 familiar with there's a story every week now about so and so you know did a horrible and
00:12:10 atrocious thing that should have sent him to jail for a long time but they try to keep him for less
00:12:16 get a sentence of less than two years in case it interrupts his immigration process and we're all
00:12:22 saying well why would we want this guy you know right this is what they do and they're doing it
00:12:26 consistently so do you see the charter or the uh the post 1982 judicial activism that the
00:12:37 thought that the charter made possible coming like why would judges have an angle on this
00:12:42 Well, they seem to have an angle on just about everything now. But here I think it's
00:12:50 more the philosophical underpinnings that we touched on a minute ago. You know, I believe
00:13:01 it was Prime Minister Trudeau Jr. who said, you know, a Canadian is a Canadian is a Canadian,
00:13:07 up to and including known terrorists.
00:13:12 And the current immigration minister has also defended
00:13:15 the right of known terrorists to remain in Canada.
00:13:19 So again, that gives you an impression of their view
00:13:23 that anyone who can come here, anyone can be a Canadian.
00:13:28 And that extends, I think, to that judicial ruling
00:13:32 that you allude to, where I believe it was an Ontario judge
00:13:36 struck down part of our legislation that was legislation that I and my team worked on
00:13:44 that would have restricted Canadian citizenship to the first generation of people born of Canadian
00:13:56 citizens abroad. Whereas now that's extended through multiple generations. So you can literally
00:14:03 have uh someone who had canadian parents uh born in paraguay and they have children and they just
00:14:12 continue to be canadian even though they have no attachment to canada and they've never been to
00:14:18 canada well who if they've never been to canada are never coming to canada presumably they're
00:14:24 not voting in canadian elections or maybe they can um there's a potential racket here
00:14:34 Well, I mean, there is the discussion of that happening in the United States.
00:14:39 I think that would be a whole, because of the birthright citizenship controversy, right?
00:14:45 So, yeah, that's something I didn't explore in the article, but it probably is something to be concerned about.
00:14:52 Yeah.
00:14:53 So, you pointed out, you quoted a subject expert, Garrett Jones,
00:15:01 and they made the argument that values the things we just automatically you know trust
00:15:09 frugality rule of law or the complete opposites right uh persist across generations yes and this
00:15:16 bears on that that uh what we're talking about at the start we were talking about
00:15:21 will people fit in right you know that was one of the things do they have skills will they fit in
00:15:26 And that's the 1967 points model.
00:15:28 All right.
00:15:29 We talked about people fitting in, but what exactly do we do with this?
00:15:37 How explicitly can the reformed points system that you're recommending incorporate cultural compatibility?
00:15:46 No, that's a very important question.
00:15:49 And interestingly, as you suggest, the point system has a rather objective way of finding potentially the most compatible people.
00:16:03 Because first of all, if you select on economic need, on skills, you will have people that can come and work immediately and are placed into a workplace where they'll be fitting in.
00:16:16 there's the English language or the language requirement and there's
00:16:21 education. I think what many of the studies including Professor Jones's
00:16:27 study show is that in the low skilled area if you have very large numbers of
00:16:32 people they have really have a hard time succeeding economically and and then
00:16:42 kind of integrating into the broader society and that tends to perpetuate
00:16:47 inter so the economic component tends to perpetuate on the value side I think
00:16:56 that's something we understand intuitively you know you look at just
00:17:02 say you know I'm from Montreal originally so the Italian community in
00:17:05 Montreal huge followers of Italian football soccer right through to the
00:17:11 second and third generation. So that's something that persists. And of course, you know, there are
00:17:16 other community attributes that persist over time, right? That's just natural. But, you know,
00:17:27 besides some of those positive attributes, there may be, let's say, more challenging attributes.
00:17:31 um say if uh if um a culture or a country um has less trust in government you touched on that as
00:17:41 well um has different views of i don't know the banking system or savings etc um i think it's
00:17:50 logical to assume that some of those values will persist uh and will um you know take a while to
00:17:58 sort out okay we don't have unlimited time john unfortunately um what there's two questions that
00:18:05 i do want to address so i want to talk about alberta alberta's planned referendum on immigration
00:18:10 numbers and benefits access is a key flashpoint here as we have the for the whole independence
00:18:16 debate how far based on your federal experience how far should provinces be allowed to go
00:18:22 in setting their own immigration parameters and what constitutional barriers do you see?
00:18:31 Well, right now, Quebec already has those powers.
00:18:36 So I think it's reasonable for Alberta to seek more control.
00:18:44 Now, the other dimension of this, which is interesting, it's not really discussed,
00:18:50 is that once you're in Canada, you can move where you want.
00:18:56 So the province, I mean, Quebec, again,
00:19:00 they will try to select on language capabilities or abilities.
00:19:08 So, and there, there's more likelihood
00:19:10 that a Francophone immigrant will stay in Quebec.
00:19:13 But in terms of Alberta, you know, we can drop down our numbers,
00:19:17 But given the fact that we have a vibrant economy, it's more than likely that someone who lands in Toronto or New Brunswick will eventually say, OK, the grass is greener in Alberta and I'll move to Alberta.
00:19:32 And we have no control over that.
00:19:33 And half of Newfoundland did that one.
00:19:35 Yes.
00:19:36 Yes, exactly.
00:19:37 All right.
00:19:37 Well, look, last question, John.
00:19:39 This is great.
00:19:40 Now, I'm going to read this because I want to get it right.
00:19:43 I mean, you acknowledge in your writings that Canada's sub-replacement birth rate, you know, we're not having enough children, and the necessity of immigration, if a future government restored a rigorous point system, but still faced the same global migration pressures, and above all, the low domestic fertility rate, what is the realistic right number of annual immigrants?
00:20:10 and how would your cell sustain selection to a public tired of both open borders
00:20:17 and also of the inevitable accusations of xenophobia and racism what's the marketing
00:20:24 pitch well that's kind of the punchline of the article because demography is something that i
00:20:30 think a lot of people haven't wrapped their heads around um and at least superficially it looks like
00:20:39 there are competing camps within Canada.
00:20:42 So Quebec appears to have decided to put the brakes on immigration
00:20:48 in order to allow for, what phrase would you use,
00:20:53 cultural continuity, preservation.
00:20:56 Whereas several groups, including the Conference Board of Canada,
00:21:01 argue for much greater immigration,
00:21:04 although interestingly, mainly to support our social programs.
00:21:09 So, when it comes down to it, at least on the economic argument, it's, okay, are we willing to adjust our social program?
00:21:21 Say you're in favor of lower numbers of newcomers. 0.90
00:21:27 Are you willing to adjust what types of benefits you get in terms of social support?
00:21:35 If you are, then you can bring the numbers down.
00:21:38 But because of, you know, that kind of pyramid scheme aspect of the system, you need to keep having, and the Conference Board of Canada report is very explicit in this.
00:21:50 They say, okay, you need a certain ratio of people in the labor force versus, you know, people, shall we say, more our demographic or approaching demographic who are not being, who are being supported.
00:22:04 you know it's never occurred to me until this very moment john that the same people who we are now
00:22:10 talking about her basically abused the immigration system for political purposes are also the ones
00:22:16 that created the necessity for this supply of new uh feeders into the ponzi scheme in the first
00:22:23 place decades ago by by making canada into a welfare state wow yeah where's john burke when
00:22:30 you need him yes that's right i'm sorry yes yes uh listen it's been great john very nice to have
00:22:36 you in here and show you around the john galt studio and the gang here in the western standard
00:22:41 who put out this great product we hope to have some words from you soon on the a little more
00:22:46 detail on what we've been talking about in the last half hour thank you so much for coming in
00:22:50 thank you it's been a pleasure for the western standard i'm nigel hannaford
00:23:00 Thank you.