Western Standard - November 19, 2024


HANNAFORD: The terrible cost of transitioning comes later

Mentioned
Minister LaGrange Updates on Efforts to Refocus Alberta’s Health Care System Poilievre and Trudeau finally agree on something — the need for carbon tax election

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

147.86

Word count

3,768

Sentence count

143

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

13

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, I interview two women who transitioned to present themselves as males, regretted it, and have transitioned back again. The experience has been difficult, painful, and a profound well of regret for both of them, and they are not back where they started. However, it is not now all as if it had never happened.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good evening western standard viewers and welcome to hanaford a weekly politics show
00:00:22 my guests this week are faith growlow and kelly lynn
00:00:27 Piri. And before I go any further, I should warn viewers that some of this may be hard to watch.
00:00:36 Faith and Kelly Lynn are women who transitioned to present themselves as males, regretted it, 0.79
00:00:44 and have transitioned back again. The experience has been difficult, painful,
00:00:51 and a profound well of regret for both of them and they are not back where they started
00:00:59 that is it is not now all as if it had never happened for the benefit of others however
00:01:07 they join me today to tell their stories faith kelly lynn welcome to the show thank you
00:01:15 can i start with you uh just tell us please what happened so i was gender questioning by about 15
00:01:24 years old i had found a show called i am jazz and so science was telling me that this little boy
00:01:29 could be a little girl and i believed that the doctors wouldn't do it if it wasn't okay
00:01:34 so i was justified in my thinking that going against my religious family was okay that their
00:01:41 concerns were just because they were old fuddy duddies and they didn't know what they were
00:01:44 talking about so by 16 i was seeing doctors and i was given puberty blockers by 17 and 18 i had
00:01:52 been approved for top surgery and i was given testosterone which is the cross-sex or wrong sex 0.89
00:01:58 hormone for me and by 18 i had aged out of the clinic because it was specifically for youth so
00:02:05 the doctors who diagnosed me and prescribed my medications did not follow up with me i was deemed
00:02:10 a successful transition to them. However by 2020 because of COVID the testosterone I was getting
00:02:17 they ran out of the vials so I had to get a more expensive medication that I couldn't afford. So I
00:02:23 was changing medications without much supervision and then it was changing the dosage as well
00:02:29 without much supervision. By 22 years old I realized I didn't need to rush and I really
00:02:36 wasn't using it consistently so I stopped all medications and I around 23 24 found some
00:02:46 information that basically solidified the idea to me that my doctors didn't really know what they
00:02:50 were doing essentially allowed me to diagnose myself incorrectly and just affirmed that rather
00:02:57 than actually questioning any of it and so I began to detransition April of this year actually
00:03:03 and started to come back out as my natural self.
00:03:08 What does it mean to detransition?
00:03:10 Stopping all medications and no longer further pursuing any surgical or chemical changes.
00:03:17 I believe you told me earlier that you had not had any kind of surgery.
00:03:23 Correct.
00:03:23 Okay. Kelly Lynn, can I ask you then, please, what's your story?
00:03:29 I grew up, I'm an adult who lives with a history of childhood sexual exploitation.
00:03:34 In that house, there was a lot of abuse, drugs, and alcohol.
00:03:38 When my mother left her pedophile husband, he went to jail for sexually interfering with me. 0.87
00:03:48 Then she got back together with my biological dad. 0.92
00:03:50 He also was an alcoholic.
00:03:52 my 20s my 30s were cycles of drugs alcohol sobriety relapse and just circling in that
00:04:01 in my early 30s in 2002 I got cleaner sober and uh in that process I the degree of social anxiety
00:04:13 um the discomfort I was living in women's support recovery and it felt like the emotions of the
00:04:20 people around me were just happening to me. And I met some individuals who were transitioning
00:04:26 themselves. And I was asking them about it. And they're like, oh, people who question,
00:04:35 like, you're wondering if you really are a woman. And the only people who are trans
00:04:41 question that. And then when I spoke with it, my drug and alcohol counselor about that,
00:04:46 She was in what's called the affirmation model, so she affirmed that, of course, a man living in a sport recovery house would be incredibly uncomfortable.
00:04:55 It wasn't about my, like I look back now and I realize that I wasn't able to regulate my emotions around so many other people, so I was constantly trying to control the other women. 0.99
00:05:06 And so just affirming my discomfort with my sex as it being about the envy I had for men was this feeling of being a male.
00:05:19 Okay.
00:05:21 I think a lot of women do see advantages in being male. 1.00
00:05:28 You have obviously both looked at it from a male point of view as well as a female view.
00:05:35 how would you answer them if they said to you oh so i want to be a man because and then cited off
00:05:42 all these advantages that they perceive i'll start again with you um i would first ask if
00:05:49 they know all of the risks truly of what they might be doing to themselves which unfortunately
00:05:55 you can't possibly because we haven't had proper clinical trials so nobody really knows long term
00:06:01 And what happens to kids who are on these drugs and any information we have is not great.
00:06:08 And how would you answer them, Kayleigh?
00:06:13 What motivates men to do the things they do, to make the sacrifices they make for their career, is very different than what motivates women. 0.55
00:06:22 I learned that during my years as a long-haul trucker.
00:06:25 I was in a specialized industry where 90% of my colleagues were men.
00:06:29 and so you were a truck driver as a woman no when i looked like a man when i had six inch beard
00:06:35 all of my co-workers thought i was a man um i really learned that men and women think very
00:06:43 differently about stuff i'd worked there for about five years and one of my colleagues commented
00:06:47 that you realize my legal name then was kenneth so he's like you realize ken that we are all very
00:06:54 afraid of you and I'm like why I'm like so calm so easygoing he's like exactly no one has even
00:07:00 seen you mildly upset so they were convinced that if they ever upset me I would just explode because
00:07:09 I've never been in the hierarchy and figuring out where guys get mildly upset and aggressive
00:07:14 towards each other and they figure out where they are in the QE and of my 45 co-workers nobody knew
00:07:20 where I was in the QA. So it was a moment of going, men think about things very differently
00:07:26 than women do. Even looking like a man, even being on testosterone, I didn't understand 1.00
00:07:31 their world and their worldview. I don't want to make light of this in any way, but who knew?
00:07:39 This is such an important decision that especially a young person would make,
00:07:47 that you've told us that the doctors didn't give you very good advice.
00:07:53 You've said that your parents were, you described them as old-fashioned
00:07:58 fuddy-duddies who went to church. 0.97
00:08:00 I can imagine what their advice to you would have been.
00:08:06 And then you mentioned a program that you had seen, a jazz or something.
00:08:11 I am jazz.
00:08:12 I am jazz.
00:08:13 What is that?
00:08:15 So Jazz Jennings is an individual who was transitioned when they were younger.
00:08:19 Born a boy, about two years old.
00:08:22 Mom saw a little boy dressing in dresses, playing dress-up with his sisters,
00:08:27 and said, oh dear, he must be a girl.
00:08:32 And ended up taking him to doctors who transitioned him at a very, very young age,
00:08:36 started to do ray blockers, gave the cross-sex hormones, eventually had surgeries.
00:08:40 This was all televised on TLC.
00:08:43 all of it all of the surgeries a 17 year old little kid so it that made it seem very very
00:08:53 normal and commonplace not only that doctors were doing this surgery but it was being televised like
00:08:58 it was nothing you know and jazz seems extremely happy in these videos for the most part because
00:09:04 that's how it's supposed to be portrayed where is he now um off yeah yeah there's been some
00:09:14 emotional issues um even in the shows nearing the end of it it was seeming like this poor kid didn't
00:09:21 know who they were and didn't feel like themselves and mom just kept saying oh no it's okay you're
00:09:27 exactly who we say you are don't worry about it it's okay like it there was no attempt at dealing
00:09:32 with the emotional distress it was just continue affirming whatever's been done
00:09:39 and that's just you know you can only do that for so long so he's a physiologically mature
00:09:46 20 early 20s right i think he's 19 20 yeah i believe he's younger than i am unable of experiencing
00:09:53 arousal like neurologically incapable from the drugs and the surgery so cannot mate bond with
00:10:04 another human being well that would seem to be first of all i think the scope and scale of this
00:10:11 is that around about the five-year period from 2018 to 2023 according to the government of
00:10:19 Canada, there were 600 young women under the age of 18 who had sexual reassignment surgery,
00:10:31 roughly half of which went the whole way.
00:10:39 What is the, how does it, what is available to, I think we do the surgery under the
00:10:48 provincial health programs but if you want to go back do they help you do that no okay so you're
00:10:57 uh what sort of expenses are you involved with to transition back to a woman you were well what's
00:11:05 called breast restoration surgery i cannot access in british columbia without the approval of the
00:11:12 Transcare BC. So my doctor will be, I'm in the stage of getting the paperwork together. My doctor
00:11:20 will send an application into Transcare BC, the people in charge of transitioning, to request
00:11:28 that I be allowed to have access to surgery to restore the appearance of having breasts 0.79
00:11:35 because I had a complete bilateral mastectomy in 2008.
00:11:41 So, okay.
00:11:45 What are the physiological effects when you transition?
00:11:51 What do you experience?
00:11:52 How does your way of life change?
00:11:54 And then how does it change again when you transition back?
00:12:00 You were just on the chemicals.
00:12:03 I'm going to ask you about yours in a moment.
00:12:05 How does it go?
00:12:09 Essentially, for me, I had already started puberty by the time I was 16, so they shouldn't have given me puberty blockers anyway.
00:12:16 And so when they did, it completely interrupted the puberty I had already started going through.
00:12:21 I went through menopause.
00:12:23 I was then given testosterone, which is a known carcinogen, and it forces you to go through a male-like puberty, 0.95
00:12:33 which I got a deeper voice. My facial hair and body hair started growing in darker and thicker.
00:12:41 I gained more muscle mass and it was distributed differently than it would be for a woman,
00:12:48 which made me fit differently in clothes. But the problem is male clothes still didn't fit
00:12:52 properly because I had the bone structure of a woman because I didn't get the puberty blockers
00:12:56 before puberty. So that didn't really help anything. My balance actually went funny,
00:13:05 because if you're on puberty blockers and testosterone, your breasts essentially deflate, 1.00
00:13:09 and I was also using a chest binder, so it made them squish down. So my center of balance
00:13:14 actually got shifted. Puberty blockers, because I did not finish out my puberty properly,
00:13:21 it stunted my physical growth, my emotional and mental growth. It actually keeps you stuck in
00:13:26 a teenage-like state mentally because you don't grow up to be able to make those long-term
00:13:32 decisions because you're suppressing all of the hormones that are supposed to help you do that
00:13:37 with me i actually was fortunate i ended up going off of the blockers a little early
00:13:42 because i was on birth control which did something similar but the doctors still
00:13:46 didn't really know what they were doing just kind of let me do what i wanted and experiment on myself
00:13:51 um and so when i went off of the puberty blockers my my system kind of kick-started again a little
00:13:59 bit uh so then i came out of menopause got to go through it backwards again um and then once i was
00:14:06 off of testosterone uh i ended up trying to finish out puberty i'm still in the midst of doing that
00:14:12 in my 20s and i'm realizing my joints haven't fused properly i may have incontinence issues
00:14:18 because i've gone in and out of menopause now and so my pelvic floor may be weakened i may have
00:14:23 liver problems potentially that's a common side effect now that's the testosterone yes
00:14:30 uh and then there's also the option of the spinal cord doesn't fuse properly all the time
00:14:36 and so there are people who get compression fractures because of that because they're
00:14:39 not getting the proper hormones in there um i may also be infertile but we don't know that until i
00:14:46 actually try to have kids i'm very optimistic that i'm fortunate enough not to be but you know we
00:14:53 don't actually know until i try it but yeah and i'm one of the luckier ones like i i have come
00:15:00 out essentially unscathed in a lot of instances compared to that so you know so the worst case
00:15:05 for those who did not come out unscathed exactly in a few words what um so there were some people
00:15:13 that i was transitioned at the same time as who have now since attempted to detransition or desist
00:15:18 but the government would only cover the actual tissue removal if you didn't have the money to
00:15:24 cover the reconstruction part then you're a girl now with no breasts or nipples um some of them 0.69
00:15:32 also will have hysterectomies some of them will have a phallus made um there is someone in the
00:15:40 States, Scott Nugent, what they go by, born a female, was transitioned as an adult, made these 0.62
00:15:48 decisions as an adult, and through all of the surgeries, ended up with horrendous infections
00:15:52 that almost killed them several times, are now still killing them. The forearm that the
00:15:57 ballast was made out of is now not functional properly, and they get chronic infections in
00:16:04 the arm, and the hand that's attached to that arm, they may have to lose that as well.
00:16:07 And these are decisions that an adult made, and now we're giving those complications to children.
00:16:13 Were you ever suicidal?
00:16:17 Yes, they weaponized that completely.
00:16:20 So were you suicidal because you wanted to be a different gender, or were there other issues?
00:16:30 There were several other issues that were overlooked.
00:16:32 So those issues were not properly diagnosed.
00:16:34 and you were allowed against the wishes of your parents
00:16:39 who would have been the most interested in your welfare.
00:16:43 Did teachers have a role in this at all?
00:16:46 Fortunately not, but I was surrounded by a lot of people
00:16:50 who were very into the affirmation model
00:16:53 and our teachers had the signs of it's a safe space and all inclusion
00:16:57 and there were actually several trans individuals
00:17:00 in the schools that I was around.
00:17:02 So I was exposed to it,
00:17:04 But then there was also a local group of, there was one trans adult and a supportive adult.
00:17:11 They had a youth group, basically, like a support group for gender questioning or trans youth.
00:17:17 And it was specifically for 17 and under.
00:17:19 Is there anybody who could have headed you off from the course of action that you took?
00:17:24 The doctors, absolutely.
00:17:26 The doctors.
00:17:28 Is it that they don't know or that they don't care?
00:17:31 I presume don't care.
00:17:32 don't care to know
00:17:34 I see
00:17:35 Kelly Lynn
00:17:38 you've heard
00:17:39 a story probably not for the first time
00:17:43 and what's your comment on
00:17:44 what she experienced
00:17:46 as you reflect upon your own
00:17:48 well in a similar way as an adult
00:17:51 there's so much information
00:17:53 they didn't give me
00:17:54 like they didn't tell me that
00:17:56 they told me that taking testosterone
00:17:58 I'd have the same health risks as a male 0.99
00:18:00 as any other male actually
00:18:03 Women on testosterone, especially with me, I have obesity. 0.99
00:18:07 I have a highly elevated risk of type 2 diabetes,
00:18:10 which I now have and I'll live with for the rest of my life.
00:18:12 They didn't talk about how our secondary sex...
00:18:17 Let's stop you there. 0.97
00:18:17 Were these doctors in general practice or are these specialists in this field?
00:18:23 Endocrinologists.
00:18:24 So these, they should have known?
00:18:26 Yes.
00:18:27 And should have told you?
00:18:28 Yes.
00:18:28 They would have known and they should have...
00:18:30 Yeah, they should have informed me and discussed with me because I already had.
00:18:34 I asked what are the health risks, and I was specifically going to an endocrinologist
00:18:46 because I already had hypothyroidism, which is considered an autoimmune disease,
00:18:54 and type 2 diabetes is also considered an autoimmune disease.
00:18:57 So the proper course of action when a doctor is prescribing a new medication
00:19:07 or a medication off-label, when they observe something out of the normal,
00:19:12 is to inform the pharmaceutical company that owns the patent.
00:19:17 This is what I'm seeing in my patient population.
00:19:19 It appears that that is not happening as it's intended to happen in this field.
00:19:29 And the WPATH files indicated the degree to which WPATH discourages the endocrinologist it trains from doing this
00:19:41 because they were actually discussing instances of liver cancer in females taking testosterone.
00:19:46 We are almost out of time, which is a dreadful shame, because this is a very, very deep subject.
00:19:56 But I do want to ask you particularly, Faith, what you think of the legislation recently put before the Alberta legislature,
00:20:11 legislature which would restrict children under the age of 18 from receiving the first of all
00:20:22 surgery and I think under the age of 17 from receiving the kind of chemical interventions
00:20:27 that you yourself received. Are we doing a good thing here or are we sentencing frustrated young
00:20:36 people to kill themselves because they can't change sex when they want to. I believe the 1.00
00:20:42 legislations would have helped because the doctors would have been forced to do a proper
00:20:45 cognitive assessment. And if the doctors actually treat the suicidal ideation and the root cause of
00:20:50 that, for one, a lot of these kids may not even be trans in the first place. And the ones who are 0.64
00:20:55 will learn how to live well-rounded lives before they even have to get any chemicals.
00:21:00 So by the time you were 18, you might not have wanted to do this?
00:21:05 No, absolutely.
00:21:07 I wasn't even sure when I went in.
00:21:08 I simply just said to my doctors, hey, I saw this thing online.
00:21:12 I think this might be what it is, but you're the expert, so let me know.
00:21:16 Do the testing and all that and figure it out.
00:21:18 But they didn't test me properly.
00:21:20 You don't just let somebody walk in and say, I have cancer.
00:21:22 Can I have chemo?
00:21:23 You don't give them chemo.
00:21:25 You have to do a test first.
00:21:26 But if you don't properly test them and just hand them out all the time, like the other thing as well, me getting these drugs when I wasn't supposed to have them, people who actually needed them now can't have them.
00:21:38 What kind of a test would have been appropriate for you?
00:21:42 Knowing I had other mental health issues.
00:21:45 Not presuming that me being sexualized when I was young was just happenstance.
00:21:53 Because that seems to be a common theme.
00:21:55 and they just bring it into the diagnostics as well,
00:21:58 saying that just seems to be a theme that's okay, though.
00:22:00 You're still trans. 0.94
00:22:01 And it's like, I wasn't, though.
00:22:03 And if they can make a mistake once, they can make a mistake again,
00:22:06 and that's just unfortunate.
00:22:08 They need to have a better system there.
00:22:11 Last thoughts, Kelly Lou?
00:22:16 Youth need an opportunity to pause and to think.
00:22:22 As an adult, I thought I was informed.
00:22:25 I had no idea how politicized the trans lobby has made research, and I am pleased to support
00:22:38 the policies of Premier Daniel Smith and her government and her stance to end the bullying,
00:22:48 especially in regards to the doctors and the researchers and the state of the research that
00:22:56 there once again be open debate about what's going on in the medical field and for it no
00:23:02 to no longer be politicized look this is i think you two are incredibly brave to
00:23:09 take your stories public and to stand out in the open and tell them knowing that there could very
00:23:16 well be people who are militantly opposed to what you are now message that you are now trying to
00:23:22 put out what is the name of your organization d trans alliance canada and you have many members
00:23:32 no i i've got a mailing list i've had a small group of people reaching out to me
00:23:39 the hardest part of getting something started is
00:23:42 we are told that it would be better death before detransition so it's this
00:23:50 idea that we are shameful for existing I've been told telling my story is a
00:23:55 threat to trans healthcare so there's a real effort to silence our voices there
00:24:03 was a trans advocate at the rally the first weekend in November who is saying
00:24:10 that detransitioners voices shouldn't even be heard on this issue well that's a pretty pretty 1.00
00:24:16 common uh reaction from the left when they hear something that they that they can't answer um
00:24:24 one last question that i know some of our viewers are going to want to know are things with mom and
00:24:29 dad my father actually passed away in about 2021 but i was able to to be very close with him
00:24:36 beforehand and uh my mom and i are getting significantly closer and she's uh very happy
00:24:42 that i've come back no doubt yes okay kelly lynn grace thank you very much for joining us today
00:24:51 and being as open and frank about your personal stories as they are this is one of the issues of
00:24:57 our day it won't last forever because these kinds of things don't something else and heaven only
00:25:03 knows what it'll be but for today you are voices for a reason and I don't suppose the
00:25:10 premier of the province minds at all that you're saying if this set of rules have been
00:25:17 in place in Ontario you wouldn't be in this position today.
00:25:24 Thank you both very much.
00:25:25 You're welcome.
00:25:26 For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Califord.