Western Standard - December 10, 2024


HANNAFORD: When you say "I do," do you know what you're really doing?

Mentioned
Police cam video released showing arrest of Johnny Gaudreau's drunken suspect It’s time to wind Canada Post down

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

170.62

Word count

3,074

Sentence count

89

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Andrea Morosik and her co-author, Peter J. Mitchell, discuss their new book, The Question Mark: A New Look at Marriage in Canada. They talk about the history of marriage in Canada, why it s so important, how it s changed over the past century, and why we should all be asking questions about it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:22 Joining me tonight is somebody who may be familiar to Western Standard readers from the days when
00:00:27 the standard was a print product that would be andrea morosik who is very much still writing
00:00:32 with her colleague peter john mitchell has just published a book good to see you again andrea
00:00:37 thanks so much for having me on nigel oh it's a pleasure andrea i've always recalled you as
00:00:42 the investigative reporter who broke the story in the western standard that sex selective abortion
00:00:47 was widely practiced in bc among you remember this i do i do yeah we have it framed on the wall
00:00:56 Yes, it was widely practiced in B.C. among immigrant communities
00:01:00 who wanted sons, not daughters.
00:01:03 I'm making light of it in this interview,
00:01:05 but of course it was an extremely serious story,
00:01:08 I think one of the landmark pieces of journalism in 2006.
00:01:13 Anyway, these days you're doing great work
00:01:15 with the Christian think tank, Cardis, in Ottawa,
00:01:17 and in fact, your job is to research marriage.
00:01:22 And that's a personal project for you as well, isn't it?
00:01:25 You made it sound like I got married as a research experiment, but yes, indeed.
00:01:30 Ten years of research into my own personal marriage, I suppose.
00:01:34 Got married quite late in life, actually, in keeping with today's Canadian statistics.
00:01:39 So I'm part of that cohort.
00:01:41 Way to go, Andrea.
00:01:43 In a few moments, I'm going to give you a chance to tell viewers where to get your book.
00:01:47 But first, marriage has been around for a while, hasn't it?
00:01:51 and yet you've called your book I dot dot dot do question mark um that sounds like it might be a
00:01:58 new angle what is it really I mean the question mark I'm glad you picked up on that it's an
00:02:04 important part of the title because today we have a culture and a younger generation who
00:02:09 view marriage as maybe nice but unnecessary and certainly not um it's something that's met with
00:02:18 think a fair amount of ambivalence as well and so we put the question mark in to reflect that
00:02:24 cultural trend but at the same time to indicate that we would like people to start asking questions
00:02:30 afresh about the institution of marriage which over time and research have come to see as far
00:02:36 more critically important not just for ourselves but for the culture and the communities that we
00:02:41 live in so the question mark reflects that ambivalence and the fact that we view marriage
00:02:46 as kind of negotiable, not necessary.
00:02:50 And also the fact that we are encouraging readers,
00:02:53 young and old, to reconsider or reimagine
00:02:57 what they think they know about marriage.
00:03:00 Really? Okay.
00:03:01 Well, to me, there's always seemed to be a contractual element to marriage.
00:03:06 And, you know, the one partner does something for the other partner
00:03:10 and the other partner does something back.
00:03:12 And to that point, we've just published a story from B.C.
00:03:16 We have a reporter in B.C., young Jared Jaeger, and he reports that a child advocacy group says nearly half the children living in poverty, as they define it, are actually in single-parent households.
00:03:29 And that's likely to be single mothers, far more likely than to be single fathers.
00:03:34 So when the man-woman contract breaks down, the one where a man basically promises to support a woman and his family,
00:03:44 and in return, she looks after him and his needs, when that breaks down, the children suffer.
00:03:49 And then, and obviously authors of the poverty study we're talking about do this, there's an appeal to the state to help.
00:03:58 So women end up looking to the state for what they should be looking for from a husband. 1.00
00:04:03 As a society, where does that take us?
00:04:06 So I think you've just said a lot, of course, but one angle of that that I'll immediately comment on is that, yes, we do see less income, less financial resources in single parenting families.
00:04:19 And marriage remains a source of stability for longevity.
00:04:22 And that's good for the kids as it is for the parents.
00:04:25 But when you see stories like that arise, and they will often talk about many aspects of poverty eradication that are very valuable, whether it's turning to the state or to the charitable sector.
00:04:39 But the one thing no one ever talks about is the obvious family angle, which is foundational to poverty eradication.
00:04:48 So I come to this question of marriage also with an eye to helping those who are poor, helping those who are living on the margin.
00:04:57 And what we see in marriage culture today is that there's a marriage divide and wealthier people continue to get married.
00:05:05 We're less wealthy, lower income people.
00:05:08 The marriage rates are dropping off even more than the population as a whole.
00:05:12 I think that that speaks to the idea of luxury beliefs, which is a term coined by a scholar, Robert Henderson.
00:05:19 He was raised virtually without family in the foster care system in the United States, but those stories also exist here in Canada.
00:05:25 So when we're thinking about some of the pressing social issues that we face as a society, be it child poverty, be it rising rates of social isolation or loneliness,
00:05:34 the family angle often, most often goes totally unmentioned.
00:05:38 And so part of the book's effort is to bring the family angle back in, not as a form of judgment or saying everybody must be married, but as a simple research question that we see benefits from this.
00:05:49 So why not talk about the institution of marriage?
00:05:52 So, Andrea, look, you said just a moment ago that for wealthier people, they tend to carry on, get married and have families, but that marriage rates are dropping off among the less prosperous.
00:06:08 mm-hmm is which is the cause and which is the effect is yeah go ahead i think you know what
00:06:16 i'm getting at yeah which is cause and effect and i think there is um different theories on that and
00:06:22 you can see um uh factors coming together in a circular way and that it's not it's a complex
00:06:27 issue and so you might have um you know simple choices amongst people who are wealthier towards
00:06:33 getting married or they're more marriageable um you have the education factor mixed in there but
00:06:38 ultimately we want to see a society where we treat people equally regardless of education level
00:06:43 regardless of income level that they everybody sees marriage as an opportunity for their own
00:06:48 family stability regardless of how we get into the place of seeing uh less educated or lower income
00:06:55 uh north americans really this is across north america we see that trend line we want marriage
00:06:59 to be an accessible option to everybody um i'm not sure if your viewers are aware but there's
00:07:04 something called the success sequence and that in the research points to the idea what is it
00:07:09 what did you just say there's nothing called a what the the success sequence um which virtually
00:07:16 eliminates the probability that you're ever going to live in poverty and that is the the sequence is
00:07:21 a simple one you finish your schooling first you get married next and you have kids after that in
00:07:27 that order and so um that i guess gets the poverty angle again as well as some of the differences
00:07:33 between high income and low income um in marriage rates but really we want marriage to be there for
00:07:39 everybody and um not just a certain segment of society so in the course of your researches
00:07:46 you must have observed that in this day and age unlike maybe 20 or 50 years ago
00:07:52 So often you have the wife earning or has the ability to earn more than the husband. 0.80
00:08:02 So if the woman is earning more than the man, does that tend to make men less anxious to be married?
00:08:09 Is it kind of a little power thing going on there that deters them?
00:08:13 I don't know about that, Nigel, but I do think there is the sense today that we have,
00:08:18 which I would argue is wrongheaded, that we just don't need marriage as much anymore.
00:08:23 And that may have something to do with income generation on the part of women and rising 1.00
00:08:28 opportunities in the workforce. Whether we're in the 2000s or back in the 50s, I think the same
00:08:36 thing is at play, which is to say that marriage acts as a future-oriented institution in your
00:08:44 life and it contains the love of partners in it and that means that we can view marriage more as
00:08:51 like an adventure tolkien style adventure rather than a rom-com and you can have a lot of variation
00:08:58 in the ways that people live out their marriages but it is still something that is future oriented
00:09:04 and holding families together maintaining stability at a greater rate than say merely
00:09:09 merely living together and it remains important regardless of the ways in which people negotiate
00:09:15 particular aspects of their married lives. I do know there's research available to suggest that
00:09:20 women still even today with all of our earning potential and all of the career opportunities 1.00
00:09:26 available which are a good thing but even today women would like men who also earn as much or 0.91
00:09:32 more than they do. I don't think this is a deal breaker for marriage as an institution really
00:09:37 we're getting at that foundational idea of marriage and how it undergirds our social stability and
00:09:42 helps us um in raising our families and having a source of long term like thinking about the long
00:09:51 term in our lives looking towards the future i think what you just talked about there is something
00:09:56 you refer to in the book as a life script this sequential uh you know i think you said you
00:10:02 finish school and and then you you get married and then you have children do it in that order
00:10:07 and things go better now i guess one of the questions would be is if you are wanting to
00:10:18 to do that do you have to be married you could still finish school start a relationship and have
00:10:25 children and i know there's a whole lot of people who are out there living in that situation who
00:10:32 would say well and it works fine for us but you're saying marriage is better what's the difference
00:10:39 yeah and the answer there is going to be a bit dry and certainly we all have those examples in
00:10:44 our lives and perhaps living them ourselves but the data on the nature of cohabitation just shows
00:10:51 that it works itself in the aggregate in spite of the wonderful examples of people who look
00:10:58 exactly as if they're married raising children happily and the data is just just not the same
00:11:04 and so I think we can intuitively understand that both can coexist both can be true but in the
00:11:10 aggregate people who end up living together have come into that relationship for different reasons
00:11:16 and some of them are very intentional and others slide into a living together arrangement by
00:11:22 accident. Maybe they have a child by accident. The intention there is not quite the same. The
00:11:27 intentionality, the purposeful nature of it may not be the same. That's actually an advantage of
00:11:32 cohabitation. If you want to get in and out quickly, it's really not the same type of commitment
00:11:40 as marriage might be in spite of many beautiful examples that we might see around us. So the
00:11:45 answers a bit dry there simply say that the data doesn't bear out but they're exactly the same
00:11:49 and so on heated issues and family and marriage can be quite heated because they are so personal
00:11:56 oftentimes i'm just like what does the data what did the data show us and the data tells us it's
00:12:01 not the same thing well being pretty ancient as i am i grew up in an arrow and the joke was that
00:12:09 men didn't want to get married but women did and it seems to me that just to take that seriously 0.97
00:12:16 for a moment for cohabitation without marriage seems whatever the law says but seems to a man
00:12:27 a kind of lower level of commitment and i think that's what you just said and so it makes it more
00:12:32 attractive now is that perhaps at the root of why the data and i where the data you're talking about
00:12:41 it's it's very clear the cohabitation the less successful outcome but is it the fact that men
00:12:49 go into this thing thinking they can get out of it a bit easier in the cohabitation side of the thing 0.94
00:12:55 the law says otherwise but what men often think stupid things you know as you were talking i 0.98
00:13:01 thought of some of the feminist literature on marriage which has really panned marriage you 0.99
00:13:06 know second wave feminism and beyond has has almost without exception said that marriage is 1.00
00:13:11 terrible for women a bit of a prison for women and that it constrains women but that conversation is 0.77
00:13:17 pushed out the side saying that what actually marriage can do is constrain men and limit their
00:13:23 options in such a way that is beneficial to the woman and perhaps mother of a child and family
00:13:29 also beneficial to men, but I often like to bring up that point of marriage as a constraint on men,
00:13:38 acting as a constraint in a way that we haven't had that conversation, because we're, you know,
00:13:43 immersed very much in this, in a lot of the feminist literature on marriage, declaring that
00:13:48 it's bad, it's bad for women. So we have a section in the book talking about the ways in which 1.00
00:13:53 marriage is beneficial to men alone, and then to women alone, then to children, as if they were 0.94
00:13:58 separate but really that amounts to benefits for everybody even if it comes through constraints so
00:14:04 endless choices don't always amount to greater happiness so you know hence all the jokes about
00:14:10 marriage everybody everybody grumbles and yet so many of us still still do it look putting this
00:14:16 together andrea you're saying that society at large has an interest in not only marriage but
00:14:22 in stable marriage and yet that can sound pretty harsh to people who have never been married but
00:14:27 wish to and to those for whom it's not even something they want should everybody be married
00:14:36 no absolutely not it's not a book that compels forced marriage the question mark remains at
00:14:43 the beginning and we hope that this book is a soft entry point into discussing the ways in which
00:14:48 marriage matters without compelling anyone to a particular course of action but because family is
00:14:53 so personal, and it's a place of great joy, but also our deepest wounds, oftentimes we can't even
00:14:57 have the conversations that engender, you know, thinking on the subject of marriage. So we haven't
00:15:04 even begun to touch on how we consider marriage today as a largely romantic expression. There's
00:15:09 a lot of emotion invested in it. We call it the soulmate model of marriage. Our hope is to return
00:15:14 to a bit of a more robust model, which is more institutional, and yet at the same time to return
00:15:19 to your question this is not to say that those who are not married are living lesser lives
00:15:24 i myself got married very very late in life and uh feel that the uh the uh 40 years leading up to
00:15:31 that were were quite uh meaningful and fruitful as it were so um it's a book written without
00:15:37 judgment and if i may toot our own horn just a little bit we were concerned about the judgment
00:15:41 factor in writing it um and one person who's read it is a divorced mother of a 14 year old
00:15:47 And her own marriage had ended for good reason, and it had been very traumatic for the family.
00:15:54 And this divorced mother was going to be giving her 14-year-old daughter a book so that she could encounter some of these more academic arguments around marriage with a lot of the heat taken out. 1.00
00:16:04 So I felt quite proud of that to understand that it was a book that spoke to people who have themselves suffered in their marriages.
00:16:11 Well, I bet you did feel proud of that. Well done. That's a great compliment.
00:16:15 And, you know, if anybody could actually take the subject of marriage and set it on one side and look at it from all angles and come up with a good read, that would be you.
00:16:25 So really, really good to hear your comments about it.
00:16:30 And how do people get a copy and can they get it in time for Christmas?
00:16:34 Oh, they can indeed. Yes, just through Amazon is the easiest way.
00:16:37 I work for Cardist and so it's up at cardist.ca as well.
00:16:40 But the easiest way is Amazon.
00:16:42 Yeah.
00:16:42 Okay.
00:16:43 Well, you know, for all the times that I've talked to people who've written books,
00:16:46 oh, get it on Amazon.
00:16:47 We really should be tapping up Amazon for some advertising, but there it is.
00:16:52 And what a great thing.
00:16:54 Speaking as a taxpayer, I sure hope that marriages will last because when marriages last,
00:17:00 they don't go back and become a charge to the state.
00:17:04 And that's when I go back into that contractual argument.
00:17:06 But anyway, you have done a wonderful job here in taking this subject apart
00:17:12 and putting it back together again.
00:17:14 Bless your heart, and it's great to see you, Andrea.
00:17:18 Thanks so much.
00:17:19 It's good to reconnect with the Western Standard.
00:17:21 What's your next project?
00:17:23 Oh, gosh, promoting this one.
00:17:25 Okay.
00:17:26 Well, consider it well done.
00:17:30 We've been privileged to have with us Western Standard viewers,
00:17:35 Andrea Morozik.
00:17:35 Morozik she works for Cardos in Ottawa and it is her job to study and be well
00:17:41 informed about marriage and she has put it out in a book and she tells us you
00:17:45 can get it via Amazon it's called I dot dot dot do question mark and by Andrea
00:17:53 Morozik thanks again for coming on Andrea and for the Western Standard I'm
00:17:59 and Nigel Hannaford.