Western Standard - December 21, 2023


Healthcare? It’s the system stupid!

Topics
Mentioned
CMS: Healthcare? It’s the system stupid! Exclusive interview with Krampus!

Episode Stats


Length

5 minutes

Words per minute

190.33

Word count

972

Sentence count

62

Harmful content

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Healthcare in Canada is broken, and people are dying while they wait to see a doctor. Canada's healthcare system is one of the worst in the world when it comes to access and access to care, and it's time to fix it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Look at the news across Canada. We'll kind of go from west to east. Well, in BCE, cancer patients
00:00:05 have been sent to the United States for treatment because the local facilities are overwhelmed.
00:00:10 In Alberta, we've got patients languishing in hospital hallways as the capacity in those
00:00:14 hospitals right now is reported to be at 150%. In Saskatchewan, patients are being sent to Alberta,
00:00:21 ironically, for diagnostic services and some surgeries because their public systems are
00:00:26 overwhelmed. In Ontario, hospital emergency departments have been experiencing rotating
00:00:30 closures because they have a lack of resources. In Quebec, conventional hospitals are reported to
00:00:37 be at 100% capacity while the children's hospitals are at 150% capacity. Parents are being urged to
00:00:43 seek home treatment for their sick kids. In Nova Scotia, the wait list for finding a regular family
00:00:49 doctor has grown to 150,000 people. I skipped some provinces and didn't go into every healthcare
00:00:55 issue. But I think you get the picture. It's the same everywhere. The Fraser Institute recently
00:01:01 released its annual report on healthcare waiting times. And the picture is bleak. The median wait
00:01:06 time for treatment after having been referred to a specialist by a general practitioner in Canada
00:01:11 is climbed to 27.7 weeks. And that's assuming the person managed to find a general practitioner in
00:01:17 the first place. How many people are dying waiting to see a specialist right now? How many conditions
00:01:23 end up becoming untreatable because people spent too much time waiting for diagnosis or treatment?
00:01:28 Canada's healthcare system is failing in every jurisdiction and in every possible way across the
00:01:33 country. I mean, there's modern facilities staffed by fantastic professionals in every province, but
00:01:38 they just can't keep up with the demand. Waiting lists for every medical service imaginable. They're
00:01:43 growing and people are dying while they're waiting for that care. We got opposition parties in every
00:01:48 province trying to score political points by blaming the party in power, but they're missing the mark.
00:01:52 It doesn't matter if it's NDP, UCP, PC, CAQ, in power, in government, in the province, the situation's
00:01:59 the same everywhere. Every province has dramatically increased healthcare spending too, so we can't
00:02:03 pretend we aren't spending enough. The federal government, love them or hate them, most of us
00:02:08 hate them, they have been increasing healthcare transfers to the provinces. So again, it's not lack
00:02:12 of money. Canada's one of the highest spending countries on earth when it comes to healthcare,
00:02:15 but it's among the worst when it comes to providing access. So funding isn't the cure,
00:02:20 and the different party isn't the cure. The problem has to lie with the system itself. This is the
00:02:25 thing that Canadians just never want to admit. Canada's healthcare system is crap. It's hopelessly 1.00
00:02:31 broken, and it's become politically taboo to point that out, and politicians are too terrified to take
00:02:36 on the healthcare unions and bureaucrats. But it's beyond time they set aside their cowardly instincts
00:02:41 and call out this system. Some premiers are trying to do what they can within the system, but it's going to
00:02:46 inevitably fail. They're doing patchwork repairs on a blown engine that needs to be torn down and
00:02:51 rebuilt. Daniel Smith in Alberta has taken on the local bureaucracy and decentralizing the
00:02:57 administration of healthcare services. Her efforts will probably lead to some improvements and some
00:03:01 better efficiency, but in the end, Canada's health act is going to overwhelm it, and the system is going 0.97
00:03:06 to remain crap. We're in a monopoly situation, government monopoly. And whether it's private or 0.89
00:03:12 government, it doesn't matter, the consumer always loses. And citizens, whether you like the term or not, are
00:03:16 consumers of healthcare, and they're forced by law to deal with only one provider. The only other nations that 0.99
00:03:22 illegalize private healthcare that way are North Korea and Cuba. Speaks volumes, doesn't it? Canada's 0.81
00:03:27 legislated healthcare monopoly makes it impossible for provinces to create real and lasting fixes to the
00:03:32 system. Unions and bureaucrats fight every effort to make changes while the costs keep climbing, and
00:03:38 efficiency keeps dropping. The only way to change this intractable cycle is to scrap or at least
00:03:44 seriously reform the federal health act and bring some new options into healthcare. While Canadians
00:03:50 constantly list healthcare as one of their top issues of concern, they've been trained to fear any
00:03:54 changes to the system aside from injecting more funds. Unions, again, and activists decry any effort
00:03:59 to improve the system as Americanization, and it's effective in frightening voters away from supporting
00:04:04 change. I tell you, I'd rather have some change than die on a waiting list. Canadians need to be educated.
00:04:09 They need to realize there are dozens of universal healthcare systems in the world, and most of them
00:04:14 are functioning better than ours. Universal, you still get covered. Politicians need to immediately
00:04:19 dismiss the two-dimensional argument that only Canada and the United States have systems in the
00:04:23 world. Political leaders need to turn the discussion to European and Asian models that have universal
00:04:28 coverage and are outperforming us. And guess what? Private healthcare provision is not a bad thing.
00:04:34 And the world provides a plethora of evidence to back that up. Fear-mongering has dominated the
00:04:38 narrative and allowed Canada to become so collectively stupid on the issue, citizens won't 0.99
00:04:43 even glance at models that are proven to provide better care than the current system. Does it really 0.99
00:04:47 matter how you're getting your care, as long as you're getting the care? Things are sure to get
00:04:52 worse with the healthcare system in Canada until the system itself is rebuilt. The only question is,
00:04:57 how bad are things going to have to get before enough Canadians understand this? And yes,
00:05:01 once enough Canadians understand it, perhaps enough of the politicians will start to act on it.